Showing posts with label Medicare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medicare. Show all posts

Thursday, April 11, 2013

Obama's Austere Budget + Glenda Jackson Takes on Thatcherism

Obama's budget is the lead story in the New York Times this morning. Nothing much new is covered by Jackie Calmes' story, "Obama Budget Whittles Democratic Party Pillars," compared to the one she wrote last week where she confirmed that Obama was indeed going to propose a reduction in Social Security cost of living adjustments. Calmes' focus today is more on the politico-historical aspect of a Democratic president going after the landmark programs, Social Security and Medicare, associated with the New Deal and the Great Society.

I found myself in agreement with the analysis of the unsigned editorial on the Opinion page, "The President's Budget." There the Times argues that a chained CPI is a bad idea; that it would have been a better to raise "the wage cap subject to a payroll tax." But the rest of Obama's budget ideas the editorial board is in agreement with:
Rejecting the president’s budget also means passing over a host of good ideas — chief among them, replacing the arbitrary and damaging sequestration cuts with more sensible reductions, along with ways to make the rich pay a larger share of revenues. 
The plan would cut spending by about $1.2 trillion over a decade, which is more than is necessary and more than Mr. Obama previously offered. The cuts include $306 billion from Medicare providers by relying more on generic drugs and demanding greater efficiencies from doctors and hospitals. Drug companies would have to pay a much larger share of the costs borne by low-income Medicare recipients. Farm subsidies would be cut by $38 billion, and spending on the military, the State Department and homeland security would also be reduced. 
Couples with incomes starting at about $170,000 a year would have to pay about 5 percentage points more for Medicare premiums. And there would be several other significant tax increases: The carried-interest tax break used by wealthy hedge fund operators would rise to ordinary-income levels, overall tax breaks for couples making more than $250,000 would be reduced, and a “Buffett Rule” that would ensure that millionaires pay at least 30 percent of their income in taxes. The federal cigarette tax would almost double to $1.95 a pack. Collectively, new revenues would bring in about $600 billion in a decade.
The Times interprets Obama's offering on Social Security as a feint to expose the phoniness of Republican posturing on deficits. This perspective is completely demolished by a Yves Smith post yesterday on naked capitalism, "Obama Moves Forward with Cutting Social Security and Medicare as We Lecture Europe Otherwise." I think her concluding paragraph is one that needs to be taken to heart by all of us who have stuck with Obama up until now:
This is what the defenders refuse to acknowledge: the Obama critics, again and again, have been proven right, yet we have seen remarkably few mea cuplas, let alone apologies (and that includes you, Charles Pierce and Scott Lemieux). Obama is proving to be a litmus test of where commentators’ loyalties really stand: is it to “liberal” beliefs, which get redefined evermore to the right, or is it to the Democratic party neoliberal technocrats, which Obama embodies? The budget battle is pure and simple about squeezing the middle class dry, and those who pretend otherwise are simply insulting the intelligence of their audience.
Let's conclude this morning with a video from yesterday of MP Glenda Jackson taking on the hagiography of the matriarch of neoliberalism, Margaret Thatcher:

