Serious -- seemingly serious, at least -- moves are underway by the big players in Syria's nearly five-year-old war. Kerry was in Moscow last night meeting with Lavrov and Putin. The discussion, as reported by the "newspaper of record" (in separate stories by Andrew Kramer and Ben Hubbard), centered on what opposition groups will be allowed to attend peace talks in New York at the end of this week.
Last week the Saudis convened their own conference of the opposition in Riyadh. ISIS and Jabhat al-Nusra weren't invited, but neither were the Syrian Kurds, the only truly consistent anti-jihadi secular fighting force. Things basically fell apart when Ahrar al-Sham dropped out. The main non-ISIS anti-Assad fighting force is the "Army of Conquest," made up predominantly of Jabhat al-Nusra and Ahrar al-Sham units. Without the principal components of the Army of Conquest participating in the talks, it is hard to imagine a substantive peace deal emerging from the ongoing Geneva process. The Saudi conference did not help matters by reiterating the "Assad Must Go" mantra as a precondition for negotiations, which Kerry was careful to disavow in Moscow.
Something is definitely shifting. Obama appeared at the Pentagon on Monday and called out the Turks, Saudis and other members of the GCC. If the waves of immigrants from the Middle East and Africa didn't cause a change in course, Paris and San Bernardino certainly have. The French neoliberal center dodged a bullet with Le Pen's underwhelming performance in the second round of regional elections. But Trump is surging.
A once somnambulant but now stirring electorate, combined with Russian gains on the ground in Syria, have highlighted the massive failure of the West's anti-ISIS military campaign. The original promise made last year was that Mosul would be liberated by the end of 2015. When that was met with howls of derision, the time table was sped up to the spring. Now it is apparent that not even the December date will be met.
And what has to be troubling for the United States is that its New Cold War, based as it is on the February 2014 coup in Kiev, is beginning to lose its luster in the capitals of Europe. Italy delayed the renewal of the EU's economic sanctions against Russia.
The goal has always been regime change in Syria. The stakes increased when Obama pushed through the P5+1 nuclear deal with Iran. In order to gain the support of his allies among the sheikhs, Obama had to recommit to taking out Assad; that is being pursued by the old routine of employing jihadist proxies. Now that the jihadist proxy war is creating destabilizing blow back in the West, Obama is hoping that once again a deal can be hatched with Russia.
It is too late probably to prevent Syria from going the way of Libya. But maybe Europe and most of Iraq can be salvaged.
Showing posts with label Geneva II. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Geneva II. Show all posts
Wednesday, December 16, 2015
Significant Moves Underway to Hasten Peace Deal on Syria
Labels:
Ahrar al-Sham,
Al-Nusra Front,
Andrew Kramer,
Army of Conquest,
Bashar al-Assad,
Ben Hubbard,
Geneva II,
John Kerry,
Obama,
Paris terror attacks,
Russia,
Saudi Arabia,
Sergey Lavrov,
Vladimir Putin
Tuesday, February 18, 2014
Get Ready for Blowback
At the start of this past three-day holiday weekend I was feeling good. I awoke early, did a few loads of laundry, and then got in a four-mile run. All that before 10 AM. I then checked in on Moon of Alabama and the blog entry "Real Or Propaganda? New Weapons To Syrian Mercenaries."
A shift is underway among the "Friends of Syria," a.k.a., Al Qaeda steering committee, to increase military pressure on the Syrian government. With the total collapse of the latest round of peace talks in Geneva, the "Friends of Syria" are staring down at a large plate of crow. Their strategy so far has been a failure. Syria has not collapsed. She is being cracked, but she still stands. And militarily, thanks to Russian-supplied helicopters, she is gaining momentum and regaining territory. Also, and perhaps equally important, Syria is winning the propaganda war. Voters within the Western bloc of the "Friends of Syria," despite a daily pummeling of images of broken children pulled from bomb rubble and words descrying Assad's use of barrel bombs against civilians, are clearly opposed to any military aid for the opposition, which at this point appears to be entirely composed of radical Sunni fundamentalist jihadis.
But after reading the comments on Moon of Alabama, I started to feel ill. "Here we go again," I thought. Rather than accept the fact that its plans have been a failure, the United States and its allies appear to be committed to expanding the violence: manpads to the rebels in a vain hope to neutralize Syrian air power. Here is how Michael Gordon, David Sanger and Eric Schmitt put it this morning in "U.S. Scolds Russia as It Weighs Options on Syrian War":
The U.S. decision to blame Russia for the impasse on Syria seems particularly stupid. Russia will not be hectored to the bargaining table to negotiate away the Syrian state, particularly after Victoria Nuland's performance in Kiev.
And what makes the present course of the Obama administration so dicey is that it is in opposition to its putative base of popular support. If Obama, already listing dangerously in the polls, continues to proceed down this bellicose path he will find the Democratic Party split and vulnerable come November, with the Senate likely returning to Republican control.
The fourth estate is doing its part, banging the war drum by focusing its coverage of the Syrian war primarily on the government's use of barrel bombs against rebel-controlled neighborhoods in Homs and Aleppo. But it will not compel any popular support for greater U.S. involvement. After the disaster of Iraq and Afghanistan, coupled with the devastating impact of the ongoing Great Recession, one would have to be entirely insane to back another belligerent escapade in the Middle East. And while the masses might be confused and uninformed, they are not insane. It is the governing elites, seemingly disconnected from everyday reality, who are insane.
A shift is underway among the "Friends of Syria," a.k.a., Al Qaeda steering committee, to increase military pressure on the Syrian government. With the total collapse of the latest round of peace talks in Geneva, the "Friends of Syria" are staring down at a large plate of crow. Their strategy so far has been a failure. Syria has not collapsed. She is being cracked, but she still stands. And militarily, thanks to Russian-supplied helicopters, she is gaining momentum and regaining territory. Also, and perhaps equally important, Syria is winning the propaganda war. Voters within the Western bloc of the "Friends of Syria," despite a daily pummeling of images of broken children pulled from bomb rubble and words descrying Assad's use of barrel bombs against civilians, are clearly opposed to any military aid for the opposition, which at this point appears to be entirely composed of radical Sunni fundamentalist jihadis.
But after reading the comments on Moon of Alabama, I started to feel ill. "Here we go again," I thought. Rather than accept the fact that its plans have been a failure, the United States and its allies appear to be committed to expanding the violence: manpads to the rebels in a vain hope to neutralize Syrian air power. Here is how Michael Gordon, David Sanger and Eric Schmitt put it this morning in "U.S. Scolds Russia as It Weighs Options on Syrian War":
Mr. Assad’s hold on power has grown over the past year, according to the head of American intelligence. Recognizing that a political settlement is unlikely if he keeps the advantage, administration officials said that Mr. Obama and other Western leaders had dropped their objections to proposals by Saudi Arabia and other countries to funnel more advanced weapons to vetted rebel groups, including portable antiaircraft weapons, often called manpads.
