Showing posts with label Rojava. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rojava. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 23, 2019

Putin Blesses Erdogan's "Safe Zone"

A joint Turkish-Russian statement issued after six hours of talks between Putin and Erdogan said they would establish a “joint monitoring and verification mechanism” to oversee implementation of the agreement.
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov was more blunt. If Kurdish forces did not retreat, Syrian border guards and Russian military police would have to fall back. “And remaining Kurdish formations would then fall under the weight of the Turkish army,” he said.
[snip] 
Ankara may also have to moderate its own military ambitions in the region. Turkish security sources said Ankara was re-evaluating a plan to set up 12 observation posts in northeastern Syria in the wake of the deal.
That change reflects the fact that Turkey, which had aimed to be the dominant force in the “safe zone” area, will now have to share that territory with Assad and Putin, who have both said that Turkish forces cannot remain in Syria in the long term.
“The most significant part of the Russian-Turkish agreement is the arrival of the Syrian border guard to the northeast, something both Damascus and Russia sought for a long time,” said Yury Barmin, a Middle East specialist at Moscow Policy Group.
“This also means de facto recognition of Assad by Erdogan.”
"Russia warns Syrian Kurdish YPG must pull back or face Turkish army," Andrew Osborne
The Putin-Erdogan powwow yesterday in Sochi puts a spotlight on a major U.S. foreign policy failure.

As Peskov said, “The United States was the closest ally of the Kurds during the last few years, and in the end the U.S. ditched the Kurds and effectively betrayed them.”

ISIS detention centers and U.S. military bases were abandoned. The plan to station exiting U.S. troops across the border in Iraqi Kurdistan has been vetoed by the Iraqi government. Now, Putin has blessed Erdogan's "safe zone."

No word yet if the Kurdish YPG plan to fight back. If they do it will be absent any backer other than the CIA. The Kurds have until Tuesday to clear out of the border.

German defense minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer is calling for a massive NATO occupation force to patrol the Syrian border along with Turkey and Russia, which is an obvious non-starter.

Moon of Alabama points out the logistical difficulties the U.S. faces in supporting its remaining operations in Syria. (This assumes that U.S. statements it will leave only a couple hundred troops in country are truthful. More likely a couple thousand.)

The entire U.S. occupation of northeast Syria, a.k.a., Rojava, has been shrouded in mystery from the get-go. Reporting has been atrocious. Has the U.S. really abandoned its airbase outside Kobani? Does the U.S. really only have a couple hundred soldiers in Deir ez-Zor? We don't know.

Nonetheless, it is a significant victory for Syria. Its troops are once again patrolling the northern border and no Turkish military bases are being erected.

Monday, October 21, 2019

U.S. Pledges to Maintain Control of Syrian Oil

Over the weekend the Pence-Pompeo ceasefire appeared to hold. As Reuters reports, "On Sunday, the SDF said they had withdrawn from the border town of Ras al Ain under the U.S.-brokered ceasefire deal, but a spokesman for Turkish-backed Syrian rebels said the withdrawal was not yet complete." Turkey has promised to resume its offensive tomorrow unless all Kurdish forces are gone.

Which raises the question, Gone from where?  Presumably from "[A] rectangular piece of territory that is bounded by the towns of Tel Abyad and Ras al-Ain on Syria’s border with Turkey, and runs south to a main highway in territory Mr. Kobani’s forces control, by Tuesday night." Mazlum Kobani, leader of the Syrian Kurdish forces, says they're already gone, but he promises trouble if Turkey plans to cleanse the area of Kurds and repopulate it with Syrian Arab refugees. At the same time, Iran is on record opposing the establishment of a dozen Turkish observation posts (a.k.a., military bases) in the cleansed area.

Secretary of Defense Mark Esper went on record today saying that U.S. troops would stay in northeast Syria to "protect" the oil fields from a defeated Islamic State, laying to rest any notion that a U.S. withdrawal would be complete. A U.S. convoy of 30 Humvees was observed exiting Syria and entering Iraq at the Sumel crossing. What's that, maybe 150 troops?

The question here is has the Trump administration convinced the Kurds to give up on that rectangular piece of territory bounded by Tel Abyad and Ras al-Ain. For now, it appears so. Erdogan meets with Putin tomorrow. We should know more in the next 36 hours.

Friday, October 18, 2019

Pense-Pompeo "Ceasfire" Meaningless

Though the announcement halts fighting for five days, and gave Mr. Pence an agreement to return home with, it was in practice less of a cease-fire deal than an acknowledgment of the United States’ rapid loss of influence in Syria since the Turkish invasion began last Wednesday.
In less than two weeks, the United States’ official position has reversed from one of tacit support for Syrian Kurdish control of northern Syria — to one of total deferral to Turkish territorial ambitions in the same area. 
"Turkey Agrees to Pause Fighting, but Not to Withdraw Forces From Northern Syria," Annie Karni, Lara Jakes and Patrick Kingsley
The Pence-Pompeo "ceasefire" announced yesterday is already crumbling (see "Kurds Accuse Turkey of Violating Truce as Shelling Continues in Syria" by Patrick Kinglsey):
A spokesman for the Kurdish forces, Mustafa Bali, said on Twitter that Turkey continued to pound civilian areas and a hospital, despite the announcement on Thursday night by Mr. Pence that there would be a five-day pause in the fighting.
Syria and Russia were not included in ceasefire discussions. Since the Kurdish YPG are now allied with Syria and Russia in the contested borderlands, the Pence-Pompeo ceasefire is essentially meaningless, a ham-handed club-footed sideshow meant to draw the attention of Trump's domestic critics.