Monday, March 11, 2013

Stuck with Obama

Do elections matter? This was the question that preoccupied me during the fiscal cliff standoff last December. Obama won a significant victory, certainly what would have been declared in prior decades a "mandate" election, yet for Republicans it was business as usual. The GOP ended up buckling a little, giving in on a tax increase for those earning above $400,000 a year which will end up raising $600 billion in revenue over 10 years. But now as Obama continues to chase after his Grand Bargain grumbling has begun in the Democratic caucus over the deal to avert the fiscal cliff. This from a story today by Richard Stevenson and John Harwood, Obama Seeks to Bridge Partisan Divide in Search of a Budget Deal:
The second-guessing extends to virtually every aspect of the deal: its failure to postpone the automatic budget cuts for more than two months, its failure to raise the federal debt limit and its yield of $600 billion in new tax revenue over 10 years out of $4 trillion of new taxes that would have taken effect had the Bush tax cuts been allowed to expire. 
Senator Amy Klobuchar, Democrat of Minnesota, said the White House should have negotiated after the election with the bipartisan group of senators that he is courting now, rather than resuming the talks with Speaker John A. Boehner that failed in 2011. In the agreement that concluded that 2011 standoff, said John D. Podesta, a former White House chief of staff for President Bill Clinton, the administration committed a “fundamental miscalculation” by believing Republican opposition to automatic Pentagon cuts would compel them to accept tax increases. 
Other Democratic critics say the president should have ratcheted up pressure on Republicans by allowing all the Bush-era tax cuts to expire, even at the risk of saddling middle-class families with tax increases and inflicting harm on the economy. 
“Thinking they’d have a second bite of the apple was a real mistake,” said Robert D. Reischauer, a former director of the Congressional Budget Office.
What Obama has put on the table now, in hopes of securing a big budget deal with Republicans, is Medicare and Social Security:
Mr. Obama has signaled a willingness to reduce cost-of-living increases for Social Security by using a less-generous measure of inflation. He has indicated openness to imposing means-testing on Medicare beneficiaries so that high-income retirees would pay more for their medical care, and he has put on the table $400 billion of cuts in Medicare over the next decade. 
Republicans say they are looking for more, including two elements they discussed with the White House during failed talks in 2011: raising the eligibility age for Medicare and cutting federal costs for Medicaid. 
White House officials said that those proposals were deeply flawed as a matter of policy and that they did not intend to submit any more offers until Republicans expressed some willingness to make tax revenue part of the equation. 
But Mr. Cantor raised an idea last month that had been endorsed by the Bowles-Simpson deficit-reduction commission: merging Medicare’s hospital and doctor coverage into one program in a way that could generate savings. Some Democrats also see that kind of proposal — in which Medicare is left fundamentally intact but is overhauled to become more efficient and which could potentially charge the affluent elderly more — as the basis for negotiation.
On the Counterpunch web site this past weekend in an article titled "The Grand Bargainer: Elections Have Consequences, Right?" Andrew Levine concludes that elections don't matter; that by now it should be clear to all those Liberals and Progressives who have supported Obama that he is not governing with their interests in mind. Case in point is entitlement cuts. Obama ran as the candidate who will protect Social Security and Medicare. Now he is negotiating to cut those programs. Levine calls for radical action without specifying what that means:
This is why elections hardly matter any more, why their consequences are superficial and cosmetic at best. 
It is not hard to imagine ways to pursue peace, abandon austerity, protect the environment, and restore the rule of law while leaving basic economic and political structures intact. Palliatives abound. 
But with capitalist power so overwhelming, even palliatives are unreachable in the usual way – through elections. 
Three decades ago, at the dawn of the neoliberal era, Margaret Thatcher famously declared: “there is no alternative.” She meant no alternative to the economic system that goes by her name and Ronald Reagan’s. She was wrong of course; there are alternatives, plenty of them. Because they are obvious, everyone knows what they are. 
But because capitalism has undermined democracy to such an extent that we cannot now get from here to there – indeed, from here to anywhere capitalist grandees don’t want to go — it is fast becoming true that the only solutions are radical ones.
But radical action rejecting the normal political process was tried recently. It was Occupy Wall Street. And, as Jeff Madrick writes in the march issue of Harper's, it was crushed by police action:
But it has become increasingly clear that OWS didn’t fizzle because its objectives were too muddled or its talk too abstract or its organization too chaotic. In fact, the movement was undone by a concerted government effort to undo it.
That's why so much of the Left is still with Obama. He's the only game in town. We'll see. If he folds and ends up agreeing to an increase in eligibility age for Medicare, I think there will be a huge ruckus in Democratic ranks and the abandonment of Obama will rapidly commence. For that reason, since it is still early in his second term, I don't think he will agree to an increase in eligibility age. A chained CPI, yes; he has already agreed to that (which is not good because it amounts to a benefit reduction). But for the time being we're stuck with Obama and the hope that he's not going to sell us down the river like Clinton did in his second term with the repeal of Glass-Steagall and his war on Yugoslavia.

