Showing posts with label Homs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Homs. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 18, 2014

Get Ready for Blowback

At the start of this past three-day holiday weekend I was feeling good. I awoke early, did a few loads of laundry, and then got in a four-mile run. All that before 10 AM. I then checked in on Moon of Alabama and the blog entry "Real Or Propaganda? New Weapons To Syrian Mercenaries."

A shift is underway among the "Friends of Syria," a.k.a., Al Qaeda steering committee, to increase military pressure on the Syrian government. With the total collapse of the latest round of peace talks in Geneva, the "Friends of Syria" are staring down at a large plate of crow. Their strategy so far has been a failure. Syria has not collapsed. She is being cracked, but she still stands. And militarily, thanks to Russian-supplied helicopters, she is gaining momentum and regaining territory. Also, and perhaps equally important, Syria is winning the propaganda war. Voters within the Western bloc of the "Friends of Syria," despite a daily pummeling of images of broken children pulled from bomb rubble and words descrying Assad's use of barrel bombs against civilians, are clearly opposed to any military aid for the opposition, which at this point appears to be entirely composed of radical Sunni fundamentalist jihadis.

But after reading the comments on Moon of Alabama, I started to feel ill. "Here we go again," I thought. Rather than accept the fact that its plans have been a failure, the United States and its allies appear to be committed to expanding the violence: manpads to the rebels in a vain hope to neutralize Syrian air power. Here is how Michael Gordon, David Sanger and Eric Schmitt put it this morning in "U.S. Scolds Russia as It Weighs Options on Syrian War":
Mr. Assad’s hold on power has grown over the past year, according to the head of American intelligence. Recognizing that a political settlement is unlikely if he keeps the advantage, administration officials said that Mr. Obama and other Western leaders had dropped their objections to proposals by Saudi Arabia and other countries to funnel more advanced weapons to vetted rebel groups, including portable antiaircraft weapons, often called manpads. 
A secret meeting in Washington last week among the intelligence chiefs from almost all of the countries attempting to oust the Assad government included extensive discussion about how to best provide that new lethal aid to rebel groups, the officials said. The gathering of the top intelligence officials from Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Turkey, Britain, France and the United Arab Emirates, and several others from the 11-nation group known as the Friends of Syria, reflected a belief that the diplomatic track has been exhausted unless Mr. Assad sustains significant military setbacks.
As Gordon et al. note in their story the Saudis have already been supplying manpads:
A fighter from the Damascus suburbs who fled to Beirut, Lebanon, said one of the reasons he left was that the Army of Islam, the rebel group led by Zahran Alloush, had surface-to-air missiles, which he said were a Syrian Army model taken from antiaircraft bases a year ago. But the Army of Islam, which is supported by Saudi private donors, has declined to share its plentiful arms and its cash with other rebel groups, particularly non-Islamist ones. That has complicated efforts to counter Mr. Assad’s forces around Damascus. 
Mr. Obama’s apparent willingness to drop objections to supplying the rebel groups with heavier weapons may simply be an acknowledgment that Saudi Arabia and gulf states that are frustrated with American policy are now prepared to do so anyway, without Washington’s blessing. American officials say they also now have a better sense than they did last year about which groups they can trust to use and secure the weapons.
Like Afghanistan more than thirty years ago, the United States plans on saturating the Levant with portable missiles. Expect to see some of those manpads used in the Sinai and in Iraq. It is all so predictable and stupid. But it does guarantee war, perpetual war.

The U.S. decision to blame Russia for the impasse on Syria seems particularly stupid. Russia will not be hectored to the bargaining table to negotiate away the Syrian state, particularly after Victoria Nuland's performance in Kiev.

And what makes the present course of the Obama administration so dicey is that it is in opposition to its putative base of popular support. If Obama, already listing dangerously in the polls, continues to proceed down this bellicose path he will find the Democratic Party split and vulnerable come November, with the Senate likely returning to Republican control.

The fourth estate is doing its part, banging the war drum by focusing its coverage of the Syrian war primarily on the government's use of barrel bombs against rebel-controlled neighborhoods in Homs and Aleppo. But it will not compel any popular support for greater U.S. involvement. After the disaster of Iraq and Afghanistan, coupled with the devastating impact of the ongoing Great Recession, one would have to be entirely insane to back another belligerent escapade in the Middle East. And while the masses might be confused and uninformed, they are not insane. It is the governing elites, seemingly disconnected from everyday reality, who are insane.

