Showing posts with label Mohamed Morsi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mohamed Morsi. Show all posts

Monday, March 30, 2015

Joint Arab Military Force: Saudis Decide to Emerge from Shadows

The bill for Saudi support of Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi's coup has come due. The Egyptian president and former general who ousted Mohamed Morsi in July 2013, beginning a bloody crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood and a rollback of the Arab Spring, announced at an Arab League meeting in Sharm el Sheikh over the weekend the formation of a joint Arab military force. David Kirkpatrick has the story, "Arab Nations to Form Military Force to Counter Iran and Islamist Extremists":
“The challenges facing our national Arab security are grave, and we have succeeded in diagnosing the reasons behind it,” Mr. Sisi said, without specifying those reasons. The meeting, he added, was “pumping the blood of hope in the arteries of Arab cooperation.”
Egypt has long considered itself the shield and protector of the oil-rich but sparsely populated gulf monarchies like Saudi Arabia. Yet Mr. Sisi has an especially close relationship with the Saudis and their gulf allies because they supported his ouster of President Mohamed Morsi of the Muslim Brotherhood in 2013. The gulf monarchies have contributed tens of billions in financial assistance to Egypt since then, including new pledges of an additional $12 billion announced this month.
Last year, Mr. Sisi also allowed jets from the United Arab Emirates to take off from Egypt for airstrikes against an Islamist-allied political faction in Libya. This year, the Egyptian Air Force carried out a strike of its own in Darnah, in eastern Libya, in retaliation for the beheading of a group of Egyptian Christians by an arm of the Islamic State, also known as ISIS or ISIL. Both Egypt and its gulf allies remain acutely concerned about Libya’s civil strife and the Islamist groups that have flourished as the government and other national institutions have crumbled.
The idea of a joint military force “has been there before but not so seriously,” said Gamal Abdel Gawad Soltan, a political scientist at the American University in Cairo. He noted that Arab joint defense treaties date to 1950 and a joint military command was previously formed for a time in the mid-1960s. That was during the era of Pan-Arab nationalism, when Arab governments joined forces against Israel. That vision ended in the Arab-Israeli War of 1967, with a humiliating defeat.
“It is the renewal of an old idea,” Mr. Soltan said, “but this time the level of seriousness looks higher, even if we do not know yet whether the outcome this time will be different than in the past.”
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia provided ample financial and diplomatic backing for Sisi's coup government. A dictator presiding over a ruthless police state is what the Saudis prefer to see worldwide. For all his talk of democracy and new beginnings in the Arab world, Obama quickly fell in line with the Arab Spring rollback.

But the Gulf Sheikhdoms are apoplectic, as are the Israelis, over the P5+1 talks with Iran on its nuclear program; that, and the reluctance of Obama to bomb Damascus to rubble and take out the Baathists in Syria once and for all. Now there is the Houthi movement in Yemen who easily toppled the Saudi stooge Abdu Rabbu Mansour Hadi.

So the despots presented Sisi with his bill: the formation of a combined Arab military force, the foot soldiers, the cannon fodder to be supplied in large part by Egypt.

It will be interesting to see the extent of Sisi's servility. Will he invade Yemen? Despite the obvious foolishness of such a move, it seems like a foregone conclusion. The problem for the Saudis, as the Kirkpatrick wryly notes, is that the Houthis are seasoned fighters, certain to hold their ground and bloody any invaders that come their way:
Speaking at the meeting in Sharm el Sheikh, Nabil el-Araby, the secretary general of the Arab League, vowed that the Saudi-led airstrikes against the Houthi movement would continue until the Houthis had surrendered, apparently leaving little hope for negotiating a prompt end to the violence.
The campaign “will continue until all Houthi militias retreat and disarm, and a strong unified Yemen returns,” he said, declaring that the intervention had saved Yemen from sliding into the abyss.
The Houthi movement, which originated in the north of Yemen and follows a strain of Shiite Islam, has seized control of the country’s capital, Sana, and other large cities in part by allying itself with military and security forces still loyal to Yemen’s former strongman, Ali Abdullah Saleh. Mr. Saleh was removed in 2012, after an Arab Spring uprising, in a transitional deal brokered by Saudi Arabia and the other gulf countries. While the Houthis have received financial support from Tehran, the Iranians do not seem to exert a strong influence over the group as they do, for example, with Hezbollah in Lebanon.
The Houthis have previously fought as many as a half-dozen different civil conflicts against Yemen’s central government since 2004. None of the previous battles have succeeded in eliminating or fully disarming the movement.
One positive that can be taken away from Sharm el-Sheikh is that the Saudis have gone above board; they are not dealing with every geopolitical problem by means of a cut-out, whether the Pentagon/CIA or Wahhabi terror groups like Al Qaeda or Islamic State. Granted, Sisi fills the role of a front man, but the Saudis are front and center on Yemen. They are leading the campaign. So a loss in Yemen will bring the war home to the Kingdom. Maybe then there will be a reevaluation of the wisdom of perpetual war.

Wednesday, January 7, 2015

NYPD: This is What the U.S. Police State Looks Like

I always thought it was interesting that the day before the December 20 murder of NYPD officers Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos by Ismaaiyl Brinsley Juan Gonzalez appeared on Democracy Now! to tell the show's leftist listeners that NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio is the real deal. Here is the blurb that accompanies Gonzalez's December 19 segment:
Democracy Now! co-host Juan González discusses his exclusive year-end interview with New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio. "The list of his accomplishments in just one year has shocked even me — a total skeptic after more 35 years of covering urban politics in this country," writes González in his latest column. "And it’s not just the big issues like education, affordable housing, reform of police-community relations, or new contracts and pay raises for city workers. It’s also a host of less publicized but important measures affecting ordinary New Yorkers. Things like paid sick leave and a living wage for low-income workers. Like the lowest rent increase in memory for 800,000."
So what we have to consider is that the ongoing quasi-"sit down" strike that the NYPD is engaged in (see yesterday's "For Second Week, Arrests Plunge in New York City" by J. David Goodman and Al Baker) is a politically reactionary statement, a coup d'état of sorts. It is reminiscent of the situation in Cairo right before the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces removed Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi in a coup. Policing had effectively ceased.

Vivian Yee sums up the precipitous drop off in policing in New York City in today's "Life in New York City, Where Arrests Are Down and Tickets Are Rarities":
In a city of more than eight million people and 33 million subway rides a week, police officers arrested or ticketed just 22 people for jumping the turnstile last week. In the same period a year ago, nearly 1,400 fare-beaters were caught. 
Tuesday morning’s alternate-side parking period found 25 cars on the wrong side of one block in Park Slope, Brooklyn, still occupying the spaces they were required to leave an hour earlier, without a single ticket in sight. None of this appeared to faze the street sweeper moving down the block — or the police cruiser just behind it, which did not stop. 
At New York City housing projects from the Bronx to Staten Island, residents said they had seen fewer officers patrolling their hallways and streets, leaving some people relieved and others frightened for their safety. 
And on Burnside Avenue in the Bronx on Tuesday morning, Leyni Soto relished sipping from a Red Bull in a brown paper bag. When he did the same thing two months ago, an officer asked him what was in the bag.
But this time was different. “They slowed down their pace, they looked at me, they looked at the bag and they kept going,” said Mr. Soto, 28, an assistant manager of a cellphone store. “It felt really good.” 
If the Police Department’s own statistics are any indication, Mr. Soto was not simply getting a lucky break. For two consecutive weeks, New York City police officers have seemed to sit back, ignoring minor offenses and parking transgressions so completely that only 347 criminal summonses were written in the seven days through Sunday, down from 4,077 in the same period a year ago. 
Such startling numbers reflect a continuing conflict between rank-and-file officers and Mayor Bill de Blasio, on whom they have literally turned their backs. But for the New Yorkers in the middle, the slowdown has not appeared to translate to a spike in serious crime so much as in a fading, for good or ill, of the blue line that keeps the city’s streets in order.
The question is whether the collapse in "broken windows" enforcement is necessarily a bad thing. There will certainly be a loss of city revenue from all those unwritten tickets. But major violent crime will most likely be unaffected. My experience of having lived five years in New York City at a time when it posted the highest numbers of homicides annually is that I had more to fear from the police than from any criminals. And I lived and moved about on the street in Washington Heights' 34th police precinct, one of the more dangerous places in New York City.

