Showing posts with label Peter Baker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter Baker. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 18, 2015

U.S. Position on Syria Becoming Untenable: How Long Can Obama Keep the Spotlight from Shining on Saudi Arabia?

How do you publish a lengthy feature on the growth of ISIS, as the Gray Lady does today with Ian Fisher's "In Rise of ISIS, No Single Missed Key but Many Strands of Blame," and barely -- maybe once or twice in passing -- mention Saudi Arabia?

It is ludicrous, but it goes directly to the heart of the U.S. position on the war in Syria. Obama is speaking out of both sides of his mouth. On the one side, he has repeatedly dismissed the seriousness of Islamic State, insisting the caliphate is an epiphenomenon of Assad's brutally; that once Assad is ushered off the stage, then the dove of peace will descend and all will set about to the righteous path. On the other side, Obama has warned of toppling the Syrian government militarily, for chaos a la Libya will reign in the absence of Baathist rule.

So what you have is a policy of slow-motion regime change where the U.S. is facilitating as best it can, according to the wishes of its partners in the GCC, a victory of jihadist forces over the Syrian government, while simultaneously hoping that the situation doesn't get too out of control.

But the situation is clearly out of control and it has been for years. It is only when a European capital city comes under assault that most people in the West suddenly appear to have arisen from slumber and started to demand answers. Of course prior to Paris, there was Beirut, Sharm el Sheikh, Ankara, etc., not to mention the huge influx of refugees to Europe from the greater Middle East.

That's why on Monday Obama was riddled with skeptical questions from reporters at the G20 conference in Turkey. In that appearance before the press (Michael Shear and Peter Baker,
"Obama Says Strategy to Fight ISIS Will Succeed") Obama contradicted his CIA chief John Brennan by saying that the Paris terror attack was not all that sophisticated but more a product of ideology, before reasserting the canard that ISIS flourished in the vacuum created by the war in Syria:
At his news conference here, Mr. Obama sounded weary as he repeatedly rejected criticism of his yearlong strategy. Wrapping up 48 hours of diplomacy in this Turkish resort community on the Mediterranean Sea, the president seemed frustrated by second-guessing and twice chided reporters for asking the same question in slightly different ways. 
He denied underestimating the Islamic State, saying that the group’s attacks have not been particularly sophisticated. “If you have a handful of people who don’t mind dying, they can kill a lot of people,” he said. “That’s one of the challenges of terrorism. It’s not their sophistication or the particular weaponry that they possess. But it is the ideology they carry with them and their willingness to die.” [But whose ideology is it? It is Saudi Wahhabism.]
***
In the end, he said, the strategy will choke off the Islamic State’s financing, cut off its supply lines and reinforcements and make it harder to hold territory. Along with a diplomatic solution to the Syrian civil war that provided a vacuum for the Islamic State to fill, “that ultimately is going to be what’s going to make a difference,” Mr. Obama said, adding, “and it’s going to take some time.” 
But who created that vacuum of war? The U.S. and its allies did.

If you want a "man on a galloping horse" perspective on the war in Syria, straight with no bullshit, consult Abel Bari Atwan's interview yesterday on Democracy Now!:
You know, Saudi Arabia is the origin of radicalism, Islamic radicalism, in the Middle East and the whole world and the whole Islamic world. Why? Because al-Qaeda ideology—sorry, Islamic State ideology is the same Wahhabi ideology which adopted by the Saudi kingdom. This is—you know, they go back to the time of Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab in 1704, you know, so they are doing—doing exactly the same. They are doing in Syria and Iraq this brutality, this savagery, the Wahhabism of the Saudi regime in 1705 and ’06, when they actually invaded Karbala and Najaf. They committed the same massacres.
So, Saudi Arabia, actually, now, they are—they are, actually, with Qatar and with Turkey. They have some sort of alliance. And they started the problem in Syria. They poured billions in Syria, hoping to topple the Assad regime for personal revenge, not for political means, not for actually, you know, a strategic move from their side. They just want to take revenge, personal revenge, because Assad insulted them in a way or another, and also because they thought that they can topple him in a few weeks, few months maximum. So they poured billions of weapons. And also, they encouraged a hundred—sorry, tens of thousands of volunteers to go through Turkey to Syria to fight against the Assad regime.
I would add that the Saudis and Turks have strategic objectives. They want to make sure after the deal with the West on its nuclear program that the Iranians do not have stable allies in Iraq and Syria. 

Monday, June 15, 2015

Obama's TPP/Asia Pivot Waterloo + Organized Labor Proof of Life + Bad News for Saudis/ISIS + Greek Default and Peak Neoliberalism

There is quite a bit of good news this Monday morning. Dire assessments of Obama's "lame duckery" continue to roll in (Peter Baker, "The Trans-Pacific Partnership and a President’s Legacy") following Friday's failed vote in the House of Representative on trade-promotion authority (Jonathan Weisman, "House Rejects Trade Measure, Rebuffing Obama’s Dramatic Appeal"). Obama's Asia pivot is being declared DOA. This is from Baker's frontpage piece this morning:
The administration tried making a foreign policy argument over the last few weeks, maintaining that if the United States does not seal the trade pact, it will be leaving the field to China, which has been exerting its clout in recent years, whether by investing in energy supplies in Africa and the Middle East or by asserting claims over disputed waters and islands. 
But some on the left argue that the administration is using China to scare lawmakers and exaggerating the competition. “I just don’t buy this China boogeyman stuff,” said Jared Bernstein, a senior fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities and a former economic adviser to Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. “If anything, I see China as being more inward looking, devoting less resources to mercantile-type trade and more to internal investment, consumption and developing human capital.” 
Supporters of the trade pact hope to hold a new vote this week on the part of the trade package rejected by the House on Friday but will need to secure 90 more votes. Representative Paul D. Ryan, the Wisconsin Republican who has worked with the White House to secure trade negotiating authority, said on Sunday that if Mr. Obama wanted to avoid being a “very lame-duck president,” he would have to win over members of his own party. 
“I think that this can be salvaged because I think people are going to realize just how big the consequences are for American leadership,” Mr. Ryan said on “Fox News Sunday.” 
But there was little indication over the weekend that many minds had been changed on the political left. “We need to regroup and come up with a trade policy which demands that corporate America start investing in this country rather than in countries all over the world,” Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination, said on “Face the Nation” on CBS.
*** 
“There is no Asia pivot without an economic component, and that component is tied up in T.P.P.,” said Walter Lohman, director of the Asian studies program at the Heritage Foundation. The challenge for Mr. Obama, he added, is that no matter how important the trade pact may be to his foreign policy, Congress will consider it through an economic lens. “Geopolitics gets it very few votes.”
As I said, good news. Good news too that organized labor figured out how to do things properly on this one, both by working in concert with citizen groups and environmentalists, as well as playing hardball with two-faced Dems. This is from Noam Sheiber's weekend story, "Labor’s Might Seen in Failure of Trade Deal as Unions Allied to Thwart It":
Labor’s smartest move was lining up opposition to the president’s trade agenda as early as 2013, when the fight was still a distant prospect. “They did a good job getting out and defining T.P.A. early among Democratic House members, really peeling off an enormous number of folks who didn’t have long history or an understanding of the issue, prior to the White House engaging,” said Simon Rosenberg, president of the advocacy group NDN and a supporter of Mr. Obama’s effort. 
Mr. Rosenberg pointed in particular to a letter labor activists helped circulate late that year, which roughly 150 House Democrats signed. “It was a letter that was going to make it hard to vote for T.P.A. once you signed it,” Mr. Rosenberg said.
***

This time around, not only did the firefighters make a considerable investment — producing ads and paying to broadcast them in five congressional districts — but Mr. Schaitberger personally led the effort within the A.F.L-C.I.O. executive council to freeze all donations to members of Congress by the political action committees of the federation and affiliated unions until after the vote on trade promotion authority. (Mr. Schaitberger, who developed the motion, credits Mr. Trumka with helping create almost unanimous support for it.) 
Mr. Schaitberger acknowledged some apprehension within the labor movement about denying money even to longtime congressional allies, but he argued that it had been the most effective way to persuade friendly members of Congress to pressure wavering Democratic lawmakers. “We wanted to encourage those members to use their influence, their passion for our position, to move some of their colleagues,” he said.
A win for labor, a blow to the Asia pivot, why not add a story about workers at Gawker Media voting to join a union? Rachel Swarns reports in "At Gawker Media, New Economy Workers Strive to Form a New Kind of Union" that
. . . Last year, about 22 percent of recent college graduates were either working part time or unemployed, compared with about 15 percent in 2007, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco.
That may be one reason young adults view unions more favorably than other age groups. In March, a national survey of 1,500 adults conducted by the Pew Research Center found that 55 percent of those ages 18 to 29 view unions positively, while 29 percent view them unfavorably.
Overseas, peace talks on Yemen begin in Geneva today. The Houthis continue to roll up victories despite the Saudi-led terror bombing. The Kurdish fighters are battering Islamic State in northern Syria, threatening to capture the main ISIS supply route from Turkey to Raqqa. All good news.

