Showing posts with label East Ghouta. Show all posts
Showing posts with label East Ghouta. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 13, 2018

The U.S. has been Warned

From a Reuters story, "U.S. warns it may act on Syria as onslaught against Ghouta grinds on," by
Michelle Nichols and Suleiman Al-Khalidi:
The Observatory, said on Monday the death toll in the civil war had passed half a million people.
It has confirmed the deaths of 511,000 people, it said, and has the names of more than 350,000 of them. About 85 percent were killed by government forces and their allies, it said. [Putting to one side the veracity of the 85% claim, how many would have died if the former colonial powers along with their allies in the GCC hadn't underwritten one of the largest covert wars in history?]
Eastern Ghouta has been besieged for years after many of its residents joined the initial protests against Assad’s rule in 2011 that triggered the slide into civil war. The United Nations says 400,000 people live in the enclave, already suffering shortages of food and medicine even before the massive assault began in mid-February.
Assad says the assault on eastern Ghouta is needed to end the rule of Islamist insurgents over the civilian population and to stop mortar fire on nearby Damascus. [Perfectly reasonable. Any head of state would take the same position.]
The United Nations has warned of dire shortages of food and medicine, where international deliveries have long been erratic and often obstructed before they could reach the enclave.
The expulsion of the rebels from eastern Ghouta would represent their biggest defeat since they lost their enclave in Aleppo in December 2016. They still control large areas in the northwest and southwest and a few scattered pockets elsewhere but have been driven from most major population centers.
From a CNBC story, "Russian military threatens action against the US in Syria," by Holly Ellyatt:
The Russian military has threatened action against the U.S. if it strikes Syria's capital city of Damascus, according to multiple news reports.
The threat, by Chief of Russia's General Staff Valery Gerasimov, was widely reported by Russia media sites such as state news agency RIA and Tass. It said Gerasimov said Russia had "reliable information" about militants preparing to falsify a government chemical attack against civilians.
He continued by saying the U.S. would then use this attack to accuse Syrian government troops of using chemical weapons. He added that the U.S. would then plan to launch a missile strike on government districts in Damascus.
"In several districts of Eastern Ghouta, a crowd was assembled with women, children and old people, brought from other regions, who were to represent the victims of the chemical incident, " Gerasimov said, according to RIA.
Gerasimov said Russia would respond to a U.S. strike on Syria if the lives of Russian servicemen were threatened, targeting any missiles and launchers involved.
"In case there is a threat to the lives of our military, the Russian Armed Force will take retaliatory measures both over the missiles and carriers that will use them," he said. [About as clear a warning as you can get.]
The U.S. Department of Defense urged Russia to "stop creating distractions" and "enabling the Assad regime's brutality" in a statement sent to CNBC responding to the allegations. [When has the brutality of an allied regime ever distracted the United States?]
The chemical weapons canard has lost all bearing to reality. Official organs of the prestige press like Reuters, The New York Times and the Washington Post don't even try to make sense of why the Syrian government would use a weapon that would invite an attack from the U.S. given that as, the NYT reports in its Tuesday briefing,
The Syrian government and its allies managed to split the rebel-held enclave of eastern Ghouta, a suburb of Damascus, into three blocs, each surrounded and besieged.
The fracturing of one of the last major rebel-controlled areas could be a turning point in a relentless scorched-earth campaign that had been backed by Russian airstrikes.
Some residents are demanding that rebels leave, hoping that their departure would eliminate the main reason for the bombings.
Chemical weapons are the agreed casus belli. All that's needed is a fiction, a concoction of some sort, and the Tomahawks will fly. That's why Gerasimov's statement is so significant. He is stating categorically that U.S. carriers will be hit if there is another Khan Sheikhoun.

My guess is Trump is smart enough not to start a shooting war with Russia. Let the Tories try that one on for size.

Thursday, February 22, 2018

Let's Keep Our Eyes Peeled for Another Bogus Chemical Weapons Attack in Syria

The New York Times editorial board is calling for the leadership of Syria, Russia and Iran to be tried for war crimes (see "Who Has Innocent Syrians’ Blood on Their Hands?") as it laments the lack of a broader U.S.-led UN-backed regime-change operation to collapse the Syrian government.