One thing is for sure. The Gray Lady thinks the police rebellion is a very bad thing. While originally stoking police ressentiment by publishing numerous stories connecting the Black Lives Matter protests and the murders of Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos with a return to the social upheaval and "white flight" decline of the Big Apple in the early 1970s, The New York Times has published several hard-hitting unsigned editorials blaming the NYPD for fascistic overreach. Today's iteration is quite good, "No Justice, No Police." I'm going to quote the whole thing:
Mayor Bill de Blasio has been in office barely a year, and already forces of entropy are roaming the streets, turning their backs on the law, defying civil authority and trying to unravel the social fabric. 
No, not squeegee-men or turnstile-jumpers. We’re talking about the cops. 
For the second straight week, police officers across the city have all but stopped writing tickets and severely cut down the number of arrests. The Times reported that in the week ending Sunday, only 347 criminal summonses were issued citywide, down from 4,077 over the same period last year. Parking and traffic tickets were down by more than 90 percent. In Coney Island, ticketing and summonses fell to zero. 
The city has been placed in an absurd position, with its police commissioner, William Bratton — a pioneer of “broken windows” policing who has just written a long, impassioned defense of that strategy as an essential crime-fighting tool — leading a force that is refusing to carry it out. 
Police union officials deny responsibility for the mass inaction. But Edward Mullins, president of the Sergeants Benevolent Association, said officers had talked among themselves and “it became contagious,” apparently like the flu. 
Call this what it is: a reckless, coordinated escalation of a war between the police unions and Mr. de Blasio and a hijacking of law-enforcement policy by those who do not set law-enforcement policy. This deplorable gesture is bound to increase tension in a city already rattled over the killing by the police of an unarmed man, Eric Garner, last summer, the executions of two officers in Brooklyn last month, and the shootings on Monday of two plainclothes officers in the Bronx. 
Mr. Bratton spoke delicately at a news conference on Monday. He said there could be other explanations, like officers being too busy handling police-reform demonstrations and attending funerals. He promised to investigate — and to “deal with it very appropriately, if we have to.” 
Mr. de Blasio’s critics foretold doom when he was elected a year ago. They said graffiti, muggings and other crime would rush back with a vengeance. They were dead wrong — crime rates continued to decline to historic lows in 2014 — but now it seems the cops are trying to help prove them right. 
The madness has to stop. The problem is not that a two-week suspension of “broken windows” policing is going to unleash chaos in the city. The problem is that cops who refuse to do their jobs and revel in showing contempt to their civilian leaders are damaging the social order all by themselves. 
Mr. de Blasio, who has been cautious since the shootings, found his voice on Monday, saying for the first time that the police officers’ protests of turning their backs at the slain officers’ funerals had been disrespectful to the families of the dead. He was right, but he needs to do more. 
He should appeal directly to the public and say plainly that the police are trying to extort him and the city he leads. 
If the Police Department’s current commanders cannot get the cops to do their jobs, Mr. de Blasio should consider replacing them.
He should invite the Justice Department to determine if the police are guilty of civil rights violations in withdrawing policing from minority communities. 
He should remind the police that they are public employees, under oath to uphold city and state laws. 
If Mr. de Blasio’s critics are right and the city is coming unglued, it is not because of what he has done. He was elected by an overwhelming vote, because he promised action on police reform, starting with the end of stop-and-frisk tactics that corralled so many innocent New Yorkers into the criminal-justice system. The city got the mayor it wanted — and then, because of Mr. de Blasio, it got Mr. Bratton. 
Mr. Bratton’s faith in “broken windows” needs rethinking. But nothing will be fixed as long as police officers are refusing to do their jobs. 
A video emerged this week of a New York cop, apparently with nothing better to do, horsing around on the hood of a squad car, falling off and hitting his head. It would hard to invent a more fitting image of the ridiculous — and dangerous — place this atmosphere of sullen insubordination has taken us.
De Blasio will not "throw down" with the NYPD, as helpfully outlined by the Gray Lady. He is a shrewd politician. He knows the police are doing more damage to themselves than he could ever do by firing police commanders or demanding a DOJ investigation. This is an educable moment. People are aroused and alert because of the Michael Brown and Eric Garner and the Black Lives Matter movement. Now here comes the NYPD acting like a bully throwing a tantrum, arguing that police safety trumps public safety, comporting themselves as if risk, sometimes deadly, is not part of their job description. (Get a building trades guy talking about whose job is more dangerous, his or the police, and you will find out what he thinks about the risk of police work compared to construction.)

The educable moment that the NYPD is treating us to is on the nature of fascism. We must genuflect to and honor the authority of a violent, privileged, corrupt gang that rules over us with impunity, regardless of any code of ethics or set of laws. Those of us who have a certain skin color, mental illness, or come from a particular ethnic group can be slaughtered. This is the police state within which we reside. It is now on full display in the cultural capital of the United States.

Monday, December 22, 2014

Collapse of the Democratic Party + Obama Embraces Egyptian Police State + Blue Lives Matter Vs. Black Lives Matter

Yesterday in the Gray Lady's Sunday edition Jonathan Martin had a story, "Role for Warren: To Push, if Not Supplant, Clinton," that had the effect of tossing a bucket of cold water on the effort by MoveOn.org to draft Senator Elizabeth Warren (Dem.-Mass.) to run for president. After reading the piece one comes away feeling fairly certain that Warren will not lock horns with Hillary Clinton for the nomination of the Democratic Party; in fact, Martin's article reads as if it had been written by a Hillary press handler, as one can tell from the first few paragraphs:
DES MOINES — Eight years ago this month, then-Senator Barack Obama began his evolution from political phenom to presidential contender with his first-ever trip to New Hampshire, a visit that attracted 2,500 voters, 150 journalists and a comparison by the state’s governor of Mr. Obama to the Rolling Stones. 
Last week, in the side room of Java Joe’s coffee shop here, the liberal group MoveOn.org took the first step to propel Senator Elizabeth Warren, Democrat of Massachusetts, on a similar path, holding a rally to encourage her to get into the 2016 race. 
Yet there were only about 75 people present, some of them local political professionals engaging in a bit of reconnaissance and recreation, and just a handful of reporters. The highest-ranking official there was the Iowa Senate president, who carefully avoided stating her support for a Warren candidacy. 
Not that there is such a thing: Ms. Warren herself was not here, and she has repeatedly stated in public that she is not running for president. In private, according to several Democrats who have talked with her, Ms. Warren, 65, has also indicated that she would not challenge Hillary Rodham Clinton.
 Martin goes on to depict the potent force, juggernaut-like, of Hillary's candidacy:
A Des Moines Register-Bloomberg poll in October showed Mrs. Clinton leading Ms. Warren by 43 percentage points. In New Hampshire, where Mrs. Clinton led Mr. Obama in a Granite State Poll at the outset of the 2008 race by 14 points, she was beating Ms. Warren by 49 points last month in a Bloomberg-Saint Anselm College survey. 
“There is only a very small segment of the party this time around that’s looking for an alternative,” said Jim Demers, a New Hampshire Democrat who backed Mr. Obama in 2008 and is now supporting Mrs. Clinton.
The bold red quote above by Jim Demers is absurd. It is not a "very small segment of the party" that does not want Hillary; it is the activist base, the ones who volunteer to knock on doors and who pay attention to current events. As I see it, Elizabeth Warren is the only politician who has enough legitimacy on issues of Main Street vs, Wall Street to keep enough of the Obama coalition -- Latinos, blacks, youth, women -- engaged and on the reservation to secure a presidential victory for the Dems in 2016. Democrat strategists have said they plan to win by having Hillary turn out the Obama coalition.

It is possible that Hillary Clinton could muddle through if the GOP nominates Scott Walker, Ted Cruz or Marco Rubio. But at this point I think Jeb Bush, if he can weather the storm of the Republican primaries, beats Hillary in a general election. At this point I won't even rule out the possibility that Mitt Romney could triumph over Hillary.

