Showing posts with label bailout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bailout. Show all posts

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Troika Wants More from Cyprus

Just getting around this morning to reading Yves Smith's post about Cyprus from yesterday, "Troika Demands Another €6 Billion from Cyprus, Making “Rescue” Bigger Than GDP." It's definitely worth checking out, particularly the assessment of the European Commission's economic forecast for Cyprus. As Smith comments, "So get this, sports fans: not only did the Eurocrats underestimate how badly their little program would hurt the economy, they are continuing to underestimate how brutal it will be."

This morning I can't get enough of Bert Jansch (1965), the self-titled debut album from the Scottish folk guitarist. This is second-to-last track, "Dreams of Love":

Friday, April 12, 2013

Cyprus Economy Predicted to Shrink 12.5%

Cyprus' economy is now predicted to shrink by 12.5% over the next two years (though even this is probably too optimistic) according to a report by the European Commission that Liz Alderman writes about today in her story, "Future Looks Bleaker Than Anticipated in Cyprus, Its Creditors Claim":
According to a bleak assessment released Thursday by its European partners, Cyprus will fall into a downward spiral for at least the next two years, with the economy contracting up to 12.5 percent during the period as the country reduces a banking sector that had ballooned to more than five times its gross domestic product.
And because the economy will do worse than expected, Cyprus must soon raise 13 billion euros ($17 billion) — nearly twice the amount the government thought it would have to come up with just a month ago — to keep its debt and deficit from spinning out of control and to meet the terms of a 10 billion euro ($13.1 billion) international bailout secured last month by the newly elected president, Nicos Anastasiades.
Cyprus plans on selling 10 tons of gold from its 13-ton reserve. Such a sale, Alderman says, would generate around 400 million euros. Unemployment now at close to 15% will increase. Pressure on Cyprus to develop its substantial offshore natural reserves will lead to conflict with Turkey.

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Troika Approves MOU on Cyprus

The troika has finalized a memorandum of understanding (MOU) on the Cyprus bailout. The MOU won't be made public until after a meeting of eurozone finance ministers in Dublin next week. According to a story by James Kanter, "I.M.F. and Europe Set Tough Terms for Cyprus Bailout,"
Though it has not yet been made public, officials say the agreement includes budget cuts, the privatization of state-owned assets and other conditions Cyprus must meet.
The MOU has to be approved  by not only the Cypriot Parliament but by the 16 other eurozone countries as well. Managing director of the IMF, Christine Lagarde, who according to Kanter has been the bad cop in these bailout negotiations, says the main fiscal measure in the MOU is raising the corporate tax in Cyprus to 12.5% from 10%.

The question I have: Why, if you're a member of parliament in Cyprus, would you voluntarily opt to go the way of Greece?

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Any Courage in Cyprus?

