Showing posts with label Matthew Rosenberg. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matthew Rosenberg. Show all posts

Sunday, January 22, 2017

Trump Swears Fealty to Deep State During Pink "CoRev"

Saturday was supposed to be a day for Mr. Trump to mend fences with the intelligence community, with an appearance at the C.I.A.’s headquarters in Langley, Va. While he was lavish in his praise, the president focused in his 15-minute speech on his complaints about news coverage of his criticism of the nation’s spy agencies, and meandered to other topics, including the crowd size at his inauguration, his level of political support, his mental age and his intellectual heft.
“I just want to let you know, I am so behind you,” Mr. Trump told more than 300 employees assembled in the lobby for his remarks.
In recent weeks, Mr. Trump has questioned the intelligence agencies’ conclusion that Russia meddled in the United States election on his behalf. After the disclosure of a dossier with unsubstantiated claims about Mr. Trump, he accused the intelligence community of allowing the leak and wrote on Twitter, “Are we living in Nazi Germany?”
On Saturday, he said journalists were responsible for any suggestion that he was not fully supportive of intelligence agencies’ work.
“I have a running war with the media,” Mr. Trump said. “They are among the most dishonest human beings on earth, and they sort of made it sound like I had a feud with the intelligence community.”
“The reason you’re the No. 1 stop [CIA HQ in Langley] is, it is exactly the opposite,” Mr. Trump added. “I love you, I respect you, there’s nobody I respect more.”
That's from "With False Claims, Trump Attacks Media on Turnout and Intelligence Rift," by Julie Hirschfeld Davis and Matthew Rosenberg. Much of the story is taken up with competing claims about the size of Trump's inaugural crowd versus Obama's (both 2009 and 2013). It is also being reported that "The women’s march in Washington was roughly three times the size of the audience at President Trump’s inauguration, crowd counting experts said Saturday." (See
"Crowd Scientists Say Women’s March in Washington Had 3 Times More People Than Trump’s Inauguration," by Tim Wallace and Alice Parlapiano.)

I count no less than six stories in Sunday's New York Times devoted to yesterday's women's march. Turnout is estimated to have been approximately half a million in Washington D.C. and 400,000 in New York City. Not bad.

The women's march had its colorful symbol (a pink hat), and it had it's own Shepherd Fairey poster of a woman wearing Old Glory as a hijab:


In other words, the women's march had all the makings for a domestic color revolution: robust numbers of regular citizens, fetching symbols, a supple propaganda apparatus, all in opposition to a bloated billionaire megalomaniac. What was missing was a provocative act of violence, like the Maidan snipers or the pepper-spray storm that kicked off the Umbrella Revolution.

I don't think the intention here was to send Trump and Melania fleeing from the nation's capital. I think the goal was to put Trump on notice that if he doesn't kneel to the Deep State the color revolution machinery can be fired up again easily; and the next time, protesters likely will have plans for civil disobedience. That was the great failing of the huge protests in the run up to the illegal U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003 -- leadership did not or could not ratchet up marches to mass civil disobedience. With Moral Mondays an established part of the bourgeois protest repertoire, I think it will be much easier now to mobilize mass civil disobedience if and when it is needed.

Friday, October 14, 2016

Out of the Closet in Yemen

The colossal stupidity of the United States Government was on display with its recent missile strikes on Yemeni radar sites. The USG is now publicly committed to protecting all Red Sea shipping in the Bab el Mandeb bottleneck. This from "Yemen Sees U.S. Strikes as Evidence of Hidden Hand Behind Saudi Air War" by Mark Mazzetti, Ben Hubbard and Matthew Rosenberg:
The United States has also kept warships in the region to guard a sea lane through which four million barrels of oil pass each day. There, in the narrow strait at the mouth of the Red Sea, the dizzying mix of warships, cargo vessels and insurgent forces this week yielded precisely what the Obama administration had spent 18 months trying to avoid. 
The American strikes, launched at rebel-held territory, came after two unsuccessful missile attacks on the Mason in four days, the Pentagon said Thursday, and were intended solely to protect American forces and other shipping in Bab el Mandeb, the strait separating Yemen from Eritrea and Djibouti.
More attacks would invite further retaliation, Peter Cook, the Pentagon spokesman, said Thursday. American and allied warships will continue to patrol the strait, he said, but “we don’t seek a wider role in the conflict.” 
That may be the case, but the United States now finds itself facing a dangerous situation in a narrow stretch of water where even small incidents run the risk of inciting a broader conflict. 
After the American strikes, Iran said it was sending two warships to the strait, presumably to support the Houthis, an indigenous Shiite group with loose connections to Iran. Saudi Arabia has portrayed the Houthis as an Iranian proxy force and has said that it needed to intervene in Yemen to protect Saudi national security by preventing the rise of a belligerent militia on its southern border.
This commitment to Bab el Mandeb  cannot be easily undone. The U.S. is now "out of the closet" in Yemen; at the same time, it is talking about a shooting war with Russia over Aleppo.

What is fascinating about this full embrace of total and perpetual war by the rulers of the "indispensable nation" is that it comes absent any evidence of support from the American masses. The organs of the mainstream media -- The New York Times, CNN -- have been cranking out noise directly from Central Intelligence, day in and day out, for months -- no, years. To no avail. People do not want to go to war with Syria, and definitely not Russia, no matter how many times little Omran Daqneesh's bloody face is flashed.

Combine this with the onrushing election of a president who is likely the most unpopular -- the only other contenders that spring to mind are Nixon 1968 and John Quincy Adams 1824 -- and you have a recipe for a lot of instability. Because you know Hillary is a warhawk.

The system is so rancid and distended I don't see how it can be maintained. A correction is called for pronto. And that is the point of politics, to provide such a correction. Is the GOP civil war correction enough? I don't think so.

Electorally, the best that could be hoped for would be record low turnout and 5% for each third-party presidential candidate, giving Greens and Libertarians federal matching funds. Militarily, there needs to be a singular, exemplary defeat along the lines of the fall of Saigon. Maybe in Kabul, or possibly a messy civil war between U.S. proxies in Mosul following the rout of the Islamic State?

Thursday, October 22, 2015

Spy vs. Spy: The Kunduz Doctors Without Borders Hospital Info War

One week ago AP reporter Ken Dilanian broke a story, "US analysts knew Afghan site was hospital," which argued that the lethal attack on the Doctors Without Borders hospital in Kunduz was premeditated, not an accident, and that its purpose was to kill a Pakistani agent from the Directorate of Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI). The ISI operative was purportedly directing the Taliban assault on Kunduz from the Doctors Without Border hospital.

Dilanian has been busted in the past for being a spook conduit. So we have to interpret his "ISI agent using the Kunduz hospital as a command and control outpost" story as a "limited hangout."

The "newspaper of record" has studiously avoided the Dilanian story. Yesterday it published what is known in the propaganda industry as a  "modified limited hangout."

Eric Schmitt and Matthew Rosenberg never refer directly to Dilanian in "Hospital Attack Fueled by Units New to Kunduz." Instead they proffer the position that the hospital attack was due to the inexperience of Fort Lewis Special Forces troops who were new to the theater, as were their Afghan counterparts. In other words, the destruction of the hospital and the murder of civilians was all just a regrettable accident, just another sorrowful tale chalked up to the fog of war.

Towards the end of the Schmitt-Rosenberg piece the reader receives a dismissal of the Dilanian hypothesis:
Since the strike, a number of Afghan officials, including Masoom Stanekzai, the acting defense minister, have publicly claimed that the Taliban were fighting from the hospital, and that the insurgents were storing heavy weapons there. There has also been talk of operatives from Pakistan’s main spy agency, the Directorate of Inter-Services Intelligence, using the hospital as a base from which to help direct Taliban fighters in Kunduz.

But the Aghan security official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to avoid directly contradicting other officials, dismissed all those claims as “unfounded — there is no hard evidence.” 
The hospital had treated many wounded Taliban fighters over the years, and some may have been there at the time of the strike. But “they were not fighting right then,” the official said.
Eric Schmitt is the Gray Lady's numero uno conduit for spookery. So what we have here is spy vs. spy. Schmitt vs. Dilanian. The overall purposes is to sow confusion, to go from limited hangout to modified limited hangout in an attempt to obscure a shocking U.S. war crime.

