Showing posts with label naked capitalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label naked capitalism. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 29, 2015

Guess What? We Don't Need to Live in a Police State

Chicago mayor Rahm Emanuel, the former Clinton and Obama administration power broker and macho-posturing one-percenter, is in trouble. As Monica Davey reported the other day, "Rahm Emanuel, Under Siege in Chicago, Shows Contrite Side":
Mr. Emanuel swept into the mayor’s office in 2011, helped in part by what black Chicagoans knew about him at the time: that Mr. Obama trusted him. Four years later, he faced a steeper climb in a city that had gotten to know him better. He was forced into a runoff with Jesus G. Garcia, a county commissioner who was seeking to become the city’s first Latino mayor, partly because of critics who said Mr. Emanuel was too brusque and more attentive to the wishes of downtown interests than the needs of residents from some poorer neighborhoods.
The mayor, whose clash with public schoolteachers helped set off the city’s first teachers’ strike in a quarter-century, drew special anger in 2013 for overseeing the closing of nearly 50 public schools, many of them in black and Latino neighborhoods. After winning the unexpectedly tense campaign in April, Mr. Emanuel promised that he had gotten the city’s message.
The start of Mr. Emanuel’s second term already was complicated by the city’s fiscal problems. Facing mounting pension payments and sinking credit ratings, Mr. Emanuel pushed through the largest property tax increase in the city’s modern history. Also, the possibility of another teachers’ strike looms.
The fatal shootings Saturday morning occurred on the city’s West Side, the police said, after officers answered a call about a domestic disturbance and were confronted by a “combative” man who relatives said was wielding a baseball bat. The man, Quintonio LeGrier, was shot dead, as was a bystander, Bettie Jones, a first-floor tenant who the police said was hit accidentally by officers’ shots. Mr. LeGrier’s relatives said that he had mental health problems and that the deaths raised questions about the Police Department’s handling of mental illness and about its use of weapons near bystanders.
Mr. Emanuel’s spokesman said the mayor was monitoring the events closely and had been in communication since early Saturday with the Police Department and his office. Mr. Emanuel spoke to the family of Ms. Jones on Sunday to offer his condolences, his spokesman said.
“Anytime an officer uses force, the public deserves answers, and regardless of the circumstances we all grieve anytime there is a loss of life in our city,” the statement from Mr. Emanuel said. “With that in mind, I have been informed that the Independent Police Review Authority has opened investigations into each shooting, and that all evidence will be shared with the Cook County state’s attorney’s office for additional review in the days ahead.”
But the focus of criticism against Mr. Emanuel has been the McDonald case. For months after Mr. McDonald, 17, was killed on the Southwest Side on Oct. 20, 2014, the city kept a police dashboard camera video of the shooting private. It showed Officer Jason Van Dyke firing at Mr. McDonald even after he lay crumpled on the ground. Mr. McDonald had been carrying a knife, but he appeared to veer slightly away from officers when Officer Van Dyke fired the fatal shots. 
Mr. Emanuel has said the city’s longstanding policy is to keep videos private until prosecutors’ investigations are complete. In Mr. McDonald’s case, the city announced in April that it would pay his family $5 million even before a lawsuit was filed. Yet the city refused to make public the video until a judge ordered it last month; only hours before the release, the Cook County state’s attorney, Anita Alvarez, charged Officer Van Dyke with murder in the shooting. 
Since then, Mr. Emanuel has fired his police superintendent, Garry F. McCarthy; replaced the head of an agency that investigates the most egregious complaints against officers; appointed a task force to recommend changes to the department; and met this month with Justice Department officials as they started a broad review of the Police Department. Mr. Emanuel, who says he did not view the McDonald video until the rest of Chicago saw it in November, made an emotional speech before the City Council apologizing for the death and pledging reforms. 
Yet demonstrators here complain that Mr. Emanuel should have released the video months ago. They question whether his stressful re-election bid played a role in the city’s quick settlement with the McDonald family and its efforts to keep the video private — claims Mr. Emanuel’s office vehemently denies. Regardless, the demonstrators say Mr. Emanuel should have demanded changes in the Police Department, with its well-documented history of mistreating black residents, long ago.
The problem for big city mayors, as New York City's Bill de Blasio discovered last year around this time, is any criticism of the "thin blue line" can lead to an open revolt. Then metropolitan citizens of the indispensable nation are confronted with the ugly realization that they actually belong to a banana republic. To question the sovereign infallibility of the police is to invite retribution. I saw it up close during the Seattle WTO when my neighborhood, home to a community college with a radical activist student body, was perceived to be a hotbed of protest and anti-police sentiment. For a week or two following the ministerial it felt like we were under quarantine.

Last week Naked Capitalism posted Matthew Haywood's helpful outline of the post-Ferguson state of affairs for American policing, "The Logic of the Police State in America," the gist of which is that police forces across the country, feeling the pressure of Black Lives Matter, are attempting to protect their "above-the-law" privileges.

The problem for the popo is in their main argument, which Haywood summarizes as follows:
If you’ve been listening to various police agencies and their supporters, then you know what the future holds: anarchy is coming — and it’s all the fault of activists.
In May, a Wall Street Journal op-ed warned of a “new nationwide crime wave” thanks to “intense agitation against American police departments” over the previous year. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie went further. Talking recently with the host of CBS’s Face the Nation, the Republican presidential hopeful asserted that the Black Lives Matter movement wasn’t about reform but something far more sinister. “They’ve been chanting in the streets for the murder of police officers,” he insisted. Even the nation’s top cop, FBI Director James Comey, weighed in at the University of Chicago Law School, speaking of “a chill wind that has blown through American law enforcement over the last year.”
According to these figures and others like them, lawlessness has been sweeping the nation as the so-called Ferguson effect spreads. Criminals have been emboldened as police officers are forced to think twice about doing their jobs for fear of the infamy of starring in the next viral video. The police have supposedly become the targets of assassins intoxicated by “anti-cop rhetoric,” just as departments are being stripped of the kind of high-powered equipment they need to protect officers and communities.  Even their funding streams have, it’s claimed, come under attack as anti-cop bias has infected Washington, D.C.  Senator Ted Cruz caught the spirit of that critique by convening a Senate subcommittee hearing to which he gave the title, “The War on Police: How the Federal Government Undermines State and Local Law Enforcement.” According to him, the federal government, including the president and attorney general, has been vilifying the police, who are now being treated as if they, not the criminals, were the enemy.
Haywood goes on to describe how violent attacks against the police are at all-time low. What is more problematic for the police state is the case of New York City, where the end of aggressive law enforcement, in the form of stop and frisk, led not to a spike in crime, as many pundits and cops predicted, but to a significant drop in crime. This from yesterday's unsigned editorial: "New York City Policing, by the Numbers":
The warnings began even before Bill de Blasio was sworn in as New York City’s mayor in January 2014. A safe New York depended on the aggressive policing tactics that began in the 1990s and flourished under Mayor Michael Bloomberg and his police commissioner, Ray Kelly. Without those tactics, the doomsayers said, the city would be swamped by a 1970s-style crime wave. 
After a federal judge ruled in 2013 that the Police Department’s “stop and frisk” policy was so sweeping that it violated the Constitution, Mr. Kelly was furious. “Violent crime will go up,” he said on NBC’s “Meet the Press.” “No question about it.” 
That prediction has, of course, been proved wrong, as crime in the city remains at historic lows under Mayor de Blasio and his police commissioner, William Bratton, even as arrests, stops and summonses continue to plummet after a peak in 2011. 
An illuminating new report released by the John Jay College of Criminal Justice provides the most comprehensive analysis yet of the numbers behind the rise and fall of police “enforcement actions” over the past decade. Between 2011 and 2014, the report found, the total number of these actions — defined as arrests for felonies and misdemeanors, criminal summonses, and stop-and-frisks — fell by more than 800,000, or 31 percent. 
The biggest drop was in street stops, which had skyrocketed to more than 685,000 in 2011 from 160,000 in 2003. Some officers admitted they felt constant pressure to meet arbitrary productivity quotas, but the effect was to disproportionately target young African-American men, most of whom were doing nothing wrong. By 2014, the number of stops was under 46,000 — a 93 percent decline in only three years, with stops going down most sharply in those poorer and minority neighborhoods where they grew the fastest over the previous decade.
Guess what? We don't need to live in a police state.

