Showing posts with label debt ceiling. Show all posts
Showing posts with label debt ceiling. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

The Threadbare Quality of Western-Manufactured Russophobia

For all those who believed that the "New Cold War" with Russia was a passing fiction, Putin's cancellation of the South Stream gas pipeline from Russia to Bulgaria should convince them otherwise.

Each day Russophobic rants appear in the prestige press of the West.  I read the Gray Lady, and I can testify that always within the first few paragraphs of the story, as is the case today in "With Russia on Brink of Recession, Putin Faces ‘New Reality’ " by Neil NacFarquhar and Andrew Kramer, there is a reference to Putin's "nationalistic adventures abroad, akin to the annexation of Crimea."

Today's Russia-bashing article by MacFarquhar and Kramer focuses on a Kremlin report yesterday that predicts recession in 2015. Due to a combination of collapsing oil prices and Western financial sanctions Russian growth is anticipated to be significantly curtailed. The ruble has gone from trading 27-to-the-dollar to 54-to-the-dollar.
Financial experts say Russia’s most pressing problem is not the sinking ruble, despite its potential to prompt a run on the banks, nor the falling price of oil, though the annual budget was based on a price of $96 per barrel, which is now hovering around $70. 
“This is all peanuts compared to the financing crisis,” said Vladimir Milov, a former deputy energy minister turned opposition politician. 
Nearly $700 billion is owed to Western banks, economists said, much of it by the giant state-run companies that constitute the heart of the Russian economy. But sanctions imposed by the United States and Europe over Russia’s annexation of Crimea and adventurism in southeastern Ukraine have blocked access to Western financing. 
Despite Moscow’s plans to turn East as an alternative, China’s banks just do not have the capacity. Instead, the debt threatens to drain the Kremlin of its $400 billion in foreign currency reserves. 
Among the companies with their hands out are Rosneft, Novatek, VTB Bank, Rusnano and Russian Railways, asking for sums well beyond the $90 billion held by the National Welfare Fund, a sovereign wealth fund for rainy days. 
Mr. Putin has yet to express publicly how he expects Russia to emerge from its financial problems. At a news conference last month, he addressed concerns about oil by saying that prices had been high enough in the first part of 2014 to finance much of the Russian budget, and that the country would just have to “wait and see” about next year.
This is the stock-in-trade of Western media: amplify the potency of the economic sanctions Europe and the United States implemented against Russia in order to protect the Banderite coup in Kiev last winter and then gloatingly foretell the collapse of Moscow. It is the puerile fantasy of D.C. and Brussels elites to see Putin return hat in hand to the throne of Western power, scraping and shuffling in front of the NATO generals and London and New York bankers.

These stories are usually pieced together out of quotes from disgruntled Muscovites living abroad or pro-Western think-tank hacks or, as is on display this morning in an OpEd by Russophobic scholar and former Reagan State Dept. employee Karen Dawisha, "Bad-Mannered Russians in the West," USG cutouts.

Dawisha's ludicrous argument is that cancerous Russian corruption and lawlessness is sullying pristine Western institutions and norms. One wonders if Dawisha ever takes the time to read the business page where she could learn about Goldman Sachs corrupting the New York Fed or the LIBOR currency-rigging scheme perpetrated by big Western banks. Dawisha is a joke.

Just to gain a little perspective on future national economic growth, take a look at Jonathan Weisman's "Uncertainty in Washington Poses Long List of Economic Perils":
WASHINGTON — As House Republicans mull another round of fiscal brinkmanship with President Obama, a dark cloud is threatening to return to otherwise clearing economic skies: fiscal and political uncertainty. 
Republican leaders moved Tuesday to finesse their way around another government shutdown next week, but the fiscal gantlet extends well beyond Dec. 11, when the current stopgap spending law that funds much of the federal government expires. 
Absent congressional action, a host of business and personal tax breaks expires on Jan. 1. The government’s borrowing limit is reinstated on March 16, although the government might not actually hit the ceiling until August. 
On March 28, unless lawmakers act, physician reimbursements from Medicare drop off a cliff. On May 31, the highway trust fund runs out of money. In June, the Export-Import Bank, which helps finance overseas purchases of American exports, might shut in the face of conservative opposition to its mission. Then on Sept. 30, the entire Children’s Health Insurance Program faces its expiration. A few days later, across-the-board spending cuts loom once again.

“I see a lot of potential for Republicans to use all these fiscal speed bumps as leverage points,” said Joel Prakken, a co-founder of Macroeconomic Advisers, a forecasting firm that calculated that previous fiscal fights, combined with tighter budgets, shaved as much as 1 percentage point off economic growth, a big sum considering that growth has averaged an annual rate of 2.15 percent since Republicans took control of the House in 2011.
House Speaker John Boehner has shown very little acumen for keeping his caucus in line. More brinkmanship lies ahead:
Congressional leaders moved to clear up some uncertainty Tuesday, but in so doing, they may merely create more. House Republican leaders would like to pass a measure funding the government through Sept. 30, but keeping the Homeland Security office open only for short bursts to pressure the president over his executive action deferring deportation of illegal immigrants. 
Most House Republicans appeared ready to go along with this half measure, but conservative groups opposed the strategy as not confrontational enough on issues like the Environmental Protection Agency’s climate change regulations or the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s antidiscrimination efforts. Anti-immigration conservatives made it clear they would keep opposing the undocumented-worker executive order.
“This is the time to fight, this is the ground to fight on, and I’m a little bit amazed that that isn’t more clear to more people,” declared Representative Steve King, Republican of Iowa.
There is a chance that it is the United States economy that will be in recession next year.

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

The End of Debt-Ceiling Politics + Hillary vs. Scott Walker in 2016?

The news arrived yesterday with little fanfare; it might not have even been the top story on the Google News page. But it is certainly a noteworthy development. The House of Representatives passed a clean debt ceiling bill -- meaning there are no conditions attached, no quid pro quo, no Keystone XL pipeline, no nibbling away at Obamacare -- raising the amount that government can legally borrow through march 2015. This morning Jonathan Weisman and Ashley Parker have the story, "House Approves Higher Debt Limit Without Condition."

It is an enormous capitulation by Speaker of the House John Boehner, who had to rely on overwhelming Democratic support (only 28 Republicans voted yes). After three years, the GOP strategy of locking down D.C. with debt-ceiling brinkmanship has been tossed on the dung heap. Last October's near Armageddon must have been enough for the national Republican brain trust, particularly when the GOP was awarded a Get Out of Jail Free card with Obamacare's disastrous online rollout. Republican leadership is keeping eyes on the prize: the U.S. Senate and possibly even the White House. Towards that goal they obviously feel that a low profile, coupled with an aggressive beatdown on Tea Party primary challengers, will deliver them to the promised land.

Clearly there is wisdom in leaving Obama to stew in his own shit. (See Monday's post for Obama's plummeting approval rating as well as the country's burgeoning socialist populism.) But Boehner's adroit elimination of debt-ceiling politics on Tuesday comes at a steep price for the GOP. The internecine warfare between the corporate-financed Tea Party and the Republican establishment which, for the most part, has been kept off the front pages (left to rage online) is now going to -- or at least there is that potential -- blow up big time. As Weisman and Parker point out,
For Mr. Boehner it was a potentially momentous decision. Conservative activists, including the Tea Party Patriots, FreedomWorks, L. Brent Bozell’s ForAmerica and commentators on the website RedState.com are all circulating petitions to end Mr. Boehner’s speakership. 
And it was Mr. Boehner who raised such high expectations around the debt limit. In 2011, he established what has become known as the “Boehner Rule”: any debt ceiling increase was supposed to be offset by an equivalent spending cut. 
“This is a lost opportunity,” the speaker conceded. “We could have sat down and worked together in a bipartisan manner to find cuts and reforms that are greater than increasing the debt limit. I am disappointed, to say the least.”
Also, there is this tasty morsel a few paragraphs down:
In a closed-door session Monday night, Representative Andy Harris, Republican of Maryland, accused the speaker of being in the pockets of the insurance industry, a charge that stirred outrage among many of his colleagues.
There is a good chance, I think, that it will blow over quickly. It probably already has. More extreme weather in the South, Tom Brokaw diagnosed with cancer, etc., will suck up the attention of news consumers.

I have a coworker who follows the daily news. When she gave me a ride to the train station yesterday after work I asked her what she thought about the House passing the debt ceiling. She said that she had glimpsed the headline right before we left, but that she didn't read the story or really even think about it.

Chalk up a "W" for Boehner and the GOP establishment.