To get a sense of just how bad things are -- for both parties -- a must-read article is "Americans Are Sick to Death of Both Parties: Why Our Politics Is in Worse Shape Than We Thought" by academics Walter Dean Burnham and Thomas Ferguson. Burnham and Ferguson describe a Democratic Party in denial of how historic -- historically poor -- its performance was in the 2014 midterms:
[O]ur cautious guess is that turnout in this year’s Congressional races will finally weigh in at around 36 percent of the potential electorate that had legal rights to cast a ballot. 
That’s a shocking statistic. Put aside for a moment all talk of 1942 and absolute levels of turnout. Instead focus on changes in turnout between presidential elections and the next off-year election. Across the whole sweep of American history, the momentous dimensions of what has just happened stand out in bold relief. The drop off in voting turnout from the presidential election of 2012 to 2014 is the second largest of all time – 24 percentage points. Only 1942’s decline from 1940 was bigger – 29 percentage points. But then there was an excuse. Millions of Americans were hurriedly fanning out across the globe to wage total war. (World War I showed a similar pattern – turnout in the off year elections of 1918 fell 22 points from 1916’s presidential race, marking the fourth largest decline ever. Which leads naturally to the question of the third largest. Read on.)
Now cast a glance at the actual levels to which turnout in many states sank this year. In the last generation, turnouts in the many formerly industrialized states in the Northeast, the Mid-Atlantic region, and parts of the Midwest have bounced around, with one or another state sometimes touching historic lows in a particular election. But this year the decline is broad and to levels that boggle the mind – rates of voting that recall the earliest days of the 19th century, before the Jacksonian Revolution swept away property suffrage and other devices that held down turnout. Turnout in Ohio, for example, fell to 34 percent — a level the state last touched in 1814, when political parties on a modern model did not exist and it had just recently entered the Union. New York trumped even this: turnout in the Empire State plunged to 30 percent, almost back to where it was in 1798, when property suffrage laws disenfranchised some 40 percent of the citizenry. New Jersey managed a little better: turnout fell to 31 percent, back to levels of the 1820s. Delaware turnout fell to 35 percent, well below some elections of the 1790s. In the west, by contrast, turnout declined to levels almost without precedent: California’s 33 percent turnout appears to be the lowest recorded since the state entered the union in 1850. Nevada also hit a record low (28 percent), as did Utah at 26 percent (for elections to the House).
We are witnessing levels of voter participation that go back two-hundred years to the days when suffrage was synonymous with property ownership. This is a collapse the size of which is truly sublime.

And what is the Democratic Party -- the party nominally committed to the "little guy," to working men and women -- doing about this crisis of legitimacy? They are telling us to line up behind Hillary Clinton, the spouse of the man who brought us NATO expansion and the war against Yugoslavia as well as the repeal of the Glass-Steagall.

This will not end well. People can no longer stomach the lies. Voters made their way to the polls in two consecutive presidential elections, giving Obama huge margins of victory in both 2008 and 2012, and for what? The benefits of the economic recovery, what of it there is, have all gone to the wealthy. Unions and pensions are less secure. We do have a new market-based system of health insurance that can count the expansion of Medicaid as an achievement. But we also have a new iteration of the Cold War and war in Iraq and Syria, both of which are largely due to the U.S. and its allies in the Gulf Cooperation Council.

A recent example of an indigestible lie: USG has cleared the way for the delivery of military helicopters to Egypt, helicopters that have been put on hold since the Egyptian military ousted the elected president Mohamed Morsi in a coup the summer of 2013. Morsi is in prison along with more than 10,000 imprisoned this year alone. Egypt is a massive police state. Yet neither the USG nor Congress will sanction the generals of Egypt and Thailand like it has sanctioned Venezuela and Russia.

And right on cue there is evidence of the U.S. police state kicking back against the Black Lives Matter protest movement by waving the bloody tunics of two police officers murdered in their squad car this past Saturday in Brooklyn. As Liz Robbins and Nikita Stewart report in "At Demonstrations, a Change in Tone After Officers Are Killed": "After the killings on Saturday, the protest motto of 'Black Lives Matter' was joined by a chorus of 'Blue Lives Matter' on social media, in support of officers."

This was all predictable. As soon as police died in the line of duty their deaths would be used as a political cudgel to beat down the Black Lives Matter movement, which has been maintaining its momentum. There are Black Lives Matter actions all over the country all the time. The precedent here is when CIA agent Richard Welch was murdered in Greece at the height of the Church Committee revelations of national security state lawlessness, his death was used to kill off calls for sunlighting the Deep State.

The police are going to be called on in short order to maintain control as the political parties continue to lose the allegiance of the people.

Wednesday, August 13, 2014

HRW vs. Sisi

With so many significant events happening in the Middle East, it is easy to skip over a story like the one that appeared yesterday, "‘Systematic’ Killings in Egypt Are Tied to Leader, Group Says," by Kareem Fahim. I did in the morning. But failing to board a train right as it was about to depart the station in the evening led to additional idle time to read. Subsequently, I thoroughly scrubbed the front section of the paper.

Fahim's story about the Human Rights Watch report is an important reminder of what a pivotal event the Sisi coup was last summer:
CAIRO — A day after Egypt barred representatives of Human Rights Watch from entering the country, the group disclosed the source of the government’s alarm: a report implicating senior officials, including Egypt’s current president, Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, in what it called the “widespread and systematic” killings of protesters. 
Human Rights Watch, which is based in New York, said Monday that it had conducted a yearlong investigation into violence that followed the military’s ouster of former President Mohamed Morsi, and found that the killings of demonstrators by the police and army forces “likely amounted to crimes against humanity.” Official statements during the killings made clear that the attacks “were ordered by the government,” the group said.
The report, which was released Tuesday, was the latest of several independent attempts by human rights workers and journalists to document a series of mass killings last summer that Egyptian authorities have failed to meaningfully investigate, and that government officials seem determined to help the country forget. 
The worst of the violence occurred on Aug. 14, 2013, when the security forces used force to disperse a large sit-in of Mr. Morsi’s supporters near the Rabaa al-Adawiya mosque in Cairo, killing more than 800 people, and possibly more than 1,000, according to Human Rights Watch. It called the episode “one of the world’s largest killings of demonstrators in a single day in recent history.” 
No security or government officials have been prosecuted in the killings, which set off a period of civil conflict and government repression that included the arrests of tens of thousands of people, including Islamists, journalists and leftist political activists. 
The report calls for an investigation of Mr. Sisi, who was commander of the armed forces at the time, and several other sitting government officials, including Egypt’s interior minister. The Obama administration has signaled its intention to return full American support for Egypt under Mr. Sisi, despite scant evidence that Egypt is becoming more democratic or inclusive. 
Human rights workers and civil society advocates have described an atmosphere that is more stifling and perilous than life under President Hosni Mubarak, who was deposed in a popular uprising in 2011.
On Monday, the executive director of Human Rights Watch, Kenneth Roth, and the director of the Middle East division, Sarah Leah Whitson, were deported from Egypt after being stopped at the airport on Sunday. 
It was the first time Egypt had denied entry to employees of Human Rights Watch, Ms. Whitson said. Airport officials wrapped a form around Ms. Whitson’s passport and checked a box that said, “For security reasons.”
David Kirkpatrick follows up this morning with "After Human Rights Watch Report, Egypt Says Group Broke Law":
Human Rights Watch “does not enjoy any legal status that may allow it to operate in Egypt,” the government said in a statement responding to the report. “Conducting investigations, collecting evidence and interviewing witnesses without any legal backing are activities that constitute a flagrant violation of state sovereignty under international law,” the statement added. It called the report a “flagrant intervention in the work of the national investigative and judicial authorities, and an attempt to impinge upon the independence and integrity of the Egyptian judiciary.”
The government also said that Human Rights Watch had issued the report “in parallel with dubious moves by the terrorist organization and its supporters” — a reference to the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist group that sponsored Mohamed Morsi, the ousted Egyptian president — “with a view to carrying out further acts of violence and terrorism against the Egyptian state and innocent civilians.”
 ***
“The government seems to be suggesting that H.R.W.’s investigation and visit to Egypt is part of a Muslim Brotherhood terrorist plot, which is farcical on its face,” Sarah Leah Whitson, the group’s executive director for the region, said in an email. She called the charges “absurd, unsubstantiated allegations, and a naked effort to intimidate us.”
Human Rights Watch is generally a close ally of the U.S. government. Maybe this report, along with one published in July about the Ukrainian junta slaughtering civilians in Donetsk with Grad rockets, is proof of pockets of discontent within the Obama administration: in the case of Egypt, the discontent would be with the way in which the U.S. has meekly swallowed its soaring rhetoric of democracy and human rights and lined up with the Saudis behind Sisi's military dictatorship; in the Ukraine, the complaint would be with the neocon's rapacious embrace of the fascist coup government and its criminal assault on the civilian population of Donbass.

Government is not a monolith. There are always opposing camps struggling for advantage over one another. Sisi's conflict with HRW reminds us of this; but, more importantly, it reminds us that the "Sisi trend" -- totalitarianism -- to roll back the Arab Spring is still being contested, albeit obliquely, within the established power structure.

