Showing posts with label Nuri Kamal al-Maliki. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nuri Kamal al-Maliki. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 10, 2015

Obama Switches Up the ISIS Narrative

An interesting item that emerged from the G7 summit in Krün was Obama's statement about the important role of foreign fighters in the offensive capabilities of Islamic State. According to Julie Hirschfeld Davis and Michael Shear, "Ukraine Crisis and Advance of ISIS Dominate Agenda for Group of 7":
At a news conference Monday after the close of the summit meeting, Mr. Obama acknowledged a need to accelerate the training of Iraqi military forces to counter the advance of Islamic State militants, and he said that he had asked the Pentagon for a plan to do that.

“We don’t have, yet, a complete strategy, because it requires commitments on the part of Iraqis as well,” Mr. Obama said. “The details are not worked out.” 
Mr. Obama said of the militants of the Islamic State, also known as ISIL and ISIS: “They’re nimble and they’re aggressive and they’re opportunistic.” 
He acknowledged that the training of Iraqi forces “has not been happening as fast as it needs to.” And he said the United States has “made some progress, but not enough” in stemming the flow of foreign fighters into Iraq and Syria. 
Mr. Obama said that “thousands” of new fighters were replenishing the ranks of the Islamic State faster than the coalition could remove them from the fight. 
“If we can cut off some of that foreign fighter flow, then we are able to isolate and wear out ISIL forces that are already there,” Mr. Obama said. “Because we are taking a lot of them off the battlefield, but if they’re being replenished, then it doesn’t solve the problem over the long term.”
The president also said that Turkey was not doing what was required to monitor its border with Syria and halt the stream of fighters. 
Earlier on Monday, Mr. Obama met with Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi of Iraq, where he reaffirmed the world powers’ commitment to supporting Iraq in the fight against the Islamic State, which has made major gains in recent weeks. 
“Although it is going to take time, and there will be setbacks and lessons learned, we are going to be successful,” Mr. Obama said at the start of his meeting with Mr. Abadi. “ISIL is going to be driven out of Iraq, and ultimately, it is going to be defeated.”
This represents an about-face by the U.S. president. From the outset, ISIS has been defined by USG/Western media as an indigenous, Anbar-based response to the predatory overreach of Iraqi prime minister Nuri al-Maliki.

The Cracker Jacks version of the story goes something like this: Because al-Maliki refused to pay the Sunni Sons of Iraq, as was promised, Al Qaeda in Iraq rose from its ashes in Anbar, using the war next door in Syria as a proving ground, and reconstituted itself as Islamic State in Iraq and Syria.

The United States spread this story last year as a way to successfully force out al-Maliki as prime minister. Now the story changes. It is really the flow of foreign fighters via the border with Turkey that makes Islamic State so lethal and not because it is an Anbar-based popular guerrilla movement.

This puts Obama more in line with the fact-based reporting of, say, a Patrick Cockburn writing for The Independent whose interviews with Sunnis who have fled Anbar establish convincingly that ISIS is foreign-led, i.e., Chechens, Saudis, Libyans, et al.

I haven't seen anything in the mainstream press drawing attention to this latest Obama somersault, though there has been a reaction to Obama's statement that "We don't have, yet, a complete strategy . . . ." For instance, Shreeya Sinha in "Obama’s Evolution on ISIS" has a helpful compendium of Obama's twists and turns, beginning with "ISIS is a J.V. squad of takfiris," or something along those lines, to the latest on June 8, "We don't have a complete strategy."

All the evasions, false starts and missteps can be attributed to the fact that Obama has to obscure the obvious -- ISIS is a creation of U.S. allies Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Qatar, the same allies the U.S. has been working with to funnel fighters into Syria. In the war against ISIS, the United States is battling an enemy that it worked to create. Naturally this kind of disingenuousness -- saying you are fighting the takfiris while aiding the takfiris -- is going to result in policy confusion.

The plan floated this morning (Michael Gordon, "U.S. Embracing a New Approach on Battling ISIS in Iraq") is that the U.S. is going to occupy Al Taqqadum, a base outside the Anbar town of Habbaniya, and use it as a training hub for the recapture of Ramadi:
To assemble a force to retake Ramadi, the number of Iraqi tribal fighters in Anbar who are trained and equipped is expected to increase to as many as 10,000 from about 5,500. 
More than 3,000 new Iraqi soldiers are to be recruited to fill the ranks of the Seventh Iraqi Army division in Anbar and the Eighth Iraqi Army division, which is in Habbaniyah, where the Iraqi military operations center for the province is also based. 
But to the frustration of critics like Senator John McCain, Republican of Arizona, who say that the United States is losing the initiative to the Islamic State, the Obama administration has yet to approve the use of American spotters on the battlefield to call in airstrikes in and around Ramadi. Nor has it approved the use of Apache helicopter gunships to help Iraqi troops retake the city.
It was the U.S.-trained Iraqi Army that disintegrated in Mosul last year at this time. One wonders how this training mission will be any different. And where is any mention of the Shiite militias currently in Anbar, the Popular Mobilization Committees?

My sense is that this is all part of the U.S. shadow dance. The U.S. is putatively at war with ISIS, but it is really at war with its Sunni allies, who are at war with Iran; at the same time, the U.S. is also at war with Iran. Everything is topsy-turvy. To keep Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Kuwait and Qatar from ratcheting up support for the takfiri fighters, the U.S. must re-station troops in the region.

That's what we're looking at here. The GCC wants the U.S. military footprint back on the ground. Absent that, more war.

Tuesday, December 16, 2014

Waltz for Debby


I'm suffering from a migraine this morning. So instead of sitting in front of the laptop and typing out something on Tim Arango's story, "Iraq’s Premier Narrows Divide, but Challenges Loom," about the ongoing Abadi-vs.-Maliki conflict in Baghdad, I went back to bed and listened to Bill Evans.

Waltz for Debby (1961) is one of those records that can be listened to repeatedly, and over the years I have.

When I was in my twenties, a coworker made me a cassette tape of the album. It was late fall, like it is now.

Tuesday, August 12, 2014

"ISIS Consolidates" But an Independent Kurdistan is Here to Stay

It appears that Maliki has a legitimate beef. Iraqi president, Fuad Masum, a Kurd, should have nominated Maliki, as head of the largest parliamentary bloc, prime minister and given him a shot at forming a new government. Instead, with the United States working diligently behind the scene to make sure Maliki was afforded no such opportunity, president Masum designated Haider al-Abadi, a member of Maliki's Dawa Party, prime minister. (There was a good OpEd yesterday by Zaid al-Ali, "Iraq’s Rot Starts at the Top," singling out Abadi as the best of a group of potential Maliki replacements because he is open to outside influence. Coincidence? Probably not.)

Maliki responded to his ouster by mustering troops in the Green Zone in Baghdad and promising legal action in the courts. But as noted in "Iraqis Nominate Maliki Successor, Causing Standoff," by Tim Arango, Alissa Rubin and Michael Gordon,
The question is whether Mr. Abadi, who like many of Iraq’s Shiite leaders led a life of exile until the American invasion in 2003 ousted Saddam Hussein, can forge a grand political bargain with meaningful roles for the two significant minority factions, Sunni Arabs and Kurds. Under the Constitution, he has a 30-day window to conclude the sort of back-room deals — promises of positions and ministries, which sustain Iraq’s system of patronage — that would be the backbone of a new government.
With 30 days to form a government Maliki can make a lot of mischief. He has an extensive security force at his disposal. But the reality is that he has all the big players lined up against him: Iran, the U.S. and the religious authority of Grand Ayatollah Sistani; plus, if things got hot in the Green Zone, it would be forces loyal to Maliki against Muqtada al-Sadr's militias and the Badr Corps of the Islamic Supreme Council of Iraq. Baghdad would be weakened by such fighting and rendered easy prey for Islamic State.

No, Maliki is gone. The writing on the wall is clear. The U.S. is dangling more support upon formation of a new government by Abadi. It seems as if the Obama administration will get its wish, which is for a federalized Iraq, a nation composed of three states: Kurdistan, Sunnistan and Shiastan.

