Showing posts with label Jeroen Dijsselbloem. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jeroen Dijsselbloem. Show all posts

Sunday, July 12, 2015

Greek Capitulation Not Good Enough for Schäuble & Co. Grexit Unavoidable

Yves Smith for all the arrows she has absorbed for her pessimism about the bargaining positions of both Greece and her creditors has for the must part been reliably on the money. This morning she writes that "A Grexit Looks Almost Inescapable":
Despite my generally dour outlook, I never thought we’d arrive at the insane juncture we are at now, that of a Grexit being all but baked in. This would be a catastrophic outcome, most of all for the Greek 99%. If a Grexit comes to pass, it should deservedly blacken the names of everyone involved, most of all Merkel, whose incrementalism meant that all of the unresolved contradictions of the Eurozone produced intensifying pressure on its fault lines, and Greece proved to be the breaking point. But as we’ll see soon, her finance minister Wolfgang Schauble would also get a particularly large badge of dishonor. 
You don’t need to know much to know that the odds of Greece escaping a Grezit are becoming vanishingly small as time progresses, and there is perilously little time left. And mind you, this sorry trajectory is occurring even after the Greek government prostrated itself and offered to meet even more stringent conditions than its voters overwhelmingly rejected in a referendum less than a week ago.
The big development is that last night's meeting of eurozone finance ministers adjourned minus any resolution. As James Kanter reports in "Meeting on Greece Debt Breaks Up With No Deal" the hardliners -- Germany, Finland, Slovakia, et al. -- don't believe that Greece will implement its latest austerity proposal:
Despite Greece’s capitulation on those terms, many countries came into this weekend’s final round of negotiations skeptical of the Tsipras government’s commitment to seeing through the changes and putting his country on firmer financial footing — and weary of the constant brinkmanship that has characterized the months of negotiations over Greece’s latest crisis.
Instead of working through the night to hammer out a statement on requirements for Greece, as had been expected, the meeting was suddenly called off shortly before midnight, and ministers left without even holding a formal news conference.
“The issue of credibility and trust was discussed, and also of course the financial issues involved,” Jeroen Dijsselbloem of the Netherlands, the head of the so-called Eurogroup of ministers, told reporters. “It is still very difficult. but work is still in progress,” he said, adding that discussions would continue later Sunday morning.
From the start, it was clear that Mr. Tsipras’s gambit had not entirely won over Germany and other countries that have been skeptical about giving a new round of loans to Greece after years in which successive governments in Athens have struggled to carry out changes that creditors have demanded as a condition of the bailouts.
“We will have exceptionally difficult negotiations,” Wolfgang Schäuble, the hard-nosed German finance minister, said on Saturday before the meeting. “We won’t be able to rely on promises.”
His prediction proved accurate, as he and fellow ministers wrangled with little apparent progress, seeking more assurances from Greece that it was committed to changing its ways, and weighing the desires of France and Italy for a deal against the more skeptical stance of Germany and the possibility of outright opposition from Finland.
What Schäuble did do in the 11th hour was forward a proposal demanding that Greece essentially be placed in receivership and banned from the euro for five years. According to The Guardian's Ian Traynor in "Greece nears euro exit as bailout talks break up without agreement," who Yves Smith quotes at length in an update to her post,
With Greece on the edge of financial and social implosion, eurozone finance ministers met to decide on the country’s fate and on what to do about its debt crisis, after experts from the troika of creditors said that new fiscal rigour proposals from Athens were good enough to form “the basis for negotiations”.
But the German finance minister, Wolfgang Schäuble, dismissed that view, supported by a number of northern and eastern European states. “These proposals cannot build the basis for a completely new, three-year [bailout] programme, as requested by Greece,” said a German finance ministry paper. It called for Greece to be expelled from the eurozone for a minimum of five years and demanded that the Greek government transfer €50bn of state assets to an outside agency for sell-off.
Timo Soini, the nationalist True Finns leader, meanwhile, threatened to bring down the government in Helsinki if Alex Stubb, the finance minister, agreed to a new bailout for Greece. Stubb apparently came to the crunch meeting on a new bailout without a mandate to agree one.
“The hawks are very vocal,” said an EU diplomat. “It’s very tough.” Berlin also demanded stronger and more intrusive powers for outside monitors to police the economic and fiscal reforms that Alexis Tsipras, the leftist Greek prime minister, would need to commit to to secure the new bailout.
Saturday night’s talks were not to agree on a third bailout, but were negotiations on whether to launch more talks on Greece’s third rescue package in five years. The ministers faced formidable problems, said Schäuble, who argued debt relief for Greece, broadly seen as essential, was banned by the EU treaties: “Athens’s proposals are far from sufficient. The funding gaps are way beyond anything we’ve seen so far,” he said.
The hard line was echoed by Peter Kazimir, finance minister of Slovakia, who said that new austerity measures tabled by Athens were already past their sell-by date.
The eurozone has been united for five months in the negotiations with Tsipras, but with the stakes rising greatly in the last 10 days, major divisions have surfaced, with the French working tirelessly to save Greece and the hardliners now pushing Greece’s expulsion for the first time openly.
The European commission and the European Central Bank issued dire warnings that a failure to grant Greece new rescue funds of up to €78bn would put the country on a trajectory of complete banking and financial collapse.
The widening gulf between eurozone hawks and doves paves the way for an acrimonious summit on Sunday, with France and Italy lining up against Germany and the northern and eastern Europeans. Matteo Renzi, the Italian prime minister, is expected to tell chancellor Angela Merkel that enough is enough and that Greece should not have to put up with any more humiliation.
Merkel is under intense pressure from the Americans not to “lose” Greece and is worried about her own legacy. But Greece fatigue is becoming endemic in Germany, and she faces growing unrest in her party ranks where Schäuble’s hard line is popular. She was said to have endorsed Schäuble’s tough position.
Whether the U.S. can work its will once again on a reluctant Merkel, as it did in the case of Russian sanctions and the whole smorgasbord of riots, a coup and the downing of the MH17 passenger jet, seems a long shot to me.

The Obama administration has not been particularly assertive about securing an amicable resolution to the Greek debt crisis. Getting the IMF to release its report saying Greece's debt load was unsustainable and that debt relief must be considered was helpful to Syriza in the run up to last Sunday's referendum, but it was far from the kind of full-court press trotted out to get the EU to embrace sanctions on Russia.

The U.S. is allowed to run roughshod over Europe when it comes to NATO force projection. But when the question is Germany's economic hegemony over the continent, Uncle Sam apparently has to wear velvet slippers.

Schäuble's 11th-hour proposal, one that Traynor says Merkel has signed off on, at least clarifies the root of Germany's incessant demands for austerity. It is not about a belief that austerity will lead to growth; that has been debunked long ago. It is about taking possession of Greece lock, stock, and barrel. Likely in the private moments of hardliners among the Finns, Germans and Slovaks are thoughts about Greek women. Why not put the young fertile ones on the auction block too?

Tuesday, July 7, 2015

Deadlines: Greek Debt Negotiations & P5+1 Talks

So we're back to deadline watch in the Greek debt drama. The new make-or-break deadline we're supposed to stay focused on is July 20. That is when 3.5 billion euros that Greece owes to the European Central Bank comes due. If Greece fails to make repayment by July 20, the ECB will be hard pressed to find a way around cutting off liquidity to already cash-strapped Greek banks.

