Showing posts with label Yemen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yemen. Show all posts

Sunday, April 4, 2021

Tariq Ali on the Saudi War on Yemen

I've been away from this page for some time. The first quarter of the year was spent moving the office that I manage from its home of more than a half century. A Herculean effort was required and a Herculean effort was delivered despite being physically diminished from the long-haul effects of a first-wave coronavirus infection.

We moved into our new office March 5. Since then I've been ironing out the wrinkles on a new phone system and attempting to reduce my hours back to a normal 40-hr. work week. I'm starting to read more of the newspaper again. 

I wish I could say it is with relish that I return to the news, but it is not. Something noxious has occurred in the short amount of time since Biden has assumed the throne. The prestige press which not too long ago was critical of policies because they had a Trump imprimatur has now lined up in support since the Biden administration has adopted them as their own.

Look no further than the Saudi war on Yemen. It was with great fanfare that Biden announced in early February the end of U.S. support for Saudi "offensive operations." It turns out that this was more public relations than a plan to bring peace to the Arabian Peninsula. As the great Tariq Ali makes clear in "Killer Prince":

Though Biden has signalled the US will end ‘offensive operations’, it will continue to provide Saudi Arabia with ‘defensive weapons’, which appear to serve much the same purpose. His Administration has said nothing about halting technical, logistical and intelligence operations. By all indications, its plan is still to extract an unconditional surrender from the Houthis while maintaining its disastrous ‘counterterrorism’ operations in the country. To date, Biden’s promised ‘recalibration’ of the US–Saudi relationship is nowhere to be seen.

Remember, Congress invoked the War Powers Act to force Trump to withdraw U.S. support for the war. Trump vetoed that resolution. Why doesn't the Democrat-controlled Congress invoke the War Powers Act again? What's at stake? Tariq Ali summarizes:

Cholera and hunger on a scale that has not been seen since the last century, with some 20 million experiencing food insecurity and 10 million at risk of famine. An estimated 110,000 have been killed in the fighting, with a death toll of 233,000 overall, mostly due to indirect causes such as lack of food and health services. Few of the country’s medical facilities are functional.

Remember this the next time a U.S. official pleads for a "humanitarian" military intervention to liberate an oppressed people.  

Monday, September 16, 2019

No Peace Dividend from Bolton's Firing

The Saudis major oil processing facility, the largest in the world, Abqaiq, was struck and damaged Saturday by a swarm of Houthi drones. Aramco has suspended production there and at another struck refinery, Khurais.

The debate now is over who is responsible. The Houthis have claimed responsibility, and the Iranians have denied it, but the U.S. is blaming Iran:
The government released satellite photographs showing what officials said were at least 17 points of impact at several Saudi energy facilities from strikes they said came from the north or northwest. That would be consistent with an attack coming from the direction of the northern Persian Gulf, Iran or Iraq, rather than from Yemen, where the Iranian-backed Houthi militia that claimed responsibility for the strikes operates.
The Saudis, however, have not, as of yet, publicly blamed Iran. And Trump appears to be deferring to al-Saud about what to do next.

The Saudis are obviously reticent to blame Iran and escalate military tension in an already hair-trigger environment because The Kingdom would be Iran's primary target, along with the myriad U.S. bases spread across the region. If Trump chooses to flex U.S. muscles and let fly a punitive one-off attack on Iran, something he opted out of in June after the downing of a U.S. surveillance drone, Armageddon will be the likely result. Iran will take the opportunity to break out of the box Trump has put it in.

Any direct military conflict with Iran will guarantee that Trump is a one-term president. War with Iran is hugely unpopular, and that's a bipartisan sentiment.

If it looked for a moment like firing Bolton meant Trump would parade as a peacemaker for the next 18 months, no such luck.

Clearly the trajectory here is for Trump to strike Iran. He'll try to limit it to a one-off, but Iran will respond. Then we're on the escalation elevator.

Friday, July 12, 2019

Saudi Coalition Imploding in Yemen

A lengthy story in The New York Times, "U.A.E. Pulls Most Forces From Yemen in Blow to Saudi War Effort," by Declan Walsh and David Kirkpatrick, confirms what was reported last week in the Wall Street Journal: United Arab Emirates is abandoning the war in Yemen. 

This is dire news for Saudi Arabia since it was UAE-led forces that have achieved most if not all of the significant battlefield victories against the Houthis in Yemen. Word is that now, with the UAE departing, the militias that control Aden will set to fighting among themselves; also, Houthi forces will be able to lift the siege of the critical port city of Hodeidah.

Walsh and Kirkpatrick's dispatch is filled with juicy quotes from Western aficionados:
The drawdown “is going to expose the Saudis to the reality that this war is a failure,” said Michael Stephens of the Royal United Services Institute, a research group in London. “It tells us the two main protagonists on the coalition side, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, don’t have the same idea of what success looks like.”
[snip]
“The only thing stopping the Houthis from taking over Yemen was the U.A.E. armed forces,” said Michael Knights, a senior fellow at the Washington Institute. “Now the glue that was holding Yemen together is being withdrawn.”
[snip] 
The Saudis, though, may still believe in a military victory. “There are voices in Riyadh who think the Houthis can be caused enough pain to do what Saudi Arabia wants,” said Peter Salisbury of the International Crisis Group. “But that feels like wishful thinking, which is not a good substitute for strategy.”
One face-saving solution for Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman would be for Trump to start a shooting war with Iran. Then MbS could announce his own drawdown in Yemen to bolster the U.S. effort.

The pressures are going to be enormous to begin a war on Iran this summer.