Jordan Shilton of Word Socialist Web Site answers that the U.S. has plenty of innocent Syrian blood on its hands (see "Syrian government offensive prompts calls for intensified US military intervention"):
When the battle shifted to Raqqa last summer, US war planes were slaughtering more than 100 innocent civilians every week as they dropped high-powered explosives on residential areas. In the end, to pursue its broader strategic goals of preventing Iran from consolidating control of eastern Syria and opening up a land corridor from Tehran to Damascus, Washington allowed thousands of ISIS fighters to escape Raqqa so they could take on pro-Assad forces.
Throughout both of these shameful episodes, which international rights groups criticized as war crimes, the Times and other establishment media mouthpieces not only buried reports of civilian casualties, not to mention images or videos from the war zone, but positively praised the US military for its supposed restraint in carrying out air strikes.
Elijah J Magnier sees the ongoing developments in Afrin as the beginning of the end for Rojava:
Only one month after the beginning of the “Olive Branch” operation, the Afrin administration began to understand the reality of the power struggle- but yet not completely. Russia is teaching the Kurds a lesson so that these understand the price of plying for favors from the US. The US feels impotent towards the Kurds and exposed, forced to reveal its plans for staying in Syria and for occupying a piece of its territory regardless of the defeat of ISIS. The Kurds can’t yet fully grasp the extent to which they are wood for the Syrian fire, caught between two superpowers.
In Syria, there are only two alternatives: either Moscow or Washington forces will remain in Syria (if the game remains rough), or they will cohabit as they did in Berlin after the Second World War.
The Afrin administration doesn’t understand that for every day that goes by there will be new Syrian demands. If the Kurds continue to resist these demands, Damascus will ask for further concessions and further withdrawal of the Kurds to the east of the Euphrates, to join the US forces (and remain as a burden on them). This is also allowing Turkey to be more determined in allowing the Syrian army to regain control of Afrin.
Although the central government in Damascus agreed to send several hundreds of local militants from Nubbl and Zahraa and other national forces as a preliminary support, it is likely that the negotiations over Afrin will continue until mid-March in Kazakhstan between Russia, Turkey, Iran and Syria (indirectly), discussing not only Afrin but also Idlib- unless the Kurds acknowledge without delay all of Damascus’s conditions. Otherwise, with every day that goes by Turkey increases its influence and occupies more territory in the enclave.
Russia is not expected to be satisfied with one hit against the US in Afrin but is accelerating the end of control by al-Qaeda and other militants (Faylaq al-Rahman and Jaish al-Islam) over al Ghouta, east of Damascus. The Russians would like to see the US alone (Russia considers Turkey is the lesser evil in Syria and can deal with it later) in Syria to point out its illegal presence and therefore illegal occupation of north east Syria, particularly when the remaining of ISIS concentration is situated within the area on the Syrian-Iraqi borders which is under the US control. The US forces are now looking like a force protecting the terrorist group and allowing it to continue its existence and operations in Syria and in Iraq.
Erdogan is promising to attack Afrin city within days. If this happens, and Afrin falls to the Turks/Free Syrian Army, Rojava will not be able to deny that for all intents and purposes it is but a fig leaf for the outlaw U.S. occupation of northeast Syria.

On the other hand, if the pro-Syrian Shiite militias entering Afrin are successful in blocking "Operation Olive Branch," then, as Magnier says, the Kurds will have to accommodate further Syrian demands.

So it doesn't look good for the Kurds. And if we accept Magnier's reasoning, what is bad for the Kurds is bad for the United States.

Anytime the U.S. is looking at the "jaws of defeat" it is always wise to consider the "make the problem bigger" scenario, a favorite page in the U.S. playbook. Here, as in the past, not to mention the signal offered by the NYT editorial, it would likely be in the form of an airstrike retaliating for alleged SAA chemical weapons use. Moon of Album warned of this last week.

There would be no support in the American electorate for such an attack. But people are distracted with the Mueller indictment -- we are being told basically that all social media is compromised by Russian bots -- and the popular uprising to ban the sale of assault weapons. So if McMaster wanted, and he was able to convince Trump to front it, he could get away with it now.

Thursday, April 6, 2017

It is All About "Safe Zones"

From this morning's Foreign Policy Situation Report:
Fighting it out. FP’s Colum Lynch, Robbie Gramer and David Kenner have more on the scene at the U.N. and Russia’s angry denials that Assad was involved in the attack. Russian officials, like president Trump, blamed former President Barack Obama’s infamous “red line” for the current violence. The New York Times has a good rundown of the holes in Russia’s various accounts of that happened in Idlib on Tuesday. The Guardian reports that Syrian aid workers have already sent soil samples from the town to “western intelligence officials” for testing in the suspected sarin attack.
To give you an idea of the NYT's "good rundown," here is the concluding section to the very brief "The Holes in Russia’s Account of the Syria Chemical Attack," by Jeffrey Marcus:
Who Is Responsible
Russian officials say insurgents making chemical weapons in a facility destroyed by the Syrian airstrike are to blame. Russia’s deputy envoy to the United Nations said on Wednesday that Islamic militants fighting the government of President Bashar al-Assad have used chemical weapons before, including chlorine, mustard gas and nerve agents, in Iraq and Syria. And he said insurgents used sarin on residents of a Damascus suburb in 2013.
Western leaders including President Trump accused the Syrian government of being behind the fatal attack on Tuesday, and they called on Russia and Iran, Mr. Assad’s backers, to hold him accountable. Investigations by the United States and Western powers into the August 2013 chemical attack near Damascus that killed more than 1,400 people concluded that it had been carried out by the Syrian government.
All the "Assad did it" accounts of the 2013 sarin attack in East Ghouta were thoroughly debunked. But the mainstream media kept repeating that the Syrian government was to blame.

This is how it works. You lose the argument. But since you control the organs of the press, you just keep repeating the lie, and it becomes received wisdom, settled science.

