Showing posts with label ATO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ATO. Show all posts

Friday, February 6, 2015

Ukrainian Junta Near Collapse: Merkel & Hollande on Bended Knee in Moscow, Begging for a Ceasefire

Since Novorossia forces regained control of the Donetsk airport at the end of last month the quality of reporting in "the newspaper of record" has been atrocious.

For example, take the captioning of the photos. Invariably a picture of the damage wrought by the shelling of Donetsk will appear in the Gray Lady's pages accompanying a one-sided story that largely parrots U.S. State Department statements. The photograph below from today's story ("U.S. and Europe Working to End Ukraine Fighting," Michael Gordon and David Herszenhorn) is case in point:


"A city official in Donetsk, Ukraine, inspected a building that local residents said was damaged by shelling on Wednesday." CreditMaxim Shemetov/Reuters

Note that the origin of the shelling goes unidentified. The most fundamental aspect of reportage, in this case that the Ukrainian Army is shelling civilians in Donetsk, is being purposely obscured by "the newspaper of record." 

This kind of crude, cynical thought control, which most Westerners would dismiss as atavistic, totalitarian, Stalinist, has been a regular feature of The New York Times coverage of the Ukrainian junta's Anti-Terrorist Operation (ATO) against the people of the Donbass. 

Most people don't read complete stories. Most people will glance at a headline, look at the pictures and then turn the page. Since the Western media has been overwhelming in its condemnation of "Putin's aggression" against Ukraine, most people will incorrectly assume that Russia is responsible for the destruction.

Of course people who follow the news know better. Any glance at the comments section that accompanies a story on the fighting in Ukraine reveals people by huge margins opposed to the U.S. role -- such as the decision being debated by the Obama administration whether to supply sophisticated lethal weaponry to the junta -- in exacerbating the conflict. More than anything, the U.S. role in last February's coup in Kiev, followed by the herding of Europe into sanctioning Russian for its defense of Crimea. and the Ukrainian junta's ongoing assault on the civilians in the Donbass, proves that neither was Obama worthy of the Nobel Peace Prize nor is there substantive democracy in the United States, where there is next to no support for Obama's New Cold War.

But now the New Cold War is rapidly getting very hot. Mike Whitney has a must-read story today on CounterPunch, "The Fallujah Option for East Ukraine: The Real Reason Washington Feels Threatened by Moscow." Whitney concludes his piece on a pessimistic note :
NOTE:  The Novorussia Armed Forces (NAF) currently have 8,000 Ukrainian regulars surrounded in Debaltsevo, East Ukraine.  This is a very big deal although the media has been (predictably) keeping the story out of the headlines.
Evacuation corridors have been opened to allow civilians to leave the area.  Fighting could break out at anytime.  At present, it looks like a good part of the Kiev’s Nazi army could be destroyed in one fell swoop.  This is why Merkel and Hollande have taken an emergency flight to Moscow to talk with Putin.  They are not interested in peace. They merely want to save their proxy army from annihilation.
I expect Putin may intervene on behalf of the Ukrainian soldiers, but I think commander Zakharchenko will resist.   If he lets these troops go now, what assurance does he have that they won’t be back in a month or so with high-powered weaponry provided by our war-mongering congress and White House?
Tell me; what choice does Zakharchenko really have? If his comrades are killed in future combat because he let Kiev’s army escape, who can he blame but himself?
There are no good choices.
I believe Whitney is right. Merkel and Hollande, the German chancellor and French president, respectively, are in Moscow basically begging for a ceasefire because the Ukrainian Army is about to sustain a seriouspotentially crippling loss. Things are so bad that the idea is even being floated of creating a whole new separate Ukrainian military.  This is broached in the Gordon and Herszenhorn report mentioned above in terms of revelations regarding a Russian intelligence penetration of the Ukrainian military:
The head of the Ukrainian security service, Valentyn Nalyvaichenko, said at a news conference on Wednesday that the accused spy, Lt. Col. Mykhailo Chornobai, had been at the center of an espionage ring in the capital and had passed military secrets directly to an agent of the separatist Donetsk People’s Republic, including the locations of volunteer regiments that were then used to pinpoint artillery attacks.
Dmytro Tymchuk, a military officer and member of Parliament, said that Colonel Chornobai was among about 300 people working in the military sphere who had been arrested since the start of the conflict.
The arrest further deepened mistrust of the leadership in Kiev that is already pervasive among the poorly equipped rank-and-file soldiers and midlevel commanders fighting on the front line. And it reinforced a view prevalent on the battlefield that the military leadership cannot be trusted to manage any weapons delivered by Western allies because of their ties to the Russian military and security service, the F.S.B.
“It’s really a huge question: Should we completely change our armed forces structure,” Mr. Koziy said, noting that one proposal was to build a second, new military structure. “Of course this idea seems very much crazy to create a whole new, parallel general staff,” he said. “But on the other hand when you look at what’s going on today inside this building, you think maybe it’s the right decision.”
I'm sure the U.S. will be happy to reprise its performance of creating another nation's armed forces (see Iraq and Afghanistan; in Iraq, the U.S. is on its second go-round -- the ISIS capture of Mosul last summer led to the collapse of the Iraqi Army).

