Showing posts with label Steven Lee Myers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Steven Lee Myers. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 23, 2015

New Cold War Another Sign of Neoliberalism's Collapse

In a post I do on Fridays called Hippies vs. Punks I explore the spiritual platform (in Schopenhauer's sense that music is pure spirit) of the industrialized Western world when our current listing, foundering political-economic paradigm was inaugurated. That paradigm, neoliberalism, has been dominant for 40 years; but for the last 15, it has lurched from crisis to crisis, from economic meltdown to war back to economic crisis. During this 15-year period it has been well known by both the ruling elite and a significant segment of those who are ruled that the planet is experiencing a man-made ecological crisis, what is being called "The Sixth Extinction."

The paradigm, neoliberalism -- defined by a worship of markets and mammon, a concentration of wealth in the 1%, the immiseration of the 99%, brutal wars of choice and record numbers of displaced persons -- is obviously bankrupt. Not only is it bankrupt and destructive to life on the planet, it is anachronistic. The United States has in little over a year reestablished a Cold War with Russia, the thawing of which 25 years ago was probably the greatest triumph of the neoliberal paradigm.

David Herszenhorn reports in "Russia Assails Extension of E.U. Sanctions in Ukraine Crisis":
MOSCOW — Kremlin officials reacted furiously Monday to the European Union’s extension of sanctions on Russia through January, calling the measure self-defeating and accusing the West of crass anti-Russian bias by timing the decision to the nation’s commemoration of the Soviet victims of World War II. 
The Russian government said it would retaliate with an extension of countersanctions in response to the decision by European Unionforeign ministers, at a meeting in Luxembourg, which had been widely expected after European ambassadors reached a tentative agreement last week in Brussels. Russia had lobbied against the renewal of sanctions, which were first imposed in July 2014 in response to the Kremlin’sinvasion and annexation of Crimea.
***
“We are deeply disappointed that once again the opinion of the Russophobic lobby, which pushed through the decision to extend illegal restrictions, dominated in the E.U.,” the Foreign Ministry’s spokesman, Aleksandr K. Lukashevich, said in the statement. “At the same time, in Brussels they are deliberately tight-lipped about the fact that this is guaranteed to be followed by hundreds of thousands of Europeans, or millions, according to some estimates, losing their jobs.”
Mr. Lukashevich also complained that the West was placing unfair responsibility on Russia for carrying out the Ukraine cease-fire agreement, which was signed in February in Minsk, Belarus. Russia has long insisted that the Ukrainian government bears the largest responsibility for the failure so far to put the accord in effect.
“The E.U. keeps laying all the responsibility over the implementation of the Minsk agreements on the Russian side,” Mr. Lukashevich said. “The absurdity of this approach has been long clear to everyone. The key to the internal Ukrainian crisis was and still remains in the hands of Kiev, which is not hurrying to implement its responsibilities.” 
As for the timing of the announcement, Mr. Lukashevich added: “It looks especially cynical that the decision to extend the anti-Russian sanctions was taken by the E.U. states on June 22, the day when fascist Germany attacked the U.S.S.R. We would like to believe that this is a coincidence, and not an intentionally planned step.”
Couple this with a story from Eric Schmitt and Steven Lee Myers, "NATO Returns Its Attention to an Old Foe, Russia," and you get the picture that the New Cold War is here to stay:
It has involved a marked increase in training rotations on territory of the newer NATO allies in the east, and stepped up patrols of the air and seas from the Baltic to the Black Sea intended to counter an increase of patrols by Russian forces around NATO’s periphery. 
Most of those are temporary deployments. But in February, NATO announced that it would set up six new command units within the Eastern allies and create a 5,000-strong rapid reaction “spearhead” force. 
And the Pentagon now plans to preposition heavy American tanks and other weaponry in Eastern Europe for the first time, prompting unease in some quarters ahead of the NATO defense ministers’ meetings, and strong protests from Moscow that coincided with an announcement by President Vladimir V. Putin that he was bolstering Russia’s arsenal of strategic nuclear weapons. 
With the leaders of NATO’s 28 members scheduled to gather in Warsaw for an important summit meeting next year, the alliance is now considering what other measures are needed to adjust its forces, to increase spending that had plummeted as part of a “peace dividend,” and to revisit NATO’s military strategy and planning.
Soon "megadeath" will return to regular usage in our vocabulary as both the U.S. and Russia upgrade their nuclear arsenals.

Obama, the Nobel Peace Prize POTUS, will see his legacy defined as the leader who recreated the Cold War; hopefully when he is remembered he will be thought of with a feeling of nausea. Neoliberal leaders will go to any length to maintain their failed system.

Thursday, June 11, 2015

NYT's Report on Crowdfunding for Novorossiya: Raising the Steel Curtain Back Up in the Western Mind

Jo Becker and Steven Lee Myers are back at work grubbing up their phony "Deep Throat" investigative reporting directed at Russia. This morning's offering has to do efforts by Novorossiya's supporters to raise money online, "Russian Groups Crowdfund the War in Ukraine." The lifeless opening three paragraphs read as follows:
WASHINGTON — The Novorossiya Humanitarian Battalion boasts on its website that it provided funds to buy a pair of binoculars used by rebels in eastern Ukraine to spot and destroy an armored vehicle. Another group, Save the Donbass, solicits donations using a photograph of a mortar shell inscribed with its web address and the names of donors. Yet another, Veche, states that its mission is to “create modern, combat-ready” military units fighting Ukraine’s central government. 
These organizations are part of an online campaign that is brazenly raising money for the war in eastern Ukraine, using common tactics that have at least tacit support from the government of President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia. Although they often portray their mission as humanitarian, most of the groups explicitly endorse the armed insurgency and vow to help equip forces in the two regions at the center of the fighting, Donetsk and Luhansk.
An examination by The New York Times of the groups’ websites, social media postings and other records found more than a dozen groups in Russia that are raising money for the separatists, aiding a conflict that has killed more than 6,400 people and plunged Russia’s relations with the West to depths not seen since the Cold War.
It is a lengthy, soporific story, complete with online "smoking gun" screen-shots, that is bereft of the obvious: There is a lot of public support for Ukraine's pro-Russian rebels, something revealed in the recent Pew survey (Michael Gordon, "Survey Points to Challenges NATO Faces Over Russia"):
The findings on Russians’ attitudes are likely to be disappointing for NATO supporters. 
Western officials have calculated that economic sanctions will eventually erode Russian support for Mr. Putin’s decision to intervene in eastern Ukraine, but he has remained extremely popular by riding a wave of nationalism and controlling much of the news media. Most Russians are unhappy with the state of the economy, but they tend to blame not Mr. Putin but the drop in oil prices and the West’s efforts to punish Russia. 
Eighty-eight percent of Russians said they had confidence in Mr. Putin to do the right thing on international affairs, the highest rating since Pew started taking polls on the question in 2003. 
“The Ukrainian situation continues to be very good for Vladimir Putin with his own people,” Mr. Stokes said. “The Russians feel the pain of the economy, but they blame it on the West, not on Putin.”
I wish Becker and Myers would have included links to Strelkov's web site. I would make a donation. Instead, this is what we get:
The Western sanctions lists, for their part, have not kept up with the groups’ ever-changing names. Mr. Strelkov’s Novorossiya Movement, for instance, stopped soliciting funds after the European Union placed sanctions on it in February. Instead, it asked that the funds be sent to a related group, not blacklisted, called Global Initiatives, run by the movement’s chief of staff and chaired by Mr. Strelkov. 
In early May, it morphed yet again, redirecting funds to yet another related group, ANO KNB. Later in the month, a group identified by the Novorossiya Movement as its partner, Strelkov Info, wrote that because of constant blocking of its accounts, “we’ve decided to not post them in places open to all”; donors could send an email “to find out transfer details.”

