Showing posts with label climate change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label climate change. Show all posts

Saturday, June 13, 2020

Planet of the Humans


Jeff Gibbs' Planet of the Humans documentary -- the one that was removed from YouTube for a spell; the one produced by Michael Moore; the one that has mainstream enviros quaking with rage -- is quite good and very cogent.

The central thesis is that renewable energy is not going to save the planet from the ravages of climate change. Solar and wind energy are not really renewable in that photovoltaic cells require plenty of toxic industrial fossil fuel inputs and have a limited life cycle. The same can be said of the turbines that generate electricity from the wind.

The biggest target of Planet of the Humans is biomass. Gibbs convincingly documents that a green giant like Germany, a country lauded for producing a high percentage of its energy from renewable sources, owes its stature to burning biomass and biofuels. Biomass is just a fancy name for cutting down trees and burning them in a furnace; garbage, too.

Gibbs illuminates the extent to which high finance has prostituted 350 and the Sierra Club. Most are aware that Al Gore is an untrustworthy, venal character, but who would have expected the same from Bill McKibben?

Our only way out of this mess -- COVID-19 is just a hint of the pain and suffering coming our way -- is a significant reduction in population combined with a massive reduction in consumption. 

Wednesday, December 18, 2019

COP25

This year's United Nations climate summit, COP25, which was held in Madrid after being moved there because of anti-austerity protests in Santiago, Chile, ended Sunday in total failure. You can read a summation in The New York Times or hear about it on Democracy Now! Basically the entire UN Conference of Parties process to address climate change has broken down. The principal activity now is blocking any meaningful measure, and the chief blocker is the United States.

I know from reading Naomi Klein's latest book On Fire, that if we don't radically reduce carbon emissions by 2030 civilization as we know it is in real trouble. Given that the wealthy nations are unwilling to change their ways, we're headed back to the Hobbesian state of nature.

As Asad Rehman explained on Democracy Now! --
So you would have expected governments to come knowing that this was a critical moment and to come with ambition. And instead, we saw the United States, aided and abetted by other rich developed countries, take a wrecking ball to those outcomes. So, first of all, governments came not willing to take action in terms of the lost decade, when they’ve literally done nothing in the previous decade, which has meant that the critical actions that are required in the coming decade are much, much harder. They came attempting to block any support for poorer developing countries, as you’ve just heard from Tasneem. I mean, this is absolutely outrageous.
And what they were actually asking for, not just the United States, but the European Union, as well, is basically to have no liability for the damage that their inaction is causing. And more heinous than that is not only are they not putting anything on the table in terms of genuine emission reductions or the desperately needed finance; what they wanted was loopholes, so that their big polluting companies could continue to pollute, loopholes that would basically bust the budget for the 1.5-degree guard rail. So we’re coming here with governments with no willingness to act and actually acting not in the interests of their citizens, but acting in the interests of their big polluting companies. And it was an absolute disaster.
So the question now we must ask ourselves is: What will it take for our voices to be heard? Now, the climate talks move to the U.K. in 2020. It’s an unprecedented moment. We’re at the end of the decade, the lost decade, and now we’re in the beginning of the new decade. If governments don’t come with that willingness, then — which we can only as citizens force them and hold our own governments to account at a national level so that they come with the right mandates — I think we’re talking about not just losing the 1.5 degree, but the 2 degree. And just to put that in context — because I totally agree with you, sometimes these climate words don’t quite have the resonance — but the difference between the Ice Age and now was only 4 degrees. And already in the pledges that we’ve got for the Paris Agreement, we’re seeing warming that will lead to 3 degrees. We have absolutely no idea of what the world will look like. But what we can say is that the impacts on the poorest people, on the most vulnerable around the world, will be absolutely devastating.
A system as irrational as ours eventually is going to collapse. That's what we are going to witness the next ten years, this collapse, but also the extreme measures wealthy governments employ to manage the collapse.

