Showing posts with label Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Gaza, the Center of a Global Meltdown

In the many years I have been a news consumer, principally of the New York Times, at no point has it been like it is today. The planet is convulsed by organized violence. Everywhere one turns there appears to be war.

The Middle East is being restructured. Islamic State, a Salafist construct of the Gulf Sheikhdoms, is raising a caliphate in northen Iraq and northern Syria (see Patrick Cockburn's excellent article, posted on Niqnaq's blog, for the latest there); Kurdistan is also rising out of the ashes of Iraq, while Iraqi Shiite parties are trying to figure out what to do next. Iran is spread thin, trying to negotiate with Great Satan on the future of its nuclear program while playing a central role in two hot wars.

In old Europe, conflict rages in Hitler's Lebensraum, as a U.S.-directed fascist junta in Kiev wages war on its civilian population in an attempt to draw the Russian Bear into a quagmire that isolates it from the rest of world capitalism. On the other side of Asia, Uncle Sam is attempting the same thing with the Chinese Dragon, drawing it into open hostilities with its smaller-nation neighbors over resource-rich and strategically-important island chains in the China Sea.

The spot on the map, AfPak, that led to the currently fraying U.S. Weltanschauung -- the post-9/11 reorganization of the state to facilitate a Global War On Terror (GWOT) -- is about to blow sky high. Much as Afghanistan descended into bloody warlord anarchy following the Soviet withdrawal in 1989 (the year of Tiananmen and the fall of the Berlin Wall), the tribes are preparing for battle royale once again as Great Satan readies for the exit.

But potentially the biggest burst of flame is the ongoing Israeli assault on Gaza. I say potentially the biggest because we appear to be at a moment when the occupation, which began not too long after I was born fifty years ago, is going to crack. Most, except for the hard right Israelis like foreign minister Avigdor Lieberman, realize that the occupation cannot continue, that the every-two-year Israeli attacks have to stop, and that border crossings have to be opened. Palestinians are willing to weather, at least for now, the slaughter dished up by Israel because they are unwilling to accept the Gaza status quo. As Anne Barnard reports in "Gazans, Desiring Deep Change, Are Ambivalent on Egypt Cease-Fire Plan":
[H]is grandmother Wedad al-Jarba might have been angry that Hamas, the militant group that dominates the Gaza Strip, did not embrace the cease-fire proposed by Egypt, and kept firing rockets as Israel briefly held its fire. Instead, she shrugged. Like many Gazans interviewed, she said she longed for a deal — one that would change life in Gaza. But she doubted Egypt’s proposal would do that. 
“Every time, they have a cease-fire, but then everything comes back: the siege, the closures,” she said. “Then they bomb again.” 
That ambivalence is widespread in the strip, a narrow, 25-mile-long Palestinian enclave sandwiched between Israel, Egypt and the sea. It may help explain why a beleaguered Hamas kept firing even after Israeli officials declared that such a decision would justify further escalation. 
Israel occupied Gaza during the 1967 Six-Day War and controls its borders, airspace and seas even now, nearly nine years after pulling out its settlers and troops. Since then, tough restrictions have effectively amounted to a blockade, reducing imports and exports to a trickle and preventing all but a few Gazans from leaving. Short but devastating wars deepen the misery.
In a story yesterday, "Gaza Families Near Israeli Border Struggle to Build a Life in the Heart of a Conflict," Barnard limned a helpful sketch of the occupation of Gaza as seen through the eyes of the Marouf family:
Ms. Marouf’s son-in-law, a father of four, lost part of a leg and suffered internal injuries in a strike on Saturday as he headed to his work at a chicken shop. That was only the latest blow to a family whose experience traces every stage of Gaza’s disappointments since 2005, when Israel unilaterally pulled out its settlements and troops, and residents briefly hoped for a new order of increased autonomy and opportunity.
Ms. Marouf grew up in the shadow of an Israeli settlement, subject, she said, to frequent security clampdowns. Her husband waited hours each day to get through security to work on Israeli farms. Then, Israel billed the pullout as the end of its occupation of the Gaza Strip, a narrow, 25-mile-long coastal territory that it seized in the 1967 war.
“We built good hopes,” Ms. Marouf said. “We want Gaza to be like any other nation, with a state, a seaport, a future for our children.”
But things only got worse. Israel never relinquished control of Gaza’s borders, airspace and waters; Palestinians consider it still occupied. Israel imposed even harsher restrictions on the movement of people and goods as militants periodically fired rockets and Hamas, which had killed hundreds of Israelis in suicide bombings, won Palestinian elections in 2006. Ms. Marouf’s husband could no longer reach Israel for work, so they invested their savings in renting land to grow strawberries.
Gaza kept sinking. Facing a boycott from Israel and the West, Hamas failed to form a government; it captured an Israeli soldier, Gilad Shalit, in 2006, prompting more Israeli bombardment as Palestinian rocket attacks continued. In 2007, Hamas took over Gaza from its rival party, Fatah, by force, dividing the Palestinian Authority.
An agreement with Israel to ease its near blockade grew even more remote, making it hard for farmers like the Maroufs to export their harvests.
Then, in late 2008, came what Israel called Operation Cast Lead, involving airstrikes and an incursion into northern Gaza to destroy rocket launchers. The Maroufs fled to a United Nations school, where an Israeli airstrike killed several people; Israeli officials called it a mistake.
Ms. Marouf gave birth to her seventh child, Saja, days later. Her daughter Hadeel, then 11, and a teenage brother went home to get baby clothes, and found their house a smoking ruin, the fields burned. As they walked away, Hadeel said Monday, several neighborhood children tagged along. An Israeli tank shell killed six of them.
“One person’s insides were spilling out,” Hadeel said, reaching for her mother’s hand. Also destroyed was the house of Ms. Marouf’s married daughter, Sabeen.
“We all have childhood memories there,” Sabeen said of her mother’s house. “But the occupation killed our memories as well.”
The family lived in tents for a year, shivering at night as the wind blew under the flaps. Their only income was about $6 a month Ms. Marouf earned making cheese at a women’s factory run under a European Union aid project; even that has disappeared, the project discontinued.
They received United Nations compensation for their house, enough to build a home only half its size, Ms. Marouf said. Construction was slow because of Israeli restrictions on importing building materials. Money ran out before the house was done, but the family moved in, without furniture, which they could not afford. The children went to school in tattered uniforms.
In an Israeli assault in Gaza in 2012, the family stayed put, but last week, they cowered under the most intense bombardments they had ever heard, knowing that if wounded, they would be too frightened to go to a hospital. Ms. Marouf said that each morning, “We thank God that the day has come and we are all right.”
In the shelter, where the family sleeps on bare floors, her daughter Saja, now 5, stared gravely from her mother’s arms and played with a shekel coin. “She won’t eat,” Ms. Marouf said.
Around the corner, a building was flattened by an airstrike on Sunday, and the family is not sure whether they are safe.
Ms. Marouf blamed Israel, Hamas and Fatah for failing to achieve peace.
“We don’t hate the mujahedeen; they defend our people, ourselves, our land,” she said, using the Arabic word for holy warriors to refer to militants. “But we are the victims,” she added, “caught between the three sides.”
Let's keep an eye on the Palestinian resistance. Their continuing steadfastness in the face of terror will offer insight as to how this global conflagration that we are in will spread. The old warpigs will not give up without a great deal of savagery.