Monday, June 24, 2019

Trump is Trapped

Reuters is reporting this morning of Iran's openness to new talks with the U.S. if Trump is willing to lift sanctions and sweeten the JCPOA (so basically a non-starter). Pompeo is in Saudi Arabia conferring with the administration's closest ally, likely apologizing for Trump's aborted strike. The definitive write-up of last week's almost-war with Iran is Andre Damon's "Minutes to disaster: Lessons to be learned from the confrontation with Iran":
The strikes against Iran would likely have been carried out by the USS Abraham Lincoln aircraft carrier and its associated battle group, consisting of at least three destroyers and one cruiser. But under these conditions, the US military was forced to see these ships not just as military assets, but as liabilities. What would be the consequences of Iran sinking a $2 billion destroyer and killing a substantial portion of its nearly 300 crew?
If Iran sank the Nimitz-class carrier USS Abraham Lincoln, with 5,000 sailors and airmen aboard, the consequences would be incalculable.
As a former member of Iran’s Revolutionary Guards told the Times, “What happened in the past 48 hours was extremely important in showing Iran’s strength and forcing the U.S. to recalculate… No matter how you look at it, Iran won.”
As Mohammad Marandi explained on Democracy Now! Friday:
But also, I’d like to point one other thing out. And that is, if indeed a military conflict is inevitable between the United States and Iran, I think there are two important things that have to be kept in mind. First, if there is a war, then, in my opinion, all of the oil and gas facilities, as well as the tankers in the Persian Gulf region, will be destroyed. This will not be just the issue of closing the Strait of Hormuz. This will be something very long-term. And that will lead to a global economic catastrophe unlike anything we’ve seen in contemporary history. In addition to that, Iranian allies across the region will engage U.S. forces and U.S. allies militarily, in Iraq, in Afghanistan and elsewhere. And then you would have the Saudi and Emirati regimes collapse immediately, because they’re completely dependent on oil. And millions of people will be on the move. So, that’s a scenario that is just something that people should not even contemplate.
The second is that the United States may carry out a small strike. Here, I think, is almost equally dangerous, because I think that there are some so-called Iran experts in the United States that are telling the U.S. government that if you carry out a limited strike, Iran will do nothing in response, or there will be just some token response. That is a major miscalculation. The Iranians will be relentless in their response. They will probably be very disproportionate, as well. And they will also strike those regional countries that are allowing—that would allow the Americans to attack. And the reason why the Iranians would respond so severely is that they want to make sure that the United States does not come to any conclusion that they could repeatedly attack Iran. And this, of course, could lead to further and further escalation. So, it would be against the interests of the whole of the international community, as well as the people of the United States, to even contemplate any strike, even limited.
Trump figured this out in the nick of time. Iran is not going to be a static target like Syria. Iran will escalate. The country is being suffocated with sanctions.

There are other vital issues in play here, Trump's hope for reelection for one. Initiating a war with Iran at the behest of unpopular allies and neocons guarantees Trump's defeat. He knows that. Bannon was quoted saying as much. This means that Pompeo is likely in the kingdom telling the royal family that it is going to have to be sanctions and cyber war until Trump's reelection. Al-Saud is not going to like this.

Another problem for the administration is Yemen. Sunday there was another drone attack on a Saudi airport by the Houthis. (For a list of the recent Houthi strikes on Saudi Arabia, see Caleb Weiss's story.)

The Saudis and Israelis, who are guiding U.S. policy through the administration's neocons, don't want a renegotiated JCPOA; they want regime change. The problem is that Trump will not be reelected if war with Iran is launched now. Trump is boxed. He can't deliver regime change for his paymasters and win reelection, and, as Houthi hostilities in Saudi Arabia increase and the U.S. Senate blocks armament transfers to al-Saud, Trump is forced to use his veto on behalf of an enormously unpopular war, spotlighting his abject servitude to the sheikhs.

Trump is trapped.

Thursday, June 20, 2019

Saudi Arabia is in Trouble

The U.S. Navy MQ-4C Triton shot down yesterday by Iran had its transponder turned off, according to a Reuters story which quoted the IRGC:
A Revolutionary Guards statement said the drone’s identification transponder had been switched off “in violation of aviation rules and was moving in full secrecy” when it was downed, Iranian state broadcaster IRIB reported.
Iran is saying the drone was brought down in its southern province of Hormozgan; the U.S., crying foul, in the international air space over the Strait of Hormuz.

Iran is to be believed here. A strong tell of U.S. duplicity is Central Command's initial denial that the drone had been shot down.

The New York Times story devoted to the downed drone emphasizes its possible connection to a recent increase in Houthi attacks on Saudi territory:
In Yemen, the Houthis’ television channel reported on Wednesday evening that one of their missiles had hit a water desalination plant in the Saudi city of Jizan, on the Red Sea near the Yemeni border. Saudi officials said the missile had landed near the plant, but did not hit it.
The Houthis have stepped up strikes on Saudi Arabia, which has been accused by international groups of indiscriminate bombing in Yemen, but it is unclear what connection there is between the increase and the regional strife involving Iran. Recently, the Houthis have fired projectiles that damaged a Saudi airport and oil pipelines and caused some injuries.
Jizan, which is also the site of a Saudi military headquarters, has been a frequent target of Houthi attacks with missiles and drones over the course of a war that has become the world’s worst humanitarian crisis.
Saudi Arabia and its partner, the United Arab Emirates, have been fighting for four years in a military intervention in Yemen, seeking to roll back a Houthi takeover of much of the country. The Arab monarchies of the Gulf view Iran as their chief regional rival and consider the fight in Yemen a part of a broader struggle against Iran around the region.
In connection with the war in Yemen, news out of the UK is a court ruling that the government broke the law by supplying weapons to Saudi Arabia:
“The decision of the court today does not mean that licenses to export arms to Saudi Arabia must immediately be suspended,” the British judge said.
“It does mean that the UK government must reconsider the matter, must make the necessary assessments about past episodes of concern, allowing for the fact that, in some cases, it will not be possible to reach a conclusion.”
The Campaign Against the Arms Trade welcomed the judgment.
“The Saudi Arabian regime is one of the most brutal and repressive in the world, yet, for decades, it has been the largest buyer of UK-made arms,” said Andrew Smith from the organization. “The arms sales must stop immediately.”
The opposition Labour Party said ministers had wilfully disregarded the evidence that Saudi Arabia was violating international humanitarian law in Yemen, while nevertheless continuing to supply them with weapons.
“What we now need is a full parliamentary or public inquiry to find out how that was allowed to happen, and which Ministers were responsible for those breaches of the law,” said Emily Thornberry, the party’s foreign affairs spokeswoman.
Saudi Arabia is in trouble. The UN is calling for sanctions against the kingdom for the murder of Jamal Khashoggi. The Houthis, for years at war with Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and all their Western allies, have actually increased their offensive capabilities, regularly penetrating Saudi territory.