One interesting aspect of the Becker and Myers piece is its description of the virtual-payment company QIWI (a blue QIWI terminal is pictured above, photo by James Hill for NYT):
But the widespread use of QIWI has created potential risks for its partner, Visa. Nearly all the fund-raising groups solicit donations through QIWI, a virtual payment company founded in 2004 and later incorporated, like many Russian companies, in Cyprus. QIWI provides consumers in Russia — and increasingly other countries — with a variety of ways to make payments online or through a network of tens of thousands of terminals that act like reverse A.T.M.s, allowing users to deposit cash and then pay participating vendors.
Users can also move money to individuals — or charitable organizations — as long as they have accounts linked to working telephone numbers. Its partnership with Visa, begun in 2012, allows customers to use a QIWI-Visa credit card to pay vendors outside QIWI’s network. 
The system has become wildly popular, used by 17 million Russians, but it has also skirted legal trouble. The company’s terminals and credit cards — along with the failure to require identification for transactions, as demanded by Russian law since last year — can be easily exploited to transfer proceeds from illicit activities, from drug dealing to tax evasion.
Once the again the Gray Lady is pumping out the column inches, making it appear as if she is documenting massive Russian corruption, and in the end there is really nothing much there.

It is illuminating in one aspect though. We are witnessing the erection of another steel curtain in the Western mind.

Wednesday, December 31, 2014

"Putin's Way": Gray Lady's Ersatz Investigative Journalism Stokes Russophobia Among American Liberals

This past Saturday the Gray Lady published an exposé (Steven Lee Myers and Jo Becker, "Even Loyalty No Guarantee Against Putin") on the recent house arrest of Russian oligarch Vladimir Yevtushenkov for money laundering, the upshot of which is that the state stripped Yevtushenkov of assets he held in the oil company Bashneft. There was a hush, hush quality to the story, as if some deep, dark perfidy was being exposed by journalists Myers and Becker.

It turns out there is nothing much to the story, a garden variety corporate-Kremlin struggle that took on a new urgency after the February coup in Ukraine, Crimea's joining the Russian Federation and the subsequent Western sanctions leveled against Russia. Yevtushenkov wanted to go ahead with a public offering of Bashneft shares in London. People in Moscow, with good cause, questioned the wisdom of such a course of action:
Rosneft had approached Mr. Yevtushenkov last year about the possibility of a merger or sale, according to news reports at the time, but Mr. Yevtushenkov resisted, and instead prepared a public offering of the company’s shares in London. 
The deterioration of relations with the West in the wake of the war in Ukraine appeared to make the sale of Bashneft’s stocks abroad increasingly worrisome to the Kremlin. In the weeks that followed the annexation of Crimea in March, the powerful Investigative Committee — an investigative body often seen as pursuing political cases at the Kremlin’s behest — quietly began a civil and criminal inquiry into Bashneft that exploded into public only in July.
The Yevtushenkov story is part three of what so far is a four-part Gray Lady series called "Putin's Way": "[A] series . . . examining how President Vladimir V. Putin’s system of personalized state-sponsored capitalism allows him to wield power at home and abroad."

After I read the Yevtushenkov story, I went back and looked for the other parts of the series because I had somehow missed them. I missed them because they had appeared in the Sunday paper, and I don't get the Sunday paper. I get Monday through Saturday. I take a pass on Sunday because it's too expensive (you can subscribe to all other days of the week for almost the same cost as Sunday) and there's too much paper that goes unread.

The first part of "Putin's Way" (Steven Lee Myers, Jo Becker, and Jim Yardley, "Private Bank Fuels Fortunes of Putin’s Inner Circle") is about Rossiya Bank, and it appeared in September. The second part (Jo Becker and Steven Lee Myers, "Putin’s Friend Profits in Purge of Schoolbooks") is about the shakeout among Russian schoolbook publishers, and it appeared at beginning of November.

These stories share the same "Deep Throat" hush, hush tone that strongly conveys to the reader that serious investigative journalism is being done. Call it the legacy of Watergate. But ever since Watergate, mainstream political investigative journalism, when it focuses on national or international targets, is more often of a Whitewater type; meaning, that there is a lot of smoke and very little flame underneath.

I'm sure in this case the liberals glance at the headline and maybe skim a few paragraphs. But the large size of the story, the amazing abundance of column inches, scares them off a thorough appraisal. So they turn the page, left with the thought, "Boy, that Putin is really rotten."

And that is the point. The Gray Lady is building the future of the New Cold War, locking in a mindless predisposition to Russophobia among the smart set.

Today's installment of "Putin's Way," part four, "How Putin Forged a Pipeline Deal That Derailed," by Jim Yardley and Jo Becker, is the best to date, and by this I mean the most illuminating in its ham-handedness. Note the opening:
SOFIA, Bulgaria — Barely two weeks after President Vladimir V. Putin annexed Crimea on one side of the Black Sea, he won a different prize on the other side. In Bulgaria’s Parliament, lawmakers gave initial passage to a bill clearing the way for a mammoth gas pipeline from Russia. 
The pipeline, known as South Stream, was Mr. Putin’s most important European project, a tool of economic and geopolitical power critical to twin goals: keeping Europe hooked on Russian gas, and further entrenching Russian influence in fragile former Soviet satellite states as part of a broader effort to undermine European unity. 
The bill that Parliament took up on April 4 was arcane. But it swept aside a host of European regulations — rules that Mr. Putin did not want to abide by — for a pipeline that would deliver gas throughout southern Europe.
It was a dream bill for Mr. Putin, and with reason. While Bulgaria’s Energy Ministry ostensibly wrote the legislation, documents reveal the hidden hand of the Kremlin: Not only did much of the language come from a subsidiary of Russia’s state-owned energy giant, Gazprom, but Mr. Putin’s energy minister was directly involved.
“If this happens in the U.S., the whole government would resign,” said Martin Dimitrov, a minister of Parliament from Bulgaria’s Reformist Bloc. “Not in Bulgaria, apparently.”
What Yardley and Becker don't point out is that it did just happen in the United States, and, no, no one in government resigned. I'm speaking here of Obama signing off on the gutting of Dodd-Frank. Citigroup wrote the language, Republicans inserted the language into the budget bill, and Obama signed off on it. We're not talking here about a pipeline deal that would benefit Europe by bypassing fracturing Ukraine. We're talking about undoing one of the main bulwarks against another meltdown of the global economy. Which is more corrupt?

At the end of the story on South Stream Yardley and Becker reveal that the U.S. blackmailed Bulgaria to drop the pipeline:
 . . . In early June, the European Commission told Bulgaria to stop work on South Stream, saying it was investigating whether the pipeline construction contracts violated European competitive-bidding rules. When the Bulgarian government refused, the European Union cut off tens of millions of euros in regional development funds. 
By this point, Ukrainian government forces were battling pro-Russian separatists in the east, and in the West there was talk of a new Cold War. On June 6, the American ambassador, Marcie B. Ries, warned Bulgarian companies against doing business with companies linked to Mr. Timchenko, who is on American sanctions lists. On June 8, a congressional delegation led by Senator John McCain, Republican of Arizona, met privately with Mr. Oresharski.
In desperate need of the European funds, the prime minister announced the next day that South Stream would be halted until it had full European Union approval.
Blackmail, plain and simple. Should we call this "Obama's Way"?

