Showing posts with label Zacarias Moussaoui. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Zacarias Moussaoui. Show all posts

Friday, August 26, 2016

Scott Shane's "Saudis and Extremism": Mostly More of the Same

Now, because of the cumulative stresses of work, that I have abandoned almost entirely the discipline of waking up at 4:00 a.m. to read the newspaper and then record a few comments here, I wonder how I was able to do it for more than three years.

Reading Scott Shane's lengthy "Secrets of the Kingdom" expose, "Saudis and Extremism: ‘Both the Arsonists and the Firefighters’," was truly enervating. Shane, who appeared in cameo on The Wire's final season, is usually given edgy assignments by "the newspaper of record." He lays out everything we basically already know about the House of Saud's export of Wahhabism worldwide.

If you have a half hour, I'd say the story is worth your time, if only because it establishes how Saudi Wahhabism is suffocating local, multi-sect, tolerant, syncretic Islam. War promises to be an ever-expanding reality.

But Shane blunts the impact of the piece by regularly spicing his reporting with caveats from Saudi-friendly academics and diplomats that there is little or no evidence that Salafist violence is directly linked to Saudi charitable support for Wahhabism. The overall effect is to create a blur, an "Oh, it is all so complex. We'll never know for sure. The poor Saudi royals are such easy targets."

Shane never references his past reporting connecting the Saudis to 9/11 and Al Qaeda, nor anything about the recent declassification of the 28 pages from the congressional investigation that strongly implicates a Saudi official with aiding 9/11 hijackers.

Monday, February 16, 2015

Moussaoui Bombshell Update

It is Presidents Day today, the last holiday before the long, exhausting march to Memorial Day. In December due to a hamstring injury and a nagging back issue I took most of the month off from exercise. The subsequent loss in conditioning was significant, really catching me off guard. I've been trying to claw my way back since the beginning of the New Year.

With the Chinese New Year, the Year of the Goat, this Thursday, I'm feeling as if I have made some headway. Upper-body strength is returning and my run times are dropping. The Bay to Breakers is three months off, and I think, if I stick with it, I could be in decent enough shape to complete the race with a little bit of dignity.

In any event, today's holiday is going to be spent catching up on reading and taking care of chores. But before I get to that I wanted to comment on the state of play the Moussaoui bombshell is receiving in the nation's press.

As you will recall The New York Times' spook specialist Scott Shane published a story at the beginning of the month detailing new allegations by the 20th 9/11 hijacker Zacarias Moussaoui that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) was involved in planning terror attacks on the United States.

Former Senator Bob Kerrey, who served on the 9/11 Commission, published an opinion piece in the New York Daily News, "Moussaoui, Saudis & the full 9/11 truth: Release the 28-page classified section of a congressional intelligence committee report," a few days after Shane's story calling for Obama to declassify the 28 pages of the "Joint Inquiry into Intelligence Community Activities before and after the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001" that Senator Bob Graham says point to a Saudi role in the attacks.

The day before Kerrey's piece appeared in the Daily News, Shane and Gray Lady colleague Ben Hubbard published a walk-back story which floated the argument that the House of Saud's support for Al Qaeda was a pre-9/11 historical artifact. The Shane-Hubbard article was built out of quotes from establishment academics who expressed skepticism about Moussaoui's claims.

