Showing posts with label Sykes-Picot. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sykes-Picot. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Iraq: Obama's Making and Unmaking

What was foreseeable this past winter, when the Nobel Peace Laureate president relaunched the Cold War with his support of a fascist-led putsch in Ukraine, has been verified by a New York Times/CBS News poll. Obama's approval rating at 40% is one point away from the doldrums of the thirties, a level of support which historically has shown a president to be operating without the consent of the governed.

According to Michael Shear and Dalia Sussman in "Poll Finds Dissatisfaction Over Iraq," the capture of large parts of Iraq by uber-Qaeda group Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham (ISIS) is the cause of the president's undoing:
The poll found that 58 percent of Americans disapprove of the way Mr. Obama is handling foreign policy, a jump of 10 points in the last month to the highest level since Mr. Obama took office in 2009. The spike in disapproval is especially striking among Democrats, nearly a third of whom said they did not approve of his handling of foreign policy.
Fifty-two percent of Americans say they disapprove of how the president is dealing with the current violence in Iraq (including about a third of Democrats); 37 percent approve. 
“I voted for him because he said, ‘Give me four more years and I will fix everything,’ but nothing is being fixed,” Michelle Roberts, 34, a Democrat from Salem, Mass., said in a follow-up interview. “I understand he wants to fight terrorism, but send in robots, drones. Don’t send in our troops. Our men and women are dying for what?” 
The erosion in support across both parties has contributed to a drop in Mr. Obama’s overall rating that threatens to undermine his administration’s political ambitions during the remaining two and a half years of his second term. The president’s approval rating is now at 40 percent, while 54 percent say they disapprove of the job he is doing in office, a six-point jump since May.
As Obama teeters on the brink, one step away from the point of no return, the indicator that bodes ill for his remaining time in office is the jump in his disapproval rating to 54%. One could argue that Obama has lived on the edge of low-forties approval since his disastrous flirtation with bombing Damascus at the end of summer last year and he has always managed to survive. But disapproval ticking closer to a super majority is proof that attitudes are hardening towards the Nobel Peace Laureate.

Another key passage by Shear and Sussman is the confusion that dominates the electorate:
Although the survey suggests that Mr. Obama’s small steps toward military action in Iraq are in line with those of many Americans, it also indicates that people may still yearn for their commander in chief to manage foreign crises, even when the solutions are not obvious to them. A large majority thinks that the United States has important interests in Iraq’s future. Two-thirds said Mr. Obama had not done enough to explain American goals in the country.
This confusion is the result of a people being indoctrinated for the better part of two decades to believe that Wahhabi-style Islam of the type practiced by the Taliban in Afghanistan and Osama bin Laden is the greatest enemy to the United States. Yet Obama and his Secretary of State Kerry spend the majority of their time so far talking about malign Iranian and Syrian influence and lecturing the one-time U.S. favorite Nuri al-Maliki, Iraq's head of state, that he has to go because he is too sectarian. And all the while there is not one word (other than some ass-covering by an "unnamed senior official" saying that the administration is aware of the problem) about the robust support ISIS receives from the Gulf Sheikhdoms. No wonder people are confused.

People are confused because Obama is playing a game, pretending that the foe is still Al Qaeda and its ilk but the administration's enemy of choice is actually Iran and the states aligned with Iran in the Middle East, Iraq and Syria. A good indication of this can be found in the administration's non-existent reaction to the news that Iraq's border crossing with Jordan has been captured by ISIS. If there were any real threat to Jordan there is no doubt that the Salafis occupying the crossing at Trebil would be blown to smithereens by U.S. aircraft.

More and more the assessment from the first days of ISIS's blitzkrieg capture of Mosul -- that what is happening in Iraq is a planned partition of the country -- seems to be the accurate one. A new secret agreement to carve Iraq into a Kurdish state as well as a Sunni caliphate encompassing parts of Syria while leaving the Shia the rest is in the offing. Call it a centennial overhaul of Sykes-Picot.

