Showing posts with label Al Qaeda. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Al Qaeda. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 5, 2018

The U.S. Defends Al Qaeda

Despite all warnings of dire consequences coming from the U.S. politburo, it doesn't appear to me that the Syrian offensive to recapture Idlib can be halted. The U.S. must either talk tough and then act modestly as it did in Douma last year or go in heavy and risk a war with Russia. The U.S. has heretofore avoided a direct conflict with the Russian Federation.

As Bill Van Auken notes this morning in "Washington escalates threats over Syria as Russia bombs Al Qaeda positions," the United States is now openly acting as a defender of Al Qaeda:
Absent from the US statements is any recognition that Idlib is effectively run by the Syrian Al Qaeda affiliate, which leads the dominant “rebel” faction, Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham (IHT), and includes large numbers of so-called foreign fighters. The IHT has reportedly set up gallows and employed firing squads to eliminate opponents seeking accommodation with the Syrian government.
The UN’s special envoy to Syria, Staffan de Mistura, has acknowledged that there are at least 10,000 Al Qaeda-affiliated fighters in Idlib. The front that the group leads is said to control 60 percent of the province’s territory along with its capital, and effectively governs the region. Others have put the number of Al Qaeda-linked fighters at between 20,000 and 30,000.
Washington is threatening to intervene not out of any humanitarian concerns. Successive US administration have carried out bloody interventions in the region—from the war of aggression in Iraq, to the regime change operations in Libya and Syria and the near genocidal US-Saudi war against Yemen—that have claimed the lives of millions and decimated entire societies. 
If it launches a new act of aggression in Syria, it will be to rescue the Al Qaeda-led “rebels,” which Washington and its Western and regional allies have supported since the onset of the proxy war for regime change in 2011, pouring billions of dollars’ worth of money and weapons to support these forces. And it will be to further US geo-strategic interests in dominating the Middle East and rolling back the influence of Iran and Russia in both Syria and the wider region.
With the open defense of Al Qaeda in Syria, Washington is unceremoniously ditching the 17-year-old “global war on terror” in favor of preparations for military confrontation with what US national security documents describe as “revisionist states” challenging US hegemony—i.e., Russia and China.
As for the warnings over a chemical weapons attack, these amount to an invitation to the Al Qaeda forces to stage an incident in order to secure air support from the US and its allies. Damascus flatly denied responsibility for earlier incidents—in Douma last April and in Khan Shaykhun a year before. Both were used as the pretext for missile and air strikes by Washington and its allies.

Monday, October 24, 2016

NFL Ratings Drop & the End of the Unipolar World

UPDATE: Today (October 26) Ken Belson, Richard Sandomir and Rory Smith of The New York Times ponder the NFL ratings drop, tossing in the even worse drop in viewership of English Premier League soccer matches, in "TV Viewership Falls in N.F.L. and Premier League: A Blip, or Something Worse?"
The two most successful sports leagues in the world, bringing in billions of dollars in revenue, the biggest corporate sponsors and mammoth audiences every game day, are now sharing an altogether different experience: The National Football League and the English Premier League are seeing startling, double-digital declines in television viewership this season.
Viewership through the first seven weeks of the N.F.L. season is down by 12 percent in the United States, while the audiences for E.P.L. soccer matches this season, which began in August, are down nearly 20 percent in Britain.
All the trends that drove viewers away from other programs on broadcast television in recent years, including cord-cutting and DVRs, never punished the N.F.L. and the Premier League in the same way. Fans — lots and lots of them — did not seem willing to look away. 
They are now, in numbers that are alarming for the leagues, which have grown used to fans tuning in to their games in good times and bad, and for the networks, some of which have spent 10-figure sums for the rights to broadcast them. Viewership for N.F.L. games on CBS on Thursday nights, on NBC on Sunday nights and on ESPN on Monday nights is down by as much as 21 percent.
Everything -- from the presidential election season, to too many games being broadcast, to absence of Tom Brady to begin the season, to distracted viewers during the games -- is considered.

Sure, the presidential election year makes a difference. And we can't ignore the digitalization of our lives -- Facebook, Twitter, Amazon, smartphones, Tinder, Google, on and on. But I think the main impetus to go cold turkey from the national opiate is the loss of competitiveness in the first month, month and a half, of the season. This synced with the shift in consciousness already underway -- the loss in faith in the mainstream; the digitalization of our attention span -- to deliver up the double-digit ratings drop.

Will the NFL rebound? It could. But, as I argue below, since U.S. global hegemony and the potency of the NFL opiate are linked, it probably won't.

****

The seventh Sunday of the National Football League's 2016 season concluded with an overtime defensive struggle between the Seahawks and Cardinals. The game ended in a rare tie, 6-6.

This kind of nailbiter is more rare now than in recent years past. Most of the games I have seen this season have been deplorable. Before last night, I can think of only a few good games all year (though with Week 6's Thursday Night match-up between the Broncos and the Chargers, it appears a shift back to competitiveness is underway).

This is unusual, and worthy of remark. I came across this opening line from a story on the NFL's latest domestic violence snafu, "N.F.L. Shows It Doesn’t Really Care About Domestic Violence," written by the excellent reporter Juliet Macur: "Television ratings for the N.F.L. are down 11 percent this season, and league officials have been grasping for possible explanations."

If anything, excellent competition has been the norm in the National Football League for more than a decade. Such was not always the case. In the 1970s and 1980s blow-outs were common. The obvious explanation for the significant ratings drop this year (one that doesn't include Kaepernick protesting white supremacy by taking a knee during the national anthem) is that the games have been lousy.

But, as I said, with Week 6, things seem to have snapped back to the competitiveness we have grown accustomed to, with exciting, close games like the Rams and the Lions, the Falcons and the Seahawks, and the Colts and the Texans.

The NFL is the premiere entertainment product in the United States. Hollywood is not what it used to be. Old media is giving way to the ubiquitous internet, and there is a scramble among corporate giants to gobble up as much content as possible.

The NFL remains the one true opiate of the masses. For that opiate to lose its potency at a time of political  tumult (Trump, Black Lives Matter, New Cold War) is auspicious.

What this portends -- and here I am being optimistic -- is some form of realignment. The U.S. unipolar world is over. (See Dilip Hiro's magisterial "American Power at the Crossroads: A Snapshot of a Multipolar World in Action.") The power elite lining up behind Hillary think that through confrontation the U.S. can maintain its monolithic status. This is clearly delusional. Most voters in the Western core, while possibly not able to explain this, nonetheless feel it in their bones. For the United States, based on the voluble new McCarthyism of Hillary and  the Democratic Party, it appears to be either catastrophic direct conflict with Russia or an embarrassing about-face.

A third way would simply be the maintenance of the status quo where the U.S. unipolar world exists as a sort of kabuki, a fiction whereby American destroyers continue to travel in waters claimed by the Dragon in the South China Sea and the CIA continues to collude with Al Qaeda in the destruction of states, blowback be damned.

But the status quo cannot be maintained. That is what we are living through right now.  That is our present tense.

Hillary chose to reboot McCarthyism to help her rancid old carcass across the finish line; it was either that or address directly the content of the WikiLeaks Podesta emails.

She is in a box now. She is going to have to retreat or escalate. And she is going to have to act with very little popular support.

Dilip Hiro thinks that U.S. global leadership will be unchallenged for decades to come. But this assumes that Europe doesn't continue to disintegrate, which should proceed rapidly in the next four years, particularly given the situation unfolding in Mosul. It also assumes stability in the American electorate. Hillary is about to ascend to the throne with the duopoly crumbling beneath her. No one can foresee how she will able to govern.

The U.S. needs it televisual opiate now more than ever, and early indications are it is not going to be there. Let the brave new world be born!

Friday, August 26, 2016

Scott Shane's "Saudis and Extremism": Mostly More of the Same

Now, because of the cumulative stresses of work, that I have abandoned almost entirely the discipline of waking up at 4:00 a.m. to read the newspaper and then record a few comments here, I wonder how I was able to do it for more than three years.

Reading Scott Shane's lengthy "Secrets of the Kingdom" expose, "Saudis and Extremism: ‘Both the Arsonists and the Firefighters’," was truly enervating. Shane, who appeared in cameo on The Wire's final season, is usually given edgy assignments by "the newspaper of record." He lays out everything we basically already know about the House of Saud's export of Wahhabism worldwide.

