Showing posts with label House Republicans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label House Republicans. Show all posts

Thursday, May 4, 2017

The Real Goal of Trumpcare: End Medicaid as We Know It

The purpose of Trumpcare is not only to repeal Obamacare, and with it Obamacare's substantial expansion in Medicaid coverage, but to end Medicaid as we know it by turning it into a block grant program run by the states.

But the fight over pre-existing conditions overshadowed a major reason the Congressional Budget Office estimated that the original bill would leave 24 million more Americans without health insurance after a decade: a rollback of the Affordable Care Act’s Medicaid expansion in states that adopted it. The House plans to vote for the latest version before the budget office can finish a fresh assessment of its cost and impact.
Erica Green deals with the latter in "A Little-Noticed Target in the House Health Bill: Special Education":
With all the sweeping changes the Republican bill would impose, little attention has been paid to its potential impact on education. School districts rely on Medicaid, the federal health care program for the poor, to provide costly services to millions of students with disabilities across the country. For nearly 30 years, Medicaid has helped school systems cover costs for special education services and equipment, from physical therapists to feeding tubes. The money is also used to provide preventive care, such as vision and hearing screenings, for other Medicaid-eligible children.
[snip] 
The new law would cut Medicaid by $880 billion, or 25 percent, over 10 years and impose a “per-capita cap” on funding for certain groups of people, such as children and the elderly — a dramatic change that would convert Medicaid from an entitlement designed to cover any costs incurred to a more limited program.
Capping children and the elderly, curtailing school-based Medicaid programs and assisted living for the aged, basically takes an ax to Medicaid. The principle foundation of social democracy in the U.S. after 30 years of neoliberalism remains Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security. With Trumpcare Medicaid becomes more like unemployment insurance -- at the whim of the individual state.

The whip count for this afternoon's vote is 16 Republican No votes with 35 undeclared. Twenty-three GOP No votes sinks Trumpcare. Let's hope for seven more Republican "nays" in the next six hours.

Friday, April 28, 2017

Trumpcare 2.0 Sign of Political Weakness

Trump is being ridiculed for a second rushed attempt to repeal Obamacare. The accepted point of view is that he is taking a stab at Trumpcare 2.0 in order to have a legislative achievement to celebrate his 100 days in office, which occurs this weekend (Saturday). But more importantly I think Trump knows how to read his base. His flipflopping on almost every single campaign promise has left him vulnerable, even if his (poor) poll numbers show that his stalwart backers are not abandoning him (for now).

If there is one issue on which the Trump True Believer can't abide a flipflop, it is the repeal of Obamacare. The fact that Trump can't wrangle it through the House is proof of his political weakness.

Trumpcare 2.0 brought on board the assassins, the Freedom Caucus, of Trumpcare 1.0 by allowing states to seek waivers from the federal government in order to dispense with basic features of Obamacare -- providing essential benefits, as well as the restriction on charging more to those with preexisting conditions. But Trumpcare 2.0 apparently lost moderate Republicans afraid of voter wrath for taking coverage away from sick people. As Thomas Kaplan and Robert Pear explain in "Health Law Repeal Will Miss Trump’s 100-Day Target Date":
The latest House plan to repeal and replace the health law would include an amendment drafted by Representative Tom MacArthur, Republican of New Jersey and a leader of a centrist bloc of lawmakers called the Tuesday Group.
Mr. MacArthur’s amendment would allow states to opt out of certain provisions of the Affordable Care Act, including one that requires insurers to provide a minimum set of health benefits and another that prohibits insurers from charging higher premiums based on a person’s health status.
Republicans say the federal mandates drive up costs, but Democrats say they provide important protections for consumers.
Under Mr. MacArthur’s amendment, states could obtain waivers letting them redefine the “essential health benefits,” which now include maternity care, emergency services, mental health care and drug addiction treatment.
Republicans say their bill maintains protections for people with pre-existing conditions. But Democrats say the waivers would severely weaken these protections because insurers could charge higher premiums to sick people who wanted to buy insurance after a gap in coverage.
Republicans say their bill offers billions of dollars that states could use to operate high-risk pools or other programs to provide or subsidize insurance for people with pre-existing conditions.
The American Medical Association and AARP, the lobby for older Americans, oppose the latest version of the Republicans’ health care bill.
“Although the MacArthur amendment states that the ban on pre-existing conditions remains intact, this assurance may be illusory, as status underwriting could effectively make coverage completely unaffordable to people with pre-existing conditions,” said Dr. James L. Madara, the chief executive of the American Medical Association.
Mr. MacArthur said Thursday that his amendment had won over some of his Republican colleagues, though not enough to pass the bill. “But we are closer today than we’ve ever been,” he said. “We’re getting there.”
At the same time, his amendment highlighted the gulf between hard-line conservatives and more moderate Republicans when it comes to how to go about repealing and replacing the Affordable Care Act.
For the Freedom Caucus, which shouldered much of the blame for the House bill’s failure last month, the amendment functioned as a way to shift any finger-pointing to a different bloc of members.
But the latest version of the House bill seemed to offer little that would entice anyone with reservations other than the hard-line conservatives.
“The proposed changes to this bill would leave too many of my constituents with pre-existing conditions paying more for health insurance coverage, and too many of them will even be left without any coverage at all,” Representative Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, Republican of Florida, said Thursday.
[snip]
The Senate Democratic leader, Chuck Schumer of New York, argued on Thursday that the core of Mr. MacArthur’s amendment would violate the budget rules that Republicans must follow in order to sidestep a Democratic filibuster.

Monday, March 27, 2017

Trump Flirts with Lame Duck but Obamacare Still in Trouble

Trump's failure to even hold a vote Friday on the Republican overhaul of the Affordable Care Act is a colossal defeat for his two-month-old administration. It might not be an overstatement to call him a lame duck with almost his entire term still ahead.

Trump and Speaker of the House Paul Ryan said they had the votes, when in reality they had nowhere near enough. Trump got rolled, plain and simple (Maureen Dowd's "Donald, This I Will Tell You" makes this point well). The Freedom Caucus, backed by the Koch's constellation of Birchite pressure groups, demanded "poison pill" rewrites of Trumpcare; and when they got those, they demanded more. Trump was exposed not as a consummate artist of the deal, but as a clown, a buffoon huckster.

The silver lining here is that knives are being sharpened in the West Wing. Bannon and company wanted to hold the vote and then start taking the scalps of those Republicans who strayed off the reservation. Ryan carried the day here with his counsel that the fractured caucus needed cover in order to pass Trump's tax reform plan. So no vote on Trumpcare was held.

All this does is kick the can down the road and place the GOP under even more pressure. Revising the tax code is no easy thing. Failure here will deliver an enormous blow not just to Trump but to the GOP and the political system at large. How can a party control all three branches of government and be paralyzed?

Democrats will try to take credit for their defense of Obamacare, but they had little to do with it. It was the Tea Party, the paranoid, Bircher reboot of the Republican Party made possible by the Affordable Care Act, that saved Obamacare and prevented the gutting of Medicaid. What an irony.

