Showing posts with label labor unions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label labor unions. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 1, 2016

Labor Wins Verizon Strike + Slaves vs. Robots?

Verizon workers who have been out on strike since April are going back to work today. From what I can tell they won big.

Verizon has a growing wireless business with a shrinking number of landline customers. The wireless side of the business is non-union and highly profitable; the wireline side -- landlines, video and Internet -- is union and not as profitable. Verizon's wireline business also includes the high-speed fiber optic Fios network, which is well regarded and lucrative.

Noam Scheiber had an informative piece yesterday, "Verizon Strike to End as Both Sides Claim Victories on Key Points." The one area the company has tried to claim victory is in its newly-bargained ability to route calls away their state of origin. But the Communication Workers of America (CWA) counters that since the calls stay within the scope of a unionized workforce, it is no victory for Verizon at all:
Perhaps the most consequential issue at stake in the standoff was Verizon’s ability to outsource work. The previous contracts included a provision requiring that a certain percentage of customer calls originating in a state be answered by workers in that state — ranging from just over 50 percent for some types of calls in some states to more than 80 percent in others. Verizon sought to significantly lower those numbers.
Under the tentative new contracts, a similar percentage of calls must be answered by a unionized worker somewhere in Verizon’s wireline footprint, which runs from Virginia to Massachusetts, rather than the particular state from which the call originates.
Both sides claimed victory in the change.
“We only care that our members somewhere in the footprint are doing the work,” said Robert Master, assistant to the District 1 vice president of the Communications Workers of America. “The push to outsource call center work was rebuffed.”
Lending partial vindication to this claim was a commitment by the company to create over 1,000 unionized call center jobs over the next four years to accommodate new demand from customers. The company also agreed to reduce the number of call center closings.
CWA and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers protected their pensions, will receive an 11% pay increase over the four-year period of the collective bargaining agreement, and Verizon even agreed to allow unionization of the previously unorganized retail wireless workers:
The unions managed to beat back proposed pension cuts, including a cap on the accrual of pension benefits after 30 years of service. 
The company also agreed to withdraw a proposal that would have allowed it to relocate workers for up to two months anywhere in its geographic coverage area, although it had already expressed an openness to withdrawing the proposal before the strike. 
Proposals to change seniority rules and to make the company’s sickness and disability policy more strict were also withdrawn, and the company agreed to change a performance review program in New York City that many workers considered abusive. 
Significantly, the new contracts also cover some 65 unionized workers at Verizon Wireless stores, signaling the first time that retail wireless workers at the company have been included in a union contract, a potentially important precedent.
While the victory for Verizon workers is being hailed as potentially precedent setting for a unionized workforce that has been declared an anachronism, a report from Rachel Abrams, "Retailers Like H&M and Walmart Fall Short of Pledges to Overseas Workers," reminds us that working conditions akin to slavery are still a global norm.

Three years ago, following the collapse of Rana Plaza in Savar, Bangladesh and the deaths of 1,100 workers, multinational retail giants like GAP, Walmart and H&M were shamed into establishing pro-worker protocols with which their suppliers were supposed to adhere. Well, no surprise, it turns out these efforts have been underwhelming:
After more than 1,100 deaths exposed dangerous labor conditions in Bangladesh in 2013, brands like H&M, Walmart and Gap were among the most powerful companies that pledged to improve the safety of some of the country’s poorest workers.
But human rights groups say that three years later, those promises are still unfulfilled, and that safety, labor and other issues persist in Bangladesh and other countries where global retailers benefit from an inexpensive work force.
A series of new reports by the Asia Floor Wage Alliance, a coalition of trade unions and other research and advocacy groups, has put a new spotlight on the conditions. In Bangladesh, the group says, tens of thousands of workers sew garments in buildings without proper fire exits. In Indonesia, India and elsewhere, pregnant women are vulnerable to reduced wages and discrimination. In Cambodia, workers who protested for an extra $20 a month were shot and killed.
The brands say that in recent years they have aggressively pushed stronger labor protections and vastly increased their monitoring of the factories that make their products. They have also made significant structural and fire repairs at many factories in Bangladesh.
But even the retail groups say that more improvement is needed, a message underscored in the new reports. Worker advocates say that progress on improving conditions at the factories has been too slow, and that some of the world’s biggest companies continue to benefit from unfair and dangerous labor practices.
“There have been substantial safety renovations in factories that have unquestionably made those factories substantially safer,” Scott Nova, the executive director of the labor monitoring group Worker Rights Consortium, said of the work in Bangladesh. “At the same time, it’s also true that there have been unacceptable delays.”
On Tuesday, the Wage Alliance released its latest report, which accuses Walmart of benefiting from forced labor and other abusive practices in a number of Asian countries. In Cambodia, for instance, workers at factories who make products sold at the company are required to work 10 to 14 hours a day in sweltering heat, without access to clean drinking water or breaks — conditions that have contributed to “mass fainting episodes,” the report said.
As more work is automated, it is worthwhile to keep in mind that the robot will have a competitor in the slave. Maybe that will be a regular post for the future -- Slaves vs. Robots.