If you have a half hour, I'd say the story is worth your time, if only because it establishes how Saudi Wahhabism is suffocating local, multi-sect, tolerant, syncretic Islam. War promises to be an ever-expanding reality.

But Shane blunts the impact of the piece by regularly spicing his reporting with caveats from Saudi-friendly academics and diplomats that there is little or no evidence that Salafist violence is directly linked to Saudi charitable support for Wahhabism. The overall effect is to create a blur, an "Oh, it is all so complex. We'll never know for sure. The poor Saudi royals are such easy targets."

Shane never references his past reporting connecting the Saudis to 9/11 and Al Qaeda, nor anything about the recent declassification of the 28 pages from the congressional investigation that strongly implicates a Saudi official with aiding 9/11 hijackers.

Wednesday, April 27, 2016

Point of No Return: President Hillary and the Demise of the European Union

I feel decent this morning for the first time in more than a week. Stress and strain on the job has led me to abandon this page. I feel like I am back at an SEIU local where I worked ten years ago, which was the closest I have ever come to being a member of a cult. Everyone was fucking each other, lying to each other, drinking and drugging, calling in sick, etc. My current situation is not anywhere near as bad. But I am ten years older, and working a 12-hour day doesn't get any easier.

So I am entertaining the idea of mothballing Burdens. My horizon looks bleak: overtime, staff retreats, six-day work week after six-day work week. We'll see. I think I can manage one post a week.

Enough about me. What about the world in which we live? Yesterday's primary results solidified last week's consensus coming out of New York. It is going to be a Trump vs. Hillary race to the bottom. Trump swept five Eastern states -- Connecticut, Delaware, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island and Maryland -- in commanding fashion, and Hillary almost equaled his performance, losing only Roger Williams' colony.

The big takeaway from yesterday is a post this morning by Nate Silver, an avowed Trump denier: "It’s Trump’s Nomination To Lose. (Well, at least if he wins Indiana.)" With the Kasich-Cruz pact to derail Trump quickly disintegrating, even FiveThirtyEight thinks Trump's path to 1,237 is all but assured. For a moment I was swayed by a Van Jones interview I saw at the beginning of this month where he argued that the GOP was headed straight for a brokered convention because Trump had proven unable to win consistently more than 50% of the vote. Well, he has proven it repeatedly in April. And I think he will do very well in California. I was hoping for a battle royale at the Republican National Convention, maybe even an event where Trump would march his delegates out.

For the Democrats, I was hoping that Bernie could win New York and California and a few other states along the way and bring his children's crusade to the City of Brotherly love where another convention fight would be staged. Remember, it was the meltdown in Chicago in 1968 that brought about the McGovern reforms that led to McGovern's nomination in 1972 and Carter's nomination in 1976, and which superdelegates were created in 1984 to counteract. So convention meltdowns have a big historical impact.

Unfortunately it doesn't look like there will be any convention meltdowns. If anything happens, it will be the big unions backing Hillary (SEIU, for one) attempting to lure disaffected youth back into the corrupt Democratic Party by staging direct action type mobilizations against Trump, possibly even at the GOP convention in Cleveland. I hope youth are too shrewd to be appropriated by Hillary, but in this regard I am not too confident; after all, there was a push in March by MoveOn to mobilize against Trump.

What does a race to the bottom between Hillary and The Donald look like? It is hard to know how the deep the depths, but deep indeed I imagine they will be. A guy who works on the same floor of the building where I work came into the office last week and handed me a sheet he had printed out. It was from The New York Times, based on the "NYT 4/19/16" he scrawled on the bottom of the page. There is no byline. I will retype the key sentences:
Meanwhile, her [Hillary's] negative ratings have been rising and now outweigh her positives by 24 points. That makes her seen no more favorably than Cruz is. Her only salvation is Trump's net negative is minus 41.
Combine these high marks of disapproval for both front runners with the low voter turnout numbers from the 2014 midterm elections, which were so low you had to go all the way back to the total war mobilization of World War Two to find comparable figures, and we could see participation levels as poor as the 1920s. And while this is proof of a broad distrust of our political system, it does not represent the kind of revolution that is called for.

At this point it looks like Clinton will muddle through. Fear usually trumps hope. By the time November arrives, Trump will be so thoroughly demonized the Rubio-voting soccer mom crossover will more than make up for any hardhat crossover in the opposite direction, leaving the election to be decided by black and Latino turnout. All hail Hillary.

We will have to look for regime change elsewhere.

Though "four more years" yawns at us, I am convinced now more than ever (and not just because I am reading Elizabeth Kolbert's excellent The Sixth Extinction: An Unnatural History) that we are headed for some sort of collapse.

This page since its inception has been preoccupied with the fracturing of the current Pax Americana neoliberal paradigm. From the fiscal cliff, Cyprus, the coup in Kiev, sarin in Ghouta, ISIS in Anbar, Syriza's Greece, Afghanistan, the refugee crisis in Europe to World War Four in Syria the paradigm is quaking.

Europe is critical. The unipolar world of Pax Americana is dependent on a supine, fraudulently monolithic Europe. That party has ended. Obama's meek and exhausted goodbye junket to the continent drove the message of defeat home.

The ceasefire in Syria is over. In the new phase of fighting the U.S. alliance with Al Qaeda affiliate Al Nusra is more manifest than ever. The only thing keeping it from popular consciousness is a polite, conspiratorial elision by the mainstream media.

Renewed fighting in Syria and Iraq means a surge in refugees to Europe. Yemen is cued up to be even worse. All in time for the June 23 Brexit referendum. (Interestingly, in 1975, Year 1 of neoliberalism, the Brits voted by a supermajority to remain part of the European Community. It will be much closer this time.)

Even if the UK votes to stay in the EU, the continent will continue to fray because war in the Middle East is going to accelerate. The sheikhs of the Gulf are engaged in an arms buying bonanza, while the Saudis are in full tilt PR smokescreen mode. The panic is palpable. The captive USG is doing its part by sabotaging Obama's remaining legacy achievement, the nuclear deal with Iran. This can't end well. Hillary, more beholden to the neocons and the Saudis, will only make things worse.

And we haven't even mentioned the militarized Asia pivot or NATO's New Cold War with Russia, both of which were initiated absent public support. This is a "no future" horizon.

Tuesday, January 5, 2016

The End of al-Saud Might Not be Too Far Off

The newspaper this morning is dominated by Saudi Arabia's provocative execution of Shiite Sheikh Nimr al-Nimr and its aftermath. The Gray Lady features not one but two frontpagers; two additional stories (both superior to the frontpagers) after the jump; and two opinion pieces, one by the editorial board, "Saudi Arabia’s Barbaric Executions," and the other a topnotch editorial, "Saudi Arabia’s Dangerous Sectarian Game," by Rutgers academic Toby Craig Jones (who appeared on Democracy Now! yesterday).