Friday, June 20, 2014

Clarifying Obama's Statement on Iraq

Yesterday after Obama's statement that the U.S. is sending 300 military advisers to assist Iraq the U.S President answered questions from reporters. If there was any doubt the Fourth Estate is bought and sold in the United States it was certainly laid to rest yesterday. There was not one question about the Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham (ISIS) and where its funds and fighters are coming from. Questions dealt with Maliki, and the role of Syria and Iran in the conflict. Unbelievable, isn't it?

I thought it would be illuminating to quote Obama's last answer to a question he fielded on Iran, crossing out Iran and replacing it with Saudi Arabia. It makes for an answer that would more truly represent the interests of American voters who elected him:
THE PRESIDENT: Well, I think that just as Iraq’s leaders have to make decisions, I think Iran  [Saudi Arabia] has heard from us. We’ve indicated to them that it is important for them to avoid steps that might encourage the kind of sectarian splits that might lead to civil war.

And the one thing that I think has to be emphasized -- we have deep differences with Iran [Saudi Arabia] across the board on a whole host of issues. Obviously, what’s happened in Syria in part is the result of Iran [Saudi Arabia] coming in hot and heavy on one side. And Iran [Saudi Arabia] obviously should consider the fact that if its view of the region is solely through sectarian frames, they could find themselves fighting in a whole lot of places. And that’s probably not good for the Iranian [Saudi] economy or the Iranian [Saudi] people over the long term either. I suspect there are folks in Iran [Saudi Arabia] who recognize that. A Iraq in chaos on their borders is probably not in their interests. But old habits die hard, and we’ll have to see whether they can take what I think would be a more promising path over the next several days.
Thank you very much, everybody.

END

2:01 P.M. EDT

Thursday, February 13, 2014

Gray Lady Peddles ISIS-Assad Canard

This morning a frontpage story, "Escaped Inmates From Iraq Fuel Syrian Insurgency," by Tim Arango and Eric Schmitt, traces the rise of Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) and its outsize role in the war in Syria as well as the daily mounting death toll in Iraq to a series of well-planned prison breaks, particularly one at Tikrit in September 2012 and one at Abu Ghraib in July 2013:
That group even had a name for its prison strategy, “Operation Breaking the Walls,” which unfolded during a 12-month campaign from July 2012 until a major break at Abu Ghraib, the main Iraqi prison, on the western outskirts of the capital, in July 2013. In all, American officials estimate, a few hundred of the escapees have joined the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, several in senior leadership roles.
The reason for the story and its prominent display in today's paper becomes apparent as one approaches its conclusion -- to peddle the oft-repeated canard that ISIS is a construct of the Syrian government. The only wrinkle here is that al-Maliki of Iraq is now being added to the mix:
Among the more moderate fighting groups within Syria, the prison breaks have helped stoke conspiracy theories that the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, which has been fighting recently with the groups, is a pawn of the Assad government. While there is no evidence to back that up, some said they believed that the Syrian government — with assistance from the Iraqi government of Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki, which has largely sided with Mr. Assad — helped orchestrate the escapes. 
“By doing this, exporting more foreign fighters to Syrian territory, the Maliki government did Assad’s regime a favor by supporting his claim of fighting terrorism inside Syria,” said Abduljabbar Osso, a rebel leader in Aleppo who has been fighting with the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria. 
Another rebel commander, Lt. Col. Ahmad al-Aboud, said that the moment his people heard about the prison escapes in Iraq, “We knew we would face more trouble after that.” 
“We have always faced difficulties smuggling light weapons from Iraq to Syria through the Iraq border,” he said, “but it was very easy for ISIS to get full patrols of vehicles, weapons and fighters across to Syria.” 
The Iraqi government has done little to explain how the prison breaks happened, although most agree that the inmates had help from the inside. Parliament members said that when they tried to investigate the Abu Ghraib break, they were stymied by security forces and top government officials. 
“Unfortunately, the government did not allow us to even get close to the prison for a week,” said Shwan Muhammed, a member of Parliament and one of the investigators.
This is not journalism; this is propaganda.

For a thorough refutation of the ISIS-Assad connection, see "The Assad Regime and Jihadis: Collaborators and Allies?" by Aymenn Al-Tamimi, which appeared this week on Joshua Landis' pro-opposition Syria Comment blog. It is a lengthy, detailed post that debunks point by point each element of the ISIS-Assad canard.

The most obvious weakness in the argument is the idea that the Syrian government would create a deadly fighting force in order to inflict damage to itself. Peddlers of the Canard insist that the Syrian Arab Army doesn't actually engage in combat with ISIS. Al-Tamimi convincingly refutes this:
With ISIS, the reasoning goes that the group does not focus on fighting regime forces, such that it even leaves regime areas alone, and in return the regime agrees not to bomb ISIS-held territory. 
This line of argument overlooks that ISIS has a record of fighting the regime on multiple fronts, including the Sheikh Said area of Aleppo province, Kwiris military airbase (where an offensive is ongoing under the leadership of muhajireen battalion Suqur al-Izz, in coordination with the Green Battalion, ISIS and Jabhat al-Nusra), Nubl and Zahara, Brigade 17 airbase in Raqqa province, Tabqa military airport, Qalamoun, Sayyida Zainab, Sakhna in Homs desert, the Qamishli area, and Latakia province. Besides these locations, one should also remember ISIS’ leading role in the capture of Mannagh airbase. 
It is of course true that ISIS is now fighting on fewer fronts against regime forces since the wider infighting with other rebels broke out, but that is only to be expected: remaining too thinly spread out would have cost the group even more territorial losses. Even so, following ISIS’ seizure of Raqqa city, Tel Abyad, Tabqa and Ma’adan, it is not true that ISIS has ignored the regime’s airbases in Raqqa province, engaging in clashes with regime forces around Brigade 17 in mid to late January before being cleared out by the end of month through airstrikes on the surroundings. 
As for Tabqa military airport, this area has been subjected to mortar shelling recently by ISIS in collaboration with Liwa Owais al-Qorani, an independent battalion in Tabqa that has not pledged bay’ah (allegiance) to ISIS but rather, as a local anti-ISIS Raqqa contact explained to me, is subordinate to and “takes orders from ISIS.” 
Coming to regime airstrikes, it is untrue that the regime has not hit ISIS strongholds, having struck Raqqa city as recently on February 7. The counter-claim is that since ISIS advertises itself on social media so much, why does the regime not strike these positions? However, this argument firstly presumes that the regime’s air force has any kind of precision in launching airstrikes. Second, as the regime’s record elsewhere demonstrates, targeting of civilian areas in rebel-held territory is part of its tactics. 
In any event, one must ask what the regime would gain strategically by constantly bombing ISIS strongholds in Raqqa province, or ISIS strongholds elsewhere, for that matter, located far beyond the frontlines. As in the wider east of Syria, the regime lacks ground forces to launch an offensive to retake any territory in Raqqa province, and must depend on airlifts from elsewhere to maintain its remaining airbases. Hence, the regime is focusing its airstrikes where it has some real expectations of advancing: most notably in Aleppo city.
Read al-Tamimi's post. It will muffle the constant drum beat of "Assad collaborates with ISIS."

But why is the New York Times now peddling this lie? I think it is of a piece with the regular efforts being made to show that ISIS has a self-sustaining funding source. In both the criminal enterprise funding source and Assad collaboration stories you get a firewall between the main jihadi organization gobbling up territory in Iraq and Syria for the Caliphate and Saudi Arabia, one of the two main U.S. allies in the Middle East.

