Showing posts with label Ilhan Omar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ilhan Omar. Show all posts

Friday, March 8, 2019

It's Official: Refusing to Pledge Allegiance to the State of Israel is Anti-Semitic

The definitive write-up of yesterday's vote in the U.S. House of Representatives on an anti-Semitism resolution camouflaged within a broader "anti-hate" resolution is Barry Grey's "Democrats push through resolution branding Rep. Omar’s criticism of Israel as 'anti-Semitic' ."

Reading the newspaper yesterday at lunch, the reporting was such that it was not clear that any resolution would be voted. Pelosi pulled the original resolution on anti-Semitism, the one backed by key members of New York's Jewish congressional delegation, following a revolt of her freshman rank'n'file.

But a new, more inclusive anti-bigotry resolution was cobbled together which included white supremacy and anti-Muslim hatred, and that's the resolution that passed overwhelming yesterday, 407-to-23.

This vote, ambiguous and watered down as it is, has to be interpreted as a significant victory for the forces fighting desperately to maintain a capsizing status quo. Criticism of the state of Israel is now deemed anti-Semitic in mainstream discourse.

Grey explains how the incident involving an appearance by Ilhan Omar, Minnesota's representative for the 5th CD, at a bookstore metastasized into the latest anti-Semitism frenzy:
Last week, speaking at a Washington DC book store, Omar complained of demands that she be thrown off of the Foreign Relations Committee, saying she should not be compelled to declare “allegiance to a foreign country.” This was seized on by Rep. Eliot Engel, a hard-line Zionist who chairs the House Foreign Relations Committee, who called her remarks an “anti-Semitic trope” echoing slanders of Jews as disloyal aliens. Engel demanded Omar apologize once again and began drawing up a condemnatory resolution.
This is important. Omar never accused Jews of being AIPAC shills or having dual loyalty. Omar merely stated the obvious: She should not, as an elected member of congress, have to pledge fealty to Israel. The "dual loyalty" implication is a leap produced in the fevered brain of stalwarts to a collapsing "centrism."

No better example of this fevered, cockeyed anti-Semitism overreach is Ted Deutch's quote from yesterday's House vote:
“We are having this debate because of the language of one of our colleagues, language that suggests Jews like me who serve in the United States in Congress and whose father earned a purple heart fighting the Nazis in the Battle of the Bulge, that we are not loyal Americans,” Representative Ted Deutch, Democrat of Florida, said Thursday morning in an emotional speech on the House floor.
Of course Omar said nothing of the sort. All she said, the most that can be implied from her words, is that she -- she -- should not have to pledge allegiance to Israel. She is right.

But even a suggestion that one doesn't wish to publicly proclaim allegiance to Israel is now being peddled in the mainstream as proof of anti-Semitism.

Amazing! What chutzpah. And unsustainable I should think.

Thursday, March 7, 2019

Bloomberg, BDS and Biden

The news is neither good nor bad: Michael Bloomberg announced on Tuesday that he would not be running for president. After an extensive examination of his chances for victory, Bloomberg concluded his money would best be spent on launching a new initiative:
Beyond Carbon: a grassroots effort to begin moving America as quickly as possible away from oil and gas and toward a 100 percent clean energy economy.
At the heart of Beyond Carbon is the conviction that, as the science has made clear, every year matters. The idea of a Green New Deal — first suggested by the columnist Tom Friedman more than a decade ago — stands no chance of passage in the Senate over the next two years. But Mother Nature does not wait on our political calendar, and neither can we.
Speaking of Tom Friedman, his latest column "Ilhan Omar, Aipac and Me," is vintage Friedman. He defends the failed status quo -- in this case, the prohibition on criticism of Israel -- by marshaling arguments from the anti-establishment left.

Friedman grants that AIPAC is a blight, and chides its joined-at-the-hip alliance with the GOP, but he takes Ilham Omar's non-committal equivocations on BDS as proof that she hankers for the destruction of the Israeli state. I kid you not.

Here's Friedman's best shot, such as it is, at Omar:
When I see that dual-loyalty charge coming from a congresswoman who first signaled opposition to B.D.S. and then support for it, when I see it coming from a congresswoman who has never been to Israel, when I see it coming from a congresswoman who, to my knowledge, has never criticized the Palestinian leadership for its corruption and failure — time and again — to seize on peace overtures from Israeli leaders who, unlike Netanyahu, actually wanted to forge a two-state solution, when I see it coming from a congresswoman who seems to be obsessed with Israel’s misdeeds as the biggest problem in the Middle East — not Iran’s effective occupation of four Arab capitals, its support for ethnic cleansing and the use of poison gas in Syria and its crushing of Lebanese democracy — it makes me suspicious of her motives.
Basically it is the same old same old: corrupt Palestinian leadership (corrupted by who?); an Iranian bogeyman (a very tough sell); and Syrian poison gas (whose poison gas?).

But back to Bloomberg's latest aborted presidential run. The New York Times story made the argument that Bloomberg's path to the White House was a long shot, but it becomes well-nigh impossible with Biden in the race.

That leads one to believe that Biden is coming in (because, remember, Bloomberg waited until after Hillary's Super Tuesday 2016 romp before announcing that he would not pursue the presidency). All indications are that Biden will join the race soon. But why hasn't he announced already? Could it be he wants Andrew Cockburn's devastating Harper's cover story "No Joe!" off the newsstands before he tosses his hat in the ring.

Biden 2020 will be a version of Hillary 2016, with the DNC mucking about and a neo-McCarthyite song so shrill voters will a large supply of wax to plug up their ears.