And it will be the final nail in Obama's presidential coffin. A guy who rose to power in the Democratic Party based on his pacific stance on the Iraq War is presiding over its bloody destruction. And the carnage and mayhem have just begun. There is no telling how bad things are going to get.

It is hard to say if it will be the wholesale undoing of the Democrats. We can only hope that moribund progressives and liberals will rise in mass and vacate the party.

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

The Future State of Kurdistan + Navi Pillay Steps Out on al-Assad


This blog has been committed to following the war in Syria. Originally part of the wave of protests that made up the Arab Spring, the popular uprising in Syria has morphed into a military conflict that pits salafi jihadists, many of whom are foreigners supported by wealthy Gulf sheikhdoms, against the Baathist Syrian government and its allies, Hezbollah, Iran and the Shia of Iraq.

Syria, like Iraq, is a former League of Nations mandate country that originated in the secret 1916 Sykes-Picot Agreement by France and Britain divvying up the Ottoman Empire. The century-old boundaries that constitute the Middle East are fraying.

This morning there is an informative piece by Tim Arango and Clifford Krause, "Kurds’ Oil Deals With Turkey Raise Fears of Fissures in Iraq." Iraqi Kurds are cutting their own oils deals absent approval from Baghdad. A second pipeline to Turkey is in the works:
Even as sectarian killing is again spiking across Iraq, and the Syrian civil war destabilizes the region, American officials in Baghdad say the flow of oil to Turkey may be the greatest potential risk to Iraq’s cohesion. 
But a year-and-a-half-long diplomatic drive by the United States to stop the flow has so far failed, reflecting Washington’s diminished influence in the region, even with its two longtime allies. Not only will trucks continue to travel daily from the Kurdish region to two Turkish cities on the Mediterranean coast, and not only will the Kurds continue to deliver oil via a pipeline to Turkey, but the parties plan to build a second pipeline, whose details have been kept secret. 
“The Kurdistan deal with Turkey is a huge violation against the Iraqi Constitution because they didn’t make the deal with the coordination of the central government,” said Ali Dhari, the deputy chairman of the Iraqi Parliament’s oil and gas committee. “This means the stealing of the Iraqi wealth, and we will not allow it.” 
The oil accords with Turkey, potentially worth billions of dollars, are part of a broader effort by Iraqi Kurds in recent years to cut their own energy deals — including exploration agreements with foreign companies like Exxon Mobil, Chevron and Gazprom — that sidelined the central government. The Kurds, and the Turks, say they will pay Baghdad its fair share. But officials in the capital have long claimed such arrangements are illegal. 
The controversy is in part the unfinished business of the American occupation of Iraq. The failure of the Iraqi government to pass a national oil law, one of the benchmarks set by President George W. Bush when he announced the United States troop “surge” in 2007, has left Baghdad and Erbil, the Kurdish capital, in a perpetual feud over how to divide profits and who has the authority to make agreements with international oil companies.
Commentators on the Left warned that the U.S. invasion and occupation of Iraq would fracture the country, but no one in power ever listens to commentators on the Left. The fact that their insights more often than not prove to be correct does not earn them any respect from state officials.

Kurds are battling and defeating Al Qaeda in northeast Syria where an autonomous Kurdish administrative territory has been declared. With an understanding now in place with archfoe Turkey, the possibility of a future state of Kurdistan seems like a good bet. The Kurds have been shrewd; they're taking small bites and doing their best to stay under the radar; they're taking the long view. They are impressive.