Tuesday, April 23, 2019

Extinction Rebellion Continues

There is a decent write-up by Robert Stevens of the ongoing Extinction Rebellion (XR) in London (see "Police arrest over 1,000 climate change protesters in London"):
More than 1,000 people have been arrested in London over the last seven days of climate change protests organised by the Extinction Rebellion (XR) group.
Protesters continued to peacefully occupy public spaces in the capital, including Parliament Square, Piccadilly Circus, Waterloo Bridge, Oxford Circus and Marble Arch, despite mounting and provocative police arrests.
[snip]
On Sunday, those gathered at Marble Arch were addressed by 16-year-old climate activist Greta Thunberg, whose protests outside Sweden’s parliament last year sparked the current wave of global strikes and demonstrations by school youth and students.
Thunberg, who will meet politicians, including Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn over the next week, said to a standing ovation, “Despite all the beautiful words and promises. … For way too long the politicians and people in power have got away with not doing anything at all to fight the climate crisis and ecological crisis …”
She added, “We are now facing an existential crisis, the climate crisis and ecological crisis which have never been treated as crises before, they have been ignored for decades.”
The New York Times has generally ignored XR, though it did publish one story by Ceylan Yeginsu, one of the newspaper's better reporters, last week. Yeginsu made note of the demands of the Extinction Rebellion:
The group has three core demands of the British government: to “tell the truth” by declaring a climate and ecological emergency; to reduce carbon emissions to zero by 2025; and to create a citizens’ assembly to lead on climate issues.
[snip]
Whether intentional or not, their cause received a lift on Wednesday from Mark Carney, the governor of the Bank of England, who warned the financial sector that it faced an existential threat from climate change and urged international banks to take immediate steps to prepare.
“As financial policymakers and prudential supervisors we cannot ignore the obvious physical risks before our eyes,” Mr. Carney wrote in a joint article with Francois Villeroy, the governor of the Banque De France, that was published in The Guardian newspaper.
Citing the threats to insurance companies and banks from the recent spate of storms, floods, fires and other natural disasters, he said, “Climate Change is a global problem, which requires global solutions, in which the whole financial sector has a central role to play.”

Wednesday, July 12, 2017

Antarctica and the Anthropocene

Bill McKibben tweeted this morning that 
An iceberg with twice the volume of Lake Erie has broken off the Larsen Ice Shelf, 'leaving the continent forever changed'
The other night I watched a Luc Jacquet documentary Antarctica: Ice and Sky. What's makes this documentary, which covers the career of renowned French glaciologist Claude Lorius, worth watching is that by the time it is finished you will never harbor any doubts about the reality of climate change.


Lorius pioneered the method of accurately measuring prehistoric temperatures by deep drilling ice cores. He was able to confirm that the Earth undergoes periodic climate change (ice ages), but what the planet has been experiencing the last 100 years is like nothing else in Lorius' vast trove of ice cores. Man has changed and is changing -- radically -- the Earth's natural systems (what's known as the "Anthropocene"). 

What adds to the impact of Lorius' message is the scope of the science involved. Spanning decades, marshaling the logistical support of several nations (the footage of the Soviet Antarctic camp is awesome), this is not some fringe pursuit the validity of which can be disputed. This is the best that governments have to offer. There should be a Nuremberg trial for political appointees like Scott Pruitt, Trump's EPA chief, who recently announced to a bunch of coal company lobbyists that he will be fielding a team of climate-change deniers to "test" the academic consensus.

Monday, February 27, 2017

Does Populism Change Everything?

I'm reading Naomi Klein's This Changes Everything. It is fantastic but dispiriting. It provides a historical account of how collective recognition of climate change corresponded with a corporate-dominated globalized free trade system -- the latter effectively negating a plan for addressing the former. In fact, the primacy of trade was memorialized at the outset at the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio.

One theme that Klein stresses throughout is localism. In order to deal with the planet's changing climate we are going to have to craft local solutions. The problem is that the neoliberal global trade architecture that has been erected the last 25 years makes localism illegal. Local goods and services cannot be privileged over those from foreign countries.

And this is why there is such hostility from the neoliberal center towards the populism that is rising throughout the West. At root this fast-growing populism is a rejection of corporate-managed international trade and banking. Being anti-immigrant is just the flower of the populist plant that has taken root.