Plus, we are now approaching the decisive moment in the Greek-troika debt negotiations. A default by Greece seems unavoidable. Yves Smith of Naked Capitalism is terming this "Peak Neoliberalism":
The resolution of the Greece/creditor deadlock may also mark Peak Neoliberalism. It’s possible, but only remotely so, that Greece and its creditor overlords will back off from their collision. But as we’ve said for years, Germany is wedded to incompatible goals, namely running large trade surpluses but not financing its trade partners. It is destined to burn them down if it fails to find a new course of action. Greece is also wedded to incompatible goals, namely getting a real break from austerity while staying in the Eurozone. 
On the current trajectory, Greece will suffer horribly under a default or Grexit. The creditors have the incentive and the means to make either one more painful than continued austerity so as to force Greek citizens to capitulate and vote in a more compliant government. There is a bloody-minded faction that includes Finland, Latvia, Spain, as well as some ECB governors that is eager to punish Greece and sees that as necessary to preserve the Eurozone. We’ll see soon enough whether these austerity radicals that we call the ultras persuade enough key players to put their plans into action. 
But even in a less punitive scenario, a default or Grexit will do very serious damage to an already fragile and deeply depressed economy. Those who assert that Greece will bounce back quickly don’t have an economy this close to being a failed state as a comparable. 
Our view has been that the most likely scenario is a default in the Eurozone, and that the authorities have likely underestimated the damage if the impasse ultimately leads to a Grexit. Even if they are correct that financial contagion is contained, political contagion over the next few years is another matter entirely. 
But on a bigger frame, no matter how badly things turn out for Greece, the institutions at the core of the European project will emerge with their image badly damaged. The dirty secret has long been that the program of European integration was designed to produce rule by technocrats. Those technocrats, by being captive to bad ideology, have failed to deliver on the basic obligation of government: to provide for the safety and well-being of their populace. In a capitalist society, that means producing enough decently remunerated jobs. 
However, even if neoliberalism winds up receding as a result of the brutal Greek negotiations, it’s naive to assume that the exposure of the bankruptcy of neoliberalism means a return to the old European model of more social welfare and (at least in theory) democratic accountability. Ironically, the train wreck we are seeing now can be presented as a prime example of the dangers of democratic rule: a democratically elected government in Greece demanding better treatment from its jailer/creditors, when the most of the debt is held by democratically elected governments who are not willing to give Greece the breaks it wants. And as we’ve stressed from the outset, the fact that the two sides can’t come to agreement is that Syriza’s red line of pensions is also a red line to voters in the states that have provided funding to Greece. 
Thus even if the Greek denouement does represent Peak Neoliberalism, that does not mean that social democracy will emerge victorious. It simply means we will grope towards a new political order. Only if citizens are vigilant and engaged do they have a hope of coming out as winners.
All very true. But what Smith chooses not to underline is that there is no alternative to scrapping neoliberalism. Yes, the way forward to a new political dispensation is not clear because the neoliberal paradigm is still completely dominant; but a perception that it is bankrupt is now broadly taking root in popular consciousness. With this in mind, tomorrow some thoughts on Hillary Clinton's quixotic makeover as a New Deal populist and a working-class suffragette.

Monday, June 8, 2015

The Fourth Estate's Russophobia Obscures Euro Storm on the Horizon

I live in a part of the country that is Democrat and pro-Obama. When I voice misgivings about Obama administration policies -- for instance, I have publicly complained about regime change in Syria and the private health market aspects of Obamacare -- I am usually greeted with confused, quizzical stares. Most people interpret news through a partisan filter. Understanding is a tribal affair. If the conversation continues, my liberal interlocutor will eventually find a way to excuse Obama's shortcomings by invoking the Republican devils in Congress. It is at this point that I bring up the New Cold War. I say, "Republicans didn't instigate a coup in the Ukraine and launch another Cold War with Russia."

This invariably halts the conversation. People have been taught to hate Putin. (Who is Public Enemy #1 if not the Russian president? It's not ISIS's Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi. He's not in the news enough.) But people cannot articulate why it is they hate Putin other than to fall back on the contradictory lies they are fed by the mainstream Western media: that he is corrupt beyond accounting; that he tirelessly works for a rebirth of Imperial Russia; that he is a brutal thug, an assassin, and so on. People are not equipped to discuss the turmoil in Ukraine with what they have been provided by the MSM. All they know is Ukraine is being attacked by Russia. When this understanding is challenged or problematized, conversation halts because there is no depth of knowledge to sustain it.

Therefore it makes perfect sense that rather than try to deepen the public's knowledge of the conflict in Ukraine and the New Cold War with Russia, a course which would necessarily lead to more popular Western support for Russia's position, the Fourth Estate continues to pump air into the inflatable cartoon Boris and Natasha version of reality. Take this morning's story by Peter Baker and Steven Erlanger, "Russia Wields Aid and Ideology Against West to Fight Sanctions," the gist of which is that there is no legitimate popular support for Russia in Europe; it is all bought and sold by Putin:
WASHINGTON — The war in Ukraine that has pitted Russia against the West is being waged not just with tanks, artillery and troops. Increasingly, Moscow has brought to bear different kinds of weapons, according to American and European officials: money, ideology and disinformation. 
Even as the Obama administration and its European allies try to counter Russia’s military intervention across its border, they have found themselves struggling at home against what they see as a concerted drive by Moscow to leverage its economic power, finance European political parties and movements, and spread alternative accounts of the conflict. 
The Kremlin’s goal seems to be to sow division, destabilize the European Union and possibly fracture what until now has been a relatively unified, if sometimes fragile, consensus against Russian aggression. At the very least, if Russia can peel off even a single member of the European Union, it could in theory prevent the renewal later this month of economic sanctions that are scheduled to expire absent the unanimous agreement of all member states.
What follows is a compendium of alleged Russian subversion of European democracy by bribing officials and financing splinter parties on both the left and right:
American and European officials have accused Moscow of financing green movements in Europe to encourage protests against hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, a move intended to defend Russia’s gas industry. And a shadowy “troll farm” in St. Petersburg uses Twitter to plant fake stories about chemical spills or Ebola outbreaks in the West.
Since long before the Ukraine crisis, money has been a means for Mr. Putin to try to shape events in the West.
After Chancellor Gerhard Schröder stepped down in Germany, he was given a lucrative position with Gazprom, the Russian state energy giant. When President George W. Bush was in office, Mr. Putin asked “would it help you” if Donald L. Evans, Mr. Bush’s close friend and former commerce secretary, were given a high-paying Russian corporate job. (Mr. Bush rejected the idea.)
Russia appears to be getting some traction lately in countries like Greece, Hungary, the Czech Republic and even Italy and France. Not only is it aligning itself with the leftists traditionally affiliated with Moscow since the Cold War, but it is making common cause with far-right forces rebelling against the rise of the European Union that are sympathetic to Mr. Putin’s attack on what he calls the West’s moral decline.
The most prominent example has been the National Front in France, which under Marine Le Pen has confirmed taking an $11.7 million loan from the First Czech-Russian Bank in Moscow, which has been tied to the Kremlin. She has denied a news report that the money was just the first installment of an eventual $50 million in loans to help her party through a presidential election in 2017.
Baker and Erlanger quote think-tank reports and Joint Chiefs head Martin Dempsey. Russia is trying to break apart the European Union; Russia is trying to fracture NATO. Thankfully, they do include one dissenting voice:
But Fiona Hill, a former national intelligence officer on Russia and now a scholar at the Brookings Institution, said that with the exception of Ms. Le Pen’s party in France, the assertions about Russia financing European parties seemed based more on speculation than facts. 
“The question is how much hard evidence does anyone have?” she asked. “And it’s useful for the Russians themselves not to refute rumors and maybe even perpetrate some of them. They want everyone to think everyone is corrupt, everyone can be influenced.”
Baker and Erlanger, if they had been tasked with writing a substantive report rather performing mouth-to-mouth on a dummy, should have focused on Greece and the probability that Athens, locked in an existential struggle with the European Commission, the European Central Bank and the IMF, will block the sanctions. The timelines on Greece's debt negotiations are converging with the EU's re-authorization of Russian sanctions. A catastrophic storm for the U.S./EU is clearly on the horizon. It is not impossible that Greece could both default and simultaneously block the Russian sanctions.

