Friday, March 22, 2013

Cypriot Parliament to Vote on New Bailout

Today the Cypriot Parliament is voting on a replacement bailout plan, swapping the widely-derided deposit confiscation scheme for a nationalization of pensions at state-run companies. The issue now, assuming that parliament passes the new bailout plan, is whether the troika accepts it. This is from Liz Alderman's "Cyprus Lawmakers Prepare to Vote on a New Bailout" article this morning:
Before concrete details emerged, German leaders made it clear they would not back a deal that involved nationalizing the state-owned companies’ pensions, a measure that is rejected in Berlin as more socially dangerous than even the original plan to tax smaller savings. 
In a closed-door meeting with members of her junior coalition partner, the Free Democrats, Chancellor Angela Merkel made clear her impatience with the government in Cyprus, stating that “under no circumstances can we give up our principles,” the public television network ARD reported. 
“When you consider that there was massive resistance against involving the savings, then it is not easy to see how tapping the pension funds, which we view as socially a much more drastic step, is a very good idea,” Steffen Seiber, Ms. Merkel’s spokesman, told reporters. 
Germany is not alone. Luc Frieden, Luxembourg’s finance minister, expressed frustration over a lack of communication in Nicosia, telling Germany’s RBB radio, “It is difficult that we are not getting any details from Cyprus.”
Krugman in his column this morning, "Treasure Island Trauma," predicts that Cyprus will go the way of Iceland -- the banks, swollen by foreign deposits, will collapse and domestic depositors will be protected:
My guess is that, in the end, Cyprus will adopt something like the Icelandic solution, but unless it ends up being forced off the euro in the next few days — a real possibility — it may first waste a lot of time and money on half-measures, trying to avoid facing up to reality while running up huge debts to wealthier nations. We’ll see.
But step back for a minute and consider the incredible fact that tax havens like Cyprus, the Cayman Islands, and many more are still operating pretty much the same way that they did before the global financial crisis. Everyone has seen the damage that runaway bankers can inflict, yet much of the world’s financial business is still routed through jurisdictions that let bankers sidestep even the mild regulations we’ve put in place. Everyone is crying about budget deficits, yet corporations and the wealthy are still freely using tax havens to avoid paying taxes like the little people. 
So don’t cry for Cyprus; cry for all of us, living in a world whose leaders seem determined not to learn from disaster.
A post on naked capitalism responds to Krugman by stressing that Cyprus is not some outlier like the Cayman Islands but very much in tune with old Europe:
As for the size of the banking sector relative to GDP, Krugman seems scandalized that the banking sector is so large relative to its economy. Yes, this is a risky model, and Cyprus made the mistake of being overly dependent on one huge client, Russia. But Cyprus is hardly alone in being a financial center with banks that are a big multiple of GDP. Luxembourg is the really extreme case here, with a banking sector at over 20x GDP. England’s banking sector is 6x GDP. Swiss banks were 6.8x GDP in 2010 (Switzerland has forced much higher equity requirements on its banks, so its balance sheets have shrunk since then). Singapore also has an outsized banking sector. But let us remember that the EU has also set out to trash the Cyprus banking sector pretty much overnight with the deposit garnishing threat. It is important to recognize that while a restructuring was necessary, the severity of the crisis and the degree of damage that will be inflicted on the economy was not.
This is not to underplay Cyprus’s problems. But it would help to depict them accurately.