Wednesday, January 15, 2014

The Sisi Trend

It has been three years since the Arab Spring. Back then it was a hopeful time. Rancid autocratic governments were being toppled by what appeared to be youthful, pro-democratic, tolerant, anti-neoliberal populations. The intractable problems of the Middle East -- oil wars, Palestine, the export of Salafi jihad -- suddenly seemed soluble by a mass people movement of the disenfranchised.

But the turds in the punch bowl didn't take long to appear. A totalitarian crackdown in Bahrain fueled by riot weapons supplied by Uncle Sam; NATO intervention in Libya; Gulf Cooperation Council intervention in Syria; a botched Muslim Brotherhood post-Mubarak democratic transition followed by the coup de grace delivered by the SCAF and the return of a more extreme version of the Mubarak police state.

Today David Kirkpartrick and Carlotta Gall report on the different trajectories of the Arab Spring in Tunisia, where Arab Spring protests began, and Egypt, where the Arab Spring was snuffed out. Tunisia at this point looks like a qualified success story with the Islamists cooperating with the secular opposition to craft a new constitution which acknowledges the Islamic character of the state without enshrining Sharia.
Ennahda [the Islamist party] won wording stating that Islam is the religion of Tunisia but gave up on any reference to Islamic law. “Tunisia is a free, independent and sovereign state, Islam is her religion, Arabic her language and republic her regime,” a clause of the preamble reads. The more liberal parties, with strong lobbying from civil society groups, secured guarantees that Tunisia would remain a civil state with separation of powers and pledges of freedoms and rights. “Tunisia is a state of civil character, based on citizenship, the will of the people and the primacy of law,” the counterpart clause of the preamble reads. 
Neither clause can be amended by future governments.
Next door in Egypt a new constitution is being voted on in a plebiscite that was conducted yesterday and finishes up today. The new constitution validates the July 3 coup of Mohamed Morsi and solemnizes the police state. The Muslim Brotherhood, now a criminal organization with its leadership behind bars, has called for a boycott. The constitution is expected to pass overwhelmingly. Sisi, the military man who led the coup, is widely predicted to run for president.

What I felt at the time of the Morsi's imprisonment last summer is that elites around the world were taking note. Violence works. Crack down and crack down hard when you feel your power slipping. That's the ticket. It might be messy, but eventually the masses will fall into line. Elections are necessary only to validate the violence perpetrated by the rulers.

Thailand, though half-a-world away, is going through, I think, a situation not entirely dissimilar from Egypt in the run up to the July 3 coup. If there is a trend that was set in motion by the SCAF in toppling Morsi, then Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra should be watching her back. It could be argued that the trend was on display in Ukraine recently and that Viktor Yanukovich was on his way out, if not for the artful intervention of Vlad Putin.

The bottom line? I see a bull market for authoritarian coups ushering in police states.

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Lakhdar Brahimi Set to Resign as Special Envoy to Syria

Today United Nations and Arab League Special Envoy to Syria Lakhdar Brahimi meets first with Russian and U.S. diplomats; then Britain, China and France join the group, followed later in the day by Syria neighbors Iraq, Turkey, Jordan and Lebanon, as well as representatives from the Arab League. Nick Cumming-Bruce and Alan Cowell have the story from Geneva, "Diplomats Try to Push Syria Peace Conference."

This is the last gasp for Geneva II. If peace talks don't get off the ground Brahimi is set to resign. This is from Somini Sengupta's profile "Few Eager to Talk Peace in Syria, but a Mediator Won’t Stop":
A former United Nations official who has spoken to Mr. Brahimi recently described him as “his own greatest skeptic.” 
“He thinks if talks do happen, it’s by no means assured anything concrete will come out of it,” said the former diplomat, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the talks were private, adding that he believed that if Geneva II did not happen in the next few weeks, Mr. Brahimi would step down. 
He has once before, under somewhat similar circumstances. Mr. Brahimi spent two years, starting in 1997, trying to stanch low-intensity fighting between the Taliban and Northern Alliance fighters in Afghanistan. 
He talked to commanders on the ground and every neighboring country that had influence over them before finally resigning in September 1999. 
“We kept going around in circles, the fighting continued, and the people of Afghanistan were held hostage to those groups whose interest seemed to be in the continuation of the conflict, not in its solution,” he said in a speech last year. He said he told the Security Council that “I was giving up because I felt I had no real support from them.”
Afghanistan is what Syria is to become if it isn't already -- a failed state rife with heavy machine gun toting jihadis. Cumming-Bruce and Cowell quote the latest data:
The talks in Geneva opened against a backdrop of increasing humanitarian alarm in Syria. 
According to the United Nations, the number of Syrians needing help has surged to 9.3 million from 6.8 million in June. The figure represents some 40 percent of the estimated 23 million people in a country that has been seized by conflict since a crackdown on peaceful protest against President Assad began in March 2011. 
Since then, more than 110,000 people have died and, while Mr. Assad has agreed to dismantle chemical weapons stockpiles, fighting with conventional munitions still claims a daily toll, forcing many to flee their homes and blocking efforts to deliver humanitarian assistance. 
Valerie Amos, the top humanitarian official at the United Nations, told the Security Council on Monday that the number who have abandoned their homes but remained in Syria stood at 6.5 million compared to 4.25 million in June. Her remarks in a closed briefing to the Security Council were relayed by a spokeswoman, Amanda Pitt. 
“The humanitarian situation in Syria continues to deteriorate rapidly and inexorably,” Ms. Amos said.
And it will continue to deteriorate because the Obama administration talks out of both sides of its mouth: working to get Geneva II up and running at the same time it assures the Saudis it is on the same page. This was on vivid display with Kerry's visit to Cairo just prior to the opening of the show trial of ousted president Mohamed Morsi. This is from a story by the excellent David Kirkpatrick and Mayy El Sheikh, "Egypt’s Ex-President Is Defiant at Murder Trial":
And the timing, analysts said, also proved awkward for Secretary of State John Kerry. On a visit to Cairo just a day before, he had said that — despite a series of mass killings of protesters, the shutdown of opposition news media outlets and apparently politicized trials like Mr. Morsi’s — “there are indications” that the generals who ousted Egypt’s first freely elected president intended to restore democracy. 
The visit was “unbelievable timing,” said Michael Wahid Hanna, an Egypt scholar at the Century Foundation in New York. He argued that opponents of the Islamists would see the trip as an American effort to protect Mr. Morsi, while Islamists would hear Mr. Kerry’s “soft and optimistic statements as a U.S. blessing to the new military-led political order.”
The Saudis are rattled because they don't think -- based on Obama's failure to launch a strike against Damascus at the end of summer -- that the United States is willing to unilaterally exercise its "full spectrum" dominance. Kerry was in Riyadh to assure the House of Saud that its security is guaranteed. This is from Michael Gordon's report, "Kerry Reassures Saudis U.S. Shares Their Goals":
Differences between the Obama administration and the Saudi leadership burst into view last month after Prince Bandar bin Sultan, the head of Saudi intelligence, privately complained to diplomats about the White House’s reluctance to intervene in Syria — concerns that were later echoed publicly by Prince Turki al-Faisal, a former intelligence chief. 
At the root of much of the Saudis’ criticism was the perception that President Obama was uncomfortable with exercising power on the world stage, a gnawing worry for Saudi officials who have become increasingly concerned about the role of their nemesis Iran in Syria and elsewhere in the region. 
As much as American officials sought to dispel such criticism, the fact that the Obama administration has felt it necessary to offer such assurances has highlighted the strains. 
Mr. Kerry said at the news conference that Mr. Obama had told him to make clear to Saudi Arabia that the United States would defend the kingdom from external attack — a public promise that American officials would not have found necessary to make several years ago.
What the Saudis don't seem to appreciate is that the American system of government is based on a duopoly, a kabuki of "indispensable enemies" where trenchant foes come together and divvy up the loot. Foreign policy, particularly nasty foreign entanglements like imperial wars, has traditionally been a bipartisan affair. When you get real change in this country — i.e., the Civil War — it is preceded by a break down in the duopoly.

That's what we are starting to experience now -- a breakdown in the duopoly. The Republican Party is at war with itself, a war hastened by Obama's 2008 landslide election, similar to but nowhere nearly as radical as the Democratic Party split after Lincoln's election in 1860.

Obama would have liked to have delivered that attack on Syria that his allies wanted but he knew that to do so could have precipitated a catastrophic system failure of the duopoly, splintering not only the GOP but his party as well.

