Showing posts with label Egypt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Egypt. Show all posts

Friday, October 4, 2019

Ayatollah Sistani Sides with Iraq Protesters

Civil unrest in Iraq, predominantly in Baghdad and the southern provinces, has roiled the country all week. The death toll is at 33 with over 1500 wounded. Security forces have resorted to live fire.

Protesters are demanding government action on unemployment, income inequality, corruption and the delivery of basic services -- fundamental demands of a democratic electorate.

No discernible political or sectarian orientation can be ascribed to this uprising, though it seems to be centered in Shiite areas of the country. One needs to be cautious given the West's penchant for color revolutions and the recent importance of Iraq in the U.S.-Iran quasi-war, but this seems to be another expression of Tahrir Square spirit (something returned to Egypt recently).

As the NYT reports, Ayatollah Sistani has sided with the protesters, calling for a formation of anti-corruption committee and protester-government dialogue:
“It is sorrowful that there have been so many deaths, casualties and destruction,” [Ayatollah Sistani] wrote in a letter read out by his representative, Ahmed al-Safi, at a sermon in Kerbala, Reuters reported. “The government and political sides have not answered the demands of the people to fight corruption or achieved anything on the ground.”
Ayatollah Sistani urged both side to step back “before it is too late,” The Associated Press reported, and he repeated his call for the formation of a committee of technocrats to address corruption.
In an effort to prove his seriousness, [prime minister Adil Abdul] Mahdi invited representatives of several political factions, including opposition parties, to meet with him and discuss how to be reduce tensions.
Mr. Mahdi’s efforts seemed aimed at dividing the protesters between those who had resorted to violence and those who insisted their goal was to protest peacefully.
“Today we are pulled between two options: having a state or having no state,” he said.
What a wonderful thing if the Middle East could get another shot at the Arab Spring. The Gulf monarchies are much more fractured today than eight years ago, as are the old colonial powers of the West. It will be difficult to play the jihadist card again with the same bravado. Maybe people power will not be so grossly subverted this go-round.

Monday, December 28, 2015

It Can Happen Here

One thing I noticed over the holiday, because I found myself in front of a television with cable, is that the latest CNN poll shows Donald Trump with a stable and commanding lead -- more than double -- over his nearest challenger. Yet why is it that most mainstream commentators persistently deny that Trump will win? Yesterday conservative columnist Ross Douthat, in an otherwise interesting op-ed, "Cracks in the Liberal Order," flat out says "Trump will not be the Republican nominee (yes, really)."

Do these commentators see something that we are missing or are they just singing for their supper? The easy answer is the latter. Clearly a circling of the wagons is going on. Trump is perceived as a threat by the elites who sit atop a crumbling order. No analyst or commentator wants to catch the baleful eye of his boss for trumpeting the Donald.

But maybe conservatives like Douthat and liberals like Nate Silver have the sagacity to look past the obvious. If the neoliberal order survived not only intact but with an even greater distribution of pie for the 1% after the Lehman Brothers meltdown and Obama's two progressive landslides, what real threat does a populist challenge from the right pose or really any of the myriad threats from whatever quarter? To pick up Douthat where he left off with Trump:
Bernie Sanders won’t beat Hillary. Far-left antics at Amherst and Oberlin and Claremont McKenna and Yale are not as significant as elite college graduates like to think.
In Europe, Jeremy Corbyn probably won’t be Britain’s next prime minister, Marine Le Pen probably won’t be France’s next president, Sweden probably isn’t about to turn fascist, the E.U. probably isn’t about to break apart. Houellebecq’s vision of an Islamified Europe, like ISIS’s vision of a new Islamic empire or Putin’s Stalinist nostalgia, is more a resonant fantasy than a plausible atlas of the future. 
It’s still wise to bet on the current order, in other words, and against its enemies and rivals and would-be saboteurs. 
But after liberalism’s year of living dangerously, for the first time in a long time it might make sense to hedge that bet.
Conservative Douthat is making much the same argument as Marxist Tariq Ali made in his book The Extreme Centre: A Warning (2015) -- neoliberalism still has a lot of juice left. At least Douthat allows that it might be wise to start looking for a hedge.

Next year should be very interesting. Depending on how the GOP primary unfolds, Republican power brokers will likely try to block Trump at the convention. Barring that, there will be moves made in the background to make sure a wounded Hillary wins the general election.

Either way, Trump unbowed or Trump beaten into the dust, the political system after Obama is stressed, its legitimacy in doubt.

Given that the Joint Chiefs worked against the Commander in Chief in order to prevent the Middle East from descending into even greater chaos, and recognizing the fact that the armed forces are the recipient of an enormous, ongoing public relations campaign, one can imagine a situation like that which unfolded in Egypt or Thailand happening here in the not-too-distant future.

Monday, November 9, 2015

The Metrojet Airbus and the New Cold War

What we get when we read the news is not what is really going on. We get a general picture, almost like clip art, and then a large, elaborate, well-constructed frame to adorn the picture and shape how we perceive it.

If you read the news every day, attempt to follow the presentation of the clip art, you develop a kind of sixth sense when something is awry. And something is definitely awry when it comes to the story of the Russian charter jet that blew apart the weekend before last over the Sinai, killing all 224 on board.

At first, all officials -- from Russia, Egypt, the United States, Britain -- denied that the Airbus A321-200 could have been downed by a terrorist attack. Why? Because Ansar Bait al-Maqdis, Islamic State's affiliate in the Sinai, allegedly doesn't possess surface-to air missiles capable of reaching the altitude of an Airbus jetliner.

But the weakness of that argument is the assumption that the only way a terrorist can strike is with a missile.

Then there were several-days worth of stories chock full of MacGuffins about the structural integrity of the Metrojet Airbus, its previously repaired tail section, the shoddy nature of Russian commercial aviation, etc.

During this time you had the Pentagon interjecting anonymously -- why? -- that it had satellite imagery showing a flash emanating from the plane which pointed to an explosion; meanwhile Russian and Egyptian officials maintained their ludicrous denials of foul play.

Finally the dam broke when the U.K. suspended flights to the Sinai resort of Sharm el-Sheikh after concluding a bomb blew apart the Russian charter jet. The Brits started shuttling their nationals out of the Sinai peninsula with the plane cargo holds empty. What does that tell you?

Obama performed an about-face and said terrorism could very well have brought down the Metrojet. Over the weekend the storyline shifted to a "those wacky Egyptians and their lax security" theme. Now it is broadly acknowledged that a bomb smuggled aboard the Airbus, as Michael Schmidt reports in "Consensus Grows for Bomb as Cause of Russian Jet Crash, Officials Say," was the cause of the crash.

Where most regular news consumers immediately assumed foul play, the mainstream media at the behest of their official minders in government took their readers, listeners and viewers on a week-long wild goose chase. Why?

Because something is happening here. Tectonic plates are shifting and realigning. I am of the opinion that Western-style democracy in the industrial core is getting harder for the power brokers to manage (look at the U.S. presidential campaign). Watching the NFL games yesterday, I have never seen such a mixing of the military with popular sports. Coaches and players wore camouflage gear on the sidelines. It is an homage to Veterans Day, but it runs far deeper than that, as the report, "Tackling Paid Patriotism," of Arizona senators John McCain and Jeff Flake makes clear. The Pentagon pays millions to have sports teams honor the military. This is fascism of course.

But the Pentagon needs to spend that money in order to maintain support for all its foreign interventions, such as bolstering its troop presence in Europe.

Russia is making its own play, and not just with its forceful intervention in Syria. Pepe Escobar makes the case in "What’s the Big Deal Between Russia and the Saudis?" that Russia is negotiating with its enemies al-Saud and Turkey on oil and pipelines. While Mike Whitney argues in "Turkey Goes to War" that a post-landslide-election Erdogan is still aiming to establish a buffer zone in northern Syria with Turkish troops.

