Showing posts with label Somini Sengupta. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Somini Sengupta. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 27, 2016

Geneva III Dies Aborning, Greece to be Sacrificed to Ares

For an excellent snapshot of the stillborn UN-brokered peace process on the war in Syria, which is scheduled to begin this Friday in Geneva, what is being referred to as Geneva III, consult this morning's Reuters story, "Syria Peace Talks Hinge on Envoy's Answers." 

The title of the piece refers to a list of clarifying questions that the handpicked Saudi opposition, which has dubbed itself the High Negotiations Committee (HNC) in an attempt to appear officially legitimate, has submitted to UN special envoy Staffan de Mistura and Secretary General Ban Ki-moon. The questions purportedly have to do with the lifting of sieges on opposition-held territory as a precondition of the peace talks.

The Saudis have no intention of bargaining in good faith. These conditions are an attempt to shift blame for the stillborn Geneva III to the Russians and Syrians. The talks were never going to get off the ground. This became apparent yesterday when de Mistura sent out invitations omitting the Syrian Kurds:
De Mistura's bid to convene the talks has already faced problems, including a dispute over who should represent the opposition. While the Saudi-backed HNC includes powerful rebel factions fighting Assad in western Syria, Russia has been demanding wider participation to include the Syrian Kurds. 
But de Mistura has not invited the Syrian Kurdish PYD party, which is affiliated to the Kurdish YPG militia that controls wide areas of northern and northeastern Syria and has become an important partner in the U.S.-led war on Islamic State.
Turkey, a major sponsor of the rebellion which views the Syrian Kurdish PYD party as a terrorist group, had said it would boycott the talks if had been invited.
Fabius said: "The PYD group was causing the most problems, and Mr de Mistura told me he had not sent them an invitation letter."
The PYD's representative in France, Khaled Eissa, who had been on a list of possible delegates proposed by Russia, blamed regional and international powers, in particular Turkey, for blocking the Kurds and forecast the talks would fail.
"You can't neglect a force that controls an area three times the size of Lebanon," he said. "We will not respect any decision taken without our participation."
One prominent Syrian opposition figure said he would boycott the talks unless the PYD was invited.
"I'll go with my friends or not (at all). There is no compromise in this question," Haytham Manna told Reuters. Manna is co-leader of an opposition group called the Syrian Democratic Council, which includes the PYD and was formed in December in Kurdish-controlled Hasaka province.
Independent Syria dissident Jihad Makdissi said would not attend the initial round of talks in order to help overcome differences over who should represent the opposition.
Not surprisingly, de Mistura's promises of robust participation by women and civil society groups in the peace process have proven hollow. According to Somini Sengupta reporting from Geneva in "An Odd Diplomatic Dance as U.N. Prepares for Syria Peace Talks":
Mr. de Mistura had promised to seek the guidance of women’s groups and civil-society representatives. But none got the mysterious invitations on Tuesday, diplomats said, which galled Mouna Ghanem, a Syrian politician who is not part of either the Russia-backed or Saudi-backed blocs. 
“Just on the doors of Geneva III, majority of men are rushing to negotiate Syrian future,” Ms. Ghanem, coordinator for the Syrian Women Forum for Peace, said in a statement. She called women’s participation “shallow and insignificant.”
De Mistura is dancing to the Saudi fiddler, as is the United States. Or Saudis are dancing to a tune produced at Langley. It is often hard to understand where the U.S. deep state stops and the House of Saud begins, so intertwined are the two. In any event, a couple things are clear at this point: 1) Russian-backed Syrian Arab Army military victories are mounting, and 2) the Saudis and Turks refuse to bargain while their regime-change operation is backpedaling.

Where do the Saudis go from here? The old standby. Terror bombing like the one the other day in the Shiite area of Homs. The Saudis work through multiple proxies, secular and Salafist.

The maintenance of our status quo of perpetual warfare means that Europe will keep its role as escape valve for a disintegrating Middle East. Now that the oft-floated solution to the problem of refugees fleeing perpetual war by bribing Erdogan to warehouse the migrants in Turkey is pretty well accepted to be a public relations gimmick, tossing Greece out the Schengen area seems to be the plan du jour. This from a Reuters story this morning, "EU Gives Greece Warning to Fix Border 'Neglect' ":
BRUSSELS — The EU executive concluded on Wednesday that Greece could face new border controls with other states of the free-travel Schengen zone in May if it does not fix "serious deficiencies" in its management of the area's external frontier. 
"If the necessary action is not being taken and deficiencies persist, there is a possibility to ... allow member states to temporarily close their borders," European Commission Vice President Vice President told a news briefing after the executive accepted a report that Athens had "seriously neglected" its obligations to fellow Schengen states. 
The move is part of a process in which EU governments aim to give them the option of reinstalling controls on their national borders for up to two years, once short-term derogations currently in place expire in May. 
Following the arrival of more than a million irregular migrants in the European Union last year, most of them via Turkey into Greece from where they trekked northward to Germany, other EU member states have instituted emergency controls on their internal Schengen borders and have warned that they might effectively suspend Athens from the passport-free travel zone. 
In practice, Greece has no land borders with the rest of the Schengen zone, so installing new frontier checks would affect only air and sea ports. Diplomats and officials have described the move to penalize tourism-dependent Greece as a means of raising pressure on Athens to implement EU measures intended to identify and register all those arriving from Turkey.
James Kanter had a story ("E.U. Ministers Spar as Bloc’s Promise of Free Movement Wavers") about this move underway in Brussels to penalize Greece for the German-, British- and French-backed Saudi/U.S. war on Syria:
The European Union has been trying to persuade Turkey to take a more active role in resolving the crisis by doing more to look after refugees there and stop them from trying the journey to the European Union. 
Another idea that has gained growing attention is to choke off some of the northward flow of migrants at the border between Greece and Macedonia, potentially leaving huge numbers of migrants in Greece at a time when that country is still recovering from its depression-like downturn. 
On Monday, over lunch at the Dutch National Maritime Museum, the ministers discussed freezing the free movement of people inside parts of the bloc for up to a further two years.
So far, six countries, including Germany and Austria, have suspended the system for a legally permissible period of six months. For Germany and Austria, that six-month period expires in late spring, just as a surge of new arrivals from the Middle East and Africa is expected. 
The ministers also agreed to continue hashing out plans to create a European Border and Coast Guard Agency. 
That plan would double the staff of the current border agency, Frontex, and would create a separate reserve force to be deployed even when a member state rejects help. [!] But some politicians suspect a blunt power grab by Brussels intended to diminish national sovereignty. 
Arriving at the meeting in Amsterdam, the Austrian interior minister, Johanna Mikl-Leitner, warned that “the external Schengen border will move back towards Central Europe” — a thinly veiled threat to exclude Greece from the passport-free area unless Athens acted more forcefully.
Rather than work for peace in the Middle East, Western power brokers will carve up the European Union piecemeal and toss the chunks of flesh on a pyre to Ares.