This morning online, which means it will be printed in tomorrow's national edition, The New York Times has a good, long article by Alissa Rubin, "Geert Wilders, Reclusive Provocateur, Rises Before Dutch Vote," devoted to the "Dutch Trump":
Geert Wilders, far-right icon, is one of Europe’s strangest politicians, not least because he comes from the Netherlands, one of Europe’s most socially liberal countries, with a centuries-long tradition of promoting religious tolerance and welcoming immigrants. 
How he and his party fare in the March 15 elections could well signal how the far right will do in pivotal elections in France, Germany and possibly Italy later this year, and ultimately determine the future of the European Union. Mr. Wilders (pronounced VIL-ders) has promised to demand a “Nexit” referendum on whether the Netherlands should follow Britain’s example and leave the union.
“The Netherlands is kind of a bellwether, a lot of trends manifest themselves here first,” said Hans Anker, a Dutch political strategist who has worked both in the Netherlands and the United States. 
“I wouldn’t rule out that Wilders could be prime minister,” he added. “This one is fundamentally unpredictable.”
The problem for Wilders, even if he wins, will be forming a government:
Right now Mr. Wilders’s party looks set to win more seats than any other or to come in second. However, he has historically polled better before elections than he has performed in them. [Same problem that Le Pen and the National Front have.] Still, after pollsters underestimated the likelihood of both Brexit and the victory of Donald Trump last year, no one is relying on predictions.
The bigger question is whether even if Mr. Wilders comes in first or second, he would be willing to form or join a governing coalition. For more than 20 years, no one party has had a majority. Other parties say they will not work with him and he has shown little interest in compromise and working with others.
What I find curious is how balanced Rubin's story is compared to, say, The Times' reporting on Labour's Jeremy Corbyn, which is always dismissive. It is as if the neoliberal center sees a possibility of collaborating or co-opting the rising populism. This is the dance underway with Trump. And at this point I think it should be apparent to all of us that Trump is willing to play along with the neoliberal center.

There are of course contradictions. The future of the EU is problematic. A Wilders wins means a Nexit vote, as a Le Pen win means a Frexit. The Trump talking point is that capitalism, for all intents and purposes, is contained in one country, and that is the United States. Multilateral trade agreements will be scrapped in favor of bilateral negotiations. Easier said than done. Globalized free trade is the key to the neoliberal unipolar world; that, and full spectrum U.S. military dominance. A kaleidoscope of bilateral trade agreements leads to a multipolar world.

****

For a good assessment of the Thomas Perez's election over Keith Ellison this weekend to lead the DNC, read Glenn Greenwald's "Key Question About DNC Race: Why Did Obama White House Recruit Perez to Run Against Ellison?"

The answer? Money, of course. It doesn't bode well for Democrat hopes of picking up seats at the midterm.

Thursday, October 15, 2015

People's Climate March 2015

I attended the People's Climate March yesterday. As the home page of the People's Climate Movement boasts: "TO CHANGE EVERYTHING, WE NEED EVERYONE, EVERYWHERE. Happening Now: Close to 200 actions in almost every state in the country calling for bold action on climate!"

An ambitious call to action, indeed; but judging by the rally and march to yet another rally, one that fell far short of its goal of everything, everyone, everywhere (at least in the Emerald City). Turnout was good I thought, maybe a city-block's worth of marchers moving uptown from city hall before turning west and then south, heading back downtown to Pioneer Square, but nothing beyond the groups already focused on climate change (though there was a robust presence from a Teamsters local, an interesting side note since the leadership of the District Council of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters has been incendiary in its criticism of other unions for opposing Shell's presence at Port of Seattle Terminal Five).

What is noteworthy this morning is that there is zero note of the event. In neither the New York Times nor the Seattle Times can I find a single mention. Climate change, though undeniably and catastrophically real, is apparently newsworthy only as a scientific topic or possibly as a platform for international diplomacy, not as a social movement. Thank goodness for Russia's RT.