Wednesday, March 6, 2019

The "Anti-Capitalism = Anti-Semitism" Freak Out

Here's the dead-end of conflating dissent against the neoliberal status quo with anti-Semitism. From Chris Marsden's "The assault on Jeremy Corbyn is a warning that must be heeded":
Blairite MP Siobhain McDonagh told John Humphrys on BBC Radio Four that anti-Semitism is “very much part… of hard left politics, to be against capitalists and to see Jewish people as the financiers of capital. Ergo you are anti-Jewish people.”
When Humphrys asked, “In other words, to be anti-capitalist you have to be anti-Semitic?” McDonagh replied, “Yes.” This astonishing libel against socialism passed without comment from the BBC’s presenter.
Now another anti-Semitism resolution is to be voted in the U.S. House of Representatives, likely tomorrow (see Sheryl Gay Stolberg's House’s "Anti-Semitism Resolution Exposes Generational Fight Over Ilhan Omar"), all because Ilhan Omar made a statement to the effect, as she tweeted in an exchange with Nita Lowey:
I should not be expected to have allegiance/pledge support to a foreign country in order to serve my country in Congress or serve on committee.
The "Israel, right or wrong" Democratic leadership of Pelosi and Hoyer are going to be on the losing end of this one. As the American Conservative notes, the polling on this skews heavily to old vs. young:
According to a 2018 Pew Research Center report, the number of Republicans that sympathize with Israel over Palestine has increased to 79 percent, while sympathy for Israel dropped among Democrats to 27 percent, a disturbing trend especially for the anti-BDS movement. Besides growing sympathy for the Palestinians, progressives are echoing the ACLU and other groups who say any law prohibiting [BDS] boycotts won’t ultimately survive a Supreme Court test. They are probably right.
Equating anti-capitalism with anti-Semitism is a true sign of desperation, a flashing red light along a road where the tried-and-true Russian bogeyman hazard has already been passed along the way to our crack-up.

Thursday, February 14, 2019

We Need to Elect More Ilhan Omars

There was some good news yesterday. The House of Representatives invoked the War Powers Act to end U.S. involvement in the Saudi-spawned genocide in Yemen. Why it took the Democrats more than a month to hold the vote is a good question. Now it's back to the Senate, where it was already passed in December but by the previous congress. Supposedly it will take another month before it is brought to a vote, and the Trump administration has, in so many words, already promised a veto. I doubt the resolution will garner as many votes, 56, as the first go-round. There will be an attempt to de-link the Khasshogi murder from U.S. facilitation of the war on Yemen. But that's going to be difficult.

The other goods news is that recently AIPAC-admonished Ilhan Omar, Representative for Minnesota's 5th CD, sprang off the ropes with her confrontation of notorious ghoul Elliott Abrams during the House Foreign Affairs Committee hearing yesterday. As Bill Van Auken notes in "Washington escalates military threats as Venezuela regime change falters":
In testimony on Capitol Hill on Wednesday, the Trump administration’s special envoy on Venezuela, Elliot Abrams was asked whether the US had increased its troop deployments in South America in response to the Venezuelan crisis and responded, “I don’t believe so.” He added that direct US military intervention was not Washington’s “preferred route.”
Asked by a member of the House Foreign Affairs Committee whether the US was funneling arms to Venezuela’s right-wing opposition, Abrams said that his answer was “a simple and unequivocal no.”
The committee’s Democratic chairman, Eliot Engel, introduced Abrams citing his posts in the Reagan and Bush administrations and his positions in various think tanks. Unmentioned was the fact that he pleaded guilty in 1991 to lying to Congress about the illegal funneling of money and guns to the CIA-backed “contras” in their terrorist war against Nicaragua and avoided jail only because of a pardon by Bush senior.
One member of the committee, Minnesota Democrat Ilhan Omar, challenged Abrams, citing his guilty plea in the contra affair, stated, “I don’t understand why members of this committee or the American people should find any testimony that you give today to be truthful.” She went on to detail his defense of the El Mozote massacre of some 800 civilians in El Salvador and similar genocidal acts by the dictatorship in Guatemala.
Abrams treated the questioning with contempt, interrupting Omar and declaring that her questions were an “attack” that did not merit an answer.
That the same kind of operations that Abrams defended in Central America are ongoing in Venezuela was indicated by the Venezuelan government’s interception of a shipment of 19 assault rifles, 118 explosive charges, 90 military-grade radio antennas and six latest generation smartphones on a Boeing 767 cargo flight by the 21Air company to the Valencia airport.
“This materiel was destined for criminal groups and terrorist actions in the country, financed by the fascist extreme right and the government of the United States,” a spokesman for the Venezuelan military charged.
The air cargo company, 21 Air, had previously run flights between US cities, but in recent months had shifted its operations to Venezuela, with stop-offs in Colombia.
For the little bit of good news there is no indication that the U.S. is going to halt its commitment to perpetual war. The U.S.-recognized coup leader, Juan Guaido, has proclaimed February 23 as the day that "volunteers" will deliver humanitarian aid from across the border in Colombia. It's a provocation. The U.S. has been powwowing with Brazil and Colombia on the next steps in the flagging coup. The New York Times, while sticking to the script that the coup is legitimate, nonetheless gives voice to skepticism regarding its implementation. According to "Humanitarian Aid Stalls, Testing Venezuela’s Opposition," by Nicholas Casey and Anatoly Kurmanaev:
“The opposition has created immense expectations, and it’s not at all clear they have a plan for actually fulfilling them,” said David Smilde, a Venezuela analyst at the Washington Office on Latin America. “Furthermore, the opposition and the U.S. have not been clear that this aid, even if allowed in, will make a significant dent in Venezuela’s humanitarian crisis.”
Some Venezuelans have even put off buying medication, expecting that the American donations will arrive across the border soon, Mr. Smilde said.
We need to elect more Ilhan Omars.