James Kanter publishes a helpful story this morning, "Greece Expected to Offer Proposals as Eurozone Leaders Prepare to Meet," that precedes yet another emergency summit of eurozone leaders in Brussels today. Kanter tilts towards the neoliberal consensus. So his writing is a helpful prism to understand how the U.S./EU elite view recalcitrant Greece:
BRUSSELS — The Greek government was expected to make proposals to eurozone leaders on Tuesday to support its battered economy and keep the country in the single currency area, as Athens and its creditors resume their struggle over an elusive solution to Greece’s long-running economic crisis. 
But a quick fix for Athens looked extremely difficult to achieve. The stakes were rising on Tuesday ahead of the latest emergency summit meeting of European leaders. None of them wants to take the blame for a possible sudden, chaotic departure from the eurozone by Greece. That means that all sides could agree to keep talking even as the crisis reaches new levels of intensity, and even as Greece hurtles toward a deadline — a payment of 3.5 billion euros, or about $3.9 billion, to the European Central Bank on July 20 — that most observers think it cannot miss without leaving the eurozone.
The Eurogroup of finance ministers is scheduled to convene at 1 p.m. in Brussels, followed by an emergency summit meeting of the 19 leaders of eurozone countries at 7 p.m. that is expected to include Mario Draghi, the president of the European Central Bank, and Jeroen Dijsselbloem, the president of the Eurogroup.
*** 
A failure to make good on the July 20 bailout payment to the European Central Bank would make it almost inevitable that Greece would have to cut a lifeline for the country’s cash-drained banks. And that could force the country to print a parallel currency that would hasten its departure from the currency bloc. 
That prospect could add pressure on the Greeks this week to commit to a number of short-term changes for bridge financing to avoid defaulting on the European Central Bank, and then conclude a wider program, with debt relief, later in the year. 
But one analyst emphasized on Tuesday that the track record of the government in Athens would make it extremely difficult to take any of its commitments at face value. 
“It remains very unclear whether the Greek government is really trying to avoid an exit from the euro area, or whether it only wants to avoid being held responsible for it by its domestic public opinion,” said Nicolas Véron, a senior fellow at Bruegel, a research organization in Brussels.
I used to be of the opinion that what Tsipras was up to was transforming consciousness in Greece -- enlightening the Greek voter -- to accept the reintroduction of the drachma. But I no longer believe that. I think that Syriza, true to what Tsipras and Varoufakis have long said in public, has no intention of leaving the eurozone. The strategy of Tsipras has been to wear down the members of the troika, and in this he has been successful. France has moved away somewhat from Germany. The IMF has broken with other members of the troika and issued a report declaring Greece's debt load unsustainable.

The problem for Tsipras is that despite the landslide "Oxi" win, the July 20 ECB repayment deadline looms large. For the hardliners in the Eurogroup who want to collapse Greek banks and be done with it, two weeks is a short time to wait. There is no need for Schauble and Dijsselbloem to offer any concessions, particularly on debt forgiveness. It appears that Tsipras will run out of time and no cavalry will ride over the hill to the rescue.

And not one but two deadlines have now been breached in the P5+1 talks in Vienna: first, the June 30 deadline, and today's July 7 deadline. The significant one for Kerry and Obama is Thursday July 9. If no agreement is reached with Iran on its nuclear program in two days then the U.S. Congress will get an additional 30 days to skewer the agreement. USG scribe Michael Gordon reports in "Iran Nuclear Talks Are Extended Once Again":
VIENNA — The talks to complete a landmark accord limiting Iran’s nuclear program have been extended for several days after negotiators acknowledged that they would be unable to meet a Tuesday deadline.
To give negotiators more time to pursue a final accord, the diplomats agreed to extend through Friday an interim nuclear accord called the Joint Plan of Action. That interim agreement, which had been set to expire on Tuesday, freezes much of Iran’s nuclear program in return for modest sanctions relief.
“We are continuing to negotiate for the next couple of days,” Federica Mogherini, the foreign policy chief for the European Union, told reporters here.
This is the second time the talks have been extended since Secretary of State John Kerry arrived here in late June. The original goal was to complete a final accord by June 30.
Ms. Mogherini said that the negotiations had entered “a difficult and sensitive” phase, but she did not discuss the remaining issues.
The unresolved issues in recent days have included what limits would be placed on the development of more efficient types of centrifuges after the first decade of an accord, what steps would be taken to address suspicions about Iran’s past nuclear activities, and the timeline for removing sanctions.
The Obama administration hoped to finish the accord by Thursday, so that it could be submitted to Congress for a 30-day review. If the agreement is finished this summer, the duration of the review period will double.
I don't see Obama walking away from the table. He wants an agreement, not only for his "legacy"
but for the future electoral viability of the Democratic Party. Not much is made of it in the media, but the Democrats' nominal association with a less bellicose foreign-policy perspective is a huge vote-getting advantage. A Democratic administration does not want to squander this.

But give the media monopoly and a Saudi- and Israeli-dominated Congress two months to inveigh and fear-monger, and the chances are high any agreement will be scuttled, which puts the feckless Obama in the difficult position of having to veto a Congressional override to protect his "legacy" agreement. 

It is hard to say at this point which is a stronger character trait in Obama: his desire to go-along-to-get-along or his lust to be inscribed in the history books. Probably the latter. So maybe there is hope for a Iranian nuclear accord after all.

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Russia Moves to Quickly Win New Cold War

To get a sense of what Greece is up against in trying to resist the troika's austerity diktats read the Reuters piece by Hugo Dixon, "Greece Must Walk the Talk, and Soon." Saying that finance minister Yanis Varoufakis has come up with the 458 million euros to meet an April 9 IMF deadline, Dixon opines:
Athens has scraped together enough cash to meet the I.M.F. payment, in part by extracting liquidity from quasi state entities. However, the left-wing government has pretty much exhausted its techniques for squeezing blood from a stone. Meanwhile, it has largely wasted two and a half months in office by lecturing its creditors, sending out mixed messages about its willingness to default and coming up with amateurish overhaul plans.

Now the government needs to get serious and — unless Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras is really willing to default — impose vicious capital controls and exit the euro. 
Athens’s eurozone creditors are still hanging tough. Although they do not want Greece to enter a spiral of self-destruction and are worried about the fallout it if does, they do not trust what the government says. As a result, the creditors rightly want to see some meaningful actions before they lend Greece more money. 
Mr. Tsipras needs to show he means business, by suffering some political cost at home as a result of implementing unpopular measures. Otherwise, there is a risk that the government will take the cash, continue to speak with a forked tongue and still default in June if it can’t get a new long-term deal to its liking.
This is the dominant thinking within the troika: Syriza-led Greece is a mendacious, troublesome political upstart that needs to be made an example of, that needs to be broken publicly on the wheel so every Spanish voter looking to support Podemos or Mick pining for Sinn Féin will think twice before questioning the status quo.

The troika's version of the domino theory for the New Cold War that Washington D.C. explicitly launched last year in Kiev with the coup of Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovich actually got its start a year earlier with eurogroup chief Jeroen Dijsselbloem's bail-in scheme for Cyprus. At the time Russia did not take kindly to the bail in, interpreting it as a direct attack on her large depositors in Cyprus.