The U.S. and its client states have one standard reaction when things aren't going their way. Make the problem bigger. That's what we're seeing now as we climb the ladder to war with Iran.

Thursday, June 13, 2019

Skullduggery in the Gulf of Oman

Interestingly Moon of Alabama thinks that Iran might indeed be behind the mysterious attacks of two tankers in the Gulf of Oman this morning:
The keyword here is "petrochemical". The tankers hit today were loaded with naphta from the UAE and methanol from Saudi Arabia. Both are petrochemical products and not simply crude oil. Last Friday, June 7, the U.S. sanctioned all trade with Iran's biggest petrochemical producer. These sanction will seriously hurt Iran. 
When the Trump administration began to sanction Iran's oil export last year, Iran announced new rules of the game. It said that it would retaliate against other Persian Gulf producers should Iran be unable to export its goods.
But after reading The New York Times dispatch (see "Tankers Attacked Again in Gulf of Oman, Raising Fears of Wider Conflict" by Richard Pérez-Peña, Stanley Reed and David D. Kirkpatrick) my first thought is that it is an Israeli-led operation, possibly in alliance with the MEK:
It was not immediately clear how the most recent attacks were carried out or by whom, just as the circumstances of last month’s attacks remain murky. The two ships that were struck on Thursday appeared to have been more seriously damaged than those hit in May. 
On a visit to the U.A.E. about two weeks ago, John Bolton, President Trump’s national security adviser, said without disclosing any evidence that Iran was “almost certainly” responsible for the attacks in May, which Iranian officials denied. “Who else would you think is doing it?” Mr. Bolton asked. 
But other American officials and Iran’s regional adversaries have been more cautious about publicly assigning blame. Emirati officials described the attacks as state-sponsored, but did not specify a state.
The incident appears to be part of the expanding conflict between Saudi Arabia and the Houthis of Yemen.

The Times story makes it sound as if the crew of one of the tankers attempted to fend off the attackers, which would lead one to believe that these attackers were glimpsed, and possibly recorded:
The other tanker, the Panamanian-flagged Kokuka Courageous, was carrying methanol, and the Iranian state news media reported that it, too, was on fire. It was reportedly headed from the Saudi port of Al Jubail to Singapore. Both the ship’s owner and its operator said that all 21 crew members had abandoned ship and were later rescued by a nearby vessel.
“We received a report that our ship was attacked,” Yutaka Katada, the president of the ship’s operator, Kokuka Sangyo, said at a news conference. The crew, all Filipinos, “kept trying to avoid the attacks, but again received an attack three hours later. So crew members left the ship by lifeboats.”

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

Drone vs. Drone

The latest from the war in Yemen is a cruise missile strike on Abha International Airport in Saudi Arabia's 'Asir Province. Vivian Yee reports in "Houthis Strike Airport in Saudi Arabia, Injuring Travelers" that 
In May, Houthi drones hit two pumping facilities along a Saudi oil pipeline and forced the Saudis to shut the pipeline temporarily, soon after a mysterious sabotage attack damaged four oil tankers outside the Emirati port of Fujairah, two of them Saudi. On Sunday, Houthi drones targeted Saudi drone facilities at another airport near Saudi Arabia’s border with Yemen, a Houthi TV channel said. 
The projectile in the most recent attack landed at the arrivals terminal of Abha International Airport, about three hours’ drive north of the kingdom’s border with Yemen, a Saudi spokesman, Col. Turki Al-Maliki, said in a statement, adding that military authorities were still investigating the incident.
It's drone vs. drone. A glimpse of the future in the here and now. Yee doesn't include in her list of recent belligerent events the Houthi blitz into Saudi Arabia's Najran Province (see last week's "Yemen’s Houthis Cross into Saudi Arabia, Seize 20 Positions").

Clearly hostilities are accelerating in the Yemen war. If you're relying on the U.S. mainstream media it's hard to form a coherent picture of the conflict because it is not reported as a conflict per se but as a proving ground for weapons supplied by the West as well as the leadership ability of the young crown prince Mohamed bin Salman. Millions near famine because of the war is mentioned as boilerplate.

In any event, the Saudis appear to be in more trouble than the mainstream media lets on.

Thursday, June 6, 2019

Trump Must be Impeached for Waging an Undeclared War in Yemen

The story is a week old, but Conor Friedersdorf's "Saudi Arabia First" is worth checking out. A bevy of constitutional scholars, not to mention congressional representatives, want Nancy Pelosi to sue the White House over the U.S. waging war in Yemen, or, better yet, begin impeachment proceedings:
On its own, waging war after an official call from Congress to stop doing so ought to be regarded as a violation of the Constitution that warrants impeachment.
[snip]
Perhaps a lawsuit of the sort urged by some legal scholars who believe votes against wars cannot be constitutionally vetoed by the president would prove effective.
“I’m confident these new arms sales provides new momentum for pursuing legal action and legislation that would end U.S. involvement in the war,” Democratic Representative Ro Khanna stated on Twitter. “The lawsuit is important to uphold Congress’ constitutional War Powers & challenge President Trump’s veto of our Yemen WPR.”
But there is a more direct remedy available to Congress. So long as some of its members are invoking alleged obstruction of justice to justify impeachment proceedings, they ought to invoke abuse of the war power, too. The prospect of being removed from office is far more likely than even a successful lawsuit to deter this president and his successors from usurping the legislature’s authority.

Wednesday, April 17, 2019

Trump Vetoes Yemen War Powers Resolution; Sledgehammers his Base

Take a look at the reader comments accompanying the Breitbart story on Trump's veto of the War Powers Resolution ending U.S. involvement in the Yemen civil war. They are almost 100% opposed to the veto.

Much is made about Trump's canniness in keeping his base tightly bound to him. And it's true. Trump has been good at shoveling red meat to his supporters. But working class white reactionaries do not approve of the Saudi royal family; they loathe them.

Attacking little Ilhan Omar comes off as all the more unseemly and perverse when Trump time and again is pictured in flagrante licking Saudi boots.

