Showing posts with label Annie Lowrey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Annie Lowrey. Show all posts

Thursday, February 27, 2014

U.S. Support of Ukraine Putsch Payback for Syria?

As tens of thousands of Russian troops mass on Ukraine's border and secessionist unrest flares in the Russian-majority Crimea, now is a good time to stand back and consider the possibility that this ham-handed putsch, almost one-week old and rapidly fraying, that was implemented with fulsome U.S. support, is part of an effort to punish Russia for its defense of Syria, in general, and its "checkmate" of the Obama administration's rush to Tomahawk Damascus last summer, in particular.

Toward that end, allow me to quote a piece -- "Was the Ukraine Coup America’s Main Event at the Sochi Olympics?" -- written by Peter Lee that appeared yesterday on the Counterpunch web site:
[A]n alternate possibility is that the United States did it [back the putsch] for revenge, to punish Putin for not going along with the US program on Syria. 
That’s not great because, if so, the decision might have been made out of short-sighted spite, and the West might have taken sole custody of the Ukrainian tar baby just as its finances are teetering to collapse and the split between eastern and western Ukrainians threatens to turn into a permanent rift. 
It would be…ironic! There’s that word again!—if punishing Putin over Syria turned Ukraine into another Syria. 
I don’t think this revenge scenario is too outlandish. President Obama seems to be a man who likes his revenge served cold—icy cold—and maybe underneath that controlled façade he was itching to show Putin that Russia could not lightly defy US demands to withdraw support from Assad and collapse the Syrian government. I believe personal disdain and the need to assert his credentials as world’s numero uno big boss drives President Obama’s foreign policy with regard to Putin, with the Chinese leadership (ever since he was subjected to a finger-wagging tirade by China’s chief climate negotiator for America’s botched outing at the Copenhagen summit in 2010), and of course, his counterproductive crusade—now in its third dismal year with a promise of further escalation– to destroy Syria and further destabilize the Middle East in order to punish Bashar Assad for refusing to go when Obama told him to go. 
One hopes that twelve-dimensional chess is guiding US moves in the Ukraine. But if that policy is in the hands of a crude neo-con like “Fuck the EU” Victoria Nuland, maybe we’re looking at another one of those “nobody could have foreseen” bloody foreign policy botches that the US seems to specialize in nowadays. 
And Putin might have the last laugh, withholding Russia’s promised contribution of $15 billion while the EU scrambles to come up with the $30 billion Ukraine needs to get through the year (amazingly, the US has to date made no commitment to provide financial aid, something the EU is probably noticing; and thinking Thanks a Billion! Not! Vicky Nuland, since the aggressive US strategy blew up the transitional government negotiated by the EU that might have kept Russia in the game and on the hook).
With the putsch parliament clearing its choices for an interim government in a faux-Occupy consensus charade on the Maidan, the machinery is clunking into place to accept an IMF bailout along with its destabilizing, dehumanizing grab bag of austerity mandates.

The IMF needs the fiction of a "legal" government in place in order to begin negotiations on terms of the bailout. Yanukovych, now apparently in Russia, made a statement denying the legality of his removal. The U.S./EU, based on statements made yesterday by John Kerry, is standing behind the putschists.

Regardless of the legality of the yet-to-be seated interim government, and assuming that Russia does not intervene militarily to protect Russian-speaking Ukrainians, whose language is no longer officially recognized by the putsch parliament, the one insurmountable roadblock for the putschists is the IMF bailout.

This is from a story today by Annie Lowrey and Michael Gordon, "Policy Makers Devise Plans to Provide Money to Kiev":
Policy makers are already hotly debating a rescue package for Ukraine, with conversations about the economy dominating discussions on the sidelines of the Group of 20 meeting of economic officials in Sydney. 
The country’s finances are now “on the verge of collapse,” the Washington-based Institute of International Finance, which represents major banks around the world, warned in a report released this week.
“With the authorities mostly preoccupied with handling the political upheaval, economic policies have remained in limbo,” said Ondrej Schneider and Lubomir Mitov of the finance institute. “Risks of prolonged political uncertainty still remain substantial, however, raising odds of delays in implementing reforms with potentially disastrous consequences for financial stability and growth.”
***

“We will be ready to engage, ready to help,” Ms. Lagarde said this weekend. “We, of course, try to go further and play the catalytic role that the I.M.F. typically plays in such situations.” 
The I.M.F. is expected to insist that Ukraine raise domestic gas prices, cut government spending, tackle corruption and allow the country’s currency to float on the international markets.
What the IMF will catalyze is more street protests. But this time dopey Yanukovych will not be the target; it will be the putschists themselves. Then the reviled police or the Right Sector "self-defense" forces will be mustered to beat down the crowds in the Maidan. And this time there will be no complaints from John Kerry or William Hague about the rights of peaceful protesters.