But as Andrew Higgins reports in "Waving Cash, Putin Sows E.U. Divisions in an Effort to Break Sanctions" all is now forgiven:
NICOSIA, Cyprus — When Cyprus seized hundreds of millions of dollars from bank depositors, many of them Russians, as part of an internationally brokered deal two years ago to rescue its collapsing financial system, the Russian leader, Vladimir V. Putin, denounced the move as “dangerous” and “unfair,” warning of a sharp chill in relations. 
But Mr. Putin was all smiles recently when he received Cyprus’s president, Nicos Anastasiades, in Moscow. He hailed relations with the Mediterranean nation as “always being truly friendly and mutually beneficial” and agreed to extend — on greatly improved terms for Cyprus — a $2.5 billion Russian loan.
The shift from fury to declarations of eternal friendship displayed Mr. Putin’s well-known flair for tactical back flips. But it also showed his unbending determination to break out of sanctions imposed on Russia by the United States and the European Union for Moscow’s annexation of Crimea and support for armed rebels in eastern Ukraine.
Mr. Putin has methodically targeted, through charm, cash, and the fanning of historical and ideological embers, the European Union’s weakest links in a campaign to assert influence in some of Europe’s most troubled corners. One clear goal is to break fragile Western unity over the conflict in Ukraine.
On Wednesday, Greece’s new left-wing prime minister, Alexis Tsipras, will be the next to visit Moscow. Ahead of the trip, Mr. Tsipras declared himself opposed to sanctions on Russia, describing them as a “dead-end policy.”
On Sunday, Mr. Putin’s efforts to peel away supporters from the European Union opened a new rift, after the United States ambassador in Prague criticized a decision by the president of the Czech Republic, Milos Zeman, to attend a military parade in Moscow on May 9. And in February, Mr. Putin visited Hungary, the European Union’s autocratic backslider, peddling economic deals.
Russia has so far been unable to turn such hand-holding into something more concrete against sanctions that require the approval of all 28 European Union members. But pressure for a rupture is building.
The rupture might be supplied by Poroshenko's obvious backsliding on the Mink 2.0 ceasefire. As David Herszenhorn reports in "Ukrainian Leader Is Open to a Vote on Regional Power":
MOSCOW — President Petro O. Poroshenko of Ukraine on Monday denounced calls for “federalization” of the country, which Russia has endorsed as a way of granting political autonomy to the areas of eastern Ukraine controlled by pro-Russian separatists.
Establishing greater local autonomy and governmental authority is widely viewed as crucial to settling the nearly yearlong war in the eastern regions of Donetsk and Luhansk, and it was a central plank in a cease-fire accord signed in February. But there are fierce disagreements over how to shape those powers, and how far they would extend.
Speaking at the first meeting of a commission charged with developing amendments to the Ukrainian Constitution, Mr. Poroshenko described federalization as tantamount to breaking apart the country, and said he was so certain Ukrainians would reject the idea that he was willing to put it to a national referendum.
“Why do I dwell in great detail on the idea of federalization?” Mr. Poroshenko said. “Because it is like an infection, a biological weapon, which is being imposed on Ukraine from abroad. Its bacteria are trying to infect Ukraine and destroy our unity.”
Leaders of the self-declared people’s republics in Donetsk and Luhansk have complained bitterly in recent weeks that Mr. Poroshenko and other officials in Kiev, including members of Parliament, were refusing to take the necessary steps to carry out the political provisions in the cease-fire agreement, which was signed in Minsk, Belarus.
***
. . . Separatist leaders noted that they had not been invited to join the commission on constitutional changes, and they took issue with Mr. Poroshenko’s remarks, including his insistence that Ukraine would remain a “unitary state” and his declaration that Ukrainian would remain the country’s only official language.
“These things are absolutely unacceptable,” Andrei Purgin, head of the Donetsk People’s Republic, told the Interfax news agency. “Everything they now say and do contradicts the Minsk agreements that took so much work to achieve.”
As for the commission and the constitutional amendment process, Mr. Purgin told Interfax: “We did not receive any invitations. We don’t have any representatives there.”
I have learned not to underestimate the obedience of the French and Germans when it comes to complying with U.S. orders, but this abrogation of Minsk 2.0 by the junta in Kiev seems impossible to defend. France, Germany, Poland, etc., might fall into the neocon line but it will be hard to secure the unanimity of all 28 EU members for increased Russian sanctions when fighting resumes in Donbass.

That is why it seems like a slam dunk that Putin will extend an offer of financial assistance to Alexis Tsipras when he visits Moscow tomorrow. If favorable terms can be found to extend a $2.5 billion loan to Cyprus, why not the bigger, politically far more important Greece?

Higgins ends his story on Russian rapprochement with Cyprus explaining the result of Dijsselbloem's bail-in. It backfired:
Vasilis Zertalis, the head of Prospectacy, a financial service company, described Cyprus as a “small piece on a big chessboard.” Europe, he said, tried to advance its own position during the 2013 banking crisis by seeking to end Cyprus’s role as a haven for Russian money. 
“They wanted to scare the Russians away,” he said. “But the money that left was from Britain, from other European countries and from America.” 
Ordinary Cypriots and politicians, he said, “all gave up on the European Union” because of the harsh bailout terms in 2013 and “know that the United States will never take a stand against Turkey.” 
“So,” he said, “the only allies Cyprus really has are Russia and maybe China.”
Putin has an opportunity to reach back into the slipstream of time and make a move that Stalin should have made. Stalin should have aided Greece instead of letting the British Empire re-install the monarchy there, setting the stage for the decades-long Cold War.

The choice should be clear now for Tsipras. The heads of the EU want to crush Syriza. I say he has no other choice at this point. He must accept Russia's offer of financial aid.

Tuesday, March 10, 2015

A Few Rays of Possible Sunshine, Greece & Ferguson, in a Darkening Sky

A few rays of sunshine were evident last week. It became apparent that eurozone finance ministers led by Jeroen Dijsselbloem were not completely successful in vanquishing the Syriza-led Greek government. Greece's finance minister, Yanis Varoufakis, continues to insist he has not caved in on Syriza's campaign pledges to roll back troika-dictated austerity. Tomorrow, technical talks begin between Greece and the troika (James Kanter and Niki Kitsantonis, "Greece’s Tense Talks With Its Creditors Escalate to the Next Phase"). The troika says no money will be released until Greece makes good on implementing structural adjustment. Greece needs to makes payments on or refinance €6 billion this month. It is make or break time. Varoufakis got himself into some trouble when he suggested a referendum might be a possible way out of the impasse with the troika:
In an interview with the Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera on Saturday, Mr. Varoufakis said Greece could call elections or a referendum in the event that its proposed overhauls are rejected by international creditors. As the Greek news media feverishly speculated over the weekend about a possible referendum on the country’s membership in the eurozone, the government accused the newspaper of distorting the minister’s comments, saying he had not suggested Greece would hold a referendum on the euro but on the country’s economic program and fiscal policy. 
Panos Kammenos, Mr. Tsipras’s junior coalition partner and the defense minister, also suggested on Saturday that a referendum could be an option. 
Antonis Samaras, the former prime minister, on Sunday rejected a potential referendum as a “very bad development,” saying it would allow the government to shirk its responsibilities. The criticism continued on Monday with central members of Mr. Samaras’s conservative party describing Mr. Varoufakis as “dangerous” because of both the referendum idea and his proposal to employ Greeks and tourists as undercover agents to bolster a tax evasion crackdown. 
Some officials of the Syriza-led government also expressed reservations about a referendum, which the prominent legislator Alexis Mitropoulos described as “naïve and thoughtless.” 
At his news conference late on Monday, Mr. Varoufakis denounced the way his comments had been presented in Corriere della Serra as part of a “process of misinformation.” Mr. Varoufakis said any reference that he made to a referendum had been entirely “hypothetical” because he was referring to the improbable circumstance that European lenders rejected all of Greece’s proposed reforms. 
Opinion polls consistently indicate that most Greeks want the country to remain in the eurozone, but a majority continue to back the government’s tough stance against creditors.
Varoufakis likely floated the idea of a referendum to Corriere della Sera in the hopes of creating a little leverage in the upcoming negotiations with the troika. But when he backtracked it made him look unprepared and vacillating.

The outcome Jeroen Dijsselbloem wants to see is Syriza implementing all the austerity diktats -- pension cuts, privatization, tearing up labor agreements -- as the troika dribbles out the cash in small allotments. This Varoufakis will not do. I am still confident of this. So some sort of rupture is coming, hopefully, by the end of this week. The troika is certain it can break Syriza. I think a referendum is a fine idea.

The second ray of sunshine visible last week was the Department of Justice report on the Ferguson Police Department in the wake of the Mike Brown shooting last summer. The DOJ lays out how Jim Crow works nowadays. "Driving while black" is a chief income source that suburban municipalities like Ferguson rely on to balance their books.

The first scalp of that report was raised yesterday (Eli Yokley and John Eligon, "Missouri Court Assigns a State Judge to Handle Ferguson Cases") when it was announced by the Missouri Supreme Court that the Missouri Court of Appeals would take over Ferguson's municipal court and "current municipal judge, Ronald J. Brockmeyer, who was repeatedly cited in the Justice Department report for abusive practices, announced his resignation after holding the position for more than a decade."

