Showing posts with label Jamal Khashoggi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jamal Khashoggi. Show all posts

Thursday, June 20, 2019

Saudi Arabia is in Trouble

The U.S. Navy MQ-4C Triton shot down yesterday by Iran had its transponder turned off, according to a Reuters story which quoted the IRGC:
A Revolutionary Guards statement said the drone’s identification transponder had been switched off “in violation of aviation rules and was moving in full secrecy” when it was downed, Iranian state broadcaster IRIB reported.
Iran is saying the drone was brought down in its southern province of Hormozgan; the U.S., crying foul, in the international air space over the Strait of Hormuz.

Iran is to be believed here. A strong tell of U.S. duplicity is Central Command's initial denial that the drone had been shot down.

The New York Times story devoted to the downed drone emphasizes its possible connection to a recent increase in Houthi attacks on Saudi territory:
In Yemen, the Houthis’ television channel reported on Wednesday evening that one of their missiles had hit a water desalination plant in the Saudi city of Jizan, on the Red Sea near the Yemeni border. Saudi officials said the missile had landed near the plant, but did not hit it.
The Houthis have stepped up strikes on Saudi Arabia, which has been accused by international groups of indiscriminate bombing in Yemen, but it is unclear what connection there is between the increase and the regional strife involving Iran. Recently, the Houthis have fired projectiles that damaged a Saudi airport and oil pipelines and caused some injuries.
Jizan, which is also the site of a Saudi military headquarters, has been a frequent target of Houthi attacks with missiles and drones over the course of a war that has become the world’s worst humanitarian crisis.
Saudi Arabia and its partner, the United Arab Emirates, have been fighting for four years in a military intervention in Yemen, seeking to roll back a Houthi takeover of much of the country. The Arab monarchies of the Gulf view Iran as their chief regional rival and consider the fight in Yemen a part of a broader struggle against Iran around the region.
In connection with the war in Yemen, news out of the UK is a court ruling that the government broke the law by supplying weapons to Saudi Arabia:
“The decision of the court today does not mean that licenses to export arms to Saudi Arabia must immediately be suspended,” the British judge said.
“It does mean that the UK government must reconsider the matter, must make the necessary assessments about past episodes of concern, allowing for the fact that, in some cases, it will not be possible to reach a conclusion.”
The Campaign Against the Arms Trade welcomed the judgment.
“The Saudi Arabian regime is one of the most brutal and repressive in the world, yet, for decades, it has been the largest buyer of UK-made arms,” said Andrew Smith from the organization. “The arms sales must stop immediately.”
The opposition Labour Party said ministers had wilfully disregarded the evidence that Saudi Arabia was violating international humanitarian law in Yemen, while nevertheless continuing to supply them with weapons.
“What we now need is a full parliamentary or public inquiry to find out how that was allowed to happen, and which Ministers were responsible for those breaches of the law,” said Emily Thornberry, the party’s foreign affairs spokeswoman.
Saudi Arabia is in trouble. The UN is calling for sanctions against the kingdom for the murder of Jamal Khashoggi. The Houthis, for years at war with Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and all their Western allies, have actually increased their offensive capabilities, regularly penetrating Saudi territory.

The U.S. and its client states have one standard reaction when things aren't going their way. Make the problem bigger. That's what we're seeing now as we climb the ladder to war with Iran.

Wednesday, June 5, 2019

This is What a Dictatorship Looks Like

Some pleasing noise is emanating from the U.S. Senate. Coalitions are forming to block Trump's planned trade war with Mexico and his arm sales to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. In both cases Trump is using a declaration of a national emergency to get what he wants.

The problem for congress is that Trump can simply veto whatever block the Senate comes up with, as he did with the War Powers Resolution on Yemen and the motion of disapproval for building a wall on the Mexican border. 

Trump is showing how a U.S. president can govern as a dictator. Invoke national emergencies and veto the congressional response.

As we taxi on the runway to the 2020 presidential election campaign, my guess is that we'll see more emergency decrees and more vetoes.

****

The coalition of senators is hoping to leverage a provision in the Arms Export Control Act that allows lawmakers to introduce what is known as a privileged joint resolution of disapproval against a proposed sale of arms, in essence forcing a debate and a vote. Their plan is to introduce 22 such resolutions, one for each proposed arms sale. A simple majority of lawmakers would need to vote to allow the debate to proceed — and if the measures advanced, the group of senators could monopolize hours of floor time as soon as mid-June.
Winning such support from Republican lawmakers is not out of the question. Members of Congress from both parties were livid early this year when the White House missed a congressional deadline to submit a report detailing whether the administration found Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman personally responsible for Mr. Khashoggi’s death.
And the Senate voted 54 to 46 in March to end American military assistance for the kingdom’s war in Yemen and to curtail presidential war powers, with seven Republican senators breaking ranks to join the resolution and the Democratic conference united in support.
To actually block the arms sales, however, backers of the resolutions would almost certainly need a veto-proof majority, and whether the measures could muster that is another question.
[snip]
New outrage emerged Tuesday, when Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia, a Democrat on the Foreign Relations Committee, disclosed that the Energy Department had approved nuclear technology transfers to the kingdom on two occasions after Mr. Khashoggi’s killing in October in the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul — including one approved two weeks after his death.
****

"Senate Republicans Warn White House Against Mexico Tariffs" by Catie Edmondson and Maggie Haberman
If Mr. Trump were to declare an emergency to impose the tariffs, the House and the Senate could pass a resolution disapproving them. But such a resolution would almost certainly face a presidential veto, meaning that both the House and the Senate would have to muster two-thirds majorities to beat Mr. Trump.
Senator Ron Johnson, Republican of Wisconsin, said he warned the lawyers that the Senate could muster an overwhelming majority to beat back the tariffs, even if Mr. Trump were to veto a resolution disapproving them. Republicans may be broadly supportive of Mr. Trump’s push to build a wall and secure the border, he said, but they oppose tying immigration policy to the imposition of tariffs on Mexico.
[snip]  
Opponents of the tariffs would use the same motion of disapproval that they tried to use to block the president from grabbing federal money for a border wall that was not appropriated for that purpose. That motion did pass Congress with significant Republican support, but not enough to overcome Mr. Trump’s veto.