Wednesday, July 8, 2015

Collapse: Greece + Yemen

The situation for Greece seems hopeless this morning. Reports over at Naked Capitalism highlight 1) that Tsipras never expected, never wanted to win the referendum and now has no idea what to do, that is why apparently Varoufakis' replacement, new finance minister Euclid Tsakalotos, showed up in Brussels without any proposal to present; and 2) complete capitulation by Syriza is coming fast. A proposal must be submitted by tomorrow and final agreement reached by Sunday. The new D-Day is now July 12, not July 20.

Though Yves Smith is reporting that Tsipras is already signalling his intention to accept most parts of the austerity package that was overwhelming rejected by Greeks at the polls this past Sunday, this might not be enough to satisfy the hardliners in the eurogroup, who are now rallying for even more austerity.

I think we have arrived at the point of Grexident. I suppose Tsipras can abjectly surrender to the eurogroup, that might have been the point of convening all parliamentary parties in a show of solidarity heading into negotiations. But then how does Syriza survive politically after receiving that 61% "Oxi" vote? It can't.

So it looks like drachmas it is. A lot of chaos is coming.

Which brings us to what I wanted to mention this morning -- Yemen. Yemen is infrequently covered in the "newspaper of record." Whether because its "Mad Max" landscape prevents Times' reporters from being dispatched to a war zone, or the more malign reason that the Gray Lady shares the foreign policy goals of the Obama administration, and the Obama administration is actively involved in the Saudi-led genocidal campaign against the poorest Arab country, New York Times readers are not receiving daily coverage of the ongoing slaughter in Yemen.

The numbers of dead as reported by CNN are as follows:
In total, more than 3,260 people have been killed in Yemen since March, [Stephen O'Brien, the top U.N. humanitarian affairs official, said Tuesday] and close to 1.3 million people have been displaced.

Of the dead, more than 1,500 are civilians, according to the U.N. human rights office.
The Gray Lady did publish a topnotch unsigned editorial yesterday, "As Yemen Collapses":
Yemen has now been added to the United Nations’ list of most severe humanitarian emergencies, along with South Sudan, Syria and Iraq. It is a tragic distinction, highlighting the peril to 80 percent of the country’s 25 million citizens. The international community, including the United States, is not doing enough to push for an immediate cease-fire in the war that is ravaging the country to make it possible to deliver aid.
Yemen, a poor country, was deeply unstable even before a coalition, led by Saudi Arabia and backed by the United States, started bombing the Houthi rebel movement in late March. Last week, Ban Ki-moon, the United Nations secretary general, declared the situation a “catastrophe.”
The coalition is seeking to reinstate the government of President Abdu Rabbu Mansour Hadi, who is now in exile in Riyadh. Mr. Hadi was ousted by the Houthis, an indigenous Shiite group allied with Iran. Most Yemenis are Sunnis, and Saudi Arabia, a leading Sunni country, has feared that a Houthi takeover would extend the influence of Iran, its regional rival.
The statistics are staggering. Over the past three months, the conflict has forced over a million Yemenis to flee their homes, and 21 million are in need of immediate help. Close to 13 million people are hungry and nearly half the provinces are “one step away” from famine, the United Nations said. Some 15 million people have no health care, and outbreaks of dengue fever and malaria are raging unchecked, in part because a fuel shortage has cut the electricity that keeps water pumps functioning.
The armed conflict is the biggest obstacle for United Nations relief agencies and private groups that are trying to reach desperate Yemenis, but a Saudi-imposed blockade along the coastline is also impeding crucial supplies from getting to those in need.
Mr. Ban and his special envoy, Ismail Ould Cheikh Ahmed, have been working to arrange a pause in the fighting so humanitarian aid can be delivered, and late last week aid groups were told that a cease-fire lasting about five days could begin soon. But the Saudi-led coalition may have hurt that goal by unleashing more airstrikes in the past few days against the Houthis and causing scores of new civilian casualties. One attack, on a marketplace near the city of Aden on Monday, killed more than 45 civilians, The Associated Press reported. In all, the United Nations has said 3,000 Yemenis have died since March, half of them civilians.
Some aid groups say five days is not enough time to resupply the millions of civilians caught in the fighting. And even if there is a pause, the conflict could grow worse unless all sides pledge not to use it to seize more territory. The Houthis did exactly that in the last brief break in the fighting.
What is needed is a permanent political solution that will ensure the Houthis, who have some legitimate grievances and are unlikely to give up, get a significant role in any new government. Negotiations should be started without preconditions. But Saudi Arabia and its allies have appeared intent on forcing the Houthis to surrender, no matter what the cost to civilians and Yemen’s cities and villages.
Yemen has been a breeding ground for extremists, including Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, the most lethal Qaeda affiliate. Its further unraveling will make it impossible to contain those threats, and that is a consequence all sides should fear.
Add to this the two Islamic State in Yemen car bombs that struck Sana yesterday, and you have a picture of superpower backed states bombing from above while its takfiri proxies Islamic State and AQAP bomb from down below.

At this point it is obvious that even if all Houthis were to spontaneously combust, Yemen would remain a cracked, failed state, a staging ground for takfiri jihad for the foreseeable future.

We have entered that stage of the dialectic where state powers in order to maintain their hegemony are destroying the possibility of any peace.

Tuesday, June 2, 2015

Greek Zero Hour: Default or Lickspittlry

The flurry of activity yesterday and today surrounding Greek debt negotiations is succinctly framed by this two-sentence paragraph found in "European Leaders Assemble for Urgent Meeting on Greek Crisis," by Liz Alderman, Niki Kitsantonis and Jack Ewing:
Unless they strike an agreement soon, Greece may not be able to make a series of coming debt payments. On Friday, Greece must make a €300 million loan repayment to the International Monetary Fund, and it owes €1.2 billion later this month.
Yves Smith at Naked Capitalism, "Greece’s Creditors Meet to Prepare Offer (Updated – Creditors Agree on Terms)," seems confident that Greece can meet Friday's deadline and has enough wiggle room to survive the month:
The press is awash with reports of a high-level meeting convened yesterday by Angel Merkel and attended by Francois Hollande, Christine Lagarde and Mario Draghi. The upshot is that Greece’s creditors have agreed to sort out their differences and come up with a proposal to present to Greece in the next few days. Greece is generally believed to be able to make its €300 milllion payment due to the IMF on Friday; if not, it has the expedient of asking to bundle payments under an existing IMF rule, which would give it till the end of the month to remit the €1.5 billion it has coming due in June.
So why the splashy optics of a Monday-night emergency powwow of big shots? There are several "technical" issues in play. Two key ones are pension overhaul and the value-added tax. The euro honchos convened to finalize an agreement on which of Syriza's "red lines" Greek leader Alexis Tsipras must cross.