Already the U.S. is greasing the skids on arms shipments -- weapons of all kinds, both light and heavy -- to the Kurds. The CIA has taken the lead, but the Pentagon is not far behind. Kurdistan is here to stay. That appears to be fact now. Allow me to quote at length a good story, "Pentagon Says Airstrikes Have Slowed but Not Stopped Sunni Militants," by Helene Cooper and Alissa Rubin:
The Central Intelligence Agency has begun directly supplying weapons to pesh merga fighters, administration officials said, after weeks of pleas and demands from leaders in the country’s semiautonomous Kurdish region for help in fighting ISIS. But it remains unclear just how much weaponry the United States has funneled through to the Kurds so far; military officials said they would probably begin sending small-arms munitions soon, too.
A C.I.A. spokesman declined to comment.
“The pesh merga are composed of capable, disciplined forces who deserve their reputation as fierce mountain-war fighters,” a United States official said. “However, it’s been almost a decade since their mostly light infantry brigades have been tested in battle, so it’s not surprising that they’ve taken some knocks from ISIL.”
The Kurds, who say they need armor-piercing munitions to help penetrate heavily fortified tanks captured by ISIS fighters from both the Syrian and Iraqi militaries, will soon be getting long-range weapons as well. 
“Some of the ISIL forces have a longer-range weapons system, so we need to make sure that the government of Iraq and the Iraqi security forces are providing longer-range weapons themselves to the Kurdish forces,” General Mayville said. 
The Kurds have asked the United States to provide — or in some way help them obtain — sniper rifles, mortars, heavy machine guns, wire-guided antitank weapons and antitank guns, rocket-propelled grenades, Humvees and tanks, among other weapons, Kurdish officials said. They have also asked for body armor and helicopters for evacuations.
A senior military official said Monday that the Pentagon was concentrating on rifles and machine guns. He declined to say what kinds of weapons the C.I.A. had begun supplying the Kurds. 
A second Pentagon official, also speaking on the condition of anonymity as a matter of policy, said that the Defense Department had yet to decide whether it would supply the pesh merga with antitank guns, but that “whatever they are getting will be in line with meeting the proper requirements for the kind of defenses that they’re conducting.” 
In the past, American officials have been hesitant about directly supplying weapons to the Kurds, who differ with Iraq’s current prime minister, Nuri Kamal al-Maliki, over the division of oil resources and how much territory should fall within the Kurdistan region’s borders. In addition, the Kurds initially took advantage of the conflict with ISIS to expand their own territory in northern Iraq. Many Obama administration officials say privately that they do not expect Kurdistan to remain part of Iraq once the fighting is over.
So even though the pesh merga were routed by Islamic State in Jalawla, a town in Diyala Province that borders Kurdistan, forcing the vaunted Kurdish fighters to stage another "tactical retreat," it is clear that with robust support from the United States the Kurds will hold on. What these means in terms of oil revenue and the status of Kirkuk is unclear; it also unclear at this point the extent to which the Obama administration is willing to roll back IS's gains in northern Iraq. Patrick Cockburn's article, "Isis Consolidates" in the London Review of Books, recommended Sunday by the Moon of Alabama blog, paints a picture of a caliphate that is going to be around for some time.

Cockburn is of the opinion that an attack on Baghdad is inevitable and that Iraq's Shia are in a state of denial, having drunk the Kool-Aid handed out by the U.S. that the problem is Maliki and that once Maliki goes all will right itself.

In the near term, Cockburn thinks that IS will turn its attention again to toppling Assad, starting with Aleppo. And that once the Syrian Arab Army crumbles the U.S. and its allies in the Middle East, the Israelis and the Gulf monarchies, not to mention Iran and Hezbollah, will have a real crisis to contend with.

Cockburn is of the school of thought that IS is a Frankenstein monster, a creation of the Saudis that has proven too powerful to control. Now it is pursuing its own agenda. I am skeptical of this.

Friday, August 8, 2014

Islamic State Riding High

The U.S. behemoth, ever ready to display its full-spectrum dominance on any battlefield no matter how remote, is doing all it can to keep from locking horns with Islamic State. What makes this so bizarre is that a greater villain, a more evil "evil doer," could not be found if you called central casting at a major Hollywood studio. ISIS rapes and murders and crucifies and steals and plunders according to the Wahhabi view of the world, brought to you thanks to the petroleum wealth of Al Saud. One would think that U.S. Special Forces, supposedly the greatest fighters on the planet, would be quickly deployed to prevent the genocide of religious minorities. I mean, really, it is all too perfect. For a nation that lives and dies by the movies -- or at least used to -- this is America's righteous moment.

But all Obama committed to in his announcement last night from the White House was air support for the Yazidis trapped on Mount Sinjar by marauding jihadis, as well as air power protection of Kurdistan's capital city of Erbil and the Iraqi capital Baghdad. According to Helene Cooper, Mark Landler and Alissa Rubin in "Obama Allows Limited Airstrikes on ISIS":
While Mr. Obama has authorized airstrikes, American officials said there had not yet been any as of late Thursday. In addition to protecting Americans in Erbil and Baghdad, the president said he had authorized airstrikes, if necessary, to break the siege on Mount Sinjar, where tens of thousands of Yazidis, a religious minority group closely allied with the Kurds, have sought refuge.
There is some mystery as to who hit ISIS with airstrikes in two towns near Erbil, whether it was the U.S., as Iraqi and Kurdish officials originally announced, or Iraq flying the few planes at its disposal:
The [senior Obama administration] official said that as conditions in Iraq deteriorated in recent days, the United States had worked with Iraqi security forces and Kurdish fighters to coordinate the response to militant advances. The official said the cooperation had included airstrikes by Iraqi forces against militant targets in the north. 
Kurdish and Iraqi officials said that airstrikes were carried out Thursday night on two towns in northern Iraq seized by ISIS — Gwer and Mahmour, near Erbil. Earlier on Thursday, The New York Times quoted Kurdish and Iraqi officials as saying that the strikes were carried out by American planes.
The conventional wisdom regarding Obama's reticence to beat down ISIS has to do with domestic politics. Obama doesn't want to do an about-face on one of his defining presidential achievements, bringing the troops home from Iraq:
“The White House is going to recognize that the need to commit air power to Iraq, even for a purely humanitarian mission, is going to open them up to greater criticism for their disengagement from Iraq,” said Kenneth M. Pollack, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. “So they will do their damnedest not to get further involved in Iraq because that would just further validate those criticisms.”
I think there is some truth to this. But the real reason, what few people seem to be talking about in the comments section appended to this story, is that the U.S. has some sort of secret arrangement with the regional powers -- Saudi Arabia and Israel -- to let Islamic State reorder the Middle East along conservative sectarian lines in the aftermath of the Arab Spring. Both the Saudis and Israelis were incensed with Obama that he cut loose Mubarak in Egypt, paving the way for the Muslim Brothers to come to power. The House of Saud was downright apoplectic that Obama didn't bomb the Assad government to kingdom come last year. Pretty much from that moment on ISIS has grown all out of any organic proportion ever heard of for a grassroots guerrilla movement, which it is obviously not.

Obama was put on notice that his school-boy fantasy of democracy for the Middle East was kaput. The neocons teeming throughout the deep U.S. national security state lined up behind the Saudi solution of a caliphate. The Israelis liked the idea because it spelled doom for their bete noire, Iran.

But ISIS, always on the lookout for low-hanging fruit, decided to go after the Kurds instead of driving immediately to Baghdad. This, I am assuming, was not part of the agreement since there was ample evidence of collusion between the Salafis and the Kurds back in June when Mosul fell to the ISIS blitz and the Kurds promptly took Kirkuk. Rod Nordland, the Gray Lady's reporter on the ground, noted that the pesh merga and the jihadis assiduously avoided one another then.

Tim Arango has an excellent story, "Jihadists Rout Kurds in North and Seize Strategic Iraqi Dam." Arango makes three things clear:

1) Maliki is history. Right now he is holding out for an immunity agreement:
As Iraqi leaders, the country’s top religious authorities and top Iranian officials, who wield considerable power within Iraq, pushed for Mr. Maliki’s removal, he was refusing to step aside Thursday night. Even those within his own State of Law bloc were demanding that he leave. 
“Everyone is saying no to Maliki now,” said a member of Parliament from State of Law, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the delicate nature of the discussions. “He’s rejected by all parties.” 
If he were to step down, Mr. Maliki has reportedly demanded immunity from prosecution for himself, his family and his inner circle, and a massive security detail, paid for by the state.
2) The martial prowess of the Kurdish pesh merga is a CIA-promoted fiction:
Kurdish fighters have a long history of resistance to central governments in Iraq and Turkey, and among Kurds, a storied reputation as mountain fighters. But since the end of the first Persian Gulf war in 1991, after which they received years of air cover from the West in their enclave in northern Iraq, they have transitioned from resistance to standing security forces. 
Kurdish forces have proven adept at providing local security in the Kurdish autonomous zones, but less capable at independent military operations. Their successes have often included Western support, including from the C.I.A. and the American Special Forces. But they are not trained, equipped or organized for large-scale independent operations, for integrating fire support into their ground operations, or for countering aggressive insurgent bombing campaigns.
Those deficiencies were apparent in fighting in recent days, as ISIS captured several towns over the weekend and continued its march north.
3) Control of Mosul Dam is a huge victory for ISIS:
The dam, on the Tigris River about 30 miles northwest of Mosul, provides electricity to Mosul and controls the water supply for a large area. A report published in 2007 by the United States government, which had been involved with work on the dam and spent nearly $30 million on repairs, warned that should it fail, a 65-foot wave of water would be unleashed across areas of northern Iraq. 
Stuart W. Bowen Jr., the former special inspector general for Iraq reconstruction, who oversaw the 2007 report on the dam, said ISIS could certainly use the dam as a weapon of war, but that it could also use it as a means of finance, by extorting money in exchange for water or electricity. 
ISIS has already used Iraq’s water supply as a weapon. Earlier this year it seized control of the Falluja Dam, in Anbar Province, and flooded a vast area that sent thousands of refugees fleeing, submerged hundreds of homes and several schools and interrupted the water supply to southern Iraq.