What UN high commissioner for human rights Navi Pillay's statement the other day -- that there is massive evidence of war crimes and crimes against humanity by Bashar al-Assad and his government -- portends is hard to suss out. Pillay says that al-Assad should be referred to the International Criminal Court. Nick Cumming-Bruce has the story, "Top U.N. Rights Official Links Assad to Crimes in Syria":
Ms. Pillay said the panel had handed her lists of names to be held securely at the human rights office in Geneva. Ms. Pillay also repeated demands that she and the panel have made that the situation in Syria should be referred to the International Criminal Court in The Hague. 
“Accountability should be key priority of international community, and I want to make this point again and again as the Geneva 2 talks begin,” she said, alluding to the second international conference on Syria scheduled to start in Geneva on Jan. 22.
At the very least Pillay's broadside makes it more difficult for Western leaders to cozy up to the Baathists in Syria, something that has been underway since the September chemical weapons deal was signed; since then there has been a polar shift in the United States away from vilifying al-Assad and praising the opposition. It's hard to imagine a situation where Pillay stepped out on her own. It must be an attempt by the West to shape the outcome of Geneva II. Al-Assad can enter negotiations but any deal the West agrees to will not include al-Assad remaining the head of government. If he agrees to step down, the West can offer him freedom from prosecution in The Hague.

Monday, August 26, 2013

U.S. Absurdly Claims "Very Little Doubt" About Syrian Poison Gas Use; It's a Run Up to Iraq Invasion Redux

The whole thing stinks to high heaven. On Sunday a nameless "senior Obama administration official said . . . there was 'very little doubt' that President Bashar al-Assad’s military forces had used chemical weapons against civilians last week and that a Syrian promise to allow United Nations inspectors access to the site was 'too late to be credible.' " This from a story by Scott Shane and Ben Hubbard that appeared yesterday on the New York Times web site.

Ask yourself the question, "Why is giving inspectors approval on Sunday after an early Wednesday morning gas attack too late to be credible?" The site of the chemical attack is behind rebel lines. The Syrian government's wariness to grant immediate access to the inspection team probably had to do with not being able to guarantee their safety. Imagine a situation where United Nations personnel are taken hostage by Al Qaeda jihadis.

Reports this morning that the U.N. convoy of inspectors came under sniper fire soon after they left the government checkpoint and headed into rebel territory highlights this danger and strongly suggests that it is the opposition that above all doesn't want an inspection, possibly because the evidence gathered will overwhelming reveal that the chemical stocks used to massacre the 300-plus civilians have a foreign signature. Why aren't France, Britain and the United States threatening strikes against opposition territory?

No, it's all like a bad flashback to the run up to the shock and awe in the Iraq war a decade ago. No matter how much access the Iraqis granted Hans Blix, and no matter the lack of any of weapons of mass destruction unearthed, none of it mattered. The United States fabricated its own proof using code-named anonymous sources and official pronouncements that were dutifully featured in the prestige press. One would hope that we had learned our lesson after the bloody -- and still bloody -- war in Iraq. But it doesn't appear that we have.

The fact that Israel is out front on this, denying any possibility other than a Syrian government origin of the chemical weapons attack and calling for inclusion of Iran in any planned military action, has to raise any news consumer's suspicion that there is something more here than fits the standard Western narrative:
Israel sharpened its message on Sunday, suggesting that the use of such weapons in the region should not go without a response. 
“This situation must not be allowed to continue,” Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said, referring to the Syrian civilians “who were so brutally attacked by weapons of mass destruction.” 
“The most dangerous regimes in the world must not be allowed to possess the most dangerous weapons in the world,” he said. 
Some Israelis have argued that international intervention in Syria would distract the world from the crucial effort to prevent a nuclear Iran. But there is a growing sense among Israelis that Syria is now a test of how the world might respond to Iran as it approaches the ability to make a nuclear weapon. 
“Assad’s regime has become a full Iranian client, and Syria has become Iran’s testing ground,” Mr. Netanyahu added.
What we've got here is a grand barbecue. It's Middle East score settling and a carving up of Sykes-Picot, not just a roll back of the three-year-old Arab Spring. The Saudis are flying high. The Egyptian generals have smashed political Islam. Now it's time to finally get rid of Baathism. Seeing the Saudis gorging themselves at the table, the Israelis are trying to elbow their way in and take out Iran during the feeding frenzy.