The problem is that what happened to Ferguson needs to happen in municipalities throughout the United States, and there is no indication that this is in the offing.

In fact, there is every indication that we are at the "creative destruction" tipping point in the United States. In by far the best story I read this morning -- the best, but easily the most depressing -- is Monica Davey's "Unions Suffer Latest Defeat in Midwest With Signing of Wisconsin Measure."

In describing Scott Walker's "shot heard 'round the world" declaration for a 2016 White House run, the Wisconsin governor presiding over the creation of a new right-to-work law in his state, Davey lines out the the present political history of the United States, the death of its unions, and the projected path forward for American-style neoliberalism -- full on cannibalization.

Key to Davey's synopsis of present political history is the GOP landslide of 2010 (At that time a national party that just two years earlier was thoroughly disgraced and in free fall successfully recreated itself by lurching hard to the right with its Tea Party re-branding, the core of which is white supremacy):
Central to the new momentum behind the laws were sweeping Republican victories in state elections in 2010, when the party got full control — in the chambers and the governor’s office — of states that included Wisconsin, Michigan and Indiana. Republicans made more gains in 2014, now controlling 68 of the 98 chambers around the country and the most state legislative seats since 1920. But it was the victories in 2010 that set off a new flood of right-to-work legislation in the Midwest, which had rarely seen it.
Soon after taking office, Mr. Walker pressed for a bill that cut collective bargaining for most public sector workers and removed requirements that they pay fees if they chose not to join unions that represented them. Republicans elsewhere followed suit, but not all of those measures flew through. Ohio, where Republicans had taken sole control of state government, passed a measure limiting collective bargaining, but it was rejected months later in a statewide ballot measure. 
Then, for right-to-work advocates, there came an even more memorable turning point: In November 2012, voters in Indiana (where a law was repealed in the 1960s) re-elected Republican legislative majorities even after labor leaders pledged to defeat them for passing a right-to-work law earlier in the year. On the same election night, voters in Michigan rejected a labor-backed ballot measure to enshrine collective bargaining rights in the State Constitution. 
“The combination sent a clear message to elected officials in the region: You can end forced dues by passing right-to-work, and voters will reward you for it,” said Patrick Semmens, a spokesman for the National Right to Work Committee, who keeps a copy of The Indianapolis Star outside his office from the day after the law passed there.
A month after the 2012 election, the Republican-held Legislature in Michigan, a cradle of the American labor movement, passed a right-to-work measure, which was promptly signed by Gov. Rick Snyder, a Republican who had said the matter was not on his agenda. 
Lee Saunders, the president of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, called it “a concerted effort by the folks who have a lot of wealth and power to get more wealth and power.” 
“They’ve had these plans a long time, and now they’ve come to fruition,” he said.
Now the path forward is quite clear: Right to work anywhere and everywhere. If you don't control the state legislature or the governor's office, pass it at the county level:
Battles over union fees are also emerging in other states. Republican legislators in Missouri and New Mexico are weighing similar measures. In Kentucky, where a split Legislature and a Democratic governor pose obstacles to a statewide bill, leaders in more than a dozen counties have approved or are weighing measures, officials there said on Saturday, and efforts in six other counties are awaiting final approval.
And in Illinois, a long-held Democratic territory with Democratic supermajorities in the legislature, the new Republican governor, Bruce Rauner, announced an executive order barring state workers who opt out of unions from being forced to pay fees based on a constitutional argument, offering a new model for states where split partisan politics have slowed right-to-work policies. 
Federal law already permits workers not to join unions. But these laws go further, permitting workers to not pay fees to them. Unions argue that the fees are fair for nonunion members who still benefit from the contracts they negotiate, and that without a requirement, their membership, financial support and very existence are threatened.
And where is the leadership of the international unions? Holed up in executive suites in Washington D.C. living well-remunerated lives of great privilege. Where is the plan to fight back? Don't hold your breath. There isn't one.

Tuesday, February 24, 2015

Syriza's About-Face and Why We Should Stomach It

Yesterday, a Monday back at work to begin another week in a series of weeks that will lead eventually to May and Memorial Day, the sense of hopelessness and fatigue was palpable. I kept checking for signs of life from Brussels, wishing that Syriza had discovered a path forward to foil the eurogroup of finance ministers and their neoliberal austerity.

But no such luck was mine. The reporting was sparse and eventually, I think it was late morning Pacific Standard Time, it was reported that Greece would submit her proposals Tuesday morning, today.

First reports (James Kanter and Niki Kitsantonis, "European Lenders to Review Greece Overhaul Plan") this morning are not encouraging:
Jeroen Dijsselbloem, the head of the Eurogroup of finance ministers, that he could not yet give a “positive assessment” of the list submitted by Athens, as the overhauls first needed to be reviewed for their effects on the Greek budget. A conference call among the 19 finance minister of the Eurogroup was set for Tuesday afternoon.
“I think they are serious,” Mr. Dijsselbloem, referring to the attitude of the government in Athens, told lawmakers on an influential economics committee at the European Parliament during scheduled testimony on Tuesday.
Among the overhauls are plans to improve management of the national budget, and to enact changes to Greece’s taxation system, including changes to the collection of sales taxes “with a view to limiting exemptions while eliminating unreasonable discounts,” according to a letter that Yanis Varoufakis, the Greek finance minister, submitted to Mr. Dijsselbloem.
The government also committed not to reverse existing privatization plans and said it would review planned sell-offs with a focus on bolstering “the state’s long-term benefits.”
In addition to streamlining the public sector, the government will review public spending at every level and will modernize the pension system in an effort to end “an excessive rate of early retirements.”
The country still plans to raise the minimum wage, one of the government’s pre-election promises, but pledges to do so in a way that safeguards competitiveness, the letter said.
The opportunity for Greece to submit the proposals was one of the few concrete concessions it won in an accord reached with its creditors late on Friday in Brussels. That accord brought to an end the bitter standoff that began when Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras pledged to redraw or scrap the bailout agreement after he came to power in January.
European and Greek officials spent much of Monday exchanging drafts of the proposals to pare back austerity measures while ensuring that Greece can still meet fiscal obligations.
The government of Mr. Tsipras had an opportunity to put its “political stamp” on a bailout plan if it respected budget targets, Mr. Dijsselbloem told the parliamentary committee.
The deal to extend the country’s bailout program with European creditors by four months is subject to the approval of the Greek Parliament, where members of Mr. Tsipras’s radical-left Syriza party have called the plan a capitulation after the party’s anti-austerity campaign promises.
Also on the list submitted by Mr. Varoufakis are plans to crack down on the smuggling of fuel and tobacco, which cost the Greek economy billions of euros a year, to address tax arrears and nonperforming bank loans, and to support struggling homeowners who are unable to meet their mortgage payments.
The overhauls will also address what Syriza has described as Greece’s “humanitarian crisis,” referring to the need for food stamps and other assistance to poor families, but Athens said the measures would be mostly “nonpecuniary” and would have “no negative fiscal effect.”
You will recall shortly after Syriza's victory at the end of January the consensus opinion was that Tsipras would be unable to crack the troika's austerity diktats; that the best Greece could hope for was a few scraps of social-welfare spending tossed from the master's table. Then Syriza's finance minister Yanis Varoufakis went on the offensive against the cruel fiction of neoliberal austerity and the fantasy that governments can cut their way to growth. Commentators zipped their lips. Maybe little Greece was going to shake up the neoliberal consensus.

Well, it appears the original conventional wisdom is going to be proven true.

