Showing posts with label TPP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TPP. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 24, 2015

Neoliberalism Unbowed: Obama Gets Fast Track and Tsipras Accepts Austerity

Two big dollops of bad news to process. First, Obama was able, with the assistance of senate GOP majority leader Mitch McConnell and 13 Democrats, to push through a critical vote on trade promotion authority, a.k.a., fast track (Jonathan Weisman, "Trade Accord, Once Blocked, Nears Passage"). Even The New York Times editorial board, always a staunch supporter of anything having to do with free trade, sounds a note of trepidation ("President Obama Must Use Trade Authority to Reach Better Agreements"):
To secure broad and bipartisan support for trade agreements, the administration needs to reach deals that address the legitimate concerns raised by many Democrats. The deals must contain strong and enforceable provisions on workers’ rights and the environment. They should bar, or at least strongly discourage, countries from manipulating their currencies to bolster exports at the expense of businesses in other countries. And the deals must not contain overreaching investor protection clauses that allow foreign businesses to file frivolous and abusive arbitration claims against governments by contending they were hurt by laws and regulations. Philip Morris Asia, for example, has used investor provisions in other treaties to challenge tobacco policies in Australia.
This is all whistling pass the graveyard. As I opined previously, the Democrats are in serious trouble if the Trans-Pacific Partnership passes, something which seems a done deal now that Obama is about to get fast track. Democrats are looking at shrunken numbers in Congress. So far unions are standing by a pledge to block donations to any member of Congress who votes for trade promotion/TPP. I am not confident that this pledge will hold up into next year when some lukewarm friends of labor like senator Maria Cantwell are in tough reelection fights. Nonetheless progressive rank-and-file support for Obama, the Democratic Party, and, by association, the S.S. Clinton will be hard to come by.

But the second item of bad news, a truly depressing development that surfaced on Monday, is that Greek leader Alexis Tsipras capitulated to the troika and proffered an austerity package of increased taxes and pension cuts. Yves Smith summarized on Monday in "Short Greece Proposal Update: Greece Folds":
Note contrary to earlier media reports, it technically does not lower pensions payments but does reduce pension spending by requiring higher contributions, including payments from retirees themselves. As the Guardian’s Athens reporter, Helen Smith, notes: 
……there’s a hefty increase in revenues from VAT over the next 18 months.
Greece has also accepted that pension must be reformed, and is planning a hike in pension contributions and an increase in health contributions from retirees. However, it appears that actual pension rates won’t be cut, allowing Athens to argue it has kept to its red line.
Another quick verdict is that “pensions are almost spared“. And while European leaders are urging their peers to consummate a deal, it’s not clear these pension moves will be enough to satisfy countries like Slovaka, which have said they can’t stomach financing Greece’s more generous pensions. One rebellious country could probably be shamed into line, but we have yet to hear of the reactions from the real hardliners like Finland and Spain, since the summit has just begun.
The Tsipras capitulation is very Obamaesque in that on the surface it does not reduce pension payments, but on the back end there are an increase in fees, such as the requirement that pensioners shoulder more responsibility for healthcare costs. Similarly, while Obamacare has increased Medicaid enrollment, it has all but wiped out the full maintenance of benefit healthcare plan that used to be the default blue-chip industry standard. Now 70/30 or 80/20 co-insurance is the new normal. You might not have a premium share but it amounts to the same thing if you go to the doctor.

Smith wrote yesterday ("Deal With Greece Still Looks Wobbly") that the Tsipras capitulation in no way guarantees that the debt deal with the troika is home free. Apparently German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble is calling for even more Greek flesh. And Jim Yardley reports today ("Greek Debt Blueprint Gets a Cold Reception in Athens") that Tsipras faces a revolt from Syriza members in parliament:
“This makes life worse for ordinary citizens,” said Despoina Charalampidou, a Syriza lawmaker who is now a deputy speaker of Parliament. “The measures constitute austerity.” 
Sitting in her office in Parliament, Ms. Charalampidou stressed that the negotiations were continuing. She did not rule out supporting a final deal, especially if it included concrete European promises to reduce Greece’s public debt, estimated at around 320 billion euros, and provided structural funds to stimulate economic growth. 
“Otherwise, I don’t think it will pass,” she added. She said the prime minister was facing a “very complex, even insurmountable task.” She blamed European creditors for using negotiations to send a stern political message about challenging austerity, saying that they “want to humiliate the Greeks for the choice they made on Jan. 25,” a reference to Election Day. 
Harry Papasotiriou, a political analyst in Athens, predicted that most Syriza members would ultimately toe the line and support any deal endorsed by Mr. Tsipras. “He’ll survive politically, but down the road, he could suffer,” Mr. Papasotiriou said. 
Adonis Georgiadis, a member of the New Democracy party, which is now in political opposition after being voted out of the government in January, pounced at the chance to affix Syriza with the stain of austerity. “If this is not an austerity measure, can you explain what austerity is?” he asked. 
In the eyes of many Syriza leftists, any compromise that constitutes a major departure from their election mandate to roll back austerity is considered politically risky. 
Even though the negotiations have been ugly, Syriza remains popular, especially Mr. Tsipras, as many ordinary Greeks have relished the confrontation with Europe. But that has also placed Syriza in a tough political spot, since most analysts say compromise is inevitable if Greece wants to remain in the eurozone. 
“These measures cannot be voted for,” Alexis Mitropoulos, another Syriza lawmaker, told the Greek media on Tuesday. “This package that you have in your hands cannot be the one to be presented in Parliament.”
At this point I am inclined to think that Syriza members in the parliament are not as corrupt as the Democrats in the senate and that Tsipras will not being able to win approval for his capitulation to the troika. My thinking here is guided by the Sunday New York Times Magazine feature on Yanis Varoufakis that appeared in May. In that article finance minister Varoufakis was categorical: There would be no cuts to pensions; and if there were, he would resign from the government.