The danger here in all of this is too immense to gauge. One thing is for sure. If Obama presides over a propaganda campaign reminiscent of the one used to frighten people into supporting an invasion of Iraq -- or even like the one used to justify bombing Yugoslavia in 1999 -- that'll be it for his ability to mobilize his diminishing base of supporters, for his legacy, for the immediate future of the Democratic Party. The promise of the Obama presidency -- if not the actual record -- has always been that he'll do whatever he can to keep American citizens from fighting foreign wars. We attack Syria, this one great promise disappears.

Friday, August 16, 2013

The Goal: Roll Back Arab Spring, Reconfigure Sykes-Picot, Reduce Iran, Secure Greater Israel

As large protest marches take place throughout Egypt today despite the imposition of martial law after the Wednesday massacre of pro-Morsi supporters by the coup government, it is illuminating to read the story by Mark Landler and Peter Baker, "His Options Few, Obama Rebukes Egypt’s Leaders." It is a snapshot of a helpless giant whose fecklessness and drift is explained away by its power-broker elite as a rational course of action -- which it is in a corrupt, "pay-to-play" system. While there are noises within the Obama administration that all options are still on the table, including obeying the law and denying $1.3 billion in aid to General Sisi's military junta, don't expect anything more than the cancellation of joint exercises with the Egyptian armed forces that Obama announced yesterday from his vacation retreat:
Given the deep schism in Egypt, this official said, the White House is still skeptical that cutting off aid would compel the generals to return the country to a democratic transition. And it could destabilize the region, particularly the security of Israel, whose 1979 peace treaty with Egypt is predicated on the aid.

For weeks, officials from Israel and several Arab countries have pressured the administration to maintain the flow of aid. If it were cut off, they said, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates would move quickly to make up the shortfall — and then some. 
Saudi Arabia and the emirates pledged $8 billion in grants and loans to Egypt’s post-Morsi government last month: $5 billion from Saudi Arabia in grants and loans; $3 billion from the emirates. That is more than enough, analysts say, to offset any cutoff from the United States, even if the two countries do not fulfill their entire pledges. 
Shutting off the aid spigot now would not have an immediate impact on the Egyptian military, defense officials say, because this year’s military assistance has already been delivered. Beyond money, Arab officials worry that a rupture between Washington and the Egyptian military would further erode American influence in a country that has historically been a bellwether in the Arab world, and would open the door to rivals like Russia or China. 
“If the aid gets cut, you can be sure that Putin will arrive in Cairo in two or three months,” one senior Arab official said. “And he will give aid with no strings attached.”
So there you have it. To head off the predatory, baleful Vlad Putin, as well as to secure cooperation with Israel, not to mention overflight rights and access to the Suez Canal, the United States will continue to pay the Egyptian military.

A robust refutation of this lazy, Washington-insider point of view can be found on New York Times Opinion Page in a piece written by Amr Darrag, Mohamed Morsi's minister of planning and international cooperation:
First, this is a battle between those who envision a democratic, pluralistic Egypt in which the individual has dignity and power changes hands at the ballot box and those who support a militarized state in which government is imposed on the people by force. 
Second, this coup has already sent Egypt back into the dark ages of dictatorship — with tight military control over both state-owned and private media, attacks on peaceful protesters and journalists, and detention of opposition leaders without criminal charges or due process. 
Third, there is no promise that General Sisi can make that he hasn’t already betrayed. He took an oath to uphold the Constitution; he suspended the Constitution. He took an oath to loyally serve in the government; he toppled that government. And in the classic doublespeak of military juntas, he loudly condemned the opposition for dealing with foreign powers, while he was actively seeking the help of Western diplomats as well as the Persian Gulf sheikdoms that largely financed his coup. 
Through all this, the United States government has pleaded impotence. Hardly a day goes by without some press officer, analyst or public official pushing the idea that Washington’s influence really isn’t that decisive with the Egyptian generals. This cop-out simply won’t do. America had influence and still does. It was an American official, not an Egyptian one, who informed President Morsi’s staff of the finality of the coup decision.
There is only one way forward in Egypt today. The legitimate government must be restored. Only then can we hold talks for a national reconciliation with every option on the table.
Iraq is being terror bombed daily by Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham. A massive bombing took place in a Hezbollah neighborhood in Beirut yesterday. There is a region-wide war being waged in the Middle East. The goal is to reconfigure Sykes-Picot, roll back the Arab Spring, reduce Iran and secure a Greater Israel. To this end look for, eventually, direct U.S. military involvement.