Plus, by raising the baleful specter of an evil group of ruthless jihadis, you artificially create the impression that there are "good" jihadis, like Islamic Front and Nusra. In reality, as al-Tamimi shows, there is little difference.

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Iraq and Iran Brett McGurk on ISIS

Reading a story, "Suicide Bomb Trainer in Iraq Accidentally Blows Up His Class," in today's paper the writers, Duraid Adnan and Tim Arango, note how much territory is currently under ISIS control:
Along with the increase in attacks on Iraqi civilians in Baghdad and elsewhere, the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria and other Sunni extremist groups have captured territory in western Anbar Province, and for weeks they have controlled the city of Falluja and parts of Ramadi, the provincial capital. Other areas of the country have also become strongholds of the Islamic State and of Al Qaeda. 
Terrorist training camps have been set up in the mountainous areas of Diyala Province. Northern Nineveh Province has become a gateway for jihadis traveling from Iraq to Syria. Mosul, Nineveh’s capital, has become a center of financing for militant groups estimated by one Iraqi official at millions of dollars a month, generated by extortion and other schemes. 
Suicide attacks make up an increasing share of the operations financed by this money stream. At a congressional hearing last week, Brett McGurk, a senior State Department official, said 50 suicide attacks occurred in Iraq in November, compared with three in November 2012. “The suicide bomber phenomenon, it is complete insanity,” Mr. McGurk said.
I'm a little skeptical about the effort that is being made to argue that ISIS has created its own funding stream by means of extortion, kidnapping and other criminal conspiracies; it seems to be a way to obscure the fact that Al Qaeda in particular and Jihad in general is financially maintained by U.S. allies in the Gulf.

McGurk's testimony to the House Foreign Affairs Committee last week can be found on C-SPAN. A transcript of his statement can be found here.

Monday, January 27, 2014

Greater Cooperation Between Uncle Sam and Al Qaeda Signaled

Yesterday in the Sunday Review section of the New York Times Ben Hubbard had a piece, "The Franchising of Al Qaeda," about the supposedly changing nature of the group led by Ayman al-Zawahri. Al Qaeda, according to Hubbard, is splintering, becoming more defuse, less centralized.

This is nothing new. We've been hearing this for the last decade. What is new here is the necessity to create distinctions among various Al Qaeda groups so that the United States can work with those that it wishes to in contravention of the Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Terrorists passed after 9/11.

This move is underway largely because of the war in Syria. The United States is already cooperating with Al Qaeda there in coordination with the Saudis and the Turks. ISIS and Nusra are the main fighting forces trying to defeat the Syrian Arab Army. Going forward, this is going to be the new normal as the Saudis and Israelis insist on war with Iran. The foot soldiers will come from the salafi groups affiliated with Al Qaeda.

The United States needs to get its voters used to cooperating with Al Qaeda. Hence, you get the line like the following one:
Beyond its open affiliation with Al Qaeda, little separates the Nusra Front from other Islamist battalions fighting in Syria. One of them, Ahrar al-Sham, even has a Qaeda member in its leadership. While these groups’ Islamic vision for the future of Syria may disturb many Americans (and Syrians), they have not attacked Western targets. “There are a lot of militant groups out there that are supporting either Islamist, salafist or jihadi doctrine, but they are not all wrapped up about the U.S., so do you call them all Al Qaeda?” said Clint Watts, a former F.B.I. agent now with the Philadelphia-based Foreign Policy Research Institute.
It is going to be a tough sell because there has been an enormous amount of  indoctrination going back to the 1990s telling us that Al Qaeda is our existential enemy. But this won't stop the elites who construct policy from moving full steam ahead.

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Gray Lady's New Focus on Jihadi Role in Syrian Civil War

Over the last couple months a shift has been apparent in the way the New York Times covers the Syrian civil war. No longer is the conflict covered solely through the prism of al-Assad's demonization. Where before the rise of Al Qaeda and Wahhabism as dominant forces among the rebels received mention, if at all, at the bottom of the story, now, it is the lede. (To give credit where credit is due, Anne Barnard, the Gray Lady's Beirut Bureau Chief and principal reporter on the civil war, fell out of love with the Syrian National Coalition at the end of summer about the time of the Ghouta gassing.)

What this undoubtedly reflects is a shift in the official United States Government position. Once the plan to attack Syria was aborted due to overwhelming public and Congressional opposition, the Obama administration has embraced a position -- at least for public consumption -- that is a polar opposite of one that it espoused just a few months ago.

Despite caterwauling by the Saudis, the U.S. now sees Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) and Al Nusra Front as far more significant threats than the Syrian government. Today's frontpage story, "Private Donors’ Funds Add Wild Card to War in Syria," by Ben Hubbard is the most recent example of the Obama administration's "pivot" to deal with the jihadi domination of pockets of Syria.
Most private donors shun the Western-backed Supreme Military Council, undermining a body meant to unify the rebels into a moderate force. And they dismiss the opposition’s political leadership as well as calls by the United States and other powers for peace talks. With funds estimated to be at least in the tens of millions of dollars, they have contributed to the effective partition of Syria, building up independent Islamist militias that control territory while espousing radical ideology, including the creation of an Islamic state.
Hubbard focuses on the funding network operating in Kuwait. Most of its support goes to Al Nusra.
The Kuwaiti government has played down the importance of the funds, saying Kuwait’s charitable contributions dwarf any cash sent for arms.
*** 
American officials disagree. 
“The Kuwaitis could be doing a lot more on this issue,” said David S. Cohen, the Treasury under secretary for terrorism and financial intelligence. He said that Kuwait posed the region’s biggest problem of financing linked to extremists in Syria, and that American efforts to press the issue with the Kuwaiti government had yielded limited results. 
Mr. Cohen declined to estimate the amount of private funding flowing through Kuwait to Syria, but said it was enough to equip extremist fighters with ample light arms and supplies.
This kind of reporting represents a significant change. The Gulf monarchies will take note. American public opinion is already strongly anti-sheikhdom, running far ahead of what is allowed in the mainstream media. If this point of view gets a toehold in the prestige press, watch out.

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Hallowed Ritual Meant to Convey Activity and Good Faith

Yesterday Lakhdar Brahimi announced that there would be no Geneva II peace talks in November. Brahimi said that he would meet again with U.S. and Russian diplomats at the end of the month to try to put something together. But after that date one wonders how long Brahimi will stick around. There has been no movement on the most basic issue of who should attend -- which rebel groups, which nations. Nick Cumming-Bruce and Rick Gladstone have the story, "Diplomats Fail to Agree on Details for Syria Peace Talks":
Mr. Brahimi made it clear that the lack of preparation on the part of Syria’s opposition was an acute and immediate cause for delaying a peace conference. “They are divided, that’s no secret for anyone, they are facing all sorts of problems,” he said. 
The opposition National Coalition has no leverage over the armed groups battling Mr. Assad, particularly the jihadist militants linked to Al Qaeda who are among the most effective fighters. They have said that any insurgents who participate in Geneva peace talks would be regarded as traitors. 
Mr. Brahimi also acknowledged that the diplomats had been unable to agree on whether Iran, Mr. Assad’s most important regional ally, would be invited to a peace conference. “Iran is definitely one of the issues that will be discussed further,” he said. 
Saudi Arabia, Iran’s regional rival and a major supporter of the Syrian insurgency, remains opposed to Iranian participation in peace talks. Western governments, recognizing Iran as an important participant, have appeared less resistant to Iran’s attendance. But diplomats say a major obstacle is Iran’s reluctance to endorse the communiqué of the first Geneva conference in June 2012, which called for a transition under a government formed by mutual consent. 
The question of Mr. Assad’s role in a transition government looms as a major obstacle. In a meeting with Mr. Brahimi in Damascus last week, Mr. Assad said “only the Syrian people are authorized to shape the future of Syria,” a formula that rejects American insistence that he step down as part of any peace process. “We are not going to Geneva to hand over power,” Syria’s information minister, Omran al-Zoubi, said on Monday, according to Syria’s official SANA news agency. “President Bashar al-Assad will remain head of state.”
Further talks in Geneva to prepare the way for a Geneva II summit are like Kerry shuttling between Netanyahu and Abbas, a hallowed ritual meant to convey activity and good faith while maintaining a status quo of perpetual war and occupation.

