Showing posts with label Right Sector. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Right Sector. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 25, 2014

Another End Game on Ukraine Approaches

I have gotten into the habit of announcing an approaching end game in Ukraine for months. When the uprising in the Donbass started in April and it looked like the Kiev junta was going to sue for peace because it couldn't field a military response, I thought a rational conclusion to the putsch crisis -- namely, federalization and neutralization of Ukraine -- was nigh. Somehow, probably with ample support from the U.S. and her European allies, the Kiev junta put its newly created national guard, the one filled with Right Sector fascists, front and center and the assault on the southeast continued.

Then there was the thought that once the chocolate king was elected president in May Russia would have a willing bargaining partner to bring the fighting to an end. Once elected, Poroshenko expanded the "anti-terror operation" (ATO).

Finally, this month, there was Gazprom's suspension of gas deliveries to Ukraine because of non-payment. I thought that would hasten the junta to the bargaining table, but nothing of the sort happened. It is summer now and fuel tanks are topped out.

Now it is time for me to announce that yet another end game is upon us. Friday European leaders meet to debate and decide whether to support an effort by the United States to increase sanctions on Russia. The U.S. position is that Russia is not doing enough to tamp down the Donbass uprising, even though Putin has recently said that he will ask the Russian Parliament to rescind its authorization allowing military intervention in Ukraine.

Peter Baker has the story, "Doubting Putin, Obama Prepares to Add Pressure," which is quite good. (Baker is a cut above the normal mercenary scribe. Reporters like David Sanger, Rick Gladstone, Michael Gordon generally do nothing to inform; they act merely as receivers of official talking points. But Peter Baker can write. And while he sticks to the government-sanctioned narrative there is usually something in his stories that illuminates what is really going on.)
Even as the Kremlin voices support for a cease-fire in eastern Ukraine, American officials remain unconvinced that it has backed up words with deeds. Russia has moved troops back to the border and positioned heavy artillery there in what American officials consider an effort to help the separatists, who on Tuesday shot down a Ukrainian military helicopter. 
But President Obama faces hurdles as he tries to keep the pressure up on the government of President Vladimir V. Putin. European Union leaders, who are scheduled to meet Friday in Brussels, are reluctant to go along if it looks like Mr. Putin may be backing down. And American business leaders objecting to unilateral actions that would hurt their companies are kicking off an advertising campaign to oppose Mr. Obama’s plans. 
Mr. Obama spoke with Mr. Putin on Monday to urge him to take more tangible steps to defuse the crisis, and the Russian leader on Tuesday seemed to respond by asking his Parliament to rescind formal authorization to intervene militarily in Ukraine. American officials considered the move positive but symbolic, assuming that it was really meant to undercut European support for additional sanctions.
The sanctions themselves will go after Russian banking, military and energy:
The Obama administration has developed three options for further actions, according to government officials: banning any interactions with some of Russia’s largest banks; cutting off technology transfers to Russian energy and defense firms; and shutting down business with Russian defense companies. 
Believe it or not, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) are about to launch a big public offensive against Obama's New Cold War. The reason is obvious. U.S. corporate interests will lose out to European competitors if Obama leads with new sanctions without Europe in tow:
The drive for more sanctions comes as American businesses are growing more vocal in protesting the possibility that the United States may act on its own. While lobbying the White House and Congress quietly until now, leading business groups plan to start a wide advertising campaign voicing their concerns. 
“With escalating global tensions, some U.S. policy makers are considering a course of sanctions that history shows hurts American interests,” reads an advertisement to be placed in major newspapers on Thursday. “We are concerned about actions that would harm American manufacturers and cost American jobs." 
The ad, signed by Jay Timmons, president of the National Association of Manufacturers, and Thomas J. Donohue, president of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, will be placed in The Financial Times, The Hill, The New York Times, Politico, Roll Call, The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post. A copy was provided on Tuesday by someone not directly affiliated with either sponsoring organization. 
Linda Dempsey, the vice president for international economic affairs at the manufacturers association, would not discuss the ad campaign but said American businesses would be unduly harmed if Washington proceeded with sanctions that were not matched by Europe. 
“Unilateral sanctions by the United States end up with other countries and their industries filling the void,” she said. “The harm and the real impact of those unilateral sanctions is on U.S. industries and U.S. workers. It’s not that we’re out of the market for a year or two. We could get out of the market for decades.”
Europe could end this charade here and now by forcefully stating that no further sanctions will be considered and that Putin has been a good-faith actor since the Kiev coup in February sent the elected president fleeing for his life.

But don't count on strong, principled action from European leaders. Their conduct in all of this has been feckless. Nonetheless, the ad roll out by NAM and the U.S. Chamber says that this is about to change. Friday Europe could very well stand upright on its hind legs and seriously bring an end to the fighting in Donbass.

But the U.S. is wily. Assuming that they can't reach consensus this Friday, the Obama administration is looking for Europe to sign off a set of sanctions that will go into effect if Russia is perceived to have begun backsliding:
If the Europeans are not willing to impose new sanctions after Friday’s meeting, the American side hopes to reach agreement on a package that would be ready to use if Mr. Putin does not follow through on his recent positive statements or reverts back to more hostile actions once the meeting has passed. In effect, that would make the sanctions package a deterrent.
This of course opens the door for a false-flag provocation, the kind of dark art in which the USG specializes. So it could very well be that I will be back here in another couple weeks or a month announcing another end game.

Friday, June 6, 2014

G-7 Sanction Ultimatum is Nonsense

As it turns out, the United States looks to have achieved what it set out to at the G-7 meeting in Brussels. Fealty to the policy of coercive sanctions against Russia was re-pledged by the major industrial nations. Peter Baker, who has been traveling with Obama on this European anti-Moscow junket, reports in "With Group of 7 Backing, Obama Gives Russia One-Month Ukraine Deadline" that:
With the backing of other world leaders, President Obama effectively set a one-month deadline for Moscow to reverse its intervention in Ukraine and help quash a pro-Russian separatist uprising or else he said it would face international sanctions far more severe than anything it had endured so far. 
Mr. Obama and other leaders of seven major democracies meeting here demanded that President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia recognize and negotiate directly with the newly elected leader of Ukraine, stop the flow of fighters and arms across the border and press separatists to disarm, relinquish seized public buildings and join talks with the central authorities in Kiev.
“Russia continues to have a responsibility to convince them to end their violence, lay down their weapons and enter into a dialogue with the Ukrainian government,” Mr. Obama said at a news conference alongside Prime Minister David Cameron of Britain after a meeting of leaders of the Group of 7 industrial powers. “On the other hand, if Russia’s provocations continue, it’s clear from our discussions here that the G-7 nations are ready to impose additional costs on Russia.”
For the first time, Mr. Obama laid out a time frame, saying that the process could not drag out.
“We will have a chance to see what Mr. Putin does over the next two, three, four weeks,” Mr. Obama said, “and if he remains on the current course, then we’ve already indicated what kinds of actions that we’re prepared to take.”
There are several problems with this ultimatum, the first of which is the obvious schizophrenia of demanding that Russian military forces abandon the border with Ukraine, which they did, only now to in effect say that they must return in order to staunch the flow of fighters and weapons to the citizens of Donbass.