Friday, June 28, 2013

Talibanizing Sykes-Picot

A decent piece summarizing the positions of the great powers in relation to the Syrian civil war appears on Reuters this morning; written by Louis Charbonneau, "Analysis: Syria peace conference: Don't hold your breath," it predicts a long conflict:
There may be no swift end to the war. And even if the opposition were to prevail, it is unlikely to bring stability. 
"The Syrian civil war is likely to go on for years," said Richard Haass, president of the Council on Foreign Relations.

"It is not just that it is proving harder and taking longer to oust the Assad regime than many expected," he told Reuters. "It is also that even if the regime were to be removed, what would follow would be a prolonged round of fighting among opposition forces who disagree on just about everything except their opposition to the current regime."
Haass, who in the past has not been shy about advocating the use of U.S. military force, recently had a opinion piece in the Sunday New York Times saying that the United States should not get involved militarily in Syria. Sadly, it appears too late for that. Kerry appears to be committed to air strikes. There are a lot of obstacles in the way, but the Franklin Lamb story, based on his discussions with congressional staffers, that the U.S. will be conducting an air war against Syria by the end of summer, is looking like a reliable prediction.

Hwaida Saad and Rick Gladstone's story, "Christian Quarter of Old City in Damascus Hit by Attacks," explains why the attacks on the Syrian pound have not phased the al-Assad government:
The conflict and the Western sanctions imposed on Syria have caused a near economic collapse in the country, and the official currency, the Syrian pound, has plummeted in value against the dollar and the euro. Last week Mr. Assad’s government ordered double-digit increases in salaries for public employees and retirees to help offset the pound’s diminished worth, which is almost certain to cause sharply higher inflation in Syria. 
But in a sign that the Syrian leadership does not seem overly concerned about a financial crisis, a senior economics official said in an interview with The Financial Times, published on its Web site Thursday, that Iran, Russia and China were helping to prop up the Syrian economy, delivering $500 million a month worth of oil and extending generous credit lines. 
The official, Qadri Jamil, deputy prime minister for the economy, was quoted as saying that the Syrian government was now doing all of its business in Iranian rials, Russian rubles and Chinese renminbi, and that the three economic allies would soon help with a “counteroffensive” against what he called a foreign plot to destroy the Syrian pound’s value. 
“It’s not that bad to have behind you the Russians, the Chinese and Iranians,” Mr. Jamil was quoted as saying.
As the terror bombings continue in Iraq, what we're witnessing, thanks to the Gulf Arab monarchies and their partners Uncle Sam and the old colonial powers Britain and France, is the Talibanizing of Sykes-Picot. In a jiffy, the Global War on Terror is tossed on the dung heap in favor of a Global War with Terror. No wonder Israel has pulled its head into its tortoise shell the last month.