A secret meeting in Washington last week among the intelligence chiefs from almost all of the countries attempting to oust the Assad government included extensive discussion about how to best provide that new lethal aid to rebel groups, the officials said. The gathering of the top intelligence officials from Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Turkey, Britain, France and the United Arab Emirates, and several others from the 11-nation group known as the Friends of Syria, reflected a belief that the diplomatic track has been exhausted unless Mr. Assad sustains significant military setbacks.As Gordon et al. note in their story the Saudis have already been supplying manpads:
A fighter from the Damascus suburbs who fled to Beirut, Lebanon, said one of the reasons he left was that the Army of Islam, the rebel group led by Zahran Alloush, had surface-to-air missiles, which he said were a Syrian Army model taken from antiaircraft bases a year ago. But the Army of Islam, which is supported by Saudi private donors, has declined to share its plentiful arms and its cash with other rebel groups, particularly non-Islamist ones. That has complicated efforts to counter Mr. Assad’s forces around Damascus.
Mr. Obama’s apparent willingness to drop objections to supplying the rebel groups with heavier weapons may simply be an acknowledgment that Saudi Arabia and gulf states that are frustrated with American policy are now prepared to do so anyway, without Washington’s blessing. American officials say they also now have a better sense than they did last year about which groups they can trust to use and secure the weapons.Like Afghanistan more than thirty years ago, the United States plans on saturating the Levant with portable missiles. Expect to see some of those manpads used in the Sinai and in Iraq. It is all so predictable and stupid. But it does guarantee war, perpetual war.
The U.S. decision to blame Russia for the impasse on Syria seems particularly stupid. Russia will not be hectored to the bargaining table to negotiate away the Syrian state, particularly after Victoria Nuland's performance in Kiev.
And what makes the present course of the Obama administration so dicey is that it is in opposition to its putative base of popular support. If Obama, already listing dangerously in the polls, continues to proceed down this bellicose path he will find the Democratic Party split and vulnerable come November, with the Senate likely returning to Republican control.
The fourth estate is doing its part, banging the war drum by focusing its coverage of the Syrian war primarily on the government's use of barrel bombs against rebel-controlled neighborhoods in Homs and Aleppo. But it will not compel any popular support for greater U.S. involvement. After the disaster of Iraq and Afghanistan, coupled with the devastating impact of the ongoing Great Recession, one would have to be entirely insane to back another belligerent escapade in the Middle East. And while the masses might be confused and uninformed, they are not insane. It is the governing elites, seemingly disconnected from everyday reality, who are insane.
Thursday, January 30, 2014
Geneva II Propaganda Campaign
If you are a reader of the New York Times and you are interested in the war being waged in Syria the reporter you have been hearing from is Beirut bureau chief Anne Barnard. At almost all times in the stories she writes Barnard sticks to the same cartoon-simple theme as peddled by the U.S. State Department: the war in Syria is entirely the fault of President Bashar al-Assad; he brutally repressed a peaceful democratic uprising, which then morphed into a sectarian region-wide war. Throughout her reporting any role played by the foreign-funded salafi groups -- the main military force fighting the Syrian Arab Army -- is consistently downplayed to the status of a footnote while Lebanon's Hezbollah is played up.
In other words, it is difficult to detect a difference between what Anne Barnard says and what the U.S. State Department says. Is she an employee of the USG? She might as well be.
One place where Barnard did stray off the reservation was in her evolving contempt for the Syrian National Council and the Free Syrian Army. Around the time of the aborted U.S. missile strike following the Ghouta sarin attack, Barnard washed her hands, so to speak, of the opposition in exile.
But no more. If you've been reading Barnard's dispatches from Switzerland, you know that the Syrian rebel group is back in her good graces. Barnard has regularly feted opposition coalition members who are participating in the Geneva II peace talks for their disciplined calm and focused message. At the same time, Barnard mocks the representatives of the Syrian government for their brittleness, mendacity, anger, etc.
Reading Barnard's stories of the last few days, such as "At Neutral Site, Syrians Feel Free to Confront the Other Side" or "After Shaky Beginning, Sides Report Progress at Syria Peace Talks," one sees a skillful propagandist at work.
Take today's offering, "Syrian Opposition’s Calm at Talks Surprises as Officials Falter."
The best that could be achieved coming out of Geneva II from the perspective of the West and its Sheikhdoms is some form of rehabilitation for its proxies in the Syrian National Coalition. The last six months have been rough on the rebels. Public opinion in the West is totally against any involvement. And that is the entire reason that the Syrian National Coalition exists -- to justify Western military intervention a la Libya.
But the public impression in Syria and abroad is that the Western-backed opposition is a group of hired clowns. According to Barnard,
Barnard, thankfully, is like any employee: she chafes at being on the clock and will usually find a way to mention what is really going on. So toward the end of today's piece you will find this gem:
In other words, it is difficult to detect a difference between what Anne Barnard says and what the U.S. State Department says. Is she an employee of the USG? She might as well be.
One place where Barnard did stray off the reservation was in her evolving contempt for the Syrian National Council and the Free Syrian Army. Around the time of the aborted U.S. missile strike following the Ghouta sarin attack, Barnard washed her hands, so to speak, of the opposition in exile.
But no more. If you've been reading Barnard's dispatches from Switzerland, you know that the Syrian rebel group is back in her good graces. Barnard has regularly feted opposition coalition members who are participating in the Geneva II peace talks for their disciplined calm and focused message. At the same time, Barnard mocks the representatives of the Syrian government for their brittleness, mendacity, anger, etc.
Reading Barnard's stories of the last few days, such as "At Neutral Site, Syrians Feel Free to Confront the Other Side" or "After Shaky Beginning, Sides Report Progress at Syria Peace Talks," one sees a skillful propagandist at work.
Take today's offering, "Syrian Opposition’s Calm at Talks Surprises as Officials Falter."
The best that could be achieved coming out of Geneva II from the perspective of the West and its Sheikhdoms is some form of rehabilitation for its proxies in the Syrian National Coalition. The last six months have been rough on the rebels. Public opinion in the West is totally against any involvement. And that is the entire reason that the Syrian National Coalition exists -- to justify Western military intervention a la Libya.
But the public impression in Syria and abroad is that the Western-backed opposition is a group of hired clowns. According to Barnard,
A more immediate goal for the coalition is to increase support within the broader opposition. Some longtime critics of the group say that with Geneva it has begun, in small ways, to repair its image inside Syria as a hapless, hotel-hopping “five-star opposition” that does not represent the people fighting or suffering on the ground.
“The coalition was able to counter that perception because of their strong stance opposite the weak and sometimes incoherent regime delegation,” said Amal Hanano, a Syrian-American writer who uses a pseudonym to protect family members in Aleppo. “The regime delegation seems unorganized and fractured when that was what people expected from the coalition.”Barnard dutifully puffs up the coalition. That was the positive part of the propaganda. The negative part was to sow dissension between the Syrian and Russian governments by stating that Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov was displeased with the conduct of Syrian Foreign Minister Walid al-Moallem during his opening statement (Moallem's opening statement is the only thing that seems to be discussed in the Western media):
Numerous Western diplomats and opposition delegates said that during the opening speeches last week in Montreux, Switzerland, Russia’s foreign minister, Sergey V. Lavrov, sat with a pained expression and even tapped his watch as Syria’s foreign minister spoke and sparred with the United Nations secretary general, Ban Ki-moon.
“We were embarrassed,” said a Russian Foreign Ministry representative who was there. But she played down the significance of the watch tap, saying that perhaps all the Syrians should have had more time to speak.Barnard also sought to sow dissension in the ranks of Syrian officials by highlighting splits between the Syrian Foreign Ministry and Assad:
Foreign Ministry delegates pledged to discuss a transitional government, only to be contradicted by Mr. Assad’s advisers. Some of the officials’ statements — claiming no knowledge of thousands of prisoners on an opposition list, saying that “terrorists” had carried out all the destruction in Homs, a city that has been bombarded by government airstrikes for two years — were, as Western diplomats put it, more “North Korea” than had been expected at a peace conference, even a largely notional one.
