Showing posts with label Yugoslavia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yugoslavia. Show all posts

Friday, March 14, 2014

Heedless West Heads for Trade War with Russia

The United States and the European Union continue to act as if they have nothing to lose by baiting and threatening Russia in the Ukraine. This was brought home to me by a quote from an unnamed State Department official in an article this morning by Michael Gordon, "Kerry Arrives in London for Crisis Talks on Crimea." Referring to this Sunday's vote in Crimea to secede from Ukraine,
“If this referendum goes forward, there will be costs,” the State Department official said. “If there is further military escalation there will be more costs. If there is not serious diplomacy there will be more costs.” 
Mr. Kerry also plans to ask Mr. Lavrov about Russia’s snap military exercise, the State Department official said. 
“We are very concerned,” the State Department official said. “This is the second time inside of a month that Russia has chosen to mass large amounts of force on short notice without much transparency around the eastern borders of Ukraine. It certainly creates an environment of intimidation.” 
“That will be one question that will be asked,” the official said. “What is meant by this?”
"What is meant by this?" Really? How pathetic. The U.S. continues to act as if it is engaged in just another drone strike on Pashtun tribesmen, or destruction of an African aspirin factory, apparently heedless of Russia's ability to apply costs of its own to Western conduct. What amazes me is the success the Obama administration in having Germany toe its line. Merkel has sounded particularly strident over the last couple of days. This is from a good story by Steven Lee Myers and Alison Smale, "Russian Troops Mass at Border With Ukraine":
The ouster of the government of Viktor F. Yanukovych in February and Russia’s subsequent intervention in Crimea have deeply divided Russia and the West, and in Berlin, Ms. Merkel underscored the potential risks, declaring that “the territorial integrity of Ukraine cannot be called into question.”
As Russia’s largest trading partner in Europe, Germany is certain to have significant influence on the debate over how to respond to Russia’s actions in Ukraine. Some politicians and observers in other European countries and in the United States have suggested that Germany’s close trading and other ties with Russia had made it hesitant to adopt sanctions against Russia. 
Ms. Merkel’s speech, however, suggested that President Vladimir V. Putin might have miscalculated the anger that the occupation and annexation of Crimea would cause — or that he might be impervious to it. 
Mr. Putin, who has remained in Sochi to attend the Paralympics there, has so far showed no sign of bending to international criticism. In a meeting on Wednesday with the directors of national Paralympic teams, he implicitly reiterated the Kremlin’s argument that the ouster of Mr. Yanukovych was an armed coup instigated by outside forces. “I would like to assure you that Russia was not the initiator of the circumstances we are now facing,” Mr. Putin said. 
In her remarks, Ms. Merkel rejected any comparison between the situation in Crimea today and that in Kosovo in the late 1990s, when NATO bombed Serbia for 78 days to halt the attacks on Kosovo Albanians by Serbian forces. 
Ms. Merkel was clear that Germany would go along with the other 27 states of the European Union, and the United States, if Russia did not open meaningful diplomatic talks and the West moved to freeze Russian accounts and impose travel bans or restrictions on leading Russian figures. 
“To make it unmistakably clear,” she said, “nobody wants it to come to that.”
The West is boxing itself into a corner. Its public is not behind this conflict despite a full-tilt propaganda campaign. The public is exhausted with constant warfare. Why spend billions to stir up trouble in Ukraine when Detroit is bankrupt? Russia, on the other hand, is operating with what appears to be overwhelming public support.

Yet despite a lack of popular approval, the West is pursuing a maximal position: the absolute territorial integrity of Ukraine (in spite of the precedent it created in cracking apart Yugoslavia) backed up by threats of economic warfare.

Clearly, as Russian forces mobilize along Ukraine's eastern border and street riots turn deadly in Donetsk, the West is going to have to put up or shut up. Putin has put up and will continue to do so. A red line has been crossed for Russia; Putin will not retreat. Elites running the show in Western capitals think that economic warfare will bring Putin to heel. I think they will find themselves the ones besieged by their own supporters in the business world. Hopefully, when the Western alliance starts to fray, the United States does not ramp up military support for Ukraine.

