Showing posts with label Thom Shanker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thom Shanker. Show all posts

Thursday, September 19, 2013

Elites Mewl Diminished Imperial Prerogative

Al Qaeda affiliate Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) took control of the Syrian border town of Azaz, routing the Free Syrian Army rebels. This is from a story by Ben Hubbard and Karam Shoumali, "Extremists Take Syrian Town Near Turkey Border":
The takeover also signals a new low in relations between the rebels fighting a civil war against Mr. Assad’s forces and international jihadists who have flocked to rebel-controlled areas to lay the groundwork for an Islamic state. 
For much of the 30-month-old conflict, the rebels welcomed jihadist fighters for the know-how and battlefield prowess they brought to the anti-Assad struggle. In recent months, however, jihadist groups have isolated local populations by imposing strict Islamic codes, carrying out public executions and clashing with rebel groups. 
In the eastern city of Deir al-Zour on Wednesday, extremist fighters took dozens of rebels captive after a gunfight near a rebel base, activists said. 
Reached by telephone, a rebel commander who gave only his first name, Khattab, said that Wednesday’s violence in Azaz began when ISIS fighters stormed the town and tried to detain German doctors who were visiting a hospital.
Turkey responded by closing one of its border crossings.

Elites continue to complain about Obama's decision to go to Congress for authorization to illegally attack Syria; it is considered a significant rollback of the imperial presidency. The story, "Former Defense Secretaries Criticize Obama on Syria," by Thom Shanker and Lauren D'Avolio, about comments by former Obama SecDefs Robert Gates and Leon Panetta regarding the commander-in-chief's handling of Syrian crisis, had the following lines that caught my eye:
Although Mr. Gates said that any unilateral military action against Syria would be a mistake, he also said it was unwise for the president to have sought Congressional authorization to use force, because of the risk to presidential prestige if he was rebuffed. 
If Congress voted no, “it would weaken him,” Mr. Gates said. “It would weaken our country. It would weaken us in the eyes of our allies, as well as our adversaries around the world.”
In other words, it doesn't matter that the most favorable outcome was achieved -- a wider war was avoided, large amounts of chemical weapons will be decommissioned, and the Constitution was honored -- because there was a risk to presidential prestige. This is what qualifies as sagacity in elite circles. Clearly it is insane, the product of a shit-sniffing, addled old courtier; but it is the conventional wisdom of the Washington smart set.

Having been on the losing side of a propaganda war that has raged since Monday when the United Nations released the Sellstrom report on the August 21 Ghouta chemical attack, Russia and Syria finally got off the ropes. For instance, Assad was interviewed on the Fox Network by former presidential aspirant and Congressman Dennis Kucinich, something of a public relations coup since Kucinich still has some chops, albeit waning, among progressives and Fox caters to an audience of hard-shell conservative know-nothing types. This is the type of "unholy alliance" that blocked Obama's AUMF in Congress and has elites like Panetta and Gates mewling about the diminishment of imperial prerogative.

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

AIPAC vs. The American Public

At the end of this morning's story "House Leaders Express Their Support for Syria Strike," by Mark Landler, Michael Gordon and Thom Shanker, finally comes a mention of the reality that Obama and his war cabinet are trying to subvert:
The calendar is Mr. Obama’s enemy: Many members from both parties are still back in their districts hearing from constituents, and the feedback, based on numerous interviews, is overwhelmingly negative. 
On Tuesday, however, a powerful pro-Israel lobbying group, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, threw its support behind military action in Syria, citing the need to send a strong message to Iran and the militant group Hezbollah, both of which support Mr. Assad.
Any gauge of sanity and basic fairness, given the decade-plus ongoing foreign occupations following 9/11 and the recent Snowden revelations of an omnipresent surveillance state that has metastasized since then, has the American public clearly in the right on this issue. Public opinion was wrong to support Bush II's invasion of Iraq, but Cheney, Wolfowitz, Rumsfeld & Co. were shrewd in their use of the fear and anger 9/11 created to sow enough confusion with their bogus intelligence to pull off the crime (so far) of the century.

Now is a different time. We're coming to the end of the 9/11 era, which also happens to be the end of the Arab Spring. People might have looked the other way on Libya because of a heady rush caused by toppling Arab dictators, but no mas. The 2012 Benghazi attack put to rest the fallacy of a problem-free intervention.

The American citizenry has been treated to a series of budget crises by a divided national political class. And suddenly that political class is coming together, but not to fund a public works project or expand early childhood education. No, the national political leadership is joined in an embrace of the Obama request for an Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF). In other words, folks, you get to carry and pay for guns but you get no butter.