Friday, February 8, 2019

Khashoggi Returns to the Headlines

The U.S. is a warfare state, plain and simple. From 9/11 on, as the hegemon began its descent, it has been very hard to deny that militarism is America's raison d'être (i.e., singing "God Bless America" during the 7th inning stretch). But it's not a militarism of triumphant conquest; it's a militarism of repeated failure fought on an ever-expanding number of battlefields, a bloodthirsty zombie war with no end in view.

The murder of Saudi dissident Jamal Khashoggi last fall in Istanbul was an important event because, like the snap of a hypnotist's fingers, it awoke even the sleepiest of heads to the reality of U.S. militarism. As Trump said, we can't demand justice for Jamal Khashoggi because Saudi Arabia buys a lot of U.S. weapons.

It was right out there in the open: Grisly murder silencing a mainstream journalist must be accepted as a cost of doing business.

After a fallow period of a couple of months the Khashoggi butchering is back in the news in a big way. First, the United Nations OHCHR report accused Saudi officials of murder:
The evidence presented to us during the mission to Turkey demonstrates a prime facie case that Mr. Khashoggi was the victim of a brutal and premeditated killing, planned and perpetrated by officials of the State of Saudi Arabia and others acting under the direction of these State agents.
Second, Amazon billionaire and Washington Post owner Jeff Bezos went public with blackmail efforts by Trump crony David Pecker, the head of American Media, which owns The National Enquirer. Jim Rutenberg and Karen Weise conclude their write-up, "Jeff Bezos Accuses National Enquirer of ‘Extortion and Blackmail’":
In his post Mr. Bezos also appeared to imply that the tabloid company was doing the bidding of Saudi Arabia, quoting from a New York Times report last year: “After Mr. Trump became president, he rewarded Mr. Pecker’s loyalty with a White House dinner to which the media executive brought a guest with important ties to the royals in Saudi Arabia. At the time, Mr. Pecker was pursuing business there while also hunting for financing for acquisitions.”
The Post has been reporting determinedly on intelligence assessments that the Saudi crown prince, Mohammed bin Salman, ordered the grisly murder of the Saudi dissident — and Post global opinion contributor — Jamal Khashoggi.
Third, The Times' Mark Mazzetti authored a story yesterday, "Year Before Killing, Saudi Prince Told Aide He Would Use ‘a Bullet’ on Jamal Khashoggi," about a newly leaked intercept of a conversation of crown prince Mohammed bin Salman plotting Khashoggi's murder a year prior to the actual event:
The conversation between Prince Mohammed and the aide, Turki Aldakhil, took place in September 2017, as officials in the kingdom were growing increasingly alarmed about Mr. Khashoggi’s criticisms of the Saudi government. That same month, Mr. Khashoggi began writing opinion columns for The Washington Post, and top Saudi officials discussed ways to lure him back to Saudi Arabia.
In the conversation, Prince Mohammed said that if Mr. Khashoggi could not be enticed back to Saudi Arabia, then he should be returned by force. If neither of those methods worked, the crown prince said, then he would go after Mr. Khashoggi “with a bullet,” according to the officials familiar with one of the intelligence reports, which was produced in early December.
Mazzetti story is likely timed to coincide with the renewed push in Congress to punish the House of Saud.

Friday, December 14, 2018

A Display of Sanity on Yemen and Khashoggi

Excellent news from Julie Hirschfeld Davis and Eric Schmitt reporting in "Senate Votes to End Aid for Yemen Fight Over Khashoggi Killing and Saudis’ War Aims":
WASHINGTON — The Senate voted on Thursday to end American military assistance for Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen in the strongest show of bipartisan defiance against President Trump’s defense of the kingdom over the killing of a dissident journalist.
The 56-to-41 vote was a rare move by the Senate to limit presidential war powers and sent a potent message of disapproval for a nearly four-year conflict that has killed thousands of civilians and brought famine to Yemen. Moments later, senators unanimously approved a separate resolution to hold Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia personally responsible for the death of the journalist, Jamal Khashoggi.
Bernie Sanders, a co-author of the resolution, says it is the first time the War Powers Act has been successfully invoked by the Senate. The House will not take up the measure until the new congress is sworn in next month:
While Thursday’s moves were largely a symbolic, if stinging, slap at the Trump administration, they previewed what could be a far more consequential debate after Democrats take over the House in 2019.
“If Paul Ryan thinks on his way out the door his last public service gift to humanity is covering up for Saudi Arabia, great, he can make that his legacy,” said Senator Tim Kaine, Democrat of Virginia, referring to the procedural gambit by Mr. Ryan, the House speaker, this week to prevent the war powers measure from coming up for a swift a vote.
“But we’re going to be around next year,” Mr. Kaine said, “and we’ll figure out ways that there can be consequences for this.”
UN-brokered peace talks in Sweden delivered a ceasefire in Hodeidah:
The agreement calls for an exchange of up to 15,000 prisoners, the creation of a humanitarian corridor into the city of Taiz and, importantly, the withdrawal of troops from Hudaydah. That city, on the Red Sea, is a key entry point to Yemen for essential products like food and medicine.
Peace talks are expected to continue in January in an effort to resolve what has become a humanitarian crisis in one of the poorest nations on Earth.

Wednesday, December 5, 2018

War Drums in Lebanon & Ukraine + INF Treaty + Zombie May + "Smoking Saw"

There are warnings of an Israeli attack on Lebanon, as well as a Ukrainian attack on Donetsk People’s Republic (DPR) in Donbass.

****

Colonel Cassad assesses the U.S. ultimatum to Russia on the INF treaty. Not good.