The real reason for the five-day pause is likely that the Turks faced difficulty in clearing and holding Tell Abyad and Ras al-Ayn, the nexus of the Turkish invasion. The five-day pause will allow the Turks to position more firepower and possibly work out an agreement with the Russians to use the kind of air power that was critical in conquering Afrin last year.

Thursday, October 17, 2019

There is No Proof that the U.S. is actually Exiting Syria

In public appearances, Trump said he was fulfilling a campaign promise to bring U.S. troops home from “endless wars” in the Middle East — casting aside criticism that a sudden U.S. withdrawal from Syria betrays the Kurdish fighters, stains U.S. credibility around the world and opens an important region to Russia. 
“We have a situation where Turkey is taking land from Syria. Syria’s not happy about it. Let them work it out,” Trump said. “They have a problem at a border. It’s not our border. We shouldn’t be losing lives over it.”
"US delegation seeking a cease-fire with Turkey and Kurds," Zeke Miller and Robert Burns
If only it were true. A helpful story by Thomas Gibbons-Neff and Eric Schmitt, "How the U.S. Military Will Carry Out a Hasty, Risky Withdrawal From Syria" appeared the other day:
As the troops withdraw, they first will collapse inward by abandoning the outposts closest to the line of advancing foreign troops, in this case the Turkish military and its ill-disciplined Syrian militia proxies, along with Russian and Syrian government forces.
U.S. troops are leaving the Turkish border but there is no reporting saying that they are exiting Syria.

Moon of Alabama continues its "best of all possible worlds" interpretation of ongoing events, providing the first reference to Syria recovering some of its oil fields in Deir ez-Zor:
Russian troops prevented attempts by Turkish supported Jihadis to attack Manbij. Russian and Syrian units have now also entered Ayn al-Arab/Kobani. Syrian government troops took control of the electricity producing dam in Tabqah and some units set up posts in Raqqa. Other units entered the Conoco and Al-Umar oil fields north of Abu Kahmal and east of Deir Ezzor. Some local tribe which profited from the oil explorations there held a small protest against the return of government control.
I remain skeptical. The official U.S. position, which presumably vice president Pence and secretary of state Pompeo are in Ankara today to convey, is a demand for a ceasefire. Trump has already undercut this position with his comments that what happens in northeast Syria is not a U.S. concern. And the House of Representatives has undercut Trump by voting a 354-60 rebuke of his troop pullout.

But so far the pullout seems limited to some bases in Kobani, Manbij, the hot zone between Tell Abyad and Ras al-Ayn, and Raqqa. The U.S. controls a substantial airbase near Kobani, as well as an Advanced Operational Base West and an Advanced Operational Base East; also, we need some confirmation that the U.S. has actually relinquished control of the oil fields in Deir ez-Zor.

Tuesday, October 15, 2019

Let's Keep an Eye on Deir ez-Zor

A Manchurian candidate stab-in-the-back narrative is beginning to take shape, the broad outlines of which are that Trump conspired with Putin and Erdogan to carve up Syria. Russian-backed Syrian troops now occupy positions abandoned by U.S. troops in Manbij. We should know soon enough if there is any substance to this new elite narrative because Turkish troops and their Syrian proxies are bearing down on Manbij. There should be a battle. If not, it would be a marvel of Russian de-confliction, and plenty of grist for Russiagaters.

Trump has pivoted to confront Turkey, offering up sanctions targeting Turkish steel that the market has laughed off. Pelosi is working with Lindsey Graham to concoct something more stringent.

Russia is skeptical that all U.S. troops are in fact exiting northeast Syria. So am I. There is no news of Deir ez-Zor (a.k.a. Deir al-Zour). Deir ez-Zor is where the Kurdish-led SDF and the U.S. fought with the Syrian Arab Army and Russian mercenaries in 2018. It is where Syria's oil fields are. Let's keep an eye Deir ez-Zor in order to understand how serious the United States is about vacating Syria.

Monday, October 14, 2019

Rojava in Chaos

This is how contradictions work themselves out. Chaos. Now that the Syrian Arab Army has deployed to Rojava and is moving to reassert control of the M4 highway, it is hard to imagine everything get buttoned up as neatly as Moon of Alabama outlines this morning.  First, we must haver some reliable reports of the Syrian Arab Army taking control of the oil fields of Deir ez-Zor and occupying the many U.S. bases and secret airfields sprinkled throughout Rojava. There hasn't been anything like that so far.

Right now the narrative is topsy turvy. The long-demonized Assad government is virtuous for doing something the United States was unwilling to do -- defend the Kurds from Turkish attacks. While the former U.S. ally Free Syrian Army is being branded a vicious mercenary jihadist invader.

Also, much is in play on the diplomatic front. The European Union has passed a ban of weapon exports to Turkey, while the Trump administration scrambles to get out in front of congressional sanctions on Turkey. Erdogan might decide it is time to open up the refugee floodgates and swamp Greece like it was 2015.

Then there is the status of the 11,000 ISIS foot soldiers imprisoned in Rojava, not to mention the thousands of Western soldiers and contractors.

To sort all this out, a reliable hegemonic force is required. The only one that currently fits the bill is Russia.