But Baker and Erlanger give us no idea that a storm is on the horizon. You have to read Yves Smith's "G-7 Throws Greece Under the Bus" this morning to find that out. Greece's European creditors are not budging on their demand for a cut to pensions. Anyone following the debt negotiations should know by now that this is an issue on which Syriza will not waver:
As we’ve said for months, there is no solution space on the issue of pensions. This has become an enormously visible issue in the Eurozone lender countries, and their leaders would have to spend an a considerable amount of political capital to support the Greek position, even if they were willing to do that. And in the countries where parliamentary approval is required to release bailout funds, it’s not clear the ruling coalitions could muster the votes, particularly given the late date. There’s not enough time to do the weeks of messaging needed to soften opinion. 
Having said that, I’d like to know how anyone pushes Greece absent giving bribes (aka relenting) given that Tsipras has deeply committed himself to his position between his Le Monde op ed and his speech last Friday, plus by being boxed in by the Left Platform. If Tsipras tries snap elections, the Left Platform MPs have threatened to bolt and form a new party. Tsipras would need them to form a new coalition. The new party would have more freedom of action and visibility outside Syriza. 
Moreover, Tsipras can create an easy excuse for a default by calling elections, either snap elections or more likely a referendum. He could argue, as he has weakly threatened before, that at such an important juncture he can proceed only in accordance with voter wishes. Given the normal minimum times for elections, everything would still be in play by June 30, the IMF default date.
 There very well could be a lot of thunder and lightning by the end of the month.

Thursday, May 14, 2015

Some Thoughts on Seymour Hersh's "The Killing of Osama bin Laden"

It took the homeward-bound commutes of Tuesday and Wednesday to read in its entirety the 10,000-word, 20-page Seymour Hersh deflowering of the Obama administration fable of how it took out Osama bin Laden ("The Killing of Osama bin Laden"), but it was time well spent.

What the reader comes away with is a feeling that the state exists to manufacture lies. Lies abound. An ocean of lies. Obama might not have ordered the burial at sea of the slain Al Qaeda mastermind, as the fable relates (instead, according to Hersh, the Navy SEALs tossed the dismembered parts of bin Laden's corpse out of the helicopter as it ferried them back to Afghanistan), but his decision to promptly publicize the assassination of OBL, reneging on a agreement that he had with Pakistan, necessitated the manufacture of numerous cover stories.

If one has ever cheated on a spouse -- something, sadly, which I did in my youth -- you know that lying about what you did -- when, where and how -- and doing so consistently replicates in the mind schizophrenic effects. One often feels as if he were hallucinating, on a "trip." The lies stack up and you find yourself in a self-created maze; it is a giddy, vertiginous feeling.

In his 10,000 words this is what Hersh successfully conveys about the Obama administration: It is drugged-up on lies. So covetous of the political windfall of bagging bogeyman numero uno with a re-election year on the horizon, Obama went against his defense secretary, the rest of the military brass, and his Pakistani allies and promptly revealed the SEALs assassination mission.

But that revelation turns out to be a lot of bullshit. For one, Osama was not living freely, directing Al Qaeda attacks. He was a prisoner of Pakistanis who had nabbed him in the Hindu Kush in 2006. The Abbottabad compound he lived in was a jail with bars on the windows and barbed wire on the roof; he was under lock and key, guarded night and day, kept under wraps by Pakistan for its own purposes but also at the behest of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The Saudi royals didn't want OBL talking to the CIA about where Al Qaeda's financial support came from for 9/11.

The U.S. found out about Osama's presence in Abbottabad not by super-sleuthing, a fiction presented in Zero Dark Thirty, but from a Pakistani walk-in who wanted the $25 million finder's fee. There was no tracking OBL down through the movements of his courier; rather, it was the U.S. confronting the Pakistanis with the evidence worked up from the walk-in. The Pakistanis, not wanting to lose out on the steady stream of cash provided by USG, fessed up and proceeded to cooperate in all aspects of the operation. Basically, the Navy SEALs mission was a heavily rehearsed execution of a jailed invalid, which Obama repackaged as a courageous display of American grit and derring-do.

The "money" passage for me in Hersh's "The Killing of Osama bin Laden" comes relatively early in the piece:
The walk-in had told the US that bin Laden had lived undetected from 2001 to 2006 with some of his wives and children in the Hindu Kush mountains, and that ‘the ISI got to him by paying some of the local tribal people to betray him.’ (Reports after the raid placed him elsewhere in Pakistan during this period.) Bank was also told by the walk-in that bin Laden was very ill, and that early on in his confinement at Abbottabad, the ISI had ordered Amir Aziz, a doctor and a major in the Pakistani army, to move nearby to provide treatment. ‘The truth is that bin Laden was an invalid, but we cannot say that,’ the retired official said. ‘“You mean you guys shot a cripple? Who was about to grab his AK-47?”’
‘It didn’t take long to get the co-operation we needed, because the Pakistanis wanted to ensure the continued release of American military aid, a good percentage of which was anti-terrorism funding that finances personal security, such as bullet-proof limousines and security guards and housing for the ISI leadership,’ the retired official said. He added that there were also under-the-table personal ‘incentives’ that were financed by off-the-books Pentagon contingency funds. ‘The intelligence community knew what the Pakistanis needed to agree – there was the carrot. And they chose the carrot. It was a win-win. We also did a little blackmail. We told them we would leak the fact that you’ve got bin Laden in your backyard. We knew their friends and enemies’ – the Taliban and jihadist groups in Pakistan and Afghanistan – ‘would not like it.’
A worrying factor at this early point, according to the retired official, was Saudi Arabia, which had been financing bin Laden’s upkeep since his seizure by the Pakistanis. ‘The Saudis didn’t want bin Laden’s presence revealed to us because he was a Saudi, and so they told the Pakistanis to keep him out of the picture. The Saudis feared if we knew we would pressure the Pakistanis to let bin Laden start talking to us about what the Saudis had been doing with al-Qaida. And they were dropping money – lots of it. The Pakistanis, in turn, were concerned that the Saudis might spill the beans about their control of bin Laden. The fear was that if the US found out about bin Laden from Riyadh, all hell would break out. The Americans learning about bin Laden’s imprisonment from a walk-in was not the worst thing.’
Despite their constant public feuding, American and Pakistani military and intelligence services have worked together closely for decades on counterterrorism in South Asia. Both services often find it useful to engage in public feuds ‘to cover their asses’, as the retired official put it, but they continually share intelligence used for drone attacks, and co-operate on covert operations. At the same time, it’s understood in Washington that elements of the ISI believe that maintaining a relationship with the Taliban leadership inside Afghanistan is essential to national security. The ISI’s strategic aim is to balance Indian influence in Kabul; the Taliban is also seen in Pakistan as a source of jihadist shock troops who would back Pakistan against India in a confrontation over Kashmir.
Adding to the tension was the Pakistani nuclear arsenal, often depicted in the Western press as an ‘Islamic bomb’ that might be transferred by Pakistan to an embattled nation in the Middle East in the event of a crisis with Israel. The US looked the other way when Pakistan began building its weapons system in the 1970s and it’s widely believed it now has more than a hundred nuclear warheads. It’s understood in Washington that US security depends on the maintenance of strong military and intelligence ties to Pakistan. The belief is mirrored in Pakistan.
I found all this very helpful. The U.S. has the Pakistani national security leadership on payroll. The public display of the U.S. and Pakistan constantly at odds over the Taliban and drone attacks is all a bluff, a "Punch and Judy" for the little people who still read the newspapers.

