Showing posts with label chained CPI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chained CPI. Show all posts

Thursday, April 11, 2013

Obama's Austere Budget + Glenda Jackson Takes on Thatcherism

Obama's budget is the lead story in the New York Times this morning. Nothing much new is covered by Jackie Calmes' story, "Obama Budget Whittles Democratic Party Pillars," compared to the one she wrote last week where she confirmed that Obama was indeed going to propose a reduction in Social Security cost of living adjustments. Calmes' focus today is more on the politico-historical aspect of a Democratic president going after the landmark programs, Social Security and Medicare, associated with the New Deal and the Great Society.

I found myself in agreement with the analysis of the unsigned editorial on the Opinion page, "The President's Budget." There the Times argues that a chained CPI is a bad idea; that it would have been a better to raise "the wage cap subject to a payroll tax." But the rest of Obama's budget ideas the editorial board is in agreement with:
Rejecting the president’s budget also means passing over a host of good ideas — chief among them, replacing the arbitrary and damaging sequestration cuts with more sensible reductions, along with ways to make the rich pay a larger share of revenues. 
The plan would cut spending by about $1.2 trillion over a decade, which is more than is necessary and more than Mr. Obama previously offered. The cuts include $306 billion from Medicare providers by relying more on generic drugs and demanding greater efficiencies from doctors and hospitals. Drug companies would have to pay a much larger share of the costs borne by low-income Medicare recipients. Farm subsidies would be cut by $38 billion, and spending on the military, the State Department and homeland security would also be reduced. 
Couples with incomes starting at about $170,000 a year would have to pay about 5 percentage points more for Medicare premiums. And there would be several other significant tax increases: The carried-interest tax break used by wealthy hedge fund operators would rise to ordinary-income levels, overall tax breaks for couples making more than $250,000 would be reduced, and a “Buffett Rule” that would ensure that millionaires pay at least 30 percent of their income in taxes. The federal cigarette tax would almost double to $1.95 a pack. Collectively, new revenues would bring in about $600 billion in a decade.
The Times interprets Obama's offering on Social Security as a feint to expose the phoniness of Republican posturing on deficits. This perspective is completely demolished by a Yves Smith post yesterday on naked capitalism, "Obama Moves Forward with Cutting Social Security and Medicare as We Lecture Europe Otherwise." I think her concluding paragraph is one that needs to be taken to heart by all of us who have stuck with Obama up until now:
This is what the defenders refuse to acknowledge: the Obama critics, again and again, have been proven right, yet we have seen remarkably few mea cuplas, let alone apologies (and that includes you, Charles Pierce and Scott Lemieux). Obama is proving to be a litmus test of where commentators’ loyalties really stand: is it to “liberal” beliefs, which get redefined evermore to the right, or is it to the Democratic party neoliberal technocrats, which Obama embodies? The budget battle is pure and simple about squeezing the middle class dry, and those who pretend otherwise are simply insulting the intelligence of their audience.
Let's conclude this morning with a video from yesterday of MP Glenda Jackson taking on the hagiography of the matriarch of neoliberalism, Margaret Thatcher:

Friday, April 5, 2013

Obama Embraces Chained CPI

Obama is negotiating with himself again. The news this morning is that the administration is going to propose benefit cuts to Social Security when it releases its budget next week. According to Jackie Calmes' frontpage story, "Obama Budget to Include Cuts to Programs in Hopes of Deal":
Some Senate Republicans have been urging the president to speak out more to Americans about his ideas for reducing the growth of entitlement programs. While the White House posted the offer to Mr. Boehner on its Web site this year, aides previously said that Mr. Obama would not include its provisions in his official budget documents. To do so, some said, would expose him to Democrats’ criticism that he is too quick to compromise and allow Republicans to embrace the proposals for spending cuts, in particular the C.P.I., but ignore those for tax increases.
Neither the president nor senior aides privately hold much hope that Republican leaders — Mr. Boehner and Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Senate Republican leader — will compromise. So Mr. Obama’s strategy of reaching out to other Senate Republicans reflects a calculation that enough of them might cut a budget deal with the Democratic Senate majority. If that happens, the reasoning goes, a Senate-passed compromise would put pressure on the House to go along.
It's hard to fathom why Obama is making this move. Embracing a chained CPI didn't lead to a breakthrough in the fiscal cliff negotiations last December. If anything Republican unwillingness to compromise, to broker a deal of any kind, has only increased in the last three months, proof of which was on display with the sequester. And, let's not forget, it was Obama's indulgence in self-bargaining that brought us the sequester in the first place; it came out of the 2011 debt ceiling debacle.