And the public understands the screwing it's getting. Support for bombing Syria has not grown since the Obama team has "flooded the zone" and the nation's fourth estate has resumed its role from the run up to Iraq's invasion -- cheerleader for illegal warfare and megaphone of tendentious intelligence. It is unquestioned in the Western media that the Syrian government is responsible for attacking the Damascus suburb of Ghouta. The unverified death toll of 1,400 is unquestioned as well. Pleas to "Save the children!" are made incessantly by beautiful, young cable news anchors. But despite all this American public opinion is unmoved.

This is not to say that the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) doesn't have a few tricks left to pull on us. Opinion might tilt a few points in the direction of launching the Tomahawks. But I don't think so. I think this will be a clear case of "which side are you on?" The 10-7 vote in the Senate Foreign Relations Committee augurs a divided Senate. But the real challenge for AIPAC and other warhawks will be in the House.

If the AUMF passes the House of Representatives, given everything that we've been through since the millennium, I think it's safe to say that electoral democracy is officially dead in this country.

Friday, August 30, 2013

Obama's Political Immolation

If you've been following the news on Syria every day, you know that the case that the United States has presented blaming the Syrian government for a chemical attack in a Damascus suburb last week is weak to nonexistent. For instance, you would expect banner headlines the morning after the Obama administration's briefing last night of Congressional leaders if there had been any compelling, "smoking gun" proof that Assad's forces were responsible. Instead all you get is a description -- inside the story "Obama Set for Limited Strike on Syria as British Vote No" by Mark Landler, David Sanger and Thom Shanker -- of heavy hitters on Obama's cabinet going through the tired motions of trying to sell an intercepted telephone call between military officials as definitive proof justifying scrapping international law in order to let the Tomahawk cruise missiles fly:
In a conference call with Republicans and Democrats, top officials from the State Department, the Pentagon and the nation’s intelligence agencies asserted that the evidence was clear that Mr. Assad’s forces had carried out the attack, according to officials who were briefed. 
While the intelligence does not tie Mr. Assad directly to the attack, these officials said, the administration said the United States had both the evidence and legal justification to carry out a strike aimed at deterring the Syrian leader from using such weapons again. 
A critical piece of the intelligence, officials said, is an intercepted telephone call between Syrian military officials, one of whom seems to suggest that the chemical weapons attack was more devastating than was intended. “It sounds like he thinks this was a small operation that got out of control,” one intelligence official said. 
But Republican lawmakers said White House officials dismissed suggestions that the scale of the attack was a miscalculation, indicating that the officials believe Syria intended to inflict the widespread damage. 
“I’m comfortable that the things the president told Assad not to do he did,” said Senator Lindsey Graham, Republican of South Carolina, who took part with seven other Republican senators in a separate briefing by the White House chief of staff, Denis R. McDonough. 
Among the officials on the conference call were Secretary of State John Kerry; Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel; the director of national intelligence, James R. Clapper Jr.; and the national security adviser, Susan E. Rice. It was unclassified, which means the administration gave lawmakers only limited details about the intelligence they assert bolsters the case for a military strike. 
Before the call, however, some prominent lawmakers expressed anger that the White House was planning a strike without significant consultations with Congress. “When we take what is a very difficult decision, you have to have buy-in by members and buy-in by the public,” Representative Mike Rogers, the Michigan Republican who is chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, said Thursday on MSNBC. “I think both of those are critically important and, right now, none of that has happened.”
If there had been definitive proof Cameron wouldn't have gone down in flames in the House of Commons yesterday.

Everywhere you look Obama is on shaky ground. No compelling evidence has been presented to justify a unilateral assault on a sovereign nation. International law will be violated if such an attack takes place. And so far the only ally to come forward vowing support is the Socialist government of Francois Hollande.

The damage that Obama is doing to his ability to govern is enormous. The source of his political power, his success as a politician both nationally and internationally, is his standing as an anti-war advocate and as proponent for peace and toleration. He beat Hillary Clinton and rose to the top of a crowded field of primary contenders in 2008 because as a Illinois state senator he came out against going to war in Iraq. Starting with the Snowden revelations and his peevish response to them, and now coming full force with his disingenuous case for an attack on Syria, Obama is eviscerating the basis of his support.

Obama has three-and-a-half years left to govern, and he is effectively mortally wounded. It's not clear going forward what impact this is going to have -- on budget negotiations with a belligerent GOP House caucus, on his ability to get any legislation through Congress, on midterm elections and the short-term viability of the national Democratic Party.

There are five destroyers in the eastern Mediterranean. Each has a payload of 36 cruise missiles. As a baseline that's what the Syrians can expect -- a barrage of 180 missiles. It will probably be worse, and it will probably commence not too long after the UN inspectors exit the country. Sunday morning? Nothing will likely be achieved other than destruction, death and Obama's political immolation. At this point, there might a silver lining in the last item.