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

Which Side Are You On? Friedrichs Case Poised to Make Public Sector Unions Open Shop in All But Name

Adam Liptak in his story, "Supreme Court Seems Poised to Deal Unions a Major Setback," makes it sound as if open shop in everything but name is the likely outcome of the Supreme Court hearing the Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association case. At issue is whether union members who work in the public sector, a.k.a., government workers, have to pay "agency fees" or "representational fees" to their labor union or whether they can opt out entirely and choose instead to be what is called a "free rider," someone who enjoys all the benefits of union membership without paying any of its costs. (It has been a settled opinion for decades that public sector workers can opt out of paying that portion of their dues that goes directly to support political campaigns, but they cannot opt out of paying their union for representing them in collective bargaining, which is the lion's share of one's union dues.)
The best hope for a victory for the unions had rested with Justice Antonin Scalia, who has written and said things sympathetic to their position. But he was consistently hostile on Monday. 
”The problem is that everything that is collectively bargained with the government is within the political sphere, almost by definition,” he said.
The court’s four liberal members were on the defensive, asking whether there was good reason to overturn a 1977 decision by the court that allowed the fees.
“You start overruling things,” Justice Stephen G. Breyer said. “What happens to the country thinking of us as a kind of stability in a world that is tough because it changes a lot?”
Justice Elena Kagan focused on the practical consequences of a decision in favor of the challengers. 
“This is a case in which there are tens of thousands of contracts with these provisions,” she said. “Those contracts affect millions of employees, maybe as high as 10 million employees.”
Michael A. Carvin, the lawyer for the teachers, emphasized what he said was the limited nature of the case. It was not, he said, an attack on the union’s exclusive representation of all workers. A decision in his clients’ favor, he added, would not affect private employers, who are not subject to the First Amendment. 
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg asked whether workers “who paid these fees against their will” were entitled to refunds. 
Mr. Carvin answered that “all we’re asking is for prospective relief.”
The fact that so much attention was devoted to the aftermath of a decision favoring the challengers suggested that at least some members of the court viewed it as a foregone conclusion.
***
Limiting the power of public unions has long been a goal of conservative groups. Even before Monday’s argument, they had reason to be hopeful that their side would prevail in the case.
In 2014, the court stopped just short of overruling a foundational 1977 decision and declaring that government workers who choose not to join unions may not be forced to pay fees in lieu of dues.
In the 1977 decision, Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, the Supreme Court made a distinction between two kinds of compelled payments. Forcing nonmembers to pay for a union’s political activities violated the First Amendment, the court said. But it was constitutional, the court added, to require nonmembers to help pay for the union’s collective bargaining efforts to prevent freeloading and ensure “labor peace.”
Justice Kagan said the 2014 ruling, along with one from 2012, “admittedly expressed some frustration with Abood.” But that was not enough, she said, to justify overruling a 40-year-old precedent.
Mr. Carvin responded that the recent decisions had “undermined the doctrinal underpinnings of Abood.” He said the court had overruled important precedents in similar circumstances in 2010 in the Citizens United campaign finance decision.
And that is an appropriate analogy here -- Citizens United. Friedrichs will likely have an impact that is in the ballpark of the Supreme Court's post-2008-Obama-landslide decision to scrap existing campaign finance law. Fairly quickly, but certainly over time, the number of free riders will grow in public sector unions, diminishing their strength.

Conservatives like the Kochs -- who have provided some financial backing for the outfit, the Center for Individual Rights, that organized the Friedrichs lawsuit -- want to see public sector unions hamstrung because there is far greater union density in the public sector than in the private sector.

Public sector unions are the bedrock of unionism in the United States. Once they are bled out, the next step will to be go after after the large building trades internationals by repealing Davis-Bacon, the federal prevailing wage law. 

All this is happening against the backdrop of increasing income inequality and the post-Great Recession stagnation in wages. The last thing you want to do is weaken the unions. And that is exactly what the conservative majority on the Supreme Court has signaled it will do.

The upside to Friedrichs is that now more than ever it will force unions to engage in the kind of "Which Side are You On?" organizing that they have shied away from for generations. The problem, as can be seen by the number of large internationals, like SEIU, that have already endorsed Hillary, is that the leadership at the top remains conflicted, addicted as they are to big money and "the lesser of two evils," and that's why labor finds itself in its present diminished and endangered state. Hitching their wagon to Hillary, who appears to be headed for a defeat in Iowa, is just another tone deaf bad move.

Monday, June 15, 2015

Obama's TPP/Asia Pivot Waterloo + Organized Labor Proof of Life + Bad News for Saudis/ISIS + Greek Default and Peak Neoliberalism

There is quite a bit of good news this Monday morning. Dire assessments of Obama's "lame duckery" continue to roll in (Peter Baker, "The Trans-Pacific Partnership and a President’s Legacy") following Friday's failed vote in the House of Representative on trade-promotion authority (Jonathan Weisman, "House Rejects Trade Measure, Rebuffing Obama’s Dramatic Appeal"). Obama's Asia pivot is being declared DOA. This is from Baker's frontpage piece this morning:
The administration tried making a foreign policy argument over the last few weeks, maintaining that if the United States does not seal the trade pact, it will be leaving the field to China, which has been exerting its clout in recent years, whether by investing in energy supplies in Africa and the Middle East or by asserting claims over disputed waters and islands. 
But some on the left argue that the administration is using China to scare lawmakers and exaggerating the competition. “I just don’t buy this China boogeyman stuff,” said Jared Bernstein, a senior fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities and a former economic adviser to Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. “If anything, I see China as being more inward looking, devoting less resources to mercantile-type trade and more to internal investment, consumption and developing human capital.” 
Supporters of the trade pact hope to hold a new vote this week on the part of the trade package rejected by the House on Friday but will need to secure 90 more votes. Representative Paul D. Ryan, the Wisconsin Republican who has worked with the White House to secure trade negotiating authority, said on Sunday that if Mr. Obama wanted to avoid being a “very lame-duck president,” he would have to win over members of his own party. 
“I think that this can be salvaged because I think people are going to realize just how big the consequences are for American leadership,” Mr. Ryan said on “Fox News Sunday.” 
But there was little indication over the weekend that many minds had been changed on the political left. “We need to regroup and come up with a trade policy which demands that corporate America start investing in this country rather than in countries all over the world,” Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination, said on “Face the Nation” on CBS.
*** 
“There is no Asia pivot without an economic component, and that component is tied up in T.P.P.,” said Walter Lohman, director of the Asian studies program at the Heritage Foundation. The challenge for Mr. Obama, he added, is that no matter how important the trade pact may be to his foreign policy, Congress will consider it through an economic lens. “Geopolitics gets it very few votes.”
As I said, good news. Good news too that organized labor figured out how to do things properly on this one, both by working in concert with citizen groups and environmentalists, as well as playing hardball with two-faced Dems. This is from Noam Sheiber's weekend story, "Labor’s Might Seen in Failure of Trade Deal as Unions Allied to Thwart It":
Labor’s smartest move was lining up opposition to the president’s trade agenda as early as 2013, when the fight was still a distant prospect. “They did a good job getting out and defining T.P.A. early among Democratic House members, really peeling off an enormous number of folks who didn’t have long history or an understanding of the issue, prior to the White House engaging,” said Simon Rosenberg, president of the advocacy group NDN and a supporter of Mr. Obama’s effort. 
Mr. Rosenberg pointed in particular to a letter labor activists helped circulate late that year, which roughly 150 House Democrats signed. “It was a letter that was going to make it hard to vote for T.P.A. once you signed it,” Mr. Rosenberg said.
***

