Showing posts with label Plan B. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Plan B. Show all posts

Friday, December 21, 2012

Boehner Can't Deliver

The jig is up.  Boehner crashes and burns.  He can't deliver his own "Plan B."  As summarized by Jonathan Weisman in a frontpage, top-of-the-fold, right-hand-side story in this morning's paper (with the subhead "Embarrassing Setback"):
The refusal of a band of House Republicans to allow income tax rates to rise on incomes over $1 million came after Mr. Obama scored a decisive re-election victory campaigning for higher taxes on incomes over $250,000. Since the November election, the president’s approval ratings have risen, and opinion polls have shown a strong majority not only favoring his tax position, but saying they will blame Republicans for a failure to reach a deficit deal.

With a series of votes on Thursday, the speaker, who faces election for his post in the new Congress next month, had hoped to assemble a Republican path away from the cliff. With a show of Republican unity, he also sought to strengthen his own hand in negotiations with Mr. Obama. The House did narrowly pass legislation to cancel automatic, across-the-board military cuts set to begin next month, and shift them to domestic programs.

But the main component of “Plan B,” a bill to extend expiring Bush-era tax cuts for everyone with incomes under $1 million, could not win enough Republican support to overcome united Democratic opposition. Democrats questioned Mr. Boehner’s ability to deliver any agreement. 
The situation as it stands now is that Republicans are going home for Christmas.  Their conference is split.  Some want a compromise; others don't.  Boehner is crippled.  The way forward being talked about is for Boehner to bring something to the floor that could pass with Democratic support and some Republican votes.  It would be a kamikaze mission for Boehner who would likely lose his speakership as a result, but some see this as a choice Boehner is willing to make provided he gets an agreement he likes with Obama.  This from the conclusion of Weisman's story:

“The math changes” with a bipartisan deal, said Representative Steven C. LaTourette, a retiring Republican moderate from Ohio, who predicted Mr. Boehner could win at least half of House Republicans. “If there’s a negotiated settlement with the president, the speaker will put it on the floor and we’ll see where the chips fall.” 
I don't see it.  Nothing Boehner has done indicates that he would buck his caucus and work with the Democrats and Obama to seal a big deal.  What does worry me -- particularly after watching his last press conference -- is what Obama might concede to a wounded Boehner to get him to try a kamikaze mission.  Obama can be rolled. 

At this point I wouldn't bother with Boehner at all.  He's unreliable; he can't deliver.  He's a sound bite, a hallucination.  Let him go.  Let's go off cliff; let's reset the terms of the debate.  We'll deal with the Mad Mullahs in the New Year.

Thursday, December 20, 2012

Wile E. Coyote Politics

On my arrival home last night after sitting through a two-hour political action committee meeting I watched Obama's thirty-six minute press conference.  He announced that vice president Biden will lead the effort to come up with legislative proposals for gun regulation.  Then he took questions.  All questions except one dealt with the fiscal cliff.  The first questioner asked why Obama broke a campaign pledge to exclude Social Security from the budget negotiations.  Obama was defensive; and throughout the question-and-answer period the defense of his decision to meet Boehner "at least halfway" revealed a contradiction.  On the one hand Obama correctly argued that he campaigned and was elected based on a pledge to raise taxes on the wealthy, that this is what a majority of Americans want; then on the other hand he said people want compromise, and that's what he did.  Of course people can desire contradictory things.  And maybe Obama is just trying to give the people what they want.  But it's bad politics.

Krugman points out in his blog from yesterday that Obama's offer to Boehner maintains most of the Bush tax cuts on dividends and capital gains.  Krugman was reserving judgment until he had learned more about what Obama had offered.  Now his position is that Obama must make absolutely no more concessions even if this means going over the cliff.  The problem, as Krugman points out, is that Republicans are interpreting Obama's latest offer as a sign of weakness and as proof that further concessions are close at hand.

And that is how to look at Boehner's "Plan B" scheduled for a vote today -- as a way not only to curry favor with voters if negotiations collapse but also as one last volley meant to extract more concessions from the president.  That's assuming that Boehner can get it passed.  The reporting today from Jackie Calmes and Jonathan Weisman casts doubt on this. 

One bright spot if Boehner can't deliver his "Plan B" is we'll know that the jig is up.  Talks will be finished.  Boehner, unable to get his own bill through, won't be able to deliver anything.  Then we can, like Wile E. Coyote, settle in and get ready for life on the downside of the cliff.

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Boehner's Plan B

The journey through the fiscal cliff labyrinth continues.  With each day the path to a deal grows more twisted.  The story today from Jonathan Weisman regards Boehner's "Plan B."  This is the speaker's plan to bring a vote to the floor of the House on Thursday on a tax increase for people earning more than a million dollars a year.  The Democrats are opposed as are a number of Republicans in Boehner's caucus.  "Plan B" is another ruse hatched by GOP leadership looking for a way to soften the blow of public disapproval once negotiations finally collapse.  The money quote from Weisman is towards the end of his story:
It is not clear whether the Boehner plan is a serious alternative or primarily a bargaining tactic to extract more concessions from Mr. Obama. Rob Nabors, the president’s chief liaison to Congress, met with House Democrats on Tuesday and said talks were moving forward.

But privately, he expressed pessimism that Mr. Boehner could sign on to any deal, according to people familiar with those conversations.
The reaction to the news that Obama is willing to accept a chained CPI continues to grow. While still hedging based on the lack of details as to what Obama actually agreed to, Krugman has come out against the chained CPI as a cruel benefit cut for seniors and an awful move -- cutting Social Security -- for a Democratic president to make. Annie Lowrey has a "Debt Reckoning" sidebar today explaining the chained CPI. It's an index that takes into account consumer substitution of higher-priced items with less costly ones. The example that is always trotted out is that if apples are expensive people will buy oranges, if they're cheaper, instead. A chained CPI is supposed to reflect this substitution. As Krugman says, "What it does mean is that after retirement your payments grow more slowly, about 0.3 percent each year. So if you retire at 65, your income at 75 would be 3 percent less under this proposal than under current law; at 85 it would be 6 percent less."
Peter Baker has a "think" piece about Obama's response to the Newtown massacre and how likely it is that he will lead a legislative battle to regulate guns.  Obama has been taciturn about his plans.  The gist of Baker's analysis is that Obama only engages in fights he thinks he can win.  He's a status quo leader.  Of course there's a lot of work to be done within the parameters of the current system.  But if the system is failing fundamentally -- as Newtown clearly showed -- we need a paradigm shift.  Last month's election provided the impetus for such a shift.  But now -- with pictures of John Boehner leading the news each day -- it's back to the Washington D.C. corporate-occupied-territory mindset.