****

The first test of strength for May's Brexit plan got off to a shaky start in parliament yesterday. Yves Smith jousts against the conventional and opines that May actually fared pretty well:
May may survive next week. Even though her bill will be shellacked, the margin of loss on the contempt vote is a reminder that the Tories will be loath to oppose her if there isn’t a viable leader in the wings. And the reason May is still standing is that there hasn’t been one since she became PM. The Tories do not want Corbyn in, and the DUP does not want to sacrifice its temporary power player role. So the DUP and Tories will vote against May only if they are pretty certain they can quickly install a new PM and avoid a general election.
The scenario that appears to be coming together is that May loses next week but not by an enormous margin. She survives to trudge off to Brussels one more time to try renegotiate the Irish backstop with the EU. The Orangemen of the DUP don't want a perpetual border-free customs union that will bind Northern Ireland to the south. Nothing will come of May's efforts other than allowing her government to live into the New Year.

****

After what looked like a triumph for crown prince Mohammed bin Salman (MbS) at the G-20 in Argentina (a high five from Putin!) the Khashoggi affair is back top of the fold. Reuters reports:
ANKARA (Reuters) - Istanbul’s chief prosecutor has filed warrants for the arrest of a top aide to Saudi Arabia’s de facto ruler and the deputy head of its foreign intelligence on suspicion of planning the killing of Jamal Khashoggi, two Turkish officials said on Wednesday.
The prosecutor’s office has concluded there is “strong suspicion” that Saud al-Qahtani and General Ahmed al-Asiri, both removed from their positions in October, were among the planners of Khashoggi’s Oct. 2 killing at the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, the officials said.
The move comes a day after senior U.S. senators said they were more certain than ever that Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman was responsible for the killing, citing a CIA briefing. The United Nations human rights chief on Wednesday called for an international investigation.
Lindsey Graham had a good line yesterday rebutting Pompeo's claim that there was "no smoking gun" linking MbS to Khashoggi's murder. Graham quipped, “There is not a smoking gun, there’s a smoking saw. You have to be willfully blind not to see it."

Friday, November 30, 2018

The Political Cost of Backing the Saudi Monarchy + The Ignored Miami Herald Bombshell

Theresa May has announced that she will meet with crown prince Mohammed bin Salman (MbS) in Buenos Aires at the Group of 20 summit. Add her name to a list of Western leaders, along with France's Emmanuel Macron, who are attempting to whitewash MbS' image post-Khashoggi.

On Wednesday the U.S. Senate at least took the first step to invoke the War Powers Act (as recounted in this morning's editorial "The Senate Steps Up on Saudi Arabia: Even Lindsey Graham — Lindsey Graham! — is offended by the administration’s callousness toward the murder of Jamal Khashoggi."). The editorial board of The New York Times believes the chances slim that congress can block vital U.S. assistance of al-Saud and the United Arab Emirates in their war on Yemen. But I'm not so sure.

Lindsey Graham has pledged to interrupt the order of business in the senate until CIA director Gina Haspel appears. And we have yet to hear from Turkish president Recep Erdogan. My guess is he is springing a trap. Once zombie May and boy king Macron genuflect and kiss the jeweled hand of the crown prince, Erdogan will make a move, further compromising the already cadaverous May and Macron.

We'll see. One thing is for sure. The longer Trump fronts for the Saudi monarchy, and the longer the United States facilitates the starvation of a nation, the more likely he loses in 2020.

Many who pay attention to politics believe that American voters don't care about overseas conflict. I think that's untrue. A majority of voters might not give a hoot, but there is a significant fraction that does, and that fraction pulls from both the left and the right; that fraction also pulls other voters along with it.

U.S. support for the Saudi monarchy is radioactive politically. How else to explain congress' sole override of an Obama veto when it enshrined into law the ability of the 9/11 families to sue the kingdom of Saudi Arabia? That happened in September of 2016. Since Trump was actively campaigning against the House of Saud at the time, complaining about the kingdom's support of terrorism, at the same time he was promising to work with Russia and Assad to end the war in Syria, one can argue -- and for me it's persuasive, given Trump's narrow victory -- that Trump is in the White House based on his criticism of the Saudis on the campaign trail.

May is finished; so is Macron; as is Trump.

May, a caretaker of an elite consensus for which there is no popular support; Macron,a ruse, a PSYOP; Trump, a bestial wail meant to frighten the turnkey but it turns out that Trump is a more sadistic turnkey than the turnkey (Hillary) whom he bested.

****

I've seen no mention -- not in Reuters, AP, NYT -- of the bombshell story published in the Miami Herald this week about Jeffrey Epstein's pedophilia network. I saw it in yesterday's Significant Digits:
80 women
Eighty women say they were molested or “otherwise sexually abused” by Jeffrey Epstein, a Palm Beach multimillionaire hedge fund manager accused of assembling a “cult-like network of underage girls,” whose friends included former President Bill Clinton and Donald Trump. Epstein could have spent the rest of his life in prison, but instead a plea deal was struck whereby he’d serve 13 months in jail and an FBI probe into his victims and other powerful figures potentially involved in his crimes was shut down. [Miami Herald]

Tuesday, November 27, 2018

Good News in the Making: Let's Take a Moment to Commend the Mainstream

Some good news. Tomorrow or Thursday the U.S. Senate will take another war powers resolution vote. The last one, in March, garnered 44 votes. That was prior to the assassination of Jamal Khashoggi and the increase in mainstream coverage of the genocidal Saudi-UAE-U.S. war on Yemen. Bob Menendez says this time it will likely pass. Bernie Sanders thinks the same.

Other good news is the possibility that Argentina will bring criminal charges against crown prince Mohammed bin Salman (MbS) for his leading role in the war on Yemen. There is a Group of 20 summit this week in Buenos Aires which MbS is scheduled to attend, showing the world it is perfectly normal for a despot to butcher a critic and then take a star turn on the red carpet.

I was mistaken in my belief that by now Erdogan would have weighed in on Trump's absolution of MbS. Yesterday Turkish investigators, apparently looking for Khashoggi's remains, searched a Saudi mansion south of Istanbul.

Rest assured, Erdogan is not done with the Khashoggi affair. The timing was not propitious for additional developments. There was May's appearance for a climactic Brexit vote in Brussels Sunday, as well as the reappearance of Banderastan top of the fold. Maybe another bomb will drop while the crown prince's ringed fingers are kissed in Buenos Aires.

This is a time to celebrate the efforts of the mainstream. Human Rights Watch, The New York Times, Reuters have all kept our noses to the grindstone to make sure the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is held to account.