The commitments to existing privatization plans and streamlining the public sector (highlighted in red in the Kanter and Kitsantonis story above) are truly ominous and confirm the view that Tsipras and Varoufakis have indeed performed an about-face. In a post yesterday, "Eurogroup to Review Greek Reform Proposals; Meeting Set for Tuesday (Updated)," Yves Smith is troubled by the Greek proposal's commitment to EU "best practices" on labor:
“EU best practices” on labor is very disconcerting, since it implies a forced embrace of “labor flexibility” as in further reduction of labor protections and bargaining rights. That would seem to be inconsistent with earlier reports, including a government announcement, that Greece was seeking an increase in the minimum wage. Perhaps that section is more of a mixed bag than the headline for that section suggests.
After the work day was done yesterday, a co-worker, the only one who really pays attention to the news, offered me a ride to the train station. I tried to explain why I felt that even though it would be damaging to us -- because our retirement is in the form of a 401(a) defined contribution pension plan that floats along the waves of the market, and the markets would most likely freak out in a bearish direction upon Greece's leaving the eurozone -- and damaging to the citizens of Greece I wanted to see the eurozone come tumbling down.

I don't think I was very articulate. What I said was something to the effect that if the eurozone cracks then U.S. hegemony is diminished. For instance, the ability of the United States to stampede the EU into Cold War 2.0 by sanctioning Russia becomes much more difficult. And this has to be considered a desirable outcome. No one wants to be incinerated in a nuclear war.

But is this true? If Greece is forced to leave the eurozone -- which I don' think is going to happen, unless Syriza MPs revolt -- does this necessarily mean Greece leaves the European Union? I don't think it does. But even if it does, and Greece is cast out entirely from all European institutions, how does this lessen U.S. foreign policy leverage on the remaining European Union states? It doesn't.

Rather, Syriza can exert more influence, even if only as a "fly in the ointment," if Tsipras and Varoufakis keep Greece in the eurozone and the EU. The EU operates by consensus. Greece can block the TTIP and future Russian sanctions, two big pieces of juicy fruit.

For a not very effective apologia of Syriza's about-face there is Mike Whitney's "Varoufakis Keeps Greece in the Eurozone, by its Fingernails: A Valiant Effort." Whitney brings up an argument I have seen elsewhere: that Varoufakis' negotiations with the eurogroup will be enormously successful so long as he is able to keep the Greek primary surplus target frozen at 1.5 percent:
The new deal also allows Greece to decide its own reform package rather than the troika dictating what government expenses to cut or which publicly owned assets to sell.  Here’s another excerpt from Haring’s post:   “Most important change of the whole document: Addition of 'The institutions will, for the 2015 primary surplus target, take the economic circumstances in 2015 into account.' Excessive, self-defeating austerity is off.  Only the target for 2015 is mentioned, because everything further out would have to be part of a new arrangement, still to be negotiated.”
So Varoufakis has achieved his goal of reducing austerity. Not only is there greater flexibility operationally but, also, Greece will control the levers of decision-making  in the “field of tax policy, privatisation, labour market reforms, financial sector, and pensions”. Naturally, the lower the primary surplus, the more fiscal stimulus is available for economic growth. (Running a surplus during a depression is absolute madness, but this is the lousy hand Varoufakis was dealt.)
Haring’s final comments are a good summary of Varoufakis’s achievement:
“Was it worth the hassle to reject the draft of 16 February, just to accept the statement four days later? For Athens it most certainly was. It got the promise that no self-defeating, excessive austerity would be asked of it any more, the assurance that it could devise its own economic and social policies, as long as they did not impact negatively on the interests of its partners, rather than having to execute and leaving in place all the measures accepted by the former government and strongly rejected by the people. These are huge improvements for Athens, with no significant counterbalancing downside compared to 16 February.”  (“Was it worth it? Concessions to Greece relative to the rejected draft of 16 February”, Nobert Haring)
A reduction in the primary surplus is a big win, no doubt. But we need to wait and see if that is something that Varoufakis really achieved.

For the time being, I am keeping my eyes focused on the veto power a Syriza-led Greece will hold over operations in Brussels going forward. "Better to run away and live again to fight another day."

Thursday, February 19, 2015

Grexit + Serious Trouble in Kiev

Greece has asked for a six-month extension of its loan agreement with the troika (Niki Kitsantonis and James Kanter, "Greece Requests Extension of Loan Agreement and Meets Resistance From Germany"). A meeting will be held tomorrow afternoon in Brussels between eurogroup chief Jeroen Dijsselbloem and Greek finance minister Yanis Varoufakis. They will attempt for the third time to arrive at an understanding.

The question, as explored in depth this morning by Yves Smith, "Obama Administration Throws Greece Under the Bus; ECB Leak Recommends Capital Controls; Greece Weighing Capitulation," is whether Greece's six-month extension request is a capitulation to the troika's austerity demands. Smith sees it as such:
Things are not going well for Greece. It appears Syriza has largely capitulated to the demands of the Troika. Greece has submitted a request for a loan extension that the Eurogroup will consider Friday. From ekathimerini:
Government officials on Wednesday worked until late finalizing a proposal…
Specifically the government is expected to seek an extension to the so-called Master Financial Assistance Facility Agreement, the official name for the European Financial Stability Facility’s loan contract. That contract stipulates, however, that the dispensation of financial assistance is dependant on Greece honoring the terms of the so-called memorandum, which contains the economic reforms that the previous government committed to and which the current SYRIZA-led coalition has contested. Indeed, former Prime Minister Antonis Samaras had made the same request in December last year when he sought to extend the European part of Greece’s bailout program, from the end of the year to February 28. Kathimerini understands that Samaras’s request had then used the words “technical extension to the existing Master Financial Assistance Facility Agreement,” the same phrase that the new government was said to be considering last night.
The compromise is expected to satisfy both sides as it would mean Athens can avoid using the phrase “extension of the existing program” and the creditors can avoid using the term “loan agreement.” In substance, however, there would be little difference from the extension sought by Samaras as the terms of the memorandum would have to be respected in order for rescue loans to be disbursed.
This means that Greece is effectively asking for an extension of the bailout, which is what it had refused to do. And that means keeping the “conditionality” as in privatizations and labor-crushing structural reforms, intact. Greece is still fighting to keep some flexibility there but it is not clear they will obtain much. Again from ekathimerini:
The European Commission’s vice president for eurozone affairs, Valdis Dombrovskis, said efforts were under way to reach a compromise by finding “common ground for an extension of the current program.”
He insisted that “the best way forward is to extend the existing program with its conditionality.” Dombrovskis noted, however, that if Greece wants to substitute some of the existing measures in the memorandum with alternatives, it could do so.
In other words, this is a “peace with honor” solution.
Smith then goes on to list what led to the presumed capitulation: 1) the Syriza-led government was abandoned by the United States (no surprise there); 2) Greece is going to run out of a cash February 24, much earlier than originally anticipated; and, most importantly, 3) the European Central Bank (ECB) is fanning a bank run and then restricting the amount of Emergency Liquidity Assistance (ELA) that Greece could tap (basically, the ECB has been working to crater the Greek banking system to force Tsipras and Varoufakis to kneel).

The problem for the troika is that clearly Greek's Syriza-led government has no intention of implementing the austerity diktats contained in the loan memo. Can you imagine a situation in Athens (approval for Syriza is sky high) where Tsipras starts taking bids on publics assets and issuing pink slips to government workers? It is not going to happen.

If there is any wiggle room in the six-month extension document, Dijsselbloem will try to eliminate it. For one, Greece insists that the troika's auditors will not be welcomed back to Athens to oversee implementation of the diktats. According to Yves Smith,
[I]t may be that even the concessions that they are apparently prepared to offer will not be deemed sufficient. For instance, it does not appear that Syriza has agreed to let the Troika monitors back in, one of the five demand seen as critical by the Germans. And even though the European Commission spokesperson Valdis Dombrovskis said there might be some negotiating room on specific conditions, that is also inconsistent with the FAZ description of the German stance. Recall that it was a European Commission trial document that Varoufakis said Greece was willing to sign but was firmly nixed by the Eurogroup. 
So it may be that this last round of concessions is meant not as a capitulation but to demonstrate how much Greece was willing to give in the face of implacable Eurogroup demands and was still rebuffed. We’ll know the outcome either way shortly.
This has been my feeling all along about the underlying strategy of Syriza. Syriza is a pro-EU party. Varoufakis spoke eloquently and sincerely -- and in an impromptu manner -- about European unity during his Monday press conference. But if Syriza can prove that the status quo is irrational, which Varoufakis has made some headway communicating over the last several weeks, then a Grexit and the resulting turmoil will not be blamed on Syriza but on the troika.