Wednesday, October 14, 2015

Obama to Rescind U.S. Troop Pullout from Afghanistan: Perpetual War the Preferred Option of the Power Elite

A good story by Matthew Rosenberg, "Obama Is Rethinking Pullout in Afghanistan, Officials Say," which directly confirms Putin's observation about U.S. military planners having mush for brains, appears in today's paper. Obama, having announced at the end of last year the wholly fictitious end of U.S. combat operations in Afghanistan, is set to rescind the deadline of year-end 2016 for a complete withdrawal of U.S. troops:
But at the very least, those pushing for an expanded mission after 2017 would like to see the United States and its NATO allies maintain at least two or three bases from which drones could be flown and Special Operations Forces could readily strike at militants. The Central Intelligence Agency also wants a larger presence to help protect its assets in Afghanistan.
For now, the option that is being most seriously considered is a proposal made this past summer by Gen. Martin Dempsey, then the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, to keep 3,000 to 5,000 troops for the counterterrorism mission.
The officials said that the Pentagon had also presented other options that range from just an embassy force of about 1,000, which mainly protects American diplomats in Kabul, to maintaining the current force of roughly 9,800, which would also allow American forces to continue training and advising the Afghans.
***
Still, Mr. Obama and some of his closest advisers remain skeptical of the military’s ability to continue training and advising Afghan forces, other officials said. Building the Afghan Army and police was the main imperative of American-led coalition for much of the past five years, and it has cost the United States more than $65 billion since the war’s outset. Yet even with roughly 17,000 NATO troops still on the ground — including the 9,800 Americans — the Taliban still managed last month to take Kunduz, seizing a city for the first time since 2001.
Afghan forces struggled to retake Kunduz, despite American airstrikes clearing a path and American Special Operations forces at times joining the fight. The city appeared to be back in government hands on Tuesday for the first time in more than two weeks after the Taliban said they were pulling out in order to avoid, as they said in a statement, the “unnecessary waste of ammunition.”
The battle for Kunduz also laid bare the risks posed by air power when, on Oct. 3, an American strike was called in by Afghan troops. The air attack hit a hospital run by Doctors Without Borders, killing 22 patients and medical staff — and no insurgents.
The president is determined to avoid a repeat of the strike on the hospital, for which he personally apologized, and wants any mission after next year to be as narrow as possible, officials said.
Seemingly the entire U.S. national security establishment is circling the wagons around a robust military presence to train and assist the Afghan Armed Forces regardless of the price tag.
Beyond the military, though, a powerful cross-section of the American foreign policy and national security establishment is also pushing for as broad a military commitment in Afghanistan as possible. The latest salvo is a paper to be released on Wednesday by the Atlantic Council, a think tank, which bluntly declares: “U.S. and NATO force levels and presence around the country, as well as intelligence assets, should be maintained at or close to present levels.”
The main argument of the paper, which was written by James B. Cunningham, a former ambassador to Afghanistan, centers on the need to continue helping Afghan forces, and to give the next American administration as much flexibility as possible.
But the most striking element of the paper, which was provided to The New York Times ahead of its release, is the list of more than 20 former senior officials, Democrats and Republicans alike, who have signed on to it. The list includes Madeleine Albright, the former secretary of state who served under President Clinton; Stephen Hadley, who was national security adviser to President George W. Bush; two former defense secretaries,Chuck Hagel and Leon Panetta (who also ran the Central Intelligence Agency); and four former American ambassadors to Afghanistan. The paper’s two sponsors are Senators John McCain, Republican of Arizona, and Jack Reed, Democrat of Rhode Island.
After 14 years of war in Afghanistan, the list of American officials who have worked with the Afghans is long. And many have in the past year stepped forward to urge Mr. Obama to keep American troops in Afghanistan; in March, when President Ashraf Ghani of Afghanistan was in Washington, a group of 23 former ambassadors and senior officials made their point in an open letter to the president.
“Those of us who worked with the Afghans over the last decade or more feel that we’ve established a relationship that is of some enduring value,” said James Dobbins, the Obama administration’s former special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan and one of the signatories to the Atlantic Council paper.
He argued that Afghanistan may be the most democratic country in the Muslim world today, and that its government was unambiguously the most pro-American. But without American troops, he said, Afghanistan’s future is grim.ontinue reading the main story
“I can’t promise you that retaining a commitment at the current level will ultimately yield a completely peaceful settled and stable Afghanistan,” he said.
But leaving behind too few troop was lead to “an Afghanistan in complete turmoil.”
“You like Syria?” he said. “How would you like to have another one?”
Of course the United States helped create the chaos in Syria. No acknowledgement of that. Nor is there acknowledgement of the gist of a story by Rod Nordland and Joseph Goldstein, "Afghan Taliban’s Reach Is Widest Since 2001, U.N. Says," from a few days back:
The data, compiled in early September — even before the latest surge in violence in northern Afghanistan — showed that United Nations security officials had already rated the threat level in about half of the country’s administrative districts as either “high” or “extreme,” more than at any time since the American invasion ousted the Taliban in 2001.
That assessment, which has not been publicly released but is routinely shared by the United Nations with countries in the international coalition, appears at odds with the assessment of its American commander, Gen. John F. Campbell, in his testimony to Congress last week.
“The Afghan security forces have displayed courage and resilience,” General Campbell testified to the Senate Armed Services Committee on Tuesday. “They’re still holding. The Afghan government retains control of Kabul, of Highway One, its provincial capitals and nearly all of the district centers.”
Afghan officials in many districts currently under attack by the Taliban depict a significantly different situation. Even Highway One, a ring road connecting all of Afghanistan’s main cities, has long suffered repeated Taliban ambushes and roadblocks in southern Afghanistan; over the past two weeks the insurgents repeatedly cut the highway in the Doshi and Baghlani Jadid districts of Baghlan Province — long an uncontested government stronghold. Few government officials now use the highway along much of its route.
In many districts that are nominally under government control, like Musa Qala in Helmand Province and Charchino in Oruzgan Province, government forces hold only the government buildings in the district center and are under constant siege by the insurgents.
“We do not have any way to escape,” said Wali Dad, the police chief in Charchino, where 400 police officers have been surrounded and pinned down for months. “If we get any means of escaping, I will not stay for a second in the district. The government is failing in their governing, and it’s better to let the Taliban rule.”
General Campbell testified that the Afghan security forces had “reversed almost all of the Taliban gains in northern Helmand after a considerable effort.” He also said they had retaken Musa Qala and held on to other districts, like Sangin and Kajaki, that had been threatened in that area.
On Saturday, however, officials in Musa Qala said the government held only the district government compound, with no freedom of movement outside it because of Taliban threats. 
“Only the government can enter the district center, and there are no government activities outside the district center,” said Haji Mohammad Sharif, the district governor. 
The United Nations data suggests that the tempo of the insurgency has increased in many parts of the country where there had been little Taliban presence in the past, including some areas in the north with scant Pashtun populations. The Taliban have been a largely Pashtun-based insurgency and have been historically strongest in Pashtun-majority areas in southern and eastern Afghanistan, with some pockets in the north, such as Kunduz. 
"We have had fighting in 13 provinces of Afghanistan over the past six months, simultaneously,” President Ashraf Ghani said this month in response to criticism after the fall of Kunduz.
It is a compendium of failure that begs for a policy reversal. Since Obama has already gone the surge route, the logical next step would be to sit down to the bargaining table and hammer out a transition. But we know that won't happen, not only because of the national security elite singing in one voice calling for an indefinite commitment, but also because of the (re)appearance of specific propaganda favorites.

For instance, the old chestnut by Alissa Rubin, "Taliban Waged a Calculated Campaign Against Women in Kunduz"; as if the United States cared anything about the rights of women. This is the same U.S. military that condones sexual slavery as practiced by its mercenary Afghan militia allies.

Another propaganda favorite justifying indefinite, unilateral U.S. military force projection is the image of ISIS on the march, gobbling up and despoiling turf. Mujib Mashal delivers such a report with "Afghan ISIS Branch Makes Inroads in Battle Against Taliban."