To begin with Jones, he emphasizes something that is repeated in almost every story I laid eyes on this morning: The Saudi execution of Sheikh Nimr was meant not only to derail Iranian integration into the global economy following the P5+1 nuclear deal, but also to obscure serious domestic budgetary problems that the House of Saud is struggling to handle following an oil price drop that it helped to bring about:
The Saudi authorities have good reason to be concerned about new calls for reform. About a week before Sheikh Nimr’s execution, the kingdom announced that it was facing an almost $100 billion deficit for its 2016 national budget. Declining oil revenues may soon force the kingdom to slash spending on social welfare programs, subsidized water, gasoline and jobs — the very social contract that informally binds ruler and ruled in Saudi Arabia. The killing of a prominent member of a loathed religious minority deflects attention from impending economic pressure.
But what is refreshing about Professor Jones' editorial is the coherent big picture of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia that it draws. That picture looks something like this: The Saudis have fomented sectarianism for a long time to maintain their absolutist hold on power. But the Saudi fueling of conflict between Sunni and Shia took a quantum leap after the Arab Spring uprising, with the Iranians always being cast as the foil. The problem now, as Professor Jones articulately notes, is that all al-Saud is capable of is sectarian-fueled warfare; it can do nothing else. Hence, the sole public rationale of the West for sticking by these despotic Gulf sheikhdoms, that they provide essential stability in an otherwise turbulent region, is no longer true:
The danger in Saudi Arabia’s ongoing sectarian and anti-Iranian incitement — of which Sheikh Nimr’s execution is just one part — is that it is uncontrollable. As is clear in Syria, Iraq and even further afield, sectarian hostility has taken on a life beyond what the kingdom’s architects are able to manage. This has already proved to be the case in Saudi Arabia, where terrorists aligned with the Islamic State have carried out several suicide bombings on Shiite mosques in the past year. 
The real problem is not just that Saudis are willing to live with violent sectarianism. They are now beholden to it, too. That the kingdom’s leaders have embraced sectarianism so recklessly suggests that they have little other choice. This should be frightening, considering more is likely to be in store. But it should also be clarifying for those who believe that Saudi Arabia is a force for stability in the Middle East. It is not.
And that is the message that beams out of today's newspaper, a kind of waking consciousness that the Saudis are not going to accept Iranian integration and that more warfare is inevitable -- a particularly unsettling proposition for Europe since the nations of the EU are the ones that have recently become the chosen destination for the U.S. and al-Saud war refugees. Sewell Chan takes notes of this in "European Sympathies Lean Toward Iran in Conflict With Saudi Arabia," summed up by a quote from establishment academic Vali Nasr:
In an interview, Vali R. Nasr, the dean of the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies in Washington and an authority on the Sunni-Shiite regional conflict, said that Western opinion in this case was weighted in Iran’s favor — in part because of the European Union’s desire for rapprochement with Iran. 
“Europeans think the dispute is serious but they think — and so does the White House — that Saudis don’t want reconciliation with Iran, want to exclude Iran from all regional discussions and want to provoke Iran into an action that would then derail engagement with West,” Dr. Nasr said. “This crisis was started by Saudi, and Riyadh was quick to use it to break ties, which means an end to any broad regional engagement like the Vienna talks.”
War can't continue forever without some form of breakdown or correction of course. And that is what we are approaching now. Europe is haltingly shaking itself free of U.S. hegemony. That process is going to have to pick up steam for there to be a breakthrough. As for us here in the homeland of "Great Satan," any of the potential presidential candidates, regardless who wins the general election in November, is going to preside over a continuing fracturing of the nation.

For instance, a company that is doing PR for the Saudis in the wake of the fallout over the Sheikh Nimr execution is none other than the Podesta Group, co-founded by John Podesta, chairman of Hillary's presidential campaign. This is from Ben Hubbard's must-read "Shiite Cleric Gained in Status as a Rivalry Deepened":
Saudi Arabia arrested Sheikh Nimr in 2012 and later sentenced him to death for charges that included breaking allegiance with the ruler, inciting sectarian strife and supporting rioting and destruction of property during protests, according to Human Rights Watch.He was killed in a mass execution with 46 other prisoners, most of them linked to Al Qaeda.
Many Saudis defended that pairing of crimes. 
“We are speaking of a terrorist person,” said Salman al-Ansari, a Saudi commentator provided by the Podesta Group, a public relations firm working for the Saudi government.
So don't look for any "Hope & Change" from Hillary.

Interestingly, though Nimr al-Nimr was a conservative cleric, he was not what you would call a Iranian stooge. He spoke out against Bashar al-Assad and supported Kurdish self-determination. He seemed to be something a leveler:
In one sermon, he spoke out against “oppressors,” Sunni or Shiite, and called for the oppressed to unite against them. 
“In any place he rules — Bahrain, here, in Yemen, in Egypt or in any place — the unjust ruler is hated,” he said. “Whoever defends the oppressor is his partner with him in oppression, and whoever is with the oppressed shares with him his reward from God.” 
He broke rank with other Shiite clerics by criticizing President Bashar al-Assad of Syria, who is backed by Iran, and supported rule by the Kurdish majority in northern Iraq. 
In another sermon, he spoke against the use of arms and said protesters should be willing to die for their cause: “Our strength is not in weapons; our strength is in martyrdom."

Monday, January 4, 2016

Saudis Scared of Peace

The execution Saturday of Saudi Shiite firebrand cleric Sheikh Nimr al-Nimr by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia was certainly meant to provoke Iran into some sort of reaction which could then be used as an excuse by al-Saud to do what it did yesterday -- cut diplomatic ties and give Iranian ambassadors 48 hours to get out of Saudi Arabia. Ben Hubbard provides a useful summary of the Iran vs. House of Saud conflict in today's "Saudi Arabia Cuts Ties With Iran Amid Fallout From Cleric’s Execution":
. . . Saudi Arabia and Iran follow separate strands of Islam and have long been rivals for influence across the Middle East and beyond. That has accelerated in recent years as the Iraq war and the Arab Spring uprisings upturned the regional order and gave both nations new ways to extend their reach.
That put them on opposite sides of various conflicts, often divided by sect. In Bahrain, Saudi Arabia sent tanks to support the Sunni monarchy against protesters led by the island nation’s Shiite majority. In Syria, Iran has bankrolled the government of President Bashar al-Assad while Saudi Arabia has supported Sunni rebels seeking his ouster. And in Yemen, Saudi Arabia has led an air campaign against Shiite Houthi rebels.
Further straining tensions are Saudi concerns that the Iranian nuclear agreement could increase Tehran’s ability to spread its influence. And Iran remains angry over Saudi Arabia’s handling of a stampede during the hajj in September that left more than 2,400 pilgrims dead, including more than 450 Iranians, according to a count by The Associated Press.
But setting off the war of words that finally broke relations was Saudi Arabia’s execution on Saturday of Sheikh Nimr, who had called for the overthrow of the Saudi royal family and served as a spiritual leader for protesters from the kingdom’s Shiite minority. The Saudi government accused him of inciting violence and executed him with 46 others, most of them said to be members of Al Qaeda. 
The reaction in the region generally broke cleanly along sectarian lines, with Shiite leaders criticizing the Saudis for killing a man they called a peaceful dissident, while Saudi Arabia’s Sunni allies applauded what they called the country’s efforts to fight terrorism. 
Then late Saturday, protesters in Tehran ransacked the Saudi Embassy, and Iranian leaders turned up the rhetoric. “God’s hand of retaliation will grip the neck of Saudi politicians,” Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, said in comments reported on his official website. 
The Iranians did, however, appear to take steps to prevent the dispute from escalating further, arresting 40 Iranians in the anti-Saudi mayhem.
Hubbard quotes a couple think-tankers saying that the execution of Sheikh Nimr is bad news for the peace process on Syria and that it likely signals an increase in proxy warfare in the region.

Moon of Alabama posts that "This was exactly what the Saudis rulers wanted and need," the idea being that things are going badly for al-Saud in Yemen (the war there is unwinnable and all the Kingdom is accomplishing is the destruction of the country) and in Syria (where momentum is increasing for some sort of negotiated settlement), and this diplomatic breach provides cover to "double down" and in time honored neocon power-mad fashion "make the problem bigger."

The problem for the Saudis and the other sheikhdoms of the Gulf is that the Iranians are not jejune poltroons who can be stampeded into an overreaction. The Iranians have already won this exchange in the eyes of the Obama administration. According to Hubbard:
That risks derailing a new round of international peace talks aimed at ending the civil war in Syria, a process that Mr. Kerry has worked hard to get going. 
The talks, meant to begin this month, were to be the first to bring together the Syrian government, the opposition and a range of countries that include Iran and Saudi Arabia. 
“We’re obviously concerned this could blow up the process,” one senior Obama administration official said. “But it’s too early to say what the impact could be.” 
Saudi officials have long said they think that Mr. Kerry’s effort is doomed to failure, and that was before Sunday’s diplomatic breach with Iran.

Still, Obama administration officials noted Iran’s efforts over the weekend to keep the situation on the streets from spinning out of control. “The Iranians, in this case, acted responsibly,” Michael Morell, the former deputy director of the C.I.A., said on CBS’s “Face the Nation.” “The police showed up very quickly. They made a number of arrests.”

Despite that, officials believe that the Sunni-Shiite proxy war that was already underway in Syria and Yemen may only grow more intense, at least for a while. And in coming weeks the United States and its negotiating partners in the Iran deal are preparing to carry out that accord, including an end to sanctions that have tied up more than $100 billion in Iranian assets frozen in overseas bank accounts. Critics are already arguing that will give Iran more money to fund the conflict in Syria and beyond.

Shortly after announcing the execution of Sheikh Nimr on Saturday, Saudi Arabia said it was ending a two-and-a-half-week-old cease-fire in Yemen that had never really taken hold.
The Sheikh Nimr execution is the latest attempt to scuttle the rapprochement between Iran and the United States that came with signing the P5+1 accord on Iran's nuclear program. Last month Congress passed a new law targeting Iran, Iraq, Syria and Sudan, which Kerry promptly walked back. Then there was the announcement of new sanctions on Iran for its ballistic missiles, which the Obama administration then said would take more time to implement.