Trump is right about one thing though. Obamacare is still in plenty of trouble, and Trump is at the control switch. As Margot Sanger-Katz outlined on Friday in "Trump’s Choice on Obamacare: Sabotage or Co-opt?":
Mr. Trump will need to decide, quickly, whether his goal is to knock over the still-functioning markets, or help prop them up. [Is that even in question? He has publicly stated his strategy going forward: He is waiting for Obamacare to collapse to get another chance to "make a deal."] If he decides to topple them, next year could be very messy.
Insurers are making their decisions right now about whether to enter the markets for next year and about how much to charge their customers. Signals from the administration in the next few weeks about whether he will help or hurt them will almost certainly guide insurers’ choices.
Fight a court case on subsidies? 
The biggest immediate decision concerns a court dispute between the House and the administration over subsidies to help low-income insurance buyers pay their deductibles and co-payments. The House has argued that the money for those subsidies was not properly authorized. The Obama White House fought the case. It is not clear whether Mr. Trump’s lawyers will do the same. The availability of those subsidies, used by a majority of Obamacare customers, is critical for insurers in the markets.
Without the subsidies, all the insurers will lose some money, and many smaller carriers will face bankruptcy. If Mr. Trump does not fight the court case, the Obamacare markets in most states will unravel quickly, leaving millions without insurance options on his watch. Many of the beneficiaries are Trump voters.
Encourage insurance companies in wobbly markets?
There are smaller decisions ahead, too, about how to administer programs, whether to enforce the law’s individual mandate, and whether to recruit insurers to participate in markets where competition is thin.
So far, Mr. Trump’s secretary for health and human services, Tom Price, has taken every opportunity to gloat about the health law’s setbacks, even as he is administering its programs.
Mr. Price, perhaps more than Mr. Trump, has long been committed to the Affordable Care Act’s demise. But now he will have to manage the law’s many programs. Obama administration officials called insurers, cajoling and reassuring them. If Mr. Trump wants the markets to be vigorous, he could use his self-described deal-making skills to woo insurance companies into the stabilizing markets.
Make the system more conservative? 
If Mr. Trump and Mr. Price can make peace with the health law, there are opportunities to steer it in a more conservative direction. The law gives broad authority to the executive branch to shape health care policy. So far, the health law has been driven by Obama administration priorities, but that could change.
A few early regulatory changes have begun that process. The Trump administration plans to make it harder for people to sign up for plans midyear. It has given insurers more wiggle room to raise their deductibles. It may be able to make alterations that loosen up benefit requirements — though it won’t be able to completely eliminate them, as Republicans sought to do at the last minute in the failed bill.
Offer states maximum flexibility? 
The administration will also have enormous power to allow states to reshape their Medicaid programs — and even their local insurance markets — through waivers to existing law. Seema Verma, the just-confirmed administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, was a consultant who helped states write pathbreaking conservative proposals for their Medicaid programs. She is ideally positioned to approve many more such waivers from Republican-led states, allowing them to impose premiums, cost-sharing and even work requirements for Medicaid beneficiaries. 
A new Obamacare waiver program has just gone into effect: It would allow states to overhaul their entire health insurance markets if they can show that their revised plans would cover as many people. That process could allow Ms. Verma and Mr. Price to approve state plans that hew more closely to the Republican vision for health care.
Change Medicare policy?
New powers granted under the Affordable Care Act allow the Department of Health and Human Services to make major changes to the Medicare program, through demonstration projects meant to lower costs and improve patient care. The Obama administration set a precedent of imposing “mandatory” projects on large portions of the country to test policy ideas. So far, Mr. Price has looked askance at such efforts. But the provision could give him power to reshape what Medicare pays for and how seniors receive their care.
Nicholas Bagley, a law professor at the University of Michigan, has criticized the Obama administration for stretching its legal authority with some of its Obamacare choices. But those choices have created a precedent for the Trump administration to stretch the health law in its own direction. “If you think Congress is done, and you don’t want to provoke a reaction anymore, then you own this,” he said. “You will be judged as an executive on the performance of Obamacare.”
For years, opposing Obamacare has been a rallying cry for Republicans. But if Republicans can’t repeal Obamacare, they could instead co-opt it. There are opportunities for Trumpcare yet.

Thursday, March 23, 2017

Trumpcare Triumphant?

Republican leadership and Trump say that they have the votes to pass the American Health Care Act (AHCA), a.k.a., Trumpcare, the oft-promised repeal of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), a.k.a., Obamacare. The House vote is today. But no one knows for sure if it will pass.

The House Freedom Caucus is driving the vote. Backed by a formidable array of uber-conservative organizations -- Americans for Prosperity, FreedomWorks, Freedom Partners Chamber of Commerce, Heritage Action for America and the Club for Growth -- the Freedom Caucus rallying cry is one of sadism: "Essential Health Benefits," the part of Obamacare that "requires insurers to cover a base set of benefits, like maternity care, preventive services, wellness checkups and rehabilitative services," currently part of Trumpcare, must be stripped out (see "House Republicans Search for Votes to Repeal Obamacare" by Thomas Kaplan and Robert Pear) in order to lower premiums.

The problem for Trump and Ryan is that the more they move in the direction of the Freedom Caucus the more Trumpcare becomes radioactive for other Republicans. Even without the repeal of the Essential Health Benefits requirement, Trumpcare's chances of passing the Senate are remote.

The House vote is basically a charade that is conjuring up memories of the 2003 Medicare prescription drug benefit vote when clocks froze for hours as Billy Tauzin bribed his way to 216 votes.

I think we are in that territory today. It is accepted that if Trump can't get Trumpcare out of the House, the rest of his legislative agenda, what of it that there is (more tax cuts?), is cooked. That's why I expect that the American Health Care Act, in some monstrous form, will find its way to the Senate.

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

GOP Got What it Needed from the CBO

The GOP got the score it wanted from the CBO. Not the 24 million people without health insurance by 2026, but the $337 billion reduction in the federal deficit over ten years. Now the Freedom Caucus, who has been calling the House plan to repeal the Affordable Care Act, "Obamacare-lite," can more easily support the bill.

I don't have a clear sense if the Republicans can whip this out of the House. If they are able to, it will be an enormous defeat for the post-election Democratic reboot and campaigns like #ResistanceRecess.

What appears to be happening is that there is a lot of legitimate grassroots organizing going on, but it is having difficulty projecting its power because it is either aligned with or butting up against the established institution of the Democratic Party.

We'll have a front-row seat for this conflict in my city when a progressive coalition that goes by the name "Trump Proof Seattle" attempts to push a citywide wealth tax through the city council of 1.5% on every dollar over $250,000 of annual income. The coalition will soon realize that politicians, even at the district level of a smallish large city like Seattle, are captive to an elite donor class.

What then for the "Resistance"? A mass movement to anarchism? That would be nice. Greater though are the odds that activism will go the way of the anti-war movement of the last decade, receding into a cyber-Panglossian tending of one's own garden.

Monday, March 13, 2017

Obamacare Repeal to be Scored by CBO this Week

Despite all the news last week about division in Republican ranks over their plan to repeal Obamacare, I wouldn't bet against it passing out of the House. The Senate is another story. The Republicans only have a slim majority, 52-48, there.

The House Republican plan to repeal Obamacare, for all its shortcomings, achieves two fundamental GOP goals: it redistributes wealth back up to the 1%, and it block-grants Medicaid.

Jessie Drucker reports in "Wealthy Would Get Billions in Tax Cuts Under Obamacare Repeal Plan" that "Two of the biggest tax cuts in Republican proposals to repeal the Affordable Care Act would deliver roughly $157 billion over the coming decade to those with incomes of $1 million or more, according to a congressional analysis."

Thad Kouusser wrote in The Hill recently, "GOP's Medicaid block grant plan should trump other concerns" --
Medicaid block grants seem at first glance like an obscure debate for the few policy wonks who care about federal funding formulas. But the outcome of this particular fight in D.C. will reverberate across all 50 states for decades to come.
Shifting from “matching rates” to a block grant for Medicaid is not a new demand from the insurgent populist Trump, but the recycling of an idea that has been proposed by small-government advocates from Newt Gingrich to George W. Bush to Paul Ryan. In January, Kellyanne Conway made it clear that they will form a centerpiece of the Trump administration’s health care policy, and they have appeared in what Trump called on Twitter “Our wonderful new Healthcare Bill.”
Though they have garnered little attention in the campaign or even today, block grants would allow Trump to unwind the biggest gains that ObamaCare made for our most vulnerable citizens, radically reduce government investment in healthcare over time, force states to make even deeper cuts when the next recession comes along, but leave no political fingerprints.
A lot is riding on the CBO scoring of the House bill. According to Kevin Quealy and Margo Sanger Katz in "The Five Big Numbers to Look For in the C.B.O. Report on Health Care Reform":
The Republican plan to replace the Affordable Care Act was released early last week, and it has already marched through consideration in two important committees. Yet members of Congress debated the policy details without essential information: The bill had not yet been “scored” by the Congressional Budget Office, a nonpartisan group of budget analysts and economists whose job is to forecast the bill’s consequences over the next decade or so.
That score is expected this week, and its estimates could make or break the Republicans’ plan. (The White House has pre-emptively cast doubt on the C.B.O. report.)
We'll see how politicized the CBO is. The big number for political purposes will be the increase in the federal deficit over ten years. If it is large, it will be hard for the Tea Party wing of the GOP to back it.