When everything appears to be in flux -- the G20 meeting in Turkey this weekend should be interesting -- stick with the obvious. The Russian charter jet was obviously brought down by a terrorist attack. The jihadis have not been successful  in bringing down commercial jets with on-board bombs, as Michael Schmidt points out:
If the Islamic State was behind the crash, it was able to mount the kind of attack that Al Qaeda has found difficult to carry out in recent years. At least three times since 2009, Al Qaeda’s affiliate in Yemen has come close but failed to bring down an airliner using bombs that were designed to be undetectable. 
Western intelligence officials have feared that the Islamic State has larger ambitions for attacks outside Syria and Iraq — where it seized large stretches of land in 2014 — especially after the United States and Russia began separate military operations against the group.
Why now? And why didn't the jihadis go after the United States? The U.S. has purportedly been bombing ISIS longer than Russia.

Bombs in cargo holds reek of spy craft, double agents and intelligence agencies. If the British were able to make a determination of terrorism because they intercepted chatter about the Metrojet explosion, they either knew that it was going to happen or knew that an ally agency was running the operation. This was definitely a tit-for-tat attack in the New Cold War.

Tuesday, October 20, 2015

The Sisi Trend in Egypt and the United States

If you live in a police state elections are usually just a formality and citizens tend not to vote. Egypt is holding parliamentary elections for the first time since 2011. Official turnout, based on Sunday and Monday voting, probably inflated, is said to be 15-16%, as David Kirkpatrick reports in "Low Voter Turnout Reflects System by Design in Egypt":
Prime Minister Ismail Sherif said Monday that 15 or 16 percent of eligible voters had turned out for the first day of voting the previous day, the state news agency reported. But he did not cite the source of his estimate and the election commission did not disclose its figures. 
Several polling places in the populous areas near Cairo were almost completely empty, except for a handful of elderly voters. Almost every news account indicated a dearth of voters elsewhere as well. 
Alarmed by the low turnout on Sunday, Mr. Sherif gave public employees a half-day holiday on Monday to encourage more voting. The governor of Alexandria dropped the fares for public transportation. Pro-government talk show hosts hectored their audiences to get out and vote.
Other Egyptians, however, traded jokes about the turnout. “I need to sit alone for a while,” many repeated on Facebook. “I am going to a polling station.” 
“No one went today either” was trending on Twitter. 
The low turnout recalled elections for the rubber-stamp parliaments under Mr. Mubarak, although Mr. Mubarak had in fact allowed more competition. In his later years in power, Mr. Mubarak had permitted the Muslim Brotherhood, Egypt’s mainstream Islamist movement and the largest opposition group, to win as many as 20 percent of the seats in the Parliament. Then a ruling party sweep eliminated the Brotherhood from Parliament completely in 2010, raising widespread allegations of rigging and setting the stage for the uprising a few months later.

Turnout swelled to 55 percent of the voting age population in 2011 for Egypt’s first free parliamentary election in decades. A party list system emphasized policy debate over candidate patronage, and the Brotherhood dominated the vote.

Then a year later a court ordered Parliament’s dissolution over a procedural technicality. The army assumed the legislative powers, and a year after that, in 2013, Mr. Sisi led the military ouster of the elected president, Mohamed Morsi of the Brotherhood.

Mr. Sisi has ruled without a legislature since 2013. The current election is expected to return lawmakers to the halls of Parliament for the first time in more than three years.

Mr. Sisi’s government has also outlawed the Brotherhood, arrested its leaders and shut down its media outlets, and the police have cracked down on more secular opposition as well.

For this parliamentary vote, Mr. Sisi put three-quarters of the seats up for competition by individual candidates, favoring the prominent and wealthy. In perhaps the most hotly contested district, in Dokki neighborhood of Giza across the Nile from Cairo, the son of a famous soccer team manager was running on the slogan “We Score for You,” with a soccer ball as his logo.
The United States is pretty much in the same situation as Sisi's Egypt. Here the candidate that generates the most interest is a reality television personality and real estate mogul. Donald Trump continues to poll as the clear choice of the "unwashed." Without substantive democracy people will opt for a circus with clowns.

To add some heft to the statement that the U.S. is in Sisi territory, look at the vote totals of the 2014 Congressional elections. Turnout was 36.4%, the lowest since 1942, a year the U.S. was fully mobilized for a world war. And while you might say that 36% is more than double Egypt's 16%, in some areas, like Ohio and New York, turnout was as low as the days before universal male suffrage.

So for the United States, compared with its own history, we are in Sisi country. How else to explain the GOP Congress, broadly derided as one of the most ineffective in the history of the nation, adding to its majority, which now stands at more than 50 seats?

And this is just the way the plutocrats want it -- a demoralized, broken citizenry staying home rather than going to the polls to rubber stamp candidates who only represent concentrated wealth.

That's why I think in a presidential election between Hillary and Trump, Trump wins because clearly more people will have a reason to vote for a circus clown than for an avatar of a failed system.

Wednesday, August 19, 2015

War Crimes in Yemen

The Gray Lady seems to be paying more attention to Yemen these days. The Saudi-led, U.S.-backed destruction of the poorest Arab nation has received spotty coverage in the "newspaper of record" because it tars the Obama administration as guilty of war crimes.

Today a story by Rick Gladstone, "Amnesty International Says All Sides in Yemen Have Committed War Crimes," makes this quite clear. Amnesty released a report, "Yemen: Bloody trail of civilian death and destruction paved with evidence of war," as did UNICEF, "Yemen Conflict: Over a thousand child casualties so far," which detail the crimes against humanity. As Gladstone says,
The Amnesty and Unicef reports were released as heavy airstrikes by the Saudi-led coalition hit Yemen’s Red Sea port of Hodeida, the main gateway for trade and emergency supplies to north and central Yemen.
Jamal Ayesh, the port director in Hodeida, said that the airstrikes hit after midnight, destroying the only five cranes in the port. He said that hangars used for maintenance and storing goods were also destroyed. “We can say that the cranes are out of service now,” he said.
Lloyd’s List, a London-based news service for the insurance industry, said Hodeida had closed because of the airstrikes.
Edward Santiago, the Yemen director for Save the Children, said in a statement that the full extent of the damage to Hodeida was unclear, but that “the impact of these latest airstrikes will be felt most strongly by innocent children and families.”
Mr. Santiago called the Hodeida bombing “the final straw.”
More than 4,000 people have been killed in Yemen, the Middle East’s poorest country, since March, when the Saudis began bombing Houthi rebels who had driven the Saudi-backed government into exile. Saudi Arabia views the Houthis as proxies of Iran, its regional rival.
Yemen is now one of the world’s most acute humanitarian catastrophes, with 80 percent of the population in dire need of food and other emergency relief.
The Houthis have suffered a series of defeats in the past month and have been driven out of the southern port of Aden by fighters aligned with the exiled government.
Although the Houthis still control Sana, the capital, exiled Yemeni officials are predicting that they will reclaim it within weeks.
The important thing to remember here is that the United States is acting as air-traffic controller for the Saudis, not to mention that the U.S. Navy is participating in the blockade of Yemen. Beyond a doubt, the Obama administration is participating in a total war on the Yemeni civilian population. The airstrikes on the port of Hodeida are intended to staunch the flow of aid to territory that the Houthis control. The Obama administration is guilty of war crimes; this should be obvious to all.

Remember this the next time some Western official stands at a lectern and admonishes the Syrian government for insufficient care to its civilian population. Because of the dominant role that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Israel play in the determination of U.S. foreign policy, Obama did a somersault and now fully and openly backs the Egyptian police state of Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi. One wonders how Obama is going to explain away the famine he is helping to create in Yemen.

Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Obama Signals Support for Widening War in Yemen: Stop on Arms to Egypt Lifted

The news out of Yemen is that the Saudis are indiscriminately bombing the civilian population (Kareem Fahim and Nick Cumming-Bruce, "Aid for Yemen Dwindles as Need Rises Amid Chaos"):
“The situation in Yemen is extremely alarming, with dozens of civilians killed over the past four days,” Mr. al-Hussein [United Nations’ human rights chief Zeid Ra’ad al-Hussein] said in a statement. “The country seems to be on the verge of total collapse.”
“The killing of so many innocent civilians is simply unacceptable,” he added.
Some hospitals have been bombed, as have private homes; schools; and civilian airports and power stations in the capital, Sana, and the cities of Saada and Al Hudaydah, the United Nations said, highlighting fears of the havoc that would result from a threatened ground invasion by Saudi forces and those of other nations.
Unicef said in a statement on Tuesday that at least 62 children had been killed in fighting in Yemen over the past week. Mr. al-Hussein said he was shocked by a Saudi airstrike Monday on Al Mazraq, a camp in the north for displaced Yemenis, which caused scores of civilian casualties.
The United Nations human rights office said its staff had confirmed that at least 19 people had been killed and 35 others wounded in that strike, but it noted that there were different accounts of the number of dead. The International Organization for Migration, which had workers in the camp, reported that 40 people had been killed.
Signalling his support for this terror bombing of a civilian population guilty of nothing other than residing in a country riven with strife, Obama removed the hold on high-tech military hardware bound for Egypt (Peter Baker, "Obama Removes Weapons Freeze Against Egypt"):
Mr. Obama’s move will release 12 F-16 fighter jets, 20 Harpoon missiles, and the shells and parts necessary to assemble up to 125 M1A1 Abrams tanks that Egypt had previously paid for but that have been held up since 2013. The F-16s are especially important to Egyptian leaders, who have bitterly raised the issue with their American counterparts at nearly every opportunity.
Intended or not, experts said Mr. Obama’s decision would be interpreted as an effort by Washington to bolster a fragile position in the region. “The U.S. is facing quite a few challenges, and it needs to shore up relations with allies,” said Steven Simon, a former Middle East adviser to Mr. Obama now affiliated with Dartmouth. “The assistance to Egypt was always predicated on its foreign policy, not its domestic policy. That was certainly the Egyptian understanding of it.”
But other experts and human rights advocates said Mr. Obama had effectively capitulated to Mr. Sisi, a former general who helped lead the military overthrow of President Mohamed Morsi’s Muslim Brotherhood government in 2013 and then won the presidency in an election tainted by wide-scale arrests of opposition figures.  . . . 
“Unsurprisingly, in this case you see that national security priorities, broadly defined, trump virtually everything else,” said Sarah Margon, the Washington director of Human Rights Watch. “And that’s a very myopic, short-term approach to fighting terrorism. Human rights abuses are actually a very bad counterterrorism strategy.”
According to Human Rights Watch and an Egyptian group called the Arabic Network for Human Rights Information, the Egyptian authorities arrested more than 40,000 people after Mr. Sisi’s removal of Mr. Morsi and have never provided a full accounting of the detentions.
Sisi this past weekend announced the formation of a joint Arab military force and promised Egyptian ground troops for Yemen if they were needed.

Make no mistake. The United States is now fully committed to a "Sisi solution" for the Middle East, which is to say, a re-imposition of Saddam Hussein-like strongman rule throughout the region. No longer will there even be lip service for democracy and basic human rights. The Saudis and Israelis are calling the shots. One can pick up a change in the climate on the Gray Lady's editorial page. The rankest neocon hatred (Bolton and Prosor) is allowed the spotlight. This does not bode well for an agreement with Iran on its nuclear program.

Yemen is the beginning of a war that will crack the Middle East wide open. Already the Iranians say they have broken the Saudi blockade, a clear statement that they will support the Houthis:
Some aid may have pierced the blockade. The state-run news media in Iran reported on Tuesday that the Iranians had airlifted humanitarian aid to Yemen, the first such delivery from Iran since the bombing campaign began.
The accounts did not specify precisely where the aid had been sent, or how the Iranians had evaded the blockade, but they said it included 19 tons of medical supplies and two tons of food donated by the Iranian Red Crescent.
A Saudi military spokesman blamed the Houthis on Tuesday for the growing number of casualties, accusing them of fighting from inside civilian areas and putting residents at risk.
That assertion came in response to a swelling chorus of criticism of the Saudi military, including from Amnesty International, which said in a statement that 14 people had been burned to death, including at least six civilians, in Saudi airstrikes early Tuesday against a Houthi checkpoint and fuel depots.
In its statement, Amnesty International accused the coalition of “turning a blind eye to civilian deaths and suffering caused by its military intervention.”
The fighting has forced hundreds of families to flee their homes, adding to the more than 334,000 people the United Nations’ refugee agency reported as displaced in the months of conflict before the recent surge in hostilities.
To escape the fighting, small numbers of Yemenis have started crossing the Red Sea to Somalia and Djibouti, said William Spindler, a spokesman for the refugee agency. “We are preparing for a larger influx,” he added.
The Gulf sheikhdoms are rotten to the core, commanding nothing but mercenaries, whether they be salafis or regular military. They have proven adept only at terrorizing civilians and collapsing paper armies like the one set up by the United States for Iraq. What is about to come in Yemen promises to be very different.

The U.S. needs to tread carefully. Whether the elites in control know it or not, the political system in the homeland commands very little support. There is a greater disconnect between government and the governed than at any time in my life. An expansive commitment to yet another battle front in the Middle East (e.g., Iran) will destroy the country.

Monday, March 30, 2015

Joint Arab Military Force: Saudis Decide to Emerge from Shadows

The bill for Saudi support of Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi's coup has come due. The Egyptian president and former general who ousted Mohamed Morsi in July 2013, beginning a bloody crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood and a rollback of the Arab Spring, announced at an Arab League meeting in Sharm el Sheikh over the weekend the formation of a joint Arab military force. David Kirkpatrick has the story, "Arab Nations to Form Military Force to Counter Iran and Islamist Extremists":
“The challenges facing our national Arab security are grave, and we have succeeded in diagnosing the reasons behind it,” Mr. Sisi said, without specifying those reasons. The meeting, he added, was “pumping the blood of hope in the arteries of Arab cooperation.”
Egypt has long considered itself the shield and protector of the oil-rich but sparsely populated gulf monarchies like Saudi Arabia. Yet Mr. Sisi has an especially close relationship with the Saudis and their gulf allies because they supported his ouster of President Mohamed Morsi of the Muslim Brotherhood in 2013. The gulf monarchies have contributed tens of billions in financial assistance to Egypt since then, including new pledges of an additional $12 billion announced this month.
Last year, Mr. Sisi also allowed jets from the United Arab Emirates to take off from Egypt for airstrikes against an Islamist-allied political faction in Libya. This year, the Egyptian Air Force carried out a strike of its own in Darnah, in eastern Libya, in retaliation for the beheading of a group of Egyptian Christians by an arm of the Islamic State, also known as ISIS or ISIL. Both Egypt and its gulf allies remain acutely concerned about Libya’s civil strife and the Islamist groups that have flourished as the government and other national institutions have crumbled.
The idea of a joint military force “has been there before but not so seriously,” said Gamal Abdel Gawad Soltan, a political scientist at the American University in Cairo. He noted that Arab joint defense treaties date to 1950 and a joint military command was previously formed for a time in the mid-1960s. That was during the era of Pan-Arab nationalism, when Arab governments joined forces against Israel. That vision ended in the Arab-Israeli War of 1967, with a humiliating defeat.
“It is the renewal of an old idea,” Mr. Soltan said, “but this time the level of seriousness looks higher, even if we do not know yet whether the outcome this time will be different than in the past.”
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia provided ample financial and diplomatic backing for Sisi's coup government. A dictator presiding over a ruthless police state is what the Saudis prefer to see worldwide. For all his talk of democracy and new beginnings in the Arab world, Obama quickly fell in line with the Arab Spring rollback.

But the Gulf Sheikhdoms are apoplectic, as are the Israelis, over the P5+1 talks with Iran on its nuclear program; that, and the reluctance of Obama to bomb Damascus to rubble and take out the Baathists in Syria once and for all. Now there is the Houthi movement in Yemen who easily toppled the Saudi stooge Abdu Rabbu Mansour Hadi.

So the despots presented Sisi with his bill: the formation of a combined Arab military force, the foot soldiers, the cannon fodder to be supplied in large part by Egypt.