Before signing off, I'd like to mention that Trip Gabriel has a good story, "In Governors’ Races This Year, Lessons for 2016," about Republican governors running for reelection. He focuses on four Republicans in the industrial North -- Walker of Wisconsin, Kasich of Ohio, Snyder of Michigan and Corbett of Pennsylvania:
National Democratic groups hope to take back the four executive mansions held by Rust Belt Republicans by attacking on social and economic issues — the incumbents’ cuts to education, their opposition to raising the minimum wage and abortion restrictions they signed into law. 
“They’ve all fostered hostility and divisiveness despite running as moderate technocrats,” said Danny Kanner, a spokesman for the Democratic Governors Association, which bought its first television ads of the 2014 cycle in Michigan, attacking Mr. Snyder. “On the economy, they gave huge tax cuts to the wealthiest and corporations. They paid for it by raising middle-class taxes, and because that wasn’t enough, they cut education.” 
Mr. Walker’s bitter 2011 showdown with the unions made him a national figure. He remains a hero of the Republican grass roots and a favorite of wealthy donors like the billionaire David H. Koch, who founded a nonprofit group that contributed heavily to the governor’s campaign to avoid a recall. That appeal to the party’s base and its donor class has some conservative pundits and strategists banging the drum for a presidential bid. 
Mr. Walker, who insists that his focus is on 2014, seems to gain in stature each day that enthusiasm for Gov. Chris Christie, Republican of New Jersey, ebbs in the scandal over the closing of bridge lanes. 
But Mr. Walker has also helped polarize his battleground state. A Marquette University Law School poll last month showed his job approval reaching a high — of just 51 percent.
Can you imagine a more nauseating general election in 2016 than Hillary vs. Scott Walker? It would be 12 months of rockem sockem corporate robots.

Thursday, October 17, 2013

Paying the Price of the Bush Years

Federal employees return to work this morning. The deal that Obama signed into law after midnight was put together in the Senate. It is the same as outlined on this blog a few days ago, minus the one-year delay in the reinsurance tax on health plans. (CNN provides the text of the actual bill.)

What does it accomplish? Basically nothing. The splinter of a bone tossed to the GOP in the form of an income verification requirement for individuals who receive a subsidy to purchase health insurance has been dismissed as meaningless by the White House. The House-Senate budget conference to be concluded by December 13 that the new law mandates will likely be a failure due to the Republican's ban on raising new revenue.

The last two-and-a-half weeks accomplished nothing and resolved very little. The New York Times editorial board said "The only things Republicans achieved were billions of dollars in damage to the economy, harm to the nation’s reputation and a rock-bottom public approval rating." This standoff was about the internal politics of the Grand Old Party. Speaker Boehner played a game where he gave the Tea Party enough rope to hang itself hoping that it would sate the fire eaters in his caucus for the next go-round. As Jonathan Weisman and Ashley Parker describe it in this morning's story, "Republicans Back Down, Ending Crisis Over Shutdown and Debt Limit":
Two weeks of relative cohesion broke down into near chaos on Tuesday when Republican leaders failed twice to unite their troops behind a last-gasp effort to prevent a default on their own terms. By Wednesday, House conservatives were accusing more moderate Republicans of undercutting their position. Representative Charlie Dent of Pennsylvania, a leading Republican voice for ending the fight, said Congress should have passed a bill to fund the government without policy strings attached weeks ago. 
“That’s essentially what we’re doing now,” Mr. Dent said. “People can blame me all they want, but I was correct in my analysis and I’d say a lot of those folks were not correct in theirs.”
Good analysis in today's paper is provided by Jeremy Peters' "Losing a Lot to Get Little." Peters is skeptical that the Tea Party has learned anything:
“We managed to divide ourselves on something we were unified on, over a goal that wasn’t achievable,” said Senator Roy Blunt, Republican of Missouri. “The president probably had the worst August and early September any president could have had. And we managed to change the topic.” 
The question so crucial to the Republican Party’s viability now, heading into the 2014 Congressional elections and beyond, is whether it has been so stung by the fallout that the conservatives who insisted on leading this fight will shy away in the months ahead when the government runs out of money and exhausts its borrowing authority yet again. 
It is not an abstract question. The deal reached Wednesday would finance the government only through Jan. 15 and lift the debt ceiling through Feb. 7. Some top Republicans suggest that this confrontation, one some of the most conservative Tea Party-aligned Republicans have been itching for since they arrived, ended so badly for them that it would curb the appetite for another in just a few short months. 
*** 
Speaker John A. Boehner’s strategy always involved a gamble that his members would come away from this clash chastened. He intentionally allowed his most conservative members to sit in the driver’s seat as they tried in vain to get the Senate to accept one failed measure after another — first to defund the health care law, then to delay it, then to chip away at it. His hope was that they would realize the fight was not worth having again.
The worry among many Republicans is that the Tea Party flank will not get the message, mainly because their gerrymandered districts are so conservative they do not have to listen. 
Some fear that history is repeating itself. After Mitt Romney’s defeat in which the Republicans lost the popular presidential vote for the fifth time in six elections, the party tried to regroup. Its establishment warned that it had to stop being so shrill, so exclusionary and so narrowly focused on issues that alienate large chunks of voters who might otherwise think about being Republicans. 
Certainly, the budget fight showed that Congressional Republicans have divergent ideas about how to heed that advice.
Like a cradle-bound baby fondling his excrement, we're doomed early next year to some form of a repeat of this October's nauseating, self-indulgent Republican identity crisis. We're paying the price of the Bush years. So frightened by the rise of Obama and the discrediting of the GOP brand after the brazen lies that led to the Iraq War and the collapse of Wall Street, Republican sachems felt the need to lie down with the kooks and the Birchers. At this point there is no indication that there will be any change of direction in 2014.

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Tea Party Destroying "Capitalism in One Country"

It's hard to see how the United States avoids default. Boehner's gambit to deflate Senate negotiations by offering up a House deal was successful for a day before the effort collapsed; once again, he couldn't line up the ultras in his caucus. The deal Boehner was trying to piece together would have taken the main components of the deal being hatched in the Senate -- paying for the operation of government through January 15; lifting the debt ceiling through February 7 -- and added Tea Party sweeteners in the form of forcing Congressional staff members to purchase Obamacare without subsidy and putting limits on what the Treasury Department can to to manage payments once the debt ceiling has been reached.

That Boehner could not garner Tea Party support for his debt-ceiling/government-shutdown deal makes it close to certain that anything that emerges from Senate negotiations today will not have Tea Party support in the House. So -- not to belabor a point made on this blog repeatedly the last two weeks -- it will be up to Boehner -- as he has done in the past with the fiscal cliff and storm relief -- to allow an up-or-down vote and to pass a bill with majority support from the Democrats.

Even if a way out of a financial meltdown is found at the eleventh hour, lasting damage has been done. Damien Cave has an interesting story today, "Viewing U.S. in Fear and Dismay," which is a collection of quotes, some by people on their way to work, from around the world:
“The U.S.’s exorbitant privilege” — of issuing the world’s most widely accepted currency — “allows it not to have a budget, to bump against debt limit with scant market reaction,” said Luis de la Calle, a Mexican economist. 
If Mexico and many other countries shut down their governments, stopped paying salaries and threatened to default, he added, the titans of global finance, as they have in the past, would make sure the consequences were swift and severe. “We have little choice but to be responsible,” Mr. de la Calle said.
What we're going through is the concentration of capitalism in one country -- this is a point that the Monthly Review has made in the past, sort of an upside down postmodern version of Stalin's "Socialism in One Country" -- combined with the reactionary, revanchist capture of one of the parties making up the duopoly.

The Tea Party was organized and financed by plutocrats fearing the progressive majority that elected Obama, twice; at the time that it was whipped into being by the captains of capital, back in the summer of 2009, I thought it revealed how desperate and out of touch conservative power brokers were. Now, as "Capitalism in One Country" starts to dissolve, the strategy of empowering the Tea Party has backfired. Clearly.

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Senate Debt/Shutdown Deal Basically a Punt

When I got home last night from work after a stop off at the grocery store (whose United Food and Commercial Workers employees are looking at potentially going on strike, having been locked for some time in contentious negotiations with the employer group) I checked the messages on my answering machine. It's campaign season. So there was an invitation to participate in a conference call sponsored by opponents of the GMO-labeling initiative that will be on the ballot in November; there was a message from a city council candidate, I believe; an offer to have my carpets and drapes professionally cleaned. But the lengthiest message of the four was one from Glenn Beck urging me to sign "even if I have already signed before" a petition telling Obama to de-fund Obamacare. Several years ago -- it has to be going on six or seven -- I ended up on a conservative robodial list. I actually I appreciate it because it lets me know what issues are percolating among the Tea Party driven Right Wing.

