Showing posts with label caliphate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label caliphate. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 27, 2017

KRG Independence Referendum Continuation of Caliphate's Political Project: Dismemberment of Iraq

You can usually infer what is troubling the Deep State by what is omitted from Foreign Policy's daily Situation Report. This morning there is zero mention of the ongoing story of Monday's independence referendum in Iraqi Kurdistan (there was a brief mention of it yesterday). The results of the referendum supposedly will be announced today. Already officials of the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) have leaked to the press that the vote is overwhelmingly "Yes" to independence.

The response from KRG's neighbors has been predictable. Turkey and Iraq are conducting military drills on KRG's northern border. Erdogan threatens war. Iran has banned flights to Iraqi Kurdistan. Iraqi prime minister Haider al-Abadi has demanded the return of the international airports by Friday. Iraq's parliament has asked Abadi to send troops to secure the oil-rich multi-ethnic city of Kirkuk. KRG seized Kirkuk, basically in coordination with ISIS when the jihadis captured Mosul, back in 2014.

Mention of this by David Zucchino, in his story "Iraq Orders Kurdistan to Surrender Its Airports," fails to emphasize the simultaneity of the ISIS-Kurdish blitz:
As the Islamic State rose in northern Iraq in 2014, Kurdish fighters took advantage of the chaos, and in some cases of fleeing Iraqi troops, to expand the Kurdish territory by 40 percent.
We need to interpret the independence referendum as a continuation of the political program of the caliphate. The caliphate was always a GCC project designed to dismember sovereign nations aligned with Iran; an independent Kurdistan, or several independent Kurdish states, accomplishes this.

The U.S. position on the referendum is clearly duplicitous. While the U.S. is officially opposed, one can divine its tacit approval from The New York Times' serially sympathetic coverage of the referendum, captured in a previous Zucchino story, "As Kurds Celebrate Independence Vote, Neighbors Threaten Military Action." The Kurds are presented as victims of Iraqi genocide.

Often the most reliable way to ascertain U.S. policy is look at its organs of propaganda.

Friday, November 20, 2015

Kamel Daoud's "Saudi Arabia, an ISIS That Has Made It"

The best, most to-the-point statement I've read about the West's Global War on Terror; it is all built on a lie, or as Kamel Daoud says in "Saudi Arabia, an ISIS That Has Made It," the denial that Saudi Arabia is exporting jihad en masse. To its credit The New York Times is publishing Daoud's essay.

If you read the newspapers every day, it is a marvel to behold, this mainstream conspiracy to occlude the obvious. Yet, as Tag Team reminded us, "Whoomp! There It Is." I ask people all the time -- people at work, people at the grocery store -- what they think about the mess we have wrought in the Middle East, and no one singles out al-Saud for blame. Usually, it is, "Oh, they've been killing each other over there for thousands of years," or "That Assad is a brute." Propaganda works. But what you will read below is the unvarnished truth.
Saudi Arabia, an ISIS That Has Made It
By Kamel Daoud
Black Daesh, white Daesh. The former slits throats, kills, stones, cuts off hands, destroys humanity’s common heritage and despises archaeology, women and non-Muslims. The latter is better dressed and neater but does the same things. The Islamic State; Saudi Arabia. In its struggle against terrorism, the West wages war on one, but shakes hands with the other. This is a mechanism of denial, and denial has a price: preserving the famous strategic alliance with Saudi Arabia at the risk of forgetting that the kingdom also relies on an alliance with a religious clergy that produces, legitimizes, spreads, preaches and defends Wahhabism, the ultra-puritanical form of Islam that Daesh feeds on.