Tuesday, July 30, 2013

SAA Secures Khalidiya District in Homs

A particularly good assessment of the current military situation in Syria can be found this morning on BBC's website. Written by Paul Wood reporting from Beirut, it stands out because it is not twisted, like so many stories that appear in the Western press, to fall in line with U.S. foreign policy. This policy demands that atrocities by rebel forces be downplayed, ignored, excused, blamed on the Syrian government while battlefield gains by the Syrian Arab Army be downplayed, ignored, explained away.

In "After Khalidiya, Syria conflict goes on," Wood reports that the main rebel-held neighborhood in Homs has fallen to government forces. The focus will now shift to securing Aleppo. Wood's assessment for the near future is difficult to dispute:
Some analysts are already speculating that this is the beginning of the end of the armed rebellion. 
Western diplomats dealing with the armed opposition believe the government may be able to establish a "secure area" running from Damascus all the way up to Hama, a city 45km (28 miles) to the north of Homs, or even to Aleppo. 
What happens now may depend on the extent of foreign intervention. 
Saudi Arabia and Qatar have been sending weapons to the FSA for some time. The US is moving towards sending small arms. The UK is contemplating such a step, but would only do so after a vote in Parliament. 
It would probably take a very large influx of weapons to break the government's momentum.
However, that does not mean that the armed uprising will be extinguished. 
President Bashar al-Assad has had to use his own foreign fighters, from Hezbollah, to pursue his offensive. 
He does not have enough loyal manpower to chase the rebels into the countryside, the mountains and the deserts. 
Even if the government takes back the big cities and the main roads, Syria will remain divided, the conflict far from over.
There was nothing in today's New York Times about the SAA victory in Khalidiya. In the Gray Lady, for the most part if not always, the only news coming out of Syria that is fit to print is the horror and suffering of war caused entirely by a brutal dictator named al-Assad. It's a cold war, cartoon version of ongoing events, and the news is sculpted to fit that perspective. In other words, it's propaganda.

Worrisome is the presence of Robert F. Worth reporting from Cairo in the absence of David Kirkpatrick. Hopefully Kirkpatrick is just taking some time off -- he's still listed as the Cairo bureau chief on the NYT website. Worth's writing has that spooky quality ("spooky" in the Langley sense), while Kirkpatrick and Kareem Fahim have been consistently excellent reporters going back to the first days of the Arab Spring.

Wednesday, July 17, 2013

No Good Endgame for Rebels

Anne Barnard and a reporter whose identity is being shielded by the New York Times have a story this morning about the the battle for Homs, "Ruins in a Center of Syria’s Uprising." After reading it a couple of things come to mind. First, the reporting that's done by Anne Barnard consistently centers blame for the civil war on the Syrian government while marginalizing any role played foreign-funded jihadis. To read Barnard one is still living the first hopeful, heady days of the Arab Spring uprising where the rebels are protesters looking for democratic representation and freedom from an Alawite Stalin. Barnard does write what is actually happening on the ground -- her reporting is not fabrication. For instance, in today's story about Homs, she does include the fact that the territory held by the rebels is awash in sewage and rubble while life continues as close to normal as possible in government-controlled districts. But for Barnard there is always the tactful sculpting of the story to push the truth about the rebels down into the later paragraphs, making it appear more as an afterthought, as unimportant.

The other thing that struck me after reading the story about Homs is that there is no happy endgame for the rebels. The government is slowly, methodically grinding away at the territory in opposition hands. The rebels respond by car bombings and assassinations, often outside Syria, like the pro-Assad commentator, Mohammad Darra Jamo, who was gunned down at his home in southern Lebanon early this morning.