Ammar Jassim, a 35-year-old resident of Falluja, fled the city earlier this year not because of the fighting but because of the flooding. “We lost everything,” he said. “It was a water invasion.” 
If the Mosul Dam were to be damaged, “it would be like a tsunami coming down the Tigris,” said Azzam Alwash, a prominent environmentalist and engineer and the founder of Nature Iraq, a nonprofit group. 
ISIS is also battling for control of the Haditha Dam, Iraq’s second largest, which is also in Anbar Province. As of Thursday, the dam was still under the control of the Iraqi security forces and allied tribal fighters.
Given Obama's weakness and reluctance I think it is safe to say that ISIS will keep pressing its advantage.

Monday, August 4, 2014

The Caliphate Grows, as Does the Case Against Kiev in the Downing of MH17

Islamic State was on the march over the weekend. The jihadis routed the vaunted pesh merga in three Iraqi cities north of Mosul: Zumar, Wana and Sinjar. Tim Arango reports from Baghdad in "Sunni Extremists in Iraq Seize 3 Towns From Kurds and Threaten Major Dam" that
In a statement, ISIS boasted of conquering “more important areas which were controlled by the pesh merga and the secular militias.” With the new territory, which the group described as “the border triangle of Iraq, Syria and Turkey,” ISIS strengthened its hold on territory that traverses the frontiers of Iraq and Syria, giving it an even greater ability to move fighters and weapons between the front lines of the civil wars in both countries. 
According to security officials and residents in the area, the Kurdish forces were routed from Zumar, a town on the road from the Syrian border that also sits on oil fields, and then Sinjar. Sinjar, an isolated city in northwestern Iraq, has been home to a sizable community of Yazidis, Kurdish speakers who ascribe to a religion that combines elements of Islam and ancient Persian religions and who are considered apostates by Muslim extremists. 
Later on Sunday, the militants captured Wana, a strategic town near the Tigris River — putting them within striking distance of the Mosul Dam, the country’s largest and an important supplier of electricity and water. The dam is on the Tigris River about 30 miles northwest of Mosul, Iraq’s second-largest city, which fell to ISIS on June 10. 
Yazidi residents of Sinjar, who were reached by phone, were terrified. They told of kidnappings and executions of members of their sect. One resident, Sami Hassan, said he was at work at a hospital on Sunday when an injured ISIS fighter arrived and demanded to know the sect to which Mr. Hassan belonged.
Mr. Hassan said he had escaped from a window while being shot at. 
Another local, Khudhur Rasho, said he had seen two Yazidi men executed and the members of 10 families, their hands bound behind their back, being led away by militants. 
A State Department spokeswoman, Jen Psaki, said Sunday that ISIS posed “a dire threat to all Iraqis, the entire region and the international community” and that the United States would continue to seek ways to support the Iraqi security forces and the Kurdish pesh merga. 
The seizing of the three towns in a triangle that stretches north and west from Mosul to the borders of Syria and Turkey allowed the extremists to expand their territory, but the capture of the Mosul Dam would be a bigger prize, and could give the militants the ability to unleash a deadly flood on large populations.
Also over the weekend, Islamic State, operating with Nusra and Free Syrian Army fighters, took the Lebanese border town of Arsal. Hwaida Saad reports in "Fighters From Syria Kill 10 Lebanese Soldiers in Battle Over Border Town" that
Islamist fighters from Syria killed 10 Lebanese soldiers and appeared to have captured more than a dozen others in an armed offensive that left them in a tense battle for control of a Lebanese border town, Lebanon’s army chief said Sunday. 
The new toll was reported one day after fighters from Syria — who included members of rebel brigades, an affiliate of Al Qaeda and the extremist Islamic State in Iraq and Syria — carried out a series of attacks on army checkpoints that left them largely in control of the town of Arsal. 
The two-day clash was the most recent spillover into Lebanon from the civil war in neighboring Syria. The two countries share a complex web of political and sectarian ties that have made the violence in Syria resonate in its smaller neighbor, where street clashes, car bombs and political deadlock related to the war in Syria have been common.
Residents, aid workers and Syrian rebels reached in Arsal on Sunday said that insurgents had seized the town but that it was surrounded by the Lebanese Army, which was shelling it.
The weekend gains by Islamic State represent acute problems for U.S. policy in the region. First, while publicly opposed to IS, as the Jan Psaki quote in the Arango story makes clear, the United States has actual done nothing to stem the caliphate's growth. In fact, overwhelming, the Obama administration's reaction to the Salafis military advance on June 10, which led to the capture of Mosul, has been to blame Iraq's Shiite prime minister Nuri al-Maliki. Now that IS has turned its aggression on the Kurds, trusted American allies, and the Kurds are crying out for military assistance, it is going to be interesting to see how the U.S. manages its allegiance to both the House of Saud, the main benefactor of Islamic State, and Kurdistan, where the United States is expanding a drone facility at Erbil.

Patrick Cockburn, who has a new book out on Islamic State, had a piece over the weekend on the Counterpunch web site that is quite bullish on the prospects of continued success for the caliphate. He sees IS as shrewd and disciplined, consolidating its territorial gains while always on the look-out to pluck low-hanging fruit. Cockburn does not have many good things to say about the Shia leadership of Iraq. He predicts a jihadi encirclement and prolonged siege of Baghdad. Things are going to go from bad to worse.

The attack on Lebanon, no favorite of the U.S. because of Hezbollah, represents trouble for Obama due to the presence of Free Syrian Army fighters among the jihadis. The FSA, presumably, remains the United States principal Syrian ally in the battle against the Assad government. Getting the FSA weapons, training and hundreds of millions of dollars is going to be difficult if it is operating in open alliance with, as State Department spokeswoman Psaki says, “a dire threat to all Iraqis, the entire region and the international community.”

So the difficulties mount for Team Obama. The presidential recount that Kerry negotiated in Afghanistan is tottering. Carlotta Gall reports in "Disputes Threaten to Derail Audit of Afghanistan Vote" that an argument between the Adbullah Abdullah and Ashraf Ghani camps as to what counts as an invalidated ballot brought the recount to a halt over the weekend, necessitating direct intervention by the U.S. State Departmant. The Abdullah camp revealed tape of a telephone conversation which seems to show that there was a criminal conspiracy by the Karzai government and international community to swing the runoff to Ghani:
Also on Sunday, Mr. Abdullah’s campaign manager released an audiotape on which he said Vice President Karim Khalili could be heard directing his followers to support Mr. Ghani in the runoff. An aide to Mr. Khalili has denounced the tape as fake, according to the independent television news channel Tolo TV. 
In the tape the speaker, who sounded like Mr. Khalili but had not been independently verified as such, said that the international community, the election commission and the president all supported Mr. Ghani for president. He even suggested that Afghanistan’s allies would tolerate the use of any means to achieve such a result. 
“Our international friends have promised us that by using any means and using any opportunity, the election outcome must turn in favor of this team, even if these opportunities, even if these means are against electoral mechanisms,” the voice said.
Mr. Abdullah’s campaign manager, Baryalai Arsalai, said the tape proved that the election fraud had been planned to return a victory for Mr. Ghani. 
“This evidence was released today to inform our countrymen that our president, other government elders and the so-called election commission are instruments,” Mr. Arsalai said. The election was a public process, he said, calling it the right of the Afghan people, not the president or the commission chief. “We have a responsibility to let people know that their rights are being violated,” he said.  
Mr. Arsalai vouched for the tape’s authenticity and said details proving that would be released later.
Afghanistan is not going to make it. Thus, with Lebanese territory now under jihadi control and the Taliban soon to be back in power, the caliphate rises, from the Mediterranean to the Durand Line.

Before signing off for the day, it is worth mentioning that the U.S. control of the MH17 narrative is slipping fast. Two good articles over the weekend -- Mike Whitney's "The Unanswered Questions of MH17" and Robert Parry's "Flight 17 Shoot-Down Scenario Shifts" -- marshal the evidence and clarify the events since July 17, and everything points to the Kiev junta. The arguments that Whitney and Parry present are compelling. There is even a possibility that their line of thinking will find its way to the mainstream.

Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Iraq's Parliamentary Standoff + Avakov Parades in Slovyansk

Yesterday an announcement was made that the Iraqi Council of Representatives would not meet for another five weeks, delaying the formation of a new government until August. After an outcry from Iraq's allies and its religious establishment a new statement was made. Parliament will convene this Sunday. According to the Alissa Rubin and Suadad al-Salhy, reporting in "Iraqi Parliament Wobbles Over Forming Government," the "Maliki Must Go" motto is a facade masking Sunni and Kurdish backroom demands -- Kirkuk for the Kurds and control of the defense ministry for the Sunnis -- that if acquiesced to by the Shiite majority will amount to the de facto partition of Iraq:
“The session was postponed until Aug. 12 because of the disagreement and the conflict between the blocs,” said Aboud al-Essawi, a member of Mr. Maliki’s predominantly Shiite State of Law party, referring to other political parties.
The Sunnis said they were ready to proceed, but wanted the Shiites to make the first move. “We are still saying that we are ready to present our candidate for speaker whenever the National Alliance presents its candidate for prime minister, and it can be anyone else but not Maliki,” said Dafar al-Ani, a spokesman for the main Sunni bloc, referring to a coalition of Shiite parties.
“The National Alliance asked for more time to make their final decision,” he added.
Beneath the blame game are real differences in what is acceptable to different groups. For instance, a large number of Shiites now want to remove Mr. Maliki, but his party won the most parliamentary seats, so he cannot be summarily kicked aside. And there are differences of opinion about who might be an acceptable successor, first to all the Shiite blocs, but then also to the Sunnis and the Kurds.
Mr. Maliki says that removing him just as Iraq is trying to reconstitute its demoralized army would undermine those in the fight. While that might seem a convenient argument to prolong his time in power, at least some lawmakers appear to agree.
Even a senior leader in the Islamic Supreme Council of Iraq, a Shiite party that now opposes Mr. Maliki, said that “replacing Maliki now could be seen as a victory for the terrorists, and it also could adversely reflect the security leadership’s morale because if Maliki is not there anymore, they could be dismissed or accused of corruption.”
The Sunnis are demanding an amnesty for the tens of thousands of Sunni imprisoned — unjustly, they say, in most cases — by the Maliki government and a bigger say in how the country is run, including its security services. While some Shiites might be willing to give that to them, others are adamantly opposed.
The Kurds believe they have an absolute right to include Kirkuk and some surrounding disputed villages in the autonomous Kurdish region, but neither the Sunnis nor the Shiites want to cede that ground, especially since the Kurds have made it plain that their ultimate goal is independence.
While each group has defensible reasons for its views, taken together they amount to stasis.
I think Maliki is gone. The only way that he stays is if the Shiite National Alliance bloc agrees to all the demands of the Sunnis and Kurds. Then all the fulminating about the menace, the corruption of Maliki will disappear overnight and he will be touted as a singularly necessary statesman. But majority of the Shiites that constitute the National Alliance are not going to go for this. The next largest Shiite political formation to Maliki's State of Law coalition is the Sadrist Al-Ahrar Bloc whose raison d'etre is dump Maliki. Then there is the clerical establishment's willingness to part ways with the prime minister. Granted, Sistani has not come right out and said "Maliki must go," but this is only because the Grand Ayatollah does not believe it is his role to publicly dictate the official composition of parliamentary government.

My understanding last week was that the National Alliance had its PM lined up, and it wasn't Maliki. Realizing this and not wanting the Shiites to succeed so quickly in forming a new government the Kurds and Sunnis walked out. Now the Kurds and Sunnis want the Shiites to "show" their candidate for prime minister before they "show" their candidates for speaker (Sunnis) and president (Kurds). The Shiites are loath to do this because once they name Maliki's replacement, if the Sunnis and Kurds continue to delay, Maliki will be the lamest of lame ducks; his authority will be gone, and his ability to actively prosecute the war against Islamic State will be nil.

Absent complete capitulation by the National Alliance to Sunni and Kurdish demands, expect the stasis to continue.

Some words about Ukraine this morning. David Herszenhorn writes from Kiev, "Ukraine Rebels Are Retreating for Last Stand," about Strelkov's forces, retreating from Slovyansk and Kramatorsk, blowing up bridges leading to Donetsk and erecting barricades around that city as well as Luhansk. The junta military is establishing a blockade.

Two things. First, a passage reaffirming the position that Russia has already won the conflict, if one believes, as I do, that this conflict has always been about Germany's economic alignment with Russia. The United States wants to block that, wants to keep the European Union under the sway exclusively of the military North Atlantic alliance. The U.S has failed.
Negotiations have faltered since Mr. Poroshenko called off the cease-fire, saying it was playing into the rebels’ hands. An abridged session in Kiev on Sunday involved representatives of Ukraine, Russia and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, but Mr. Lavrov described it as pointless without the participation of militants, who he noted could not travel to the capital “for obvious reasons.” 
Echoing Mr. Lavrov, the German government on Monday issued an urgent plea, calling for a rapid, unconditional and mutual cessation of hostilities, and said it was urgent to organize talks that included the separatists. However, in a television interview, the deputy chief of staff of Mr. Poroshenko’s administration, Valeriy Chaly, said Ukraine would follow its own course.
Finally, I am very critical of the Gray Lady and the reporters who labor for her. Yes, these reporters are careerists; but even when they are scribbling the party line, they often find ways to subvert the official narrative. Occasionally, they are even brilliant, as is Herszenhorn at the end of his story when he describes the Goebbelsian junta interior minister Arsen Avakov taking a victory lap in a shattered, terrorized, bomb-strewn Slovyansk:
On Monday afternoon in Slovyansk, Ukraine’s interior minister, Arsen Avakov, stood under a statue of Lenin, promising to bring the “terrorists” to justice and restore basic services to the city by the end of the day.
Residents greeted him with questions about reconstruction and compensation for damage as a light mist coated the central square. Some shed tears at the mere mention of running water.
“What kind of future is there for Ukraine?” one elderly woman in a blue plastic poncho asked the minister.
“A beautiful one,” Mr. Avakov said, flashing a smile.
But beauty was nowhere to be found in Slovyansk, where broken glass, severed electrical cables and a wasteland of unexploded mortar shells define the landscape. Control came at the expense of untold destruction.
Outside a gold-domed church on the northern edge of the square, Ukrainian soldiers distributed water from the back of a truck. While thirsty residents accepted the aid, their attitudes toward the new armed arrivals were decidedly mixed.
Sveta Zinovyeva, 17, spent the end of her school year holed up in a basement with her family. She said she had read romance novels to distract from the “horrible fear.”

Thursday, July 3, 2014

The Gray Lady Keeps the "Maliki to Blame" Headlines Coming

Yesterday this page opined that the U.S. reaction to the adjournment of the opening session of Iraq's parliament after less than a hour would be very illuminating in terms of what the Obama administration's position on an independent Kurdistan and a newly risen caliphate actually is. I said, "To continue to blame Maliki's government at this point when it is clear that he is on his way out and that the Shiite alliance has a replacement ready would be compelling proof of a conspiracy to aid the advance of Islamic State and the de facto partition of Iraq."

Well, we have a clear answer today. Rod Nordland, after providing a wonderful report yesterday about how Sunni and Kurdish politicians hijacked the formation of a new government, returns to the familiar "blame Maliki" script in "Iraqi Premier Places Unity Second to Fighting ISIS." The assumption I am making here, which I believe to be a safe one, one that is readily accepted by anyone who has read the Gray Lady everyday for years as I have, is that the New York Times largely reflects Foggy Bottom thinking, policies and priorities.

The story Nordland writes today is really no story, but more of an excuse to print a headline that places the horns yet again on the scapegoat Maliki. The Iraqi leader went on state television yesterday and made the innocuous statement that the first priority of the state should be security and not the parliamentary process to form a new government:
“Politicians in Iraq need to realize that it is no longer business as usual,” the top United Nations representative here, Nickolay Mladenov, said on Tuesday, criticizing the political impasse. And American officials have said that major military support for Iraq would be dependent on a new, inclusive government being formed. 
Mr. Maliki, however, appeared to reject that reasoning. “The battle today is the security battle for the unity of Iraq,” he said. “I don’t believe there is anything more important than mobilizing people to support the security situation. Other things are important, but this is the priority.” 
He said the political process would not be able to proceed without a strong military. “We will move on in the political process,” he said, “but we have to focus on the battle, which is on behalf of the people.” 
Iraq’s Sunni and Kurdish politicians have refused to accept Mr. Maliki as a candidate for a third term, and the majority Shiite coalition was maneuvering to determine his replacement. Both the powerful Shiite marja, or council of ayatollahs, and the American government have shown little enthusiasm for Mr. Maliki to remain in power, although his party won the most votes in the April 30 elections.
But we know from Nordland's story yesterday that a third term for Maliki is not the issue. He is out. The Kurds and the Sunnis know this; they know that the Shiite bloc has a new candidate for prime minister ready to go; that is why they walked out of parliament so quickly. The Sunnis and Kurds don't want a rapid, smooth, successful formation of a government. They want to maintain the canard -- their cover story, a demonization of Maliki -- as long as possible while they establish facts on the ground and continue to extort concessions from the Shiite majority. The Gray Lady's Nordland does his part by pumping air back into the fiction of the al-Maliki bogeyman.