Here's the skinny on the deal being hatched in the Senate to re-open the federal government and to avoid default on the sovereign debt of the United States. Based on what's being reported there are five components to the deal, one of which is not a repeal of the medical device tax. The best synopsis I have read is one that Paul Krugman links to in a blog post from yesterday, "Almost Over"; it is an update provided by Roll Call's Niels Lesniewski. The five components are:
  1. Reopen the government through January 15.
  2. Lift the debt ceiling through February 7.
  3. Begin a House-Senate conference with a deadline of December 15 to pass a budget that ends the sequester.
  4. Department of Health and Human Services certify incomes of individuals qualifying for a health care subsidy.
  5. Delay for one year a reinsurance tax that mandates, according to the IRS, "[A]ll health insurance issuers and third-party administrators on behalf of self-insured group health plans to make contributions under this program to support payments to individual market issuers that cover high-cost individuals."
Numbers four and five are meant to balance out. Four is a conservative demand; five is a union one (according to Lesniewski unions pushed for the delay; they're worried about absorbing the hit to their health & welfare funds). By having four and five offset you can make the argument that you're not caving in to Tea Party blackmail. But the New York Times editorial board isn't buying it. This is from today's unsigned editorial, "The Senate Tries to End the Crisis":
Senate negotiators insist that the income verification process would not impose any delays on the health law’s coverage of the uninsured, beginning in January, or the individual mandate to buy insurance. They said Kathleen Sebelius, the secretary of health and human services, would quickly make the certification, which would later be audited by the department’s inspector general. But the White House needs to provide assurance that this would not affect the implementation of the law in the slightest.

Delaying the insurance company tax, according to negotiators, doesn’t count as ransom, because Republicans never asked for it. In fact, it was requested by unions who object to paying more through their own health policies. But that strained logic doesn’t make it a good idea. If the delay is not paid for in some way — details remain unclear — it could force some insurers to raise premiums and make coverage less affordable. Without another source of money, the proposal should not be included in the final package.
Excepting income verification and reinsurance tax delay, the Senate deal shaping up is a punt, plain and simple. It is hard to see how the Tea Party caucus in the House votes for a punt. Maybe they do, figuring they can shut down the government again on January 15. But that seems unlikely. You can't keep pressing the shutdown button. Sooner or later there will be some serious blowback; organized push-back, I would imagine, is not far off.

So once again, we're back to where we started. Does Boehner allow a vote?

Monday, October 14, 2013

Back to Where We Started: Boehner Will Have to Go Against His Caucus

The confidence that caused an increase in the Dow on Friday quickly disappeared over the weekend when a Paul Ryan brokered deal to end the government shutdown/debt ceiling standoff fell through.

Republicans are loudly blaming Democrats. Strange stuff since Republicans are the ones that initiated the shutdown and are the ones threatening default.

Apparently the fault lies with the Democrats because they're unwilling to throw the Republicans a bone; in other words, the government shutdown is going to continue and the the world financial system is going to have to get work on building a new foundation because Democrats will not reward Republican blackmail.

As Krugman says in his column this morning, "The Dixiecrat Solution":
[O]ur current state of dysfunction looks like a chronic condition, not a one-time event. Even if the debt ceiling is raised enough to avoid immediate default, even if the government shutdown is somehow brought to an end, it will only be a temporary reprieve. Conservative activists are simply not willing to give up on the idea of ruling through extortion, and the Obama administration has decided, wisely, that it will not give in to extortion.
U.S. Treasury bills can longer be viewed as a completely safe. Republicans want a bone tossed to them so they can maintain extortion as a weapon to enhance their minority status. A potentially catastrophic default on U.S. sovereign debt, one would imagine, renders this weapon inoperable for future use. This is why Democrats are correctly refusing to offer any concessions. Concessions mean we go through this all over again the next time we butt up against the debt ceiling or the government needs to be funded.

The deal being worked on in the Senate is under the care of Susan Collins, Republican of Maine. Jonathan Weisman describes the Collins plan this morning in his story, "Spending Dispute Leaves a Senate Deal Elusive":
The Collins plan would maintain sequestration-level spending through Jan. 15, when formal budget negotiators would be required to complete a House-Senate agreement on spending and taxation over the next decade. That date was already a concession. Ms. Collins, along with Senators Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, both Republicans, initially wanted to finance the government for six months at those levels. The initial proposal by Ms. Collins would also have extended the debt ceiling only to Nov. 15, but at the request of Senate Democratic leaders, she and Mr. McConnell pushed it back to Jan. 31.
Having embraced this proposal, Senate minority leader Mitch McConnell is presumably using it as the basis for talks with Senate majority Harry Reid. As of now Democrats want the reduced spending of the sequester to last only through mid-November, not into the new year as Collins proposes.

It's hard to see how the Tea Party controlled House passes the Collins plan. So we're back to where we were at the beginning. Speaker of the House Boehner is going to have to go against the majority of his caucus and release whatever emerges from the Senate for an up-or-down floor vote. This is Krugman's conclusion, and it basically repeats the dynamic from the fiscal cliff negotiations last New Year's Eve.

Senate Democrats need to stand firm. They are who will determine if the neo-Dixiecrat rump will continue to dominate the federal government.

Friday, October 11, 2013

Republicans Beat the Retreat back to Paul Ryan + Free Syrian Army Implicated in Massacre

There is some confusion this morning about the possibility of a deal being reached between Republicans and Democrats on raising the debt ceiling. Conflicting reports from yesterday had Obama willing to sign off on a clean bill lifting the debt ceiling until November 22 without ending the government shutdown. As it turns out this was not the case. The Democratic position, reaffirmed by Senate majority leader Harry Reid, is that the government shutdown must end as well. Whether the GOP can get any deal through its caucus in the House is another question entirely.

All the to and fro yesterday of Democrats and Republicans meeting separately with Obama tended to obscure the real news of the last 48 hours -- the Tea Party demand that Obamacare be de-funded as the price to re-open government and lift the debt ceiling is now off the table. It is done, broadly acknowledged as a failure. A good story that captures the prevailing wisdom that the shuttering of government to coincide with the October 1 opening of the online health insurance exchanges has backfired is the Eric Lipton and Nick Confessore "Kochs and Other Conservatives Split Over Strategy on Health Law":
Opponents of the approach are arguing that conservatives would have been better served by trying to force an overall reduction in federal spending and tying that effort to the debt ceiling fight, a step the Koch-backed Americans for Prosperity urged this week. Specifically, the group argues that stopping the health care plan should be a years-long effort to marshal what it says will be growing public animosity toward the law. That will help elect Republican majorities in both houses of Congress, which will repeal it.
Conservatives are tossing recriminations back and forth as they beat a retreat back to fallen angel Paul Ryan and an elusive grand bargain on the budget.

I slightly misspoke yesterday when I assumed that the basis for Ryan's budget proposal offered in exchange for raising the debt ceiling was his 2012 The Path to Prosperity block granting of Medicaid and privatizing of Medicare. Chastened from his shellacking in last year's presidential election Ryan's budget prescriptions are apparently more modest and focused. This is from Jonathan Weisman's "Ryan Is Again in the Forefront for the G.O.P.":
An opinion piece [Ryan] wrote in The Wall Street Journal this week laid out what has now become the House Republican plan: a debt ceiling increase tied to changes to Medicare and Medigap plans that would save more than enough money to ease some of the across-the-board cuts to domestic and defense programs; a fast track for the comprehensive simplification of the tax code; and a demand for immediate, serious and structured negotiations with the White House and Democratic Senate. 
The fact that Mr. Ryan’s plan quite obviously made no mention of the health care law as a bargaining chip quickly drew him scorn from some on the right, but to Democrats and more moderate Republicans, the sidelining of the health care fight immediately gave the plan credibility. 
He marketed his idea on Wednesday to the House’s hard-line conservatives in the Republican Study Committee, getting enough favorable reaction to pull in the Republican leadership. On Thursday, after Mr. Boehner presented it to the full Republican conference, it became the official Republican position. As Mr. Boehner laid it out to the public, Mr. Ryan stood silently behind him. 
On Friday, he will take his message to the Values Voters Summit, a meeting of social conservatives. But according to an advance text of his remarks, he will add words of caution: “This president, he won’t agree to everything we need to do. A budget agreement — with this president and this Senate — it won’t solve all of our problems. But I hope it’s a start. I hope we can get a down payment on our debt.” 
Republicans and Democrats said Thursday that the success or failure of this new path forward will rest on Mr. Ryan’s shoulders. Republicans hope that with Mr. Ryan leading the charge, Washington will finally grapple with the true drivers of the federal budget deficit: entitlement programs like Medicare that are swelling as the population ages. Senator Rob Portman, Republican of Ohio, said conversations between Mr. Ryan and the senators he will need on his side had already begun. 
Democrats, closely examining the outlines of the Ryan plan, say he is showing a new modesty and a narrower vision than the one rejected by American voters in the 2012 presidential campaign. Back then, and even earlier this year, Mr. Ryan championed converting Medicare into a voucherlike program in which beneficiaries would be given fixed premium subsidies they would use to buy private health insurance. 
Now he is talking about means-testing Medicare to make richer beneficiaries pick up more of the tab and ensuring that taxpayers do not subsidize the private Medigap plans purchased by upper-income recipients to augment Medicare coverage. Versions of both of those proposals are in Mr. Obama’s budget for the current fiscal year.
It is hard to imagine that means-testing Medicare is going to mollify the fire eaters in the Tea Party caucus; there are not many realists in its ranks. The question is whether the Tea Party still has enough juice, now that conventional wisdom has coalesced around the idea that the shutdown and debt ceiling standoff has been an unmitigated disaster, to torpedo a deal based on Ryan's plan.