This time around, not only did the firefighters make a considerable investment — producing ads and paying to broadcast them in five congressional districts — but Mr. Schaitberger personally led the effort within the A.F.L-C.I.O. executive council to freeze all donations to members of Congress by the political action committees of the federation and affiliated unions until after the vote on trade promotion authority. (Mr. Schaitberger, who developed the motion, credits Mr. Trumka with helping create almost unanimous support for it.) 
Mr. Schaitberger acknowledged some apprehension within the labor movement about denying money even to longtime congressional allies, but he argued that it had been the most effective way to persuade friendly members of Congress to pressure wavering Democratic lawmakers. “We wanted to encourage those members to use their influence, their passion for our position, to move some of their colleagues,” he said.
A win for labor, a blow to the Asia pivot, why not add a story about workers at Gawker Media voting to join a union? Rachel Swarns reports in "At Gawker Media, New Economy Workers Strive to Form a New Kind of Union" that
. . . Last year, about 22 percent of recent college graduates were either working part time or unemployed, compared with about 15 percent in 2007, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco.
That may be one reason young adults view unions more favorably than other age groups. In March, a national survey of 1,500 adults conducted by the Pew Research Center found that 55 percent of those ages 18 to 29 view unions positively, while 29 percent view them unfavorably.
Overseas, peace talks on Yemen begin in Geneva today. The Houthis continue to roll up victories despite the Saudi-led terror bombing. The Kurdish fighters are battering Islamic State in northern Syria, threatening to capture the main ISIS supply route from Turkey to Raqqa. All good news.

Plus, we are now approaching the decisive moment in the Greek-troika debt negotiations. A default by Greece seems unavoidable. Yves Smith of Naked Capitalism is terming this "Peak Neoliberalism":
The resolution of the Greece/creditor deadlock may also mark Peak Neoliberalism. It’s possible, but only remotely so, that Greece and its creditor overlords will back off from their collision. But as we’ve said for years, Germany is wedded to incompatible goals, namely running large trade surpluses but not financing its trade partners. It is destined to burn them down if it fails to find a new course of action. Greece is also wedded to incompatible goals, namely getting a real break from austerity while staying in the Eurozone. 
On the current trajectory, Greece will suffer horribly under a default or Grexit. The creditors have the incentive and the means to make either one more painful than continued austerity so as to force Greek citizens to capitulate and vote in a more compliant government. There is a bloody-minded faction that includes Finland, Latvia, Spain, as well as some ECB governors that is eager to punish Greece and sees that as necessary to preserve the Eurozone. We’ll see soon enough whether these austerity radicals that we call the ultras persuade enough key players to put their plans into action. 
But even in a less punitive scenario, a default or Grexit will do very serious damage to an already fragile and deeply depressed economy. Those who assert that Greece will bounce back quickly don’t have an economy this close to being a failed state as a comparable. 
Our view has been that the most likely scenario is a default in the Eurozone, and that the authorities have likely underestimated the damage if the impasse ultimately leads to a Grexit. Even if they are correct that financial contagion is contained, political contagion over the next few years is another matter entirely. 
But on a bigger frame, no matter how badly things turn out for Greece, the institutions at the core of the European project will emerge with their image badly damaged. The dirty secret has long been that the program of European integration was designed to produce rule by technocrats. Those technocrats, by being captive to bad ideology, have failed to deliver on the basic obligation of government: to provide for the safety and well-being of their populace. In a capitalist society, that means producing enough decently remunerated jobs. 
However, even if neoliberalism winds up receding as a result of the brutal Greek negotiations, it’s naive to assume that the exposure of the bankruptcy of neoliberalism means a return to the old European model of more social welfare and (at least in theory) democratic accountability. Ironically, the train wreck we are seeing now can be presented as a prime example of the dangers of democratic rule: a democratically elected government in Greece demanding better treatment from its jailer/creditors, when the most of the debt is held by democratically elected governments who are not willing to give Greece the breaks it wants. And as we’ve stressed from the outset, the fact that the two sides can’t come to agreement is that Syriza’s red line of pensions is also a red line to voters in the states that have provided funding to Greece. 
Thus even if the Greek denouement does represent Peak Neoliberalism, that does not mean that social democracy will emerge victorious. It simply means we will grope towards a new political order. Only if citizens are vigilant and engaged do they have a hope of coming out as winners.
All very true. But what Smith chooses not to underline is that there is no alternative to scrapping neoliberalism. Yes, the way forward to a new political dispensation is not clear because the neoliberal paradigm is still completely dominant; but a perception that it is bankrupt is now broadly taking root in popular consciousness. With this in mind, tomorrow some thoughts on Hillary Clinton's quixotic makeover as a New Deal populist and a working-class suffragette.