But even more fundamental than this schizophrenia is the hallucinogenic notion that Moscow somehow has command and control of what is a civil war in the Ukrainian southeast. If you have ever lived in a community that has been put under assault by state security forces (as I have, during the 1999 Seattle WTO ministerial), you know that no direction from on high is necessary. When someone or something is setting off bombs in your neighbor and shooting at people walking on the street, you leave your home and confront the attacker. This is as natural as any other animal function.

So for the G-7 to lay all blame at Putin's feet while ignoring the atrocities committed by the ruling Junta in Kiev -- the massacres in Odessa and in Mariupol; the siege of Slovyansk; the aerial bombardment of downtown Luhansk; the terrorism of a marauding National Guard chock full of Right Sector neo-Nazis -- is absurd. It denies any human agency to the citizens of Donbass.

The only conclusion one can draw is that the West enjoyed some success, or at least it believes it did, in backing Moscow off the Ukrainian border and softening the Russian tone toward Kiev. Now the West wants to press on. The U.S./EU power elite feel, have some inside dope, that the Kremlin is wobbly in the face of further sanctions.

This brings us to the main problem with this one-month deadline: There is no real support within Europe to wage a trade war with Russia. The historic EU elections a couple weeks back that delivered the core ruling parties a stunning rebuke in country after country was based on the profound failure of neoliberal austerity-based economics to deliver growth and put people to work as well as a sense that Brussels was relaunching the Cold War. Obviously none of this has been internalized by leaders of the G-7. It is full speed ahead.

But the reality remains that nowhere in Europe will corporations write off huge investments in Russia to please Washington. To any informed observer the trajectory of growth is to the East not the West. Businessmen will not sacrifice future growth and profits in order to maintain American hegemony in Europe.

This is a game of chicken that the U.S. will not win.

Monday, June 2, 2014

Kiev Losing Control

Not having posted on Ukraine since the sham OSCE round table talks the middle of May, there is a good place to dip back. Sabrina Tavernise has an interesting story this morning, "Separatists Storm Border Post in Eastern Ukraine." What is interesting about it is the story undercuts its own headline. But I'll get to that in a minute.

First, a few words about Sabrina Tavernise. I remember her as a reporter in Iraq covering the U.S. occupation during the period of time preceding the surge. She is very attractive, which is memorable, but I also thought she was intelligent. I didn't follow her in Lebanon, but recently she has been covering public health in the United States. (I did a post on a story she did about the low life expectancy in the U.S. compared to other developed countries.)

That's why it is sad for me to find her in Donbass peddling the U.S. Department/Gray Lady line: the Russian-speaking east of Ukraine is experiencing a Putin-contrived violent rebellion against the people-powered democratic government in Kiev.

This morning she reports that a border control headquarters in the city of Luhansk was attacked by "Hundreds of separatist fighters":
The attack in Luhansk, Ukraine’s easternmost province, began at 4 a.m. and fighting was still raging at noon. Oleg Slobodyan, a spokesman for the Ukrainian state border service, said about 500 rebels had stormed the district headquarters building in the Mirny neighborhood, using automatic weapons and rocket launchers with snipers posted in nearby apartment buildings.
Five rebels were killed and eight wounded, Mr. Slobodyan said, though there was no independent confirmation of that count. Seven border guards were injured, he added.
Then five paragraphs later she refutes the first part of the story and says it was the Right Sector dominated Ukrainian National Guard that attacked the border control HQ:
The rebels gave a different view of the fight, saying that their forces were battling members of the ultranationalist Ukrainian group Pravy Sektor and the National Guard, a quasi-governmental force that includes many of the so-called defenders of Maidan who were part of the protests in Kiev that toppled the government this year. 
According to an account from the Russian news agency Itar-Tass, citing the press service of the separatist Luhansk People’s Republic, several hundred armed men took up positions around the border patrol building and began shooting at around 4 a.m. It was not clear who the men were, but the agency characterized the fight as being between Ukrainian nationalist radicals and central government forces. 
It also said that the Ukrainian military had sent a fighter jet to defend the building. Mr. Slobodyan acknowledged that a jet had been dispatched, but he said it flew over without taking action because the fighting was taking place in a residential area.
This squares with plenty of information about the reluctance of the Ukrainian military to get involved in the fighting going back to the beginning of the Donbass uprising. Right Sector is there to guarantee that the Ukrainian military fights. Here is how The Saker describes it in a post from Saturday:
Right now the junta is using an old Bolshevik technique: they send conscript units into combat and right behind them they use "blocking squads" - special Right Sector death squads which will summarily execute anybody not willing fight. While such methods are more or less doable in open terrain they are absolutely impossible to use in an urban environment. Thus, those Ukrainian army forces which might be able to competently execute an urban assault (paratroopers) are rarely willing to do so, while those who would be most willing to do so would either be killed in minutes ("street rioter turned national guardsman in 2 weeks") or to cowardly to try (death squads).
Tavernise basically paints the same picture in her story:
The attack was a deeply troubling sign for Ukraine’s new government, whose president elect, Petro O. Poroshenko, has pledged to crush the separatist movement in the country’s east. That promise may prove difficult to keep, particularly in the lawless areas of southeastern Luhansk, where separatists control large swaths of territory that have become combat zones for Ukrainian forces. 
The assault also raised the question of how strong the central government’s forces are in the east, where many members of the police and other state security forces have either melted away or joined the rebels. Border guards are one of the few forces left in eastern Ukraine, but are not particularly practiced in combat.
If you take the forty minutes or so to watch Frontline's "The Battle for Ukraine," which was broadcast May 27, you come away with a similar impression. The country is being pushed towards anarchy and civil war by the Ukrainian ultra-nationalism of Right Sector. The reporting is strongly skewed toward the Western perspective. The Donbass uprising is portrayed as violent and lawless and paid for by Russia; the bloody attacks on the Maidan in February are entirely the fault of Yanukovych's security forces; Yanukovych abandoned the government in Kiev instead of escaping from a Right Sector death squad; Stepan Bandera was a nationalist hero who fought both the Soviets and the Nazis without a word about the ample role of Bandera's Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA) in the Holocaust; the strong turnout for the independence vote in Donbass was downplayed; etc.

Nonetheless, the picture "The Battle for Ukraine" presents is clear. Right Sector is attacking the east and Ukraine is being torn apart. You have Dmytro Yarosh on camera saying so.

Thursday, May 1, 2014

Putschists Admit Defeat in Donbass


One of the great Descendents songs from the 1980s is "Coolidge," which includes the line "You can only be a victim if you admit defeat."