It will be interesting to see the extent of Sisi's servility. Will he invade Yemen? Despite the obvious foolishness of such a move, it seems like a foregone conclusion. The problem for the Saudis, as the Kirkpatrick wryly notes, is that the Houthis are seasoned fighters, certain to hold their ground and bloody any invaders that come their way:
Speaking at the meeting in Sharm el Sheikh, Nabil el-Araby, the secretary general of the Arab League, vowed that the Saudi-led airstrikes against the Houthi movement would continue until the Houthis had surrendered, apparently leaving little hope for negotiating a prompt end to the violence.
The campaign “will continue until all Houthi militias retreat and disarm, and a strong unified Yemen returns,” he said, declaring that the intervention had saved Yemen from sliding into the abyss.
The Houthi movement, which originated in the north of Yemen and follows a strain of Shiite Islam, has seized control of the country’s capital, Sana, and other large cities in part by allying itself with military and security forces still loyal to Yemen’s former strongman, Ali Abdullah Saleh. Mr. Saleh was removed in 2012, after an Arab Spring uprising, in a transitional deal brokered by Saudi Arabia and the other gulf countries. While the Houthis have received financial support from Tehran, the Iranians do not seem to exert a strong influence over the group as they do, for example, with Hezbollah in Lebanon.
The Houthis have previously fought as many as a half-dozen different civil conflicts against Yemen’s central government since 2004. None of the previous battles have succeeded in eliminating or fully disarming the movement.
One positive that can be taken away from Sharm el-Sheikh is that the Saudis have gone above board; they are not dealing with every geopolitical problem by means of a cut-out, whether the Pentagon/CIA or Wahhabi terror groups like Al Qaeda or Islamic State. Granted, Sisi fills the role of a front man, but the Saudis are front and center on Yemen. They are leading the campaign. So a loss in Yemen will bring the war home to the Kingdom. Maybe then there will be a reevaluation of the wisdom of perpetual war.

Thursday, March 19, 2015

Fulsome U.S. Support for the Egyptian Police State Four Years After Arab Spring

It is easy to criticize the daily-newspaper industry as a "mask of enlightenment," a for-profit potpourri of the mundane and rudimentary that is increasingly obsolete in our digital age. Indeed, it is not hard to imagine in the not too distant future that only one or two dailies will be left: one conservative and one "liberal," national in scope and each representing a camp within the permanent, invisible government.

That being said, daily newspapers are still the foundation of any kind of articulate cultural consciousness that we possess as a body politic. What is trending on Twitter cannot -- I hope -- replace the daily newspaper.

Now and again the editorial board of The New York Times will publish a broadside that is the direct opposite of the muck they usually stovepipe on behalf of the United States Government. This morning is case in point. "Abetting Egypt’s Dictatorship" highlights the absolute bankruptcy of the self-proclaimed U.S. leadership on human rights when it comes Egypt. Let me quote it at length:
Senior administration officials see Egypt as an indispensable ally in the campaign against the Islamic State as well as in other foreign policy priorities in the region. But the Egyptian government’s crackdown on Islamist movements, including moderate ones who denounce the use of violence, is likely to lead to broader radicalization in communities that have no way to further their objectives and voice their grievances.
Since Mr. Sisi took power in July 2013, following a wave of protests against the country’s first democratically elected president, Mohamed Morsi, an Islamist, it has become increasingly clear that the Egyptian government has no intention of building democratic institutions or tolerating opposing views.
Civil society and pro-democracy organizations have been threatened or forced to shut down. The news media is tightly controlled, and protests are banned. Nearly all leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist movement that became the dominant political force in the country after the Arab Spring protests, are locked up.
While American officials have voiced concern about these trends in boilerplate language, they continue to provide Egypt with $1.3 billion in military aid each year and have only taken modest steps to condition the aid improvements in democratic governance. Much of the time, they merely express hope that progress is being made, while ignoring a level of brutality and repression that is worse than in the era of Hosni Mubarak.

The government, clearly eager for foreign investment, wants to appear as a legitimately elected government playing a constructive role in the region. But it is becoming increasingly clear that Egypt has become a dictatorship that justifies its abuses under the pretext of containing the threat posed by radical Islamists. A parliamentary election that was to be held this month has been indefinitely postponed. Journalists are languishing in jail. Courts have imposed mass death sentences following proceedings that lasted just minutes. While some American lawmakers have raised alarm and sought to cut off, or condition, the military aid package in recent years, they have been outmaneuvered by those who think that standing by the Sisi regime is a necessary evil in a volatile part of the world.

Last year, Congress gave the White House authority to keep Egypt’s military aid flowing without having to certify that the government respects human rights and is taking steps to govern democratically, conditions that had been in the previous spending bill. And, for the first time, lawmakers gave the State Department the right to keep as a classified secret its rationale for disbursing the aid.

Administration officials said that Mr. Kerry favors continuing the military aid and is awaiting a final decision from the White House. If the aid is extended, the United States would be abetting Egypt’s ruthless business as usual.
The restoration of Egypt's police state under Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi, crushing the Arab Spring democracy movment, I think, in one form or another, is the trend that elites in all nations want to emulate. It is going to be hard to accomplish. But clearly it is the direction we are headed.

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Paying Fealty to al-Saud, the Murder of Shaimaa al-Sabbagh and Obama's Al-Azhar Speech Five Years Later

Briefly yesterday a story appeared on the Gray Lady's home page about Obama's visit to kiss the ring of the new king of Saudi Arabia. Written by Michael Gordon and Peter Baker, "Top Officials Join Obama in Brief Visit to Saudi King" describes a large entourage of current and former USG officials arriving in the Kingdom as an act of fealty to the new ruler of the House of Saud:
RIYADH, Saudi Arabia — President Obama met with King Salman of Saudi Arabia on Tuesday, leading a bipartisan delegation of prominent current and former officials to shore up an important relationship and offer condolences for the death of King Abdullah. 
American officials said the meetings were the first official discussions the new monarch has held with a visiting foreign dignitary. 
Air Force One landed on a clear, mild afternoon with a brisk wind snapping the American and Saudi flags to attention. At the Erga Palace, the king and the president sat in gold chairs as their meeting got under way. 
Mr. Obama was in Riyadh for only a few hours, detouring from the return leg of a three-day visit to India. Still, the fact that he made the stop was significant, because he rarely travels overseas to mark the death of a foreign leader; more often, he dispatches the vice president, secretary of state or other dignitaries to represent the United States.
American relations with Saudi Arabia were strained by Mr. Obama’s decision not to mount military strikes in Syria against the government of President Bashar al-Assad over the use of chemical weapons. Saudi Arabia has been a bitter foe of Mr. Assad, who has repressed the Sunni Muslim majority in Syria and who has the backing of Iran, the Saudis’ regional rival.
The Saudis are also uneasy about the Obama administration’s pursuit of a nuclear deal with Iran, fearing that it will do too little to restrain the Iranians from developing nuclear weapons. And they were unhappy with American policy toward the Arab Spring uprisings, especially in Egypt, where they accused the United States of turning its back on a friend, President Hosni Mubarak.
Still, the Obama administration has worked assiduously to try to repair relations with the Saudis. After a pivotal June meeting in Jidda between Secretary of State John Kerry and King Abdullah, Saudi Arabia agreed to join the United States in carrying out airstrikes against Islamic State fighters in Syria and Iraq.
Joining the president for the visit on Tuesday were his Republican opponent from 2008, Senator John McCain of Arizona, and several veterans of Republican administrations, including two former secretaries of state, James A. Baker III and Condoleezza Rice.
Ms. Rice was also one of four former national security advisers in the delegation, which also included Brent Scowcroft, Stephen J. Hadley and Samuel Berger.
Senior figures from the Obama administration who joined the delegation included Mr. Kerry; Susan E. Rice, the current national security adviser and former ambassador to the United Nations; John O. Brennan, the director of the C.I.A.; and Gen. Lloyd J. Austin III, who oversees Middle East operations. Democratic members of Congress also took part, including Senator Mark Warner of Virginia and Representatives Nancy Pelosi and Ami Bera of California and Eliot L. Engel and Joseph Crowley of New York.
What is strange about this story, besides the obvious -- leaders of the United States, the world's beacon of freedom and democracy, kowtowing to an absolute monarchy -- is that it didn't remain for long in its prominent spot on the NYT home page, and this morning it can't even be found online in the "World" section, one has to type "Saudi Arabia" in the search box and sort by "Newest."

Obviously the story is embarrassing and needs to be hidden. The fawning tweets of Kerry and Susan Rice portray a government in thrall to al-Saud, a totalitarian dictatorship that exports the jihad the lickspittle U.S. leadership is ostensibly waging a war against. It is all hogwash.