For a good reading of the tea leaves of what Obama's latest capitulation means check out this morning's naked capitalism post by Yves Smith, "Now It's Official: Obama Sells Catfood Futures, Um, Social Security and Medicare Cuts":
There is no more pretense possible. As we’ve warned for some time, Obama is eager to put a notch on his belt by being the President that rolled back the New Deal programs that helped create broad-based middle-class prosperity and dignity. He’s cast himself as an adult inflicting discipline on profligate Americans. But in reality, the profligacy was most concentrated among elite financiers who used leverage on leverage vehicles to stoke liquidity that led to worldwide underpricing of risk. They paid themselves record bonuses in the years immediately preceding the crisis, and then in a grotesque display of ingratitude, did so again in 2009, able to do so only thanks to massive taxpayer support, alphabet-soup special borrowing programs, and the tax on savers known as ZIRP. And the direct result of their looting exercise that produced the crisis was the explosion in government deficits, due to a collapse in tax revenues and a rise in payments under countercyclical programs such as unemployment insurance and food stamps.
Yes, it's all very disspiriting but, sadly, unsurprising. The Counterpunch Left has been shouting about Obama's craven nature for years. Now it's almost impossible to deny. Obama apologists might float the argument that he's only proposing benefit cuts because he knows there is no chance, due to Republican intransigence, that they will go into effect; he just wants to see if it's possible to get a budget through the Senate with GOP support in order to reap the whirlwind in the reconciliation process with the House. This, as Yves Smith says, is Obama as 11-dimensional chess master, and it is a fantasy. Our worry should be a repeat of the 2011 debt ceiling crisis.

To return to Calmes' article, here are the nuts and bolts, besides the chained CPI, of what will be in Obama's budget:
According to administration officials, the president’s budget plan would reduce projected annual deficits by $1.8 trillion over 10 years, even with the select spending increases. To offset the initiatives’ cost and avoid adding to deficits, Mr. Obama will propose the tobacco tax increase, a limit of $3 million on how much people can accumulate in tax-preferred savings accounts and repeal of a loophole that allows people to collect both disability and unemployment benefits.
Together with the $2.5 trillion in deficit reductions that Mr. Obama and Congressional Republicans have agreed to since 2010, that would bring the total deficit reduction to more than $4.3 trillion over 10 years by the administration’s computations — just over the goal that both parties have set for stabilizing the growth of the national debt. 
Of the more than $2.5 trillion to date in projected 10-year budget savings, nearly 80 percent would result from spending cuts. The rest would derive from tax increases on high incomes that became law on Jan. 1, in the tax agreement that the two parties reached at year-end when the efforts for a broader deficit-reduction deal collapsed. 
Mr. Obama’s proposals to reduce deficits $1.8 trillion more over a decade track his offer to Mr. Boehner, adjusted for the roughly $600 billion in higher taxes that became law in January. He will propose more than $600 billion in new revenues — his last offer had called for $1.2 trillion in taxes — mostly by limiting to 28 percent the deductions that individuals in higher tax brackets can claim. Congress has ignored that idea in past years. 
Deficits would be reduced another $930 billion through 2023 as a result of spending cuts and other cost-saving changes to domestic programs, and $200 billion more due to reduced interest payments on the federal debt. 
Mr. Obama’s proposed spending reductions include about $400 billion from health programs and $200 billion from other areas, including farm subsidies, federal employee retirement programs, the Postal Service and the unemployment compensation system.
In Medicare, the savings would mostly come from payments to health care providers, including hospitals and pharmaceutical companies, but Mr. Obama also proposes that higher-income beneficiaries pay more for coverage.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

GOP Government Shutdown Plan

House Republicans set their extortion calendar. Jonathan Weisman's story today about yesterday's House vote to suspend enforcement of the debt ceiling until May 18 lays out how the government-shutdown thrill ride will proceed in the coming months. The good news is that we will be spared this frontpage-hog for the remainder of the month and all of February. Then March 1 "$110 billion in across-the-board spending cuts to military and domestic programs — known as a sequester — will go into force."
The next real showdown will come by March 27, when the stopgap measure financing the government expires. Republicans have made clear that they are willing to let the government shut down at that time to force deep spending cuts or changes to Medicare and Social Security that would bring down deficits in the long run.
Included in the debt-ceiling suspension is a provision to "withhold the pay of lawmakers in a chamber of Congress that fails to pass a budget blueprint by April 15." This is aimed at Senate Democrats who have not passed a budget since 2009.

