Showing posts with label Chemical Weapons Convention. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chemical Weapons Convention. Show all posts

Friday, November 1, 2013

Kerry Jets to Riyadh to Kiss the Ring of the King

As Secretary of State John Kerry prepares to pay fealty to Saudi ruler King Abdullah with a trip to Riyadh next week, the Israelis have apparently indulged in one of their periodic missile attacks on Syria, this one coming Wednesday night against a Syrian Arab Army base outside Latakia; the reason being given is the familiar one, a shipment of Russian missiles bound for Hezbollah in Lebanon.

The Syrian government has met its deadline to dismantle its chemical weapons production facilities. Anne Barnard reports in "Syria Destroys Chemical Sites, Inspectors Say":
Syria’s ability to produce chemical weapons has been destroyed and its remaining toxic armaments secured, weapons inspectors said Thursday, as President Bashar al-Assad has offered unexpectedly robust cooperation, at least so far, with a Russian-United States accord to dismantle his arsenal. 
Elimination of Mr. Assad’s manufacturing ability is the most significant milestone yet in a process that still faces a monumental task: destroying the government’s 1,290 tons of declared chemical weapons in the midst of a bloody civil war that has killed well over 100,000 people and carved up control of the country.
So we're left with the status quo ante Ghouta: a Syrian civil war that is no longer a civil war but a Saudi-funded and inspired jihad against a secular state that has much more support domestically than any of its opponents. Kerry's meeting with King Abdullah looms large for the fate of peace talks in Geneva. It seems to me that the United States is no longer committed to Geneva II. Back in September when Obama was facing a revolt by his party there was a sense that the administration wanted nothing more to do with war games in the Middle East and that it was prepared to shift the paradigm. Out of this came Obama's one-on-one contact with newly-elected Iranian president Rouhani, and ever since we've been dealing with the Saudi and to a lesser extent the Israeli reaction. This is from Rick Gladstone's story, "Kerry to Visit Saudi Arabia to Smooth Relations":
The Saudis are known to have been upset by President Obama’s telephone call with President Hassan Rouhani of Iran on Sept. 27, the first direct contact between an American and Iranian president since the 1979 Islamic Revolution. The call was one of a number of signs that the United States and Iran want to settle the longstanding dispute over Iran’s nuclear energy program. Saudi Arabia considers Iran its strategic rival in the Middle East.
Last week the Moon of Alabama blog raised an important issue: "Syria: After CW Removal, Obama May Again Go For Regime Change." While I don't think Obama will mess with any Tomahawk cruise missile attacks launched from U.S. carriers in the Mediterannean Sea, this doesn't mean that Kerry and King Abdullah won't agree to scuttle Geneva II and then reinvest in the covert war along the Jordanian border.

Iraq is connected of course. Al-Maliki's meeting with Senators Menendez and Corker who lead the Foreign Relation Committee did not go well. Menendez and Corker serve the interests of Israel and House of Saud. The Obama administration's decision on whether to supply the military hardware -- drones, Apache helicopters, Hellfire missiles -- al-Maliki wants to deal with the efflorescence of ISIS in western Iraq should illuminate the way forward on Syria and Iran.

Thursday, October 31, 2013

Gray Lady Once Again Blames the Victim

Today's lede unsigned editorial in the New York Times, "Endless War, Endless Suffering," blames Russia and China for not contributing enough to the United Nations to mitigate the damage caused by Syria's civil war, a war, the Times once again reminds its readers, caused by "President Bashar al-Assad of Syria [when he] used force to crush peaceful protests that began in 2011." 

Nowhere is there a condemnation of the Gulf sheikhdoms for the pipeline of jihadis creating havoc in the region. The Gray Lady acknowledges that the polio outbreak in the eastern city of Deir al-Zour is linked to jihadis from Pakistan: "Public health experts suspect that jihadists who entered Syria to join the fight against Mr. Assad may have been the carriers." But she can't find the words to condemn the nations -- the Saudis in particular -- that are funding these jihadis and actively working against peace talks in Geneva.