The failed occupation will continue. More districts will fall to Taliban. The U.S. and its Afghan puppet government will maintain a cosmetic presence in the district centers. Gradually Kabul will be encircled. But the U.S. elites will have their drones bases and possibly an expanded CIA program for mayhem and murder. The Carter Doctrine can be maintained, I suppose the Beltway thinking goes, as long as you have a sharp stick to stir up the hornet nest.

There is also a pacifying spillover in the homeland. Ever since 9/11 we sing "God Bless America" during the seventh-inning stretch. Back then, we invaded Afghanistan instead of uprooting Al Qaeda's backers in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Now, almost 15-years later, we're still in Afghanistan, still losing hearts and minds, and the Saudis have expanded their jihadist terrorism, aided by the CIA, cracking apart the Sykes-Picot Middle East. The U.S. homeland is more militarized than at any time since the Vietnam War.

Then it took Congress to defund the Vietnam War to shut it down. The same thing is going to have to happen now in Afghanistan. The problem is that we are far less democratic a nation than we were 40 years ago. Congress is completely captive to wealth. Both political parties have nothing to do with the interests of ordinary voters. It is going to take a collapse of the system, a crackup, a revolution to get us back on the right path.

Monday, March 16, 2015

Fourth Anniversary of War in Syria + CIA Funds Al Qaeda

A number of interesting stories appeared over the weekend that reaffirm the idea that the future is one of perpetual war.

First, there was Ben Hubbard's marking of the four-year anniversary of the war in Syria, "An Ever-Bleaker Syria, From All Vantage Points":
. . . [O]ne of the starkest indications of what four years of conflict have done to Syria came from space, with new satellite images showing that mass destruction and displacement have extinguished more than four-fifths of the country’s lights, according to an analysis by Xi Li of Wuhan University in China and the University of Maryland at College Park. 
The Syria conflict began four years ago this week with protests calling for political reforms inspired by the Arab Spring uprisings elsewhere in the Middle East.
Since then, it has repeatedly metastasized: President Bashar al-Assad unleashed soldiers and thugs to quell the unrest; the opposition spawned armed rebel groups; foreign powers poured in military aid; and the resulting violence spread chaos in increasingly large expanses of territory, allowing extremist groups to establish footholds and increase their power.
Syria enters its fifth year of conflict with few signs that the war will end soon. International efforts to bring the warring parties together for peace talks have fallen dormant, and the United Nations envoy, Staffan de Mistura, has made little progress on even his modest goal of a short-term cease-fire in only one of Syria’s many battleground cities. 
Instead, international attention has shifted to military action against the extremists of the Islamic State, who control parts of Syria and Iraq and have shocked the world by beheading their foes and demolishing historical sites.
You'll notice that Hubbard never directly mentions the United States as a "foreign power" that fanned the conflict in Syria (which used to be uniformly referred to as a "civil war," but an undeniable influx of jihadis from abroad, an influx aided by the Gulf monarchies, Turkey, the U.S. and U.K., made that designation impossible even for the purveyors of crass propaganda).

The U.S. role has not gone unmentioned in the "newspaper of record." The CIA runs covert operations in both Jordan and Turkey to rid Syria of its Baathist government. This has been reported by the Gray Lady in the past, as has the U.S. high-tech weapons transfers to the "good" Syrian rebels which always manage to find their way to the "bad" jihadis (for a helpful roundup of evidence of an Islamic State-U.S. linkage, see Tim Anderson's "The Relationship between Washington and ISIS: The Evidence.")

Now that we are at the fourth anniversary of the cracking of Syria, to get a sense of the U.S. role in that cracking, we should all again read Seymour Hersh's "The Red Line and the Rat Line," something to keep in mind as Hubbard ticks off the toll of Syria's destruction:
Aid organizations say that the rise of the Islamic State, also known as ISISor ISIL, has not only inflicted deprivation and violence on the communities it conquers, but has also siphoned international attention from a growing humanitarian crisis that is echoing increasingly far from Syria’s borders. Last year, for example, brought a record high for illegal migration across the Mediterranean to Europe. Many of those taking the often-lethal trips were Syrian.
Humanitarian organizations issued a barrage of reports for the anniversary of the war’s beginning that quantify how hard life has become for Syrians.
About half of the country’s prewar population has fled from home, according to the United Nations, and nearly four million people have become refugees abroad, putting large burdens on neighboring countries like Turkey, Jordan and Lebanon.
A report by the Syrian Center for Policy Research said that education was in a “state of collapse”; that 6 percent of Syrians had been killed or wounded; and that life expectancy had dropped by 20 years since 2010.
“The numbers are staggering,” said Valerie Amos, the departing emergency relief coordinator for the United Nations. “They are so staggering that they have become almost meaningless to people.” 
For Syrian civilians in the country, the war has meant a downward spiral of death, uncertainty, poverty and displacement.
***
Hopes that the situation would improve rose briefly a year ago when the United Nations Security Council passed its first resolution on Syria, calling for free access to humanitarian aid. Another resolution authorized aid shipments across borders not controlled by the Syrian government.
But last week, a coalition of 21 aid groups released a harsh report saying that the resolutions had failed to make much difference.
“There is more death, more displacement, an increase in restrictions by neighboring countries and a more desperate situation for the refugees and for those displaced inside Syria,” said Daniel Gorevan, who handles Syria policy for Oxfam, one of the groups that participated in the report.
In countries bordering Syria, the flood of refugees has put a heavy burden on economies and budgets. In Lebanon, where about one in five residents is a refugee, some communities have been transformed by the human tide.
There you have it. Another Palestinian-like diaspora in the Middle East, with all misery and conflict that entails for the future.

One wonders why if the U.S. accepted the rehabilitation in Egypt of the old guard Mubarak forces in a bloody display of despotic force, peace can't made with Assad. But judging from the State Department's quick walk back of Kerry's statement that peace can be negotiated with Assad, "Kerry Suggests There Is a Place for Assad in Syria Talks," the war in Syria will grind on until there is some sort of region-wide collapse. Why? Because U.S. policy answers to the Saudis and Israelis, and this is the way they want it.

The Obama administration is slowing its troop withdrawal schedule in Afghanistan. This story appeared the same day as The New York Times spotlighted Matthew Rosenberg's bombshell, "C.I.A. Cash Ended Up in Coffers of Al Qaeda," which is actually a follow up to a story he wrote nearly two-years ago about the slush fund the Central Intelligence Agency set up for then president Hamid Karzai. That was the fund tapped to pay Al Qaeda ransom money for a Afghan diplomat, Abdul Khaliq Farahi, son-in-law to a powerful advisor of Karzai.

As Rosenberg reports, the CIA's slush fund practices continue under current president Ashraf Ghani:
The cash flow has slowed since a new president, Ashraf Ghani, assumed office in September, Afghan officials said, refusing to elaborate. But they added that cash was still coming in, and that it was not clear how robust any current American constraints on it are. 
“It’s cash,” said a former Afghan security official. “Once it’s at the palace, they can’t do a thing about how it gets spent.”
This how the "Great Game" works. It is money for war, and it is war all the time.

Friday, February 13, 2015

The Greek Austerity Face Off + Globalized Afghanistan + Cracking Yemen -- This is World War IV

A quick rundown this Friday morning of some critical storylines heading into the weekend. 

First, the state of play between Greece, representing the forces of humanity, versus the eurozone, representing the forces of austerity in defense of an exhausted neoliberal paradigm which worships Mammon, or as Naked Capitalism's Yves Smith says, "Mr. Market."