Sunday, March 9, 2014

How the Snipers on the Maidan Figure in the Kosovo Precedent

The big Ukraine story that the Gray Lady is featuring this Sunday is actually a good one. Written by Peter Baker, "Sovereignty vs. Self-Rule: Crimea Reignites Battle" explores the applicable precedents of the Wilsonian doctrine of self-determination. The one that gets the most ink, and the one that makes Obama's national security public relations man Benjamin Rhodes defensive, is Kosovo. If Kosovo can secede from a democratically elected government why can't Crimea?
Kosovo declared independence in 2008. The United States under George W. Bush recognized it, as did Britain, France and Germany, but Russia adamantly rejected it, as did Spain. The International Court of Justice later ruled that Kosovo’s declaration was legal. 
“We never saw it as setting a precedent, but there were some nations that saw it that way and still do,” said James W. Pardew, who was Mr. Clinton’s special representative for the Balkans.
John B. Bellinger III, who was the top lawyer at the State Department under Bush, said: “We were very careful to emphasize that Kosovo was a unique situation. We were fond of saying it was sui generis — and it did not create a precedent that would likely be replicable anywhere else.” 
That is not how the Kremlin sees it. Ever since, Russia has cited Kosovo to justify support for pro-Moscow separatist republics in places like Georgia, where it went to war in 2008 and recognized the independence of Abkhazia and South Ossetia over Western objections.
But here is the "money" passage:
“Kosovo is very much a legitimate precedent,” said Dimitri K. Simes, president of the Center for the National Interest, a Washington research organization, agreeing with Moscow’s argument. “Independence was accomplished despite strong opposition by a legitimate, democratic and basically Western-oriented government of Serbia.” By contrast, he said, the new pro-Western government in Kiev “lacks legitimacy,” since it came to power by toppling a democratically elected president.
The Obama administration maintains that the cases cannot be compared. Serbia, White House officials said, lost its legitimacy and right to rule in Kosovo by its violent crackdown. Despite Russian claims, there has been little, if any, independent evidence of such a campaign against the Russian-speaking population in Crimea. 
“There’s no repression or crimes against humanity that the government in Kiev has committed against the people of Crimea,” Mr. Rhodes said. “There’s no loss of legitimacy.”
But what if the "legitimate" government in Kiev came to power by means of a violent crackdown, a putsch? This is obviously what happened. And it is getting trickier for the Obama administration since a leaked phone call between Estonian Foreign Minister Urmas Paet and EU foreign affairs representative Catherine Ashton reveals that the sniper fire that killed both the protesters and police on the Maidan had the same "handwriting," meaning it came from the same snipers.

Why would the snipers, if they were Yanukovych goons, as the Obama administration prefers, gun down police? They wouldn't. Therefore the sniper fire was an act of provocation designed to create mayhem, mayhem used by the putsch leaders and their Western allies to delegitimize the Yanukovych government.

The Guardian ran the story last Wednesday. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov is now pressuring the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) to investigate. Agence France Presse has the story. Lavrov is making his request because the putsch government refuses to investigate.

I assume the Gray Lady will maintain her blackout of this story for as long as she can, even up to and including the OSCE actually conducting an investigation (maybe then she would assign it a sidebar). In any event, add this sniper issue to the March 16 Crimea vote to align with the Russian Federation (not to mention the enormous funding issues facing the putschists, ably outlined in a story by Steven Erlanger, as well as the political rise of anti-EU-integration Right Sector) and you have a train coming round the bend that is sure to fly off the rails.

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

What Kosovo (Not to Mention Western Business Interests in Russia) Reveals About the Crisis in Ukraine

There is a price to pay for backing a putsch. Hopefully that is a lesson that elites in Western capitals will have learned once the dust settles in Ukraine (though right now it is unclear when that will occur).

An important historic parallel for what is happening today is the 1999 NATO war against Yugoslavia. President Vlad Putin brought it up today in connection with Russia's defense of the Crimea: This from "Citing ‘Coup’ in Ukraine, Putin Reserves Right to Use Force" by Steven Lee Myers, Ellen Barry and Alan Cowell:
[Putin] said Russia is not considering annexing Crimea, but said Crimean citizens should be allowed to determine their own future, presumably as part of Russia or Ukraine. 
“We are not considering this possibility,” he said. “It’s up to people living in a certain territory, if they can exercise their free will, and determine their future. For example, if Kosovo’s Albanians were allowed to do that, self-determination, which according to U.N. documents is a right, but we will never instigate it, never support such trends.” 
“Only the people who live in a certain territory have the right to decide their own future,” he said.
Hence, one destabilizing U.S. precedent come home to roost, and not just in terms of international norms; Obama should be mindful of the fate of the Democrats post-Kosovo. Clinton took his high approval ratings coming out his Republican impeachment trial in the Senate and used them to mobilize support for bombing a European capital, Belgrade, on behalf of a criminal organization, the Kosovo Liberation Army. The result? Approval of Clinton quickly dropped and his vice president, Al Gore, lost to the scion of a none-too-popular conservative political family dynasty, and this despite Gore being able to boast of a leadership role in an administration that presided over the creation of a full-employment economy.