Wahhabism, a messianic radicalism that arose in the 18th century, hopes to restore a fantasized caliphate centered on a desert, a sacred book, and two holy sites, Mecca and Medina. Born in massacre and blood, it manifests itself in a surreal relationship with women, a prohibition against non-Muslims treading on sacred territory, and ferocious religious laws. That translates into an obsessive hatred of imagery and representation and therefore art, but also of the body, nakedness and freedom. Saudi Arabia is a Daesh that has made it. 
The West’s denial regarding Saudi Arabia is striking: It salutes the theocracy as its ally but pretends not to notice that it is the world’s chief ideological sponsor of Islamist culture. The younger generations of radicals in the so-called Arab world were not born jihadists. They were suckled in the bosom of Fatwa Valley, a kind of Islamist Vatican with a vast industry that produces theologians, religious laws, books, and aggressive editorial policies and media campaigns. 
One might counter: Isn’t Saudi Arabia itself a possible target of Daesh? Yes, but to focus on that would be to overlook the strength of the ties between the reigning family and the clergy that accounts for its stability — and also, increasingly, for its precariousness. The Saudi royals are caught in a perfect trap: Weakened by succession laws that encourage turnover, they cling to ancestral ties between king and preacher. The Saudi clergy produces Islamism, which both threatens the country and gives legitimacy to the regime. 
One has to live in the Muslim world to understand the immense transformative influence of religious television channels on society by accessing its weak links: households, women, rural areas. Islamist culture is widespread in many countries — Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Mali, Mauritania. There are thousands of Islamist newspapers and clergies that impose a unitary vision of the world, tradition and clothing on the public space, on the wording of the government’s laws and on the rituals of a society they deem to be contaminated. 
It is worth reading certain Islamist newspapers to see their reactions to the attacks in Paris. The West is cast as a land of “infidels.” The attacks were the result of the onslaught against Islam. Muslims and Arabs have become the enemies of the secular and the Jews. The Palestinian question is invoked along with the rape of Iraq and the memory of colonial trauma, and packaged into a messianic discourse meant to seduce the masses. Such talk spreads in the social spaces below, while up above, political leaders send their condolences to France and denounce a crime against humanity. This totally schizophrenic situation parallels the West’s denial regarding Saudi Arabia.

All of which leaves one skeptical of Western democracies’ thunderous declarations regarding the necessity of fighting terrorism. Their war can only be myopic, for it targets the effect rather than the cause. Since ISIS is first and foremost a culture, not a militia, how do you prevent future generations from turning to jihadism when the influence of Fatwa Valley and its clerics and its culture and its immense editorial industry remains intact?
Is curing the disease therefore a simple matter? Hardly. Saudi Arabia remains an ally of the West in the many chess games playing out in the Middle East. It is preferred to Iran, that gray Daesh. And there’s the trap. Denial creates the illusion of equilibrium. Jihadism is denounced as the scourge of the century but no consideration is given to what created it or supports it. This may allow saving face, but not saving lives. 
Daesh has a mother: the invasion of Iraq. But it also has a father: Saudi Arabia and its religious-industrial complex. Until that point is understood, battles may be won, but the war will be lost. Jihadists will be killed, only to be reborn again in future generations and raised on the same books. 
The attacks in Paris have exposed this contradiction again, but as happened after 9/11, it risks being erased from our analyses and our consciences.

Wednesday, September 9, 2015

U.S. Defends the Caliphate + Hillary Mounts Dead Mother Again

First, let's go to the last paragraph of a story ("U.S. Moves to Block Russian Military Buildup in Syria" by Michael Gordon and Eric Schmitt) that appears in today's paper. It is a quote from U.S. State Department spokesman John Kirby:
“Russia is not a member of the coalition against ISIL, and what we’ve said is that their continued support to the Assad regime has actually fostered the growth of ISIL inside Syria and made the situation worse,” [Kirby] said, using an acronym for the Islamic State. “If they want to be helpful against ISIL, the way to do it is to stop arming and assisting and supporting Bashar al-Assad.”
This is the U.S. position: Russia is indirectly responsible for the rise of Islamic State because it supports the sovereignty of the Syrian Arab Republic. Put another way, by supporting international law, Russia is fostering terrorism.

Notice the absurdity of the U.S. position. Never mind that U.S. allies in the region -- member nations of the Gulf Cooperation Council, as well as Turkey and Israel -- have been actively collaborating with ISIS and Al Qaeda affiliate Nusra Front to destabilize Iraq, Syria and Lebanon; the important question to ask is what is the U.S. plan for Syria the day after Assad relinquishes power.

The answer is that there is none, which means that, absent Assad, a caliphate, in one form or another, is going to be the de facto state. Russia's moves to fortify Latakia Province with Spetsnaz special forces is Putin's way of saying that such an outcome is unacceptable. Once again Russia is on the correct side. U.S. attempts to block Russian overflight is pitiful.