Cyprus, as it turns out, has the ability to block the bailout deal with the troika. This from a story today by Liz Alderman and James Kanter about the resignation of finance minister Michalis Sarris, "Cyprus Chief of Finance Quits Post":
But the Cypriot Parliament must still vote on a memorandum of understanding with the so-called troika of international organizations — the European Central Bank, the European Commission and the International Monetary Fund — that agreed to the bailout. 
That memorandum, still being drafted, will outline the budget cuts and other conditions Cyprus will have to meet to receive its allotments of money. A parliamentary vote is expected in coming weeks. The governments of Germany and Finland, under their national rules on bailout loans, are also expected to seek the approval of their Parliaments. 
The memorandum will probably be the subject of heated debate in Nicosia. Many lawmakers, already unhappy with the tough capital controls that have been slapped on bank accounts for the better part of a month, are dismayed by what they see as harsh terms that will tip Cyprus’s already enfeebled economy over the edge. 
But Mr. Sarris’s resignation should “help the Cypriot government win approval for the bailout program in the Cypriot Parliament,” said Mr. Rahman, the analyst.
The Cypriot Parliament has all the evidence it needs to scrap the deal. This is from today's story by David Jolly, "Unemployment in Euro Zone Reaches 12%":
The jobless crisis is hitting hardest in the south of Europe. Eurostat said Greece, with its economy in free fall, had the euro zone’s highest unemployment rate ,at 26.4 percent in December, the latest month for which data are available. Among Greek youth, the jobless rate has hit a staggering level, 58.4 percent. 
Spain, where the economy has contracted sharply after the collapse of the global credit bubble, posted the second-highest unemployment rate in the euro zone in February, at 26.3 percent. 
Cyprus’s jobless rate, at 14.0 percent, is almost certain to rise because the country’s recently negotiated bailout deal will crimp the economy for years to come, said Mr. Cliffe, of ING. “We’ve already seen how this story plays out in Greece,” he said. “We’re about to see it play out again in Cyprus.”
The question is do the elected leaders of Cyprus have the courage to leave the eurozone and go their own way. In the short term such a move would likely cause a drop in the markets, but in the long run Cyprus would be doing all of us an enormous favor by driving a stake through the zombie brain that can think only of bigger being better and that austerity somehow magically generates growth. Sadly, politicians, whether east or west or north or south, have a consistent track record of cowardice and plutocratic capture; so to expect emancipatory leadership is naive. But there is always hope. Hope is the anchor.

Ben Judah has an article on the Opinion page, "Did Putin Sink Cyprus?," that argues that Putin's failed promise to bring law and order to Russia along with the cultivation of his cult of personality has led to billions in capital flight. Judah concludes the piece by casting some blame the EU's way:
Whatever remains of the Russian fortunes in Nicosia seems sure to flee again — but not back to Russia. It may go to other European havens, like the Dutch Antilles and the British Virgin Islands. Malta and Luxembourg are possibilities, but analysts have both on bailout watch. 
Meanwhile, Brussels is not impotent. The European Union must clamp down on offshore havens, insist on transparent banking and toughen up on money laundering. This is austerity Europe — and bloated tax havens not only put Europe at risk but also make its financial system complicit with offshore corruption. 
But it cannot erase the truths exposed by the Nicosia bust. Europe, it turns out, is studded with vulnerable, contagious tax islands, and their availability only compounds Russia’s deeper problem: it is both too corrupt and too paranoid to keep its billions at home.