Thursday, June 16, 2016

Edsall in Pottstown, PA: For the GOP the 2016 Election is All About the Down-Ticket

I used to read Thomas Edsall's column every week. But then I switched employers, and I no longer had to while away the hours on the train. Consistently excellent, Edsall's reporting usually tells the story of a country wracked by inequality and economic dislocation while its major political parties struggle with how to win votes without doing anything to address the voters' concerns.

This week Edsall describes a visit to postindustrial Pottstown, PA, "Measuring the Trump Effect," where support for the presumptive Republican presidential nominee breaks down along gender lines:
My interviews this week with Pottstown voters in working and middle class white neighborhoods showed almost no support for Trump among women, but steady support among men.
“I like him because he is to the point, and it’s time for a change, I think he’s got the oomph to rattle some cages,” John Keyser, a nonunion employee at Universal Concrete Products Corporation, said. Universal Concrete is one of the few manufacturing facilities left in the area. Keyser told me that he usually votes for Democrats and thinks that Bill Clinton was “one of the greatest and best presidents we ever had.” But this year he supports Trump:
I’d rather have somebody who does get angry and has feelings than what we have had with politicians who don’t care either way. I like the emotional involvement.
In a number of cases, local support for Trump among white men was based as much on their animosity to Hillary Clinton as it was on their faith in Trump.
“I’d vote for the devil before I would ever vote for that woman,” said a man in his 60s who identified himself only as Keith. In a phrase repeated by at least three others, Keith said that Hillary Clinton “belongs in jail.”
Stacey Weinstein, a 53-year-old psychiatric social worker, reflected the opposite side of the coin: she distrusts Clinton, but sees Trump as by far the worse choice.
“I’m not terribly enthusiastic about her because I think she has done some very underhanded things,” Weinstein said, but “Donald Trump is a misogynist, and I don’t like misogynists.”
What stood out in the interviews I conducted on June 13 here and in an upscale development in East Goshen, 24 miles south of Pottstown, was that the Trump supporters were male, with one exception; Clinton backers were decisively (but not exclusively) women.
News consumers would be better informed if more reporters did what Edsall does in this week's column -- go to a town; describe briefly its history, both demographic and economic; and ask people what they think about the candidates. The interviews he quotes breathe fresh air and provide a slice of life we too rarely get to sample. It's too bad that Edsall only appears online and not in NYT's national print edition.

The rest of the story Edsall wrestles with the down-ticket ramifications of Trump's candidacy. This is the $64,000 question for the GOP and explains why party leaders have vacillated so when it comes to embracing or criticizing Trump. Basically the Republican Party is trapped and elders don't know what to do. Look at Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell. First, he said the party would run attack ads in select states against its own nominee if it ends up being Trump. Then he was one of the first high-profile Republicans in Congress to endorse Trump.

For the GOP it is all about protecting its majorities in the Senate and House, which means inoculating its down-ticket from any Trump backlash at the same time it grabs whatever ride is available on Trump's coattails. Maybe such a calculation is possible at the level of the individual race, but certainly not at the national level. That's why Congressional Republicans seem so adrift when it comes to Trump, and it is not something that is going to be solved between now and November. The GOP hope is to fudge things and not lose too many seats.

Monday, September 28, 2015

Hard Times in U.S. Aborning: Putin and Trump on 60 Minutes

There is an ample amount of handwringing and "Oh, woeisme"ing among the political class and power brokers on the Potomac following Friday's surprise announcement by Republican Speaker of the House John Boehner that he plans on resigning effective October 30. Take this delightful passage from "John Boehner’s Move Deepens a Republican Chasm" by David Herszenhorn and Jonathan Martin:
The hard-liners seem poised to attack a likely deal this week between Mr. Boehner and Democrats to avoid a government shutdown as yet another example of collusion between establishment Republican leaders and the Obama White House. 
And the legislative stakes will become greater. Congress will most likely have to vote this fall on whether to raise the federal debt ceiling as well as deal with the imminent expiration of many highway programs, a continuing debate over reauthorizing the Export-Import Bank and the need for a longer-term spending bill with an expected deadline of Dec. 11. 
Standing in the Speaker’s Lobby just off the House floor, Representative Bill Pascrell Jr., Democrat of New Jersey, predicted that Mr. Boehner’s departure would make things harder rather than easier. “November and December are going to be like Dante’s ‘Inferno’ around here,” he said.
Things are indeed headed for the cliff. And not just the kind of "fiscal cliff" that Congress and Obama faced after his landslide victory over Richie Rich Romney at the end of 2012. This cliff might be more akin to a helicopter taking off from a besieged Saigon embassy with panicked asylum-seekers clutching for dear life to the skids.

A complete collapse of belief in the official state is underway in the Western world. Whether people position themselves on the left or the right of the ideological spectrum, all agree that the status quo is a fucked up place and elected leadership is not representing the interests of "We the people."

I watched 60 Minutes last night probably for only the second or third time since NBC began televising Sunday Night Foot in the same slot ten years ago. A Charlie Rose interview with Russian President Vladimir Putin, "All eyes on Putin," kicked the show off.

Two of the better exchanges had to do with the principal canard peddled by the United States and dutifully repeated by European leaders; this is the propaganda that Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad is attacking his own people, and that if only Assad would leave everything would start to improve right away.
Charlie Rose: President Assad, you support him. Do you support what he is doing in Syria and what is happening to those Syrian people, those many millions of refugees and the hundreds of thousands of people that have been killed, many by his own force? 
President Putin: Well, tell me, what do you think about those who support the opposition and mainly the terrorist organizations only in order to oust Assad without thinking about what will happen to the country after all the government institutions have been demolished? Today, you have repeatedly said that Assad is fighting against his own population. But look at those who are in control of 60 percent of the territory in Syria. It's controlled by either ISIS or by others-- 
Charlie Rose: Al-Nusra? 
President Putin: --such as al-Nusra and other terrorist organizations. They are recognized as terrorist organizations by the United States, by other states and by the United Nations.
And a little later, this exchange:
Charlie Rose: I come back to the problem that many people look at. And they believe that Assad helps ISIS. That his reprehensible conduct against the Syrian people using barrel bombs and worse is a recruiting tool for ISIS and that if he was removed, transitioned, at some point, it would be better in the fight against ISIS, al-Nusra and others. 
President Putin: Well, speaking in a professional language of intelligence services I can tell you that this kind of assessment is an "active measure" by enemies of Assad. It is anti-Syrian propaganda.
The U.S. game in Iraq and Syria is rapidly unraveling thanks to Russian efforts. The kabuki of the U.S. military combating the Salafist jihadis while those jihadis continue to gain territory and destabilize the region has been exposed by recent Russian moves, such as yesterday's announcement of an intelligence-sharing agreement between Russia, Iran, Iraq and Syria. The U.S. complains about Iraq's participation but there is nothing it can do. The Obama administration has very little credibility on the issue, particularly given the refugee crisis in Europe (not to mention its support for the war crimes against Yemen).

After the Charlie Rose interview of Putin, the next segment was Scott Pelley's interrogation, "Trump gets down to business on 60 Minutes," of the man who is likely the next POTUS, billionaire blowhard Donald Trump.