Kerry will kiss the rings that need to kissed; he will kneel and scrape. Peace talks will not happen. Brahimi will resign. War will rage on.

Friday, August 16, 2013

The Goal: Roll Back Arab Spring, Reconfigure Sykes-Picot, Reduce Iran, Secure Greater Israel

As large protest marches take place throughout Egypt today despite the imposition of martial law after the Wednesday massacre of pro-Morsi supporters by the coup government, it is illuminating to read the story by Mark Landler and Peter Baker, "His Options Few, Obama Rebukes Egypt’s Leaders." It is a snapshot of a helpless giant whose fecklessness and drift is explained away by its power-broker elite as a rational course of action -- which it is in a corrupt, "pay-to-play" system. While there are noises within the Obama administration that all options are still on the table, including obeying the law and denying $1.3 billion in aid to General Sisi's military junta, don't expect anything more than the cancellation of joint exercises with the Egyptian armed forces that Obama announced yesterday from his vacation retreat:
Given the deep schism in Egypt, this official said, the White House is still skeptical that cutting off aid would compel the generals to return the country to a democratic transition. And it could destabilize the region, particularly the security of Israel, whose 1979 peace treaty with Egypt is predicated on the aid.

For weeks, officials from Israel and several Arab countries have pressured the administration to maintain the flow of aid. If it were cut off, they said, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates would move quickly to make up the shortfall — and then some. 
Saudi Arabia and the emirates pledged $8 billion in grants and loans to Egypt’s post-Morsi government last month: $5 billion from Saudi Arabia in grants and loans; $3 billion from the emirates. That is more than enough, analysts say, to offset any cutoff from the United States, even if the two countries do not fulfill their entire pledges. 
Shutting off the aid spigot now would not have an immediate impact on the Egyptian military, defense officials say, because this year’s military assistance has already been delivered. Beyond money, Arab officials worry that a rupture between Washington and the Egyptian military would further erode American influence in a country that has historically been a bellwether in the Arab world, and would open the door to rivals like Russia or China. 
“If the aid gets cut, you can be sure that Putin will arrive in Cairo in two or three months,” one senior Arab official said. “And he will give aid with no strings attached.”
So there you have it. To head off the predatory, baleful Vlad Putin, as well as to secure cooperation with Israel, not to mention overflight rights and access to the Suez Canal, the United States will continue to pay the Egyptian military.

A robust refutation of this lazy, Washington-insider point of view can be found on New York Times Opinion Page in a piece written by Amr Darrag, Mohamed Morsi's minister of planning and international cooperation:
First, this is a battle between those who envision a democratic, pluralistic Egypt in which the individual has dignity and power changes hands at the ballot box and those who support a militarized state in which government is imposed on the people by force. 
Second, this coup has already sent Egypt back into the dark ages of dictatorship — with tight military control over both state-owned and private media, attacks on peaceful protesters and journalists, and detention of opposition leaders without criminal charges or due process. 
Third, there is no promise that General Sisi can make that he hasn’t already betrayed. He took an oath to uphold the Constitution; he suspended the Constitution. He took an oath to loyally serve in the government; he toppled that government. And in the classic doublespeak of military juntas, he loudly condemned the opposition for dealing with foreign powers, while he was actively seeking the help of Western diplomats as well as the Persian Gulf sheikdoms that largely financed his coup. 
Through all this, the United States government has pleaded impotence. Hardly a day goes by without some press officer, analyst or public official pushing the idea that Washington’s influence really isn’t that decisive with the Egyptian generals. This cop-out simply won’t do. America had influence and still does. It was an American official, not an Egyptian one, who informed President Morsi’s staff of the finality of the coup decision.
There is only one way forward in Egypt today. The legitimate government must be restored. Only then can we hold talks for a national reconciliation with every option on the table.
Iraq is being terror bombed daily by Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham. A massive bombing took place in a Hezbollah neighborhood in Beirut yesterday. There is a region-wide war being waged in the Middle East. The goal is to reconfigure Sykes-Picot, roll back the Arab Spring, reduce Iran and secure a Greater Israel. To this end look for, eventually, direct U.S. military involvement.

Monday, August 5, 2013

Ambassador Ford

Based on a reading of Michael Gordon's story this morning, "Former Envoy to Syria Said to Be Choice for Cairo Post," it looks like another nail in the Muslim Brotherhood's coffin. Robert S. Ford, a Foreign Service Officer seasoned in Iraq during the U.S. occupation, will succeed Anne "Hayzaboon" Patterson as American ambassador to Egypt. Ford is currently chief American envoy to the Syrian opposition, now headed by Saudi Arabia's man, Ahmad al-Jarba.

Kareem Fahim and Asmaa Al Zohairy published a story on Saturday, "Restraint Urged for Egypt’s Security Services," which can be interpreted to mean that the crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood sit-ins is on its way. You have Mohamed ElBaradei soft-pedaling the possibility of violence, which is his role in the pro-coup "transitional" government -- to provide liberal-sounding assurances to Western governments and media -- while the coup grinds on and the mechanics of criminalizing the Muslim Brotherhood proceeds apace.

Ben Hubbard and Mayy El Sheikh report this morning that three top Muslim Brotherhood officials -- "supreme guide, Mohamed Badie; his deputy, Khairat el-Shater; and another official, Mohamed Bayoumi" -- will go on trial at the end of this month for inciting murder:
The scheduling of the trial will most likely further complicate intensive political and diplomatic efforts to persuade Mr. Morsi’s supporters to break up two large sit-ins in Cairo that they have committed to maintaining until he is restored to power. 
Egypt’s new military-backed government has said it would not let the sit-ins continue indefinitely, but many fear that efforts to forcefully disperse the protesters would unleash new violence. Envoys from the European Union, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates and the United States have tried to help broker a solution. 
The prosecutions could be an effort to put more pressure on the group to strike a deal to end the current crisis, said Shadi Hamid of the Brookings Doha Center. 
The case concerns events during the final days of Mr. Morsi’s tenure, when hundreds of rioters — equipped with stones, Molotov cocktails and firearms — attacked the Muslim Brotherhood’s headquarters in Cairo and tried to burn those inside alive. 
Police officers in the area during the attack did not intervene, and a few men inside the darkened building fired guns from the windows. Health officials said eight people were killed outside the building, and a video posted online showed one badly beaten man being dragged from the building.
The idea that trials are a pressure tactic to get the Muslim Brotherhood to drop their demands for a return of Morsi to office and participate in the coup government is a ridiculous one. It is what it is -- a ban on the Brotherhood -- no more, no less.

Thursday, July 25, 2013

Crackdown Coming to Egypt

Instability is mounting in Egypt. Tomorrow protesters, responding to a call from commander of the military, General Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi, will fill the streets and public squares and violence will be the likely result. The only question is how much violence. Will the clashes between opposing groups -- Muslim Brotherhood vs. Tamarod/Mubarakists -- be so great that the military cracks down with a heavy hand and martial law is declared? It is a distinct possibility. The United States, unhappy with el-Sisi's handling of the post-Coup transition, has held up the delivery of four F-16s.

General el-Sisi is going back to the well. The best part of the coup so far has been the June 30 protests. The robust turnout, inflated wildly, had Western news consumers, myself included, feeling that Morsi had to go. The initial queasiness I felt when the military intervened, suspended the constitution and locked up Morsi in an unknown location has only gotten worse since July 3.

The coup is indefensible. But el-Sisi is going to give it a go. (See yesterday's Moon of Alabama post, Egypt: Preparing The Repression, for a good discussion of el-Sisi's call to fill the streets.) The gamble is that enough protesters will show up to justify General el-Sisi's obvious next step: a brutal crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood.

One aspect of the coup has been a complete success -- for the Israelis. Eighty percent of the tunnels connecting Egypt to Gaza have been shut down by el-Sisi's military. Gaza's economy has basically ground to a halt. The story, "Gaza’s Economy Suffers From Egyptian Military’s Crackdown," is told today in the New York Times by Fares Akram. I was somewhat aware that the commerce trafficked through the tunnels is taxed by Hamas, but I had no idea the extent to which Gaza's economy -- and the Hamas government -- relies on such traffic:
More materially, Hamas relies on the taxes it collects from the underground trade. Experts have estimated the group’s annual budget at $900 million. Hamas employs almost 50,000 government workers in Gaza, and two-thirds of the budget is said to be spent on salaries. 
Omar Shaban, a Gaza economist and the director of PalThink, an independent research institute, said taxes collected from the tunnel trade made up about a third of the budget. Additional income has come from taxes on local businesses, many of which also depend on cheap commodities from the tunnels that are now in short supply. Fuel from Egypt is sold here at half the price of fuel imported from Israel.
General el-Sisi can count on some powerful allies -- Israel, Saudi Arabia, et al. -- when civil war blows up in Egypt.