In a troubling sign, the odious Samantha Power was back in the news denigrating the Syrian government and questioning the accuracy of its declaration to the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons. The OPCW has said verification is on schedule and the Syrian government is complying. Once again this sets up the familiar conflict between the United States and an international agency responsible for administering a United Nations Security Council resolution. U.S. warmongering goes unsupported by its people, but it is supported by elites and the foreign governments that maintain those elites. So warmongering will continue.

This despite proof that the policy of fomenting war and rebellion is having the opposite effect of the overarching U.S. national security mission (at least as it is formulated for public consumption) of eradicating Al Qaeda and its affiliates. Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) continues to consolidate its hold on northern Syria. The caliphate springs up on the border of NATO.

Attempting to break the logjam, Russia is offering to host informal talks between the Syrian government and members of the opposition.

Since I have mentioned "a hallowed ritual meant to convey activity and good faith," I should note that yesterday was Election Day in the United States. There wasn't a whole lot to celebrate. Bill de Blasio, a progressive Democrat, won the New York City mayor's race in an impressive landslide. That's good news. Corporate Democrat and uber-Clintonite Terry McAuliffe was elected governor of Virginia over a Tea Party troglodyte Ken Cuccinelli. One can debate the merits of McAuliffe's victory. In Washington State, the bad news is that I-522, a GMO-labeling initiative, is headed for defeat. It shared the fate of last year's GMO-labeling initiative in California -- buried by a blizzard of negative advertising paid for by corporate behemoths like Monsanto and PepsiCo.

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

Mr. al-Maliki Goes to Washington

Much has been made of the recent Saudi tantrum -- renouncing a seat on the United Nations Security Council, publicly complaining about a lack of American leadership. It is the topic of today's lede unsigned editorial in the New York Times, "Allies in Revolt":
Saudi Arabia and Israel are deeply worried about the Obama administration’s decision to negotiate a nuclear deal with Iran — their mortal enemy. Saudi Arabia and Turkey are sore at President Obama’s refusal to become militarily involved in ousting President Bashar al-Assad of Syria, in particular his decision not to respond with military strikes to Mr. Assad’s use of chemical weapons. Mr. Obama instead chose a diplomatic deal under which Syria’s chemical weapons would be dismantled. 
The Saudis are also unhappy that Mr. Obama withdrew support for Hosni Mubarak, the deposed Egyptian president, and then worked with Mohamed Morsi, a Muslim Brotherhood member who was elected to replace Mr. Mubarak but was later thrown out.
Another source of Saudi and Israeli ire arrives in Washington D.C. today. Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki is leading a large delegation in search of Apache attack helicopters and other military aircraft. Iraq still has no air force. But what it does have is a state of war with Saudi-funded Al Qaeda affiliate Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, something that would seem to automatically qualify Iraq and its Prime Minister for the complete support of the United States since we have been in a declared war against Al Qaeda and its affiliates since 9/11.

But this isn't the case. Instead what one learns reading the paper today is that power brokers in the U.S. Senate are enraged at al-Maliki. Why? Because he is allowing Iranian overflights to Syria. This is from "Senators Warn Obama Before Iraq Leader’s Visit" by Michael Gordon and Eric Schmitt:
Earlier on Tuesday, two of the senators spoke angrily in separate interviews about Mr. Maliki’s failure to unify the competing factions in Iraq. “He’s got a lot of work to do in terms of pulling together diverse elements of his country,” said Senator Carl Levin, a Michigan Democrat who heads the Armed Services Committee. “He’s not done a particularly good job of it.” 
Mr. Levin also criticized Mr. Maliki for acquiescing in, if not facilitating, Iran’s efforts to supply weapons to President Bashar al-Assad of Syria, using flights through Iraqi airspace. “They’ve allowed overflights, Iranian planes, to supply Syria,” Mr. Levin said. 
Senator Bob Corker of Tennessee, the senior Republican on the Foreign Relations Committee, which is to meet with Mr. Maliki on Wednesday, was even more critical of the Iraqi leader. “What he’s done is create a situation where the population is more accepting of what Al Qaeda is doing there because of his lack of inclusiveness,” Mr. Corker said. 
The other senators who signed the letter were John McCain of Arizona and Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, both Republicans who have long taken a strong interest in Iraq; Robert Menendez, the New Jersey Democrat who is chairman of the Senator Foreign Relations Committee; and James M. Inhofe, a Republican from Oklahoma who is the ranking minority member of the Armed Services Committee.
Prime Minister al-Maliki has a sensible piece published today in the New York Times in which he explains what the civil war in Syria has wrought:
The war in Syria has become a magnet that attracts sectarian extremists and terrorists from various parts of the world and gathers them in our neighborhood, with many slipping across our all-too-porous borders. We do not want Syria or Iraq to become bases for Al Qaeda operations, and neither does the United States. 
While the world sees Syria as a humanitarian tragedy, we also see an immediate threat to the security of our own country. Al Qaeda is engaged in a renewed, concerted campaign to foment sectarian violence and drive a wedge between our people. We will not let that happen again. 
Because we do not want Syria to continue to attract violent extremists, much less cause a regional conflagration, our top priority is to end the bloodshed and achieve a negotiated settlement. The Iraqi government is serious about not allowing our own citizens to arm any side of the Syrian conflict. 
We are also committed to preventing the territory, the waterways and, yes, the airspace of our country from being used by any outside entity to fuel the conflict in Syria. But, with many better-armed neighbors and no air force or air defenses to speak of, our ability to enforce this policy is limited. This is one of many reasons we are urgently seeking to improve our air defense capabilities.
The United States Congress is Israeli and Saudi occupied territory. It is clear from the reaction to al-Maliki's visit that the Saudis and Israelis are reluctant to have Uncle Sam provide air power to the Iraqis.

Twelve years after 9/11 it should be clear by now who the enemies of peace are -- the Saudis and Israelis. Al Qaeda does not flourish without support from Saudi Arabia. Recently Al Qaeda was declared all but defunct. Then suddenly it burst to life out of its ashes when the Gulf monarchies decided to take out the Baathists in Syria. As for the Israelis, they profit from a region at war with itself. It distracts attention from Palestine. Informed people often ask the question, "Why doesn't Al Qaeda ever attack Israel?"

The decision the Obama administration makes on whether to provide Apache helicopters to Iraq will provide an indication how real the rift with Saudi Arabia and Israel is. For peace and a much needed shift in paradigm in the Middle East let's hope that the rift is wide and deep.

