Showing posts with label estate tax. Show all posts
Showing posts with label estate tax. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Senate Passes Fiscal Cliff Deal

I awoke this morning in the New Year -- a few revelers still making noise on the street below -- to learn that the Senate passed in a 89-8 vote what's being called the McConnell-Biden Plan, details of which are compactly supplied in a New York Times sidebar.

The top tax rate for individuals earning above $400,000 a year, $450,000 for couples, reverts to the Clinton-era 39.6%, and capital gains and dividend taxes go from 15% to 20% for these earners; also, personal exemptions and deductions are phased out for singles making more than $200,000 and couples making more than $250,000.  The deal is projected to generate $600 billion in new revenue over ten years.

Where the administration got rolled was on the estate tax which bumped up a modest 5%, from 35% to 40%, on inheritances over $5 million.  Right now until the House passes the McConnell-Biden Plan and Obama signs it estates over $1 million are taxed at 55%.  This is a big giveaway and a huge loss of leverage.  Apparently Obama was pressured by some Democrats in Senate to go easy on concentrated wealth.

What the administration got was a one-year extension of emergency unemployment benefits (which are absolutely vital to millions of people), a permanent indexing of the alternative minimum tax for inflation, and an extension for five years of the middle-class tax cuts in the 2009 stimulus bill -- the child tax credit, an expanded earned income credit and a college tuition credit.

What all workers lost and what was never really on the table to maintain was the payroll tax holiday of 2%.  Most of us will notice a smaller paycheck in the next couple of weeks.

Overall no one appears satisfied with the McConnell-Biden Plan.  David Brooks supplies the consensus opinion that all this deal portends is more conflict: "Far from laying the groundwork for future cooperation, it sentences the country to another few years of budget trench warfare. There will be a fight over drastic spending cuts known as sequestration, then over the debt limit and on and on."  Then he proceeds to blame the dysfunctionality of our political economy on voters who feel entitled to health care when they retire; not a word about rising inequality or the outsized role of a too-big-to-fail financial sector.

Jonathan Weisman tells us what's in store the next couple of months:
The nature of the deal ensured that the running war between the White House and Congressional Republicans on spending and taxes would continue at least until the spring. Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner formally notified Congress that the government reached its statutory borrowing limit on New Year’s Eve. Through some creative accounting tricks, the Treasury Department can put off action for perhaps two months, but Congress must act to keep the government from defaulting just when the “pause” on pending cuts is up. Then in late March, a law financing the government expires.
We'll hit the debt ceiling at the same time the two-month hold on the sequester expires.  Then after that, assuming we make it through without a default, we have to negotiate the continuing resolution that keeps the government running.

Paul Krugman frames the big picture on his blog this morning.  After being critical of the McConnell-Biden Plan as it was coming to fruition he is more positive today.  Neither Medicare nor Social Security is tomahawked, and the difference in new revenue between what Obama originally proposed and what he got is not a big deal when looked at in terms of GDP.  Krugman explains why it is the McConnell-Biden Plan leaves this bachelor feeling lousy:
So why the bad taste in progressives’ mouths? It has less to do with where Obama ended up than with how he got there. He kept drawing lines in the sand, then erasing them and retreating to a new position. And his evident desire to have a deal before hitting the essentially innocuous fiscal cliff bodes very badly for the confrontation looming in a few weeks over the debt ceiling.

If Obama stands his ground in that confrontation, this deal won’t look bad in retrospect. If he doesn’t, yesterday will be seen as the day he began throwing away his presidency and the hopes of everyone who supported him. 
Maybe the House will do us a favor and vote McConnell-Biden down.

Thursday, December 13, 2012

The Woes of the Speaker of the House

Boehner has trouble with his caucus.  The gist of today's fiscal cliff story from Jonathan Weisman is captured in the quote from Democratic leader Chris Van Hollen:
“The biggest impediment right now is the speaker’s ability to get a decent number of Republican votes for an agreement,” said Representative Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, who is the lead Democrat on the House Budget Committee.

“I’m getting increasingly concerned that one of the reasons the speaker is deciding to, I think, string out these discussions is that he wants to wait until Jan. 3, when the election for speaker takes place,” he said.
Which makes sense.  It appears the only way that the fiscal cliff is going to be resolved in the next two weeks is if Boehner can bring something back to the House for a vote, knowing full well that by doing so he might have to rely on Democrats and not Republicans to get it passed.  According to Van Hollen, Boehner is unwilling to do this; he wants to wait until his leadership position is secure.

Officially Boehner's bargaining position is unchanged.  He opposes an increase in tax rates for the rich; accepts the need to raise revenue in the amount of $800 billion by altering the tax code to close loopholes; and is waiting for Obama to agree to a major entitlement change, e.g., raising the Medicare eligibility age.  Unofficially Boehner is reported to be willing to accept an increase in tax rates for the rich as long he gets the Medicare change and/or a COLA reduction for Social Security.