That has been it as far as Moussaoui coverage in the NYT with the exception of a strange story published last week by James Risen fresh from the witness stand in the Jeffrey Sterling whistleblower case. I say strange because in "Terrorist Claims Return Sept. 11 Suit to Spotlight," Risen never once mentions the name of the lead law firm, Cozen O'Connor, in the 9/11 litigation against KSA; he mentions the Cozen O'Connor partner, Sean Carter, who is point-man for the suit, but not the law firm itself. Bizarre, an omission that I would think had to be intentional:
Last week, though, the case drew headlines when lawyers for the families disclosed that Zacarias Moussaoui, a former Qaeda operative now in federal prison, had told them that members of Saudi Arabia’s royal family had been major donors to the terrorist organization in the late 1990s. 
While those claims were quickly challenged by some foreign policy experts and rejected by Saudi officials, the assertions helped bring the once-simmering issue of possible Saudi involvement in the 9/11 attacks back into public view and renewed awareness of the lawsuit, which has occupied the federal court docket for almost the entire 21st century. 
“When I began this, I would never have guessed that I would have spent so much of my legal career on one case,” said Sean Carter, a lawyer for plaintiffs in the case. “There are times when it is exhausting, but everyone is committed to see it through.”
Risen traces the origin of the claim against al-Saud to a larger than life, now deceased Southern attorney name Ron Motley:
[Sean Carter] and other lawyers continue to steer the Motley lawsuit and a series of others that have been consolidated into one giant legal action in federal court in Manhattan. 
Over the years, the case has suffered so many delays and false starts, endured so many ups and downs, that it has sometimes been compared to Jarndyce v. Jarndyce, the endless legal drama at the heart of Charles Dickens’s “Bleak House.” The case has also provoked strange questions about whether some investigators hired by the lawyers for the victims’ families were also working for the American government on unrelated intelligence operations at the same time. Those questions led to a secret investigation by the Justice Department’s inspector general into the relationship between the investigators and the F.B.I.
When they began their legal campaign against the Saudis in the heated aftermath of Sept. 11, Mr. Motley and other lawyers adopted a shotgun approach, naming hundreds of institutions and individuals as defendants. Today, some lawyers involved in the case acknowledge that that approach was a mistake, because it led to wasted years of procedural fights as many of the defendants sought to be removed from the case. 
“Turn the clock back 13 years, I would have preferred a more focused case,” said Jim Kreindler, one of the lawyers for the Sept. 11 families. “But we stayed alive.”
Many of the original defendants succeeded in getting dismissed from the case — including the Saudi government and members of the royal family, who argued that they were protected by the doctrine of foreign sovereign immunity, which grants recognized nations immunity from the reach of American courts.
But after the government and royal family members were dismissed in 2005, lawyers for the plaintiffs appealed, beginning a lengthy legal war to get them brought back in. Finally, in 2013, an appeals court reversed its own decision and ruled that the victims’ families could pursue their case against the Saudi government.
The ruling did not extend to the individual members of the Saudi royal family who had been dismissed, but it still gave the lawsuit new life and a new focus, with far fewer defendants.
“We started with five or six hundred defendants, including governments of several countries — it was painted with a broad brush in the beginning,” Mr. Kreindler said. “Now it is primarily focused on the government of Saudi Arabia.”
But the Saudi government is fighting back, and is scrambling once again to be removed from the case. The Moussaoui statements were filed with the court by the lawyers for the 9/11 families as part of a larger response to the Saudi government’s latest motion for dismissal.
Mr. Kreindler estimated that the continuing fight over whether the Saudi government should stay in the lawsuit could take yet another three years, as the issue winds its way once more through the legal system. He predicted it could end up before the Supreme Court, which has already dealt with the case three times, twice declining to hear appeals from the plaintiffs and once declining to hear an appeal from the defendants, according to lawyers involved in the case.
The lawyers for the families now hope Congress will short-circuit the process by passing legislation that would prevent the doctrine of foreign sovereign immunity from protecting countries that provide support to terrorism.
After several lawsuits were consolidated in Federal District Court in New York in 2003, the giant case was given to Judge Richard Conway Casey, the nation’s first blind federal trial judge, and after his death in 2007, the case was transferred to Judge George Daniels. In 2010, lawyers for the Sept. 11 families filed to have Judge Daniels removed from the case because he was too slow, but the effort failed.
By far the most mysterious episode in the case revolves around some of the investigators Mr. Motley brought in to investigate Saudi Arabia. Working through a small investigative firm called Rosetta Research and Consulting, which was formed to work on the case, some of the investigators also became involved in operations with the F.B.I. and later the Drug Enforcement Administration. Most notably, they were involved in an operation to lure an Afghan drug lord to the United States. In 2005, they persuaded the Afghan, Haji Bashir Noorzai, to go to New York, where he was arrested by the Drug Enforcement Administration. He has since been convicted and sentenced to life in prison.
The role of the investigators from the Sept. 11 lawsuit in the Noorzai operation was baffling and embarrassing to many top officials in the government, and the connections between the investigators and the F.B.I. prompted an investigation by the Justice Department’s inspector general, which never made its findings public. Mr. Motley and his firm, Motley Rice, ultimately cut their ties, and Rosetta collapsed.
Today, the lawyers for the Sept. 11 families have seen so many changes of fortune that they are careful not to describe Mr. Moussaoui’s statements as a breakthrough. But in carefully chosen words of optimism, the lawyers do describe the new statements as adding to the evidence they need to make their case.
Risen does at least clarify that the Saudi royals have been dismissed from the case, something of which I wasn't aware. But there is really no distinction between the Saudi royals and the government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. They are one and the same. The distinction between the two is merely a legal fiction.