After arriving at impasse on Wednesday, the parties are reported to resume technical negotiations today. Landon Thomas Jr. and Jack Ewing have a good DealBook piece, "Greek Debt Standoff Awaits a Decisive Move," that forecasts a Cyprus-like conclusion to the showdown: capital controls to keep Greek banks from collapsing, but creating a two-tiered euro, with the Syriza-led government eventually kneeling before Mammon and accepting the austerity diktats.
A growing number of analysts think that Mr. Schäuble, Mr. Dijsselbloem and Mr. Draghi are advancing a combined strategy that aims to wait Greece out.
The thinking goes like this. Say “no” politely, but repeatedly, to Greece’s request for a financial rescue package. As conditions deteriorate, cut off access to emergency loans for the bank’s troubled financial institutions.
If that happens, Greece would have to impose capital controls to help prop up the banks, leading to economic disarray and prompting a public outcry. The Greek government would then be forced to accommodate Europe.
“Game theory only works if the other side wants to keep playing with you,” said Adam Lerrick, a sovereign debt expert.
Under this theory, Greece does not leave the euro, Mr. Lerrick said. A majority of Greeks reject such an outcome.
Instead, the country becomes quarantined within Europe, with Greeks prohibited from removing large sums from banks and sending cash abroad. Such was the case with Cyprus in 2013.
Confidantes of Mr. Varoufakis say that, all along, he has been wary of such an approach — which is why he is pushing so hard for a €10 billion lifeline. With the money comes breathing room to put his government’s plan to work. “Time is our most precious commodity,” he has said repeatedly.
But why not capital controls and default? Why don't Thomas and Ewing game out this scenario? It seems to me that if Greece gets as far as Cyprus in placing limits on banking then why not go whole hog and default? The pressure will then be on Germany and other proponents of hardball within the eurozone as Mr. Market freaks out.

This morning Yves Smith is hedging her bets. In "Fog of Negotiations: Greece and Germany Make Friendlier Noises, Restart Talks, But Press Reports Diverge," she pulls back from her default forecast of yesterday. She has a colleague who is well versed in the German press, and this colleague, normally pessimistic, is telling her that the chances of a forthcoming deal are good -- 60/40 or even 65/35. So the normally cynical Smith is basically punting for the time being.

Next, let's go to Afghanistan where a big story ("U.S. Is Escalating a Secretive War in Afghanistan: Data From Seized Computer Fuels a Surge in U.S. Raids on Al Qaeda," by Matthew Rosenberg and Eric Schmitt) provides a look at what U.S. war-making is going to be in the next decade regardless of the outcome of the vote on Obama's Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF) against Islamic State. Despite the announcement of the end of combat operations in Afghanistan at the end of last year, nighttime raids conducted by coalition Special Operations forces with their Afghan counterparts against Taliban and Al Qaeda targets are going gangbusters; drone strikes too:
The spike in raids is at odds with policy declarations in Washington, where the Obama administration has deemed the American role in the war essentially over. But the increase reflects the reality in Afghanistan, where fierce fighting in the past year killed record numbers of Afghan soldiers, police officers and civilians.
American and Afghan officials, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were discussing operations that are largely classified, said that American forces were playing direct combat roles in many of the raids and were not simply going along as advisers.
“We’ve been clear that counterterrorism operations remain a part of our mission in Afghanistan,” Rear Adm. John Kirby, the Pentagon press secretary, said on Thursday. “We’ve also been clear that we will conduct these operations in partnership with the Afghans to eliminate threats to our forces, our partners and our interests.”
The raids appear to have targeted a broad cross section of Islamist militants. They have hit both Qaeda and Taliban operatives, going beyond the narrow counterterrorism mission that Obama administration officials had said would continue after the formal end of American-led combat operations last December.
The tempo of operations is “unprecedented for this time of year” — that is, the traditional winter lull in fighting, an American military official said. No official would provide exact figures, because the data is classified. The Afghan and American governments have also sought to keep quiet the surge in night raids to avoid political fallout in both countries.
“It’s all in the shadows now,” said a former Afghan security official who informally advises his former colleagues. “The official war for the Americans — the part of the war that you could go see — that’s over. It’s only the secret war that’s still going. But it’s going hard.”
Criticisms of Obama's new AUMF center around its non-repeal of the super-broad "Al Qaeda and associates" 9/11 AUMF and its lack of any geographic boundaries. The ISIS AUMF does sunset in three years, but without the repeal of the 9/11 AUMF what it effectively does is globalize Afghanistan. A precedent is going to be established for super-stealthy Special Operations units -- "Afghan and American officials said the raids over the past few months had been carried out by the elite commandos of the National Directorate of Security, Afghanistan’s main spy agency, and members of a mix of American military Special Operations units, such as Navy SEALs and Army Rangers, and paramilitary officers from the C.I.A." -- a Schutzstaffel to terrorize the planet. This has been the fantasy of war planners all along.

Finally -- quickly -- Yemen is being cracked, like Libya, with the blessing of the United States, which led the rush of Western embassies out of the country the other day despite ongoing negotiations, brokered by the United Nations, between the Houthis and other parties to form a new government. Rod Nordland, who usually toes the State Department line but also finds a way to slip a paragraph or two into his stories that give the reader an idea what is really going on, writes, along with Shuaib Almosawa, in "In Yemen, Militants Are Increasingly Isolated" that
Many saw the move as intended to pressure Yemen’s power brokers to come to an agreement. Although the embassies cited security concerns as the reason behind the closings, they came amid relative calm in Sana, the capital, even on the anniversary of its Arab Spring revolution, with peaceful pro- and anti-Houthi demonstrations.

The British and American embassies in Sana were closed Wednesday, with the last diplomats from both embassies withdrawn. The German Embassy was also closed, a security official said, although its diplomats had not yet left. France urged all its citizens in Yemen to leave and said that the embassy would close Friday.
Nordland, working again with Shuaib Almosawa, reported yesterday that Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) captured the "Yemeni National Army’s 19th Brigade after heavy fighting at its headquarters in the Baihan District of Shabwa Province, an important oil-producing area in southeastern Yemen."

This is all about the Saudis who are unwilling to have the Houthis formalize their control of Yemen. Now, instead, we will get yet another cracked state with a civil war raging. This is what the U.S./Saudi axis specializes in. We are going to have to start calling it what it is: World War IV.

Sunday, January 18, 2015

Afghanistan Supports Pakistani Taliban

Last we mentioned Afghanistan was in a Wednesday post. The People's Republic of China hosted the Afghan Taliban in Beijing (Edward Wong, "Exploring a New Role: Peacemaker in Afghanistan"). I take this as a sign of the current "all-bets-are-off" atmosphere in Kabul. The combat mission of the U.S. military is officially over. The Ghani-Abdullah amalgam government finally announced the heads of its ministries (Joseph Goldstein, "Strains Show as Afghan Leaders Announce Long-Awaited Cabinet Nominees").

But what caught my eye was yesterday's story by Matthew Rosenberg, "Afghan Spy Chief Defies Labels, Usefully," and the admission in the august pages of The New York Times that the Afghan CIA, the National Directorate of Security, runs the Pakistani Taliban
Among [spy chief, Rahmatullah Nabil's] first tasks was resuming a sensitive project he had begun during his first turn at the N.D.S.: turning the No. 2 official in the Pakistani Taliban, Latif Mehsud, into a source — and possibly a proxy to be used against Pakistan.
Mr. Nabil said Mr. Mehsud had been cultivated primarily as a source of intelligence. But the Afghans also wanted “to send a message to Pakistan that if they can do this, we also can do it.”
No matter what it was, American officials were furious about the relationship when they discovered it in September 2013. They dispatched a Special Operations team to seize Mr. Mehsud from an N.D.S. convoy that was carrying him to Kabul last year. He was held by American forces until December, when he was turned over to the Pakistani authorities.
If Mr. Nabil is still angry about having his prize asset pried away at gunpoint, he betrayed no hint of it during the interview. And though he would not explicitly confirm that the N.D.S. had continued to develop other militant contacts, he strongly suggested that was the case.
For his part, Mr. Nabil said that the Americans “came to me, and I said that just like any other intelligence agency, we have the right to have sources.”
He added, “I think it is very important just to be very frank.”
Pakistan's Directorate for Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) manages the Afghan Taliban; Afghanistan's National Directorate for Security maintains a close relationship with the Pakistani Taliban. The whole thing is a toxic swamp of death and destruction which will remain as long as the states of Pakistan and Afghanistan remain. The same can be said about the United States.