The advantage that the Saudis have is that while the players on Team Obama might not be jejune they are poltroons in that they will not directly confront the Saudi-neocon-Israeli axis that has so much say in how the U.S. warfare state conducts itself.

The correct thing for the Obama administration to do after the Saudi provocation of Sheikh Nimr's execution would be to announce -- publicly would be best but privately would do too -- that it was bowing out of the air war on Yemen. The Saudis can refuel and traffic their own war planes.

This of course won't happen because al-Saud has correctly seized up Obama as someone who knows his limits, a leader who has shown time after time that he is not willing to restructure the self-destructive institutions of American hegemony, whether it is the Pentagon or Wall Street.

The Saudis are making the problem bigger because they are scared that the region might be moving towards peace. They are terrified of peace.

Tuesday, September 29, 2015

Obama's Old, Tired Lies about Syria: Crack Up for U.S. and EU is Coming

For weeks an Obama-Putin meeting at the United Nations General Assembly has been written about as a possible turning point in efforts to bring an end to the war in Syria. This morning the official appraisal ("Obama and Putin Clash at U.N. Over Syria Crisis," Michael Gordon and Gardiner Harris) is that the conflict will grind on. The meeting between Putin and Obama is being written off as a failure due to intransigent Russian support for Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad.

Obscured in all the mainstream news analysis and prevaricating Obama administration talking points is the absurdity of the U.S. position.

The talking points circulated to rebut Putin's defense, that Assad is engaged in an existential battle against Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, are found in an unsigned Gray Lady editorial, "Putin and Obama Have Profound Differences on Syria":
Mr. Putin said it was “an enormous mistake to refuse to cooperate with the Syrian government and its armed forces, who are valiantly fighting terrorism face-to-face,” conveniently ignoring the fact that Mr. Assad’s main target has always been his domestic opposition, not the Islamic State. He portrayed Mr. Assad as a force for stability and said the only solution “is to restore their statehood where it has been destroyed.” 
Mr. Obama correctly argued that in 2011 Mr. Assad “reacted to peaceful protests by escalating repression and killing that, in turn, created the environment for the current strife,” which the Islamic State has been able to exploit. He said Mr. Assad and his allies “cannot simply pacify the broad majority of a population who have been brutalized by chemical weapons and indiscriminate bombing,” and Mr. Obama reiterated his call for a “managed transition” away from Mr. Assad to a more inclusive government.
This in a nutshell is the U.S. case for prolonging the war in Syria, and it is entirely false.

For starters, the idea that everything -- all the mayhem and violence is Assad's fault; that the Syrian president is constantly engaged in attacking his own peaceful people -- this is pure propaganda discredited years ago; it has been rejected by no less an official authority than vice president Joe Biden. This is from an excellent analysis piece by Robert Parry, "Will US Grasp Putin’s Syria Lifeline?"
On Oct. 2, 2014, Vice President Joe Biden let more of the cat out of the bag when he told an audience at Harvard’s Kennedy School: “our allies in the region were our largest problem in Syria … the Saudis, the emirates, etc., what were they doing? They were so determined to take down Assad and essentially have a proxy Sunni-Shia war, what did they do? They poured hundreds of millions of dollars and tens of thousands of tons of military weapons into anyone who would fight against Assad, except the people who were being supplied were Al Nusra and Al Qaeda and the extremist elements of jihadis coming from other parts of the world.” [Quote at 53:20 of clip.]
The idea that Assad is not primarily attacking Islamic State fighters but "his domestic opposition" leaves unspecified that the "domestic opposition" is nonetheless Salafist jihadis fighting under one Sunni Islamist banner or another, whether it is Al Qaeda or Ahrar al-Sham. Last year Obama himself refuted this myth of a domestic opposition:
“This idea that we could provide some light arms or even more sophisticated arms to what was essentially an opposition made up of former doctors, farmers, pharmacists and so forth, and that they were going to be able to battle not only a well-armed state but also a well-armed state backed by Russia, backed by Iran, a battle-hardened Hezbollah, that was never in the cards,” Obama said.
Obama was commenting about the beginning of the Syrian conflict, the time of the Arab Spring uprising in 2011. From the outset the decision was made to go with foreign fighters recruited by the Wahhabi networks of the Gulf Cooperation Council. In other words, there is no "domestic opposition" that can project power on the ground in Syria; hence, there are no partners for a transitional phase of government. Salafis only believe in a caliphate. So it is the Syrian Arab Republican or no civil government at all.

Obama's claim of chemical-weapons use by the Syrian government is another widely discredited claim that taps propaganda that has failed to keep up with events reported in even the mainstream press; for instance, that "Islamic State Ordnance Shows Traces of Chemical Agents, U.S. Says."

What is going on here I believe is apparent. In order to win Saudi and Israeli acquiescence to the Iranian nuclear deal, Obama promised not to relent when it came to Assad's ouster. Also, Obama agreed to back to the hilt the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia's genocidal war in Yemen.

The Saudis and Israelis agreed to the bargain because they believe that if Syria and Iraq remain broken and plagued by jihadis, eventually Iran will crater. Russia checked the move by positioning heavy weapons and air power in Latakia.

The U.S. response was never seriously in doubt, and that response did not include a peace deal brokered by Russia. Now what we will see is more war and more refugees. The next huge wave of asylum-seekers is likely to come from Iraq, assuming that the promised offensive to re-take Mosul begins in a few months.

The European Union is going to fracture, and so is the United States. Congress will shut down and Donald Trump is on his was to the White House.

Thursday, May 14, 2015

Some Thoughts on Seymour Hersh's "The Killing of Osama bin Laden"

It took the homeward-bound commutes of Tuesday and Wednesday to read in its entirety the 10,000-word, 20-page Seymour Hersh deflowering of the Obama administration fable of how it took out Osama bin Laden ("The Killing of Osama bin Laden"), but it was time well spent.

What the reader comes away with is a feeling that the state exists to manufacture lies. Lies abound. An ocean of lies. Obama might not have ordered the burial at sea of the slain Al Qaeda mastermind, as the fable relates (instead, according to Hersh, the Navy SEALs tossed the dismembered parts of bin Laden's corpse out of the helicopter as it ferried them back to Afghanistan), but his decision to promptly publicize the assassination of OBL, reneging on a agreement that he had with Pakistan, necessitated the manufacture of numerous cover stories.

If one has ever cheated on a spouse -- something, sadly, which I did in my youth -- you know that lying about what you did -- when, where and how -- and doing so consistently replicates in the mind schizophrenic effects. One often feels as if he were hallucinating, on a "trip." The lies stack up and you find yourself in a self-created maze; it is a giddy, vertiginous feeling.

In his 10,000 words this is what Hersh successfully conveys about the Obama administration: It is drugged-up on lies. So covetous of the political windfall of bagging bogeyman numero uno with a re-election year on the horizon, Obama went against his defense secretary, the rest of the military brass, and his Pakistani allies and promptly revealed the SEALs assassination mission.

But that revelation turns out to be a lot of bullshit. For one, Osama was not living freely, directing Al Qaeda attacks. He was a prisoner of Pakistanis who had nabbed him in the Hindu Kush in 2006. The Abbottabad compound he lived in was a jail with bars on the windows and barbed wire on the roof; he was under lock and key, guarded night and day, kept under wraps by Pakistan for its own purposes but also at the behest of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The Saudi royals didn't want OBL talking to the CIA about where Al Qaeda's financial support came from for 9/11.

The U.S. found out about Osama's presence in Abbottabad not by super-sleuthing, a fiction presented in Zero Dark Thirty, but from a Pakistani walk-in who wanted the $25 million finder's fee. There was no tracking OBL down through the movements of his courier; rather, it was the U.S. confronting the Pakistanis with the evidence worked up from the walk-in. The Pakistanis, not wanting to lose out on the steady stream of cash provided by USG, fessed up and proceeded to cooperate in all aspects of the operation. Basically, the Navy SEALs mission was a heavily rehearsed execution of a jailed invalid, which Obama repackaged as a courageous display of American grit and derring-do.