The West and its sheikh clients need a triggering event. So they're attempting a do-over of East Ghouta. But a trigger for what? A cruise missile attack on Damascus to "decapitate" Assad? That seems too much for an addled Trump to pull off.

The Tillerson powwow in Turkey that led to the announcement of a new FSA-led coalition to rule Idlib seems to point the way. A land grab ("safe zones") for the sheikhs and spooks is underway. Syria is being carved up.

The deaths in Khan Sheikhoun are/will be used to justify a U.N. resolution creating "safe zones."

I've said it before, and I'll say it again, the Kurds in Rojava should be nervous.

Tuesday, February 14, 2017

Here We Go Again: Fabricating a Casus Belli with Syria

Last week it was Amnesty International's "HUMAN SLAUGHTERHOUSE: MASS HANGINGS AND EXTERMINATION AT SAYDNAYA PRISON, SYRIA," thoroughly demolished by Rick Sterling in his "Amnesty International Stokes Syrian War."

Then yesterday it was the Atlantic Council's "Breaking Aleppo," which, according to The New York Times' Michael Gordon, the man who helped bring us the 2003 invasion of Iraq, "The analysis shows that the hospital, contrary to claims by a Russian general, was bombed multiple times. It indicates that Russian aircraft used incendiary munitions and cluster bombs, despite the Kremlin’s denials, and concludes that Syrian forces used chlorine gas on a far greater scale than is commonly believed."

But all one needs to know about "Breaking Aleppo" comes midway through the article: "Much of the analysis of the photos and social media was done by [Eliot] Higgins, a Britain-based researcher who founded the investigative website bellingcat.com." To mention that Eliot Higgins is a principal author of the report (a guy who is clearly a government agent) without mentioning his role in using spurious arguments and bogus evidence to blame the Syrian government for the 2013 chemical attack in East Ghouta, a Damascus suburb, or his role in arguing for Russian complicity in the downing of MH17 in Eastern Ukraine is clearly misleading to the Gray Lady's readers. Once again with The New York Times we are in the realm of crass banana-fingered propaganda.

Now comes the absurd "Syria: Coordinated Chemical Attacks on Aleppo," released yesterday by Human Rights Watch (HRW). Rick Gladstone, like his colleague Michael Gordon, another spook posing as a reporter, writes breathlessly in "Syria Used Chlorine Bombs Systematically in Aleppo, Report Says" -- the opening paragraph -- that
Syrian military helicopters systematically dumped canisters of chlorine gas, a banned weapon, on residential areas of Aleppo at least eight times late last year in the final weeks of the battle to retake the city from rebels, Human Rights Watch said in a detailed study released Monday.
But skim through the report --  it is not hard to do -- and for all the video links and purported photographic evidence there is not one image of a Syrian helicopter dumping chlorine canisters! An example of the willful suspension of disbelief that Human Rights Watch is asking of us can be found below:
Omar Arnaout, a photographer, said that he saw a helicopter drop an object near a cemetery in Qadi Askar at about 3 p.m. on November 28:
"Suddenly, yellow smoke started spreading followed by the smell of chlorine a few minutes later. It’s the smell of the liquid that we use to clean toilet, but more intense, much more intense. People were unable to breathe, they are coughing. Some children were throwing up. The smell was everywhere."
Arnaout said that about 20 civilians were injured in the attack and taken to hospitals for treatment.
If he is a photographer, why didn't he take a picture of the helicopter? I guess he didn't have his camera with him. Then why in this instance, which is supposed to document a Syrian helicopter dropping a chlorine bomb, mention that he is a photographer? Clearly it is a rhetorical sleight of hand meant to convey to the reader photographic evidence where there is none.

The HRW report is chock full of everything we've seen plenty of times before -- pictures of spent shell casings, eyewitness testimony from jihadis posing as citizen activists, photos of babies in emergency rooms receiving oxygen.

The overall idea is to reboot the Western war on Syria now that the Syrian-Russian-Iranian coalition is about to conquer the Western-backed jihadis; that, and block the Trump administration from working with Russia. With Flynn out it looks like the U.S. posture to Syria will be identical to the one during Obamatime.

Monday, September 9, 2013

Will the AUMF Pass Congress?

In trying to predict how Congress will vote on granting the Obama administration Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF) against Syria, a good place to start is with the same question people should be asking about the chemical attack on August 21 on a Damascus suburb, "Cui bono?"

Who benefited from the gas attack? Certainly not the Syrian government. The opposition had everything to gain in perpetrating the attack because it provocatively crossed a red line that Obama had previously laid down. Since the Obama administration has been publicly predicting the collapse of the Assad regime for some time, and since it has a covert program in Jordan to train and arm rebels, and since the United States has worked to block United Nations investigators from entering Syria at the invitation of the government to assess the possibility that chemical arms were used in the Khan al-Assal massacre (the UN inspection team was in Syria last month to investigate Khan al-Assal when they were sidetracked by the East Ghouta chemical attack), the obvious conclusion to draw is that a chemical weapons attack -- any chemical attack -- would be blamed reflexively on the Syrian government.