Risen's introduction of the whole Rosetta Research and Consulting Noorzai operation is interesting but beside the point. It adds a tangent, a Hitchcockian McGuffin that takes the reader away from the main story at the heart of Cozen O'Connor, which Chris Mondics of the Philadelphia Inquirer once again ably puts forth in Sunday's "City firm presses 9/11 case: Cozen suit, alleging a high Saudi role, has moved in fits and starts for years":
"The case is about whether Saudi government agents in the United States and elsewhere aided the Sept. 11 hijackers and supported al-Qaeda," said Sean Carter, a partner at the Center City law firm of Cozen O'Connor, who deposed Moussaoui. 
"An array of evidence points a strong finger at officials stationed in the Islamic Affairs offices of the Saudi Embassy in Washington, D.C., and the consulate in Los Angeles. If any Saudi official had a role in 9/11, we need and deserve to know about it."
***
Moussaoui's allegation that he plotted with a Saudi government employee to shoot down Air Force One is important because the Cozen lawyers allege the 9/11 attackers received support from other Saudi government operatives in advance of the attacks. 
A central allegation of the lawsuit is that hijackers Nawaf al-Hazmi and Khalid al-Mihdhar met with a Saudi government employee shortly after they arrived in Southern California in February 2000, and that the employee, Omar al-Bayoumi, helped them get settled, finding them an apartment and occasionally paying their rent.
Mihdhar and Hazmi later became part of the five-member team that crashed American Airlines Flight 77 into the Pentagon, after taking off from Washington's Dulles International Airport.
Former Florida Sen. Bob Graham, who chaired the Senate intelligence committee after the attacks, has said that he believes Bayoumi was a Saudi government agent, that he provided assistance to the hijackers, and that he was "acting at the direction of elements of the Saudi government."
Bayoumi also had dealings during this time with an employee of the Saudi Consulate in Los Angeles named Fahad al-Thumairy, who was later expelled from the United States. 
A central claim in the 9/11 lawsuit is that Saudi radicals with diplomatic credentials helped promote al-Qaeda's jihadist goals in the U.S. and abroad. Some 16 employees of the Saudi Embassy in Washington, who worked in the ministry of Islamic affairs, were expelled from the U.S. in 2003, the lawsuit points out.
The latest filings in the lawsuit also cite an FBI analysis of Bayoumi's phone records, which show that he made dozens of telephone calls to the Saudi Embassy in Washington, the Saudi Consulate in Los Angeles, and other Saudi entities from January through March of 2000, around the time Bayoumi was helping Hazmi and Mihdhar get settled in San Diego.
Imagine if there was a fraction of evidence that pointed to Iran, Venezuela or Russia being involved in 9/11. The United States invaded and destroyed Iraq based on even less proof of foul play.

Monday, February 9, 2015

Prestige Press Black Out of 9/11 Lawsuit Against Saudi Arabia: If This Isn't Evidence of a Cover-Up, What Is?

What I find extremely strange about last week's story by Scott Shane, "Moussaoui Calls Saudi Princes Patrons of Al Qaeda," is that I had no knowledge of the lawsuit filed against Saudi Arabia by the families of 9/11 victims and insurers who were left on the hook for damages which prompted the interview of Moussaoui at his supermax federal prison in Colorado. I say strange because having read The New York Times daily for the better part of two decades there is little chance I could have missed this story, the only chance being if it had consistently been buried in the back pages of the Business section.