Obama has been here once before, with the summer of 2011 debt ceiling negotiations, and he got burned.  He acquiesced to entitlement cuts, got outed, and then Boehner couldn't deliver.  Obama is not stupid.  He will not make the same mistake twice.  And the reason he won't, all strategy aside, is that the facts are overwhelming regarding the enormous redistribution of wealth over the last 30 years to the top 1%.  This from an excellent story today by Annie Lowrey:
The Congressional Budget Office has found that between 1979 and 2007, the top 1 percent of households saw their inflation-adjusted income grow 275 percent. For the bottom 20 percent, it grew just 18 percent, and federal tax and transfer programs also did less and less to reduce income inequality over that period.

The mounting concentration of wealth is even more dramatic. A recent Economic Policy Institute study found that between 1983 and 2010 about three-quarters of all new wealth accrued to the wealthiest 5 percent of households. Over the same period, the bottom 60 percent actually became poorer.
As we enter the third week of December I don't see that anything much has really changed.  Because of the Mad Mullahs in his conference Boehner doesn't feel like he can deliver anything unless he has big entitlement cuts, cuts which come at the expense of a working class that has been hammered decade after decade.  It's the debt ceiling negotiations all over again; it's as if the 2012 election never happened.  The wild card in all this is the rapid approach of Mad Mullah paradise, the debt limit.  I saw an interview the other day with Jackie Calmes.   She said a stumbling block in the talks has been the unwillingness of Republicans to bargain away their vote to raise the government's borrowing limit.

So the action over the next two weeks is going to be in what gets peeled off from the fiscal cliff negotiations and passed on its own.  Pay attention because what Congress decides to deal with by December 31 is what is really important to the people in power.  An argument can be made, and there are mentions of it in the press, that the Bush tax cuts will be extended for the 98%.  It could happen.  Politicians are interested in reelection.  But I see movement foremost on the estate tax, maybe in combination with an extension in emergency unemployment benefits.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Other Taxes on the Table Besides Income

The last fews days there has been a noticeable reduction in fiscal cliff coverage.  I interpret this as a sign that neogiations are being conducted in earnest.

Today Brian Knowlton and Jackie Calmes have a story about a one-on-one meeting in the White House yesterday between Boehner and Obama; also, they mention GOP Senator Bob Corker's appearance on "Fox News Sunday" where he argued that his party should publicly concede the debate over raising the top tax rates in order to shift the focus to entitlement cuts.

Jackie Calmes had a front page story in the Sunday paper yesterday on revenue arithmetic.  Raising the top tax rates only gets Obama a quarter of his desired $1.6 trillion in new revenue over 10 years:

Seldom mentioned is that Mr. Obama’s revenue total also reflects four other changes from Bush-era tax cuts: higher tax rates on investment income from capital gains and dividends, and the restoration of two other Clinton-era provisions limiting deductions and tax exemptions for affluent individuals.

Together those changes would raise $407.4 billion over a decade — nearly as much as the president’s proposal on higher rates, which would raise $441.6 billion by 2023, for a total of $849 billion. Another $119 billion would come from higher estate taxes, opposed by Republicans and some Democrats.

And both the president and Republicans are committed to raising hundreds of billions of dollars by overhauling the tax code to further limit or end the tax breaks that high-income taxpayers can claim, though they differ in how to do that.
The Counterpunch left is convinced Obama is a Manchurian Candidate for the plutocracy and that a large, painful selling out on Medicare and Social Security is coming our way.  If this proves true then I will have been wrong about Obama.  I suppose a red line for me is the eligibility age for Medicare.  If it goes up as part of the bargain to avoid the fiscal cliff then I think we've been sold down the river.

Saturday, December 1, 2012

Safe Bet: No Cliff Fall

Two items from yesterday's paper leave me convinced that Boehner's flat rejection of Geithner's proposal to avoid going off the fiscal cliff is just posturing.  First, from Jonathan Weisman's story, I was not aware that the cliff includes an enormous increase in the estate tax:

[Obama] also wants the estate tax to be levied at 45 percent on inheritances over $3.5 million, a step several Democratic senators balked at. The Senate bill made no changes to the estate tax, which currently taxes inheritances over $5 million at 35 percent. On Jan. 1, the estate tax is scheduled to rise to 55 percent beginning with inheritances exceeding $1 million.
Next, a story from Thom Shanker that the Pentagon has no Plan B on the shelf if we do go off the cliff: "[A] range of Defense Department and military officials say there is no formal planning under way on how the Pentagon budget could or should be trimmed further."  The feeling is that even if a deal is brokered that avoids "Cuts of $500 billion over the next 10 years, representing roughly 5 to 8 percent of the Pentagon’s budget," cuts are coming no matter what.  So why whet Congressional appetite?

Given this, Pentagon avoidance combined with a significant estate tax increase, the safe bet is that we will not go off the fiscal cliff.  Whether a Leftist or Rightist, all can acknowledge that concentrated wealth and the Department of Defense are scared objects in the church of American politics.