Thursday, April 16, 2015

$15 Now Last Gasp for Organized Labor

Yesterday was another nationwide mobilization to demand a $15-an-hour minimum wage for low-wage workers. The fast-food industry has been the principal target. Service Employees International Union (SEIU) is the key labor organization spearheading the push. For instance, SEIU ran the successful 2013 initiative campaign for a $15/hr. minimum wage in SeaTac, the city that is home to Seattle's airport, at the same time it provided valuable support in socialist Kshama Sawant's victory over an entrenched corporate liberal Seattle City Council incumbent. Sawant's win paved the way for Seattle's breakthrough $15/hr. minimum wage, which was copied, in one form or another (usually a lower rate of pay), in other cities and states.

"In Test for Unions and Politicians, a Nationwide Protest on Pay," by Noam Scheiber, provides background and an overview to yesterday's 200-city-plus protest. It is a good story.
“America, period, is unequal,” said Chasten Florence, 26, a construction worker from Jamaica, Queens. “Once we accept that, we can change that." 
McDonald’s said in a statement: “We respect people’s right to peacefully protest, and our restaurants remain open every day with the focus on providing an exceptional experience for our customers.” 
The campaign, staffed in part by organizers from the Service Employees International Union, orchestrated the country’s first-ever fast-food industry strike in November 2012, when 200 New York City workers walked off their jobs. The periodic protests expanded to six other cities in the spring of 2013, 60 cities in August of that year, 150 cities in May 2014, and 190 last December. 
The protests have coincided with an extraordinary shift in the political consensus on the minimum wage. In the last two years, Seattle has moved to gradually increase its minimum wage to $15 an hour, from $9.32. Oakland, Calif., established a new minimum wage of $12.25, while Chicago approved an increase to $13, from $8.25, over the next four years. Alaska and Arkansas passed minimum wage increases by referendum in 2014. 
In 2013, President Obama endorsed raising the federal minimum wage to $9, from $7.25 an hour, then increased that to $10.10 by the fall of that year. Democrats in the Senate are now working on a proposal to raise the national minimum wage to $12 by 2020.
But there was not a peep about the event yesterday in my place of employment, and I work for a union. And that is the problem. There is a yearning on the part of the broad public for a change in working conditions, which Scheiber makes clear, but, besides SEIU, the other big international unions have shown no ability to capitalize on the unrest.
“The labor movement has been stuck,” said Janice R. Fine, an associate professor of Labor Studies at Rutgers University. “They deserve a lot of credit in deciding that, in a situation this bleak, you needed ‘climate change’ ”— that is, a change in how the public views low-wage work — “before you’d actually get an opportunity to organize again.”
Partly in response to the political shift as well as competitive pressure from tighter labor markets, several major employers of low-wage workers have moved to raised their base pay in recent months. Walmart, Target and McDonald’s have all announced plans to increase their minimum wage to or near $10, though for McDonald’s it would apply only to the roughly 10 percent of its workers employed directly by the company, not by its franchisees.
But business groups argue that a substantially higher increase would force employers to reduce hiring, accelerate automation and even threaten the basic economic model of some industries.
For Mary Kay Henry, the president of S.E.I.U., the investment in the Fight for $15 campaign was initially controversial among her colleagues, many of whom wondered why the union should spend millions of dollars on a campaign that did not immediately net it dues-paying members. 
But it was the result of a calculation that the 20th-century model of organizing workers was rapidly becoming obsolete for those in a growing sector where employers considered it essentially costless to replace them. “We can no longer change our lives, and our kids’ lives, without the support of a broader movement of workers,” Ms. Henry said.
The origins of the Fight for $15 campaign date back to early 2012, when organizers from New York Communities for Change, which had built support for Occupy Wall Street activists among more established progressive activists and labor organizers, began canvassing low-income New Yorkers, many of them employed in the fast-food industry.
At the same time, public opinion was shifting. According to the General Social Survey, regarded by researchers as the gold standard in public opinion data, the share of Americans who agreed that “inequality continues to exist because it benefits the rich and powerful” spiked by more than 10 points from 2010 to 2012, to over 60 percent.
“People know Walmart and McDonald’s are doing pretty well, people at top,” said Leslie McCall, a professor of sociology at Northwestern University, who has closely analyzed the opinion data on inequality. “It was like: ‘Wait a minute. We’re into the recovery, the unemployment rate is going down. But most people aren’t doing well.’”
Even politically moderate voters appear to believe that it is the responsibility of corporations to mitigate the problem. In her own preliminary surveys, Professor McCall found that, when asked to choose who should be most responsible for reducing inequality — the poor, the rich, the government, major companies, or that it did not need to be reduced — a plurality of Republican respondents, about 37 percent, chose “major companies.”
The Fight for $15 campaign hopes to harness these sentiments in ways that Occupy Wall Street never quite succeeded in doing. In Seattle, Steve Gelb, who makes above minimum wage at a work force training outfit, said he supported the protests because “the disparity of wealth has reached alarming proportions and the salaries of business owners and executives are way out of proportion.”
There is some evidence that the big internationals headquartered in D.C. are beginning to get the message. But it is not about income inequality and economic justice and the need for a broad mobilization of low-wage workers. What the big, wealthy internationals are afraid of is the rapid spread of right-to-work laws, some of which are being passed at the local and county level. The right senses weakness and fear and it is lunging for the jugular. Right to work has become a new litmus test for Republican governors. Wisconsin's Scott Walker is the matinee idol of the movement. His chances of winning the GOP presidential nomination are as good as anyone's.