There are many "tells" throughout the Yardley and Becker expose that we're dealing with hortatory rhetoric unconcerned with balance or truth. For instance, Bush apparatchik C. Boyden Gray is quoted several times -- he's given the last word -- without mentioning that he is a conservative Republican operative. How fair is that to Gray Lady's liberal subscribers?
The final, unexpected development came on Dec. 1 when Mr. Putin, on a state visit to Turkey, announced that South Stream was dead. He blamed Europe and, according to press reports in Turkey, said he was “fed up with Bulgarians.” 
Since then, Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany, Europe’s most powerful leader, has suggested that South Stream might yet be built. After meeting with her, the new Bulgarian prime minister said he was confident European Union objections could be overcome. 
Even if they are not, some diplomats contend that Mr. Putin achieved many of his goals. 
While “he overreached, and he underestimated the response” to his intervention in Ukraine, said Mr. Gray, the former American diplomat, the Russian leader has been “quite effective” in countries like Bulgaria. 
“He won a great deal by getting Nabucco stopped,” Mr. Gray said. “Ultimately, his goal is to keep as much control over the former parts of the Soviet empire as possible.”
We're back to the future. The New Cold War is here, and The New York Times is playing its part.

Monday, March 24, 2014

The Fable of Western Sanctions

Obama is in the Netherlands today to attend a G-7 meeting (G-8 minus an ostracized Russia). His goal will be largely confined to public relations gimmickry, to convey unity of purpose among the G-7 industrial nations towards "Russian aggression" in the Crimea. There is no unity of purpose. All one has to do is look at the graphic "How Much Europe Depends on Russian Energy" that was included in a story by Steven Lee Myers and Neil MacFarquhar this past Saturday to know that any sanctions Europe imposes on Russia will be window dressing only. Here's why: Germany, the largest economy in the Eurozone, imports 30% of its energy from Russia; the Netherlands, 34%; Sweden, 46%; Italy, 28%; Finland, 76%; Poland, 91%; Czech Republic, 73%; Lithuania, 92% -- and so on down the line.

The lede story today in the Gray Lady admits as much:
The other members of the Group of 7 economic partnership hardly have interests identical with those of the United States, and in many ways they are divided even among themselves, complicating any effort to draw a firmer line with Moscow. 
Mr. Obama’s sanctions, announced last week, were aimed at sowing pain among members of a Russian economic and political elite who owe their wealth and loyalties to Mr. Putin. But the sanctions were also targeted to minimize disruption to the global economy and to avoid further jeopardizing already meek Russian cooperation on issues like the war in Syria, Iran’s nuclear program, the Middle East and North Korea. 
For European countries, the risk of wider conflict with Russia is even graver. Britain hosts Russian billionaires and their money; Germany gets about one-third of its energy from Russia and sells it machinery and cars; France is in the process of delivering sophisticated attack ships to the Kremlin; and Italy depends on Russia for some 28 percent of its energy.
The U.S. position boils down to lies and bluffs. First, the lies: Pretend the putsch that sent the elected Ukrainian president fleeing for his life is perfectly legal and that there is no precedent, like, say, the U.S. dismemberment of Yugoslavia, for Russian actions in the Crimea. Next, the bluff: Talk incessantly of serious economic consequences for Russia when clearly nothing of the sort is in the works.

It is both clumsy and obvious; it is simply embarrassing.

More proof of the crass nature of the Obama administration's information war is its fear-mongering the military exercises Russia is conducting on its Ukrainian border. Though fears of an incursion into eastern Ukraine have subsided with Russia agreeing to the presence of OSCE monitors, this salient fact is ignored; rather, war hysteria is played up.

The United States would be much better served by quieting things down. But apparently its leadership, beginning to realize that it is now responsible for a dysfunctional Ukrainian state, cannot accept the fact that its stewardship of the February putsch (Assistant Secretary of State for Europe and Eurasian Affairs Vicky Nuland's famous and oft-quoted "Fuck the EU") has turned into a punch bowl caked with turds.

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Look to the East in Ukraine to Discern U.S. Intentions

At this point, with Joe Biden being trundled off to Poland and the Baltics to calm the former Soviet satellites, I am sure Obama wishes Ukraine would just disappear, at least for a while.

This morning, following Putin's speech announcing that Crimea will be accepted as a member of the Russian Federation and a pervasive sense of mirthful derision that has greeted the stentorian proclamation of  Russian sanctions by the U.S. and Europe, it is clear that the Western defense of the putsch in Ukraine has arrived stillborn.

The best riff on the sanctions dud is quoted this morning in "Putin Declares Crimea Is a Part of Russia" by Steven Lee Myers and Peter Baker:
The American sanctions targeted prominent Russian officials, but not those likely to have many overseas assets; the European list generally went after lower-level targets. As a result, the actions were met with derision and even mockery in Moscow. 
“This is a big honor for me,” said Mr. Surkov, once called the “gray cardinal” of the Kremlin and known as the architect of Mr. Putin’s highly centralized political system. He told a Russian newspaper that he had no assets abroad: “In the U.S., I’m interested in Tupac Shakur, Allen Ginsberg and Jackson Pollock. I don’t need a visa to access their work.”
Obama warns that more sanctions are to come; that the lucrative Russian arms industry is next. But to truly harm Russia, sanctions would have to come from Europe and they would have to target Gazprom and/or Rosneft. There is no indication Europe will go in that direction:
Asked whether the European Union had failed to match tough words with strong actions, Radoslaw Sikorski, the Polish foreign minister, told journalists: “The U.S. is from Mars and Europe is from Venus. Get used to it.” 
He noted that “Europe is closer and will therefore pay a bigger cost for sanctions against Russia.” He also pointed to Europe’s collective decision-making process. 
“In the United States, one man takes a decision on the basis of an executive order,” Mr. Sikorski said, “whereas in Europe, for these measures to be legal, we need a consensus of 28 member states.”
If round one in Ukraine went to the Nuland neocons and the Right Sector street fighters, round two goes to Russia. Now, with the clock ticking, the momentum has decidedly shifted  in favor of Putin and against the putschists in Kiev. Shortly, the International Monetary Fund will come forward with a bailout deal. I would imagine this will represent a significant challenge for the putsch government. The fiction floated by Western governments and their servile press is that the putschists have a popular mandate from the people; the truth is, the putsch only represents a minority. Once the austerity features of the IMF loan package are published, the putsch government should begin to fray.

Appreciation of this is probably what is motivating Kerry to consider previously dismissed Russian proposals for a constitutional overhaul of Ukraine to allow for federalization. As laid out the last couple of days on the Moon of Alabama blog ("Ukraine: U.S. Takes Off-Ramp, Agrees To Russian Demands"),
There was another phone call today between Secretary of State Kerry and the Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov. The call came after a strategy meeting on Ukraine in the White House. During the call Kerry agreed to Russian demands for a federalization of the Ukraine in which the federal states will have a strong autonomy against a central government in a finlandized Ukraine. Putin had offered this "off-ramp" from the escalation and Obama has taken it.
Going forward, the West needs Russia to help solve the crisis it created in Ukraine. But I am not confident that the United States has the ability to act cooperatively at this point. The logic of U.S. hegemony is "If you don't get what you want, just make the problem bigger." Populate the planet with a series of failed states. Granted, Obama and Kerry took the off ramp in the run up to war against Syria; let's hope that was not just a one-off.

Proof that Russia is going to bide its time is found in a refreshingly unbiased story by C.J. Chivers and Andrew Roth about protests in the pro-Russian Ukrainian city of Kharkiv, "In Eastern Ukraine, the Curtain Goes Up, and the Clash Begins." We should be able to interpret the intentions of the U.S. going forward by the response to pro-Russian protesters in the east. If there is a harsh crackdown by the putschist-aligned security forces, we know that it is the U.S. sticking to script, trying to the make problem bigger.