Tuesday, August 19, 2014

Coup Coming Shortly to Afghanistan + Europe Grows Tired of Kiev + Intifada in St. Louis County Continues

A particularly good story today from Matthew Rosenberg, "Amid Election Impasse, Calls in Afghanistan for an Interim Government," reminding us once again what poor prospects there are for peace and stability. Currently a whispering campaign is underway for an interim government, a.k.a., a putsch, to rule the country in absence of any hope that the Abdullah-Ghani recount will ever be concluded or unity government of the two candidates agreed upon:
That official and others interviewed in recent days spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were discussing plans that could be considered seditious. The fact that they discussed the plans in advance suggests that they are using the threat of a coup to achieve political ends, not simply plotting in secret to execute one. 
The officials said they believed they would have the backing of Afghanistan’s army, police and intelligence corps. Though no concrete plans are in place, several officials said a committee would most likely be formed to run Afghanistan and that representatives of Mr. Abdullah and Mr. Ghani would be asked to join. Both candidates have dismissed the idea of an interim government. 
Many Afghans are liable to view any step to an interim government as a power grab by the men who surrounded Mr. Karzai for the last 12 years who may be seeking an excuse to preserve their power.
The United States and European countries are loath to see Afghan officials make an end-run around Afghanistan’s Constitution, which would call into question the lives lost and billions spent by the West in Afghanistan. Yet, in the two months since the runoff, the Abdullah and Ghani campaigns have proved unable or unwilling to compromise.
At the same time, talks on creating a national unity government, which the candidates agreed to as part of an American-brokered deal to end the crisis, have made limited progress. A special audit of all 8.1 million votes under the supervision of the United Nations agreed to as part of the same deal has been mired by arguments over what constitutes a fraudulent vote.
Along with the threat of violence, the political fight has brought Afghanistan’s ethnic divides back to the surface, pitting the smaller Tajik and Hazara communities against the dominant Pashtuns. The economy is suffering as well. Two Afghan officials warned that the government would soon be unable to pay its civil servants because revenue from taxes and customs were down by nearly a third this year.
The primary motivation for a coup/interim government appears to be the signing of the stalled bilateral security agreement (BSA) with the United States. The Taliban is gaining ground, and the U.S. needs an agreement in place by the middle of next month in order to keep troops in country; otherwise, like the Russians did in 1989, the superpower promises to exit completely by the end of the year:
Signs of fraying within the Karzai government have already begun to emerge. With Taliban military advances threatening entire districts, for instance, some Afghan officials are now deploying army and police units and seeking help from the American-led military coalition in defiance of Mr. Karzai, who has tried to limit when and where foreign and Afghan forces can operate. 
A new government is needed soon if there is to be any chance of securing deals to keep American and European troops here after the end of the year, some Afghan officials said. They said it would be better to start laying the groundwork to justify an interim government now in case Mr. Abdullah and Mr. Ghani cannot not find a solution.
Talk about plans for an interim government intensified after some of Mr. Abdullah’s most powerful backers — men who command well-armed militias — came within days of trying to seize power and declare their candidate the president after the release of preliminary results that gave Mr. Ghani a wide lead.
Three senior Afghan officials said they needed a government in place by mid-September to ensure security agreements needed to keep some United States and NATO forces in Afghanistan beyond the end of the year. They said a new presidential election could most likely be held next year, probably at the same time Afghanistan will elect a new parliament, which would help keep costs under control.
Karzai's refusal to sign a BSA, along with his wariness to engage Taliban advances, leads one to believe he is probably operating according to an understanding with the Taliban's sponsors in the Gulf, Qatar and Saudi Arabia. The caliphate, though suffering some setbacks recently, could one day span Asia from the Mediterranean to the Pacific.

Turning to Eurasia, Angela Merkel has announced her first visit to Kiev since the February coup. Billed as a peace mission -- maybe, though I can point to no evidence, Merkel now realizes that left to its own proclivities the junta will indeed create a failed state (is there any doubt at this point?) on the eastern edge of Europe, a Kosovo on steroids that just happens to be where a significant amount of the fuel that powers Germany's economy transits -- anyhow, billed as a peace mission, possibly that is the reason the junta is blaming the rebels for the atrocity of blowing up a caravan of refugees.

Something is happening here -- what with the Russian aid convoy stilled stalled at the border, foreign ministers negotiating in Berlin, the Western prestige press going over the top with its front-loading of specious junta claims -- the destruction of Russian APCs that crossed the border into the Ukraine, the Ukie military capturing downtown Luhansk, and now the rebels, conjuring up images of MH17, knowingly slaughtered refugees -- but what it is ain't exactly clear. The junta appears to be throwing up as much dust, generating as much noise as possible.

It could be this: Europe has grown tired. The show cannot go on. A deal must be secured that grants the Donbass substantial autonomy within a federalized Ukraine. In other words, the deal Russia originally proposed last winter.

Quickly, a few words on the uprising in St. Louis County. Missouri Governor Jay Nixon's mustering of the National Guard did not the cow the protesters who took to the streets again last night. Monica Davey, John Eligon and Alan Blinder report in "National Guard Troops Fail to Quell Unrest in Ferguson":
As darkness set in along West Florissant Avenue, one of the city’s main thoroughfares and a center of the weeklong protests, demonstrators were required to keep moving. 
After more than an hour of peaceful protests, some in the crowd began to throw bottles at the police, who brought out armored vehicles and tactical units. But many peacekeepers in the crowd formed a human chain and got the agitators to back down.
At another point, as protesters gathered near a convenience store, some of them threw objects; the police responded with tear gas. 
And near midnight, the police began announcing over loudspeakers that people needed to leave the area or risk arrest after what the police said were repeated gunshots and a deteriorating situation. 
A few blocks away, at the police command post, National Guard members in Army fatigues, some with military police patches on their uniforms, stood ready but never entered the area where protesters were marching. State and local law enforcement authorities oversaw operations there. 
Residents seemed puzzled and frustrated by the continually changing approaches, suggesting that the moving set of rules only worsened longstanding tensions over policing and race in this town of 21,000. 
“It almost seems like they can’t decide what to do, and like law enforcement is fighting over who’s got the power,” said Antione Watson, 37, who stood near a middle-of-the-street memorial of candles and flowers for Mr. Brown, the 18-year-old killed on a winding block here. 
“First they do this, then there’s that, and now who can even tell what their plan is?” Mr. Watson said. “They can try all of this, but I don’t see an end to this until there are charges against the cop.”

Wednesday, August 6, 2014

No Hope for Negotiations in Cairo; No Hope for U.S. Mission in Afghanistan

The ceasefire in Arsal between the ISIS-led jihadis and Lebanese Army quickly broke down yesterday. Arsal is a Sunni town in the Bekaa Valley that is home to several refugee camps filled with people who have fled the war next door in Syria. Two of the refugee camps were reported to have been set ablaze by "indiscriminate artillery fire."

The ceasefire negotiations between Israel and Hamas are getting underway in Cairo. David Kirkpatrick has an interview, "A Part of Hamas Negotiates, and Another May Fight Again,"
with Hamas bigwig Mousa Abu Marzook that is worth reading if only to get a sense of the futility of these bargaining sessions. Israel and Egypt are operating in lockstep. Their position is adamant: No easing of the blockade unless Gaza is demilitarized. Abu Marzook is equally adamant: Hamas' military wing, the Qassam Brigades, will remain. Abu Marzook is going to try to sell the idea of political and military separation. On the one hand, the Palestinian Authority will return to Gaza to administer the territory as the political power; while on the other, the Qassam Brigades will act as a national guard:
[A]fter more than 1,600 Palestinian deaths in Gaza from the Israeli attacks over the last month, Mr. Abu Marzook said Tuesday that Hamas had won a victory just by surviving and argued that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel had failed to achieve any of his goals. Mr. Abu Marzook said Hamas had gained popularity, remained able to fire rockets at Israel, and could re-establish its network of tunnels under Gaza. 
For agreeing to the cease-fire, he argued that Hamas should receive relief from the blockade on its territory. “The Palestinians should gain something out of these battles,” he said. “They want the siege to end; they want all the gates to open.”
That is a nonstarter with Israel and Egypt while Hamas controls Gaza, but Mr. Abu Marzook said Hamas was prepared for the unified government to take over, including assuming responsibility in Gaza for security and the borders.
He acknowledged that some tensions remained. Hamas and the Palestinian Authority, controlled by Fatah, have parallel payrolls of employees to run Gaza. 
“Two people on one chair is very difficult,” Mr. Abu Marzook said. “Now it is our duty to resolve this problem and make a real unity Palestinian government.” 
But he brushed off past concerns within Hamas about the possibility that the loyal presidential guard of its chief rival, Fatah’s leader, Mahmoud Abbas, might take positions in Gaza.
I don't see Israel and Egypt coming anywhere near this. The Palestinian Authority (PA) is widely unpopular, while support for Hamas has grown significantly since Israel's invasion. Abbas is a joke. PA rule in Gaza would be cosmetic. The real power would be Hamas, something Israel and Egypt will not accept. In the past, the United States might have had enough leverage to get the deal Abu Marzak suggests done, but no longer. The U.S., it appears to me, is not calling the shots but rather tagging along. The Saudis are driving events in the Middle East. This means Hamas gets nothing. So we're looking at a situation where Hamas will have to accept a return to the status quo ante, the blockade, or it will have to start sending rockets into Israel again. Not a very palatable choice.