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

The Age of Megacrises: Slavery is Not Far Off

Somini Sengupta reports from the United Nations, "Dispute Over Opposition’s Seat at Table Threatens to Push Back Syria Peace Talks," that peace talks on the war in Syria scheduled to begin next week in Geneva will likely be delayed. The reason? The Saudis are demanding the exclusive right to name the opposition, meaning they will determine who will negotiate with the Syrian government. Currently the Saudis are barring participation by the Kurdish People's Protection Units, fighters who have proven time and again to be superior to the Salafi jihadists. But they are Marxist in orientation. So the sheikhs of monarchical al-Saud will not countenance them at "their" table. The Russians have responded that if al-Saud gets a veto over composition of the negotiating teams, so too will Russia. 

Unless the Saudis relent this doesn't seem like it is going to be resolved. And there is very little in the last several years to lead one to believe that the Saudis are going to relent. If they are made to toe the line because of U.S. pressure, they'll find some other way to scuttle the peace talks. Already the promised ceasefire that was trumpeted when these talks were agreed to last month is being walked back.

The war will of course continue. Hence the importance of another story by Somini Sengupta, one that appeared in yesterday's paper, "U.N.-Appointed Panel Calls for a Tax to Pay for Crises." Acknowledging that global megacrises are not going away -- in fact, they are expected to increase -- the United Nations is considering a small transaction tax on high-volume goods and services, like that morning Starbucks:
UNITED NATIONS — What if the next time you buy World Cup tickets or summon an Uber ride, you found yourself paying a few cents extra to pay for winter blankets for Syrian refugees or clean water for those displaced in Darfur, Sudan? 
That idea — a small tax on high-volume goods and services — is among those proposed by an independent panel appointed by the United Nations to figure out how to pay for the staggering humanitarian crises facing the world today. The report, released Sunday, plainly acknowledges the limits of traditional charity on the part of the world’s rich and calls for a sea change in thinking about how to pay for lifesaving aid in what the Secretary General, Ban Ki-moon, called “the age of the megacrises.”
The nine-member panel’s report comes as new conflicts erupt in places like Yemen, old ones persist in places like Darfur and climate change intensifies floods and droughts in already fragile countries. Aid for the millions of people affected has sharply risen, but it has not kept pace with demands.
The world needs $40 billion each year to meet the needs of those affected by wars and natural disasters and already faces a shortfall of $15 billion for this year. Those needs are expected to grow; as the report stated bluntly, “Never before has generosity been so insufficient.” Already, food aid has been repeatedly slashed for refugees fleeing conflict in places like Somalia and Syria.
The panel — which includes representatives of donor governments, corporations and civil society — takes pains to point out that despite the growing needs, what the world needs to pony up for emergency relief is a fraction of the $78 trillion global economy. It also argues that in the end, while “helping people in distress is morally right,” providing aid is also in the interest of donor countries.
A new UN tax is not going to be popular with the "black helicopter" Tea Party crowd; it will confirm in their minds that there is a vast global conspiracy to enslave them. And there is. But the ring leader is not Ban Ki-moon. All the UN report does is confirm that its member states are committed to warfare and not so committed to addressing climate change; hence, the need for a dedicated revenue stream to deal with all the refugees created by war and flooding.

Participating in a peaceful march on Martin Luther King, Jr. Day I chatted with a fellow union member and we agreed that a return of slavery is the end game of the 1%. It might not look the plantation system of the Old South in the United States, though there might be similarities. I think first we'll see some sort of de jure form of indenture or peonage rather than the de facto second-class citizenship or "sub-citizenship" so common in today's low-growth, low-wage dominant neoliberal paradigm.

For an interesting discussion of the contradictions inherent in today's U.S. economy -- slow growth vs. healthy hiring -- read Nelson Schwartz's "U.S. Growth and Employment Data Tell Different Stories." This prediction caught my eye:
To be sure, some experts are not convinced that healthy payroll increases necessarily portend faster growth, arguing that the economy is on very shaky ground. 
“People commonly use employment as a leading indicator,” said David A. Levy, a veteran independent economist in Mount Kisco, N.Y., “but it’s a lagging indicator.” 
Mr. Levy said the optimists were underestimating just how big the impact from weakness overseas will be. 
“The U.S. economy is going to be pulled into a recession for the first time since World War II by overseas events,” he said. “Emerging markets, including China, are this cycle’s housing bubble.”
Previously I have been of the mind that the Chinese had a steady hand on the controls of their economy. Now I'm moving with the herd. I think China is overextended, and they are in a box with global deflation.

The first story to catch my eye this morning was a short one by Liam Stack, "Scholastic Halts Distribution of ‘A Birthday Cake for George Washington’." Apparently Scholastic, a publisher for children (and my first post-college workplace), killed a book because of outrage over the depiction of joyful slaves toiling happily for General Washington. At first, Scholastic stood by the book:
The plot of the book focuses on Hercules, an enslaved cook in the home of George Washington, and his daughter Delia as they bake the president a birthday cake. 
Earlier this month, Andrea Davis Pinkney, the executive editor of Scholastic Trade Publishing, defended the book in a blog post as a complex portrayal of American slavery that approached the topic with “the utmost care.” 
She wrote that Mr. Washington “admired” Hercules and that the cook lived a life of “near-freedom” because of the president’s fondness for him. Hercules and the other kitchen slaves reciprocated those warm feelings, she said, and “took great pride in their ability to cook for a man of such stature.”
That pride in their position in the president’s kitchen is why the book’s illustrator, Vanessa Brantley-Newton, chose to depict the slaves “as happy people,” Ms. Pinkney wrote. 
“They were not happy about being enslaved, but there was joy in what they created through their intelligence and culinary talent,” she said, adding that some historians consider Hercules to have been “the first celebrity chef in America.” 
Critics were unimpressed by those explanations, however, and the backlash against the book led to an avalanche of one-star reviews on Amazon and a Change.org petition calling for its removal from stores.
This I fear is what is coming down the pike: We must learn to love our lives of "near-freedom" and relish and take "great pride" in being in proximity to people of stature. If this is what we are teaching our children, slavery is not far off.