Before signing off this morning I can't help mention a word or two on the latest Hillary reboot (Maggie Haberman, "Hillary Clinton, Citing Her ‘Mistake,’ Apologizes for Private Email"):
When asked if she had ever second-guessed her decision to make another run at the White House, Mrs. Clinton began to choke up, admitting that she had, at times, before invoking her mother’s admonitions to “fight for what you believe in, no matter how hard it is.” 
“I think about her a lot. I miss her a lot. I wish she were here with me,” Mrs. Clinton said of her mother, who died in 2011. But, she added: “I don’t want to just fight for me. I mean, I could have a perfectly fine life not being president. I want to fight for all the people like my mother who need somebody in their corner. And they need a leader who cares about them again. So that’s what I’m going to try to do.”
The Clinton campaign riding the bones of Hillary's dead mother was at the core of the last reboot, the one at the end of this past spring. Now that summer is coming to a close it must be time to flay the corpse again. Hillary showing emotional vulnerability is the only thing that the Clinton campaign has for a sure-fire winner. What I am waiting for next is a tearful revelation from the candidate that she was sexually abused as a child by an adult male relative who has recently passed away.

Thursday, August 20, 2015

The Spectacular Failure of Syriza

The Associated Press has a succinct roundup of Syriza's abject failure in "Greece Gets First Batch of New Bailout Loans, Avoids Default," while the Gray Lady's Alison Smale provides a lifeless puff piece, "An Architect of the Latest Greek Bailout Navigates Germany’s Dual Roles," on Germany's victorious finance minister Wolfgang Schäuble.

Syriza's capitulation is complete now that the third bailout agreement has been finalized and the money from the creditors to the creditors is starting to flow. Nothing has changed, as the AP story makes clear. The chairs on the Titanic have been rearranged:
ATHENS, Greece — Greece received the first 13 billion euros ($14.5 billion) from its new bailout package on Thursday, allowing it to pay a debt of 3.2 billion euros to the European Central Bank and avoid a messy default.
Greece could not have afforded Thursday's debt repayment, which was confirmed by the debt management agency, without the rescue funds from 18 other European nations that share the euro currency. Missing the payment would have raised new questions about the country's ability to remain in the euro.
European bailout fund supervisors approved the release of the first batch of loans on Wednesday evening. Twelve billion euros are earmarked for repaying debts and the remainder for settling arrears to public sector suppliers.
The new three-year bailout package — Greece's third bailout in little more than five years — is worth a total of 86 billion euros ($96 billion), and the gradual disbursement of funds depends on the Greek government implementing a series of reforms, including steep tax hikes and spending cuts.
Accepting the conditions was a major reversal of policy for Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras and the coalition government between his radical left Syriza party and the small nationalist Independent Greeks. It has cost him a major rebellion within Syriza that threatens to split the party and could lead to an early election as soon as next month.
Tsipras has been contemplating his options after a parliament vote to approve the bailout conditions led to dozens of his own party lawmakers voting against him. Among the options being discussed are for him to call a vote of confidence in his government or to call an early election outright, potentially in September.
The government has said its main priority was to secure the bailout funding and to repay the ECB loan on Thursday, after which it would announce any further action.
The prime minister was holding meetings with his ministers, and there was speculation an announcement could come as soon as Thursday afternoon.
The political uncertainty took its toll on the market, with the Athens Stock Exchange down 2.8 percent in early afternoon trading.
Tsipras won general elections in January on promises to repeal similar austerity measures attached to Greece's two previous bailouts. But he has said accepting creditor demands for yet more reforms was the only way to ensure his country remains in the eurozone, which opinion polls have shown the vast majority of his population wants.
Hardliners within his party have accused him of capitulating to unreasonable demands that will plunge the Greek economy further into recession.
Hopefully Tsipras will be tossed from power. The dominant neoliberal paradigm survives because politicians say one thing to the electorate -- promising to tax the super-rich and invest money in social programs; economic justice, basically -- and then when they govern they refuse to do what they were elected to do. Tsipras is a prime example. Obama is another. It also explains why Hillary Clinton has a lot of name recognition but very shallow support. Voters know what they are going to get -- a lot of articulate remedies delivered at campaign events, but nothing or next to nothing once on the throne. It is why there has been a Trump boom. His pandering seems to have ruptured the conventional boundaries of neoliberal discourse. Trump is critical of free trade and by demonizing immigrants he is trying to frack what is left in the played-out well of white backlash. Maybe Greece will lurch rightward in a Trumpist direction after Syriza's spectacular failure.