Sunday, October 13, 2019

Erdogan Speaks

At news conference today Turkish president Tayyip Erdogan confirmed that his goal is the total control of the Turkish-Syrian border:
ISTANBUL (Reuters) - Turkey’s incursion into Syria will stretch from Kobani in the west to Hasaka in the east, going some 30 km (19 miles) into Syrian territory, President Tayyip Erdogan said on Sunday, and the town of Ras al Ain was already under Turkish control.
Addressing a news conference in Istanbul, Erdogan said the Turkish-led forces had also besieged the Syrian border town of Tel Abyad, west of Ras al Ain, in its fight against the YPG Kurdish militia, which Ankara says is a terrorist organization. 
“We focused first on the 120-km (75-mile) area between Ras al Ain and Tel Abyad. Thus we will divide the 480-km terrorist corridor down the middle,” Erdogan said.
“Then we will take control of Hasaka on the one side and Ain al Arab (Kobani) on the other and complete the operation,” he said, referring to towns either side of the current focus of operations. “We will go down to a depth of around 30-35 km, in line with the safe zone map which we declared previously."
[snip]
The Turkey-led forces have so far seized control of 109 square km (42 square miles), territory including 17 villages around Tel Abyad and four villages around Ras Al Ain, Erdogan said.
Every indication is that things are going to get increasingly ugly because at this point no power is stepping in to curb the Turkey's campaign against the Kurds. Germany's making pro forma demands that Turkey halt its invasion, while the U.S. abandons more bases to remove its forces from the line of fire. Unless the YPG is capable of more fight-back than it has shown to date, its looks like it is going to unfold exactly as Erdogan outlines.

Saturday, October 12, 2019

"The Annihilation of Rojava"

In the left critique of impeachment one can detect an implicit assumption that Trump standing in the crosshairs of the deep state is somehow an anti-imperialist. The header of yesterday's Moon of Alabama post, "Trump Brings Troops Back Home To Saudi Arabia," perfectly encapsulates this fallacy, as does the conclusion to Bill Van Aucken's "US sends 3,000 more troops to defend Saudi monarchy":
While the Democrats’ exclusive focus on Trump’s failure to pursue a sufficiently bellicose policy against Russia and prosecute the war for regime change in Syria has allowed the US president to absurdly posture as an opponent of war, the reality is that he has overseen a staggering increase in military spending designed to prepare for “great power” confrontations, particularly with China.
Meanwhile, whatever his political pretense, Trump has done nothing to end any of the wars in the Middle East. While he has ordered US troops to pull back, allowing the Turkish invasion, none of them have been withdrawn from Syria.
With the latest buildup of US forces in Saudi Arabia, Washington is preparing, behind the backs of the working class, to launch a catastrophic military conflict with Iran. The most urgent task posed by these developments is the building of a global antiwar movement led by the working class. This movement must be armed with a socialist and internationalist program to unify working people in the United States, Europe and the Middle East in a common struggle against imperialist war and its source, the capitalist system.
Turkey's goal in its four-day offensive appears to be the control of the entire border of Rojava. For a cogent assessment of what's in store for Rojava read "The Annihilation of Rojava," which appeared Tuesday on Jacobin.

Thursday, October 10, 2019

Turkish Invasion of Rojava Larger than Advertised

Reporting on Turkey's invasion of Rojava, now in its second day, is generally poor. The invasion appears to be larger than originally advertised. The New York Times features a map of Turkish strikes from Kobani all the way to Qamishli, basically the entire northern border of Rojava with the exception of the eastern tip. The Turkish Defense Ministry boasts of tangible progress; the Kurdish Syrian Democratic Forces, the opposite. One thing seems certain, the United States did not restrict the use of Turkish air power.

Though they're making noises of alarm, the Western powers know what's happening here. Let's be plain. If the Turkish invasion goes as stated, we're talking about ethnic cleansing. Reuters reports that
NATO-ally Turkey has said it intends to create a “safe zone” for the return of millions of refugees to Syria. But world powers fear Turkey’s action could deepen the conflict, and runs the risk of Islamic State prisoners escaping from camps amid the chaos.
[snip]
In the Turkish border town of Akcakale, around 30 vehicles carrying Syrian rebels, many pick-up trucks mounted with anti-aircraft machines drove along the main along the Turkish side of the border from Syria’s Tel Abyad, a Reuters journalist said.
The double-cross of the Kurds comes at an inconvenient time for Trump. He needs his troops in congress loyal. But as the extent of the Turkish invasion comes to light, there will be great pressure on congress to act.

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

Rojava and Impeachment

With the Turkish invasion of northeast Syria about to begin, Kurdish forces are vowing to resist. One can understand why. The Syrian towns of Tel Abyad and Ras al Ain, where Turkish forces are massing and where U.S. forces recently pulled back, lie at the center of Rojava.

The Pentagon has pledged to close theater airspace to Turkish F16 jets. Turkey used air power extensively to defeat the Kurds last year in Afrin. Maybe some of those Javelin anti-tank missiles sold to Ukraine can be diverted to the Kurds, leveling the playing field.

Trump has threatened Turkey with devastating reprisals if its invasion is bloody and destabilizing, at the same time he gave it the green light to go ahead. Congress could punish Turkey if Trump fails to:
Senator Lindsey Graham, Republican of South Carolina, addressed Turkey on his own Twitter account on Tuesday, warning the country not to go ahead with the operation.
“To the Turkish Government: You do NOT have a green light to enter into northern Syria,” Mr. Graham wrote. “There is massive bipartisan opposition in Congress, which you should see as a red line you should not cross.”
Trump has an equally big mess on his hands at home. White House counsel Pat Cipollone sent a letter yesterday to the U.S. House of Representatives declaring that the White House will not cooperate with the impeachment inquiry. Nancy Pelosi now needs to schedule a full vote of the House on impeachment. She wins that vote, Trump will likely tack back and provide some sort of limited cooperation.