Wednesday, November 11, 2015

The West "Doubles Down": British Foreign Secretary Praises the Downing of Russian Charter Jet

We are in the "double down" phase in Syria as far as the Great Powers are concerned. "Double down," a gambling reference which means to double one's bet and hence one's risk, seems to be the quote du jour for the last few days. First, today, in an interesting story by David Sanger and Helene Cooper, "Obama Turns to Diplomacy and Military in Syria, and Is Met With Doubts":
At White House meetings, administration officials say, Mr. Kerry has argued that without applying both military and diplomatic pressure, the Russian intervention that began in late September would shore up Mr. Assad “and actually wind up destroying Syria.” [Rich, isn't it?]
But the question is whether the military element of the strategy — which reversed Mr. Obama’s previous determination to keep American combat troops out of the country — will be enough to make a difference.
“What he is doing will not work,” Fareed Zakaria, a journalist whom Mr. Obama frequently speaks with, wrote in a column in The Washington Post last week. “In a few months,” he predicted, the United States “will face the challenge again — back down or double down. So far, President Obama has responded each time with increased intervention.” 
Reflecting a willingness to do more, Defense Secretary Ashton B. Carter said Sunday that additional troops could be sent to Syria if the United States could find more local forces to work with.
The White House is hoping that the Syrian, Arab and Kurdish coalition, aided by American pilots and special operators on the ground, can seize and hold territory. The United States also plans to step up airstrikes. Mr. Obama deployed 12 A-10 warplanes and is sending additional F-15 fighter jets to Incirlik Air Base in Turkey.
The theory is that over time the combination will increase the pressure on Mr. Assad to step down. The immediate focus is not on Mr. Assad’s strongholds, though; it is on territory seized by the Islamic State, including its capital, Raqqa.
But there is a far more immediate problem: identifying friends and enemies on the ground in Syria. Several rebel groups aided by the United States have been bombed by the Russians in recent weeks. American officials say they believe that Russia is trying to wipe out Mr. Assad’s opponents while claiming that it is going after the Islamic State, also known as ISIS or ISIL.
Eventually, American and Russian officials will have to share lists about the groups that they support and that could be credible interlocutors for a cease-fire and political solution. But the United States has declined to do so, for fear that the Russians or Mr. Assad would immediately target the groups for attacks.
Then would come the practical problem of engineering a cease-fire and a referendum to replace Mr. Assad.
It is this supplying of a list of "credible interlocutors" that is going to be a huge problem for the Obama administration; it was the subject of yesterday's report by Somini Sengupta, "Invitation List Looms as Test for Syria Talks." It is in Sengupta's story that we encounter the use of "double down" again, this time from the lips of British foreign secretary Philip Hammond. Hammond amazingly lays claim to Islamic State Sinai Province's destruction of the Russian charter jet as an effective tactic to bring Russia closer to the West's negotiating position:
The diplomatic standoff over who is a terrorist and who counts as a legitimate opposition group comes on top of the significant differences that remain on the future of President Bashar al-Assad of Syria. Russia and Iran want to leave open the possibility that Mr. Assad can stand for election once more. The United States, Britain and their Persian Gulf allies resolutely oppose that idea. 
The Russian foreign minister, Sergey V. Lavrov, during a visit to Armenia on Monday, said that the talks should concern themselves with who should represent the Syrian opposition and who should be considered extremists, instead of whether to replace Mr. Assad, The Associated Press reported. As for which opposition group is legitimate, Mr. Assad has dismissed all his armed rivals as terrorists, and Russia, his most powerful backer, has largely supported his assertion. Indeed, over the last five weeks, Russian airstrikes have repeatedly attacked positions of several Western-backed groups. 
Mr. Hammond also said that his government suspected that the Islamic State or operatives “inspired” by the organization were behind the destruction of a Russian airliner in Egypt on Oct. 31. He added that he hoped that would persuade President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia to take a more flexible posture in the Syria talks.

“We’ll see whether the Russians now double down or whether they decide that they never wanted to be too deeply engaged anyway in Syria and that this is a warning shot to them and we’ll sense a greater willingness to engage in the talks in Vienna this coming Saturday,” he said. [!]
While Mr. Hammond declined to offer any details on which groups could eventually take part in political negotiations, his comments suggested that the West might be prepared to back Sunni Islamist groups with close ties to allies, including Saudi Arabia. “What we mean by a secular constitution, and what people in the Muslim world will understand by secular will be two different things,” Mr. Hammond said.
Sort of takes one's breath away, doesn't it? Here you have the West basically coming right out and acknowledging an overlap -- if not explicit collaboration -- between it and the terrorist jihadists it is purportedly locked in a death match with.

Another mainstream illumination of this manifest interlocking between the West -- in this instance, NATO-member Turkey -- and Islamic State is Roger Cohen's "Turkey’s Troubling ISIS Game," which appeared in the Sunday NYT. Read it and you come away with an understanding how Islamic State is used to further objectives of the Turkish government. The advantage to the United States, Turkey, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA), UK, et al., is that Islamic State can be disavowed. Better yet, the exact opposite can be claimed, that U.S., KSA, Turkey, UK are "at war" with ISIS.

The problem for the U.S. is that while it "doubles down" its "double game" is increasingly exposed and ultimately untenable as a strategy. If the U.S. provides a list of "credible interlocutors," that list will either include the groups of Jaish al-Fateh ("Army of Conquest"), members of which are Al Qaeda affiliate Jabhat al-Nusra as well as Islamist Ahrar al-Sham, or fictitious, U.S.-created ghost armies. There are also indications that the Army of Conquest is beginning to fray.

So the U.S. is in a pickle. If it wants to double its bet yet again by placing more troops in northern Syria, eventually Congress will demand to vote on authorizing the move, a vote I don't think the administration can win.

Thursday, May 7, 2015

"Need That Poison Gas" Redux

For the states -- Turkey, Saudi Arabia, as well as other members of the Gulf Cooperation Council -- that came tantalizingly close to pulling off the Ghouta sarin gas scam in August 2013 the temptation to pluck the note again and again until the desired result is finally achieved -- the exit of the Baathists from power in Syria -- never ends.

Not long after Syria started dismantling its arsenal of chemical weapons in a deal brokered by Russia, reports started to emerge of chlorine bombs being dropped from helicopters. These reports usually originated with "activists" aligned with the "opposition" to the Syrian state, and they were summarily dismissed as crude propaganda by representatives of the Assad government. But the stories have remained a regular feature as the months roll along.

Today's offering is a fine example. In "Syria Is Using Chemical Weapons Again, Rescue Workers Say" Anne Barnard and Somini Sengupta earn their pay as propagandists for the USG by filing another fallacious story about Syria's use of chemical weapons; fallacious because it is sourced to a "civilian defense" NGO called White Helmets. An inspection of the group's web site -- Barrel Bombs! -- linked to in the Barnard-Sengupta article, leaves one with the distinct impression that it is a CIA front. The allegations of White Helmets are then amplified by USG officials. This is the old familiar propaganda pattern. You have an "Astro-Turf" organization, an ersatz citizen group of some sort that has been mocked up by a foreign intelligence agency, make a specious charge, and then that charge is taken up by the United States in the United Nations Security Council:
Two years after President Bashar al-Assad agreed to dismantle Syria’s chemical weapons stockpile, there is mounting evidence that his government is flouting international law to drop jerry-built chlorine bombs on insurgent-held areas. Lately, the pace of the bombardments in contested areas like Idlib Province has picked up, rescue workers say, as government forces have faced new threats from insurgents. The Assad government has so far evaded more formal scrutiny because of political, legal and technical obstacles to assigning blame for the attacks — a situation that feels surreal to many Syrians under the bombs, who say it is patently clear the government drops them.
“People are so used to it, they know from the sound,” said Hatem Abu Marwan, 29, a rescue worker with the White Helmets civil defense organization, a note of exasperation creeping into his voice when asked to explain. “We know the sound of a helicopter that goes to a low height and drops a barrel. Nobody has aircraft except the regime.”
Prodded by the United States, the United Nations Security Council is discussing a draft resolution that would create a panel, reporting to the secretary general, to determine which of the warring parties is responsible for using chlorine as a weapon, according to Council diplomats.
“The Security Council must address the need to determine who is responsible for using chlorine as weapons in Syria,” said an American official, who declined to offer specifics and requested anonymity to discuss continuing negotiations. “Doing so is critical to getting justice for the Syrian people and accountability for those who have repeatedly used chemical weapons in Syria.”
Advertisement
Syrian state media dismiss the allegations as propaganda, and the Council remains divided and hamstrung. That leaves people like Mr. Abu Marwan, who has responded to nine suspected chlorine attacks, feeling abandoned. “There is no law to defend us as human beings, this is what we understand from the Security Council,” said Mr. Abu Marwan, a law school graduate, weeping as he recalled holding a dying child in Sarmeen. “I didn’t see in humanitarian law anything that says ‘except for Syrians.’ ”
You have the propaganda all there in a nutshell: the nefarious Assad; the hamstrung UNSC; the devoted, virtuous law-school graduate weeping with a dead gassed baby cradled in his arms. It is crass, and, at this point, tapped so often as it has been, it is ineffective. But the propaganda machine must extrude its product regardless of quality.