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Troika Tough Love

The news out of Cyprus this morning is not encouraging. Proposals -- such as issuing new bonds based on the confiscation of state-run pension funds or using Church of Cyprus property as collateral to issue new bonds or selling offshore gas exploration rights to Gazprom -- cobbled together to satisfy troika (ECB, IMF and the European Commission) demands to raise 5.8 billions euros seemed to have fallen flat. The ECB, from a story this morning by Liz Alderman, proclaimed that if by Monday there is no deal it will cut off funding. According to a naked capitalism post this morning, "ECB to Push Cyprus over the Brink,"
This is tantamount to cutting off its central bank and pushing it out of Eurozone if it does not capitulate. 
During the day yesterday, Eurozone officials made it clear that they would not accept some other ideas that Cyprus had developed to try to shield depositors, such as accessing pensions fund assets, restructuring the two largest banks, and selling its gas rights to Russia. This was deemed unacceptable in that it would increase debt levels. The fallacy, of course, is that the Trokia is unduly obsessed with the numerator of this equation (the borrowings) and not the denominator (the impact on the economy). Cyprus.com estimates the impact of trashing the banking system to be a minimum 20% contraction of GDP in two years. And mind you, this is after Cyprus was a good Eurozone citizen and sent €3 billion to help the Greek government.
The ECB has given Cyprus virtually no runway. It’s a deal by end of Monday or off with their heads. Given the difficulty of cobbling anything else together, this would seem to force Cyprus into only being able to structure yet another variant of the “rape depositors” plan. They seem either to rely on a reaction like the US had to the TARP, to having Congress capitulate after the markets swooner, or perhaps they sincerely believe that even a worse case scenario, of dumping Cyprus out of the Eurozone, is acceptable because it will tell all those lazy Latins that they’d better not even think of crossing the Troika. (It’s inconceivable that a forced Cyprus exit would not lead to deposit flight from Portugal and Spain, which will pressure the Eurozone tremendously. They’ve really drunk their own “Cyprus is a special case” PR if so.)
According to Alderman people are already queuing up in front of ATMs this morning in Nicosia:
Meanwhile, the mood turned sour on the streets of Nicosia, the Cypriot capital, where people flocked to cash machines Thursday morning to withdraw as much money as possible after the government declared that banks would remain closed until next Tuesday to give officials time to renegotiate the bailout deal.
The tough love approach that the troika is taking with Cyprus only makes sense as homeopathic quakery. Take a tiny member of the eurozone and implement a bank levy. When the patient, the eurozone, survives the patient will be healthier. Then move on to the next country and repeat the cure. The gamble here is that bank runs can be contained.

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Super Fly

In addition to Last Tango in Paris, another great film from 1972 is Super Fly, by Gordon Parks, Jr. I don't think I had ever sat down and made a study of it until I was laid off in 2011 (over the years since I was a kid I've seen parts of the movie many times over on television). What struck me is that it's all about trying to get out of the rat race (the rat race in this case being the drug trade). Priest, played by Ron O'Neal, is trying to hit one more big score and then he's out. He's just like every other American. We all go to work every day in the hope that one day we won't have to. This is what unites the minimum-wage worker with the 1% -- the desire to be free of the rat race.


The Curtis Mayfield soundtrack is timeless; I always have it loaded on my iPod. Tonight on a brisk run (so brisk my left hamstring is aching) I was accompanied by "Little Child Runnin' Wild":

Cypriot Parliament Rejects Bailout

Yesterday the Cypriot Parliament rejected the Euro Group bailout deal which called for raising 5.8 billion euros through a tax on all bank deposits even though deposits under 100,000 euros are guaranteed in Cyprus. Liz Alderman reports today that following the vote the European Central Bank put Cyprus on notice that time to arrive at a new agreement is limited:
After the parliamentary vote, the European Central Bank indicated that it would not immediately cut off emergency cash — without which Cypriot banks probably could not survive. In a terse statement, the central bank said it was consulting with the International Monetary Fund and the European Commission, its partners in the so-called troika of international lenders. 
But in a tacit warning that it would not provide assistance forever, the central bank said it would stick to rules that allow lending only to solvent banks. The Cyprus banks, while wobbly, are not yet insolvent.
Cyprus' finance minister, Michalis Sarris, is in Moscow today for talks with the Russians. Apparently, as reported today by Andrew Kramer, there is a Gazprom deal on the table to provide Cyprus bailout money in exchange for exploration rights to offshore gas deposits:
Though not widely publicized, the Russian proposal to prop up Cyprus with assets belonging to the Gazprom pension fund was apparently taken seriously enough by Germany’s chancellor, Angela Merkel. Her office issued a statement on Tuesday noting she had warned the president of Cyprus in a telephone call not to consider alternatives to the European bailout; Russia’s offer is the only known alternative. 
Michael Olympios, chairman of the Cypriot Investors Association, said one possibility under active consideration was for a Russian bank to buy Cyprus’s biggest troubled lender, the Cyprus Popular Bank, in a deal that could reduce the amount of the 10 billion euro bailout sought by Cyprus. Any such move would most likely be backed by the Kremlin, Mr. Olympios added, and could reduce the tax that Russian depositors might otherwise have to pay. 
Russian officials were preparing for talks in Moscow on Wednesday with the Cypriot finance minister, Michalis Sarris, who was expected to request that Russia postpone the maturity date on a 2.5 billion euro loan that it extended to Cyprus in 2011.
A detailed post this morning on naked capitalism, "Gaming the Cyprus Negotiations," argues that there is indeed a chance that a deal might not be reached:
My belief is that there are a lot of moving parts, and while it is perfectly rational for everyone to come to some sort of deal, the principals have a lousy negotiating dynamic at work. Russia has been excluded and is feeling angry and abused, and the Wall Street Journal description of the 10 hours negotiations that led to the original deal sound nightmarish: confused, chaotic, dysfunctional. It’s proof of the old notion that people (in this case finance ministers) should never negotiate their own deals unless they are super experienced negotiators (and pretty much everyone overestimates their negotiating skills). And these all-over-the-map negotiations took place when the principals were in the same location. It’s worse doing this sort of things by phone and e-mail.
So the odds are not trivial that a deal fails to come together, not because a pact is impossible (as in there is appears to be a bargaining space where everyone could find a solution they could swallow) but that the key actors will be unable to get to that agreement before time runs out. Stay tuned.
I think there's some merit to this point of view. But in the end we're talking about a tiny amount of money in the Great Power scheme of things. Certainly you would think someone -- Putin? Merkel? Draghi? -- would intervene.