Monday, January 6, 2014

I, Robot

An interesting, brief article written by Sam Smith appeared on the Counterpunch web site this past weekend. "America Under the Management Cult" tells us what we already know -- though I was unaware that Obama in his student days was employed by a CIA front company -- but prefer not to dwell on because of its depressing nature. Here is a sample:
And now the Democrats appear headed towards nominating Hillary Clinton despite her seedy past, her several criminal associates and her less than progressive politics. If she wins and survives two terms, for over 50% of the previous half century America will have been run by two of the most corrupt families to reach the top of our country’s politics. For nearly three quarters of the previous half century our country will have been run by those with direct or familial connections to the CIA. And, for a topping, for two thirds of the half century the country will have been run by graduates of Harvard Business School or the Harvard or Yale law schools. 
This is not the America we were taught to love and assist in its noble purposes. But then, these days most of our children are nor even introduced to such thoughts in any meaningful way, except, say, as Answer C in a multiple choice exam. 
You can’t have a working democratic republic without an education that supports it, but with No Child Left Behind and Common Core, corporate interests and their political serfs are reducing education to robotic exercises in preparation for students’ similarly robotic experiences in adult life. 
But then this is the goal of the multinational corporations that have grasped control of our land and its leaders. Not since the pre-revolutionary colonial days of the British East India Company has America been so much a hostage to such alien institutions. Thanks to such expediencies as Citizens United and international trade agreements, if one follows the money, it leads inexorably away from the natural interests of the United States to huge corporations that are challenging whole countries, including ours, as major possessors of power.
Yes, that's right. That's what it feels like to me. I am becoming a robot. With the ascension of IT and the large corporations that control IT, time, the fundamental way that we experience time, has begun a metamorphosis. Time is being constricted and digitized and the large multinational corporations and the governments that serve them are overseeing this process.

To go along with this insight, Annie Lowrey had a story in the Sunday New York Times about the persistence of poverty in the United States 50 years after the State of the Union address where LBJ announced a war on poverty:
[H]igh rates of poverty — measured by both the official government yardstick and the alternatives that many economists prefer — have remained a remarkably persistent feature of American society. About four in 10 black children live in poverty; for Hispanic children, that figure is about three in 10. According to one recent study, as of mid-2011, in any given month, 1.7 million households were living on cash income of less than $2 a person a day, with the prevalence of the kind of deep poverty commonly associated with developing nations increasing since the mid-1990s. 
Both economic and sociological trends help explain why so many children and adults remain poor, even putting the effects of the recession aside. More parents are raising a child alone, with more infants born out of wedlock. High incarceration rates, especially among black men, keep many families apart. About 30 percent of single mothers live in poverty. 
In some cases, government programs have helped fewer families because of program changes and budget cuts, researchers said. For instance, the 1996 Clinton-era welfare overhaul drastically cut the cash assistance available to needy families, often ones headed by single mothers. 
“As of 1996, we expected single mothers to go to work,” Professor Ziliak said. “But if they’re shelling out most of their weekly pay in the form of child care, they can’t make sense of doing it.” 
The more important driver of the still-high poverty rate, researchers said, is the poor state of the labor market for low-wage workers and spiraling inequality. Over the last 30 years, growth has generally failed to translate into income gains for workers — even as the American labor force has become better educated and more skilled. About 40 percent of low-wage workers have attended or completed college, and 80 percent have completed high school. 
Economists remain sharply divided on the reasons, with technological change, globalization, the decline of labor unions and the falling value of the minimum wage often cited as major factors. But with real incomes for a vast number of middle-class and low-wage workers in decline, safety-net programs have become more instrumental in keeping families’ heads above water.
For decades elites have been telling us that wage gains only go to those who have invested in education. So if we want to be prosperous we better get a college degree. At least now that canard is being exploded. If 40 percent of low-wage workers have some form of college education, being better educated is no guarantee of a higher income.

Back in the days of Occupy I thought that this -- the immiseration of our college-educated youth and their reduction to student-loan low-wage peonage -- would be the catalyst to overhaul our behemoth banana republic. But force works. The encampments were razed. Take the military coup in Egypt last July as an example. The Arab Spring was in essence repealed. Elites took note. Force, at least for the time being, works. That's what we have playing out now in the Middle East. A rosy future for war. Force is being used in an attempt to keep the masses satisfied with their miserable lot.