If you want an introduction to Trump, this interview is an excellent primer. The man is mesmerizing. Listening to him is like riding a roller coaster. The fact some of what he is saying is gibberish will not bother most American voters.

Here is the gibberish passage. He is going to implement a national health-care system that provides universal coverage but that is privately run but is not Obamacare:
Scott Pelley: What's your plan for Obamacare? 
Donald Trump: Obamacare's going to be repealed and replaced. Obamacare is a disaster if you look at what's going on with premiums where they're up 40, 50, 55 percent.
Scott Pelley: How do you fix it?
Donald Trump: There's many different ways, by the way. Everybody's got to be covered. This is an un-Republican thing for me to say because a lot of times they say, "No, no, the lower 25 percent that can't afford private. But--"
Scott Pelley: Universal health care.
Donald Trump: I am going to take care of everybody. I don't care if it costs me votes or not. Everybody's going to be taken care of much better than they're taken care of now.
Scott Pelley: The uninsured person is going to be taken care of. How? How?
Donald Trump: They're going to be taken care of. I would make a deal with existing hospitals to take care of people. And, you know what, if this is probably--
Scott Pelley: Make a deal? Who pays for it?
Donald Trump: --the government's gonna pay for it. But we're going to save so much money on the other side. But for the most it's going to be a private plan and people are going to be able to go out and negotiate great plans with lots of different competition with lots of competitors with great companies and they can have their doctors, they can have plans, they can have everything.
Trump sounded jejune when he weighed in on Iraq and Syria, but almost like Ralph Nader when he talked about the offshoring of U.S. jobs:
Scott Pelley: How do you keep them from exporting American jobs to Mexico?
Donald Trump: Let's say Ford-- let's say Ford moves to Mexico. If they want to sell that car in the United States they pay a tax. Here's what's gonna happen, they're not going to build their plant there. They're going to build it in the United States.
Scott Pelley: But there is a North American Free Trade Agreement.
Donald Trump: And there shouldn't be. It's a disaster.
Scott Pelley: But it is there.
Donald Trump: OK, yeah, but--
Scott Pelley: If you're president, you're going to have to live with it.
Donald Trump: Excuse me, we will either renegotiate it or we will break it. Because, you know, every agreement has an end.
Scott Pelley: You can't just break the law.
Donald Trump: Excuse me, every agreement has an end. Every agreement has to be fair. Every agreement has a defraud clause. We're being defrauded by all these countries.
Scott Pelley: It's called free trade--
Donald Trump: No it's not.
Scott Pelley: --and it is a plank--
Donald Trump: It's not the--
Scott Pelley: --of the Republican platform.
Donald Trump: Scott we need fair trade. Not free trade. We need fair trade. It's gotta be fair.
It is going to be hard to beat Trump.

Thursday, September 10, 2015

Nate Silver and Nate Cohn in Basic Agreement with Ayatollah Khamenei + Half of the Satanic Duopoly Begins a "Draft Kerry" Campaign

The place to begin this morning is a quote from Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei (Thomas Erbrink, "Iran’s Supreme Leader Says Israel Won’t Exist in 25 Years"):
Iranians must not forget that the United States is the “Great Satan,” Ayatollah Khamenei warned, criticizing those calling for better relations. “Some want to show this Satan as an angel, but the Iranian nation has pushed this Satan out,” he said. “We should not allow it to sneak back in through the window.”
As GOP dead-enders in the House of Representatives seek to satisfy their Saudi and Likud paymasters by delaying debate on the agreement over Iran's nuclear program, American voters are of a similar mind as Ayatollah Khamenei. They want to throw out Satan.

The two halves of Satan's brain -- the Republican-Democrat duopoly -- are having a difficult time processing this information. Nate Cohn today, "Donald Trump vs. the Party: Why He’s Still Such a Long Shot," still cannot accept that he was wrong back in July when he dismissed Trump as a flash in the pan. His argument that Trump cannot win now seems to rely on the fact that America is actually not a democracy. Elite party opinion, not voters, decide who a nominee is:
For past candidates, elite support has been necessary, and unified party opposition has been fatal. Without elite support, an ordinary candidate can’t build a top campaign or raise big money or draw major attention from traditional media. 
Party opposition is even worse. It ensures a chorus of influential critics in the media and a well-funded opponent with endless resources for advertisements to echo the attacks. Grass-roots support and super PACs can help compensate for a lack of broad support, but they probably can’t overcome broad opposition. The voice of the elites is too strong and influential.
The blogging sage, Nate Silver, the guy Nate Cohn was hired to replace, basically agrees with his replacement ("Stop Comparing Donald Trump And Bernie Sanders"):
What Sanders and Trump have in common is they’re both unlikely to be nominated. (If I were laying odds, I’d put either one at something like 15-1 or 20-1 against.) But it’s for different reasons. Sanders is losing now, but if he eventually overtakes Clinton — and if Biden fails to come to the establishment’s rescue — his position might become more viable. Trump is nominally winning, but the GOP race is much more volatile. And if he doesn’t lose steam on his own accord, the Republican establishment will use every tool at its disposal to stop him.
Sanders and Trump cannot win because voters in the United States really don't choose their leaders. That's the point of view that Silver and Cohn are peddling here. Where Iran's supreme leader interprets this as evidence of Great Satan, what is disappointing to me is that I don't think the two Nates do.

Democrats are reading the same tea leaves, and they are pitifully casting about for a stand-in should Hillary continue to falter. For a particularly dire assessment of the state of the Democratic Party, Patrick Healy's "Big-Name Plan B’s for Democrats Concerned About Hillary Clinton" is a must-read:
It is not just Mrs. Clinton’s weakness in the polls that has generated talk of other alternatives, but also the strength of Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, who is routinely drawing huge crowds at campaign events. That has been disconcerting to Democratic officials who believe that Mr. Sanders, a socialist, is so liberal that his presence at the top of the party’s ticket in 2016 would be disastrous. 
“If party leaders see a scenario next winter where Bernie Sanders has a real chance at the Democratic nomination, I think there’s no question that leaders will reach out to Vice President Biden or Secretary of State Kerry or even Gore about entering the primaries,” said Garnet F. Coleman, a Texas state lawmaker and Democratic national committeeman.
***
“You have Democrats beginning to panic about the one thing that a lot of them never worried about, which was Clinton’s electability in the general election,” said Robert Shrum, a veteran strategist who was a senior adviser to Mr. Gore and Mr. Kerry during their presidential runs. “You still have to think of her as the odds-on favorite for the Democratic nomination. But the challenge she faces in the general election is both the trust problem and the likability problem.”
The bottom line on Healy's piece? A draft Kerry movement is lurching to life. A true sign of desperation.

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

The Cantor Bombshell

Sitting down last night to a modest repast of grocery-store sushi, the computer monitor offered up a surprise nosegay. The serpent-like Eric Cantor, Republican House Majority Leader and one of the architects of the 2010 Tea Party revolution, had been resoundingly defeated in Virginia's 7th Congressional District primary by a Tea-Party backed Randolph-Macon econ professor, Dave Brat.

Cantor, who spearheaded most of the high-drama budget-based brinkmanship of the 112th and 113th Congresses -- the fiscal cliff, the sequester, the debt ceiling, the government shutdown last October -- ended up being hoisted by his own petard.