The math on right to work is unforgiving. Once passed it quickly leads to a loss of 20 percent in union dues-paying membership. So the message that is coming from on high is not "We need to mobilize our membership and develop a radical consciousness," it is, "We need to get our budgets in line with a possible 20-percent loss in operating revenue. We need to think about a dues increase."

Unions are gray at the top and completely captive to business-as-usual, conventional thinking. There is zero ability to transform into a radical organization capable of spearheading progressive social change. The guys at the top are all about dollars and cents and the size of their pension funds and the amount of bonus miles they have on their credit cards. They have their eyes on retirement. They'll willingly file aboard the Titanic of Hillary's presidential campaign and argue that it is a vessel for working people.

Even SEIU, a local of which I have worked for, is a conventional, top-down, tyrannical hierarchy that produces a culture of mendacity. Our problem is that it is the only game in town. There needs to be a new leftist political formation. At least SEIU has shown a willingness to work with a socialist like Kshama Sawant.

Thursday, February 26, 2015

Wisconsin Set to Pass Right to Work, Union Leadership Looks Forward to a Juicy Retirement

The last couple of days the Gray Lady has run stories ("Word of Threat Cuts Short Hearing on Right-to-Work Measure in Wisconsin" by Mitch Smith and "Scott Walker Is Set to Deliver New Blow to Labor in Wisconsin" by Monica Davey and Mitch Smith) about the Republican-controlled Wisconsin legislature moving quickly to pass a right to work law.

The stories are framed in terms of Scott Walker -- a governor who rose to national prominence in 2011 when he supported and signed a law curtailing collective bargaining rights for Wisconsin public-sector workers (with an exception for police and firefighters) -- and Walker's 2016 presidential run.

But the atmospheric backdrop of the two stories is a defeated labor movement. Monica Davey covered the 2011 battle in Madison. Organized labor mustered its troops at the capital but to no avail. Walker prevailed, he signed Act 10 into law, which gutted Wisconsin's public-sector unions, and in so doing he built a national profile for himself.

Davey and Smith open and close their report today accentuating the beaten nature of the unions:
MADISON, Wis. — It was a flashback to 2011: Hundreds of union members in hard hats and work boots waved signs under falling snow, denouncing Gov. Scott Walker and his fellow Republican lawmakers outside this Capitol building on Wednesday. Yet this time, their numbers were smaller, their chants softer. 
As Mr. Walker builds a presidential run on his effort to take on unions four years ago, he is poised to deliver a second walloping blow to labor. After saying for months that an effort to advance so-called right-to-work legislation would be “a distraction” from dealing with larger issues like the state’s economy and job growth, Mr. Walker is now preparing to sign a measure — being fast-tracked through the Republican-held State Legislature — that would bar unions from requiring workers to pay the equivalent of dues.
The State Senate passed the bill, 17 to 15, mostly along party lines, Wednesday night after about eight hours of debate. As the results were announced and senators left the chamber, protesters chanted “Shame” from the balcony. The State Assembly is expected to take up the measure next week. Where Mr. Walker’s earlier high-profile strike against labor cut collective bargaining rights for most public-sector unions, this one is aimed at workers in the private sector. And where Mr. Walker led the drive in 2011, he has taken a far less publicly forceful role this time, saying only that he will sign a bill. Yet the political effect will be the same, burnishing Mr. Walker’s record as an unafraid foe of Big Labor, who has been able to prevail in a state where Democrats have won presidential elections.
*** 
Before a crowd of demonstrators that spilled out around the Capitol on Wednesday, Phil Neuenfeldt, the president of the Wisconsin A.F.L.-C.I.O., called out, “We’re back.” He promised, to cheers, “We’re not going to forget about it.” Cold weather, short notice and work schedules may have diminished the crowds, some protesters said, but there was also a sense of inevitability — and of weary déjà vu.
“From day one,” Mr. Finkler, the retired university worker, said, “Walker was all about running for president.” About two hours into the debate on Wednesday afternoon, protesters inside the Capitol had dwindled to several dozen.
Davey and Smith give a succinct definition of right to work:
The measure would allow private-sector workers who choose not to join unions to avoid paying the equivalent of dues, known as “fair share” payments, which union leaders say are reasonable for anyone who benefits from union contracts. The widely protested 2011 law gave most public employees that same right. Neither provision would apply to police officers and firefighters.
Make no mistake, right to work destroys union density wherever it is passed. And with the loss of union density goes any hope of a political force for working people. Wisconsin is set to join Michigan and Indiana, two states of the nation's former industrial heartland that have recently passed right to work. Jimmy Hoffa's spirit is weeping.

And where is the push back from the AFL-CIO? Where is a declaration of resolve, a plan of counterattack, a mass mobilization of all members and political allies? There isn't one. And there won't be one.

Union leaders at the national and local level make six-figure incomes. Their overriding concern first and last is not to upset the apple cart. They can't do mass mobilizations; they can't do large organizing drives. The only thing they can do is turn members out for staged protests on the steps of capital buildings, like they did in Madison in 2011 and the other day, and like they do in Olympia in my home state of Washington. And what Walker has shown along with the Republican legislature in Wisconsin is that this theater can be ignored at very little electoral cost.

Organized labor's failure in Wisconsin should have been a wake-up call to upend business as usual. The fact that it did nothing of the sort is proof that unions are dead men walking, old white guys who are hoping to quietly muddle through for the next few years until they can retire with multiple fat pensions.

The answer -- which is no answer -- that will be forthcoming from the marble halls of the AFL-CIO will be to elect Hillary, no friend of labor. Members will be called on to man the phones and hit the doors. But the members in all their ignorance know better and the turnout for Hillary will be anemic.