Trump's veto takes a sledgehammer to his conservative base. As Mark Landler and Peter Baker remind us in "Trump Vetoes Measure to Force End to U.S. Involvement in Yemen War," the Yemen War Powers resolution was co-sponsored by arch-Trump Republicans:
“This is deeply disappointing,” said Representative Ro Khanna, Democrat of California, who was one of the original sponsors of the measure in the House and had sought a meeting with Mr. Trump to try to persuade him to sign it.
“The president had the opportunity to sign a historic War Powers Resolution and stand with a bipartisan coalition, including his allies Rand Paul, Mark Meadows and Matt Gaetz, to stop endless wars,” Mr. Khanna said. “He failed to uphold the principles of the Constitution that give Congress power over matters of war and peace.”
Mr. Khanna was referring to the Republican senator from Kentucky, Mr. Paul, and two Republican representatives, from North Carolina and Florida, Mr. Meadows and Mr. Gaetz, who are closely aligned with Mr. Trump, but split with fellow Republicans to vote with Democrats in favor of the resolution. Members of the group had asked to meet with Mr. Trump to make their case against a veto, but the White House brushed them off.
Trump is gambling that Yemen disappears as a campaign issue a year from now. His veto guarantees that it won't, particularly if the Sanders runaway train continues to gain speed.

Friday, April 5, 2019

Trump Guarantees Himself a One-Term Presidency if He Vetoes the War Powers Act Resolution on Yemen

AP has an extensive story (see Ahmed al-Haj's "Cholera is surging once again in war-ravaged Yemen") about a doubling of reported cholera cases in Yemen.

It took a while but yesterday the U.S. House of Representatives voted to end military involvement in Yemen (see Catie Edmondson's "U.S. Role in Yemen War Will End Unless Trump Issues Second Veto"),

What was particularly encouraging about the vote is that the GOP's ultimate nullifier, crying wolf over anti-Semitism in form of an anti-BDS amendment, failed to work this go-round. There was Democratic unity. The War Powers Act resolution passed 247-to-176, "with 16 Republicans joining all House Democrats."

Now it is on to the White House for a promised Trump veto, which will amount to a new presidential power to declare war unilaterally with a mere one-third support in either chamber of congress.

The silver lining of a veto is that it will be political suicide for Trump; it will box him in with his hard-shell minority, a base from which he cannot win a national election.

A veto will also create a legitimate, non-Mueller-oriented movement to impeach Trump for waging an illegal war.

Thursday, February 14, 2019

We Need to Elect More Ilhan Omars

There was some good news yesterday. The House of Representatives invoked the War Powers Act to end U.S. involvement in the Saudi-spawned genocide in Yemen. Why it took the Democrats more than a month to hold the vote is a good question. Now it's back to the Senate, where it was already passed in December but by the previous congress. Supposedly it will take another month before it is brought to a vote, and the Trump administration has, in so many words, already promised a veto. I doubt the resolution will garner as many votes, 56, as the first go-round. There will be an attempt to de-link the Khasshogi murder from U.S. facilitation of the war on Yemen. But that's going to be difficult.

The other goods news is that recently AIPAC-admonished Ilhan Omar, Representative for Minnesota's 5th CD, sprang off the ropes with her confrontation of notorious ghoul Elliott Abrams during the House Foreign Affairs Committee hearing yesterday. As Bill Van Auken notes in "Washington escalates military threats as Venezuela regime change falters":
In testimony on Capitol Hill on Wednesday, the Trump administration’s special envoy on Venezuela, Elliot Abrams was asked whether the US had increased its troop deployments in South America in response to the Venezuelan crisis and responded, “I don’t believe so.” He added that direct US military intervention was not Washington’s “preferred route.”
Asked by a member of the House Foreign Affairs Committee whether the US was funneling arms to Venezuela’s right-wing opposition, Abrams said that his answer was “a simple and unequivocal no.”
The committee’s Democratic chairman, Eliot Engel, introduced Abrams citing his posts in the Reagan and Bush administrations and his positions in various think tanks. Unmentioned was the fact that he pleaded guilty in 1991 to lying to Congress about the illegal funneling of money and guns to the CIA-backed “contras” in their terrorist war against Nicaragua and avoided jail only because of a pardon by Bush senior.
One member of the committee, Minnesota Democrat Ilhan Omar, challenged Abrams, citing his guilty plea in the contra affair, stated, “I don’t understand why members of this committee or the American people should find any testimony that you give today to be truthful.” She went on to detail his defense of the El Mozote massacre of some 800 civilians in El Salvador and similar genocidal acts by the dictatorship in Guatemala.
Abrams treated the questioning with contempt, interrupting Omar and declaring that her questions were an “attack” that did not merit an answer.
That the same kind of operations that Abrams defended in Central America are ongoing in Venezuela was indicated by the Venezuelan government’s interception of a shipment of 19 assault rifles, 118 explosive charges, 90 military-grade radio antennas and six latest generation smartphones on a Boeing 767 cargo flight by the 21Air company to the Valencia airport.
“This materiel was destined for criminal groups and terrorist actions in the country, financed by the fascist extreme right and the government of the United States,” a spokesman for the Venezuelan military charged.
The air cargo company, 21 Air, had previously run flights between US cities, but in recent months had shifted its operations to Venezuela, with stop-offs in Colombia.
For the little bit of good news there is no indication that the U.S. is going to halt its commitment to perpetual war. The U.S.-recognized coup leader, Juan Guaido, has proclaimed February 23 as the day that "volunteers" will deliver humanitarian aid from across the border in Colombia. It's a provocation. The U.S. has been powwowing with Brazil and Colombia on the next steps in the flagging coup. The New York Times, while sticking to the script that the coup is legitimate, nonetheless gives voice to skepticism regarding its implementation. According to "Humanitarian Aid Stalls, Testing Venezuela’s Opposition," by Nicholas Casey and Anatoly Kurmanaev:
“The opposition has created immense expectations, and it’s not at all clear they have a plan for actually fulfilling them,” said David Smilde, a Venezuela analyst at the Washington Office on Latin America. “Furthermore, the opposition and the U.S. have not been clear that this aid, even if allowed in, will make a significant dent in Venezuela’s humanitarian crisis.”
Some Venezuelans have even put off buying medication, expecting that the American donations will arrive across the border soon, Mr. Smilde said.
We need to elect more Ilhan Omars. 