Bear this in mind as stories circulate about Saudi vows to acquire a nuclear bomb to counter Iran's nuclear program, I'm sure al-Saud already has a covert program up and running.

Also bear in mind that the drum beat of stories about Syria's use of chlorine is just more lies meant to put pressure on Assad. The quality of the lies here is so poor one marvels at the temerity of the press to publish them. This is from today's story by Peter Baker and Eric Schmitt, "Traces of Chemicals in Syria Add to Pressure on Obama to Enforce a ‘Red Line’ ":
Secretary of State John Kerry raised the issue of chlorine attacks during his talks with Russian officials in Sochi this week. The Assad government is the only force in Syria’s multifront civil war that has the aircraft that witnesses have said have been dropping chlorine bombs. But the Security Council, where Russia wields a veto, has yet to assign blame, and it is far from clear that Washington and Moscow can work together on the issue.
The statement that "The Assad government is the only force in Syria’s multifront civil war that has the aircraft that witnesses have said have been dropping chlorine bombs" is absurd. Where are the pictures from these witnesses? Everyone has a smartphone camera these days. Only Assad's government has helicopters? What about Turkey? What about the CIA, which is operating in the area? What about equipment that ISIS has captured?

Lies. Read the Seymour Hersh article on the slaying of Osama bin Laden and you come away knowing that is the primary role of the state -- the manufacture of lies.

Tuesday, May 12, 2015

Iran War Looms

The problem with the rich is that they are out of touch with reality as lived by the overwhelming majority of the world's population, the 99%. The problem for the overwhelming majority of us who populate the 99% is that the rich run the world. 

Billionaire royals govern the Gulf Cooperation Council; these are the leaders to whom this week in Washington Obama will be pitching the P5+1 accord on Iran's nuclear program. Citizens of the "indispensable nation" will be treated to the unseemly spectacle of their elected leader feting despots.

The GCC has registered its disapproval of the P5+1 negotiations. Only two of six heads of state will be in attendance. Saudi King Salman, after indicating last Friday that he would come to Washington, has cancelled. This has caused some soul searching of the special relationship between the U.S. and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to reach the front page of the "newspaper of record."

As far as it goes, "King’s Absence at Meeting Signals a Saudi-U.S. Marriage Adrift," by Peter Baker and Michael Shear (labeled "News Analysis") is a so-so summary of the recent estrangement of the House of Saud with Obama. The reporters even toss in an acknowledgement of what the Gray Lady has previously denied -- that the Saudi-engineered oil-price drop was a conspiracy hatched with the U.S. to punish Russia:
In the 70 years since Franklin D. Roosevelt met with King Abdul Aziz, the relationship between the United States and Saudi Arabia has been a complicated marriage of shared interests, clashing values and cynical accommodations. The common denominator was a desire for stability. But now the two sides define that differently. 
For Mr. Obama, a diplomatic agreement with Iran curbing its nuclear program offers the strongest chance of keeping conflict in the region from escalating. For the Sunni-led Saudi government, the relaxation of sanctions in the proposed deal would simply give Iran, a predominantly Shiite state, billions of dollars to foment more instability around the region. 
While the Americans and the Saudis are now cooperating to fight the Islamic State, Riyadh wants more action to force out the government of President Bashar al-Assad in Syria, while Mr. Obama has been reluctant to intervene. Similarly, while Mr. Obama has portrayed the drive for greater democracy in the region as a force for good, the Saudis see the still simmering Arab Spring movement as a threat to their hold on power. 
In the midst of all that, the politics of energy have shifted along with the surge in oil production in North Dakota and Texas. No longer so dependent on foreign crude, the United States can flex muscles without worrying about the Saudis cutting its energy supply. Yet Washington still relies on Riyadh to keep the price of oil low to pressure Russia’s energy-based economy in the standoff over Ukraine.
Iran is a rising power. It has far more "people power" behind it than anything the GCC can muster. The only broadly popular active initiative that the Obama administration is supporting -- it is certainly not the TPP or drilling in the Arctic -- is the peace deal with Iran.

One huge problem with the rich, and particularly the super-rich, is that they believe that their money can alter any reality. So you have the unprecedented Netanyahu appearance before a joint session of Congress in March, a foreign leader using "the people's House" as a backdrop for a campaign commercial, criticizing a sitting president's chief foreign policy initiative, an appearance that was apparently facilitated by billionaire casino magnate Sheldon Adelson. The no show by King Salman is more of the same.

But one hopeful note sounded by Ben Hubbard in an accompanying story, "Despite Displeasure With U.S., Saudis Face Long Dependency," is that money doesn't always buy love. Take for instance the reticence of Egypt and Pakistan, despite billions spent by al-Saud, to supply cannon fodder for Yemen:
Saudi Arabia has, however, asked for help from fellow Muslim countries like Pakistan in its Yemen campaign. But despite bankrolling the Pakistani nuclear program and offering other aid over the years, the Saudis were shocked when the Pakistani parliament unanimously voted not to send troops.
Egypt, whose government has been kept afloat by billions of dollars in Persian Gulf aid in recent years, has also declined to send ground troops. 
Despite the reluctance of would-be allies to step up, the gulf nations appear to be at the beginning of what could be a long process of learning to rely more on themselves and other allies. 
“They would prefer for the U.S. to be the godfather and protector, but they also realize that they have to stand on their own feet,” Dr. Seznec said.
Hubbard's story is useful in that it clearly outlines the deep, structural ties between the U.S. and Saudi Arabia. The special relationship is not going to end in divorce:
Decades of cooperation and billions of dollars in weapons contracts have left the gulf nations deeply entwined with the United States and Britain in ways that cannot be quickly undone, analysts say. Qatar hosts the largest United States air base in the region, and Bahrain is the home port of the Navy’s Fifth Fleet. And their efforts to make reliable military partners of fellow Muslim nations like Pakistan and Egypt have met little success, despite tens of billions of dollars in aid.
American-made fighter jets are being used in the Saudi-led bombing campaign in Yemen, but “none of these airplanes would fly if the United States refused to send parts,” Dr. Seznec said. ["Jean-Francois Seznec, a professor of Persian Gulf political economy at the School of Advanced International Studies at Johns Hopkins University.']

***
[T]he Saudis remain heavily reliant on the United States, and to a lesser extent on Britain, in nearly every branch of their security apparatus. 
“The Saudi air force could not carry out day-in, day-out bombing missions without help from U.S. trainers and maintenance experts and the flow of spare parts and ammunition,” said Bruce Riedel, senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, speaking about the Saudi-led bombing campaign against Shiite rebels in Yemen.
A recent report by the Congressional Research Service said Saudi Arabia’s decision to update and expand its air force with American F-15 fighter jets would perpetuate Saudi reliance on parts and training provided by the United States military and defense contractors.
The United States is also involved in training the army and modernizing the Saudis’ national guard, and American advisers paid for by the Saudi government are “embedded in industrial, energy, maritime and cybersecurity offices within the Saudi government,” the report said.
Saudi Arabia, the United States and Britain also have close intelligence ties, with top officials from the three countries meeting frequently and sharing information.
In addition, contracts for fighter jets include agreements on maintenance, spare parts and software upgrades that can go on for years, Mr. Riedel said, keeping the countries’ security operations bound tightly together far into the future.
Dr. Seznec, of the School of Advanced International Studies, estimates that Saudi Arabia has spent about $500 billion to build its military in the last 20 years. About three-quarters of that money has gone to the United States.
“Those are huge amounts of money,” he said.
What motivates the realpolitik bloc behind Obama's peace initiative with Iran is the realization that to do otherwise means an eventual war, sooner now than later. The Saudi/Israeli bet is that whoever succeeds Obama will be amenable to scrapping the P5+1 accord, assuming it is finalized, which is anything but certain, and to maintaining the financial architecture of Iranian sanctions; or, absent that, another war.

The big hurdle in all of this for the billionaire despots and the deep state power brokers who answer to them is public opinion. Maybe I am wrong here, but I don't think the public will stomach an Iran war. If one is launched, it will destroy the country. But that is where things are heading.

