Showing posts with label Arseniy Yatsenyuk. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arseniy Yatsenyuk. Show all posts

Monday, April 11, 2016

From Otpor! and Tamarod to Today

I went to bed last night thinking about Egypt. I arrived there in my mind after reading a piece that appeared on the TomDispatch web site at the beginning of last month. "Three Times When the World Broke Open -- and Two When It Might Again: In Praise of Impractical Movements," by Mark Engler and Paul Engler, is a refutation of gradualism in politics, where change is engineered in piecemeal fashion by consensus of ruling elites, in favor of sudden paradigm shift powered by the ruled masses.

Nothing to argue with there. The problem I had with the essay was one of the three examples of nonviolent change offered as proof of the potency of spontaneous revolt. The Englers applaud the Serbian student group Otpor! for sparking the movement that removed Slobodan Milosevic from power in October 2000 (what is commonly classed as a color revolution though it is named after a bulldozer), something that the military might of NATO was unable to achieve the prior year. But it is well established that Otpor! received substantial assistance from the U.S. government, including training in nonviolent resistance.

This brought to mind Tamarod, the youth-led Egyptian protest movement that purportedly collected 22 million signatures calling for early presidential elections and sparked the June 2013 mass demonstrations that prefigured the July 3rd coup. It turns out Tamarod was part of the military takeover all along.

Two stories this morning provide insight into the rough shape of "astroturf" popular uprisings a few years on. The first, "Egypt Gives Saudi Arabia 2 Islands in a Show of Gratitude," by Declan Walsh, describes how the el-Sisi government has signed over two islands at the mouth of the Gulf of Aqaba in exchange for agreements with the Saudis worth billions. The second, "Arseniy Yatsenyuk, Ukraine’s Premier, Quits Amid Splits in Post-Revolution Alliance," by Andrew Kramer, explains how the U.S. has finally eaten its Maidan prodigy, "Yats," forcing him out in favor of the "chocolate king" Poroshenko.

Re-branding coups as popular revolts does not a revolution make. These ersatz rebellions are a ruse to maintain the old, exploitative privileges which motivate the popular uprisings to begin with. It is not a sustainable model for social transformation, to say the least.

Thursday, October 30, 2014

New Cold War to Grow Hot Again?

The New Cold War between Russia and the West seems to be heating up again in Ukraine. Judging by the number of stories this morning in the Gray Lady, informational flagship of U.S. unipolarity, something is afoot.

NATO is squawking about a large presence of Russian military aircraft over the Black, Baltic and North Seas as well as the Atlantic. If one reads to the end of the AP story, "Spike Seen in Russian Military Flights," it seems as if this is more a case of Western fear-mongering than a serious new threat:
Brynjar Stordal, spokesman for the operational command of Norway’s armed forces, said Norwegian F-16s intercepted one formation of Bear bombers and tankers west of Norway. The tankers turned back north, he said, but the bombers kept flying south all the way to international airspace west of Portugal and Spain. 
“We’ve had several of these incidents, around 40 a year,” Mr. Stordal said. “What sets this apart from some of the missions we see from the Russian side is the formation was a little bit larger than we usually see, and they went a bit further south than they usually do.”
Hardly the stuff that merits an entire story or a scary headline.

Then there is the David Jolly story, "France Denies It Agreed to Deliver Mistral-Class Warship to Russia," about France overriding the contractor on delivery of the first of two Mistral-class helicopter carrier warships:
On Wednesday, Mr. Rogozin [deputy prime minister of Russia] posted a photograph on Twitter of what appeared to be an invitation letter to Anatoly Isaikin, the head of Rosoboronexport, from Pierre Legros, a senior vice president in DCNS’s surface ships and naval systems division [the contractor] and a member of the company’s executive board. 
In the letter, Mr. Legros thanks Russia’s Defense Ministry for having accepted a modified delivery date and adds, “Accordingly, it is now my pleasure to invite you personally to this ceremony, which will take place on Nov. 14, 2014, in St.-Nazaire.” 
The day’s itinerary includes “transfer of ownership and delivery act signature on board the Vladivostok.” 
DCNS could not immediately be reached for comment on the Twitter post.
So what is going on?

Several things. For one, Yats, Arseniy Yatsenyuk the prime minister who set off the election that was just completed when he tendered his resignation last summer, is improbably poised -- based on the surprising first-place finish of his People's Front party, edging the Bloc Petro Poroshenko 22.2 percent to 21.8 percent -- to return to the Rada as prime minister. David Herszenhorn has the story, "After Ukraine Vote, a New Test: Burying a Legacy of Dysfunctional Politics."

Let's not forget that Yats is the U.S. man in Kiev, the one memorialized in the famous Victoria Nuland cell-phone "Fuck the EU" intercept as State Department property; he's the one that is going to bring the neoliberal wood to Ukrainian behinds as they say goodbye to fuel subsidies and pension benefits in order to align with European "norms."

All I can say about Yats' miraculous victory is to quote a passage from an earlier Herszenhorn story, "Ukraine President Claims Win for Pro-West Parties." The guy, Yuri Boiko, who led a reformed Party of Regions under the name of "the Opposition Bloc," called the recent parliamentary elections "the dirtiest ever."
The exit polls showed one party that is generally regarded as pro-Russian winning enough votes to clear the threshold for forming a faction in the Parliament. That party, the Opposition Bloc, includes some of Mr. Yanukovych’s former allies with strong ties to the embattled east, and it could ultimately prove crucial to future negotiations with Mr. Putin and to resolving the simmering conflict there. 
The party is led by Yuri Boiko, a former deputy prime minister and energy minister under Mr. Yanukovych. Mr. Boiko also has served as energy minister and was head of the Ukrainian national energy company, Naftogaz, from 2002 to 2005, giving him extensive business dealings with Russia. 
The Opposition Bloc was also heavily supported by Sergiy V. Liovochkin, one of Ukraine’s richest businessmen and a former chief of staff to Mr. Poroshenko. Mr. Liovochkin had a falling out with Mr. Yanukoych over the response to the protests last fall and tried to resign. 
After the polls closed, Mr. Boiko thanked voters, but called the elections “the dirtiest ever.” Ukraine has a long history of corruption and ballot fraud.
 I think it highly likely that Yats bribed and ballot-stuffed his way to first place.

This is all happening against the high-stakes poker of the tripartite -- Russia, Ukraine and EU -- gas talks in Brussels, which apparently have collapsed (Gazprom representatives have flown home to Moscow) over Europe's unwillingness to guarantee Ukraine's loan.

As Professor Nicolai Petro explained to RT:
RT: What about gas agreements? Do you think there are still some points that require discussion? 
NP: No, I don’t because all of the aspects of the gas agreement have been negotiated and agreed to except for the amount of the loan that Ukraine needs to pay for its debt without which Russia will not allow gas to flow, without the amount that it ships being paid for in advance. The decision on that loan, at least as President Putin sees it, is entirely in the hands of European Union, how it wants to negotiate that loan. Clearly, Ukraine does not have the money to pay for it. There is a conceptual understanding and agreement that the EU or some private bank within Europe must provide that loan guarantee until the next IMF tranche comes through. So it is basically entirely in the hands of the EU negotiators at this point.
The U.S./EU appears to be back to playing hardball -- NATO squawking about the menacing Russian bear; trade sanctions reaffirmed; Yats back at the helm -- all that needs to happen is for the Minsk ceasefire protocol, always frail, to be completely rescinded. And there is plenty to argue that is about to happen.

Thursday, September 4, 2014

Putin Predicts Peace Deal to Emerge Tomorrow from Minsk Negotiations

Up here in the Pacific Northwest the autumn chill can already be felt in the mornings. With gas deliveries having been suspended for the entire summer while fighting has raged in the Donbass, I'm sure the change in weather can felt by Ukrainian president Petro Poroshenko.

Putin announced yesterday that a ceasefire agreement will be signed tomorrow in Minsk. Neil MacFarquhar describes what the deal would look like in today's "Putin Lays Out Proposal to End Ukraine Conflict":
In announcing the plan, Mr. Putin said he expected Ukraine and the separatists to wrap up an agreement after a new round of negotiations in Minsk, Belarus, on Friday. Ukraine, Russia and Europe are all party to the talks there, and they include representatives of the separatists. The two-day NATO summit meeting is also scheduled to end Friday. 
Aside from the cease-fire, the plan laid out by Mr. Putin called for Ukrainian artillery to pull back and out of range of the eastern separatists’ strongholds; an end to airstrikes; an exchange of all detainees; opening up humanitarian corridors for residents of the separatist areas; repairing damaged infrastructure; and deploying international observers to monitor the cease-fire. 
It made no mention of autonomy for the separatist eastern regions, the central political demand that Russia has emphasized since March. That is widely seen as critical to the Kremlin’s long-term goal of maintaining influence over Ukraine’s domestic affairs and blocking any future attempt to join NATO. 
Putin's plan made no mention of autonomy for Donetsk and Luhansk because it is unnecessary: a real ceasefire guarantees autonomy for the Donbass. It is the oft quoted "facts on the ground."