There will be much discussion in the next few days of what caused Cantor's undoing. For a member of the House leadership to lose a primary, and to lose by a landslide -- 10%, is almost unheard of. Jonathan Martin's frontpage synopsis, "Eric Cantor Defeated by David Brat, Tea Party Challenger, in G.O.P. Primary Upset," points to the Majority Leader's insufficiently hostile stance on immigration as the possible cause of his undoing. But what is apparent to me is that Cantor lost because he is seen as a fat cat wheeler dealer who represents an establishment that has failed to deliver anything at all for the average citizen:
Republicans were so sure that Mr. Cantor would win that most party leaders had been watching for how broad his victory would be. His defeat will reverberate in the capital and could have major implications for any chance of an immigration overhaul. 
Mr. Cantor, 51, who is in his seventh term, had sought to counter Mr. Brat’s accusations that he was too willing to compromise on immigration. The majority leader, who had raised $5.4 million for the campaign, blanketed Virginia’s Seventh Congressional District with fliers and television advertisements in which he emphasized that he opposed an “amnesty” policy. 
Apparently, Brat went hat in hand looking for help from the big ultra-conservative groups (without knowing for sure, I would imagine he talked to Club for Growth and Americans for Prosperity) but got nowhere:
Mr. Brat had little help from national groups that have funded other Tea Party challengers. Instead, he relied mostly on state and local activists. 
Larry Nordvig, executive director of the Richmond Tea Party, said the national groups were not aware of “how much activity was going on underneath the surface down here and how large the ABC — Anybody But Cantor — mentality was.”
Jonathan Weisman, per usual, is the reporter to turn to (writing here with Jennifer Steinhauer) for the straight dope, "Cantor’s Loss a Bad Omen for Moderates":
One measure of the extraordinary defeat could be seen in the candidate’s finances. Since the beginning of last year, Mr. Cantor’s campaign had spent about $168,637 at steakhouses compared with the $200,000 his challenger, David Brat, had spent on his entire campaign. With Mr. Cantor out, members from solidly Republican states will almost certainly be vying for one of the top jobs, if not Mr. Boehner’s gavel. The current Republican leadership slate is filled with members from swing states where the pressure to moderate views on topics such as immigration looms.
What is going on here is the same thing as the European Parliament elections a couple weeks back; it is the"Ballad of a Thin Man." Seismic change is rumbling right under foot and the mainstream -- the prestige press, the establishment pols -- is not registering it. As Nancy Pelosi parties into the Georgetown night celebrating the the unexpected bonanza of Cantor's demise, the system continues its collapse.

What is maddening is that it is all so obvious. Capitalism is not spreading the wealth, producing employment. People are fed up, want change. Once again, Thomas Edsall has an excellent op-ed, "The Downward Ramp," that pretty much sums it up:
With the bursting of the tech bubble at the start of the 21st century, two decades of growth at the high end of the job market — once the province of college graduates with strong cognitive abilities — came to an abrupt halt, according to detailed studies of employment and investment patterns by three Canadian economists. We are still feeling the ramifications. 
But new evidence produced by Paul Beaudry and David A. Green of the University of British Columbia, and Ben Sand of York University, demonstrates that the collapse, between 1980 and 2000, of mid-level, mid-pay jobs — gutted by automation or foreign competition (and often both) — has now spread to the high-skill labor market. 
The U-shaped pattern of job growth characteristic of recent decades – strong at the top and bottom, but weak throughout the middle — has now become “a bit more like a downward ramp,” according to David Autor, an economist at M.I.T. who documented the decline in mid-level jobs in the 1980s and 1990s. 
Preliminary findings suggest that this trend is alarming in almost every respect. Just one example: the drying up of cognitively demanding jobs is having a cascade effect. College graduates are forced to take jobs beneath their level of educational training, moving into clerical and service positions instead of into finance and high tech. 
This cascade eliminates opportunities for those without college degrees who would otherwise fill those service and clerical jobs. These displaced workers are then forced to take even less demanding, less well-paying jobs, in a process that pushes everyone down. At the bottom, the unskilled are pushed out of the job market altogether.
Edsall's columns, focused on the politics of inequality and race, provide a codekey of the neoliberal paradigm.
Larry Mishel, president of the Economic Policy Institute and a co-author of a major new study of employment patterns, wrote me that “Beaudry et al are finding exactly what we find.” The E.P.I. report, “Raising America’s Pay,” points out that “entry-level hourly wages fell on average for both female and male college graduates from 2000 to 2013 (8.1 percent among women and 6.7 percent among men).” 
These trends are certain to reverberate into the political system.
The downward pressures means that the problem of declining opportunity will now be a fact of life across nearly all classes.
But the political system, captured as it is by the 1%, is unable to address the problem. So you have the fringe parties kicking ass in the European elections and now the Cantor bombshell. Expect more bombs to drop.

Monday, March 10, 2014

C.J. Chivers Plumbs New Propaganda Low

With bluster, propaganda and probably a number of covert operations we don't know anything about yet, the United States continues to play out its weak hand in the Ukraine. On the propaganda front, a new low in is on frontpage display in the Gray Lady today. Written by C.J. Chivers, the author last September of the now debunked "smoking gun" article arguing that azimuth data taken from impact craters "proved" that Syrian government forces launched the August 21 chemical weapons attack on the Ghouta suburb, "A Kiev Question: What Became of the Missing?" takes an issue, post-putsch missing protesters, that even the Maidan group, Euromaidan S O S, tasked with finding the "disappeared" dismisses as much ado about nothing and blows it up into a sort of killing fields whodunnit:
In all, 661 people have been reported missing since protests began last December, according to Euromaidan S O S, a volunteer group leading efforts to find the disappeared. The fates of 272 of them remained unknown late last week. 
Many people were found in prison cells or hospitals, or resurfaced on their own, said Vitaliy Selyk, a Euromaidan S O S coordinator. Some cases were caused by breakdowns in communications, including people who lost cellphones or ran out of credit on SIM cards, he said. 
A few of the missing were people estranged from families and whose recent silence was by choice. Mr. Selyk said he expected that most of the remaining cases would be solved and that the missing would turn up. 
But beneath that hope lies the grim concern that many Ukrainians may have disappeared after being seized by the Berkut riot police unit, by pro-Russian provocateurs or by unofficial forces that worked to keep Mr. Yanukovych in power.
From there C.J. Chivers repeats every dark rumor and every bit of fantastical bloody innuendo he can muster, not to mention re-reporting all the tales of pre-putsch savagery alleged to have been committed by shadowy Russian-speaking allies of the Yanukovych security forces. It is a sorry, sloppy attempt to occlude the story gaining attention in the European press, that, as The Guardian reported last week in a leaked phone conversation between  Estonian Foreign Minister Urmas Paet and the EU's Catherine Ashton, "[S]nipers responsible for killing police and civilians in Kiev last month were protest movement provocateurs rather than supporters of then-president Viktor Yanukovych."

Once this story hits the U.S. market, any hope of the Obama administration salvaging even a shred of credibility would seem to be a distant one. The Crimea secession vote is this Sunday. I would imagine that neither the Paet-Ashton conversation nor Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov's request for an OSCE investigation into the Maidan snipers will get any play in the U.S. media until the results of the vote are tallied.

And speaking of a vote count, Jonathan Weisman has a story, "House Republicans Balk at Wording in Obama Emergency Aid Package for Ukraine," about difficulties the Obama administration is having getting the money to the putschists. It has to do with a reorganization of the International Monetary Fund that conservative Republicans are unwilling to go along with because of a perception that it would weaken U.S. control of the IMF; there is language in the Ukraine aid bill "that would extend a separate billion-dollar package of loans from the fund to $1.6 billion by expanding loan limits for countries like Ukraine." As with the effort to bomb Syria last summer, Obama is having problems getting a green light from Congress.

How long will Obama maintain his bluff when it is obvious that the hand he holds is a losing one?

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

The End of Debt-Ceiling Politics + Hillary vs. Scott Walker in 2016?

The news arrived yesterday with little fanfare; it might not have even been the top story on the Google News page. But it is certainly a noteworthy development. The House of Representatives passed a clean debt ceiling bill -- meaning there are no conditions attached, no quid pro quo, no Keystone XL pipeline, no nibbling away at Obamacare -- raising the amount that government can legally borrow through march 2015. This morning Jonathan Weisman and Ashley Parker have the story, "House Approves Higher Debt Limit Without Condition."