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

Cyprus Synopsis

The Cyprus bailout crisis is retold this morning by Liz Alderman in a story, "Cypriots Feel Betrayed by the European Union," that focuses on an average Joe, Charalambos Alexandrou, who owns a roofing business, and his wife, Aliki Perganti, who works for a ceramics company. The contours of a standard narrative are taking shape. Cyprus joins the EU in 2004; the eurozone, in 2008. In doing so, it moves away from agriculture and manufacturing and refashions itself along the lines of Switzerland and Luxembourg as a strategic money hub uniquely situated to serve Europe, Asia and the Middle East. And the money flows in, creating a real estate boom. Then in 2010 the chickens come home to roost. Risky loans begin to default. The coup de grace is the haircut on Greek government bonds the Cypriot banks are forced to take as part of the troika engineered bailout of Greece. When it was Cyprus' turn to go hat in hand to the troika Germany made sure, because of an intelligence assessment that Cypriot banks were flush with ill-gotten Russian wealth, that any bailout would have to include a bail-in, a.k.a., inflicting pain and suffering on depositors. As Alderman says,
And with losses of up to 60 percent being imposed on deposit accounts above 100,000 euros at the Bank of Cyprus, [Charalambos Alexandrou] said, even many of his friends — not just Russian oligarchs — were losing big portions of savings they so diligently tucked away during the good years.
An unsigned editorial in today's Opinion section of the New York Times, "Cyprus Is Not an Exception," points out that in the eurozone it's not just Cyprus that has a banking sector that is at a large multiple of GDP; both Malta and Luxembourg have banking sectors that are larger than Cyprus':
Luxembourg and Malta, which have established themselves as tax havens serving big global corporations and the superrich, have banking systems that are even larger. Luxembourg’s bank assets are a staggering 22 times its gross domestic product, and Maltese bank assets clock in at eight times the size of its economy. 
Leaders of both countries have insisted that they should not be compared with Cyprus and that they expected European leaders to stand behind their governments and banks come what may. Speaking of his banking system, the finance minister of Luxembourg, Luc Frieden, said: “We want to expand it further, not to downsize it.” 
Banks in Luxembourg and Malta, many owned by big European and American financial firms, are healthier than those in Cyprus, according to the International Monetary Fund. But the I.M.F. raised concerns about the ability of the countries to properly monitor their banks or support them in a crisis. In other words, the euro zone and the I.M.F. would have to step in to bail them out if they ran into trouble. 
In any case, the euro zone needs urgently to finish work on a banking union that would allow the European Central Bank to supervise large banks instead of leaving that task to national policy makers who may be too protective of their banks. Europe should also have a common process to restructure troubled banks, which should reduce the risk of Cyprus-like debacles. A banking union would also give savers more confidence that their insured deposits are truly guaranteed, an assurance that was deeply shaken by what happened in Cyprus. 
Thankfully, the crowds were not as big and chaotic as people had feared when banks in Cyprus reopened last week after for two weeks — but only after the country imposed tough capital controls to prevent depositors from fleeing. Europeans may not be as lucky next time.
There seems to be a lot of clucking satisfaction from those who championed the view that Cyprus was a little one-off that so far there is no evidence of a run on banks. I say it's early yet. People are still in shock. Events are still unfolding in Italy. Give it some time.

Friday, March 29, 2013

Cyprus Temporary Capital Controls Likely To Last a Long Time

Cyprus' capital controls, only to last for one week, will now be in effect for at least a month. This from a story today by Andrew Higgins and Liz Alderman, "Long Lines as Banks Reopen in Cyprus After Freeze":
Not since the introduction of the euro in January 1999 has a European country blocked bank depositors from having full access to their own cash. Under European Union treaties, such restrictions are normally forbidden. But the European Commission, the union’s administrative arm, issued a statement Thursday morning that the Cyprus controls were legal — though urging that they be rescinded as soon as possible. Originally, the controls were to be in place for one week. But on Thursday, the Cypriot foreign minister, Ioannis Kasoulides, said that restrictions on financial transactions would not be lifted for a month.
A naked capitalism cross post from VoxEU today by Jon Danielsson, Director of the ESRC funded Systemic Risk Centre, London School of Economics, argues that the example of Iceland proves that temporary capital controls should, for all intents, be considered permanent:
Another European country was forced to implement `temporary’ capital controls in its crisis – Iceland, as discussed here on Vox (Danielsson and Arnason 2011). 
The Icelandic government, its central bank and the IMF considered the controls necessary because so many foreigners, and the occasional wealthy Icelander, had lost faith in the economy and only wanted to take their money out. While such individuals were considered misguided, their exit would have had disastrous consequences. Hence it was thought necessary to `temporarily’ prevent capital outflows. 
The authorities said at the time the controls would be temporary and limited in scope – lasting a few weeks or, at worst, a month or two. Half a decade later, the capital controls are still in place and getting more and more restrictive. 
This was the second time Iceland had implemented `temporary’ capital controls. The first time it did so, in the 1930s, led to the controls being in place until 1993. This is in line with the historical evidence; once capital controls are imposed, they are really hard to abolish, and a temporary arrangement usually ends up being permanent.
Reporting from Nicosia, Landon Thomas Jr. says the prevailing wisdom appears to be holding. Cyprus is a one-off and will not spread:
“People have lost all their money,” screamed a young financier Wednesday night, as he knocked back drink after drink at a local nightclub — which, despite the earsplitting din of Greek rap music, was half empty. “To me, that feels like war.” 
But on a global scale, investors have refused to panic, other than unloading the risky bonds of second-tier banks in Spain and Italy. 
And while the bond yields of Italian government debt have spiked in recent days, a signal of investor wariness, and the euro has traded down against the dollar, the view, for now, is that even though Europe’s handling of the crisis has been a mess, broader contagion has largely been avoided. 
“This does not worry us at all — Cyprus is just not systemic,” said a senior executive at a large sovereign wealth fund based in the Middle East, who was not authorized to speak publicly. 
Even Cypriot government bonds that are due to reach maturity this June are holding up fairly well, trading at 88 cents, not far from their recent high of 94 cents earlier this week, though a 12 percent discount from their face value.
But Floyd Norris in a High & Low Finance column that appears side by side with Thomas' piece sees signs of a spreading instability:
The fact the hot money stayed even after it became clear the Cypriot banks were in trouble — in large part because of all the Greek bonds they owned — is a testament to the false security the euro provided even after the Greek crisis erupted. That security has faded, at least a little. The cost of credit-default swaps on European banks has been rising since Cyprus got into trouble, suggesting the market thinks bank defaults have grown more likely. That cost continued to rise after the latest plan was announced. It does not help that European leaders seem unable to decide whether the Cypriot deal would set a precedent if banks in other countries get into trouble. It does, whatever they say, or at least it could. 
A few months ago, Europe was supposed to be on the way to a banking union, an arrangement that it was hoped would prevent what has now happened in Cyprus. What happens to those plans will be an indication of whether Europe can continue to hold the euro zone together. 
It may help that Cyprus is so insignificant. Its economy is about one-tenth the size of Ireland’s, which itself is among the smaller economies in the euro zone. It is even smaller than Vermont’s, which is smaller than that of any other state. We can only shudder at what might happen if banks in a big euro zone country got into a lot of trouble.
The next small eurozone country headed to the troika for a bailout, according to naked capitalism's Yves Smith, is Slovenia.

