Showing posts with label People's Republic of Donetsk. Show all posts
Showing posts with label People's Republic of Donetsk. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 20, 2014

Expect a Donbass Deal Next Week

Usually I scan the news before going to bed. I'll read quickly a full article if I think is important, like I did last night with "Ukrainian and Russian Leaders Will Meet as Rebels Continue to Falter," by Andrew Higgins and Andrew Kramer:
KIEV, Ukraine — Ukrainian forces pushed deeper into territory controlled by pro-Russian rebels on Tuesday, fighting street battles in the besieged city of Luhansk and pressuring the outer defenses of Donetsk in a further blow to the separatists’ crumbling virtual state. 
While continuing its offensive, the Ukrainian government said it saw a chance for a peaceful settlement after an announcement that President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia would meet next Tuesday with his Ukrainian counterpart, Petro O. Poroshenko, and European Union leaders in Minsk, the capital of Belarus.
Things are not going particularly well for Novorossiya.  While the dispatches from Colonel Cassad list plenty of junta losses, they also frequently mention a "crisis" atmosphere for a rebel militia attempting to cover the entire theater of the Ukrainian military offensive. Then there is the issue of the LPR/DPR's loss of leadership. Andrew Kramer reports in "Plenty of Room at the Top of Ukraine’s Fading Rebellion" that it has had an immediate adverse impact on the rebellion:
. . . President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia appears to be maneuvering for a face-saving settlement, analysts say, a way to escape a losing situation without puncturing his strongman image or antagonizing the ultranationalists at home who were expecting him to follow up his annexation of Crimea with an invasion of Ukraine. 
Step 1 has been a change in leadership. In recent weeks, in what separatist officials hopefully call the “Ukrainianization” of the leadership, almost all the original Russian leaders of the rebellion have resigned and gone home, replaced by Ukrainians of dubious qualifications. 
Aleksandr Borodai, a Russian citizen, stepped down as prime minister of the Donetsk People’s Republic, to make way for a Ukrainian, Aleksandr Zakharchenko, who had led a police advocacy group before the war. In the Luhansk region, Valery Bolotov, a Russian citizen, announced last week he had “temporarily resigned” as prime minister and left for Russia for medical treatment. He was replaced by Igor Plotnitskiy, a former public health inspector in Ukraine. 
Igor Girkin, who uses the nickname Igor Strelkov, or Igor the Shooter, a former colonel in the Federal Security Service who led the Russian military takeover of Crimea before arriving in eastern Ukraine, resigned as defense minister of the Donetsk People’s Republic. Vladimir Kononov, a local resident and former judo instructor, took his place. 
The shuffle also removed those in charge when Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 was shot down on July 17, including Igor Bezler, who used the nickname Bes, or the Demon. Mr. Bezler, a native of Crimea, appeared in a video in April identifying himself as a lieutenant colonel in the Russian Army. His location is unknown. 
The only remaining senior Russian here is Vladimir Antyufeyev, a reputed spy who lived under an assumed name for a decade and is now the first deputy prime minister. 
For the pro-Russian enterprise, the change of leadership was a gamble. While opening the prospect of peace talks, as the authorities in Kiev have refused to negotiate with Russian citizens, it has also left the rebel military ranks adrift, with control in the hands of local Ukrainians with modest résumés.
Kramer goes on to play up the loss of leadership as feeding the drunken anarchy that rules the streets of Donetsk without exploring the possibility that the excessive alcohol consumption might be a reaction to the junta's shelling of the city, a war crime.

In any event, something is in the works. Merkel will be in Kiev on Saturday; Putin in Minsk with Poroshenko on Tuesday. A deal has to get done for the simple reason that when the Ukie military enters Luhansk and Donetsk, the "Aleppo" phase of urban combat will commence and the humanitarian crisis will expand exponentially. While an argument could be made that the United States has been angling for such an outcome all along, the hope for Putin and Merkel is that the junta can see clearly enough to realize that by turning Donetsk and Luhansk into Aleppo it is destroying the future viability of the Ukraine. Also, I am sure that Merkel and Putin come with purses filled. Putin has Gazprom; Merkel has the European Central Bank.

So I think a deal will be done. I hope a deal will be done. But last night I dreamed a disturbing dream. I boarded a train. The train was waiting on the platform, and I walked in the open doors. Others waited on the platform. For some reason when I entered the train I decided to leave my shoulder bag/brief case on the platform. I think my thought was that I wanted to check out to make sure the train was headed in the right direction. There were a few riders who were already sitting down inside.

Shortly after I entered the train, the conductor announced the train was leaving and then the doors shut. I got up to leave, but it was too late. I looked at my bag sitting on the platform where a few commuters milled about waiting for the next train.

Immediately I became panicked. My wallet, with all my credit cards and identification and $100 cash, was in the bag. The amount of time to replace all that stuff was too staggering to comprehend. I had to get off the train. But how to do that? The next stop -- when was the next stop?