Wednesday, November 21, 2018

Trump Wades Directly into the Khashoggi Brier Patch

Trump's statement regarding the Saudi assassination of Jamal Khashoggi was a pitchman's defense of the crown prince and the kingdom: Iran is the enemy; the world is a dangerous place; and the Saudis pump a lot of oil and purchase a lot of U.S. weapons. Go piss off, basically. No additional sanctions against Saudi Arabia.

The midterms were the beginning of the end for Trump. Trump's kowtowing to the absolutist monarchy of al-Saud before the dust has even settled on those midterms is more proof of his coming demise.

Trump's troubles in regard to the kingdom have just begun. Already the senate foreign relations committee has requested a determination from the administration as to who is responsible for Khashoggi's murder. Trump will have to consult the intelligence agencies, agencies that have already assessed, the CIA at least, that crown prince Mohammed bin Salman is to blame.

Then there is the question of Erdogan's next move. Turkey has outmaneuvered the United States and al-Saud at every turn. I would expect a rejoinder to Trump's statement before the end of the Thanksgiving holiday weekend.

Monday, November 19, 2018

MbS Absolved in Exchange for an End to War in Yemen? + Path of Exit from Brexit Emerges

Brexit and the Khashoggi affair now seem to be unfolding on synchronized calendars. Tomorrow the White House is supposed to present the result of its investigation into the murder of Saudi dissident Jamal Khashoggi. It's a foregone conclusion that crown prince Mohammed bin Salman will not be held responsible, putting Trump at odds once again with the Central Intelligence Agency.

Mark Landler provides the Khashoggi rehash in "Despite Evidence on Khashoggi, Trump Sticks With the Crown Prince. Why?" It contains a good quote from Bruce Riedel, former spook now with Brookings:
Given the passions generated by the Yemen war on Capitol Hill, the White House is likely to use the Khashoggi affair as leverage to force Prince Mohammed to wind down the conflict as quickly as possible. But Saudi experts warn that this will be difficult since an abrupt Saudi retreat would further tarnish the prince’s image inside the kingdom.
“It’s very clear that what the administration wants is to buy off Congress with Yemen,” Mr. Riedel said. “But it doesn’t solve the underlying problem, which is that Mohammed bin Salman is a destabilizing force in the region.”
Theresa May travels to Brussels this week ahead of Sunday's EU summit. The word is that she is trying to secure concessions to keep additional ministers from bolting her cabinet. As Reuters reports, "The EU is due to hold a summit to discuss the draft deal on Nov. 25. Some Brexit-supporting ministers are reported to want to rewrite parts of it, though Germany has ruled this out." (Yves Smith at Naked Capitalism predicted that this would happen, that the draft would be used to elicit more negotiations with the EU.)

At the same time the number of Tory letters asking for a confidence vote is approaching the magic number 48. My guess is a confidence vote is a sideshow and that the real danger for May is more defections from her cabinet.

Corbyn came out yesterday and agreed to a second Brexit referendum. The die is cast. May goes. Snap elections. New parliament. Re-vote Brexit.

The problem is the March 29 deadline. Can it be postponed?

Sunday, November 18, 2018

Trump Shifts from Rope-a-Dope to Cover-up on Khashoggi

The big announcement on the Khashoggi affair that Trump had promised last week ended up being nothing of the sort. Seventeen Saudi nationals were sanctioned for their role in the murder of Jamal Khashoggi. That news was overshadowed by the announcement of the Saudi public prosecutor that the kingdom would seek the death penalty for five of the accused. Then that news was overtaken the following day, Friday, by the CIA's conclusion that crown prince Mohammed bin Salman was to blame for the plot to assassinate and dismember Khashoggi in Istanbul.

Yesterday, in response to questions about the CIA conclusion, Trump promised another really big announcement, this one in two days.

The resignation Friday of the National Security Council official responsible for the Persian Gulf is a strong tell that in two days the Trump White House will shield the crown prince from punishment for his role as mastermind of the Khashoggi hit. Some form of window dressing will be presented as suitable reprisal for a rogue operation right under MbS's nose, and then the administration will turn the page.

The problem is that it won't be possible to turn the page.

On the Khashoggi affair Trump has made the slight but nonetheless discernible (and momentous) shift from rope-a-dope to cover-up. He's going from a position of "Okay, let's wait and see." to "The crown prince is not the guilty party. Let's move on."

The Western media monopoly will cry "Huzzah!" and flambé the administration. Khashoggi news already regularly tops the Reuters world news feed; The New York Times publishes a new substantive report seemingly daily. The paper's video documentary is a compelling indictment that the Khashoggi hit was so elaborate it must have had state sanction. And remember, in Saudi Arabia the royal family is the state.

The other prime player who will block any Trump move to change the subject is Erdogan. What got lost last week is David Kirkpatrick's story "Turkey Calls for International Inquiry in Khashoggi Killing."

Even if Trump attempts to cover-up for the crown prince Turkey is prepared to go to the United Nations. Then what the does the U.S. do, vote against a fact-finding commission? After its ruckus over the Skripals?

Then there is congress. To avoid a vote on U.S. support for the war on Yemen, the GOP, which controls the house for a couple more months, tucked it into a bill removing the gray wolf from the endangered species list. It narrowly passed. This gives you an idea how toxic anything having to do with al-Saud is now. While in the senate you have Bernie Sanders crusading against U.S. involvement in Yemen.

When the new Democratic house takes over in January there will be no way to stop it from invoking the War Powers Act. That's why there is a push now by the Saudi-UAE-U.S. coalition to take Hodeidah before the end of the year. That's why peace talks were called off until the end of the year.

By fronting for crown prince Mohammed bin Salman Trump is about to make things exponentially worse for himself and the House of Saud.

Tuesday, November 13, 2018

Khashoggi Back in the News

Now that the U.S. midterm elections are out of the way -- with the exception of high-profile races in Florida and Georgia -- a steady diet of Khashoggi news has resumed. On successive days over the holiday weekend the NYT's David Kirkpatrick, the Gray Lady's principal reporter during the Arab Spring revolution in Cairo's Tahrir Square, with various pen pals, published:
Before Erdogan arrived in Paris for the centenary commemorating the end of World War One, he announced at a press conference in Ankara that Turkey had provided to the U.S., Germany, France, Britain and Saudi Arabia copies of the audio recording of Khashoggi's murder. The U.S. declined to comment. France denied it.