Thursday, March 28, 2013

Capital Controls in Cyprus, Bank Lines Not as Long as Expected

Banks opened today in Cyprus. There were lines but not as long as some anticipated. The S&P 500 established a new record, 1569.19, breaking the old one set in October of 2007. I'd say it's time to start selling.

The capital controls in Cyprus include the following: funds cannot be electronically transferred to another country; a maximum of 3,000 euros in cash can be taken out of the country; allowable ATM withdrawals have been increased to 300 euros a day from 100 euros; credit and debit card charges are limited to 5,000 euros a person a month; banks will accept payroll checks as deposits but will not cash them. This info can all be found in Liz Alderman's story, "Cyprus Sets Up Tight Controls as Banks Prepare to Reopen," from this morning.

Imagine the same restrictions in the United States. There would be an armed insurrection.

The EU is coming under fire. As Alderman says,
Under European Union treaties, restricting the free movement of capital is forbidden. Critics say that what is happening in Cyprus shows that union rules will be flouted when the International Monetary Fund, the European Central Bank and European Union leaders find it convenient to do so.
By imposing capital controls, European and Cypriot officials have effectively created two classes of euro: cash that can be freely spent, and cash that is locked up by capital controls, effectively diminishing its value.
“It has to be acknowledged that this is something entirely new,” said Nicolas Véron, a senior fellow at Bruegel, a research group in Brussels, and a visiting fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington. “This will shape expectations in other countries, and the issue is whether capital controls can be avoided in future episodes.”
Borrowing rates for Italy and Spain increased yesterday.