The left case against impeachment, articulated by Taibbi and Urie, is that the whistleblower who got the ball rolling is not a real whistleblower but a spook and impeachment is a CIA-instigated coup. To which I say, okay, yes, you are right. But this doesn't mean that impeachment should be blocked or Trump defended. The underlying facts of Russiagate were never proven. The underlying facts of Ukrainegate are not even in dispute.

Taibbi says
The argument that’s supposed to be galvanizing everyone right now is the idea that we need to “stand up and be counted,” because failing to rally to the cause is effectively advocacy for Trump. This line of thinking is based on the presumption that Trump is clearly worse than the people opposing him.
That might prove to be true, but if we’re talking about the treatment of whistleblowers, Trump has a long way to go before he approaches the brutal record of the CIA, the NSA, the FBI, as well as the cheerleading Washington political establishment. Forgetting this is likely just the first in what will prove to be many deceptions about a hardcore insider political battle whose subtext is a lot more shadowy and ambiguous than news audiences are being led to believe.
My point is that impeachment is a galvanizing and informative exercise. Already the quality reporting that has been done on Ukrainian politics in the last week is much better than what has been delivered in the last three years.

Tuesday, October 8, 2019

The Return of the Free Syrian Army and the Fabled "No-Fly/Safe Zone"

Judging from the hue and cry brought on by Trump's announcement of a troop pullout in northeast Syria, one would think that it was 1948 and the United States had just abandoned West Berlin to Soviet tanks. Rojava must indeed be vitally important to U.S. strategic interests in the middle east: a quasi-state chock full of secret airfields to bomb any foe anytime -- exactly what the "deep state" wants.

But Trump is angling after a two-fer here: one, he gets to pose as a peacenik -- a little appreciated aspect of his successful presidential campaign -- in the run up to 2020; and, two, he gets to implement a strategic goal long sought by Western powers in Syria, the fabled "no-fly/safe zone" occupied by Syrian rebels.

The must read article this morning is Carlotta Gall's "Syrian Rebels See Chance for New Life with Turkish Troops." The much maligned and repeatedly left for dead Free Syrian Army is back at the centers of things once more:
Mr. Trump’s decision, announced late Sunday, has been sharply criticized by politicians of both political parties in the United States as a desertion of the Kurdish-led forces — the most reliable American partners in fighting Islamic State militants in Syria. But fighters and veterans of the Free Syrian Army point out that they were also abandoned by Mr. Trump when he cut support to their force in 2017.
Now, the Free Syrian Army, which has largely been marginalized in the conflict, sees a chance to regain lost territory in its struggle against President Bashar al-Assad of Syria.
[snip]
Hisham al-Skeif, a former civilian leader of the anti-Assad uprising and a spokesman for a faction of the rebel army, said the creation of the safe zone had been negotiated to avoid clashes. Free Syrian Army soldiers would be on the ground, backed by Turkish forces, but would avoid areas where United States forces and their Kurdish-led allies were based, he said.
“We are allied with the Turks, and we are convinced this is for peace and not war,” he said. “We always say we never want to fight.”
Mr. al-Skeif said Free Syrian Army soldiers and Turkish troops were expected to occupy a strip of territory between the two border towns of Tell Abyad and Ras al-Ayn, where most residents are Arabs. The Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces, which have been allied with the United States, were reported to have withdrawn from the towns on Monday.
The operation to create a safe zone, if successful, would be a boost for Mr. Erdogan, who is under political pressure at home from splinter groups in his own party and growing public resentment against Syrian refugees.
Seen in this light, there is no U.S. double-cross of its Kurdish allies. The principal actors sat around a map and made a decision together. The U.S. has been talking to Turkey for months if not years about just this moment. What's happening now as Turkey prepares to invade is everyone is playing to their domestic audience.

Monday, October 7, 2019

NATO Engineered Genocide of Syria's Kurds?

Breaking news this morning (see "Trump Endorses Turkish Military Operation in Syria, Shifting U.S. Policy" by Eric Schmitt, Maggie Haberman and Edward Wong):
On Monday, witnesses in Syria saw United States forces withdrawing from two positions in northeastern Syria: observation posts in Tel Abyad and Ein Eissa.
“Turkey will soon be moving forward with its long-planned operation into Northern Syria,” the White House said in a statement released just before 11 p.m. [Sunday] in Washington. “The United States Armed Forces will not support or be involved in the operation, and United States forces, having defeated the ISIS territorial ‘Caliphate,’ will no longer be in the immediate area.”
It's not clear how significant a military campaign Turkey is launching here. Erdogan's "safe zones" are supposed to span 300 miles along the Turkey-Syria northeast border while penetrating 20 miles inside Syria, all territory presently claimed by the Kurdish state of Rojava. Anthropologist and left intellectual David Graeber sees a genocide in the making, one with NATO fingerprints.

