Showing posts with label G-8. Show all posts
Showing posts with label G-8. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Finally, the Gray Lady Paints a Fair Picture of the Ukraine Crisis

I woke this morning to a drunk singing on the street below my apartment. Listening to lugubrious, slurred moans and wails is not the ideal way to begin one's day, but it does seems consistent with what has been in the news the last several months.

The good news this morning is that David Herszenhorn has a story that is probably one of the best things that has been published in the Gray Lady on the Ukrainian crisis. While "In Crimea, Russia Moved to Throw Off the Cloak of Defeat," begins with a denigration of the Russian Black Sea Fleet at Sevastopol -- the Cold Warrior information war mode that a regular reader of the New York Times has come to expect -- Herszenhorn unexpectedly changes course and presents a helpful, if still biased, appraisal of the East-West trade war in the Ukraine that led to the putsch, which was followed by Russia claiming Crimea:
“For 23 years after 1991, Russia has been treated consciously or subconsciously as defeated in the Cold War,” said Dmitry Kosyrev, a writer and political commentator with the RIA Novosti news agency in Moscow. “Russia has not accepted this mentality. We have something to say. We have not only interest, but experience. We are not a defeated country in the Cold War; we are something separate like India, like China.” 
Mr. Kosyrev added, “Not talking to us, not accepting our point of view, that’s exactly what brought Europe and the United States to the crisis in Ukraine.”
*** 
The contest for influence in Ukraine, long torn between Russia and the West, stretches back much further than last autumn. It is part of a wider tug-of-war that the West had dominated since the fall of the Soviet Union, drawing into Europe’s fold not just former Eastern bloc nations like Poland and Bulgaria, but the ex-Soviet republics — Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia — in the Baltics. 
Mr. Putin and many Russians believe that the Soviet leader Mikhail S. Gorbachev had received assurances that the NATO alliance would not extend beyond a reunited Germany. They consider it a betrayal that NATO now includes the Baltics, reaching Russia’s borders — a point that Mr. Putin stressed in his speech announcing the annexation of Crimea.
***

In the case of Ukraine, Mr. Putin had been waging a battle for months to prevent Mr. Yanukovych from signing accords with the European Union,wielding a mix of threatened trade sanctions and the enticements of fiscal aid— precisely the economic tools that the West views as the preferred way to conduct geopolitical combat in the 21st century.
Last summer, Russia blocked Ukrainian imports at the border for stepped-up customs inspections, and issued a series of threats of debilitating trade sanctions. Mr. Putin personally conveyed those threats to Mr. Yanukovych, who ultimately told European leaders he could not sign the accords. In the contest for Ukraine, Mr. Putin thought he had won with soft power. 
After protests broke out in Kiev in late November, and Western leaders moved aggressively to revive the political and trade agreements, Mr. Putin once again reached into his economic arsenal, offering Ukraine $15 billion in credit assistance along with discounts on Russian natural gas. By his view, the West had refused to accept Russia’s fair victory. 
While it appears much of the protests in Kiev were organic, fueled by genuine public outrage against Mr. Yanukovych that grew in response to police brutality, Mr. Putin and the state-controlled Russian media portrayed the uprising as fomented and sponsored by the West.
What Herszenhorn chooses not to mention here is the famous "Fuck the EU" hacked phone call between Nuland and Pyatt where the two U.S. officials discuss their collusion with Ukrainian opposition politicians to topple the elected Yanukovych government. It's hard to dismiss this phone call as Russian paranoia, as it is Nuland's statement that the U.S. has spent $5 billion promoting "democracy" in Ukraine.

But Herszenhorn finishes his piece quoting a former Bush I and Clinton official, Andrew Weiss, that leaves no doubt that Europe instigated the current mess:
Andrew S. Weiss, who worked on Russia issues in the administrations of Presidents Bill Clinton and the elder George Bush and is now vice president for studies at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said Mr. Putin’s actions were logical, even if not compatible with Western interests, in seeking to destabilize Ukraine rather than allowing it to fall into Europe’s sphere of influence. 
“There is a very straight line rational strategy at work here,” Mr. Weiss said. 
Mr. Weiss also said that Europe repeatedly refused to hear Russia’s concerns, effectively forcing a conflict by insisting the trade deal with Europe was incompatible with joining Russia’s customs union, a trade bloc it formed with Belarus and Kazakhstan. Europe also resisted three-way talks with Russia and Ukraine. 
“In some ways the E.U. has taken maximalist positions with the Russians and acted as if they were surprised that Russia took offense or got angry,” Mr. Weiss said.
So with Russia read out of the G-8 by the G-7, and with the bluff of further sanctions in abeyance pending Russian moves into eastern Ukraine, we should be entering a period of relative quiet. Except I think that the putsch government cannot stand peace and quiet because what it represents -- IMF austerity, increased militarism -- is anathema to the citizens of Ukraine. So I would expect some sort of provocation, some form of loud bang, a diversion, to keep eyes off the necessarily unpopular, undemocratic moves that have to made. This should go on for some time because Ukraine is in bad shape.