The "smoking gun" in the Barnard-Sengupta story is the helicopter. The chlorine gas is dropped in barrels by low-flying helicopters. We are supposed to baldly accept that only the Syrian government possesses helicopters. What the propagandists are attempting to capitalize on is the "barrel bombs" meme that the Western mainstream media has invested so robustly in. The reader has been conditioned to accept that the Syrian government and only the Syrian government bombs its people from the air by rolling barrels packed with explosives out of helicopters.

Hence, the conclusion to the Barnard-Sengupta piece:
A video taken Sunday in the town of Khansafra shows a barrel dropping from a helicopter and rescue workers holding up a portion of a canister labeled in English. The camera shakes, blurring all but a few words: “hazard,” “may cause irritation,” “caution,” “breathing.”
The obvious question is, Whose helicopter is it? Are there any markings? If it is a black helicopter, is there evidence that the Syrian government uses such helicopters?

An obvious question is, Why couldn't one of the Islamist jihadi groups, which have captured much Iraqi and Syrian military equipment, have piloted the helicopter?

The fact that Barnard and Sengupta give hardly a hint of the Iraqi Kurd reports from March that Islamic State used chlorine gas in attacks against its peshmerga is a strong tell that the two Gray Lady reporters are singing for their supper. Any open-minded reporter would explore the possibility that Nusra or ISIS could stage chlorine attacks. There is only this pro forma mention:
Frustrated with the Security Council’s impasse over the issue, rescue workers and doctors are now working to bring evidence of chlorine gas attacks directly to the French, British and American governments for testing. The aim is to give states a solid basis for action against the attacks, in the Security Council or through quieter diplomatic pressure, said James Le Mesurier, the British director of a nonprofit group, Mayday Rescue, that trains and equips the White Helmets, Syrian volunteers supported by the British, Danish and Dutch governments. 
Going directly to governments that have pushed for Mr. Assad’s ouster creates its own challenges. His allies may dismiss their evidence as politically tainted and can point to recent chlorine attacks in Iraq for which the government there blamed insurgents, not to mention the discredited American claims of an Iraqi chemical weapons program that were used to justify invading Iraq.
All we need to know about the recent spate of chlorine bomb attacks is that the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW), which set up a special mission last spring to look into the use of chlorine gas in Syria, won't endorse the claims that the Syrian government is to blame:
But investigators face difficulties. Chlorine dissipates quickly in the atmosphere and does not last in blood or urine, and residue stays in soil for just 48 hours, leaving little time to transport samples across borders. Also, Mr. Le Mesurier said, the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons differentiates evidence it collects itself from evidence collected by rescue workers, categorizing the latter as circumstantial.
Emergency workers said they met recently with investigators from the organization, but Dr. Tennari called the body’s response “poor and slow.” Mr. Le Mesurier remarked, “No one showed up on a white steed.”
Three other Syrian doctors said the organization’s rules resulted in valuable evidence they collected going unexamined. 
One, who protects his identity with the nickname “Chemical Hazem” for his safety, said he reached one of the April 2014 attack sites, Tal Minnes, within hours, smelling bleach in the air. He smuggled samples from two victims to Turkey without waiting for border clearances. But he said the O.P.C.W. refused to accept an unexploded canister, which remains in Syria. 
“The ultimate evidence of the regime’s use of chemical weapons is gone,” he said, adding that no one seemed interested in getting samples out of Syria. “We can’t blame anyone who wants to follow the legal channels — but do any exist?”

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

U.S. Hedges on Syrian Peace Talks + Minsk Ceasefire Fiction Evaporates + Garrow Maligns Black Lives Matter & Occupy Wall Street

I took the three-day holiday weekend as an opportunity to catch up on sleep. That's why this page has had only two short posts since Saturday. I slept. I exercised. I watched the conference championships on Sunday. Yesterday, rather than participating in the annual Martin Luther King Day rally and march, I stayed home and cleaned. I find that since my place of employment moved out of the city, lengthening my daily commute from 35-minute walk each way to a 90-minute walk-train-&-bus-ride both to and from the office, that I need a holiday just to scrub my stove top, dust and whatnot. Pretty pathetic.

The holiday weekend turned out to be a good one to hibernate. Anne Barnard did report a lethal Israeli strike on Hezbollah forces in southern Syria, which also managed to kill an Iranian general. Interpreted as part of the March 17 Knesset election campaign, a way for Netanyahu to look tough, Iran and Hezbollah will not overtly respond.