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Tea Party Propaganda War + ISIS

The Tea Party is unbowed one day in to their shutdown of the federal government. The coverage in today's New York Times points to a propaganda war that will unfold in the next few days as the House Republicans attempt to pass piecemeal spending bills, which they failed to accomplish last night, hoping to force Senate majority leader Harry Reid to take them up. If he refuses, then the GOP can blame the Democrats for keeping the national parks and veterans' centers closed. 

But there is peril on this path for Republican hardliners. To get piecemeal spending bills passed over Democratic opposition they must do so under ordinary rules requiring a simple majority vote. This opens up the possibility that "a clean CR" -- a bill to reopen the government without language to limit, delay or repeal Obamacare -- could make it to the House floor for an up or down vote.

Here is how the august Jonathan Weisman explains it in his "House G.O.P. Pushes Piecemeal Approach as Democrats Stand Firm":
Aides to the Republican leadership said the bills would be introduced on Wednesday under ordinary rules that require only simple majorities, and they should easily pass. But Democrats are likely to be granted procedural votes of their own, which would be an opportunity to test how many Republicans would defy their leadership and vote to reopen the entire government without crippling President Obama’s health care law — the standoff that shut down the government at 12:01 a.m. on Tuesday. 
As public anger grows, more Republicans are coming forward to call for such a rebellion. 
“The frustration and anger over Obamacare is being interpreted to be an all-or-nothing calculation,” said Representative Patrick Meehan, Republican of Pennsylvania, who now favors a simple stopgap spending measure to reopen the government. “People are very worried about Obamacare. Some of its pieces are problematic. 
“But they want us to come here and work on problems across America, and we can’t get to doing that if both sides are dug in,” he said. 
Democrats face pressure of their own to drop their stance of approving a spending bill only if it is free of policy prescriptions. Senate Democratic leaders say they plan to immediately kill all three of the piecemeal House bills, arguing that they will not be forced to choose between financing veterans’ programs or cancer research at the National Institutes of Health.
Tea Party stalwarts are convinced that they can still win the battle for American hearts and minds, even though the first-day response to the opening of the online Obamacare insurance market was so robust it led to meltdowns in the system.

The House GOP is suffering from the same kind of magical thinking that predicted a Romney win absent any polling data last election eve. Nonetheless, they will launch this piecemeal spending bill strategy and try to create some traction in the Senate. I read yesterday that Senator Dick Durbin, Democrat from Illinois, broached the idea of a deal based on a repeal of the medical device tax part of Obamacare. Thankfully, this was quickly shot down by Harry Reid.

Give the propaganda war a few days to play out.

There is a good story by Ben Hubbard this morning, "Qaeda Branch in Syria Pursues Its Own Agenda," about the method of operation of Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS):
The rise of extremist groups has exacerbated Syria’s instability. ISIS has attacked rebel bases to capture supplies, and routed rebel groups last month to seize control of Azaz, a strategic city near the Turkish border, leading to a tense cease-fire. Last week, Qaeda fighters tried to storm a village in Idlib Province to kidnap some rebels, leaving 20 dead from both sides, including the jihadis’ Libyan commander. 
“We want to keep Syria together as a country of freedom and equality,” a leader in an Islamist rebel group opposed to ISIS, called Suqour al-Sham, who gave his name as Abu Bashir, said via Skype. “They want to form an Islamic state that comes together with Iraq.” 
In an audio statement released online late Monday, a Qaeda spokesman defended the group, saying its contributions to the anti-Assad fight had been underappreciated and denying that it had started fights with rebel groups. 
“Those who aspire to sideline the state are many because of incorrect beliefs and doctrines,” said the spokesman, Abu Mohammed al-Adnani al-Shami. “They are greedy for power and for the worthless things of this world.” 
Analysts say the group is a revival and extension of Al Qaeda in Iraq, whose sectarian-fueled insurgency pushed that country to the brink of civil war in 2006 and 2007, before the group suffered major defeats at the hands of tribal fighters and American troops. 
In Syria, however, the group has found the vast territories that have fallen into rebel hands near Syria’s northern and eastern borders as an ideal environment to regroup and advance its agenda. 
The area is stateless, covered by a weak patchwork of local councils and rebel groups struggling to administer their towns and often competing with one another for resources. This gives the group a wide area to work in with no immediate enemies. The porousness of the Iraqi and Turkish borders also makes it easy for the group to bring in supplies and fighters. 
Brian Fishman, a former director of research at the Combating Terrorism Center at West Point and now a fellow at the New America Foundation, said those factors gave Al Qaeda a more favorable environment in Syria than it ever had in Iraq. 
“The conditions in Syria will be ripe for ISIS for quite some time,” he said.
There is a good Moon of Alabama blog post from a few days back that discusses negotiations between the Free Syrian Army and the Syrian government. The reality that is sinking in with the non-jihadi opposition is that the true enemy is the Saudi- and Qatari-funded mujahideen.

Wednesday, September 25, 2013

Gray Lady's Anne Barnard Interviews Syrian Deputy Foreign Minister Fayssal Mekdad

Anne Barnard has a decent story this morning built around her Tuesday interview in Damascus with Syria's deputy foreign minister, Fayssal Mekdad. It's worth checking out. Some of the highlights:
  • Geneva II is unlikely to happen anytime soon. So the Syrian government is talking about the possibility of staging its own peace talks with "religious and community leaders 'who have influence on the ground' with fighters."
"But Mr. Mekdad suggested the government doubted the usefulness of talking to leaders of the National Coalition of Syrian Revolutionary and Opposition Forces, the exile group that the West and its Arab allies have tried to set up as the government’s opposition counterpart and the civilian leadership of the loose-knit rebel Free Syrian Army. Excluding that group would be a nonstarter for the United States and its allies.
"But Mr. Mekdad and prominent government supporters in Damascus said the coalition was increasingly irrelevant, not only lacking control over its own forces, but over foreign jihadist groups increasingly prominent on the battlefield — a view widely shared by Syrians who oppose the government."
  • Following Syria's agreement to get rid of its chemical weapons, "Mr. Mekdad said the natural next step was an international push for Israel to relinquish its arsenal of nuclear weapons, which the neighboring state has never formally acknowledged."
  • The Syrian deputy foreign minister said that the government was "100 percent sure" that the rebels were behind the August 21 Ghouta chemical weapon attack.
  • Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) is consolidating its position in northern Syria and hardening its drive for a caliphate by attacking other rebel groups:
"A Syrian journalist said recent fighting between armed groups in the rebel-held north changed the calculations of Syrian and Western leaders regarding the proposed talks in Geneva.

"The journalist, who supports the government but requested anonymity to go beyond official statements, said he believed the extremist Islamic State in Iraq and Syria was trying to seize ground from other rebel groups. 
"'I don’t think Geneva is really close to us, but what is close to us is a huge problem,' he said. 'If we don’t fight it in next two, three, four weeks, this means that inside of the Middle East, near Europe’s border, there is a state auto-financed and controlled by terrorists.'
"He said he could even envision a situation in which an international coalition was formed to fight alongside the Syrian Army against the jihadists, a prospect that seemed unlikely for now as the West continues to insist Mr. Assad leave power.
"Mr. Mekdad dismissed that notion and said the government sought a “peace coalition” to end the financing of armed opposition groups by America’s allies Saudi Arabia and Qatar, adding that aid to the Syrian government from its allies Russia and Iran was permissible within relations between sovereign states."
I think that there's a greater chance that the West will use the existence of an Al Qaeda enclave in northern Syria as an excuse to launch strikes against the Syrian government rather than cooperate with it. It's part of pattern that we've come to expect from the United States and its allies: foment unrest and then use that unrest as an excuse to exercise military force.