Whitney opens his article with a rundown of what is at stake in Ukraine:
Washington needs a war in Ukraine to achieve its strategic objectives. This point cannot be overstated.
The US wants to push NATO to Russia’s western border. It wants a land-bridge to Asia to spread US military bases across the continent.  It wants to control the pipeline corridors from Russia to Europe to monitor Moscow’s revenues and to  ensure that gas continues to be denominated in dollars. And it wants a weaker, unstable Russia that is more prone to regime change, fragmentation and, ultimately, foreign control. These objectives cannot be achieved peacefully, indeed, if the fighting stopped tomorrow,  the sanctions would be lifted shortly after, and the Russian economy would begin to recover. How would that benefit Washington?
It wouldn’t. It would undermine Washington’s broader plan to integrate China and Russia into the prevailing economic system, the dollar system. Powerbrokers in the US realize that the present system must either expand or collapse. Either China and Russia are brought to heel and persuaded to accept a subordinate role in the US-led global order or Washington’s tenure as global hegemon will come to an end.
This is why hostilities in East Ukraine have escalated and will continue to escalate. This is why the U.S. Congress  approved a bill for tougher sanctions on Russia’s energy sector and lethal aid for Ukraine’s military. This is why Washington has sent military trainers to Ukraine and is preparing to provide $3 billion in  “anti-armor missiles, reconnaissance drones, armored Humvees, and radars that can determine the location of enemy rocket and artillery fire.” All of Washington’s actions are designed with one purpose in mind, to intensify the fighting and escalate the conflict. The heavy losses sustained by Ukraine’s inexperienced army and the terrible suffering of the civilians in Lugansk and Donetsk are of no interest to US war-planners. Their job is to make sure that peace is avoided at all cost because peace would derail US plans to pivot to Asia and remain the world’s only superpower.
One other aspect of the conflict in Ukraine that notably absent from the reporting of The New York Times is the dangerous unstable condition of the Ukrainian economy. This is another reason for Merkel and Hollande begging for a ceasefire. Oren Dorell, writing for USA Today has the story, "Collapsing economy is second front in Ukraine's war":
As U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry lands in Kiev on Thursday to discuss Ukraine's economy and the ongoing conflict, the military and financial impact of the war is being felt deeply across the nation. 
The country's national government is reeling from a spike in defense spending and the loss of production and trade, particularly after separatists seized Ukraine's main industrial and coal-mining regions of Donetsk and Luhansk in eastern Ukraine. 
The fighting is also creating a distraction for Ukrainian leaders under pressure by international investors to restructure a collapsing economy. Ukraine's economic output dropped by 6.5% in 2014, according to the International Monetary Fund, which has sent a team to the capital of Kiev to assess the nation's economic needs. 
In order to meet a large foreign debt due in the coming months, Ukraine needs $15 billion in assistance. IMF chief Christine Lagarde has said she would support an expanded funding plan for Ukraine in return for unspecified fiscal reforms. 
Ukraine's war effort costs $7 million a day, a $2.5 billion yearly expense that is cutting into a budget decimated by reduced revenues related to the fighting, Ukraine's Deputy Foreign Minister Volodymyr Prystaiko told USA TODAY during a recent visit to Washington. 
Defense spending, which includes items not directly associated with the day-to-day costs of the fighting, now eats up 5.2% of the national budget, compared with just 1% in 2013.
Clearly Ukraine cannot sustain this absent a massive infusion of aid from the West, something which is going to be difficult rationalize.