Coming down the pike in 2016? Scott Walker, elected POTUS.

Wednesday, November 19, 2014

Get Ready for a Scott Walker Presidential Run

I've said it before, and I'll say it again. One of the best sources of information for what is going on nationally in politics is Thomas Edsall's online opinion column for the Gray Lady. Appearing every Wednesday, Edsall paints a picture of an America steadily pauperizing while an aggressive Republican Party fights to stovepipe more wealth up to the 1% at the same time it is beating back the revanchist, volatile Tea Partiers in its ranks; the Democrats meanwhile dither and play pat-a-cake with their own super-rich, pissing away the electoral advantage provided by the huge demographic shift underway (colored youth) in the U.S.

For his first opinion piece after the midterm election results have fully settled, "Republicans Sure Love to Hate Unions," the sagacious Edsall highlights the curious contradiction of the GOP preoccupation with organized labor versus the predilection of Democrats to institutionally ignore unions.

I say curious, but one could also label it neurotic or psychotic. Without organized labor the Democratic Party isn't credibly competitive. Yet year after year the Democratic Party delivers nothing to the unions; it takes their money and uses union volunteers to knock on doors and make phone calls, while at the same time it pursues free-trade deals and Wall-Street-friendly tax policies and bailouts.

The current GOP strategy to weaken organized labor and eviscerate the Democrats centers around going after public-sector unions. Elect hard-charging Republican governors who, acting in concert with GOP-controlled legislatures, rescind collective-bargaining rights for government employees. Call it the Scott Walker phenomenon. It worked to wonderful effect in Wisconsin:
A paradox of American politics is that Republicans take organized labor more seriously than Democrats do. 
The right sees unions as a mainstay of the left, a crucial source of cash, campaign manpower and votes. 
“Unions are the largest player in American politics and they will be for some time,” Grover Norquist, the president of Americans for Tax Reform, declared in March at the Conservative Political Action Conference. “Fourteen million Americans have to pay union dues. If they average $500, and that is a low estimate, that’s a $7 billion slush fund for the left.” 
Democrats are happy to get labor’s votes and money, but they have done little to revitalize the besieged movement. 
“The unions basically have become an A.T.M. for Democrats,” Steve Rosenthal, a former political director of the A.F.L.-C.I.O., told me in a phone conversation. “There is a sense of taking unions for granted, no place else to go, don’t need to do much for them.” 
Republicans are willing to go to great lengths to weaken the union movement, especially at the state level. Even as the strength of organized labor as a whole declines, conservatives view unions that represent public sector employees, in particular, as anathema. They are desperate to gut the power of the 7.2 million organized government workers — who range from teachers, to clerks in the Department of Motor Vehicles, to social workers, public hospital employees, meat and poultry inspectors, road workers, property tax auditors and civil servants in general. These are the employees who populate the extensive bureaucracies that the right loathes.
Unions the right has targeted include the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the Service Employees International Union, the American Federation of Government Employees, the National Education Association and the American Federation of Teachers.
Reince Priebus, chairman of the Republican National Committee, appearing at the same C.P.A.C. event as Norquist, boasted that in Wisconsin the successful drive to render public sector unions impotent was the result of a coordinated effort between the party and the conservative movement: "We had total and complete unity between the state party, Americans for Prosperity, the tea party groups, the Grandsons of Liberty, the 9-12ers were involved. It was a total and compete agreement that nobody got the credit, that everyone was going to run down the track together."
The anti-union alliance between the Republican Party and movement conservatives got a big boost on Nov. 4. The heroes of this anti-union drive, Scott Walker, the governor of Wisconsin, and Rick Snyder, the governor of Michigan, were re-elected in states with a long history of strong labor movements. Prospects for the enactment of additional anti-labor legislation also improved as Republicans made substantial gains in legislatures and governor’s races across the country.
After the 2010 election, Republicans had complete control (governor and both legislative branches) in 21 states, almost double the 11 states with complete Democatic control. Now, 24 states are fully in Republican hands; Democrats dominate in just 7.
 The 2014 election was “a major political defeat for the unions, particularly state-wide public sector unions, because it shows how much the voting public sees unions as part of the problem of persistent unemployment and underemployment, rather than being part of the solution,” Gary Chaison, a professor of industrial relations at Clark University, replied in response to my email. Chaison’s assessment: "The election of Republicans is indicative of the degree to which the voters have turned on the unions. There was once a time, two decades ago, when candidates to the governor’s officer sought the endorsement of major unions in his or her state; now they run on being anti-union crusaders. Quite a reversal of fortunes. The public sector was, for fifty years, the engine of union growth in America. This will happen no more. The brake on union decline is gone. The victory of Republican governors shows how much unions have lost their political power – now they are vulnerable to attempts to strip them of their power at the state level. Every new governor seems to be a Chris Christie, ready for a fight."
By 2013, 11.3 percent of wage and salary workers were covered by unions, down from 23.4 percent in 1983.
Republicans have good reason to target public sector unions. Without them, the share of the work force represented by unions would be even smaller than it is now. By last year, union coverage of private sector workers had fallen to 7.5 percent, from a high of roughly 35 percent in the mid-1950s. Government workers today make up 15.8 percent of the total work force, but union representation of this sliver has grown from less than 10 percent in the 1950s to 35.3 percent.
Norquist told the C.P.A.C. conference that conservatives hadn’t taken on public employee unions in the mistaken belief that “you can’t do anything about the public sector. The rules are set, and they elect the guys who set the rules.” But Walker’s success in winning a recall election, and in getting re-elected, has permanently changed thinking on the right, Norquist declared. By this reasoning, Walker’s survival and ultimate triumph demonstrates that changing the rules to make it more difficult to organize public workers, to collect dues and to bargain over wages and fringe benefits is politically viable, even in a Northern state.
In 2011, when Walker first took office, 37 percent of the nation’s 21-plus million public sector employees were union members; by 2012, this droppedto 35.9 percent; and last year, it fell to 35.3 percent.
So that's the formula for 2016: Continue the frontal assault on public-sector unions because that is where the union density is; get overall union density down to where it is in the private sector, below 8%, and choke out what is left in the bathtub; oh, yes, and elect Scott Walker as POTUS.