So I did a search of "Cozen O'Connor," the lead law firm in the suit alleging Saudi Arabia played a key role in the 9/11 attacks, on The New York Times web site. A lot of articles pop up -- wedding announcements, a list of top Obama fundraisers, Bernie Madoff and sundry other corporate litigation -- as befits a nationwide law firm, but nothing other than Scott Shane's story from last week mentions the 9/11 suit against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

Intrigued, I did searches for "Cozen O'Connor" on The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post web sites. Nothing. Well, I should say, plenty of stories, but nothing that I could find that relates to Cozen's lawsuit against the Saudis. (Fortunately, Cozen O'Connor is a unique name, which makes searching relatively simple.)

The only newspaper, that I can tell, which has regularly reported on the 9/11 lawsuit against the Saudis is Cozen O'Connor's hometown paper, The Philadelphia Inquirer. Reporter Chris Mondics has covered the story from the beginning in 2003 when Cozen O'Connor first filed its claim. There have been lots of ups and downs and ins and outs. In 2008 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled that Saudi Arabia could not be the target of a terrorism lawsuit. Only governments designated by USG as supporters of terrorism could be sued (which in itself is proof of a conspiracy since it is accepted as fact that Saudi Arabia is the main sponsor of jihad through its funding of madrassas around the globe). The Second Circuit reversed itself in December of 2013 by reinstating the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia as a defendant. (The reversal was the result of a ruling in another case where the court said a government not officially designated as a sponsor of terrorism could be sued.) The Saudis appealed the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court and the Supreme Court last summer declined to hear it.