Smith says that Tsipras is giving ground on pensions, agreeing to raise the retirement age to 67. The endgame here is to cripple Syriza and beat back any challenge to a bankrupt neoliberal orthodoxy. If Tsipras is made to kneel, violating his own campaign promises to protect if not increase pensions, and schlep a pension-cut deal back to parliament for approval, the troika will have won. Syriza's parliamentary majority will splinter. Already the Left Platform bloc of Syriza is gaining momentum. Left Platform wants to default on debt payments and return Greece to the drachma. As Alderman, Kitsantonis and Ewing explain:
Far-left Syriza lawmakers have become increasingly agitated recently, accusing Mr. Tsipras of making too many compromises on the anti-austerity pledges that helped sweep the party to power in January’s elections.
A new political uproar broke when a group of Syriza lawmakers refused to back the government’s nominee for a new representative at the International Monetary Fund, Elena Panaritis, a former Greek parliamentarian who once worked at the World Bank. In a letter on Sunday, more than 40 Syriza members, mostly lawmakers, took issue with her support of Greece’s last international bailout agreement in 2012, which the party considered to have been unfair and overly harsh. Ms. Panaritis withdrew from consideration on Monday, citing the opposition.
Although symbolic, it was the latest in a series of uprisings within Syriza, which during the election campaign had promised to take a hard line with Greece’s creditors in debt negotiations and to resist austerity measures. A hard-left faction recently pressed for but lost an internal central committee party vote to have Athens stop paying its creditors altogether if they demanded further austerity.
Mr. Tsipras is facing an array of pressures as critics from both the left and right in the Greek government question whether he has a viable plan to restart the economy, which slid back into a recession in the first quarter. At the same time, Greece’s creditors, the I.M.F. in particular, have resisted unlocking any aid unless the government can show that it will put its finances on a sound footing and run enough of an operating surplus to make regular debt payments. 
The dispute over Ms. Panaritis on Monday “shows that there’s a lot of exasperation in Syriza ahead of a deal with creditors,” said Harry Papasotiriou, a professor of political science at the Panteion University in Athens and the head of the Institute of International Relations. 
Even if dissent within Syriza deepens, the government would probably band together to push through any legislation needed to secure the bailout funds. Few lawmakers want to precipitate a default or force Greece to exit the currency union. But the hard-liners of Mr. Tsipras’s party could eventually break away, analysts said, especially the Left Platform, a faction that has already pushed for Greece to stop paying its creditors if they continue with “blackmailing tactics.”
This is the outcome I believe Merkel, Largarde, Hollande, Draghi et al are after. They want to force Tsipras into "Obama mode." Talk "hope & change" and deliver more of the same. Syriza's governing majority collapses as a result, and the moral to the story becomes, "See, that is what happens when you try to change the order of things."

AP is reporting this morning (Elena Becatoros "Greece submits draft bailout plan, creditors say not enough") that Tsipras has delivered a proposal to the creditors, and he's talking tough:
"It is now clear that the decision for whether they want to adapt to realism and emerge from the crisis without the division of Europe ... belongs to the political leadership of Europe," Tsipras said.
In the end, this is all a Kabuki. There is no alternative to a default. Greece has been hemorrhaging capital and must soon implement controls. This is the last paragraph from the Alderman et al piece:
In the meantime, Greece’s finances continue to deteriorate as deepening political uncertainty accelerates a decline in tax receipts and withdrawals of deposits from the nation’s banks. Last week, Greece’s central bank reported that deposits fell in April to €133 billion, the lowest level in a decade, after savers withdrew nearly €5 billion from the banks during the month. More than €30 billion was withdrawn between the end of last November and the end of April, according to the Bank of Greece.
And yet the troika persists in maintaining the fiction of robust primary surplus targets. According to Smith:
Things are even worse than they appear. The target for this year was 3%, and 4.5% for 2016. Most observers thought both figures were insane. And remember, when Syriza assumed office, Greece has a small primary surplus. As of April, the IMF projected a deficit of 1.5%, and matters can’t have gotten any better. To just meet Greece’s ask of 1% now means a swing of a full 2.5% of GDP, almost the unreasonable level they were expected to hit for 2015. Even if the creditors make what they think is a generous offer of 2% for 2015, that is equivalent to an asphyxiating 3.5% consolidation from the new starting point of negative 1.5%. 
So the creditors may have read too much into Tsipras’ offer to negotiate on pensions. Or they may feel they have to go this step regardless of whether their gambit will work. Or they may be in denial as to how badly Tsipras has been boxed in by his Left Forum (although he can always cut a deal with To Potami). At a minimum, both sides appear to finally be about to get out of the Groundhog Day phase of these negotiations to an end game. 
Zero Hour is rapidly approaching (although this has been said many times before). The "Either/Or" here seems clearer than before. Either Greece defaults on its debt, or Tsipras brings back the creditors' crummy deal to parliament and manages to get it approved only to see Syriza splinter, and with it the momentum of a resurgent Left.

Monday, May 11, 2015

Greek Debt Negotiations to Muddle Along, But Things Actually Looking Up for Syriza

It is Monday morning which must mean that there is a meeting in Brussels between eurozone finance ministers and Yanis Varoufakis' Greek negotiating team. Tomorrow is the deadline for repayment of 750 million euros to the IMF. Last week Varoufakis said Greece would make the repayment. The ever-skeptical Yves Smith of Naked Capitalism is not so sure. As she argues in her post today, "Greece Finally Threatens Default as Deal with Creditors Remains Remote,"
The ruling Greek coalition appears to have finally woken up to the fact that it it cornered. As we indicated, the longer the creditors keep Greece in the sweatbox, the more its popularity is destined to decline. 
While the latest polls still show Syriza as the most popular party, its support is now at 36%, a round trip from a huge surge after the government took office to back to where it stood when it was voted into office. Approval ratings of the government’s strategy have dropped precipitously from the very high levels reached shortly after the new government took office. As e pointed out early on, the best strategy for the creditors was simply to remain non-negotiable. Either Syriza would capitulate to their demands, or the government would lose support, paving the way for the return of a more complaint coalition. Syriza appears to realize that following the inertial path of trying to extend its negotiating runway does not work in its favor. Even if Greece were to pull a rabbit out of the hat and make the €750 million IMF payment, it has a total of €1.5 billion coming due to the IMF in June, which it almost certainly can’t satisfy if it fails to unlock the bailout funds.
Yves Smith seems to think that Syriza can either make the IMF payment tomorrow and risk having to issue scrip to pensioners and government workers at the end of the month, or it can stiff the IMF, a course of action that would not immediately precipitate default and Grexit. As Smith explains:
The situation is more fluid than it appears. The odds are high that blame game political calculations will win over sound policy. We’re already seeing jockeying starting to take place. Notice Schauble’s “justifiable conditions” caveat. He’s made clear repeatedly that he’d just as soon see Greece leave the Eurozone, but no one, particularly Merkel, wants to be seen to have pushed Greece out. Thus if Greece plays its cards so it can be depicted to have brought the default (and if it comes to that, an exit), that works to the advantage of the hardliners who see Greece as disposable and believe a default/possible exit can be made painful enough for the Greek people so as to make any other country that might contemplate leaving the Eurozone to see that alternative as too costly.
Despite the continued impasse, and virtual certainty of a default on Tuesday [!], the creditors have quite a lot of choices and options. For instance, despite the IMF’s tough talk about not giving Greece any grace period on a default, an IMF default is not as fine a trigger event at a private sector bond default. As the Financial Times explains:
But that hard line masks a little wiggle room created by the IMF’s own procedures. Under the official timeline plan, it is not until a month after a missed payment that the managing director formally notifies the board and not until three months afterwards that a formal statement to the outside world is expected to be made.
In other words, even if Greece defaults on the loan repayment to the IMF, things can continue to muddle along as they have. The June repayments are larger than this month's. But if missed payments can play out over months before a default is officially declared, there is no reason why this can't repeat itself next month.