Thursday, December 27, 2018

Centcom Chief Caught Lying to Congress

An excellent story appeared yesterday on the front page of The New York Times. In "Arms Sales to Saudis Leave American Fingerprints on Yemen’s Carnage" Declan Walsh and Eric Schmitt establish beyond a reasonable doubt that the U.S. military, despite statements to the contrary, knows exactly what decisions the Saudi coalition makes in Yemen:
The Pentagon and State Department have denied knowing whether American bombs were used in the war’s most notorious airstrikes, which have struck weddings, mosques and funerals. However, a former senior State Department official said that the United States had access to records of every airstrike over Yemen since the early days of the war, including the warplane and munitions used.
[snip] 
While American officials often protested civilian deaths in public, two presidents ultimately stood by the Saudis. President Obama gave the war his qualified approval to assuage Saudi anger over his Iran nuclear deal. President Trump embraced Prince Mohammed and bragged of multibillion-dollar arms deals with the Saudis.
As bombs fell on Yemen, the United States continued to train the Royal Saudi Air Force. In 2017, the United States military announced a $750 million program focused on how to carry out airstrikes, including avoiding civilian casualties. The same year, Congress authorized the sale of more than $510 million in precision-guided munitions to Saudi Arabia, which had been suspended by the Obama administration in protest of civilian casualties.
Walsh and Schmitt expose the head of Central Command, Gen. Joseph L. Votel, lying to Congress:
But in Congress, the mood was souring. In the March [2018] hearing, senators accused the Pentagon of being complicit in the coalition’s errant bombing, and pressed its leaders on how directly the United States was linked to atrocities.
General Votel said the military knew little about that. The United States did not track whether the coalition jets that it refueled carried out the airstrikes that killed civilians, he said, and did not know when they used American-made bombs. At a briefing in Cairo in August, a senior United States official echoed that assessment.
“I would assume the Saudis have an inventory system that traces that information,” said the official, who spoke anonymously to discuss diplomatically sensitive relations. “But that’s not information that is available to the U.S.”
But Larry Lewis, a State Department adviser on civilian harm who worked with the Saudi-led coalition from 2015 to 2017, said that information was readily available from an early stage.
At the coalition headquarters in Riyadh, he said, American liaison officers had access to a database that detailed every airstrike: warplane, target, munitions used and a brief description of the attack. American officials frequently emailed him copies of a spreadsheet for his own work, he said.
The data could easily be used to pinpoint the role of American warplanes and bombs in any single strike, he said. “If the question was “Hey, was that a U.S. munition they used?” You would know that it was,” he said.
Just Foreign Policy is circulating a petition asking senators and representatives to call Votel back to Congress to testify under oath:
Incoming House Intelligence Chair Adam Schiff has promised a "deep dive" on the U.S. role in the Saudi regime's war in Yemen in his committee. Other Congressional committees should do the same. In particular, they should compel General Votel to testify, under oath, in both open and closed session, about what Votel knew about the U.S. role in Saudi atrocities in Yemen, and when he knew it; about what he should he have known, and when should he have known it; and about why this knowledge wasn't reflected in Votel's testimony to Congress in March, when the Senate was about to vote on the U.S. role in the war.
So much of what Obama did in the Middle East -- the war on Yemen, the war on Syria -- was predicated on getting the Iran nuclear deal finalized. When Trump came in and pulled out of the nuclear agreement it turned all U.S. policy in the region upside down. Trump was thinking, Why fight proxy wars when you can fight one war with the main enemy and win everything in one fell swoop?

The troop pullout in northern Syria is merely a prelude for a greater conflict.

Friday, December 14, 2018

A Display of Sanity on Yemen and Khashoggi

Excellent news from Julie Hirschfeld Davis and Eric Schmitt reporting in "Senate Votes to End Aid for Yemen Fight Over Khashoggi Killing and Saudis’ War Aims":
WASHINGTON — The Senate voted on Thursday to end American military assistance for Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen in the strongest show of bipartisan defiance against President Trump’s defense of the kingdom over the killing of a dissident journalist.
The 56-to-41 vote was a rare move by the Senate to limit presidential war powers and sent a potent message of disapproval for a nearly four-year conflict that has killed thousands of civilians and brought famine to Yemen. Moments later, senators unanimously approved a separate resolution to hold Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia personally responsible for the death of the journalist, Jamal Khashoggi.
Bernie Sanders, a co-author of the resolution, says it is the first time the War Powers Act has been successfully invoked by the Senate. The House will not take up the measure until the new congress is sworn in next month:
While Thursday’s moves were largely a symbolic, if stinging, slap at the Trump administration, they previewed what could be a far more consequential debate after Democrats take over the House in 2019.
“If Paul Ryan thinks on his way out the door his last public service gift to humanity is covering up for Saudi Arabia, great, he can make that his legacy,” said Senator Tim Kaine, Democrat of Virginia, referring to the procedural gambit by Mr. Ryan, the House speaker, this week to prevent the war powers measure from coming up for a swift a vote.
“But we’re going to be around next year,” Mr. Kaine said, “and we’ll figure out ways that there can be consequences for this.”
UN-brokered peace talks in Sweden delivered a ceasefire in Hodeidah:
The agreement calls for an exchange of up to 15,000 prisoners, the creation of a humanitarian corridor into the city of Taiz and, importantly, the withdrawal of troops from Hudaydah. That city, on the Red Sea, is a key entry point to Yemen for essential products like food and medicine.
Peace talks are expected to continue in January in an effort to resolve what has become a humanitarian crisis in one of the poorest nations on Earth.

Monday, December 10, 2018

Theresa May, Putschist + NYT Continues Attack on al-Saud

Well, I suppose I might have been incorrect last week when I opined that British democracy was not more dysfunctional than the American variety.

After repeatedly assuring the public last week that the momentous Brexit vote in parliament would proceed on schedule for Tuesday, December 11, BBC is reporting, based on insider accounts, that May will postpone the vote.

"The report that May could cancel the vote came just hours after the top EU court ruled that Britain could cancel its notice to leave the bloc, which it is due to exit on March, 29."

May's path forward appears to be another trip to Brussels to plead for additional concessions. Why would the EU oblige her? Clearly May's only goal is to extend the life of her split, unpopular government and prevent new elections. The zombie plods on!