But who benefits if Congress passes the AUMF? Certainly not the American people, who will have to pay for and fight any conflict, and not any senator or congressman or congresswoman who votes for it, whether Democrat or Republican, because he/she will likely, based on the overwhelming opposition so far to another foreign military intervention, face a spirited primary challenge. The only beneficiary in the U.S. body politic, besides the overarching "National Security State" with its weapons manufacturers and think-tank pundits and surveillance chiefs, is the Obama administration.

Why would the Republican-controlled House do anything to benefit Obama? The answer is that it wouldn't. That's why it is safe to say that the AUMF won't clear the House. There are some who argue that AIPAC is all powerful and money rules the roost in D.C. and Congress is totally venal. But we have a recent example where this wasn't the case -- sequestration. Republicans were willing to sacrifice the military in order to achieve across-the-board budget cuts.

The result in the Senate is anyone's guess. My sense is that despite Obama's upcoming Tuesday speech and all the over-the-top inflammatory rhetoric of Secretary of State John Kerry -- saying that this vote is the country's "Munich moment" or that Assad refuses to negotiate when it is in fact the United States and its ally the Syrian National Coalition that refuses to negotiate -- the public will not shift its anti-war stance.

Senators are more insulated than those who serve in the House: their terms are longer and they can raise money more easily. There will be senators who will stick with Obama thinking that they can weather the storm of voter disgust. But will there be enough to get the AUMF out of the senate? The Obama administration can make no missteps. All the news coming out of Syria has to go the administration's way. There has to be a positive response to Obama's call for war from the White House. People suddenly have to soften to John Kerry's brazen warmongering. Rand Paul's filibuster has to fizzle.

That's a lot of stuff that needs to break the warhawks' way. This doesn't mean it can't happen. The state is powerful, and there's always the possibility of a watered-down AUMF squeaking through. But at the end of the day, even if an AUMF in some form emerges from the Senate, you're still left with a No vote in the House. Shenanigans in any House-Senate conference are almost guaranteed. Assuming Obama waits this long to launch the Tomahawks, the United Nations report on what happened in East Ghouta should be available by then.

Friday, September 6, 2013

The People vs. Obama

Here's something to consider, the distilled wisdom of the Obama administration, in the form of a quote from its prodigy Benjamin Rhodes as he makes the pitch to Congress to authorize military force against Syria:
“One thing for Congress to consider,” said Benjamin J. Rhodes, his deputy national security adviser, “is the message that this debate sends about U.S. leadership around the world — that the U.S. for decades has played the role of undergirding the global security architecture and enforcing international norms. And we do not want to send a message that the United States is getting out of that business in any way.”
This from Peter Baker's "White House Looks to Syria Vote as Rudder for Rest of Term." Needless to say, this is exactly the message the voters are sending to Congressional Representatives, "Get us out of the business of being the world police." You hear it time and again. "Let's spend the money here at home." It's so obvious and sensible, it requires an immense perversity to try to persuade people otherwise. Obama's electoral success was largely due to his ability to convince people that he felt as they did; he campaigned as a leader who would do some "nation building here at home."

But now what's on display is the polar opposite. According to Peter Baker's story, the administration is relying on a version of the domino theory to rally Congressional support for the authority to strike Syria. The argument goes something like, "If you don't show we mean business on Syria then Iran will start pumping out nuclear bombs and Israel will be imperiled." It's the Sunday funnies version of reality; it has held sway with Congress before, but now times are different.

To get a snapshot of the anti-war mindset that dominates the country today, read Michael Wines' dispatch from Waynesburg, PA, "Skepticism and Wariness in Talk of Syria Attack":
Jennifer Taylor said that she was managing the officers’ club at the Marine Corps Air Station in Cherry Point, N.C., and cheering on Mr. Bush when American forces invaded Iraq. But this week, from her spot tending bar at Hot Rod’s, she was decidedly against the use of force in Syria and questioned Mr. Obama’s motivations in proposing it. 
“Obama was against” the invasion of Iraq, Ms. Taylor noted, “and I don’t understand why he’s changed his stance.” Seconds later, she offered an explanation: “He’s having trouble keeping his popularity up; this war on guns has made him unpopular. And this is his way of getting back up.” 
Indeed, her customer, Mr. Tripp, suggested that the use of chemical weapons was actually a plot by Al Qaeda to lure the United States into toppling the Syrian government, and that Mr. Obama was falling for it. Terrorists will rush into the vacuum once Mr. Assad is gone, he warned.
You won't find any in-depth coverage by the Gray Lady of a false flag attack being at the center of what happened in East Ghouta on August 21, but there are plenty of voters who are willing to consider the possibility.

No, Obama still has a steep climb ahead of him. It's a classic Mr. Smith Goes to Washington showdown. The people -- represented by who? -- against the institutional power structure represented by Obama and the fourth estate and D.C. beltway neoliberal elites.

No one should believe Obama that the bombing of Syria will be limited and surgical. David Sanger and Eric Schmitt have a story this morning, "Pentagon Is Ordered to Expand Potential Targets in Syria With a Focus on Forces," that puts that lie to rest.