Wednesday, April 15, 2015

About-Face by Obama on Senate Foreign Relations Bill Big Win for Iran

Yesterday after seeing the news (Jonathan Weisman and Peter Baker, "Obama Yields, Allowing Congress Say on Iran Nuclear Deal") of Obama's about-face on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee Iran sanctions review bill I said to a coworker, the only one in a office of more than a dozen people who I know at least keeps an eye on the headlines, "This guy is even weaker than I thought." 

What other conclusion can we draw? Obama and Kerry had been promising to fight to the last gasp any encroachment by the Senate on the administration's agreement with Iran on its nuclear program only to meekly acquiesce to a Congressional role after a vote count revealed overwhelming Democratic support for Senate Foreign Relations Chair Bob Corker's draft legislation.

But this morning I think differently -- not that Team Obama is any stronger, but that Team Obama clearly won this round by its tactical retreat. A protracted fight over a veto of a sanctions review bill would have revealed a president without a party and accentuated Obama's lame duckness, at the same time undercutting negotiations on a final agreement in the remaining two months of the P5+1 talks in Switzerland. As Weisman and Baker point out:
White House officials blitzed Congress in the days after the framework of a nuclear deal was announced, making 130 phone calls to lawmakers, but quickly came to the conclusion that the legislation could not be blocked altogether. 
Moreover, officials increasingly worried that an unresolved fight could torpedo the next phase of negotiations with Iran. 
“Having this lingering uncertainty about whether we could deliver on our side of the deal was probably a deal killer,” said a senior administration official, who asked for anonymity to describe internal deliberations.
No, Obama won this one. The sanctions review period was cut in half from 60 days to 30 (though after the time for a presidential veto and Congressional response is added, it comes to 52 days) and the White House does not have to certify every 90 days that Iran is not sponsoring terrorism. In the end, sometime in July, Congress will get to vote on the nuclear deal. A majority will vote against lifting sanctions. Obama will veto, and he will only need 34 Democrats in the Senate to maintain that veto, something I think he will be able to do:
As Congress considers any accord on a very short timetable, it would essentially be able to vote on an eventual end to sanctions, and then later take up the issue depending on whether Iran has met its own obligations. But if it rejected the agreement, Mr. Obama could veto that legislation — and it would take only 34 senators to sustain the veto, meaning that Mr. Obama could lose upward of a dozen Democratic senators and still prevail.
Proof that Obama got the best of the deal is the testy Congressional insistence that the Senate Foreign Relations Committee got everything it originally intended, which is clearly not the case:
White House officials insisted they extracted crucial last-minute concessions. Republicans — and many Democrats — said the president simply got overrun.
“We’re involved here. We have to be involved here,” said Senator Benjamin L. Cardin of Maryland, the committee’s ranking Democrat, who served as a bridge between the White House and Republicans as they negotiated changes in the days before the committee’s vote on Tuesday. “Only Congress can change or permanently modify the sanctions regime.”
***
“We’ve gone from a piece of legislation that the president would veto to a piece of legislation that’s undergone substantial revision such that it’s now in the form of a compromise that the president would be willing to sign,” Mr. Earnest said. “That would certainly be an improvement.”
Senator Bob Corker, Republican of Tennessee and the committee’s chairman, had a far different interpretation. As late as 11:30 a.m., in a classified briefing at the Capitol, Mr. Kerry was urging senators to oppose the bill. The “change occurred when they saw how many senators were going to vote for this, and only when that occurred,” Mr. Corker said.
Mr. Cardin said that the “fundamental provisions” of the legislation had not changed.
An important point to weigh here is that Obama would not have made this tactical retreat unless he had vetted it with his Iranian counterparts. The mild response by President Rouhani to the 19-0 Senate Foreign Relations vote shows that the Iranians can live with the bill and that the P5+1 talks will move along to a final agreement.

This does not mean that Obama will be able to deliver a final agreement even if he can maintain a veto of Congressional obstruction. Congress is controlled by the Saudi and Israeli interests. How else to explain the absurd statement by Tom Cotton?
The agreement “puts Iran, the world’s worst state sponsor of terrorism, on the path to a nuclear weapon,” said Senator Tom Cotton, Republican of Arkansas, as he emerged from the briefing. “Whether that’s a matter of months or a matter of years, that’s a dangerous outcome not just to United States and allies like Israel but to the entire world.”
But the end game here appears to be isolation of Congress and its Saudi and Israeli paymasters from the rest of the world. As the Gray Lady makes clear in an unsigned editorial today, "A Reckless Act in the Senate on Iran":
Mr. Obama’s acquiescence might be a tactical move. He could veto the congressional vote on the final agreement, which is supposed to be concluded by the June 30 deadline, rather than expending political capital in vetoing this measure if it were to pass both chambers of Congress. But the Senate committee’s action puts him in an weakened position as the only leader involved in the negotiations who may not be permitted to fully honor commitments that were made.
The nuclear deal is the product of a multinational negotiation with Iran conducted by the United States, France, Britain, China, Germany and Russia. In no other country has a legislative body demanded the right to block the agreement. Even if Congress barred Mr. Obama from waiving American sanctions, the European Union and the United Nations Security Council could lift the sanctions they imposed, thus undercutting the American decision.
This is the bottom line: Unless Obama gets cold feet and kills the talks in the next two months, an international agreement on Iran's nuclear program will be concluded; at which time, even if Congress can prevent the U.S. from ratifying the agreement, it will not be able to block the rest of the world from doing business with the Islamic Republic.

That is why I think it is a pretty safe bet that Israel and al-Saud will gin up some sort of attack on Iran.

Monday, April 6, 2015

Obama's Weakness on Full Display in Interview with Tom Friedman: Too Many Lies Make Delivering Final Nuclear Agreement Unlikely

Obama sat down in the Oval Office on Saturday with his preferred midwife, the reliable sycophant Thomas Friedman, to expound for 46 minutes why the recent tentative agreement negotiated with Iran over its nuclear program is the best deal possible. Friedman's account, "The Obama Doctrine and Iran," was featured prominently on the home page of The New York Times yesterday; at the top of the story is a video of Friedman's interview of Obama in its entirety.

I watched all of it last night. And what I can tell you if you have yet to view the interview but plan to do so is prepare to be aggravated. Obama wholeheartedly embraces all the lies that have the resulted in the current ongoing destruction of the Middle East, principal of which is that Iran is a hostile, terrorist aggressor in the region and that America's "friends and allies," Israel and the Gulf sheikhdoms, are positioned in a merely defensive posture.

This is of course a Bizarro world retelling of facts on the ground. The fact is that Israel is an undeclared nuclear power with an arsenal of over 500 warheads that unilaterally attacks its neighbors in the region (Syria and Lebanon), while the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is the global export king of Wahhabi extremism -- from Fredrikstad, Norway to Bloomington, Minnesota, and myriad points in between -- the chief source of terrorism in the world today. It is Iran and its allies in Hezbollah and Syria that are playing defense.

Not once in Obama's discussion with Friedman did I hear a pitch to the American people as to why peace and prosperity with Iran is in their best interests. Most of the pitching was done to Israel, more specifically the hard-line American Jews who have been funding an exodus to the Republican Party; then after that an obsequious sales job to the despotic Gulf kleptarchies that Obama slickly re-branded the "Sunni states."

In both cases -- Israel and the Gulf monarchies -- Obama made a significant commitment to their defense and territorial integrity. Peter Baker in his frontpage recapitulation of the interview this morning, "President Obama Calls Preliminary Iran Nuclear Deal ‘Our Best Bet’," highlights the commitment to Israel at the top of his story -- "we've got their backs" -- but ignores the commitment to the Wahhabi despots entirely.

This omission bodes ill for the future of nuclear agreement. As long as Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, U.A.E., Qatar are allowed to skirt any official responsibility for instability in the region they will continue to export their maximally destabilizing terrorism. The Iranians will be blamed by the United States, the despots have their guarantee of protection from the U.S., and the endless cycle of death and destruction will continue.

In March, after the Netanyahu soft coup in his speech to a supine Congress and the Cotton letter to Iran, I thought that Obama was locked into an agreement for purely tactical domestic reasons. Failure at this stage would guarantee very little presidential leverage in his remaining two years in office. But in the last couple of weeks I thought that Kerry might walk away over the issue of how quickly sanctions would be removed.