Thursday, October 10, 2013

Government Shutdown Bait and Switch Underway

The date for when the government will default if Congress does not authorize an increase in the debt ceiling is apparently now November 1 not October 17. This according to a story by Annie Lowrey, "Tracing the Calendar Down to the Last Cent":
That is when more than $55 billion in federal payments come due, almost certainly more than enough to use up whatever cash the Treasury might still have on hand. The three weeks between now and then — should Congress fail to raise the debt ceiling — would most likely be ones of market turbulence, plummeting confidence and a slowing economy.
But so far the markets have not reacted in a significant way. Jesse Eisinger writes in a DealBook column "Complacency on Wall Street Could Be Worse Than a Panic" that having gone through this once before people are jaded and feel that this is all a pantomime on the Potomac that can be ignored. Eisinger cautions that this is dangerous and could lead to disaster; he thinks that there are real not fictive barriers to reaching a deal. As someone who has been predicting an adverse market reaction by now if a deal had not been reached, I tend to agree with him.

There appears to be a deal of sorts in the offing. That deal, according to the reliable Jonathan Weisman, involves a short-term funding of the government and raising of the debt ceiling while negotiations begin once again in pursuit of the El Dorado of the "grand bargain." The problem with the grand bargain is there is no deal at the end of that rainbow. It is a Paul Ryan initiative. It is my perception that anything Ryan touches -- not unlike George W. Bush, another youthful-seeming, modestly telegenic GOP standard bearer -- turns to shit in his hands. Ryan wants to take a meat ax to Medicare and Medicaid. There are not the Democratic votes there. Any grand budget deficit bargain would have to be extremely modest to get through the Senate. Then you're right back at the problem that started all this -- the Tea Party fire eaters in the House. They will torpedo any modest grand bargain.

As for the problem that started all this, the fire-eating Tea Party, there is a frontpage story by Eric Lipton, Nick Confessore and Nelson Schwartz, "Business Groups See Loss of Sway Over House G.O.P.," that is worth checking out. I think it oversells the extent to which groups like the National Retail Federation and National Federation of Independent Businesses will go out of their way to recruit and fund primary candidates to take down some of the Tea Party yahoos in the House. Nonetheless the article features some choice quotes:
“We ask them to carry our water all the time,” said one corporate sector lobbyist, who demanded anonymity in order to speak frankly about the relationship with Republicans. “But we don’t necessarily support them 100 percent of the time. And what has happened is the rise of an ideological wing that is now willing to stand up to business interests.”
Lipton, Confessore and Schwartz rightly point out that the Tea Party phenomenon is a Frankenstein monster of the Chamber of Commerce's making:
To some extent, the Chamber itself, along with other lobbying groups, helped create the conditions for Washington’s impasse. 
After the 2010 elections, the Chamber and other business interests funneled millions of dollars into Republican redistricting efforts around the country, helping draw overwhelmingly safe Republican districts whose occupants — many among the most conservative House members — are now far less vulnerable to challenges from more moderate Republicans. 
The Chamber spent more than $32 million on the 2012 election, nearly all of it backing Republicans. Similarly, the American Banking Association sent 80 percent of its $2.6 million in political action committee donations to Republicans in the last election cycle, compared with 58 percent in 2008, according to data compiled by the Center for Responsive Politics, out of dissatisfaction with Democratic efforts to impose more financial regulations.
Two-thousand-and-eight might seem like a lifetime ago but the political vibe that it created at the time remains vivid to this day. Bush and Cheney had thoroughly discredited the Republican Party with a disastrous invasion and occupation of Iraq and a ham-handed response to the Lehman Brothers collapse. A black man won the presidential election in a rout. He had large Democratic majorities to work with in the House and Senate. Business leaders were shitting their britches. They feared a raft of progressive legislation -- card check, carbon regulation, universal health care -- churning out of Washington.

Starting in the summer of 2009 they fired up the assault engines. In order to man those engines, the only people around willing to be used for the cause were the kooks and conspiracy-theorist types.