Bear that in mind as you read today's story by Alison Smale and Andrew Roth, "Ukraine Says That Militants Won the East":
It is by now a well-established pattern. Armed, masked men in their 20s to 40s storm a public building of high symbolic value in a city somewhere in eastern Ukraine, evict anyone still there, seize weapons and ammunition, throw up barricades and proclaim themselves the rulers of a “people’s republic.” It is not clear who is in charge or how the militias are organized. 
Through such tactics, a few thousand pro-Russian militants have seized buildings in about a dozen cities, effectively establishing control over much of an industrial region of about 6.5 million nestled against the Russian border. 
Day by day, in the areas surrounding the cities of Donetsk and Luhansk, pro-Russian forces have defied all efforts by the central government to re-establish its authority, and on Wednesday, Ukraine’s acting president conceded what had long been obvious: The government’s police and security officials had lost control.
“Inactivity, helplessness and even criminal betrayal” plague the security forces, the acting leader, Oleksandr V. Turchynov, told a meeting of regional governors in Kiev. “It is hard to accept but it’s the truth. The majority of law enforcers in the east are incapable of performing their duties.”
With Mr. Turchynov’s acknowledgment that a significant chunk of the country had slipped from the government’s grasp, the long-simmering conflict in Ukraine seemed to enter a new and more dangerous phase. Whether that amounts to the lasting dismemberment of Ukraine or hands control of the east to Russia and its president, Vladimir V. Putin, were among the many questions left unanswered after Mr. Turchynov delivered his stark assessment.
Note the red highlights I added to the copy above. The feckless conduct of the putsch government is going to be papered over in the West with heaping column inches of anti-Putinism. The prestige press and USG could boast no spectacular achievements of propaganda when it came to bestowing legitimacy on the putschist cabal in Kiev. So now that defeat is being openly acknowledged no effort will be spared to lay blame on the "evil Putin." Here is a sample from the same Smale and Roth story:
But so far that has not been necessary. Through stealth and misdirection, and in defiance of Western sanctions, Russia has managed to achieve its immediate goal of what Western and Ukrainian officials believe is rendering Ukraine so chaotic that it cannot guarantee order, mend its teetering economy or elect new leaders to replace Mr. Turchynov and the acting government installed after the pro-Russian president, Victor F. Yanukovych, fled in February.
Nothing sensible like the conclusion that coming to power by means of a coup does not lead to stability and full support from the citizenry. No, the poor patriots in Kiev were destabilized by the adroit wirepulling of Russia's new Rasputin.

But make no mistake. The putschists are in trouble, and it is of their and the West's own making. Yanukovych and the EU had a deal back in February that would have transitioned Ukraine to the kind of democratic gains the western part of the country wanted. But that was torpedoed by U.S. support of the Right Sector spearheaded putsch. You get what you get when you go with violence, something that U.S. policymakers cannot seem to grasp, ever.

As a side note, over at the Moon of Alabama, the blog announced the end is near for the putsch. Moon of Alabama has an excellent track record on declaring victory -- when Obama's missile strike was foiled at the end of last summer, when earlier this year Syria turned the corner on its foreign-funded jihadis, and now in Ukraine.

Thursday, April 24, 2014

The Battle in Eastern Ukraine: Greystone vs.the Green Men

Well, the battle(s) to retake eastern Ukraine appear to be underway this morning. The Gray Lady's C.J. Chivers reporting from Donetsk, along with Andrew Higgins in Kiev and Alan Cowell in London, writes that the putsch interior minister Arsen Avakov is claiming victory in clearing the Mariupol city hall of protesters thanks to the vigilance of "civilian activists" (read: Right Sector goon squad) wearing masks and wielding baseball bats:
In his Facebook posting, Mr. Avakov said there had been “no victims” in the tussle for City Hall in Mariupol, but that bomb disposal experts were checking the building for explosives. 
The A.P. quoted Yulia Lasazan, a spokeswoman for Mariupol’s police department, as saying that roughly 30 masked men had used baseball bats to beat pro-Russia protesters after storming the building in the early hours of Thursday. 
The occupiers did not offer resistance, even though some of them were believed to be armed, The A.P. said, but called the police instead. 
Five people were taken to a hospital, Ms. Lasazan said. 
Ms. Lasazan said the police were controlling the perimeter and were negotiating with the remaining protesters, asking them to leave the building.
So Mariupol city hall has fallen to the putschists. While that is not goods news, Mariupol is not one of the critical protest zones in the east. Slovyansk is. And what is being reported there is that five pro-Russian protesters have been killed manning barricades that block entry into the city. The Wall Street Journal has the story, "Ukraine Says Up to 5 Militants Killed in East":
Ukrainian authorities said Thursday that up to five pro-Russian militants were killed and three roadblocks overrun outside an eastern city at the heart of a local insurgency, as Kiev restarted a military operation to regain control in the region. 
Also on Thursday, Russian President Vladimir Putin said the use of military force against Ukrainian civilians would have consequences for the leadership in Kiev. He didn't elaborate on what they would be. 
"If the Kiev regime begins to use the army against its own citizens, that is, without a doubt, a very serious crime," he said. "This will certainly have an impact on those who make such decisions and on our bilateral relations." 
Mr. Putin didn't repeat his previous statements that Moscow reserves the right to defend ethnic Russians or Russian-speakers in eastern Ukraine. There was no immediate indication that Moscow was preparing to use military force, though it has built up troops along the border with Ukraine.
There are a couple of questions here. First, if five died defending a few roadblocks at the edge of the city, what is the death toll going to be if an attempt is made to clear Slovyansk city hall? I would imagine it is going to be much higher. Judging from the video of a funeral service for a young man slain on Easter manning one of the barricades, Slovyansk is a city mobilized and solidly anti-putsch. The putschist special forces are going to be confronting enraged old women as well as armed men. This is a combination that routed the first "anti-terrorism" campaign last week. And recall then that Avakov had initially celebrated the success of securing an airfield at Kramatorsk before everything collapsed fantastically.

My assessment at the time was that the debacle the putschists experienced was proof that Russia was not going to allow a single victory for Kiev in the east. So that is the second question this morning: Does this assessment still hold? Will Russia allow the pro-Russian uprising in the Donbass to be rolled up by what is likely a U.S. mercenary-filled military force?

I don't see how Russia can. First, there is public opinion in Russia. For Putin to stand by as pro-Russian protesters are either killed or rounded up would be devastating to his standing domestically. Then there is the fact that if the putschists are successful in pacifying the east and completing their May 25 presidential election, predations against Russians are not going to magically cease. There is a strong chance they will accelerate. If Obama is willing to directly support the canard that the protesters in Donetsk were creating a system of registration for Jews, then there is little doubt that he will provide public relations assistance for the Kiev gang as they mop up the dissidents in the Donbass.

No, Russia has to act. And right now that looks like they are willing to match their "green men," their special forces, against whatever mercenaries the CIA has been able to piece together for the putschists. Call it Greystone vs. the Green Men. At this point I don't see a Russian ground invasion.

Monday, April 21, 2014

The Obama Legacy: A New Cold War

The Geneva statement issued last Thursday has already unraveled. Early Sunday morning at a checkpoint outside of Slovyansk pro-Russian protesters came under fire. Three people have been reported killed and four wounded. The attackers are likely the neo-fascist group Right Sector. Andrew Kramer reporting from Slovyansk has the story, "Shootout Underscores Fragile Truce in Ukraine":
Ukraine’s Foreign Ministry issued a statement on Sunday calling groundless the Russian ministry’s assertion that the attackers had been members of Right Sector. Right Sector also denied any involvement. 
“The Russian side must be reminded about their obligations under the Geneva agreement to bring all necessary influence to bear on separatists to clear illegally held buildings, unblock roads, lay down arms and prevent any bloodshed,” the Ukrainian statement said. 
Life News, a Russian tabloid television channel, reported that pro-Russian militants had found a business card of the leader of Right Sector, Dmytro Yarosh, among the belongings said to have been left behind by one of the attackers, along with guns and stacks of American dollars. 
The Russian Foreign Ministry issued a statement saying that “as a result of an attack by insurgents of the so-called Right Sector, innocent civilians have died.” It added that pro-Russian fighters had found “aerial photographs of that district” and Right Sector emblems in cars seized from the attackers. “The Russian side is indignant at this provocation of the insurgents, which shows the Kiev authorities’ unwillingness to rein and disarm the nationalists and extremists,” it said.
As to be expected, in order to divert attention from this brazen violation of the Geneva statement, the Obama administration peddled putsch government photographs that purportedly prove Russian special forces are directing the pro-Russian uprising in the Donbass. Andrew Higgins, Michael Gordon and Andrew Kramer have the story, "Photos Link Masked Men in East Ukraine to Russia":
“There has been broad unity in the international community about the connection between Russia and some of the armed militants in eastern Ukraine, and the photos presented by the Ukrainians last week only further confirm this, which is why U.S. officials have continued to make that case,” Jen Psaki, the State Department spokeswoman, said Sunday. 
The question of Russia’s role in eastern Ukraine has a critical bearing on the agreement reached Thursday in Geneva among Russian, Ukrainian, American and European diplomats to ease the crisis. American officials have said that Russia would be held responsible for ensuring that the Ukrainian government buildings were vacated, and that it could face new sanctions if the terms were not met.
This is the U.S. attempt to shift the narrative away from Right Sector violence; it likely also prefigures another round of largely cosmetic sanctions directed at the Russian ruling elite. Also, make note. Whenever you see a story written or co-written by Michael Gordon, what you are getting is the official lie.