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Listen to the Left

Peter Eavis' frontpage story this morning about the Dow hitting its all-time high yesterday is worth reading. It's peppered with skepticism. We had a tech bubble followed by a real estate bubble; this is a Fed bubble:
Previous highs occurred when investors believed the economy could keep growing without any extraordinary assistance. By contrast, this rally has occurred on the back of enormous monetary stimulus by the Fed and the world’s other central banks. 
Since the end of 2007, five major central banks have injected some $6 trillion into the global economy, according to figures from the Bank for International Settlements. This was done to prevent bank runs and revive economies. 
As the stimulus forced down interest rates, it eventually whetted investors’ appetite for riskier assets like stocks.
And this from today's naked capitalism blog:
It’s hard to fathom the celebratory mood in the US markets, save that the moneyed classes are benefiting from a wall of liquidity reminiscent of early 2007, when risk spreads across virtually all types of lending shrank to scarily low levels. Then the culprit was not well understood, although Gillian Tett discerned that CDOs were a huge source of leverage, and in April 2007, an analyst, Henry Maxey at Ruffler, LLC, did an impressive job of piecing together how levered structured credit strategies were driving market liquidity. 
Now it’s a lot easier to see what is afoot. The Fed has been trying to reflate asset values to goose the real economy. What it has done instead is goose the incomes of the top 1% while everyone else is on the whole worse off. But the central bank is suffering from a very bad case of “if the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail” syndrome. It’s unwilling or unable to admit that its program is working only for a very few. It has convinced itself that if it just keeps on the same failed path long enough, things will turn around. As we can see from Japan, “long enough” can exceed 20 years, and it is not clear that the latest Japanese pump priming will finally pull the economy out of the ditch.
What's called for is a massive public works program that would employ the unemployed and build things that future generations could use to live better lives. But this is not going to happen because Republicans as a minority party have figured out how to control the national government. I would guess the GOP will control the House and the Supreme Court for at least the next decade. And to be charitable to Obama, assuming he's not the Manchurian Candidate of the 1% as the Counterpunch Left perceives him, I think this is what lies behind his search for a grand budgetary bargain with Republicans here and now; he doesn't see them going away anytime soon. So better to try to cut a deal now on Social Security and Medicare that doesn't include an increase in eligibility age; cut a deal now while his election mandate hasn't completely evaporated (as it almost already has).

Generally, as a rule of thumb, the Left is right; that's why it's wise to pay attention to what is being said on blogs like naked capitalism and web sites like Counterpunch and in publications like Monthly Review; while not being 100% correct (who is?), the interpretive framework is more coherent. To give one prominent example of the Left being spectacularly correct while simultaneously the Right was disastrously wrong recall Saddam's weapons of mass destruction. The Left went with Hans Blix and said there's nothing there. And they were right. Don't ignore the Left.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

GOP Government Shutdown Plan

House Republicans set their extortion calendar. Jonathan Weisman's story today about yesterday's House vote to suspend enforcement of the debt ceiling until May 18 lays out how the government-shutdown thrill ride will proceed in the coming months. The good news is that we will be spared this frontpage-hog for the remainder of the month and all of February. Then March 1 "$110 billion in across-the-board spending cuts to military and domestic programs — known as a sequester — will go into force."
The next real showdown will come by March 27, when the stopgap measure financing the government expires. Republicans have made clear that they are willing to let the government shut down at that time to force deep spending cuts or changes to Medicare and Social Security that would bring down deficits in the long run.
Included in the debt-ceiling suspension is a provision to "withhold the pay of lawmakers in a chamber of Congress that fails to pass a budget blueprint by April 15." This is aimed at Senate Democrats who have not passed a budget since 2009.

The GOP design here is to get the Senate to produce a budget that can be reconciled in conference with the Ryan Plan, a.k.a., "The Path to Prosperity," and inflict as much damage as possible on Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security. We're talking about the block granting of Medicaid; the privatizing of Medicare and raising its eligibility age; and while Ryan changed his tune and now calls for no changes in Social Security, Boehner sought a chained CPI in the recent fiscal cliff negotiations, and privatization remains the Republican Holy Grail. And what Boehner is talking about, a balanced budget over the next ten years, is actually much worse than the Ryan Plan, which doesn't balance the budget until 2040. This is from today's lead unsigned editorial in the New York Times:
If the House actually wants to put forth a balanced budget over the next 10 years, as Mr. Boehner vowed to do on Wednesday, let the public see what that really means: unimaginable cuts and changes to Medicare and Medicaid, and the elimination of scores of popular and vital programs that benefit both the poor and the middle class. Up to now, Republicans have been understandably wary of specifying how that would be done without raising taxes. Mitt Romney wouldn’t do it, and even Representative Paul Ryan’s budgets up to now wouldn’t balance the budget until 2040.