Monday, July 14, 2014

Gray Lady Reports from Novorossiya Begin to Let the Sunshine in

As the junta military presses its assault on the People's Republic of Donetsk and the People's Republic of Luhansk, I have begun to pick up a shift in the "newspaper of record." This weekend, reporting from Marinka, Sabrina Tavernise wrote a hard-hitting anti-junta story, "Civilians Pay a Price for Gains of Ukraine Forces," that completely upended the official narrative that all woe in the Donbass tracks back to the pro-Russian federalization forces. As Tavernise writes,
But while the Ukrainian forces might have scored tactical victories, they were not winning any friends in Marinka, where the assumption was they were to blame. The attack there left five civilians dead and four wounded, according to the regional government, a grim sign of the imprecision and blunt force of the weapons being used by both sides in this war, which began in the spring when pro-Russian rebels seized Ukraine’s southeastern edge and declared independence.
“Pigs,” said a man with gray hair who was wiping away tears. “People were sleeping in their beds.”
The source of the rocket attack was in dispute. A Ukrainian military officer, who asked that his name not be used because he was not authorized to speak to the news media, said the Ukrainians did not have artillery positions close enough to hit Marinka. 
“Our artillery just wouldn’t have reached there,” the officer said. “It’s as simple as that.”
A military spokesman, Vladislav Seleznyov, said that Ukraine did not use its airpower or heavy artillery against rebel targets that were close to civilians. 
But the proximity of civilians did not stop the Ukrainians from shelling in and around Slovyansk, the former rebel stronghold they took back this month. And rebels in Marinka showed a reporter exploded rocket casings and a gaping hole in the animal feed factory where they were based, as evidence that the rockets had come from the Ukrainian military. Two rebels had been injured, they said. 
Across the street from the factory was the apartment building that took the worst hit, No. 6 Zavodskaya Street, a gray brick building rimmed with pretty gardens of brown-eyed susans and marigolds. A hole opened into a living room, which had collapsed in on itself. A door ripped from its hinges lay atop a large pile of curtains, cabinets and bricks. 
Igor Nersisyan, a retiree who lives on the second floor, said he had helped a neighbor dig her husband out from under that rubble early Saturday morning. The man, whom Mr. Nersisyan identified as Victor Belotserkovny, was dead when they reached him, the top of his skull sheared off in the blast. 
“They are trying to destroy peaceful people,” said Mr. Nersisyan, who blamed the Ukrainian military, as residents with bags of belongings walked away from the building.
Pair this with the story that David Herszenhorn wrote last week about the destruction the junta military visited upon Slovyansk, and I would count this as a significant shift by the main organ, the New York Times, for broadcasting U.S. foreign policy. Whether it is reporters on the ground bucking editors (which I don't see as possible), or there is actually a reappraisal underway, that the junta's Anti-Terrorist Operation (ATO) is doing massive damage to the fascist cabal running the show in Kiev, and, because the junta is operating under the direction of Washington, presumably from DCI Brennan, to the credibility, already almost irredeemably tarnished (ask Angela Merkel), of the United States.

The ATO has always been primarily about drawing Russia directly into the southeast. Now that it is apparent that the Kremlin is not going to chomp down on the bait (see Neil MacFarquhar's story this past Saturday), the junta is getting increasingly desperate. According to a story, "Ukrainian Forces Close In on Rebel-Held Luhansk," by Tavernise that appears in this morning's paper, the junta in its attempt to take Luhansk is now lobbing shells inside Russia and killing Russia citizens:
The military advances came as relations between Ukraine and Russia fell to a new low. On Sunday, a Russian citizen was killed on Russian soil by what the Russian government said was an errant Ukrainian shell. Ukraine denied firing a shell into Russian territory. Russia said the episode could have “irreversible consequences.”
It could be that the Gray Lady's tilt toward the truth is merely an aberration. We've seen the truth slip out over the weekend before. I'm thinking back to the early days of the putsch when Steven Erlanger published a story where he basically called out the Maidanistas as neo-Nazis. I thought that story heralded a collapse of Western support for the coup, that leaders in Europe and the United States were too queasy selling a fascist putsch as a popular democratic uprising that was constitutionally legitimate. I was wrong. Erlanger's story was a one-off. The Gray Lady, with Crimea joining the Russian Federation, went into full-on Cold War mode.

I do think that reality is beginning to intrude on the bellicose, fevered planners in Langley. Putin has checkmated them again. Moscow is not going to launch an invasion for the liberation of Novorossiya. Germany, World Cup in Ms. Merkel's possession, has been lost; she is now actively working on Russia's side. Putin is in Uncle Sam's backyard this week to announce the creation of a BRICS development bank. All the U.S. has proven it can do is sow death and destruction. Obama is a failure.

Sadly, like a murderous robot out of control, the ATO will continue, and many more people will die. The Kiev junta will rule over rubble.