It turns out, as Baker ably sets forth, the sanctions issue was fudged in the tentative agreement, along with the issue of how invasive inspections would be. (You'll recall from Scott Ritter that the Iraq inspections were completely compromised by spooks from Israel and the United States; that recent experience makes it hard to believe that Iran will agree to intrusive inspections of its military facilities):
Under the agreement, Iran would limit enrichment of uranium at its Natanz facility to a level useful only for civilian purposes; cut back the number of installed centrifuges by approximately two-thirds; convert its Fordo deep-underground enrichment facility into a research center; and modify its Arak heavy-water reactor to render it incapable of producing plutonium for a bomb.
But the structure of international inspections was left vague, as was the timing for lifting sanctions.
Mr. Obama said that inspectors would be able to watch “the entire nuclear chain” and that a “procurement committee” would examine Iranian imports to be sure equipment would be appropriate for peaceful nuclear uses, not a weapon. Inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency, he said, “can go anyplace.” 
But the administration has been vague about how to define “anyplace,” and Iran has said it would not be required to allow inspections of military bases.
“Iran could object,” Mr. Obama acknowledged, “but what we have done is to try to design a mechanism whereby once those objections are heard, that is not a final veto that Iran has but in fact some sort of international mechanism will be in place that makes a fair assessment.”

Mr. Obama said sanctions would be lifted only after Iran lived up to its commitments. “There are still details to be worked out,” he said, “but I think that the basic framework calls for Iran to take the steps that it needs to around Fordo, the centrifuges and so forth. At that point, then the U.N. sanctions are suspended.” 
He said the United States would “preserve the ability to snap back those sanctions if there is a violation.” And he added that separate sanctions imposed for other reasons, namely Iran’s sponsorship of terrorists and its ballistic missile program, would remain in place.
Administration officials said they envisioned Iran being able to take the required steps within months or a year of an agreement, at which point nuclear-related economic sanctions would be removed. But a major sticking point in the coming months will be the issue of additional sanctions imposed for other reasons.
Mr. Obama said almost nothing about how the United States and its allies would force Iran to answer questions about suspected past work on weapons designs. For years, Iran has blocked inspectors from visiting laboratories where such work is believed to have been conducted.
In the final paragraph you will notice the way forward for the neocon warmongers who want to hijack the nuclear deal. They will force Iran to answer to falsified evidence, the famous pilfered laptop containing evidence of weapons of mass destruction.

No, the game is not finished for the neocons, not by a long shot. Lindsey Graham has promised Obama that he will back off until a final agreement is revealed in June. But Obama's bowing and scraping to Bob Corker, calling the Tennessee senator who takes his orders from Israel and Saudi Arabia, a "good and decent man," is a very bad sign. Obama is weak. His interview with Friedman proves it. At this point I don't think he can deliver a final agreement.

Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Obama Signals Support for Widening War in Yemen: Stop on Arms to Egypt Lifted

The news out of Yemen is that the Saudis are indiscriminately bombing the civilian population (Kareem Fahim and Nick Cumming-Bruce, "Aid for Yemen Dwindles as Need Rises Amid Chaos"):
“The situation in Yemen is extremely alarming, with dozens of civilians killed over the past four days,” Mr. al-Hussein [United Nations’ human rights chief Zeid Ra’ad al-Hussein] said in a statement. “The country seems to be on the verge of total collapse.”
“The killing of so many innocent civilians is simply unacceptable,” he added.
Some hospitals have been bombed, as have private homes; schools; and civilian airports and power stations in the capital, Sana, and the cities of Saada and Al Hudaydah, the United Nations said, highlighting fears of the havoc that would result from a threatened ground invasion by Saudi forces and those of other nations.
Unicef said in a statement on Tuesday that at least 62 children had been killed in fighting in Yemen over the past week. Mr. al-Hussein said he was shocked by a Saudi airstrike Monday on Al Mazraq, a camp in the north for displaced Yemenis, which caused scores of civilian casualties.
The United Nations human rights office said its staff had confirmed that at least 19 people had been killed and 35 others wounded in that strike, but it noted that there were different accounts of the number of dead. The International Organization for Migration, which had workers in the camp, reported that 40 people had been killed.
Signalling his support for this terror bombing of a civilian population guilty of nothing other than residing in a country riven with strife, Obama removed the hold on high-tech military hardware bound for Egypt (Peter Baker, "Obama Removes Weapons Freeze Against Egypt"):
Mr. Obama’s move will release 12 F-16 fighter jets, 20 Harpoon missiles, and the shells and parts necessary to assemble up to 125 M1A1 Abrams tanks that Egypt had previously paid for but that have been held up since 2013. The F-16s are especially important to Egyptian leaders, who have bitterly raised the issue with their American counterparts at nearly every opportunity.
Intended or not, experts said Mr. Obama’s decision would be interpreted as an effort by Washington to bolster a fragile position in the region. “The U.S. is facing quite a few challenges, and it needs to shore up relations with allies,” said Steven Simon, a former Middle East adviser to Mr. Obama now affiliated with Dartmouth. “The assistance to Egypt was always predicated on its foreign policy, not its domestic policy. That was certainly the Egyptian understanding of it.”
But other experts and human rights advocates said Mr. Obama had effectively capitulated to Mr. Sisi, a former general who helped lead the military overthrow of President Mohamed Morsi’s Muslim Brotherhood government in 2013 and then won the presidency in an election tainted by wide-scale arrests of opposition figures.  . . . 
“Unsurprisingly, in this case you see that national security priorities, broadly defined, trump virtually everything else,” said Sarah Margon, the Washington director of Human Rights Watch. “And that’s a very myopic, short-term approach to fighting terrorism. Human rights abuses are actually a very bad counterterrorism strategy.”
According to Human Rights Watch and an Egyptian group called the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information, the Egyptian authorities arrested more than 40,000 people after Mr. Sisi’s removal of Mr. Morsi and have never provided a full accounting of the detentions.
Sisi this past weekend announced the formation of a joint Arab military force and promised Egyptian ground troops for Yemen if they were needed.

Make no mistake. The United States is now fully committed to a "Sisi solution" for the Middle East, which is to say, a re-imposition of Saddam Hussein-like strongman rule throughout the region. No longer will there even be lip service for democracy and basic human rights. The Saudis and Israelis are calling the shots. One can pick up a change in the climate on the Gray Lady's editorial page. The rankest neocon hatred (Bolton and Prosor) is allowed the spotlight. This does not bode well for an agreement with Iran on its nuclear program.

Yemen is the beginning of a war that will crack the Middle East wide open. Already the Iranians say they have broken the Saudi blockade, a clear statement that they will support the Houthis:
Some aid may have pierced the blockade. The state-run news media in Iran reported on Tuesday that the Iranians had airlifted humanitarian aid to Yemen, the first such delivery from Iran since the bombing campaign began.
The accounts did not specify precisely where the aid had been sent, or how the Iranians had evaded the blockade, but they said it included 19 tons of medical supplies and two tons of food donated by the Iranian Red Crescent.
A Saudi military spokesman blamed the Houthis on Tuesday for the growing number of casualties, accusing them of fighting from inside civilian areas and putting residents at risk.
That assertion came in response to a swelling chorus of criticism of the Saudi military, including from Amnesty International, which said in a statement that 14 people had been burned to death, including at least six civilians, in Saudi airstrikes early Tuesday against a Houthi checkpoint and fuel depots.
In its statement, Amnesty International accused the coalition of “turning a blind eye to civilian deaths and suffering caused by its military intervention.”
The fighting has forced hundreds of families to flee their homes, adding to the more than 334,000 people the United Nations’ refugee agency reported as displaced in the months of conflict before the recent surge in hostilities.
To escape the fighting, small numbers of Yemenis have started crossing the Red Sea to Somalia and Djibouti, said William Spindler, a spokesman for the refugee agency. “We are preparing for a larger influx,” he added.
The Gulf sheikhdoms are rotten to the core, commanding nothing but mercenaries, whether they be salafis or regular military. They have proven adept only at terrorizing civilians and collapsing paper armies like the one set up by the United States for Iraq. What is about to come in Yemen promises to be very different.

The U.S. needs to tread carefully. Whether the elites in control know it or not, the political system in the homeland commands very little support. There is a greater disconnect between government and the governed than at any time in my life. An expansive commitment to yet another battle front in the Middle East (e.g., Iran) will destroy the country.