The reason, diplomats speculated, was that officials were under scrutiny from hard-liners in Damascus and feared retribution should a too-conciliatory phrase slip. It is also possible they assumed the conference would never happen, the Western diplomat said, counting on the opposition to boycott.Publish rumor and innuendo whispered by a "Western diplomat" and your propaganda mission is complete.
Barnard, thankfully, is like any employee: she chafes at being on the clock and will usually find a way to mention what is really going on. So toward the end of today's piece you will find this gem:
The [Syrian] government also gained some support for its argument that its opponents are Western puppets; opposition delegates met daily with Western diplomats and, Mr. Zoubi said, submitted documents in English, not Arabic.
But those meetings, where diplomats and a new team of British and American public relations consultants coached opposition members not to rise to the government’s bait, seemed fruitful.
Louay Safi, an opposition spokesman, was tested when a representative of the state-run SANA news agency asserted that in a government-blockaded area “there are no civilians, only terrorists,” and asked if efforts to get food there aimed to “save the terrorists.”
“Two good questions, and I thank you for them,” Mr. Safi said, before calmly answering.In other words, Geneva II is a farce.
Thursday, January 23, 2014
The Silver Lining so Far at Montreaux
Based on the reporting from "the paper of record" one of the most noteworthy things that happened at yesterday's peace conference in Montreaux was that Syrian Foreign Minister Walid al-Moallem spoke for longer than he should have in making his opening statements. The gist of the story by Michael Gordon and Anne Barnard is don't expect much from the ongoing negotiations:
On the first point, there is another big story today about the Qatari-funded dossier of alleged Assad regime murder and torture, pictures of which were smuggled out of the country by an anonymous policeman, code named Caesar. Two things about this piece by Mark Landler and Ben Hubbard, "State Dept. Learned in November of Photos Said to Show Torture in Syria": 1) Even while promoting the report, significant questions about its reliability are raised:
But a silver lining for the Syrian government in the last 48 hours is the success it has had in asking the question that concludes the report from Montreaux by Gordon and Barnard:
By the end of the day, the sense that the new peace talks were headed for trouble was compounded when the proceedings ended without any hint of progress toward imposing local cease-fires or opening humanitarian corridors for the delivery of food and medicine to besieged towns and cities.The role of the Western media in the Syrian conflict is to make sure the script stays focused on the brutality of the Assad regime as well as the fiction that the opposition actually represents Syrians inside Syria (rather than foreign intelligence agencies).
On the first point, there is another big story today about the Qatari-funded dossier of alleged Assad regime murder and torture, pictures of which were smuggled out of the country by an anonymous policeman, code named Caesar. Two things about this piece by Mark Landler and Ben Hubbard, "State Dept. Learned in November of Photos Said to Show Torture in Syria": 1) Even while promoting the report, significant questions about its reliability are raised:
The report on the photos, though led by three experts with experience in international war crimes trials, also raised some questions. While saying that the full archive consists of about 55,000 photographs, indicating the execution of around 11,000 people, the investigators acknowledged they had examined only 5,500 photos showing 835 individuals.
The timing of the report’s release also suggested that it had been timed to undermine Mr. Assad’s government as talks began. The report says investigators interviewed the photographer, Caesar, on Jan. 12, 13, and 18, meaning the report was prepared within days of the last interview.
One of the investigators said the timing of the report’s release had no bearing on the credibility of its findings.
“Whether it was a month ago or a month from now, this is clear and convincing evidence of an industrial killing machine that is indicative of what Assad is doing in this civil war,” said David M. Crane, who previously indicted President Charles G. Taylor of Liberia.
Much also remains unclear about how the photos made it out of Syria and what will be done with them now. Mr. Rashid, whose group helped smuggle them out, said it had worked for months with contacts in Syria and in unnamed “neighboring countries” to get the defector and his photos out of Syria.
Mr. Crane played down the role of Qatar, which commissioned the report, and denied that the release of the report before the conference was political.
“That report is to serve the rights of the victims, but we see this as a legal, humanitarian document,” he said. “It is not political at all.”And 2), as can be seen in the passage above, the main advocate for the code name Caesar report is David Crane, who is always described as being someone who prosecuted Charles Taylor at The Hague. But what is never mentioned is his long service in the United States Government in prestigious positions such as Director of the Office of Intelligence Review and assistant general counsel of the Defense Intelligence Agency. It is hard to believe that this omission is just lazy journalism.
But a silver lining for the Syrian government in the last 48 hours is the success it has had in asking the question that concludes the report from Montreaux by Gordon and Barnard:
In an interview, Fayssal Mekdad, the Syrian deputy foreign minister, said he welcomed sitting face to face with the government’s opponents. “We look forward to looking them in the eye,” he said, “and asking them, ‘Who do you represent?’ ”This question -- "Who does the opposition really represent?" -- was also raised, and I think quite effectively, by al-Assad himself in his interview with Agence France Presse:
AFP: The opposition that will participate in Geneva is divided and many factions on the ground don't believe it represents them. If an agreement is reached, how can it be implemented on the ground?
President Assad: This is the same question that we are asking as a government: when I negotiate, who am I negotiating with? There are expected to be many sides at Geneva, we don't know yet who will come, but there will be various parties, including the Syrian government. It is clear to everyone that some of the groups, which might attend the conference, didn't exist until very recently; in fact they were created during the crisis by foreign intelligence agencies whether in Qatar, Saudi Arabia, France, the United States or other countries. So when we sit down with these groups, we are in fact negotiating with those countries. So, is it logical that France should be a part of the Syrian solution? Or Qatar, or America, or Saudi Arabia, or Turkey? This doesn't make any sense. Therefore, when we negotiate with these parties, we're in fact negotiating with the countries that are behind them and that support terrorism in Syria. There are other opposition forces in Syria that have a national agenda; these are parties that we can negotiate with. On the issue of the vision for Syria's future, we are open for these parties to participate in governing the Syrian state, in the government and in other institutions. But as I mentioned earlier, anything that is agreed with any party, whether in Geneva or in Syria, must be subject to people's endorsement, through a referendum put to Syrian citizens.
***
AFP: Are you prepared to have a prime minister from the opposition in a future government?
President Assad: That depends on who this opposition represents. When it represents a majority, let’s say in parliament, naturally it should lead the government. But to appoint a prime minister from the opposition without having a majority doesn’t make any political sense in any country in the world. In your country, for example, or in Britain or elsewhere, you can’t have a prime minister from a parliamentary minority. This will all depend on the next elections, which we discussed in the Syrian initiative; they will reveal the real size of support for the various opposition forces. As to participation as a principle, we support it, of course it is a good thing.
AFP: Are you prepared to have, for example, Ahmed Jarba or Moaz Khatib, be your next prime minister?