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

War for as Far as the Eye Can See

The news from yesterday is that ministers for the European Union declared Lebanon's Hezbollah a terrorist organization. Hezbollah responded dryly with the statement, “It appears that the decision was written with an American hand in Zionist ink.” This from an article, "European Union Adds Military Wing of Hezbollah to List of Terrorist Organizations," by James Kanter and Jodi Rudoren. Since the blacklist covers only Hezbollah's military operation, much of which is kept confidential, and not the many social organizations that the Party of God operates, it is unclear how much of an impact the EU decision will have:
After the decision, [William] Hague [British foreign secretary] sought to reassure member states that support for Lebanon, including significant aid payments, would remain intact.
Kamel Wazne, a Lebanese analyst and director of the Beirut-based Center for American Strategic Studies, said that by designating only the military wing of Hezbollah, the Europeans appeared to want to maintain dialogue with others in the group, including members of Parliament and the cabinet. He doubted such a strategy would work.
Others called the European Union’s action a significant setback for Hezbollah, partly because it could provide the United States with a new legal basis for strengthening its own sanctions against Hezbollah’s commercial and fund-raising activities in a way that could then pressure the Europeans to do the same.
The toughened European sanctions against Iran, including an oil boycott, evolved in the same way under American pressure, said Mark Dubowitz, executive director of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, a group in Washington that supports sanctions. “Today’s military designation was a powerful symbolic blow,” he said. “It hasn’t been a death blow. But it’s certainly laid an important predicate.”
A bigger story in today's New York Times is from Mark Landler and Thom Shanker, "Pentagon Lays Out Options for U.S. Military Effort in Syria." Joint Chiefs chairman General Martin Dempsey enumerates in a letter to Senate Armed Services Committee chairman Carl Levin the military options available for intervention in the Syrian civil war. Never mind the lack of public support for another war in the Middle East. Never mind that the opposition against the Syrian government is led by forces that the United States is at war with. The only important thing is that al-Assad must go, even if it creates an enormous failed state in the heart of the Middle East.

To Dempsey's credit, he alludes to all this, albeit gingerly. The options for intervention are listed as follows:
If ordered by the president, General Dempsey wrote, the military is ready to carry out options that include efforts to train, advise and assist the opposition; conduct limited missile strikes; set up a no-fly zone; establish buffer zones, most likely across the borders with Turkey or Jordan; and take control of Mr. Assad’s chemical weapons stockpile. 
“All of these options would likely further the narrow military objective of helping the opposition and placing more pressure on the regime,” General Dempsey wrote. But he added: “Once we take action, we should be prepared for what comes next. Deeper involvement is hard to avoid.”
Dempsey says that it will cost $1 billion a month to impose a no-fly zone.

Clearly the Pentagon, at least the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, is mindful of the folly of declaring war on Syria. But this doesn't faze the people's elected representatives, who are going ahead with support for Obama's covert war conducted out of Jordan:
The plan to supply the rebels with small arms and other weaponry is being run as a covert operation by the Central Intelligence Agency, and General Dempsey made no mention of it in his letter. 
On Monday, Representative Mike Rogers, a Michigan Republican who heads the House Intelligence Committee, said that despite “very strong concerns about the strength of the administration’s plans in Syria and its chances for success,” the panel had reached a consensus to move ahead with the White House’s strategy, without specifically mentioning the covert arms program. Senate Intelligence Committee officials said last week that they had reached a similar position. 
A Syrian opposition leader said in an e-mail Monday night that with the Congressional reservations largely addressed, American arms would most likely begin flowing to the rebels within a few weeks. “We think August is the date,” the official said. 
In an interview, Lakhdar Brahimi, the United Nations special envoy to Syria, expressed disappointment at the Congressional approval. “Arms do not make peace,” he said. “We would like to see the delivery of arms stopped to all sides.”
In anticipation of the arrival of weaponry, jihadi fighting units are scrubbing religious names in favor of innocuous labels like "9th Brigade." But Congressional reservations are not largely addressed. Politico is reporting that a vote is forthcoming in the House on whether the military aid is consistent with the War Powers Act.

One Obama administration shift noted by Landler and Shanker is the acknowledgement that the Baathist-led Syrian government is not going anywhere anytime soon:
[T]he White House began publicly hedging its bets about Mr. Assad. After saying for nearly two years that Mr. Assad’s days were numbered, the press secretary, Jay Carney, said, “While there are shifts in momentum on the battlefield, Bashar al-Assad, in our view, will never rule all of Syria again.”
Those last four words represent a subtle but significant shift in the White House’s wording: an implicit acknowledgment that after recent gains by the government’s forces against an increasingly chaotic opposition, Mr. Assad now seems likely to cling to power for the foreseeable future, if only over a rump portion of a divided Syria.
Covert support for one side, dominated by Wahhabi jihadists, in a civil war where the other side is supported by Mother Russia -- we've seen this before in Afghanistan, and it didn't end well; in fact, it's still playing out, with the full impact of negative repercussions yet to be tallied. One thing is for sure, war fills the horizon for as far as the eye can see.