In the Business section of today's "newspaper of record" is a slightly more sanguine treatment of the Brussels negotiations. Peter Eavis, Jack Ewing and Landon Thomas, "I.M.F. and Central Bank Loom Large Over Greece’s Debt Talks," see a chink in the troika's armor, and it is not the wiggle room on IMF repayments; it is the risk aversion of the European Central Bank:
It would of course also be a high-stakes gamble for Greece to do anything that could undermine relations with the central bank, which is shoring up Greece’s banking system. It has lent Greek banks more than €110 billion, cash the lenders need to operate but would have trouble raising on international money markets. 
The support to the banks is not the debt that the officials in the Greek government would consider for default. Instead, the idea would be to not repay Greek government bonds held by the central bank. Greece is scheduled to repay nearly €7 billion on those this summer. 
If the Greek banks could not repay their central bank loans, the losses would be passed on to other eurozone countries. An outcry would come from Germany and other countries already fed up with what they regard as Greece’s misbehavior. The central bank’s credibility — probably a central bank’s most important asset — could be damaged. 
Still, the central bank’s deep caution about financial stability would most likely limit how hard it pressed Greece. As the guardian of the single currency, the central bank may not want to do anything that could set off a chain of catastrophic events in Greece’s banking sector that could lead the country to quit the euro. 
“The E.C.B. does not want to be responsible for precipitating a crisis,” said Mujtaba Rahman, practice head for the European Union at Eurasia Group, a political consultancy. “They are very, very concerned about having blood on their hands.”
I know at the end of April when last I wrote about this I said climax was near. Then it looked impossibile that Varoufakis could scrape together the 750 million euros due the IMF on May 12. At the time there was the brouhaha over Varoufakis' obstreperousness; things seemed to be at an unbridgeable impasse and something was going to fracture. But then Tsipras organized a deft cosmetic reshuffling of the bargaining team, with Varoufakis nominally sent to the sidelines, and that seemed to cool things down. Also, I had no idea just how wide the nonpayment wiggle room to the IMF is. Things can continue to go on as they have for months.

Syriza will get some rhetorical help from the Scottish National Party blasting away at austerity. And there is evidence that the U.S. is extremely jealous of Russian pipeline overtures to Greece. So all in all I am more hopeful of some sort of resolution that favors Greece than I have been in months.

Thursday, February 5, 2015

Maybe Not a Grexit but a Default: Naked Capitalism's Yves Smith on Greece's Efforts to Free Itself From Bloodsucking Austerity

With recent moves by the European Central Bank to force Greece's Syriza government to accept the same neoliberal austerity program that it was elected to reject, the one that has led to 25% unemployment and a 25% reduction in the size of the Greek economy, and to accept it quickly it seems to me that the only option available to Varoufakis and Tsipras is to default.

Naked Capitalism's Yves Smith's writing on Syriza's efforts to beat back austerity, though pessimistic, has been superb. Her "Will the Cavalry Ride Over the Hill in Time for Greece?" is a must read:
We’ve cautioned readers that Greece is in a very weak bargaining position relative to its financial overlords in the Troika. As much as Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis is making sound, logical arguments and presenting proposals that if anything are too accommodating, despite initial cool reactions, many of Greece’s soi disantpartners are diehard neoliberals and/or are politically constrained. Varoufakis is approaching them as if they can deal in good faith, when their idea of “good faith” comes from a punitive parallel universe.
While Varoufakis and presumably Tsipras are unwilling to deploy the one realpolitik tool at their disposal, a threat of Grexit, other parties who have influence on the recalcitrant actors are more sensitive to the fact that much more is at issue than just the fate of Greece. The ongoing game of extend and pretend has managed to forestall what amounts to an existential crisis for the Eurozone. Its founders knew its structure was incomplete and imperfect, but they believed the logic of preventing future wars was so compelling that the inevitable future crises would be resolved by further integration. 
Unfortunately, as we’ve been chronicling off and on since 2010, the northern bloc, and most important, Germany, have not wanted to give up its catbird seat. It has influence in excess of its population, continues to run trade surpluses with the rest of the Eurozone, which is tantamount to stealing demand, yet it is unwilling to accept the inevitable consequence of running sustained trade surpluses, which is that you must finance your trade partners (or to put it in the terms of petrostates, recycle your surpluses). Moving toward integration, particularly more powerful governance at the Eurozone level, and having more fiscal transfers to allow countries like Greece to have enough demand to have manageable levels of production and employment, means that Germany will have to cede power. And Europe still has strong nationalistic impulses, another obstacle to cementing the alliance. 
But it has also been clear, with the rise of ultra-right, anti-Eurozone parties, and to a lesser degree, anti-austerity parties like Syriza and Spain’s Podemos, that this unsustainable status quo is if anything past its sell-by date. Thus for the more forward-thinking technocrats and politicians, Greece’s efforts to free itself from failed austerity policies serve as a focus point for their own agendas to move away from anti-growth, anti-democratic policies. 
The problem for Varoufakis and Syriza generally is that the magnitude of the task before them, of negotiating what they hope is a deal with significant new components, is already difficult to accomplish by June, the longest time frame they are likely to have, even if their interlocutors were more receptive. With limited knowledge of the power structures in the key governments with which they are dealing, it’s well nigh impossible for them to find, let alone work with, mid level and senior level figures who are their natural allies. 
Thus Varoufakis (at least for now) is forced to broadcast his messages when narrowcasting would be better. Broadcasting means he will almost inevitably offend some key audience, given if nothing else how far apart Syriza’s voters and German officials are in their expectations for the negotiations. But the broadcasting is critical to communicating and rallying both insider allies as well as voters in periphery countries, since shifts in poll results increase pressure on the Eurozone reactionaries. Perversely, the best thing for Syriza’s chances were the Hebdo murders, since the boost it gave to anti-Eurozone Front National leader Marine Le Pen is a big wake-up call for the Eurozone elites.
Today, after ECB announced that it will not accept Greek government debt as collateral for new loans, Smith writes in "ECB to Greece: Drop Dead":
Even by the standards of bank thuggishness, the move by the ECB against Greece last night was a stunner. Americans have become used to banks taking houses under dubious pretexts when both the investors and borrowers would do better with a writedown. But to see the ECB try take a country is another matter entirely. As one seasoned pro said, “If anyone had tried something like this against a country with a decent sized military, the tanks would be rolling.” 
The ECB’s bombshell was to put Greece at risk of an intensification of its ongoing bank run in order to pressure it to agree to a deal with the Troika under an impossibly tight timetable, even shorter than the February 28 pre-existing deadline that Greece Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis had planned to extend until June. As we’ve discussed at length previously, a longer negotiation timetable would be necessary to meet Greece’s objective of restructuring of the relationship with the Troika. Greece wanted that to be based on the recognition that Greece could never pay off its debts and that it was in both side’s interest to let Greece implement more growth-oriented policies. But the message from the enforcers at the ECB was unambiguous: Greece has no rights and needs to accept its debtcropper status. 
The ECB has thus also effectively said that it would rather have fascists like Golden Dawn running Greece, which is what will eventually occur if it succeeds in breaking Syriza. It also just handed France’s Marine Le Pen, head of the nationalistic, anti-Eurozone Front National fantastic fodder for her campaign. 
The February 28 date was the result of Greece presumably needing access to so-called bailout funds to pay off an IMF obligation coming due. Varoufakis said he would refuse those funds, and could get by until June, when more loans came due, by relying on existing tax receipts and getting what he regarded as minor waivers from the central bank. He also had some creative ideas for restructuring Greece’s debts and said that he wanted the OECD rather than the Troika to provide auditors on behalf of the lenders. 
Even though we warned that the ECB was likely to use its control over liquidity facilities to stymie Syriza’s plans and force Greece to the negotiating table sooner rather than later, the smackdown was even more brutal than we imagined possible.
***
As we have said before, Greece is in a weak bargaining position. It may be able to go beyond February 28, but probably not very long. Some readers have suggested appealing to Russia, but not only would that unleash even more brutal treatment from the Troika, but the German press has also reported that Russia is not interested. 
Varoufakis has ruled out a Grexit as ultimately hugely detrimental to Greece. Even if the Tsipras government were to decide to reverse course (likely leading Varoufakis to resign), he would probably want a referendum to make sure it had popular support. Most governments have procedures that don’t allow for them to be launched on short order. So even with this averse development, a Grexit seems unlikely. 
The Greek government can implement emergency measures, like capital controls and restrictions on daily bank withdrawals, to reduce the bank run. Measures like nationalizing all domestic banks and implementing a plan to allow foreign banks to leave the country in an orderly manner works only if the Greek central bank can backstop the domestic banks, and that in turn works only in the event of a Grexit, since the central bank needs to be a currency issuer. 
And of course, Greece can default. 
In response to an e-mail tonight, Varoufakis wrote, “One thing we will not do is capitulate.” I hope readers will wish him and his fellow citizens good luck. But the Troika seems determined to destroy Greece if that is what it takes to show that their authority remains unchallenged. But the cost of discipling Greece is likely to be far greater than they imagine, not just in financial terms, but to the Eurozone project itself. 