President Assad: This takes us back to the previous question. Do any of these people represent the Syrian people, or even a portion of the Syrian people? Do they even represent themselves, or are they just representatives of the states that created them? This brings us back to what I mentioned earlier: every one of these groups represents the country that created them. The participation of each of these individuals means the participation of each of those states in the Syrian government! This is the first point. Second, let’s assume that we agreed to the participation of these individuals in the government. Do you think that they would dare to come to Syria to take part in the government? Of course they wouldn’t. Last year, they claimed that they had control of 70% of Syria, yet they didn’t even dare to come to the areas that they had supposed control of. They did come to the border for a 30-minute photo opportunity and then they fled. How can they be ministers in the government? Can a foreigner become a Syrian minister? That’s why these propositions are totally unrealistic, but they do make a good joke!
Wednesday, January 22, 2014
Code Name Caesar
The timing of a report released by a team of lawyers paid for by the government of Qatar, an early backer of the jihadi pipeline into Syria, accusing the Syrian government of widespread use of torture is highly suspect coming as it does at the beginning of the Geneva II round of talks.
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry in his opening remarks today reiterated the Western / Sheikhdom position that Syrian President Bashar al-Assad must step down before the violence can stop, saying “The right to lead a country does not come from torture." Thus, the Qatari-commissioned report was put to use right away.
The origin of the photographic documentation that forms the basis of the report is described in a story today by Ben Hubbard (a reporter who I thought did decent work in Cairo in the run up to the Sisi coup before he was sent to Lebanon to help Anne Barnard hew to the anti-Assad / pro-Saudi line) and the great David Kirkpatrick, "Photo Archive Is Said to Show Widespread Torture in Syria":
No doubt horrible things are happening in Syria today. But if you look at what is happening in prisons in any country horrific things will jump out at you. One can only wonder what kind of brutality and perversion is sanctioned in Saudi jails. The important thing to remember is that the United States had no problem with the Syrian "torture factories" when we needed a post-9/11 location for our rendition of terror suspects.
The timing of the report's appearance by an anonymous defector with code name Caesar (can you say, "Curveball"?) allows Kerry to assume the high ground the West has lost since Al Qaeda assumed the leading role in the Syrian "rebellion."
It is a pathetic attempt, a thin sheet meant to obscure the monstrous U.S. policy of fomenting jihad only to have its citizens surrender life and liberty to fight it.
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry in his opening remarks today reiterated the Western / Sheikhdom position that Syrian President Bashar al-Assad must step down before the violence can stop, saying “The right to lead a country does not come from torture." Thus, the Qatari-commissioned report was put to use right away.
The origin of the photographic documentation that forms the basis of the report is described in a story today by Ben Hubbard (a reporter who I thought did decent work in Cairo in the run up to the Sisi coup before he was sent to Lebanon to help Anne Barnard hew to the anti-Assad / pro-Saudi line) and the great David Kirkpatrick, "Photo Archive Is Said to Show Widespread Torture in Syria":
The photos were made public by an anonymous military policeman who had a grim role in the bureaucracy of the Syrian security apparatus, according to the lawyers’ report assessing the photos’ veracity.
The photos were used to provide death certificates to the families of the victims without turning over the bodies, and were archived as a record that the men had been killed.
After “psychological suffering” caused by his job, Caesar saved the photos on a portable disk drive, and he and the disk were smuggled out of the country by antigovernment activists, the report said. The activists contacted the Qatari government, Qatar hired a London law firm, and it commissioned a team of legal and forensics experts to assess the credibility of Caesar and his photos.Two of the Qatari hired-gun lawyers, David Crane and Geoffrey Nice, are no stranger to high-profile, empire-approved political investigations. Nice prosecuted Slobodan Milosevic; Crane is a spook-lawyer (he worked as assistant general counsel of the Defense Intelligence Agency) who helped prosecute Charles Taylor. Crane provides the obligatory quote comparing Assad's Syria to Nazi Germany: “It is very rare to have this kind of government-backed, industrial, machinelike, systematic torture and killing of human beings, the likes of which we haven’t seen since Nuremberg.”
No doubt horrible things are happening in Syria today. But if you look at what is happening in prisons in any country horrific things will jump out at you. One can only wonder what kind of brutality and perversion is sanctioned in Saudi jails. The important thing to remember is that the United States had no problem with the Syrian "torture factories" when we needed a post-9/11 location for our rendition of terror suspects.
The timing of the report's appearance by an anonymous defector with code name Caesar (can you say, "Curveball"?) allows Kerry to assume the high ground the West has lost since Al Qaeda assumed the leading role in the Syrian "rebellion."
It is a pathetic attempt, a thin sheet meant to obscure the monstrous U.S. policy of fomenting jihad only to have its citizens surrender life and liberty to fight it.
Tuesday, January 21, 2014
The Geneva II Farce
If you were away celebrating Martin Luther King, Jr. Day yesterday, maybe participating in a march, and did not have an opportunity to scan the headlines, you would have missed the embarrassing news of United Nations secretary general Ban Ki-moon inviting Iran to participate in the Geneva II round of peace talks (to begin tomorrow) and then some hours later rescinding that invitation at the behest of the United States.
The day quickly descended into "he said"/"she said" imbroglio. Ban said that Iran had agreed to accept Geneva I, meaning that al-Assad would be ushered out and a transitional government with opposition representatives sharing power with certain Western-approved Baathists from the Syrian government would be installed. Iran denied agreeing to any preconditions to attend. The United States expressed shock -- Secretary of State Kerry was said to be apoplectic with rage -- that Ban would step out on his own and invite Iran; Ban said that the U.S. knew what he was up to.
In any event, the Syrian National Coalition, the opposition cobbled together by the West, Turkey and the Gulf monarchies, said it would not attend if Iran participated. The United States instructed Moon to disinvite the Iranians. Moon complied. And there you have it. That is where we are at with one day to go before Geneva II opens in Montreaux.
Meanwhile the Shiite district of Haret Hreik in south Beirut sustained another terror bombing. Sectarian fighting between Sunni and Shiite has started again in the northern Lebanese city of Tripoli. The attempt to resolve the ISIS occupation of Falluja in Iraq's Al Anbar Governorate collapsed. Al-Maliki will now have to go in heavy. Death and destruction is sure to follow with a good possibility that Iraq will permanently fracture.
And all the while the region burns the United States fiddles. To get a sense of what the U.S. and its Syrian opposition hope to achieve in Geneva II, here is the takeaway passage from today's story by Michael Gordon, Anne Barnard and Alan Cowell, "U.N.’s Reversal on Iran Prompts Outcry From Syrian Allies":
Despite the enormous obstacles, the State Department asserts that the talks are worth holding because the push to establish a transitional body to govern Syria, a main goal of the conference, might encourage defections among Mr. Assad’s traditional supporters, including the Alawite sect, of which he is a member.
“There are elements inside the regime itself, among its supporters, that are anxious to find a peaceful solution, and we’ve gotten plenty of messages from people inside; they want a way out,” the State Department official said.
“That’s the whole point of their going to Geneva,” the official added, referring to officials of the Syrian opposition. “To promote the alternative, the alternative vision.”Yes, you read it right. The goal of Geneva II isn't to end the fighting, even if to secure a temporary ceasefire; the goal of Geneva II according to the U.S. State Department is to encourage Baathist defections.
It is hard to properly frame just how unhinged this strategy is. The Syrian Arab Army is superior in the field. Without a display of air power, the rebels, now composed entirely of jihadists, have done nothing but cede territory as they fight among themselves. The response to this weakness by the sheikhdoms who manage the jihadi armies is to direct them to soft targets in Iraq and Lebanon. Now those two nations are on the brink of civil war from which they might not ever return. Yet all the U.S. cares about is peeling away a few defectors from al-Assad's government. It is insanity.