It is an enormous capitulation by Speaker of the House John Boehner, who had to rely on overwhelming Democratic support (only 28 Republicans voted yes). After three years, the GOP strategy of locking down D.C. with debt-ceiling brinkmanship has been tossed on the dung heap. Last October's near Armageddon must have been enough for the national Republican brain trust, particularly when the GOP was awarded a Get Out of Jail Free card with Obamacare's disastrous online rollout. Republican leadership is keeping eyes on the prize: the U.S. Senate and possibly even the White House. Towards that goal they obviously feel that a low profile, coupled with an aggressive beatdown on Tea Party primary challengers, will deliver them to the promised land.

Clearly there is wisdom in leaving Obama to stew in his own shit. (See Monday's post for Obama's plummeting approval rating as well as the country's burgeoning socialist populism.) But Boehner's adroit elimination of debt-ceiling politics on Tuesday comes at a steep price for the GOP. The internecine warfare between the corporate-financed Tea Party and the Republican establishment which, for the most part, has been kept off the front pages (left to rage online) is now going to -- or at least there is that potential -- blow up big time. As Weisman and Parker point out,
For Mr. Boehner it was a potentially momentous decision. Conservative activists, including the Tea Party Patriots, FreedomWorks, L. Brent Bozell’s ForAmerica and commentators on the website RedState.com are all circulating petitions to end Mr. Boehner’s speakership. 
And it was Mr. Boehner who raised such high expectations around the debt limit. In 2011, he established what has become known as the “Boehner Rule”: any debt ceiling increase was supposed to be offset by an equivalent spending cut. 
“This is a lost opportunity,” the speaker conceded. “We could have sat down and worked together in a bipartisan manner to find cuts and reforms that are greater than increasing the debt limit. I am disappointed, to say the least.”
Also, there is this tasty morsel a few paragraphs down:
In a closed-door session Monday night, Representative Andy Harris, Republican of Maryland, accused the speaker of being in the pockets of the insurance industry, a charge that stirred outrage among many of his colleagues.
There is a good chance, I think, that it will blow over quickly. It probably already has. More extreme weather in the South, Tom Brokaw diagnosed with cancer, etc., will suck up the attention of news consumers.

I have a coworker who follows the daily news. When she gave me a ride to the train station yesterday after work I asked her what she thought about the House passing the debt ceiling. She said that she had glimpsed the headline right before we left, but that she didn't read the story or really even think about it.

Chalk up a "W" for Boehner and the GOP establishment.

Before signing off, I'd like to mention that Trip Gabriel has a good story, "In Governors’ Races This Year, Lessons for 2016," about Republican governors running for reelection. He focuses on four Republicans in the industrial North -- Walker of Wisconsin, Kasich of Ohio, Snyder of Michigan and Corbett of Pennsylvania:
National Democratic groups hope to take back the four executive mansions held by Rust Belt Republicans by attacking on social and economic issues — the incumbents’ cuts to education, their opposition to raising the minimum wage and abortion restrictions they signed into law. 
“They’ve all fostered hostility and divisiveness despite running as moderate technocrats,” said Danny Kanner, a spokesman for the Democratic Governors Association, which bought its first television ads of the 2014 cycle in Michigan, attacking Mr. Snyder. “On the economy, they gave huge tax cuts to the wealthiest and corporations. They paid for it by raising middle-class taxes, and because that wasn’t enough, they cut education.” 
Mr. Walker’s bitter 2011 showdown with the unions made him a national figure. He remains a hero of the Republican grass roots and a favorite of wealthy donors like the billionaire David H. Koch, who founded a nonprofit group that contributed heavily to the governor’s campaign to avoid a recall. That appeal to the party’s base and its donor class has some conservative pundits and strategists banging the drum for a presidential bid. 
Mr. Walker, who insists that his focus is on 2014, seems to gain in stature each day that enthusiasm for Gov. Chris Christie, Republican of New Jersey, ebbs in the scandal over the closing of bridge lanes. 
But Mr. Walker has also helped polarize his battleground state. A Marquette University Law School poll last month showed his job approval reaching a high — of just 51 percent.
Can you imagine a more nauseating general election in 2016 than Hillary vs. Scott Walker? It would be 12 months of rockem sockem corporate robots.

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Tea Party Destroying "Capitalism in One Country"

It's hard to see how the United States avoids default. Boehner's gambit to deflate Senate negotiations by offering up a House deal was successful for a day before the effort collapsed; once again, he couldn't line up the ultras in his caucus. The deal Boehner was trying to piece together would have taken the main components of the deal being hatched in the Senate -- paying for the operation of government through January 15; lifting the debt ceiling through February 7 -- and added Tea Party sweeteners in the form of forcing Congressional staff members to purchase Obamacare without subsidy and putting limits on what the Treasury Department can to to manage payments once the debt ceiling has been reached.

That Boehner could not garner Tea Party support for his debt-ceiling/government-shutdown deal makes it close to certain that anything that emerges from Senate negotiations today will not have Tea Party support in the House. So -- not to belabor a point made on this blog repeatedly the last two weeks -- it will be up to Boehner -- as he has done in the past with the fiscal cliff and storm relief -- to allow an up-or-down vote and to pass a bill with majority support from the Democrats.

Even if a way out of a financial meltdown is found at the eleventh hour, lasting damage has been done. Damien Cave has an interesting story today, "Viewing U.S. in Fear and Dismay," which is a collection of quotes, some by people on their way to work, from around the world:
“The U.S.’s exorbitant privilege” — of issuing the world’s most widely accepted currency — “allows it not to have a budget, to bump against debt limit with scant market reaction,” said Luis de la Calle, a Mexican economist. 
If Mexico and many other countries shut down their governments, stopped paying salaries and threatened to default, he added, the titans of global finance, as they have in the past, would make sure the consequences were swift and severe. “We have little choice but to be responsible,” Mr. de la Calle said.
What we're going through is the concentration of capitalism in one country -- this is a point that the Monthly Review has made in the past, sort of an upside down postmodern version of Stalin's "Socialism in One Country" -- combined with the reactionary, revanchist capture of one of the parties making up the duopoly.

The Tea Party was organized and financed by plutocrats fearing the progressive majority that elected Obama, twice; at the time that it was whipped into being by the captains of capital, back in the summer of 2009, I thought it revealed how desperate and out of touch conservative power brokers were. Now, as "Capitalism in One Country" starts to dissolve, the strategy of empowering the Tea Party has backfired. Clearly.

Thursday, October 3, 2013

Tea Party Revanchism


After meeting last night with Speaker of the House John Boehner, along with Senate majority leader Harry Reid and House minority leader Nancy Pelosi, Obama's stated position is that "grand bargain" talks on the federal budget can begin once the government reopens with a clean funding resolution and the debt ceiling is raised.

Republicans promptly rejected this. They have no intention of giving up their leverage, which is what agreeing to Obama's conditions would entail. The GOP has no wish to enter into negotiations. Republicans have been sidestepping budget talks for the entire year. They have no intention of giving something up to get something in return. They think that Obama can be made to cave in.

Already sights are set on October 17, the deadline when the federal government reaches the debt ceiling. The Tea Party now sees that once you go over the brink, as it has with the government shutdown, it no longer provides any strategic advantage; in fact, it becomes a liability.

And that's where we are at now. Can the Tea Party caucus wagging the dog in the House remain intact for the next two weeks until the next brink, the debt ceiling deadline?

There was a sharp drop off from late morning on yesterday in interest in the government shutdown. I measure this by the number of stories that appear on the Google News page and the chatter among my office coworkers. So there is the possibility that the country could muddle along for the next two weeks with a government shutdown as the new normal. But bit by bit the GOP will suffer, and overall there is no question that they are losing the propaganda war. I am doubtful that House Republicans can hold out until October 17. Obama is putting Wall Street to work on lobbying the GOP leadership. This might not bear fruit this week -- I originally thought the Tea Party would be deflated by Friday -- but I bet by next week Boehner will be ready to release a "clean CR" for a vote.