Tuesday, February 3, 2015

"Syriza is the Only Game in Town"

From time to time we among the news-consuming public are treated to a focusing of the lens that reveals a basic conflict, a sort of good guys versus bad guys, the outcome of which might change before our eyes the world we live in. Cyprus vs. the troika at the beginning of 2013 is an example. It looked for a moment there as if the eurozone might come tumbling down, of which I was in favor because it seemed to me that rather than providing an alternate model of the dominant race-to-the-bottom neoliberalism of the United States, the European Union was copying it, hollowing out the rich social democracies of its member nations.

After Cyprus there was Syria in the summer of 2013. A false flag chemical attack in a Damascus suburb was meant to launch a saturation bombing campaign led by the U.S., the idea being to drive out the ruling Baathists and carve up Syria, re-crafting Sykes-Picot. The Russians intervened with some deft diplomacy, the result of which was that the U.S. would call off its air power campaign in exchange for al-Assad giving up all of Syria's chemical weaponry. This so incensed the Saudis that Islamic State was given the "Go" signal. By the next summer we had a version of the Sykes-Picot reboot that the Gulf sheikhdoms were hankering after all along.

Also last summer there was Cold War 2.0. It looked for a while like the rebels of the Donetsk People's Republic and Luhansk People's Republic were going to smash so thoroughly the Ukrainian military that the junta in Kiev might collapse. Then there was the Minsk ceasefire in September. Now that fiction has evaporated and we are back to where we were last summer with "boilers" in the Donbass and the junta military getting its clocked clean.

Right now the good guys vs. bad guys narrative moment of clarity has to do with Greece's new Syriza-led government. Since its convincing election victory ten days ago, Syriza's leader Alexis Tsipras has stepped back from the international limelight and finance minister Yanis Varoufakis has stepped forward.

Varoufakis has been seemingly everywhere of late, parrying with BBC talking heads and eurogroup chief Jeroen Dijsselbloem, flying to Paris to meet with France's finance minister, all in an attempt to break the stranglehold that German-dictated austerity has on the continent.

Yves Smith of Naked Capitalism has been following these perambulations and, despite the outpouring of joy from the Western left that greeted Syriza's election, she has been bearish on Syriza's chances of achieving its aims, i.e., restoring social spending and collective bargaining rights, halting privatization, negotiating a debt jubilee with Greece's creditors.

Smith's post this morning, "Greek Finance Minister Varoufakis Retreats on Debt Writedowns, Public Spending Promises," is a good example:
We’ve said that Greece had a weak negotiating position in trying to get a better deal from its creditors. That is playing out before our eyes. Greek Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis has stepped down some of his early proposals even before formal talks have begun. This is a sad but predictable situation, since the Germans and the other members of the northern bloc are not at all willing to cut Greece much if any slack, since that would lead bigger, more powerful countries to try to slip the yoke of austerity.
The tragic thing about this situation is that Varoufakis is simply describing economic reality and has a number of sound ideas for how to make conditions better for Greece, which in the end will also lead to better results for its lenders. Yet he has run into a massive, if predictable wall, with his willingness to make unvarnished descriptions of the obvious, abject failure of Eurozone economic policies regularly depicted as “confrontational”. One reason Varoufakis may be going this route is to use his newfound high profile to send a message to voters and anti-austerlity politicians throughout Europe, since as we have stressed, the more popular anti-austerity and anti-Eurozone parties become, the more even the Germans will have to fear.
The Germans have a short-sighted view of the stakes. With the ECB holding a sword of Damocles over the Greek banking system, in terms of its ability to cut off access to emergency liquidity facilities, and Syriza and Varoufakis personally having rejected a Grexit, they can dictate terms. In their eyes, the only reason to cut Greece any slack is that, as Varoufakis keeps stressing, Syriza is the sole party that is not loyal to Greek’s oligarchs. If they want corruption tamped down and the tax system cleaned up, Syriza is the only game in town.
Today in a Financial Times interview, Varoufakis walked back his negotiating ask for debt cancellation, instead proposing a series of “debt swaps” that would achieve more or less the same result. He was more obvious that might have been ideal in stating that he regarded this as a fix to placate Germany. From the Financial Times, which broke the story:
Greece’s radical new government revealed proposals on Monday for ending the confrontation with its creditors by swapping outstanding debt for new growth-linked bonds, running a permanent budget surplus and targeting wealthy tax-evaders…
Attempting to sound an emollient note, Mr Varoufakis told the Financial Times the government would no longer call for a headline write-off of Greece’s €315bn foreign debt. Rather it would request a “menu of debt swaps” to ease the burden, including two types of new bonds.
The first type, indexed to nominal economic growth, would replace European rescue loans, and the second, which he termed “perpetual bonds”, would replace European Central Bank-owned Greek bonds.
He said his proposal for a debt swap would be a form of “smart debt engineering” that would avoid the need to use a term such as a debt “haircut”, politically unacceptable in Germany and other creditor countries because it sounds to taxpayers like an outright loss.
But there is still deep scepticism in many European capitals, in particular Berlin, about the new government’s brinkmanship and its calls for an end to austerity policies.
“What I’ll say to our partners is that we are putting together a combination of a primary budget surplus and a reform agenda,” Mr Varoufakis, a leftwing academic economist and prolific blogger, said. “I’ll say, ‘Help us to reform our country and give us some fiscal space to do this, otherwise we shall continue to suffocate and become a deformed rather than a reformed Greece’.”
In a more sophisticated undercutting of Varoufakis than the disgraceful BBC interview of last week, a Financial Times video embedded in the article features a commentator discussing Varoufakis’ progress thus far. The segment depicts Varoufakis as being confrontational and as not having gotten on well with the UK chancellor of the exchequer, and also focuses on the flight of financial assets from Greece and its falling stock market. Does it not occur to anyone that a substantial portion of the money exodus is that of those very oligarchs that Syriza has threatened? The rest of the EU says they want the country cleaned up, yet they attack Syriza for the predictable results of their seriousness.
But while it may seem trivial for them to get their way with Greece, this victory is likely to be Pyrrhic. The more it becomes obvious that the northern countries will keep inflicting pain on Greece out of a desire to keep a bad status quo intact, the more the other victims in better bargaining positions (by virtue of having larger economies and even more fractious voters) are likely to escalate. Indeed, Varoufakis, by challenging the Troika on so many fronts, is conveying a powerful message that subservience is neither necessary nor desirable. No wonder the technocrats are out to discredit him personally.
Ambrose Evans-Pritchard argues that Greece holds the trump cards. Here I disagree. With de facto control over Greece’s banking system, the ECB can bring Greece to heel. We’ll see if the ECB imposes any conditions on its approval of the Greece’s request to use ELA funds on Wednesday. If they are anything other than cosmetic, that means the ECB is supporting the northern countries and is determined to box Syriza in. But I do agree that in a longer time frame, Germany is losing. The problem is it may not lose quickly enough for Greece to get the relief it desperately needs. 
Interestingly, right after Syriza won the election all the talk was that the troika would extend the bailout program set to expire on February 28. Nothing of the sort materialized, and last week Varoufakis staked out the position that Greece would not accept the bailout funds because doing so would lock the country into conditions the new government rejects.