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

Brooks on Health Care Spending

David Brooks' column this morning looks at the nomination of Chuck Hagel to lead the Department of Defense through the prism of budgetary battles to come.  Obama needs a Republican war hero to provide political cover for a Democratic administration to reduce the size of the Pentagon.  Brooks has been playing Cassandra when it comes to the dangers of ever-growing Medicare spending.  Soon it will blot out nearly all else that the government does:
As the federal government becomes a health care state, there will have to be a generation of defense cuts that overwhelm anything in recent history. Keep in mind how brutal the budget pressure is going to be. According to the Government Accountability Office, if we act on entitlements today, we will still have to cut federal spending by 32 percent and raise taxes by 46 percent over the next 75 years to meet current obligations. If we postpone action for another decade, then we have to cut all non-interest federal spending by 37 percent and raise all taxes by 54 percent.

As this sort of crunch gradually tightens, Medicare will be the last to go. Spending on things like Head Start, scientific research and defense will go quicker. These spending cuts will transform America’s stature in the world, making us look a lot more like Europe today. This is why Adm. Mike Mullen called the national debt the country’s biggest security threat.
This assumes that we will continue to provide and pay for health care in the manner that we do today.  We can't.  The math doesn't lie.  A shift to preventative medicine is going to have to take place.  This of course is easier said than done.  For each person to begin to take responsibility for his or her own health is akin to an Apollo program or a World-War-Two-type mobilization.  Infantile narcissism and the consumerism that makes it a defining characteristic of our culture will have to be put in check.

Andrew Ross Sorkin in a DealBook column this morning argues that the four-year delay in the implementation of the Basel III liquidity requirements was less a heinous capitulation on the part of bank regulators than an unavoidable acceptance of reality:
In truth, the reason that regulators ultimately chose to relax the rules was simple practicality: many banks in Europe and some in the United States would have never been able to meet the requirements without significantly reducing the amount of credit they were to extend to Main Street over the next two years, according to people involved in the Basel decision process.
My problem with this is it is a continuation of the Wall Street-bailout, Too-Big-to-Fail logic: Let's go easy on the banks because if we don't they'll hurt Main Street.  How is this different from calling the 1% "job creators"?

Friday, January 4, 2013

Class Warfare

Boehner wins re-election as speaker of the House and in doing so he talks tough about deficit reduction.  This from today's Jonathan Weissman story:
The agenda laid out by both Mr. Boehner and Senator Mitch McConnell, the Republican leader in the Senate, jibed well with the demands of small-government conservatives who have complained that neither leader has been sufficiently confrontational with Mr. Obama.

Both said cutting spending would be front and center, putting them on a collision course with the president and Democratic leaders. And neither was taking seriously the president’s pledge not to bargain over raising the government’s statutory borrowing ceiling.
Krugman's column takes in the big picture about the current conflict consuming our national politics.  He calls it a class war.  Republicans want to undo the New Deal and Great Society to lock in low taxes for the wealthy.  The identity of the Democratic Party is predicated on Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and now Obamacare.  Since the GOP doesn't have the power to pass any legislation all it can do is extort cuts by means of threat -- of default (by refusing to vote for an increase in the debt ceiling) or government shutdown (by refusing to approve a continuing resolution at the end of March).  The class war will be fought in budgetary battles.  As Krugman says:
[T]he G.O.P. retains the power to destroy, in particular by refusing to raise the debt limit — which could cause a financial crisis. And Republicans have made it clear that they plan to use their destructive power to extract major policy concessions.

Now, the president has said that he won’t negotiate on that basis, and rightly so. Threatening to hurt tens of millions of innocent victims unless you get your way — which is what the G.O.P. strategy boils down to — shouldn’t be treated as a legitimate political tactic.

But will Mr. Obama stick to his anti-blackmail position as the moment of truth approaches? He blinked during the 2011 debt limit confrontation. And the last few days of the fiscal cliff negotiations were also marked by a clear unwillingness on his part to let the deadline expire. Since the consequences of a missed deadline on the debt limit would potentially be much worse, this bodes ill for administration resolve in the clinch.

So, as I said, in a tactical sense the fiscal cliff ended in a modest victory for the White House. But that victory could all too easily turn into defeat in just a few weeks.
Rationality is the ability to recognize a pattern and act on it.  The clear pattern at work here is that Obama says one thing to appeal to his base -- those voters who put him in office -- and then ends up acting differently.  Now that the election is over what leverage do voters have to alter this pattern?