After a long phone call with Putin yesterday, Poroshenko declared that a lasting ceasefire agreement had been reached. He then walked it back, saying that the need for a ceasefire was agreed upon.

Likely what happened is that the U.S. nixed the deal. Obama, about to take his "great statesman" star turn at the Cardiff NATO summit, did not want to be upstaged yet again by Putin. A clue to this is the yapping of the neocon miniature terrier nonpareil, junta prime minister Arseniy Yatsenyuk. According to MacFarquhar:
In Kiev, the idea of a cease-fire was received with mixed emotions. 
There is open hostility to the idea that Russia will be able to dictate terms to its weaker neighbor after already wrenching away the Crimean peninsula in March. Any compromise after months of condemning the separatists as “terrorists” risks weakening Mr. Poroshenko in central and western Ukraine. 
Prime Minister Arseniy P. Yatsenyuk called Mr. Putin’s proposal “an attempt to confuse the international community” before the NATO summit meeting and the expected announcement of new sanctions from the European Union. 
“Putin’s real plan is the destruction of Ukraine and the resumption of the U.S.S.R.,” Mr. Yatsenyuk said, according to a statement posted on a government website. Peace will come only once Russia withdraws its troops and proxy force, it said. 
But many Ukrainians, horrified by the mounting toll of more than 2,600 dead and uneasy about the economic costs for a country already on the edge of bankruptcy, want an end to the violence. Winter is approaching, and the other confrontation with Russia, over gas sales, seems unlikely to be resolved while fighting rages in the east. 
“We are in a situation where any kind of cease-fire would be progress,” said Olexander Scherba, an ambassador at large in the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry. “Last week was devastating after Russia started this open invasion of Ukraine.”
Even if a agreement is penned tomorrow in Minsk, it doesn't solve any of the problems of how to implement such a ceasefire:
There is a long road ahead before any real settlement can be reached, analysts noted. Moscow does not fully control the separatists; nor is it clear that Kiev can automatically rein in the armed militias it has unleashed alongside its military in the east. 
Vladislav Brig, a senior official in the self-declared Donetsk People’s Republic, said by telephone that the rebels expected Ukrainian forces to withdraw from the entire region as a condition for peace. “The negotiating side here is not Russia; it is the Donetsk People’s Republic,” he said. “We will stop the offensive when Ukrainian troops leave our territory.” 
Ukraine has said repeatedly that it will not contemplate a full withdrawal from the Donbass region. “It depends on Russia,” Mr. Scherba said. “Russia is the one that started this and can bring it to an end.”
In this analysis, MacFarquhar, a reliable USG voice, is not that far off from some of the more independent commentators of the blogosphere -- El Murid (as translated on Niqnaq's page), for instance.

What we know is this: Fall is approaching and Ukraine's standoff with Gazprom cannot be ignored for too much longer; Ukraine has been defeated militarily by the Novorossiya militias; and the political turmoil among the constituent junta parties is growing. A deal must be struck sooner rather than later.

Another hurdle to factor in for the junta is that as early as tomorrow the Dutch Safety Board is going to publish its report on the downing of Malaysia Airlines Flight 17. Even if the report avoids an opinion as to who was responsible for shoot-down of the commercial airliner and the death of its 298 passengers and crew, Kiev could come in for some criticism. This is from Nicola Clark's "E.U. Urges Sharing Data to Avert Air Disasters":
European legislators at the hearing [of the European Parliament’s transportation committee] on Wednesday expressed consternation as to why Ukrainian officials did not close the airspace to civilian air traffic and why international safety regulators appeared not to have questioned Ukraine’s assessment of the threat to passenger traffic.
Maybe I was right a few weeks back when I saw a deal coming out of Minsk. I was just a couple weeks off.

Friday, August 29, 2014

Kiev Has Lost

The end of summer approaches. The Labor Day weekend begins. The end appears to be approaching for the coup-makers in Kiev. The junta military is about to snap. How else to interpret Putin's address to the Novorossiya militia?
It is clear the militia has achieved a major success in intercepting Kiev’s military operation, which represents a grave danger to the population of Donbass and which has already led to the loss of many lives among peaceful residents. 
As a result of the militia’s actions, a large number of Ukrainian service members who did not participate in the military operation of their own volition but while following orders have been surrounded. 
I call on the militia groups to open a humanitarian corridor for Ukrainian service members who have been surrounded, so as to avoid any needless loss of life, giving them the opportunity to leave the combat area unimpeded and reunite with their families, to return them to their mothers, wives and children, and to quickly provide medical assistance to those who were injured in the course of the military operation. 
For its part, the Russian side is ready and willing to provide humanitarian aid to the people of Donbass, who have been affected by this humanitarian catastrophe. 
I once again call on the Ukrainian authorities to immediately stop military actions, cease fire, sit down at the negotiating table with Donbass representatives and resolve all the accumulated problems exclusively via peaceful means.
Andrew Roth reports this morning from Moscow in "Putin Commends Separatist Militias in Ukraine" that there is dissension within the Ukrainian military:
Ukrainian irregular troops, who primarily serve in volunteer battalions, have complained in recent days of receiving no military support in pockets of strong separatist resistance. Semyon Semenchenko, the head of the pro-Kiev Donbass battalion, whose forces have been pinned down for more than a week in the city of Ilovaysk, called on Facebook for protests at the army’s headquarters in Kiev. 
“We have been tricked once again,” Mr. Semenchenko wrote on Wednesday. “There will be no help today. Those responsible are the minister of defense and the commander of the ATO,” he wrote, using the shorthand for Kiev’s anti-terrorist operation against the rebels in the east. 
The Ukrainian news media also reported that the Transcarpathian battalion, another pro-Kiev group, had returned home to western Ukraine after its soldiers came under heavy artillery fire from Grad rockets.
What makes this all so bizarre is that two weeks ago Gray Lady reporter Andrew Kramer, who was on the ground in Donetsk, predicted that the rebels' days were numbered but a few. Now, the junta military is surrounded southeast of Donetsk and the self-defense forces control a road to the west. Quite a turnabout.

I must admit that two weeks ago I was lost in the fog of war and Andrew Kramer's reporting. The junta's terror campaign of shelling the metropolitan centers of Luhansk and Donetsk led me to conclude that Putin would try to secure a ceasefire and some sort of reconciliation with Kiev. This turned out, as we see, not to be the case.

And that is why there is such a hue and cry in the West and from Kiev, with junta prime minister Yatsenyuk making a desperate plea for Western support, because the jig is almost up. The junta military offensive has always been a circus meant to keep the attention of the masses diverted from the impossibly high hurdles that Ukrainian economic integration with Europe represents. Putin reminded everyone of this in Minsk on Tuesday.

But for now the U.S. and Kiev will do what they have done since March, wail and gnash teeth over Russian aggression. Neil MacFarquhar and Michael Gordon in "Ukraine Leader Says ‘Huge Loads of Arms’ Pour in From Russia" sum up this wailing as follows:
Mr. Poroshenko spoke as NATO released satellite images to corroborate accusations that Russian forces were actively involved in Ukraine fighting. NATO also said that more than 1,000 Russian soldiers had joined the separatists battling the Ukrainian military. 
“Over the past two weeks we have noted a significant escalation in both the level and sophistication of Russia’s military interference in Ukraine,” Brig. Gen. Nico Tak of the Netherlands, a senior officer in NATO’s military command, said in a statement. One image, dated Aug. 21, shows a Russian military convoy with self-propelled artillery moving in the Krasnodon region inside Ukraine. Another, dated Aug. 23, shows Russian self-propelled artillery units in firing positions near Krasnodon.
General Tak said the Russian soldiers were backing the separatists and “fighting with them.” He also said NATO estimated that about 20,000 Russian troops were deployed on Russian territory near the Ukrainian border.
The United States ambassador to Ukraine, Geoffrey R. Pyatt, said in a series of Twitter messages that Russian military assistance to the separatists had failed to help them sufficiently, “so now an increasing number of Russian troops are intervening directly in fighting on Ukrainian territory.” He also asserted that Russia had sent its newest air defense systems, including an effective weapon, the SA-22, into eastern Ukraine, “and is now directly involved in the fighting.”
The Novorossiya militia responded by saying that there are Russians fighters among its ranks but they are volunteers:
“There are active soldiers fighting among us who preferred to spend their vacation not on the beach, but with us, among their brothers, who are fighting for their freedom,” Aleksandr Zakharchenko, a rebel commander and the prime minister of the self-declared Donetsk People’s Republic, said in an interview on Russian state-run television. 
Mr. Zakharchenko said that 3,000 to 4,000 Russians had fought alongside separatists since the conflict erupted. 
That assertion evaded the issue of direct Russian involvement by painting the soldiers as volunteers. It suggests, however, that Moscow still seeks to organize and to some extent control a force that could be operated at arm’s length with a backbone of local participation. 
While the United States and its European allies have condemned Russia, they have not responded to criticism that the Ukrainian tactics against the separatists have included shelling civilian areas in rebel strongholds. The United Nations has estimated that 2,000 people have been killed in eastern Ukraine violence.
Yesterday Obama promised more sanctions. But there are already significant sanctions targeting Russian banking, military and technology. Any additional steps will have to go after the behemoth, Gazprom, which will harm Europe. Will France cancel its warship contract with Russia? If the answer is no, then the sanctions game has run its course.