The "money" passage for me in Hersh's "The Killing of Osama bin Laden" comes relatively early in the piece:
The walk-in had told the US that bin Laden had lived undetected from 2001 to 2006 with some of his wives and children in the Hindu Kush mountains, and that ‘the ISI got to him by paying some of the local tribal people to betray him.’ (Reports after the raid placed him elsewhere in Pakistan during this period.) Bank was also told by the walk-in that bin Laden was very ill, and that early on in his confinement at Abbottabad, the ISI had ordered Amir Aziz, a doctor and a major in the Pakistani army, to move nearby to provide treatment. ‘The truth is that bin Laden was an invalid, but we cannot say that,’ the retired official said. ‘“You mean you guys shot a cripple? Who was about to grab his AK-47?”’
‘It didn’t take long to get the co-operation we needed, because the Pakistanis wanted to ensure the continued release of American military aid, a good percentage of which was anti-terrorism funding that finances personal security, such as bullet-proof limousines and security guards and housing for the ISI leadership,’ the retired official said. He added that there were also under-the-table personal ‘incentives’ that were financed by off-the-books Pentagon contingency funds. ‘The intelligence community knew what the Pakistanis needed to agree – there was the carrot. And they chose the carrot. It was a win-win. We also did a little blackmail. We told them we would leak the fact that you’ve got bin Laden in your backyard. We knew their friends and enemies’ – the Taliban and jihadist groups in Pakistan and Afghanistan – ‘would not like it.’
A worrying factor at this early point, according to the retired official, was Saudi Arabia, which had been financing bin Laden’s upkeep since his seizure by the Pakistanis. ‘The Saudis didn’t want bin Laden’s presence revealed to us because he was a Saudi, and so they told the Pakistanis to keep him out of the picture. The Saudis feared if we knew we would pressure the Pakistanis to let bin Laden start talking to us about what the Saudis had been doing with al-Qaida. And they were dropping money – lots of it. The Pakistanis, in turn, were concerned that the Saudis might spill the beans about their control of bin Laden. The fear was that if the US found out about bin Laden from Riyadh, all hell would break out. The Americans learning about bin Laden’s imprisonment from a walk-in was not the worst thing.’
Despite their constant public feuding, American and Pakistani military and intelligence services have worked together closely for decades on counterterrorism in South Asia. Both services often find it useful to engage in public feuds ‘to cover their asses’, as the retired official put it, but they continually share intelligence used for drone attacks, and co-operate on covert operations. At the same time, it’s understood in Washington that elements of the ISI believe that maintaining a relationship with the Taliban leadership inside Afghanistan is essential to national security. The ISI’s strategic aim is to balance Indian influence in Kabul; the Taliban is also seen in Pakistan as a source of jihadist shock troops who would back Pakistan against India in a confrontation over Kashmir.
Adding to the tension was the Pakistani nuclear arsenal, often depicted in the Western press as an ‘Islamic bomb’ that might be transferred by Pakistan to an embattled nation in the Middle East in the event of a crisis with Israel. The US looked the other way when Pakistan began building its weapons system in the 1970s and it’s widely believed it now has more than a hundred nuclear warheads. It’s understood in Washington that US security depends on the maintenance of strong military and intelligence ties to Pakistan. The belief is mirrored in Pakistan.
I found all this very helpful. The U.S. has the Pakistani national security leadership on payroll. The public display of the U.S. and Pakistan constantly at odds over the Taliban and drone attacks is all a bluff, a "Punch and Judy" for the little people who still read the newspapers.

Bear this in mind as stories circulate about Saudi vows to acquire a nuclear bomb to counter Iran's nuclear program, I'm sure al-Saud already has a covert program up and running.

Also bear in mind that the drum beat of stories about Syria's use of chlorine is just more lies meant to put pressure on Assad. The quality of the lies here is so poor one marvels at the temerity of the press to publish them. This is from today's story by Peter Baker and Eric Schmitt, "Traces of Chemicals in Syria Add to Pressure on Obama to Enforce a ‘Red Line’ ":
Secretary of State John Kerry raised the issue of chlorine attacks during his talks with Russian officials in Sochi this week. The Assad government is the only force in Syria’s multifront civil war that has the aircraft that witnesses have said have been dropping chlorine bombs. But the Security Council, where Russia wields a veto, has yet to assign blame, and it is far from clear that Washington and Moscow can work together on the issue.
The statement that "The Assad government is the only force in Syria’s multifront civil war that has the aircraft that witnesses have said have been dropping chlorine bombs" is absurd. Where are the pictures from these witnesses? Everyone has a smartphone camera these days. Only Assad's government has helicopters? What about Turkey? What about the CIA, which is operating in the area? What about equipment that ISIS has captured?

Lies. Read the Seymour Hersh article on the slaying of Osama bin Laden and you come away knowing that is the primary role of the state -- the manufacture of lies.

Monday, March 23, 2015

Islamic State a Spook-Run Operation

One of the principal canards about Islamic State peddled in the Western press is that the caliphate is an indigenous formation growing out of grievances that Sunnis have with the Shiite-majority government of Iraq and the Alawites of Syria. But besides the high profile of the Caliph Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, where is there any evidence that ISIS is a homegrown movement? In fact, the overwhelming preponderance of evidence is that ISIS is exogenous to Iraq and Syria, attracting foreign fighters, thanks to a sophisticated online presence, to enter the caliphate through Turkey.

Patrick Cockburn has recently published a number of stories for The Independent describing life inside Islamic State. (The stories have been re-posted on the CounterPunch website.) Cockburn
interviews members of the growing Sunni diaspora in Iraqi Kurdistan, people, mostly from Anbar Province, who have fled the ISIS occupation of their towns and cities.

Cockburn's "The One-Day Siege: ISIS’s Conquest of Hit" is a good example:
It was on 4 October last year that Isis captured the small city of Hit, seizing complete control in the space of just a few hours. For the city’s 100,000 mostly Sunni residents the takeover by the self-proclaimed Islamic State has brought changes that some support, but others deeply resent. 
Among those living in Hit when Isis rolled in was Faisal, a 35-year-old government employee who is married with two children, and a keen observer of all that has befallen the agricultural centre and former transport hub over the past five months. 
He recently fled to the Kurdish capital, Erbil, where he described to me the rule of Isis and its impact on Hit, starting with the day the city was captured.
Faisal goes on to describe a religious police state where there is little money to pay for food, little communication with the outside world, and no work except for the jihadis -- all overseen by foreign fighters and imams:
The internet has not worked in Anbar Province for the last eight months, compelling people to use satellite internet connections that are monitored by Isis. More recently the group offered a limited internet service, though this is only available in internet offices and other locations monitored by the jihadist group. There is no internet access from private homes, while in the public locations, Faisal says, “Isis can spy on computers so they can see what you are surfing and to whom you are talking”.
Predictably, Isis focuses on religion and spreading its variant of Islam. Faisal says: “Many preachers (imams) were replaced by foreign preachers from the Arab world, mostly Saudis, Tunisians and Libyans, as well as Afghans. Some new imams are appointed temporarily just for Friday speech and prayer, while others are permanent appointments. Isis removed some of the old preachers who have left for Baghdad or KRG (the Kurdish-controlled region). These are often Sufis, whose beliefs are rejected by Isis.”
There are many other signs of Isis imposing its cultural agenda in Hit. Faisal says that “at the entrance to every main street and bazaar, there are Isis groups holding black dresses that cover the whole body including the face and head. If a woman does not have one, she must buy one [for about £8] and the money goes to the Isis treasury.”
Are people joining Isis in Hit? Faisal says they do, often for economic reasons. “I know many people in my neighbourhood in Hit who joined Isis,” he says. “They are paid little money, about 175,000 dinars (£80), but they say that the salary is enough because they also enjoy many privileges, including free fuel, cooking gas, sugar, tea, bread, and many other foodstuffs and services.
“Isis still has a strong financial basis. It confiscates the houses of the people who were previously employed in the police, courts, and security forces. These houses, and any furniture in them, are confiscated by the Sharia (legal or religious) court, where the judges are Libyan and Tunisian, though the other staff are locals. The ruling authority in Hit is headed by the military governor, the religious (legal) governor, the security governor and finally the administrative governor.”
Faisal’s account of life in Hit is confirmed by eyewitnesses from other parts of the Islamic State. Isis at first benefited from widespread popular relief that the Iraqi Army was gone, but there is deepening resentment against the enforcement of outlandish rules on personal behaviour that is contrary to local religious and social traditions. These include women being forced to wear the niqab (covering their faces), obligatory attendance at prayers and the destruction of mosques, such as the Younis mosque in Mosul, deemed by Isis to be un-Islamic shrines.
There is also the fear of conscription of young men to fight for the Islamic State, an obligation that is increasingly difficult to avoid and is leading many families to try to leave Isis-controlled territory, which is not easy to do.
But despite resentment by many at its takeover of mosques and schools, Isis is able to use these to propagate its views and to make converts – something that may strengthen the forces of the Islamic State. Conscription does not seem to have diluted the fanaticism of Isis fighters, or their willingness to take heavy casualties, according to Kurdish commanders who have come under attack by Isis units in recent months.
Local eyewitnesses confirm that the unpopularity of Isis is not universal. Sameer, a Kurdish shopkeeper in Mosul, told The Independent last November that “in spite of the coalition air strikes every night and every morning, Isis increases in terms of the number of its men and the territory they occupy”.
Since then, Isis has retreated from much of the Sinjar area west of Mosul, but Ali Hussein Mustafa, a 21-year-old university student who left Mosul last month, says that “many Isis men were much better than the fighters of the Iraqi Army in dealing with people and helping them”.
He says this better behaviour was not invariable and criticised Isis fighters at some checkpoints who harassed or swore at women whose face was not hidden. He added, however, that many people had now concluded that “Isis rule is no better, and maybe worse, than what they endured before [when the US or Iraqi government was in charge of Mosul from 2003 to 2014]”.
It should be said that Patrick Cockburn has always stuck to the "ISIS is an indigenous response to Shiite misrule of al-Maliki" argument, putting the leftist journalist in line with the U.S. State Department. But recently he published a story, "Is the Defeat of ISIS in Iraq Inevitable?," that sort of softened his pro-Sunni "It's all Maliki's fault" slant:
As Isis’s columns advanced last year, its fighters carried out massacres to spread fear just as Saddam Hussein had done against the Kurds and Shia a quarter of a century earlier. When the government’s Badush prison, near Mosul, was captured by Isis, its fighters slaughtered 670 Shia prisoners. At Camp Speicher, outside Tikrit, 800 Shia cadets were lined up in front of trenches and machine-gunned. Pictures of the scene resemble those of atrocities carried out by the German army in Russia in 1941. In August, when Isis fighters stormed into Kurdish-held regions, they targeted the Yazidis as “pagans” to be murdered, raped and enslaved.
To me it seems obvious that ISIS is a spook-run operation, meaning a government intelligence bureau is either at the control board or actively assisting a small leadership group in directing the caliphate. Popular movements are messy and enthusiastic, always either falling short or spilling over stated objectives in a public way. ISIS is nothing of the sort. It is opaque and mercenary; its messaging strictly controlled. No, this is definitely a top-down production.