The kooks have always been around. In our recent political dispensation, say since the 1960s, they have been known as Birchers, the far Right Wing ideologues that filled the ranks of the John Birch Society in Southern California suburbs and who believed communists were everywhere hiding in plain sight. The difference is that in our present-day period these kooks have been provided a megaphone. The media dutifully fell in line and reported the orchestrated response of kooks being lined up to speak out against health care reform at the Congressional townhalls conducted that summer of 2009 as somehow signifying a grassroots popular democratic mass uprising against Obama and progressive policy. It was nothing of the sort. It was nothing more than an assiduous stove-piping of select events and images which created the impression of an uprising. "If you build it, they will come." And they did. Citizens United helped. The 2010 elections were a watershed for the Tea Party.

And here we are today.

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Reinhart-Rogoff Austerity Study Controversy

Annie Lowrey's story today covers the controversy surrounding a main pillar of the pro-austerity camp, the Reinhart-Rogoff study that asserts a connection between high levels of debt and low growth. Economists from the University of Massachusetts at Amherst have written a paper that spotlights basic errors in the computation of the underlying data that Reinhart and Rogoff use to draw their conclusion. Here's how Yves Smith put it in her excellent post from last night on naked capitalism, "Linchpin Pro-Austerity Paper Rife with Errors; Recomputed Results Show No Growth Hit from High Government Debt":
There appears to be no intellectually honest defense of austerity left standing.

The IMF has already ‘fessed up that it does not work in practice, that cutting government spending when growth is weak simply leads the economy to contract further, making debt to GDP levels even worse than before. That admission was based on the miserable results it has produced when implemented.

But now, a new paper by Thomas Herndon, Michael Ash and Robert Pollin of PERI, “Does High Public Debt Consistently Stifle Economic Growth? A Critique of Reinhart and Rogoff,” is a devastating takedown of the factoid commonly bandied about by austerians, that if government debt rises above 90% of GDP, growth suffers. That belief in turn was based on a paper “Growth in the Time of Debt” by Carmen Reinhardt and Kenneth Rogoff, which did a 20 country comparison from 1946 to 2009. This paper claimed that when debt rose over the scary 90% to GDP level, growth fell to -0.1%.

Turns out that is not true. A number of economists had challenged the findings for asserting causality when all it showed was a correlation. In addition, a number of economists tried replicating the Reinhart-Rogoff results for years, with no success. Reinhardt and Rogoff refused to share their underlying computations. Five years later, now that the Reinhart/Rogoff work is widely accepted as true, they finally sent their “working spreadsheet” to the PERI team. As Herndon, Ash, and Pollin report:
Our finding is that when properly calculated, the average real GDP growth rate for countries carrying a public-debt-to-GDP ratio of over 90 percent is actually 2.2 percent, not −0.1 percent as published in Reinhart and Rogoff. That is, contrary to RR, average GDP growth at public debt/GDP ratios over 90 percent is not dramatically different than when debt/GDP ratios are lower.
While Lowrey's piece leaves unmentioned the possibility that rather than innocent error data sculpting might be the issue here, it's hard not to draw that conclusion.

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

"Shock Doctrine" Applied to Europe

Jacob Lew was in Brussels yesterday where he appeared at a press conference with Herman Van Rompuy, head of the European Council. Annie Lowrey covers it in a story, "In Effort to ‘Rebalance,’ Europe Appears Committed to Austerity Plan," that appears in this morning's paper:
“Our economic recovery is gathering strength,” Mr. Lew said. “The U.S. economy has expanded for 14 consecutive quarters, and although the pace of job creation is not as fast as we would like, the private sector has added jobs for 37 straight months.”
In contrast, the euro zone continues to struggle with shrinking economies and rising unemployment, with Germany, France and Spain all contracting in the fourth quarter of 2012. That has made meeting Europe’s goals of reducing fiscal deficits even harder.
Van Rompuy stuck to the austerity script:
But Mr. Van Rompuy reaffirmed the Continent’s strategy, rather than indicating a change in direction despite the rising unemployment and worse than expected contraction. 
“The European economies face a high level of debt, deep structural medium-term challenges and short-term economic headwinds that we need to confront,” he added. “There is no room for complacency.”
We've always been told in this country that Europe, because of its parliamentary system and strong labor unions, has a richer social democracy than the United States. Well, the welfare state in Europe is being dismantled, and this is bad news for the rest of us wherever it is that we live.

The financial system failed, but it is the social safety net that must be cut. It's a complete validation of the Naomi Klein's book The Shock Doctrine. Crises provide cover to implement neoliberal "reforms," even when neoliberal reforms create the crises to begin with (such as the repeal of Glass-Steagall). It's not clear that we have a way out of this circle of cannibalization. If Europe can't do it, we're in serious trouble.