NATO will likely station more troops and hardware in Poland and the Baltics, on a rotating basis to evade promises not to garrison Russia's borders. But a greater worry for the West should be what to do about the mess that they have made of Ukraine.

Tuesday, July 29, 2014

U.S. Full-Court Press Against Russia Covers Kiev's Weakness

The newspaper today is loaded with stories pertaining to Russia and the Ukraine. The place to begin is not with the front page "bombshell," written by government mule Michael Gordon, on alleged Russian violation of the Intermediate-range Nuclear Forces Treaty (INF) Treaty. That story has been waiting on the back burner for the U.S. to serve up at the appropriate time.

The appropriate time is now. Along with a ruling by a panel in The Hague awarding $50 billion to shareholders of Yukos oil company for its seizure by the Russian government, and the new raft of sanctions being debated and implemented today in Brussels, the U.S. assertion that Russia is in violation of the INF is part of a full-court press. And our question should be why now.

I have an answer. The answer is the junta in Kiev is in trouble. The inherent instability in the coup coalition of Svoboda/Right Sector Nazis and Fatherland neoliberal predators was made manifest last week when putsch prime minister Arseniy Yatsenyuk tendered his resignation, paving the way for new elections this fall. The clock is ticking. The Donbass uprising has to be put down in the next few months in order for the Kiev junta to begin implementing the IMF reforms; otherwise, Kiev will run out of money.

But the current junta offensive is not going well, despite assurances from Andriy Lysenko, spokesman for the junta's fascist security council. Let's turn to Andrew Kramer and David Herszenhorn, "Officials Pull Back From Crash Site as the Army Puts Pressure on Rebels":
Fighting raged farther east along the highway as well, overnight and through the day. Outside Shakhty-20, a coal mining town on the road, a photographer who was passing through Monday morning saw the scorched hulks of Ukrainian armored personnel carriers in the road, and the bodies of Ukrainian soldiers lying about. 
The Ukrainian offensive was intensive enough that the separatists’ military commander — a Russian citizen who uses the name Igor Strelkov, or Igor the Shooter — held a news conference on Monday to deny rumors that he had fled the city or that important positions had fallen.
“Everywhere, the fight was tough,” he said. “They attacked from the north and the south. As a result of the fierce fighting, most of the advance was pushed back.”

The Malaysian airliner was on its way from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur on July 17 when it fell from the sky over eastern Ukraine, killing all 298 people aboard. Ukrainian and American officials say that a Russian-made surface-to-air missile fired from territory held by separatist rebels brought the jetliner down. The Kremlin and the rebels say the Ukrainian government was responsible for the crash.

Asked at the news conference if he had shot down the plane, Mr. Strelkov said that he would not have known how, even though he once served as a guard in an air defense unit. He also denied that his forces had the type of missile the United States says brought down the plane. “I did not have under my command any Buk systems, so I could not have ordered them to shoot at the airplane of Malaysia Airlines,” he said. “My subordinates did not do it.” 
In Kiev, Andriy Lysenko, a spokesman for the government’s security council, said the Ukrainian offensive had made gains, capturing a hilltop World War II monument complex that rebels have used for weeks as a stronghold. The claim could not be independently verified. In Donetsk, Mr. Strelkov said the site had not fallen.
The polite way the Gray Lady has devised for the serial mendacity of Lysenko and other junta representatives is to mention that the claims could not be independently verified.

But to return to the line of thought that I was pursuing, the offensive is not meeting with resounding success. Add to that the shift in the narrative that has taken place over the last week and is still ongoing as to who is at fault for bringing MH17 down. The week following the July 17 crash of the Malaysia Airlines passenger jet it was a foregone conclusion that the Novorossiyan militia, operating with Russian technical guidance, was to blame. That has shifted, with the unanswered questions piling up and the Kiev/U.S. case falling flat. So that now whenever MH17 is mentioned the standard form is to say that on the one hand Kiev/U.S. blames the rebels, while on the other the rebels/Russia blame the junta. For a sample of why Kiev/U.S. are running scared on the MH17, look at Lavrov's forceful statement:
In Moscow on Monday, the foreign minister, Sergey V. Lavrov, repeated a Russian call for the United States to make public whatever proof it has that Flight 17 was brought down by a missile fired from rebel-controlled territory. “We do not understand why the Americans, who say that they have strong evidence to support their accusation, why they do not show that evidence,” he said at a news conference. 
Mr. Lavrov also said that the United Nations should guarantee security at the crash site, and he called on Ukraine to respect a United Nations Security Council resolution adopted on July 21 asking all parties to refrain from any action that would complicate the investigation.
The last paragraph refers to the agreement to cease hostilities within a 24-mile radius of the wreckage site. The junta is in direct violation of the UNSC resolution due to its offensive. So when serial liar Lysenko says "[W]e have information that terrorists from time to time are shelling the plane crash area, in particular from mortars and artillery, in order to destroy all possible evidence,” he is really talking about the junta.

Sabrina Tavernise and Noah Sneider report from Donetsk in "Enmity and Civilian Toll Rise in Ukraine While Attention Is Diverted" another reason for the big PR roll out by the United States. Kiev is losing the "hearts and mind" war. Even spook-infested Human Rights Watch is accusing the junta of war crimes:
In a report released on Thursday, Human Rights Watch documented four instances of the use of unguided Grad rockets, which killed at least 16 civilians in and around Donetsk in nine days. While both rebels and Ukrainian forces use the rockets — descendants of World War II-era weapons — the investigation “strongly indicates that Ukrainian government forces were responsible” for the four attacks. 
“Using these kinds of weapons in populated areas is a violation of the laws of war,” said Ole Solvang, senior emergencies researcher at Human Rights Watch. “International allies of the Ukrainian government — the United States, the European Union — should condemn this use and urge the government to stop.”
The junta's indiscriminate shelling in the urban centers of Luhansk and Donetsk, backed up by HRW, has given Russia all the justification it needs to rationalize an invasion of Ukraine for humanitarian purposes. All Russia need do is invoke the Kosovo precedent.

The U.S. is on shaky ground. That is the big picture. And true to form the U.S. is covering up its wobbliness with a lot of noise and bluster. It is a shame to see Europe bamboozled into placing more sanctions on Russia. The capital markets ban of Russian banks accessing medium- and long-term loans will no doubt hurt, but I don't think it is an existential threat. The dual-use machinery ban, depending on what gets placed on the black list, could be extremely damaging. Dual-use sanctions are what drove Iraq into poverty and caused the deaths of 500,000 Iraqi children, eliciting the famous Madeleine Albright quote, "We think the price is worth it."

Already reservations are being voiced that this could drive Russia into more bellicose behavior, manifesting the very outcome that U.S.-led sanctions are designed to avoid. But for the United States the goal has not been the territorial integrity of Ukraine or peace and harmony. For the Unites States the goal all along has been to reestablish the Cold War, to rebuild a wall between Europe and Russia.

Friday, July 25, 2014

MH17 Crash Site Canard + Maliki on His Way Out, So U.S. Moves the Goal Posts

Yatsenyuk submits his resignation as the junta prime minister of Ukraine, clearing the way for new parliamentary elections this fall. Europe is set to announce today a list of targets for a new round of sanctions against Russia. And the Western media monopoly persists in the canard, even when stories it publishes prove the exact opposite, that there is a Russian-backed conspiracy to tamper with evidence and block access to the Malaysia Airlines crash site in eastern Ukraine. Let's start there, with Sabrina Tavernise and Thomas Erdbrink and the misleading headline "Ukraine Disaster in Search of an Investigation":
There were a few new faces at the site on Thursday. Three Australian investigators worked in the field, joining three Malaysians. Before departing Thursday, the Malaysians said that they were surprised at the amount of access they had to the site and that they felt safe, Mr. Bociurkiw [a spokesman for the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe] said. 
There have been widespread reports of looting, but Mr. Bociurkiw said his monitoring group, which has now spent more time at the site than any other, had not seen any. The Malaysians said they had seen valuables in the fields untouched, he noted, including a bottle of duty-free perfume, auto parts, backpacks full of belongings, a watch and some jewelry.