Thursday, September 19, 2013

Elites Mewl Diminished Imperial Prerogative

Al Qaeda affiliate Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) took control of the Syrian border town of Azaz, routing the Free Syrian Army rebels. This is from a story by Ben Hubbard and Karam Shoumali, "Extremists Take Syrian Town Near Turkey Border":
The takeover also signals a new low in relations between the rebels fighting a civil war against Mr. Assad’s forces and international jihadists who have flocked to rebel-controlled areas to lay the groundwork for an Islamic state. 
For much of the 30-month-old conflict, the rebels welcomed jihadist fighters for the know-how and battlefield prowess they brought to the anti-Assad struggle. In recent months, however, jihadist groups have isolated local populations by imposing strict Islamic codes, carrying out public executions and clashing with rebel groups. 
In the eastern city of Deir al-Zour on Wednesday, extremist fighters took dozens of rebels captive after a gunfight near a rebel base, activists said. 
Reached by telephone, a rebel commander who gave only his first name, Khattab, said that Wednesday’s violence in Azaz began when ISIS fighters stormed the town and tried to detain German doctors who were visiting a hospital.
Turkey responded by closing one of its border crossings.

Elites continue to complain about Obama's decision to go to Congress for authorization to illegally attack Syria; it is considered a significant rollback of the imperial presidency. The story, "Former Defense Secretaries Criticize Obama on Syria," by Thom Shanker and Lauren D'Avolio, about comments by former Obama SecDefs Robert Gates and Leon Panetta regarding the commander-in-chief's handling of Syrian crisis, had the following lines that caught my eye:
Although Mr. Gates said that any unilateral military action against Syria would be a mistake, he also said it was unwise for the president to have sought Congressional authorization to use force, because of the risk to presidential prestige if he was rebuffed. 
If Congress voted no, “it would weaken him,” Mr. Gates said. “It would weaken our country. It would weaken us in the eyes of our allies, as well as our adversaries around the world.”
In other words, it doesn't matter that the most favorable outcome was achieved -- a wider war was avoided, large amounts of chemical weapons will be decommissioned, and the Constitution was honored -- because there was a risk to presidential prestige. This is what qualifies as sagacity in elite circles. Clearly it is insane, the product of a shit-sniffing, addled old courtier; but it is the conventional wisdom of the Washington smart set.

Having been on the losing side of a propaganda war that has raged since Monday when the United Nations released the Sellstrom report on the August 21 Ghouta chemical attack, Russia and Syria finally got off the ropes. For instance, Assad was interviewed on the Fox Network by former presidential aspirant and Congressman Dennis Kucinich, something of a public relations coup since Kucinich still has some chops, albeit waning, among progressives and Fox caters to an audience of hard-shell conservative know-nothing types. This is the type of "unholy alliance" that blocked Obama's AUMF in Congress and has elites like Panetta and Gates mewling about the diminishment of imperial prerogative.

Friday, August 16, 2013

The Goal: Roll Back Arab Spring, Reconfigure Sykes-Picot, Reduce Iran, Secure Greater Israel

As large protest marches take place throughout Egypt today despite the imposition of martial law after the Wednesday massacre of pro-Morsi supporters by the coup government, it is illuminating to read the story by Mark Landler and Peter Baker, "His Options Few, Obama Rebukes Egypt’s Leaders." It is a snapshot of a helpless giant whose fecklessness and drift is explained away by its power-broker elite as a rational course of action -- which it is in a corrupt, "pay-to-play" system. While there are noises within the Obama administration that all options are still on the table, including obeying the law and denying $1.3 billion in aid to General Sisi's military junta, don't expect anything more than the cancellation of joint exercises with the Egyptian armed forces that Obama announced yesterday from his vacation retreat:
Given the deep schism in Egypt, this official said, the White House is still skeptical that cutting off aid would compel the generals to return the country to a democratic transition. And it could destabilize the region, particularly the security of Israel, whose 1979 peace treaty with Egypt is predicated on the aid.

For weeks, officials from Israel and several Arab countries have pressured the administration to maintain the flow of aid. If it were cut off, they said, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates would move quickly to make up the shortfall — and then some. 
Saudi Arabia and the emirates pledged $8 billion in grants and loans to Egypt’s post-Morsi government last month: $5 billion from Saudi Arabia in grants and loans; $3 billion from the emirates. That is more than enough, analysts say, to offset any cutoff from the United States, even if the two countries do not fulfill their entire pledges. 
Shutting off the aid spigot now would not have an immediate impact on the Egyptian military, defense officials say, because this year’s military assistance has already been delivered. Beyond money, Arab officials worry that a rupture between Washington and the Egyptian military would further erode American influence in a country that has historically been a bellwether in the Arab world, and would open the door to rivals like Russia or China. 
“If the aid gets cut, you can be sure that Putin will arrive in Cairo in two or three months,” one senior Arab official said. “And he will give aid with no strings attached.”
So there you have it. To head off the predatory, baleful Vlad Putin, as well as to secure cooperation with Israel, not to mention overflight rights and access to the Suez Canal, the United States will continue to pay the Egyptian military.

A robust refutation of this lazy, Washington-insider point of view can be found on New York Times Opinion Page in a piece written by Amr Darrag, Mohamed Morsi's minister of planning and international cooperation:
First, this is a battle between those who envision a democratic, pluralistic Egypt in which the individual has dignity and power changes hands at the ballot box and those who support a militarized state in which government is imposed on the people by force. 
Second, this coup has already sent Egypt back into the dark ages of dictatorship — with tight military control over both state-owned and private media, attacks on peaceful protesters and journalists, and detention of opposition leaders without criminal charges or due process. 
Third, there is no promise that General Sisi can make that he hasn’t already betrayed. He took an oath to uphold the Constitution; he suspended the Constitution. He took an oath to loyally serve in the government; he toppled that government. And in the classic doublespeak of military juntas, he loudly condemned the opposition for dealing with foreign powers, while he was actively seeking the help of Western diplomats as well as the Persian Gulf sheikdoms that largely financed his coup. 
Through all this, the United States government has pleaded impotence. Hardly a day goes by without some press officer, analyst or public official pushing the idea that Washington’s influence really isn’t that decisive with the Egyptian generals. This cop-out simply won’t do. America had influence and still does. It was an American official, not an Egyptian one, who informed President Morsi’s staff of the finality of the coup decision.
There is only one way forward in Egypt today. The legitimate government must be restored. Only then can we hold talks for a national reconciliation with every option on the table.
Iraq is being terror bombed daily by Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham. A massive bombing took place in a Hezbollah neighborhood in Beirut yesterday. There is a region-wide war being waged in the Middle East. The goal is to reconfigure Sykes-Picot, roll back the Arab Spring, reduce Iran and secure a Greater Israel. To this end look for, eventually, direct U.S. military involvement.