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

AIPAC vs. The American Public

At the end of this morning's story "House Leaders Express Their Support for Syria Strike," by Mark Landler, Michael Gordon and Thom Shanker, finally comes a mention of the reality that Obama and his war cabinet are trying to subvert:
The calendar is Mr. Obama’s enemy: Many members from both parties are still back in their districts hearing from constituents, and the feedback, based on numerous interviews, is overwhelmingly negative. 
On Tuesday, however, a powerful pro-Israel lobbying group, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, threw its support behind military action in Syria, citing the need to send a strong message to Iran and the militant group Hezbollah, both of which support Mr. Assad.
Any gauge of sanity and basic fairness, given the decade-plus ongoing foreign occupations following 9/11 and the recent Snowden revelations of an omnipresent surveillance state that has metastasized since then, has the American public clearly in the right on this issue. Public opinion was wrong to support Bush II's invasion of Iraq, but Cheney, Wolfowitz, Rumsfeld & Co. were shrewd in their use of the fear and anger 9/11 created to sow enough confusion with their bogus intelligence to pull off the crime (so far) of the century.

Now is a different time. We're coming to the end of the 9/11 era, which also happens to be the end of the Arab Spring. People might have looked the other way on Libya because of a heady rush caused by toppling Arab dictators, but no mas. The 2012 Benghazi attack put to rest the fallacy of a problem-free intervention.

The American citizenry has been treated to a series of budget crises by a divided national political class. And suddenly that political class is coming together, but not to fund a public works project or expand early childhood education. No, the national political leadership is joined in an embrace of the Obama request for an Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF). In other words, folks, you get to carry and pay for guns but you get no butter.

And the public understands the screwing it's getting. Support for bombing Syria has not grown since the Obama team has "flooded the zone" and the nation's fourth estate has resumed its role from the run up to Iraq's invasion -- cheerleader for illegal warfare and megaphone of tendentious intelligence. It is unquestioned in the Western media that the Syrian government is responsible for attacking the Damascus suburb of Ghouta. The unverified death toll of 1,400 is unquestioned as well. Pleas to "Save the children!" are made incessantly by beautiful, young cable news anchors. But despite all this American public opinion is unmoved.

This is not to say that the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) doesn't have a few tricks left to pull on us. Opinion might tilt a few points in the direction of launching the Tomahawks. But I don't think so. I think this will be a clear case of "which side are you on?" The 10-7 vote in the Senate Foreign Relations Committee augurs a divided Senate. But the real challenge for AIPAC and other warhawks will be in the House.

If the AUMF passes the House of Representatives, given everything that we've been through since the millennium, I think it's safe to say that electoral democracy is officially dead in this country.

Tuesday, September 3, 2013

Cable News Bloodlust

Away from the Internet since Saturday, I relied on a steady diet of cable news for my information. My mother, who is a resident of an assisted living facility, usually has her television tuned to CNN, but she bounces regularly to MSNBC and Fox, as well as the local PBS affiliate. So I got what I think is fairly representative sampling.

And I don't know why I was shocked but I was. The obscene war lust and crass propaganda was appalling. First off, there is a complete acceptance, absent any caveats that the assessment is being provided by intelligence agencies that assured us that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction, that the Syrian government is the perpetrator of the chemical weapons attack two weeks ago. No exploration of the possibility that the rebels might have launched such an attack despite the fact that there is ample reporting saying as much. No discussion of why John Kerry is always getting out in front of the UN chemical weapons investigation team, first by falsely claiming that their efforts to collect samples in East Ghouta was a waste of time because of Syrian Arab Army shelling, and then by saying that hair and blood samples from first responders to the Ghouta attack tested positive for signatures of sarin, even though a signature of sarin is very different from sarin exposure itself (see yesterday's excellent "Moon of Alabama" post for a discussion of this).

But worst of all are the crude appeals for violence on behalf of children being victimized by the brute Assad. Ann Curry provides the most excessive, ludicrous example of this. It's a rhetorical specialty of the humanitarian bombers: We have to blow up children to save the children. While Curry discussed her harrowing visit to the Zaatari refugee camp in Jordan she shared a split screen with rotating still images of refugee children. It was like watching a SPCA commercial.

There were a few bright spots. CNN interviewed Congressman Alan Grayson (D-Florida) a couple of times and each time he absolutely destroyed -- completely silenced -- the talking-head warhawks. To paraphrase: "It's a civil war. Sending in cruise missiles is not going to enhance our credibility or send a message to Iran or save any children. It's going to cost a billion dollars -- money that should be spent here at home -- and not do anything but make things worse." Congresswoman Janice Hahn was also excellent. To paraphrase: "When I attended Labor Day picnics and parades people kept coming up to me saying, 'Whatever you do, don't send us into another war.' "

In addition to being absent from the Internet, I was also away from the New York Times for Sunday and Monday. Dipping back in today, it's apparent to me that going to Congress with a blank-check Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF) Obama is looking to make a much larger strike than he has been calling for in public. There is no doubt that what is being contemplated by the elites who run the show is an open-ended military engagement that will likely last for a generation or two. Take down Syria, mop up Hezbollah, go after Iran. It's hard to understand where they see the support in the general populous for this Battle of Armageddon. There is certainly support among the rulers of Saudi Arabia and Israeli Likudniks. But among your average Democrat and Republican? No, absolutely not. It's baffling. Are elites that out of touch? Apparently.