The fact that Portugal's constitutional court pushed back against austerity is good news. Possibly the judiciary can do what the people's representatives in the legislature and executive have up until now failed to do -- halt the cannibalization. Raphael Minder's story today, "Portugal Warns Citizens of More Economic Pain," reports on plutocratic worries over developments in Portugal as revealed in a Fitch report from yesterday:
The decision has now called into question how the government can meet its budgetary goals in the near term and raised the broader issue of just how much austerity will be tolerated, not only by disgruntled citizens but also by justices who often act as the guardians of the Continent’s cherished social welfare system.
“The ruling could be interpreted as saying that all public spending cuts that affect civil servants are unconstitutional,” Fitch, the credit rating agency, wrote on Monday. “If that interpretation is correct, the ruling represents a setback to future fiscal adjustment efforts in Portugal.” 
It added, “This is a greater concern than its immediate impact.”

Monday, April 8, 2013

Portuguese Judiciary Deals a Blow to Austerity

Portugal is in the news because its constitutional court tossed out part of its austerity package. This from a story today by Raphael Minder, "Portuguese Debt Crisis Brings New Trouble for Euro":
In an address to his beleaguered nation on Sunday, Prime Minister Pedro Passos Coelho warned that his government would be forced to cut spending more and that lives “will become more difficult” after a court on Friday struck down some of the austerity measures put in place after a bailout package two years ago. 
The renewed tension in Portugal raised the threat of further trouble elsewhere in the euro zone, where ailing members have struggled to rebuild economic growth after enduring wrenching spending cuts. 
“The risks in the euro zone have increased markedly over the past six weeks or so,” wrote Nicholas Spiro, managing director of Spiro Sovereign Strategy, a London-based consultancy that assesses risk on sovereign debt. 
A critical moment for the latest trouble took place on Friday, when Portugal’s Constitutional Court struck down four of nine contested austerity measures that the government introduced as part of a 2013 budget that included about 5 billion euros, or $6.5 billion, of tax increases and spending cuts. The ruling left the government short about 1.4 billion euros of expected revenue, or more than one-fifth of the 2013 austerity package. 
Specifically, the court, which began reviewing the legality of the government’s austerity measures in January, ruled as unconstitutional and discriminatory the government’s plans to cut holiday bonuses for civil servants and pensioners, as well as to reduce sick leave and unemployment benefits.
Minder also quotes Jens Weidmann, the head of Bundesbank, saying Cyprus may need an additional bailout:
Cyprus received a bailout of 10 billion euros from international creditors last month. It may need even more to save its banks, a top German policy maker said on Sunday. 
“The situation in Cyprus has stabilized in the last few days,” Jens Weidmann, president of the Bundesbank, the German central bank, told Deutschlandfunk radio. “However, I wouldn’t rule out that the need for liquidity in Cyprus could increase.” 
The crisis in Cyprus reflects how urgent it is for the euro zone to establish a means to shut down failed banks without burdening taxpayers or endangering the financial system, Mr. Weidmann said. 
“There continues to be a problem with banks that may be too connected and too big to wind down without creating a danger for the financial system,” he said.
Last Friday Landon Thomas Jr. had a story, "Ex-Bank Officials Named in Cyprus Inquiry," about the findings of an investigative report commissioned by the central bank of Cyprus. Known as the Alvarez report after the financial consulting firm Alvarez & Marsal that the central bank hired to look into why the Bank of Cyprus doubled down on risky Greek bonds, it establishes what has already been widely reported. According to Thomas,
The Bank of Cyprus, long considered the better run of the two large banks that have been at the center of the Cypriot bailout debacle, decided to speculate in high-yielding Greek bonds by accumulating a 2.4 billion euro position from late December 2009 until June 2010, just as the Greece government was running out of money. 
That decision resulted in a loss of 1.9 billion euros, or about $2.4 billion, when bond investors were eventually forced to take a 75 percent haircut under the final terms of the Greek bailout, worked out last year. 
That loss and a larger one at the other big Cypriot bank, Laiki Bank, on a similarly misguided investment foray, totaled 4.5 billion euros. That was more than Cyprus, with a gross domestic product of 18 billion euros, was able to sustain. And the losses resulted in a near-collapse of the Cypriot banking sector, leading the country’s government to seek a 10 billion euro bailout from the troika of international lenders: the International Monetary Fund, the European Commission and the European Central Bank.
The Alvarez report provides new details on the extent to which Bank of Cyprus officials were hoping that the high yields generated by the Greek bonds would cover the bank’s imploding loan book. 
Alvarez investigators said that, according to the records they were able to secure from the bank, the decision to buy the bonds was based on a last gasp effort by the bank to generate profits as their loan book began to sour in late 2009 and through the spring of 2010. 
Investigators also said that the bank, like others in Europe at the time, made use of cheap financing from the European Central Bank to make these bets. As a result, executives in the bank’s treasury department bought the riskiest high-yielding bonds available and found willing sellers in banks eager to reduce their exposure to Greece. 
When it became clear not long after the Greek bailout in May 2010 that some form of debt restructuring would have to take place, the Bank of Cyprus found itself stuck with a 2.4 billion euro portfolio of Greek bonds.
Annie Lowrey has a story today, "Lew to Press for Growth in Europe," about Treasury secretary Jacob Lew's trip this week to Europe to ostensibly jawbone leaders there to dial back on austerity. What's interesting about the story is that the normally excellent Lowrey undercuts her lead halfway through the article:
But countries like Germany have shown little willingness to ease the constraints of austerity for peripheral European countries, or to engage in stimulus spending themselves. And for years, European officials have bridled at being lectured by officials from Washington — particularly because many feel that their financial crisis was largely caused by American financial products exported around the world by American banks. 
Though Mr. Lew will travel to Europe with a familiar message from Washington, it may not be delivered as urgently as in the past. The European crisis continues to weigh on American growth, cutting into exports, but many economists believe that the United States has entered a cycle of self-sustaining economic growth driven by a turnaround in housing and improving household budgets. 
Moreover, American companies have over the last few years steeled themselves against Europe’s financial woes, and the risk of contagion is perceived to be relatively low. 
Europe was the primary international concern for Timothy F. Geithner, Mr. Lew’s predecessor as Treasury secretary and a familiar face on the Continent. But perhaps as a sign of Europe’s diminishing threat to United States economic stability, Mr. Lew’s first overseas trip as Treasury secretary, last month, was not to Paris or Berlin or Brussels, but to Beijing.
Apparently what Lew is really in Europe to do is continue negotiations on a free trade agreement between the United States and the European Union. In other words, it is neoliberalism full speed ahead. Talk up stimulus, continue with austerity, and finalize the free trade agreement.