Friday, March 14, 2014

Heedless West Heads for Trade War with Russia

The United States and the European Union continue to act as if they have nothing to lose by baiting and threatening Russia in the Ukraine. This was brought home to me by a quote from an unnamed State Department official in an article this morning by Michael Gordon, "Kerry Arrives in London for Crisis Talks on Crimea." Referring to this Sunday's vote in Crimea to secede from Ukraine,
“If this referendum goes forward, there will be costs,” the State Department official said. “If there is further military escalation there will be more costs. If there is not serious diplomacy there will be more costs.” 
Mr. Kerry also plans to ask Mr. Lavrov about Russia’s snap military exercise, the State Department official said. 
“We are very concerned,” the State Department official said. “This is the second time inside of a month that Russia has chosen to mass large amounts of force on short notice without much transparency around the eastern borders of Ukraine. It certainly creates an environment of intimidation.” 
“That will be one question that will be asked,” the official said. “What is meant by this?”
"What is meant by this?" Really? How pathetic. The U.S. continues to act as if it is engaged in just another drone strike on Pashtun tribesmen, or destruction of an African aspirin factory, apparently heedless of Russia's ability to apply costs of its own to Western conduct. What amazes me is the success the Obama administration in having Germany toe its line. Merkel has sounded particularly strident over the last couple of days. This is from a good story by Steven Lee Myers and Alison Smale, "Russian Troops Mass at Border With Ukraine":
The ouster of the government of Viktor F. Yanukovych in February and Russia’s subsequent intervention in Crimea have deeply divided Russia and the West, and in Berlin, Ms. Merkel underscored the potential risks, declaring that “the territorial integrity of Ukraine cannot be called into question.”
As Russia’s largest trading partner in Europe, Germany is certain to have significant influence on the debate over how to respond to Russia’s actions in Ukraine. Some politicians and observers in other European countries and in the United States have suggested that Germany’s close trading and other ties with Russia had made it hesitant to adopt sanctions against Russia. 
Ms. Merkel’s speech, however, suggested that President Vladimir V. Putin might have miscalculated the anger that the occupation and annexation of Crimea would cause — or that he might be impervious to it. 
Mr. Putin, who has remained in Sochi to attend the Paralympics there, has so far showed no sign of bending to international criticism. In a meeting on Wednesday with the directors of national Paralympic teams, he implicitly reiterated the Kremlin’s argument that the ouster of Mr. Yanukovych was an armed coup instigated by outside forces. “I would like to assure you that Russia was not the initiator of the circumstances we are now facing,” Mr. Putin said. 
In her remarks, Ms. Merkel rejected any comparison between the situation in Crimea today and that in Kosovo in the late 1990s, when NATO bombed Serbia for 78 days to halt the attacks on Kosovo Albanians by Serbian forces. 
Ms. Merkel was clear that Germany would go along with the other 27 states of the European Union, and the United States, if Russia did not open meaningful diplomatic talks and the West moved to freeze Russian accounts and impose travel bans or restrictions on leading Russian figures. 
“To make it unmistakably clear,” she said, “nobody wants it to come to that.”
The West is boxing itself into a corner. Its public is not behind this conflict despite a full-tilt propaganda campaign. The public is exhausted with constant warfare. Why spend billions to stir up trouble in Ukraine when Detroit is bankrupt? Russia, on the other hand, is operating with what appears to be overwhelming public support.

Yet despite a lack of popular approval, the West is pursuing a maximal position: the absolute territorial integrity of Ukraine (in spite of the precedent it created in cracking apart Yugoslavia) backed up by threats of economic warfare.

Clearly, as Russian forces mobilize along Ukraine's eastern border and street riots turn deadly in Donetsk, the West is going to have to put up or shut up. Putin has put up and will continue to do so. A red line has been crossed for Russia; Putin will not retreat. Elites running the show in Western capitals think that economic warfare will bring Putin to heel. I think they will find themselves the ones besieged by their own supporters in the business world. Hopefully, when the Western alliance starts to fray, the United States does not ramp up military support for Ukraine.

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

A Question or Two for Yats and Obama Tomorrow

To get a sense of the Bizarro World that the United States presently occupies take a peek at its wish list, intended to resolve the Ukrainian crisis, that Kerry delivered to Lavrov this past weekend:
In a Saturday morning call with Mr. Lavrov, Mr. Kerry emphasized that Russian steps to annex Crimea would close the window for more diplomacy. Later that day, the State Department sent Mr. Lavrov a page-and-half document with a series of questions that were intended to see whether the Kremlin was receptive to the United States’ proposals before Mr. Kerry traveled to meet with Mr. Putin.
American officials wanted to know if Russia would cease its military advances in Crimea, rein in Crimean militias and also work with the contact group on steps like an International Monetary Fund program to stabilize the Ukrainian economy and a countrywide election. They also wanted Russia to halt moves to annex the Crimean Peninsula, and were looking for signs that Russia would be willing to return their troops to their barracks, allow international monitors to work in Crimea and, importantly, meet with new Ukrainian government, either directly or as part of a contact group. 
Russia never responded officially to the questions. Yet an answer of sorts came on Monday when, to the surprise of the State Department, Russian television carried the short video clip of Mr. Putin and Mr. Lavrov. 
Mr. Putin said that he had authorized Mr. Lavrov to invite Mr. Kerry to Russia. Mr. Lavrov responded that he had expected Mr. Kerry to arrive as early as Monday for talks that could involve Mr. Putin himself. 
“But then on Saturday he called and said that he would like to postpone the trip for the moment,” Mr. Lavrov added, referring to Mr. Kerry. 
The Russian foreign minister went on to complain that the paper Mr. Kerry had given him on Friday cast Moscow as a belligerent and treated the establishment of the new Western-backed government in Ukraine as a “fait accompli.”
This appears in "U.S. and Russia Hit Diplomatic Roadblock Trying to Start Ukraine Talks" by Michael Gordon and Steven Lee Myers. As a first proposal, the Obama administration must know that it is a non-starter. For it to be anything but an intentional non-starter would mean that there is no one in a position of authority in the Obama administration who can interpret the obvious -- that Russia is deadly serious about what is going on in Ukraine and is not going to settle for some sort of accommodation with the putschists. This is from a good story by Ellen Barry, "Titans in Russia Fear New Front in Ukraine Crisis":
Russia’s tycoons have been silent since the crisis began, apart from approving messages on social media. Many inside Russia’s large corporations are no doubt supportive of Mr. Putin’s moves in Crimea, which are widely seen here as correcting a historical error made by the Soviet leader Nikita S. Khrushchev, when he transferred Crimea to the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic. Mr. Putin’s approval ratings are at their highest point since he returned to the presidency in 2012. If corporate leaders are complaining, they are doing it quietly. 
“Of course they’re upset, but it doesn’t mean they are prepared to challenge Russia’s foreign policy,” said Mikhail E. Dmitriyev, an economist whose research group, the Center for Strategic Research, was originally founded to shape Mr. Putin’s economic platform. “This is a new reality. Even if somebody has reservations with regard to the policy’s effectiveness, I strongly doubt they would express it. This is a policy which, for the moment, is backed by the vast majority of the public. It’s not an exaggeration.”
Kerry and Obama enjoy no such support. Citizens of the homeland see only more war games and billions spent overseas while their rents are raised and a couple bags of groceries add up to a $100. European allies have already made clear their reluctance to slap economic sanctions on Russia.

Then there is the unstable situation within the putsch government itself. It is a business-as-usual, Orange-Revolution-redux oligarchical structure that came to power by means of Svoboda and Right Sector muscle. At this point it is not clear that this pairing is anything more than an evanescent marriage of convenience. Right Sector has promised to reformulate itself as an electoral organization that will vie for power in upcoming elections. Right Sector, at least from what I have read, is to the right of Svoboda, does not support greater integration with Europe and its decadent values, and currently is riding a crest of popularity for its role on the Maidan.