An important story worth mentioning is Human Rights Watch's report concluding that Syrian rebels committed "crimes against humanity" in an August 4 massacre of 190 civilians in Latakia province. Anne Barnard reports in today's New York Times that the Western-backed Free Syrian Army is implicated in the massacre and could be guilty of war crimes:
[A]t least 20 groups took part in the fighting, the report says, including some affiliated with the Free Syrian Army, the loose-knit collection of mainly Syrian rebel forces the council is trying to organize. 
And in a video filmed nearby during the operation, Gen. Salim Idris, who leads the military council, is seen insisting that his forces played a leading role, in statements responding to criticism from Islamist groups that his fighters were hanging back. The report said it was unclear whether forces linked to General Idris took part in the initial Aug. 4 attack, when forensic evidence suggests most of the civilians were killed. But it also said that anyone continuing to coordinate with such groups could be complicit in war crimes. 
The Human Rights Watch report accuses the five leading fighting groups of crimes against humanity; names several private donors in Kuwait and other Persian Gulf countries as financiers of the operation; blames Turkey for allowing the fighters to use its territory; and calls for an arms embargo against the five groups, adding to its previous calls for such an embargo against the Syrian government. 
“Unified action by the international community is really long overdue when it comes to trying to deter these abuses and violations,” Ms. Fakih said, recommending that war crimes in Syria be referred to the International Criminal Court, which could investigate all parties.

Thursday, October 10, 2013

Government Shutdown Bait and Switch Underway

The date for when the government will default if Congress does not authorize an increase in the debt ceiling is apparently now November 1 not October 17. This according to a story by Annie Lowrey, "Tracing the Calendar Down to the Last Cent":
That is when more than $55 billion in federal payments come due, almost certainly more than enough to use up whatever cash the Treasury might still have on hand. The three weeks between now and then — should Congress fail to raise the debt ceiling — would most likely be ones of market turbulence, plummeting confidence and a slowing economy.
But so far the markets have not reacted in a significant way. Jesse Eisinger writes in a DealBook column "Complacency on Wall Street Could Be Worse Than a Panic" that having gone through this once before people are jaded and feel that this is all a pantomime on the Potomac that can be ignored. Eisinger cautions that this is dangerous and could lead to disaster; he thinks that there are real not fictive barriers to reaching a deal. As someone who has been predicting an adverse market reaction by now if a deal had not been reached, I tend to agree with him.

There appears to be a deal of sorts in the offing. That deal, according to the reliable Jonathan Weisman, involves a short-term funding of the government and raising of the debt ceiling while negotiations begin once again in pursuit of the El Dorado of the "grand bargain." The problem with the grand bargain is there is no deal at the end of that rainbow. It is a Paul Ryan initiative. It is my perception that anything Ryan touches -- not unlike George W. Bush, another youthful-seeming, modestly telegenic GOP standard bearer -- turns to shit in his hands. Ryan wants to take a meat ax to Medicare and Medicaid. There are not the Democratic votes there. Any grand budget deficit bargain would have to be extremely modest to get through the Senate. Then you're right back at the problem that started all this -- the Tea Party fire eaters in the House. They will torpedo any modest grand bargain.

As for the problem that started all this, the fire-eating Tea Party, there is a frontpage story by Eric Lipton, Nick Confessore and Nelson Schwartz, "Business Groups See Loss of Sway Over House G.O.P.," that is worth checking out. I think it oversells the extent to which groups like the National Retail Federation and National Federation of Independent Businesses will go out of their way to recruit and fund primary candidates to take down some of the Tea Party yahoos in the House. Nonetheless the article features some choice quotes:
“We ask them to carry our water all the time,” said one corporate sector lobbyist, who demanded anonymity in order to speak frankly about the relationship with Republicans. “But we don’t necessarily support them 100 percent of the time. And what has happened is the rise of an ideological wing that is now willing to stand up to business interests.”
Lipton, Confessore and Schwartz rightly point out that the Tea Party phenomenon is a Frankenstein monster of the Chamber of Commerce's making:
To some extent, the Chamber itself, along with other lobbying groups, helped create the conditions for Washington’s impasse. 
After the 2010 elections, the Chamber and other business interests funneled millions of dollars into Republican redistricting efforts around the country, helping draw overwhelmingly safe Republican districts whose occupants — many among the most conservative House members — are now far less vulnerable to challenges from more moderate Republicans. 
The Chamber spent more than $32 million on the 2012 election, nearly all of it backing Republicans. Similarly, the American Banking Association sent 80 percent of its $2.6 million in political action committee donations to Republicans in the last election cycle, compared with 58 percent in 2008, according to data compiled by the Center for Responsive Politics, out of dissatisfaction with Democratic efforts to impose more financial regulations.
Two-thousand-and-eight might seem like a lifetime ago but the political vibe that it created at the time remains vivid to this day. Bush and Cheney had thoroughly discredited the Republican Party with a disastrous invasion and occupation of Iraq and a ham-handed response to the Lehman Brothers collapse. A black man won the presidential election in a rout. He had large Democratic majorities to work with in the House and Senate. Business leaders were shitting their britches. They feared a raft of progressive legislation -- card check, carbon regulation, universal health care -- churning out of Washington.

Starting in the summer of 2009 they fired up the assault engines. In order to man those engines, the only people around willing to be used for the cause were the kooks and conspiracy-theorist types.

The kooks have always been around. In our recent political dispensation, say since the 1960s, they have been known as Birchers, the far Right Wing ideologues that filled the ranks of the John Birch Society in Southern California suburbs and who believed communists were everywhere hiding in plain sight. The difference is that in our present-day period these kooks have been provided a megaphone. The media dutifully fell in line and reported the orchestrated response of kooks being lined up to speak out against health care reform at the Congressional townhalls conducted that summer of 2009 as somehow signifying a grassroots popular democratic mass uprising against Obama and progressive policy. It was nothing of the sort. It was nothing more than an assiduous stove-piping of select events and images which created the impression of an uprising. "If you build it, they will come." And they did. Citizens United helped. The 2010 elections were a watershed for the Tea Party.

And here we are today.

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

As Debt Ceiling Approaches GOP Doubles Down on Bunkum

Republicans acknowledge that their decision to link the reopening of the government to the health care law is unpopular. A Washington Post/ABC News poll released Monday found that disapproval of Congressional Republicans had jumped to 70 percent, from 63 percent late last month.

But David Winston, a Republican pollster close to Mr. Boehner, said Mr. Obama’s stance was likely to prove unpopular as well. “Anyone who says he knows how this is going to turn out doesn’t know,” Mr. Winston said. “We are in a very unsettled time.”
That's from today's story, "Senate Leaders Mull Raising Debt Ceiling in Challenge to House," by Jonathan Weisman and Jackie Calmes, and it pretty much says it all. Republicans have a losing strategy on their hands, one that promises to do lasting damage to the party's already tarnished brand, and the longer they stick with it the worse it is going to get for them. But rather than change course, judging by the quote from Boehner's pollster, the GOP plans to double down, hoping that some of the ensuing gore will splatter on Obama and besmirch him as well.

People are not trusting of the Republican mantra of "Just come to the table and talk" because everyone intuitively understands extortion and exploitation when he or she sees it. If this were all merely about talking and horse trading why the closure of government? Why the threats to default on U.S. debt and thereby undercut the global gold standard? No, people understand that this is blackmail carried out by an ignorant, bitter minority.

The Dow was down close to one percent yesterday. As Republicans maintain their charade -- the odious Andrew Ross Sorkin writes in a DealBook column today about some on Wall Street who think that failure to lift the debt ceiling is no big deal -- this will worsen. It should provide some impetus to efforts in the Senate to pass a debt ceiling bill. And, assuming that Obama doesn't toss the GOP a lifeline and snatch defeat from the jaws of victory, all that will be left will be the inevitable -- for Boehner to capitulate and allow a straight up-or-down vote in the House.