Obama should be very careful. He has neither the support of European allies nor the public that Clinton had. In terms of the former, consult this passage at the end of Peter Baker's story, "Top Russians Face Sanctions by U.S. for Crimea Crisis":
Russia is effectively the world’s biggest energy supplier, exporting more natural gas than any other country and more oil than any other nation after Saudi Arabia. Russia is also the biggest exporter of industrial metals and the fifth-biggest consumer market globally. 
“The biggest argument for severe economic sanctions not being imposed is that the European countries don’t have much of an alternative to Russian energy supplies,” said Jens Nordvig, the New York-based managing director of currency research at Nomura Holdings Inc. 
Several of the biggest Western energy companies have major investments in Russia, including B.P. and Royal Dutch Shell. 
It may also be difficult for Mr. Obama to sell sanctions to the American business community if it is being cut off while competitors still have access to Russian markets. Russia is Pepsi’s second-largest market and a significant market, too, for companies like Boeing, General Motors, John Deere and Procter & Gamble. 
ExxonMobil, the largest American oil company, has a joint venture deal with the state-controlled oil company, Rosneft, to explore what may be a very rich Arctic area called the Kara Sea. ExxonMobil is also working with Rosneft on drilling in the Baltic Sea and on other projects. 
But congressional leaders said they would move forward with sanctions as well as aid to Ukraine. A Senate Foreign Relations Committee bill would use $200 million in aid and loan guarantees to leverage $1 billion in international economic assistance. An additional $50 million would be steered from existing State Department accounts for electoral administration.
While governmental elites are immune to the entreaties of their constituents asking for an end to constant foreign wars, they do listen to their corporate benefactors, many of whom have their snouts in Mother Russia's lap. The PepsiCo and ExxonMobil connections lead one to draw the conclusion that for all of Obama's tough talk about economic reprisals nothing substantive will come of it. Maybe a few Russian officials will be banned from travel to the United States. Also, don't expect Europe to join the tough talk charade. Even if the EU embraces fracking immediately, it will still be dependent on Gazprom for decades to come.

I continue to believe that time is on Russia's side. Obama's approval will continue to drop. The putsch government will fracture as soon as the IMF austerity mandates are publicized.

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Comparing Syria to Yugoslavia

Putin takes flak at the G-8 summit for his support of Syria, and the rebels, in a story that doesn't sound authentic, purportedly killed 60 government troops in a suicide bombing of a military base near Aleppo.

But what I found noteworthy this morning was an opinion piece, "To Get a Truce, Be Ready to Escalate," by Wesley Clark, former U.S. presidential aspirant and NATO supreme allied military commander for Europe. It is noteworthy because it is an excellent illustration of the weakness and rot in pro-interventionist thinking prevalent in the U.S. foreign policy establishment.

It goes something like this: Inaction is not an option. And though it is likely that a U.S.-enforced no-fly zone would lead to full-scale military engagement and even though it is unclear what Syria would look like after Assad, we should nonetheless escalate the use of force to bring al-Assad to the negotiating table.

Proof of the success of such a strategy? NATO's 1999 bombing campaign against Yugoslavia. We're hearing this argument made frequently these days. Bill Clinton made it last week in his criticism of Obama for not doing more to aid the rebels.

Some points to keep in mind:
  • Kosovo is not a viable state. It is an Albanian rump rife with criminality. It is held together by means of United Nations support. Do we want this in the heart of the Middle East? Do we want Afghanistan in the heart of the Middle East? (Take a look at this analysis, provided by Syria expert Aron Lund, of the Islamist nature of the opposition.)
  • It is not the Syrian government that is unwilling to negotiate. It is the opposition and the GCC and the West who insist that al-Assad agree to relinquish power as a precondition of any talks. In other words, victory before any bargaining begins. Absurd. The West is engaged in an absurdity.
Here's Clark's wished for outcome:
The formula for diplomacy is clear: a cease-fire agreement; a United Nations presence; departure of foreign fighters; disarmament of Syrian fighters; international supervision of Syria’s military; a peaceful exit for Mr. Assad, his family and key supporters; a transitional government; and plans for a new Syria.
It's absurd. It's delusional. It's a desire for anarchy in the Middle East. It's a clear prescription for disaster. And this passes for interventionist prevailing wisdom?