Sunday, February 17, 2013

New Numbers from Saez: 1% Doing Even Better

New numbers from U.C. Berkeley economist Emmanuel Saez show that the income gains of the last four years have gone to the top 1%. According to yesterday's story from Annie Lowrey, who is a reporter to look for,
The numbers, produced by Emmanuel Saez, an economist at the University of California, Berkeley, show overall income growing by just 1.7 percent over the period. But there was a wide gap between the top 1 percent, whose earnings rose by 11.2 percent, and the other 99 percent, whose earnings declined by 0.4 percent. 
Mr. Saez, a winner of the John Bates Clark Medal, an economic laurel considered second only to the Nobel, concluded that “the Great Recession has only depressed top income shares temporarily and will not undo any of the dramatic increase in top income shares that has taken place since the 1970s.”
I'm thinking as I'm reading Lowrey's story yesterday: Saez has been so strong on the issue of income inequality, when is that Acorn-sting clown O'Keefe or one of Karl Rove's 501(c)(4)s going to target him?
In his analysis, Mr. Saez said he saw no reason that the trend would reverse for 2012, which has not yet been analyzed. For that year, the “top 1 percent income will likely surge, due to booming stock prices, as well as retiming of income to avoid the higher 2013 top tax rates,” Mr. Saez wrote, referring to income tax increases for the wealthy that were passed by Congress in January. The incomes of the other “99 percent will likely grow much more modestly,” he said. 
Excluding earnings from investment gains, the top 10 percent of earners took 46.5 percent of all income in 2011, the highest proportion since 1917, Mr. Saez said, citing a large body of work on earnings distribution over the last century that he has produced with the economist Thomas Piketty of the Paris School of Economics.
The data analyzed by Mr. Piketty and Mr. Saez shows that income inequality — as measured by the proportion of income taken by the top 1 percent of earners — reached a modern high just before the recession hit in 2009. The financial crisis and its aftermath hit wealthy families hard. But since then, their earnings have snapped back, if not to their 2007 peak. 
That is not true for average working families. After accounting for inflation, median family income has declined over the last two years. In 2011, it stagnated for the poorest and dropped for those in the middle of the income distribution, census data show. Median household income, which was $50,054 in 2011, is about 9 percent lower than it was in 1999, after accounting for inflation.
The last two paragraphs let us know that the reign of the 1% -- despite reforms already in the pipeline like Dodd-Frank and Obamacare, as well as the recent increase of the top marginal tax rate -- is with us for the foreseeable future:
Mr. Saez has advocated much more aggressive policies aimed at income inequality. “Falls in income concentration due to economic downturns are temporary unless drastic regulation and tax policy changes are implemented,” Mr. Saez said in his analysis. 
The recent policy changes, including tax increases and financial regulatory reform, he wrote, “are not negligible but they are modest relative to the policy changes that took place coming out of the Great Depression. Therefore, it seems unlikely that U.S. income concentration will fall much in the coming years.”