Sunday, June 16, 2013

Sunni Clerics Calling for Holy War

The sectarian unraveling of the Middle East along a Sunni-Shiite divide is consistently presented in the Western media as the fault of Bashar al-Assad and his Iranian allies and Hezbollah. But this morning's news -- reported in "U.S. to Keep Warplanes in Jordan, Pressing Syria," by Michael R. Gordon and Thom Shanker -- that Egyptian president Mohamed Morsi is severing diplomatic ties with Syria is yet more proof, along with the news from late last week of Sunni clerics in Cairo issuing fatwas calling for jihad against Syria, that the fires of sectarian region-wide warfare are being stoked by Sunni fundamentalists. Morsi, following his usual pattern, is no doubt following orders issued in Saudi Arabia.

As the United States positions Patriot missiles and F-16s in Jordan for the foreseeable future to provide protection for the CIA's ongoing rebel training program, it is hard to see anything but a larger war coming down the pike. Gordon and Shanker note that the Obama administration, despite the constant invocation of a "political settlement," has given up on Geneva II for the time being:
Mr. Kerry flew to Moscow last month and secured Russia’s agreement to hold an international conference that would bring the Assad government and the Syrian opposition to the negotiating table to try to bring an end to the fighting. Since then, however, the Obama administration has become concerned that the advances made by pro-government forces would give Mr. Assad little reason to negotiate a political transition in which he would give up power. 
As a result, White House and State Department officials now favor delaying the talks. Supplying arms to the rebels, officials have said, is partly intended to turn the tide enough to force a real negotiation. Mr. Lavrov, by contrast, argued for moving forward with the international conference on Syria.
For a sober point-by-point refutation of the current bellicose course of United States policy read Ramzy Mardini's opinion piece, "Bad Idea, Mr. President," which appears today in the New York Times Sunday Review:
Interventionists tend to detach their actions from longer-term consequences. This myopia is often coupled with a prevalent misunderstanding of the political and cultural context of where they want to intervene. Both problems are present in the current American approach to Syria.
The Syrian revolution isn’t democratic or secular; the more than 90,000 fatalities are the result of a civil war, not a genocide — and human rights violations have been committed on both sides. 
Moreover, the rebels don’t have the support or trust of a clear majority of the population, and the political opposition is neither credible nor representative. Ethnic cleansing against minorities is more likely to occur under a rebel-led government than under Mr. Assad; likewise, the possibility of chemical weapons’ falling into the hands of terrorist groups only grows as the regime weakens. 
And finally, a rebel victory is more likely to destabilize Iraq and Lebanon, and the inevitable disorder of a post-Assad Syria constitutes a greater threat to Israel than the status quo.
Civil war has returned to Iraq. The death toll has returned to a level not seen since 2008. To answer Mardini, the conclusion one must come to is that war, not long-term strategic interest, is what motivates Western policy makers. A piggish love of war.

Saturday, December 1, 2012

Safe Bet: No Cliff Fall

Two items from yesterday's paper leave me convinced that Boehner's flat rejection of Geithner's proposal to avoid going off the fiscal cliff is just posturing.  First, from Jonathan Weisman's story, I was not aware that the cliff includes an enormous increase in the estate tax:

[Obama] also wants the estate tax to be levied at 45 percent on inheritances over $3.5 million, a step several Democratic senators balked at. The Senate bill made no changes to the estate tax, which currently taxes inheritances over $5 million at 35 percent. On Jan. 1, the estate tax is scheduled to rise to 55 percent beginning with inheritances exceeding $1 million.
Next, a story from Thom Shanker that the Pentagon has no Plan B on the shelf if we do go off the cliff: "[A] range of Defense Department and military officials say there is no formal planning under way on how the Pentagon budget could or should be trimmed further."  The feeling is that even if a deal is brokered that avoids "Cuts of $500 billion over the next 10 years, representing roughly 5 to 8 percent of the Pentagon’s budget," cuts are coming no matter what.  So why whet Congressional appetite?

Given this, Pentagon avoidance combined with a significant estate tax increase, the safe bet is that we will not go off the fiscal cliff.  Whether a Leftist or Rightist, all can acknowledge that concentrated wealth and the Department of Defense are scared objects in the church of American politics.