Boehner might lose his speakership as a result.

And while the other option -- that Boehner stands by the Tea Party and hurls the nation into default -- remains a possibility, I think it is unlikely. The Republican Party would suffer enormous damage, probably more than its gerrymandering could withstand.

Thursday, October 3, 2013

Tea Party Revanchism


After meeting last night with Speaker of the House John Boehner, along with Senate majority leader Harry Reid and House minority leader Nancy Pelosi, Obama's stated position is that "grand bargain" talks on the federal budget can begin once the government reopens with a clean funding resolution and the debt ceiling is raised.

Republicans promptly rejected this. They have no intention of giving up their leverage, which is what agreeing to Obama's conditions would entail. The GOP has no wish to enter into negotiations. Republicans have been sidestepping budget talks for the entire year. They have no intention of giving something up to get something in return. They think that Obama can be made to cave in.

Already sights are set on October 17, the deadline when the federal government reaches the debt ceiling. The Tea Party now sees that once you go over the brink, as it has with the government shutdown, it no longer provides any strategic advantage; in fact, it becomes a liability.

And that's where we are at now. Can the Tea Party caucus wagging the dog in the House remain intact for the next two weeks until the next brink, the debt ceiling deadline?

There was a sharp drop off from late morning on yesterday in interest in the government shutdown. I measure this by the number of stories that appear on the Google News page and the chatter among my office coworkers. So there is the possibility that the country could muddle along for the next two weeks with a government shutdown as the new normal. But bit by bit the GOP will suffer, and overall there is no question that they are losing the propaganda war. I am doubtful that House Republicans can hold out until October 17. Obama is putting Wall Street to work on lobbying the GOP leadership. This might not bear fruit this week -- I originally thought the Tea Party would be deflated by Friday -- but I bet by next week Boehner will be ready to release a "clean CR" for a vote.

The Tea Party, which is the populist base of the current Republican Party, is based on nostalgia for a time that we haven't seen in this country since the full employment and social and racial homogeneity of the 1960s. The Tea Party's revanchism is founded on a desire to return to the past -- before Vietnam was recognized as the quagmire it was, before the Black Panthers, before Haight-Ashbury spread to every large city in the nation -- when factory jobs were still plentiful and rents inexpensive and the suburbs were new and futuristic.

I've been reading an excellent history of The Chocolate Watchband, a 1960s Garage Punk Psychedelic band from the San Jose suburbs, written by lead singer David Aguilar. Aguilar captures the essence of the middle-60s -- the raw power -- that I believe to be at the heart of Tea Party revanchism:
It was the spring of 1966. It was a very different world than what it is today. 
Using the words of Tom Shachtman, "America was a monster. Our booming economy was one leg of the colossus and the other was our Military might. In the world, only the Soviets and we counted. We believed our environment and natural resources were virtually limitless. We were certain American ingenuity, technological virtuosity, and money could solve the world's problems. We believed Americans could fix anything and that nuclear missiles, the ultimate weapons of destruction, could actually keep us from having a global war. On the ladder of life, youth was expected to start at the bottom and creep upward as described by the system. In other words, the ladder of success was a long and arduous climb everybody had to make to succeed in this world. We lived in a dream of constant upward mobility. It was powered by never-ending consumption. We knew how much people above us were earning because it was reflected in the things they owned." 
The Watchband lived in nuclear families in identical little patio homes in the suburbs of San Jose. The nuclear family consisted of a man and woman, married for the first and only time to each other, living together with their natural 2.4 children with a cat and dog thrown in for good measure. Single-parent families were rare and the thought of one was difficult to comprehend to our society. Mark's dad had passed away when he was 2 and his mother had never remarried. He was the exception in the group. We all went to the same schools, studied the same things, and had the same teachers our brothers and sisters had. At school we dressed up in costumes for Halloween, planted trees on Arbor Day, sent tiny little punch-out paper hearts around for Valentine's Day and had both Lincoln's and Washington's birthdays off. We obeyed most of the rules, feared discipline from our parents if we screwed up, and any young woman getting pregnant paid the penalty of either being banished to a relatives' house until delivery and adoption took place or was she ushered immediately into the wedding chapel. If it was before the sixth month, she got to wear white. There were no ifs, ands or buts about this one. Single mothers and inter-racial marriages were unheard of. FM radio was called "Underground Radio" because they played songs longer than 3 minutes in length and didn't have a lot of commercials. TV went off the air at 1 AM and came back on at 6 AM. Milky Ways and Snickers cost a nickel and Cokes in green bottles were a dime with 2 cents returned on the empty bottle .... no lie!
The irony of Tea Party revanchism is that the prosperity of the 1960s created the conditions for undoing the rigid social boundaries and simplicity that the lily-white, predominantly rural, present-day Know Nothings hanker after.

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

Tea Party Doomed

An important thing to remember as we begin the first day of a House GOP shutdown of the federal government is that the Tea Party ideology that is driving all this is a distinctly minority point of view. Mitt Romney, Republican standard bearer who campaigned on a repeal of Obamacare in last year's presidential election, lost by 5 million votes. Republicans maintained control of the House of Representatives but lost eight seats in the process and Democrats candidates ended up winning 1.4 million votes nationwide. Gerrymandering has helped the GOP maintain its majority in the House. In the Senate, Republicans were widely predicted to regain control. But thanks to some extremely incendiary comments by Tea Party candidates, Democrats, in an amazing turnabout that was the highlight of the election season, actually picked up two seats.

The Tea Party is a revanchist movement that wants to return to a past which is a fantasy. It is a splinter movement that has been blown up into flame by plutocrats who were frightened to discover following Obama's 2008 election that a strong, multicultural Progressive majority exists in the United States.

We first saw the Tea Party on display during the orchestrated demonstrations against national health care legislation at Congressional town halls the summer of 2009. The paranoid types have always been with us. Go to any public forum -- any meeting of your city council or school board -- and they'll be there. But what was different this time around is that the kooks had some deep-pocketed backers who were willing to provide an organizational infrastructure.

It is this moneyed assistance that is important to keep in mind when noting that Speaker of the House John Boehner, a man who if nothing else is a dedicated servant of concentrated wealth, could end the government shutdown promptly by allowing the clean Senate continuing resolution a vote on the House floor. This is from Joe Nocera's column this morning, "Those Banana Republicans":
The House speaker, John Boehner, won’t bring “a clean C.R.” — that is, a continuing resolution without any of the anti-Obamacare language — not because it won’t pass, but because it probably would, which would infuriate the Tea Party wing of his party and jeopardize his leadership post. Indeed, as Boehner well knows, many House Republicans do not want the government to shut down and would probably vote for the Senate’s clean bill if given half a chance. Their unwillingness to speak out against the extreme faction in their party is shameful. And it’s tragic that, at a time when the House desperately needs a strong speaker, it has John Boehner instead. 
What was clear on Monday was that if the government does shut down, the Republicans are going to be blamed. All day long, we watched the Democrats, starting with President Obama, make the case that Republican demands were unreasonable, and, indeed, dangerous, given what was at stake. Republicans spent the day on the defensive. Senator Elizabeth Warren, the liberal Democrat from Massachusetts, described Republican tactics to me as “hostage taking.” Harry Reid, the Senate majority leader, told reporters that if “we can’t pass this” — meaning a clean C.R. — “we’re only truly entering a banana republican mind-set.”
Wall Street is on board the government shutdown because it couldn't take place without assistance from Boehner. Boehner is not a man who is going to buck the boss.

So what's going on?

I think what's going on is that the plutocrats who whipped a political movement into being have lost the degree of control that they come to expect. Active Tea Party opposition to bombing Syria no doubt upset the Wall Street types who don't like to see any loss of imperial prerogatives even if a black man is the commander-in-chief. And what really must dismay the plutocrats is the possibility of a government default in a couple of weeks if the House Republicans refuse to raise the debt ceiling, a default that would send shock waves through the global capitalist system.

The longer the government stays shut down the more the Tea Party caucus will splinter. In another week or two, assuming the government remains shuttered, the Tea Party will be thoroughly discredited, the public ire coming its way immense. It will be broken and in no position to engineer a default on sovereign debt.

There is a war on within the GOP. This very well could be the battle where the Karl Rove-led Wall Streeters route the Tea Party Birchers.

Monday, September 30, 2013

Absent Tea Party Surrender Government Headed for Shutdown

Judging from the coverage this morning, it looks like Senate majority leader Harry Reid is not going to buckle in the showdown with the Tea-Party-led House Republicans. Good. This needed to have happened at the end of last year following Obama's landslide election win and the GOP's pathetic showing in November.