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Cyprus: "The Money is Going to Stay There for a Very Long Time"

Banks are scheduled to open tomorrow in Cyprus and rules outlining how people can access their money are still being promulgated. This is from today's story, "In Cyprus, Big Losses Expected on Deposits," by Landon Thomas Jr.:
The government is also struggling to come up with some form of capital controls in a bid to prevent too much money from draining from the banks and leaving the country. Given that more than 30 percent of the Bank of Cyprus’s 14 billion euros in long-term deposits belongs to foreigners — mostly Russians and Greeks — who would not hesitate to take their money out of the country, the restrictions on those funds are likely to be onerous, bankers say. 
“That money is going to stay there for a very long time,” said one person who has been involved in the discussions, but who requested anonymity because he was not authorized to speak publicly.
Beyond the challenge of dealing with the large depositors is the question of what to do with about 27 billion euros in deposits in accounts under 100,000 euros that now carry the Cypriot government’s full backing, following last weekend’s reversal of the decision to tax those deposits, too. That figure alone exceeds Cyprus’s annual gross domestic product of 18 billion euros. 
If the banks reopen on Thursday, as planned, Cyprus’s shellshocked citizens will have access to their insured deposits for the first time in more than a week. With their bills and fears mounting, it is widely expected that many will immediately seek to remove these funds from the banks. 
For now, officials say, it is likely that uninsured depositors will face stiff restrictions when it comes to withdrawing money from an automated teller machine or sending money abroad. But if a depositor at Bank of Cyprus wanted to transfer funds to, say, Hellenic Bank, a smaller institution that is in better shape, the controls would be less severe because that money would remain within the Cypriot banking system. Such arcane mechanisms are now being thrashed out in Brussels and Frankfurt.
With more time to consider the bailout an assessment has gone from bad to worse. The low end of the haircut, 30%, for uninsured depositors at the Bank of Cyprus has given way to the high end, 40%, because the bailout estimate of a 3% contraction of Cyprus' economy is being reassessed as too modest; now, according to Thomas' story, economists are predicting a shrinkage of 5%-10% within a year.

Andrew Higgins and Liz Alderman have a good "how we got here" story today, "Europeans Planted Seeds of Crisis in Cyprus." The Eurogroup's decision in October 2011 to make private-sector investors take a 50% write-down on Greek government bonds doomed Laiki Bank. Higgins and Alderman conclude their story with seven paragraphs that pretty much sum up the whole story heretofore. And the gist of it is that the eurozone is finished:
After the Greek write-down, Cyprus compounded its problems by dithering on whether to seek a bailout from the European Union. At first, it appealed to Russia, which provided a 2.5 billion-euro loan in December 2011. But this money quickly ran out, and when Cyprus did finally go cap-in-hand to its European partners for a lifeline, it received a rude shock: Germany, already gearing up for an election this year, wanted not just budget cuts and other conventional austerity measures but a complete overhaul of Cyprus’s economic model, built around financial services for foreigners seeking ways to dodge taxes and, Berlin suspected, launder dirty money. 
“They did not want the Cypriot model to exist as it did — they wanted Cyprus to stop being a financial center,” said Pambos Papageorgiou, a former central bank board member who is now a member of parliament and on its finance committee. “It was very brutal, like warfare.” 
Mr. Papageorgiou complained that the European Union had shown “the opposite of solidarity” in its dealings with one of its weakest and most vulnerable members. 
In the three years since Europe’s rolling debt crisis first exploded in Greece, governments and citizens in the hardest-hit nations have fumed that decisions made in Brussels pay little heed to their interests and are dictated instead by the economic concerns and election cycles of Germany. Whether in Athens, Dublin, Rome, Madrid or Nicosia, people increasingly ask whether the European Union serves their own aspirations or those of remote institutions dominated by others, particularly Germans. 
Such questions have grown to a furious pitch in Cyprus, where terms set early Monday for a 10 billion-euro bailout will deepen an already painful recession and send unemployment — now at 15 percent — soaring. They require the dismantling of Laiki Bank, with the loss of around 2,500 jobs, and a significant reduction in the country’s role as an offshore financial center. 
“We are looking at a very grim future for Cyprus,” said Michael Olympios, chairman of the Cyprus Investor Association, a lobbying group. “Even firm believers in European project like myself see now that it was a bad idea and that we should have at least stayed out of the euro.” 
As jobs disappear and the economy contracts, Mr. Olympios said, faith in Europe will wither. “I used to be a believer. Not anymore.”
The eurozone will continue on for some time of course. But this is the beginning of the end. Bigger is not always better. The idea has finally sunk in.