Now, following the post-election bank runs, Smith sees a lot of importance in what position the European Central Bank will take Wednesday regarding Greece's request for Emergency Liquidity Assistance. According to Smith, the game for the Syriza can be up pretty much by tomorrow if the ECB demands onerous conditions to access ELA money.

My sense is that Syriza is shrewder and tougher than Smith is willing to credit. At this point "There Is No Aletrnative" to a party like Syriza, other than, given time, one more to the left or the far right. Varoufakis, it seems to me, is waiting for the troika to overplay its hand. And so far this seems to be transpiring, which is having the effect of radicalizing the public. The point is that the general populous has to be moved from its false consciousness to one that is more real, more radical. That is happening. But as Smith asks, Will Syriza have enough time?

Friday, January 30, 2015

Democrats are Doomed

For a snapshot that conjures up Jim Jones' Guyana, take a look at "House Democrats, Facing Long Odds, Take Inspiration From the Top" by Emmarie Huettemen and Michael Shear. The story describes a pep rally House Democrats held in Philadelphia yesterday. Obama made a rousing appearance. The message -- please, don't chuckle -- is that the Democratic Party is the shield of the working class, defending the little people from the predatory rich and their rapacious servants in the Republican Party.

A few discreet words were dropped to explain the horrifically poor showing in the 2014 midterms. Democrats in the House apparently forgot to stay on the economic justice message. (If you haven't got around to it yet, take the time to read Thomas Ferguson's masterful assessment of the 2014 midterm election, "Americans Are Sick to Death of Both Parties: Why Our Politics Is in Worse Shape Than We Though.") But fear not, good citizen. The Party of Jackson is going to redouble its efforts to protect me and you and make sure that we get some of that wealth that has been vacuumed up to the 1% during the Obama years:
As the Democratic lawmakers gathered here Thursday, their leaders did not shy from admitting that their postelection strategies bore a strong resemblance to the emphasis they placed on issues like wage inequality before they lost 13 seats in November’s election.
“It is the same and critically important message,” said Representative Steny H. Hoyer of Maryland.
Representative Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, the ranking member on the House Budget Committee, said the party did not need to find a new message. Rather, he said, lawmakers and the president need to do a better job focusing that message and motivating turnout of voters next year. “There should have been more unity behind the president’s economic agenda,” Mr. Van Hollen said.
Mr. Obama urged the Democrats in Philadelphia not to be shy in embracing the party’s values, and he promised that he would not relent in pressuring the Republicans.
“We need to stand up and go on offense and not be defensive about what we believe,” Mr. Obama said. “I promise you I’m not going out the last two years sitting on the sidelines. I’m going to be out there making the case every single day.”
This is a picture of an organization that is not in touch with reality; that, or its leaders are lying through their teeth. They must take us for a bunch of witless boobs.

An indication where the Democrats are headed at full speed can be detected in an excellent piece that appears on Naked Capitalism. Hope for Greece, and Perhaps Europe Too, by Mathew D. Rose, an independent journalist living Berlin, encapsulates the situation in Europe that led to Syriza's victory this past Sunday. Obeisance to neoliberal austerity and market fundamentalism has hollowed out Europe's socialist parties:
[Europe’s Social Democrats] are clearly on the decline, as they have lost credibility as a party of the people. Their natural replacement, ergo their most menacing opponent, will be the new parties on the left. The once predominant social democratic party in Greece, PASOK, could not even muster five percent of the vote in Sunday’s elections. The PSOE in Spain is plumbing the 20 percent barrier, things look scarcely better for Germany’s Social Democrats; while in France Hollande and his acolytes seem set on immolating their party. Even in Britain, where the Labour Party was hoping to come out of the upcoming elections as the strongest party, it has not only lost one of its heartlands, Scotland, to the Scottish National Party, but is facing a surge in England by the Greens, who are adopting an ever increasing leftist agenda and brazenly showing solidarity with Syriza and its programme.
One could add Sinn Féin to this list of authentic leftist parties rising to challenging the corrupt neoliberal hegemony.

As it stands now, I think Scott Walker wins the general election in 2016. And then woe unto us all. To prevent this from happening the Democrats will have to reinvent themselves pronto. And nothing points to this happening.

Thursday, January 29, 2015

Syriza is For Real

I have been greatly impressed this past week as Alexis Tsipras has rolled out the new Syriza-led government. For instance, his finance minister, Yanis Varoufakis, is an economist and blogger whose writings I have posted on this page before. Another unexpected ray of sunshine is the possibility that a Syriza-led Greece could block a new round of sanctions against Russia. Jim Yardley reported yesterday in "Greece’s New Left-Wing Cabinet Signals Willingness to Confront E.U. Over Policies" that,
Two days after he ousted Greek’s conservative government in an emphatic election victory, Mr. Tsipras, 40, assembled a new, streamlined cabinet dominated by members of his radical-left Syriza party, among them academics, labor activists and human rights advocates.
His most closely watched selection was his new finance minister, Yanis Varoufakis, an economist and avid blogger who has described Europe’s austerity policies as “fiscal waterboarding.”
European leaders began to send their congratulations on Tuesday after a mostly chilly initial response to the victory by Syriza, which is demanding a renegotiation of the tough terms of Europe’s 240 billion euro bailout of Greece.

Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany wished Mr. Tsipras “much strength and success,” if also noting that “you are taking office in a difficult time in which you face great responsibility.”
Mr. Tsipras quickly demonstrated that Europe must not treat Greece as a weak junior partner. His government on Tuesday denounced a European Council statement in which European leaders blamed Russia for the escalating violence in Ukraine and raised the prospect of new economic sanctions.
In its own statement, Mr. Tsipras’s office said the European statement had been issued “without the consent of Greece.” The prime minister also complained by telephone to Federica Mogherini, the European Union’s foreign policy chief.
Mr. Tsipras has been a sharp critic of European sanctions against Moscow and has displayed past good will toward Russia, a sentiment common among many Greeks.
President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia sent Mr. Tsipras a congratulatory telegram on Monday, the day he was sworn into office, while that same day, Mr. Tsipras met with the Russian ambassador in Athens.
Having a Greek prime minister with a strongly dissenting view on Russian sanctions could greatly complicate European Union foreign policy, which has benefited from a German-led unanimity among heads of state on confronting Mr. Putin.
Further sanctions cannot be approved without a unanimous vote from the leaders of European Union member nations, and Mr. Tsipras might find sympathetic partners in countries like Hungary or Slovakia, which dislike sanctions but generally go along.
Political analysts in Athens interpreted Mr. Tsipras’s early warning shots as clever political positioning, given that his government will soon open negotiations with the country’s European creditors over the punishing bailout provisions. Showing that he could complicate European goals in Ukraine may give him leverage in his economic negotiations, analysts said.
In a blog post, "A question of respect (or lack thereof)… – the Greek veto over Russia that never was," Varoufakis protests that the position of the new Greek government is not one that categorically opposes a new round of economic sanctions targeting Russia, but rather one that insists on its national sovereignty:
On the first day in our ministries, the power of the media to distort hit me again. The world’s press was full of reports on how the SYRIZA government’s first foreign policy ‘move’ was to veto fresh sanctions on Russia. Now, I am not qualified to speak on foreign affairs but, nonetheless, I must share this with you at a personal level. Our Foreign Minister, Nikos Kotzias, briefed us that on his first day at the job he heard in the news bulletins that the EU had approved new sanctions on Russia unanimously. The problem was that he, and the new Greek government, were never asked! So, clearly, the issue was not whether our new government agrees or not with fresh sanctions on Russia. The issue is whether our view can be taken for granted without even being told of what it is! From my perspective, even though (let me state it again) I am certainly not qualified to speak on foreign affairs, this is all about a question of respect for our national sovereignty.Could journalists the world over try to draw this important distinction between protesting our being neglected from protesting the sanctions themselves? Or is this too complicated?
Regardless of how you frame it, the point has been made. Syriza represents a huge potential impediment to business as usual.