So we are at the point that either Syriza revolts and maintains its legitimacy as a standard bearer for a left alternative to neoliberal austerity, or it goes along with the Tsipras capitulation and another promising popular progressive movement is subverted.

Tuesday, June 16, 2015

Chozick on the Hillary Reboot: The Triangulator Triangulates Obama as He Attempts a TPP Triangulation of His Own

Amy Chozick has worked the Clinton beat for two years now. Chozick acts as midwife for the public relations campaigns launched one after the next to reinvent the bloated power broker we have come to know as Hillary, but Chozick can also be a stealthy critic as well.

An example can be found in last Saturday's repackaging ("Hillary Clinton Embraces Her Mother’s Emotional Tale") of Hillary as a loving daughter to a mother with a hardscrabble, emotionally-harrowing working-class story. If Hillary had a privileged, stable Illinois upbringing, her mother did not. Here is how Chozick sums up the Hillary reboot in a tidy four paragraphs that open the story:
Dorothy Howell [Hillary's mother] was 8 years old when her parents sent her away. It was 1927. Her mother and father, who fought violently in the Chicago boardinghouse where the family lived, divorced. Neither was willing to take care of Dorothy or her little sister. 
So they put the girls on a train to California to live with their grandparents. It did not go well. Her grandmother favored black Victorian dresses and punished the girls for inexplicable infractions, like playing in the yard. (Dorothy was not allowed to leave her room for a year, other than for school, after she went trick-or-treating one Halloween.) 
Unable to bear it, Dorothy left her grandparents’ home at 14, and became a housekeeper for $3 a week, always hoping to return to Chicago and reconnect with her mother. But when she finally did, a few years later, her mother spurned her again.
It took a long time for Hillary Rodham Clinton to fully understand the story of her mother’s devastating childhood. But now, four years after her death, Dorothy’s story is forming the emotional foundation of her daughter’s campaign for president, and will be a central theme in her big kickoff speech on Saturday.
Chozick, a media reporter before taking on the Clinton beat, explains to her readers why this reboot is important:
A sympathetic tale of her mother’s struggles could help Mrs. Clinton convince a struggling middle class that she understands their problems, aides said. A CNN poll released on June 2 showed that 47 percent of voters thought that Mrs. Clinton “cares about people like you,” down from 53 percent last July. Mrs. Clinton’s campaign aides have publicly shrugged off such polls as evidence that voters distrust Washington and politics in general, but privately they are strategizing about how to reframe the conversation.
The task at hand for the Clinton campaign is enormous, almost akin to an alchemical squaring of the circle: How to convince people that Hillary is not what she is? -- a member of the "Davos elite," a powerful, jet-setting celebrity that accepts gargantuan checks from sheikhs and moguls and cares less for ordinary working people than an antebellum plantation owner would for one of his infirm slaves. Hence, we have Hillary piggybacking on her dead mother's backstory.

Hillary came out swinging last Saturday (Amy Chozick, "Hillary Clinton, in Roosevelt Island Speech, Pledges to Close Income Gap") on Roosevelt Island, the long spit in the East River between Manhattan and Queens, promising to fight for the truck drivers and nurses. Chozick couldn't help getting in the dig that
For as much as the content of the speech mattered, the theater of it was equally important. For a campaign criticized for lacking passion, the event gave Mrs. Clinton the ability to create a camera-ready tableau of excitement.
The Brooklyn Express Drumline revved up the crowd assembled on a narrow stretch at the southern tip of the island. And Marlon Marshall, the campaign’s director of political engagement, rattled off statistics about the number of volunteers who have signed up and house parties held in the early nominating states. A section with giant screens set up for an overflow crowd stood nearly empty. 
But a crowd of supporters and volunteers from the staunchly Democratic New York area does not exactly represent the electorate writ large. The real test for Mrs. Clinton and how the speech was perceived will be in Iowa, where she was to travel on Saturday evening for several events. Iowa, the first nominating state, shunned her the last time she sought the presidency, in 2008.
The Clintons when they occupied the the White House in the 1990s were known for something called "triangulation," which was a way of running against your own party by cherry-picking policies from the opposition. Tony Blair made a career out of it in the UK as well.