At first this strategy of bringing terror to neighboring countries seemed somewhat effective at ratcheting up pressure for foreign state intervention. The Western press raised alarms, incoherently blaming Hezbollah while ignoring the Sunni jihadist fingerprints, and called for action to stem a regional war. But now, with a many-sided conflict breaking out among the rebels in northern Syrian -- Kurdish militants took control of a border town from the Al Nusra Front; last week a commander for the Free Syrian Army was murdered by fighters of the Islamic State of Iraq and Levant -- there's no way that Western intervention can be neatly packaged in the Manichean narrative of good vs. evil that the editorial pages of the prestige press prefer. Support for the jihadis by Gulf Arab monarchies and Western powers has created the predicted blowback.

Friday, July 5, 2013

Al-Assad Has Good Reason to Gloat

The Associated Press is reporting this morning that the Syrian National Coalition is calling for immediate intervention by the West and the United Nations to provide food and medical assistance to the besieged rebel-held areas of Homs and Dara'a. We've seen this before in the run up to Syrian Arab Army control of Qusayr.

It's hard to imagine things going any worse for the rebels. The Syrian National Coalition is meeting in Istanbul to agree on new leadership. So far there is no indication that divisions can be bridged. The coup in Cairo will sow even more division. The big benefactor nations will  turn their attention to Egypt. The GCC has come out in support of the Egyptian military while Tunisia and Turkey defend their political brethren in the Muslim Brotherhood. The United States is biding its time. Al-Assad feels strengthened by the turn of events.

If civil war breaks out in Egypt between Islamists and the military, the United States will favor an immediate cease fire. This will put it odds with its position regarding Syria, which is that more blood needs to be spilled before al-Assad is softened up enough to negotiate his power away.

If civil war does not break out and the Egyptian military manages a smoother transition to a more inclusive Democratic state this time around, then al-Assad will not have to worry about Sunni imams using Cairo to issue calls for jihad against Syria. The Egyptian military doesn't want jihadis returning from foreign wars to stir up trouble at home.

Either outcome of the coup, al-Assad has reason to gloat.

Saturday, June 29, 2013

The Poverty of Elections

Elections are proving not to be the answer. Look at Obama's solid, one might even argue historic, progressive repudiation of a troglodyte conservative Republican Party. Nothing has changed. The economy remains hobbled with too many unemployed; the national security state grows ever stronger. Even Nobel Peace Prize winner Obama's one great promise -- that he'll wind down the wars in the Middle East -- has turned into a lie as we end up where we began 35 years ago -- arming the mujahideen.

Elections that brought the Muslim Brotherhood to power in Egypt have done nothing to address the nation's ills. The Mubarak security forces remain ensconced in the Interior Ministry; the economy teeters on the brink; and the society is divided between followers of conservative Islam and everyone else. Violence spiked yesterday in the run up to Sunday's huge planned protest. There could be a full-blown civil war in a matter of days.

Iraq is suffering through daily multiple terror bombings.

Al Nusra Front jihadis are claiming to have taken the Binayat checkpoint from the Syrian Arab Army in the southern city of Dara'a. But even the pro-opposition Syrian Observatory for Human Rights doubts the veracity of the claim. According to the story by Hania Mourtada and Rick Gladstone in this morning's paper,
Video posted on the Internet showed what the rebels claimed to be the destruction of a high-rise building at the checkpoint, along with proclamations of victory by fighters of the Nusra Front “and the Islamic battalions who participated in the operation.” 
Rami Abdulrahman, the head of the Syrian Observatory, said the insurgents had not taken full control of Dara’a. But in remarks quoted by Reuters, he said the Syrian military’s position in Dara’a was under threat and “this could change the balance of power there.”
An anti-Assad activist from Dara’a who is currently in Jordan agreed in a telephone interview that the seizure of the Binayat checkpoint was a setback for Syrian forces in Dara’a, but cautioned that the rebel claims of victory could be overstated. “The Islamic groups are trying to make a big deal behind this operation, a boasting attempt,” said the activist, who identified himself only by his given name, Taysir, for security reasons.
In other words, an attack on a government checkpoint has, thanks to the power of jihadi magical thinking, turned into the capture of an entire city.

The Guardian is reporting stepped up government activity to retake the Khalidiyah district in Homs.

I woke up this morning thinking that what's happening here is that the Wahhabis are making their move to take control of the Middle East. It's hard to think that in this environment the Israelis are going to budge one inch towards a two-state solution. This is a war for survival.