Matthew Rosenberg and Helene Cooper have a useful postmortem, "U.S. General Is Killed in Attack at Afghan Base; Others Injured," of the green-on-blue attack at the Marshal Fahim National Defense University in Kabul that killed U.S. Army Major General Harold Greene who "had been dispatched to Afghanistan to help the Afghan military address one of its most potentially debilitating weaknesses: an inability to manage soldiers and weaponry."

The story by Rosenberg and Cooper provides a reminder to anyone who is paying attention of why U.S. involvement in Afghanistan will end in failure. Any vestigial U.S. force that remains in the country, assuming that the deal Kerry struck for a recount and power-sharing government between the Ashraf Ghani and Abdullah Abdullah camps holds (and that is highly unlikely), will be there as a training force. But how can you train people if you hunkered down in your bases for fear of your life?
Yet the shooting was a blunt reminder that discipline and vetting remain a challenge, and rogue Afghan soldiers and policemen remain a threat, despite a sharp drop in insider attacks since 2012, when the violence peaked and dozens of coalition service members were killed by Afghan counterparts. 
With foreign troops having largely ceded their front-line role to Afghan forces in the past two years, training and advising Afghans is one of the few crucial roles still played here by the coalition. American soldiers largely stay out of the Taliban’s line of fire, but they must still maintain close contact with Afghan soldiers and policemen. Foreign forces have few options for protecting themselves, short of cutting off contact with the Afghans. 
But that would make the training mission impossible, as General Greene, 55, most likely knew.
*** 
The attack occurred around noon and sent shock waves through the coalition command and Afghanistan’s defense establishment, bringing nearly all other work to a halt. In the immediate aftermath, Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr., the commander of coalition forces, ordered all foreign advisers and trainers out of Afghan government ministries and back to their bases.

Tuesday, August 5, 2014

Sullied Israel Embraces Ceasefire + Emerging Zeitgeist Spotted in Afghanistan

A ceasefire went into effect in Gaza this morning. The IDF has announced its complete withdrawal from the territory. Now negotiations with Hamas will begin in Cairo. The ceasefire is to last for 72 hours. Steven Erlanger recites the numbers in "Cease-Fire in Gaza Begins as Israel Says It Pulls Troops":
Gaza officials say that 1,834 Palestinians have died in the conflict, most of them civilians. Israel says 64 of its soldiers and three civilians have been killed since fighting began on July 8. 
*** 
Lt. Col. Peter Lerner, the Israeli military spokesman, said that Israel had completed the destruction of “approximately 32 tunnels” built by Hamas into Israel, and that Israeli forces had killed “approximately 900 militants in combat.” He said that Israel had destroyed more than 3,000 rockets belonging to Hamas and its ally Islamic Jihad, that those groups had launched more than 3,300 rockets toward Israel, and that Israel believed they had remaining stocks of 3,000 rockets.
Erlanger opines that Hamas and Islamic Jihad were ready to call it quits. No evidence or analysis is provided other than "They accepted an Egyptian proposal little changed from one that they had rejected earlier in the conflict; an earlier American attempt at a similar cease-fire also broke down quickly." Given that Netanyahu's cabinet unanimously rejected the previous ceasefire, one could just as easily say that it was the Israelis who were ready to call it quits. International public opinion was overwhelming opposed to Israel's assault on Gaza and its attacks on UN sanctuaries. Israel had also succeeded in alienating its benefactor in the White House. Mark Landler has the sordid details in "U.S. Diplomacy on Gaza Has Little Sway on Israel":
When the State Department condemned Israel’s strike on a United Nations school in Gaza on Sunday, saying it was “appalled” by this “disgraceful” act, it gave full vent to what has been weeks of mounting American anger toward the Israeli government. 
The blunt, unsparing language — among the toughest diplomats recall ever being aimed at Israel — lays bare a frustrating reality for the Obama administration: the government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has largely dismissed diplomatic efforts by the United States to end the violence in Gaza, leaving American officials to seethe on the sidelines about what they regard as disrespectful treatment.
Even as Israel agreed to a new cease-fire with Hamas, raising hopes for an end to four weeks of bloodshed, its relationship with the United States has been bruised by repeated clashes, from the withering Israeli criticism of Secretary of State John Kerry’s peacemaking efforts to Mr. Netanyahu’s dressing down of the American ambassador to Israel.

“This is the most sustained period of antagonism in the relationship,” said Daniel C. Kurtzer, a former American ambassador to Israel who now teaches at Princeton. “I don’t know how the relationship recovers as long as you have this president and this prime minister.”
Landler then goes on to admit that the U.S.-Israel relationship is essentially unchanged:
The White House seems determined to tamp down the latest eruption in tensions. “The nature of our relationship is strong and unchanged,” the press secretary, Josh Earnest, told reporters on Monday, pointing to comments by Mr. Netanyahu over the weekend, in which he said, “I think the United States has been terrific.” 
The two statements are part of a recurring pattern for this administration: an angry outburst, followed by calmer words and the grudging recognition that little is going to change in the fundamental relationship between the United States and its closest ally in the Middle East.
Israel has the political establishment and media monopoly wired. That is a given. But I believe what hastened its withdrawal from Gaza along with an acceptance to begin negotiations in Cairo is that the disconnect between public opinion on the one hand and the captured media and political elite on the other was gaining too wide a purchase. As Robert Fisk pointed out last week, readers were in open rebellion against their newspapers' false-equivalence portrayal of the conflict. The slaughter of innocents, particularly those located in UN sanctuary schools, could not be papered over with crude and specious arguments about "terror tunnels" and human shields. And when the pro-Israel media monopoly attempted to do just that, it had the effect of confirming to a mainstream audience all that we on the "lunatic fringe" have been saying about Zionist domination of Western public discourse. Also, I would imagine, the BDS Movement, which I am sure Israel keeps a close eye on, received and is receiving a big boost.

No, the Zionist domination of public discourse was too much on display in this the latest orgy of war crimes inflicted on the people of Gaza; hence, the ceasefire. Now the pressure will be on the Palestinians to avoid the outcome that followed the last two Israeli assaults, after which the ceasefire held but so too did the blockade. Hamas will have to deliver; the blockade will have to end. Otherwise, Israel wins and the death of 1,800 Gazans will be just another episode of Israel "mowing the grass."

Ramzy Baroud, in article last week, "The War Netanyahu Cannot Possibly Win," thinks that at the very least the old leadership of the Palestinian Authority, represented by Mahmoud Abbas, will be swept away. As Baroud says, "[T]here is much more to Palestine than the whims of the aging Palestinian Authority ‘President’ Mahmoud Abbas and his Ramallah-based henchmen, or even Hamas’s regional calculations following the rise and fall of the ‘Arab Spring.’ " I hope so.