As Obama's attempt at triangulation to get the Trans-Pacific Partnership through Congress has exploded in a ball of flames, it is interesting to note that at the core of Hillary's messaging is the triangulation of the Obama presidency. According to Chozick and Patrick Healy in today's story "Hillary Clinton’s Vows to ‘Fight’ Evoke a Populist Appeal and a Contrast With Obama":
In a roughly 45-minute speech on Saturday, Hillary Rodham Clinton made 14 references to herself as a fighter. 
She said she would “fight” back against Republicans, “fight” climate change, “fight” to “strengthen America’s families” and “fight” to “harness all of America’s power.” She used the verb in many of the same ways at her first major rally in Des Moines on Sunday, adding that she would “fight” for Midwestern values. 
The presidential campaign’s effort to define Mrs. Clinton as a fighter is, on the surface, a way to persuade middle-class voters that she is on their side. But it is also helping to convey a more subtle message: When it comes to political combat and perseverance, Mrs. Clinton is not President Obama. 
The theme is emerging just as Mr. Obama has suffered a major setback on trade, one that many in Congress say reflects his weaknesses, namely his standoffishness and his inability to forge coalitions for an agenda.
It is a hall of mirrors. Obama is working with Republicans to surreptitiously reintroduce Fast Track while Hillary is positioning herself on the corpse of Democrats' hopes that Obama was a transformative politician.

This cannot end well. Hillary has not put Benghazi and the email issue behind her, let alone successfully relaunching herself as a working-class champion. I am still of the belief that absent the GOP nominating Ted Cruz Hillary cannot win.

Monday, June 15, 2015

Obama's TPP/Asia Pivot Waterloo + Organized Labor Proof of Life + Bad News for Saudis/ISIS + Greek Default and Peak Neoliberalism

There is quite a bit of good news this Monday morning. Dire assessments of Obama's "lame duckery" continue to roll in (Peter Baker, "The Trans-Pacific Partnership and a President’s Legacy") following Friday's failed vote in the House of Representative on trade-promotion authority (Jonathan Weisman, "House Rejects Trade Measure, Rebuffing Obama’s Dramatic Appeal"). Obama's Asia pivot is being declared DOA. This is from Baker's frontpage piece this morning:
The administration tried making a foreign policy argument over the last few weeks, maintaining that if the United States does not seal the trade pact, it will be leaving the field to China, which has been exerting its clout in recent years, whether by investing in energy supplies in Africa and the Middle East or by asserting claims over disputed waters and islands. 
But some on the left argue that the administration is using China to scare lawmakers and exaggerating the competition. “I just don’t buy this China boogeyman stuff,” said Jared Bernstein, a senior fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities and a former economic adviser to Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. “If anything, I see China as being more inward looking, devoting less resources to mercantile-type trade and more to internal investment, consumption and developing human capital.” 
Supporters of the trade pact hope to hold a new vote this week on the part of the trade package rejected by the House on Friday but will need to secure 90 more votes. Representative Paul D. Ryan, the Wisconsin Republican who has worked with the White House to secure trade negotiating authority, said on Sunday that if Mr. Obama wanted to avoid being a “very lame-duck president,” he would have to win over members of his own party. 
“I think that this can be salvaged because I think people are going to realize just how big the consequences are for American leadership,” Mr. Ryan said on “Fox News Sunday.” 
But there was little indication over the weekend that many minds had been changed on the political left. “We need to regroup and come up with a trade policy which demands that corporate America start investing in this country rather than in countries all over the world,” Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination, said on “Face the Nation” on CBS.
*** 
“There is no Asia pivot without an economic component, and that component is tied up in T.P.P.,” said Walter Lohman, director of the Asian studies program at the Heritage Foundation. The challenge for Mr. Obama, he added, is that no matter how important the trade pact may be to his foreign policy, Congress will consider it through an economic lens. “Geopolitics gets it very few votes.”
As I said, good news. Good news too that organized labor figured out how to do things properly on this one, both by working in concert with citizen groups and environmentalists, as well as playing hardball with two-faced Dems. This is from Noam Sheiber's weekend story, "Labor’s Might Seen in Failure of Trade Deal as Unions Allied to Thwart It":
Labor’s smartest move was lining up opposition to the president’s trade agenda as early as 2013, when the fight was still a distant prospect. “They did a good job getting out and defining T.P.A. early among Democratic House members, really peeling off an enormous number of folks who didn’t have long history or an understanding of the issue, prior to the White House engaging,” said Simon Rosenberg, president of the advocacy group NDN and a supporter of Mr. Obama’s effort. 
Mr. Rosenberg pointed in particular to a letter labor activists helped circulate late that year, which roughly 150 House Democrats signed. “It was a letter that was going to make it hard to vote for T.P.A. once you signed it,” Mr. Rosenberg said.
***