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Paying Fealty to al-Saud, the Murder of Shaimaa al-Sabbagh and Obama's Al-Azhar Speech Five Years Later

Briefly yesterday a story appeared on the Gray Lady's home page about Obama's visit to kiss the ring of the new king of Saudi Arabia. Written by Michael Gordon and Peter Baker, "Top Officials Join Obama in Brief Visit to Saudi King" describes a large entourage of current and former USG officials arriving in the Kingdom as an act of fealty to the new ruler of the House of Saud:
RIYADH, Saudi Arabia — President Obama met with King Salman of Saudi Arabia on Tuesday, leading a bipartisan delegation of prominent current and former officials to shore up an important relationship and offer condolences for the death of King Abdullah. 
American officials said the meetings were the first official discussions the new monarch has held with a visiting foreign dignitary. 
Air Force One landed on a clear, mild afternoon with a brisk wind snapping the American and Saudi flags to attention. At the Erga Palace, the king and the president sat in gold chairs as their meeting got under way. 
Mr. Obama was in Riyadh for only a few hours, detouring from the return leg of a three-day visit to India. Still, the fact that he made the stop was significant, because he rarely travels overseas to mark the death of a foreign leader; more often, he dispatches the vice president, secretary of state or other dignitaries to represent the United States.
American relations with Saudi Arabia were strained by Mr. Obama’s decision not to mount military strikes in Syria against the government of President Bashar al-Assad over the use of chemical weapons. Saudi Arabia has been a bitter foe of Mr. Assad, who has repressed the Sunni Muslim majority in Syria and who has the backing of Iran, the Saudis’ regional rival.
The Saudis are also uneasy about the Obama administration’s pursuit of a nuclear deal with Iran, fearing that it will do too little to restrain the Iranians from developing nuclear weapons. And they were unhappy with American policy toward the Arab Spring uprisings, especially in Egypt, where they accused the United States of turning its back on a friend, President Hosni Mubarak.
Still, the Obama administration has worked assiduously to try to repair relations with the Saudis. After a pivotal June meeting in Jidda between Secretary of State John Kerry and King Abdullah, Saudi Arabia agreed to join the United States in carrying out airstrikes against Islamic State fighters in Syria and Iraq.
Joining the president for the visit on Tuesday were his Republican opponent from 2008, Senator John McCain of Arizona, and several veterans of Republican administrations, including two former secretaries of state, James A. Baker III and Condoleezza Rice.
Ms. Rice was also one of four former national security advisers in the delegation, which also included Brent Scowcroft, Stephen J. Hadley and Samuel Berger.
Senior figures from the Obama administration who joined the delegation included Mr. Kerry; Susan E. Rice, the current national security adviser and former ambassador to the United Nations; John O. Brennan, the director of the C.I.A.; and Gen. Lloyd J. Austin III, who oversees Middle East operations. Democratic members of Congress also took part, including Senator Mark Warner of Virginia and Representatives Nancy Pelosi and Ami Bera of California and Eliot L. Engel and Joseph Crowley of New York.
What is strange about this story, besides the obvious -- leaders of the United States, the world's beacon of freedom and democracy, kowtowing to an absolute monarchy -- is that it didn't remain for long in its prominent spot on the NYT home page, and this morning it can't even be found online in the "World" section, one has to type "Saudi Arabia" in the search box and sort by "Newest."

Obviously the story is embarrassing and needs to be hidden. The fawning tweets of Kerry and Susan Rice portray a government in thrall to al-Saud, a totalitarian dictatorship that exports the jihad the lickspittle U.S. leadership is ostensibly waging a war against. It is all hogwash.

Note the conclusion to the piece:
Mr. Obama said before flying to Riyadh from India that the United States has an interest in a strong partnership with Saudi Arabia, despite its record of repression, human rights abuses and links to terrorism.
“It is important for us to take into account existing relationships, the existing alignments within a very complicated Middle East, to recognize that we have strategic interests in common with Saudi Arabia, and that even as we work on those common interests — for example, countering terrorist organizations — that we are also encouraging them to move in new directions, not just for our sake but more importantly for their sake,” he said in an interview in New Delhi with Fareed Zakaria of CNN.
Mr. Obama was asked whether he would raise the case of the Saudi blogger who was sentenced to receive 1,000 lashes. He said he would not on this occasion, but that he does regularly raise human rights issues with the Saudi government, just as he does with other countries with undemocratic governments.
“What I’ve found effective is to apply steady, consistent pressure, even as we are getting business done that needs to get done,” Mr. Obama said. “And oftentimes, that makes some of our allies uncomfortable. It makes them frustrated. Sometimes we have to balance our need to speak to them about human rights issues with immediate concerns that we have in terms of countering terrorism or dealing with regional stability.”
One wonders what kind of "steady, consistent pressure" is being applied to Egypt where police gunned down protesters last weekend commemorating the fourth anniversary of the Arab Spring.


Robert Mackey reports today in "Egypt Condemns Western Outrage at Fatal Shooting of Protester" on the growing tumult over the murder of socialist activist Shaimaa al-Sabbagh:
Egypt’s Foreign Ministry expressed dismay on Tuesday that the killing of a female activist in Cairo, which occurred as riot police used force to disperse a peaceful protest, had drawn widespread condemnation from the West.
The death of the activist, Shaimaa al-Sabbagh, on Saturday sparked outrage online in large part because it was so well-documented. Wrenching images of Ms. Sabbagh bleeding in the arms of a colleague who picked her up afterher heart and lungs were pierced by shotgun pellets reverberated on social networks.
While Interior Ministry officials initially denied that the police officers who were filmed firing in her direction had played any part in her death, the state prosecutor opened an investigation a day later, in the face of widespread skepticism and the testimony of numerous witnesses.
The graphic images of Ms. Sabbagh’s last moments evoked comparisons to the fatal 2009 shooting of the Iranian protester Neda Agha-Soltan, who bled to death as two witnesses recorded the scene on their phones. 
That Ms. Sabbagh, 32, was engaged in a peaceful protest, with a handful of marchers carrying flowers to Tahrir Square in memory of those killed there in the Egyptian revolution four years ago, helped make her death a focus of anger at the police in a way that the death of at least 18 civilians in clashes the next day did not.
Where are the State Department tweets reminding the Egyptian government of Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi about the Universal Declaration of Human Rights?

Egypt is propped up by the Saudis. So don't expect any outrage from USG.

I went back to read Obama's ballyhooed Cairo address, the one he delivered in June of 2009, the full flush of his "Hope and Change" popularity, at Al-Azhar University announcing a new day in relations between the West and the Muslim world. It is a conservative speech, and knowing what we know today about Obama, that he has been a great failure as a progressive leader, it reads even more as an apologia for business-as-usual U.S. unipolarity.

Something of course that rings absolutely false today is the part of his speech devoted to democracy:
I know there has been controversy about the promotion of democracy in recent years, and much of this controversy is connected to the war in Iraq. So let me be clear: no system of government can or should be imposed upon one nation by any other. 
That does not lessen my commitment, however, to governments that reflect the will of the people. Each nation gives life to this principle in its own way, grounded in the traditions of its own people. America does not presume to know what is best for everyone, just as we would not presume to pick the outcome of a peaceful election. But I do have an unyielding belief that all people yearn for certain things: the ability to speak your mind and have a say in how you are governed; confidence in the rule of law and the equal administration of justice; government that is transparent and doesn't steal from the people; the freedom to live as you choose. Those are not just American ideas, they are human rights, and that is why we will support them everywhere. 
There is no straight line to realize this promise. But this much is clear: governments that protect these rights are ultimately more stable, successful and secure. Suppressing ideas never succeeds in making them go away. America respects the right of all peaceful and law-abiding voices to be heard around the world, even if we disagree with them. And we will welcome all elected, peaceful governments – provided they govern with respect for all their people. 
As a full partner in the Saudi rollback of the Arab Spring, Obama couldn't make this speech in Cairo today. The blowback will be felt in the U.S. homeland in the form of reduced turnout for Democratic nominee during the next presidential election. There are consequences for such a dramatic about-face. People lose faith. Trust erodes.  Better to stay at home than be gulled into another false message of "Hope and Change."