Thursday, July 11, 2013

"Deep Politics" Revealed

A must-read story that appears in today's New York Times is "Sudden Improvements in Egypt Suggest a Campaign to Undermine Morsi" by Ben Hubbard and David Kirkpatrick. The power outages, gasoline shortages and high crime due to absent police that marked Mohamed Morsi's presidency have miraculously disappeared in one week's time. It turns out that Tamarod, the youth movement that gathered over 20 million anti-Morsi signatures that culminated in the June 30 protest that preceded the coup, was critically underwritten by billionaire businessman Naguib Sawiris. According to Hubbard and Kirkpatrick,
Mr. Sawiris, one of Egypt’s richest men and a titan of the old establishment, said Wednesday that he had supported an upstart group called “tamarrod,” Arabic for “rebellion,” that led a petition drive seeking Mr. Morsi’s ouster. He donated use of the nationwide offices and infrastructure of the political party he built, the Free Egyptians. He provided publicity through his popular television network and his major interest in Egypt’s largest private newspaper. He even commissioned the production of a popular music video that played heavily on his network. 
“Tamarrod did not even know it was me!” he said. “I am not ashamed of it.” 
He said he had publicly predicted that ousting Mr. Morsi would bolster Egypt’s sputtering economy because it would bring in billions of dollars in aid from oil-rich monarchies afraid that the Islamist movement might spread to their shores. By Wednesday, a total of $12 billion had flowed in from Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Kuwait. “That will take us for 12 months with no problem,” Mr. Sawiris said.
I was always a little skeptical, having done a fair amount of signature gathering in my day, about the ability of Tamarod to orchestrate a huge petition drive solely on a volunteer, grass-roots basis. Refreshingly, in relationship to what is transpiring in Egypt, I have seen mentioned in the last couple of days the "deep state." (Peter Dale Scott might be finally getting his due.) Thomas Friedman mentioned it in yesterday's column, "Egypt at the Brink":
The Brotherhood posits that “Islam is the answer.” The military favors a return to the deep state of old. But more religion alone is not the answer for Egypt today and while the military-dominated deep state may provide law and order and keep Islamists down, it can’t provide the kind of fresh thinking and educational, entrepreneurial, social and legal reforms needed to empower and unleash Egypt’s considerable human talent and brainpower.
Sharif Abdel Kouddous referred to it yesterday on Democracy Now! And then this morning, Hubbard and Kirkpatrick:
When Mr. Mubarak was removed after nearly 30 years in office in 2011, the bureaucracy he built stayed largely in place. Many business leaders, also a pillar of the old government, retained their wealth and influence. 
Despite coming to power through the freest elections in Egyptian history, Mr. Morsi was unable to extend his authority over the sprawling state apparatus, and his allies complained that what they called the “deep state” was undermining their efforts at governing. 
While he failed to broaden his appeal and build any kind of national consensus, he also faced an active campaign by those hostile to his leadership, including some of the wealthiest and most powerful pillars of the Mubarak era.
This is "deep politics," how the state really operates. I remember in the aftermath of the WTO protests how the police force pulled back and disappeared from my neighborhood, Capitol Hill, which was protester terra firma and a main source of resistance to the police and national guard crackdown.

It now appears that the Egyptian military does indeed plan to pursue a pre-Arab Spring approach to governing. It's rounding up and arresting Muslim Brotherhood leadership and continuing to detain protesters from the Monday morning massacre in Nasr City. David Kirkpatrick has the story, "Egypt’s Government Broadens Its Accusations Against Islamists."

The New York Times has a solid unsigned editorial which highlights the issues at play: the ongoing military crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood and the flawed, hasty transition process announced on Tuesday and how both will likely result in civil war. At this point, the way things are shaping up, with the military -- bankrolled by Saudi Arabia, U.A.E. and Kuwait -- seemingly committed to rolling back the Arab Spring, the choice appears to be violence or obeisance.

Monday, July 8, 2013

Mayhem in Nasr City + Somalia on Turkey's Southern Border

The sit-in in front of the Republican Guard officers' club in Nasr City where deposed president Mohamed Morsi is believed to be held was fired on. Over 40 people are reported dead. This from David Kirkpatrick and Kareem Fahim, "At Least 40 Die as Soldiers Said to Open Fire on Morsi Backers":
Egyptian soldiers opened fire on hundreds of unarmed supporters of ousted President Mohamed Morsi early Monday as they were praying before dawn outside the facility where he is believed to be detained, dozens of witnesses said. 
At least 43 civilians were killed, all or most of them shot, and more than 300 wounded, doctors and health officials said. Security officials said one police officer died as well. 
The attack marked a sharp escalation in the confrontation between the generals who forced out the president and his Islamist supporters in the streets. 
Dozens of Islamists who had gathered in vigil for Mr. Morsi denied there was any provocation for the attack. Two bystanders who had supported Mr. Morsi’s ouster also said that the demonstrators were unarmed and ran in terror as the attack began. 
Bullet holes in cars, lampposts and corrugated metal barriers indicated that gunfire was coming from the top of a nearby building where the sandbag barriers around makeshift gun turrets were visible. Bullet casings on the ground and collected by Islamist demonstrators bore the label of the Egyptian Army.
It would be remarkable if this doesn't spark a move by Islamists away from civil protest to civil war in Egypt. David Kirkpatrick reports that Al Nour, the Salafi party that scuttled the naming of Mohamed ElBaradei as prime minister, has withdrawn from negotiations over the composition of the interim government as a result of the massacre. This might be just as well since Al Nour's bottom line is the inclusion of Islamic law in any Egyptian Constitution. Eventually this was going to be a flash point with the other members of the anti-Morsi coalition. The downside is that it removes the Islamic fig leaf from the anti-Morsi coalition, making it harder to argue this isn't about secularism vs. religion in politics.

Anne Barnard and Hania Mourtada have a story this morning, "Opposition in Syria Continues to Fracture," covered yesterday by Reuters, about fighting between rebels affiliated with the Free Syrian Army and the new Al Qaeda franchise on the block, Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham:
Islamist fighters said recently that they had driven a rival rebel brigade out of Raqqa, a rebel-held provincial capital in northeastern Syria, because they had found some of its fighters drinking wine and consorting with women, and because they considered brigade reluctant to fight.
And in the most recent confrontation, in Dana, a rebel-held town in Idlib Province near the Turkish border, members of an extremist Islamist group were accused of beheading two rival fighters and leaving their severed heads beside a garbage can in a town square.
That grim discovery on Sunday followed a protest and clashes in the town, highlighting the antagonism that some Syrian fighters and civilians are beginning to feel toward some of the radical factions. 
Simmering tensions within the insurgency have intensified lately, especially between rebels affiliated with the Free Syrian Army, the loose-knit umbrella group backed by the West, and members of the Islamic State of Iraq and Al Sham, the new Syria-based affiliate of Al Qaeda, which includes the well-armed fighters of the Nusra Front.
The disputes that have erupted in provinces like Raqqa, Idlib and Aleppo are often centered as much on individual egos and economic resources as on ideology. Still, the frictions inhibit the insurgency from functioning as a single fighting force, and as government forces have appeared to retake control of some rebel-held territory, they are threatening to deepen into a new conflict that would further weaken the rebels on the battlefield.
According to residents, activists and fighters, popular resentment toward radical factions including foreign fighters began sweeping into villages that had been under the control of the Free Syrian Army and trying to impose their strict conception of Islamic law, sometimes even carrying out summary public executions. 
The Nusra and Free Syrian Army fighters have accused each other of profiting from the war, demanding bribes at checkpoints and selling oil from captured wells. The Qaeda-affiliated units are said to be buying up land in Aleppo and Idlib Provinces and trying to monopolize supplies of wheat and fuel, Reuters reported.
The Associated Press is reporting this morning that the SAA has taken the Khaldiyeh district in Homs. There has been intense fighting in the rebel-held areas of Homs. The government appears to be adding territory to its control. And with the news out of Idlib of rebel factions at war with each other and civilians being mowed down in the crossfire, it's time for the warhawk U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry to get real and agree to conditions to get talks underway as soon as possible. Otherwise we're looking at a situation where there will be a Somalia-type Hobbesian state on Turkey's southern border.