Those talks, Geneva II, now appear to be headed for another postponement thanks to Saudi Arabia. This is from Anne Barnard's "Foreign Support for Syrian Rebels Is Hindering Deal, Assad Says":
After a burst of optimism about convening the Geneva talks following Syria’s agreement last month to destroy its chemical weapons arsenal, which averted an American military strike on Mr. Assad’s forces, diplomats have become increasingly pessimistic. Some now privately suggest the talks may be postponed. 
Russia’s foreign minister, Sergey V. Lavrov, who collaborated with Secretary of State John Kerry to push for the chemical weapons agreement and the peace talks, expressed some frustration on Wednesday, suggesting that Saudi Arabia in particular was posing a new obstacle over its unhappiness that the United States had dropped a threat to attack Mr. Assad’s forces. 
“The situation is somewhat more complicated because there have already been open objections to that conference initiated by Russia and the United States, objections not only from various Syrian factions but also from the capitals of some neighboring and not only neighboring states,” Mr. Lavrov told a news conference in Athens, where he was on an official visit. 
Without specifying Saudi Arabia by name, Mr. Lavrov said that “those who sought regime change and helped voluntarily or involuntarily to create an extremists’ state there are now unable to hide their emotions.”
Alan Cowell reports that all Syrian chemical weapons production sites have been decommissioned. As for the two sites that could not be accessed because they were in territory controlled by rebels, the Syrian government has declared to the OPCW that the chemical weapons had been previously removed from those sites:
The Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons in The Hague said in a statement that a joint team of its inspectors and United Nations officials had visited 21 of the 23 chemical sites Syria declared to them. While the remaining two sites were too hazardous to visit because of the country’s continuing civil war, the chemical-making equipment there had already been moved to other sites which the inspectors could visit. 
“The Joint O.P.C.W.-U.N. mission has inspected 21 of the 23 sites declared by Syria, and 39 of the 41 facilities located at those sites,'’ the statement said. “The two remaining sites were not visited due to safety and security concerns. But Syria declared those sites as abandoned and that the chemical weapons program items they contained were moved to other declared sites, which were inspected.” 
“The joint mission is now satisfied that it has verified — and seen destroyed — all of Syria’s declared critical production and mixing/filling equipment,” it added.
Cowell provides a little more detail as to the location of the CW production facilities not in government control:
The watchdog has not specified the precise location of the sites that inspectors were not able to visit on a mission that showed the perils of operating in a war zone where some places are under siege and, in others, battle lines shift unpredictably. 
Michael Luhan, a spokesman for the O.P.C.W., said one of the sites was in the area around Damascus and the other was in the northern Aleppo area, where news reports say government forces have bombarded the town of Safira in recent weeks to try to dislodge rebels including Islamist fighters linked to Al Qaeda. 
“Access to both sites would be extremely risky,” Mr. Luhan said.
Then there is this nugget in the second-to-last paragraph of the story:
“In addition, the Syrian authorities have reported finding two cylinders not belonging to them, which are believed to contain chemical weapons,” the report said, without elaborating, according to the news agency.
As I said before, there needs to be an official reappraisal by the United States of its position that only the Syrian government has access to chemical weapons.

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

Rebels Control Two Syrian Chemical Weapons Sites, Western Reappraisal of Ghouta Attack Called For

The Syrian government has presented a plan to the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons for removal and destruction of the precursor chemicals that make up its chemical weapons arsenal. The United States approves of this method of dismantling Syria's chemical weapons, but as of yet no country has stepped forward to host the mobile American destruction equipment; Norway declined last week. Syria, also to pleasure of USG officials, announced the existence of 41 chemical weapons facilities at 23 sites, putting it more in line with the U.S. assessment that 45 chemical weapons sites existed.

All of this is contained in a story this morning by Nick Cumming-Bruce and Michael Gordon, "Inspectors Visit All but 2 of Syria’s Declared Chemical Sites." Inspectors have visited all 23 sites except for two "because they are in contested areas in Syria’s civil war, the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons said in a statement on Monday."