"U.S. Signals Shift on How to End Syrian Civil War," by Anne Barnard and Somini Sengupta, prominently featured on the Gray Lady's web site for the better part of a day, is obviously intended to announce USG's retreat from its Geneva II diktat that "Assad Must Go." It strikes me as nothing more than rhetoric though, an adjustment in State Department public diplomacy in the wake of the Charlie Hebdo massacre. People are once again awake to the role of key U.S. ally Saudi Arabia in exporting Wahhabism. It is difficult for the Unites States to be seen as on the side of jihadis now when the United Nations is working on an Aleppo ceasefire and Russia is holding peace talks on Syria. As Barnard and Sengupta write,
Juliette Touma, a spokeswoman for Mr. de Mistura [Staffan de Mistura, the United Nations envoy for the crisis in Syria], said that his plan would not resemble the past cease-fires, and that the United Nations, not the Syrian government, would be the guarantor. Yet even the modest Aleppo proposal is on shaky ground. While Mr. Assad has said he will consider it, his government has not signed off on the plan; Mr. de Mistura’s deputy arrived Sunday in Damascus for consultations. 
The Moscow talks are arguably in worse shape. While Mr. Kerry said he hoped the talks “could be helpful,” several crucial opposition groups have refused to attend and say the United States has not pressured them to go. 
That leaves American policy ambiguous, offering only modest verbal support to the new mediation efforts while continuing to finance some Syrian insurgents, yet not enough to seriously threaten Mr. Assad. Even a new program to train them to fight ISIS will not field fighters until May. 
Critics argue that Washington is simply trying to disengage and offload the Syria problem to Mr. Assad’s allies, Russia and Iran, even at the cost of empowering them. 
Still, any attempt to bring the parties to the table should be considered constructive, another Western diplomat said. “You can’t say to the Russians, ‘Go to hell.’ ”
Also in the news this weekend is increased fighting for the airport in Donetsk. Reports have gone back and forth. First, that DPR forces had finally gained control from the Ukrainian junta; then the junta counterattacked with tanks. An indication that the September Minsk ceasefire agreement is now largely worthless is that the Gray Lady is starting to report on the armed conflict in the Donbass again and doing so in terms found in Andrew Kramer's latest, "Ukraine Accuses Russia of Sending More Troops and Artillery to Aid Rebels":
MOSCOW — In as clear a sign as any of the unraveling peace process in eastern Ukraine, the authorities in Kiev accused Russia on Monday of again sending regular army soldiers into Ukraine to prop up pro-Russian separatists who were losing a battle. 
About 700 soldiers crossed Russia’s western border into the snowy war zone in eastern Ukraine, the Ukrainian National Security and Defense Council said in a statement that was not possible to verify independently. 
They came armed with a wide array of heavy weapons, Prime Minister Arseniy P. Yatsenyuk told journalists in Kiev, the capital. The country’s intelligence agencies “confirm that men and equipment entered from Russia,” he said. Howitzers and other artillery and antiaircraft systems were said to have crossed the border.
This repeats a well-worn pattern from last summer's fighting: the junta suffers a setback, a military defeat, and immediately a keening that "The Russians are coming! The Russians are coming!" commences in Kiev, in this case from the chief putschist and U.S. lackey, "Yats." I interpret this to mean that things are not going well for the Kiev junta.

Finally, a word about present-history and the Black Lives Matter protest movement. Tanzina Vega had a faintly praising, mostly critical assessment of the Mike Brown/Eric Garner police accountability/racial justice protests. One quote from her "Protesters Out to Reclaim King’s Legacy, but in Era That Defies Comparison" caught my eye; it was from David Garrow, establishment academic and Pulitzer-winning biographer of Martin Luther King, Jr.:
What is far less clear is whether today’s protesters have the ability, or even the intention, to build an organized movement capable of creating social change. 
David J. Garrow, a historian and the author of “Bearing the Cross: Martin Luther King Jr. and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference,” said the impromptu protests that had erupted in recent months were not comparable to the strategies used by civil rights groups of the 1960s, which had clear goals such as winning the right to vote or the right to eat at a segregated lunch counter. 
“You could call it rebellious, or you could call it irrational,” Mr. Garrow said of the new waves of protests. “There has not been a rational analysis in how does A and B advance your policy change X and Y?” 
Mr. Garrow compared the protesters to those of Occupy Wall Street. “Occupy had a staying power of, what, six months?” Mr. Garrow said. “Three years later, is there any remaining footprint from Occupy? Not that I’m aware of.”
Remaining "footprint from Occupy?" What about Obama's second term? During my hibernating weekend I watched a couple Frontline documentaries from a few years back. One was "Cliffhanger," about how Obama's failed "Grand Bargain" negotiations with Boehner ended up creating the "fiscal cliff" trade-off that was supposed to be resolved by whomever won the 2012 presidential election. What the Frontline documentary skipped was how Occupy Wall Street sprang to life after the 2011 debt-ceiling standoff that created the "fiscal cliff," and how Occupy Wall Street completely changed the frame of reference from a preoccupation with "crippling debt" to income inequality and how the system is rigged by the 1% against the 99%. Obama appropriated the Occupy Wall Street message for his general election campaign, siphoned off some of its activist energy, and went on to win his second landslide.

So don't accept elite dismissals of Occupy or Black Lives Matter. They are movements that are here to stay and will continue to have an impact.

Thursday, December 11, 2014

Strategy Behind Ongoing Campaign to Cover Up CIA Torture Program Revealed

A second day dawns following the release of the Senate report on CIA torture and it is clear where the action is. The action is going to be in holding the United States accountable to international legal conventions to which it is signatory.

The take-away from two different articles (one by Somini Sengupta, "Americans Involved in Torture Can Be Prosecuted Abroad, Analysts Say"; the other by Joseph Goldstein and Rick Gladstone, "Afghan Leader Expresses Shock at Torture Revelations") is a statement by United Nations high commissioner for human rights, Hashemite scion Prince Zeid Ra’ad Zeid al-Hussein, making clear that “The [International Convention on Torture] lets no one off the hook — neither the torturers themselves, nor the policy-makers, nor the public officials who define the policy or give the orders.”

The Obama administration has argued as recently as last month that the U.S. is in compliance with the International Convention on Torture because of a four-year Department of Justice criminal investigation into the CIA torture program led by federal prosecutor John H. Durham. Durham recommended against bringing charges and Attorney General Eric Holder agreed.

Now the Gray Lady is going to court to access documents from this DOJ investigation in order to allow the public to see some of the interviews with CIA officials and understand the reasoning why no charges were brought by Durham. Charlie Savage has the must-read story, "U.S. Tells Court That Documents From Torture Investigation Should Remain Secret":
Last month, in a presentation in Geneva before the United Nations Committee Against Torture, which oversees compliance with a global anti-torture treaty, the Obama administration pointed to Mr. Durham’s investigation as having fulfilled the United States’ obligation under the treaty to investigate torture. 
The United Nations panel expressed skepticism about the Durham investigation, pressing for details like whether Mr. Durham’s team had spoken only with government officials, or whether it also interviewed any current or former detainees as part of the investigation. A Justice Department lawyer who was part of the delegation defended the investigation as vigorous and told the committee that Mr. Durham’s team had interviewed about 96 witnesses. But he declined to identify them because no charges were filed. 
The Senate and Justice Department investigations trace back to a December 2007 article by The Times that the C.I.A. had destroyed videotapes of interrogation sessions. The Intelligence Committee started an oversight investigation, and the attorney general at the time, Michael B. Mukasey, appointed Mr. Durham to lead a criminal inquiry. 
In 2009, as President Obama took office, the committee voted to expand its investigation into the C.I.A. program. Months later, Mr. Holder announced that he was expanding Mr. Durham’s mandate to look into whether charges should be brought for any interrogation that went beyond approved techniques. 
In 2010, Mr. Durham, an assistant United States attorney in Connecticut, recommended against any charges connected with the tape destruction. The next year, he recommended closing the preliminary investigation into the treatment of about 100 detainees in C.I.A. custody, but elevated two other incidents that resulted in detainee deaths into full investigations. In 2012, he also recommended closing those without any indictments. 
“In light of our assessment of the evidence, the reports thoroughly analyzed the type and nature of criminal charges that could be brought against suspected wrongdoers, along with various defenses that could be raised in opposition to any such charges,” Mr. Durham wrote in his declaration filed on Tuesday. “The reports also discussed what the evidence showed and did not show, and evaluated previous investigations conducted by other entities.”
Accessing these investigatory documents could be the Rosetta Stone for deciphering the CIA torture program. That is why the Obama administration is going to court to block their release.