Checking with Yves Smith this morning, she lists the probable outcomes if May's vote had failed tomorrow:
  • May could face a vote of no confidence in the Commons. Kier Starmer has said that Labour would table a vote, but with the DUP stating that they would support the Conservatives in such a vote, this is unlikely to succeed. If the Government did fall, there would be 14 days for another Government to win a vote of confidence in the Commons, or the country will have a General Election.
  • Conservative MPs put in 48 letters, and the party has to have a confidence vote in the Prime Minister. If 48 letters go in, this would require a swift vote of confidence, where May must win more than 50 per cemt of the 315 eligible MPs. If she lost, the party then has to elect a new leader. Given the incredibly short timescale before 29th March, the Conservative Party would be signing its own death warrant to do this.
  • Labour tries to table a censure motion about May – this is effectively a personal vote of no confidence in the Prime Minister, which is what happened recently to Chris Grayling. This would potentially allow Tory MPs to vote against the May without bringing down the Government. However the Government is under no obligation to provide time for an Opposition Day before Christmas, so this is unlikely to happen.
  • The Prime Minister goes to negotiate with Brussels and brings back an amended deal. This would then require the Government to win a vote on its renegotiated deal, using the procedure outlined above. If no negotiated deal can pass through the Commons the UK will leave the EU without a deal.
For the last several weeks the scenario of choice floated in the pages of the mainstream press has been for May to lose the initial vote in parliament, but not by a disastrous margin, at which point she would proclaim renewed determination for a better deal and off to Brussels she would go.

That scenario started to disintegrate at the end of last week when it became apparent that May had been lying to the public about what exactly her Brexit deal with the EU entailed. Most MPs could not be seen to publicly support it. It was headed for a huge defeat in parliament.

So, despite numerous promises that the vote would go on, May is skipping the "lose round one" part of the scenario and, apparently, proceeding directly to the return to Brussels kabuki.

The shortcoming of May's about-face is that it deprives her coalition government, already living on borrowed time, of the last shred of credibility. May has zero credibility. The mainstream media can no longer shield her. 

A sort of putsch is underway where the Tories and the DUP are trying to lock in a crash-out. That's the only thing that makes sense at this point, above and beyond blocking snap elections. But the only way that's possible, given the EU ruling that Britain can simply cancel its notice to leave the bloc, is for the Tory coalition government to stay in power until March 29. Given all that has transpired since Chequers, to accomplish this will require a putsch.

Once again, as this latest Brexit episode illustrates, the zombie neoliberal paradigm refuses to be defeated. We are reminded again and again by those in power that there is no alternative. Use this lens to look at the unfolding events in France.

****

Yesterday The New York Times devoted prominent placement in its cultural aircraft carrier, the Sunday edition, to two weighty, significant attacks on the House of Saud: the front-page account, "The Wooing of Jared Kushner: How the Saudis Got a Friend in the White House," of how Trump arrived at his main foreign policy initiative via a November 2016 meeting between son-in-law Jared Kushner and a Saudi delegation of high-raking officials; and Nicholas Kristof's must-read "Your Tax Dollars Help Starve Children," which thoroughly demolishes the U.S. case for assisting the Saudi-UAE coalition's war on Yemen.

Friday, November 30, 2018

The Political Cost of Backing the Saudi Monarchy + The Ignored Miami Herald Bombshell

Theresa May has announced that she will meet with crown prince Mohammed bin Salman (MbS) in Buenos Aires at the Group of 20 summit. Add her name to a list of Western leaders, along with France's Emmanuel Macron, who are attempting to whitewash MbS' image post-Khashoggi.

On Wednesday the U.S. Senate at least took the first step to invoke the War Powers Act (as recounted in this morning's editorial "The Senate Steps Up on Saudi Arabia: Even Lindsey Graham — Lindsey Graham! — is offended by the administration’s callousness toward the murder of Jamal Khashoggi."). The editorial board of The New York Times believes the chances slim that congress can block vital U.S. assistance of al-Saud and the United Arab Emirates in their war on Yemen. But I'm not so sure.

Lindsey Graham has pledged to interrupt the order of business in the senate until CIA director Gina Haspel appears. And we have yet to hear from Turkish president Recep Erdogan. My guess is he is springing a trap. Once zombie May and boy king Macron genuflect and kiss the jeweled hand of the crown prince, Erdogan will make a move, further compromising the already cadaverous May and Macron.

We'll see. One thing is for sure. The longer Trump fronts for the Saudi monarchy, and the longer the United States facilitates the starvation of a nation, the more likely he loses in 2020.

Many who pay attention to politics believe that American voters don't care about overseas conflict. I think that's untrue. A majority of voters might not give a hoot, but there is a significant fraction that does, and that fraction pulls from both the left and the right; that fraction also pulls other voters along with it.

U.S. support for the Saudi monarchy is radioactive politically. How else to explain congress' sole override of an Obama veto when it enshrined into law the ability of the 9/11 families to sue the kingdom of Saudi Arabia? That happened in September of 2016. Since Trump was actively campaigning against the House of Saud at the time, complaining about the kingdom's support of terrorism, at the same time he was promising to work with Russia and Assad to end the war in Syria, one can argue -- and for me it's persuasive, given Trump's narrow victory -- that Trump is in the White House based on his criticism of the Saudis on the campaign trail.

May is finished; so is Macron; as is Trump.

May, a caretaker of an elite consensus for which there is no popular support; Macron,a ruse, a PSYOP; Trump, a bestial wail meant to frighten the turnkey but it turns out that Trump is a more sadistic turnkey than the turnkey (Hillary) whom he bested.

****

I've seen no mention -- not in Reuters, AP, NYT -- of the bombshell story published in the Miami Herald this week about Jeffrey Epstein's pedophilia network. I saw it in yesterday's Significant Digits:
80 women
Eighty women say they were molested or “otherwise sexually abused” by Jeffrey Epstein, a Palm Beach multimillionaire hedge fund manager accused of assembling a “cult-like network of underage girls,” whose friends included former President Bill Clinton and Donald Trump. Epstein could have spent the rest of his life in prison, but instead a plea deal was struck whereby he’d serve 13 months in jail and an FBI probe into his victims and other powerful figures potentially involved in his crimes was shut down. [Miami Herald]

Sunday, November 18, 2018

Trump Shifts from Rope-a-Dope to Cover-up on Khashoggi

The big announcement on the Khashoggi affair that Trump had promised last week ended up being nothing of the sort. Seventeen Saudi nationals were sanctioned for their role in the murder of Jamal Khashoggi. That news was overshadowed by the announcement of the Saudi public prosecutor that the kingdom would seek the death penalty for five of the accused. Then that news was overtaken the following day, Friday, by the CIA's conclusion that crown prince Mohammed bin Salman was to blame for the plot to assassinate and dismember Khashoggi in Istanbul.