The problem we have as citizens of this country is that we have no effective institutions to communicate our will. Congress is bought and so are the ever-shrinking unions. We can vote the bums out but it's usually too little and too late. And when new representatives get to D.C. -- what Nader called "corporate occupied territory" -- it's hard for them not to be quickly compromised.

There's still a possibility that enough Tea Party Republicans and Progressive Democrats -- fearful for their own survival -- will ban together and block the AUMF in the House. That's our best bet. It might seem fruitless, but practice some civic faith and take time to either write or call your Senators and Congressional Representative.

Saturday, August 31, 2013

"U.S. Assessment of Syrian Use of Chemical Weapons" a Faith-Based Document

If you take the time to read "U.S. Assessment of Syrian Use of Chemical Weapons" -- it was released yesterday and is only a few pages and takes no more than five minutes to ingest -- you'll quickly come to the conclusion that it is a "faith based" document. No compelling proof is offered of Syrian government responsibility for the chemical attack that occurred in the early morning of August 21 in the Damascus suburb of East Ghouta; in fact, no proof is offered at all other than frequent references to social media.

Intercepted signal traffic, frequently referred to in the media and often cited by the Obama administration, is the assessment's smoking gun. But it is not provided. We still haven't heard it or read a transcript of it. So it doesn't make sense to shred the United Nations Charter and launch an attack on a country based on an opaque assessment from a government guilty of one of the worst canards in recorded history with its bogus intelligence manufactured to show that Iraq possessed a potent arsenal of weapons of mass destruction. We are supposed to accept on faith that the smoking gun exists.

There are two massive doubts to consider, doubts which prevent a facile acceptance of this document:

Number one, if the evidence is of such quality that it produces a "high confidence assessment" that "is the strongest position that the U.S. Intelligence Community can take short of confirmation," why dismiss the work of the UN investigators on the ground and try to rush them out of country as soon as possible? This makes absolutely no sense. If the evidence is compelling and on your side you want the investigators to stay and do a thorough job. The fact that John Kerry has been jawboning Ban Ki-moon to get the inspectors out of Syria casts doubt on the evidence the United States possesses. As Putin says, "Show it to us."

Number two, "cui bono" has never been remotely addressed by the Obama administration. Yes, a superficial rationale has been provided as to why Assad would use gas. The Syrian Arab Army purportedly relies on it to clear pockets of rebels that can't be cleared by conventional arms. But all the reporting, both pro- and anti-Assad, had the military making gains in this area prior to the East Ghouta attack. Most importantly, the warhawks will never acknowledge that which is the most obvious -- the opposition has been trying to get the West to intervene militarily from the outset. This fact alone, that proponents of a cruise missile assault on Syria refuse to at least accept in theory that the rebels had everything to gain from a chemical weapons attack being linked to Assad, should make us very suspicious of a rush to war.

****

I'm out of town for the next few days. "Burdens of a Bachelor" will return Tuesday.

Thursday, August 29, 2013

Growing U.S. Isolation on Syria

In the space of a day the seemingly inexorable U.S.-led run up to war on Syria appears to have come undone. Obama is still talking tough but it is apparent that the United States is for now almost entirely isolated. The United Nations is clearly on record with statements by Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and Special Envoy to Syria Lakhdar Brahimi that the inspectors be given time to do their job and that any military action must be approved by the Security Council. Adding to the Obama administration's woes is an announcement yesterday by Syrian UN ambassador Bashar Jaafari that
[H]e had submitted evidence of the three new instances of chemical weapons use in Syria, which he asserted had been carried out by armed terrorist groups, the government’s blanket term for Syrian opposition forces.

Mr. Jaafari said they occurred on Aug. 22, 24 and 25, and were also in the Damascus suburbs. He said Syrian soldiers were the targets. The ambassador did not explain why he waited to come forth with the allegations. 
“The Syrian government is requesting the secretary general to immediately instruct the investigation team operating in Damascus to investigate immediately these three heinous crimes,” the ambassador said. 
Mr. Jaafari repeated the Syrian government’s denials that it had ever used chemical weapons in the conflict and said the accusations were a conspiracy by Western nations acting on Israel’s behalf. He rejected assertions by the United States, Britain and other Western allies that there was persuasive evidence of Syrian government culpability in the use of the banned weapons. 
“We are not warmongers,” he told reporters outside the Security Council chambers. “We are a peaceful nation seeking stability.”
This from a story by Stephen Castle, Steven Erlanger and Rick Gladstone, "Britain to Wait on Weapons Report Ahead of Syria Strikes," which, given the extensive coverage in the press this morning, is probably the best single story on yesterday's setback for the warhawks.