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

The Hinge is 1975

If you missed Obama's State of the Union address last night, as I did, today's lede unsigned editorial in the New York Times provides a synopsis. One proposal, to increase the the federal minimum wage to $9 an hour from $7.25 and to index it to inflation, is the subject of Annie Lowrey's story today:
Many state and local government set their own minimum wages above the federal floor. Currently Washington is the only state that sets a minimum wage above $9 an hour, but several states exceed the current rate of $7.25.
The White House said that the $1.75 increase in the minimum wage would be enough to offset roughly 10 to 20 percent of the increase in income inequality since 1980. According to data compiled by the economists Thomas Piketty, at the Paris School of Economics, and Emmanuel Saez, at the University of California, Berkeley, inequality has worsened considerably during that time, and many metrics show that wages have stagnated or declined for millions of working families. The income share of the top 1 percent of earners has doubled, to 20 percent in 2011 from 10 percent in 1980. Between 1980 and 2008, according to analysis by the Economic Policy Institute, the top 10 percent of earners captured 98 percent of all income gains. 
The proposal is one of several that the White House has put forward to tackle that inequality. In the speech, Mr. Obama also proposed expanding early childhood education programs — another path that experts say can tackle inequality by leveling the playing field and increasing mobility among children from low-income families. “Every dollar we invest in high-quality early education can save more than $7 later on by boosting graduation rates, reducing teen pregnancy, even reducing violent crime,” Mr. Obama said. “Let’s do what works, and make sure none of our children start the race of life already behind. Let’s give our kids that chance.” 
In his 2008 campaign, Mr. Obama proposed lifting the minimum wage yet higher, to $9.50. Under the current proposal, the White House said that a family earning $20,000 to $30,000 would see an additional $3,500 of income a year. 
“This single step would raise the incomes of millions of working families,” said Mr. Obama on Tuesday night. “It could mean the difference between groceries or the food bank, rent or eviction, scraping by or finally getting ahead. For businesses across the country, it would mean customers with more money in their pockets. In fact, working folks shouldn’t have to wait year after year for the minimum wage to go up while C.E.O. pay has never been higher.”
Anytime the research of Piketty and Saez finds its way into the mainstream press it's a good day. Piketty and Saez have captured the Zeitgeist -- the "unprecedented surge in top wage incomes starting in the 1970s and accelerating in the 1990s." The 1%. I track it to 1975; that's the hinge. The critical presidential administration is Gerald Ford's, although Carter's has to be included in the mix. By the time Reagan assumes power the flight path of the Zeitgeist has already been established.

There are currently ten states that peg their minimum wage to cost-of-living increases. Washington State has the highest minimum wage because we established our inflation peg (by means of a ballot initiative for which I helped gather signatures) sooner than others. Seemingly each legislative session in Olympia the restaurant lobby tries to repeal it.

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Boehner's Plan B

The journey through the fiscal cliff labyrinth continues.  With each day the path to a deal grows more twisted.  The story today from Jonathan Weisman regards Boehner's "Plan B."  This is the speaker's plan to bring a vote to the floor of the House on Thursday on a tax increase for people earning more than a million dollars a year.  The Democrats are opposed as are a number of Republicans in Boehner's caucus.  "Plan B" is another ruse hatched by GOP leadership looking for a way to soften the blow of public disapproval once negotiations finally collapse.  The money quote from Weisman is towards the end of his story:
It is not clear whether the Boehner plan is a serious alternative or primarily a bargaining tactic to extract more concessions from Mr. Obama. Rob Nabors, the president’s chief liaison to Congress, met with House Democrats on Tuesday and said talks were moving forward.