There are still scenes left to play out in this drama as it unfolds today in D.C. Absent a bargain of some sort the government will shut down tomorrow. Here -- this is from Jeremy Peters and Jonathan Weisman's story this morning, "Senate Action on Health Law Moves to Brink of Shutdown" -- is what we can expect today:
Republican lawmakers said on Sunday that the House leadership had one more card to play, but that it was extremely delicate. They can tell Mr. Reid he must accept a face-saving measure, like the repeal of the tax on medical devices, which many Democrats support, or they will send back a new amendment that would force members of Congress and their staffs, and the White House staff, to buy their medical insurance on the new health law’s insurance exchanges, without any subsidies from the government to offset the cost. 
Republicans expressed certainty that for all the discomfort a shutdown would inflict on Capitol Hill, Democrats would not risk it to protect their own benefits.
If the Tea Party caucus is willing to settle for this -- a repeal of the tax on medical devices -- then there is a chance a deal could be reached. It would be unfortunate because it would maintain the GOP penchant for budgetary brinkmanship as a negotiating tactic, and it would guarantee further drama on down the line as the House Republicans continue their attempts to nibble away at Obamacare. But it's not clear that the Tea Party is willing to set its sights so low. Tea Party Republicans feel as if they have already given up a lot over the weekend by agreeing to a one-year delay in the implementation of the Affordable Care Act rather than its de-funding.

And on the other side of the aisle I think it has finally dawned on the Democratic leadership, and quite possibly even the conciliator-in-chief, that negotiating with the House Republicans in the face of threats to shut down the government or default on the sovereign debt is a losing proposition.

Even if a deal is struck today that avoids a government shutdown tomorrow, rest assured that an even larger conflict is coming our way in a couple of weeks with the vote to raise the debt ceiling. That's why my thinking from last week -- that a shutdown would be avoided -- has changed.

I now think that it has dawned on the Democrats that it's better to have the House GOP shutter the government in the near term, thoroughly discrediting Republicans to a broad majority of the public and thereby undercutting them going into a debt-ceiling standoff.

Barring a complete capitulation by the Tea Party -- or turnabout by Speaker Boehner to allow a clean bill without any anti-Obamacare chicanery -- the federal government is headed for a shutdown.

Friday, April 5, 2013

Obama Embraces Chained CPI

Obama is negotiating with himself again. The news this morning is that the administration is going to propose benefit cuts to Social Security when it releases its budget next week. According to Jackie Calmes' frontpage story, "Obama Budget to Include Cuts to Programs in Hopes of Deal":
Some Senate Republicans have been urging the president to speak out more to Americans about his ideas for reducing the growth of entitlement programs. While the White House posted the offer to Mr. Boehner on its Web site this year, aides previously said that Mr. Obama would not include its provisions in his official budget documents. To do so, some said, would expose him to Democrats’ criticism that he is too quick to compromise and allow Republicans to embrace the proposals for spending cuts, in particular the C.P.I., but ignore those for tax increases.
Neither the president nor senior aides privately hold much hope that Republican leaders — Mr. Boehner and Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Senate Republican leader — will compromise. So Mr. Obama’s strategy of reaching out to other Senate Republicans reflects a calculation that enough of them might cut a budget deal with the Democratic Senate majority. If that happens, the reasoning goes, a Senate-passed compromise would put pressure on the House to go along.
It's hard to fathom why Obama is making this move. Embracing a chained CPI didn't lead to a breakthrough in the fiscal cliff negotiations last December. If anything Republican unwillingness to compromise, to broker a deal of any kind, has only increased in the last three months, proof of which was on display with the sequester. And, let's not forget, it was Obama's indulgence in self-bargaining that brought us the sequester in the first place; it came out of the 2011 debt ceiling debacle.

For a good reading of the tea leaves of what Obama's latest capitulation means check out this morning's naked capitalism post by Yves Smith, "Now It's Official: Obama Sells Catfood Futures, Um, Social Security and Medicare Cuts":
There is no more pretense possible. As we’ve warned for some time, Obama is eager to put a notch on his belt by being the President that rolled back the New Deal programs that helped create broad-based middle-class prosperity and dignity. He’s cast himself as an adult inflicting discipline on profligate Americans. But in reality, the profligacy was most concentrated among elite financiers who used leverage on leverage vehicles to stoke liquidity that led to worldwide underpricing of risk. They paid themselves record bonuses in the years immediately preceding the crisis, and then in a grotesque display of ingratitude, did so again in 2009, able to do so only thanks to massive taxpayer support, alphabet-soup special borrowing programs, and the tax on savers known as ZIRP. And the direct result of their looting exercise that produced the crisis was the explosion in government deficits, due to a collapse in tax revenues and a rise in payments under countercyclical programs such as unemployment insurance and food stamps.
Yes, it's all very disspiriting but, sadly, unsurprising. The Counterpunch Left has been shouting about Obama's craven nature for years. Now it's almost impossible to deny. Obama apologists might float the argument that he's only proposing benefit cuts because he knows there is no chance, due to Republican intransigence, that they will go into effect; he just wants to see if it's possible to get a budget through the Senate with GOP support in order to reap the whirlwind in the reconciliation process with the House. This, as Yves Smith says, is Obama as 11-dimensional chess master, and it is a fantasy. Our worry should be a repeat of the 2011 debt ceiling crisis.

To return to Calmes' article, here are the nuts and bolts, besides the chained CPI, of what will be in Obama's budget:
According to administration officials, the president’s budget plan would reduce projected annual deficits by $1.8 trillion over 10 years, even with the select spending increases. To offset the initiatives’ cost and avoid adding to deficits, Mr. Obama will propose the tobacco tax increase, a limit of $3 million on how much people can accumulate in tax-preferred savings accounts and repeal of a loophole that allows people to collect both disability and unemployment benefits.
Together with the $2.5 trillion in deficit reductions that Mr. Obama and Congressional Republicans have agreed to since 2010, that would bring the total deficit reduction to more than $4.3 trillion over 10 years by the administration’s computations — just over the goal that both parties have set for stabilizing the growth of the national debt. 
Of the more than $2.5 trillion to date in projected 10-year budget savings, nearly 80 percent would result from spending cuts. The rest would derive from tax increases on high incomes that became law on Jan. 1, in the tax agreement that the two parties reached at year-end when the efforts for a broader deficit-reduction deal collapsed. 
Mr. Obama’s proposals to reduce deficits $1.8 trillion more over a decade track his offer to Mr. Boehner, adjusted for the roughly $600 billion in higher taxes that became law in January. He will propose more than $600 billion in new revenues — his last offer had called for $1.2 trillion in taxes — mostly by limiting to 28 percent the deductions that individuals in higher tax brackets can claim. Congress has ignored that idea in past years. 
Deficits would be reduced another $930 billion through 2023 as a result of spending cuts and other cost-saving changes to domestic programs, and $200 billion more due to reduced interest payments on the federal debt. 
Mr. Obama’s proposed spending reductions include about $400 billion from health programs and $200 billion from other areas, including farm subsidies, federal employee retirement programs, the Postal Service and the unemployment compensation system.
In Medicare, the savings would mostly come from payments to health care providers, including hospitals and pharmaceutical companies, but Mr. Obama also proposes that higher-income beneficiaries pay more for coverage.

Monday, February 25, 2013

Grand Bargain Sought

Friday the sequester kicks in. Republicans aren't budging, though some in their caucus are grumbling about the Pentagon cuts. A good place to start the work week is Robert Pear's story this morning, "As Governors Meet, White House Warns Cuts Would Hurt States"; it runs down the basic math of the sequester:
On Friday, the administration said, $85 billion in cuts will automatically begin to take effect, with many domestic programs facing reductions of 9 percent and some military programs being reduced by 13 percent in the remaining seven months of the federal fiscal year.
“There are constraints to what an agency can do in taking this across-the-board $85 billion cut,” Mr. Werfel [the controller of President Obama’s budget office] said. “The way the law is written, it has to be taken from a percentage cut from every program, project and activity.”
Under the Budget Control Act of 2011, which created the latest version of the sequester, some programs, like Medicaid and food stamps, are exempt from the automatic cuts, and cuts in Medicare payments cannot exceed 2 percent. 
Social Security benefits would not be cut. But the White House said that the automatic budget cuts would force the agency to “curtail service to the public,” and that the backlog of Social Security disability claims would increase.
The Obama administration is outlining what these cuts actually mean: loss of education funding in Ohio; vaccines in Georgia; services for victims of domestic violence in Pennsylvania; etc. Republicans are crying foul; they're asserting all the doom and gloom is a public relations stunt designed to scare. But if you're a Republican what else can you say since you are unwilling to put corporate tax loopholes on the table?