Nordland's story today, despite its headline, actually reinforces yesterday's narrative. The Kurds are digging in and are not about to agree to participate in a new government until they get what they want -- continued control of Kirkuk and its natural resources:
In Washington, Secretary of State John Kerry spoke by telephone to Massoud Barzani, the president of the autonomous Kurdish region in Iraq, and urged the Kurds to help with the process of forming a new Iraqi government. 
A Kurdish delegation, including Fuad Hussein, Mr. Barzani’s chief of staff, also met with Mr. Kerry on Wednesday.
Kurdish officials said later that the Kurds were prepared to play a role in forming a new government in Baghdad. But they stressed that the Kurdish participation was conditional on an arrangement that would grant the Kurds expanded political and economic autonomy. 
“If we are not going in the direction of restructuring Iraq radically toward federalism and toward democracy, then we cannot be part of that system,” Mr. Hussein said in an appearance at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. 
Mr. Hussein also said that the Kurds would not accept a government in which Mr. Maliki served a third term as prime minister. 
“If I was Nuri al-Maliki, I would go to the Parliament and I would say, ‘I am sorry I could not manage this country.’ So I would leave. But it seems he doesn’t recognize that,” Mr. Hussein said. “So we must wait for another one to be in charge.”
It would seem that the proper response to this never-ending demonization of Maliki would be for the Shiite unity alliance to publicly name its replacement candidate and be done with it. The problem here, which Nordland alluded to in his piece yesterday, is that the Sunnis and Kurds could, and almost certainly would, continue to block the formation of a new government, leaving Maliki exposed as a helpless wounded duck and the state of Iraq adrift. This is of course what the Kurds, the Sunnis and their USG and Saudi sponsors want.

Given this, I don't imagine that we will be seeing a new government formed anytime soon, even after parliament reconvenes next week. To keep blame from being properly apportioned, expect a steady stream of "Maliki to blame" headlines.

Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Mexican Standoff in Iraq's Parliament

It is important to follow the action in Iraq's parliament because it lies at the heart of the U.S.-peddled canard. From the capture of Mosul last month by Islamic State in a blitz that brought jihadis to the outskirts of Samarra, to the Kurds mobilizing the Peshmerga to control Kirkuk, USG, accompanied by a chorus in the media, explained the revolutionary turn of events by blaming the government of Iraqi prime minister Nuri al-Maliki. If only Maliki had been more inclusive of Sunni representatives, the story goes, Islamic State would not be flying the black flag over Iraq's second-largest city as well as claiming control of numerous border crossings. The United States has conditioned its support for a military response to Islamic State with a demand that Maliki has to go. 

Yesterday the Iraqi parliament, known officially as the Council of Representatives of Iraq, convened for the first time since the April 30 elections to give the U.S. exactly what it wants, a quickly formed  government without Nuri al-Maliki as the chief executive. And therein lies the rub. The Shiite parties are willing to oust Maliki. But this is not what the U.S. is really after; it has always just been a cover story to obscure the partition of Iraq. Hence the sudden turnabout by the Sunni bloc, effectively sabotaging the opening session of parliament and delaying the formation of a government for another week.

Rod Nordland has an excellent story today, "As Iraqi Violence Rages, Lawmakers Fail to Reach Deal on New Government," that lays everything out. But before we get to the pith of the Sunni sabotage, let's take a peek at the opening paragraphs where Nordland highlights Kurdish chutzpah:
BAGHDAD — Iraq’s major parties initially thought they had a deal ready when they sat down Tuesday to form a new government, but the effort collapsed in factional acrimony in less than half an hour. 
“We need our salaries,” shouted a Kurdish representative, Najiba Najib, complaining that the Shiite-dominated government in Baghdad had not been paying Kurdish officials since the Kurdistan region all but broke away last month. When extremists with the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, or ISIS, drove the Iraqi Army from northern Iraq, the Kurds took the opportunity to seize control of the oil-rich city of Kirkuk. The Kurds have long laid claim to the city, and insisted that they intend to keep it.
“You brought ISIS into our country and took the Iraqi flag down in Kirkuk and put your flag up!” shouted Mohammed Naji, a Shiite politician, at Ms. Najib. “Go and sell your oil to Israel.” 
The meeting’s rocky start did not come about for lack of incentive. American diplomats have suggested that any major new military assistance against extremists would come only if the Iraqis form an inclusive government acceptable to all sects. The powerful Shiite religious establishment had issued an edict telling legislators they had to conclude the entire deal by Tuesday. And around much of the country, Sunni militants pressed the government on numerous fronts.
As Nordland clearly explains, the process to form a government in Iraq is that first the Sunnis elect a speaker; the speaker then oversees the election of the president, a Kurd; the president asks the the largest parliamentary bloc, which is Shiite, to designate the prime minister, who assumes power with a two-thirds vote. Everything was supposed to go like clockwork. The Sunni alliance had its choice for a replacement prime minister lined up. And then suddenly after less than a hour the Sunni and Kurds walked out. Can you smell a rat?
Sunnis and Kurds were to have agreed on Salim al-Jabouri, a Sunni, to become the new speaker, replacing Osama al-Nujaifi. In exchange, they expected the Kurds to announce their choice for president, who has to be a Kurd, and the Shiites’ National Alliance bloc to announce a Shiite prime minister to replace the incumbent, Nuri Kamal al-Maliki. Both Sunnis and Kurds, along with some Shiites, have insisted that Mr. Maliki has to go. 
Sunnis at the last minute faced a challenge from Mr. Nujaifi, who wants to hold onto his seat, said the Shiite politician Haider al-Abadi, a supporter of Mr. Maliki’s State of Law party. And Kurds were nowhere near agreeing on a candidate for president. Kurds and Sunnis, however, said the Shiites reneged by not coming to the meeting with a nominee for the post of prime minister.
Iraq’s complex system of choosing a government makes such deal-making difficult and essential. The speaker is necessary to preside over Parliament to elect a president, who then chooses the biggest bloc in Parliament, which picks the prime minister. But a two-thirds vote is required to choose the speaker, so politicians try to have the entire deal agreed on in advance. 
“We cannot jump to the last stages without taking the first step,” said Mr. Abadi, adding that it would be foolish for the Shiites to announce their candidate for prime minister now if the process ended up taking months. That, he said, might render Mr. Maliki a lame-duck leader in the middle of running a war, if someone else were chosen. 
So after Ms. Najib and Mr. Naji exchanged words, a recess was called by the temporary speaker, Mahdi Ahmed Hafith. Only 60 legislators returned from the recess, however, so there was no quorum to continue. Parliament was adjourned until July 8.
The United Nations pussyfooted around who was to blame for the failure of the opening session when it was obvious to all that Sunni prevarication was the root cause:
Within hours, the United Nations issued an unusually strong rebuke. “Politicians in Iraq need to realize that it is no longer business as usual,” said the top representative here, Nickolay Mladenov. “I call upon all political leaders to set aside their differences.” 
Mr. Mladenov called the June death toll “staggering.”
Keep watch for any statement issued by USG. To continue to blame Maliki's government at this point when it is clear that he is on his way out and that the Shiite alliance has a replacement ready would be compelling proof of a conspiracy to aid the advance of Islamic State and the de facto partition of Iraq.

What is going on behind the scenes is that the Sunnis and Kurds are bargaining. They want guarantees before they participate in any government. In the case of the Sunnis, they want the defense ministry; the Kurds want their seizure of Kirkuk blessed, as well as the right to market and sell oil. The Shiite bloc will not grant these guarantees. In order to shield the intransigent Sunnis and Kurds from blame and rebuke, the U.S., based on past practice, will step in with some sort of disinformation campaign. This looks to be the way things are going to go in the month of July.

Monday, June 30, 2014

U.S. (Non)Response to ISIS

As Russia speeds delivery of SU-25 fighter planes to besieged Iraq, let's take a step back and reconnoiter the U.S. response, or lack thereof, to the emerging ISIS caliphate. First, blame Iraqi prime minister Nuri al-Maliki. The idea here, as floated by USG and -- uniformly -- its media minions, is that ISIS is a creation not of the rich Gulf emirates, whose history of funding and exporting Wahhabi jihad is well documented, but of the democratically elected Maliki government because that democratically elected government is not more inclusive of Sunnis.

The most obvious shortcoming of this argument is the absence of proof that Sunnis, who would be open to participating in Iraq's government if only given a sinecure, have -- anywhere -- gone over wholesale to a medieval movement that considers democracy irreligious. What the reporting has shown so far is that a relatively compact force of jihadis augmented by ex-Baathist Sufis led by former Saddam henchman Izzat Ibrahim al-Douri took Mosul by blitzkrieg on June 10. The Kurds followed by taking Kirkuk a couple days later. The whole thing had the vibe of central planning.

There have been hints in Anbar that the Sons of Iraq, the "Awakening" movement that battled ISIS precursor Al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI) during the U.S. occupation last decade, has gone over to ISIS. But this has only been alluded to, not documented at any length in anything that I have seen.