Below is a convenient snapshot of the Cozen O'Connot lawsuit which Chris Mondics published in The Inquirer last fall, "Law Review: City firm keeps making case against Saudis and 9/11":
Chris Mondics, Inquirer Staff Writer
Last updated: Wednesday, October 1, 2014, 1:08 AM
Posted: Tuesday, September 30, 2014, 8:44 PM 
Was it all merely a coincidence?
One of the most salient and disturbing facts to emerge within hours of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks was that 15 of the 19 terrorists were from Saudi Arabia.
Without once mentioning Saudi Arabia, President Obama spoke at length last Wednesday before the United Nations about the need to crack down on extremist ideologies emanating from the Middle East.
But 13 years after the attacks, evidence continues to point not only to the involvement of Saudi extremists and terrorism financiers in the 9/11 attacks, but also perhaps to elements of the Saudi government itself.
This point is made chillingly clear in a new filing by Center City lawyers suing the government of Saudi Arabia for the attacks on behalf of the victims, insurers, and others who suffered grievous losses that day.
The lawsuit by Cozen O'Connor has been discounted repeatedly by the Saudis' American lawyers, and by U.S. officials who have sought to quash it or otherwise frustrate efforts by the plaintiffs' lawyers. For years, the administrations of President George W. Bush and Obama have blocked release of a report by Congress that details evidence of involvement in the plot by Saudi government employees.
But the Cozen lawsuit and the latest filing two weeks ago, based on newly acquired information through discovery and Freedom of Information Act requests, are unlikely to go away.
In December, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in Manhattan reinstated Saudi Arabia, a country where convicted criminals are beheaded and women have no right to vote or drive, as a defendant after it had been removed by a trial judge. A trial is beginning to seem more likely in federal district court in Manhattan, which is overseeing the Cozen claim and several other lawsuits seeking compensation for the attacks.
The heart of the new filing, essentially an amended complaint reflecting Saudi Arabia's reinstatement, is the argument that the Saudi royal family, in a bid to retain power, ceded ever greater authority to radical clerics in the early 1980s.
That strategy followed an armed revolt by religious fanatics who briefly took over the Grand Mosque in Mecca, the holiest site in Islam. The attack made clear that the royal family was on thin ice. To compensate, the family gave fundamentalists broad access to government ministries, Islamist charities, and diplomatic missions, enabling them to spread a virulent form of Islam.
One of those diplomatic missions was the Saudi consulate in Los Angeles, where the complaint alleges that a cell of al-Qaeda operatives made preparations for the 9/11 attacks. At the center of this group was a Saudi government employee named Omar al-Bayoumi, who helped two of the hijackers, Nawaf al-Hazmi and Khalid al-Mihdhar, get settled in Southern California after they arrived there in early 2000.
Bayoumi claimed after the World Trade Center attacks that his meeting the hijackers was coincidental. But it is one of a chain of events that appear too improbable to be random.
The key facts unfold on the morning of Feb. 1, 2000, when Bayoumi says he traveled from his home in San Diego to the Saudi consulate in Los Angeles to meet with an official of the Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs named Fahad al-Thumairy.
A few hours later, Bayoumi claims to have met Hazmi and Mihdhar by chance at a nearby Middle Eastern restaurant. Three days later, Bayoumi offered to resettle Hazmi and Mihdhar in San Diego, where he helped them find an apartment and open a bank account.
That same day, Bayoumi made four phone calls to Anwar al-Awlaki, an al-Qaeda recruiter and operative, whose radical preaching had served as inspiration for Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan, the Fort Hood shooter, according to an FBI memorandum acquired by the Cozen firm.
Awlaki's inglorious career as a top-level terrorist ended on Sept. 30, 2011, when he was killed in a strike by two U.S. Predator drones in Yemen. Bayoumi had earlier returned to Saudi Arabia. Former Sen. Bob Graham (D., Fla.), the cochair of the Congressional Joint Inquiry into the 9/11 attacks and former chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said in an affidavit filed in the Cozen lawsuit that Bayoumi likely was a Saudi agent and that both he and Thumairy, who was banned from the United States by the State Department in 2003, were working with the hijackers.
"Just as a matter of coincidence, you would have less of a chance running into that many people with links to terrorism in Afghanistan on Sept. 10, 2001," said Sean Carter, the lead Cozen litigator on the case. 
A similar scenario played out at the Saudi embassy in Berlin, where a diplomat with alleged terrorist ties to Mohammed Fakihi was spotted meeting with 9/11 leader Mohamed Atta and other members of his hijacking team in advance of the attacks, according to the complaint. Fakihi later left the country after German authorities raised questions about his links to terrorist groups.
The Cozen filing makes clear that there is a lot that the American public doesn't yet know about the 9/11 attacks.
Maybe the most important unanswered question is: Will the U.S. and Saudi governments ever fill in the blanks?
The Gray Lady did publish this small letter from Representative Walter B. Jones (Rep.-NC) this past Friday under the title "The Saudis and 9/11":
To the Editor: 
“Terrorist Calls Saudi Princes Qaeda Patrons” (front page, Feb. 4) cites recent statements by Zacarias Moussaoui, a former operative of Al Qaeda now in a federal prison, that expose the financial link between members of the Saudi royal family and Al Qaeda.
The testimony by Mr. Moussaoui is further reason to declassify a 28-page section of the Joint Inquiry report into 9/11. Its contents do not pose a threat to national security but deal with relationships that the George W. Bush administration had before 9/11.
Senator Bob Graham, who led the Joint Inquiry as chairman of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, has made it clear that the 28 pages deal with the relationship between the Saudis and the Bush administration. 
It is time that the American people know the truth about what led to the 9/11 attacks, which is why I, along with five others from both parties, have introduced H.R. 14 to urge President Obama to declassify the 28 pages. 
WALTER B. JONES
Washington 
The writer, a Republican, represents North Carolina’s Third District in the House.

Thursday, February 5, 2015

Follow Up on the Zacarias Moussaoui Bombshell Connecting Saudi Arabia to 9/11

It is encouraging to see The New York Times follow up Scott Shane's "Moussaoui Calls Saudi Princes Patrons of Al Qaeda" with two additional stories today.

Yesterday I monitored Google News to see how much play the Moussaoui bombshell was getting. The answer was not that much. The big news at the top of the page was on the fatal Metro-North Railroad accident in New York and Islamic State's immolation of a caged Jordanian fighter pilot, First Lt. Moaz al-Kasasbeh. I was prepared for the Moussaoui story to be a one-off.

Unfortunately one of the two stories today -- "Pre-9/11 Ties Haunt Saudis as New Accusations Surface," by Ben Hubbard and Scott Shane -- is a pitiful effort by the Gray Lady to walk back, or at least muddy, Shane's original report. I say pitiful because it is constructed out of quotes from establishment academics (Princeton's Bernard Haykel and Texas A & M Bush School of Government's Gregory Gause III, whose universities are likely endowed by Saudi money), Saudi royalty and former U.S. ambassador to Saudi Arabia Charles Freeman all casting doubt on the veracity of Moussaoui's claim that key members of the Saudi royal family with critical positions in the Kingdom backed the 9/11 attacks.