Note the conclusion to the piece:
Mr. Obama said before flying to Riyadh from India that the United States has an interest in a strong partnership with Saudi Arabia, despite its record of repression, human rights abuses and links to terrorism.
“It is important for us to take into account existing relationships, the existing alignments within a very complicated Middle East, to recognize that we have strategic interests in common with Saudi Arabia, and that even as we work on those common interests — for example, countering terrorist organizations — that we are also encouraging them to move in new directions, not just for our sake but more importantly for their sake,” he said in an interview in New Delhi with Fareed Zakaria of CNN.
Mr. Obama was asked whether he would raise the case of the Saudi blogger who was sentenced to receive 1,000 lashes. He said he would not on this occasion, but that he does regularly raise human rights issues with the Saudi government, just as he does with other countries with undemocratic governments.
“What I’ve found effective is to apply steady, consistent pressure, even as we are getting business done that needs to get done,” Mr. Obama said. “And oftentimes, that makes some of our allies uncomfortable. It makes them frustrated. Sometimes we have to balance our need to speak to them about human rights issues with immediate concerns that we have in terms of countering terrorism or dealing with regional stability.”
One wonders what kind of "steady, consistent pressure" is being applied to Egypt where police gunned down protesters last weekend commemorating the fourth anniversary of the Arab Spring.


Robert Mackey reports today in "Egypt Condemns Western Outrage at Fatal Shooting of Protester" on the growing tumult over the murder of socialist activist Shaimaa al-Sabbagh:
Egypt’s Foreign Ministry expressed dismay on Tuesday that the killing of a female activist in Cairo, which occurred as riot police used force to disperse a peaceful protest, had drawn widespread condemnation from the West.
The death of the activist, Shaimaa al-Sabbagh, on Saturday sparked outrage online in large part because it was so well-documented. Wrenching images of Ms. Sabbagh bleeding in the arms of a colleague who picked her up afterher heart and lungs were pierced by shotgun pellets reverberated on social networks.
While Interior Ministry officials initially denied that the police officers who were filmed firing in her direction had played any part in her death, the state prosecutor opened an investigation a day later, in the face of widespread skepticism and the testimony of numerous witnesses.
The graphic images of Ms. Sabbagh’s last moments evoked comparisons to the fatal 2009 shooting of the Iranian protester Neda Agha-Soltan, who bled to death as two witnesses recorded the scene on their phones. 
That Ms. Sabbagh, 32, was engaged in a peaceful protest, with a handful of marchers carrying flowers to Tahrir Square in memory of those killed there in the Egyptian revolution four years ago, helped make her death a focus of anger at the police in a way that the death of at least 18 civilians in clashes the next day did not.
Where are the State Department tweets reminding the Egyptian government of Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi about the Universal Declaration of Human Rights?

Egypt is propped up by the Saudis. So don't expect any outrage from USG.

I went back to read Obama's ballyhooed Cairo address, the one he delivered in June of 2009, the full flush of his "Hope and Change" popularity, at Al-Azhar University announcing a new day in relations between the West and the Muslim world. It is a conservative speech, and knowing what we know today about Obama, that he has been a great failure as a progressive leader, it reads even more as an apologia for business-as-usual U.S. unipolarity.

Something of course that rings absolutely false today is the part of his speech devoted to democracy:
I know there has been controversy about the promotion of democracy in recent years, and much of this controversy is connected to the war in Iraq. So let me be clear: no system of government can or should be imposed upon one nation by any other. 
That does not lessen my commitment, however, to governments that reflect the will of the people. Each nation gives life to this principle in its own way, grounded in the traditions of its own people. America does not presume to know what is best for everyone, just as we would not presume to pick the outcome of a peaceful election. But I do have an unyielding belief that all people yearn for certain things: the ability to speak your mind and have a say in how you are governed; confidence in the rule of law and the equal administration of justice; government that is transparent and doesn't steal from the people; the freedom to live as you choose. Those are not just American ideas, they are human rights, and that is why we will support them everywhere. 
There is no straight line to realize this promise. But this much is clear: governments that protect these rights are ultimately more stable, successful and secure. Suppressing ideas never succeeds in making them go away. America respects the right of all peaceful and law-abiding voices to be heard around the world, even if we disagree with them. And we will welcome all elected, peaceful governments – provided they govern with respect for all their people. 
As a full partner in the Saudi rollback of the Arab Spring, Obama couldn't make this speech in Cairo today. The blowback will be felt in the U.S. homeland in the form of reduced turnout for Democratic nominee during the next presidential election. There are consequences for such a dramatic about-face. People lose faith. Trust erodes.  Better to stay at home than be gulled into another false message of "Hope and Change."

Tuesday, December 2, 2014

From Cairo to Ferguson a Shift in Consciousness is Creating Fear in the Power Elite

We need a change in consciousness, and there is plenty of evidence that such a change is underway. When I got out of the train station last night I stepped into one of the many Ferguson protests that occurred nationwide yesterday. I didn't see or hear any protesters, but there were lots of police, and they were guarding the entrances to the big downtown shopping malls. My feeling is that these protests are not going softly into the night; they are a continuation of the Occupy Wall Street movement for economic justice but with the added powerful message of racial equality, not to mention a critique of excessive state force.

Why it is a safe bet to say that these protests are not going away one merely has to think back three years. Occupy was zapped because there were still enough people who believed that Obama represented a progressive trend in politics that had to be defended; hence, when the main Zuccotti Park encampment was rolled up by Gotham's finest in November of 2011, energy shifted to the 2012 presidential campaign and defending Obama from GOP attacks. Obama marshaled some of the Occupy rhetoric and ended up trouncing a weak Republican standard-bearer, Mitt Romney.

Now, besides some Democratic Party apparatchiks, there is no wellspring of support for Obama's presidency. He has alienated the peace wing of the party; I don't believe his "too little, too late" immigration overhaul is anything more than a chess move to checkmate Republicans, and I think that Latinos sense this; finally, his dissembling, feckless treatment of the Ferguson protests have finally splintered his bedrock constituency, blacks.

This was clearly on display yesterday at Obama's White House summit on Ferguson. Mark Landler has an excellent summary of the event in "Obama Offers New Standards on Police Gear":
Among those in the White House meetings on Monday were Mayor Bill de Blasio of New York and Mayor Michael A. Nutter of Philadelphia; the president of the National Urban League, Marc Morial; the Rev. Al Sharpton; and two civil rights leaders from Ferguson, Rasheen Aldridge and Brittany Packnett.
Besides the photo op, there were three items of substance that Obama announced yesterday: 1) a change in federal programs dispensing military hardware to local police departments; 2) federal funding for police body cameras; and 3) a creation of a task force to provide answers on how to improve policing.

But as it turns out the first item of substance is really not substantial at all. All Obama proposed was a change in reporting and an undefined training requirement:
WASHINGTON — President Obama, grappling with how to respond to the racial unrest in Ferguson, Mo., and a wave of anger at law enforcement officials across the country, said Monday that he would tighten standards on the provision of military-style equipment to local police departments and provide funds for police officers to wear cameras. 
But Mr. Obama stopped short of curtailing the transfer of military-grade gear to local law enforcement authorities and continued to put off a visit to Ferguson. Instead, the White House tried to channel the rage over the fatal police shooting of a black teenager there into a national debate about how to restore trust between the police and the public.