Before signing off this morning, Matthew Rosenberg and Harris Kakar are reporting, "Three NATO Officers Killed at Afghan Military Academy, Officials Say," a big green-on-blue attack at the Afghan National Army Officer Academy outside Kabul:
The Afghan official and a coalition official said that it appeared that the foreign casualties were high-ranking officers who were taking part in a meeting at the academy.
Lt. Gen. Afzal Aman, the director of operations at Afghanistan’s Defense Ministry, said that the academy’s commander, Brig. Gen. Ghulam Saki, was wounded in the shooting along with two other senior Afghan officers.
General Aman added that it was only American officers who were present during the shooting, but said that he could not provide any additional details because the entire academy was under lockdown and information remained scarce. 
The attacker was killed, the defense official said.
The Afghan Defense Ministry declined to comment, saying it was still investigating the incident. 
Sher Alam, an Afghan soldier guarding the entrance to the academy, located at Camp Qargha, said that senior Afghan and coalition officers had been meeting there on Tuesday, and that reports from inside the camp indicated that a number of the foreign officers were killed in the attack. He said that soon after the shooting, coalition helicopters landed inside the academy to evacuate the dead and wounded. 
Tuesday’s shooting was the first so-called insider attack in Afghanistan in months. Such attacks, in which Afghan troops open fire on unsuspecting coalition forces, at one point posed a serious challenge to the war effort, sowing distrust and threatening to upend the American-led training mission that is vital to the long-term strategy for keeping the Taliban at bay. 
Though the number of attacks has dropped sharply since 2012, when dozens occurred, they remain a persistent threat for coalition troops serving alongside Afghan forces.
As Afghanistan falls back under the sway of the Taliban and the U.S. moves towards its exit, I am going to try to keep a watch on events there. The Iranian Revolution and U.S. funding of the mujahidin in Afghanistan mark the entryway at the end of the 1970s to our current exhausted neoliberal paradigm. Events in both countries will reveal the way forward to the new Zeitgeist emerging.

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Despite Scare Headlines, Expect U.S. Troops in Afghanistan Post-2014

It is not easy to interpret what is going on in Afghanistan. President Hamid Karzai, the post-9/11 quisling of the West, has been engaged in a prolonged, nasty squabble with his paymasters. Just yesterday the New York Times published a frontpage blockbuster, "Karzai Arranged Secret Contacts With the Taliban," that was really more smoke than fire. All reporters Azam Ahmed and Matthew Rosenberg came up with is that Karzai had tentative, unproductive talks at the end of last year with the Taliban, and that no deal is currently on the table:
But other Afghan and Western officials said that the contacts had fizzled, and that whatever the Taliban may have intended at the outset, they no longer had any intention of negotiating with the Afghan government. They said that top Afghan officials had met with influential Taliban leaders in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, and in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, in recent weeks, and were told that any prospects of a peace deal were now gone.
But reading Ahmed and Rosenberg is fruitful in that it reminded me of something that I had already forgotten -- the United States itself was negotiating with the Taliban:
The only known genuine negotiating channel to those leaders [with connections to Mullah Omar] was developed by American and German diplomats, who spent roughly two years trying to open peace talks in Qatar. The diplomats repeatedly found themselves incurring the wrath of Mr. Karzai, who saw the effort as an attempt to circumvent him; he tried behind the scenes to undercut it. 
Then, when an American diplomatic push led to the opening of a Taliban office in Qatar, Mr. Karzai lashed out publicly at the United States. Afghan officials said that to them, the office looked far too much like the embassy of a government-in-exile, with its own flag and a nameplate reading “The Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan.” Within days, the Qatar initiative stalled, and Mr. Karzai was fuming at what he saw as a plot by the United States to cut its own deal with Pakistan and the Taliban without him. 
In the wake of the failure in Qatar, Afghan officials redoubled their efforts to open their own channel to Mullah Omar, and by late autumn, Mr. Karzai apparently believed those efforts were succeeding. Some senior Afghan officials say they did not share his confidence, and their doubts were shared by American officials in Kabul and Washington.
Something is happening here and what it is ain't exactly clear. As good a place as any to start, just in terms of the basics, is today's story by Peter Baker and Matthew Rosenberg, "Old Tensions Resurface in Debate Over U.S. Role in Post-2014 Afghanistan." Yesterday Obama met in the White House for a powwow on Afghanistan with his top military brass:
As part of his review, Mr. Obama met Tuesday with Gen. Martin E. Dempsey, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the general’s vice chairman, Adm. James A. Winnefeld Jr.; Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr., commander of American and allied forces in Afghanistan; Gen. Lloyd J. Austin III, the head of the United States Central Command; and Adm. William H. McRaven, head of the United States Special Operations Command.
Afghanistan will have a presidential election in April. What I don't understand about all the jockeying of Karzai by the Obama administration is why not wait to cut a deal with his successor? Probably because any successor to Karzai will be as tough or tougher when it comes to negotiating a bilateral security agreement (BSA) with the United States.

Right now there are some 55,500 Western troops in Afghanistan, 36,500 of which are American.

Post-2014, NATO is planning for a force of 8,000 to 12,000, made up of two-thirds Americans; the U.S. wants to keep a force of 10,000, with an additional 5,000 troops made up of foreign forces.

The United States wants a BSA that includes the usual status of forces agreement (SOFA) immunity guarantee as well as the right to continue its terror-inducing practice of raiding private residences. Karzai has flip-flopped on signing the BSA and threatened to bargain a deal solely with NATO. The U.S. military is allegedly pressuring Obama into an all or nothing posture, "Give us want we want, Karzai, or we will pull all our troops out of country."

As a sign that Uncle Sam is serious, Congress has already cut development aid to Afghanistan in half to $1.2 billion, with the remaining money threatened if Karzai goes ahead with the release of 37 suspected Taliban detainees.

We know that Karzai has plenty of leverage. Pakistan is a huge national security issue for the U.S. The CIA drone bases in Afghanistan are prized for their ability to project power into and eavesdrop on a nuclear-armed Pakistan that also harbors Al Qaeda and Taliban leadership.

Regardless of the U.S. tough talk of a "zero option," Obama is not about to give up those drone bases. Karzai knows this. He knows he can't lose, no matter how much he angers his bosses in Congress and the White House. He is playing with house money.

Despite all the distracting scare headlines, expect a deal to be brokered that keeps U.S. troops in Afghanistan post-2014. Those drones will continue to fly east to Pakistan.

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Islamists Dominate Rebels

Reuters has a story, "Syria's Islamists seize control as moderates dither," this morning which confirms the impression one gets from reading the daily news coming out of Syria. The rebels on the battlefield no longer include significant groupings of secularists fighting for political rights. Sunni fundamentalists fighting for a religious state dominate:
It's a pattern repeated elsewhere in the country. During a 10-day journey through rebel-held territory in Syria, Reuters journalists found that radical Islamist units are sidelining more moderate groups that do not share the Islamists' goal of establishing a supreme religious leadership in the country. 
The moderates, often underfunded, fragmented and chaotic, appear no match for Islamist units, which include fighters from organizations designated "terrorist" by the United States. 
The Islamist ascendancy has amplified the sectarian nature of the war between Sunni Muslim rebels and the Shi'ite supporters of Assad. It also presents a barrier to the original democratic aims of the revolt and calls into question whether the United States, which announced practical support for the rebels last week, can ensure supplies of weapons go only to groups friendly to the West.
World powers fear weapons could reach hardline Islamist groups that wish to create an Islamic mini-state within a crescent of rebel-held territory from the Mediterranean in the west to the desert border with Iraq.
That prospect is also alarming for many in Syria, from minority Christians, Alawites and Shi'ites to tolerant Sunni Muslims, who are concerned that this alliance would try to impose Taliban-style rule.
And speaking of the Taliban, though it was not addressed in this morning's substantial story, "Taliban Step Toward Afghan Peace Talks Is Hailed by U.S.," by Matthew Rosenberg and Alissa Rubin, my sense is this was a quid pro quo for the U.S. agreeing to arm the Syrian rebels. Qatar, where the Taliban reopened their political office yesterday, has been the Gulf Arab nation most active in its support of al-Assad's ouster.

The Obama administration knows that once Western military forces depart next year the Afghan government will collapse soon after. So some sort of agreement with the Taliban is essential not only to salvage a silver lining from the decade-plus occupation but also to maintain future viability of NATO out-of-area adventurism. To facilitate these negotiations, Obama is willing to provision the rebels with light arms.

It could be that Obama, cornered by his "red line" statement about the use of chemical weapons and hawks in his State Department, tried to make the most out of an atrocious situation by getting Qatar to muscle the Taliban to the table. Rosenberg and Rubin don't see much coming out of new talks. The Taliban are merely increasing their international profile as they prepare to take power.

Rounding out other Syria news, Russia got the best of the other G-8 nations. The final statement called for peaceful negotiations to begin as soon as possible, making no mention of al-Assad stepping down nor the alleged use of poison gas by the Syrian government. The Lebanese Army was sent to the port city of Sidon to quell gun battles between loyalists to Sunni cleric Sheik Ahmad al-Assir, who has called for jihad against al-Assad, and Hezbollah.