Sunday The New York Times tied in the Mueller probe with the Khashoggi killing by reporting that George Nader and Joel Zamel met with crown prince Mohammed bin Salman's right-hand an, Maj. Gen. Ahmed al-Assiri, to pitch a plan to sabotage Iran's economy. Al-Assiri was more interested in talking about Murder, Inc. He wanted to know if Nader and Zamel could assassinate Qassim Suleimani, the leader of the Quds force of Iran’s Revolutionary Guard. Nader demurred, but said that there was a company in the UK that he could refer al-Assiri to.

As Kirkpatrick and his co-authors put it:
Both Mr. Nader and Mr. Zamel are witnesses in the investigation by Robert S. Mueller III, the special counsel, and prosecutors have asked them about their discussions with American and Saudi officials about the Iran proposal. It is unclear how this line of inquiry fits into Mr. Mueller’s broader inquiry. In 2016, a company owned by Mr. Zamel, Psy-Group, had pitched the Trump campaign on a social media manipulation plan.
Then, yesterday, something of a first. We are actually getting snippets of dialogue from the Khashoggi murder audio recording. One of the 15-man Saudi hit team, Maher Abdulaziz Mutreb, can be heard to say, Tell your boss the deed is done.

Of course Mutreb doesn't say, Tell MbS the deed is done. But at this point everyone knows that the crown prince is guilty of murder.

Trump has promised a big announcement this week of punitive measures directed at the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. So far all the U.S. has managed are public statements promising to discontinue in-flight refueling of Saudi-UAE fighter-bombers and promising to level sanctions against the guilty Saudis under the Global Magnitsky Act.

Trump sinks or swims with the crown prince. The administration's launch of its total embargo on Iran got off to a shaky start last week. But all in all it's proceeding as planned. SWIFT has cut off Iran's central bank. The Iranian economy will be suffocated gradually.The U.S. needs Saudi regional clout. It can't sanction both al-Saud and the Islamic Republic of Iran simultaneously and expect anything other than failure. So expect Trump's "big announcement" about Saudi Arabia to be all smoke and mirrors.

A real difficulty for the U.S. position in Yemen is that control of the House now returns to the Democrats. There are plenty of indicators that Congress is not going to be satisfied with an administration proclamation ending mid-air refueling. All assistance to the Saudi-UAE coalition must stop.

Hodeidah is hanging by a thread. Peace talks have been pushed back to the end of the year, not the end of the month as originally promised. The Saudis no doubt demanded the delay in order to have time to capture Hodeidah and bring the Houthis to the bargaining table as supplicants. As is often reported, 80 percent of all food comes through Hodeidah. Once the Saudi-UAE-U.S. coalition takes control of Hodeidah, they control Sanaa.

One positive development to note: the reporting on the war in Yemen has definitely improved since the Khashoggi assassination. For instance, the latest dispatch from Al Jazeera goes beyond the usual "more than 10,000 killed," citing 56,000, and then concludes:
Concerned by the rise of the Houthis, a US-backed Saudi-UAE military coalition intervened in 2015 with a massive air campaign aimed at reinstalling Hadi's government.
Since then, data collected by Al Jazeera and the Yemen Data Project has found that more than 18,000 air attacks have been carried out in Yemen, with almost one-third of all bombing missions striking non-military sites.
Weddings, funerals, schools and hospitals, as well as water and electricity plants, have been targeted, killing and wounding thousands.

Friday, November 2, 2018

Trump's Iranian Oil Sanctions already a Bust

In "Despite Stigma of Khashoggi Killing, Crown Prince Is Seen as Retaining Power," by David Kirkpatrick and Ben Hubbard, the two reporters assess Saudi crown prince Mohammed bin Salman's standing a month into the Khashoggi affair. (The story today is that Khashoggi's body was dismembered and then dissolved.)

Elite opinion considers the U.S.-Saudi strategy of waiting out the public's outrage to be a winning one. The Trump administration appears confident that it can limit to the merely cosmetic any sanctions that congress might impose. Already military brass and banking "masters of the universe" are speaking up on behalf of the kingdom:
One person familiar with the White House deliberations said the administration expected that bipartisan pressure from Congress will force the imposition of some sanctions.
But the White House intends to keep the sanctions limited enough to avoid a rupture with Prince Mohammed. For one thing, he remains central to the plans of the president’s son-in-law and Middle East adviser, Jared Kushner, including hopes to build an Arab-Israeli alliance against Iran and to pressure the Palestinians into a peace agreement.
Two people close to the Saudi royal court said Mr. Kushner and Prince Mohammed communicate often, including by text message, and multiple times since Mr. Khashoggi’s disappearance. A White House spokesman declined to comment about those communications.
[snip]
The crown prince’s stature in Washington may be stabilizing, with at least a handful of American voices extolling the importance of the Saudi-American alliance.
“There is no change in any military relationship we have with Saudi Arabia,” Gen. Joseph Votel, the top United States commander in the Middle East, told the military publication Defense One.
Major figures in finance signaled that they, too, intended to look past the killing. “I understand the emotion around the story,” John Flint, the chief executive of HSBC, told Reuters, “but it is very difficult to think about disengaging from Saudi Arabia given its importance to global energy markets.”
Jamie Dimon, the chief executive of JP Morgan Chase, said that he had accomplished “nothing” by dropping out of the prince’s investment conference and that his bank expected to continue to pursue business with the kingdom. “Being engaged is not a bad thing; it does not mean you condone everything,” Mr. Dimon said at a conference organized by the publication Axios.
Ms. Yahya, of the Carnegie Middle East Center, said such responses send an instructive message to other Arab strongmen.
“You can be even more brutal than you already are,” she said. “Just be smarter about it next time. Don’t kill a well-known journalist inside a consulate.”
The crown prince's public rehabilitation is a necessity because Monday Trump launches his oil sanctions on Iran.