The Dutch Safety Bureau said in a statement that an initial examination showed that both of Flight 17’s so-called black boxes had been damaged, but that their memory chips were intact. The bureau added that there was “no evidence or indications of manipulation” of either the cockpit voice recorder or the flight data recorder, and that the data from both had been downloaded by experts from Britain’s Air Accidents Investigation Branch in Farnborough, England.
Given the high-volume mendacity of the junta, one wonders what the condition of the black box would have been if it had fallen into the hands of Kiev instead of the DPR. What is important to note is the prevalence across a wide range of stories -- stories coming out of Kiev and Brussels and D.C. -- of the bald lie that the Novorossiyan militia is somehow restricting access to the site and impeding the collection of evidence. This is such a bald lie, supported by not a single shred of evidence, that it leads me to believe that it is being used to 1) justify a Western military footprint in Donetsk, and 2) dismiss any evidence that emerges which shows the junta was to blame. That is why the crash-site story is being kept alive, even as Tavernise makes clear there is no story there. It is strange to see the prestige press engaged in conspiracy theories. In this case though there are no inconvenient facts exposed or complex theories limned; it is all bald lies and misleading headlines.

Speaking of bald lies, the goal posts are now being moved on the "It's All Maliki's Fault" canard. You'll recall from last month that as soon as Islamic State launched its blitzkrieg that captured Mosul the messaging across all sectors of the Western media and government was that the success of the ultra-jihadis was due to the Iraqi prime minister's authoritarianism driving normal Sunnis into the ranks of the Salafis. Therefore Maliki had to go.

Well, come to find out, now that it appears that Maliki is on his way out, he really isn't the problem after all. The Kurds selected their choice for president yesterday, clearing the way for the Shia to select their candidate for prime minister and seating a new government. According to Tim Arango and Suadad al-Salhy in "Iraq Picks New President to Confront Militant Threat":
The Parliament voted to approve Fouad Massoum, 76, a Kurdish politician and former guerrilla fighter against Saddam Hussein’s regime, as the country’s new president. He replaces Jalal Talabani, a Kurd who had been president since 2005 and was seen as a rare unifying figure among Iraq’s many factions but has been largely absent from the political scene since suffering a stroke in late 2012.

“Everyone likes him,” Abbas al-Bayati, a Shiite lawmaker, said of Mr. Massoum. “He is a moderate man and was agreed to by everyone.”
A week before, Parliament elected Salim al-Jubouri, a moderate Sunni Islamist, to the position of speaker, which was the first step in forming a new government after national elections in April. Under an informal political bargain forged after the toppling of Mr. Hussein in 2003, the Iraqi presidency is held by a Kurd, the speaker of Parliament is a Sunni Arab and the position of prime minister, the most powerful post, goes to a Shiite. 
The next political step, the selection of a new prime minister, will be more fraught. That process will determine the future of Mr. Maliki, who has been in power since 2006 but who has become an increasingly polarizing figure as the insurgency has grown and sectarian violence has intensified to a level not seen since 2006 and 2007.
***
Mr. Maliki has insisted that he will seek a third term, but he faces an array of opponents and has lost support from abroad. American officials, who believe he has become too divisive to lead the nation out of its current crisis, have been working behind the scenes to push Iraq’s leaders to select someone else. And Iran, which exerts enormous influence here, has signaled it would like to see new leadership. 
Last week, several Iranian officials, including Ali Shamkhani, a top national security official, visited the holy city of Najaf, in southern Iraq, and conveyed to religious leaders that Iran would prefer that Mr. Maliki be replaced, according to a senior Shiite lawmaker in Baghdad. 
But even if Mr. Maliki were replaced, there is little sense that the Iraqi political class would be able to establish a new political bargain that could bring peace. “There’s no glue to hold whatever grandiose governing coalition that emerges together,” said Ramzy Mardini, an Iraq expert and fellow at the Atlantic Council. He added, “the idea that if Maliki should leave and then we’d be on the path of reconciliation and compromise is wishful thinking.”
Lo and behold! Once the Iranians line up with Great Satan and agree that Maliki should be ushered off the main stage in order to get down to business of smashing the caliphate rising and piecing Iraq back together the story is changed. Now it is not Maliki's fault but the inherent politically instability of Iraq. Brett McGurk was back in front of Congress arguing for a friendly neighbor policy towards Islamic State:
In testimony before the House on Wednesday, Brett McGurk, the deputy assistant secretary of state for Iran and Iraq, portrayed an increasingly decentralized Iraqi government as the most likely way forward. “There is a recognition in Iraq that from the center out you’re never going to fully control all of these areas, and particularly given the capacity of ISIL,” he said, using an alternative acronym for ISIS.
Combine that with yesterday's soft focus almost loving portrayal of Islamic State's stewardship of Raqqa that appeared on the front page of the Gray Lady and it is not hard to make out the handwriting on the wall. The caliphate, backed by the United States and its client Gulf Sheikhdoms, is the answer the people of the Middle East are being given to the question raised by the Arab Spring.

Monday, June 16, 2014

End Game Approaching in Ukraine

We have arrived at the moment of truth in Ukraine. Sad to say that moment didn't come back in April when the junta launched its "Anti-Terrorist Operation" (ATO) against the southeast region of the country. Shelling and murder of civilians will not rouse the leaders of the West to broker a settlement, but I believe Gazprom's suspension of gas deliveries very well could. Neil MacFarquhar has the story this morning, "Gazprom Stops Supplying Natural Gas to Ukraine":
The Russian energy giant Gazprom stopped supplying natural gas to Ukraine on Monday, warning that the reduction could diminish the amount of gas flowing to the rest of Europe and escalating the political crisis between the two countries. 
After the government in Kiev failed to meet a 10 a.m. deadline imposed by Moscow to pay a nearly $2 billion installment for gas, Gazprom announced that it would no longer supply on credit. 
“Gazprom supplies to Ukraine only the amount that has been paid for, and the amount that has been paid for is zero,” a Gazprom spokesman, Sergei Kupriyanov, told reporters. 
A source close to Gazprom said the gas flow into Ukraine had been reduced by the amount intended for Ukraine itself. 
All of the gas flowing into Ukraine as of 10 a.m. Monday was meant only for transporting across the country to Europe, the source said.
The thing to keep in mind here is that Russia has been very balanced and measured in its handling of the coup aftermath in Ukraine. Many wanted Russia to go in with guns blazing and rout the junta military and fascist national guard from Novorossiya. Instead, Putin pulled Russian forces away from the border in a show of working with the West in allowing the junta to conduct its sham presidential election.

My impression is that Russian leadership, mindful of its many advantages in the conflict, has been careful not to create any opening for the United States to force energy sector sanctions against Gazprom. Hence, the apparent pussyfooting of Putin in the face of the shrieking of Yatsenyuk and the mendacious braying of Kerry.

Putin's rise and the rise of post-Yeltsin Russia is synonymous with the success of Gazprom. So Gazprom must be protected. That's why Gazprom chief Aleksei Miller went out of his way to make concessions to the junta.

One has to read to the very end of MacFarquhar's story to understand the bargaining positions of the parties. First, you have to wade through more shrieking by Yatsenyuk, Washington's man in Kiev, about Russian aggression before finding out that Gazprom wants Ukraine to pay the same price as Europe:
Russia and Ukraine have been negotiating for weeks over the price for gas, which Russia had been delivering at a subsidized rate that was lower than that which it charged European customers. Russia wants Ukraine to pay $385 per 1,000 cubic meters, which is the standard measure for gas in Europe. That figure was up from $268, an increase of about 44 percent. 
Gazprom, the world’s largest natural gas producer, increased the price after Ukrainian protesters toppled the government, a Russian ally, in February.
What MacFarquhar does not say is that the subsidized rate Ukraine was receiving was in exchange for the Russia military leases in Crimea. Now that Crimea is no longer part of Ukraine, having voted to join the Russian Federation three months back, there is no reason for Gazprom to supply Ukraine gas at the subsidized rate.

Ukraine gets two-thirds of its natural gas from Russia; Europe receives about one-fifth from Russia.

Both Russia and Ukraine have gone to court seeking restitution on previous gas shipments:
[Gazprom], which is 50.01 percent owned by the Russian government, also said that it was filing a lawsuit in an arbitration court in Stockholm to force Ukraine to pay $4.5 billion for gas that had already been delivered. Gazprom has repeatedly insisted that the dispute is more about getting paid than about the political tensions between the two countries. 
[Ukraine's] Naftogaz responded by saying that it had filed a suit of its own in the Stockholm court against Gazprom to establish a fair market price for the gas. Naftogaz said the suit would also ask the court to fine Gazprom for what the Ukrainian company claims to be $6 billion in overcharging since 2010. 
The Stockholm trade court, formally known as the Arbitration Institute of the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce, has long been used to settle East-West trade disputes because of Sweden’s neutrality.
This is the moment of truth in Ukraine because it is going to force Europe to take a position. Either Europe continues following the U.S. path of the New Cold War and embraces preferential treatment for Ukraine in supplying it with gas, the outcome of which is likely a broad trade war and energy sector sanctions against Russia, or Europe breaks from the U.S. and demands that the junta pay up and shut up.

The U.S. wants mayhem and war. Europe wants peace and the continued economic integration of Eurasia.