Friday, May 3, 2013

When the Money Disappears So Does Karzai

The work week began Monday with Matthew Rosenberg's frontpage story detailing the CIA's plying of Afghan quisling Hamid Karzai with countless bags of cash (at one point we were in competition with Iran) -- a practice stretching back to the foundation of the current state of Afghanistan. Warlords were paid to fight the Taliban. Rosenberg's story is not merely a revelation of corrupt practices; it provides insight into the very nature of our mission in Afghanistan, which now stands revealed as a sham. As soon as the money dries up Karzai's government will disappear (either that or become the proxy of another foreign power willing to foot the bill).

It's been interesting to gauge the reaction to this story, which as far as I can tell has been pretty close to zero. The New York Times followed up Rosenberg's frontpage story Monday with a reaction piece -- Karzai in Finland thanking the U.S. for the money -- the next day also written by Rosenberg. Wednesday the Times published an unsigned editorial asking Congress to demand an explanation from the CIA. Mark Steel had a story, "Look on the bright side: There’s a roaring heroin trade in Afghanistan, and it's all thanks to us," in yesterday's Independent. And that's about it. (Kevin Mahken has a short piece in the New Republic pointing out that this is the way things have been done throughout history.)

Today the New York Times under a "Cash for Karzai: A C.I.A. Caper" header publishes several good letters, one of which is from a former Foreign Service officer:
Your report is old news, albeit dramatic and in flagrante delicto. 
As a Foreign Service officer for three decades, I observed up close the contradiction between C.I.A. officers, usually under embassy cover, paying cash for access and secrets while the rest of us did it by charm alone. 
It was particularly disheartening in post-independence Africa of the 1960s, when idealism still prevailed and the Agency for International Development was charged with building democracy while the Central Intelligence Agency rushed to outbid the French, the Russians and others to corrupt new and vulnerable African leaders. 
Today, we have the demeaning spectacle of agency bag men vying with the Iranians to bestow briefcases bulging with cash on the notably corrupt Afghan president, Hamid Karzai. 
This is occurring while American servicemen and women are still fighting and dying in Afghanistan, and while we still have the temerity to talk about bringing democracy to that benighted land. 
RICHARD L. JACKSON
Wellington, Fla., April 29, 2013
Our imperial project in Afghanistan is irredeemable. Let's hope that this is so widely acknowledged that the scheduled troop withdrawal proceeds according to plan.

Wednesday, May 1, 2013

We're in a Dismal Place

The old stars of the New York Times Op-Ed page have decent columns today. Maureen Dowd accurately assesses the current state of our national politics in "Bottoms Up, Lame Duck":
During the 2012 campaign, the president and his top advisers liked to make the argument that if he was re-elected, the “fever” would break. Washington would no longer be the graveyard of progress, the crypt of consensus. Once dystopian Republicans accepted that Obama was not running again, they would start cooperating with him. 
But it’s beginning to sink in that the opposite may be true.
We're in a dismal place. I began this blog at the end of last November with the question, Do elections matter? The answer by now, five months later, is they obviously do not.

Thomas Friedman, that tireless booster of technology and capitalism, describes in "It's a 401(k) World" the Hell Realm we occupy today thanks to technology and capitalism. It's a brutal, super-fast, hyperconnected, survival-of-the-fittest, technologically-sophisticated world:
When I say that “everyone has to pass the bar now,” I mean that, as the world got hyperconnected, all these things happened at once: Jobs started changing much faster, requiring more skill with each iteration. Schools could not keep up with the competencies needed for these jobs, so employers got frustrated because, in a hyperconnected world, they did not have the time or money to spend on extensive training. So more employers are demanding that students prove their competencies for a specific job by obtaining not only college degrees but by passing “certification” exams that measure specific skills — the way lawyers have to pass the bar. Last week, The Economist quoted one labor expert, Peter Cappelli of the Wharton business school, as saying that companies now regard filling a job as being “like buying a spare part: you expect it to fit.”
This is the world that Friedman has been championing for over a decade. But I don't think he anticipated the extent of its destructiveness. He of course always celebrated capitalism's "creative destruction" in theory. But now that we're living through it, I think it's dawning on him that it's not going to end well. Whether we hear this from Friedman in one of his columns is doubtful.

There is an unsigned editorial today, "'Ghost Money,' and Lots of It," in which the New York Times asks Congress to "publicly call the C.I.A. to account" for delivering bags of cash to Afghan President Hamid Karzai:
There are many reasons to be outraged. Not the least of these is that the payments helped fuel corruption just when other agencies, including the White House and State Department, were pressing the Afghans to crack down on corruption and prosecute those responsible. American leaders have argued again and again that Afghanistan’s success, and America’s success in Afghanistan, including its ability to withdraw troops by the end of 2014, depended on a government in Kabul that could win the hearts and minds of its people and competently deliver services. A government riddled with corruption had little if any chance of achieving these objectives. 
Meanwhile, there are signs that Mr. Karzai will use state machinery to ensure the election next year of a handpicked successor, which would further discourage Afghans who had hoped that years of war would yield not just stability but some semblance of participatory democracy. Yet, as Mr. Karzai has shown many times, neither the C.I.A.’s millions nor the Pentagon’s billions, devoted to building his army and trying to keep his country safe, can buy more than minimal and erratic cooperation. 
The United States and other donors have warned the Afghans that continued international assistance — which the country is expected to need for years to come — will be conditioned on concrete steps to curb corruption. Now that the C.I.A. payments have been exposed, it will be harder to make that argument.

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

CIA Attempts Old-Fashioned Party Building in Afghanistan

Matthew Rosenberg follows up his story from yesterday about the CIA leaving bags of cash at the Afghan presidential palace with a confirmation today by Hamid Karzai, "Afghan Leader Confirms Cash Deliveries by C.I.A.":
The C.I.A. money continues to flow, Mr. Karzai said Monday. “Yes, the office of national security has been receiving support from the United States for the past 10 years,” he told reporters in response to a question. “Not a big amount. A small amount, which has been used for various purposes.” He said the money was paid monthly. 
Afghan officials who described the payments before Monday’s comments from Mr. Karzai said the cash from the C.I.A. was basically used as a slush fund, similarly to the way the Iranian money was. Some went to pay supporters; some went to cover other expenses that officials would prefer to keep off the books, like secret diplomatic trips, officials have said. 
After Mr. Karzai’s statement on Monday, the presidential palace in Kabul said in a statement that the C.I.A. cash “has been used for different purposes, such as in operations, assisting wounded Afghan soldiers and paying rent.” The statement continued, “The assistance has been very useful, and we are thankful to them for it.” 
The C.I.A. payments open a window to an element of the war that has often gone unnoticed: the agency’s use of cash to clandestinely buy the loyalty of Afghans. The agency paid powerful warlords to fight against the Taliban during the 2001 invasion. It then continued paying Afghans to keep battling the Taliban and help track down the remnants of Al Qaeda. Mr. Karzai’s brother Ahmed Wali, who was assassinated in 2011, was among those paid by the agency, for instance. 
But the cash deliveries to Mr. Karzai’s office are of a different magnitude with a far wider impact, helping the palace finance the vast patronage networks that Mr. Karzai has used to build his power base. The payments appear to run directly counter to American efforts to clean up endemic corruption and encourage the Afghan government to be more responsive to the needs of its constituents.
It's clear what the CIA was/is trying to do. Politics is the art of the quid pro quo. And the ultimate quid pro quo medium is cash. As Jesse Unruh, the Speaker of the California State Assembly in the Golden State's heyday, famously said, "Money is the mother's milk of politics." The CIA was/is engaged in political formation, and the script it's following is fundamental; in this country we associate it with Tammany Hall.  And while "Tammany" might be a pejorative term, it is at root what politics is all about. It explains why 1% of the population controls politics in a democratic system of hundreds of millions of citizens. The 1% has most of the money.

Rosenberg can't resist taking a poke, in the story's final paragraph, at the claim that the CIA money was used to provide care for wounded soldiers:
Outside official circles, some Afghans offered a lighter take. “They make it sound as if it was a charity money dashed by a spy agency,” wrote Sayed Salahuddin, an Afghan journalist, on Twitter, referring to the palace statement that money had been used to help wounded soldiers. “They must have ‘treated’ many people.”