Kitsantonis and Kanter are reporting that Germany is opposed to Greece's six-month extension request:
Germany is probably the central eurozone member in [Friday's] proceedings, and a German Finance Ministry spokesman, Martin Jäger, said in a statement on Thursday that the letter from Athens was “not a substantial proposal to resolve matters.” He added: “The written document does not meet the criteria agreed in the Eurogroup on Monday.”
Germany's intention is to break Syriza, de-legitimize it. Smith said the German ambassador to Greece requested that Varoufakis be replaced as finance minister. Germany sees Greece as a serf in bondage, and Germany will not accept an outcome that places the nations on equal footing.

The temptation in the West to interpret every relationship as one of lordship and bondage is on display in Ukraine. The junta's loss in Debaltseve is clearly a turning point. The Ukrainian Army which was cracking prior to Debaltseve (to the point that the Gray Lady was reporting plans floated in Kiev to create a brand new army) will probably not be able to recover from the rout it suffered this week. The Saker outlines the Debaltsve turning point as follows:
The real problem for Kiev is that more or less all of the current line of contact can become a potential counter-offensive point for the Novorussians who, by the way, have never concealed their desire to get back all of the historical Novorussian lands. So while the current (relative) cease-fire is all nice and dandy, I think that by this spring, when the Novorussians will have reinforced their infantry with up to 100'00 more men the situation for the Kiev regime will become absolutely horrific and no amount of US weapon deliveries will change that. This might well be the beginning of the end for the Nazi experiment in Kiev. 
The implications for the AngloZionist empire are rather clear: if the 1%ers have any kind of sense of reality left, they should toss out Poroshenko and the rest of the crazies and foster some kind of government of technocrats in charge of drafting a new constitution and organizing a referendum on federalization simply because the folks in Kiev better negotiate while there still is something left to negotiate then to way to be hiding in a surrounded bunker like their hero Hitler did. Alas, I don't think Uncle Sam or the Eurocretins have any common sense left in them. 
Whatever may be the case, by the ballot or by the bullet, but we *are* winning.
With the Ukrainian Army mortally wounded, Poroshenko is trying to get UN peacekeepers introduced to Donbass. Russia has nixed the move.

Would the U.S. try to piece together a "coalition of the willing"? I don't think so; such a move would invite an enormous Russian response.

No, Kiev's days are numbered, and so too apparently the eurzone's.

Wednesday, February 18, 2015

Germany's Reaction to NAF's Victory in Debaltseve Bad Sign for Greece

Debaltseve has fallen to the Novorossiya Armed Forces (NAF). What is interesting about David Herszenhorn's story, "Ukraine Forces Withdraw From Debaltseve, a Strategic Town," is he doesn't let on to where the Ukrainian Army is planning to retreat. 
Andriy Lysenko, a spokesman for the Ukrainian national security and defense council, confirmed the retreat at a briefing in Kiev, the capital, on Wednesday afternoon, and said that the pullout was nearly completed. 
“Today, the armed forces of Ukraine are conducting the organized, planned retreat of units of forces of the antiterrorist operation from the city of Debaltseve,” Mr. Lysenko said. “At the moment, almost 80 percent of the Ukrainian units have retreated from this sector, and this operation is to be completed soon.”
Herszenhorn doesn't mention in his story that Debaltseve is encircled by the NAF. There is nowhere for the Ukrainian Army to flee. But in a story yesterday by Andrew Kramer, "Despite Ukraine Truce, a Battle That Continues," it is clear Poroshenko's troops are surrounded and in deep trouble:
As many as 8,000 Ukrainian soldiers are holed up in the city, a rail hub connecting the capitals of the two rebel regions, Donetsk and Luhansk. Rebels have reportedly sent text messages to phones in the town, telling the soldiers that they have been abandoned and should surrender.
The Ukrainian government maintains that the town was not surrounded before the cease-fire took effect, and that European monitors of the truce should insist that the separatist forces halt their offensive and open a corridor to evacuate the wounded.
The main rebel group, the Donetsk People’s Republic, has said it will not observe the agreement in Debaltseve, saying that it was encircled before the cease-fire began and that it is therefore now an internal region in its enclave, not a section of the front.
The only resupply road into Debaltseve is mined, in range of rebel artillery and at times held by pro-Russian infantry. On Friday, eight Ukrainian soldiers reportedly escaped on foot through the fields, and on Sunday, a dozen or so made it out in a truck [one of the soldiers on the truck said it was dumb luck that they made it out alive]. 
On Tuesday, however, Ukrainian rocket-launching trucks and tanks were barreling down the resupply road toward the fighting, though the cease-fire required both sides to withdraw heavy weaponry starting at midnight Monday.
The Saker explains in a post yesterday, "Yet another monumental failure for the junta," that worse is yet to come for Kiev:
All my sources confirm that Debaltsevo is mostly in Novorussian hands and that the junta forces are in full retreat to the south of the pocket. All the top Novorussian brass was on hand today, including Kononov, Motorola, Givi, Mozgovoi and Zakharchenko as were many tens of Ukrainian prisoners. It appears that the junta forces were unable to provide the kind of resistance they showed in Peski, and that make sense because in Peski they were not surrounded and they had the fire support of Ukrainian forces just north and west of them. This time the cauldron is too deep and the "lid" too strong.
You can see that the cauldron "lid" has now closed on Debaltsevo from the north and that the junta forces are either surrendering of fleeing south where there is quite literally nothing for them to do then to wait until they run out of food and ammo. Bottom line: it's over for the Ukie forces in the Debaltsevo cauldron.
Amazingly, the freaks in Kiev as still insisting that there is no cauldron but only a "bridgehead". The good news is that apparently nobody buys that nonsense any more and the mothers and wifes of the men caught in the cauldron are trying everything they can to force the Ukie high command to accept the Novorussian offer of an evacuation corridor. The try to protest in front of the General Staff building in Kiev, then the blocked traffic. In a particularly poignant moment one of these women put a megaphone next to a cellphone to amplify the voice of her son/husband calling from the cauldron and announcing that they had for about 3 hours of supplies left.
All this is truly catastrophic news for the junta in Kiev. First, their policy of denying the issue made it impossible for their forces to get out while it was still possible. According to Russian military experts, about half of all the (comparatively) combat capable units of the Ukrainian military have been surrounded in this cauldron and that means that 50% of the Ukrainian army is now gone. Second, while Poroshenko and the junta freaks tried as hard as they could to completely deny the very existence of the cauldron, thanks to the Internet and the Russian TV channels most folks in junta-controlled Ukraine know that they are being lied to. That, in turns, means that the regime is loosing the very little credibility it might have had with the general public. Last and not least, now there will be a lot of very ugly recriminations from all sides of the political spectrum about who is guilty for that latest disaster. I would not be surprised one bit if the Ukrainian death-squads (aka Azov battalion & Co.) decided to storm Kiev for two reasons: a) to take out their rage on the regime and b) because it is safer to storm Kiev than Donetsk. Poroshenko better watch his back now. By the way, rumor (unconfirmed!) has it that he already evacuated his family to Germany.
Novorussian intel is reporting that the junta is trying to assemble three battalion tactical groups and numerous MLRS north of the cauldron to try to rescue the surrounded forces, but this will be too little too late. The Novorussians are used to Ukie artillery and they don't fear their armor or, even less so, infantry. Besides, I bet you that now that they are inside Debaltsevo, the Novorussians will deeply dig in. When is the last time that the junta forces succeeded in an urban assault operation? Exactly.
Bottom line: yet another brilliant victory for the Novorussian forces and yet another humiliating defeat for the junta in Kiev.
Judging from the reaction to Debaltseve by various participants at Minsk last week, The Saker is on the money: This is another titanic blunder by the junta which bodes ill not just for Kiev but for the West and Russia as well.