At the end of the month, June 27, Ukraine is set to sign the association agreement with the European Union, the same one that led to the coup when Yanukovych refused to sign it. Also at the end of the month the U.S. has promised more sanctions if the fight is still raging in Donbass, something which obviously puts the junta in control.

I must say, banking on a supine Europe to suddenly stand on its hind legs does not seem to me like a good bet.

Thursday, May 15, 2014

Kiev Junta Makes Sham of OSCE Talks. Expect More of the Same.

Based on its reporting of the last few days, a shift appears to be underway at the New York Times. No longer is there complete unquestioned fealty to the Obama administration line that everything bad currently happening in Ukraine is due to Russian aggression against a peaceful democratic people yearning to be free of that evil Rasputin Putin.

Take this morning's story by David Herszenhorn, "Talks on Ukraine Crisis Open in Kiev Without Representation for Separatists." Herszenhorn makes clear that the Kiev junta is not bargaining in good faith:
Senior Ukrainian officials and leading public figures opened talks here on Wednesday that they portrayed as an effort to end the country’s six-month-old political crisis, but the provisional Ukrainian government offered little compromise and there was no one present directly representing the pro-Russian separatists in eastern Ukraine. 
Officials said the negotiating effort would continue with a session on Saturday in the embattled eastern city of Donetsk. 
Pro-Russian leaders in the east reacted dismissively, saying they were not invited to participate in the so-called round-table talks, while officials connected to the region who did attend urged the government to develop concrete proposals that could be presented at the next meeting. 
Oleksandr Yefremov, a member of Parliament from Luhansk, urged the provisional government to put forward solid initiatives. “I really would like to see all the officials who are now represented by the acting president and prime minister come to the round table, come with some proposals and not just slogans,” Mr. Yefremov said. “We have to give answers.” 
While some officials from the east, like Mr. Yefremov, attended the talks, the provisional government in Kiev had vowed not to negotiate with the leaders of the masked gunmen, whom they refer to as “terrorists” and “killers.” As a result there were no representatives of the separatist factions, who are crucial to reaching an accord that might resolve the crisis. 
Mr. Yefremov, in his opening remarks, said he expected more of a presence from his region, and he complained that the talks had opened with sharp words by a leader of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, Patriarch Filaret, blaming Russia for the crisis. 
“I am surprised that nobody is here from Luhansk,” he said, “and I also don’t understand why we start our dialogue with morality.” He added, “We have people who think differently, who have different culture, and we have a responsibility to create a state that corresponds to the needs of our people.”
Herszenhorn quotes Donetsk's junta-appointed governor, oligarch Sergei Taruta, saying the obvious: there is no support for the coup government in the east. The billionaire knows which way the wind blows. He wants to maintain the size of his fortune, something not possible if the junta sticks with its absolutist position:
Sergei A. Taruta, the billionaire governor of Donetsk, another embattled eastern region, also attended the talks, which were held in the Parliament building and featured two former presidents of Ukraine as well as religious leaders. While the negotiations were billed as round-table talks, the table itself was oblong in shape. 
Mr. Taruta warned that there was genuine opposition in the east, known collectively as Donbass. “The majority of Donbass population is for Ukraine’s unity, but at the same time against the current authorities in Kiev,” he said. 
The acting prime minister, Arseniy P. Yatsenyuk, was among the first to speak on Wednesday, and he reiterated a promise to fight graft and urged unity. But he made no particular outreach to the besieged eastern regions where separatist leaders on Sunday held referendums that they said showed broad public support for seceding from Ukraine. 
“To fight corruption and provide people with jobs is our main task,” Mr. Yatsenyuk said. “And that will unite our country.”
Yatsenyuk does nothing without consultation with his U.S. masters. And the U.S. position apparently is -- no surprise here -- to stage-manage a display of "good faith" talks under the auspices of the OSCE, floating phony federalization-lite proposals (what the junta labels "decentralization") that go no further than offering more regional control of tax receipts, all the while terrorizing the civilian population of Donbass with a mercenary-directed Ukrainian national guard and lining up the rubber-stamp acceptance by Europe of the May 25 presidential election.

The United States is not looking for a reasonable solution to the impasse. It wants control of east by Kiev, and short of that it wants war. There is no indication so far of anything else. We'll see how the next round of talks goes. I would assume, based on a turn to more reality-based reporting by the Gray Lady, that the junta will be under pressure to be more inclusive in its public relations, particularly since opinion in Europe is growing more estranged from the putschists. But the U.S. is still running the show. And there is a great deal of arrogance in its conduct. So expect no substantive changes.

Monday, May 5, 2014

The Coming Collapse of U.S. Hegemony

Events seem to be moving in the direction of a big battle for control of Slovyansk city center. The junta military has established checkpoints surrounding the city, according to putschist interior minister Arsen Avakov. Since Avakov does a great job impersonating Joseph Goebbels, it is difficult to assess how strong these roadblocks are and how likely it is that junta troops will storm Slovyansk. But if they do, there is no doubt that the conflict in Ukraine will graduate to another level of violence.

Based on a reading of the blogs -- Moon of Alabama, The Vineyard of the Saker -- over the weekend, the sense out there is that Russia is being provoked by the United States to intervene militarily in Ukraine in order to block European integration east with the Russia and China. A Russian invasion would force Europe to side with its North Atlantic partner in building up NATO military forces on Russia's border as well as severing trade ties with the Russian Federation. At this point, barring mass slaughter of civilians by the putsch government, it doesn't look like Russia is going to take the bait.

Energy supply is the obvious vulnerability in any plan to sever Europe from Russia. Andrew Higgins explores the current U.S.-generated fantasy of how Ukraine can achieve independence from Gazprom in "Kiev Struggles to Break Russia’s Grip on Gas Flow." The idea is that Slovakia has the pipeline capacity to reverse flow natural gas to Ukraine. But for some reason -- Higgins sees the baleful, corrupting influence of Vlad Putin at work -- the Slovak government has been slow to embrace the scheme. It is a long story. One has to read to the end to get to the obvious. Reverse flows depend on the agreement of all parties, meaning that Gazprom would have to sign off in it. Why would they do that?
Alexander Medvedev, the head of Gazprom’s export arm, said he had no problem in principle with reverse-flow supplies to Ukraine but said such arrangements “require the agreement of all parties involved,” including Gazprom. 
“Normally, you can’t arrange a physical reverse flow without a new pipeline,” he added, indicating Gazprom’s opposition to the use of existing Slovak pipelines.
The main event over the weekend was the Friday massacre in Odessa. Federalist, pro-Russian protesters were attacked by Ukrainian nationalist soccer hooligans, chased into a building and the building was set on fire. Forty people died. Putsch prime minister Yatsenyuk in a gross perversion of common decency immediately blamed Russian provocation and police ineptitude. The Gray Lady dutifully echoed his words, even though video evidence and crime-scene reporting established that the slaughter was caused by Ukrainian nationalist mobs. Robert Parry, whose Consortium News web site does an excellent job keeping the February Ukrainian coup in proper perspective, asks, "Will Ukraine Be NYT's Waterloo?"

Andrew Kramer brings the Gray Lady back closer to what really happened in Odessa over the weekend with his "Ukraine’s Reins Weaken as Chaos Spreads":
Yanus Milteynus, a 42-year-old construction worker and pro-Russian activist, said he watched from the roof as the pro-Ukrainian crowd threw firebombs into the building’s lower windows, while those inside feared being beaten to death by the crowd if they tried to flee. 
“Some people jumped or tried to run away, but they chased them and beat them,” he said. Videos of the inferno, however, also show pro-Ukrainian activists trying to move scaffolding from a stage to the building, to rescue those inside. 
Only when the police managed to form a cordon to escort out those rescued by firefighters was he able to leave. If the roof caught fire before then, he said, “I would have stayed and sizzled like a sausage in a frying pan.” 
The conflict is hardening hearts on both sides. As the building burned, Ukrainian activists sang the Ukrainian national anthem, witnesses on both sides said. They also hurled a new taunt: “Colorado” for the Colorado potato beetle, striped red and black like the pro-Russian ribbons. Those outside chanted “burn Colorado, burn,” witnesses said. Swastikalike symbols were spray painted on the building, along with graffiti reading “Galician SS,” though it was unclear when it had appeared, or who had painted it. 
“The biggest thing they ever did to make me hate this country was sing the anthem,” Mr. Milteynus said. “I was going to die, and they sang the anthem. I hate them deeply.”
The United States will pay a large price for fomenting this coup in Ukraine. This is no Kosovo. In what increasingly looks like a desperate, reckless attempt to maintain its global hegemony, the USG is paving the way for its collapse. Democrats cannot win as a pro-war party. This means that Republicans will reap the reward. GOP national leadership will further fracture and discredit the country. Get ready. This is what is in store.