This time around, not only did the firefighters make a considerable investment — producing ads and paying to broadcast them in five congressional districts — but Mr. Schaitberger personally led the effort within the A.F.L-C.I.O. executive council to freeze all donations to members of Congress by the political action committees of the federation and affiliated unions until after the vote on trade promotion authority. (Mr. Schaitberger, who developed the motion, credits Mr. Trumka with helping create almost unanimous support for it.) 
Mr. Schaitberger acknowledged some apprehension within the labor movement about denying money even to longtime congressional allies, but he argued that it had been the most effective way to persuade friendly members of Congress to pressure wavering Democratic lawmakers. “We wanted to encourage those members to use their influence, their passion for our position, to move some of their colleagues,” he said.
A win for labor, a blow to the Asia pivot, why not add a story about workers at Gawker Media voting to join a union? Rachel Swarns reports in "At Gawker Media, New Economy Workers Strive to Form a New Kind of Union" that
. . . Last year, about 22 percent of recent college graduates were either working part time or unemployed, compared with about 15 percent in 2007, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco.
That may be one reason young adults view unions more favorably than other age groups. In March, a national survey of 1,500 adults conducted by the Pew Research Center found that 55 percent of those ages 18 to 29 view unions positively, while 29 percent view them unfavorably.
Overseas, peace talks on Yemen begin in Geneva today. The Houthis continue to roll up victories despite the Saudi-led terror bombing. The Kurdish fighters are battering Islamic State in northern Syria, threatening to capture the main ISIS supply route from Turkey to Raqqa. All good news.

Plus, we are now approaching the decisive moment in the Greek-troika debt negotiations. A default by Greece seems unavoidable. Yves Smith of Naked Capitalism is terming this "Peak Neoliberalism":
The resolution of the Greece/creditor deadlock may also mark Peak Neoliberalism. It’s possible, but only remotely so, that Greece and its creditor overlords will back off from their collision. But as we’ve said for years, Germany is wedded to incompatible goals, namely running large trade surpluses but not financing its trade partners. It is destined to burn them down if it fails to find a new course of action. Greece is also wedded to incompatible goals, namely getting a real break from austerity while staying in the Eurozone. 
On the current trajectory, Greece will suffer horribly under a default or Grexit. The creditors have the incentive and the means to make either one more painful than continued austerity so as to force Greek citizens to capitulate and vote in a more compliant government. There is a bloody-minded faction that includes Finland, Latvia, Spain, as well as some ECB governors that is eager to punish Greece and sees that as necessary to preserve the Eurozone. We’ll see soon enough whether these austerity radicals that we call the ultras persuade enough key players to put their plans into action. 
But even in a less punitive scenario, a default or Grexit will do very serious damage to an already fragile and deeply depressed economy. Those who assert that Greece will bounce back quickly don’t have an economy this close to being a failed state as a comparable. 
Our view has been that the most likely scenario is a default in the Eurozone, and that the authorities have likely underestimated the damage if the impasse ultimately leads to a Grexit. Even if they are correct that financial contagion is contained, political contagion over the next few years is another matter entirely. 
But on a bigger frame, no matter how badly things turn out for Greece, the institutions at the core of the European project will emerge with their image badly damaged. The dirty secret has long been that the program of European integration was designed to produce rule by technocrats. Those technocrats, by being captive to bad ideology, have failed to deliver on the basic obligation of government: to provide for the safety and well-being of their populace. In a capitalist society, that means producing enough decently remunerated jobs. 
However, even if neoliberalism winds up receding as a result of the brutal Greek negotiations, it’s naive to assume that the exposure of the bankruptcy of neoliberalism means a return to the old European model of more social welfare and (at least in theory) democratic accountability. Ironically, the train wreck we are seeing now can be presented as a prime example of the dangers of democratic rule: a democratically elected government in Greece demanding better treatment from its jailer/creditors, when the most of the debt is held by democratically elected governments who are not willing to give Greece the breaks it wants. And as we’ve stressed from the outset, the fact that the two sides can’t come to agreement is that Syriza’s red line of pensions is also a red line to voters in the states that have provided funding to Greece. 
Thus even if the Greek denouement does represent Peak Neoliberalism, that does not mean that social democracy will emerge victorious. It simply means we will grope towards a new political order. Only if citizens are vigilant and engaged do they have a hope of coming out as winners.
All very true. But what Smith chooses not to underline is that there is no alternative to scrapping neoliberalism. Yes, the way forward to a new political dispensation is not clear because the neoliberal paradigm is still completely dominant; but a perception that it is bankrupt is now broadly taking root in popular consciousness. With this in mind, tomorrow some thoughts on Hillary Clinton's quixotic makeover as a New Deal populist and a working-class suffragette.

Monday, June 1, 2015

Democrats in Trouble: If TPP Passes, Expect a GOP Landslide in 2016

Things are bad and people know it. If they are not always able to articulate why things are bad -- whether it is savage war in the Middle East, environmental planetary crisis, or the persistent lack of remunerative employment -- most will say it has something do with the growing gap between the rich and everyone else.

Obama was elected in two separate landslides to restore decency and fairness to a system out of whack. It is his profound failure, with 18 months left in office, to deliver anything substantial (besides the Affordable Care Act's expansion of Medicaid and some EPA rule making) to the vast majority of voters who supported him that creates a pervasive sense that the United States is at a dead end.

Hillary is not the answer. There are indications that this is not merely a fringe belief. The Clinton Foundation continues to make the front page. The latest example, a kick-back scheme involving model Petra Nemcova's Happy Hearts Fund, was featured in Saturday's Gray Lady, "An Award for Bill Clinton Came With $500,000 for His Foundation." The story, by Deborah Sontag, provides the reader an education on how philanthropy of the 1% dovetails with big business and government. It is not a pretty picture, not one that will motivate working-class voters to get to the polls for Hillary.