In the near term, the United States continues to lose the information war. And the reason it is losing the propaganda battle is the insistence that the putschists are legitimately democratic. In order to make this stick, a tremendous feat in perception management is required, given that we are indoctrinated in the West from the time we learn how to read that democracy means elections. And Yanukovych was the legitimately elected leader of the country, who just happened to be run out of town by armed goons -- not what most normally consider to be a legitimate, democratic process.

As if to underscore this, today Yanukovych was trundled before the cameras. Steven Lee Myers has the story, "Ukraine’s Ousted Leader Urges Military to Resist New Government":
Mr. Yanukovych has mostly remained in hiding since he fled Ukraine, and his public role in the conflict has been so marginalized that he began his remarks by dismissing rumors of his ill health and even death. “I am alive,” he said, going on to dispute the legality of the actions the Parliament took after a European-brokered agreement on Feb. 21 collapsed. “And I have not been impeached, according to the Ukrainian Constitution.”
This is a shrewd move by Moscow, preempting tomorrow's White House meeting between putsch president Arseniy Yatsenyuk and Obama. If there is any reporter worth his or her salt allowed to question the putschist and his sponsor, this question will be asked: "Was President Yanukovych impeached as set forth in the Ukrainian Constitution? And, if not, how is the current government legal?"

Friday, March 7, 2014

Ukraine is Going to Get Even Messier

As another week comes to an end and Washington and Moscow are still jousting over Ukraine, the best statement, a statement that properly encapsulates what we are witnessing in this new Cold War, comes from the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs' rebuttal to the embarrassingly weak “President Putin’s Fiction: 10 False Claims About Ukraine” put out by the U.S. State Department on Wednesday:
“They cannot get over it and come to terms with the fact that they cannot always dictate their will and act in their customary role of ‘infallible judge,’ which is followed by — the last word,” it said. “Their nerves are giving out, but that is no reason to thrust guilt on the innocent.”
It is just going to get worse for the United States. Crimea will vote in nine days to secede from Ukraine and join the Russian Federation, and there is nothing the United States can do about it. And this is driving the smart set at Great Satan HQ batty. Obama, in what is becoming regular ritualized performances of "The Emperor Has No Clothes," steps before the cameras and denounces the Crimean vote as a violation of international law. “Any discussion about the future of Ukraine must include the legitimate government of Ukraine.”

And therein lies the problem for the U.S./EU: the insistence that a government that came to power by means of a violent insurrection in Kiev spearheaded by fascists from western Ukraine is legitimately democratic, while an autonomous jurisdiction that is historically Russian seeking to realign with the Russian Federation by plebiscite is illegal, unconstitutional and anti-democratic. Obama's statement is risible.

One would hope that the Cold Warriors in the State Department would cut their losses now and end this charade, but don't count on it. I don't think that they are going to let the Crimea vote come off unimpeded. Whether through overt saber rattling by sending more U.S. fighter jets to the region or more war ships to the Black Sea, or a covert campaign of destabilization using Right Sector shock troops, as was done during the February putsch, I don't know. But as of now I think that some form military escalation is likely.

Take the news, reported today in "Moscow Signals It Will Embrace Crimean Move for Secession," by Steven Lee Myers, David Herszenhorn and Alan Cowell, that DmytroYarosh, the head of the fascist organization Right Sector, plans to re-brand his group and run for president:
In Kiev, the leader of the Right Sector movement, Dmytro Yarosh, will run for president of Ukraine, the chairman of the local branch of the movement, Andriy Tarasenko, said on Friday. The nationalist group, which was important in the fight for Kiev’s Independence Square, will rename itself at a congress in a week and participate in elections at all levels, Mr. Tarasenko said. 
Right Sector has been controversial for its semi-military organization, but it has also refrained from working in eastern Ukraine, where its presence could be seen as a provocation by Russia. But Mr. Tarasenko said that the group is prepared to fight, in Crimea and elsewhere, “if the Kremlin tramples on us further.” He added, “Accordingly, we are conducting mobilization and are preparing to repel foreign aggression.”
This is bad news for the West. Not only does it expose the lie that far right ultranationalists were a negligible part of the uprising against Yanukovych, it means that the putsch government might have great difficulty implementing the IMF austerity mandates coming their way. Right Sector, according to a decent, dispassionate appraisal by Emmanuel Dreyfus, "Who Was in Kiev’s Independence Square?," that appears in the weekend edition on the Counterpunch web site, is to the right of Svoboda, another Banderist political construct, and does not support integrating with the European Union:
The biggest, Pravy Sektor (right sector), emerged after the Grushevsky Street clashes and, for the moment, enjoys real popular support. It has a few thousand members across the country, including people disappointed by Svoboda, members of ultra-nationalist groups, hooligans and dropouts. Their common denominator is a taste for radical action, and for the ideology that one of the movement’s leaders, Andrei Tarassenko, dispensed from its high-security headquarters on the fifth floor of Trade Union House, on Independence Square. Pravy Sektor defines itself as “neither xenophobic nor anti-Semitic, as Kremlin propaganda claims” and above all as “nationalist, defending the values of white, Christian Europe against the loss of the nation and deregionalisation”. Like Svoboda, it rejects multiculturalism, as “responsible for the disappearance of the crucifix and the arrival of girls in burqas in your schools”, but it does not advocate joining the EU, which it describes as “liberal totalitarianism in which God has vanished and values are turned upside down”.
Pravy Sektor supports none of the opposition parties, especially not Svoboda, disappointed by its “appeals for calm and negotiation with the authorities”. It could contemplate becoming a party itself, which would be awkward for Svoboda’s Tyahnybok: besides seeing his reputation as an anti-system champion seriously dented by his appeals for moderation during the clashes, he would have to come to terms with a party even further to the right, whose feats of arms and determination are known. 
Svoboda’s success over the past few years and the presence of neo-fascist groups such as Pravy Sektor in Independence Square are signs of a crisis in Ukrainian society. It is first and foremost a crisis of identity: in 22 years of independence, Ukraine has not managed to develop an unbiased historical narrative presenting a positive view of all its regions and citizens: even today, the Ukrainians are seen as liberators in Galicia but as fascists in Donbass. It is also a political crisis: some Ukrainians, exasperated and disappointed with the Orange Revolution, have turned to voting for extremist parties, more out of pique than for real ideological reasons. Though Independence Square will go down in history as an extraordinary example of collective and popular action, the political outcome is as yet unclear. Ukraine is in need of a new force that truly serves the people and transcends its many social and political divides.
Ukraine is going to get even messier. The United States has made a terrible blunder and there is no indication that any remedy is in the works.

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

What Kosovo (Not to Mention Western Business Interests in Russia) Reveals About the Crisis in Ukraine

There is a price to pay for backing a putsch. Hopefully that is a lesson that elites in Western capitals will have learned once the dust settles in Ukraine (though right now it is unclear when that will occur).

An important historic parallel for what is happening today is the 1999 NATO war against Yugoslavia. President Vlad Putin brought it up today in connection with Russia's defense of the Crimea: This from "Citing ‘Coup’ in Ukraine, Putin Reserves Right to Use Force" by Steven Lee Myers, Ellen Barry and Alan Cowell:
[Putin] said Russia is not considering annexing Crimea, but said Crimean citizens should be allowed to determine their own future, presumably as part of Russia or Ukraine. 
“We are not considering this possibility,” he said. “It’s up to people living in a certain territory, if they can exercise their free will, and determine their future. For example, if Kosovo’s Albanians were allowed to do that, self-determination, which according to U.N. documents is a right, but we will never instigate it, never support such trends.” 
“Only the people who live in a certain territory have the right to decide their own future,” he said.
Hence, one destabilizing U.S. precedent come home to roost, and not just in terms of international norms; Obama should be mindful of the fate of the Democrats post-Kosovo. Clinton took his high approval ratings coming out his Republican impeachment trial in the Senate and used them to mobilize support for bombing a European capital, Belgrade, on behalf of a criminal organization, the Kosovo Liberation Army. The result? Approval of Clinton quickly dropped and his vice president, Al Gore, lost to the scion of a none-too-popular conservative political family dynasty, and this despite Gore being able to boast of a leadership role in an administration that presided over the creation of a full-employment economy.