Tuesday, March 26, 2013

Cyprus Augurs End of Euro

Why is Cyprus so important? Because it marks the end of the euro as we know it. This from today's excellent offering from Liz Alderman and Landon Thomas Jr., "With or Without Bailout, Cypriots Lose Trust in Banks":
“For the first time, we have capital controls in the euro zone,” said Nicolas Véron, a senior fellow at Bruegel, a policy research group in Brussels, and a visiting fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington. “The next time there is a crisis somewhere else in the world, people will think of what happened in Cyprus and will try to get their money out much faster. These are the new rules of the game.”
My interest in and concern with Cyprus is what happens to markets once the realization sinks in that the eurozone is starting to disintegrate. Yesterday, after Eurogroup head Jeroen Dijsselbloem said that Cyprus would be a model going forward, European markets dropped. This from Alderman and Thomas:
Stocks were down broadly in Europe on Monday, after the head of the Eurogroup, Jeroen Dijsselbloem, suggested that the idea of skimming savers’ accounts to bail out banks could be considered a “template” for other countries. The borrowing costs of the financially shaky Spain and Italy surged upward as the markets digested the Cyprus news — and the broader implications for the euro currency union.
Dijsselbloem later disavowed this statement, saying that Cyprus was a one-off, and in this he was supported by officials from the ECB (for more, check out the story this morning by Liz Alderman and David Jolly, "Head of Cyprus's Biggest Bank Resigns"). But even if it's not true, and bail-ins are not the new normal, the impression created by the Cyprus bailout negotiations is one of chaos. As the New York Times sums up in an editorial this morning:
Though it is better than the initial plan, the new agreement does not inspire much hope. It represents the latest in a series of slapdash and last-minute European efforts to prevent financial Armageddon in one country or another. Many analysts have noted that this deal leaves the government of Cyprus with an impossibly high debt burden, about 140 percent of its gross domestic product, and will impose many years of hardship and pain on its people and its economy.
For Spain, Italy and other troubled euro zone countries, Cyprus is an unnerving example. Individuals and businesses in those countries will probably split up their savings into smaller accounts or move some of their money to another country. If a lot of depositors withdraw cash from the weakest banks in those countries, Europe could have another crisis on its hands. 
The way to prevent financial catastrophes like this is to impose strong centralized regulations on all banks and recapitalize or restructure weakened ones. Most important, the policy makers need to scrap austerity programs that are making it nearly impossible for the European economy and financial system to recover.
Suffering is certainly ahead for Cypriots as they go the way of Greece and Portugal and Ireland and Spain. The question is whether that pain finds its way to our shores. A scenario that has to be contemplated is one where U.S. markets react negatively as the eurozone's disintegration accelerates. We are not flush with economic health in this country; we cannot sustain another significant market drop. Yesterday at work I saw a Reuter's headline online, "Student loan write-offs hit $3 billion in first two months of year" -- up 36% from the same period last year. More people are going back to school. Why? Because there is nothing else to do. There is not enough work.