Yesterday, in response to questions about the CIA conclusion, Trump promised another really big announcement, this one in two days.

The resignation Friday of the National Security Council official responsible for the Persian Gulf is a strong tell that in two days the Trump White House will shield the crown prince from punishment for his role as mastermind of the Khashoggi hit. Some form of window dressing will be presented as suitable reprisal for a rogue operation right under MbS's nose, and then the administration will turn the page.

The problem is that it won't be possible to turn the page.

On the Khashoggi affair Trump has made the slight but nonetheless discernible (and momentous) shift from rope-a-dope to cover-up. He's going from a position of "Okay, let's wait and see." to "The crown prince is not the guilty party. Let's move on."

The Western media monopoly will cry "Huzzah!" and flambé the administration. Khashoggi news already regularly tops the Reuters world news feed; The New York Times publishes a new substantive report seemingly daily. The paper's video documentary is a compelling indictment that the Khashoggi hit was so elaborate it must have had state sanction. And remember, in Saudi Arabia the royal family is the state.

The other prime player who will block any Trump move to change the subject is Erdogan. What got lost last week is David Kirkpatrick's story "Turkey Calls for International Inquiry in Khashoggi Killing."

Even if Trump attempts to cover-up for the crown prince Turkey is prepared to go to the United Nations. Then what the does the U.S. do, vote against a fact-finding commission? After its ruckus over the Skripals?

Then there is congress. To avoid a vote on U.S. support for the war on Yemen, the GOP, which controls the house for a couple more months, tucked it into a bill removing the gray wolf from the endangered species list. It narrowly passed. This gives you an idea how toxic anything having to do with al-Saud is now. While in the senate you have Bernie Sanders crusading against U.S. involvement in Yemen.

When the new Democratic house takes over in January there will be no way to stop it from invoking the War Powers Act. That's why there is a push now by the Saudi-UAE-U.S. coalition to take Hodeidah before the end of the year. That's why peace talks were called off until the end of the year.

By fronting for crown prince Mohammed bin Salman Trump is about to make things exponentially worse for himself and the House of Saud.

Tuesday, November 13, 2018

Khashoggi Back in the News

Now that the U.S. midterm elections are out of the way -- with the exception of high-profile races in Florida and Georgia -- a steady diet of Khashoggi news has resumed. On successive days over the holiday weekend the NYT's David Kirkpatrick, the Gray Lady's principal reporter during the Arab Spring revolution in Cairo's Tahrir Square, with various pen pals, published:
Before Erdogan arrived in Paris for the centenary commemorating the end of World War One, he announced at a press conference in Ankara that Turkey had provided to the U.S., Germany, France, Britain and Saudi Arabia copies of the audio recording of Khashoggi's murder. The U.S. declined to comment. France denied it.

Sunday The New York Times tied in the Mueller probe with the Khashoggi killing by reporting that George Nader and Joel Zamel met with crown prince Mohammed bin Salman's right-hand an, Maj. Gen. Ahmed al-Assiri, to pitch a plan to sabotage Iran's economy. Al-Assiri was more interested in talking about Murder, Inc. He wanted to know if Nader and Zamel could assassinate Qassim Suleimani, the leader of the Quds force of Iran’s Revolutionary Guard. Nader demurred, but said that there was a company in the UK that he could refer al-Assiri to.

As Kirkpatrick and his co-authors put it:
Both Mr. Nader and Mr. Zamel are witnesses in the investigation by Robert S. Mueller III, the special counsel, and prosecutors have asked them about their discussions with American and Saudi officials about the Iran proposal. It is unclear how this line of inquiry fits into Mr. Mueller’s broader inquiry. In 2016, a company owned by Mr. Zamel, Psy-Group, had pitched the Trump campaign on a social media manipulation plan.
Then, yesterday, something of a first. We are actually getting snippets of dialogue from the Khashoggi murder audio recording. One of the 15-man Saudi hit team, Maher Abdulaziz Mutreb, can be heard to say, Tell your boss the deed is done.

Of course Mutreb doesn't say, Tell MbS the deed is done. But at this point everyone knows that the crown prince is guilty of murder.

Trump has promised a big announcement this week of punitive measures directed at the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. So far all the U.S. has managed are public statements promising to discontinue in-flight refueling of Saudi-UAE fighter-bombers and promising to level sanctions against the guilty Saudis under the Global Magnitsky Act.

Trump sinks or swims with the crown prince. The administration's launch of its total embargo on Iran got off to a shaky start last week. But all in all it's proceeding as planned. SWIFT has cut off Iran's central bank. The Iranian economy will be suffocated gradually.The U.S. needs Saudi regional clout. It can't sanction both al-Saud and the Islamic Republic of Iran simultaneously and expect anything other than failure. So expect Trump's "big announcement" about Saudi Arabia to be all smoke and mirrors.

A real difficulty for the U.S. position in Yemen is that control of the House now returns to the Democrats. There are plenty of indicators that Congress is not going to be satisfied with an administration proclamation ending mid-air refueling. All assistance to the Saudi-UAE coalition must stop.

Hodeidah is hanging by a thread. Peace talks have been pushed back to the end of the year, not the end of the month as originally promised. The Saudis no doubt demanded the delay in order to have time to capture Hodeidah and bring the Houthis to the bargaining table as supplicants. As is often reported, 80 percent of all food comes through Hodeidah. Once the Saudi-UAE-U.S. coalition takes control of Hodeidah, they control Sanaa.

One positive development to note: the reporting on the war in Yemen has definitely improved since the Khashoggi assassination. For instance, the latest dispatch from Al Jazeera goes beyond the usual "more than 10,000 killed," citing 56,000, and then concludes:
Concerned by the rise of the Houthis, a US-backed Saudi-UAE military coalition intervened in 2015 with a massive air campaign aimed at reinstalling Hadi's government.
Since then, data collected by Al Jazeera and the Yemen Data Project has found that more than 18,000 air attacks have been carried out in Yemen, with almost one-third of all bombing missions striking non-military sites.
Weddings, funerals, schools and hospitals, as well as water and electricity plants, have been targeted, killing and wounding thousands.