Obama should be very careful. He has neither the support of European allies nor the public that Clinton had. In terms of the former, consult this passage at the end of Peter Baker's story, "Top Russians Face Sanctions by U.S. for Crimea Crisis":
Russia is effectively the world’s biggest energy supplier, exporting more natural gas than any other country and more oil than any other nation after Saudi Arabia. Russia is also the biggest exporter of industrial metals and the fifth-biggest consumer market globally. 
“The biggest argument for severe economic sanctions not being imposed is that the European countries don’t have much of an alternative to Russian energy supplies,” said Jens Nordvig, the New York-based managing director of currency research at Nomura Holdings Inc. 
Several of the biggest Western energy companies have major investments in Russia, including B.P. and Royal Dutch Shell. 
It may also be difficult for Mr. Obama to sell sanctions to the American business community if it is being cut off while competitors still have access to Russian markets. Russia is Pepsi’s second-largest market and a significant market, too, for companies like Boeing, General Motors, John Deere and Procter & Gamble. 
ExxonMobil, the largest American oil company, has a joint venture deal with the state-controlled oil company, Rosneft, to explore what may be a very rich Arctic area called the Kara Sea. ExxonMobil is also working with Rosneft on drilling in the Baltic Sea and on other projects. 
But congressional leaders said they would move forward with sanctions as well as aid to Ukraine. A Senate Foreign Relations Committee bill would use $200 million in aid and loan guarantees to leverage $1 billion in international economic assistance. An additional $50 million would be steered from existing State Department accounts for electoral administration.
While governmental elites are immune to the entreaties of their constituents asking for an end to constant foreign wars, they do listen to their corporate benefactors, many of whom have their snouts in Mother Russia's lap. The PepsiCo and ExxonMobil connections lead one to draw the conclusion that for all of Obama's tough talk about economic reprisals nothing substantive will come of it. Maybe a few Russian officials will be banned from travel to the United States. Also, don't expect Europe to join the tough talk charade. Even if the EU embraces fracking immediately, it will still be dependent on Gazprom for decades to come.

I continue to believe that time is on Russia's side. Obama's approval will continue to drop. The putsch government will fracture as soon as the IMF austerity mandates are publicized.

Thursday, February 20, 2014

U.S. Credibility Gap on Ukraine Vis-a-Vis Egypt and Seattle WTO

A full scale civil war is unfolding in Ukraine. Live fire is now the norm in Kiev as rebels broke the short-lived truce and recaptured Independence Square. In the country's west rebels have captured an Interior Ministry arsenal in Lviv, as well as police stations and government administration buildings. Andrew Higgins and Andrew Kramer, who have given up nearly all pretense of neutrality at this point and have become purely a conduit of the U.S. State Department, have the story, "Kiev’s Brief Truce Shatters in Bursts of Gunfire":
Beyond Lviv, antigovernment activists besieged or seized police stations and administrative buildings in the western cities of Uzhgorod, Lutsk and Khmelnitsky and the eastern city of Poltava. 
In Lutsk, protesters attacked the regional police department, which responded with stun grenades and other fire. The building was then set on fire by protesters throwing gasoline bombs.
This is an insurrection, a rebellion. What else could it be called? Yet Obama is threatening the Ukrainian government not to declare a state of emergency: This is from Steven Lee Myers, useful piece "Violence in Ukraine Creates Deepening Clash Between East and West":
President Obama, on a visit to Mexico, interrupted his opening meeting with President Enrique Peña Nieto to tell reporters that “the United States condemns in the strongest terms” the violence that has claimed lives in the last two days. He pointedly warned the Ukrainian military on Wednesday to stay out of the political crisis that has already ravaged the streets of Kiev and said the United States would hold the government responsible for further violence. 
The president’s decision to address the Ukrainian situation without being asked reflected the growing concern by the White House that the standoff between the government and demonstrators in the street had spiraled out of control. 
“We have been watching very carefully, and we expect the Ukrainian government to show restraint, to not resort to violence in dealing with peaceful protesters,” Mr. Obama said. “There will be consequences if people step over the line.” 
The substance of that threat became clear on Wednesday evening, when the Obama administration said it had imposed a visa ban on 20 senior Ukrainian officials whom it accused of playing a role in the government’s crackdown on Tuesday. The State Department declined to say which officials were on the list, but a senior State Department official said it included “the full chain of command responsible for ordering the violence last night.”
Such perversity -- "peaceful protesters"!?! -- is mind-boggling. Bear in mind that Obama's Ambassador to China, Gary Locke, when he was Governor of Washington State, mustered the National Guard during the 1999 WTO ministerial in Seattle after one small Starbucks and the facade of Niketown were vandalized and some storefront plate glass was broken. A "No Protest Zone" was even declared. And here is Obama threatening sanctions against the government of Viktor Yanukovych if force is used to respond to the death of its security personnel, not to mention the country's capital being set ablaze or its armories seized.

Where are the sanctions on members of the Sisi military junta? Remember it was security forces under the command of the Egyptian coup government of Abdul-Fattah el-Sisi that slaughtered hundreds of peaceful sit-in protesters in what amounted to a "fish-in-the-barrel" shoot last August. Obama won't even call what happened in Egypt a coup.

Such mendacity cannot go without some form of blowback. And that blowback is already underway. It is an erosion of credibility all Western governments are experiencing, what at earlier time of political tumult was known as "the credibility gap."

There is a pattern to the collapse in Obama's public approval. Conventional wisdom points to the continuing aftereffects of the Great Recession and an economy that produces few new jobs and those that it does produce are for low wages. But I think, equally important, is Obama's steadfast advocacy for the U.S. national security state -- for the unconstitutional prerogatives of NSA spying, for hounding Snowden and Assange, for trumpeting the dawn of a democratic age in the Middle East and then backing an anachronistic military coup in Egypt and facilitating the rise of jihad in Syria, Iraq and Lebanon.

Now Obama is recreating the Cold War. Amazing. Like his Oval Office predecessor, W., everything Obama touches turns to shit. After five years, this should be obvious to everyone except for the most blinded of partisans.

But the United States should proceed with caution when it comes to throwing down the gauntlet to Russia. Russia is not some tribe of Sunni fundamentalists. Russia is a great state. And while the West too is a bloc of great states, they are states that daily grow farther removed from the populations they govern. Rebellion cannot be far off.