Saturday, July 6, 2013

ElBaradei Apparently Not PM

Ben Hubbard is now reporting, "Signs of Disarray Emerge in Egyptian Generals’ Plan for Governance," that because a Salafi party, an important Islamist part of the anti-Muslim Brotherhood coalition, balked and withdrew from SCAF's transition plan, Mohamed ElBaradei is not prime minister, at least for now.

The other thing about last night's street battles between pro- and anti-Morsi fighters that I forgot to mention was the large number of guns and gunshot wounds, which is unusual because gun ownership is not a prevalent part of Egyptian culture (as it is here in the land of Yankee Doodle Dandy). This does not bode well for the possibility of nonviolent protest.

In Cairo, Street Fights Move to Hospital Wards

Reading Ben Hubbard's account of the aftermath of street battles last night in Cairo, it appears that Egypt is in for a long, grinding, violent conflict:
Dr. Abu Aisha said the hardest part was the continuation of street fights in the sprawling hospital’s wards. 
“There were dead and wounded from both sides, and they wanted to finish each other off, so they beat each other inside the hospital,” he said. “There is no agreement and everyone is sticking to their views and we can’t come up with a plan to move the country forward.”
In the surgery ward, Muhammad Ibrahim, 20, recalled seeing someone shot dead next to him and then watching his twin brother, Ahmed, collapse after being shot twice in the abdomen in a clash with pro-Morsi marchers. 
“We want there to be stability — not people getting shot every day,” Mr. Ibrahim said. “We’ll let anyone rule as long as there is stability.” 
He said both he and his brother had voted for Mr. Morsi, hoping that he would use Islam to improve life for Egyptians, but they had given up on him when life got worse for the general population. He reserved judgment on Gen. Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi, leader of the armed forces, who described the military’s intervention into politics as a step toward healing the country. 
“We’ll see if he does anything good or if he’ll say he’s with the people and do nothing, like the others who came before,” Mr. Ibrahim said.
The quick installation of  ElBaradei as Prime Minister is proof that the SCAF is interested in currying favor with Obama. Franklin Lamb has a piece on the Counterpunch web site this weekend which tells of ElBaradei's good relations with the Obama administration and his energetic lobbying for Morsi's ouster; it also mentions that ElBaradei has pledged fealty to Israel. The Moon of Alabama blog thinks that ElBaradei is basically decent -- I tend to agree -- but that Egypt's problems are too numerous and too large, and that he will burn out in no more than two years. I think if ElBaradei is still around in two years then the SCAF will have successfully pulled off its coup. I think at this point that's looking overly optimistic.

We'll see what happens with the Muslim Brotherhood's sit-in in front of the Republican Guard officers' club in Nasr City. Morsi, it is believed, is being held there. If the military cracks down, then soon talk of peaceful resistance will give way to jihad, and the suicide bombers can't be far behind.

Thursday, July 4, 2013

"Hayzaboon, Go Home"

All day I've been ingesting the coverage of the military coup in Egypt. Fighting has broken out in deposed President Mohamed Morsi's hometown of Zagazig. The leadership of the Muslim Brotherhood is being rounded up and put under arrest. The Gulf Arab monarchies, even Qatar, have publicly expressed support for Egyptian Gen. Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi's ouster of Morsi who is being detained. A big pro-Morsi "Friday of Rejection" protest is planned for tomorrow following weekly prayers.

The United States is stepping gingerly. Obama's position so far is that he is deeply concerned about Morsi's ouster and the suspension of the Egyptian Constitution and hopes that new elections will be scheduled soon.

But what caught my eye was Mark Landler's piece on Ambassador Anne W. Patterson in this morning's national edition :
Ms. Patterson’s problems started on June 18 when she was invited, at a time of mushrooming demonstrations against Mr. Morsi’s government, to speak to an audience in Cairo about the United States’ relationship with the Muslim Brotherhood. It was, she said, a welcome chance to “set the record straight.” 
While the United States supported Egypt’s democratic development, it still had to deal with those in power, Ms. Patterson said, adding, “I don’t think the elected nature of this government is seriously in doubt.” Moreover, she said she was “deeply skeptical” that “street action will produce better results than elections.” 
Even as Ms. Patterson sought to distance the United States from the Muslim Brotherhood, those words marked her as an enemy of the crowds in Tahrir Square, reviving memories of Mr. Obama’s early reluctance to cut loose Mr. Mubarak, a longtime ally of the United States. 
“She manipulates people and secretly governs the country,” Mona Mohammed, 52, a bank employee said of Ms. Patterson at an antigovernment rally. “The ambassador is part of a conspiracy against Egypt and its people,” Ms. Mohammed added, clutching a poster with a caricature of Ms. Patterson and the slogan “Hayzaboon, Go Home.” (Hayzaboon is Arabic for ogre.)
The United States government is despised by the Egyptian masses, the European masses (for spying on them), the Latin American masses (for, among a host of reasons, getting Spain, Italy, France and Portugal to deny overflight of Bolivian President Evo Morales' plane because of suspicions that NSA whistle blower Edward Snowden was a stowaway) -- even the American masses (for being dysfunctional).

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Egypt Headed Toward Civil War

The Egyptian Armed Forces have given president Mohamed Morsi an ultimatum, resign or be removed. This from today's frontpage story written by David Kirkpatrick and Ben Hubbard:
The standoff threatened to roll back the clock to the day two years ago when the generals first seized power from Hosni Mubarak and to thrust Egypt into an extended period of instability and perhaps escalating violence. The military’s vow to intervene raised questions about whether Egypt’s revolution would fulfill its promise to build a new democracy at the heart of the Arab world. And the defiance of Mr. Morsi and his Brotherhood allies raised the specter of the bloody years of the 1990s when fringe Islamist groups used violence in an effort to overthrow the military government. 
Under the banner headline “removal or resignation,” Al Ahram reported that the generals would “abolish the controversial Constitution” and form a committee of experts to write a new charter, form an interim presidential council with three members led by the chief of the constitutional court, and put a military leader in charge of the executive branch as an interim prime minister. 
Citing an unidentified military official, the newspaper said that “to ensure the country’s security” the military and security services had already put some of Mr. Morsi’s Muslim Brotherhood allies under house arrest, and had issued orders for the arrest of “anybody who resists these decisions” for trial in special courts. 
Mr. Morsi refused to back down. In an impassioned, if at times rambling, midnight address broadcast on state television, he hinted that his removal would lead only to more violence. 
“The people empowered me, the people chose me, through a free and fair election,” he said. 
“Legitimacy is the only way to protect our country and prevent bloodshed, to move to a new phase,” Mr. Morsi said. “Legitimacy is the only thing that guarantees for all of us that there will not be any fighting and conflict, that there will not be bloodshed.” 
“If the price of protecting legitimacy is my blood, I’m willing to pay it,” he said. “And it would be a cheap price for the sake of protecting this country.”
It's hard to imagine a situation where this doesn't end up in civil war. The Muslim Brotherhood feels clean in the pursuit of martyrdom; they won the election fair and square. They see the military's demand as a coup. They feel as if they've been abandoned.

I wonder to what extent the Gulf Arab monarchies will support the Brotherhood once the shooting war really takes off. It seems as if the Saudis and Qataris are obsessed with toppling al-Assad and bringing sharia to Syria. A civil war in Egypt queers that pitch. The fact the Muslim Brotherhood is quoted repeatedly in today's paper saying that they've been abandoned leads one to believe that the advice they're getting from their benefactors in the Gulf is to stand down.

Certainly the United States, supplying the Egyptian military with $1.3 billion in aid annually, signed off on the plan to oust Morsi and rewrite the Constitution; it's a way to bring back a version of the Mubarak era.

The Brotherhood's pledge to go down fighting will definitely complicate things for the U.S. and its allies -- the old colonial powers, Israel and the Gulf Arab monarchies -- and it will be a boon for Syria, Iran, Lebanon, Russia and China. The European markets, sensing this, are already down.

SAA is steadily grinding away at a disorganized mercenary Wahhabi opponent. A civil war in Egypt will potentially draw jihadi support away from the Syrian war zone as foreign fighters come to the aid of the Muslim Brotherhood. At the very least it will distract the war pigs who have been coordinating the assault on Syria as they have to focus their attention on salvaging their political formation in Egypt

Sunday, June 16, 2013

Sunni Clerics Calling for Holy War

The sectarian unraveling of the Middle East along a Sunni-Shiite divide is consistently presented in the Western media as the fault of Bashar al-Assad and his Iranian allies and Hezbollah. But this morning's news -- reported in "U.S. to Keep Warplanes in Jordan, Pressing Syria," by Michael R. Gordon and Thom Shanker -- that Egyptian president Mohamed Morsi is severing diplomatic ties with Syria is yet more proof, along with the news from late last week of Sunni clerics in Cairo issuing fatwas calling for jihad against Syria, that the fires of sectarian region-wide warfare are being stoked by Sunni fundamentalists. Morsi, following his usual pattern, is no doubt following orders issued in Saudi Arabia.