John Helmer has a piece, "Russia's and Greece's Fraught New Relationship," on Naked Capitalism that doesn't mention the new sanctions veto and cautions against great expectations. In the recent past, Russia has viewed Greece through the lens of her oligarchs, oligarchs that Tsipras has promised to go after:
Against the plots and plans of the friends who are Greece’s enemies, there is also the experience of Greek history of the 1980s (my history, too). That shows how little the friend who is the enemy of Greece’s enemy is worth when Greece’s life and death are at stake. It is already clear that Putin, on the advice of Igor Sechin, Igor Shuvalov, and many others, has cast a strategic card on Turkey. The alternative card Greece has to offer isn’t obvious [What about a veto of another round of EU sanctions?], at least not to the Kremlin, and not yet.
So when the Americans, British, Germans, and Turks revive against Tsipras – as they are certain to do — the infowar and regime-change tactics used against Andreas Papandreou between 1982 and 1989, the Kremlin cannot be counted on to support Greece’s rebalancing of power. Twenty-six years ago, it was the Politburo’s conviction – spelled out in secret in February 1989 – that Papandreou was an American puppet who could not be relied upon. The Politburo was wrong about Andreas; it proved to be right about his son, George Papandreou (below), the fool and coward who has been dismissed in Sunday’s poll with a 2.7% vote — the first time in a century that no Papandreou is judged by Greek voters worthy to represent them in parliament.
The NATO script of the 1980s can already be read in the tweeting of the enemy press in London, Berlin, and Washington. Tsipras is unlikely to rely on public relations agents or on the ambassadors of his foreign ministry to fight back. More fundamental Greek tactics are being devised, including those which are still not revealed from the 1980s. It will take more than ceremonies at Greece’s cemeteries to remember the victims of German war crimes and Turkish genocide. The modern Δροσουλίτες (Droussolites) have much to remind, but not in public.
The Greek agenda for the Kremlin is already obvious – resumption of the food trade; rouble tourism; Cyprus; a new gas hub for southern Europe; NATO in Ukraine and the Balkans. For these negotiations it is also clear that Russian oligarchs and Gazprom fixers, and their Greek counterparts, who have dominated the relationship with Athens in recent years, are unacceptable to Tsipras. Officials like Sechin, Shuvalov, and the circle around Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev also showed themselves in their Orlov colours during the negotiations for the Cyprus bailout loan of 2013. By Athens they can be ignored.
Naked Capitalism has been consistently pessimistic (some would say realistic) about Syriza's chances to implement its agenda and roll back the neoliberal tide engulfing the planet. I remain optimistic. Granted, I have a tendency to be buoyed by any election win of a leftist party. But my optimism is fueled by the belief that the neoliberal status quo has a hit a wall. It rules by a duopoly, where both parties serve financial capital and not the overwhelming mass of voters, whose prescription, quantitative easing, to deal with the low growth and high unemployment endemic in the West doesn't work to solve those problems but works wonderfully to funnel more wealth to the super-rich.

Such a failed system can't be expected to operate unchecked indefinitely. To attempt keep it up and running is going to require extraordinary measures, such as the Koch brothers budgeting $900 million to elect Scott Walker POTUS. In the last few years in countries with a tradition of military coups (Egypt, Thailand) we have seen a return of the totalitarian police state with little protest from USG.

If one was wondering how Obama, who has consistently prodded Europe to pursue stimulus to rouse its ailing economy, would greet the new leftist government of Greece, wonder no more. Liz Alderman reports in "Tsipras’s Debt Plan Sends Athens Stock Market Sliding" that
The White House confirmed that Mr. Tsipras spoke by telephone on Wednesday with President Obama, who has generally been critical of Europe's austerity approach and supportive of more growth-oriented policies. But Mr. Obama has also recognized the need for structural reforms to accompany growth policies. 
The White House would describe the telephone conversation only in general terms. But a spokesman made clear that Mr. Obama favored a balanced strategy. 
“The United States looks forward to working closely with the new Greek government to build on recent structural reforms, which lay the groundwork for economic recovery,” Mark Stroh, a White House spokesman, said in a written statement. “We will also continue to discuss ways to boost demand and job creation with our European partners to help foster an environment that supports reforms in Greece and elsewhere in Europe.”
The structural reforms that Obama is alluding to are the social spending cuts, union busting and privatization, a.k.a., neoliberalism, the rejection of which gave Syriza its resounding victory at the polls on Sunday.

The fact that the market has responded so adversely -- "The Athens Stock Exchange, where billions of euros in value were wiped out during Greece’s election campaign, fell 9.2 percent on Wednesday after slumping around 11 percent on Tuesday. Shares in banks in Greece plummeted nearly 27 percent on Wednesday." -- is a good sign. It means that the money boys think Tsipras can deliver on his promises.

Proof of that, and an indication that Syriza is not going to kowtow to Obama administration calls for more "structural reforms," comes at the end of Alderman's story. She also provides a neat encapsulation of conventional neoliberal wisdom as voiced by a London banker:
Still, the sell-off, while drastic, was not far out of line with the kind of volatility that has characterized the Athens financial markets since the onset of the country’s crisis in 2010. Indeed, investors now tend to treat Greece more like a developing country than a member of the developed world. That volatility could die down as quickly as it arose should a suitable solution be found.
The most likely outcome, according to Holger Schmieding, chief economist at Berenberg Bank in London, is that “facing reality, Prime Minister Tsipras will eventually get real.”
“A patient Europe will offer face-saving compromises,” he said.
Still, Mr. Schmieding said in a research note, that in the meantime there could “be a rough ride for Greece.” And he warned that the odds of an “accidental” Greek exit from the eurozone, at 35 percent, were not insignificant.
Adding to the uncertainty was a report that Mr. Tsipras had basically frozen Greece’s privatization program, which had been a central demand of creditors in approving the country’s international bailouts. The troika had expected Greece to raise tens of billions of euros to pay its debts by privatizing state assets.
But the country’s new energy minister, Panagiotis Lafazanis, told Greek television that the government was immediately halting plans to privatize a public power company. It was also delaying the sale of a portion of Piraeus Port, one of the most strategically placed in the Mediterranean, to the Chinese state-owned company Cosco, which already owns half of Piraeus and had recently signed an agreement to start expanding cargo capacity on the other half of the port.
Mr. Tsipras said he was well aware of the high expectations for him in Greece, and the heavy responsibility his government shouldered. He suggested that the rousing messages of support he had received from leaders in numerous countries, from Russia to France to Spain, signaled that compromise was possible.
“The country is lifting up its head, assuming global significance, attracting international interest,” he added. “Greece is regaining its self-confidence and building alliances that will allow it to set its own agenda at the European table.” 
“We have no time to delay,” he added. “There is no room for mistakes.”
Tsipras has impressed me. He sees his project larger than just Greece. This bodes ill for business as usual within the European Union.