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

"Hanging on the Telephone"

Though never a big Blondie fan (they were huge my freshman and sophomore years of high school, 1978-1980), they did come out of the same CBGB's scene that birthed Patti Smith, Television, Richard Hell and the Ramones.

I heard "Hanging on the Telephone" the other day. And believe it or not for a moment I thought it was Kathleen Hanna. A lot of things get buried in the past.

Consensus: Cyprus Crisis Won't Spread

A consensus seems to be forming that the debt crisis underway in Cyprus will not spread to vulnerable, big eurozone countries like Italy and Spain. The reason? Cyprus is unique because of the outsize role played by money-laundering Russians. Here's how Andrew Ross Sorkin, a reliable Wall Street mouthpiece, puts it in his DealBook column today:
Cyprus is unique. Besides being tiny, its banking system looks different from those in most other countries. Much of the big money deposited in its banks is from foreign investors, including Russians who have long been suspected of money laundering. Those investors had fair warning that Cypriot banks were troubled. The issue has been simmering for six months. But those investors left their money in the bank, in part because they were gambling that the banks would be bailed out at no cost to them. If the current plan is approved, depositors will have lost that bet. 
Worse, the strategy employed in the bailout of Greece — in which bondholders of its sovereign debt were paid less than face value — will not work in Cyprus. Cyprus’s banks own much of the country’s debt, so any effort to reduce that debt by forcing debt holders to accept less would only make the banks more troubled. 
Given the brutal history between Russia and so much of Europe — and speculation that so much of the money is ill gotten — it is clear why it would be so politically unpalatable to countries in the euro zone, Germany in particular, to bail out Russian depositors. And even if the move were to create a run on the banks in Cyprus, the contagion would be limited. 
There is very little chance that politicians would ever choose to use the model they developed in Cyprus in a country like Italy or Spain, where a run on the banks would have such profound implications. By the way, if you’re wondering why investors left so much money in troubled Cypriot banks, here’s a trivia question: Would you have been better off leaving your money in a bank in the United States or in Cyprus over the last five years? 
The answer: You would have been better off in Cyprus, even after the bailout, when your money was “confiscated.” If you had 100,000 euros in a Cypriot bank account over the last five years, where the interest rate has averaged about 5 percent, you would have about 127,600 euros today. Even after the bailout, which would require you to give up 10 percent of your deposit — 12,760 euros — you would be left with 114,840 euros. The American bank? The $100,000 you deposited at Bank of America five years ago is about $105,100, at the going rate of about 1 percent interest a year.
Dismissing the bank run in Cyprus as a one-off because nearly a quarter of its deposits are held by Russians seems too convenient to me, too redolent of the old cold war. The issue isn't the Russians. The issue is getting a bailout through parliament, whether in Cyprus or in other eurozone countries.