Going forward, what we are working our way towards, and the direction events have been moving since Crimea last month, is -- "How serious is the West about initiating a trade war with Russia?" We have heard a lot of talk from Obama and Kerry about costs, but so far those costs have been negligible. The conundrum facing the United States is that as soon as it really starts to walk the talk, that will be the time that prominent EU members -- like Germany and Italy -- begin to make noise about getting off the train. Europe's future growth is in the east not the west.

What seems apparent is that the White House is not going to abandon the putschists in Kiev. We are dealing with a parent's love of his child. This means that we can expect more deadly shenanigans from Right Sector goon squads, which will eventually lead to a thorough counterattack from the "green men."

This is not going to end well for either the putschists nor the Obama administration. What Obama must realize is that there is zero popular support for this New Cold War he is creating. This is not 1948 Berlin. The more he pursues it, the greater the chances of his legacy being one of infamy.

Thursday, April 17, 2014

Get Ready for Banderastan

The Gray Lady presents a horn of plenty in her coverage of the unfolding crisis in Ukraine this morning. But on closer inspection the edibles turn out to be the usual assortment of dried dung we have come to expect from the paper's foreign affairs reporting.

There are two noteworthy pieces. First, Andrew Kramer's tendentious coverage ("Ukrainian Security Forces Kill 3 Pro-Russian Protesters") of the murder of pro-Russian protesters in the port city of Mariupol by members of the newly created neo-Nazi National Guard. Kramer repeats the line being laid down by putschist interim interior minister Arsen Avakov that after repeated attempts to calmly and peacefully disperse an armed mob trying to overrun the Guard's military installation there was an exchange of fire and three pro-Russian protesters were killed:
Ukrainian security forces killed three pro-Russian protesters, wounded 13 and took 63 captive in a firefight overnight in the eastern city of Mariupol, the interim Ukrainian interior minister said on Thursday. The clash was the most lethal so far in the east of the country. 
The minister, Arsen Avakov, said pro-Russian protesters had tried to storm a base used by troops in the newly formed National Guard, which has drawn from volunteers who took part in last winter’s protest movement against the government.
For a different perspective, check out The Guardian's version, "Fatal clashes at Ukrainian military base":
But footage published by 0629 appeared to show a disorganised assault by protesters, who said they had been unarmed and were seeking negotiations. 
In a video posted on the site, a masked man wearing a St George's ribbon and a military helmet said after "the gates came down" soldiers began shooting at protesters and also threw stun grenades, wounding several of them. A man with him said a wounded comrade had been left inside the base, indicating protestors had penetrated the walls. 
"We were yelling, asking for the troops, the commander, to come out for negotiations, because no one here wants blood. They answered with shooting," the first man said. 
A third man said troops had fired at "peaceful residents". In another video, a masked man with a megaphone standing behind some lorries calls on troops inside the base to come out: "We don't want you – our guys, friends, comrades – to suffer."
None of this is even hinted at in Kramer's story, nor is the well-known fact, except for the person who reads the Gray Lady exclusively, that the new Ukrainian National Guard is composed mainly of Right Sector and Svoboda fighters.

But Kramer outdoes himself in providing an apologia for the stunning -- maybe a better word would be "epic" -- rout of the Ukrainian military yesterday in its failed effort to subdue the popular uprising in the Donbass:
Driving off the separatists in such a mixed crowd, or even trying to arrest them, would be a difficult task for a well-disciplined force with high morale. It would risk endangering civilians, potentially leading to bloodshed that might provoke a Russian military reaction. 
But there are few signs that the Ukrainian military or the National Guard is trained or equipped for such crowd-control tactics. Ukraine disbanded the country’s riot police, the Berkut, after the uprising in February. 
The methods appear to put the current government in the position of facing the protest and street fighting tactics that brought it to power just two months ago. The pro-Russians, however, are backing a different cause: Those in the east are not seeking the overthrow of a corrupt government and closer association with the European Union, but an expansion of Russian influence in Ukraine.
No, protesters in eastern Ukraine are seeking to separate themselves from an illegal government brought to power in a putsch by an armed gang of neo-Nazis.

This is why the Western governments and their heralds in the prestige press continue to lose the information war. They have to elide the glaringly obvious: the current national government in Kiev is illegal; it came to power through a violent insurrection against a elected president. Any occlusion of this fact, which is a sin qua non for the Gray Lady's coverage of the crisis in Ukraine, is going to strain the credibility of the reporting.

Kramer does provide some delicious texture to the putschists' epic defeat yesterday:
In Kiev, the Ministry of Defense initially denied that the armored vehicles had been captured. Then Sergei Sobolev, the acting head of the Fatherland party in Parliament, claimed that the armored vehicles had flown Russian flags as part of an ingenious subterfuge to get through pro-Russian crowds. 
Ukrainian news media quoted Mr. Sobolev as saying it was a “guerrilla approach” to infiltrate separatist-controlled areas through pro-Russian civilian mobs. Rather than a disastrous setback for Ukrainians, he said the appearance of Ukrainian military vehicles flying Russian flags was a “breakthrough” for the Ukrainian offensive, though it proved to be nothing of the sort. 
Later, the Ukrainian military conceded that six vehicles had been captured but said nothing of the surrender of rifles from the other column. 
Others struggled to understand why things had gone so badly wrong. “We try not to criticize our authorities, but it is obvious that we have more and more problems,” said Dmytro Tymchuk, a former military officer and director of the Center of Military and Political Research, a Kiev-based research group.
The second noteworthy story is Michael Gordon's "Kerry Joins Geneva Talks on Crisis in Ukraine," an earlier version of which was much more strident in its anti-Russian tone. Gordon is a faithful scribe of the U.S. State Department; really, he is identical to a government employee. In explicating the U.S. negotiating position going into the four-party talks that start today, Gordon quotes a senior State Department official saying, "The idea here is that they [Russia] would stop aiding and abetting and supporting the separatists and that they would pull their troops back from the border." Obviously this is a non-starter.