The one silver lining is that it is becoming harder for the U.S. to feign concern for the humanity crisis created by the Syrian war and pretend that it is acting in the best interests of the Middle East to end the fighting. It is now abundantly clear that the U.S. is acting to expand the war both in length of time and breadth of geography in the deluded hope that the sovereign government of Syria will surrender.
Thursday, January 2, 2014
Geneva II
The Geneva II peace talks on Syria begin in three weeks and a lot is in play in the Middle East. Majid bin Muhammad al-Majid, head of the Al Qaeda-affiliated Abdullah Azzam Brigades and a Saudi, has been taken into custody. The Adbullah Azzam Brigades had claimed responsibility for the November suicide bombing of the Iranian Embassy in Beirut, and they were suspected of firing a missile into northern Israel on Sunday. Anne Barnard has the story, "Lebanon Arrests Leader of Qaeda-Linked Group, Reports Say":
One thing that jumped out at me from Lund's piece is the large number of nations attending Geneva II:
An Iranian national security official, Alaeddin Boroujerdi, on Wednesday praised the Lebanese security forces for apprehending Mr. Majid, and blamed him for the embassy bombing. He also urged the Lebanese government to consider the fact that “the main element in the operation is of Saudi nationality,” Iran’s semiofficial Fars News Agency reported.
***
The Iranian official, Mr. Boroujerdi, said that Lebanese security forces had arrested two people, including someone involved in “the assassination of the Hezbollah leader in Lebanon,” an apparent reference to the shooting death in December of Hassane Laqees, a senior Hezbollah militant. It was unclear whether he was blaming the Abdullah Azzam Brigades or Saudi Arabia for killing Mr. Laqees. Citing the killers’ professionalism, Hezbollah had blamed the hit on Israel rather than Sunni jihadist groups.
Mr. Majid’s detention was potentially sensitive in a divided Lebanon, especially under a caretaker government that has been in place for months because of political stalemate. The army has tried to maintain its reputation as the only largely neutral security agency, even as it remains too weak to challenge Hezbollah’s independent militia, and Lebanese Sunnis increasingly see it as leaning toward the Shiite party.The Iranians are still barred from attending Geneva II, ostensibly because they won't sign off on Geneva I and the concept of a Baathist-opposition transitional government with full executive powers, even though it is broadly accepted that no deal is possible without Iranian participation. Aron Lund breaks it down in "Can Iran Go to Geneva II Without Endorsing Geneva I?" on his Syria in Crisis blog. Lund seems to think that endorsing Geneva I is meaningless and that Iran could do so at anytime without compromising its bargaining position. He seems to think that Iran is holding out for further concessions by the United States.
One thing that jumped out at me from Lund's piece is the large number of nations attending Geneva II:
Apart from Syria’s government and opposition, the Geneva II guest list includes representatives of the United Nations, the Arab League, the European Union, the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, the United States, Russia, France, the United Kingdom, China, Algeria, Brazil, Canada, Denmark, Egypt, Germany, India, Indonesia, Iraq, Italy, Japan, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Morocco, Norway, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, and the United Arab Emirates.The more countries attending, the more likely it is the event will be nothing but ceremonial, a performance for the cameras. This does not preclude that possibility that a substantive agreement can be reached at a meeting that is not part of the formally recognized mega-gathering and then brought to the larger group for a sign-off. It just seems like a long shot to me.
Monday, November 25, 2013
Obama Discovers a Truer Legacy
Pundits in the media always talk about a president's second term as a restless pursuit of legacy. Ego is definitely the main driver of political ambition; ego, and then down a ways, money.
Obama's signature domestic achievement has turned out to be a steaming crock of shit. Even if the online insurance exchange is repaired and registration becomes a simple, seamless event, you're still at the end of the day left with nothing more than a massive expansion of the U.S. health care status quo. As Ralph Nader pointed out this past weekend in an article, "21 Ways the Canadian Health Care System is Better than Obamacare," that appeared on the Counterpunch web site,
No, Obama's legacy achievement is shaping up to be foreign policy. First, forgoing a missile strike against Syria in favor of an agreement he struck with the Russians for the government of Bashar al-Assad to give up its chemical weapons; this prevented the Syrian civil war from metastasizing into World War Three. Now, comes the agreement penned in Geneva on Sunday to ensure that Iran's nuclear program is peaceful. As Mark Landler writes this morning in his frontpage story, "Nuclear Accord With Iran Opens Diplomatic Doors in the Mideast":
What does that tell you? It says that the House of Saud and the Likudniks who run Israel want war. They are states that thrive on war. But the neoliberal/neoconservative paradigm that coincides with the 1979 Iranian Revolution, the Grand Mosque Seizure and the Soviet Army deployment in Afghanistan is out of juice; it is all but dead. Yet it still governs the globe. And that's the problem. Obeisance to a dead, juiceless four-decade-old paradigm is killing us.
We need a shift. And that's what the Iranian nuclear program deal represents. It is a de facto acknowledgment (and one could argue that the "Joint Plan of Action" provides de jure recognition) of Iran's right to enrich uranium; it gets us out of the war track and onto a peace track. Already renewed efforts are being made for the Geneva II round of peace talks on the Syrian civil war.
Netanyahu and his Saudi allies will do everything they can to maintain the old paradigm. They have ample resources and a great deal of Congressional support. They have to proceed cautiously though. It's Thanksgiving week in the United States and people are in no mood to hear the war drums pounding. The people know who the warmongers are and they have had enough war.
The action will commence when Congress returns from the holiday and attempts to kill the Iranian deal by ratcheting up sanctions and then attaching those sanctions to any and all vital legislation in the hope that Obama will have to acquiesce. But Obama will not because he has found his true legacy.
Obama's signature domestic achievement has turned out to be a steaming crock of shit. Even if the online insurance exchange is repaired and registration becomes a simple, seamless event, you're still at the end of the day left with nothing more than a massive expansion of the U.S. health care status quo. As Ralph Nader pointed out this past weekend in an article, "21 Ways the Canadian Health Care System is Better than Obamacare," that appeared on the Counterpunch web site,
In the United States, under Obamacare, for thousands of Americans, it’s pay or die – if you can’t pay, you die. That’s why many thousands will still die every year under Obamacare from lack of health insurance to get diagnosed and treated in time.Obamacare does nothing to mend the complexity, high co-pays and deductibles that prevent people from seeking medical attention. If this isn't apparent to most now, it will be in a few years.
No, Obama's legacy achievement is shaping up to be foreign policy. First, forgoing a missile strike against Syria in favor of an agreement he struck with the Russians for the government of Bashar al-Assad to give up its chemical weapons; this prevented the Syrian civil war from metastasizing into World War Three. Now, comes the agreement penned in Geneva on Sunday to ensure that Iran's nuclear program is peaceful. As Mark Landler writes this morning in his frontpage story, "Nuclear Accord With Iran Opens Diplomatic Doors in the Mideast":
But the mere fact that after 34 years of estrangement, the United States and Iran have signed a diplomatic accord — even if it is a tactical, transitory one — opens the door to a range of geopolitical possibilities available to no American leader since Jimmy Carter.