Where is an outline of the case against Saudi Arabia that the families of the 9/11 victims are pursuing? That is what should be addressed in this follow up because it is civil suit that has not be reported on extensively. We get plenty of stories about Jewish families going after Hamas and Iran in civil court for backing terrorism but very little about the great white whale of international jihad, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

The gist of the Hubbard and Shane walk back is that, yes, the Saudis supported the mujahedeen in Afghanistan, along with the U.S. government, and these mujahedeen morphed into Al Qaeda, But the Saudis cut their ties with Al Qaeda.

For a sample of the quality of the walk back there is this quote from Princeton's Haykel:
By 1994, when Osama bin Laden was stripped of his Saudi citizenship and banned from the kingdom, the Qaeda founder was “writing nonstop against the Saudi regime with the idea of toppling it,” said Bernard Haykel, professor of Near Eastern studies at Princeton. “That the Saudis would knowingly support a movement that sought to destroy them makes no sense to me.”
I guess a prestigious perch at an Ivy League university blinds an intellectual like Haykel to the possibility that Saudis might support Al Qaeda with the understanding that its targets will be first and foremost the "Far Enemy."

In any case, Hubbard and Shane have a tough pull on their hands. Piles of evidence point to the Saudis. Everyone knows it, accepts it as an existential reality. The story even acknowledges a continuation of the pattern today with Saudis funding fighters in Libya and Syria:
. . . American officials have praised the Saudi government for cracking down on militants inside the kingdom and for acting to stop terrorist financing by Saudi citizens. But the kingdom has continued to support militant groups other than Al Qaeda and armed tribes that it sees as advancing its policies in Libya, Syria and elsewhere. And at home, the kingdom’s traditional religious establishment promotes and enforces a strict interpretation of Islam.
The point of the Hubbard and Shane walk back is to muddy the waters, float the narrative that Saudi support for Al Qaeda was a historical artifact that preceded 9/11 (even though there is a paragraph in the piece built around a quote from Ambassador Freeman that states the Saudis didn't seriously change their thinking on Al Qaeda until 2003 when there were Qaeda-linked bombings in the Kingdom) as well as cast doubt on Zacarias Moussaoui.

The second story today on the Saudi connection to 9/11 is by the reliable Carl Hulse ("Claims Against Saudis Cast New Light on Secret Pages of 9/11 Report") and focuses on the long, strange history of the national security classification of the 28 pages classified 13 years ago obviously finger the Saudis as the funding source for the 9/11 attacks -- former Florida Senator Bob Graham has said as much. And Obama has promised family members of 9/11 victims that he will release section 4, but he never has. The reason? Pressure for some sort of action against the House of Saud would be hard to resist. Why not some fianancial sanctions? We have plenty levied against Iran and Iran didn't attack us on 9/11.

Another reason is that the U.S. doesn't want to stop funding for jihad as this has replaced the Cold War as the primary rationale for its globe-straddling militarism. As one of plaintiffs in the civil suit against the Saudis explains:
WASHINGTON — A still-classified section of the investigation by congressional intelligence committees into the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks has taken on an almost mythic quality over the past 13 years — 28 pages that examine crucial support given the hijackers and that by all accounts implicate prominent Saudis in financing terrorism. 
Now new claims by Zacarias Moussaoui, a convicted former member of Al Qaeda, that he had high-level contact with officials of the Saudi Arabian government in the prelude to Sept. 11 have brought renewed attention to the inquiry’s withheld findings, which lawmakers and relatives of those killed in the attacks have tried unsuccessfully to declassify. 
“I think it is the right thing to do,” said Representative Stephen F. Lynch, Democrat of Massachusetts and an author of a bipartisan resolution encouraging President Obama to declassify the section. “Let’s put it out there.”