Nowhere is there any indication that the elites who run the show in Washington D.C. will seek to calm the situation and work with Russia to make sure that Ukraine can remain a viable state. Russia has to be a partner for Ukraine to exist. The White House doesn't care apparently. Its goal appears to be primarily a military one. So expect more mayhem. Get ready for Banderastan.

Monday, April 14, 2014

What Pearls of Wisdom CIA Chief Brennan Imparted While in Kiev are Hard to Imagine

The pro-Russian uprising in eastern Ukraine appears at this point to be unbowed and gaining traction. This from a solid round-up of the events this past weekend by Andrew Kramer and Andrew Higgins, "No Action Seen From Ukraine as Deadline for Militants Passes":
Through Monday morning, as the sun burned off a dense mist rising from stubbly winter fields in the region, the Ukrainian news media reported no efforts to storm occupied buildings in the eastern part of the country. No police officers or military personnel were gathered outside the regional administration building in Donetsk, which flies a Russian flag as well as the flag of the recently declared but as yet unrecognized People’s Republic of Donetsk. 
In another indication of the scale of the loss of control by the central government, pro-Russian protesters set up a checkpoint on a main highway about 25 miles outside of Donetsk. 
The government’s push on Sunday to reassert its authority in a vital industrial and coal-mining region appeared to have made little headway. Pro-Russian protesters appeared to control not only the police station but also the entire town of Slovyansk, after having set up checkpoints at major streets leading into town.
The protesters blocked a major highway in the east, and Russian and Donetsk flags flew over administrative buildings in several other midsize towns, including Mariupol, where protesters seized a building Sunday.
My sense is that the putschists in Kiev don't have control of the armed forces. Why else throw out ultimatums that can't be met? They might have an "elite" unit or two like Alfa, which may or may not be composed largely of mercenaries, as well as Right Sector hooligans. But apparently these forces are not enough to storm and hold the myriad government buildings under occupation. Also, I would guess that Russia has elite special forces in plainclothes on the ground in these eastern cities. Once the Ukrainian attack begins we can expect that they will play a role.

The fact that CIA chief John Brennan was reported to be in Kiev instructing the putschists over the weekend is proof that things are very shaky for Yats & Co.:
Russian news media reported Sunday that the American C.I.A. director, John O. Brennan, had arrived in Kiev on a secret visit to advise Ukrainian officials in charge of domestic security and defense. The American Embassy in the Ukrainian capital declined to comment on the reports.
The problem for the putschists is while these buildings can be stormed and taken by mercenaries, how can they be held? The military and state security apparatus obviously cannot be relied upon; hence, the appearance of Greystone personnel. What pearls of wisdom Brennan had to impart are hard imagine.

Wednesday, April 9, 2014

Contradictions From the Gray Lady's Foreign Correspondents

At times I feel sympathy for the Gray Lady's foreign correspondents. They are, as I am, factotums. Their job is to produce copy that toes the paper's line, a line designed to mirror that of the USG. This requires reportage filled with contradictions. Take for instance today's Ukraine installment by Andrew Higgins and David Herszenhorn, "U.S. and NATO Warn Russia Against Further Intervention in Ukraine." The story begins with that prodigious liar Secretary of State John Kerry ominously claiming to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that the pro-Russian protests and government building occupations in eastern Ukraine are the work of Russian saboteurs. Herszenhorn and Higgins then proceed to make a compelling case, complete with quotes from a Ukrainian Interior Ministry official, for the opposite. The uprising in the East is a bickering, not broadly representative movement led by pensioners whose goals are myriad and contradictory -- independence, accession to the Russian Federation, autonomous status within Ukraine:
Ukrainian security experts said the pro-Russia camp in Donetsk was bitterly divided over its goals and scoffed at its attempt to seize power. “They have no clear idea of what they want,” said Nikolai Yakubovich, an adviser to the Interior Ministry in Kiev. “It is a nonsense, a dangerous nonsense.” He said negotiations had started between protest leaders in Donetsk and the authorities but had been hampered by infighting between rival pro-Russia factions over their aims. 
As part of its efforts to regain control, the government in Kiev flew antiterrorism forces to the Donetsk airport on Tuesday and vowed to prevent eastern Ukraine from going the way of Crimea, where pro-Russia demonstrations paved the way for a formal annexation by Moscow.
If this was a Russian operation like Crimea, as Kerry claims, there would be nothing but precision and efficiency. That is what Crimea showed, prompting a love letter of sorts to the new Russian military from C.J. Chivers, an unlikely source. But the Gray Lady must stick to the script, which is that the pro-Russian protests are not a spontaneous vox populi; rather, they are the work of the evil Putin. This allows the U.S. State Department to call for a brutal crackdown on protesters when they inveighed against any such moves on the Maidan. Nonetheless the reporting shows the strain of the contradiction.

The same can be said for Andrew Higgins' "Among Ukraine’s Jews, the Bigger Worry Is Putin, Not Pogroms," which seems to be written in belated response to the widespread acceptance that neo-Nazis were an essential part of the putsch coalition that brought down Yanukovych in February. Call it damage control. But, once again, if one takes the time to read the story, the headline rings hollow. Higgins, in making the case that Jews have nothing to worry about from Right Sector and Svoboda, actually creates the impression that they should be very worried:
When protests against Mr. Yanukovych started in November, [Rabbi Kaminezki said], many Jews shared the pro-European aspirations of the demonstrators who gathered in Kiev’s Independence Square, though some worried about the role played by far-right groups. One such group, Svoboda, stirred particular unease because of anti-Semitic remarks by its leaders in the past and its lionization of Ukrainian nationalist heroes who, in some cases, helped the Nazis and shared their ethnicity-based concept of nationhood. 
But Rabbi Kaminezki [chief rabbi of Dnipropetrovsk] said fears of a fascist revival had faded, “as there is a difference between what these people say to their own crowd and what they do when they become legitimate political leaders.” Anti-Semitism, he added, “exists in Ukraine, like everywhere,” but it has shown no sign of increasing since Mr. Yanukovych lost power. 
After a series of unsolved anti-Semitic attacks since his ouster, including an assault on a rabbi and his wife in Kiev, the new head of Ukraine’s state security service told Jewish leaders that he would reopen a special unit to fight xenophobia and anti-Semitism that had been shut down under Mr. Yanukovych. 
Even Right Sector, a coalition of ultranationalist and in some cases neo-Nazi organizations, has made an effort to distance itself from anti-Semitism. In late February, its leader, Dmytro Yarosh, pledged during a meeting with Israel’s ambassador in Kiev to fight all forms of racism.
See, it is all good. Dmytro Yarosh is going to lead the struggle for tolerance.