The GOP design here is to get the Senate to produce a budget that can be reconciled in conference with the Ryan Plan, a.k.a., "The Path to Prosperity," and inflict as much damage as possible on Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security. We're talking about the block granting of Medicaid; the privatizing of Medicare and raising its eligibility age; and while Ryan changed his tune and now calls for no changes in Social Security, Boehner sought a chained CPI in the recent fiscal cliff negotiations, and privatization remains the Republican Holy Grail. And what Boehner is talking about, a balanced budget over the next ten years, is actually much worse than the Ryan Plan, which doesn't balance the budget until 2040. This is from today's lead unsigned editorial in the New York Times:
If the House actually wants to put forth a balanced budget over the next 10 years, as Mr. Boehner vowed to do on Wednesday, let the public see what that really means: unimaginable cuts and changes to Medicare and Medicaid, and the elimination of scores of popular and vital programs that benefit both the poor and the middle class. Up to now, Republicans have been understandably wary of specifying how that would be done without raising taxes. Mitt Romney wouldn’t do it, and even Representative Paul Ryan’s budgets up to now wouldn’t balance the budget until 2040.

Thursday, January 3, 2013

The Next Armageddon

This morning's paper is filled with talk of the debt ceiling.  We lurch from one Armageddon to the next (which doesn't make sense because in the Book of Revelation there's only one grand battle that brings the end of the world).  Before the American Taxpayer Relief Act was even signed into law focus had already shifted to Obama's promise not to negotiate with House Republicans on the debt ceiling.  This is the way it is put in an unsigned editorial in the New York Times:
Mr. Obama sounded resolute on Tuesday night in vowing he will not submit to this blackmail. “I will not have another debate with this Congress over whether or not they should pay the bills that they’ve already racked up through the laws that they passed,” he said. But will he really keep this promise?

The White House won several victories in the fiscal-cliff package, but its eagerness for a deal disappointed many who believed the president’s promise to raise far more revenue. It is hard to see how he avoids giving in to Republican demands, as he was forced to do in 2011. 
Michael Shear and Jackie Calmes have a frontpage story which gives voice to a beltway skepticism of Obama's ability to hold the line:
Some people in both parties questioned why Mr. Obama would so emphatically vow not to negotiate over the debt limit, a promise he may ultimately be forced to break if necessary to avoid economic shock waves.

“It’s bizarre,” said one veteran Democratic senator who would not be named, citing the proven willingness of Republicans to force a fiscal crisis unless the president makes a deal for additional spending cuts.
I don't watch the markets like I used to; one thing I can say for sure is that the last time there was a standoff on the debt ceiling the Dow was badly shaken.  And since Obama has already agreed in theory to a chained CPI, why would a hard-to-control House Republican caucus accept anything less in exchange for raising the debt limit?  This debt-ceiling drama will play for a two-month run, which is the same amount of time the fiscal cliffhanger took.

Before rushing into the new Armageddon let's take a moment to appreciate what Obama has achieved.  Take a peek at this quote from David Leonhardt's think piece:
On average, the top 0.1 percent of earners — whose incomes start at $2.7 million and go much higher — will pay $444,000 more in taxes in 2013 than they otherwise would have, according to the Tax Policy Center. The increases stem from both the fiscal deal and the new taxes in the health care law.

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Boehner's Plan B

The journey through the fiscal cliff labyrinth continues.  With each day the path to a deal grows more twisted.  The story today from Jonathan Weisman regards Boehner's "Plan B."  This is the speaker's plan to bring a vote to the floor of the House on Thursday on a tax increase for people earning more than a million dollars a year.  The Democrats are opposed as are a number of Republicans in Boehner's caucus.  "Plan B" is another ruse hatched by GOP leadership looking for a way to soften the blow of public disapproval once negotiations finally collapse.  The money quote from Weisman is towards the end of his story:
It is not clear whether the Boehner plan is a serious alternative or primarily a bargaining tactic to extract more concessions from Mr. Obama. Rob Nabors, the president’s chief liaison to Congress, met with House Democrats on Tuesday and said talks were moving forward.