“No matter what you think of it, this is a historic deal,” said Vali R. Nasr, the dean of the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies. “It is a major seismic shift in the region. It rearranges the entire chess board.”In both cases, Syria joining the chemicals convention and the Iranians agreeing to halt uranium enrichment at 5%, the Israelis and Saudis were apoplectic, publicly venting their frustration and lashing out at the Obama administration.
What does that tell you? It says that the House of Saud and the Likudniks who run Israel want war. They are states that thrive on war. But the neoliberal/neoconservative paradigm that coincides with the 1979 Iranian Revolution, the Grand Mosque Seizure and the Soviet Army deployment in Afghanistan is out of juice; it is all but dead. Yet it still governs the globe. And that's the problem. Obeisance to a dead, juiceless four-decade-old paradigm is killing us.
We need a shift. And that's what the Iranian nuclear program deal represents. It is a de facto acknowledgment (and one could argue that the "Joint Plan of Action" provides de jure recognition) of Iran's right to enrich uranium; it gets us out of the war track and onto a peace track. Already renewed efforts are being made for the Geneva II round of peace talks on the Syrian civil war.
Netanyahu and his Saudi allies will do everything they can to maintain the old paradigm. They have ample resources and a great deal of Congressional support. They have to proceed cautiously though. It's Thanksgiving week in the United States and people are in no mood to hear the war drums pounding. The people know who the warmongers are and they have had enough war.
The action will commence when Congress returns from the holiday and attempts to kill the Iranian deal by ratcheting up sanctions and then attaching those sanctions to any and all vital legislation in the hope that Obama will have to acquiesce. But Obama will not because he has found his true legacy.
Labels:
Afghanistan,
Benjamin Netanyahu,
Geneva II,
Grand Mosque Seizure,
Iranian nuclear talks,
Iranian Revolution,
Israel,
Likud,
Obama,
Obamacare,
Ralph Nader,
Saudi Arabia,
Syrian civil war
Tuesday, November 12, 2013
Uncle Sam Knuckles Down on Syrian National Coalition + Haqqani Network Fundraiser Assassinated
I would not take seriously the news emerging out of Istanbul that the Syrian National Coalition has agreed to attend the Geneva II peace talks. What appears to be going on is some linguistic pussyfooting to appease the West. Rather than demanding that the Baathist government of Bashar al-Assad step down prior to any peace talks, now the opposition's position is that any transitional government that emerges from Geneva cannot include al-Assad and his principals. Anne Barnard and Hwaida Saad have the story, "Leading Syrian Opposition Group, Yielding to Pressure, Votes to Join Peace Talks":
With the Monday vote, the coalition appeared to drop its demand that Mr. Assad step down before any talks. But it continued to insist that it would participate only if there are guarantees that the talks would lead to a full transfer of executive power, including over military and security forces, to a transitional government in which Mr. Assad and “those with blood on their hands” would have “no role.”Other conditions stipulated by the National Coalition for Syrian Revolutionary and Opposition Forces include the release of prisoners and full access to humanitarian aid.
This doesn't sound like a breakthrough that will enable substantive peace talks anytime soon. What is encouraging is the line currently coming from the U.S.:
Stoking tensions all around, Robert S. Ford, the United States ambassador to Syria, told the activists on the sidelines that the emerging reality presented them with unpalatable options: accept that the current government could continue in power longer than they would like, or face the continued rise of extremist jihadist groups that have terrified residents, clashed with rival insurgents and undermined Western support.The U.S. is telling the opposition, "It's either ISIS or the regime," basically saying to the rebels, "Shit or get off the pot. The days of pretending to be a potent force while arguing in hotel conference rooms are over. Either go with the jihadis or sit down and talk to the Baathists in Geneva." It's about time.
Declan Walsh and Ihansullah Tipu Mehsud have an informative piece on the assassination of Nasiruddin Haqqani, chief fundraiser for the Haqqani network and scion of founder Jalaluddin Haqqani, who was gunned down last night outside a bread store on the outskirts of Islamabad:
The killing added to an impression of increased turbulence for the militant groups harbored in Pakistan’s tribal belt, including Al Qaeda, the Pakistani Taliban and the Haqqani network. Over just two months, one major leader has been arrested, two have been killed in a drone strike, and now a major financier — Mr. Haqqani — has died.
The link, if any, between those events remains hidden in the miasma of tribal politics, skulduggery and treachery that has for centuries haunted the rugged frontier between Pakistan and Afghanistan. But many are taking the violence as a portent of increased upheaval as rival intelligence services and militant groups vie for power and influence ahead of the withdrawal of American combat troops from the region next year.
The first major shot came when American forces detained Latif Mehsud, a senior commander for the Pakistani Taliban, inside Afghanistan. Weeks later, on Nov. 1, a C.I.A. drone strike killed the Pakistani Taliban’s leader, Hakimullah Mehsud, and a top deputy. Now, Mr. Haqqani, a looming figure in a militant network closely allied with the Taliban and Al Qaeda, is dead.Nasiruddin Haqqani was a crucial link to Pakistan's ISI and funders in the GCC. The Haqqani network is aligned with the Afghan Taliban but is really a Saudi and ISI tool. More war can be expected in the tribal belt as jihadi factions positions themselves for the torrent of spoils to be reaped once the United States pulls out next year.
Wednesday, November 6, 2013
Hallowed Ritual Meant to Convey Activity and Good Faith
Yesterday Lakhdar Brahimi announced that there would be no Geneva II peace talks in November. Brahimi said that he would meet again with U.S. and Russian diplomats at the end of the month to try to put something together. But after that date one wonders how long Brahimi will stick around. There has been no movement on the most basic issue of who should attend -- which rebel groups, which nations. Nick Cumming-Bruce and Rick Gladstone have the story, "Diplomats Fail to Agree on Details for Syria Peace Talks":
Mr. Brahimi made it clear that the lack of preparation on the part of Syria’s opposition was an acute and immediate cause for delaying a peace conference. “They are divided, that’s no secret for anyone, they are facing all sorts of problems,” he said.
The opposition National Coalition has no leverage over the armed groups battling Mr. Assad, particularly the jihadist militants linked to Al Qaeda who are among the most effective fighters. They have said that any insurgents who participate in Geneva peace talks would be regarded as traitors.
Mr. Brahimi also acknowledged that the diplomats had been unable to agree on whether Iran, Mr. Assad’s most important regional ally, would be invited to a peace conference. “Iran is definitely one of the issues that will be discussed further,” he said.
Saudi Arabia, Iran’s regional rival and a major supporter of the Syrian insurgency, remains opposed to Iranian participation in peace talks. Western governments, recognizing Iran as an important participant, have appeared less resistant to Iran’s attendance. But diplomats say a major obstacle is Iran’s reluctance to endorse the communiqué of the first Geneva conference in June 2012, which called for a transition under a government formed by mutual consent.
The question of Mr. Assad’s role in a transition government looms as a major obstacle. In a meeting with Mr. Brahimi in Damascus last week, Mr. Assad said “only the Syrian people are authorized to shape the future of Syria,” a formula that rejects American insistence that he step down as part of any peace process. “We are not going to Geneva to hand over power,” Syria’s information minister, Omran al-Zoubi, said on Monday, according to Syria’s official SANA news agency. “President Bashar al-Assad will remain head of state.”Further talks in Geneva to prepare the way for a Geneva II summit are like Kerry shuttling between Netanyahu and Abbas, a hallowed ritual meant to convey activity and good faith while maintaining a status quo of perpetual war and occupation.