White House officials say the administration has undertaken a review on whether to release the pages but has no timetable for when they might be made public.
Mr. Lynch and his allies have been joined by former Senator Bob Graham of Florida, who as chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee was a leader of the inquiry. He has called for the release of the report’s Part 4, which dealt with Saudi Arabia, since President George W. Bush ordered it classified when the rest of the report was released in December 2002.
Mr. Graham has repeatedly said it shows that Saudi Arabia was complicit in the Sept. 11 attacks. “The 28 pages primarily relate to who financed 9/11, and they point a very strong finger at Saudi Arabia as being the principal financier,” Mr. Graham said last month as he pressed for the pages to be made public.
Relatives of those killed on Sept. 11 as well as plaintiffs in a federal lawsuit against Saudi Arabia have also demanded that the pages be made public, seeing them as the vital link that they believe connects an important ally of the United States to the deadly attacks. They say the pages, Part 4 of the report, could also help in determining the source of current funding for terrorist activities.
“If we stop funding of terrorism and hold those people accountable, wouldn’t it make a dent in the financing of terrorism today?” asked William Doyle, whose son, Joseph, was killed in the World Trade Center. Mr. Doyle said that President Obama personally assured him after the death of Osama bin Laden that he would declassify that section of the report.
Proponents of releasing Part 4, titled “Finding, Discussion and Narrative Regarding Certain National Security Matters,” have suggested that the Bush and Obama administrations have held it back for fear of alienating an influential military and economic partner rather than for any national security consideration.
I don't see how section 4 can remain classified now. To keep it classified with a presidential campaign fast approaching would require a great deal of political capital, something the Democrats don't have. I would imagine what will happen is that there will be more attacks on Moussaoui, more muddying and prevarication in the prestige press, high profile senators will eventually stand on their hind legs and voice support for their paymasters in the Kingdom, and Obama will grudgingly release the 28-pages, possibly at date designated after the 2016 election, in a highly redacted form.

***CORRECTION***

Originally I said that the 28 classified pages are part of the 9/11 Commission Report. That is incorrect. The 28 classified pages are part of the "Joint Inquiry into Intelligence Community Activities before and after the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001," which Senator Bob Graham co-chaired.