Saturday, December 29, 2012

Obama to Outline Budget Deal on Meet the Press

Obama will be on "Meet the Press" this Sunday morning to make the pitch for a deal that appears to be taking shape in the Senate.  According to today's story by Jonathan Weisman and Jennifer Steinhauer the Bush tax cuts will be allowed to expire for those earning more than $400,000 a year.  Dickering continues on the estate tax.
Senator Max Baucus of Montana, chairman of the Finance Committee, said “things are starting to gel” around a deal. According to aides familiar with the talks, the plan, in its early stages, centered on a deal that would extend all the expiring Bush income tax cuts up to $400,000 in income.

Some spending cuts would pay for a provision putting off a sudden reduction in payments to medical providers treating Medicare patients. The deal would also prevent an expansion of the alternative minimum tax to keep it from hitting more of the middle class. It would extend a raft of already expired business tax cuts, like the research and development credit, and would renew tax cuts for the working poor and the middle class included in the 2009 stimulus law.
A farm bill has to be produced as well: "The most recent farm bill, passed in 2008, expired on Sept. 30. If a new farm bill is not passed or the current one extended, farm programs would lose billions in financing and revert to the 1949 law." 

The debt ceiling will be kicked down the road for the new Congress, assuring that this drama of ill will and mendacity will continue unabated into next year.

Friday, December 28, 2012

Fiscal Cliff a Political Creation of GOP

The canard in D.C. plays on.  Members of the Senate are back in session and the House has been called back for Sunday.  Jonathan Weisman reports that there is both hope and pessimism that a deal can be struck: hope from Mitch McConnell that talks are finally percolating; gloom from Harry Reid that procedurally there is not enough time on the clock to finalize any legislation before the end of the year.

Yes, year's end.  Thank goodness.  Today is my last working day of 2012.  And I am relieved.  Jennifer Steinhauer has an entertaining story about the prickly and despondent senators called away from holiday back to the Capitol; it's rich with atmospheric detail, which is unusual for political correspondence.  This is the delightful second-to-last paragraph:
The House and Senate have held numerous pro forma sessions during the week between Christmas and New Year over the years, and in 1995 during a major budget battle. But the last time they held roll call votes that week, before Thursday, was during the second session of the 91st Congress, in 1970, amid a large spending fight and a filibuster over financing for a supersonic transport plane.
For some reason I am fascinated by a SST filibuster in the final days of 1970. Pat and Dick in the White House. The Weather Underground on the run.

The mirage of a deal taking shape, according to Weisman, seeks to "avert most of the tax increases on Jan. 1, to prevent a sudden cut in payments to medical providers treating Medicare patients and to extend expiring unemployment benefits."

Nelson Schwartz has a story about the economic impact of the fiscal cliff negotiations.  Consumer confidence took a big hit in the first part of the month; it's being compared to the debt ceiling debacle from the summer of 2011:
Several economists said the current situation recalls the standoff over raising the federal debt ceiling in the summer of 2011. In that case, too, consumer confidence eroded as both sides in Washington refused to blink until the last moment, but experts added the consequences were likely to be longer-lasting this time because the changes in tax policy affect individuals directly.
We must remember, as housing prices finally start to recover and unemployment continues its incremental decline, that the fiscal cliff is a political creation of the Republican Party. The GOP wants to alter fundamentally popular government programs, social democratic programs, like Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security.  Republicans are willing to risk a crisis to achieve this goal.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Maintenance of a Failed Satus Quo

A fiscal cliff deal does seem to be in the offing.  I read Jonathan Weisman's story online last night and again this morning with the delivery of the paper and the gist of the bargain is that Obama has reduced his revenue demand by four hundred billion dollars, from $1.6 trillion to $1.2 trillion, in an attempt to meet Boehner, who recently raised his revenue target from $800 billion to $1 trillion.  Also, "The White House plan would permanently extend Bush-era tax cuts on household incomes below $400,000, meaning that only the top tax bracket, 35 percent, would increase to 39.6 percent. The current cutoff between the top rate and the next highest rate, 33 percent, is $388,350."  Obama's position now is to let only the top tax rate, not the top two tax rates, revert to Clinton-era levels.

On the spending side, Obama has come up with $1.22 trillion in cuts over ten years, part of which is from changing the way the government calculates inflation.  Medicare and Medicaid are to be cut by $400 billion.

Obama wants a two-year increase in the debt ceiling.  Boehner is willing to give one year.  Included in any deal, Obama wants an extension of the emergency federal unemployment benefits and some more stimulus spending .  Nothing was reported on the fate of the estate tax.  Boehner is set to bring the deal to his conference this morning.