First, Herszenhorn reports Putin's reaction as follows:
[Poroshenko's] comments [asserting bizarrely that Ukrainian troops had accomplished their mission in Debaltseve], however, came after the separatists boasted of controlling the town, and after President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia suggested on Tuesday in Hungary that Ukraine should accept its defeat at Debaltseve by separatist forces he described as “underdogs.”

“Life is life; it just goes on,” Mr. Putin said. “No need to dwell on it.”
Germany's reaction is troubling: more sanctions, more blame for Russia. According to Herszenhorn:
Ms. Merkel’s office condemned the separatist offensive, calling it a clear violation of a cease-fire. 
At a regular government news conference, Steffen Seibert, Chancellor Merkel’s spokesman, said Europe was prepared to support a new round of sanctions against Russia if the situation in Ukraine continued to deteriorate. 
“There has been a massive violation of the cease-fire which took effect on Sunday,” Mr. Seibert said, according to Reuters. He said it was too early to say whether the Minsk peace deal had collapsed. 
“The hopes linked to the Minsk agreement have been seriously damaged,” he said. “We must push for the implementation of the package of measures.” 
“We see the U.N. resolution as an impulse in this direction, and in the coming days, we will work with the possibilities that we have,” he said.
To blame the NAF solely for a violation of the Minsk 2.0 ceasefire is not credible. Even the extremely biased Gray Lady reports that the Ukrainian Army violated the ceasefire. All indications are that the West is going to continue to back the junta. Hopefully, The Saker is right and Kiev will collapse from within either due to a new Maidan uprising or another Right Sector putsch. Because of the lifeline the West keeps extending to Poroshenko, change will have to come from within, and that appears to me to be a longshot.

Germany's insane behavior -- doing the same thing (sanctions) and expecting a different result (surrender of the NAF) -- does not bode well for the outcome of loan negotiations between Greece and the troika. Germany's institutional obtuseness has to be factored in.

On the other hand, one might argue that what determines German behavior is what Washington wants. Germany did not want a civil war in Ukraine, but Merkel has gone along with the disastrous U.S.-backed ATO in the Donbass. Washington supports some flexibility for Greece (see today's NYT unsigned editorial, "Give Greece Room to Maneuver"); Obama has voiced support, albeit meekly, for the Syriza-led government being allowed to implement some of its pro-growth policies. The idea here, as expressed in an "Upshot" today by Neil Irwin, "A Possible Day of Reckoning, Again, for Greece and Europe," is that eventually Germany will capitulate in favor of European unity:
If Greece ends up dropping out of the euro currency zone entirely, with unpredictable ripple effects across the Continent and the world financial system, the events of the last few days will look like a turning point that led to that moment. As of Tuesday, to be clear, markets were predicting nothing of the sort. European stock markets were down only slightly, and the value of the euro was actually up a bit. In effect, markets have seen this show before: the sturm und drang of threats and counterthreats that end in a last-minute deal.
The hedge fund manager Mark Dow offered on Twitter a way to think about the tense negotiations: “EZ bears underestimate the short-term resolve of EZ policy makers. EZ bulls overestimate the long-term viability of the exchange rate system.” 
Here’s what Mr. Dow is saying. We have seen again and again that this generation of European leaders, who built their careers on the altar of European unity, will eventually do what it takes to prevent the common currency from ripping apart. If this recent history is a guide, then the drama of the last few days is merely the theatrics required to get these finance ministers to arrive at a deal. 
On the other hand, Mr. Dow also points out, Europe really does have a big and plausibly unsolvable macroeconomic problem.
One more way to look at it is if Germany goes against her interests in Ukraine by supporting the Washington war drive then she earns the right to lead in negotiations with Greece. This means that the Moscovici document that Varoufakis was willing to sign but that was withdrawn at that last moment by Jeroen Dijsselbloem at Germany's behest will not be recycled. There are reports in the media that this is what is in the works.

Right now, given Germany's reaction to the fall of Debaltseve, it looks like continued impasse between the troika and Greece.

Monday, February 16, 2015

Viva Varoufakis!

Talks between Greece and the heads of eurozone broke down today in Brussel's. Jeroen Dijsselbloem tried to bum rush Varoufakis, and Varoufakis beat him back. 

Today Varoufakis published a fantastic Op-Ed in the Gray Lady, "No Time for Games in Europe," where he justifies the stance of his government and its insistence to establish a real strategy for growth as opposed to mindless, petty, inhuman austerity. 

In the critical last two paragraphs of the piece he invokes Kant! In particular, Kant's ethics (which, as the Konigsbergian argued, is as close as we can get to the noumenon):
One may think that this retreat from game theory is motivated by some radical-left agenda. Not so. The major influence here is Immanuel Kant, the German philosopher who taught us that the rational and the free escape the empire of expediency by doing what is right.
How do we know that our modest policy agenda, which constitutes our red line, is right in Kant’s terms? We know by looking into the eyes of the hungry in the streets of our cities or contemplating our stressed middle class, or considering the interests of hard-working people in every European village and city within our monetary union. After all, Europe will only regain its soul when it regains the people’s trust by putting their interests center-stage.
Viva Varoufakis!

Tuesday, February 3, 2015

"Syriza is the Only Game in Town"

From time to time we among the news-consuming public are treated to a focusing of the lens that reveals a basic conflict, a sort of good guys versus bad guys, the outcome of which might change before our eyes the world we live in. Cyprus vs. the troika at the beginning of 2013 is an example. It looked for a moment there as if the eurozone might come tumbling down, of which I was in favor because it seemed to me that rather than providing an alternate model of the dominant race-to-the-bottom neoliberalism of the United States, the European Union was copying it, hollowing out the rich social democracies of its member nations.

After Cyprus there was Syria in the summer of 2013. A false flag chemical attack in a Damascus suburb was meant to launch a saturation bombing campaign led by the U.S., the idea being to drive out the ruling Baathists and carve up Syria, re-crafting Sykes-Picot. The Russians intervened with some deft diplomacy, the result of which was that the U.S. would call off its air power campaign in exchange for al-Assad giving up all of Syria's chemical weaponry. This so incensed the Saudis that Islamic State was given the "Go" signal. By the next summer we had a version of the Sykes-Picot reboot that the Gulf sheikhdoms were hankering after all along.

Also last summer there was Cold War 2.0. It looked for a while like the rebels of the Donetsk People's Republic and Luhansk People's Republic were going to smash so thoroughly the Ukrainian military that the junta in Kiev might collapse. Then there was the Minsk ceasefire in September. Now that fiction has evaporated and we are back to where we were last summer with "boilers" in the Donbass and the junta military getting its clocked clean.

Right now the good guys vs. bad guys narrative moment of clarity has to do with Greece's new Syriza-led government. Since its convincing election victory ten days ago, Syriza's leader Alexis Tsipras has stepped back from the international limelight and finance minister Yanis Varoufakis has stepped forward.

Varoufakis has been seemingly everywhere of late, parrying with BBC talking heads and eurogroup chief Jeroen Dijsselbloem, flying to Paris to meet with France's finance minister, all in an attempt to break the stranglehold that German-dictated austerity has on the continent.

Yves Smith of Naked Capitalism has been following these perambulations and, despite the outpouring of joy from the Western left that greeted Syriza's election, she has been bearish on Syriza's chances of achieving its aims, i.e., restoring social spending and collective bargaining rights, halting privatization, negotiating a debt jubilee with Greece's creditors.