Rojava and the Kurdish-led SDF are a contradiction that Trump inherited from the Obama administration. The existence of Rojava is considered by Turkey, a NATO ally, an unacceptable threat. But Rojava provides the U.S. a substantial footprint to wage ghost wars in the middle east. Trump, in a show of hollow bombast last year, called for the complete withdrawal of U.S. forces from Syria, only to capitulate ultimately. Now, though, it does seem as if the Kurds have been double-crossed:
Last December, Mr. Trump called for a complete United States withdrawal from Syria, but ultimately reversed himself after a backlash from Pentagon, diplomatic and intelligence officials, as well as important allies in Europe and the Middle East.
Soner Cagaptay, the director of the Turkish Research Program at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, and author of “Erdogan’s Empire: Turkey and the Politics of the Middle East,” said in a telephone interview that a Turkish incursion uncontested by the United States would allow Turkey to cut another swath into Kurdish-controlled territory in Syria. That would give Mr. Erdogan a ready place to send hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees and prove yet again his influence with Mr. Trump on Syria policy.
“It’s quite a significant development,” Mr. Cagaptay said.
Many Syria experts criticized the White House decision and cautioned that American abandonment of its Kurdish allies could widen the eight-year Syrian conflict and prompt the Kurds to ally with the Syrian government of President Bashar al-Assad to combat the much larger and more technologically advanced Turkish army.
“Allowing Turkey to move into northern Syria is one of the most destabilizing moves we can do in the Middle East,” Representative Ruben Gallego, an Arizona Democrat and former Marine who served in the Iraq war, said on Twitter on Sunday night. “The Kurds will never trust America again. They will look for new alliances or independence to protect themselves.”
The announcement by the White House came as a shock to the S.D.F., Kurdish officials said on Monday. In a statement, the S.D.F. said that it had fulfilled its obligations in the efforts to reduce tensions with the Turks but that the United States had not.
The statement warned that a Turkish incursion could endanger the progress made to establish security in the wake of the battle against the Islamic State. It also called on Kurdish forces to “defend our homeland from the Turkish aggression.”
Mr. Erdogan has demanded a “safe zone” for his nation to run 20 miles deep and 300 miles along the Turkish-Syrian border east of the Euphrates. That area, he has said, would be reserved for the return of at least a million Syrian refugees now inside Turkey. Mr. Erdogan has threatened to send a wave of Syrian migrants to Europe instead if the international community does not support the initiative to send them back to Syria.
Since early August, the American and Turkish militaries have been working together on a series of confidence-building measures — including joint reconnaissance flights and ground patrols — in a 75-mile-long strip of that 300-mile border area.
American-backed Kurdish forces have pulled back several miles and destroyed fortifications in that area.

Thursday, September 12, 2019

Erdoğan Pledges to Settle One Million Refugees in Syrian Buffer Zone

Carlotta Gall had a must-read article the other day, "Turkey’s Radical Plan: Send a Million Refugees Back to Syria." Turkey is cracking down on Syrian refugees within its borders. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan promises to build new cities and resettle one million Syrians in the "safe zones" Turkey is negotiating with the United States. The safe zones, or buffer zones, are in U.S.-backed Kurdish-controlled territory in Syria, a.k.a., Rojava. As Gall notes,
The United States and Turkey agreed in principle last month to establish a jointly patrolled zone for refugees along the border but they are still negotiating the details and major differences remain.
Mr. Erdogan wants the zone to be 20 miles deep and run for 300 miles along the Turkish-Syrian border east of the Euphrates. The United States has limited Turkey’s access to a few miles.
American and Turkish troops conducted their first joint patrol of a small zone on Sunday.
But Syria has already called the plan a violation of its sovereignty and Russia emphasized the need to preserve Syria’s territorial integrity. The Kurds oppose the deal but have reportedly pulled back heavy weaponry from part of the border area.
American officials are focused on preventing clashes between Turkish and Kurdish forces.
Because Erdoğan is not getting what he wants he has started to threaten Europe again with an influx of migrants. The EU has given Turkey billions since 2015 to warehouse migrants and prevent another crisis that led to Brexit and the ultra-nationalism of Pegida and Matteo Salvini.

The U.S. is trying to square the circle here. It is likely using airfields in Rojava to conduct "mystery airstrikes" against Iraq, Iran, Syria and Lebanon. The U.S. needs the Kurdish shadow state to keep doing what it is doing, and it can't have a Kurdish shadow state without Kurdish support. So eventually there is going to be some sort of eruption. 

Tuesday, September 3, 2019

Obscuring the Obvious about who Ultimately Controls al-Hawl

What's interesting about Vivian Yee's "Guns, Filth and ISIS: Syrian Camp Is ‘Disaster in the Making’," a description of the al-Hawl refugee camp (or "Al Hol detention camp," as The New York Times describes it), a place where the survivors of the caliphate have been concentrated, is that the United States is barely mentioned, and when it is, it is as a concerned third party.

Yee mentions the United States twice: once at the beginning and once at the end of her story:
The daily ordeals of overcrowded latrines and contaminated water, limited medical care, flaring tensions between residents and guards, and chronic security problems have left the residents embittered and vulnerable. A recent Pentagon report that cautioned that ISIS was regrouping across Iraq and Syria said Islamic State ideology has been able to spread “uncontested” at the camp.
[snip]
The Pentagon report said local forces did not have enough resources to provide more than “minimal security,” allowing extremist ideology to spread unchecked.
Al-Hawl is located in northeast Syria and is controlled by the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), a  proxy army that would not exist if not for the United States.

The U.S. as guarantor of the SDF is therefore ultimately responsible for al-Hawl. This is pretty basic. The Times' obscuring of the obvious might be due to the Pentagon's need for an excuse to hold onto the large chunk of territory it illegally occupies in northeast Syria.