Sunday, March 24, 2013

Bailout Agreements Getting Worse

The Cyprus bailout deal seems to have changed from when I posted yesterday. Now what's being reported by James Kanter and Liz Alderman is that the uninsured deposits above 100,000 euros to be hit with a levy are at the Bank of Cyprus not Laiki Bank, and the tax will be 20% not 22% to 25%. There will a 4% tax on all uninsured deposits at all banks; also, gone is the nationalization of pension funds from state-run companies. According to Kanter and Alderman,
The revised terms under discussion would assess a one-time tax of 20 percent on deposits above 100,000 euros at the Bank of Cyprus, which has the largest number of savings accounts on the island. Because the Bank of Cyprus suffered huge losses on reckless bets that it took on Greek bonds, the government appears to be taking depositors’ money to help plug the hole. 
A separate tax of 4 percent would be assessed on uninsured deposits at all other banks, including the 26 foreign banks that operate in Cyprus. 
Under the plan, savings under 100,000 euros would not be touched — a significant difference from the original plan, which not only enraged Cypriot citizens but ignited fear that precedent had been set for euro zone governments to tap insured bank savings in times of a national emergency. 
Cypriot officials have also backed off a proposal that would have sought to raise billions of additional euros by nationalizing state-owned pension funds. Germany, whose political and financial clout dominates euro zone policy, had indicated it opposes the move.
Naked capitalism is keeping it real per usual with a cross post from Professor Yanis Varoufakis, who blogs regularly on the euro crisis, "While waiting for Cyprus' Godot....":
Every bailout agreement, beginning with Greece’s in May 2010, seems less logical and more toxic than the previous one. The culmination was of course Cyprus this past week. Think about it: In one short week, Europe has managed:
  • To put in jeopardy the hitherto sacrosanct concept of state guaranteed deposit insurance
  • The monetary integrity of the Eurozone
  • The European Union’s single market principle according to which capital controls are a no-no.

Friday, March 22, 2013

Cypriot Parliament to Vote on New Bailout

Today the Cypriot Parliament is voting on a replacement bailout plan, swapping the widely-derided deposit confiscation scheme for a nationalization of pensions at state-run companies. The issue now, assuming that parliament passes the new bailout plan, is whether the troika accepts it. This is from Liz Alderman's "Cyprus Lawmakers Prepare to Vote on a New Bailout" article this morning:
Before concrete details emerged, German leaders made it clear they would not back a deal that involved nationalizing the state-owned companies’ pensions, a measure that is rejected in Berlin as more socially dangerous than even the original plan to tax smaller savings. 
In a closed-door meeting with members of her junior coalition partner, the Free Democrats, Chancellor Angela Merkel made clear her impatience with the government in Cyprus, stating that “under no circumstances can we give up our principles,” the public television network ARD reported. 
“When you consider that there was massive resistance against involving the savings, then it is not easy to see how tapping the pension funds, which we view as socially a much more drastic step, is a very good idea,” Steffen Seiber, Ms. Merkel’s spokesman, told reporters. 
Germany is not alone. Luc Frieden, Luxembourg’s finance minister, expressed frustration over a lack of communication in Nicosia, telling Germany’s RBB radio, “It is difficult that we are not getting any details from Cyprus.”
Krugman in his column this morning, "Treasure Island Trauma," predicts that Cyprus will go the way of Iceland -- the banks, swollen by foreign deposits, will collapse and domestic depositors will be protected:
My guess is that, in the end, Cyprus will adopt something like the Icelandic solution, but unless it ends up being forced off the euro in the next few days — a real possibility — it may first waste a lot of time and money on half-measures, trying to avoid facing up to reality while running up huge debts to wealthier nations. We’ll see.
But step back for a minute and consider the incredible fact that tax havens like Cyprus, the Cayman Islands, and many more are still operating pretty much the same way that they did before the global financial crisis. Everyone has seen the damage that runaway bankers can inflict, yet much of the world’s financial business is still routed through jurisdictions that let bankers sidestep even the mild regulations we’ve put in place. Everyone is crying about budget deficits, yet corporations and the wealthy are still freely using tax havens to avoid paying taxes like the little people. 
So don’t cry for Cyprus; cry for all of us, living in a world whose leaders seem determined not to learn from disaster.
A post on naked capitalism responds to Krugman by stressing that Cyprus is not some outlier like the Cayman Islands but very much in tune with old Europe:
As for the size of the banking sector relative to GDP, Krugman seems scandalized that the banking sector is so large relative to its economy. Yes, this is a risky model, and Cyprus made the mistake of being overly dependent on one huge client, Russia. But Cyprus is hardly alone in being a financial center with banks that are a big multiple of GDP. Luxembourg is the really extreme case here, with a banking sector at over 20x GDP. England’s banking sector is 6x GDP. Swiss banks were 6.8x GDP in 2010 (Switzerland has forced much higher equity requirements on its banks, so its balance sheets have shrunk since then). Singapore also has an outsized banking sector. But let us remember that the EU has also set out to trash the Cyprus banking sector pretty much overnight with the deposit garnishing threat. It is important to recognize that while a restructuring was necessary, the severity of the crisis and the degree of damage that will be inflicted on the economy was not.
This is not to underplay Cyprus’s problems. But it would help to depict them accurately.