Friday, April 25, 2014

The Putschist Ruse in Ukraine is Almost Up

Putschist interior minister Arsen Avakov has distinguished himself among the Kiev gang for a Goebbels-like facility for distortion of the truth. Today he is front and center with the coinage of a cute acronym for the second failed putschist offensive in as many weeks against the uprising in eastern Ukraine. Andrew Higgins, David Herszenhorn and Alan Cowell have the story this morning, "Ukraine Says Its Efforts to Regain Control of East Will Continue":
Sounding increasingly strident alarms, Ukraine’s interim prime minister, Arseniy P. Yatsenyuk, accused Moscow on Friday of seeking to create a wider conflict. “Attempts at military conflict in Ukraine will lead to a military conflict in Europe,” Mr. Yatsenyuk told the interim cabinet in remarks broadcast live, according to Reuters. “The world has not yet forgotten World War II, but Russia already wants to start World War III.”
In a posting on Facebook, Interior Minister Arsen Avakov declared that Ukraine’s military operations in the east — known as “ATO,” meaning Anti-Terrorist Operation — had not been suspended.
“There has been no suspension of the ATO in connection to the threat of invasion by Russia’s armed forces,” Mr. Avakov said, apparently responding to local news reports saying the operation had been called off because of the “heightened risk” of a Russian invasion. “The ATO goes on. The terrorists should be on their guard around the clock. Civilians have nothing to fear.” 
Despite the minister’s warning, there have been no reports of renewed conflict since Ukrainian forces moved briefly against pro-Russian positions on Thursday in what Mr. Avakov, apparently playing down the action, described on Friday as an operation by “insignificant” government forces that had deployed “without the use of tanks or other heavy armor.”
So there you have it. The putschists cannot control the east. A military attack on the buildings occupied by pro-Russian protesters is unlikely as long as Russia is conducting large drills on the Ukrainian border. This means that the chances of the putschist May 25 presidential election being deemed free and fair are remote. Gazprom is ratcheting up the pressure for Ukraine to pay its gas bill. Europe is getting queasy about the trade war that is barreling its way. We are getting close to the "put up or shut up" point for the U.S. Cue Secretary of State John Kerry, a noxious manikin and lie machine. Kerry's remarks last night amounted to nothing more than a doubling down on a busted hand.

We're getting close now, very close, to the ruse being up. Sanctions and the threat of creating capital flight out of Russia is the last act in this U.S.-sponsored drama. According to Higgins et al.,
In Washington, Secretary of State John Kerry warned Russia on Thursday night that it would face additional economic sanctions if it failed to carry out that agreement. “The window to change course is closing,” he said. Sanctions could be announced as soon as Friday if the Russians do not respond, said one administration official who asked not to be identified while discussing internal planning.
The threat of intensified sanctions was under underscored on Friday when the rating agency Standard & Poor’s downgraded its assessment of Russia.
“In our view, the tense geopolitical situation between Russia and Ukraine could see additional significant outflows of both foreign and domestic capital from the Russian economy and hence further undermine already weakening growth prospects,” the agency wrote. 
In his most detailed accusation of Russian interference to date, Mr. Kerry said that American intelligence services had concluded that Russia’s “military intelligence services and special operators are playing an active role in destabilizing eastern Ukraine with personnel, weapons, operational planning and coordination.” 
“Some of the individual Special Operations personnel who were active on Russia’s behalf in Chechnya, Georgia and Crimea have been photographed in Slovyansk, Donetsk and Luhansk,” Mr. Kerry said. “Some are even bragging about it by themselves on their Russian social media sites.” 
On Friday, Mr. Kerry’s Russian counterpart, Sergey V. Lavrov, hit back, accusing Washington of seeking only to further its interests in Ukraine. 
“The West wants to take control of Ukraine while exclusively putting its geopolitical interests, not the interests of the Ukrainian people, at the forefront,” Mr. Lavrov told a conference of young diplomats from former Soviet republics. 
“We are talking about the methods that Americans use with states of different regions,” Mr. Lavrov said. “This is not our method. We will not blackmail, we will not threaten, we are all polite people,” he said. 
“Without batting an eye, our Western partners keep demanding day after day that Russia stop interfering in Ukrainian affairs, pull out troops and remove certain agents who have reportedly been caught in the southeast and who are reportedly guiding these processes,” Mr. Lavrov said, adding, “I even find it difficult to respond. I try to make the conversation constructive.”
This is the moment of truth. And since the United States is a power that does not deal in the truth, expect the moment to be avoided. Any sanctions announced in the next few days will remain largely cosmetic, targeting members of the Russian ruling elite and possibly some banks or other institutions. The sanctions cannot be too biting because once they bite London, Berlin and Paris will part company with the Obama administration.

As for Gazprom, the putsch government does not have the ability to pay its bill, and the West will not unless it can secure future pricing and supply guarantees (which will not be forthcoming).

So we are right at the place we have been all along: the putschists and their U.S. backers are cradling a crock of shit, and that crock of shit is a place called "Banderastan."

****

There is some news this morning that an assault on Slovyansk is in the offing. Ukrainian military are encircling the city, blocking roads and sending snipers into the surrounding woods. It sounds like a siege.

Monday, April 14, 2014

What Pearls of Wisdom CIA Chief Brennan Imparted While in Kiev are Hard to Imagine

The pro-Russian uprising in eastern Ukraine appears at this point to be unbowed and gaining traction. This from a solid round-up of the events this past weekend by Andrew Kramer and Andrew Higgins, "No Action Seen From Ukraine as Deadline for Militants Passes":
Through Monday morning, as the sun burned off a dense mist rising from stubbly winter fields in the region, the Ukrainian news media reported no efforts to storm occupied buildings in the eastern part of the country. No police officers or military personnel were gathered outside the regional administration building in Donetsk, which flies a Russian flag as well as the flag of the recently declared but as yet unrecognized People’s Republic of Donetsk. 
In another indication of the scale of the loss of control by the central government, pro-Russian protesters set up a checkpoint on a main highway about 25 miles outside of Donetsk. 
The government’s push on Sunday to reassert its authority in a vital industrial and coal-mining region appeared to have made little headway. Pro-Russian protesters appeared to control not only the police station but also the entire town of Slovyansk, after having set up checkpoints at major streets leading into town.
The protesters blocked a major highway in the east, and Russian and Donetsk flags flew over administrative buildings in several other midsize towns, including Mariupol, where protesters seized a building Sunday.
My sense is that the putschists in Kiev don't have control of the armed forces. Why else throw out ultimatums that can't be met? They might have an "elite" unit or two like Alfa, which may or may not be composed largely of mercenaries, as well as Right Sector hooligans. But apparently these forces are not enough to storm and hold the myriad government buildings under occupation. Also, I would guess that Russia has elite special forces in plainclothes on the ground in these eastern cities. Once the Ukrainian attack begins we can expect that they will play a role.

The fact that CIA chief John Brennan was reported to be in Kiev instructing the putschists over the weekend is proof that things are very shaky for Yats & Co.:
Russian news media reported Sunday that the American C.I.A. director, John O. Brennan, had arrived in Kiev on a secret visit to advise Ukrainian officials in charge of domestic security and defense. The American Embassy in the Ukrainian capital declined to comment on the reports.
The problem for the putschists is while these buildings can be stormed and taken by mercenaries, how can they be held? The military and state security apparatus obviously cannot be relied upon; hence, the appearance of Greystone personnel. What pearls of wisdom Brennan had to impart are hard imagine.

Thursday, March 13, 2014

Crimea Secession a Done Deal U.S. Seeks to Move the Goal Posts

War is toxic to the body politic. It blots out all else. Day after day after day it fills the newspapers and airwaves. All other information becomes secondary. It is a horrible way to live.

For almost a month now we have been living this way, longer if you factor in the riots in Kiev that led up to the putsch that sent President Yanukovych fleeing from the capital.

Viewed from on high, it is a fairly simple story. There is an East-West split in Ukraine, the same one that fueled the 2004 Orange Revolution. The West won, took control of Kiev and quickly installed a pro-neoliberal government composed of the usual suspects from the Fatherland Party along with the neo-Nazi muscle (Svoboda, Right Sector) that led the street fighting on Independence Square. Russia reacted by asserting control of Crimea, home to its Black Sea Fleet. This Sunday, the historically Russian Crimea will conduct a referendum on whether to secede from Ukraine and join the Russian Federation.

The position of the West is that such a vote is illegal, a violation of international law and the Ukrainian Constitution. The West is largely silent about the legal status of the putsch government. Obama and Kerry intone that it is the legitimate government without mentioning its constitutional status because it is not constitutional. The Ukrainian Constitution outlines an impeachment process that must be followed in order to remove the president. Like in the U.S., a trial must be conducted. A trial must be conducted so evidence can be weighed. Running a man out of town for fear of his life is not a weighing of evidence. Nonetheless the United States' only argument for the legitimacy of the putsch government led by Arseniy Yatsenyuk and Oleksandr Turchynov seems to be that Yanukovych skipped town.