Tuesday, February 3, 2015

A Vindication of the Obvious: Moussaoui Fingers King Salman

Scott Shane has this bombshell posted on the Gray Lady web site within the last hour, "Moussaoui Calls Saudi Princes Patrons of Al Qaeda":
WASHINGTON — In highly unusual testimony inside the federal supermax prison, a former operative for Al Qaeda has described prominent members of Saudi Arabia’s royal family as major donors to the terrorist network in the late 1990s and claimed that he discussed a plan to shoot down Air Force One with a Stinger missile with a staff member at the Saudi Embassy in Washington.
The Qaeda member, Zacarias Moussaoui, has received a diagnosis of mental illness but was found competent to stand trial on terrorism charges. He was sentenced to life in prison in 2006 and is held in the most secure prison in the federal system, in Florence, Colo.
Last year, he wrote to Judge George B. Daniels of United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, who is presiding over a lawsuit filed against Saudi Arabia by relatives of those killed in the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. He said he wanted to testify in the case, and after lengthy negotiations with Justice Department officials and the federal Bureau of Prisons, a team of lawyers was permitted to enter the prison and question him for two days last October.
In a statement Monday night, the Saudi Embassy noted that the national Sept. 11 commission had rejected allegations that the Saudi government or Saudi officials had funded Al Qaeda.
“Moussaoui is a deranged criminal whose own lawyers presented evidence that he was mentally incompetent,” the statement said. “His words have no credibility.”
The allegations from Mr. Moussaoui come at a sensitive time in Saudi-American relations, less than two weeks after the death of the country’s longtime monarch, King Abdullah, and the succession of his brother, King Salman.
There has often been tension between Saudi leaders and the Obama administration since the Arab uprisings of 2011 and the efforts to manage the region’s resulting turmoil. Mr. Moussaoui describes meeting in Saudi Arabia with Salman, then the crown prince, and other Saudi royals while delivering them letters from Osama bin Laden.
There has long been evidence that wealthy Saudis provided support for bin Laden, the son of a Saudi construction magnate, and Al Qaeda before the 2001 attacks. Saudi Arabia had worked closely with the United States to finance Islamic militants fighting the Soviet Army in Afghanistan in the 1980s, and Al Qaeda drew its members from militant fighters.
But the extent and nature of Saudi involvement in Al Qaeda, and whether it extended to the planning and financing of the Sept. 11 attacks, has long been a subject of dispute.
Mr. Moussaoui’s testimony, if judged credible, provides new details of the extent and nature of that support in the pre-9/11 period. In more than 100 pages of testimony, filed in federal court in New York on Monday, he comes across as calm and largely coherent, though the plaintiffs’ lawyers questioning him do not challenge his statements.
“My impression was that he was of completely sound mind — focused and thoughtful,” said Sean P. Carter, a Philadelphia lawyer with Cozen O’Connor who participated in the deposition on behalf of the plaintiffs. He said that the lawyers needed to get a special exemption from the “special administrative measures” that keep many convicted terrorists in federal prisons from communicating with outsiders.
The French-born Mr. Moussaoui was detained weeks before Sept. 11 on immigration charges in Minnesota, so he was incarcerated at the time of the attacks. Earlier in 2001, he had taken flying lessons and was wired $14,000 by a Qaeda cell in Germany, evidence that he might have been preparing to become one of the hijackers.
Prince Turki al-Faisal, formerly a Saudi spy chief, who a former Qaeda operative said was on a list of the group’s donors. Credit: Mandel Ngan/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
He said in the prison deposition that he was directed in 1998 or 1999 by Qaeda leaders in Afghanistan to create a digital database of donors to the group. Among those he said he recalled listing in the database were Prince Turki al-Faisal, then the Saudi intelligence chief; Prince Bandar Bin Sultan, the longtime Saudi ambassador to the United States; Prince al-Waleed bin Talal, a prominent billionaire investor; and many of the country’s leading clerics.
“Sheikh Osama wanted to keep a record who give money,” he said in imperfect English — “who is to be listened to or who contributed to the jihad.”
Mr. Moussaoui said he acted as a courier for Bin Laden, carrying personal messages to prominent Saudi princes and clerics. And he described his training in Qaeda camps in Afghanistan in preparation for various proposed plots.
He helped conduct a trial explosion of a 750-kilogram bomb as a trial run for a planned truck-bomb attack on the American Embassy in London, he said, using the same weapon used in the Qaeda attacks in 1998 on the American Embassies in Kenya and Tanzania. He also studied the possibility of staging attacks with crop-dusting aircraft.
In addition, Mr. Moussaoui said, “We talk about the feasibility of shooting Air Force One.”
Specifically, he said, he had met an official of the Islamic Affairs Department of the Saudi Embassy in Washington when the Saudi official visited Kandahar. “I was supposed to go to Washington and go with him” to “find a location where it may be suitable to launch a Stinger attack and then, after, be able to escape,” he said.
He said he was arrested before being able to carry out the reconnaissance mission.
Mr. Moussaoui’s behavior at his trial in 2006 was sometimes erratic. He tried to fire his own lawyers, who presented evidence that he suffered from serious mental illness. But Judge Leonie M. Brinkema, who presided, declared that she was “fully satisfied that Mr. Moussaoui is completely competent” and called him “an extremely intelligent man.”
“He has actually a better understanding of the legal system than some lawyers I’ve seen in court,” she said.
Mr. Carter, the plaintiffs’ lawyer, said that he and his colleagues hoped to return to the Colorado prison to conduct additional questioning of Mr. Moussaoui and that they had been told by prison officials it would be permitted. “We are confident he has more to say,” Mr. Carter said.
I'm sure Moussaoui will be dismissed as insane. Nonetheless, more loss of credibility for the state when they deny yet again the obvious -- that the Saudis maintain the jihadis -- ISIS, Al Qaeda, you name them -- and we play along so we can keep the warfare state forever up and running.

Watch as bought and sold Senators from both sides of the aisle rush to defend the Kingdom -- first the most corrupt, Bob Menendez; then Bob Corker. Thank goodness for the families of the 9/11 victims and their lawyers. If USG actively moves to suppress this based on national security or some other nonsense, we're looking at a total collapse of public support, what little of it there is left, for federal authority. Then we will be that much closer to Egypt.