But privately, he expressed pessimism that Mr. Boehner could sign on to any deal, according to people familiar with those conversations.
The reaction to the news that Obama is willing to accept a chained CPI continues to grow. While still hedging based on the lack of details as to what Obama actually agreed to, Krugman has come out against the chained CPI as a cruel benefit cut for seniors and an awful move -- cutting Social Security -- for a Democratic president to make. Annie Lowrey has a "Debt Reckoning" sidebar today explaining the chained CPI. It's an index that takes into account consumer substitution of higher-priced items with less costly ones. The example that is always trotted out is that if apples are expensive people will buy oranges, if they're cheaper, instead. A chained CPI is supposed to reflect this substitution. As Krugman says, "What it does mean is that after retirement your payments grow more slowly, about 0.3 percent each year. So if you retire at 65, your income at 75 would be 3 percent less under this proposal than under current law; at 85 it would be 6 percent less."
Peter Baker has a "think" piece about Obama's response to the Newtown massacre and how likely it is that he will lead a legislative battle to regulate guns.  Obama has been taciturn about his plans.  The gist of Baker's analysis is that Obama only engages in fights he thinks he can win.  He's a status quo leader.  Of course there's a lot of work to be done within the parameters of the current system.  But if the system is failing fundamentally -- as Newtown clearly showed -- we need a paradigm shift.  Last month's election provided the impetus for such a shift.  But now -- with pictures of John Boehner leading the news each day -- it's back to the Washington D.C. corporate-occupied-territory mindset.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Maintenance of a Failed Satus Quo

A fiscal cliff deal does seem to be in the offing.  I read Jonathan Weisman's story online last night and again this morning with the delivery of the paper and the gist of the bargain is that Obama has reduced his revenue demand by four hundred billion dollars, from $1.6 trillion to $1.2 trillion, in an attempt to meet Boehner, who recently raised his revenue target from $800 billion to $1 trillion.  Also, "The White House plan would permanently extend Bush-era tax cuts on household incomes below $400,000, meaning that only the top tax bracket, 35 percent, would increase to 39.6 percent. The current cutoff between the top rate and the next highest rate, 33 percent, is $388,350."  Obama's position now is to let only the top tax rate, not the top two tax rates, revert to Clinton-era levels.

On the spending side, Obama has come up with $1.22 trillion in cuts over ten years, part of which is from changing the way the government calculates inflation.  Medicare and Medicaid are to be cut by $400 billion.

Obama wants a two-year increase in the debt ceiling.  Boehner is willing to give one year.  Included in any deal, Obama wants an extension of the emergency federal unemployment benefits and some more stimulus spending .  Nothing was reported on the fate of the estate tax.  Boehner is set to bring the deal to his conference this morning.

If this is the deal, I'm not satisfied.  It is basically a maintenance of the status quo, a status quo which is not working for working people.  Recalling Paul Krugman's column from last Friday, where he argued that the fiscal cliff is more a political crisis than a budgetary one, the deal being reported by Weisman doesn't alter the political landscape in the way that going off the cliff would.  And that's what we need -- a big paradigm shift.  We've got to start acting more collectively to address the numerous huge problems that confront us.  We will not be able to do so as long as the Mad Mullahs, who serve at the behest of the 1%, hold sway in the House.  Going off the fiscal cliff would call the question.

What I've been calling the Counterpunch Left is apparently right and I've been wrong.  Obama is a Manchurian Candidate for the plutocracy to that extent that he maintains a status quo that is fundamentally plutocratic and unsustainable.

It's interesting that Krugman blogged yesterday afternoon that he wants to see if the "Republican crazies" scuttle the deal before weighing in on whether to support it.  He says a "chained CPI" is a real benefit cut but far less damaging than an increase in the Medicare eligibility age.  He says there's some merit in going off the cliff in order to out the GOP Mad Mullahs; then he says, "but there’s also an argument that this might not work."