In a troubling sign, the odious Samantha Power was back in the news denigrating the Syrian government and questioning the accuracy of its declaration to the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons. The OPCW has said verification is on schedule and the Syrian government is complying. Once again this sets up the familiar conflict between the United States and an international agency responsible for administering a United Nations Security Council resolution. U.S. warmongering goes unsupported by its people, but it is supported by elites and the foreign governments that maintain those elites. So warmongering will continue.
This despite proof that the policy of fomenting war and rebellion is having the opposite effect of the overarching U.S. national security mission (at least as it is formulated for public consumption) of eradicating Al Qaeda and its affiliates. Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) continues to consolidate its hold on northern Syria. The caliphate springs up on the border of NATO.
Attempting to break the logjam, Russia is offering to host informal talks between the Syrian government and members of the opposition.
Since I have mentioned "a hallowed ritual meant to convey activity and good faith," I should note that yesterday was Election Day in the United States. There wasn't a whole lot to celebrate. Bill de Blasio, a progressive Democrat, won the New York City mayor's race in an impressive landslide. That's good news. Corporate Democrat and uber-Clintonite Terry McAuliffe was elected governor of Virginia over a Tea Party troglodyte Ken Cuccinelli. One can debate the merits of McAuliffe's victory. In Washington State, the bad news is that I-522, a GMO-labeling initiative, is headed for defeat. It shared the fate of last year's GMO-labeling initiative in California -- buried by a blizzard of negative advertising paid for by corporate behemoths like Monsanto and PepsiCo.
Friday, November 1, 2013
Kerry Jets to Riyadh to Kiss the Ring of the King
As Secretary of State John Kerry prepares to pay fealty to Saudi ruler King Abdullah with a trip to Riyadh next week, the Israelis have apparently indulged in one of their periodic missile attacks on Syria, this one coming Wednesday night against a Syrian Arab Army base outside Latakia; the reason being given is the familiar one, a shipment of Russian missiles bound for Hezbollah in Lebanon.
The Syrian government has met its deadline to dismantle its chemical weapons production facilities. Anne Barnard reports in "Syria Destroys Chemical Sites, Inspectors Say":
Iraq is connected of course. Al-Maliki's meeting with Senators Menendez and Corker who lead the Foreign Relation Committee did not go well. Menendez and Corker serve the interests of Israel and House of Saud. The Obama administration's decision on whether to supply the military hardware -- drones, Apache helicopters, Hellfire missiles -- al-Maliki wants to deal with the efflorescence of ISIS in western Iraq should illuminate the way forward on Syria and Iran.
The Syrian government has met its deadline to dismantle its chemical weapons production facilities. Anne Barnard reports in "Syria Destroys Chemical Sites, Inspectors Say":
Syria’s ability to produce chemical weapons has been destroyed and its remaining toxic armaments secured, weapons inspectors said Thursday, as President Bashar al-Assad has offered unexpectedly robust cooperation, at least so far, with a Russian-United States accord to dismantle his arsenal.
Elimination of Mr. Assad’s manufacturing ability is the most significant milestone yet in a process that still faces a monumental task: destroying the government’s 1,290 tons of declared chemical weapons in the midst of a bloody civil war that has killed well over 100,000 people and carved up control of the country.So we're left with the status quo ante Ghouta: a Syrian civil war that is no longer a civil war but a Saudi-funded and inspired jihad against a secular state that has much more support domestically than any of its opponents. Kerry's meeting with King Abdullah looms large for the fate of peace talks in Geneva. It seems to me that the United States is no longer committed to Geneva II. Back in September when Obama was facing a revolt by his party there was a sense that the administration wanted nothing more to do with war games in the Middle East and that it was prepared to shift the paradigm. Out of this came Obama's one-on-one contact with newly-elected Iranian president Rouhani, and ever since we've been dealing with the Saudi and to a lesser extent the Israeli reaction. This is from Rick Gladstone's story, "Kerry to Visit Saudi Arabia to Smooth Relations":
The Saudis are known to have been upset by President Obama’s telephone call with President Hassan Rouhani of Iran on Sept. 27, the first direct contact between an American and Iranian president since the 1979 Islamic Revolution. The call was one of a number of signs that the United States and Iran want to settle the longstanding dispute over Iran’s nuclear energy program. Saudi Arabia considers Iran its strategic rival in the Middle East.Last week the Moon of Alabama blog raised an important issue: "Syria: After CW Removal, Obama May Again Go For Regime Change." While I don't think Obama will mess with any Tomahawk cruise missile attacks launched from U.S. carriers in the Mediterannean Sea, this doesn't mean that Kerry and King Abdullah won't agree to scuttle Geneva II and then reinvest in the covert war along the Jordanian border.
Iraq is connected of course. Al-Maliki's meeting with Senators Menendez and Corker who lead the Foreign Relation Committee did not go well. Menendez and Corker serve the interests of Israel and House of Saud. The Obama administration's decision on whether to supply the military hardware -- drones, Apache helicopters, Hellfire missiles -- al-Maliki wants to deal with the efflorescence of ISIS in western Iraq should illuminate the way forward on Syria and Iran.
Thursday, October 31, 2013
Gray Lady Once Again Blames the Victim
Today's lede unsigned editorial in the New York Times, "Endless War, Endless Suffering," blames Russia and China for not contributing enough to the United Nations to mitigate the damage caused by Syria's civil war, a war, the Times once again reminds its readers, caused by "President Bashar al-Assad of Syria [when he] used force to crush peaceful protests that began in 2011."
Nowhere is there a condemnation of the Gulf sheikhdoms for the pipeline of jihadis creating havoc in the region. The Gray Lady acknowledges that the polio outbreak in the eastern city of Deir al-Zour is linked to jihadis from Pakistan: "Public health experts suspect that jihadists who entered Syria to join the fight against Mr. Assad may have been the carriers." But she can't find the words to condemn the nations -- the Saudis in particular -- that are funding these jihadis and actively working against peace talks in Geneva.
Those talks, Geneva II, now appear to be headed for another postponement thanks to Saudi Arabia. This is from Anne Barnard's "Foreign Support for Syrian Rebels Is Hindering Deal, Assad Says":
After a burst of optimism about convening the Geneva talks following Syria’s agreement last month to destroy its chemical weapons arsenal, which averted an American military strike on Mr. Assad’s forces, diplomats have become increasingly pessimistic. Some now privately suggest the talks may be postponed.
Russia’s foreign minister, Sergey V. Lavrov, who collaborated with Secretary of State John Kerry to push for the chemical weapons agreement and the peace talks, expressed some frustration on Wednesday, suggesting that Saudi Arabia in particular was posing a new obstacle over its unhappiness that the United States had dropped a threat to attack Mr. Assad’s forces.
“The situation is somewhat more complicated because there have already been open objections to that conference initiated by Russia and the United States, objections not only from various Syrian factions but also from the capitals of some neighboring and not only neighboring states,” Mr. Lavrov told a news conference in Athens, where he was on an official visit.