Monday, March 24, 2014

The Fable of Western Sanctions

Obama is in the Netherlands today to attend a G-7 meeting (G-8 minus an ostracized Russia). His goal will be largely confined to public relations gimmickry, to convey unity of purpose among the G-7 industrial nations towards "Russian aggression" in the Crimea. There is no unity of purpose. All one has to do is look at the graphic "How Much Europe Depends on Russian Energy" that was included in a story by Steven Lee Myers and Neil MacFarquhar this past Saturday to know that any sanctions Europe imposes on Russia will be window dressing only. Here's why: Germany, the largest economy in the Eurozone, imports 30% of its energy from Russia; the Netherlands, 34%; Sweden, 46%; Italy, 28%; Finland, 76%; Poland, 91%; Czech Republic, 73%; Lithuania, 92% -- and so on down the line.

The lede story today in the Gray Lady admits as much:
The other members of the Group of 7 economic partnership hardly have interests identical with those of the United States, and in many ways they are divided even among themselves, complicating any effort to draw a firmer line with Moscow. 
Mr. Obama’s sanctions, announced last week, were aimed at sowing pain among members of a Russian economic and political elite who owe their wealth and loyalties to Mr. Putin. But the sanctions were also targeted to minimize disruption to the global economy and to avoid further jeopardizing already meek Russian cooperation on issues like the war in Syria, Iran’s nuclear program, the Middle East and North Korea. 
For European countries, the risk of wider conflict with Russia is even graver. Britain hosts Russian billionaires and their money; Germany gets about one-third of its energy from Russia and sells it machinery and cars; France is in the process of delivering sophisticated attack ships to the Kremlin; and Italy depends on Russia for some 28 percent of its energy.
The U.S. position boils down to lies and bluffs. First, the lies: Pretend the putsch that sent the elected Ukrainian president fleeing for his life is perfectly legal and that there is no precedent, like, say, the U.S. dismemberment of Yugoslavia, for Russian actions in the Crimea. Next, the bluff: Talk incessantly of serious economic consequences for Russia when clearly nothing of the sort is in the works.

It is both clumsy and obvious; it is simply embarrassing.

More proof of the crass nature of the Obama administration's information war is its fear-mongering the military exercises Russia is conducting on its Ukrainian border. Though fears of an incursion into eastern Ukraine have subsided with Russia agreeing to the presence of OSCE monitors, this salient fact is ignored; rather, war hysteria is played up.

The United States would be much better served by quieting things down. But apparently its leadership, beginning to realize that it is now responsible for a dysfunctional Ukrainian state, cannot accept the fact that its stewardship of the February putsch (Assistant Secretary of State for Europe and Eurasian Affairs Vicky Nuland's famous and oft-quoted "Fuck the EU") has turned into a punch bowl caked with turds.

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Comparing Syria to Yugoslavia

Putin takes flak at the G-8 summit for his support of Syria, and the rebels, in a story that doesn't sound authentic, purportedly killed 60 government troops in a suicide bombing of a military base near Aleppo.

But what I found noteworthy this morning was an opinion piece, "To Get a Truce, Be Ready to Escalate," by Wesley Clark, former U.S. presidential aspirant and NATO supreme allied military commander for Europe. It is noteworthy because it is an excellent illustration of the weakness and rot in pro-interventionist thinking prevalent in the U.S. foreign policy establishment.

It goes something like this: Inaction is not an option. And though it is likely that a U.S.-enforced no-fly zone would lead to full-scale military engagement and even though it is unclear what Syria would look like after Assad, we should nonetheless escalate the use of force to bring al-Assad to the negotiating table.

Proof of the success of such a strategy? NATO's 1999 bombing campaign against Yugoslavia. We're hearing this argument made frequently these days. Bill Clinton made it last week in his criticism of Obama for not doing more to aid the rebels.

Some points to keep in mind:
  • Kosovo is not a viable state. It is an Albanian rump rife with criminality. It is held together by means of United Nations support. Do we want this in the heart of the Middle East? Do we want Afghanistan in the heart of the Middle East? (Take a look at this analysis, provided by Syria expert Aron Lund, of the Islamist nature of the opposition.)
  • It is not the Syrian government that is unwilling to negotiate. It is the opposition and the GCC and the West who insist that al-Assad agree to relinquish power as a precondition of any talks. In other words, victory before any bargaining begins. Absurd. The West is engaged in an absurdity.
Here's Clark's wished for outcome:
The formula for diplomacy is clear: a cease-fire agreement; a United Nations presence; departure of foreign fighters; disarmament of Syrian fighters; international supervision of Syria’s military; a peaceful exit for Mr. Assad, his family and key supporters; a transitional government; and plans for a new Syria.
It's absurd. It's delusional. It's a desire for anarchy in the Middle East. It's a clear prescription for disaster. And this passes for interventionist prevailing wisdom?