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Rebel Defeat in Qusayr

Jacob Wirtschafter, reporting for USA TODAY, says that Qusayr has been taken by government troops:
"Yes, al-Qusayr fell to regime control," said 25-year-old Muhammad Awad of the Free Syrian Army's al-Farouk Battalion in Qusayr. "Let the world, the regime and all the people against us be happy. We retreated because we could not take them on anymore." 
The Free Syrian Army, which had held on to the city for months through increasingly fierce bombardment and attacks by the regime, killing hundreds, conceded that they had to make a retreat from the town that lies on a key supply route.
Widely predicted to determine the outcome of the revolution, Qusayr puts the West in a difficult spot. How will it respond? Look no further than today's story by Steven Erlanger, Nick Cumming-Bruce and Alan Cowell, "France and Britain Say Nerve Gas Likely Used in Syria":
A day after France announced that French laboratory tests had confirmed that sarin gas had been used “multiple times” in Syria “in a localized way,” Britain on Wednesday repeated an earlier assessment that “a growing body of limited but persuasive information” pointed to the use of the same toxin.
The French foreign minister, Laurent Fabius, said that in one case, at least, “there is no doubt it was the regime and its accomplices” that used the gas. France and Britain said their conclusions were based on samples brought out of Syria.
The statements came as United States, Russian and United Nations officials prepared for talks on Wednesday in Geneva on setting up a possible international peace conference. 
In a statement, Mr. Fabius said samples of body fluids taken from victims in Syria and tested at a French laboratory — including urine samples carried out of Syria by French reporters — “prove the presence of sarin,” a poisonous nerve gas. 
“It would be unacceptable that those guilty of these crimes can benefit from impunity,” Mr. Fabius said, without specifying of whom he spoke. But sarin is in the government’s stock of chemical weapons, and he later told France 2 television that blood samples from victims of a helicopter attack in April in Idlib Province left no doubt that it was the government that had used sarin. 
“We are aware of the entire chain, from when the attack took place to when the people were killed and the samples taken,” he said.
The Assad government, so it appears, has finally mastered how to defeat the rebels: use surface-to-surface missiles and air power to pound opposition forces and then send in tanks and infantry. The rebels can't hold turf in face of this; they don't have the firepower. For a description of this, check out C.J. Chivers' frontpage story this morning, "Syrian Rebels Meet Setbacks on a New Front." Chivers describes the fighting in the towns of the Hama plain east of the Damascus-Aleppo Highway in northern Syria:
The battles have shown the strains on all sides in a war in its third year. 
The rebels are pulled between the limits inherent to a lightly equipped and fundamentally guerrilla force and their urge to fight with the battlefield weight of an army.
And the Syrian Army and its loyalist militias are simultaneously trying to maintain a sprawling network of outposts on territory sympathetic to the opposition, while repositioning forces with hopes of reversing the rebels’ gains of the past year. 
The West now appears to be committed to ginning up a justification for direct military intervention. It won't have a UN stamp of approval. Carla Del Ponte's statement in early May that UN investigators had "strong, concrete suspicions" that rebels used sarin gas undercuts the rationale for an attack on the Assad government. This means that it would have to be a NATO operation like Libya. But it is not clear -- because of Germany -- that NATO would lead an assault. So it would probably fall to the old colonial powers -- France, Britain -- in concert with the U.S., Israel and the Gulf monarchies. To go this route the West will have to accept the likely outcome -- world war in the Middle East and replacing Sykes-Picot for something that would look like Somaliland. At this point I'm not sure that the West is willing to stomach this. Clearly a bellicose posture is being maintained in an attempt to get Assad to bargain away the territorial integrity of Syria.

Saturday, June 1, 2013

Patrick Cockburn on Syria

A must-read article that appears on the Counterpunch web site this weekend is Patrick Cockburn's "How Syria Became a More Dangerous Quagmire Than Iraq." Cockburn, a veteran Middle East correspondent, provides an even-handed, no-bullshit assessment of the Syrian civil war. To give you a flavor of the analysis provided, check out the following paragraph:
The feeling that the future of whole states is in doubt is growing across the Middle East – for the first time since Britain and France carved up the remains of the Ottoman Empire after the First World War. ‘It is the end of Sykes-Picot,’ I was told repeatedly in Iraq; the reference was to the agreement of 1916 which divided up the spoils between Britain and France and was the basis for later treaties. Some are jubilant at the collapse of the old order, notably the thirty million Kurds who were left without a state of their own after the Ottoman collapse and are now spread across Iraq, Turkey, Iran and Syria. They feel their moment has come: they are close to independence in Iraq and are striking a deal with the Turkish government for political rights and civil equality. In March, the Kurdish guerrillas of the PKK declared an end to their thirty-year war with the Turkish government and started withdrawing into the mountains of northern Iraq. The 2.5 million Kurds in northern Syria, 10 per cent of the population, have assumed control of their towns and villages and are likely to demand a high degree of autonomy from any postwar Syrian government.
Cockburn doesn't see a way out of the current violent stalemate.