Monday, August 26, 2019

Turkish Buffer Zone in Northeast Syria Takes Shape

Turkey and the United States announced over the weekend that a joint operations center for overseeing the new buffer zone in northeastern Syria, or "safe zone" as Turkish president Tayyip Erdogan prefers, is opened for business. As Selcan Hacaoglu reports for Bloomberg,
Turkey sees its deal with the U.S. to carve out a narrow security zone in northern Syria as just the beginning, two Turkish officials said, with Ankara determined to purge Kurdish fighters from a much larger section of the border region.
After weeks of difficult negotiations, the NATO allies agreed this month to jointly patrol an area stretching 125 kilometers (78 miles) between the Syrian towns of Tal Abyad and Ras al-Ayn, and up to 15 kilometers deep, according to the officials, who have direct knowledge of the talks but asked not to be identified in line with regulations barring them from talking to the media.
While the agreement should allow Turkey’s military to move into northeast Syria without firing a shot, the country could unleash a unilateral incursion if the zone isn’t deepened and extended by as much as several hundred kilometers at a later date, they said.
The Pentagon did not respond to a request for comment on the Turkish plans.
Turkey has deployed 10 brigades along its frontier between the Euphrates River and the Iraqi border to confront an estimated 15,000 members of the Kurdish YPG, the officials added.
A joint Turkish-U.S. headquarters designed to oversee a buffer zone in northern Syria became “fully operational” on Saturday, state-run Anadolu Agency reported, citing Defense Minister Hulusi Akar. A first helicopter flight over the zone, which will be off-limits to U.S.-backed YPG forces, was planned for Saturday.
It looks like Turkey is getting much of what it wants. The Kurdish YPG must abandon its fortified positions, hand over its heavy weapons to the U.S. and leave the area:
The Turkish-U.S. agreement foresees the immediate withdrawal of YPG fighters from the buffer zone, with the U.S. collecting heavy weapons it had supplied to the group, the officials said. Fortified Kurdish positions and tunnels were to be destroyed, they said. Turkey wants members of the YPG’s political wing, called the PYD, to leave the area as well.
[snip]
The deal allows for Turkish armed drones to start surveillance flights over the zone but the U.S. hasn’t yet agreed to overflights by Turkish warplanes, the officials said. The U.S. also opposes Turkey’s proposal to move Ankara-backed rebels of the Free Syrian Army to the area, but did agree that refugees living in Turkey could return, they said.
Joint military patrols are expected to start within a month and Turkey will set up four bases ahead of the creation a local security force, the officials said.
Turkish demands to be able to deploy as many troops as it considers necessary to enforce security were rebuffed, with the U.S. agreeing only to the deployment of two Turkish soldiers for every American soldier, they added.
Turkey has stepped up attacks on the Kurdistan Workers Party; at the same time, Turkish alignment with Al Qaeda in Idlib has been exposed and is going poorly.

The Kurds are sophisticated actors. They will either resist a campaign of ethnic cleansing approved by the United States; or the U.S. has provided assurances that the safe zone is a ruse. It's hard to imagine the latter.

Thursday, August 8, 2019

U.S. and Turkey Agree to Fudge on the Buffer Zone in Northeast Syria

Turkey and the United States decided to settle there differences over a proposed buffer zone in northeast Syria by agreeing to a hollow statement reaffirming the idea. According to Carlotta Gall,
Defense officials from both countries issued separate but similar statements after three days of talks in Ankara, the Turkish capital. The statements gave no details on the size of the zone or how it will be policed, which may still be undecided, but the agreement was presented by Turkey as a meeting of its demands.
[snip]
Discussions have been focused on the S.D.F. pulling its forces and weaponry away from the border area and on the size of the safe zone. The United States has preferred a zone that is just a few miles wide, whereas Turkey has sought a corridor along its border as deep as 20 miles.
The agreement announced on Wednesday appeared to be aimed only at ensuring that Turkish and American forces, who are NATO allies, do not come into conflict.
Syria blasted the agreement.

Thursday, July 25, 2019

Turkey Threatens Rojava

U.S. Special Envoy for Syria James Jeffrey met with senior Turkish officials this week to hash out the details on the creation of "safe zones" in northern Syria. The talks did not go to Ankara's liking. According to Reuters,
After U.S. special envoy for Syria James Jeffrey held talks with Turkish officials, Turkey said on Wednesday it had run “out of patience” with Washington and warned that it would carry out a military operation in the region if an agreement on the safe zone was not reached.
Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu said the United States was stalling progress on the safe zone, just as it did with a joint roadmap agreed to clear the northern Syrian town of Manbij of the YPG last year.
At a briefing in Ankara on Thursday, Turkish military officials said talks on the planned safe zone with the United States would continue, but reiterated that Turkey’s expectations on the Manbij roadmap had not been met.
“Work is planned to continue in the coming period. We cannot share details as efforts are under way. Our aims are clear. The Turkish army is the only force capable of doing this,” one of the officials said regarding the safe zone.
These safe zones were agreed to by Trump last December. Trump promised at the same time to withdraw all U.S. forces in northeast Syria, which prompted the resignation of U.S. Defense Secretary James Mattis and ISIS czar Brett McGurk. Trump eventually walked back the troop withdrawal. Today thousands of U.S. troops remain in Syria.

What are these "safe zones"? The Defense Post reports that
How such a buffer zone would be created by Turkey is unclear. A 20-mile zone would encompass the majority-Kurdish towns including Qamishli and Kobane as well as strategic cities controlled by groups affiliated to the Syrian Democratic Forces, such as Tal Abyad and Manbij. It would also include Ayn Issa, the new administrative center for north and east Syria.
The Turkish government has long been threatening to launch a military incursion to clear the border area of the predominantly Kurdish YPG, which forms the core of the U.S.-led Coalition-backed SDF in ground operations against Islamic State.
Washington’s support for the group has infuriated the Turkish government, which views the YPG as a branch of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, or PKK, designated a terrorist organization by Turkey and its Western allies.
In Manbij, Turkey expected the U.S. to get rid of all heavy weapons, eliminate the YPG, and hand the city over to a Turkish-approved governing council.

Turkey does not appear to be willing to settle for anything less than military control of this 20-mile buffer along the border, an area heavily populated by the Kurds and vital to any future Rojava.