The rest of the dream was like a Steve McQueen action movie. I think I actually pried the doors of the train car open and jumped out, leaving me in an industrial rail yard with new stubbly spring grass on the surrounding hills. I took off running, calculating the entire time the probability that my bag would still be there when I finally arrived back at the platform.

The point? Don't get on the train. Get off the train. And that is what I think Putin does.

Monday, July 14, 2014

Gray Lady Reports from Novorossiya Begin to Let the Sunshine in

As the junta military presses its assault on the People's Republic of Donetsk and the People's Republic of Luhansk, I have begun to pick up a shift in the "newspaper of record." This weekend, reporting from Marinka, Sabrina Tavernise wrote a hard-hitting anti-junta story, "Civilians Pay a Price for Gains of Ukraine Forces," that completely upended the official narrative that all woe in the Donbass tracks back to the pro-Russian federalization forces. As Tavernise writes,
But while the Ukrainian forces might have scored tactical victories, they were not winning any friends in Marinka, where the assumption was they were to blame. The attack there left five civilians dead and four wounded, according to the regional government, a grim sign of the imprecision and blunt force of the weapons being used by both sides in this war, which began in the spring when pro-Russian rebels seized Ukraine’s southeastern edge and declared independence.
“Pigs,” said a man with gray hair who was wiping away tears. “People were sleeping in their beds.”
The source of the rocket attack was in dispute. A Ukrainian military officer, who asked that his name not be used because he was not authorized to speak to the news media, said the Ukrainians did not have artillery positions close enough to hit Marinka. 
“Our artillery just wouldn’t have reached there,” the officer said. “It’s as simple as that.”
A military spokesman, Vladislav Seleznyov, said that Ukraine did not use its airpower or heavy artillery against rebel targets that were close to civilians. 
But the proximity of civilians did not stop the Ukrainians from shelling in and around Slovyansk, the former rebel stronghold they took back this month. And rebels in Marinka showed a reporter exploded rocket casings and a gaping hole in the animal feed factory where they were based, as evidence that the rockets had come from the Ukrainian military. Two rebels had been injured, they said. 
Across the street from the factory was the apartment building that took the worst hit, No. 6 Zavodskaya Street, a gray brick building rimmed with pretty gardens of brown-eyed susans and marigolds. A hole opened into a living room, which had collapsed in on itself. A door ripped from its hinges lay atop a large pile of curtains, cabinets and bricks. 
Igor Nersisyan, a retiree who lives on the second floor, said he had helped a neighbor dig her husband out from under that rubble early Saturday morning. The man, whom Mr. Nersisyan identified as Victor Belotserkovny, was dead when they reached him, the top of his skull sheared off in the blast. 
“They are trying to destroy peaceful people,” said Mr. Nersisyan, who blamed the Ukrainian military, as residents with bags of belongings walked away from the building.
Pair this with the story that David Herszenhorn wrote last week about the destruction the junta military visited upon Slovyansk, and I would count this as a significant shift by the main organ, the New York Times, for broadcasting U.S. foreign policy. Whether it is reporters on the ground bucking editors (which I don't see as possible), or there is actually a reappraisal underway, that the junta's Anti-Terrorist Operation (ATO) is doing massive damage to the fascist cabal running the show in Kiev, and, because the junta is operating under the direction of Washington, presumably from DCI Brennan, to the credibility, already almost irredeemably tarnished (ask Angela Merkel), of the United States.

The ATO has always been primarily about drawing Russia directly into the southeast. Now that it is apparent that the Kremlin is not going to chomp down on the bait (see Neil MacFarquhar's story this past Saturday), the junta is getting increasingly desperate. According to a story, "Ukrainian Forces Close In on Rebel-Held Luhansk," by Tavernise that appears in this morning's paper, the junta in its attempt to take Luhansk is now lobbing shells inside Russia and killing Russia citizens:
The military advances came as relations between Ukraine and Russia fell to a new low. On Sunday, a Russian citizen was killed on Russian soil by what the Russian government said was an errant Ukrainian shell. Ukraine denied firing a shell into Russian territory. Russia said the episode could have “irreversible consequences.”
It could be that the Gray Lady's tilt toward the truth is merely an aberration. We've seen the truth slip out over the weekend before. I'm thinking back to the early days of the putsch when Steven Erlanger published a story where he basically called out the Maidanistas as neo-Nazis. I thought that story heralded a collapse of Western support for the coup, that leaders in Europe and the United States were too queasy selling a fascist putsch as a popular democratic uprising that was constitutionally legitimate. I was wrong. Erlanger's story was a one-off. The Gray Lady, with Crimea joining the Russian Federation, went into full-on Cold War mode.

I do think that reality is beginning to intrude on the bellicose, fevered planners in Langley. Putin has checkmated them again. Moscow is not going to launch an invasion for the liberation of Novorossiya. Germany, World Cup in Ms. Merkel's possession, has been lost; she is now actively working on Russia's side. Putin is in Uncle Sam's backyard this week to announce the creation of a BRICS development bank. All the U.S. has proven it can do is sow death and destruction. Obama is a failure.

Sadly, like a murderous robot out of control, the ATO will continue, and many more people will die. The Kiev junta will rule over rubble.