Always a long shot, today's announcement of sanction waivers to some of Iran's biggest customers (India, Japan) is basically an acknowledgment of failure by the administration.

Gardiner Harris had a good write-up the other day ("As New Sanctions Loom, U.S. Push Against Iran Faces Steep Obstacles") about the delusional nature of Trump's Iranian oil sanctions:
The administration’s stated goal for its sanctions campaign is for Iran to make a dozen fundamental changes to its domestic and foreign policies, including ending its support for Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas in Gaza and the Houthi rebels in Yemen. Few analysts believe the present Iranian government could fulfill the demands and survive.
“There is no way the Trump administration will be able to achieve its 12 stated objectives because they’re utterly unrealistic,” said Robert Einhorn, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. “Unless significant changes are made, it’s a policy destined to fail.”

Thursday, November 1, 2018

Pompeo Calls for Ceasfire in Yemen

According to "U.S. and Britain Seek Yemen Cease-Fire as Relations With Saudis Cool," by Gardiner Harris, Eric Schmitt and Rick Gladstone:
Mr. Pompeo emphasized that the Houthi rebels in Yemen, who are fighting the Saudi-led coalition, must first stop firing missiles at Saudi Arabia and its chief ally, the United Arab Emirates. But he also said that “subsequently, coalition airstrikes must cease in all populated areas in Yemen.”
Note the "in all populated areas" qualifier. So Pompeo's ceasefire appears to apply only to cities.

The Pompeo ceasefire is being interpreted as a way to salvage the war on Yemen before Congress returns to work:
Already troubled by the Yemen war and outraged over Mr. Khashoggi’s killing, Republicans and Democrats in Congress have been calling on the Trump administration to penalize Saudi Arabia. On Wednesday, five Republican senators asked President Trump to cut off civilian nuclear talks with the Saudis in a letter reported by NBC News.
The administration’s Yemen cease-fire proposal appeared aimed at least in part at heading off congressional fury and preserving the Saudi relationship.
“This is clearly something that’s driven by events that the U.S. government wants to get out in front of,” said Michael Knights, a fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
Whether the calls by the United States and Britain will be backed by stronger action to pressure the Saudis and other combatants in the conflict was not clear.

Wednesday, October 31, 2018

Prince Ahmed Returns to Riyadh + The Deaths of Whitey Bulger and the United Kingdom

UPDATE: Talks between Turkey and Saudi Arabia apparently have reached impasse. According to a dispatch from Reuters:
“Despite our well-intentioned efforts to reveal the truth, no concrete results have come out of those meetings,” the Istanbul prosecutor’s office said of the talks on Monday and Tuesday between Mojeb and Istanbul chief prosecutor Irfan Fidan.
Of course this could also be a cover for an amicable resolution. The Turks say, "We haven't arrived at the truth yet," the Saudis stay mum, and the whole Khashoggi affair eventually disappears from the collective consciousness.

****

Today the mainstream Khashoggi news remains: "In Intanbul, Saudi public prosecutor Saud Al Mojeb continues to barter with Turkish officials."

David Kirkpatrick and Ben Hubbard report that King Salman's last remaining full brother, Prince Ahmed bin Abdulaziz, returned to Riyadh yesterday. Ahmed had been living in London for the last six years. He recently made public comments critical of the war in Yemen, the king and crown prince Mohammed bin Salman.

Ahmed's return to Saudi Arabia is being interpreted as a move to shore up the kingdom, a ceremonial display to placate Western governments that the crown prince has some oversight.
Prince Ahmed is widely seen as a figure of special gravitas in the family because he is the king’s only surviving full brother. He and the king are the last of the so-called Sudairi 7: the seven sons of the modern kingdom’s founder, King Abdul Aziz, by his favorite wife, Hussa bint Ahmed al-Sudairi. The brothers formed a powerful bloc among the king’s dozens of progeny, passing the throne from brother to brother and divvying up key ministries among themselves. 
Whitey Bulger was found beaten to death yesterday at Hazelton federal penitentiary in West Virginia. As Robert McFadden says in his story "Whitey Bulger Is Dead in Prison at 89; Long-Hunted Boston Mob Boss":
[Bulger] had been moved from prison to prison in recent years and was incarcerated in Florida before being transferred to Hazelton, which has been rife with violence. 
One of the workers said that the inmates were thought to be “affiliated with the mob.” A law enforcement official who oversees organized crime cases said he was told by a federal law enforcement official that a mob figure was believed to be responsible for the killing.
A couple years back I saw a decent documentary Whitey: United States of America V. James J. Bulger, about which I commented for my public library:
The takeaway from WHITEY is an obvious but important one: the United States Government is willing to collaborate with criminals and butchers to achieve strategic objectives. In this case, taking out the Boston area Cosa Nostra. We do it overseas -- working with the rich Gulf emirates who at the same time fund global jihad -- so why not at home? Whitey Bulger was mid-level tough Irish muscle before being made a king by the FBI. Our tax dollars hard at work.
In his latest blog post, "The Ignominious Death of the United Kingdom," Craig Murray predicts that the end of the United Kingdom is coming soon:
Astonishingly, this collection of untalented careerists that constitutes the “government of the United Kingdom” is managing currently to extend its lead in the UK wide opinion polls, while falling back again into third place in Scotland. I have sympathy for friends in England who do not wish Scotland to be independent, because the Tories have such a majority in England. But they have no right to force Scotland to live under a succession of Tory governments, which it has not voted for in over 60 years. Similarly, the Scots have no right to prevent the English from living under Theresa May – or even under Jacob Rees Mogg – if the English continue inexplicably to wish to do so. 
I have expressed for many years the hope that I will see Scottish Independence and a United Ireland before I die. I am happy to say I am now convinced that I will do so. That the end of the UK would be marked by such a squalid, incompetent and dysfunctional political leadership I could not have dared to hope. Thank God the UK will soon be over.

Tuesday, October 30, 2018

Where'd the Khashoggi News Go? + German Federal Elections by Next Fall

Today marks day three of a mainstream news cycle largely devoid of Khashoggi news. Saudi public prosecutor Saud Al Mojeb has been in Istanbul the last couple of days holding talks with Turkish officials. The lack of salacious Khashoggi morsels in Erdogan's loyal press leads one to be believe that headway is being made in negotiations between Turkey and al-Saud.