Whither the dialectic? Can the dialectic, the engine of history, be stemmed? That is what we are seeing in our present history. The rulers are refusing to budge. They are trying to roll back the tide, whether it is the Arab Spring or Occupy Wall Street or Syriza. Neoliberalism will out.

The 2011 Arab Spring has been, at least temporarily, successfully subverted at the cost of destroying the Sykes-Picot Middle East. Instead of an efflorescence of democracy, the region now has a caliphate which has re-legalized slavery.

Occupy Wall Street was successfully razed and then co-opted by Obama 2012. But Obama in his second term was quickly a disappointment. By 2013 the faithful were deserting en masse.

Syriza following its election victory in January became the vehicle for change. Instead, it ended up implementing neoliberal austerity. More of the same, even though the people voiced support to break free of the paradigm in the historic "Oxi" vote.

The hubris of the power brokers is the belief that history can be mastered, toyed with, subverted -- that neoliberalism can be maintained, despite enormous costs, with a tweak here and there.

But it cannot.

Tuesday, October 21, 2014

Significant Defeat for Islamic State at Kobani

There is more to the headline "Turkey to Let Iraqi Kurds Cross to Syria to Fight ISIS" than meets the eye. Less a change of heart or the result of concessions won from the United States, it is Turkey acknowledging that the Kurdish People's Protection Units, the YPG, have won the critical battle for Kobani.

The Turks are not allowing PKK-affiliated fighters transit to the battle zone; rather, it is the Kurdish pesh merga, with whom Ankara has cordial relations. As Kareem Fahim and Karam Shoumali report,
The decision to permit fighters aligned with different Iraqi Kurdish factions — groups that are aligned with Turkey — to join the battle in Kobani allows Mr. Erdogan to maintain his stance against the P.K.K. while addressing some of the criticism of his policy.
“Opening a passage for the pesh merga creates the impression that Turkey has changed its stance, and is on board with the coalition against ISIS,” said Halil M. Karaveli, an expert on Turkey and a senior fellow at the Central Asia-Caucasus Institute in Stockholm. “But this move is actually in Turkey’s own interests.” Mr. Karaveli said the pesh merga would counterbalance the Kurdish groups in Kobani that Turkey opposes.
The U.S. decision to resupply the YPG with arms (supplied by Iraqi Kurdistan), including antitank weapons, and ammunition by means of airdrop seems to have forced Erdogan's hand. Islamic State fighters have been pushed back and, in a sign of losing tactical advantage, have resorted to car bombings and torching homes.

This is a significant defeat for ISIS. Jihadis were massed along with APCs and tanks to take the town, which, contrary to initial Obama administration claims that the area was of little strategic value, was of utmost importance to the caliphate (for the reasons why, see Carl Drott's "What is at Stake in Kobani"). Now, the People's Protection Units, bolstered by the pesh merga, can go on the offensive, pushing east against the jihadis.
A senior Pentagon official said on Monday, speaking on the condition of anonymity, that “it will be a significant change to be able to have a free flow of fighters going into Kobani.” 
A Kurdish defense official in Kobani, Ismet Sheikh Hassan said he had not been given any information about when the pesh merga would arrive. He welcomed the influx, while asserting that the Kurdish fighters already in the city — members of the People’s Protection Forces, the Y.P.G. — were not desperate for more fighters. 
“We are short on ammunition and weapons,” he said “not on human power.” 
But Mohamed Arif Ali, a doctor working in Kobani, said that the arrival of even a few pesh merga fighters was symbolically important, and would bolster Kurdish unity. “It means a lot to the civilians and fighters,” he said. “They are not left alone facing ISIS.”

Friday, September 12, 2014

Obama's War on ISIS Crashes on the Launch Pad

Obama made his speech announcing a new iteration of the Global War on Terror (GWOT), this one ostensibly directed against the Islamic State rising in northern Iraq and Syria, on Wednesday evening. The day-after coverage faithfully repeated the president's message -- that U.S. airstrikes on ISIS in its Syrian stronghold are in the works; that Syria's president Bashar al-Assad cannot be a partner in this struggle; that Sunni allies in the Middle East will be organized; and that local "moderate" Sunni fighters will trained in Saudi Arabia with half-a-billion dollars Congress has yet to approve -- with the exception of one discordant frontpage "news analysis" article by Peter Baker which sounded the alarm that what Obama was proposing amounted to perpetual war.