The Tea Party, which is the populist base of the current Republican Party, is based on nostalgia for a time that we haven't seen in this country since the full employment and social and racial homogeneity of the 1960s. The Tea Party's revanchism is founded on a desire to return to the past -- before Vietnam was recognized as the quagmire it was, before the Black Panthers, before Haight-Ashbury spread to every large city in the nation -- when factory jobs were still plentiful and rents inexpensive and the suburbs were new and futuristic.

I've been reading an excellent history of The Chocolate Watchband, a 1960s Garage Punk Psychedelic band from the San Jose suburbs, written by lead singer David Aguilar. Aguilar captures the essence of the middle-60s -- the raw power -- that I believe to be at the heart of Tea Party revanchism:
It was the spring of 1966. It was a very different world than what it is today. 
Using the words of Tom Shachtman, "America was a monster. Our booming economy was one leg of the colossus and the other was our Military might. In the world, only the Soviets and we counted. We believed our environment and natural resources were virtually limitless. We were certain American ingenuity, technological virtuosity, and money could solve the world's problems. We believed Americans could fix anything and that nuclear missiles, the ultimate weapons of destruction, could actually keep us from having a global war. On the ladder of life, youth was expected to start at the bottom and creep upward as described by the system. In other words, the ladder of success was a long and arduous climb everybody had to make to succeed in this world. We lived in a dream of constant upward mobility. It was powered by never-ending consumption. We knew how much people above us were earning because it was reflected in the things they owned." 
The Watchband lived in nuclear families in identical little patio homes in the suburbs of San Jose. The nuclear family consisted of a man and woman, married for the first and only time to each other, living together with their natural 2.4 children with a cat and dog thrown in for good measure. Single-parent families were rare and the thought of one was difficult to comprehend to our society. Mark's dad had passed away when he was 2 and his mother had never remarried. He was the exception in the group. We all went to the same schools, studied the same things, and had the same teachers our brothers and sisters had. At school we dressed up in costumes for Halloween, planted trees on Arbor Day, sent tiny little punch-out paper hearts around for Valentine's Day and had both Lincoln's and Washington's birthdays off. We obeyed most of the rules, feared discipline from our parents if we screwed up, and any young woman getting pregnant paid the penalty of either being banished to a relatives' house until delivery and adoption took place or was she ushered immediately into the wedding chapel. If it was before the sixth month, she got to wear white. There were no ifs, ands or buts about this one. Single mothers and inter-racial marriages were unheard of. FM radio was called "Underground Radio" because they played songs longer than 3 minutes in length and didn't have a lot of commercials. TV went off the air at 1 AM and came back on at 6 AM. Milky Ways and Snickers cost a nickel and Cokes in green bottles were a dime with 2 cents returned on the empty bottle .... no lie!
The irony of Tea Party revanchism is that the prosperity of the 1960s created the conditions for undoing the rigid social boundaries and simplicity that the lily-white, predominantly rural, present-day Know Nothings hanker after.

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Tea Party Propaganda War + ISIS

The Tea Party is unbowed one day in to their shutdown of the federal government. The coverage in today's New York Times points to a propaganda war that will unfold in the next few days as the House Republicans attempt to pass piecemeal spending bills, which they failed to accomplish last night, hoping to force Senate majority leader Harry Reid to take them up. If he refuses, then the GOP can blame the Democrats for keeping the national parks and veterans' centers closed. 

But there is peril on this path for Republican hardliners. To get piecemeal spending bills passed over Democratic opposition they must do so under ordinary rules requiring a simple majority vote. This opens up the possibility that "a clean CR" -- a bill to reopen the government without language to limit, delay or repeal Obamacare -- could make it to the House floor for an up or down vote.

Here is how the august Jonathan Weisman explains it in his "House G.O.P. Pushes Piecemeal Approach as Democrats Stand Firm":
Aides to the Republican leadership said the bills would be introduced on Wednesday under ordinary rules that require only simple majorities, and they should easily pass. But Democrats are likely to be granted procedural votes of their own, which would be an opportunity to test how many Republicans would defy their leadership and vote to reopen the entire government without crippling President Obama’s health care law — the standoff that shut down the government at 12:01 a.m. on Tuesday. 
As public anger grows, more Republicans are coming forward to call for such a rebellion. 
“The frustration and anger over Obamacare is being interpreted to be an all-or-nothing calculation,” said Representative Patrick Meehan, Republican of Pennsylvania, who now favors a simple stopgap spending measure to reopen the government. “People are very worried about Obamacare. Some of its pieces are problematic. 
“But they want us to come here and work on problems across America, and we can’t get to doing that if both sides are dug in,” he said. 
Democrats face pressure of their own to drop their stance of approving a spending bill only if it is free of policy prescriptions. Senate Democratic leaders say they plan to immediately kill all three of the piecemeal House bills, arguing that they will not be forced to choose between financing veterans’ programs or cancer research at the National Institutes of Health.
Tea Party stalwarts are convinced that they can still win the battle for American hearts and minds, even though the first-day response to the opening of the online Obamacare insurance market was so robust it led to meltdowns in the system.

The House GOP is suffering from the same kind of magical thinking that predicted a Romney win absent any polling data last election eve. Nonetheless, they will launch this piecemeal spending bill strategy and try to create some traction in the Senate. I read yesterday that Senator Dick Durbin, Democrat from Illinois, broached the idea of a deal based on a repeal of the medical device tax part of Obamacare. Thankfully, this was quickly shot down by Harry Reid.

Give the propaganda war a few days to play out.

There is a good story by Ben Hubbard this morning, "Qaeda Branch in Syria Pursues Its Own Agenda," about the method of operation of Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS):
The rise of extremist groups has exacerbated Syria’s instability. ISIS has attacked rebel bases to capture supplies, and routed rebel groups last month to seize control of Azaz, a strategic city near the Turkish border, leading to a tense cease-fire. Last week, Qaeda fighters tried to storm a village in Idlib Province to kidnap some rebels, leaving 20 dead from both sides, including the jihadis’ Libyan commander. 
“We want to keep Syria together as a country of freedom and equality,” a leader in an Islamist rebel group opposed to ISIS, called Suqour al-Sham, who gave his name as Abu Bashir, said via Skype. “They want to form an Islamic state that comes together with Iraq.” 
In an audio statement released online late Monday, a Qaeda spokesman defended the group, saying its contributions to the anti-Assad fight had been underappreciated and denying that it had started fights with rebel groups. 
“Those who aspire to sideline the state are many because of incorrect beliefs and doctrines,” said the spokesman, Abu Mohammed al-Adnani al-Shami. “They are greedy for power and for the worthless things of this world.” 
Analysts say the group is a revival and extension of Al Qaeda in Iraq, whose sectarian-fueled insurgency pushed that country to the brink of civil war in 2006 and 2007, before the group suffered major defeats at the hands of tribal fighters and American troops. 
In Syria, however, the group has found the vast territories that have fallen into rebel hands near Syria’s northern and eastern borders as an ideal environment to regroup and advance its agenda. 
The area is stateless, covered by a weak patchwork of local councils and rebel groups struggling to administer their towns and often competing with one another for resources. This gives the group a wide area to work in with no immediate enemies. The porousness of the Iraqi and Turkish borders also makes it easy for the group to bring in supplies and fighters. 
Brian Fishman, a former director of research at the Combating Terrorism Center at West Point and now a fellow at the New America Foundation, said those factors gave Al Qaeda a more favorable environment in Syria than it ever had in Iraq. 
“The conditions in Syria will be ripe for ISIS for quite some time,” he said.
There is a good Moon of Alabama blog post from a few days back that discusses negotiations between the Free Syrian Army and the Syrian government. The reality that is sinking in with the non-jihadi opposition is that the true enemy is the Saudi- and Qatari-funded mujahideen.