Responding to Britain's failed effort to clear a authorization of force out of the Security Council, State Department spokeswoman Marie Harf did her best to impersonate the bellicose tones of former Bush UN ambassador John Bolton:
“All previous attempts to get the Security Council to act on Syria have been blocked, and we cannot allow diplomatic paralysis to be a shield for the perpetrators of these crimes,” she said. “We do not believe that the Syrian regime should be able to hide behind the fact that the Russians continue to block action on Syria at the U.N.” 
Asked if the United States would await the findings of the United Nations inspectors, Ms. Harf repeated the administration’s assertions that their work was too late to be credible because Syrian government forces had repeatedly shelled the attack sites, compromising evidence-gathering efforts. 
“We’re going to make our own decisions on our own timelines about our response,” she said. “Obviously, we will continue consultations with our international partners around the world, but we are making decisions based on our own timeline.”
It's all right out of the Bush playbook. It's as if we're suddenly reliving the end of 2002 and the beginning of 2003. But the good news here is that while in the past Obama has been able to successfully put over the same old Bush policies -- drones, surges -- because of his gravitas as a Nobel Peace Prize winner, those days are effectively done.

Cameron had to agree to two not one Parliamentary votes spread out over nearly a week. The debate promises to be lively with the warhawks taking a drubbing since their position is riddled with contradictions and omissions. What's the purpose of limited strikes other than to kill more innocents? Why can't the rebels be behind the Ghouta chemical attack? Unlike Iraq, why not let the inspectors complete their mission this time? The U.S. Congress, though less convincingly than its British cousins, is also demanding a debate and a vote.

Today the Obama administration will reveal its "irrefutable evidence" of Syrian government responsibility for last week's chemical attack. Its lies -- Biden repeated again yesterday the canard that Syrian Arab Army shelling of the site of the chemical attack has rendered any inspection not credible -- and silence up until now foretell a presentation that will be underwhelming.

Wednesday, August 28, 2013

Western Warhawks Headed for Tough Times

For the first time since the end of last week a ray of sunshine, of reason, of hope this morning that there will be some pushback against the Western war machine. The Arab League declined to endorse an attack on Syria. This queers the pitch for Obama and the leaders of the old colonial powers Britain and France. They say that they got what they needed in the form of a Arab League statement blaming the Syrian government for the chemical attack in a Damascus suburb last Wednesday. Nonetheless they're embarking on an illegal war with very little if any popular mandate. They have no support domestically, and they can't even get a public go-ahead from the Gulf emirates who have been fueling the conflict and aggressively lobbying for U.S. intervention.

The story can be read this morning in David Kirkpatrick (thank goodness for David Kirkpatrick) and Mark Landler's "Arab League Stance Muddies U.S. Case." Doubtless the warhawks in the West wish for now they had Morsi back running the show in Cairo rather than the generals. It was Egypt that stood up to the Saudis and blocked harsher language against Assad from being included in the Arab League statement:
But while they will not say it publicly, several countries in the region have been working vigorously behind the scenes to topple the Assad government. For two years, the governments of Saudi Arabia, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates and Turkey have been shipping money and arms to rebels challenging Syrian troops. Neither Saudi Arabia nor any of the Sunni-dominated gulf states have publicly endorsed Western intervention. But all feel threatened by the regional rivalry with Iran, and all have privately urged the Western powers to intervene on behalf of the rebels, Western diplomats say. 
In the Arab League meeting on Tuesday, Arab diplomats said, Saudi Arabia pushed for stronger language explicitly condemning Mr. Assad for launching the attack, which would have come closer to helping the Western powers justify military action. 
But Egypt, still the most populous Arab state with the largest Arab military, disagreed, Arab diplomats said. 
“It shows the schizophrenia of the Arab world,” said Salman Shaikh, director of the Brookings Doha Center, noting that gulf states and Jordan also appear to be working closely with the West on possible intervention while refusing to endorse it publicly. 
But their silence created a potential problem for the United States and its European allies, he said, because it undermined the notion of a broad-based coalition with Arab support. “And every day that it goes on, opponents will try to exploit it,” he said.
And more trouble awaits the West today when Britain takes the Western case for war on Syria to the United Nations. At this point the West will have to reveal the evidence it has linking the Syrian government to the chemical attack in Ghouta. Up until now all that Secretary of State John Kerry and Press Secretary Jay Carney have mentioned is a circumstantial case: a chemical attack occurred; the Syrian government possesses chemical weapons; therefore it is beyond doubt that the Syrian government is responsible for the attack. This is the threadbare reasoning that the United States has relied on in its run up to war. Appalling, isn't it? There has been some whispering in the media about intercepted signal traffic that has Syrian government forces directing operations of the chemical attack. But the fact that Britain will be doing the heavy lifting at the UN leads one to believe that the Obama administration is leery about repeating a Colin Powell moment.