But privately, he expressed pessimism that Mr. Boehner could sign on to any deal, according to people familiar with those conversations.
The reaction to the news that Obama is willing to accept a chained CPI continues to grow. While still hedging based on the lack of details as to what Obama actually agreed to, Krugman has come out against the chained CPI as a cruel benefit cut for seniors and an awful move -- cutting Social Security -- for a Democratic president to make. Annie Lowrey has a "Debt Reckoning" sidebar today explaining the chained CPI. It's an index that takes into account consumer substitution of higher-priced items with less costly ones. The example that is always trotted out is that if apples are expensive people will buy oranges, if they're cheaper, instead. A chained CPI is supposed to reflect this substitution. As Krugman says, "What it does mean is that after retirement your payments grow more slowly, about 0.3 percent each year. So if you retire at 65, your income at 75 would be 3 percent less under this proposal than under current law; at 85 it would be 6 percent less."
Peter Baker has a "think" piece about Obama's response to the Newtown massacre and how likely it is that he will lead a legislative battle to regulate guns.  Obama has been taciturn about his plans.  The gist of Baker's analysis is that Obama only engages in fights he thinks he can win.  He's a status quo leader.  Of course there's a lot of work to be done within the parameters of the current system.  But if the system is failing fundamentally -- as Newtown clearly showed -- we need a paradigm shift.  Last month's election provided the impetus for such a shift.  But now -- with pictures of John Boehner leading the news each day -- it's back to the Washington D.C. corporate-occupied-territory mindset.

Thursday, December 13, 2012

The Woes of the Speaker of the House

Boehner has trouble with his caucus.  The gist of today's fiscal cliff story from Jonathan Weisman is captured in the quote from Democratic leader Chris Van Hollen:
“The biggest impediment right now is the speaker’s ability to get a decent number of Republican votes for an agreement,” said Representative Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, who is the lead Democrat on the House Budget Committee.

“I’m getting increasingly concerned that one of the reasons the speaker is deciding to, I think, string out these discussions is that he wants to wait until Jan. 3, when the election for speaker takes place,” he said.
Which makes sense.  It appears the only way that the fiscal cliff is going to be resolved in the next two weeks is if Boehner can bring something back to the House for a vote, knowing full well that by doing so he might have to rely on Democrats and not Republicans to get it passed.  According to Van Hollen, Boehner is unwilling to do this; he wants to wait until his leadership position is secure.

Officially Boehner's bargaining position is unchanged.  He opposes an increase in tax rates for the rich; accepts the need to raise revenue in the amount of $800 billion by altering the tax code to close loopholes; and is waiting for Obama to agree to a major entitlement change, e.g., raising the Medicare eligibility age.  Unofficially Boehner is reported to be willing to accept an increase in tax rates for the rich as long he gets the Medicare change and/or a COLA reduction for Social Security.

Obama has been here once before, with the summer of 2011 debt ceiling negotiations, and he got burned.  He acquiesced to entitlement cuts, got outed, and then Boehner couldn't deliver.  Obama is not stupid.  He will not make the same mistake twice.  And the reason he won't, all strategy aside, is that the facts are overwhelming regarding the enormous redistribution of wealth over the last 30 years to the top 1%.  This from an excellent story today by Annie Lowrey:
The Congressional Budget Office has found that between 1979 and 2007, the top 1 percent of households saw their inflation-adjusted income grow 275 percent. For the bottom 20 percent, it grew just 18 percent, and federal tax and transfer programs also did less and less to reduce income inequality over that period.

The mounting concentration of wealth is even more dramatic. A recent Economic Policy Institute study found that between 1983 and 2010 about three-quarters of all new wealth accrued to the wealthiest 5 percent of households. Over the same period, the bottom 60 percent actually became poorer.
As we enter the third week of December I don't see that anything much has really changed.  Because of the Mad Mullahs in his conference Boehner doesn't feel like he can deliver anything unless he has big entitlement cuts, cuts which come at the expense of a working class that has been hammered decade after decade.  It's the debt ceiling negotiations all over again; it's as if the 2012 election never happened.  The wild card in all this is the rapid approach of Mad Mullah paradise, the debt limit.  I saw an interview the other day with Jackie Calmes.   She said a stumbling block in the talks has been the unwillingness of Republicans to bargain away their vote to raise the government's borrowing limit.

So the action over the next two weeks is going to be in what gets peeled off from the fiscal cliff negotiations and passed on its own.  Pay attention because what Congress decides to deal with by December 31 is what is really important to the people in power.  An argument can be made, and there are mentions of it in the press, that the Bush tax cuts will be extended for the 98%.  It could happen.  Politicians are interested in reelection.  But I see movement foremost on the estate tax, maybe in combination with an extension in emergency unemployment benefits.