When ISIS suffered a defeat recently in Tikrit at the hands of the Iraqi Army and Shiite militias working in concert with Kurdish pesh merga there was a prompt asymmetrical response: the terror attack targeting tourists at a museum in Tunisia and the suicide bombings at two Zaydi Shiite mosques in Sana. This reminded me of the old Rumsfeld neocon logic of "When you have a problem one way to solve it is to make it bigger."

Scott Shane had a story, a good one, that was featured prominently on The New York Times website for most of the weekend. In "From Minneapolis to ISIS: An American’s Path to Jihad," it is clear that the young Somali men from Minneapolis were able to hook up with ISIS recruiters at a mosque in Bloomington. Answer the question of who paid for their plane tickets and we'll be a little clearer how the ISIS network operates and who funds it.

And it will turn out that ISIS is no different than Al Qaeda, an organization funded and supported by the Gulf Sheikhdoms.

Monday, March 16, 2015

Fourth Anniversary of War in Syria + CIA Funds Al Qaeda

A number of interesting stories appeared over the weekend that reaffirm the idea that the future is one of perpetual war.

First, there was Ben Hubbard's marking of the four-year anniversary of the war in Syria, "An Ever-Bleaker Syria, From All Vantage Points":
. . . [O]ne of the starkest indications of what four years of conflict have done to Syria came from space, with new satellite images showing that mass destruction and displacement have extinguished more than four-fifths of the country’s lights, according to an analysis by Xi Li of Wuhan University in China and the University of Maryland at College Park. 
The Syria conflict began four years ago this week with protests calling for political reforms inspired by the Arab Spring uprisings elsewhere in the Middle East.
Since then, it has repeatedly metastasized: President Bashar al-Assad unleashed soldiers and thugs to quell the unrest; the opposition spawned armed rebel groups; foreign powers poured in military aid; and the resulting violence spread chaos in increasingly large expanses of territory, allowing extremist groups to establish footholds and increase their power.
Syria enters its fifth year of conflict with few signs that the war will end soon. International efforts to bring the warring parties together for peace talks have fallen dormant, and the United Nations envoy, Staffan de Mistura, has made little progress on even his modest goal of a short-term cease-fire in only one of Syria’s many battleground cities. 
Instead, international attention has shifted to military action against the extremists of the Islamic State, who control parts of Syria and Iraq and have shocked the world by beheading their foes and demolishing historical sites.
You'll notice that Hubbard never directly mentions the United States as a "foreign power" that fanned the conflict in Syria (which used to be uniformly referred to as a "civil war," but an undeniable influx of jihadis from abroad, an influx aided by the Gulf monarchies, Turkey, the U.S. and U.K., made that designation impossible even for the purveyors of crass propaganda).

The U.S. role has not gone unmentioned in the "newspaper of record." The CIA runs covert operations in both Jordan and Turkey to rid Syria of its Baathist government. This has been reported by the Gray Lady in the past, as has the U.S. high-tech weapons transfers to the "good" Syrian rebels which always manage to find their way to the "bad" jihadis (for a helpful roundup of evidence of an Islamic State-U.S. linkage, see Tim Anderson's "The Relationship between Washington and ISIS: The Evidence.")

Now that we are at the fourth anniversary of the cracking of Syria, to get a sense of the U.S. role in that cracking, we should all again read Seymour Hersh's "The Red Line and the Rat Line," something to keep in mind as Hubbard ticks off the toll of Syria's destruction:
Aid organizations say that the rise of the Islamic State, also known as ISISor ISIL, has not only inflicted deprivation and violence on the communities it conquers, but has also siphoned international attention from a growing humanitarian crisis that is echoing increasingly far from Syria’s borders. Last year, for example, brought a record high for illegal migration across the Mediterranean to Europe. Many of those taking the often-lethal trips were Syrian.
Humanitarian organizations issued a barrage of reports for the anniversary of the war’s beginning that quantify how hard life has become for Syrians.
About half of the country’s prewar population has fled from home, according to the United Nations, and nearly four million people have become refugees abroad, putting large burdens on neighboring countries like Turkey, Jordan and Lebanon.
A report by the Syrian Center for Policy Research said that education was in a “state of collapse”; that 6 percent of Syrians had been killed or wounded; and that life expectancy had dropped by 20 years since 2010.
“The numbers are staggering,” said Valerie Amos, the departing emergency relief coordinator for the United Nations. “They are so staggering that they have become almost meaningless to people.” 
For Syrian civilians in the country, the war has meant a downward spiral of death, uncertainty, poverty and displacement.
***
Hopes that the situation would improve rose briefly a year ago when the United Nations Security Council passed its first resolution on Syria, calling for free access to humanitarian aid. Another resolution authorized aid shipments across borders not controlled by the Syrian government.
But last week, a coalition of 21 aid groups released a harsh report saying that the resolutions had failed to make much difference.
“There is more death, more displacement, an increase in restrictions by neighboring countries and a more desperate situation for the refugees and for those displaced inside Syria,” said Daniel Gorevan, who handles Syria policy for Oxfam, one of the groups that participated in the report.
In countries bordering Syria, the flood of refugees has put a heavy burden on economies and budgets. In Lebanon, where about one in five residents is a refugee, some communities have been transformed by the human tide.
There you have it. Another Palestinian-like diaspora in the Middle East, with all misery and conflict that entails for the future.

One wonders why if the U.S. accepted the rehabilitation in Egypt of the old guard Mubarak forces in a bloody display of despotic force, peace can't made with Assad. But judging from the State Department's quick walk back of Kerry's statement that peace can be negotiated with Assad, "Kerry Suggests There Is a Place for Assad in Syria Talks," the war in Syria will grind on until there is some sort of region-wide collapse. Why? Because U.S. policy answers to the Saudis and Israelis, and this is the way they want it.