Jeroen Dijsselbloem, Labour Party member and Dutch Minister of Finance who is the current head of the Euro Group, nationalized SNS Reaal in February, wiping out its shareholders. If he can take a hard line in the Netherlands why can't he do the same to a tiny country like Cyprus? The push back came from Cypriot President Nicos Anastasiades -- as documented in today's frontpage story by James Kanter, Nicholas Kulish and Andrew Higgins -- who fought to keep confiscation on deposits of more than 100,000 euros below ten percent. This meant the small fry have to fork over more, which is the recipe for a bank run.

Contrary to Sorkin's dismissal of concern over Cyprus, it's unclear at this point that the contagion won't spread. This from today's story, "Second Thoughts in Europe as Anxiety Rises in Cyprus," by Liz Alderman and Landon Thomas Jr.:
While it is too early to tell if Italian, Spanish and Greek savers will pull out their deposits in response to the Cyprus tax, investors holding the bonds of banks in Spain and especially Italy are already taking action. 
In Italy, ravaged by a stagnating economy, banks are experiencing a steep increase in nonperforming loans — one of the highest rates in the euro zone — that worries regulators and has made an investment fad of betting against Italian bank bonds. 
For now, no one is predicting a European bailout of Italian banks. But just as problems with Spain’s smaller savings banks last year quickly escalated into a crisis requiring a European bank rescue, a growing number of analysts are warning that Italy’s most troubled banks could lead to a broader systemic threat to Italian banking.

Monday, March 18, 2013

"In Your Line" + "Indictment"

On my walk home through the blossoming trees a smile-inducing double play greeted my ears thanks to the alphabetical sort by song title. First, the DJ/rupture-Matt Shadetek remix of Telephathe's "In Your Line":


Followed by Antibalas' "Indictment":


But what I wanted to talk about is Last Tango in Paris -- the Bernardo Bertolucci directed film from 1972 starring Marlon Brando and Maria Schneider -- which I saw again last night for the second time in a year. When I first saw the movie with my wife I was a young man in my early twenties. I didn't really understand it. I understood the basic plot -- a guy who is mourning the suicide of a wife with whom he lived but was alienated begins a relationship with a young woman who he meets one day by accident when they're both looking at an empty, old apartment; I got that. What I didn't get was the guy's attempt to keep the relationship depersonalized and confined to the old apartment, which he ends up renting and which serves as the lovers' "walled garden." And what I was completely baffled by was the ending tango competition where he suddenly loses his cold, dominating demeanor and becomes a giddy lovesick school girl.

I think I saw Last Tango again a decade ago. And while I was better able to follow everything, I still didn't really appreciate it; I thought the ending foolish. Then again, a decade ago I couldn't imagine not having a girlfriend.

But when I saw it again last year, streaming it this time from Amazon, it hit me head on. This is a manifesto labeled ration for a burdened bachelor:
Paul: You want this man you love to protect and take care of you. 
Jeanne: Yeah. 
Paul: You want this golden, shining, powerful warrior to build a fortress where you can hide in. So you don't have to ever ... have ... You don't ever have to be afraid. You don't have to feel lonely or empty. -- That's what you want, isn't it? 
Jeanne: -- Yes. 
Paul: -- Well, you'll never find it.
Jeanne: -- But I find this man. 
Paul: Then it won't be long until he'll want you to build a fortress for him out of your tits and your cunt and your hair and your smile and the way you smell. And ... and some place where he can feel comfortable and secure enough so that he can worship in front of the altar of his own prick.
Jeanne: -- But I find this man!
Paul: -- No, you're alone. You're all alone. You won't be free of that feeling of being alone until you look death right in the face. I mean, that sounds like bullshit, some romantic crap, until you go right up into the ass of death. Right up in his ass ... till you find the womb of fear. And then ... maybe ... Maybe then, you'll be able to find him.
Paul/Brando's mistake is that he thought he could control the man-woman dynamic. And he was doing pretty well there for a while, keeping the relationship bottled up in the old, empty apartment in Passy; he was talking and walking a good game. Then he falls in love, which is what always happens eventually, and she kills him.

Lately, the last couple of months, I've been cautiously approaching the idea that the root of war is the relation between the sexes. Man and woman try to make two into one. But two is not one and cannot be one. Nonetheless man and woman keep on trying. So there is a lot of devouring, a lot of pain and suffering. This is nature. But multiplicity cannot be reduced to sameness. There is no going back to that fortress of tits and cunt and hair. To mommy. You can try though. That's what were stuck with. Good luck.