One of the most bow-backed of the Gray Lady's scribes is Anne Barnard; she has had to shoulder untold column inches of manure fertilizing the canard that the war in Syria is result of a bloodthirsty dictator's lust to obliterate skyping pro-democracy activists in skinny jeans, rather than a region-wide war pitting Shiite-aligned states against the West and their Gulf sheikhdom clients. But at this point in the war, with any Syrian opposition swallowed up by jihadis, and the jihadis at war among themselves and regularly defeated on the battlefield by the Syrian Arab Army and its allies in Hezbollah, Barnard, while never missing an opportunity to denigrate or downplay the Assad government, lets it be known that Syria is winning the war. Her story today, "Muslim Shrine Stands as a Crossroads in Syria’s Unrest," is worth reading:
Hezbollah has long said that protecting the shrine [the tomb of Zeinab, a granddaughter of the Prophet Muhammad, outside Damascus] was a major rationale for sending fighters to Syria, a move that upended regional alliances, deepened Lebanon’s political and sectarian divisions and turned crucial battles in the Syrian government’s favor. 
Hezbollah and Syrian officials long played down the party’s role, saying the Syrian Army led the fight. But with recent victories, their calculus appears to be shifting. Hezbollah’s leader, Hassan Nasrallah, recently declared that the Syrian government was safe from collapse and that his group’s only mistake was entering the battle “late.” 
Some in Syria are newly eager to catalog, as a show of strength, the added muscle from abroad, and not just from Hezbollah.
A Syrian who coordinates between government forces and Hezbollah around the shrine said that Iran’s elite Revolutionary Guards are not simply advising Damascus, but fighting near the northern city of Aleppo. Hezbollah and Iran, he said, have trained more than 100,000 Syrians, in Syria, Lebanon and Tehran, to form the National Defense Forces militias. On Tuesday, Iran delivered 30,000 tons of food supplies to Syria, The Associated Press reported. 
“The game is changed,” the coordinator said, asking not to be identified for his safety. He confirmed much of what Western officials assert about the government’s foreign support, calling it a trump card that Damascus saved for the right moment. 
“It is no longer a secret,” he added. “It is on the table.”
The government could not have advanced on the Lebanese border and east of Damascus without Hezbollah’s expert fighters, he said. But the bulk of Shiite volunteers, he added, are Iraqi Shiites, lightly trained in Iraq and sent to front lines in Damascus suburbs like Qaboun and Jobar because “we need numbers.” 
But now, after new training as the Abu Fadl al-Abbas brigades, the Iraqis are “able to do something, not just coming to be killed,” the coordinator said.
This is a huge achievement for Hezbollah, Iraq and Syria. I assume a lot of the turmoil in Ukraine, Turkey and of course Iraq is connected to the bad fortune of the jihadis in Syria.

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Unrest in Eastern Ukraine Benefits Putschists

Since last month's accession of Crimea to the Russian Federation we've been waiting for the other shoe to drop in Ukraine's industrial East. Something like the sound of a boot thudding on the floorboards is presently audible. Beginning Sunday pro-Russian demonstrators occupied government buildings throughout eastern Ukraine, principally the cities of Donetsk, Lugansk and Kharkiv. The Kharkiv occupation has been rolled back by Ukrainian Interior Ministry troops, who, according to the Russians, are rife with Right Sector goons and mercenaries from the contractor formerly known as Blackwater. This is from today's story, "Ukrainian Troops Move to Reassert Control in East," by David Herszenhorn and Andrew Roth:
The Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, responding to the deployment of Ukrainian Interior Ministry troops, issued a stern statement accusing the Ukrainian government of embedding within its forces in eastern Ukraine both nationalist militants from the group Right Sector and private American mercenaries from a company called Greystone. 
It said the American contractors were being disguised as members of a military unit called “Falcon.” 
Academi, a private American security company affiliated with Greystone that was once known as Blackwater, notorious for its military contracting work in Iraq, issued a statement in mid-March saying its personnel were not working in Ukraine, after similar allegations surfaced in the Russian press. 
The company did not immediately respond to the statement from the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
In Donetsk the protesters called for the formation of an independent republic and a referendum on secession. The occupations in Lugansk and Donetsk are under siege.

The message being sent in unison from the putschists in Kiev and their Western benefactors is that this outbreak in the East is from Russian orchestration:
While widely regarded as political theater that is supported, if not directed, by the Kremlin, the protests could help promote what analysts say is Russia’s primary goal of destabilizing the shaky government in Kiev, preventing it from drifting further into the West’s orbit and giving Moscow leverage over the country’s future ahead of presidential elections in May. 
The turmoil in eastern Ukraine also makes it extremely difficult for the provisional government in Kiev to begin putting in place austerity measures and financial overhauls required by the International Monetary Fund as a condition for an $18 billion loan package that the country desperately needs to avert a default on its debt. 
The protesters themselves may be trying to provoke a violent response from Kiev, analysts say, hoping to provide the pretext for a Crimea-like military incursion in a country that Moscow considers an integral part of historical Russia.
You'll notice that in making the case for Russian string-pulling, Herszenhorn and Roth actually produce an argument that points to the putschists being the main beneficiaries of turbulence in the East. The IMF mandates, likely not only to fire up the Maidan once implementation begins but also end any hope of keeping Right Sector on the reservation, can be put off as long as there is a crisis of potential invasion from Russia.

The Gray Lady's lede unsigned editorial today, "A Familiar Script in Ukraine," repeats the same contradiction: It starts off asserting Russia's initiation of the protests but then makes a persuasive case that the Russians couldn't be behind the building seizures because they have nothing to gain and a lot to lose:
Yet [Putin] must understand that the cost of invading eastern Ukraine would be much greater than the putsch in Crimea, both in damage to Russia’s already sagging economy and in the new Cold War that would surely arise. Ukrainians would not forgive the theft of an economically critical region; NATO would be re-energized; and opposition within Russia would also grow as isolation and potential recession shut off the freedoms and prosperity Russians were learning to enjoy.
One thing we have learned is that Russia, unlike the United States, is a rational actor. Clearly Putin knows the difference between Donetsk and Sevastopol. The Crimea operation was a slam dunk. Assimilating eastern Ukraine into the Russian Federation would be no such thing. This is obvious.

No, the Russians have been consistent here. Their bargaining position is -- 1) give the regions broad autonomy, and 2) no NATO inclusion for the Ukrainian state. The putschists, holding a terrible hand, facing painful austerity and economic collapse, are taking a page from the playbook of their Western benefactors -- when you have a problem, make it bigger.

Russia, as I see it, was content to wait unlike the billionaire chocolate oligarch Petro Poroshenko is elected president next month, at which point his seized Russian factory would be on the negotiating table as part of any deal.

The putsch regime is fundamentally unstable. The neo-Nazis can only be kept on the reservation as long as the Russian bogeyman is alive and kicking. Once austerity sets in all bets are off.

Monday, March 17, 2014

Threat of EU Sanctions on Russia Already Falling Flat

After an ennui-drenched Friday, a wonderful weekend.

Saturday was spent throwing a football with a coworker's sons, marching and chanting for "$15 Now!" The speeches at the post-march rally were actually good/informative. James Bible, former head of the Seattle NAACP, spoke about the class warfare being waged on the poor. Then Kshama Sawant laid out the plan for dealing with plutocratic opposition to the $15/hr. minimum wage -- agreeing to a three-year phase in for small business and non-profits to neutralize the plutocrats' tactic of hiding behind small business and then full speed ahead on gathering signatures to bring the $15/hr. minimum wage to the ballot as an initiative. I topped off the day by streaming two good movies: Out of the Furnace (2013) and Inside Llewyn Davis (2013). Both hard-luck stories.

Sunday I ran the annual St. Paddy's Day Dash, which I do every year. I enjoy the course, which is up 99 from Seattle Center until just before you get to the bridge over to Wallingford; then you turn around and come back to Seattle Center. I was worried my time would be worse than it was, but it wasn't, despite being waterlogged by a steady rain. The rest of the day after the morning race I relaxed. Good weekend.