Edsall goes on to describe why the Democratic Party is not only not doing anything to fight back against this assault, it is actually attacking unions itself. As Edsall explains,
If Republicans and conservatives place a top priority on eviscerating labor unions, what is the Democratic Party doing to protect this core constituency? Not much. 
In fact, the Obama administration has undermined the bargaining leverage of the most successful unions by imposing a 40 percent excise tax, which takes effect in 2018, on health insurance premiums in excess of $10,200 annually for individuals, and $27,500 for families, in order to finance Obamacare. The provision, which covers what many of labor’s enemies call “Cadillac plans,” has provoked an angry response from labor leaders. They see the tax as threatening the continued survival of key health insurance benefits that unions have won as part of total employee compensation packages.
In an email to me, Joel Parker, national vice president of the merged Transportation Communications International Union and International Association of Machinists, wrote about the consequences of the new excise tax:
The result is a nightmare for union workers at large companies, and even worse for non-union workers. For the latter, companies will simply unilaterally cut benefits and/or shift to high-deductible plans. Institutionally, the bill weakens unions, one of the remaining core groups in the Democratic coalition. Private sector unions’ main selling point to non-union workers was superior health and pension plans. The health insurance advantage, if the excise tax is allowed to survive, will gradually disappear. 
Democrats neglect the union movement at their peril. Not only does organized labor provide millions of dollars – the Center for Responsive Politics reports that unions spent $116.5 million on politics in 2013-14 – but union members are a loyal Democratic constituency. On Nov. 4, the 17 percent of voters who come from union households supported Democratic House candidates by a margin of 22 points, 60-38, while the remaining 83 percent from non-union households supported Republicans 54-44.
I know something about unions. I've worked for various union locals, central labor councils and Taft-Hartley trusts for 15 years. Unions are dying. No question about it. And, yes, Obamacare is hastening the process because it is helping to drive out the "blue chip" medical, full-maintenance-of-benefits type plan in favor of these 80-20/70-30 co-insurance, high out-of-pocket limit plans.

Mostly though unions are dying because there is a lack of class consciousness in leadership. Union chiefs see themselves closely aligned with plutocrat-friendly Dem politicians; they fancy themselves executives in a corner offices with a shiny nameplates. And that kind of thinking is a serious problem.

Friday, April 4, 2014

Hippies vs. Punks: The Yardbirds

In order for a society to move forward it has to be able to generate a popular vision of the future -- A WAY OUT. What makes our present age so perilous is we have lost our ability to produce a collective perception of a way out. Our current neoliberal neoconservative cultural dead end predominantly manufactures dystopian fantasies (The Walking Dead, Breaking Bad) or historical paeans (Vikings, Mad Men).

The Hippie was the new man the Western World produced at the zenith of its 1960s post-war prosperity. The Punk was the new man spawned in reaction to the Hippie's failure. The Hip Hop artist has been our new man here in the West for decades -- really since Grunge quickly collapsed under the weight of its commercial excesses twenty years ago.


I don't think there is a finer, more sensitive, honest, hopeful vision of the future -- a discourse on possibility itself -- than Michelangelo Antonioni's Blowup (1966). This is what the Western World looked like when there was still hope and the future was open. Starring a Dylanesque David Hemmings as a fashion photographer in "Swinging London," The Yardbirds appear in the middle of the film performing "Stroll On." Antonioni wanted The Who because he was entranced by Pete Townshend's guitar-smashing routine. The Who declined. Antonioni then tried to get The Velvet Underground but was unable to either because of the band's inability to secure a work permit in the UK or the prohibitive cost of transatlantic travel. So he settled on The Yardbirds; Jeff Beck did the guitar smashing.

When I last saw this film, my unemployment spring of 2011, I was struck by how fresh and new the band looked, as if they truly were pioneering new territory with no attachments to binding constraints of the past.

The Yardbirds, along with The Who, were the new men of the middle 1960s. They as much as anyone else created the Hippies and the Hippie era. This is Lester Bangs' take. The Yardbirds changed music. They brought fraying, shattering guitar distortion to the fore, and they perfected a heavy-bottom backbeat. This inspired countless imitators and knockoffs ("Punks," such as Count Five of Bangs' title essay in Psychotic Reactions and Carburetor Dung) across the broad expanse of Great Society suburban American. Out of the suburban garage emerges the Hippie.


Bangs' spontaneous-prose-style analysis is basically in line with an academic study by Michael Hicks titled Sixties Rock: Garage, Psychedelic and Other Satisfactions (1999) I read last summer.


We all know that out of the ashes of The Yardbirds Jimmy Page forms the Hippie supergroup Led Zeppelin, an endless source of Bangs' ire (so too for the Punks) because of the band's artistic pretensions and superstar status demanding hero worship and mindless fan obeisance.

****
Last night I attended a union meeting. We voted on a tentative agreement (TA) that will more than likely result in the loss of our current health plan in favor of a cheaper one. This means that for those of us who seek medical attention regularly there will be a significant increase in out-of-pocket expenses.

I voted against the TA. Our bargaining team only met with the employer group twice, and then basically rolled over and presented us with a TA that is nothing but givebacks.