The Obama administration is slowing its troop withdrawal schedule in Afghanistan. This story appeared the same day as The New York Times spotlighted Matthew Rosenberg's bombshell, "C.I.A. Cash Ended Up in Coffers of Al Qaeda," which is actually a follow up to a story he wrote nearly two-years ago about the slush fund the Central Intelligence Agency set up for then president Hamid Karzai. That was the fund tapped to pay Al Qaeda ransom money for a Afghan diplomat, Abdul Khaliq Farahi, son-in-law to a powerful advisor of Karzai.

As Rosenberg reports, the CIA's slush fund practices continue under current president Ashraf Ghani:
The cash flow has slowed since a new president, Ashraf Ghani, assumed office in September, Afghan officials said, refusing to elaborate. But they added that cash was still coming in, and that it was not clear how robust any current American constraints on it are. 
“It’s cash,” said a former Afghan security official. “Once it’s at the palace, they can’t do a thing about how it gets spent.”
This how the "Great Game" works. It is money for war, and it is war all the time.

Monday, March 2, 2015

Netanyahu's Request to Congress: War on Iran

The frontpage news has a tendency to lurch from one "bell cow" to the next. Recently that bell cow has been Greece's negotiations with the troika in Brussels and the Novorossiya Armed Forces victory in Debaltseve. Islamic State's war crimes have taken on a background white noise quality.

The new bell cow is Netanyahu's speech before Congress tomorrow. The paper is rife with stories -- about Israeli public opinion regarding the rift between Democrats and Likudniks, about Jews in Congress and whether they will attend Netanyahu's speech, about John Kerry's hands-on negotiations with Iran over its nuclear program.

What doesn't get highlighted in any of the above stories is how unprecedented it is for a House Speaker to invite the leader of a foreign country to address Congress without the consent of the Executive Branch. And it is not as if Netanyahu's address will be some pro forma exercise in praise of the filial bonds between Israel and the United States; rather, it will be a pointed critique of ongoing negotiations between the United States and Iran, the failure of which will likely entail some form of attack on Iran.

Basically, Netanyahu is coming to Washington D.C. to request that Congress wage war on Iran. This is what it boils down to. Netanyahu's calculation is that Obama and the Democrats, following the 2014 midterms, are dead politically, and that it is better to risk the optics of a soft coup and a display of overt partisanship than have the United States agree to a deal with Iran which formalizes its right to process uranium.

The problem with the Israeli position -- a totally decommissioning of Iran's nuclear program -- is that its only international support comes from the foully corrupt Gulf sheikhdoms, the same countries that are tacitly supporting Al Qaeda and Islamic State.

And herein lies the untenable nature of the U.S. position in the Middle East: It is tacitly working with Iran to beat back Islamic State and Al Qaeda in Iraq, Yemen and Syria while at the same time it is collaborating with the Saudis and Turks to make sure Sunni Salafi interests are preserved in these very regions. It is the dance of perpetual war.

The dance can be maintained because there is no substantive democracy in the United States. The people can vote for a peace candidate but that candidate will do nothing other than deliver up more war. All Netanyahu's appearance tomorrow will do is ram home the obvious -- Americans don't live in a democracy.

AIPAC will praise a Congress that is universally loathed by the people it purports to represent. Yet Samantha Power and Susan Rice will appear before AIPAC today in an act of obeisance.

Israel's elections are March 17. At the end of the month the P5+1 talks are supposed to conclude with the announcement of a framework agreement, the details of which are to be hashed out by summer. My guess is that a framework agreement will be reached. Congress will try to pass more sanctions. The votes are probably there to override a filibuster in the Senate. Then Obama will veto the sanctions. It should be interesting.

Thursday, February 5, 2015

Follow Up on the Zacarias Moussaoui Bombshell Connecting Saudi Arabia to 9/11

It is encouraging to see The New York Times follow up Scott Shane's "Moussaoui Calls Saudi Princes Patrons of Al Qaeda" with two additional stories today.

Yesterday I monitored Google News to see how much play the Moussaoui bombshell was getting. The answer was not that much. The big news at the top of the page was on the fatal Metro-North Railroad accident in New York and Islamic State's immolation of a caged Jordanian fighter pilot, First Lt. Moaz al-Kasasbeh. I was prepared for the Moussaoui story to be a one-off.

Unfortunately one of the two stories today -- "Pre-9/11 Ties Haunt Saudis as New Accusations Surface," by Ben Hubbard and Scott Shane -- is a pitiful effort by the Gray Lady to walk back, or at least muddy, Shane's original report. I say pitiful because it is constructed out of quotes from establishment academics (Princeton's Bernard Haykel and Texas A & M Bush School of Government's Gregory Gause III, whose universities are likely endowed by Saudi money), Saudi royalty and former U.S. ambassador to Saudi Arabia Charles Freeman all casting doubt on the veracity of Moussaoui's claim that key members of the Saudi royal family with critical positions in the Kingdom backed the 9/11 attacks.

Where is an outline of the case against Saudi Arabia that the families of the 9/11 victims are pursuing? That is what should be addressed in this follow up because it is civil suit that has not be reported on extensively. We get plenty of stories about Jewish families going after Hamas and Iran in civil court for backing terrorism but very little about the great white whale of international jihad, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

The gist of the Hubbard and Shane walk back is that, yes, the Saudis supported the mujahedeen in Afghanistan, along with the U.S. government, and these mujahedeen morphed into Al Qaeda, But the Saudis cut their ties with Al Qaeda.

For a sample of the quality of the walk back there is this quote from Princeton's Haykel:
By 1994, when Osama bin Laden was stripped of his Saudi citizenship and banned from the kingdom, the Qaeda founder was “writing nonstop against the Saudi regime with the idea of toppling it,” said Bernard Haykel, professor of Near Eastern studies at Princeton. “That the Saudis would knowingly support a movement that sought to destroy them makes no sense to me.”
I guess a prestigious perch at an Ivy League university blinds an intellectual like Haykel to the possibility that Saudis might support Al Qaeda with the understanding that its targets will be first and foremost the "Far Enemy."

In any case, Hubbard and Shane have a tough pull on their hands. Piles of evidence point to the Saudis. Everyone knows it, accepts it as an existential reality. The story even acknowledges a continuation of the pattern today with Saudis funding fighters in Libya and Syria:
. . . American officials have praised the Saudi government for cracking down on militants inside the kingdom and for acting to stop terrorist financing by Saudi citizens. But the kingdom has continued to support militant groups other than Al Qaeda and armed tribes that it sees as advancing its policies in Libya, Syria and elsewhere. And at home, the kingdom’s traditional religious establishment promotes and enforces a strict interpretation of Islam.
The point of the Hubbard and Shane walk back is to muddy the waters, float the narrative that Saudi support for Al Qaeda was a historical artifact that preceded 9/11 (even though there is a paragraph in the piece built around a quote from Ambassador Freeman that states the Saudis didn't seriously change their thinking on Al Qaeda until 2003 when there were Qaeda-linked bombings in the Kingdom) as well as cast doubt on Zacarias Moussaoui.

The second story today on the Saudi connection to 9/11 is by the reliable Carl Hulse ("Claims Against Saudis Cast New Light on Secret Pages of 9/11 Report") and focuses on the long, strange history of the national security classification of the 28 pages classified 13 years ago obviously finger the Saudis as the funding source for the 9/11 attacks -- former Florida Senator Bob Graham has said as much. And Obama has promised family members of 9/11 victims that he will release section 4, but he never has. The reason? Pressure for some sort of action against the House of Saud would be hard to resist. Why not some fianancial sanctions? We have plenty levied against Iran and Iran didn't attack us on 9/11.

Another reason is that the U.S. doesn't want to stop funding for jihad as this has replaced the Cold War as the primary rationale for its globe-straddling militarism. As one of plaintiffs in the civil suit against the Saudis explains:
WASHINGTON — A still-classified section of the investigation by congressional intelligence committees into the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks has taken on an almost mythic quality over the past 13 years — 28 pages that examine crucial support given the hijackers and that by all accounts implicate prominent Saudis in financing terrorism. 
Now new claims by Zacarias Moussaoui, a convicted former member of Al Qaeda, that he had high-level contact with officials of the Saudi Arabian government in the prelude to Sept. 11 have brought renewed attention to the inquiry’s withheld findings, which lawmakers and relatives of those killed in the attacks have tried unsuccessfully to declassify. 
“I think it is the right thing to do,” said Representative Stephen F. Lynch, Democrat of Massachusetts and an author of a bipartisan resolution encouraging President Obama to declassify the section. “Let’s put it out there.”