Wednesday, December 17, 2014

Oil-Price Drop Russian Currency Collapse: The Lunacy of the Washington-Riyadh Axis

A top story today is the collapse of Russia's currency. Yesterday, despite the central bank raising interest rates to 17%, the ruble reached the depths of 80 to the dollar before climbing back to 68. The ruble has lost half its value since the beginning of the year. 

What's the cause of this panic? The oil-price drop engineered by the Saudis. Saudi Arabia has refused to cut production despite demands from others in OPEC. Mike Whitney has a helpful primer on the issue, "The Oil Coup: US-Saudi Subterfuge Send Stocks and Credit Reeling," which appeared yesterday on the Counterpunch web site:
Here’s what’s happening: Washington has persuaded the Saudis to flood the market with oil to push down prices, decimate Russia’s economy, and reduce Moscow’s resistance to further NATO encirclement and the spreading of US military bases across Central Asia. The US-Saudi scheme has slashed oil prices by nearly a half since they hit their peak in June. The sharp decline in prices has burst the bubble in high-yield debt which has increased the turbulence in the credit markets while pushing global equities into a tailspin. Even so, the roiled markets and spreading contagion have not deterred Washington from pursuing its reckless plan, a plan which uses Riyadh’s stooge-regime to prosecute Washington’s global resource war. Here’s a brief summary from an article by F. William Engdahl titled “The Secret Stupid Saudi-US Deal on Syria”:
The details are emerging of a new secret and quite stupid Saudi-US deal on Syria and the so-called IS. It involves oil and gas control of the entire region and the weakening of Russia and Iran by Saudi Arabian flooding the world market with cheap oil. Details were concluded in the September meeting by US Secretary of State John Kerry and the Saudi King . . . 
. . . [T]he kingdom of Saudi Arabia, has been flooding the market with deep discounted oil, triggering a price war within OPEC… The Saudis are targeting sales to Asia for the discounts and in particular, its major Asian customer, China where it is reportedly offering its crude for a mere $50 to $60 a barrel rather than the earlier price of around $100. That Saudi financial discounting operation in turn is by all appearance being coordinated with a US Treasury financial warfare operation, via its Office of Terrorism and Financial Intelligence, in cooperation with a handful of inside players on Wall Street who control oil derivatives trading. The result is a market panic that is gaining momentum daily. China is quite happy to buy the cheap oil, but her close allies, Russia and Iran, are being hit severely . . . 
According to Rashid Abanmy, President of the Riyadh-based Saudi Arabia Oil Policies and Strategic Expectations Center, the dramatic price collapse is being deliberately caused by the Saudis, OPEC’s largest producer. The public reason claimed is to gain new markets in a global market of weakening oil demand. The real reason, according to Abanmy, is to put pressure on Iran on her nuclear program, and on Russia to end her support for Bashar al-Assad in Syria….More than 50% of Russian state revenue comes from its export sales of oil and gas. The US-Saudi oil price manipulation is aimed at destabilizing several strong opponents of US globalist policies. Targets include Iran and Syria, both allies of Russia in opposing a US sole Superpower. The principal target, however, is Putin’s Russia, the single greatest threat today to that Superpower hegemony.
The danger of the the Washington-Riyadh oil-price-drop strategy to bring Russia to heel is that the panic will spread globally. The Dow has already dropped close to 1,0000 points in a week, while yesterday European markets were roiled. As Jack Ewing reports in "Anxiety Over European Banks Amid Ruble Crisis," companies perceived to have exposure to Russia took a hit. Ewing makes clear this is panic selling. European banks are much less exposed to Russia than, say, for instance, tiny Greece. Part of the problem is lack of information. When the European Central Bank ran its stress tests earlier this year it failed to include Russian loans because the ruble was perceived to be stable. Now -- after a year that saw a U.S.-backed coup in Kiev, the EU herded into a sanctions campaign against Russia following Crimea joining the Russian Federation, a civil war in Ukraine, and the recent oil-price drop -- things look very different.
Adding to the nervousness on Tuesday was the lack of precise, up-to-date information about which European banks might have large holdings of, say, Russian government debt. When the European Central Bank began its examination of the resilience of eurozone lenders at the beginning of the year, a ruble decline seemed like a remote possibility. Hardly anyone anticipated the steep fall in energy prices that would undercut the Russian economy. 
As a result, the European Central Bank did not include a ruble crisis among the hypothetical scenarios it used to test banks’ ability to withstand stress. Data released by the central bank in October following the bank review provide detailed information on individual banks’ exposure to the government debt of countries like Malta or Slovenia, but not Russia. 
The European Central Bank declined to comment on Tuesday, but a person with knowledge of its bank supervisory arm said that officials were closely monitoring banks that are exposed to the Russian economy or Russian debt.
In the vacuum of public data, investors ganged up on banks and other companies known to have large Russian holdings. The targets included Raiffeisen Bank International in Vienna and the Danish brewer Carlsberg. 
Shares of Carlsberg, whose Baltika brand is the biggest selling beer in Russia, fell 7.5 percent. A Carlsberg spokesman declined to comment, except to refer to an earnings report published last month that described the Russian market as “difficult.” Shares of Raiffeisen Bank, which earned more than 70 percent of its pretax profit from its Russian subsidiary in the first nine months of this year, fell more than 8 percent on Tuesday. 
“All financials with exposure to Russia are currently suffering,” Ingrid Krenn-Ditz, a Raiffeisen spokeswoman, said in an email. “In Russia we continue to pursue a policy of selective underwriting” with a focus on customers, she added.
The flames of panic are being fanned, and on top of this the U.S. Congress has weighed in with a new sanctions bill which also includes $350 million in direct military aid to the Kiev junta. Peter Baker writes ("Obama Signals Support for New U.S. Sanctions to Pressure Russian Economy") that the legislation empowers Obama to go after Gazprom (I wonder if this means that U.S. citizens can no longer purchase Gazprom stock); it also provides for tens of millions in "democracy promotion" in the former Soviet Union:
The legislation also authorizes the president — but does not require him — to impose sanctions on international companies that invest in certain types of unconventional Russian crude-oil energy projects and to further restrict the export of equipment for use in Russia’s energy sector. And it authorizes the president to bar investment or credit to Gazprom, the Russian state energy giant. 
In addition, the legislation authorizes the provision of lethal arms to the Ukraine government, including antitank weapons, tactical surveillance drones and counter-artillery radar. Mr. Obama has resisted sending weaponry to Kiev on the theory that it would only escalate the fighting in eastern Ukraine, so it is not clear whether he will follow through on the authorization. 
The measure went beyond only penalties to authorize $10 million in each of the next three fiscal years to counter Russian propaganda in the former Soviet Union and prioritize Russian-language broadcasting in Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia. And it authorized $20 million in each of the next three years to promote democracy, independent news media, uncensored Internet access and anticorruption efforts in Russia.
But under pressure from the Obama administration, lawmakers removed elements that would have tied the president’s hands, including a provision that would have barred lifting sanctions until Russia was not only out of Ukraine but Moldova and Georgia, too, where lingering conflicts are not likely to be resolved soon. 
“President Putin bears responsibility for any outcomes that flow from his actions and breach of the international order,” said Senator Robert Menendez, Democrat of New Jersey, the chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, who pushed for the sanctions along with the panel’s senior Republican, Senator Bob Corker of Tennessee. “The United States Congress stands with Ukraine in the face of Russian aggression,” Mr. Menendez said.
What we need are some of those millions of dollars to be spent here at home, starting with Menendez's New Jersey. If only we could have real democracy in New Jersey then the planet wouldn't be cursed with a blatantly corrupt, bought-and-paid-for neocon machine pol like Bob Menendez. The nation would also be spared the likes of dangerous Chris Christie.

And the reason I have hope is that we are on the cusp of a democratic awakening here in the United States. I am almost convinced that popular consciousness has been raised to a level sufficient to reject Hillary Clinton's presidential candidacy. What this portends -- merely a GOP victory, another false Dem messiah (Elizabeth Warren?), or an actually split in the Democratic Party with the possibility for a third-party alternative movement -- is yet to be determined. Something is definitely happening here. The power elite are out of touch to such extent that they think they can jigger and job their way out of the mess that they have created and maintain their death grip on the control switch. The status quo is so bent and corrupted the people in charge will blow up the planet to maintain the power they have amassed