No, what is going on in Iraq smacks of a "Great Game" operation. The U.S. has done nothing so far to stem the jihadis. The 300 military advisers and surveillance flights are more to keep tabs on the Iraqi Army and the assistance it is receiving from Russia and Iran. Let's keep our eyes peeled for any strike on ISIS by the U.S. I'm skeptical one will every come off. Maybe once it is clear that the jihadis are being routed Obama will order a cosmetic Predator drone attack on a column of retreating Salafi foot soldiers, if only to maintain the cover story that USG is concerned about a terrorist safe haven.

The second aspect of the U.S. response to consider, besides the scapegoating of Maliki, is the linkage to Syria. Yes, Syria is linked to Iraq and the rise of ISIS. There is no denying that. But using the ISIS capture of Mosul and most of the Syria-Iraq border posts as an excuse to forward a half-a-billion dollar request to train and equip a non-existent "moderate" Syrian rebel army is also a strong tell. The target here is not ISIS but Assad.

So in both cases -- first, the blame-Maliki game; then the funding request for a discredited Syrian opposition -- USG is doing all it can to avoid confronting the real problem, which is ISIS and its Gulf sponsors.

It is truly pitiful, and one wonders how much longer it can continue, what with Russia and Iran acting with alacrity and the jihadis starting to suffer their first military defeats of the blitz. I'm sure the hope in Jidda and D.C. is that the gains of the blitz can be locked in -- Kurdish control of Kirkuk; Salafi control of Mosul -- and a long, grinding, costly (for Iraq, Iran, Syria, Russia) guerrilla war commences.

There will be a price to pay politically in the United States. If the conflict grinds on and Obama continues his feckless dithering, Democrats will hemorrhage. If Iraq convincingly rolls back the ISIS blitz, the Fourth Estate will shriek that the sky is falling. Let's hope for the latter.

Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Iraq: Obama's Making and Unmaking

What was foreseeable this past winter, when the Nobel Peace Laureate president relaunched the Cold War with his support of a fascist-led putsch in Ukraine, has been verified by a New York Times/CBS News poll. Obama's approval rating at 40% is one point away from the doldrums of the thirties, a level of support which historically has shown a president to be operating without the consent of the governed.

According to Michael Shear and Dalia Sussman in "Poll Finds Dissatisfaction Over Iraq," the capture of large parts of Iraq by uber-Qaeda group Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham (ISIS) is the cause of the president's undoing:
The poll found that 58 percent of Americans disapprove of the way Mr. Obama is handling foreign policy, a jump of 10 points in the last month to the highest level since Mr. Obama took office in 2009. The spike in disapproval is especially striking among Democrats, nearly a third of whom said they did not approve of his handling of foreign policy.
Fifty-two percent of Americans say they disapprove of how the president is dealing with the current violence in Iraq (including about a third of Democrats); 37 percent approve. 
“I voted for him because he said, ‘Give me four more years and I will fix everything,’ but nothing is being fixed,” Michelle Roberts, 34, a Democrat from Salem, Mass., said in a follow-up interview. “I understand he wants to fight terrorism, but send in robots, drones. Don’t send in our troops. Our men and women are dying for what?” 
The erosion in support across both parties has contributed to a drop in Mr. Obama’s overall rating that threatens to undermine his administration’s political ambitions during the remaining two and a half years of his second term. The president’s approval rating is now at 40 percent, while 54 percent say they disapprove of the job he is doing in office, a six-point jump since May.
As Obama teeters on the brink, one step away from the point of no return, the indicator that bodes ill for his remaining time in office is the jump in his disapproval rating to 54%. One could argue that Obama has lived on the edge of low-forties approval since his disastrous flirtation with bombing Damascus at the end of summer last year and he has always managed to survive. But disapproval ticking closer to a super majority is proof that attitudes are hardening towards the Nobel Peace Laureate.

Another key passage by Shear and Sussman is the confusion that dominates the electorate:
Although the survey suggests that Mr. Obama’s small steps toward military action in Iraq are in line with those of many Americans, it also indicates that people may still yearn for their commander in chief to manage foreign crises, even when the solutions are not obvious to them. A large majority thinks that the United States has important interests in Iraq’s future. Two-thirds said Mr. Obama had not done enough to explain American goals in the country.
This confusion is the result of a people being indoctrinated for the better part of two decades to believe that Wahhabi-style Islam of the type practiced by the Taliban in Afghanistan and Osama bin Laden is the greatest enemy to the United States. Yet Obama and his Secretary of State Kerry spend the majority of their time so far talking about malign Iranian and Syrian influence and lecturing the one-time U.S. favorite Nuri al-Maliki, Iraq's head of state, that he has to go because he is too sectarian. And all the while there is not one word (other than some ass-covering by an "unnamed senior official" saying that the administration is aware of the problem) about the robust support ISIS receives from the Gulf Sheikhdoms. No wonder people are confused.

People are confused because Obama is playing a game, pretending that the foe is still Al Qaeda and its ilk but the administration's enemy of choice is actually Iran and the states aligned with Iran in the Middle East, Iraq and Syria. A good indication of this can be found in the administration's non-existent reaction to the news that Iraq's border crossing with Jordan has been captured by ISIS. If there were any real threat to Jordan there is no doubt that the Salafis occupying the crossing at Trebil would be blown to smithereens by U.S. aircraft.

More and more the assessment from the first days of ISIS's blitzkrieg capture of Mosul -- that what is happening in Iraq is a planned partition of the country -- seems to be the accurate one. A new secret agreement to carve Iraq into a Kurdish state as well as a Sunni caliphate encompassing parts of Syria while leaving the Shia the rest is in the offing. Call it a centennial overhaul of Sykes-Picot.

And it will be the final nail in Obama's presidential coffin. A guy who rose to power in the Democratic Party based on his pacific stance on the Iraq War is presiding over its bloody destruction. And the carnage and mayhem have just begun. There is no telling how bad things are going to get.

It is hard to say if it will be the wholesale undoing of the Democrats. We can only hope that moribund progressives and liberals will rise in mass and vacate the party.

Monday, June 23, 2014

Kerry's Theater of the Absurd

Foreign affairs as practiced by U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry is a theater of the absurd, a traveling roadshow of lies, that makes one pine for the almost Achesonian (in comparison) Hillary Clinton. Once Kerry climbs aboard his jet aircraft with his faithful scribe Michael Gordon in tow you can expect the mendacity to run like the wind and absolutely nothing to be accomplished.

Presently, the Secretary of State is in Baghdad trying to secure a replacement for Iraq's Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki; this despite the fact that he solemnly pronounced at his last stop, in Cairo, that the United States was "not in the business of picking Iraq’s leaders." Don't count on al-Maliki stepping down.

In Cairo, Kerry embraced the military coup government of President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, announcing that all -- the massacre of innocents, the show trials culminating in blanket death sentences for hundreds, the abolition of political organizations -- is forgotten and the money will flow. According to David Kirkpatrick and Michael Gordon, writing in "Kerry Says U.S. Is Ready to Renew Ties With Egypt":
Mr. Kerry expressed firm confidence that the United States would soon fully restore $650 million — the first tranche of the $1.3 billion in annual aid — to the military that the Obama administration had partly withheld after the takeover.
“I am absolutely confident we will get on track there,” he said. Addressing a previously suspended shipment of 10 Apache helicopter gunships that the Egyptian military has been especially eager for, Mr. Kerry said he was just as confident “that the Apaches will come, and that they will come very, very soon.”
And in Egypt’s economic challenges, Mr. Kerry said, President Obama and the United States are “committed to be helpful.”
Three years after Mr. Obama called publicly for President Hosni Mubarak to bow to the Arab Spring uprising demanding his ouster, Mr. Kerry’s remarks appeared to suggest that the administration is now ready to work with another military-backed strongman.
Mr. Sisi won 97 percent of the official votes in a barely contested election last month, and both European and United States-funded observer delegations said it fell short of international standards of democracy. But Mr. Kerry’s comments suggested that the Obama administration was nonetheless ready to try to work with Egypt’s new military-backed government while urging it to improve its records on human rights.
Mr. Kerry tacitly acknowledged the administration’s criticisms of the new government’s authoritarian record, including its heavy-handed crackdown on both the Islamist opposition and liberal or leftist dissenters. “I emphasized also our strong support for upholding the universal rights and freedoms of all Egyptians, including freedom of expression, peaceful assembly and association,” he said. 
Mr. Kerry said they had talked about the verdict expected Monday in the case of three journalists who have been jailed since December on politicized charges without any publicly disclosed evidence of a crime. And he said they had also talked about the hurried mass trials that had handed death sentences to more than a dozen senior leaders of the Islamist opposition and hundreds of their supporters, arousing horrified alarms from Western governments and rights groups. 
He also alluded to the government’s criminalization of membership in the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist group whose party dominated the recent free elections but has since been excluded from politics. “There is no question that Egyptian society is stronger when all of its citizens have a say and a stake in its success,” Mr. Kerry said.
The Leveretts, along with Seyed Mohammad Marandi, in their most recent article, "Trying to Force Iran to “Surrender” Will Backfire—Why U.S. Engagement with Tehran Needs to Respect Iranian Independence," remind us that the policy of Egyptian subjugation to U.S. hegemony enshrined in the Camp David Accords is tied to the rise of Saudi-backed jihad and Israeli regional military unilateralism:
The United States has tried subordinating the strategic orientation of a major Middle Eastern state before. Three and a half decades ago, the U.S.-brokered Camp David accords reduced Egypt to a strategic and economic dependency of the United States. While American foreign policy elites regularly extol the regional “stability” wrought by Camp David, that stability was in fact dangerously illusory.
In the wake of Camp David, Saudi Arabia made promotion of violent jihadism an increasingly prominent tool in Saudi foreign policy—a trend that incubated al Qaeda and is still spawning an ever-proliferating array of ideologically similar threats to international security. Three decades of rule by a U.S.-puppet regime, with accompanying political repression and economic stagnation, made Egypt itself a prime source for jihadi ideologues (such as al Qaeda leader Ayman Zawahiri) and fighters. And allowing the Israeli military to consolidate nearly absolute freedom of unilateral initiative—one of Camp David’s first fruits—has been deeply corrosive of America’s regional standing.
On the jet to Cairo, Gordon scribbled down the prevarications of a "senior official" regarding the funding of Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham:
[ISIS] is largely self-sustaining because of its success with extortions and in the plundering of the banks in Mosul, Iraq's second-largest city, which it controls. But some funding "has flowed into Iraq from its neighbors," a senior official on Mr. Kerry's plane said.
"That does not mean that it is the result of an official government policy in many, if not most, cases," the official added.
The idea that ISIS funds itself by looting banks in a city it has held for two weeks is absurd. ISIS has been in control of large parts of northern Syria for a year. Efforts are being made to distance the member states of the GCC from ownership of ISIS, a sign that last week the truth was emerging as to the role of Saudi, Qatari and Kuwaiti sponsorship.