Administration officials said they concluded after a review that the vast majority of transfers of military-style equipment strengthened local policing, even after the police in Ferguson were criticized for heavy-handed use of such gear to quell protests last summer. But the officials said local authorities needed common standards in the types of hardware they requested and better training in how to use it.
All told, the changes were modest, and Mr. Obama himself was circumspect in remarks about Ferguson after an orchestrated day of meetings at the White House with civil rights and religious leaders, big-city mayors, and law enforcement officials. The president seemed eager to keep the focus not on what happened in Ferguson but on its broader lessons for the country.
***
Curtailing those transfers, experts said, would be a reversal of years of policy and would have scant support in Congress. The militarization of police has been part of a broader counterterrorism strategy of fortifying American cities, which took root after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, and has become a reliable source of federal largess for local authorities.
With no legislation likely, Mr. Obama has instead focused on standardizing regulations across the multiple federal agencies — primarily the Department of Homeland Security — that supply this equipment to cities and towns. He would also seek to improve training and require “after-action” reports for incidents involving federal equipment. 
The report, the White House said, found “a lack of consistency in how federal programs are structured, implemented and audited.” Criticism of the practices swelled after the police in full body armor, on heavily armed vehicles, confronted protesters in Ferguson with assault rifles.
*** 
To bolster local policing, the government also announced a $263 million program that will provide up to 50,000 body cameras for police. The video footage from these cameras could clarify disputed incidents like the deadly encounter between the teenager in Ferguson, Michael Brown, and the police officer, Darren Wilson.
***
The president also announced on Monday the formation of a task force to improve local policing. Leading the panel will be Charles H. Ramsey, the commissioner of the Philadelphia Police Department, and Laurie Robinson of George Mason University, a leading criminal law scholar.
Don't get your hopes up that the task force is anything other than a cosmetic effort by Obama because as Landler reports at the end of his story,
The White House also faced skepticism in its choice of Commissioner Ramsey as a co-chairman of the task force. During his tenure as police chief in the District of Columbia from 1998 to 2007, he was criticized for the mass arrest of people protesting International Monetary Fund and World Bank meetings. 
“We were just dumbfounded when we heard they had chosen Chief Ramsey,” said Mara Verheyden-Hilliard, executive director of the Partnership for Civil Justice Fund, which brought suits against Mr. Ramsey in Washington. “You’d be hard pressed to find a more inappropriate choice.”
Obama is spent. He can't keep the indians on the rez anymore. We are at the beginning of a great conflict. The established political parties are absent legitimacy. There will be a tendency to reassert the legitimacy of the state by means of a display of force -- like the pools of police officers I saw guarding department stores last night. This will have the opposite effect, diminishing the government's legitimacy even more.

In the United States we are heading in the direction of what I have been calling the "Sisi option" -- a sunlighting of the Deep State, a public embrace by the power elite of a massive police state. Thailand is already there.

Apropos of this it is worthwhile to read the Gray Lady's unsigned editorial on Mubarak's release from prison, "In Egypt, a Verdict Turns Back the Clock":
The Egyptian court that threw out the murder charges against former President Hosni Mubarak may have closed the final chapter on the Arab Spring. After the country’s brief, flawed attempt at democracy, the army and its supporters put in place an even more authoritarian system than the Mubarak regime. 
Now, in a final insult to the hundreds of protesters who were killed in the 2011 uprising, Mr. Mubarak apparently will go free, and there will be no justice for those who died or accountability for the decades of human rights abuses by his government.
***

The public prosecutor could appeal the murder case to the Court of Cassation, Egypt’s highest criminal court. But, on Sunday, President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, the former army general who overthrew the country’s first democratically elected president, Mohamed Morsi, in 2013, seemed to rule that out. Meanwhile, Mr. Morsi and thousands of his Muslim Brotherhood supporters still languish in prison. 
Mr. Sisi said Egypt must “look to the future” and “cannot ever go back.” It appears that the Obama administration feels the same way. In a bizarre response, a State Department spokeswoman offered diplomatic pablum when asked to comment on the verdict and referred queries to the Egyptian government.
*** 
Since Saturday, protests against the ruling have drawn hundreds of participants and involved numerous clashes with security forces. Two demonstrators were killed. While the demonstrations have been smaller than those in 2011, the venues — university campuses across the country — suggest that it may be harder for Mr. Sisi to erase the past than he thinks. Among other challenges, Egypt is struggling with a depressed economy, an insurgency in Sinai, and an Islamic State affiliate that late Sunday took responsibility for killing an American oil worker in Egypt’s Western Desert in August. 
Half of Egypt’s population is under the age of 25, and many of those young people were at the heart of the Arab Spring movement and its demands for jobs, education, housing and greater freedoms. 
Those aspirations won’t go away. And while Egyptians may want stability, repression and a lack of accountability will produce only more discontent. The Mubarak verdict is another shift away from long delayed hopes for a productive and just society.
The same goes for the United States.

**** 

Update on Missouri Governor Jay Nixon's call for a special session of the legislature to find ways to pay for the lengthy deployment of the national guard and state highway patrol. Turns out he doesn't need a special session -- which would have allowed for a spirited public debate on the wisdom and effectiveness of martial law; he can fund by fiat. According to Monica Davey, John Eligon, Jess Bidgood in "A Week Later, Protesters Remain Vocal on Ferguson, Partly With Silence":
Gov. Jay Nixon of Missouri said on Monday that there was no longer a need for a special legislative session, which he had called to authorize more money for Ferguson-related expenses by the National Guard and the State Highway Patrol. He and senior legislative leaders agreed that he could use his budget authority to cover the payments.

Wednesday, August 13, 2014

HRW vs. Sisi

With so many significant events happening in the Middle East, it is easy to skip over a story like the one that appeared yesterday, "‘Systematic’ Killings in Egypt Are Tied to Leader, Group Says," by Kareem Fahim. I did in the morning. But failing to board a train right as it was about to depart the station in the evening led to additional idle time to read. Subsequently, I thoroughly scrubbed the front section of the paper.

Fahim's story about the Human Rights Watch report is an important reminder of what a pivotal event the Sisi coup was last summer:
CAIRO — A day after Egypt barred representatives of Human Rights Watch from entering the country, the group disclosed the source of the government’s alarm: a report implicating senior officials, including Egypt’s current president, Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, in what it called the “widespread and systematic” killings of protesters. 
Human Rights Watch, which is based in New York, said Monday that it had conducted a yearlong investigation into violence that followed the military’s ouster of former President Mohamed Morsi, and found that the killings of demonstrators by the police and army forces “likely amounted to crimes against humanity.” Official statements during the killings made clear that the attacks “were ordered by the government,” the group said.
The report, which was released Tuesday, was the latest of several independent attempts by human rights workers and journalists to document a series of mass killings last summer that Egyptian authorities have failed to meaningfully investigate, and that government officials seem determined to help the country forget. 
The worst of the violence occurred on Aug. 14, 2013, when the security forces used force to disperse a large sit-in of Mr. Morsi’s supporters near the Rabaa al-Adawiya mosque in Cairo, killing more than 800 people, and possibly more than 1,000, according to Human Rights Watch. It called the episode “one of the world’s largest killings of demonstrators in a single day in recent history.” 
No security or government officials have been prosecuted in the killings, which set off a period of civil conflict and government repression that included the arrests of tens of thousands of people, including Islamists, journalists and leftist political activists. 
The report calls for an investigation of Mr. Sisi, who was commander of the armed forces at the time, and several other sitting government officials, including Egypt’s interior minister. The Obama administration has signaled its intention to return full American support for Egypt under Mr. Sisi, despite scant evidence that Egypt is becoming more democratic or inclusive. 
Human rights workers and civil society advocates have described an atmosphere that is more stifling and perilous than life under President Hosni Mubarak, who was deposed in a popular uprising in 2011.
On Monday, the executive director of Human Rights Watch, Kenneth Roth, and the director of the Middle East division, Sarah Leah Whitson, were deported from Egypt after being stopped at the airport on Sunday. 
It was the first time Egypt had denied entry to employees of Human Rights Watch, Ms. Whitson said. Airport officials wrapped a form around Ms. Whitson’s passport and checked a box that said, “For security reasons.”
David Kirkpatrick follows up this morning with "After Human Rights Watch Report, Egypt Says Group Broke Law":
Human Rights Watch “does not enjoy any legal status that may allow it to operate in Egypt,” the government said in a statement responding to the report. “Conducting investigations, collecting evidence and interviewing witnesses without any legal backing are activities that constitute a flagrant violation of state sovereignty under international law,” the statement added. It called the report a “flagrant intervention in the work of the national investigative and judicial authorities, and an attempt to impinge upon the independence and integrity of the Egyptian judiciary.”
The government also said that Human Rights Watch had issued the report “in parallel with dubious moves by the terrorist organization and its supporters” — a reference to the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist group that sponsored Mohamed Morsi, the ousted Egyptian president — “with a view to carrying out further acts of violence and terrorism against the Egyptian state and innocent civilians.”
 ***
“The government seems to be suggesting that H.R.W.’s investigation and visit to Egypt is part of a Muslim Brotherhood terrorist plot, which is farcical on its face,” Sarah Leah Whitson, the group’s executive director for the region, said in an email. She called the charges “absurd, unsubstantiated allegations, and a naked effort to intimidate us.”
Human Rights Watch is generally a close ally of the U.S. government. Maybe this report, along with one published in July about the Ukrainian junta slaughtering civilians in Donetsk with Grad rockets, is proof of pockets of discontent within the Obama administration: in the case of Egypt, the discontent would be with the way in which the U.S. has meekly swallowed its soaring rhetoric of democracy and human rights and lined up with the Saudis behind Sisi's military dictatorship; in the Ukraine, the complaint would be with the neocon's rapacious embrace of the fascist coup government and its criminal assault on the civilian population of Donbass.