Sunday, June 16, 2013

Organ Trafficking in Kosovo

I made the work-week commute in the late afternoon yesterday. The occasion was a retirement party for the business manager of the local where I work.

Riding the train out to SeaTac on a Saturday -- the party was held at the local's first-floor meeting hall -- was not something to which I was particularly looking forward. But the weather was perfect and the change of pace turned out to be enjoyable. The train was chock full of weekend shoppers and sightseers. Fathers out with their families and single women carrying bags from the department stores. I used the hour trip to read the lengthy The New Yorker piece by Nicholas Schmidle on Kosovo's criminal organ-harvesting enterprise. It's a sordid tale but one that needs to be learned. Too many supposedly knowledgeable people point to Bill Clinton's NATO war on Yugoslavia as a successful example of Western military intervention. But it must be remembered that during the spring of 1999 when the United States was leading the attack, the Chinese embassy in Belgrade was bombed and Wesley Clark almost fired on Russian forces in Pristina. Both incidents could have led to a much wider and more devastating conflict. Today Kosovo is not a viable state absent United Nations assistance; it is an Albanian criminal enterprise.

Schmidle spends the first half of his story constructing a rigorous brief on the criminal nature of the Kosovo Liberation Army. Then he pisses in his own punch bowl the second half by speculating that Serbs have suborned perjury in their obsession to secure convictions of former KLA leaders at the ICTY. He concludes his essay with a sympathetic account of Hashim Thaci.

In the end, Schmidle can't break out of the official mindset: evil Serbs, innocent "Kosovars." At the time Schmidle's article appeared in April he made the following blog post, "An Organ-Trafficking Conviction in Kosovo":
In this week’s issue of The New Yorker, I investigate allegations that, around the time of the 1999 Kosovo war, the Kosovo Liberation Army trafficked prisoners across the border into Albania, killed them, and harvested their organs. Hashim Thaci, the current Prime Minister of Kosovo, is among those accused of being responsible; a 2010 report, published by the Council of Europe, accused him of being the “boss” of a “network of unlawful activity,” which included prisoner abuse and organ harvesting. Thaci strongly denies the allegations and, despite all of these nasty insinuations, not a single case of suspected organ trafficking has gone before a judge and yielded a verdict.

That changed Monday, when an international panel of judges from the European Union Rule of Law Mission in Kosovo issued multiple convictions of human trafficking and organized crime. The charges don’t relate directly to the war years, or include Thaci or his close associates; they are centered on Medicus, a transplant clinic in Pristina, Kosovo’s capital. The prosecution argued that, in 2008, a urologist named Lutfi Dervishi began performing kidney transplants there for money. (The sale of organs is outlawed everywhere in the world except Iran.) In its 2010 report, the Council of Europe cited Dervishi’s clinic as evidence of an organ trade that began during the war and continued afterward, “albeit in other forms.”
The investigation continues. So expect more revelations of the true nature of the state created out of the smoke of Bill Clinton's stunning military-intervention success story.

Tuesday, April 23, 2013

NATO's Future

The NATO bombing campaign against Yugoslavia in 1999 created a precedent for the War in Afghanistan, which created a precedent for the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq. NATO is a defensive alliance. Its member nations were not under attack by either Yugoslavia or Afghanistan. But in both cases a rationale was pieced together. The underlying imperative was captured by the slogan "Out of area or out of business."

That imperative remains intact a decade later despite significant reductions in military spending by European countries, as reported today by Steven Erlanger in his story, "Shrinking European Military Spending Stirs Concern":
The challenge is particularly acute as NATO pulls its forces out of Afghanistan after a long, wearying and unsatisfying war, with results widely seen as fragile, even unsustainable. After Afghanistan, with Europeans looking inward and the Russian threat considered more rhetorical than real, some wonder once more about the real utility of NATO. 
James M. Goldgeier, dean of the School of International Service at American University in Washington, thinks that NATO has some considerable soul-searching ahead if its European members become increasingly unwilling to operate abroad.
“If NATO isn’t outward looking, it’s got nothing to do,” he said. “It can’t go back to managing a threat from Russia, because it’s not a real threat.”
The U.S. picks up three-quarters of NATO's tab. The EU's aspiration for a common defense force, eurocorps, has been a bust. Germany, the chief economic power of the EU, has been actively opposed to out-of-area actions in Libya and Mali. The United States will need at least nominal European support for its "Pivot to Asia."