Turkey appears willing to fight. The Defense Post story ends with the following:
Turkish media reported a significant buildup of Turkish military forces along the Syrian border in the days following the [S-400] missile system’s initial delivery.
An undisclosed number of U.S. troops still remain in northern Syria. American officials have taken Turkey’s threats seriously in past internal discussions.
American patrols were reported in the border area near Serê Kaniyê (Ras al-Ayn) earlier this week after the Turkish military said it retaliated against rocket fire from the Syrian side that landed in the Turkish town of Ceylanpinar.
Both the SDF and YPG also said a shell was fired from Syrian territory but denied responsibility and said an investigation was underway.
The YPG called the incident a “provocative act” and a “clear attempt to disrupt stability in NE Syria.”
The United States is vulnerable in northeast Syria. It would have to use air power to defend its troops on the ground. Erdogan's purchase of the S-400 is proof that Turkey is serious about attacking Rojava.

Friday, January 11, 2019

Don't Believe the Hype

The United States military announced today that the troop withdrawal from Syria has begun, but it doesn't say where or when:
The surprise announcement came in a statement from Col. Sean Ryan, the spokesman for the United States-led coalition against the Islamic State. Colonel Ryan said the coalition had “begun the process of our deliberate withdrawal from Syria,” adding that he would provide no further information about “specific timelines, locations or troop movements.”
But the announcement, coming days after [national security adviser John] Bolton’s remarks, added to a climate of chaos surrounding Washington’s policy on Syria at a time when Turkey has threatened to invade the country.
Ben Hubbard, "U.S. Begins Syria Withdrawal, Amid Uncertainty Over Strategy"
 Russia is skeptical that anything of the sort is actually happening:
Reflecting the confusion, Interfax reported that the spokeswoman for the Russian Foreign Ministry, Maria Zakharova, said in Moscow on Friday that the American military’s announcement added to the Kremlin’s growing doubts that the United States would soon withdraw from Syria.
It seems like Washington “is looking for a reason to stay,” she said. “I cannot share your confidence that they are leaving there because we never saw an official strategy.
Trump's initial announcement that U.S. troops would withdraw from Syria in 30 days precipitated a march of the zombies. SecDef Mad Dog Mattis and ISIS czar Brett McGurk resigned. Then the withdrawal was moved from 30 days to four months. Then, this week, Bolton announced that there were conditions that had to met before the U.S. would leave Syria. These conditions were dismissed by Turkey, with Turkish foreign minister Mevlut Cavusoglu promising once again a military campaign to oust U.S. proxy Kurdish forces from their Rojava stronghold.

We're right back to where we started when Trump made his initial pullout pledge. Hence the need to trot out a military spokesman to say, "No, we're really going. Trust us." The whole thing is a charade.

Like the Tories commitment to Brexit, zombie logic rules the U.S. occupation of northern Syria: It's unsustainable, shot through with contradictions, and is maintained by complete prevarication.

The only solace one can find is looking forward to the eventual collapse of the zombie. Brexit and northern Syria seem to be running on parallel timelines.

Next week May's zombie government should -- I say should because I've predicted her demise more than once -- lose a crucial vote and begin to wind down.

In Idlib Al Qaeda (HTS/Nusra) has recently consolidated its hold on the province at the expense of the Turkish proxy Free Syrian Army (re-branded the National Liberation Front). HTS/Nusra never adhered to the Sochi ceasefire agreement.

The question now is whether the U.S. will threaten to bomb the Syrian Arab Army if it begins an offensive against Al Qaeda in Idlib. It did last time, prior to the Sochi ceasefire. Now there will no question that the U.S. is acting as "Al Qaeda's air force."

Meanwhile, the Kurds are in talks with Syria regarding the status of Rojava. The Turks no doubt have communicated their red lines to Damascus: disarmament, no political autonomy, etc.

One thing is clear. No one can count on the United States. It's a blubbering zombie.

Thursday, December 20, 2018

Now that the U.S. Appears to be Leaving Syria, a Real Political Settlement can be Reached

With Trump's announcement yesterday that he will withdraw 2,000 special operations troops from northern Syria the prestige press is emitting its expected animal wail, encapsulated as follows by The New York Times editorial board ("Trump’s Decision to Withdraw From Syria Is Alarming. Just Ask His Advisers."):
An American withdrawal would also be a gift to Vladimir Putin, the Russian leader, who has been working hard to supplant American influence in the region, as well as to Iran, which has also expanded its regional footprint. It would certainly make it harder for the Trump administration to implement its policy of ratcheting up what it calls “maximum pressure” on Iran.
David Sanger, The New York Times' principal national security reporter, amplifies this "Great Game" wail in his "A Strategy of Retreat in Syria, With Echoes of Obama":
In fact, as recently as Monday, as Mr. Trump was contemplating getting out, the State Department insisted that America was not going anywhere — and Mr. Assad would be making a big mistake if he thought the United States was going to leave.
“I think if that’s his strategy, he is going to have to wait a very long time,” James F. Jeffrey, the United States special representative for Syria, said in an address at the Atlantic Council in Washington.
As it turns out, Mr. Assad will have to wait only about a month for the American withdrawal to be complete.
In his speech this week, Mr. Jeffrey made an impassioned case that the civil war in Syria was not just about the half-million people dead, nor the 11 million others who have been driven from their homes.
It has “become a great-power conflict,” he said, with Americans, Russians, Iranians, Turks and Israelis all involved. Any American policy, he said, “cannot focus only on the internal conflict.” He added later than “Iran has to get out of there,” meaning Iranian ground troops.
What goes unmentioned is any legal basis for the continued presence of U.S. troops on Syrian soil. The Hajin pocket, the last remaining toehold for ISIS in Syria, has been captured. The Times claims 20,000 - 30,000 ISIS fighters there, but that's ludicrous, an embarrassing display of "fake news" to gin up support for continued participation in the Great Game.