But what's really troubling is Richard Stevenson's article from this past Saturday. What has not been mentioned much in the sequester coverage is what Obama is willing to give up:
Even as President Obama lashes out at Republicans over the automatic spending cuts that take effect next week, he is simultaneously sending them a strikingly different message: he is still interested in a big deficit-reduction deal and as evidence of his good faith has left on the table proposed Medicare and Social Security cuts that liberals hate.
His aides point to Mr. Obama’s continued willingness to swallow, over the intensifying objections of most of the left side of his party, a new way of calculating inflation adjustments for Social Security benefits that would reduce the growth of payments – in effect, a benefit cut. And Mr. Obama has alluded repeatedly to his willingness to re-engage with Republicans based on his last offer for $400 billion in Medicare cuts, made during the negotiations in December over the so-called fiscal cliff; that’s a level that gives heartburn to some Democrats in Congress who see no need to compromise at this point.
As the citizenry goes back to sleep after the election last November followed by the high stakes fiscal cliff negotiations in December, Obama's proposed cuts to Social Security and Medicare are flying under the radar. Here's the take from a post this morning on naked capitalism:
The only logical inference that can be drawn is that Obama remains committed to inflicting the “Grand Bargain” (really, the Grand Betrayal) on the Nation in his quest for a “legacy” and continues to believe that the Sequester provides him the essential leverage he feels he needs to coerce Senate progressives to adopt austerity, make deep cuts in vital social programs, and to begin to unravel the safety net. Obama’s newest budget offer includes cuts to the safety net and provides that 2/3 of the austerity inflicted would consist of spending cuts instead of tax increases. When that package is one’s starting position the end result of any deal will be far worse.
In any event, there is a clear answer to how to help our Nation. Both Parties should agree tomorrow to do a clean deal eliminating the Sequester without any conditions. By doing so, Obama would demonstrate that he had no desire to inflict the Grand Betrayal.
This is also Krugman's position: just repeal the sequester. But, according to today's frontpage story by Jonathan Weisman and Ashley Parker, the sequester is going forward, not so much for the reason stated by Republicans, that it is a strategy to bring Obama to the table willing to make cuts to Social Security and Medicare (because we know from the Stevenson story that Obama is already there); no, the sequester is going forward for purely political reasons. According to Weisman and Parker,
With so many rank-and-file Republicans adamant that they would rather see the cuts stand than raise any taxes, Speaker John A. Boehner finds himself in a bind. Three times this year — on the tax deal to resolve the fiscal cliff, on a measure to suspend the debt ceiling and on a package of Hurricane Sandy relief — he has let legislation pass the House against the votes of a majority of Republicans. In 2011, Republicans accepted caps on military spending as well. 
Each time, the speaker has promised to stand his ground on the next showdown with the president. That showdown comes this week. 
Representative Tom Cotton of Arkansas, an Iraq War veteran with combat experience and a rising Republican star, said that the speaker was in a “very tough position” in one-on-one negotiations with the president, and that the opportunity for a grand bargain was gone.
Republicans must feel as if they have lost the upper hand with Obama in the recent fiscal cliff and debt ceiling negotiations. Never mind the results of last November's election. But given Obama's willingness to sell the working class down the river in search of a grand bargain, I'd say the House GOP is doing all of us a favor.

Friday, February 22, 2013

The Sequester

The column inches are beginning to pile up on the latest budget standoff. It's the sequester this time. It has been over four weeks since the Boehner-led House voted to raise the debt ceiling on January 23. So we've been spared for a month, allowing us to concentrate on other matters.

If you're just starting to dip back in a good place to start is today's lead unsigned editorial in the New York Times, "Why Taxes Have To Go Up." The answer? The lasting damage of the Bush tax cuts and an aging population:
Contrary to Mr. Boehner’s “spending problem” claim, much of the deficit in the next 10 years can be chalked up to chronic revenue shortfalls from the Bush-era tax cuts, which were only partly undone in the fiscal-cliff deal earlier this year. (Wars and a recession also contributed.) It stands to reason that a deficit caused partly by inadequate revenue must be corrected in part by new taxes. And the only way to raise taxes now without harming the recovery is to impose them on high-income filers, for whom a tax increase is unlikely to cut into spending. 
Raising taxes at the top is neither punitive nor gratuitous. It is a needed step, both to achieve near-term budget goals and to lay the foundation for a healthy budget in the future. As the economy strengthens and the population ages, more taxes will be needed from further down the income scale, both to meet foreseeable commitments, especially health care, as well as unforeseeable developments, from wars to technological challenges. But there will never be a consensus for more taxes from the middle class without imposing higher taxes on wealthy Americans, who have enjoyed low taxes for a long time.
In today's offering, "Sequester Of Fools," Krugman says that Congress should repeal the sequester:
The right policy would be to forget about the whole thing. America doesn’t face a deficit crisis, nor will it face such a crisis anytime soon. Meanwhile, we have a weak economy that is recovering far too slowly from the recession that began in 2007. And, as Janet Yellen, the vice chairwoman of the Federal Reserve, recently emphasized, one main reason for the sluggish recovery is that government spending has been far weaker in this business cycle than in the past. We should be spending more, not less, until we’re close to full employment; the sequester is exactly what the doctor didn’t order.
And he warns against the false equivalence being peddled in the media (for a fine example one can cast his glance to the left of the opinion page and read David Brooks' column, "The D.C. Dubstep"). Krugman says,
As always, many pundits want to portray the deadlock over the sequester as a situation in which both sides are at fault, and in which both should give ground. But there’s really no symmetry here. A middle-of-the-road solution would presumably involve a mix of spending cuts and tax increases; well, that’s what Democrats are proposing, while Republicans are adamant that it should be cuts only. And given that the proposed Republican cuts would be even worse than those set to happen under the sequester, it’s hard to see why Democrats should negotiate at all, as opposed to just letting the sequester happen.
This is a political problem the source of which is Republican intransigence. Why do we have this problem? To find the answer all one has to do is consult the reporting of the excellent Jonathan Weisman. In a story yesterday, "GOP Resisting Obama on Tax Increase," Weisman, as always, lets his readers know that Republicans don't feel they need to compromise because they are politically invulnerable due to gerrymandering:
But House Republicans say they are feeling invulnerable in the current clash. Not only can they point to last year’s bills to replace the cuts, but redistricting has made most of them immune to political threats and entreaties. For many representing conservative districts where the president holds little sway, an attack by Mr. Obama is a badge of honor, senior Republican House aides say.
This is the neo-Dixiecrat GOP, a rump party holed up in the House of Representatives with majority status for the foreseeable future thanks to a radical Supreme Court hellbent on shredding all campaign finance law.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

GOP Government Shutdown Plan

House Republicans set their extortion calendar. Jonathan Weisman's story today about yesterday's House vote to suspend enforcement of the debt ceiling until May 18 lays out how the government-shutdown thrill ride will proceed in the coming months. The good news is that we will be spared this frontpage-hog for the remainder of the month and all of February. Then March 1 "$110 billion in across-the-board spending cuts to military and domestic programs — known as a sequester — will go into force."
The next real showdown will come by March 27, when the stopgap measure financing the government expires. Republicans have made clear that they are willing to let the government shut down at that time to force deep spending cuts or changes to Medicare and Social Security that would bring down deficits in the long run.
Included in the debt-ceiling suspension is a provision to "withhold the pay of lawmakers in a chamber of Congress that fails to pass a budget blueprint by April 15." This is aimed at Senate Democrats who have not passed a budget since 2009.

The GOP design here is to get the Senate to produce a budget that can be reconciled in conference with the Ryan Plan, a.k.a., "The Path to Prosperity," and inflict as much damage as possible on Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security. We're talking about the block granting of Medicaid; the privatizing of Medicare and raising its eligibility age; and while Ryan changed his tune and now calls for no changes in Social Security, Boehner sought a chained CPI in the recent fiscal cliff negotiations, and privatization remains the Republican Holy Grail. And what Boehner is talking about, a balanced budget over the next ten years, is actually much worse than the Ryan Plan, which doesn't balance the budget until 2040. This is from today's lead unsigned editorial in the New York Times:
If the House actually wants to put forth a balanced budget over the next 10 years, as Mr. Boehner vowed to do on Wednesday, let the public see what that really means: unimaginable cuts and changes to Medicare and Medicaid, and the elimination of scores of popular and vital programs that benefit both the poor and the middle class. Up to now, Republicans have been understandably wary of specifying how that would be done without raising taxes. Mitt Romney wouldn’t do it, and even Representative Paul Ryan’s budgets up to now wouldn’t balance the budget until 2040.