Smith's post this morning, "Greek Finance Minister Varoufakis Retreats on Debt Writedowns, Public Spending Promises," is a good example:
We’ve said that Greece had a weak negotiating position in trying to get a better deal from its creditors. That is playing out before our eyes. Greek Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis has stepped down some of his early proposals even before formal talks have begun. This is a sad but predictable situation, since the Germans and the other members of the northern bloc are not at all willing to cut Greece much if any slack, since that would lead bigger, more powerful countries to try to slip the yoke of austerity.
The tragic thing about this situation is that Varoufakis is simply describing economic reality and has a number of sound ideas for how to make conditions better for Greece, which in the end will also lead to better results for its lenders. Yet he has run into a massive, if predictable wall, with his willingness to make unvarnished descriptions of the obvious, abject failure of Eurozone economic policies regularly depicted as “confrontational”. One reason Varoufakis may be going this route is to use his newfound high profile to send a message to voters and anti-austerlity politicians throughout Europe, since as we have stressed, the more popular anti-austerity and anti-Eurozone parties become, the more even the Germans will have to fear.
The Germans have a short-sighted view of the stakes. With the ECB holding a sword of Damocles over the Greek banking system, in terms of its ability to cut off access to emergency liquidity facilities, and Syriza and Varoufakis personally having rejected a Grexit, they can dictate terms. In their eyes, the only reason to cut Greece any slack is that, as Varoufakis keeps stressing, Syriza is the sole party that is not loyal to Greek’s oligarchs. If they want corruption tamped down and the tax system cleaned up, Syriza is the only game in town.
Today in a Financial Times interview, Varoufakis walked back his negotiating ask for debt cancellation, instead proposing a series of “debt swaps” that would achieve more or less the same result. He was more obvious that might have been ideal in stating that he regarded this as a fix to placate Germany. From the Financial Times, which broke the story:
Greece’s radical new government revealed proposals on Monday for ending the confrontation with its creditors by swapping outstanding debt for new growth-linked bonds, running a permanent budget surplus and targeting wealthy tax-evaders…
Attempting to sound an emollient note, Mr Varoufakis told the Financial Times the government would no longer call for a headline write-off of Greece’s €315bn foreign debt. Rather it would request a “menu of debt swaps” to ease the burden, including two types of new bonds.
The first type, indexed to nominal economic growth, would replace European rescue loans, and the second, which he termed “perpetual bonds”, would replace European Central Bank-owned Greek bonds.
He said his proposal for a debt swap would be a form of “smart debt engineering” that would avoid the need to use a term such as a debt “haircut”, politically unacceptable in Germany and other creditor countries because it sounds to taxpayers like an outright loss.
But there is still deep scepticism in many European capitals, in particular Berlin, about the new government’s brinkmanship and its calls for an end to austerity policies.
“What I’ll say to our partners is that we are putting together a combination of a primary budget surplus and a reform agenda,” Mr Varoufakis, a leftwing academic economist and prolific blogger, said. “I’ll say, ‘Help us to reform our country and give us some fiscal space to do this, otherwise we shall continue to suffocate and become a deformed rather than a reformed Greece’.”
In a more sophisticated undercutting of Varoufakis than the disgraceful BBC interview of last week, a Financial Times video embedded in the article features a commentator discussing Varoufakis’ progress thus far. The segment depicts Varoufakis as being confrontational and as not having gotten on well with the UK chancellor of the exchequer, and also focuses on the flight of financial assets from Greece and its falling stock market. Does it not occur to anyone that a substantial portion of the money exodus is that of those very oligarchs that Syriza has threatened? The rest of the EU says they want the country cleaned up, yet they attack Syriza for the predictable results of their seriousness.
But while it may seem trivial for them to get their way with Greece, this victory is likely to be Pyrrhic. The more it becomes obvious that the northern countries will keep inflicting pain on Greece out of a desire to keep a bad status quo intact, the more the other victims in better bargaining positions (by virtue of having larger economies and even more fractious voters) are likely to escalate. Indeed, Varoufakis, by challenging the Troika on so many fronts, is conveying a powerful message that subservience is neither necessary nor desirable. No wonder the technocrats are out to discredit him personally.
Ambrose Evans-Pritchard argues that Greece holds the trump cards. Here I disagree. With de facto control over Greece’s banking system, the ECB can bring Greece to heel. We’ll see if the ECB imposes any conditions on its approval of the Greece’s request to use ELA funds on Wednesday. If they are anything other than cosmetic, that means the ECB is supporting the northern countries and is determined to box Syriza in. But I do agree that in a longer time frame, Germany is losing. The problem is it may not lose quickly enough for Greece to get the relief it desperately needs. 
Interestingly, right after Syriza won the election all the talk was that the troika would extend the bailout program set to expire on February 28. Nothing of the sort materialized, and last week Varoufakis staked out the position that Greece would not accept the bailout funds because doing so would lock the country into conditions the new government rejects.

Now, following the post-election bank runs, Smith sees a lot of importance in what position the European Central Bank will take Wednesday regarding Greece's request for Emergency Liquidity Assistance. According to Smith, the game for the Syriza can be up pretty much by tomorrow if the ECB demands onerous conditions to access ELA money.

My sense is that Syriza is shrewder and tougher than Smith is willing to credit. At this point "There Is No Aletrnative" to a party like Syriza, other than, given time, one more to the left or the far right. Varoufakis, it seems to me, is waiting for the troika to overplay its hand. And so far this seems to be transpiring, which is having the effect of radicalizing the public. The point is that the general populous has to be moved from its false consciousness to one that is more real, more radical. That is happening. But as Smith asks, Will Syriza have enough time?

Tuesday, March 26, 2013

Cyprus Augurs End of Euro

Why is Cyprus so important? Because it marks the end of the euro as we know it. This from today's excellent offering from Liz Alderman and Landon Thomas Jr., "With or Without Bailout, Cypriots Lose Trust in Banks":
“For the first time, we have capital controls in the euro zone,” said Nicolas Véron, a senior fellow at Bruegel, a policy research group in Brussels, and a visiting fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington. “The next time there is a crisis somewhere else in the world, people will think of what happened in Cyprus and will try to get their money out much faster. These are the new rules of the game.”
My interest in and concern with Cyprus is what happens to markets once the realization sinks in that the eurozone is starting to disintegrate. Yesterday, after Eurogroup head Jeroen Dijsselbloem said that Cyprus would be a model going forward, European markets dropped. This from Alderman and Thomas:
Stocks were down broadly in Europe on Monday, after the head of the Eurogroup, Jeroen Dijsselbloem, suggested that the idea of skimming savers’ accounts to bail out banks could be considered a “template” for other countries. The borrowing costs of the financially shaky Spain and Italy surged upward as the markets digested the Cyprus news — and the broader implications for the euro currency union.
Dijsselbloem later disavowed this statement, saying that Cyprus was a one-off, and in this he was supported by officials from the ECB (for more, check out the story this morning by Liz Alderman and David Jolly, "Head of Cyprus's Biggest Bank Resigns"). But even if it's not true, and bail-ins are not the new normal, the impression created by the Cyprus bailout negotiations is one of chaos. As the New York Times sums up in an editorial this morning:
Though it is better than the initial plan, the new agreement does not inspire much hope. It represents the latest in a series of slapdash and last-minute European efforts to prevent financial Armageddon in one country or another. Many analysts have noted that this deal leaves the government of Cyprus with an impossibly high debt burden, about 140 percent of its gross domestic product, and will impose many years of hardship and pain on its people and its economy.
For Spain, Italy and other troubled euro zone countries, Cyprus is an unnerving example. Individuals and businesses in those countries will probably split up their savings into smaller accounts or move some of their money to another country. If a lot of depositors withdraw cash from the weakest banks in those countries, Europe could have another crisis on its hands. 
The way to prevent financial catastrophes like this is to impose strong centralized regulations on all banks and recapitalize or restructure weakened ones. Most important, the policy makers need to scrap austerity programs that are making it nearly impossible for the European economy and financial system to recover.
Suffering is certainly ahead for Cypriots as they go the way of Greece and Portugal and Ireland and Spain. The question is whether that pain finds its way to our shores. A scenario that has to be contemplated is one where U.S. markets react negatively as the eurozone's disintegration accelerates. We are not flush with economic health in this country; we cannot sustain another significant market drop. Yesterday at work I saw a Reuter's headline online, "Student loan write-offs hit $3 billion in first two months of year" -- up 36% from the same period last year. More people are going back to school. Why? Because there is nothing else to do. There is not enough work.