This morning the discordant notes have multiplied. All the main stories in the Gray Lady today regarding Obama's commitment to wage war on ISIS are thoroughly negative.

The place to begin . . . or, better yet, if you are to read only one article today, make sure it is "U.S. Pins Hope on Syrian Rebels With Loyalties All Over the Map" by Ben Hubbard, Eric Schmitt and Mark Mazzetti. It punctures the lie at the heart of the president's war plans: the training of a "moderate" Sunni fighting force to take on ISIS. Point by point it goes through and debunks the hooey being peddled by the administration:

1) The idea that there is a "moderate" group, the Free Syrian Army (FSA), ready to partner with the U.S. is a fiction:
Analysts who track the rebel movement say that the concept of the Free Syrian Army as a unified force with an effective command structure is a myth. 
***
The Syrian rebels are a scattered archipelago of mostly local forces with ideologies that range from nationalist to jihadist. Their rank-and-file fighters are largely from the rural underclass, with few having clear political visions beyond a general interest in greater rights or the dream of an Islamic state. 
Most have no effective links to the exile Syrian National Coalition, meaning they have no political body to represent their cause. And the coalition’s Supreme Military Council, which was intended to unite the moderate rebel forces, has all but collapsed. 
“There’s a lot of skepticism about this piece of the president’s strategy,” said Representative Adam B. Schiff, Democrat of California, a member of the House Intelligence Committee. “The so-called moderate rebels have often been very immoderate and ineffective.”
2) Arms intended for the "moderates" end up with the jihadis:
Even as they line up to support Mr. Obama’s strategy against ISIS, some European allies remain skeptical about the efficacy of arming the Syrian rebels. Germany, for instance, has been arming and training Kurdish pesh merga forces in Iraq, but has resisted doing the same for any groups in Syria — partly out of fear that the weapons could end up in the hands of ISIS or other radical groups. 
“We can’t really control the final destination of these arms,” said Peter Wittig, the German ambassador to the United States.
3) Forming local fighters into an armed fighting force has a poor track record (i.e., Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.):
The approach — training and arming local fighters — has also not been effective in other arenas, whether Iraq, where the military melted away when ISIS attacked, or in Mali, where forces trained in counterterrorism switched sides to join Islamist fighters.
4) The U.S. experience so far -- the April 2013 approved CIA covert operations in Jordan and Turkey -- in arming and training the Syrian opposition has been a bust:
American involvement with the rebels so far has largely been through so-called operations rooms in Jordan and Turkey staffed by intelligence officials from the United States and other countries that have provided arms to limited numbers of vetted rebels. So far, the support provided has included light arms, ammunition and antitank missiles, which have helped the groups destroy government armor but have not resulted in major rebel advances or helped control the spread of ISIS.
“The United States can probably work with them to some extent, but they haven’t been hugely effective so far, which is why the Islamic State is there in the first place,” said Mr. Lund, the Syria analyst. 
The support so far has been limited, leaving many rebels feeling that the aid is prolonging the war, not helping them win. And the fluidity of battlefield alliances in Syria means that even mainline rebels often end up fighting alongside the Nusra Front, whose suicide bombers are relied on by other groups to soften up government targets.
Combine the Hubbard, Schmitt and Mazzetti story with one by Anne Barnard and David Kirkpatrick, "Arabs Give Tepid Support to U.S. Fight Against ISIS," and you get a sense of Obama's GWOT relaunch crashing on the pad. The only nations in the region, Syria and Iran, expressing an interest in partnering with the U.S. to eradicate ISIS are being shunned:
While Arab nations allied with the United States vowed on Thursday to “do their share” to fight ISIS and issued a joint communiqué supporting a broad strategy, the underlying tone was one of reluctance. The government perhaps most eager to join a coalition against ISIS was that of Syria, which Mr. Obama had already ruled out as a partner for what he described as terrorizing its citizens. 
Syria’s deputy foreign minister, Fayssal Mekdad, told NBC News that Syria and the United States were “fighting the same enemy,” terrorism, and that his government had “no reservations” about airstrikes as long as the United States coordinated with it. He added, “We are ready to talk.”
Turkey, the nation most critical to a successful crackdown on the caliphate, refused to even sign a communique pledging military support:
At a meeting in Jidda, Saudi Arabia, to build a coalition for the American mission, at least 10 Arab states signed a communiqué pledging to join “in the many aspects of a coordinated military campaign,” but with the qualification “as appropriate” and without any specifics. Turkey attended the meeting but declined to sign.
Turkey is critical because its border is the main jihadi route to the Syrian battlefield. As Patrick Cockburn made clear  in "Isis Consolidates," the only way to deal with ISIS is for Turkey to crack down on the jihadis crossing its borders. (Also worthy of mention here is Seymour Hersh's article pointing blame at Turkey for the Ghouta poison gas attack last summer that was used as a false flag to prompt a U.S. attack on Damascus.) Turkey's non-committal stance is a strong tell that ISIS will survive.