One Khashoggi bombshell from yesterday that the prestige press chose to ignore is a British tabloid story from the Daily Express alleging that UK intelligence knew, based on intercepts, that the Khashoggi hit was going to happen, tried to wave off the operation by contacting the Saudis directly, but then remained silent when that proved unsuccessful. Khashoggi was about to reveal, so the story goes, Saudi use of chemical weapons in Yemen; that's why he was brutally murdered.

Today there is plenty of mulling over Merkel's announcement to stand down as party leader of the Christian Democratic Union. The New York Times published a love letter in the form of an unsigned editorial, "In Merkel, Europe Loses a Leader." I think neoliberal passion burns hotter for Merkel than any other head of state, except for maybe Obama when he was in power.

The consensus opinion appears to be that Germany will hold new federal elections sooner than those scheduled for 2021. Katrin Bennhold and Melissa Eddy reporting from Berlin say,
The chancellor said she would step down as leader of her conservative party in December and would not seek re-election in 2021. That means Ms. Merkel may remain on the political scene for months to come. But few observers believe she could hang on until the end of her term, speculating that new elections could be held as early as next year.
Alex Gorka, writing for Strategic Culture, agrees:
With no support in her own party, her chances for retaining the position of chancellor are slim at best. In theory, she could remain chancellor until 2021 even after resigning, but in practice this would be a very slim hope. After all, it was she who advocated for the idea that the position of the party’s leader and chancellor be held by one person wearing two hats. Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer, the CDU General Secretary and the chancellor’s preferred successor, believes that the Social Democrats (SPD) could quit the ruling coalition after its poor showing in the polls, thus triggering a general election. With the CDU polling at 26-27% nationally, Merkel’s era would come to an end.
Minister for Economic Affairs and Energy, Peter Altmaier, provides a nonsensical defense of the continuation of the GroKo, saying that, “The grand coalition will hold together because the SPD, CDU and CSU would otherwise lose a huge amount of voters’ trust.”

It's a safe bet that there will be federal elections in Germany by next fall.

Saturday, October 27, 2018

The U.S. Can't Bomb its Way Out of the Khashoggi Affair

There is no indication that the United States and Saudi Arabia have any intention to do anything other than wait out the Khashoggi affair.

Mattis this morning at the Manama Dialogue in Bahrain embraced the status quo in the Middle East: the U.S.-Saudi marriage is "ironclad"; yes, the war in Yemen and the murder of Jamal Khashoggi are regrettable, but Iran is still the region's big bogeyman.

The loathsome Saudi foreign minister Adel al-Jubeir appeared at the same conference and rejected Turkey's calls for the extradition of suspects in Khashoggi's murder, calling the global reaction to butchering the dissident in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, "hysterical."

Continuing to stall seems to me a poor strategy. Serious movement on Syria is afoot. Putin, Erdogan, Merkel and Macron are meeting in Istanbul to discuss Idlib. Decisions are being made absent the "indispensable nation."

As Rouhani says, the U.S. is isolated. Besides the Gulf monarchies, Israel and a UK led by a foundering Conservative Party, the United States under Trump has no strong allies.

The U.S. can't bomb its way out of this one.

Friday, October 26, 2018

After Khashoggi, More Mainstream Reporting on al-Saud's Genocidal War on Yemen

One unquestionable benefit that has come from the Khashoggi affair is that the prestige press has suddenly started to publish more features on the genocidal war waged by Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and the United States against impoverished Yemen. Prior to Khashoggi there was the occasional blurb pulled from a wire service and the rare, like once every three months, feature. Now Yemen is au courant. It even made the morning blog post of the hipster Emerald City weekly:
This piece on Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen is absolutely heart-breaking: Read it. But maybe wait till the end of the day—I’m warning you that while journalism like this is absolutely necessary, some of these graphic images of emaciated, starving children could be enough to stop your day cold in its tracks—and maybe it should?
French President Emmanuel Macron really doesn’t want to stop selling arms to Saudi Arabia: European countries are asking Macron to halt sales over the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi, but he’s responded, “What’s the link between arms sales and Mr. Khashoggi’s murder? I understand the connection with what’s happening in Yemen, but there is no link with Mr. Khashoggi.” He understands, he doesn’t understand—either way he’s got an itch to sell. In 2017, our president Donald Trump signed a $110 billion arms deal with Saudi Arabia. Oh yeah, that deal also calls for $350 billion “of additional defense purchases over the next 10 years.”
The Macron story is even better than that because it shows how Macron is actually jousting with Germany, the Czech Republic and Austria, nations that have taken tougher positions on the House of Saud.

Is Rojava a Sticking Point between Turkey and Saudi Arabia in the Khashoggi Affair?

Over the last 24-hours there has been a distinct lull in the mainstream press coverage of "All Khashoggi, All the Time." For instance, AP's "The Latest" list of Khashoggi developments has hardly any entries.

Ben Hubbard has a decent round-up, "Khashoggi Killing Overshadows Saudis’ Grand Economic Ambitions," vis-à-vis crown prince Mohammed bin Salman's Future Investment Initiative, a.k.a., "Davos in the Desert."

The Future Investment Initiative is an annual conference to promote "Saudi Vision 2030," the crown prince's scheme to neoliberalize the kingdom. The foundation of this neoliberal vision is taking Saudi Aramco public, an effort that has been delayed numerous times even prior to Khashoggi's assassination.

Pakistan's Imran Khan and Jordan's King Abdullah left the conference with billions in Saudi aid. And while overall attendance was down this year because of the Khashoggi media firestorm, Hubbard concludes his story on a note of "And This Too Shall Pass":
“Practically, is this going to delay M.B.S.’s ambitions? Yes. Is it going to wreck them? No,” said Denis Florin, a partner at Lavoisier Conseil, a consulting firm specializing in energy. “I do not see a major revolution in the business attitude toward the middle and long-term prospects of Saudi Arabia.”
The only news regarding Khashoggi is Erdogan's address in Ankara to AKP officials from the provinces. Reuters is reporting that Erdogan said the Saudis need to identify those responsible for Khashoggi's murder; that Turkey has not revealed all that it possesses. Erdogan's message to al-Saud is basically "Shit or get off the pot."