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

U.S. Still at Work on No-Fly Zone Despite Rise of Al Qaeda in Syria

It's important to recall that several months ago there were reports in the press predicting that an American-led no-fly zone was in the works for parts of Syria and might be up and running as soon as summer's end. Lest we forget, Thom Shanker, reporting from Tel Aviv, has a story headlined "Syrian War Shapes Trip by Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff" about Joint Chiefs head Martin Dempsey's junket to the Middle East:
The chairman, Gen. Martin E. Dempsey, said his talks in Jordan would include an assessment of whether American surveillance aircraft or collaboration on other border-control techniques could help the Jordanians, whose country is the emergency home to tens of thousands of Syrian refugees — and, increasingly, a route for black-market weapons transported both ways across the Syrian frontier. 
Syria has accused Jordan of acting as a transit point for weapons supplied to Syrian rebels, an accusation Jordan has denied. In recent days, the Jordanian authorities have detained suspected smugglers, including Syrians, accused of attempting to bring antitank missiles, surface-to-air missiles, assault rifles and other arms from Syria into Jordan — possibly part of an attempt by jihadists in Syria to foment unrest in Jordan as well. 
The Pentagon already has deployed air-defense missile batteries in Jordan, along with crewed F-16s to train alongside the Jordanian Air Force in patrolling Jordan’s border and airspace. A few hundred American military planners, including communications experts and logisticians, also are in Jordan.
American war plans roll along according to schedule. The only wrinkle has been the ascension over the last six months of Al Qaeda linked jihadis. They now constitute the main rebel fighting force in Syria. That's why Free Syrian Army General Salim Idris's "me too" photo op in Bashar al-Assad's Alawite home territory of Latakia province smacks of desperation. The push to occupy villages in Latakia was reported last week as being an ISIS initiative. Idris wants to show his paymasters that he's on the job.

Since Al Qaeda and its affiliates are the sworn enemy of the United States, a foe that we have been locked in existential battle with for over a decade, one that has reconfigured our society into a surveillance state and justified wholesale spying on the homeland, you would think that the ascension of Al Qaeda jihadis as the dominant opposition military force in Syria controlling swaths of territory and its resources would prompt the Obama administration to immediately sue for peace with the Syrian government. But you would think wrong. The only change made by the U.S. so far is a rhetorical one. Whereas before it ignored the presence of jihadis, now it is acknowledging the threat they pose, particularly to Syria's chemical weapons stockpile, and using it as a justification to continue its military planning for control of Syria. General Dempsey laments the rise of radical Islamists while at the same time rationalizing coordination with them:
“I am very concerned about the radical element of the opposition, and I am concerned about the potential that extremist ideologies will hijack what started out to be a popular movement to overthrow an oppressive regime,” he said. 
He acknowledged that radical militias, which assumed an ascendant role in the civil war about six months ago, remained a powerful force with some of the best fighters on the rebel side. But in the last six months, he said, the United States has increased its ability to identify moderate opposition leaders, and to begin communicating with them in substantive ways. 
Even so, he acknowledged that battlefield necessity may require radical and moderate militias to cooperate for tactical gains against the Assad government — a convergence that would complicate American and allied policy making.
“It doesn’t surprise me that from time to time they collaborate with each other,” he said. “What we have to be alert for are opportunities to convince the more moderate aspects of the opposition that Syria will be a far better place if the moderate opposition dominates in the end game.”
C.J. Chivers and Eric Schmitt have a story this morning, "Arms Shipments Seen From Sudan to Syria Rebels," outlining an arms pipeline to rebels that flows from Sudan via Ukrainian commercial air transport to Turkey thanks to funds supplied by Qatar. Sudan denies involvement because it receives military and technical assistance from Iran and China, stalwart allies of the Syrian government.

Thursday, August 1, 2013

Peace Talks on Syrian Civil War Will Not Happen

In a story by Michael Gordon written last weekend that appeared in Monday's national edition of the New York Times, the head of the Syrian National Coalition, Ahmad al-Jarba, announced, albeit lukewarmly and with some caveats, that he would meet with Syria's Baathist government for peace talks in Geneva.

Well, the canard didn't last long. Al-Jarba, in a interview yesterday with Qatar News Agency, reversed himself. Ben Hubbard, reporting from Beirut, has the story, "Head of Syrian Opposition Rejects Talks With Assad":
Mr. Jarba could not immediately be reached for comment about his change in position, but Samir Nashar, a member of the coalition, said that Mr. Jarba’s earlier statements on peace talks had upset others in the coalition by suggesting a softer line. 
The coalition had agreed, Mr. Nashar said, that conditions for any talks included removing Mr. Assad from power, the withdrawal from Syria of all fighters who have joined Mr. Assad’s side from Iran and the Lebanese group Hezbollah, and prosecutions for those accused of war crimes. 
Mr. Nashar also said that talks could begin only if the rebels were winning. “Many are refusing to go with the current conditions,” he said. “The opposition won’t go unless there are military achievements on the ground.”
In other words, peace talks can't begin until the Syrian government is prepared for unconditional surrender.

A reading of Hubbard's story leaves one with an renewed understanding of the fictitious nature of the Syrian National Coalition:
The Syrian government has also expressed doubts that the opposition, which is troubled by internal disagreements and rivalries, can honor any agreement reached. 
Mr. Jarba’s organization has limited links to the many groups battling Mr. Assad’s forces in Syria and is not recognized by the extremist battalions linked to Al Qaeda that are often the most effective militarily. 
Momentum in the war has shifted in favor of Mr. Assad in recent weeks as his forces have retaken territory, and many rebel groups have become bogged down in local turf battles and infighting.
Even if a peace agreement were to be reached with the opposition it would mean nothing on the ground. Al Nusra Front and Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham fighters want a caliphate not a democracy; the Kurdistan Workers Party want a Kurdish state. The idea that sitting down and talking with al-Jarba will accomplish anything other than wasting time and diverting attention is now quite clear I think.

What is troubling is today's offering from Michael Gordon, "Some Syria Missiles Eluded Israeli Strike, Officials Say." Based on a leaked classified U.S. intelligence assessment by an unnamed official stating that Israel's July 5 bombing of a warehouse near Latakia did not destroy all the Russia Yakhont antiship cruise missiles stored there, the point of Gordon's spooky story is to announce further Israeli strikes.

The entire piece reads as if it had been written by a loyal government factotum punching the clock at Langley. Bradley Manning is looking at over 100 years in prison for his release of classified information. But his leak didn't bolster the company line.

The second half of Gordon's story is devoted to rehashing the number of foreign forces fighting in Syria for the Assad government: Iranian Quds force, Iraqi Badr Corps, Hezbollah. Any word about the significant Wahhabi groups affiliated with Al Qaeda who are waging jihad against the Syrian government and people? No, not really. We get one sentence, the last, sort of as an afterthought: "Both Saudi Arabia and Qatar have been arming the Syrian rebels, and Congress recently dropped objections to a proposal by President Obama to provide training and light arms to them."

Often these days reading the Gray Lady's coverage of Syria is akin to reading Pravda in the 1950s.

Monday, July 22, 2013

Improved Reporting of Syrian Civil War + ISIS Terror Bombing

As Anne Barnard has been on assignment in Damascus, Ben Hubbard and Hwaida Saad have taken over the daily coverage of the Syrian civil war and there has been a marked improvement in the reporting. Take this morning's offering for instance. In "Across Syria, Violent Day of Attacks and Ambush," the most newsworthy items are placed at the top of the story -- a significant government victory in the town of Adra and ongoing clashes between Kurdish militia and rebels on the northern border with Turkey -- while the news -- bloody fighting in the coastal province of Tartus heavily populated with Alawites and Christians -- that seems to be more like opposition propaganda and is sourced only to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights is placed at the bottom. This order would likely be reversed if Barnard had written the story, and without the caveats that "The account could not be independently confirmed."