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Who Sponsors ISIS Has U.S. Playing Defense

This is the last paragraph of "As Sunnis Die in Iraq, a Cycle Is Restarting," by Alissa Rubin and Rod Nordland, which can be found in today's paper:
The Iraqi government issued a statement accusing Saudi Arabia of funding the Sunni extremists, as Mr. Maliki continued to offer explanations for the stunning success of the Sunni extremists that do not focus on his leadership. The statement drew almost immediate criticism from the United States, with Jen Psaki, the State Department spokeswoman, describing it as inaccurate and “offensive.”
Reuters has a little more information about the statement, which was made yesterday by Maliki's cabinet:
Maliki's government accused Saudi Arabia, the main Sunni power, of backing ISIL - something Riyadh denies. 
"We hold them responsible for supporting these groups financially and morally and for its outcome - which includes crimes that may qualify as genocide: the spilling of Iraqi blood, the destruction of Iraqi state institutions and historic and religious sites," a government statement said. 
Maliki has blamed Saudi Arabia for supporting militants in the past, but the language was unprecedented. On Monday, Riyadh blamed sectarianism in Baghdad for fuelling the violence.
NBC's story, by Cassandra Vinograd, "Iraq Cabinet Accuses Saudi Arabia of Spurring 'Genocide'," reads like it was written by USG as a Saudi defense brief.

But for corroboration of the Iraq cabinet statement there is Josh Rogin's Daily Beast article which appeared this past Saturday, "America's Allies Are Funding ISIS":
But in the years they were getting started, a key component of ISIS’s support came from wealthy individuals in the Arab Gulf States of Kuwait, Qatar and Saudi Arabia. Sometimes the support came with the tacit nod of approval from those regimes; often, it took advantage of poor money laundering protections in those states, according to officials, experts, and leaders of the Syrian opposition, which is fighting ISIS as well as the regime.
“Everybody knows the money is going through Kuwait and that it’s coming from the Arab Gulf,” said Andrew Tabler, senior fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. “Kuwait’s banking system and its money changers have long been a huge problem because they are a major conduit for money to extremist groups in Syria and now Iraq.”
Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki has been publicly accusing Saudi Arabia and Qatar of funding ISIS for months. Several reports have detailed how private Gulf funding to various Syrian rebel groups has splintered the Syrian opposition and paved the way for the rise of groups like ISIS and others.
Gulf donors support ISIS, the Syrian branch of al Qaeda called the al Nusrah Front, and other Islamic groups fighting on the ground in Syria because they feel an obligation to protect Sunnis suffering under the atrocities of the Assad regime. Many of these backers don’t trust or like the American backed moderate opposition, which the West has refused to provide significant arms to.
***
“ISIS is part of the Sunni forces that are fighting Shia forces in this regional sectarian conflict. They are in an existential battle with both the (Iranian aligned) Maliki government and the Assad regime,” said Tabler. “The U.S. has made the case as strongly as they can to regional countries, including Kuwait. But ultimately when you take a hands off, leading from behind approach to things, people don’t take you seriously and they take matters into their own hands.”
Donors in Kuwait, the Sunni majority Kingdom on Iraq’s border, have taken advantage of Kuwait’s weak financial rules to channel hundreds of millions of dollars to a host of Syrian rebel brigades, according to a December 2013 report by The Brookings Institution, a Washington think tank that receives some funding from the Qatari government.
“Over the last two and a half years, Kuwait has emerged as a financing and organizational hub for charities and individuals supporting Syria’s myriad rebel groups,” the report said. “Today, there is evidence that Kuwaiti donors have backed rebels who have committed atrocities and who are either directly linked to al-Qa’ida or cooperate with its affiliated brigades on the ground.”
Kuwaiti donors collect funds from donors in other Arab Gulf countries and the money often travels through Turkey or Jordan before reaching its Syrian destination, the report said. The governments of Kuwait, Qatar, and Saudi Arabia have passed laws to curb the flow of illicit funds, but many donors still operate out in the open. The Brookings paper argues the U.S. government needs to do more.
“The U.S. Treasury is aware of this activity and has expressed concern about this flow of private financing. But Western diplomats’ and officials’ general response has been a collective shrug,” the report states.
When confronted with the problem, Gulf leaders often justify allowing their Salafi constituents to fund Syrian extremist groups by pointing back to what they see as a failed U.S. policy in Syria and a loss of credibility after President Obama reneged on his pledge to strike Assad after the regime used chemical weapons.
That’s what Prince Bandar bin Sultan, head of Saudi intelligence since 2012 and former Saudi ambassador in Washington, reportedly told Secretary of State John Kerry when Kerry pressed him on Saudi financing of extremist groups earlier this year. Saudi Arabia has retaken a leadership role in past months guiding help to the Syrian armed rebels, displacing Qatar, which was seen as supporting some of the worst of the worst organizations on the ground.
The Saudis say that they only fund moderate Islamists. But the whole moderate vs. extremist distinction is a word game meant to obscure the fact that, as in the heady days of "Charlie Wilson's War," the U.S. is up to its old tricks again backing, along with its good monarchical friends in the gulf, the Mujahideen.

That's why you have the denial by the truly odious Jen Psaki. As a rule of thumb, if Psaki goes out of her way to issue a strong denial, as she did by labeling the Iraq cabinet statement as "offensive," you know there is a rat in the house. Psaki lies. This is what she does for a living.

For seasoned news consumers, the unified response from Western governments and the prestige press that Maliki is to blame for all that is presently going wrong in Iraq (with nary a word about the role of wealthy gulf emirs in Jiffy Popping a Salafi army into being, nor the destabilizing effects of the 2003 U.S. invasion) is a strong indication that the goal of USG is not to fight terrorism but to neuter Shiite state power.

Another fruitful line of inquiry is to look at the rat line of Salafi fighters. Carlotta Gall made a start yesterday with "Spanish Police Target Cells Recruiting War Volunteers." More than half of ISIS's fighters are foreigners. Getting them to the battlefield requires a logistics network that a localized Anbar jihadi group could not have put together in such a short span of time. The jihad network is run out of mosques and madrassas. This network is funded by the gulf emirates, foremost of which is Saudi Arabia.

USG knows all this. But where is the rallying cry for sanctions? Compare it to the U.S. response to the peaceful vote in Crimea to accede to the Russian Federation. The U.S. is now in the midst of relaunching the Cold War with all its inherent risk of nuclear annihilation. And in the case of Crimea becoming part of Russia, there is no risk to U.S. national security. But a caliphate rising in the Middle East? That certainly represents a risk. So far the U.S. seems to be doing everything it can to make sure it becomes a reality.