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Cypriot Parliament Rejects Bailout

Yesterday the Cypriot Parliament rejected the Euro Group bailout deal which called for raising 5.8 billion euros through a tax on all bank deposits even though deposits under 100,000 euros are guaranteed in Cyprus. Liz Alderman reports today that following the vote the European Central Bank put Cyprus on notice that time to arrive at a new agreement is limited:
After the parliamentary vote, the European Central Bank indicated that it would not immediately cut off emergency cash — without which Cypriot banks probably could not survive. In a terse statement, the central bank said it was consulting with the International Monetary Fund and the European Commission, its partners in the so-called troika of international lenders. 
But in a tacit warning that it would not provide assistance forever, the central bank said it would stick to rules that allow lending only to solvent banks. The Cyprus banks, while wobbly, are not yet insolvent.
Cyprus' finance minister, Michalis Sarris, is in Moscow today for talks with the Russians. Apparently, as reported today by Andrew Kramer, there is a Gazprom deal on the table to provide Cyprus bailout money in exchange for exploration rights to offshore gas deposits:
Though not widely publicized, the Russian proposal to prop up Cyprus with assets belonging to the Gazprom pension fund was apparently taken seriously enough by Germany’s chancellor, Angela Merkel. Her office issued a statement on Tuesday noting she had warned the president of Cyprus in a telephone call not to consider alternatives to the European bailout; Russia’s offer is the only known alternative. 
Michael Olympios, chairman of the Cypriot Investors Association, said one possibility under active consideration was for a Russian bank to buy Cyprus’s biggest troubled lender, the Cyprus Popular Bank, in a deal that could reduce the amount of the 10 billion euro bailout sought by Cyprus. Any such move would most likely be backed by the Kremlin, Mr. Olympios added, and could reduce the tax that Russian depositors might otherwise have to pay. 
Russian officials were preparing for talks in Moscow on Wednesday with the Cypriot finance minister, Michalis Sarris, who was expected to request that Russia postpone the maturity date on a 2.5 billion euro loan that it extended to Cyprus in 2011.
A detailed post this morning on naked capitalism, "Gaming the Cyprus Negotiations," argues that there is indeed a chance that a deal might not be reached:
My belief is that there are a lot of moving parts, and while it is perfectly rational for everyone to come to some sort of deal, the principals have a lousy negotiating dynamic at work. Russia has been excluded and is feeling angry and abused, and the Wall Street Journal description of the 10 hours negotiations that led to the original deal sound nightmarish: confused, chaotic, dysfunctional. It’s proof of the old notion that people (in this case finance ministers) should never negotiate their own deals unless they are super experienced negotiators (and pretty much everyone overestimates their negotiating skills). And these all-over-the-map negotiations took place when the principals were in the same location. It’s worse doing this sort of things by phone and e-mail.
So the odds are not trivial that a deal fails to come together, not because a pact is impossible (as in there is appears to be a bargaining space where everyone could find a solution they could swallow) but that the key actors will be unable to get to that agreement before time runs out. Stay tuned.
I think there's some merit to this point of view. But in the end we're talking about a tiny amount of money in the Great Power scheme of things. Certainly you would think someone -- Putin? Merkel? Draghi? -- would intervene.