And one of the reasons the weekend was so good, in addition to a welcome decline in number of the usual threats emanating from Great Satan's orifice, was the result of the referendum in Crimea went smoothly. According to a story this morning by Alan Cowell, "Lawmakers in Crimea Move Swiftly to Split From Ukraine":
The referendum — in which 96.77 percent of voters supported breaking from Ukraine and joining the Russian Federation — was greeted as a triumph in Moscow on Monday, and lawmakers there promised to move quickly to adopt legislation to absorb Crimea into the Russian Federation. “Crimea returns to Russia!” a headline in Komsomolskaya Pravda said, while Nezavisimaya Gazeta declared that “Kiev lost Crimea.”
A member of Parliament announced that President Vladimir V. Putin would deliver an address to lawmakers on the situation in Crimea on Tuesday. Mr. Putin told President Obama on Sunday that the vote was legal and cited the independence of Kosovo — which Russia has not recognized — as the precedent for Crimea’s secession, the Kremlin said in a statement.
“The referendum was organized in such a way as to guarantee Crimea’s population the possibility to freely express their will and exercise their right to self-determination,” the Kremlin’s statement on the latest of a series of conversations between the two leaders said. 
Mr. Putin also continued to raise the issue of violence and protests in other parts of Ukraine, which have stoked fears that Russia could move forces beyond Crimea. He told Mr. Obama that “the current authorities in Kiev have so far failed to demonstrate the ability and desire to rein in the ultranationalist and radical groups that are destabilizing the situation in the country and terrorizing ordinary people, including the Russian-speaking population and Russia’s compatriots,” the Kremlin statement said.
The putschists in Kiev called up reservists (which they have done before, to little effect) and added another 20,000 to a new national guard being put together under the direction of the neo-Nazis in Right Sector.

Now the ball is in Brussels' court. So far the sounds emanating from the European bureaucracy are meek:
In Brussels, foreign ministers of European Union countries met on Monday to weigh a first response to Moscow’s unfolding strategy in Ukraine, including possible economic sanctions. 
One of the ministers attending the European Union meeting in Brussels, Sebastian Kurz of Austria, gave a strong indication that the punitive European measures under debate would not initially reach into the highest echelons of Russia’s powerful energy companies, which are close to the Kremlin.
In a radio interview, Mr. Kurz said Sunday’s ballot in Ukraine would trigger an array of measures including visa bans and the freezing of assets held by political and military figures who orchestrated Russia’s intervention in Crimea, Reuters reported. 
Asked whether the list would include the heads of the energy giants Gazprom and Rosneft, as reported on Friday in Germany, Mr. Kurz replied: “This is not expected at this time.” 
He added: “I think picking business bosses indiscriminately would be a wrong step.” 
The foreign ministers meeting in Brussels, he said, would draw up a list of people to be subjected to the measures. The ministers have been reported to be trying to reduce a tally of up to 130 names to a smaller number.
Western tough talk on sanctions already appears to be falling flat.

But before we leave to discuss briefly the long, to-be-expected hand-wringing think piece about the tarnished luster of U.S. hegemony by David Sanger, a statement from British Foreign Secretary William Hague:
As he arrived in the Belgian capital on Sunday, Mr. Hague called the Crimea referendum “a mockery of proper democratic practice.”
But a lethally violent insurrection in a nation's capital that sent the elected president fleeing in order to avoid being lynched by neo-Nazis brandishing weapons from a looted armory, this is "proper democratic practice"?

Western rulers and their court ideologues have turned the world upside down in defense of unilateralism. This is on full display in the aforementioned David Sanger analysis, "Global Crises Put Obama’s Strategy of Caution to the Test." Sanger runs through the standard "Neocon vs. Realist" debate. There is not much to recommend taking the time to read it. Public opinion -- what the voters in the "Greatest Nation on Earth"™ think about endless warfare to police the entire planet -- rates only a brief, indirect mention out of a lot of column inches of copy:
Not surprisingly, the testing of administration policy at a time the president is politically weakened at home has sparked a critical question. Is it Mr. Obama’s deliberative, pick-your-battles approach that is encouraging adversaries to press the limits? Or is this simply a time when exercising leverage over countries that defy American will or the international order is trickier than ever, and when the domestic pressure to stay out of international conflicts is obvious to overseas friends and foes alike?
This is obviously the question to explore, but Sanger ignores it. How long can governing elites continue to act as if they exist in a free-floating cloud above the masses who elect them?

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

A Question or Two for Yats and Obama Tomorrow

To get a sense of the Bizarro World that the United States presently occupies take a peek at its wish list, intended to resolve the Ukrainian crisis, that Kerry delivered to Lavrov this past weekend:
In a Saturday morning call with Mr. Lavrov, Mr. Kerry emphasized that Russian steps to annex Crimea would close the window for more diplomacy. Later that day, the State Department sent Mr. Lavrov a page-and-half document with a series of questions that were intended to see whether the Kremlin was receptive to the United States’ proposals before Mr. Kerry traveled to meet with Mr. Putin.
American officials wanted to know if Russia would cease its military advances in Crimea, rein in Crimean militias and also work with the contact group on steps like an International Monetary Fund program to stabilize the Ukrainian economy and a countrywide election. They also wanted Russia to halt moves to annex the Crimean Peninsula, and were looking for signs that Russia would be willing to return their troops to their barracks, allow international monitors to work in Crimea and, importantly, meet with new Ukrainian government, either directly or as part of a contact group. 
Russia never responded officially to the questions. Yet an answer of sorts came on Monday when, to the surprise of the State Department, Russian television carried the short video clip of Mr. Putin and Mr. Lavrov. 
Mr. Putin said that he had authorized Mr. Lavrov to invite Mr. Kerry to Russia. Mr. Lavrov responded that he had expected Mr. Kerry to arrive as early as Monday for talks that could involve Mr. Putin himself. 
“But then on Saturday he called and said that he would like to postpone the trip for the moment,” Mr. Lavrov added, referring to Mr. Kerry. 
The Russian foreign minister went on to complain that the paper Mr. Kerry had given him on Friday cast Moscow as a belligerent and treated the establishment of the new Western-backed government in Ukraine as a “fait accompli.”
This appears in "U.S. and Russia Hit Diplomatic Roadblock Trying to Start Ukraine Talks" by Michael Gordon and Steven Lee Myers. As a first proposal, the Obama administration must know that it is a non-starter. For it to be anything but an intentional non-starter would mean that there is no one in a position of authority in the Obama administration who can interpret the obvious -- that Russia is deadly serious about what is going on in Ukraine and is not going to settle for some sort of accommodation with the putschists. This is from a good story by Ellen Barry, "Titans in Russia Fear New Front in Ukraine Crisis":
Russia’s tycoons have been silent since the crisis began, apart from approving messages on social media. Many inside Russia’s large corporations are no doubt supportive of Mr. Putin’s moves in Crimea, which are widely seen here as correcting a historical error made by the Soviet leader Nikita S. Khrushchev, when he transferred Crimea to the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic. Mr. Putin’s approval ratings are at their highest point since he returned to the presidency in 2012. If corporate leaders are complaining, they are doing it quietly. 
“Of course they’re upset, but it doesn’t mean they are prepared to challenge Russia’s foreign policy,” said Mikhail E. Dmitriyev, an economist whose research group, the Center for Strategic Research, was originally founded to shape Mr. Putin’s economic platform. “This is a new reality. Even if somebody has reservations with regard to the policy’s effectiveness, I strongly doubt they would express it. This is a policy which, for the moment, is backed by the vast majority of the public. It’s not an exaggeration.”
Kerry and Obama enjoy no such support. Citizens of the homeland see only more war games and billions spent overseas while their rents are raised and a couple bags of groceries add up to a $100. European allies have already made clear their reluctance to slap economic sanctions on Russia.