Later on in the story, the second-to-last paragraph, the reporters try to obscure the obvious, that rebels have access to and control of the very chemicals that the United States alleged that only the Assad regime does:
The two sites the inspectors have not visited are in “contested areas where you need some kind of cease-fire or guarantees for the safety of the inspectors,” Michael Luhan, the agency’s spokesman, said in a telephone interview. It is not clear whether opposition groups control either of the two sites or the territory that inspectors would have to travel through to reach them.
There was no such prevarication when the New York Times reported the story, "Syrian Rebels Urged to Let Inspectors See Arms Sites," of rebel control of chemical weapon sites two weeks ago:
A Western diplomat in the Arab world said that though the Syrian government was legally responsible for dismantling its chemical weapons under an international agreement, its opponents should also cooperate in the process, because several chemical weapons sites were close to confrontation lines or within rebel-held territory. 
“The international community also expects full cooperation from the opposition,” the diplomat said, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss a delicate issue. “However divided the opposition might be, it would look very bad if the government was seen to be cooperating fully, while inspections were held up because of problems with the opposition.”
This is important point because the casus belli  for the Obama administration's aborted missile strike on Syria was based on the argument that Assad's Baathist government had to be responsible for the gas attack on the Damascus suburb of Ghouta that killed hundreds because the rebels didn't have access to the chemicals used in that attack. This was roundly ridiculed by opponents of Western intervention; nonetheless, Secretary of State John Kerry and White House Press Secretary Jay Carney repeated it regularly and the mainstream medium dutifully passed it along to the demos unchallenged. Thankfully, people are much more skeptical about government assurances of "conclusive proof" after Iraq.

Now that it is widely reported that the rebels in fact are in control of some CW sites, you would think that there would be some sort of reappraisal in the prestige press, something along the lines of the mea culpa after the invasion of Iraq revealed no WMD, something that said, "Well, actually, the rebels did have access to the chemicals used in the Ghouta attack."

Maybe it is forthcoming, but I doubt it will be any time soon. The concern among elites is that the American people have grown isolationist in the aftermath of two costly failed occupations. To spotlight another example of our government falsifying, or, to be charitable, tendentiously advocating, a casus belli means that the next invasion is going to be an even tougher sales job. And since it is the mainstream medium's role to pitch wars, owners, executives and editors are not going to go out of their way to make their job more difficult.

Friday, September 27, 2013

Bad Day for the Warmongers

It's a bad day for the warmongers. The United States, France and Britain were unsuccessful in the attempt to craft a Security Council resolution governing Syria's compliance with the Chemical Weapons Convention that would have automatic penalties under Chapter VII of the United Nations Charter. Any penalties for non-compliance will require a second vote of the Security Council. Michael Gordon has the story, "U.N. Deal on Syrian Arms Is Milestone After Years of Inertia."

Here is the "Text of Draft United Nations Resolution on Syrian Chemical Weapons."

This is a resounding win for Syria, for antiwar forces, for Russia. Despite protestations that an attack against Syria would be of a limited nature, it was apparent that what the West had in mind was a Yugoslavia-, Libya-like air power campaign that would drive the Baathist government from office. What would follow in its wake didn't seem to worry the warmongers. At the worst, so the warmonger reasoning goes, there would be more warfare. And this suits the warmonger just fine.

While the civil war will grind on in Syria, the collapse of a sovereign state due to aggression by the West has been avoided for the time being.

My suspicion was that by now the the warmongering foreign policy elite of the United States wanted to have military forces inserted inside Syria with no-fly/no-go zones. Not only is this off the table -- and not only is the chemical weapons canard removed as a future source of provocation -- but the fictional nature of the official opposition -- the Syrian National Coalition -- has recently been exposed. To top it all off, talks between Iran and the West seem to be progressing.

Wednesday, September 25, 2013

Gray Lady's Anne Barnard Interviews Syrian Deputy Foreign Minister Fayssal Mekdad

Anne Barnard has a decent story this morning built around her Tuesday interview in Damascus with Syria's deputy foreign minister, Fayssal Mekdad. It's worth checking out. Some of the highlights:
  • Geneva II is unlikely to happen anytime soon. So the Syrian government is talking about the possibility of staging its own peace talks with "religious and community leaders 'who have influence on the ground' with fighters."
"But Mr. Mekdad suggested the government doubted the usefulness of talking to leaders of the National Coalition of Syrian Revolutionary and Opposition Forces, the exile group that the West and its Arab allies have tried to set up as the government’s opposition counterpart and the civilian leadership of the loose-knit rebel Free Syrian Army. Excluding that group would be a nonstarter for the United States and its allies.
"But Mr. Mekdad and prominent government supporters in Damascus said the coalition was increasingly irrelevant, not only lacking control over its own forces, but over foreign jihadist groups increasingly prominent on the battlefield — a view widely shared by Syrians who oppose the government."
  • Following Syria's agreement to get rid of its chemical weapons, "Mr. Mekdad said the natural next step was an international push for Israel to relinquish its arsenal of nuclear weapons, which the neighboring state has never formally acknowledged."
  • The Syrian deputy foreign minister said that the government was "100 percent sure" that the rebels were behind the August 21 Ghouta chemical weapon attack.
  • Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) is consolidating its position in northern Syria and hardening its drive for a caliphate by attacking other rebel groups:
"A Syrian journalist said recent fighting between armed groups in the rebel-held north changed the calculations of Syrian and Western leaders regarding the proposed talks in Geneva.