Without specifying Saudi Arabia by name, Mr. Lavrov said that “those who sought regime change and helped voluntarily or involuntarily to create an extremists’ state there are now unable to hide their emotions.”Alan Cowell reports that all Syrian chemical weapons production sites have been decommissioned. As for the two sites that could not be accessed because they were in territory controlled by rebels, the Syrian government has declared to the OPCW that the chemical weapons had been previously removed from those sites:
The Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons in The Hague said in a statement that a joint team of its inspectors and United Nations officials had visited 21 of the 23 chemical sites Syria declared to them. While the remaining two sites were too hazardous to visit because of the country’s continuing civil war, the chemical-making equipment there had already been moved to other sites which the inspectors could visit.
“The Joint O.P.C.W.-U.N. mission has inspected 21 of the 23 sites declared by Syria, and 39 of the 41 facilities located at those sites,'’ the statement said. “The two remaining sites were not visited due to safety and security concerns. But Syria declared those sites as abandoned and that the chemical weapons program items they contained were moved to other declared sites, which were inspected.”
“The joint mission is now satisfied that it has verified — and seen destroyed — all of Syria’s declared critical production and mixing/filling equipment,” it added.Cowell provides a little more detail as to the location of the CW production facilities not in government control:
The watchdog has not specified the precise location of the sites that inspectors were not able to visit on a mission that showed the perils of operating in a war zone where some places are under siege and, in others, battle lines shift unpredictably.
Michael Luhan, a spokesman for the O.P.C.W., said one of the sites was in the area around Damascus and the other was in the northern Aleppo area, where news reports say government forces have bombarded the town of Safira in recent weeks to try to dislodge rebels including Islamist fighters linked to Al Qaeda.
“Access to both sites would be extremely risky,” Mr. Luhan said.Then there is this nugget in the second-to-last paragraph of the story:
“In addition, the Syrian authorities have reported finding two cylinders not belonging to them, which are believed to contain chemical weapons,” the report said, without elaborating, according to the news agency.As I said before, there needs to be an official reappraisal by the United States of its position that only the Syrian government has access to chemical weapons.
Wednesday, September 25, 2013
Gray Lady's Anne Barnard Interviews Syrian Deputy Foreign Minister Fayssal Mekdad
Anne Barnard has a decent story this morning built around her Tuesday interview in Damascus with Syria's deputy foreign minister, Fayssal Mekdad. It's worth checking out. Some of the highlights:
- Geneva II is unlikely to happen anytime soon. So the Syrian government is talking about the possibility of staging its own peace talks with "religious and community leaders 'who have influence on the ground' with fighters."
"But Mr. Mekdad suggested the government doubted the usefulness of talking to leaders of the National Coalition of Syrian Revolutionary and Opposition Forces, the exile group that the West and its Arab allies have tried to set up as the government’s opposition counterpart and the civilian leadership of the loose-knit rebel Free Syrian Army. Excluding that group would be a nonstarter for the United States and its allies.
"But Mr. Mekdad and prominent government supporters in Damascus said the coalition was increasingly irrelevant, not only lacking control over its own forces, but over foreign jihadist groups increasingly prominent on the battlefield — a view widely shared by Syrians who oppose the government."
- Following Syria's agreement to get rid of its chemical weapons, "Mr. Mekdad said the natural next step was an international push for Israel to relinquish its arsenal of nuclear weapons, which the neighboring state has never formally acknowledged."
- The Syrian deputy foreign minister said that the government was "100 percent sure" that the rebels were behind the August 21 Ghouta chemical weapon attack.
- Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) is consolidating its position in northern Syria and hardening its drive for a caliphate by attacking other rebel groups:
"A Syrian journalist said recent fighting between armed groups in the rebel-held north changed the calculations of Syrian and Western leaders regarding the proposed talks in Geneva.
"The journalist, who supports the government but requested anonymity to go beyond official statements, said he believed the extremist Islamic State in Iraq and Syria was trying to seize ground from other rebel groups.
"'I don’t think Geneva is really close to us, but what is close to us is a huge problem,' he said. 'If we don’t fight it in next two, three, four weeks, this means that inside of the Middle East, near Europe’s border, there is a state auto-financed and controlled by terrorists.'
"He said he could even envision a situation in which an international coalition was formed to fight alongside the Syrian Army against the jihadists, a prospect that seemed unlikely for now as the West continues to insist Mr. Assad leave power.
"Mr. Mekdad dismissed that notion and said the government sought a “peace coalition” to end the financing of armed opposition groups by America’s allies Saudi Arabia and Qatar, adding that aid to the Syrian government from its allies Russia and Iran was permissible within relations between sovereign states."I think that there's a greater chance that the West will use the existence of an Al Qaeda enclave in northern Syria as an excuse to launch strikes against the Syrian government rather than cooperate with it. It's part of pattern that we've come to expect from the United States and its allies: foment unrest and then use that unrest as an excuse to exercise military force.
Sunday, June 16, 2013
Sunni Clerics Calling for Holy War
The sectarian unraveling of the Middle East along a Sunni-Shiite divide is consistently presented in the Western media as the fault of Bashar al-Assad and his Iranian allies and Hezbollah. But this morning's news -- reported in "U.S. to Keep Warplanes in Jordan, Pressing Syria," by Michael R. Gordon and Thom Shanker -- that Egyptian president Mohamed Morsi is severing diplomatic ties with Syria is yet more proof, along with the news from late last week of Sunni clerics in Cairo issuing fatwas calling for jihad against Syria, that the fires of sectarian region-wide warfare are being stoked by Sunni fundamentalists. Morsi, following his usual pattern, is no doubt following orders issued in Saudi Arabia.
As the United States positions Patriot missiles and F-16s in Jordan for the foreseeable future to provide protection for the CIA's ongoing rebel training program, it is hard to see anything but a larger war coming down the pike. Gordon and Shanker note that the Obama administration, despite the constant invocation of a "political settlement," has given up on Geneva II for the time being:
Mr. Kerry flew to Moscow last month and secured Russia’s agreement to hold an international conference that would bring the Assad government and the Syrian opposition to the negotiating table to try to bring an end to the fighting. Since then, however, the Obama administration has become concerned that the advances made by pro-government forces would give Mr. Assad little reason to negotiate a political transition in which he would give up power.
As a result, White House and State Department officials now favor delaying the talks. Supplying arms to the rebels, officials have said, is partly intended to turn the tide enough to force a real negotiation. Mr. Lavrov, by contrast, argued for moving forward with the international conference on Syria.For a sober point-by-point refutation of the current bellicose course of United States policy read Ramzy Mardini's opinion piece, "Bad Idea, Mr. President," which appears today in the New York Times Sunday Review:
Interventionists tend to detach their actions from longer-term consequences. This myopia is often coupled with a prevalent misunderstanding of the political and cultural context of where they want to intervene. Both problems are present in the current American approach to Syria.
The Syrian revolution isn’t democratic or secular; the more than 90,000 fatalities are the result of a civil war, not a genocide — and human rights violations have been committed on both sides.
Moreover, the rebels don’t have the support or trust of a clear majority of the population, and the political opposition is neither credible nor representative. Ethnic cleansing against minorities is more likely to occur under a rebel-led government than under Mr. Assad; likewise, the possibility of chemical weapons’ falling into the hands of terrorist groups only grows as the regime weakens.
And finally, a rebel victory is more likely to destabilize Iraq and Lebanon, and the inevitable disorder of a post-Assad Syria constitutes a greater threat to Israel than the status quo.Civil war has returned to Iraq. The death toll has returned to a level not seen since 2008. To answer Mardini, the conclusion one must come to is that war, not long-term strategic interest, is what motivates Western policy makers. A piggish love of war.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)