No, the Democrats are in trouble. A report yesterday by Eric Lichtblau and Nicholas Confessore, "Democrats Seek a Richer Roster to Match G.O.P.," details the difficulties the Clintons are having in raising Super PAC funds:
WASHINGTON — Over the last few months, Harold M. Ickes, a longtime ally of Hillary Rodham Clinton, has helped organize private meetings around the country with union leaders, Clinton backers and Democratic strategists. The pressing topic: Who will step up to be the Democrats’ megadonors in the 2016 presidential race?
Republican contenders have already secured hundreds of millions of dollars in commitments from a stable of billionaires, including a Wall Street hedge fund executive, a Las Vegas casino magnate, a Florida auto dealer, a Wyoming investor and, of course, the Kansas-born billionaires David H. and Charles G. Koch. But none of the biggest Democratic donors from past elections — for example, the Chicago investor Fred Eychaner, the climate-change activist Tom Steyer and the entertainment mogul Jeffrey Katzenberg — have committed to supporting Mrs. Clinton on nearly the same scale.
“No one has stepped forward as the savior,” said Matt Bennett, a longtime Democratic consultant in Washington.
The leading super PAC backing Mrs. Clinton, Priorities USA Action, has won commitments of only about $15 million so far, Democrats involved with the group’s fund-raising said. And while the absence of a competitive race for the Democratic nomination gives Mrs. Clinton more time to catch up with Republican rivals, her allies are planning to push the party’s wealthiest donors for more money than most of them have ever given.
In planning sessions and one-on-one meetings with donors, Mr. Ickes, who is a Priorities USA board member, and other Clinton supporters are discussing how to raise as much as $300 million for Democratic outside groups. That is almost twice as much as Democratic super PACs and other outside groups spent to help re-elect President Obama in 2012, when conservative super PACs far outspent liberal ones.
This ambitious goal will require the emergence of a new class of at least 20 Democratic donors who can give $5 million or even $10 million each. Mr. Ickes said recruiting them would not be easy.
“Our side isn’t used to being asked for that kind of money,” Mr. Ickes said. “If you asked them to put up $100 million for a hospital wing, they’d be the first in line.”
The hurdles begin with the candidate. While Mrs. Clinton has committed to meeting personally with potential super PAC donors, people close to her say she has not yet grappled with the kind of big-donor courting that has framed the early months of the Republican race.
The rich don't put up a lot of money unless they get something in return. For the billionaire Republican donors like the Kochs and Adelson, it is not hard to imagine what kind of return they are expecting on their investment. For starters, the obligatory tax overhaul favorable to the 1% and possibly turning Medicaid over to the states in the form of block grants and then the voucherizing of Medicare; for the Kochs, a gutting of the EPA; for Adelson, war on Iran.

For big Democrat donors what would be the point in gifting tens of millions to a Hillary Super PAC? Marriage equality? It is already here for the most part. Renewable energy? Tom Steyer donated a whopping $74 million in the 2014 election cycle, and what did he get? A Republican landslide. I doorbelled for one of his candidates, a bloodless corporate Dem running for a Seattle suburb statehouse seat. He lost. I'm sure a shrewd hedge-fund investor like Steyer is not going to make the same mistake twice.

Democrats will be in even more trouble if Obama manages to push a fast-tracked Trans-Pacific Partnership through the House of Representatives. Jonathan Weisman has a helpful story, "Obama’s Trade Deal Faces Bipartisan Peril in the House," which summarizes the issues at stake as well as the math in the House. Pelosi has promised only 17 Democrat votes, which means that Boehner will have to deliver 200 from his caucus:
Only 17 Democrats out of 188 have come out in favor of so-called fast-track authority — and many of them are being hounded by labor and environmental groups to change their minds. Opponents of the trade deal say just seven Democrats remain truly undecided.
Representative Nancy Pelosi of California, the minority leader, who has yet to declare her position, has told House Speaker John A. Boehner of Ohio that he will have to produce 200 Republican votes to win the 217 he needs. In other words, she is not promising a single new convert.
“We’re not quite there, but we’re getting close,” said Representative Paul D. Ryan of Wisconsin, chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee and co-author of the trade legislation. But Mr. Obama, he added, “needs to deliver some votes. It’s just that clear.”
The president needs the authority to finish up the Pacific accord, the largest trade deal in a generation, linking 12 nations — including Canada and Chile in the Americas, and Japan and Australia across the Pacific — in a pact that would not just further cut generally low tariffs on goods but also put in place investment rules for roughly 40 percent of the global economy. The White House says, moreover, that the deal is an essential element in America’s strategic posture in Asia vis-à-vis the rising power of China.
Most congressional Democrats are skeptical. They argue that since the North American Free Trade Agreement was approved in 1993, such accords have only hastened the flow of manufacturing jobs overseas and pressured wages downward through international competition. Corporations, their executives and shareholders have prospered, but globalization has helped hollow out the middle class, many Democrats say.
For a helpful, easy-to-digest synopsis of just how bad the TPP is, check out Amy Goodman's recent interview of Julian Assange. TPP is not a trade agreement so much as it is a financial treaty binding the signatory nations together in fealty to neoliberalism.

Democrats who support Obama on TPP are looking at a primary challenge in 2016. Competition is something politicians loath.