As the United States positions Patriot missiles and F-16s in Jordan for the foreseeable future to provide protection for the CIA's ongoing rebel training program, it is hard to see anything but a larger war coming down the pike. Gordon and Shanker note that the Obama administration, despite the constant invocation of a "political settlement," has given up on Geneva II for the time being:
Mr. Kerry flew to Moscow last month and secured Russia’s agreement to hold an international conference that would bring the Assad government and the Syrian opposition to the negotiating table to try to bring an end to the fighting. Since then, however, the Obama administration has become concerned that the advances made by pro-government forces would give Mr. Assad little reason to negotiate a political transition in which he would give up power. 
As a result, White House and State Department officials now favor delaying the talks. Supplying arms to the rebels, officials have said, is partly intended to turn the tide enough to force a real negotiation. Mr. Lavrov, by contrast, argued for moving forward with the international conference on Syria.
For a sober point-by-point refutation of the current bellicose course of United States policy read Ramzy Mardini's opinion piece, "Bad Idea, Mr. President," which appears today in the New York Times Sunday Review:
Interventionists tend to detach their actions from longer-term consequences. This myopia is often coupled with a prevalent misunderstanding of the political and cultural context of where they want to intervene. Both problems are present in the current American approach to Syria.
The Syrian revolution isn’t democratic or secular; the more than 90,000 fatalities are the result of a civil war, not a genocide — and human rights violations have been committed on both sides. 
Moreover, the rebels don’t have the support or trust of a clear majority of the population, and the political opposition is neither credible nor representative. Ethnic cleansing against minorities is more likely to occur under a rebel-led government than under Mr. Assad; likewise, the possibility of chemical weapons’ falling into the hands of terrorist groups only grows as the regime weakens. 
And finally, a rebel victory is more likely to destabilize Iraq and Lebanon, and the inevitable disorder of a post-Assad Syria constitutes a greater threat to Israel than the status quo.
Civil war has returned to Iraq. The death toll has returned to a level not seen since 2008. To answer Mardini, the conclusion one must come to is that war, not long-term strategic interest, is what motivates Western policy makers. A piggish love of war.

Sunday, February 10, 2013

Meet the New Boss Same as the Old Boss

Last Wednesday there was a great story from David Kirkpatrick -- "Cairo Activist Fighting Tear Gas With Tear Gas." It's a description of the ongoing real war of the Egyptian Revolution as seen through the eyes of a street fighting man.The Mubarak police state remains alive and well in the Interior Ministry; the street fighters -- the real force of the uprising in Tahrir Square two years ago -- feel, and rightly so, that the Revolution is unfinished as long as the police of the Interior Ministry are unbowed:
Now, while elite politicians tussle over matters of ideology or provisions of the Constitution, street protesters like Mr. Mokbel say they are carrying on the fight that kindled the original revolt, a battle against Mr. Mubarak’s abusive and unaccountable security services. Two years later, they note, the security forces are still largely intact, and reports of torture, extortion and excessive force continue.
The street war between protesters and the police presents a double-edged challenge to President Mohamed Morsi, a former leader of the Muslim Brotherhood who had been jailed without trial under Mr. Mubarak. Brotherhood leaders close to Mr. Morsi say he does not yet fully control the Interior Ministry. Its officers make no secret of their hostility to the Islamists, and Brotherhood leaders say that the new president is struggling to win the ministry’s trust in order to tame it.
But many in the street have turned against Mr. Morsi in part because they believe that he has sided with the security forces. Activists like Mr. Mokbel say they fear that like the region’s secular dictators, Mr. Morsi may use the security police against his opponents as a tool of political power.
“They are trying to build a new regime exactly like the old one, with all its disadvantages,” said Mr. Mokbel, an artist with a small and slender frame who, between battles, studies painting in a graduate program in one of Egypt’s top art schools.
The protesters, Mr. Mokbel argued, are the ones defending the rule of law, standing up for their right to peaceful expression. With no personal gain, he said, they risk their lives for their cause, for one another, and for their many friends who have fallen. “We owe them something,” he said. “Not just a better economic situation, a government that deals with the people, that is not authoritarian or repressive.”
Rather than extirpate the cancer the Morsi government has been gentle with the Interior Ministry hoping to co-opt it:
But now the Islamists’ apparent monopoly on power has turned activists cynical about Egypt’s young democratic process. Since Mr. Morsi’s decree temporarily suspending the power of the courts to challenge his decisions, violence around the country has escalated sharply. “When the regime smashes the judiciary against the wall, and uses the police as a tool of repression, who will conduct elections?” Mr. Mokbel asked. “If we wait for elections, what guarantees do we have?”
Senior Brotherhood officials close to Mr. Morsi say moving too fast to reform the Interior Ministry might provoke an open revolt by the police at a time when public security is already fraying. Instead, after recent clashes with police officers killed dozens of civilians, Mr. Morsi publicly thanked the security forces for their work, and in certain cities expanded police powers.
More proof of the fundamentally conservative nature of the Morsi Muslim Brotherhood government is provided by Kareem Fahim and Mayy El Sheikh in a story published the same Wednesday as Kirkpatrick's; it has to do with Iranian president Ahmadinejad's visit to Egypt. Mubarak and before him Sadat were opponents of Iran under the clerics. I didn't know that a street in Tehran was named after Sadat's assassin:
The relationship had atrophied over decades, damaged in particular by the Egyptian President Anwar el-Sadat’s granting of asylum to the deposed Iranian shah, Mohammad-Reza Pahlavi, who was given a state funeral in Cairo in 1980. When Mr. Sadat was assassinated the next year, Iran named a street after his killer, Khaled Islambouli.
Mr. Morsi, an Islamist and Egypt’s first elected leader, promised a new direction for foreign policy that he said would be more independent than his predecessors’ and would reassert Egypt’s historical leadership role. Extending a hand to Iran was seen as part of an effort to improve ties with regional powers and, more important, to broker a solution to the war in Syria. 
Iranian officials were even more eager to mend the relationship, speaking of Egypt and Iran as the core of an axis of regional military powers. Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has been promoting the idea that the recent Arab uprisings were inspired by the Iranian revolution of 1979.
The first major step toward repairing the relationship came in August, when Mr. Morsi visited Tehran during the meeting of the Nonaligned Movement, in what was seen as an effort toward easing Iran’s international isolation.
 But in Tehran Morsi toed the Saudi line, criticizing the Assad government:
But that trip also veered off script. Mr. Morsi embarrassed his hosts somewhat by delivering a stinging condemnation of President Assad, delighting Saudi Arabia and Qatar, strong financial supporters of both Egypt and the Syrian insurgency.
And in speaking about the Arab uprisings, Mr. Morsi notably avoided, as he often does, any mention of the Shiite-led revolt against Bahrain’s Sunni monarchy, further endearing him to allies in the gulf region who have portrayed the uprising as an Iranian plot rather than a popular movement. 
Many analysts think it unlikely that the Egypt-Iran thaw will develop into fully restored relations, given the pressure exerted by the United States and the gulf monarchies on Mr. Morsi to keep his distance. Despite his talk of charting a new path for Egypt, “the Morsi administration is trying to avoid any direct confrontation with the international system,” said Emad Shahin, a political scientist at the American University of Cairo. 
A separate attempt by the Egyptian leader to develop closer ties with Iran, by including it in a regional effort with Turkey and Saudi Arabia to solve the Syrian crisis, also faltered, after the Saudis stopped participating, diplomats said. 
“Morsi is learning the constraints and the realities of the cold wars in the region — the old rivalries and local calculations,” Mr. Shahin said.
"Meet the new boss. Same as the old boss," as the Who remind us in "Won't Get Fooled Again." Robert Dreyfuss' book Devil's Game lays out the long, rich relationship between the Muslim Brotherhood and the United States. The Egyptian street is coming to the conclusion that the Muslim Brotherhood is going to provide a version of the state very similar to Mubarak's, with the notable exception that the Brotherhood can legitimately win -- at least so far -- popular elections.