Thursday, November 1, 2018

Pompeo Calls for Ceasfire in Yemen

According to "U.S. and Britain Seek Yemen Cease-Fire as Relations With Saudis Cool," by Gardiner Harris, Eric Schmitt and Rick Gladstone:
Mr. Pompeo emphasized that the Houthi rebels in Yemen, who are fighting the Saudi-led coalition, must first stop firing missiles at Saudi Arabia and its chief ally, the United Arab Emirates. But he also said that “subsequently, coalition airstrikes must cease in all populated areas in Yemen.”
Note the "in all populated areas" qualifier. So Pompeo's ceasefire appears to apply only to cities.

The Pompeo ceasefire is being interpreted as a way to salvage the war on Yemen before Congress returns to work:
Already troubled by the Yemen war and outraged over Mr. Khashoggi’s killing, Republicans and Democrats in Congress have been calling on the Trump administration to penalize Saudi Arabia. On Wednesday, five Republican senators asked President Trump to cut off civilian nuclear talks with the Saudis in a letter reported by NBC News.
The administration’s Yemen cease-fire proposal appeared aimed at least in part at heading off congressional fury and preserving the Saudi relationship.
“This is clearly something that’s driven by events that the U.S. government wants to get out in front of,” said Michael Knights, a fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
Whether the calls by the United States and Britain will be backed by stronger action to pressure the Saudis and other combatants in the conflict was not clear.

Friday, October 26, 2018

After Khashoggi, More Mainstream Reporting on al-Saud's Genocidal War on Yemen

One unquestionable benefit that has come from the Khashoggi affair is that the prestige press has suddenly started to publish more features on the genocidal war waged by Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the United States against impoverished Yemen. Prior to Khashoggi there was the occasional blurb pulled from a wire service and the rare, like once every three months, feature. Now Yemen is au courant. It even made the morning blog post of the hipster Emerald City weekly:
This piece on Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen is absolutely heart-breaking: Read it. But maybe wait till the end of the day—I’m warning you that while journalism like this is absolutely necessary, some of these graphic images of emaciated, starving children could be enough to stop your day cold in its tracks—and maybe it should?
French President Emmanuel Macron really doesn’t want to stop selling arms to Saudi Arabia: European countries are asking Macron to halt sales over the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi, but he’s responded, “What’s the link between arms sales and Mr. Khashoggi’s murder? I understand the connection with what’s happening in Yemen, but there is no link with Mr. Khashoggi.” He understands, he doesn’t understand—either way he’s got an itch to sell. In 2017, our president Donald Trump signed a $110 billion arms deal with Saudi Arabia. Oh yeah, that deal also calls for $350 billion “of additional defense purchases over the next 10 years.”
The Macron story is even better than that because it shows how Macron is actually jousting with Germany, the Czech Republic and Austria, nations that have taken tougher positions on the House of Saud.

Thursday, October 4, 2018

Battle for Hodeida Resumes

AP has a long report, "Key battle in Yemen’s war risks tipping country into famine," this morning about the U.S.-blessed resumption of the battle for Hodeida:
BAJIL, Yemen (AP) — With American backing, the United Arab Emirates has resumed an all-out offensive aimed at capturing Yemen’s most vital port, Hodeida, where Shiite rebels are digging in to fight to the last man. Thousands of civilians are caught in the middle, trapped by minefields and barrages of mortars and airstrikes.
[snip]
Hodeida’s port literally keeps millions of starving Yemenis alive, as the entry point for 70 percent of food imports and international aid. More than 8 million of Yemen’s nearly 29 million people have no food other than what is provided by world relief agencies, a figure that continues to rapidly rise.
A protracted siege could cut off that lifeline. The battle has already killed hundreds of civilians and forced hundreds of thousands to flee their homes, adding to the more than 2 million Yemenis displaced by the war. Amid the fighting, cholera cases in the area leaped from 497 in June to 1,347 in August, Save the Children reported Tuesday.
[snip]
The battle brings in to sharp relief a question hanging over the war: What will be the shape of Yemen after all the destruction it has wreaked?
Notably absent from the fight to take Hodeida are the forces of Hadi’s government — the government that the coalition says it aims to restore. Several pro-Hadi officials told the AP that the UAE squeezed him out.
“The government knows nothing about what is going on in Hodeida,” one senior official said. “It’s all in the hands of the Emiratis.” He and the other officials spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivities of relations with the Emirates.
Mistrust runs deep between Hadi’s government and the UAE, which has set up military bases across southern Yemen and controls much of the south through the militias it funds. Some Hadi allies accuse the UAE of seeking to impose its own dominion over Yemen — and see the assault on Hodeida as adding another piece to its hold over the country’s coastline.
Houthi-free southern Yemen has turned into a patchwork of splintered regions under rival militias. Aden, the southern capital, has seen assassinations and street battles between pro-UAE and pro-Hadi militias, as well as increasing crime, robbery and rape.
You will find the AP story in "the newspaper of record" but no original report. The Times has Declan Walsh stationed in Cairo but his last dispatch, "Battle Intensifies for Yemeni Port as Dock Workers Still Unload Aid," on Yemen was published at the end of spring. How many features on the Rohingya -- tales of gang rapes and babies snatched from their mothers breasts to be tossed into a bonfire -- have been published since then? Hannah Beech's output alone numbers half-a-dozen stories, and she has had to cover the Thai underwater cave rescue, various typhoons, earthquakes and tsunamis during the same time period.

It's impossible to avoid the conclusion tweeted by Iranian foreign minister Javad Zarif:
US abrogated JCPOA -a multilateral accord enshrined in UNSC Resolution 2231- arguing that it seeks a bilateral treaty with . Today US withdrew from an actual US-Iran treaty after the ICJ ordered it to stop violating that treaty in sanctioning Iranian people. Outlaw regime.
One wants to recite a prayer: "O outlaw regime. May you be brought low and made to atone for your crimes. Darkness approaches and the earth waits to fold you under its skin."