If TPP passes the damage will be immense. Groups that represent mass constituencies essential to electing Democrats will not be able to mobilize their members. The GOP will win in a landslide.

Monday, November 10, 2014

U.S. Business Decries Chinese for Enforcement of Antitrust Law

After a blissful 21-hours away from the Internet, a return to the laptop this morning reveals a Gray Lady overtaken with stories on the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit underway in Beijing, where a lamed Obama arrives this morning.

According to Mark Landler, "Obama Arrives in China on Trip With Complex Agenda," one of the main goals for Obama in Beijing will be to secure commitment to the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) as well as a new bilateral treaty with China:
Later on Monday, Mr. Obama was to speak to business executives from that group, the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum. He will also meet leaders from 11 countries involved in trying to create the Trans-Pacific Partnership, an ambitious American-led trade pact that would be a central pillar of Mr. Obama’s “strategic pivot” to Asia.

The White House has methodically lowered expectations that a deal will be reached in Beijing. But the fact that Mr. Obama is meeting the other leaders so early in the trip — combined with recent reports of progress in talks with one of the key participants, Japan — has prompted trade analysts to speculate that there could be some kind of a surprise. 
The Trans-Pacific Partnership does not include China, so Mr. Obama’s main commercial proposal for the Chinese will be a new bilateral investment treaty between the countries. Economists said it could be the most significant opening of the Chinese market for American companies since China joined the World Trade Organization in 2001. 
American businesspeople view the treaty as an indicator of how serious Mr. Xi is about overhauling the Chinese economy, after a start that many describe as shaky. It would require the Chinese to open dozens of sensitive markets, some that remained closed to American companies, or required Chinese partners. 
“Optimism is moderating in the American business community,” said John Frisbie, the president of the U.S.-China Business Council. “The reason for that softening is policy uncertainty. What’s the reform policy direction? We’ve seen little tangible impact so far.”
A reason for the moderating optimism in the American business community is the subject of an excellent report today by Keith Bradsher, "No Longer Business as Usual in China." China is using its antimonopoly laws to go after companies, a percentage of which are foreign multinationals, for corruption and price gouging:
While China has long presented unique challenges for businesses, the regulatory and legal environment has been especially perilous in recent months, with authorities pushing companies to cut prices and punishing them with large fines. GlaxoSmithKline, Volkswagen, Chrysler, Mead Johnson, Samsung, Johnson & Johnson and other companies have been hit with multimillion-dollar fines this year, while Microsoft, Daimler and Qualcomm are under investigation. 
Then suddenly, in the last five weeks, there has been a lull in what had been a rapid pace of punishments. The pause has been all the more abrupt because Chinese officials were putting the finishing touches on what seemed likely to be their heaviest penalties yet in the continuing crackdown on monopolistic practices. The target was even identified by Chinese officials at a news conference in mid-September as Qualcomm, which invents and licenses mobile technology.
***
While national and provincial investigators appear to have pressed pause, township governments have quietly stepped up their activities, raiding the local offices of multinationals. 
The townships, which do not have the legal authority to enforce antitrust legislation, are operating under old, vaguely worded laws against price gouging as well as collusion that are still on the books even as China has modernized much of its legal code to embrace more market-oriented principles. The local investigators have been copying large amounts of memos, tax records and financial documents. The more complex documents have then been forwarded to more experienced investigators in provincial capitals.
“We have clients that are investigated by very, very rudimentary teams who have no clue what they are doing,” said an adviser to multinationals who insisted on anonymity because of the legal sensitivity of the cases. Those teams, the adviser said, nonetheless manage to accumulate large quantities of confidential corporate data, sending a shudder through the head offices of the affected multinationals.
It is wonderful to read the squeals of Western corporate chieftains and captains of industry. Where are the hosannas to the rule of law? Of operating in a corruption-free commercial market?