Government is not a monolith. There are always opposing camps struggling for advantage over one another. Sisi's conflict with HRW reminds us of this; but, more importantly, it reminds us that the "Sisi trend" -- totalitarianism -- to roll back the Arab Spring is still being contested, albeit obliquely, within the established power structure.

Wednesday, August 6, 2014

No Hope for Negotiations in Cairo; No Hope for U.S. Mission in Afghanistan

The ceasefire in Arsal between the ISIS-led jihadis and Lebanese Army quickly broke down yesterday. Arsal is a Sunni town in the Bekaa Valley that is home to several refugee camps filled with people who have fled the war next door in Syria. Two of the refugee camps were reported to have been set ablaze by "indiscriminate artillery fire."

The ceasefire negotiations between Israel and Hamas are getting underway in Cairo. David Kirkpatrick has an interview, "A Part of Hamas Negotiates, and Another May Fight Again,"
with Hamas bigwig Mousa Abu Marzook that is worth reading if only to get a sense of the futility of these bargaining sessions. Israel and Egypt are operating in lockstep. Their position is adamant: No easing of the blockade unless Gaza is demilitarized. Abu Marzook is equally adamant: Hamas' military wing, the Qassam Brigades, will remain. Abu Marzook is going to try to sell the idea of political and military separation. On the one hand, the Palestinian Authority will return to Gaza to administer the territory as the political power; while on the other, the Qassam Brigades will act as a national guard:
[A]fter more than 1,600 Palestinian deaths in Gaza from the Israeli attacks over the last month, Mr. Abu Marzook said Tuesday that Hamas had won a victory just by surviving and argued that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel had failed to achieve any of his goals. Mr. Abu Marzook said Hamas had gained popularity, remained able to fire rockets at Israel, and could re-establish its network of tunnels under Gaza. 
For agreeing to the cease-fire, he argued that Hamas should receive relief from the blockade on its territory. “The Palestinians should gain something out of these battles,” he said. “They want the siege to end; they want all the gates to open.”
That is a nonstarter with Israel and Egypt while Hamas controls Gaza, but Mr. Abu Marzook said Hamas was prepared for the unified government to take over, including assuming responsibility in Gaza for security and the borders.
He acknowledged that some tensions remained. Hamas and the Palestinian Authority, controlled by Fatah, have parallel payrolls of employees to run Gaza. 
“Two people on one chair is very difficult,” Mr. Abu Marzook said. “Now it is our duty to resolve this problem and make a real unity Palestinian government.” 
But he brushed off past concerns within Hamas about the possibility that the loyal presidential guard of its chief rival, Fatah’s leader, Mahmoud Abbas, might take positions in Gaza.
I don't see Israel and Egypt coming anywhere near this. The Palestinian Authority (PA) is widely unpopular, while support for Hamas has grown significantly since Israel's invasion. Abbas is a joke. PA rule in Gaza would be cosmetic. The real power would be Hamas, something Israel and Egypt will not accept. In the past, the United States might have had enough leverage to get the deal Abu Marzak suggests done, but no longer. The U.S., it appears to me, is not calling the shots but rather tagging along. The Saudis are driving events in the Middle East. This means Hamas gets nothing. So we're looking at a situation where Hamas will have to accept a return to the status quo ante, the blockade, or it will have to start sending rockets into Israel again. Not a very palatable choice.

Matthew Rosenberg and Helene Cooper have a useful postmortem, "U.S. General Is Killed in Attack at Afghan Base; Others Injured," of the green-on-blue attack at the Marshal Fahim National Defense University in Kabul that killed U.S. Army Major General Harold Greene who "had been dispatched to Afghanistan to help the Afghan military address one of its most potentially debilitating weaknesses: an inability to manage soldiers and weaponry."

The story by Rosenberg and Cooper provides a reminder to anyone who is paying attention of why U.S. involvement in Afghanistan will end in failure. Any vestigial U.S. force that remains in the country, assuming that the deal Kerry struck for a recount and power-sharing government between the Ashraf Ghani and Abdullah Abdullah camps holds (and that is highly unlikely), will be there as a training force. But how can you train people if you hunkered down in your bases for fear of your life?
Yet the shooting was a blunt reminder that discipline and vetting remain a challenge, and rogue Afghan soldiers and policemen remain a threat, despite a sharp drop in insider attacks since 2012, when the violence peaked and dozens of coalition service members were killed by Afghan counterparts. 
With foreign troops having largely ceded their front-line role to Afghan forces in the past two years, training and advising Afghans is one of the few crucial roles still played here by the coalition. American soldiers largely stay out of the Taliban’s line of fire, but they must still maintain close contact with Afghan soldiers and policemen. Foreign forces have few options for protecting themselves, short of cutting off contact with the Afghans. 
But that would make the training mission impossible, as General Greene, 55, most likely knew.
*** 
The attack occurred around noon and sent shock waves through the coalition command and Afghanistan’s defense establishment, bringing nearly all other work to a halt. In the immediate aftermath, Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr., the commander of coalition forces, ordered all foreign advisers and trainers out of Afghan government ministries and back to their bases.

Monday, June 23, 2014

Kerry's Theater of the Absurd

Foreign affairs as practiced by U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry is a theater of the absurd, a traveling roadshow of lies, that makes one pine for the almost Achesonian (in comparison) Hillary Clinton. Once Kerry climbs aboard his jet aircraft with his faithful scribe Michael Gordon in tow you can expect the mendacity to run like the wind and absolutely nothing to be accomplished.

Presently, the Secretary of State is in Baghdad trying to secure a replacement for Iraq's Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki; this despite the fact that he solemnly pronounced at his last stop, in Cairo, that the United States was "not in the business of picking Iraq’s leaders." Don't count on al-Maliki stepping down.