The deal is not yet done though. Don't count out the military just yet, as Mark Landler, Helene Cooper and Eric Schmitt report in "Trump Withdraws U.S. Forces From Syria, Declaring ‘We Have Won Against ISIS’":
The abrupt, chaotic nature of the move — and the opposition it immediately provoked on Capitol Hill and beyond — raised questions about how Mr. Trump will follow through with the full withdrawal. Even after the president’s announcement, officials said, the Pentagon and State Department continued to try to talk him out of it.
“We have won against ISIS,” Mr. Trump declared in a video posted Wednesday evening on Twitter, adding, “Our boys, our young women, our men — they’re all coming back, and they’re coming back now.”
“We won, and that’s the way we want it, and that’s the way they want it,” he said, pointing a finger skyward, referring to American troops who had been killed in battle.
The White House did not provide a timetable or other specifics for the military departure. “We have started returning United States troops home as we transition to the next phase of this campaign,” Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the White House press secretary, said in a statement. Defense Department officials said that Mr. Trump had ordered that the withdrawal be completed in 30 days.
The decision brought a storm of protest in Congress, even from Republican allies of Mr. Trump’s like Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, who said he had been “blindsided.” The House Democratic leader, Representative Nancy Pelosi of California, suggested that the president had acted out of “personal or political objectives” rather than national security interests.
[snip]
Gen. Joseph Votel, the commander of United States Central Command, and Brett H. McGurk, the American envoy to the coalition fighting the Islamic State, fiercely protested the military withdrawal, administration officials said. Both argued that the Islamic State would never have been defeated without the Kurdish fighters, whom General Votel said suffered many casualties and always lived up to their word.
Officials said General Votel argued that withdrawing American troops would leave the Kurds vulnerable to attack from Turkey, which has warned it will soon launch an offensive against them. It would also cement the survival of Mr. Assad, whose ouster had long been an article of faith in Washington.
The Pentagon said in a statement that it would “continue working with our partners and allies to defeat” the Islamic State wherever it operated.
More on the humiliation of the odious McGurk, one of the architects of the caliphate, from Rod Nordland in "U.S. Exit Seen as a Betrayal of the Kurds, and a Boon for ISIS":
Brett McGurk, Mr. Trump’s special envoy in the fight against the Islamic State, said in a briefing last week that the fight was far from over.
“If we’ve learned one thing over the years, enduring defeat of a group like this means you can’t just defeat their physical space and then leave,” he said. “You have to make sure the internal security forces are in place to ensure that those gains, security gains, are enduring.”
He did not mince words about what an American withdrawal would mean. “It would be reckless if we were just to say, well, the physical caliphate is defeated, so we can just leave now,” he said. “I think anyone who’s looked at a conflict like this would agree with that.”
Efforts to reach Mr. McGurk on Wednesday were unsuccessful.
Not all is lost for the YPG. The PKK collaboration with the United States and Saudi Arabia was doomed to begin with. Rojava has a greater chance of survival as a (new) constitutionally protected federal territory within Syria.

As the Russians say, now that the U.S. appears to be going, a real political settlement can be reached.

Monday, June 18, 2018

The Siege of Hodeidah Compared to Afrin City

UPDATE: The latest from Hodeidah is that the Saudi-UAE coalition has successfully wrested portions of the airport from the Houthis. This is denied by the Houthis, a spokesman for which said the coalition forces are in retreat. The airport is destroyed and civilian casualties are growing. The seaport is still operating. UN special envoy for Yemen, Martin Griffiths, left Sanaa without any agreement. The battle for Hodeidah grinds on with no end in sight.

****

If looked at through the prism of the Kurdish failure in March to hold Afrin City against the Turks, it's hard to imagine a more hopeful outcome for the Houthis in Hodeidah. The stakes are different as is the terrain. Afrin is a river city in Syria near the Turkish border that is the production center for olive growing. Hodeidah is the principal port -- both air and sea -- on the Red Sea; it is Yemen's fourth largest city with a population of 400,000. Hodeidah falls to the UAE-Saudi coalition and Sanaa the capital starves.

It took the Turks and their Free Syrian Army proxies less than a week to conquer Afrin City, sending the Kurds of the YPG and YPJ retreating into the surrounding hills. The siege of Hodeidah is already into its sixth day.

At first there were breathless reports that the UAE-Saudi coalition was proceeding methodically and with little trouble to control both air and sea ports. The story this morning is not so sanguine. Houthi fighters are stubbornly resisting; the coalition has responded with shelling, which is impacting neighborhoods surrounding the airport. There are civilian casualties.

My assessment back in March was that the if YPG/YPJ failed to hold Afrin City, they would prove themselves merely a U.S. proxy, unable to achieve their objective of an independent Rojava. With the news that Turkish forces are entering the outskirts of Manbij, this assessment has proven accurate.

We'll soon find out if the Houthis are nothing more than Iranian proxies -- which has been the prevailing mainstream wisdom, with an occasional caveat, since the Yemeni Civil War began three years ago.

The Houthis are not Iranian proxies. My guess is that they will put up more of a fight than the Kurds. Moon of Alabama notes reports that French special forces are part of the coalition attacking Hodeidah. What we're looking at is another inconclusive Western-backed military campaign. Plenty of death and destruction, but not much of anything else.