Monday, June 30, 2014

U.S. (Non)Response to ISIS

As Russia speeds delivery of SU-25 fighter planes to besieged Iraq, let's take a step back and reconnoiter the U.S. response, or lack thereof, to the emerging ISIS caliphate. First, blame Iraqi prime minister Nuri al-Maliki. The idea here, as floated by USG and -- uniformly -- its media minions, is that ISIS is a creation not of the rich Gulf emirates, whose history of funding and exporting Wahhabi jihad is well documented, but of the democratically elected Maliki government because that democratically elected government is not more inclusive of Sunnis.

The most obvious shortcoming of this argument is the absence of proof that Sunnis, who would be open to participating in Iraq's government if only given a sinecure, have -- anywhere -- gone over wholesale to a medieval movement that considers democracy irreligious. What the reporting has shown so far is that a relatively compact force of jihadis augmented by ex-Baathist Sufis led by former Saddam henchman Izzat Ibrahim al-Douri took Mosul by blitzkrieg on June 10. The Kurds followed by taking Kirkuk a couple days later. The whole thing had the vibe of central planning.

There have been hints in Anbar that the Sons of Iraq, the "Awakening" movement that battled ISIS precursor Al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI) during the U.S. occupation last decade, has gone over to ISIS. But this has only been alluded to, not documented at any length in anything that I have seen.

No, what is going on in Iraq smacks of a "Great Game" operation. The U.S. has done nothing so far to stem the jihadis. The 300 military advisers and surveillance flights are more to keep tabs on the Iraqi Army and the assistance it is receiving from Russia and Iran. Let's keep our eyes peeled for any strike on ISIS by the U.S. I'm skeptical one will every come off. Maybe once it is clear that the jihadis are being routed Obama will order a cosmetic Predator drone attack on a column of retreating Salafi foot soldiers, if only to maintain the cover story that USG is concerned about a terrorist safe haven.

The second aspect of the U.S. response to consider, besides the scapegoating of Maliki, is the linkage to Syria. Yes, Syria is linked to Iraq and the rise of ISIS. There is no denying that. But using the ISIS capture of Mosul and most of the Syria-Iraq border posts as an excuse to forward a half-a-billion dollar request to train and equip a non-existent "moderate" Syrian rebel army is also a strong tell. The target here is not ISIS but Assad.

So in both cases -- first, the blame-Maliki game; then the funding request for a discredited Syrian opposition -- USG is doing all it can to avoid confronting the real problem, which is ISIS and its Gulf sponsors.

It is truly pitiful, and one wonders how much longer it can continue, what with Russia and Iran acting with alacrity and the jihadis starting to suffer their first military defeats of the blitz. I'm sure the hope in Jidda and D.C. is that the gains of the blitz can be locked in -- Kurdish control of Kirkuk; Salafi control of Mosul -- and a long, grinding, costly (for Iraq, Iran, Syria, Russia) guerrilla war commences.

There will be a price to pay politically in the United States. If the conflict grinds on and Obama continues his feckless dithering, Democrats will hemorrhage. If Iraq convincingly rolls back the ISIS blitz, the Fourth Estate will shriek that the sky is falling. Let's hope for the latter.