White House officials say the administration has undertaken a review on whether to release the pages but has no timetable for when they might be made public.
Mr. Lynch and his allies have been joined by former Senator Bob Graham of Florida, who as chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee was a leader of the inquiry. He has called for the release of the report’s Part 4, which dealt with Saudi Arabia, since President George W. Bush ordered it classified when the rest of the report was released in December 2002.
Mr. Graham has repeatedly said it shows that Saudi Arabia was complicit in the Sept. 11 attacks. “The 28 pages primarily relate to who financed 9/11, and they point a very strong finger at Saudi Arabia as being the principal financier,” Mr. Graham said last month as he pressed for the pages to be made public.
Relatives of those killed on Sept. 11 as well as plaintiffs in a federal lawsuit against Saudi Arabia have also demanded that the pages be made public, seeing them as the vital link that they believe connects an important ally of the United States to the deadly attacks. They say the pages, Part 4 of the report, could also help in determining the source of current funding for terrorist activities.
“If we stop funding of terrorism and hold those people accountable, wouldn’t it make a dent in the financing of terrorism today?” asked William Doyle, whose son, Joseph, was killed in the World Trade Center. Mr. Doyle said that President Obama personally assured him after the death of Osama bin Laden that he would declassify that section of the report.
Proponents of releasing Part 4, titled “Finding, Discussion and Narrative Regarding Certain National Security Matters,” have suggested that the Bush and Obama administrations have held it back for fear of alienating an influential military and economic partner rather than for any national security consideration.
I don't see how section 4 can remain classified now. To keep it classified with a presidential campaign fast approaching would require a great deal of political capital, something the Democrats don't have. I would imagine what will happen is that there will be more attacks on Moussaoui, more muddying and prevarication in the prestige press, high profile senators will eventually stand on their hind legs and voice support for their paymasters in the Kingdom, and Obama will grudgingly release the 28-pages, possibly at date designated after the 2016 election, in a highly redacted form.

***CORRECTION***

Originally I said that the 28 classified pages are part of the 9/11 Commission Report. That is incorrect. The 28 classified pages are part of the "Joint Inquiry into Intelligence Community Activities before and after the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001," which Senator Bob Graham co-chaired.

Tuesday, February 3, 2015

A Vindication of the Obvious: Moussaoui Fingers King Salman

Scott Shane has this bombshell posted on the Gray Lady web site within the last hour, "Moussaoui Calls Saudi Princes Patrons of Al Qaeda":
WASHINGTON — In highly unusual testimony inside the federal supermax prison, a former operative for Al Qaeda has described prominent members of Saudi Arabia’s royal family as major donors to the terrorist network in the late 1990s and claimed that he discussed a plan to shoot down Air Force One with a Stinger missile with a staff member at the Saudi Embassy in Washington.
The Qaeda member, Zacarias Moussaoui, has received a diagnosis of mental illness but was found competent to stand trial on terrorism charges. He was sentenced to life in prison in 2006 and is held in the most secure prison in the federal system, in Florence, Colo.
Last year, he wrote to Judge George B. Daniels of United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, who is presiding over a lawsuit filed against Saudi Arabia by relatives of those killed in the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. He said he wanted to testify in the case, and after lengthy negotiations with Justice Department officials and the federal Bureau of Prisons, a team of lawyers was permitted to enter the prison and question him for two days last October.
In a statement Monday night, the Saudi Embassy noted that the national Sept. 11 commission had rejected allegations that the Saudi government or Saudi officials had funded Al Qaeda.
“Moussaoui is a deranged criminal whose own lawyers presented evidence that he was mentally incompetent,” the statement said. “His words have no credibility.”
The allegations from Mr. Moussaoui come at a sensitive time in Saudi-American relations, less than two weeks after the death of the country’s longtime monarch, King Abdullah, and the succession of his brother, King Salman.
There has often been tension between Saudi leaders and the Obama administration since the Arab uprisings of 2011 and the efforts to manage the region’s resulting turmoil. Mr. Moussaoui describes meeting in Saudi Arabia with Salman, then the crown prince, and other Saudi royals while delivering them letters from Osama bin Laden.
There has long been evidence that wealthy Saudis provided support for bin Laden, the son of a Saudi construction magnate, and Al Qaeda before the 2001 attacks. Saudi Arabia had worked closely with the United States to finance Islamic militants fighting the Soviet Army in Afghanistan in the 1980s, and Al Qaeda drew its members from militant fighters.
But the extent and nature of Saudi involvement in Al Qaeda, and whether it extended to the planning and financing of the Sept. 11 attacks, has long been a subject of dispute.
Mr. Moussaoui’s testimony, if judged credible, provides new details of the extent and nature of that support in the pre-9/11 period. In more than 100 pages of testimony, filed in federal court in New York on Monday, he comes across as calm and largely coherent, though the plaintiffs’ lawyers questioning him do not challenge his statements.
“My impression was that he was of completely sound mind — focused and thoughtful,” said Sean P. Carter, a Philadelphia lawyer with Cozen O’Connor who participated in the deposition on behalf of the plaintiffs. He said that the lawyers needed to get a special exemption from the “special administrative measures” that keep many convicted terrorists in federal prisons from communicating with outsiders.
The French-born Mr. Moussaoui was detained weeks before Sept. 11 on immigration charges in Minnesota, so he was incarcerated at the time of the attacks. Earlier in 2001, he had taken flying lessons and was wired $14,000 by a Qaeda cell in Germany, evidence that he might have been preparing to become one of the hijackers.
Prince Turki al-Faisal, formerly a Saudi spy chief, who a former Qaeda operative said was on a list of the group’s donors. Credit: Mandel Ngan/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
He said in the prison deposition that he was directed in 1998 or 1999 by Qaeda leaders in Afghanistan to create a digital database of donors to the group. Among those he said he recalled listing in the database were Prince Turki al-Faisal, then the Saudi intelligence chief; Prince Bandar Bin Sultan, the longtime Saudi ambassador to the United States; Prince al-Waleed bin Talal, a prominent billionaire investor; and many of the country’s leading clerics.
“Sheikh Osama wanted to keep a record who give money,” he said in imperfect English — “who is to be listened to or who contributed to the jihad.”
Mr. Moussaoui said he acted as a courier for Bin Laden, carrying personal messages to prominent Saudi princes and clerics. And he described his training in Qaeda camps in Afghanistan in preparation for various proposed plots.
He helped conduct a trial explosion of a 750-kilogram bomb as a trial run for a planned truck-bomb attack on the American Embassy in London, he said, using the same weapon used in the Qaeda attacks in 1998 on the American Embassies in Kenya and Tanzania. He also studied the possibility of staging attacks with crop-dusting aircraft.
In addition, Mr. Moussaoui said, “We talk about the feasibility of shooting Air Force One.”
Specifically, he said, he had met an official of the Islamic Affairs Department of the Saudi Embassy in Washington when the Saudi official visited Kandahar. “I was supposed to go to Washington and go with him” to “find a location where it may be suitable to launch a Stinger attack and then, after, be able to escape,” he said.
He said he was arrested before being able to carry out the reconnaissance mission.
Mr. Moussaoui’s behavior at his trial in 2006 was sometimes erratic. He tried to fire his own lawyers, who presented evidence that he suffered from serious mental illness. But Judge Leonie M. Brinkema, who presided, declared that she was “fully satisfied that Mr. Moussaoui is completely competent” and called him “an extremely intelligent man.”
“He has actually a better understanding of the legal system than some lawyers I’ve seen in court,” she said.
Mr. Carter, the plaintiffs’ lawyer, said that he and his colleagues hoped to return to the Colorado prison to conduct additional questioning of Mr. Moussaoui and that they had been told by prison officials it would be permitted. “We are confident he has more to say,” Mr. Carter said.
I'm sure Moussaoui will be dismissed as insane. Nonetheless, more loss of credibility for the state when they deny yet again the obvious -- that the Saudis maintain the jihadis -- ISIS, Al Qaeda, you name them -- and we play along so we can keep the warfare state forever up and running.

Watch as bought and sold Senators from both sides of the aisle rush to defend the Kingdom -- first the most corrupt, Bob Menendez; then Bob Corker. Thank goodness for the families of the 9/11 victims and their lawyers. If USG actively moves to suppress this based on national security or some other nonsense, we're looking at a total collapse of public support, what little of it there is left, for federal authority. Then we will be that much closer to Egypt.