Saturday, January 19, 2013

House GOP Quick Kicks Debt Ceiling

House Republicans decide to "punt" on the debt ceiling.  The story by Ashley Parker (she covered the Romney campaign during the past presidential election) in yesterday's paper about the Republican retreat in Williamsburg revealed that Paul Ryan was arguing for a short-term extension of the debt ceiling. I thought that this would take time to play out, like a week, as the Republicans haggled among themselves. But by Friday House Republicans had uncharacteristically reached consensus. Here's how Jonathan Weisman lays it out in today's frontpage story:
The decision represents a victory — at least for now — for Mr. Obama, who has said for months that he will not negotiate budget cuts under the threat of a debt default. By punting that threat into the spring, budget negotiations instead will center on two earlier points of leverage: March 1, when $1 trillion in across-the-board military and domestic cuts are set to begin, and March 27, when a stopgap law financing the government will expire.
Reordering the sequences of those hurdles was central to the delicate Republican deliberations that resulted in the new plan. In the days leading to the Williamsburg retreat, Representative Paul D. Ryan of Wisconsin, the House Budget Committee chairman and former vice-presidential nominee, had been meeting with the leader and three past chairmen of the conservative House Republican Study Committee to discuss a way through the debt ceiling morass.
Those conversations led into Thursday morning, when Mr. Boehner and Representative Eric Cantor of Virginia, the No. 2 House Republican, opened the retreat by going through the timeline for the coming budget fights, according to aides who were there.
They turned the floor over to Representative Dave Camp of Michigan, the House Ways and Means chairman, who delivered a blow-by-blow description of the economic disaster that could be wrought by a government default. Mr. Camp also talked through the notion held by some Republicans that the Treasury Department could manage a debt ceiling breach by channeling the daily in-flow of tax dollars to the most pressing needs, paying government creditors, sending out Social Security checks and financing the military. His message was that it would not work, the aides said.
Then Mr. Ryan stood to talk over the options he had developed with the House conservative leaders. They could do a longer-term debt ceiling extension with specific demands, like converting Medicare into a voucherlike program. Or they could lower expectations, reorder the budget hurdles with a three-month punt, and add the “no budget, no pay” provision.
Persuading Republicans who adamantly oppose raising the debt ceiling took some time, and the ensuing discussion stretched on and on, breaking at noon for lunch on Thursday, resuming at 2:30, until 4 p.m., then concluding Friday.
Representative Kevin McCarthy of California, the House majority whip, met with freshmen early Friday to make sure they were on board. Mr. Boehner and Mr. Cantor joined Mr. Ryan for one last meeting with conservative leaders — Representatives Steve Scalise of Louisiana, Jim Jordan of Ohio, Jeb Hensarling of Texas and Tom Price of Georgia — to make sure they were on board. Then the top four leaders sealed the agreement midmorning.
I would call it more of a quick kick than a punt.  Quick kicks are not done anymore in the NFL. Dan Pastorini was the last guy I saw do a quick kick (maybe Danny White did one that I saw, but I don't remember). It's when the quarterback takes the snap from center, usually on third down, and punts it into the secondary. It catches the defense off guard and leads in theory to better field position than running a regular play on third down and then bringing out the punting team on fourth. The quick kick was a third-and-long play. Quick kicks aren't done anymore because passing attacks are much more sophisticated now and picking up long yardage on third down is a regular occurrence; also, passers used to be punters; punting was a skill set expected of your quarterback. No more.

House Republicans quick kicked wisely I believe. They're on more solid footing to extract their social welfare cuts when the sequester kicks in and then after that when the continuing resolution expires. The closer we got to February the greater the chance for another downgrade by one of the rating agencies; Fitch had said as much. When S&P dropped U.S. debt one notch from AAA to AA+ because of the last debt-ceiling standoff it cost taxpayers billions, not to say anything about loses in the markets. If the GOP Mad Mullahs in the House had pressed ahead with a default it would have been insanely destructive to global capitalism, which, as the Monthly Review argues, is largely concentrated in one country, the United States.

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Return of Fiscal Dueling Banjos

News consumers have been enjoying a holiday. For the last several weeks the number of stories originating from the District of Columbia having to do with the budgetary battles of Congress have been minimal. To be sure there have been fiscal cliff postmortems and think pieces about trillion-dollar coins, but very little in the way of sweet noise from the chief antagonists. This has created space for a diversity of big frontpage stories: the impending U.S. escape from Afghanistan; the hottest year on record in the U.S.; France's exercise of its old colonial prerogative by bombing Islamist fighters in Northern Mali (recalling the infamous words of David Lloyd George, "We insisted on reserving the right to bomb niggers"); and Cuomo's leadership on new gun laws.

But yesterday, according to a story by Jackie Calmes and Jonathan Weisman that appears discretely tucked away on page A15 of today's National Edition, Obama called a press conference to reiterate his debt-ceiling arguments:
“They will not collect a ransom in exchange for not crashing the American economy,” Mr. Obama vowed in the East Room, a week before his second inauguration. “The financial well-being of the American people is not leverage to be used. The full faith and credit of the United States of America is not a bargaining chip.” 
House Speaker John A. Boehner, immediately after Mr. Obama’s news conference, said in a statement: “The American people do not support raising the debt ceiling without reducing government spending at the same time. The consequences of failing to increase the debt ceiling are real, but so, too, are the consequences of allowing our spending problem to go unresolved.”
So with about a month to go before the government runs out of money it appears we're back to the nauseating fiscal-cliff theater of dueling banjos. Republicans are going to insist on a bald lie, that their threat to meltdown global financial markets has the popular support of the American people. And while in some tangentially connected way one could argue that most people would agree that it is not wise to spend more money than one has, that's not the case here.  What the debt ceiling is about is paying for spending that has already been approved by the very body that is now threatening -- in a singular display of deadbeat behavior -- not to pay. As Obama says,
And -- and I just want to repeat, because I think sometimes the American people understandably aren’t following all -- all the debates here in Washington, raising the debt ceiling does not authorize us to spend more. All it does is say that America will pay its bills. And we are not a deadbeat nation. And the consequences of us not paying our bills, as I outlined in my opening statement, would be disastrous.
At the end of the Calmes and Weisman story the absurdity of the GOP position is given a two-paragraph airing.  Even if you tally all the cuts House Republicans want to see in exchange for a debt-ceiling increase -- cuts to Medicaid, to food stamps, to children's health insurance, to Meals on Wheels and other anti-poverty programs -- and you combine them with the across-the-board reductions that will take hold once the sequester kicks in at the beginning of March, this comes to a savings of $900 billion over ten years, or enough to raise the debt ceiling for one year. Then the whole dark drama has to be repeated in 2014, an election year.

Friday, January 4, 2013

Class Warfare

Boehner wins re-election as speaker of the House and in doing so he talks tough about deficit reduction.  This from today's Jonathan Weissman story:
The agenda laid out by both Mr. Boehner and Senator Mitch McConnell, the Republican leader in the Senate, jibed well with the demands of small-government conservatives who have complained that neither leader has been sufficiently confrontational with Mr. Obama.

Both said cutting spending would be front and center, putting them on a collision course with the president and Democratic leaders. And neither was taking seriously the president’s pledge not to bargain over raising the government’s statutory borrowing ceiling.
Krugman's column takes in the big picture about the current conflict consuming our national politics.  He calls it a class war.  Republicans want to undo the New Deal and Great Society to lock in low taxes for the wealthy.  The identity of the Democratic Party is predicated on Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and now Obamacare.  Since the GOP doesn't have the power to pass any legislation all it can do is extort cuts by means of threat -- of default (by refusing to vote for an increase in the debt ceiling) or government shutdown (by refusing to approve a continuing resolution at the end of March).  The class war will be fought in budgetary battles.  As Krugman says:
[T]he G.O.P. retains the power to destroy, in particular by refusing to raise the debt limit — which could cause a financial crisis. And Republicans have made it clear that they plan to use their destructive power to extract major policy concessions.

Now, the president has said that he won’t negotiate on that basis, and rightly so. Threatening to hurt tens of millions of innocent victims unless you get your way — which is what the G.O.P. strategy boils down to — shouldn’t be treated as a legitimate political tactic.

But will Mr. Obama stick to his anti-blackmail position as the moment of truth approaches? He blinked during the 2011 debt limit confrontation. And the last few days of the fiscal cliff negotiations were also marked by a clear unwillingness on his part to let the deadline expire. Since the consequences of a missed deadline on the debt limit would potentially be much worse, this bodes ill for administration resolve in the clinch.

So, as I said, in a tactical sense the fiscal cliff ended in a modest victory for the White House. But that victory could all too easily turn into defeat in just a few weeks.
Rationality is the ability to recognize a pattern and act on it.  The clear pattern at work here is that Obama says one thing to appeal to his base -- those voters who put him in office -- and then ends up acting differently.  Now that the election is over what leverage do voters have to alter this pattern?