In Cairo, Kerry embraced the military coup government of President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, announcing that all -- the massacre of innocents, the show trials culminating in blanket death sentences for hundreds, the abolition of political organizations -- is forgotten and the money will flow. According to David Kirkpatrick and Michael Gordon, writing in "Kerry Says U.S. Is Ready to Renew Ties With Egypt":
Mr. Kerry expressed firm confidence that the United States would soon fully restore $650 million — the first tranche of the $1.3 billion in annual aid — to the military that the Obama administration had partly withheld after the takeover.
“I am absolutely confident we will get on track there,” he said. Addressing a previously suspended shipment of 10 Apache helicopter gunships that the Egyptian military has been especially eager for, Mr. Kerry said he was just as confident “that the Apaches will come, and that they will come very, very soon.”
And in Egypt’s economic challenges, Mr. Kerry said, President Obama and the United States are “committed to be helpful.”
Three years after Mr. Obama called publicly for President Hosni Mubarak to bow to the Arab Spring uprising demanding his ouster, Mr. Kerry’s remarks appeared to suggest that the administration is now ready to work with another military-backed strongman.
Mr. Sisi won 97 percent of the official votes in a barely contested election last month, and both European and United States-funded observer delegations said it fell short of international standards of democracy. But Mr. Kerry’s comments suggested that the Obama administration was nonetheless ready to try to work with Egypt’s new military-backed government while urging it to improve its records on human rights.
Mr. Kerry tacitly acknowledged the administration’s criticisms of the new government’s authoritarian record, including its heavy-handed crackdown on both the Islamist opposition and liberal or leftist dissenters. “I emphasized also our strong support for upholding the universal rights and freedoms of all Egyptians, including freedom of expression, peaceful assembly and association,” he said. 
Mr. Kerry said they had talked about the verdict expected Monday in the case of three journalists who have been jailed since December on politicized charges without any publicly disclosed evidence of a crime. And he said they had also talked about the hurried mass trials that had handed death sentences to more than a dozen senior leaders of the Islamist opposition and hundreds of their supporters, arousing horrified alarms from Western governments and rights groups. 
He also alluded to the government’s criminalization of membership in the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist group whose party dominated the recent free elections but has since been excluded from politics. “There is no question that Egyptian society is stronger when all of its citizens have a say and a stake in its success,” Mr. Kerry said.
The Leveretts, along with Seyed Mohammad Marandi, in their most recent article, "Trying to Force Iran to “Surrender” Will Backfire—Why U.S. Engagement with Tehran Needs to Respect Iranian Independence," remind us that the policy of Egyptian subjugation to U.S. hegemony enshrined in the Camp David Accords is tied to the rise of Saudi-backed jihad and Israeli regional military unilateralism:
The United States has tried subordinating the strategic orientation of a major Middle Eastern state before. Three and a half decades ago, the U.S.-brokered Camp David accords reduced Egypt to a strategic and economic dependency of the United States. While American foreign policy elites regularly extol the regional “stability” wrought by Camp David, that stability was in fact dangerously illusory.
In the wake of Camp David, Saudi Arabia made promotion of violent jihadism an increasingly prominent tool in Saudi foreign policy—a trend that incubated al Qaeda and is still spawning an ever-proliferating array of ideologically similar threats to international security. Three decades of rule by a U.S.-puppet regime, with accompanying political repression and economic stagnation, made Egypt itself a prime source for jihadi ideologues (such as al Qaeda leader Ayman Zawahiri) and fighters. And allowing the Israeli military to consolidate nearly absolute freedom of unilateral initiative—one of Camp David’s first fruits—has been deeply corrosive of America’s regional standing.
On the jet to Cairo, Gordon scribbled down the prevarications of a "senior official" regarding the funding of Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham:
[ISIS] is largely self-sustaining because of its success with extortions and in the plundering of the banks in Mosul, Iraq's second-largest city, which it controls. But some funding "has flowed into Iraq from its neighbors," a senior official on Mr. Kerry's plane said.
"That does not mean that it is the result of an official government policy in many, if not most, cases," the official added.
The idea that ISIS funds itself by looting banks in a city it has held for two weeks is absurd. ISIS has been in control of large parts of northern Syria for a year. Efforts are being made to distance the member states of the GCC from ownership of ISIS, a sign that last week the truth was emerging as to the role of Saudi, Qatari and Kuwaiti sponsorship.

Tuesday, June 10, 2014

Don't Think It Can't Happen Here: How the Police State is Shaping Up

There was a terrific, terrifying story published yesterday in the Gray Lady by Matt Apuzzo, "War Gear Flows to Police Departments," detailing the massive militarization of local police forces in the U.S. It is a must-read:
[A]s President Obama ushers in the end of what he called America’s “long season of war,” the former tools of combat — M-16 rifles, grenade launchers, silencers and more — are ending up in local police departments, often with little public notice. 
During the Obama administration, according to Pentagon data, police departments have received tens of thousands of machine guns; nearly 200,000 ammunition magazines; thousands of pieces of camouflage and night-vision equipment; and hundreds of silencers, armored cars and aircraft. 
The equipment has been added to the armories of police departments that already look and act like military units. Police SWAT teams are now deployed tens of thousands of times each year, increasingly for routine jobs. Masked, heavily armed police officers in Louisiana raided a nightclub in 2006 as part of a liquor inspection. In Florida in 2010, officers in SWAT gear and with guns drawn carried out raids on barbershops that mostly led only to charges of “barbering without a license.”
With crime declining throughout the country, what excuse is there for a municipality to load up on MRAPs?


Military Equipment for Local Police

As the nation’s wars abroad wind down, many of the military’s surplus tools of combat have ended up in the hands of state and local law enforcement. Totals below are the minimum number of pieces acquired since 2006 in a selection of categories.


MRAPS BY STATE
WA
ME
432
= 1 vehicle
ND
MT
VT
MN
MRAPs
OR.
MA
ID
NY
WI
WY
Mine-Resistant Ambush Protected armored vehicles
MI
CT
NE
IA
NJ
PA
NV
OH
UT
MD
CA
IL
IN
CO
WV
VA
KS
KY
MO
NC
TN
AR
AZ
OK
NM
SC
GA
AL
LA
TX
FL
HI
435
44,900
533
93,763
180,718
Other armored
vehicles
Night vision
pieces
Aircraft
Machine guns
Magazines




The answer supplied by one police officer is that the war overseas can come home:
“You have a lot of people who are coming out of the military that have the ability and knowledge to build I.E.D.’s and to defeat law enforcement techniques,” Sgt. Dan Downing of the Morgan County Sheriff’s Department told the local Fox affiliate, referring to improvised explosive devices, or homemade bombs. Sergeant Downing did not return a message seeking comment.
And that is how it works. The nation spends a profligate amount in blood and treasure to send its sons and daughters abroad -- Afghanistan, Iraq, Africa -- to protect the homeland, and lo and behold! We have to arm up, turning our constabulary into Navy SEALs wannabes, to protect our communities from those very same sons and daughters when they come home.

The idea of rogue enlisted men wreaking havoc on Main Street is bullshit, of course. The real reason, though unacknowledged, for all those 100-round M-16 ammunition clips is to have the firepower at hand when the citizenry goes native. Unrest is coming, and it won't be just to a theater near you.

Militarization of the local police is one ominous sign of an impending crackdown. New articulations of a sophisticated police state are another. First, note how the Thai military is managing dissent after its recent coup. The story, "In Thailand, Growing Intolerance for Dissent Drives Many to More Authoritarian Nations," is by Thomas Fuller and it appeared this past Saturday:
The curfew imposed after the coup has been lifted in tourist areas and is loosely enforced from midnight to 4 a.m. in other parts of the country. Of the scores detained in the early days of the coup, most have been freed, including former Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra. 
But freedom of expression has been sharply curtailed. Thailand’s cacophonous news media has been partly silenced by the military junta, which closely monitors television news and has released detained journalists only under the condition that they not speak out. 
The junta has also banned gatherings of five people or more — a rule that does not apply to its own attempts to manage the public mood, which have included staging performances in Bangkok titled “Return Happiness to the People.” The shows, which feature women dancing and singing in camouflage miniskirts, were organized by specialists in psychological warfare, according to the Thai news media. 
Nearly every evening, the military announces on television the names of people summoned for questioning or detention. Democracy advocates, academics and anyone who speaks publicly about politics watch with anxiety to see if their names have been added to the list of more than 350 people already summoned. Those released from detention are forced to sign an agreement that bars them from taking part in “political movements.” 
“If I violate these conditions or support political activities, I consent to face legal action immediately and consent to the suspension of my financial transactions,” says the military’s document, which the coup makers posted on their Facebook page. The army has threatened to try dissenters in military courts.
Then there is Egypt, another prime example of how to implement a coup (brutal, bloodthirsty ruthlessness adorned with a display of popular support and a patina of constitutional legitimacy). Before handing over the scepter of government to president-elect Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, interim president Adly Mansour, former head of the Supreme Constitutional Court (to which he is returning), issued seven decrees, foremost of which was a new election law. According to David Kirkpatrick, "Egyptian Election Law Helps to Block Opposition":
The election law was the most significant new measure because it appeared designed to produce a compliant legislature instead of to promote political pluralism or a balance of power. 
The measure allows election authorities to bar the candidacy of any supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist group that dominated Egypt’s free elections after the 2011 uprising but has been outlawed. Election authorities can disqualify any candidate who is deemed to support a religiously-based or religiously discriminatory organization — both criteria could apply to the Brotherhood. The law also allows the authorities to exclude candidates who support an organization that has been involved in violence; the government has already decreed the Brotherhood a terrorist group. 
The GOP is already hard at work at the state level trying to prevent people from voting. The next step is legislation, like that decreed by interim president Mansour on his way out the door, to block certain candidates from running. Already onerous filing requirements are the norm in most parts of the U.S. It is not a stretch to imagine something like what Egypt has popping up here.

What I'm saying is that it would not be prudent to believe it can't happen here.