Charlie Savage does an excellent job concisely tracing the history of both the DOJ and Senate probes to the illegal destruction of the torture tapes in 2005.

Savage also does a superb job of deftly unpacking the mechanics of the cover-up actively perpetrated by the Obama administration. The main line of attack by the CIA and its Republican defenders is that the Senate report is false because it includes no interviews with CIA personnel responsible for the torture. That wasn't by choice of the Senate investigators; that was because CIA personnel wouldn't talk to Senate investigators because of Durham's active criminal investigation.

Savage deftly describes the mechanics of the ongoing cover-up:
The Justice Department said in a statement on Tuesday that its investigators had looked at the full version of the Senate Intelligence Committee report “and did not find any new information that they had not previously considered in reaching their determination,” adding that Mr. Durham’s “inquiry was extraordinarily thorough and we stand by our previously announced decision not to initiate criminal charges.” 
Mr. Holder’s decision in 2009 to open a criminal investigation into the C.I.A.’s treatment of detainees abroad had prompted a political backlash and made it difficult for congressional investigators to speak with current and former agency officials, since they faced legal jeopardy. 
Citing the fact that the Senate investigation would have to rely only on internal C.I.A. documents and not interviews with witnesses, committee Republicans withdrew their support for it. And since the report’s release, defenders of the C.I.A. have argued that the report should not be seen as an accurate and complete historical account.

Michael Davidson, who was the top lawyer for the Senate Intelligence Committee until his retirement in 2011 and who worked on the first four years of its investigation, portrayed the executive branch’s stance as a Catch-22. 
“One agency of the executive branch (the C.I.A.) complains that no one was interviewed,” he said in an email. “Another element of the executive branch (D.O.J.) actually conducted lots of interviews,” he added, referring to the Department of Justice.
“Its investigation made it difficult for a Senate committee to conduct interviews. So check there. Then D.O.J. objects to disclosing them. So checkmate there. That leaves the C.I.A. free to complain about lack of interviews. Pretty neat,” he said.
It is too early to say that we have to returned to the social ferment of the 1970s when the Church Committee and the Pike Committee shined a light on the CIA's family jewels, when the Weather Underground still roamed the land, when athletes were activists. But it seems like we're getting there.

Thursday, August 7, 2014

Gray Lady Reporter Finally Asks the Obvious, "Why No Action Against ISIS?"

As the Islamic State offensive wreaks havoc in Christian communities west of Mosul, sending refugees fleeing to the Kurdistan border and proving once again that the pesh merga have fallen short of their well-crafted reputation for martial prowess, the story to turn to is Somini Sengupta's,
"Islamic Militants in Iraq Are Widely Loathed, Yet Action to Curb Them Is Elusive."

Sengupta is the Gray Lady's United Nations reporter. She is a reliable parrot of whatever the company line is at the moment. But recently she has written some interesting stories, like last week's piece devoted to Israel's war on the UN. Today Sengupta takes on the question, albeit obliquely, that has been demanding an answer since ISIS rose to prominence last year: Why is there no coordinated action, no coalition of the willing, to roll back a terror group more fearsome than Al Qaeda ever was? Good question.

Never mind the decapitations, the crucifixions, the shrine demolitions, the vicious attacks on religious minorities, the oil and gas field seizures, the international recruitment of jihadis from seemingly every nation on the globe. What about the Global War on Terror (GWOT) according to which the West has reconfigured itself in the last 15 years? Aren't the trillions spent on national defense meant to prevent a movement like that represented by Islamic State from doing exactly what it is doing?

The answer that Sengupta comes up with? Basically, it is a version of, "It's complicated":
“With Iran and Saudi Arabia locked in a proxy war in Syria, Saudi Arabia competing with Qatar and Turkey for influence throughout the region, and Kurds — themselves hardly united — leaning ever further toward independence, it is not realistic to expect a coherent strategy for confronting ISIS to emerge from the region,” said Noah Bonsey, the Syria expert at the International Crisis Group. “The U.S. has the clout and capacity to build partnerships capable of reversing ISIS gains, but seems to lack the necessary vision and will.” [Note how the U.S. doesn't lack the "necessary vision and will" to foster a coup in the Ukraine, effectively paving the way for a new Cold War. Yet the U.S. cannot seem to find a way to confront its latest existential enemy, "Islamofascism."]
ISIS threatens not just Iraq and Syria. It has drawn fighters from countries as far-flung as India and China, Belgium and Britain. United Nations experts said fighters from rival jihadist groups, including the Nusra Front, an affiliate of Al Qaeda, have steadily defected to ISIS, because it has more money and guns. Military analysts say that it is exceedingly difficult to neutralize a group that now finances itself — it controls several oil fields in Iraq and Syria— and is heavily armed with weapons seized from both Iraqi and Syrian military bases.
***
The United States has plenty of reason to worry, said Julia McQuaid, an analyst at the Center for Naval Analyses in Arlington, Va., and not just because Western recruits to ISIS can come home and wreak havoc. 
ISIS propounds the idea of a Sunni “caliphate,” which by definition threatens the borders of nation-states. “While there should be little concern for any current jihadist movement successfully establishing a global caliphate under its banner,” Ms. McQuaid wrote in a blog post, the Islamic State’s model “may have profound implications on the security environment in other countries.”
No kidding.

The obvious answer as to why there has been no response from the greatest military power on the planet as the ISIS juggernaut gobbles up vital territory is that ISIS is a creation of U.S.-ally Saudi Arabia, and Washington and the House of Saud are using Islamic State to achieve strategic goals that could not otherwise be conventionally achieved, namely, partitioning Iraq, fracturing Syria, and pressuring Iran and Hezbollah. Where it will end we do not know. ISIS's clashing with Kurdistan represents a shift in the script since back in June when Mosul fell to the jihadi blitz, the Kurds, in what had to be a coordinated move, took Kirkuk. The pesh merga and Salafis assiduously avoided one another. Now they are fighting one another. And what provides proof that the U.S., so far at least, is firmly in the Saudi/ISIS camp is that Washington has not done much of anything to aid Erbil.

Yes, where the caliphate will stop nobody knows. We know that Afghanistan will soon return to the Taliban, and that the Taliban have same sponsor, the Saudis, as ISIS. We know that China is dealing with a shadowy Islamic insurrection in its western province of Xinjiang, not to mention pirate hijackings of tankers in the South China Sea that may have an origin in ISIS recruiting efforts in Malaysia. Then there is the case of the middle-class Indian Muslim men who disappeared to go fight with ISIS in Iraq. Islamic State apparently already has a toehold in the second-most-populated Muslim nation on the planet; the potential for mayhem -- think 2008 Mumbai Thanksgiving massacre -- is immense.