In any event, a debate will be had in a global forum, and it promises to be unkind to the bellicose Western perspective. The Brits will then hold a Parliamentary debate tomorrow which should also prove to be rough going for the Tories. Archbishop of Canterbury, Most Rev. Justin Welby, weighed in with a plea for caution and good sense in a Daily Telegraph interview yesterday. Foreign Secretary William Hague, who has been the point man for the Western warhawks, provided the case for intervention, which basically boils down to "We have to violate the UN Charter to protect decades of painstaking work to create rules and regulations to prevent the use of chemical weapons"; that, and the by now -- coming on the heels of support for the Egyptian military coup of a duly elected government -- totally unbelievable tripe about democratic nations living up to their values.

I imagine it's going to be rough going in the days ahead for the warhawks. It doesn't mean that an attack on Syria will not go forward, just that the West is going to pay a price for it, and I hope it's a steep one. Iran is threatening retaliation. Already the Obama administration is talking up the limited nature of its attack -- just some Tomahawk cruise missiles. I wouldn't believe it. And even if the strikes are limited there are always targeting errors and civilian casualties.

A major impediment to the Western case for intervention is the obviously counterintuitive nature of the Syrian government gassing a suburb shortly after the UN inspectors arrive into the country. Tactically there was no call for the attack. There is almost unanimous agreement that the SAA had no need for chemicals; the military was racking up steady gains in the area. The worst thing that Assad had to fear was foreign intervention, the very thing that the opposition has been trying to initiate for years. The rebels had everything to gain and Assad nothing by the use of chemical weapons.

So clearly the basic framework of the civil war up until now points to opposition being the perpetrators of the chemical attack in Ghouta. This is obviously a problem for the warhawks; hence, the story today by CIA scribe and rebel propagandist Anne Barnard, "Reports of Syria Chemical Attack Spur Question: Why?" It's a weak piece of tendentious reporting, but we've come to expect that from Barnard. From the outset she assumes that the Syrian government is the source of the chemical attacks; then she interviews a couple think tank hacks who explain that Assad ordered the attacks because he could, that he knew that there would be no repercussions.

If you were expecting more, that's all there is, which, incidentally, is identical to statement put out by the Syrian National Coalition. No where does Barnard engage the Syrian or Russian position and ask the question "Why would the rebels use chemicals on their own supporters?" The answer of course is too obvious. It's unfolding before our eyes.

Friday, August 23, 2013

Bad News Day

Some mornings are worse than others, but I can't remember a more depressing start to the day than what's in the news today.

First, let's take the story by David Kirkpatrick and Rob Nordland, "Mubarak Is Moved From Prison to House Arrest, Stoking Anger of Islamists":
Mr. Mubarak was released from prison the same day that a committee of jurists released a proposed constitutional overhaul that would in many ways bring back the Mubarak-era charter. 
The package would remove some provisions about the role of religion approved by last year’s Islamist-led constitutional assembly. The main addition in that charter set a framework for applying the principles of Shariah law, in accordance with established Sunni Muslim thought. But the overhaul preserves a longstanding clause grounding Egyptian law in the principles of Shariah. It brings back another clause left out last year that would limit women’s equality where it contradicts Shariah. 
On the question of rights, freedoms, women’s equality or decentralization, the proposed overhaul provides little or no improvement, legal analysts said. It still leaves broad and ill-defined loopholes for limiting freedoms of speech and assembly. On all those questions, “it is essentially the same,” said Zaid al-Ali, a researcher at the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance. “No one’s life in Egypt is going to improve because of these proposed changes.”
At the outset of the June 30 Coup there were those on the Left who argued that the SCAF was ushering in a new age of toleration, secularism and democracy for Egypt. I think it's clear now that's not going to be the case; rather, it's back to an aggressive form of Mubarakism.

Next, for a look at the contours of a Talibanized Syria take the time to read C.J. Chivers account of the Nusra Front abduction, imprisonment and torture of American photographer Matthew Schrier in "American Tells of Odyssey as Prisoner of Syrian Rebels."

And finally, for the coup de grace, take in "Obama Officials Weigh Response to Syria Assault," by Mark Landler, Mark Mazzetti and Alissa Rubin. The U.S. war machine rumbles into readiness regardless of reason. Not once in the story is the question asked, Why, with UN inspectors newly arrived into the country, would the Syrian government launch the deadliest chemical weapons attack since the infamous gassing by Saddam Hussein of the Kurdish village of Halabja in 1988? To the credit of Washington Post, its reporters Loveday Morris and Colum Lynch do:
The [UN Security Council] diplomat and his colleagues remain puzzled at what motivation Syrian authorities would have to undertake a chemical weapons attack while U.N. inspectors were in the area. 
“We are all asking ourselves this same question, this is not logical,” the diplomat said. “What would be their interest in launching such an attack?” 
Note the absurd answer supplied by the rebels:
Khalid Saleh, a spokesman for the Syrian Opposition Coalition, called on Assad to allow access to the U.N. team if he had nothing to hide. 
“The reason they’ve done it now is very simple,” he said. “It’s such a strong message to Syrians. The regime is telling people, we own you, we can do anything even when the inspectors are here, and we know the international community won’t act.”
The Big Lie has been a success so far. This morning it's being reported that Russia is urging Syria to allow Ake Sellstrom's UN inspection team access to East Ghouta where the chemical attack took place. Regardless of the facts uncovered plans for war will proceed.