Monday, September 30, 2013

Absent Tea Party Surrender Government Headed for Shutdown

Judging from the coverage this morning, it looks like Senate majority leader Harry Reid is not going to buckle in the showdown with the Tea-Party-led House Republicans. Good. This needed to have happened at the end of last year following Obama's landslide election win and the GOP's pathetic showing in November.

There are still scenes left to play out in this drama as it unfolds today in D.C. Absent a bargain of some sort the government will shut down tomorrow. Here -- this is from Jeremy Peters and Jonathan Weisman's story this morning, "Senate Action on Health Law Moves to Brink of Shutdown" -- is what we can expect today:
Republican lawmakers said on Sunday that the House leadership had one more card to play, but that it was extremely delicate. They can tell Mr. Reid he must accept a face-saving measure, like the repeal of the tax on medical devices, which many Democrats support, or they will send back a new amendment that would force members of Congress and their staffs, and the White House staff, to buy their medical insurance on the new health law’s insurance exchanges, without any subsidies from the government to offset the cost. 
Republicans expressed certainty that for all the discomfort a shutdown would inflict on Capitol Hill, Democrats would not risk it to protect their own benefits.
If the Tea Party caucus is willing to settle for this -- a repeal of the tax on medical devices -- then there is a chance a deal could be reached. It would be unfortunate because it would maintain the GOP penchant for budgetary brinkmanship as a negotiating tactic, and it would guarantee further drama on down the line as the House Republicans continue their attempts to nibble away at Obamacare. But it's not clear that the Tea Party is willing to set its sights so low. Tea Party Republicans feel as if they have already given up a lot over the weekend by agreeing to a one-year delay in the implementation of the Affordable Care Act rather than its de-funding.

And on the other side of the aisle I think it has finally dawned on the Democratic leadership, and quite possibly even the conciliator-in-chief, that negotiating with the House Republicans in the face of threats to shut down the government or default on the sovereign debt is a losing proposition.

Even if a deal is struck today that avoids a government shutdown tomorrow, rest assured that an even larger conflict is coming our way in a couple of weeks with the vote to raise the debt ceiling. That's why my thinking from last week -- that a shutdown would be avoided -- has changed.

I now think that it has dawned on the Democrats that it's better to have the House GOP shutter the government in the near term, thoroughly discrediting Republicans to a broad majority of the public and thereby undercutting them going into a debt-ceiling standoff.

Barring a complete capitulation by the Tea Party -- or turnabout by Speaker Boehner to allow a clean bill without any anti-Obamacare chicanery -- the federal government is headed for a shutdown.

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Government Shutdown?

This blog began last November in anticipation of a decisive political showdown. Obama's drubbing of Mitt Romney in the presidential election and the epic failure of the Grand Old Party to gain any seats in the House or Senate, despite the deluge of cash unleashed by the plutocrat-friendly Supreme Court's Citizens United ruling, portended a route of the Tea Party in the fiscal cliff budget battle that brought 2012 to a close.

Obama won in 2012 thanks to a clear Progressive majority. These are voters who believe in the virtue of government-sponsored social programs like Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and who don't want to be inserted into any more foreign wars of choice. Of the two major party candidates, Obama offered the better choice.

But since last November things have become murkier. The Tea Party caucus, which wags the dog in the House, managed to duel Obama to draw on the fiscal cliff. Giving up a little ground on the top income tax rate, House Republicans earned their spurs back earlier this year by holding fast on the implementation of across the board 10% cuts in government spending known as sequestration.

In the meantime, Obama's political capital has drained away steadily since the election; it's to the point now where it's almost safe to call him a lame duck -- and he has more than three years left in his second term.

Obama's first mistake was during the negotiations to avoid the fiscal cliff he agreed to a Social Security reduction in the form of a chained CPI, contradicting a campaign pledge. The deal he ended up arriving at with Republicans did not include any Social Security cuts, but there was a feeling among his Progressive base that Obama had squandered the tactical high ground offered by the fiscal cliff where the GOP would have been uniformly blamed and despised by voters for raising everyone's taxes in order to avoid a tax increase on the wealthiest. The Progressive base was looking for a decisive battle while the issue of social democracy vs. plutocracy was still front and center from the election campaign. Knowing the fight would have to be fought with the House Republicans eventually, the feeling was better now as we head into a new year.

Obama then lost on the sequester. He made a decision to push for gun control legislation in the wake of the Newtown massacre, and he couldn't deliver on that. Then at the end of summer, Obama, the Nobel Peace Prize winner, attempted to insert the United States in yet another war in the Middle East. Except that this time it would be on the same side as an enemy, Al Qaeda, we have been at war with since 9/11. Voters rebelled and war was avoided thanks to some fancy Russian diplomatic footwork.

That's where we are now. Obama is on the ropes. The bete noire of the Tea Party, the Affordable Care Act, a.k.a., Obamacare, is set to launch on October 1, the same time a new budget has to be approved to avoid a government shutdown. Assuming that can be done, sometime at the end of October the government will reach its debt limit. The House GOP, which must vote to approve raising the debt ceiling, promises default unless Obamacare is de-funded.

Obama is weakened and the majority that elected him is dispirited. This gives the House Republicans enough wiggle room to shut down the government if that is what they really want to do. But I don't think that's what they want. This wouldn't play well with independents. What I read over the weekend, something which makes sense, is that Speaker of the House John Boehner will accept whatever comes over from the Senate and send it back with language delaying enforcement of a tax penalty on filers who can't show proof of health insurance. Then it will be up to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid to shut down the government.

Friday, September 20, 2013

Warmongers Hemmed In

Next week is shaping up to be a momentous one. The United Nations General Assembly convenes and the United States House of Representatives, currently being led by the Tea Party caucus, will decide whether to shut down the government.

The news today is buzzing with the possibility of a deal between Obama and new Iranian president, Hassan Rouhani, over Iran's nuclear program. They will likely meet in New York City where both will be attending the General Assembly.

Meanwhile, Secretary of State John Kerry is proceeding along the same belligerent path he has trod from the beginning in relation to Syria, ignoring the unmistakable turn of events of the last two weeks since his Monday, September 9, faux pas during a London press conference opened the door for the Russian proposal for Syria to adopt the Convention on Chemical Weapons.

Michael Gordon has a good summary this morning of the effort underway, based on what Kerry says is indisputable proof of Syrian government guilt, to allow the Security Council the use of force if Syria does not comply with the agreement to get rid of its chemical weapons. To this end, Kerry is trying to isolate the Russians by getting the Chinese to join with the U.S., France and Britain in supporting Chapter VII sanctions. It's not going to happen.

The Obama Administration has its hands full: Iran, a Tea Party emboldened by its defeat of Obama's Authorization for the Use of Military Force looking to shut down the government, and, now, finding a plausible way to upend peace talks with Syria. This is from Gordon's story, "Kerry Presses Security Council to Act on Syrian Arsenal":
Mr. Kerry plans to meet next week with Mr. Lavrov and Lakhdar Brahimi, the United Nations envoy on the Syria crisis, to discuss planning for a possible peace conference. 
No date for a conference has been set, and Russia and the United States are at odds over who should attend. Russia, for example, has insisted that Iran should participate. The United States has opposed including Iran and said the “London 11,” a group of European and Arab nations that support the Syrian opposition, should attend.
Engaged in negotiations with Iran over its nuclear program makes it hard to deny them a place at the table in talks on Syria.

The Guardian had a story yesterday on Putin's take on Syria; it included this sensible question from the Russian president:
The Russian president also reiterated suspicions that the 21 August chemical attack near Damascus was carried out by rebels and not by forces loyal to Assad. 
"We talk all the time about the responsibility of Assad regime if it turns out that they did it, but nobody is asking about the responsibility of the rebels if they did it," said Putin. "We have all the reasons to believe it was a clever provocation."
The warmongers, it goes without saying, will do everything in their power to reassert the primacy of force. But with food stamps being axed by House Republicans, who at the same time are hurtling towards a collision in their quixotic effort to repeal Obamacare, the United States Government is in no position to threaten other countries.