I understand that the costs to our current health have shot through the roof -- a 29% jump this year alone -- and that it cannot be maintained and in the long run we will have to move to another plan. But year after year the only thing that we focused on in our bargaining was maintaining the health plan. Now in less than two full bargaining sessions we are caving in. Unacceptable.

Nonetheless, the tentative agreement passed, and it passed by a healthy margin. People are scared and beat down and have no fight left in them. Our union representative, who is also the head of the union local and our chief negotiator with the employer as well as a trustee of our foundering health plan, took the employer's side. The message, simply put, was that we all are a bunch of monkeys easily replaced, and we are lucky to have whatever the employer gives us. So we should shut our fucking traps and take was is being offered pronto.

Needless to say, it was an unpleasant experience. One interesting sidebar was our union representative's opinion that the Affordable Care Act (ACA), a.k.a., Obamacare is proving to be very damaging to union Taft-Hartley regulated health plans. There is a firewall between Taft-Hartley plans and the ACA insurance exchange; they cannot buy insurance on the exchange. Yet the ACA brought a whole host of additional costs, such as covering adult children up to the age of 26.

The crowning achievement of the Obama administration, elected with fulsome union support, is Obamacare. Obamacare will be the undoing of a basic foundation of union membership, blue-chip medical coverage. Defined-benefit pensions are almost all gone (see the recent Boeing Machinists' capitulation where they voted to go to a 401(k) plan); now, fully-paid, employer-provided health insurance. Soon belonging to a union will not mean much.

As this reckoning sinks in, the only way Democrats will be able to win elections is solely by tapping plutocrats and playing the big money game. They do this now of course. But they have managed to keep healthy numbers of working people aligned with the party because it is the lesser of two evils. After Obamacare and the death of the unions, this alignment becomes increasingly problematic.

We need new men! We must be inspired by a vision of the future as fecund as Blowup and The Yardbirds of the middle-60s. Right now there is nothing.

Friday, January 25, 2013

Labor's Decline

Organized labor continues to shrink. We're down to 11.3% of the work force, the lowest since 1916; this according to new information reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. If you read the story yesterday by Steven Greenhouse, you know that the right-to-work law in Indiana and the loss of collective bargaining rights for public sector workers in Wisconsin, both passed by Republican legislatures following Tea-Party fueled triumphs in the 2010 midterm elections, had a lot to do with the significant one-year decline:
Union membership showed sharp drops in Wisconsin, which passed a law in 2011 curbing the collective bargaining rights of many public employees, and in Indiana, which enacted a right-to-work law last February that may have prompted many workers to drop their union membership.
Such laws prohibit requiring employees at unionized workplaces to pay union dues or fees. The bureau’s report showed that union membership fell by 13 percent last year in Wisconsin and by 18 percent in Indiana — both unusually large numbers for a single year.
Barry T. Hirsch, a labor economist at Georgia State University, said an analysis he conducted found that the number of government employees in Wisconsin belonging to a union slid by 48,000 last year, to 139,000 from 187,000, as many public sector workers evidently decided to quit their unions after the Republican-led legislature stripped them of most of their bargaining rights.
Speaking about the nation as a whole, Professor Hirsch said: “I am really surprised that the drop in unionization was as large as it is in a single year, and it was particularly big in the public sector. It does seem you are seeing reductions in some of the states that you might expect.”
For instance, in Indiana, where the right to work law took effect last March, unionization dropped to 9.1 percent from 11.3 percent in 2011. Michigan enacted a similar law last month.
I asked at least four people at the local where I work if they had seen this story. No one had. Not a single person. Greenhouse quotes the chief economist for the AFL-CIO, William Spriggs, who tries to spin the the bleak BLS report by arguing that unionization is up in key states like California, Texas and North Carolina. “'It’s not a simple story that we don’t have our act together,' Mr. Spriggs said. 'I would be more concerned if union membership was down among Latinos and Asian-Americans, because that’s a growing demographic, but it’s up.'”

But it is a simple story that labor doesn't have its act together. Unions have money, at least the internationals and large locals do. Organizers could be employed; things could be turned upside down. But leadership is overwhelming old and overwhelming preoccupied with holding on to the assets it controls. So as the boat sinks the shibboleth for labor is, "Don't rock the boat."

Thursday, December 20, 2012

Political Action Committee Meeting Woes

Children splashing in their urine.  I'm sorry.  I'm not being charitable.  But that's what it felt like I was witnessing as I sat at a conference table for two hours at a meeting of my local union's political action committee (PAC).  People -- not everyone -- need to get their gun off; they need to hear themselves and they need to be heard.  So discussion rather than staying on point will digress and then circle back and then digress again.

I've been active in my union off and on for over ten years.  Back in my salad days of the millennium I was something of a small caliber politico active in a variety of causes with an assortment of groups.  I was a union steward and briefly a central labor council delegate.  But I burned out and pulled back.  Then I changed unions and put in a nightmarish stint at a SEIU local before returning to the fold of the office employees international about a year-and-a-half later.  I began commuting two-and-a-half hours a day on the bus working as a dispatcher for a commercial carpenters local at the same time I was wrapped up in a doomed relationship with a massage therapist.  I couldn't spare a moment to volunteer, or so I thought.

After I parted company with my girlfriend I started to become active again.  First, I devoted what turned out to be an inordinate amount of energy to make a modest correction in our local's out-of-work list.  Next, along with a coworker ally, I set my sights on boosting PAC membership.  It's a work in progress.  Currently less than 2% of our local's members contribute to the PAC.  Woeful.  People are distracted, ignorant, while collective bargaining rights disappear in front of our eyes. 

There is nothing to do but try harder no matter how discouraging it gets.  Labor unions are precious no matter how imperfect; they are one of the great manifestations of Western rationality.