Speaking of Yatsenyuk, he was in Washington D.C. yesterday making the rounds. The stories this morning in the Gray Lady --  "Obama Makes Diplomatic Push to Defuse Crisis in Ukraine" by Peter Baker and Michael Gordon; "Kerry Plans 11th-Hour Meeting With Russians Over Crimea" by Michael Gordon -- leave the impression that the goal posts are being moved:
Mr. Kerry held out the hope that a political solution might be reached even though there have been no public hints of Russian flexibility. Even if the referendum in Crimea went ahead, he suggested, there might be a chance for a political solution if Russia stopped short of annexing the province. 
“There are a lot of variants here, which is why it is urgent that we have this conversation with the Russians,” he said.
That was from Kerry's testimony yesterday before the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Foreign Operations. And here is basically the same take from Obama and Yats:
Mr. Obama said Mr. Yatsenyuk told him that a new Ukrainian government formed after elections scheduled for May 25 could find ways to address Crimea’s concerns. “There is a constitutional process in place and a set of elections that they can move forward on that, in fact, could lead to different arrangements over time with the Crimean region,” Mr. Obama said. “But that is not something that can be done with the barrel of a gun pointed at you.” 
At a separate appearance later in the day, Mr. Yatsenyuk expressed willingness to consider concessions to Crimea. “We the Ukrainian government are ready to start a nationwide dialogue how to increase the rights of autonomous Republic of Crimea, starting with taxes and ending with other aspects like language issues,” he told an audience at the Atlantic Council.
The takeaway? The U.S. and its putschist quislings are writing off a Yes vote for secession this Sunday in Crimea. They are moving the goal posts to say that a Yes vote does not preclude continued negotiations; that a settlement on Crimea could include enhanced autonomy with guarantees for the Russian Black Sea Fleet. But the catch is that Russia will have to acknowledge the legitimacy of the putschists and bless their May 25 elections.

It is not going to happen. My read is that Russia no longer trusts the United States to deliver anything in good faith regarding Ukraine. Russia will now proceed to implement plans that it sees will bolster its national interest in its sphere and let the West react.

Merkel came forward with a tough statement against Russia yesterday, embracing the architecture of a New Cold War as dictated by the United States. My assessment is that this is a bluff. If big American business is actively lobbying against economic sanctions, what do you think German big business -- with far more exposure to Russia -- is doing?

Russia holds fast, stays strong -- and the North Atlantic alliance frays.

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

Cold War Renaissance

Administration officials said the internal debate was not whether to penalize Russia for its actions — there is broad consensus for that, one that hardens with each passing day — but when, and how hard. Beyond freezing assets of individuals, the administration could sanction banks and potentially cut the country off from the dollar economy.
Peter Baker                                                   
The putschist prime minister Arseniy Yatsenyuk peddles ass today in D.C. In addition to an Oval Office ménage à quatre with Biden, Kerry and Obama (scheduled for 2:45 PM EST), "Yats" will indulge in an evening orgy on Capitol Hill hosted by New Jersey's finest "Rent-a-Senator," Bob Menendez. There is a competition underway in Congress between the House and the Senate to see who can bring back the Cold War back the quickest. Menendez, as Chairman of the United States Senate Committee on Foreign Relations, is backing legislation that, if passed, would guarantee future hostilities with Russia. He outlined his bill in a Washington Post opinion piece yesterday:
Our policies toward Russia require urgent reexamination. Congress has a particular role to play. Legislation I’m offering includes the following components: 
●It provides for loan guarantees for Ukraine, consistent with the $1 billion announced by the Obama administration in recent days and mirroring just-passed House legislation. 
●It directs the Obama administration to assist the Ukrainian government in identifying, securing and recovering assets linked to acts of corruption by former prime minister Viktor Yanu­kovych, members of his family or other former or current Ukrainian government officials. 
●It authorizes $50 million for democracy, governance and civil society assistance and $100 million for enhanced security cooperation for Ukraine and other states in Central and Eastern Europe. 
●It provides for additional sanctions, complementing the president’s executive order, against Ukrainians and Russians alike responsible for violence and serious human rights abuses against anti-government protesters and those responsible for undermining the peace, security, stability, sovereignty or territorial integrity of Ukraine. 
●It imposes sanctions on Russians complicit in or responsible for significant corruption in Ukraine.
●It includes needed reforms to the United States’ participation in the International Monetary Fund, which would allow Washington to leverage significant support from the IMF for Ukraine today and for similar crises in the future. 
Russian actions at home and abroad must be viewed in a broader context, not as isolated incidents but as connected events in a troubling pattern of behavior that cannot continue unchecked.
Arguing against this approach, which funds more skullduggery in the form of "democracy" and "civil society assistance,"  is the United States Chamber of Commerce and National Association of Manufacturers. This is from the Peter Baker story at the top of the post:
But American businesses are warning against overreaction. Representatives of groups like the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the National Association of Manufacturers and the United States-Russia Business Council have been holding meetings at the White House or in Congress to share their views. 
They are urging policy makers to be sure that any sanctions would actually have an impact on Russian behavior, that the costs not outweigh the benefits and that they be multilateral. “We are working closely with policy makers on both sides of the aisle to safeguard manufacturing employees and manufacturers’ investments around the world,” said Jay Timmons, president of the manufacturers association. 
Although the United States does only $40 billion in trade with Russia each year, American businesses argue that the amount understates the real economic ties. Ford, for instance, has two assembly plants in Russia that make cars with material that comes from Europe, so that would not be reflected in import-export figures. 
Boeing has sold or leased hundreds of planes in Russia and projects that the republics of the former Soviet Union will need an additional 1,170 planes worth nearly $140 billion over the next 20 years. Moreover, the company has a design center in Moscow, has just announced new manufacturing and training facilities in Russia and depends on Russia for 35 percent of its titanium.
The Deep State battle shaping up is between the hawks (the neocon national security state) versus the doves (in this case, American big business).

Then there is Europe. To my mind, though Germany, France and Britain are making the appropriate noises of fealty to the U.S. and the idea of economic warfare on Russia, I don't see how they can go along with the kind of Nouveau Cold War advocated by Menendez and the neocons. Europe's level of economic integration with Russia is too significant to hurtle thirty-years backward.

But in the end, I think that is the dynamic we are going to be dealing with -- the United States wants a return of the global polarity provided by the Cold War -- great powers locked in a long struggle marked not by World War III but covert warfare in the developing war -- a replay of Uncle Sam's salad days following World War II. I think this is what Obama's Asia pivot was designed to do to begin with. Some form of great power theater is demanded if only to obscure what has become obvious over the last year in Syria: our purported existential enemy, Al Qaeda, is actually an irregular force dispatched by Uncle Sam's partners in the Persian Gulf, the wealthy oil sheikhdoms. Like Hydra or A.I.M. in Marvel Comics, the Wahhabis provide a perpetual foil for our superheroes in the national security state. So the comic books keep coming . . . .

But the problem with the Nouveau Cold War is Europe. Europe cannot go along with this comic book. And in that there is hope; hope that after the vote in Crimea on Sunday and the U.S. responds by slapping economic sanctions on Russia, we will catch the first glimpse of a new multi-polar world, as Europe goes her own way.

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

A Question or Two for Yats and Obama Tomorrow

To get a sense of the Bizarro World that the United States presently occupies take a peek at its wish list, intended to resolve the Ukrainian crisis, that Kerry delivered to Lavrov this past weekend:
In a Saturday morning call with Mr. Lavrov, Mr. Kerry emphasized that Russian steps to annex Crimea would close the window for more diplomacy. Later that day, the State Department sent Mr. Lavrov a page-and-half document with a series of questions that were intended to see whether the Kremlin was receptive to the United States’ proposals before Mr. Kerry traveled to meet with Mr. Putin.
American officials wanted to know if Russia would cease its military advances in Crimea, rein in Crimean militias and also work with the contact group on steps like an International Monetary Fund program to stabilize the Ukrainian economy and a countrywide election. They also wanted Russia to halt moves to annex the Crimean Peninsula, and were looking for signs that Russia would be willing to return their troops to their barracks, allow international monitors to work in Crimea and, importantly, meet with new Ukrainian government, either directly or as part of a contact group. 
Russia never responded officially to the questions. Yet an answer of sorts came on Monday when, to the surprise of the State Department, Russian television carried the short video clip of Mr. Putin and Mr. Lavrov. 
Mr. Putin said that he had authorized Mr. Lavrov to invite Mr. Kerry to Russia. Mr. Lavrov responded that he had expected Mr. Kerry to arrive as early as Monday for talks that could involve Mr. Putin himself. 
“But then on Saturday he called and said that he would like to postpone the trip for the moment,” Mr. Lavrov added, referring to Mr. Kerry. 
The Russian foreign minister went on to complain that the paper Mr. Kerry had given him on Friday cast Moscow as a belligerent and treated the establishment of the new Western-backed government in Ukraine as a “fait accompli.”
This appears in "U.S. and Russia Hit Diplomatic Roadblock Trying to Start Ukraine Talks" by Michael Gordon and Steven Lee Myers. As a first proposal, the Obama administration must know that it is a non-starter. For it to be anything but an intentional non-starter would mean that there is no one in a position of authority in the Obama administration who can interpret the obvious -- that Russia is deadly serious about what is going on in Ukraine and is not going to settle for some sort of accommodation with the putschists. This is from a good story by Ellen Barry, "Titans in Russia Fear New Front in Ukraine Crisis":
Russia’s tycoons have been silent since the crisis began, apart from approving messages on social media. Many inside Russia’s large corporations are no doubt supportive of Mr. Putin’s moves in Crimea, which are widely seen here as correcting a historical error made by the Soviet leader Nikita S. Khrushchev, when he transferred Crimea to the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic. Mr. Putin’s approval ratings are at their highest point since he returned to the presidency in 2012. If corporate leaders are complaining, they are doing it quietly. 
“Of course they’re upset, but it doesn’t mean they are prepared to challenge Russia’s foreign policy,” said Mikhail E. Dmitriyev, an economist whose research group, the Center for Strategic Research, was originally founded to shape Mr. Putin’s economic platform. “This is a new reality. Even if somebody has reservations with regard to the policy’s effectiveness, I strongly doubt they would express it. This is a policy which, for the moment, is backed by the vast majority of the public. It’s not an exaggeration.”
Kerry and Obama enjoy no such support. Citizens of the homeland see only more war games and billions spent overseas while their rents are raised and a couple bags of groceries add up to a $100. European allies have already made clear their reluctance to slap economic sanctions on Russia.