Bradsher's story wonderfully, if unintentionally, highlights Western hypocrisy as it lays out the lax, captive regulatory environment U.S. and European multinationals have grown accustomed to:
Whether the Chinese government is focusing disproportionately on foreign companies is the subject of considerable dispute. 
Foreign business groups calculate that half the recent national and provincial antitrust and collusion penalties have been aimed at multinationals even though they represent a very small share of the Chinese economy. But Chinese officials said in late September that if all collusion penalties assessed by local governments are included, then multinationals are only the targets a tenth of the time. 
Western companies have been taken aback by many procedural aspects of the investigations, which diverge significantly from practices in the United States and Europe. 
Chinese regulators have been pushing through antitrust cases in a few weeks, giving companies little chance to respond. In the United States, they take two years or more.
China also does not have clear rules on whether investigators need warrants to search offices or whether executives are entitled to lawyers, particularly foreign lawyers. So many companies have been raided that the European Union Chamber of Commerce in China has organized a conference for executives in Beijing on Nov. 21 titled, “Dawn Raids in China — How to avoid and answer a sudden knock at your door?” 
Antitrust authorities in China also routinely share evidence with other agencies, including tax collectors. The information, which generally cannot be shared among agencies in the United States, has opened up new avenues for potential cases. 
People’s Daily, the official newspaper of the Communist Party, devoted nearly an entire page on Oct. 13 to accusing foreign corporations of diverting large profits out of the country without paying taxes on them — a complaint sometimes levied against multinationals in the United States and Europe.
Yuan Shuhong, the deputy director of the legislative affairs office of China’s State Council, or cabinet, said at a news conference in Beijing on Thursday that China planned to enact an administrative procedures law to require that due process and other legal norms be followed during government regulatory actions. But the law may take considerable time to draft and approve, he warned.  
Some lawyers contend that the Chinese government is simply looking to create a robust regulatory framework and stamp out corruption. Chinese government agencies “are becoming more and more sophisticated, and confident in launching investigations against foreign companies,” said Michael Gu, an antimonopoly specialist at the AnJie Law Firm. 
To others, the legal cases are signs that the government’s growing nationalism — already evident in state-run media and China’s contentious relationships with neighboring countries — extends to economic policy as well. Critics contend China is going beyond the spirit, and possibly the letter, of the free-trade rules of the World Trade Organization, even though China, as the world’s largest exporter, has been the biggest beneficiary of the W.T.O. 
“China should be out there in the front trying to make W.T.O. rules stronger, not undermining them,” said Susan C. Schwab, who was the United States trade representative from 2006 to 2009. “But I don’t get the sense there is anyone in Beijing making that case, because you’ve got a very self-absorbed focus on industrial policy coming out of parts of the government.” 
China’s assertive stance has created a dilemma for the United States and other trading partners. While they are reluctant to defend companies that may have bribed officials or colluded with competitors, they are also unsettled by China’s insistence that companies cut prices for products or otherwise hamper business. The Obama administration has ended up saying little publicly even as American business leaders have fumed. 
“We have been in regular contact with U.S. companies on a range of issues that may affect the business climate in China and want to ensure foreign firms are not singled out for Anti-Monopoly Law investigations and are treated fairly by Chinese enforcers,” Matt McAlvanah, the chief spokesman for the Office of the United States Trade Representative, said in a written reply to questions. “The U.S. has had longstanding discussions with the Chinese government on antimonopoly law and we will continue this engagement.” 
Advocates of a more confrontational trade strategy have criticized the administration for not taking a more public stance. They point to various potential tools, like threatening to limit China’s access to the American market.
So there you have it. Really all you need to know. The U.S. Trade Representative is being lobbied, with requests to threaten a trade war, to punish China for cracking down on corruption in its marketplace. I'm sure American consumers would love government action to cut prices; we just know not to expect it.

Andre Vltchek had a terrific piece, "‘Pro-Democracy Protests’ in Hong Kong," this past weekend on the Counterpunch web site. Vltchek travels to Hong Kong and talks to the Umbrella Movement protesters at the various occupation sites. He finds a lot of bourgeois youth hopped up on the Western media with little understanding of their role in the U.S.-backed color revolution scheme.

What Vltchek's story also accomplishes is an appraisal of China that is not predisposed to see it as a growing evil dragon biding its time until it can gobble up the peaceful democratic West:
For years, Western propaganda has tried to convince the world that China is actually ‘not communist’, not even socialist. A highly successful communist nation would be the worst nightmare to the Empire; it would torpedo Western dogma about the ideological victory over non-capitalist and non-imperialist forms of government. 
So far, the propaganda has been extremely successful. If people were asked in Berlin, London or Paris, many would make ludicrous statements that ‘China is more capitalist than many openly capitalist countries.’
By provoking China, directly and through its client states like Japan, Philippines and South Korea, the West hopes that the big dragon will eventually lose its patience, will snap, and consequently gain a reputation as a highly aggressive creature. That could, in turn, ‘justify’ another arms race, perhaps even a direct conflict with China.
The more socialist China becomes, the more the West panics. And China is becoming increasingly socialist: by maintaining the central planning system, by holding in state hands its key industries, by commanding the private sector what to produce, or by declaring that if the people would not be given free medical care and free education, the country would lose its right to call itself communist. The more public parks are built, the more high-speed trains and urban subway lines, as well as theaters and cultural centers, the more terrified the West becomes.
Now the revanchist students in Hong Kong admit that China (PRC) actually is a communist nation, but from their lips comes something extremely negative. And they declare openly how much they hate communism.
It all goes really well in the West, because China, together with Russia, Venezuela and Iran, are on the top ‘hit list’.
Protests in Hong Kong surely came in at an extremely opportune time, for the Empire.
Although China is acting with tremendous restraint (much greater than the US, France or UK have shown towards their own protesters), it has become a target of yet another smear campaign in the Western mass media outlets.

Sunday, November 9, 2014

Chinese Editorial Correctly Diagnoses Obamaism in 12 Short Paragraphs

Yesterday reading Mark Landler's "To China, Shift in Obama’s Political Fortunes Eclipses U.S. Economic Gains" I stumbled across this wonderful passage:
China’s state media has been unforgiving about Mr. Obama’s political travails. “Obama always utters ‘Yes, we can,’ which led to the high expectations people had for him,” said The Global Times, an English-language website affiliated with People’s Daily, the official Communist Party newspaper, in a postelection editorial. “But he has done an insipid job, offering nearly nothing to his supporters. U.S. society has grown tired of his banality.” 
The timing of the editorial, just a few days before Mr. Obama’s arrival in Beijing, was unusual. But it reflects a broader nationalist strain in China, embodied by Mr. Xi, who has consolidated his power and displayed few signs of conciliation toward Mr. Obama on thorny issues like Chinese cyberattacks on American companies.
Obama is traveling to Beijing for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. We all need to be very concerned about the TPP getting greased through the newly empowered Republican Congress.