Friday, September 13, 2013

Rebels Apoplectic Over Possibility of Peace + Anne Barnard Wising Up

Now that the focus of the Syrian civil war has shifted away from a vote in the U.S. Congress authorizing military force to diplomacy in Geneva the warmongering opposition is growing increasingly agitated. The Syrian National Coalition and its paymasters in the Gulf Cooperation Council don't want any talks regardless of their content, except possibly for a discussion of the details of an unconditional surrender of the Alawite-led Baathist government. That's what jumped out at me after reading this morning's news. Take Michael Gordon and Steven Lee Myers' "Syria Talks Yield Plan to Discuss Peace Conference":
Sitting on a dais with Mr. Kerry, Mr. Lavrov hailed effort of the Russian president, Vladimir V. Putin, to persuade President Bashar al-Assad of Syria to join the treaty banning chemical arms, and stressed the need to resume peace talks in Geneva. 
Mr. Lavrov said it was “very unfortunate, that for a long time, the Geneva communiqué was basically abandoned,” referring to the 2012 document that outlined basic terms for the peace talks. 
Despite the public facade of unity, however, the United States and Russia have been sharply divided over how to organize a political settlement and who should attend a peace conference.
After Mr. Kerry flew to Moscow and proposed a peace conference in May, Russia wanted to include Iran, which along with the Kremlin is one of the principal backers and arms suppliers of the Assad government. 
The United States has opposed including Iran and has argued instead for including the “London 11,” a group of European and Arab nations that have been supporting the Syrian resistance. But that has been rejected by Moscow. 
Another possible complication is getting the Syrian opposition to attend. Syrian rebel leaders are bitter about Mr. Obama’s decision to put off military action and explore a disarmament plan with the Russians. 
In a recent statement, Gen. Salim Idris, the head of the military wing of the Syrian opposition, rejected the Russian initiative and said the Syrians who carried out the Aug. 21 chemical attack near Damascus that started the current crisis must be punished.

In an effort to address their fears, Mr. Kerry spoke Thursday with General Idris and Ahmad al-Jarba, the president of the Syrian opposition, and sought to assure them that the military option remained on the table and that the Obama administration would insist that any understanding about Syria’s chemical weapons be verifiable and enforceable, a State Department official said.
But it remains to be seen whether Mr. Kerry made any headway in calming the opposition’s anxieties.
The Syrian National Coalition depends on many lies, first and foremost of which is that it represents the aspirations of Syrians who rose up in protest during the Arab Spring. Another big lie that is told repeatedly by both the opposition and the United States Government is that Assad and his Russian backers resist negotiations; in fact, the Russians have been pushing for months for Geneva II talks to begin. It is the U.S. and the rebels that have resisted diplomacy, something that was clear back in the late spring and early summer but which has grown increasingly obscure as the reporting tended to focus predominantly on the ascension of Al Qaeda-affiliated jihadists on the battlefield and then last month the chemical attack in the Damascus suburb of Ghouta.

But now peace talks are back in the news and the opposition is apoplectic. What does that tell you? It tells you that the chemical attack was designed to spur a U.S.-led attack on Syria that would significantly weaken the Syrian Arab Army and force Assad from office. Regime change a la Libya. The opposition and its supporters didn't factor public opinion into its calculations. Overwhelming voter opposition representing the entire political spectrum scared politicians in the West to hold off on an illegal, unilateral military intervention.

The next immediate concern for the warmongers is to try to spin the United Nations report on the Ghouta chemical attack before it comes out. The media is already rife with stories from anonymous sources saying that the investigation shows the Syrian government is to blame.

The Syrian National Coalition has no popular support. Even its advocates in the press are wising up. Check out Anne Barnard's story today, "Syrian Rebels Say Saudi Arabia Is Stepping Up Weapons Deliveries":
Rebels in southern Syria who nominally answer to the loose-knit, Western-backed Free Syrian Army said Thursday that they had received new infusions of arms from Saudi Arabia, delivered through Jordan, and that the weapons had helped them gain ground near the border. 
At the same time, Gen. Salim Idris, the nominal commander of the Free Syrian Army, declared on Thursday his “absolute rejection” of the chemical weapons deal offered by the Syrian and Russian governments. He said rebel fighters felt they were being “left alone,” without “direct military support” from the United States.
The repeated insertion of "nominal" is noteworthy, as is the petulance of Free Syrian Army commander Gen. Salim Idris set off in quote marks. Barnard has been a strong proponent of the rebels, but of late her support seems to be slipping. Her article today is actually a sensible exposition of the power politics of the proxy war underway in Syria.

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Awaiting Cairo Crackdown + Barack Obama, Poltroon

A crackdown that appeared likely last weekend seems even more so this weekend. Ramadan is coming to a close and the coup government has declared that it is done negotiating. David Kirkpatrick, back on the job in Cairo, has the story, "Egypt Government Hints at Force to End Large Sit-Ins":
But after an urgent meeting of Egypt’s interim cabinet, Prime Minister Hazem el-Beblawi said Wednesday on state television that the decision to clear the sit-ins was “irreversible.” He said that the clearing could begin any time, and he warned the Islamists against any resistance. 
The government has already authorized the police to use force to carry out such an order. Security forces have detained Mr. Morsi, jailed scores of Islamist leaders and killed a total of more than 140 of the ousted president’s supporters in two mass shootings at demonstrations seeking his reinstatement. 
But talks aimed at resolving the impasse have nonetheless continued behind the scenes, with envoys from the United States, the European Union, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates all meeting with officials on both sides to broker some resolution. 
The Western envoys have said that they sought to persuade the military’s government to release the Islamists while at the same time persuading the Muslim Brotherhood to participate in a renewed democratic process despite its forced ouster.
As I argued at the end of last week, dislodging sit-ins are difficult and messy. The coup government risks greater instability by trying to clear the encampments; but, nonetheless, this looks like the direction el-Sisi et al. prefer to be headed. And while you might think that this crackdown will make it more difficult for the Obama administration to maintain the $1.5 billion in aid to Egypt, I don't see anything changing. The only thing in flux is Obama's standing, both globally and at home. Events of the last few months have exposed him to be a truly feckless leader. There's a telling quote in today's story, "Ties Fraying, Obama Drops Putin Meeting," by Peter Baker and Steven Lee Myers. I don't know if it is accurate, if Putin does indeed despise Obama, but it's worth repeating:
Andrei A. Piontovsky, a political analyst, said the cancellation underscored a visceral personal enmity between the two leaders. “Putin openly despises your president, forgive my bluntness,” he said. 
He added that Russia sensed weakness in Mr. Obama that could lead to more dangerous confrontations. 
“The fact is the relations were completely broken for a very long time,” he said. “The main raison d’être of Putin’s policy now is to make an enemy of the United States.”
Reasoning from a Russian perspective, the thinking has got to be its time to wash our hands of this guy. He's duplicitous, he can't deliver on anything he says, and he's unwilling to stand up to the bellicose, regressive forces in his administration. And along with Russia eventually goes the majority of Americans who supported Obama. The next several years are going to be painful for Democratic voters as they come to accept that Obama has been a failure, that he has broken promises repeatedly and that almost nothing has been delivered. As it stands now, as I score it, he has the troop withdrawal from Iraq, a modest stimulus bill during the financial crisis and scrapping the missile defense system in Eastern Europe to his credit. I'm reserving judgment on the Affordable Care Act. These are all first-term accomplishments. And while they are commendable, they fall far short of the type of systemic change that voters hoped for in electing Obama.

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

How the Gray Lady Works for the Government

This Friday Russian foreign minister Sergey Lavrov and Russian defense minister Sergei Shoigu will confer with their American counterparts, Secretary of State John Kerry and Secretary of Defense of Chuck Hagel, in Washington D.C. to see if they can salvage the September presidential summit in Moscow between Putin and Obama. The main sticking point seems to be Russia's decision to grant renegade NSA contractor Edward Snowden temporary asylum. But, according to a story by Michael Shear and Steven Lee Myers that appears in today's New York Times, "Kerry, Hagel and Russians Will Meet on Issues Imperiling Obama-Putin Visit," differences over Syria loom large as well.