If this is the deal, I'm not satisfied.  It is basically a maintenance of the status quo, a status quo which is not working for working people.  Recalling Paul Krugman's column from last Friday, where he argued that the fiscal cliff is more a political crisis than a budgetary one, the deal being reported by Weisman doesn't alter the political landscape in the way that going off the cliff would.  And that's what we need -- a big paradigm shift.  We've got to start acting more collectively to address the numerous huge problems that confront us.  We will not be able to do so as long as the Mad Mullahs, who serve at the behest of the 1%, hold sway in the House.  Going off the fiscal cliff would call the question.

What I've been calling the Counterpunch Left is apparently right and I've been wrong.  Obama is a Manchurian Candidate for the plutocracy to that extent that he maintains a status quo that is fundamentally plutocratic and unsustainable.

It's interesting that Krugman blogged yesterday afternoon that he wants to see if the "Republican crazies" scuttle the deal before weighing in on whether to support it.  He says a "chained CPI" is a real benefit cut but far less damaging than an increase in the Medicare eligibility age.  He says there's some merit in going off the cliff in order to out the GOP Mad Mullahs; then he says, "but there’s also an argument that this might not work."

Monday, December 17, 2012

Negotiations Progress + Right Wing Strategy

The fiscal cliff news today reported by Jonathan Weisman and Jackie Calmes is that there is progress in the negotiations between Boehner and Obama.  The progress is that Boehner has finally agreed to a rate increase for the rich.  The problem is that the rate increase would apply only to households making more than $1 million a year, raising only $300 billion over ten years.  This is far short of Obama's recently lowered demand of $1.4 trillion in new revenue over ten years.  Republicans have yet to specify how they will make up the difference.  What deductions would be eliminated?

Another idea floated by Boehner is a one-year increase in the debt ceiling.  And while Boehner has shelved the proposal to raise Medicare eligibility from 65 to 67, he is sticking to his demand that government reduce its cost-of-living adjustments.

It seems like a ruse to me, the smallest of gestures; so when talks finally collapse and the Bush tax cuts expire for everyone and the sequester kicks in Boehner can say, "See, I tried; I gave ground."  This way he can deflect some of the public ire that polls show is coming the GOP's way once we go off the cliff.

An important story in today's paper is Nicholas Confessore and Monica Davey's description of how Amway scion Dick Devos along with the Koch brothers' Americans for Prosperity ginned up right-to-work legislation in Michigan.  Rightist strategy appears oriented towards gaining control in state legislatures and thereby ensuring "a favorable position for Congressional redistricting." 

The Mad Mullahs in the House of Representatives are going to be with us for a while.  Will we continue to placate them?

Thursday, December 13, 2012

The Woes of the Speaker of the House

Boehner has trouble with his caucus.  The gist of today's fiscal cliff story from Jonathan Weisman is captured in the quote from Democratic leader Chris Van Hollen:
“The biggest impediment right now is the speaker’s ability to get a decent number of Republican votes for an agreement,” said Representative Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, who is the lead Democrat on the House Budget Committee.

“I’m getting increasingly concerned that one of the reasons the speaker is deciding to, I think, string out these discussions is that he wants to wait until Jan. 3, when the election for speaker takes place,” he said.
Which makes sense.  It appears the only way that the fiscal cliff is going to be resolved in the next two weeks is if Boehner can bring something back to the House for a vote, knowing full well that by doing so he might have to rely on Democrats and not Republicans to get it passed.  According to Van Hollen, Boehner is unwilling to do this; he wants to wait until his leadership position is secure.

Officially Boehner's bargaining position is unchanged.  He opposes an increase in tax rates for the rich; accepts the need to raise revenue in the amount of $800 billion by altering the tax code to close loopholes; and is waiting for Obama to agree to a major entitlement change, e.g., raising the Medicare eligibility age.  Unofficially Boehner is reported to be willing to accept an increase in tax rates for the rich as long he gets the Medicare change and/or a COLA reduction for Social Security.