It's a refreshing departure for the New York Times, putting it more in line with the reporting provided by Reuters and The Associated Press. Here are the important paragraphs in Hubbard and Saad's story. First, on the rebel setback in Adra:
In the deadliest attack, government forces ambushed a group of rebel fighters in the town of Adra, northeast of Damascus, and left dozens of dead bodies lying in the sand, according to video broadcast on Al Manar, a television station run by Hezbollah, the Lebanese militant group and political party that supports President Bashar al-Assad. 
The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, an anti-Assad group based in Britain that tracks the conflict through a network of contacts on the ground, said on Monday that 65 people had been killed in the countryside around Damascus, including 58 insurgent fighters. The ambush in Adra accounted for 49 rebel deaths. 
It was another blow to the rebel movement. The momentum in the civil war has shifted in favor of Mr. Assad, whose forces have rolled back a number of rebel gains near Damascus, the capital, and elsewhere. Infighting among rebels who took up arms to topple Mr. Assad has allowed his forces to solidify their hold on central Syria and gradually expand their reach.
Next, the Kurds vs. Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS):
Clashes have been raging for days across the ethnically mixed strip of land along the northern border with Turkey, pitting mainstream rebels and extremist groups linked to Al Qaeda against Kurdish militias. The Kurds, Syria’s largest ethnic minority, seek greater control of their own areas and fight to keep the rebels out. 
On Sunday, Kurdish fighters surrounded the local leader of one of the groups linked to Al Qaeda, the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, inside a school he and his fighters were using as a base near the border town of Tel Abyad. Activists said the Kurdish fighters did not storm the school to detain the group’s leader, who is known by the nom de guerre Abu Musab, because they feared he would blow up the school. 
To push the Kurds to grant him safe passage, rebels and the group’s fighters detained hundreds of Kurdish civilians. The two sides finally reached a deal and the group’s leader was released in return for the 300 detained Kurdish civilians, according to the Syrian Observatory group. 
Syria’s Kurds have used the erosion of state control during the civil war to push for greater autonomy in their areas. This has increased tensions with the area’s rebel fighters, many of whom hope to found an Islamic state. Other rebel groups resent the extremists who have joined the fight in Syria to serve their own ends.
With ISIS blowing up mostly civilians throughout Iraq, 250 people have been killed since the start of Ramadan, there has been sparse New York Times reporting from Baghdad. Tim Arango, who had been reporting from Iraq, hasn't been heard from since he covered the Gezi Park protests in Istanbul this June. This is a big failure for the Gray Lady. There is an obvious connection between the violence in Iraq and Syria; it's a regional jihad bankrolled no doubt by wealthy Wahhabis. I am reminded of the Rumsfeldian neoconservative wisdom, "When you've got a problem, often the way to solve it is to first make the problem bigger." Or something to that effect. But if the Times accurately covered the regional nature of the jihad and whose money is making it possible that would queer the anti-Assad pitch of the U.S. State Department that the paper has been parroting in its daily reporting.

Monday, July 8, 2013

Mayhem in Nasr City + Somalia on Turkey's Southern Border

The sit-in in front of the Republican Guard officers' club in Nasr City where deposed president Mohamed Morsi is believed to be held was fired on. Over 40 people are reported dead. This from David Kirkpatrick and Kareem Fahim, "At Least 40 Die as Soldiers Said to Open Fire on Morsi Backers":
Egyptian soldiers opened fire on hundreds of unarmed supporters of ousted President Mohamed Morsi early Monday as they were praying before dawn outside the facility where he is believed to be detained, dozens of witnesses said. 
At least 43 civilians were killed, all or most of them shot, and more than 300 wounded, doctors and health officials said. Security officials said one police officer died as well. 
The attack marked a sharp escalation in the confrontation between the generals who forced out the president and his Islamist supporters in the streets. 
Dozens of Islamists who had gathered in vigil for Mr. Morsi denied there was any provocation for the attack. Two bystanders who had supported Mr. Morsi’s ouster also said that the demonstrators were unarmed and ran in terror as the attack began. 
Bullet holes in cars, lampposts and corrugated metal barriers indicated that gunfire was coming from the top of a nearby building where the sandbag barriers around makeshift gun turrets were visible. Bullet casings on the ground and collected by Islamist demonstrators bore the label of the Egyptian Army.
It would be remarkable if this doesn't spark a move by Islamists away from civil protest to civil war in Egypt. David Kirkpatrick reports that Al Nour, the Salafi party that scuttled the naming of Mohamed ElBaradei as prime minister, has withdrawn from negotiations over the composition of the interim government as a result of the massacre. This might be just as well since Al Nour's bottom line is the inclusion of Islamic law in any Egyptian Constitution. Eventually this was going to be a flash point with the other members of the anti-Morsi coalition. The downside is that it removes the Islamic fig leaf from the anti-Morsi coalition, making it harder to argue this isn't about secularism vs. religion in politics.

Anne Barnard and Hania Mourtada have a story this morning, "Opposition in Syria Continues to Fracture," covered yesterday by Reuters, about fighting between rebels affiliated with the Free Syrian Army and the new Al Qaeda franchise on the block, Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham:
Islamist fighters said recently that they had driven a rival rebel brigade out of Raqqa, a rebel-held provincial capital in northeastern Syria, because they had found some of its fighters drinking wine and consorting with women, and because they considered brigade reluctant to fight.
And in the most recent confrontation, in Dana, a rebel-held town in Idlib Province near the Turkish border, members of an extremist Islamist group were accused of beheading two rival fighters and leaving their severed heads beside a garbage can in a town square.
That grim discovery on Sunday followed a protest and clashes in the town, highlighting the antagonism that some Syrian fighters and civilians are beginning to feel toward some of the radical factions. 
Simmering tensions within the insurgency have intensified lately, especially between rebels affiliated with the Free Syrian Army, the loose-knit umbrella group backed by the West, and members of the Islamic State of Iraq and Al Sham, the new Syria-based affiliate of Al Qaeda, which includes the well-armed fighters of the Nusra Front.
The disputes that have erupted in provinces like Raqqa, Idlib and Aleppo are often centered as much on individual egos and economic resources as on ideology. Still, the frictions inhibit the insurgency from functioning as a single fighting force, and as government forces have appeared to retake control of some rebel-held territory, they are threatening to deepen into a new conflict that would further weaken the rebels on the battlefield.
According to residents, activists and fighters, popular resentment toward radical factions including foreign fighters began sweeping into villages that had been under the control of the Free Syrian Army and trying to impose their strict conception of Islamic law, sometimes even carrying out summary public executions. 
The Nusra and Free Syrian Army fighters have accused each other of profiting from the war, demanding bribes at checkpoints and selling oil from captured wells. The Qaeda-affiliated units are said to be buying up land in Aleppo and Idlib Provinces and trying to monopolize supplies of wheat and fuel, Reuters reported.
The Associated Press is reporting this morning that the SAA has taken the Khaldiyeh district in Homs. There has been intense fighting in the rebel-held areas of Homs. The government appears to be adding territory to its control. And with the news out of Idlib of rebel factions at war with each other and civilians being mowed down in the crossfire, it's time for the warhawk U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry to get real and agree to conditions to get talks underway as soon as possible. Otherwise we're looking at a situation where there will be a Somalia-type Hobbesian state on Turkey's southern border.