Then there is the unstable situation within the putsch government itself. It is a business-as-usual, Orange-Revolution-redux oligarchical structure that came to power by means of Svoboda and Right Sector muscle. At this point it is not clear that this pairing is anything more than an evanescent marriage of convenience. Right Sector has promised to reformulate itself as an electoral organization that will vie for power in upcoming elections. Right Sector, at least from what I have read, is to the right of Svoboda, does not support greater integration with Europe and its decadent values, and currently is riding a crest of popularity for its role on the Maidan.

In the near term, the United States continues to lose the information war. And the reason it is losing the propaganda battle is the insistence that the putschists are legitimately democratic. In order to make this stick, a tremendous feat in perception management is required, given that we are indoctrinated in the West from the time we learn how to read that democracy means elections. And Yanukovych was the legitimately elected leader of the country, who just happened to be run out of town by armed goons -- not what most normally consider to be a legitimate, democratic process.

As if to underscore this, today Yanukovych was trundled before the cameras. Steven Lee Myers has the story, "Ukraine’s Ousted Leader Urges Military to Resist New Government":
Mr. Yanukovych has mostly remained in hiding since he fled Ukraine, and his public role in the conflict has been so marginalized that he began his remarks by dismissing rumors of his ill health and even death. “I am alive,” he said, going on to dispute the legality of the actions the Parliament took after a European-brokered agreement on Feb. 21 collapsed. “And I have not been impeached, according to the Ukrainian Constitution.”
This is a shrewd move by Moscow, preempting tomorrow's White House meeting between putsch president Arseniy Yatsenyuk and Obama. If there is any reporter worth his or her salt allowed to question the putschist and his sponsor, this question will be asked: "Was President Yanukovych impeached as set forth in the Ukrainian Constitution? And, if not, how is the current government legal?"

Friday, March 7, 2014

Ukraine is Going to Get Even Messier

As another week comes to an end and Washington and Moscow are still jousting over Ukraine, the best statement, a statement that properly encapsulates what we are witnessing in this new Cold War, comes from the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs' rebuttal to the embarrassingly weak “President Putin’s Fiction: 10 False Claims About Ukraine” put out by the U.S. State Department on Wednesday:
“They cannot get over it and come to terms with the fact that they cannot always dictate their will and act in their customary role of ‘infallible judge,’ which is followed by — the last word,” it said. “Their nerves are giving out, but that is no reason to thrust guilt on the innocent.”
It is just going to get worse for the United States. Crimea will vote in nine days to secede from Ukraine and join the Russian Federation, and there is nothing the United States can do about it. And this is driving the smart set at Great Satan HQ batty. Obama, in what is becoming regular ritualized performances of "The Emperor Has No Clothes," steps before the cameras and denounces the Crimean vote as a violation of international law. “Any discussion about the future of Ukraine must include the legitimate government of Ukraine.”

And therein lies the problem for the U.S./EU: the insistence that a government that came to power by means of a violent insurrection in Kiev spearheaded by fascists from western Ukraine is legitimately democratic, while an autonomous jurisdiction that is historically Russian seeking to realign with the Russian Federation by plebiscite is illegal, unconstitutional and anti-democratic. Obama's statement is risible.

One would hope that the Cold Warriors in the State Department would cut their losses now and end this charade, but don't count on it. I don't think that they are going to let the Crimea vote come off unimpeded. Whether through overt saber rattling by sending more U.S. fighter jets to the region or more war ships to the Black Sea, or a covert campaign of destabilization using Right Sector shock troops, as was done during the February putsch, I don't know. But as of now I think that some form military escalation is likely.

Take the news, reported today in "Moscow Signals It Will Embrace Crimean Move for Secession," by Steven Lee Myers, David Herszenhorn and Alan Cowell, that DmytroYarosh, the head of the fascist organization Right Sector, plans to re-brand his group and run for president:
In Kiev, the leader of the Right Sector movement, Dmytro Yarosh, will run for president of Ukraine, the chairman of the local branch of the movement, Andriy Tarasenko, said on Friday. The nationalist group, which was important in the fight for Kiev’s Independence Square, will rename itself at a congress in a week and participate in elections at all levels, Mr. Tarasenko said. 
Right Sector has been controversial for its semi-military organization, but it has also refrained from working in eastern Ukraine, where its presence could be seen as a provocation by Russia. But Mr. Tarasenko said that the group is prepared to fight, in Crimea and elsewhere, “if the Kremlin tramples on us further.” He added, “Accordingly, we are conducting mobilization and are preparing to repel foreign aggression.”
This is bad news for the West. Not only does it expose the lie that far right ultranationalists were a negligible part of the uprising against Yanukovych, it means that the putsch government might have great difficulty implementing the IMF austerity mandates coming their way. Right Sector, according to a decent, dispassionate appraisal by Emmanuel Dreyfus, "Who Was in Kiev’s Independence Square?," that appears in the weekend edition on the Counterpunch web site, is to the right of Svoboda, another Banderist political construct, and does not support integrating with the European Union:
The biggest, Pravy Sektor (right sector), emerged after the Grushevsky Street clashes and, for the moment, enjoys real popular support. It has a few thousand members across the country, including people disappointed by Svoboda, members of ultra-nationalist groups, hooligans and dropouts. Their common denominator is a taste for radical action, and for the ideology that one of the movement’s leaders, Andrei Tarassenko, dispensed from its high-security headquarters on the fifth floor of Trade Union House, on Independence Square. Pravy Sektor defines itself as “neither xenophobic nor anti-Semitic, as Kremlin propaganda claims” and above all as “nationalist, defending the values of white, Christian Europe against the loss of the nation and deregionalisation”. Like Svoboda, it rejects multiculturalism, as “responsible for the disappearance of the crucifix and the arrival of girls in burqas in your schools”, but it does not advocate joining the EU, which it describes as “liberal totalitarianism in which God has vanished and values are turned upside down”.
Pravy Sektor supports none of the opposition parties, especially not Svoboda, disappointed by its “appeals for calm and negotiation with the authorities”. It could contemplate becoming a party itself, which would be awkward for Svoboda’s Tyahnybok: besides seeing his reputation as an anti-system champion seriously dented by his appeals for moderation during the clashes, he would have to come to terms with a party even further to the right, whose feats of arms and determination are known. 
Svoboda’s success over the past few years and the presence of neo-fascist groups such as Pravy Sektor in Independence Square are signs of a crisis in Ukrainian society. It is first and foremost a crisis of identity: in 22 years of independence, Ukraine has not managed to develop an unbiased historical narrative presenting a positive view of all its regions and citizens: even today, the Ukrainians are seen as liberators in Galicia but as fascists in Donbass. It is also a political crisis: some Ukrainians, exasperated and disappointed with the Orange Revolution, have turned to voting for extremist parties, more out of pique than for real ideological reasons. Though Independence Square will go down in history as an extraordinary example of collective and popular action, the political outcome is as yet unclear. Ukraine is in need of a new force that truly serves the people and transcends its many social and political divides.
Ukraine is going to get even messier. The United States has made a terrible blunder and there is no indication that any remedy is in the works.