I tracked down The Global Times editorial quoted in Landler's piece through a link in a USA Today story. The complete editorial, which appeared Wednesday after the GOP rout of the Democrats, is actually balanced, as you can see below. It acknowledges the hurdles for Obama -- racism and increased partisanship -- and gives him credit for his prudence.

Nonetheless, the editorial knocks it out of the park when it says "[H]e has done an insipid job, offering nearly nothing to his supporters. U.S. society has grown tired of his banality,” or "Obama's best performance is empty rhetoric, while he achieved nothing on issues such as lowering the income gap. The American people have not benefited from the economic recovery."

Sometimes one's adversary can offer the most candid appraisal.
Midterm result will further thwart Obama
Source:Global Times Published: 2014-11-5 0:18:02 
The US midterm elections kicked off Tuesday. The overall situation does not favor President Barack Obama. In the Republican-controlled House of Representatives, Democrat seats are likely to decrease. The Republicans also aim for a big change in the Senate so as to control both houses of Congress. If so, the lame-duck president will be further crippled.
US public opinion has downgraded Obama. Former president George W. Bush met with criticism due to his failure in the war on terror.
Obama always utters "Yes, we can," which led to the high expectations people had for him. But he has done an insipid job, offering nearly nothing to his supporters. US society has grown tired of his banality.
Undoubtedly, Obama is one of the post-Cold War presidents who had to undergo difficult times. He has encountered the global financial crisis and the decline of US influence. He has found many thorny problems because he is the first African-American president in history. As a result, he can only get limited tolerance and acceptance. 
Obama has behaved much more prudently than most of his predecessors, and has thus lacked the ability to push forward complicated issues. What's worse, Obama is in the midst of a time when partisan politics is becoming more extreme. 
That party interests are placed higher than the interests of the country and its people is an inherent shortcoming of Western political systems. The problem is particularly acute when the US undergoes difficulties. Cohesion in American society is diminishing.  
Obama's best performance is empty rhetoric, while he achieved nothing on issues such as lowering the income gap. The American people have not benefited from the economic recovery.
In foreign policy, Obama must also take his share of the blame. He has managed to take US troops out of Iraq and Afghanistan, but left no peace. Osama Bin Laden was killed during his tenure, but the IS has emerged from the Middle East.  
Moreover, the Ukrainian crisis has almost brought Europe back to the Cold War era, and his pivot to Asia strategy only increased mistrust between China and the US and among East Asian countries. 
The US public used to speak highly of Obama, but now many seem to have reversed their opinions. Bush, who dared to do everything, and Obama, who dares to do nothing, come from different parties but have the same destiny. Is this their problem or the problem of the US system?
Renowned scholar Francis Fukuyama believes it is due to dysfunction in the US system. But many others do not. They believe their country only needs a new president.

With China's rise, we gradually have the ability to have a clear understanding of the US. The country is too lazy to reform. US society selected Obama, but there is no great American president in this era.

Thursday, February 6, 2014

Edsall on the TPP

I mentioned yesterday in my description of marching downtown with a mass of Seahawks fans for the Super Bowl victory parade how it reminded me of the 1999 Seattle WTO protests in terms of the sheer number of people. It turns out another momentous round of trade negotiations is currently being conducted. Popularly known by the acronym "TPP," which stands for the Trans-Pacific Partnership, it is a proposed trade agreement between 12 nations. 

If you have heard about the TPP most likely it has been negative. The negotiations have been conducted under a cloak of secrecy with even members of Congress having difficulty finding out what is on the table. What has leaked out is not good. A massive increase in intellectual property rights, a.k.a., corporate control of information, as well as a loss of net neutrality.

Yesterday the august Thomas Edsall devoted his online New York Times opinion column to the TPP. For a one-stop primer on the TPP in particular and multilateral trade agreements in general check out "Free Trade Disagreement."

I know I rave on about Thomas Edsall's columns. What I find so amazing about them is that they provide a Noam Chomsky or Ralph Nader perspective, delivered in the sober tones of an accomplished, establishment reporter, nestled right in the Gray Lady's bosom. Read the last few paragraphs of Edsall's piece and ask yourself how this differs from a Trotskyite Socialist:
On Sept. 8 last year, Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts declared in a speech to the AFL-CIO: 
“Why are trade deals secret? I’ve heard people actually say that they have to be secret because if the American people knew what was going on, they would be opposed. Think about that.” 
Warren is right. Trade negotiations have, in fact, become so wide in scope, with so many losers and winners, that negotiations cannot be conducted in the open. 
The case of trade reflects a larger shift in the balance of power. As multinational or “stateless” capital diminishes the sovereignty of individual countries, including the United States, and strengthens the autonomy of international corporations, it weakens the already fragile economic security of millions of out-of-work Americans. Their plight appears to be unheeded in the world of “advisory committees.” One can only fear what comes next.