Tuesday, June 17, 2014

U.S. Target in Iraq is Maliki not ISIS

A perplexing game by the United States is currently being played with regards to the unfolding Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS, or, if you prefer, ISIL -- Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant; it depends on the news outlet) offensive in Iraq. Tal Afar, a city of 200,000 in the north, has fallen to ISIS; ISIS also is reported to have ambushed a number of Iraqi volunteers (29 dead, 190 wounded) near Samarra. The U.S. is said to have met with senior Iranian diplomats in Geneva to discuss ways to defuse the crisis. Michael Gordon and David Sanger have the story, "U.S. Is Exploring Talks With Iran on Crisis in Iraq":
The outreach to Tehran was a surprising turnabout for the Obama administration, which has not held talks over regional crises with Iran. Cooperation between the United States and Iran to contain the Iraqi crisis would represent the first time the two countries have jointly undertaken a common security purpose since they shared military intelligence to counter the Taliban in Afghanistan after the attacks on Sept. 11, 2001.
But don't get your hopes up that the rising caliphate could signal a rapprochement between Great Satan and the Islamic Republic. As Gordon and Sanger note in the next four paragraphs:
Mr. Kerry, in fact, worked furiously in January to persuade the United Nations to disinvite Iran from the Geneva peace talks on Syria, arguing that Tehran’s military support to Syria’s president, Bashar al-Assad, disqualified it from participating. 
The United States and Iran have long been bitter, and even deadly, rivals in Iraq. Iran’s Quds Force trained Iraqi Shiite militias that targeted American troops, and it supplied those militants with powerful explosive devices. The American military established a task force to hunt Iranian-backed Shiite Iraqi fighters. 
The Bush administration held talks with Iranian officials in Baghdad during the American occupation of Iraq. But those discussions made no headway. 
Moreover, the Treasury Department accused Iran this year of harboring an militant who provided support to Al Qaeda.
The real story here, as Obama makes a show of methodically deliberating military options, is what the U.S. is demanding in exchange for military strikes against ISIS:
The Obama administration’s strategy is to pressure Iraq’s prime minister, Nuri Kamal al-Maliki, and his Shiite-dominated government to form a multisectarian government with Sunnis and Kurds in an effort to heal the rifts being exploited by the insurgents. But that goal could be frustrated if Iran decided to back hard-line Shiite leaders or sent Quds Force fighters into Iraq, aggravating the already inflamed tensions.
The Iraqi position, elegantly stated by the Iraqi ambassador to the United States in a story yesterday by Mark Landler and Michael Gordon, "Obama Pushes Iraqis to Mend Sectarian Rifts," is reasonable. They have a framework agreement with the U.S. Now is not the time for quid pro quo haggling. Let's act now:
The United States, a senior Iraqi official said, is “conditioning its actions on genuine reconciliation and cooperation among Iraqi leaders, leading to a new representative government.” 
Whether those leaders are prepared to take those kinds of steps, especially during a raging insurgency, is far from clear. Lukman Faily, Iraq’s ambassador to Washington, noted that the Strategic Framework Agreement between Iraq and the United States “talks about the importance of maintaining the territorial integrity of Iraq.” 
“The urgency on the ground should be enough reason to act,” Mr. Faily said in an interview. “We think that addressing the immediate threat to Iraq’s sovereignty should take priority over discussions regarding political reform.”
This is U.S.-Iraq face off appears again in a lede story this morning by Alissa Rubin and Rod Nordland, "Sunnis and Kurds on Sidelines of Iraqi Leader’s Military Plans":
“Now there’s a war, there’s not reconciliation,” said Amir al-Khuzai, a longtime friend of Mr. Maliki’s. 
“With whom do we reconcile?” he said.
President Obama has made it clear that the United States will not provide military support unless Mr. Maliki engineers a drastic change in policy, reaching out to Sunnis and Kurds in a show of national unity against the Sunni militants, whose shock troops are the extremist Islamic State in Iraq and Syria. Without that, analysts say, the country is at risk of a renewed sectarian war in which Baghdad could lose control over nearly a third of the country for the foreseeable future.
You have to read to the end of the article to learn that Maliki did in fact reach out to Iraq's Sunni leadership. The Sunni price for supporting the state they represent? They want their own military:
But Mr. Maliki has little faith in the Sunni political leaders, said Mr. Khuzai and other Shiite colleagues. 
As recently as last week in the wake of the fall of Mosul, Mr. Maliki appeared to have a chance to create a unified multisectarian, multiethnic block to fight ISIS and those who support it. In a long late-night meeting with Sunni and Kurdish leaders, it appeared they might emerge with a unified stand. Hours passed, and when they emerged there was no agreement. 
It turned out the Sunnis proposed raising in effect a Sunni army, a sort of new version of the tribal Awakening Councils that fought Al Qaeda in 2007 and 2008. But that idea was rejected by Mr. Maliki, even as the Shiite militias were beginning to organize. 
While the idea of separate Sunni and Shiite armies is an indication of the depths of the sectarian divide, Mr. Maliki’s inability to use the moment to try to build trust is telling, and his outright rejection left the Sunni leaders with nothing to deliver to their supporters. 
So the speaker of Parliament, Osama al-Nujaifi, a Sunni, delivered a scathing assessment of Mr. Maliki, further deepening the divide. 
“We don’t want this prime minister; we reject him,” Mr. Nujaifi said. “We tried to take him down on more than one occasion.”
What the quote above illuminates, besides the fact that there is no willing reconciliation partner, is that there is already multiethnic, multisectarian government in Iraq. You have Kurds and Sunni in major leadership positions already.

Obama's demand for Maliki to include Kurds and Sunnis in a "genuine" reconciliation government is just another way of saying regime change. It's Syria all over again. The rhetoric is not as cut and dried, but the message is still the same. Regime change and a fractured, weakened state.

Sunday, June 15, 2014

Friedman Lets Slip: "We Have to be Careful How Much We Aid Iran's Sunni Foes"

I am amazed at the subdued reaction of the pundit class to the caliphate rising in northern Iraq/eastern Syria. Nowhere have I seen evidence of alarm that Islamic State of Iraq and Levant (ISIS) now controls an expanded Sunni Triangle (see yesterday's "Iraq Rebels Stall North of Baghdad as Residents Brace for a Siege," by Rod Nordland and Alissa Rubin, for a comparison of the territory that was the hotbed of the Sunni insurgency during the U.S. military occupation with the area where ISIS is erecting its caliphate in northeast Syria and northern Iraq).

A good example is Thomas Friedman's column today, "5 Principles for Iraq." ISIS is not mentioned once! But Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki is treated harshly, as is Iran. After reading Friedman's piece, you can't blame someone for thinking that it was actually an Iranian-sponsored Shiite terror group that had executed the 1,700 Iraqi soldiers (rather than the Saudi-financed Wahhabis of ISIS).

Friedman even gloats that the present state of chaos in Iraq is a win for the U.S. and a loss for Iran:
Maybe Iran, and its wily Revolutionary Guards Quds Force commander, Gen. Qassem Suleimani, aren’t so smart after all. It was Iran that armed its Iraqi Shiite allies with the specially shaped bombs that killed and wounded many American soldiers. Iran wanted us out. It was Iran that pressured Maliki into not signing an agreement with the U.S. to give our troops legal cover to stay in Iraq. Iran wanted to be the regional hegemon. Well, Suleimani: “This Bud’s for you.” Now your forces are overextended in Syria, Lebanon and Iraq, and ours are back home. Have a nice day.

We still want to forge a nuclear deal that prevents Iran from developing a bomb, so we have to be careful about how much we aid Iran’s Sunni foes. But with Iran still under sanctions and its forces and Hezbollah’s now fighting in Syria, Lebanon and Iraq, well, let’s just say: advantage America.
So there you have it. Thomas Friedman, one the top pitchmen of bloody Pax Americana, flat out admits "[W]e have to careful about how much we aid Iran's Sunni foes."

This opinion, that the enemy is Iran along with its Shiite allies in the Middle East, has been uniformly repeated in the opinion pages since ISIS's capture of Mosul last Tuesday.

The problem is that the punditocracy, fused as it is with USG, is running far afield of public opinion. The public is unaware that the Sunni extremism of Osama bin Laden is now to be treated as an allied ideology. The spadework of public diplomacy has not be done. The populace is unprepared and unwilling to once again embrace Wahhabi suicide bombers as freedom fighters. That is why initially you had plenty of news stories about American veterans of the Sunni Triangle giving voice to anger and frustration that their enemy has triumphantly returned. (We will probably see less of those.)

But it is going to be tough to undo 15 years of programming. If Obama's failed attempt to bomb Syria at the end of last summer is any indication, people aren't going to go for it. The Far Right was front and center denouncing an attack as nothing more than the U.S. acting as "Al Qaeda's air force." Public outcry was enormous.

The pundits of the mainstream media should know that they can't have it both ways. The Friedmans and Kristofs have to expect that, when the newspaper that employs them frontpages stories about FBI concerns of homegrown jihadis traveling to Syria and Iraq only to return home as potential suicide bombers, their exhortations to blame Maliki and Iran and ignore ISIS will not make sense to most readers.

At least we can hope.