"The journalist, who supports the government but requested anonymity to go beyond official statements, said he believed the extremist Islamic State in Iraq and Syria was trying to seize ground from other rebel groups. 
"'I don’t think Geneva is really close to us, but what is close to us is a huge problem,' he said. 'If we don’t fight it in next two, three, four weeks, this means that inside of the Middle East, near Europe’s border, there is a state auto-financed and controlled by terrorists.'
"He said he could even envision a situation in which an international coalition was formed to fight alongside the Syrian Army against the jihadists, a prospect that seemed unlikely for now as the West continues to insist Mr. Assad leave power.
"Mr. Mekdad dismissed that notion and said the government sought a “peace coalition” to end the financing of armed opposition groups by America’s allies Saudi Arabia and Qatar, adding that aid to the Syrian government from its allies Russia and Iran was permissible within relations between sovereign states."
I think that there's a greater chance that the West will use the existence of an Al Qaeda enclave in northern Syria as an excuse to launch strikes against the Syrian government rather than cooperate with it. It's part of pattern that we've come to expect from the United States and its allies: foment unrest and then use that unrest as an excuse to exercise military force.

Wednesday, September 18, 2013

Chapter VII a Stretch for the West Despite Winning Propaganda War on Ghouta CW Attack

C.J. Chivers, a reporter who does good work, has another story today, "U.N. Data on Gas Attack Points to Assad’s Top Forces," fleshing out the azimuths evidence contained in the recently released United Nations report on the August 21 chemical weapons attack in the Damascus suburb of Ghouta. The angle of impact taken from rocket craters point to the Republican Guard 104th Brigade located atop Mount Qasioun. This revelation, mostly unanswered in the last 36 hours, is being countered this morning by the Syrian government. Agence France Presse reports that "Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said Wednesday after the first of two days of talks in Damascus that the Syrian regime has handed Russia new materials implicating rebels in the attack that horrified the world." Ake Sellstrom's UN investigators are returning to Syria to continue inspections.

Regardless of the actual truth of who is behind the Ghouta chemical attack, the Syrian government has been losing the rhetorical war with the West since Monday. This has given renewed impetus in the Security Council to include Chapter VII sanctions in the draft resolution governing Syrian compliance with the Chemical Weapons Convention. Here's Rick Gladstone's take in "Security Council Returns to Role in Syria Conflict":
[D]iplomats, who declined to be identified, said Russia, Syria’s most important ally, was resisting components of the draft, composed by the three Western permanent members — Britain, France and the United States — that discuss the threat of force to ensure Syrian compliance, whether to condemn the Syrian government for chemical weapons use and whether suspected users should be referred to the International Criminal Court for war crimes prosecutions. 
The discussions are unlikely to produce a quick resolution, the diplomats said, and it is unclear when a draft will be ready for a vote.
Even though Syria and their Russian ally are losing the public relations war on the Ghouta attack, they remain in a strong position vis-a-vis the West. Public opinion is overwhelming against military intervention even though a super-majority already believes the Syrian government to be responsible for the attack; that's what polls published earlier showed. The United States Government is facing the very real threat of a shutdown in the near future. In his negotiations with the House GOP there is no way Obama is going to risk losing public support by launching a unilateral strike. Russia will block any threat of force or official condemnation in the Security Council. It is likely that Sellstrom's inspection team will eventually document evidence of rebel chemical weapons use. The West will do everything it can to prevent this because once it happens any military support for the opposition will be exceedingly difficult to justify to a public bludgeoned about the horrors of using gas on the battlefield.