Towards the end of the story, after Shear and Myers have summarized the American position on Snowden's asylum, there is a description of Russia's stance on various issues, including the Syrian civil war:
[Mr. Lavrov] also discussed the need to move ahead with Syrian peace talks that he and Mr. Kerry agreed to in Moscow in May. 
“The more we delay calling it, the more victims there will be among civilians,” Mr. Lavrov said, according to the Interfax news agency. He blamed the Syrian rebels for resisting opening talks with President Bashar al-Assad’s government.
The bold facing of the last sentence is mine. I think it's noteworthy because though otherwise an innocuous statement -- it is factually accurate -- it is manipulative. There is no question that the Syrian National Coalition is opposed to peace talks. This is beyond dispute. Ahmad al-Jarba, the head of the opposition, did briefly, the weekend before last, raise the possibility of his group attending peace talks in Geneva, but then, a few days later, he corrected himself and returned to the opposition's default position: No peace talks until military gains are achieved and al-Assad steps down.

To frame this as Russians blaming the rebels for resisting negotiations is to make it seem as if it is all just tit-for-tat, "he said/she said," blame-game petulance of equally guilty squabbling parties trying to secure the upper hand. It's nothing of the sort. It's a civil war where one side -- the side the United States supports with money and munitions and CIA training -- favors war, with its resulting death and devastation, over peace. The United States position is to continue with war and death. This has to be elided somehow, obfuscated. And the Gray Lady, as an extension for the most part of the U.S. government, plays its part.

Coming on the heels of yesterday's report of Islamist rebel gains in Aleppo at the Minakh airbase and the push by ISIS into the coastal mountain Alawite villages surrounding Latakia, there is a report this morning of a government ambush of Al Nusra Front fighters outside Damascus with over 60 killed.

Saturday, June 1, 2013

Kerry's Bilious Bosspeak

If you are looking for a bilious dose of "Bosspeak," check out Secretary of State John Kerry's statement to the press yesterday:


Israel's right to terrorize nations in the Middle East must not be challenged. The Russian S-300 missile defense system would allow Syria some protection from Israeli acts of aggression. Therefore, because of the West's sacred concern for Israeli "security" (a.k.a., aggression), Syria cannot be allowed to possess this missile battery.

Things are not going well for the West. The Syrian Coalition bickers in Istanbul hotel conference rooms while the rebels continue to lose ground throughout Syria. A reliable signal that things are not going the rebels' way is the rocket barrages from Syria falling on Hezbollah turf in Lebanon's eastern Bekaa Valley. Also, Steven Lee Myers and Michael Gordon report this morning in "Kerry Castigates Russia Over Syria-Bound Missiles" that the Al Nusra Front has been added to the UN blacklist:
Al Nusra Front, a Qaeda affiliate that is one of the most successful Syrian insurgent groups, was added on Friday to a global sanctions blacklist by the United Nations Security Council. The classification means the group is subject to an arms embargo and a freeze on its assets.
Beware. Rebel claims of government atrocities will begin to multiply as Syrian forces take full control of Qusayr. The goal of such claims being the rebel holy grail -- Western military intervention.

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Senate Foreign Relations Committee Approves Military Support for Rebels

Of particular interest in "Iran and Hezbollah Support for Syria Complicates Peace-Talk Strategy," by Michael Gordon and Steven Lee Myers, is the news that Iranian and Iraqi paramilitaries are fighting alongside Hezbollah with the Syrian army:
According to American intelligence reports, there are some 200 Iranian paramilitary Quds Force personnel in Syria. Qassim Suleimani, the Quds Force commander, recently ordered Iranian artillery and armor officials to help Mr. Assad’s regime, American officials say.

And Mr. Suleimani has also requested that several hundreds fighters from Asaib al-Haq and Kataib Hezbollah, two Iraqi Shiite militias that have been trained by the Iranians, join the war effort in Syria, according to officials familiar with the intelligence assessments. Iran is heavily involved in training thousands of members of Mr. Assad’s militia, the Jaish al-Sha’bi, including in Iran.
Therefore it is likely that there are Western "advisers" on the ground with the rebels. Imagine U.S. Special Forces fighting alongside Al Nusra Front jihadists. Whence GWOT? The Senate Foreign Relations Committee voted yesterday to supply weapons to the rebels:
In Washington, the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, of which Mr. Kerry was chairman before becoming secretary of state, voted on Tuesday to approve legislation that would authorize expanded assistance to the rebels in Syria, including weapons. 
“I think all of us understand the risks that come with this type of legislation,” said Senator Bob Corker, Republican of Tennessee. “But we also know that if we don’t shift the balance there and the moderate groups don’t have the opportunity to be successful the day after Assad, then I think all of us are going to regret we did not play a role in helping make that happen.” 
Caitlin Hayden, a spokeswoman for the National Security Council, declined to comment on the proposed legislation but said the White House’s policy was clear. 
“We are working urgently to end the conflict in Syria and hasten a transition from Bashar al-Assad to a democratic Syria that is inclusive of all Syrians,” she said.
Working urgently to end the conflict by arming Al Qaeda and thereby creating an inclusive, democratic Syria. How does that smell to you?

Thomas Friedman, though still wedded to his personal fantasy of the magical healing powers of capitalism, sensibly cautions us to think twice before supplying weapons to the Free Syrian Army. In his column today, "Tell Me How This Ends," he lists the likely outcomes of the civil war. It's worth quoting at length:
We can only properly answer the question — should we be arming the Syrian rebels? — if we first answer what kind of Syria do we want to see emerge and what will it take, beyond arms, to get there? 
If we want Bashar al-Assad’s regime to be toppled and pluralistic democracy to emerge in Syria, then we not only need to arm the rebels but we need to organize an international peacekeeping force to enter Syria as soon as the regime falls to help manage the transition. Otherwise, when Assad is toppled, there will be at least two more wars in Syria. First will be a war between Sunnis and Alawites, the sect that Assad represents. The Alawites will fight to defend their perks and turf. After that, there will be a war within the opposition — between the Islamists and more secular fighting forces that have very different visions of a future Syria. Only an outside peacekeeping force could make up for the lack of trust and shared vision and try to forge a new Syria. And it would be a very, very long haul. 
If our goal is to arm the rebels just to serve our strategic interests — which are to topple the Assad regime and end the influence of Iran and Hezbollah in Damascus and not care what comes next — then we need to be ready for the likely fragmentation of Syria into three zones: one Sunni, one Alawite and one Kurdish. 
That might eventually solve the trust and civil war problems, as everyone would be living “with their own,” but I am not sure it would better enable Syrians to address their development challenges.

A third option would be to arm the rebels just to ensure a stalemate — in the hope that the parties might eventually get exhausted enough to strike a deal on their own. But, again, I find it hard to see how any deal that might set Syria on the long, difficult path to a decent, inclusive political system could be implemented without outside help on the ground to referee. 
So let’s do something new: think two steps ahead. Before we start sending guns to more people, let’s ask ourselves for what exact ends we want those guns used and what else would be required of them and us to realize those ends?
In "Syrian Forces and Hezbollah Fighters Press Assault on Key City," Hania Mourtada and Anne Barnard report on the fog of war. The Syrian state news agency, SANA, reports steady gains by government forces in taking control of Qusayr, which is denied via Skype by activists inside the city. Syria says it destroyed an Israeli jeep that had crossed into its territory in the Golan Heights. Israel claims that the jeep was only lightly damaged and it never left its side of the border.
SANA said the incursion was meant to raise the “collapsed morale” of the rebels after the blows they had suffered in Qusayr. It was the second time in two days that the Syrian state news media, aiming to bolster its case that Syria’s opposition was allied with Israel, claimed that it had evidence that Israel had aided the rebels. On Monday, the state news media showed pictures of what it said was an Israeli jeep found in Qusayr, but it appeared to be an old vehicle, and experts said it could have been supplied to Israeli-allied militias in southern Lebanon years ago.
There does seem to be a pattern emerging. Rebel losses on the ground are followed by an Israeli attack. At the beginning of this month government gains in Tartus Province were followed by the Sunday morning mega-bombing outside Damascus. Something to keep an eye on.