Monday, January 26, 2015

Syriza Wins, Now Comes the Hard Part

In the end there was nothing to be worried about. Greeks were deaf to the fear-mongering of New Democracy. Syriza won big. According to Liz Alderman and Jim Yardley, "After Victory at Greek Polls, Leftist Politician Forms Coalition Government":
With nearly all the votes counted, Mr. Tsipras’s Syriza party had won 36.3 percent of votes and secured 149 seats in the Greek Parliament, short of the 151 that he needed to secure an outright majority. 
New Democracy, led by the defeated incumbent prime minister, Antonis Samaras, took 27.8 percent of the votes. The neo-facist Golden Dawn party, whose popularity has increased amid economic hardship, won 6.3 percent of votes, coming in third. 
Syriza has become the first anti-austerity party to take power in a eurozone country and to shatter the two-party establishment that has dominated Greek politics for four decades.
(The former governing socialist party Pasok trailed fascist Golden Dawn. What does that tell you about the health of the political status quo?)

Alexis Tsipras, leader of the Coalition of the Radical Left (Syriza), promptly formed a governing coalition with Independent Greeks, a right-wing anti-austerity party that won 4.7 percent of the vote. This is a good sign, proof that Syriza has a plan and that plan is first and last based on renegotiation of the bloodsucking, murderous troika bailout agreement.

Greece in a nutshell is a laboratory of neoliberal orthodoxy. The idea being tested, that idea that austerity -- government spending cuts during a recession -- is stimulative, that the private sector will react positively (what Paul Krugman has termed the "confidence fairy") and invest more, has proven to be a spectacular failure. The Greek economy has shriveled and depression-level unemployment is now endemic. Greece requires ever-more loans to pay off the prior bailout loans when they come due. It is a sadistic fantasy to think that austerity will ever lead to a way out of this vicious circle.

Today Paul Krugman outlines all of this in "Ending Greece’s Nightmare":
The Greek government is collecting a substantially higher share of G.D.P. in taxes than it used to, but G.D.P. has fallen so quickly that the overall tax take is down. Furthermore, the plunge in G.D.P. has caused a key fiscal indicator, the ratio of debt to G.D.P., to keep rising even though debt growth has slowed and Greece received some modest debt relief in 2012.
Why were the original projections so wildly overoptimistic? As I said, because supposedly hardheaded officials were in reality engaged in fantasy economics. Both the European Commission and the European Central Bank decided to believe in the confidence fairy — that is, to claim that the direct job-destroying effects of spending cuts would be more than made up for by a surge in private-sector optimism. The I.M.F. was more cautious, but it nonetheless grossly underestimated the damage austerity would do. 
And here’s the thing: If the troika had been truly realistic, it would have acknowledged that it was demanding the impossible. Two years after the Greek program began, the I.M.F. looked for historical examples where Greek-type programs, attempts to pay down debt through austerity without major debt relief or inflation, had been successful. It didn’t find any. 
So now that Mr. Tsipras has won, and won big, European officials would be well advised to skip the lectures calling on him to act responsibly and to go along with their program. The fact is they have no credibility; the program they imposed on Greece never made sense. It had no chance of working. 
If anything, the problem with Syriza’s plans may be that they’re not radical enough. Debt relief and an easing of austerity would reduce the economic pain, but it’s doubtful whether they are sufficient to produce a strong recovery. On the other hand, it’s not clear what more any Greek government can do unless it’s prepared to abandon the euro, and the Greek public isn’t ready for that. 
Still, in calling for a major change, Mr. Tsipras is being far more realistic than officials who want the beatings to continue until morale improves. The rest of Europe should give him a chance to end his country’s nightmare.
It is good to see Krugman come down forcefully on the side of Syriza; he has shown such a pro-establishment, Russophobic fervor of late, I was a little worried.

But his feeling that Syriza's prescription will be too modest to produce the kind of recovery necessary to pull Greece out of its long-running recession is seconded over at Naked Capitalism. Yves Smith has a long post today, "How Much Success is Syriza Likely to Have in Ending Austerity?," that is a must-read if only to get a handle on the timeline Tsipras is dealing with: "The current Greek bailout expires at the end of February. Greece has €10 billion of debt repayments due over the summer and has €7 billion of aid that is on hold unless and until it negotiates a new bailout deal."

Smith goes on to explains that Finland is dead set against any extension, but that the Germans and the Eurogroup led by Jeroen Dijsselbloem will engage Syriza in lengthy negotiations, which will allow Tsipras to walk back the expectations of the Greek electorate, possibly by allowing for some increased social spending.

This sounds about right to me. The neoliberals who lead the troika are not going to budge significantly. The only thing that might get them moving in a direction away from austerity is if they believed Tsipras was sincere in moving Greece out of the eurozone. But that is not Syriza's nor Podemos' position. They want to remain part of the eurozone.

The only hope one is left with after reading Smith's piece is that Syriza's victory yesterday is the front end of anti-austerity/anti-neoliberal political train that is hurtling down the European track. In other words, a revolution in party politics:
While the election results in Greece have sent shockwaves through European technocratic elites and have rattled investors, it is not clear how successful Syriza will be in getting big enough changes implemented in Eurozone policies and its own bailout terms to end the humanitarian crisis, rather than just create the sort of bounce off the bottom growth that analysts like to depict as progress. Indeed, once you walk though the likely bargaining positions of the various parties, there is little reason to be optimistic on Syriza’s behalf. 
Bear in mind that Syriza has yet to make any official statement as to what its negotiating position with the Troika will be. Both presumed prime minister Alex Tsiprias and one of his finance minister candidates, Yanis Varoufakis, articulated bolder positions a year ago, when they were further from power. In the runup to to the election, Syriza has tried to depict itself as an anti-austerity, yet pro Eurozone party. As Jamie Galbraith described it, via Mark Thoma: 
"The Syriza program is a pro-European program. It is, and I think Europe and Europeans, people are committed to the European project, can consider it a great stroke of luck that there has arisen in Greece, and consequently, partly consequently and subsequently, in Spain, as well as in the present government of Italy, a pro-European set of parties, whose objective is change, constructive change, to make the European project viable."
The nut of that problem, as we will see, is that while may be a very estimable-sounding position, it may not be as pragmatic as it appears. Greece likely has better odds of winning concessions if it is less reasonable, since the Germans and the even more implacable Fins are convinced that the periphery countries are immoral beggars who deserve to be ground into the dust if they cannot or will not pay their debts. Greece is unlikely to be able to shake the perception in the North that they have the upper hand and can force Greece to heel, giving at most only fairly minor concessions. 
Greece’s best hope is if it there is an upsurge in popularity of other anti-austerity and anti-Eurozone parties in the rest of Europe. And they are more likely to rally support in the rest of the Eurozone if they take bold positions rather than careful, studied ones. And even then, that may not be enough for them to resolve the deep-seated problems they face. It isn’t simply that they face a very difficult challenge politically vis-a-vis the Troika, but that even if they get most of what they want, their policies do not look likely to generate enough demand to pull Greece out of its ditch.
Now comes the hard part, a message that Pablo Iglesias, leader of Spain's surging anti-austerity Podemos, delivered in a stirring speech to an election rally in Athens on Thursday:
Winning the elections is far from winning power. That’s why we must bring everyone who is committed to change and decency together around our shared task, which is nothing more than turning the Universal Declaration of Human Rights into a manual for government. Our aim today, unfortunately, is not the withering away of the state, or the disappearance of prisons, or that Earth become a paradise. But we do aspire, as I said, to make it so that all children go to public schools clean and well-fed; that all the elderly receive a pension and be taken care of in the best hospitals; that any young person—independently of who their parents are—be able to go to college; that nobody have their heat turned off in the winter because they can’t pay their bill; that no bank be allowed to leave a family in the street without alternative housing; that everyone be able to work in decent conditions without having to accept shameful wages; that the production of information in newspapers and on television not be a privilege of multi-millionaires; that a country not have to kneel down before foreign speculators. In one word: that a society be able to provide the basic material conditions that make dignity and happiness possible.
These modest objectives that today seem so radical simply represent democracy. Tomorrow is ours, brothers and sisters!
I am hopeful that we are now at the beginning of something new and transformative, if only because the dominant neoliberal paradigm is so bankrupt.