Monday, June 16, 2014

End Game Approaching in Ukraine

We have arrived at the moment of truth in Ukraine. Sad to say that moment didn't come back in April when the junta launched its "Anti-Terrorist Operation" (ATO) against the southeast region of the country. Shelling and murder of civilians will not rouse the leaders of the West to broker a settlement, but I believe Gazprom's suspension of gas deliveries very well could. Neil MacFarquhar has the story this morning, "Gazprom Stops Supplying Natural Gas to Ukraine":
The Russian energy giant Gazprom stopped supplying natural gas to Ukraine on Monday, warning that the reduction could diminish the amount of gas flowing to the rest of Europe and escalating the political crisis between the two countries. 
After the government in Kiev failed to meet a 10 a.m. deadline imposed by Moscow to pay a nearly $2 billion installment for gas, Gazprom announced that it would no longer supply on credit. 
“Gazprom supplies to Ukraine only the amount that has been paid for, and the amount that has been paid for is zero,” a Gazprom spokesman, Sergei Kupriyanov, told reporters. 
A source close to Gazprom said the gas flow into Ukraine had been reduced by the amount intended for Ukraine itself. 
All of the gas flowing into Ukraine as of 10 a.m. Monday was meant only for transporting across the country to Europe, the source said.
The thing to keep in mind here is that Russia has been very balanced and measured in its handling of the coup aftermath in Ukraine. Many wanted Russia to go in with guns blazing and rout the junta military and fascist national guard from Novorossiya. Instead, Putin pulled Russian forces away from the border in a show of working with the West in allowing the junta to conduct its sham presidential election.

My impression is that Russian leadership, mindful of its many advantages in the conflict, has been careful not to create any opening for the United States to force energy sector sanctions against Gazprom. Hence, the apparent pussyfooting of Putin in the face of the shrieking of Yatsenyuk and the mendacious braying of Kerry.

Putin's rise and the rise of post-Yeltsin Russia is synonymous with the success of Gazprom. So Gazprom must be protected. That's why Gazprom chief Aleksei Miller went out of his way to make concessions to the junta.

One has to read to the very end of MacFarquhar's story to understand the bargaining positions of the parties. First, you have to wade through more shrieking by Yatsenyuk, Washington's man in Kiev, about Russian aggression before finding out that Gazprom wants Ukraine to pay the same price as Europe:
Russia and Ukraine have been negotiating for weeks over the price for gas, which Russia had been delivering at a subsidized rate that was lower than that which it charged European customers. Russia wants Ukraine to pay $385 per 1,000 cubic meters, which is the standard measure for gas in Europe. That figure was up from $268, an increase of about 44 percent. 
Gazprom, the world’s largest natural gas producer, increased the price after Ukrainian protesters toppled the government, a Russian ally, in February.
What MacFarquhar does not say is that the subsidized rate Ukraine was receiving was in exchange for the Russia military leases in Crimea. Now that Crimea is no longer part of Ukraine, having voted to join the Russian Federation three months back, there is no reason for Gazprom to supply Ukraine gas at the subsidized rate.

Ukraine gets two-thirds of its natural gas from Russia; Europe receives about one-fifth from Russia.

Both Russia and Ukraine have gone to court seeking restitution on previous gas shipments:
[Gazprom], which is 50.01 percent owned by the Russian government, also said that it was filing a lawsuit in an arbitration court in Stockholm to force Ukraine to pay $4.5 billion for gas that had already been delivered. Gazprom has repeatedly insisted that the dispute is more about getting paid than about the political tensions between the two countries. 
[Ukraine's] Naftogaz responded by saying that it had filed a suit of its own in the Stockholm court against Gazprom to establish a fair market price for the gas. Naftogaz said the suit would also ask the court to fine Gazprom for what the Ukrainian company claims to be $6 billion in overcharging since 2010. 
The Stockholm trade court, formally known as the Arbitration Institute of the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce, has long been used to settle East-West trade disputes because of Sweden’s neutrality.
This is the moment of truth in Ukraine because it is going to force Europe to take a position. Either Europe continues following the U.S. path of the New Cold War and embraces preferential treatment for Ukraine in supplying it with gas, the outcome of which is likely a broad trade war and energy sector sanctions against Russia, or Europe breaks from the U.S. and demands that the junta pay up and shut up.

The U.S. wants mayhem and war. Europe wants peace and the continued economic integration of Eurasia.

At the end of the month, June 27, Ukraine is set to sign the association agreement with the European Union, the same one that led to the coup when Yanukovych refused to sign it. Also at the end of the month the U.S. has promised more sanctions if the fight is still raging in Donbass, something which obviously puts the junta in control.

I must say, banking on a supine Europe to suddenly stand on its hind legs does not seem to me like a good bet.