Negotiations are no doubt proceeding round the clock. Who knows what's on the table? I imagine the future status of Rojava is a topic of discussion. Trump is having the Saudis pick up the Kurdish tab for Syria.

It makes sense that Erdogan is using the Khashoggi affair to prune Rojava. When Erdogan makes his bold moves it's usually to go after internal enemies, i.e., Gülenists or the PKK.

Thursday, October 25, 2018

Pipe Bombs and Poppycock

The pipe bombs destined for the mail boxes of prominent liberals have accomplished one thing for Trump: it has knocked Khashoggi news out of the pole position. According to AP,
The attacks overtook other news in an already-tense political season that could reshape Congress and serve as a referendum on the first two years of Trump’s presidency. The actions, which caused panicked building evacuations and reports of additional explosives that later proved unfounded, are bound to add to fears that overheated rhetoric could lead to deadly violence as the parties engage in bitter fights over immigration, the Supreme Court and the treatment of women.
The pipe bombs have allowed Trump to return to his comfort zone and rail against the fake news manufactured by the mainstream corporate media, which, well all is said and done, is the source of his rock-solid 40% approval rating.

There is a stable "American" minority whose identity is based on boorishness, whiteness and a cockeyed fantasy of "exceptionalism" -- the very same identity promoted by the corporate media that acts as Trump's foil.

Juxtaposed to the solid Trump minority is an anti-Trump majority, usually around 52-53%. The problem for the anti-Trump majority is that beyond "Never Trump" it does not have a stable identity.

The latest Khashoggi developments include crown prince Mohammed bin Salman's public declaration of disapproval of the assassination that he ordered and CIA director Haspel's study of Turkey's audio recordings of Khashoggi's murder.

The breaking news is that Saudi Arabia has changed its story once again. Now the Saudi public prosecutor is saying Khashoggi's death was premeditated and not the accidental result of a brawl.

It's part of the "rope-a-dope" strategy. Rest against the ropes while public outrage punches itself out. Replace one load of poppycock with another. At the end of the day the crown prince remains in power.

Wednesday, October 24, 2018

Haspel in Ankara to Threaten Erdogan

The place to start this morning is Craig Murray's blog post, "Khashoggi, Erdogan and the Truth." Murray cuts right to the chase. Turkey has already shared with the major intelligence agencies the audio and video proof of the Saudis butchering of Jamal Khashoggi. And CIA director Gina Haspel is in Ankara to threaten Erdogan in hopes of reining him in:
The Turkish account of the murder of Khashoggi given by President Erdogan is true, in every detail. Audio and video evidence exists and has been widely shared with world intelligence agencies, including the US, UK, Russia and Germany, and others which have a relationship with Turkey or are seen as influential. That is why, despite their desperate desire to do so, no Western country has been able to maintain support for Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman. I have not seen the video from inside the consulate, but have been shown stills which may be from a video. The most important thing to say is that they are not from a fixed position camera and appear at first sight consistent with the idea they are taken by a device brought in by the victim. I was only shown them briefly. I have not heard the audio recording.
[snip]
The same scepticism is true many times over when related to CIA Director Gina Haspel, who personally supervised torture in the CIA torture and extraordinary rendition programme. Haspel was sent urgently to Ankara by Donald Trump to attempt to deflect Erdogan from any direct accusation of Mohammed Bin Salman in his speech yesterday. MBS’ embrace of de facto alliance with Israel, in pursuit of his fanatic hatred of Shia Muslims, is the cornerstone of Trump’s Middle East policy.
Haspel’s brief was very simple. She took with her intercept intelligence that purportedly shows massive senior level corruption in the Istanbul Kanal project, and suggested that Erdogan may not find it a good idea if intelligence agencies started to make public all the information they hold.
Whether Erdogan held back in his speech yesterday as a result of Haspel’s intervention I do not know. Erdogan may be keeping cards up his sleeve for his own purpose, particularly relating to intercepts of phone and Skype calls from the killers direct to MBS’ office. I have an account of Haspel’s brief from a reliable source, but have not been updated on who she then met, or what the Turks said to her. It does seem very probable, from Trump’s shift in position this morning to indicate MBS may be involved, that Haspel was convinced the Turks have further strong evidence and may well use it.
Trump continues to bob and weave. Pompeo announced the first U.S. penalties to be meted out to Saudi Arabia for the Khashoggi assassination. Visas of 21 Saudis will be revoked. The names on the blacklist have not been published. So it is not even "name and shame."

Mohammed bin Salman opened his "Davos in the Desert" conference and received a standing ovation from the congregated capitalists. Parts of Khashoggi's carcass, reportedly discovered yesterday, have yet to surface, but the search continues.

Iran's president Rouhani has entered the fray by saying that al-Saud would not have butchered Khashoggi without a go-ahead from the U.S.

My sense is that while there will be more revelations in the coming days and weeks -- for one, unless Khashoggi's body has been chopped into fine particles and flushed down the toilet, parts of his corpse will eventually surface -- real action is going to have to come from legislatures because there is no evidence that government ministries are willing to upend the gravy train. The Socialist government of Spain has announced that arm sales to Saudi Arabia will continue, same with the UK and Canada. And you know that Trump is going to do the absolute minimum. The only reason Trump has been less than fulsome in his defense of Mohammed bin Salman is that there is a national election in the United States in two weeks. To the average American voter the Saudi royal family is about as bad as it gets.

There is an excellent chance that a blue wave will engulf Trump. All the fundamentals point to a Democratic capture of the House. This is a desired outcome because after Khashoggi I don't see how a Democratic House can maintain support for the U.S. partnership with KSA-UAE in the war on Yemen, nor aid in the initiating of a hot war with Iran after the "sainted" Obama struggled to craft the JCPOA as one of his legacy achievements.

The GOP will likely maintain control of the Senate. But the story will be Trump's failure to hold the House, particularly given how he is pulling out all the stops to win.