Obama has been here once before, with the summer of 2011 debt ceiling negotiations, and he got burned.  He acquiesced to entitlement cuts, got outed, and then Boehner couldn't deliver.  Obama is not stupid.  He will not make the same mistake twice.  And the reason he won't, all strategy aside, is that the facts are overwhelming regarding the enormous redistribution of wealth over the last 30 years to the top 1%.  This from an excellent story today by Annie Lowrey:
The Congressional Budget Office has found that between 1979 and 2007, the top 1 percent of households saw their inflation-adjusted income grow 275 percent. For the bottom 20 percent, it grew just 18 percent, and federal tax and transfer programs also did less and less to reduce income inequality over that period.

The mounting concentration of wealth is even more dramatic. A recent Economic Policy Institute study found that between 1983 and 2010 about three-quarters of all new wealth accrued to the wealthiest 5 percent of households. Over the same period, the bottom 60 percent actually became poorer.
As we enter the third week of December I don't see that anything much has really changed.  Because of the Mad Mullahs in his conference Boehner doesn't feel like he can deliver anything unless he has big entitlement cuts, cuts which come at the expense of a working class that has been hammered decade after decade.  It's the debt ceiling negotiations all over again; it's as if the 2012 election never happened.  The wild card in all this is the rapid approach of Mad Mullah paradise, the debt limit.  I saw an interview the other day with Jackie Calmes.   She said a stumbling block in the talks has been the unwillingness of Republicans to bargain away their vote to raise the government's borrowing limit.

So the action over the next two weeks is going to be in what gets peeled off from the fiscal cliff negotiations and passed on its own.  Pay attention because what Congress decides to deal with by December 31 is what is really important to the people in power.  An argument can be made, and there are mentions of it in the press, that the Bush tax cuts will be extended for the 98%.  It could happen.  Politicians are interested in reelection.  But I see movement foremost on the estate tax, maybe in combination with an extension in emergency unemployment benefits.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Other Taxes on the Table Besides Income

The last fews days there has been a noticeable reduction in fiscal cliff coverage.  I interpret this as a sign that neogiations are being conducted in earnest.

Today Brian Knowlton and Jackie Calmes have a story about a one-on-one meeting in the White House yesterday between Boehner and Obama; also, they mention GOP Senator Bob Corker's appearance on "Fox News Sunday" where he argued that his party should publicly concede the debate over raising the top tax rates in order to shift the focus to entitlement cuts.

Jackie Calmes had a front page story in the Sunday paper yesterday on revenue arithmetic.  Raising the top tax rates only gets Obama a quarter of his desired $1.6 trillion in new revenue over 10 years:

Seldom mentioned is that Mr. Obama’s revenue total also reflects four other changes from Bush-era tax cuts: higher tax rates on investment income from capital gains and dividends, and the restoration of two other Clinton-era provisions limiting deductions and tax exemptions for affluent individuals.

Together those changes would raise $407.4 billion over a decade — nearly as much as the president’s proposal on higher rates, which would raise $441.6 billion by 2023, for a total of $849 billion. Another $119 billion would come from higher estate taxes, opposed by Republicans and some Democrats.

And both the president and Republicans are committed to raising hundreds of billions of dollars by overhauling the tax code to further limit or end the tax breaks that high-income taxpayers can claim, though they differ in how to do that.
The Counterpunch left is convinced Obama is a Manchurian Candidate for the plutocracy and that a large, painful selling out on Medicare and Social Security is coming our way.  If this proves true then I will have been wrong about Obama.  I suppose a red line for me is the eligibility age for Medicare.  If it goes up as part of the bargain to avoid the fiscal cliff then I think we've been sold down the river.

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

GOP Counteroffer

Today's fiscal cliff story from Jonathan Weisman is a recapitulation of yesterday's Republican counteroffer to last week's proposal by Geithner.  No new ground is covered.  Revenues are raised by jiggering with deductions, though no details are provided as to which deductions would be affected.  There is no increase in rates for the top 2%.  Cuts would come to all entitlement programs by changing the way the government calculates inflation.  In addition, there is an increase in the eligibility age for Medicare.

The GOP's position is weak.  In normal circumstances, with a compliant commander in chief in the White House, a group of senators would come together and give the Republicans in the House what they want.  This is how the federal government in Washington D.C. works.  But contrary to what the Counterpunch Left purports, I don't think Obama is an abject tool of the plutocracy.  He would veto any Gang of Six Bowlesian chicanery.

What is gradually formulating in my mind is that Republicans don't actually want any deal.  Once we go off the cliff there will be scare headlines and confusion and some fear regarding the reduced paychecks to come; and in such a crisis-type environment they will have more leverage to get what they want than they do now.  We'll see.