No, the main warfare state, the United States, is aligned here with Saudi Arabia, and its proxy, Islamic State, to make sure the planet has a "rosy future of war."

Friday, August 1, 2014

Israel's Lunacy

From 1 AM this morning until about 45 minutes ago, around 4:30 AM, a man shouted and sang on the street below my studio apartment. Whether he was insane, drunk or stoned was unclear to me. If I had to pick one, I would say the first. I am almost positive that he is the same guy, a young white man of the street, who I ran into early one perfect quiet sunny morning in June as I returned from a run. It was 9 AM. The neighborhood still slept. The morning sky was sunny blue clear. The birds sang and bees danced. Then shooting through this cinematic perfection was this angry insane ranting. I thought the guy might be frying on acid.

At 1 AM this morning it began with loud bellicose tuneless singing. Then it devolved into the pattern I was familiar with from the sunny morning in June. He calls out to some invisible interlocutor. Calls out a name. Says something like, "I'm here! I love you!" That repeats for a time and then trails off. After listening to this for 30 minutes, I drifted off to sleep, and when I started to dream I dreamed inside this young insane guy's patter. I was dreaming his insanity.

But at least I slept. When I woke at 4 AM, someone from one of the nearby apartment buildings was shouting down his own insanity -- I guess he was not so lucky as I in being able to sleep -- at the insane guy on the street below. Lots of insanity.

That is the world today. There are those of us who wake early every morning and study the news, note the contradictions in the official narrative provided by the media monopoly, attempt to draw attention to the pathological levels of violence practiced by the dominant powers, and basically make some attempt (in my case, quite meager) to point out the ruses, the lies, the divisiveness as the great game is played on the grand chessboard. We occupy what is known as the "lunatic fringe."

Real lunacy is on front-page display lately. Israel, in its slaughter of innocent women and children in Gaza, has now picked a fight with the United Nations. But before getting to that story, let us note that the Kerry-brokered ceasefire which began at 8 AM this morning has already collapsed. There was an exchange of fire between the IDF and Hamas at a tunnel in Rafah in southern Gaza. A Israeli soldier was captured by Hamas. Israel responded with saturation bombing of Rafah. According to Isabel Kershner and Fares Akram in "Gaza Cease-Fire Collapses; Israeli Soldier Is Captured":
Gaza health officials said that 35 Palestinians were killed and more than 100 wounded as Israeli forces bombarded the area. Palestinian witnesses said by telephone that Israeli tank shells hit eastern Rafah as residents returned to inspect homes they had evacuated. 
Hamas blamed Israel for violating the truce, saying in a statement that the announcement about the capture of one of its soldiers was “to cover up the barbaric massacres, especially in Rafah.”
The Kerry ceasefire lasted 90 minutes. How could it be sustained when it allowed the IDF to continue military operations against Palestinian "terror tunnels"? So it wasn't really a ceasefire to begin with; its short duration proved.

But on the front page of the Gray Lady this morning is the story penned by two reliable court scribes, Michael Gordon and Mark Landler, "Cease-Fire in Gaza Conflict Takes Effect as Talks Are Set," praising the U.S. Secretary of State for his hard work putting the ceasefire together. The idea was to have a ceasefire that would freeze the IDF's forward operations in Gaza but let it continue to root about for the "terror tunnels" in places it had troops. Hamas could respond if fired upon. In the meantime, all the players were rushing to Cairo to begin negotiations. The U.S. was sending heavy hitters like William Burns, the guy who got the nuclear talks with Iran cooking. The hope was that enough progress would be made in three days to extend the ceasefire.

An important passage in the Gordon/Landler story is the likely failure of any bargaining between Israel and Hamas:
The substance of the negotiations will be no less tricky than the choreography. Israel and Hamas have both said they will not be satisfied with a “quiet-for-quiet” deal like those that ended violence in 2012 and 2009. 
Hamas, and the broader Palestinian leadership, is demanding a lifting of all Israeli restrictions on import, export, farming and fishing, as well as an opening of the border crossings — which depends not only on Israel but on Egypt. 
Mr. Netanyahu has increasingly emphasized the need to demilitarize Gaza — a process that some say can be accomplished only by Israel effectively reoccupying Gaza — and will be looking for an international mechanism to guarantee that Hamas’ rocket stockpile will not be replenished and that it will not be able to dig new tunnels into Israel.
Mr. Abbas may have his own set of demands, like the release of long-serving prisoners in Israeli jails who were supposed to be freed as part of the American-brokered peace talks that collapsed in April. Hamas has also asked for the release of some 50 men, who were freed in a 2011 exchange for an abducted Israel soldier and rearrested during an Israeli crackdown in June.
With the collapse of the ceasefire and Israel's resumption of saturation bombing of defenseless civilians, the story to read is Somini Sengupta's "Tensions Escalate Between Israel and a Second Party in Gaza: The United Nations." Israel has declared war on the United Nations.

Gaza, since Israel's 2007 blockade, is now more than ever a United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) responsibility. UNRWA feeds 800,000 of Gaza's population of 1.7 million.
In public, the war of words intensified this week, with the United Nations blaming Israel for an attack that killed at least 19 people who were taking refuge at a United Nations school early Wednesday and Israel, in turn, accusing the world body of helping Hamas.
The United Nations has been dragged into the conflict: Eight of its staff members have been killed in the past 24 days, and more than 100 of its facilities have come under fire, including the school. United Nations officials said they had repeatedly told Israel of its exact location. 
The deputy secretary general, Jan Eliasson, a former Swedish diplomat, was visibly riled on Wednesday when he publicly reminded Israel of the Geneva Conventions, which established international law governing warfare. In Geneva, the United Nations’ top human rights official, Navi Pillay, raised the prospect of war crimes. 
Christopher Gunness, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency spokesman in Gaza, broke down at the end of an interview with Al Jazeera, which promptly went viral. And Pierre Krähenbühl, the commissioner general of Unrwa, the agency responsible for aiding Palestinians, told the Security Council on Thursday that military operations had been “waged with excessive — and at times disproportionate — force in densely populated urban settings.”
Israel has responded by mocking the UN as a tool of Hamas, a position that even the U.S. cannot parrot. This is from the Gordon and Landler story:
The White House on Thursday came closer than it had since the conflict began to criticizing Israel’s actions, saying it did not dispute the United Nations’ conclusion that Israel was responsible for the shelling. 
“What we are simply asking the Israelis to do — in fact, urging the Israelis to do — is to do more to live up to the standards that they have set for their own military operations to protect the lives of innocent civilians,” the press secretary, Josh Earnest, told reporters. 
Mr. Earnest called the strike on the school “totally unacceptable and totally indefensible.”
But behind closed doors, the United States is blocking any condemnation of Israel's bloody assault by the United Nations Security Council. Sengupta says:

Regardless of the verbal volleys, there is little that United Nations officials can do without instructions from the Security Council. The Council met Thursday for more than three hours behind closed doors, but failed to reach consensus on a proposed statement that would have condemned attacks on United Nations installations. Diplomats said they were stuck on language that would have also condemned the use of its facilities to store rockets. 
In the past, the United Nations has been useful in supporting political deals and keeping warring parties at bay in the Middle East: One of its first peacekeeping missions was in the Golan Heights. The tensions now may make it far more difficult for the United Nations to play that role. 
As the Security Council met behind closed doors, the Palestinian envoy, Riyad Mansour, shoulders hunched, rued that it had not taken any legally binding steps to end the fighting. “There’s a big test for the 15 members in the chamber as they are deliberating right now — I think tests to their hearts, tests to their conscience, tests to their brains — whether they’ll condemn these crimes,” Mr. Mansour said. 
Like his Israeli counterpart, he was not too bullish on the international community. He said the people of Gaza “feel the international community is failing them.”
Israel has gone too far. The BDS Movement will flourish. The Intifada will ignite the West Bank and Israel. The U.S. has no more moral legitimacy to shield Israel from the rest of the world.

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Lakhdar Brahimi Set to Resign as Special Envoy to Syria

Today United Nations and Arab League Special Envoy to Syria Lakhdar Brahimi meets first with Russian and U.S. diplomats; then Britain, China and France join the group, followed later in the day by Syria neighbors Iraq, Turkey, Jordan and Lebanon, as well as representatives from the Arab League. Nick Cumming-Bruce and Alan Cowell have the story from Geneva, "Diplomats Try to Push Syria Peace Conference."

This is the last gasp for Geneva II. If peace talks don't get off the ground Brahimi is set to resign. This is from Somini Sengupta's profile "Few Eager to Talk Peace in Syria, but a Mediator Won’t Stop":
A former United Nations official who has spoken to Mr. Brahimi recently described him as “his own greatest skeptic.” 
“He thinks if talks do happen, it’s by no means assured anything concrete will come out of it,” said the former diplomat, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the talks were private, adding that he believed that if Geneva II did not happen in the next few weeks, Mr. Brahimi would step down. 
He has once before, under somewhat similar circumstances. Mr. Brahimi spent two years, starting in 1997, trying to stanch low-intensity fighting between the Taliban and Northern Alliance fighters in Afghanistan. 
He talked to commanders on the ground and every neighboring country that had influence over them before finally resigning in September 1999. 
“We kept going around in circles, the fighting continued, and the people of Afghanistan were held hostage to those groups whose interest seemed to be in the continuation of the conflict, not in its solution,” he said in a speech last year. He said he told the Security Council that “I was giving up because I felt I had no real support from them.”
Afghanistan is what Syria is to become if it isn't already -- a failed state rife with heavy machine gun toting jihadis. Cumming-Bruce and Cowell quote the latest data:
The talks in Geneva opened against a backdrop of increasing humanitarian alarm in Syria. 
According to the United Nations, the number of Syrians needing help has surged to 9.3 million from 6.8 million in June. The figure represents some 40 percent of the estimated 23 million people in a country that has been seized by conflict since a crackdown on peaceful protest against President Assad began in March 2011. 
Since then, more than 110,000 people have died and, while Mr. Assad has agreed to dismantle chemical weapons stockpiles, fighting with conventional munitions still claims a daily toll, forcing many to flee their homes and blocking efforts to deliver humanitarian assistance. 
Valerie Amos, the top humanitarian official at the United Nations, told the Security Council on Monday that the number who have abandoned their homes but remained in Syria stood at 6.5 million compared to 4.25 million in June. Her remarks in a closed briefing to the Security Council were relayed by a spokeswoman, Amanda Pitt. 
“The humanitarian situation in Syria continues to deteriorate rapidly and inexorably,” Ms. Amos said.
And it will continue to deteriorate because the Obama administration talks out of both sides of its mouth: working to get Geneva II up and running at the same time it assures the Saudis it is on the same page. This was on vivid display with Kerry's visit to Cairo just prior to the opening of the show trial of ousted president Mohamed Morsi. This is from a story by the excellent David Kirkpatrick and Mayy El Sheikh, "Egypt’s Ex-President Is Defiant at Murder Trial":
And the timing, analysts said, also proved awkward for Secretary of State John Kerry. On a visit to Cairo just a day before, he had said that — despite a series of mass killings of protesters, the shutdown of opposition news media outlets and apparently politicized trials like Mr. Morsi’s — “there are indications” that the generals who ousted Egypt’s first freely elected president intended to restore democracy. 
The visit was “unbelievable timing,” said Michael Wahid Hanna, an Egypt scholar at the Century Foundation in New York. He argued that opponents of the Islamists would see the trip as an American effort to protect Mr. Morsi, while Islamists would hear Mr. Kerry’s “soft and optimistic statements as a U.S. blessing to the new military-led political order.”
The Saudis are rattled because they don't think -- based on Obama's failure to launch a strike against Damascus at the end of summer -- that the United States is willing to unilaterally exercise its "full spectrum" dominance. Kerry was in Riyadh to assure the House of Saud that its security is guaranteed. This is from Michael Gordon's report, "Kerry Reassures Saudis U.S. Shares Their Goals":
Differences between the Obama administration and the Saudi leadership burst into view last month after Prince Bandar bin Sultan, the head of Saudi intelligence, privately complained to diplomats about the White House’s reluctance to intervene in Syria — concerns that were later echoed publicly by Prince Turki al-Faisal, a former intelligence chief. 
At the root of much of the Saudis’ criticism was the perception that President Obama was uncomfortable with exercising power on the world stage, a gnawing worry for Saudi officials who have become increasingly concerned about the role of their nemesis Iran in Syria and elsewhere in the region. 
As much as American officials sought to dispel such criticism, the fact that the Obama administration has felt it necessary to offer such assurances has highlighted the strains. 
Mr. Kerry said at the news conference that Mr. Obama had told him to make clear to Saudi Arabia that the United States would defend the kingdom from external attack — a public promise that American officials would not have found necessary to make several years ago.
What the Saudis don't seem to appreciate is that the American system of government is based on a duopoly, a kabuki of "indispensable enemies" where trenchant foes come together and divvy up the loot. Foreign policy, particularly nasty foreign entanglements like imperial wars, has traditionally been a bipartisan affair. When you get real change in this country — i.e., the Civil War — it is preceded by a break down in the duopoly.

That's what we are starting to experience now -- a breakdown in the duopoly. The Republican Party is at war with itself, a war hastened by Obama's 2008 landslide election, similar to but nowhere nearly as radical as the Democratic Party split after Lincoln's election in 1860.

Obama would have liked to have delivered that attack on Syria that his allies wanted but he knew that to do so could have precipitated a catastrophic system failure of the duopoly, splintering not only the GOP but his party as well.

Kerry will kiss the rings that need to kissed; he will kneel and scrape. Peace talks will not happen. Brahimi will resign. War will rage on.