Then there is the unstable situation within the putsch government itself. It is a business-as-usual, Orange-Revolution-redux oligarchical structure that came to power by means of Svoboda and Right Sector muscle. At this point it is not clear that this pairing is anything more than an evanescent marriage of convenience. Right Sector has promised to reformulate itself as an electoral organization that will vie for power in upcoming elections. Right Sector, at least from what I have read, is to the right of Svoboda, does not support greater integration with Europe and its decadent values, and currently is riding a crest of popularity for its role on the Maidan.

In the near term, the United States continues to lose the information war. And the reason it is losing the propaganda battle is the insistence that the putschists are legitimately democratic. In order to make this stick, a tremendous feat in perception management is required, given that we are indoctrinated in the West from the time we learn how to read that democracy means elections. And Yanukovych was the legitimately elected leader of the country, who just happened to be run out of town by armed goons -- not what most normally consider to be a legitimate, democratic process.

As if to underscore this, today Yanukovych was trundled before the cameras. Steven Lee Myers has the story, "Ukraine’s Ousted Leader Urges Military to Resist New Government":
Mr. Yanukovych has mostly remained in hiding since he fled Ukraine, and his public role in the conflict has been so marginalized that he began his remarks by dismissing rumors of his ill health and even death. “I am alive,” he said, going on to dispute the legality of the actions the Parliament took after a European-brokered agreement on Feb. 21 collapsed. “And I have not been impeached, according to the Ukrainian Constitution.”
This is a shrewd move by Moscow, preempting tomorrow's White House meeting between putsch president Arseniy Yatsenyuk and Obama. If there is any reporter worth his or her salt allowed to question the putschist and his sponsor, this question will be asked: "Was President Yanukovych impeached as set forth in the Ukrainian Constitution? And, if not, how is the current government legal?"

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

Hard Times Ahead for Ukraine's Putsch

Things are only going to get worse in Ukraine. As long as the story stays focused on the predations of the disgraced President Viktor Yanukovych, who is currently on the run from the putschists, the depressing reality of the country post-putsch can remain somewhat obscured to both the casual news consumer in the West and the Ukrainian citizen enjoying a revolutionary high.

But as Hegel once remarked, "What is real is rational, and what is rational is real," or something along those lines. While the Gray Lady dutifully does her part as a member of the United States foreign affairs team, posting video of Ukrainians gape-mouthed wandering the grounds of Yanukovych's presidential palace, as well as soaring images of the victorious protesters massed on the Maidan, the truth finds its way to the surface in the reports filed by her staff.

Take for instance today's effective hit piece by Andrew Higgins, "An Unfinished Ukraine Palace and a Fugitive Leader’s Folly"; effective because it keeps the narrative squarely focused where the U.S./EU wants it, not on the machinations of the putsch government but on the illegal greed and corruption of President Yanukovych (who, by Western druthers, is to be considered a present-day Nicolae Ceaușescu).

Higgins describes workers walking off the construction site of a mansion Yanukovych was building for himself in an old-growth forest along the Crimean coast. Who can defend a plutocrat who illegally erects yet another mansion for himself, this time in an old-growth forest that had been used by regular folks as a place to hike? Certainly not your average reader of the New York Times.

But like many a reporter under the Gray Lady's yoke (for example, Beirut bureau chief, Anne Barnard), Higgins finds a way to subvert the narrative (venal, Ceaușescu-like despot as the personification of evil) at the story's end:
“Why does he need a palace every few kilometers? He thought he was a czar,” said Mr. Pilti, who was in Kiev on business during Saturday’s takeover by protesters and was staggered to see the size of Mr. Yanukovych’s captured spread outside the capital. 
Sergei, the contractor, said he did not like the new government in Kiev at all but was “still happy about what has happened — it had to happen sooner or later.” Ukraine, he added, desperately needs a more open system so the people can clearly know what is going on when a valued public forest suddenly gets fenced off and cut down to make way for a private mansion. 
His chief quarrel with Mr. Yanukovych’s opponents, he added, is not that they ousted a good leader, but that they, too, are deeply corrupt and will soon be building villas of their own if they manage to hang on to power. 
“Everyone knew what was happening here,” he said, gesturing at the concrete extravaganza he helped to build, “but they didn’t say anything because they were doing the same thing, only smaller.”
"Why does he need a palace every few kilometers?" is of course a question those of us who reside in "The greatest nation on Earth"™ ask ourselves. You see, we have oligarchs of our own.

And this is what will be the undoing of the putsch: getting rid of Yanukovych is not going to rid the country of its predatory oligarchs; aligning itself with the U.S./EU will not reopen shuttered hospitals and put the unemployed back to work and lessen corruption.

First off, member states of the European Union are loath to float a financial rescue because of prevalence of corruption in Ukraine regardless of party. This is from a story today by Steven Erlanger and David Herzsenhorn, "Tentatively, European Union Weighs Its Options on Support for a New Ukraine":
The European Investment Bank can also help with quick money but, Mr. Rehn [European Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs and the Euro] noted, “E.U. resources lie predominantly with member states” — hence the idea of a donors’ conference. But there is little obvious enthusiasm among member states, many of them still in recession or just emerging from it, to pump large amounts of money into an unreformed Ukraine that has been famous for crony capitalism and corruption. 
Poland, for example, which has been a key interlocutor on Ukraine, has said that it wants to see significant structural change in the country first. On Monday, Prime Minister Donald Tusk said that a stable Ukraine was in Poland’s interest. As for foreign aid, he said, “Poland will not sweat its guts out.” 
Ukraine needs to show that it can absorb foreign aid and not waste it, Mr. Tusk said. “It cannot be that we will organize huge funds for Ukraine and Ukraine will continue to waste this money by, for example, corrupt governments or oligarchs,” he said.
Ukraine needs $35 billion to keep from going bankrupt. Since the money is not likely to come from the EU, this means that the bailout has to come from the International Monetary Fund. And we know what that means. Brutal austerity. Hence the delay by the putsch parliament in forming an interim government. No one wants to sign off on IMF austerity because he/she will be ending his/her political career. Rada members are attempting to avoid this outcome by making it appear that they are consulting the EuroMaidan protesters and getting their consent. This is from an illuminating piece by David Herzsenhorn, "Infighting Poses Hurdle to Formation of New Coalition in Ukraine":
“This government will be legitimate not when it is voted in the Parliament but when it receives support of the people who stood on Maidan,” said Arseniy P. Yatsenyuk, a lawmaker in the party Fatherland who is a leading contender to serve as acting prime minister. 
Mr. Yatsenyuk also pleaded with colleagues to end their infighting and swiftly reach an agreement on the designation of an interim government, which is needed to formally request emergency economic assistance from the International Monetary Fund. 
“The deadline is Thursday,” he told reporters outside the Parliament chamber. “This government will face tremendous challenge. And we have to say absolutely openly that those who go into this government are rescuing the country on one hand, but on the other hand they should be aware that they are committing political suicide.”
Originally, the agreement brokered with Yanukovych last Friday by France, Germany and Poland would have avoided all this. Yanukovych would have appointed a new, "technical government" to oversee the U.S./EU/IMF austerity mandates. After this, Yanukovych's political career would have been terminated. Not to worry though, he would have had that mansion in the old-growth forest on the Crimean coast in which to comfortably enjoy his retirement. But this was upended by the putsch, a foolish move. Now the putschists are on the hook for the onrushing austerity.

Russia still holds all the cards. Russia is Ukraine's largest trading partner and supplies the country with its fuel. Russia's bear claws are resting on Ukraine's jugular. Additionally, Europe has to remain respectful of Russian interests since Germany receives a significant amount of natural gas from Gazprom.