The problem here might be that this social movement is headed, while not aggressively, certainly in the direction of a head-on collision with capitalism; along the way it is embracing a critique of institutional racism. (The march began with a listless bit of street theater lampooning the greed of the Trans-Pacific Partnership that Congress is now considering.) Criticism of capitalism and institutional racism is almost never allowed in the pages of the press. That is why Occupy Wall Street, $15 Now and Black Lives Matter deserve a great deal of respect. These movements managed to make the inequities of capitalism and the savagery of institutional racism breaking news covered by the mainstream media on a daily basis.

The climate justice movement isn't there yet. It is still too diffuse. But from what I saw yesterday I think there is reason for hope. Something is definitely building, taking shape. It is anti-capitalist and anti-racist. The age demographic skews to the old and the young -- old Hippies and Hip-Hop kids. It has to broaden out and rope in rockers who came of age in the Eighties and Nineties, the acolytes of Van Halen and Alice in Chains. A tall order but not completely impossible.

Tuesday, July 28, 2015

Hillary Embraces Renewable Energy: The Democratic Base is Progressive; the Candidate, Not So Much

Analogies for the Clinton campaign are legion. All tend to accentuate hugeness and torpidity. The image that leaps to mind is a retired ocean liner like the RMS Queen Mary. Blogger Lambert Strether frequently refers to Hillary's presidential run as the "S.S. Clinton."

But as Clinton tacks to and fro to catch the fancy of the Democratic electorate, her campaign illuminates just how progressive the base of the party has become.

The problem for Hillary is that she suffers from what was referred to in LBJ's day as the "credibility gap." Democrats don't believe 1) that her policy prescriptions go far enough in a left direction to substantively address issues like income inequality (Hillary has talked about changing corporate culture by adjusting the capital gains tax based on how long you have held a stock); and 2) that she will even attempt to implement them if she wins the presidency.

A fine example is this morning's topnotch story by Trip Gabriel and Coral Davenport, "Hillary Clinton Lays Out Climate Change Plan." Hillary has
. . . set a goal to produce 33 percent of the nation’s electricity from renewable sources by 2027, up from 7 percent today — a higher goal than the 20 percent that President Obama has called for by 2030.
Mrs. Clinton’s strategists see climate change as a winning issue for 2016. They believe it is a cause she can advance to win over deep-pocketed donors and liberal activists in the nominating campaign, where she is facing Democratic challengers to her left on the issue. It is also one that can be a weapon against Republicans in a general election. Polls show that a majority of voters support candidates who pledge policy action on the warming climate.
Mrs. Clinton called for installing a half-billion solar panels by 2020, a sevenfold increase from today, and to generate enough energy from carbon-free sources within 10 years of her inauguration to power every home in America.
All good stuff. And, coming from the S.S. Clinton, no doubt poll tested and vetted carefully by focus group.

Then Gabriel and Davenport set to work exposing the plan's limitations. Congressional green-energy mandates will be required to hit Clinton's targets; and since Congress will continue in GOP control for the foreseeable future, the chances of this happening are minuscule. Also, apparently Hillary's plan is as much about tapping into hedge-fund billionaire Tom Steyer's deep pockets as it is about climate change. And, finally, to add to this common Hillary theme of insincerity, the Clinton Campaign won't even distance itself from the rotting cadaver of Keystone XL:
While Mr. Obama’s climate change goals, driven by regulations from the Environmental Protection Agency, would lift the nation’s renewable power to about 20 to 25 percent, according to E.P.A. estimates, the rest of the increase, experts said, will be impossible without new laws requiring renewable power. Congress has failed over the past decade to pass such laws. 
The Clinton campaign emphasized that her targets cleared a bar set last week by the billionaire environmentalist Tom Steyer, who spent $74 million on political races in 2014. He announced that for candidates to receive his support in 2016, they must offer policies that would lead the nation to generate half its electricity from clean sources by 2030, and 100 percent by 2050. 
Former Gov. Martin O’Malley of Maryland, who has made climate change the center of his Democratic presidential campaign, laid out a plan last month that meets the criteria, winning Mr. Steyer’s blessing. Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, who has called for a tax on carbon emissions, draws thunderous applause at rallies by promising bold action to combat climate change. 
Although Mrs. Clinton has emphasized fighting global warming as a priority in earlier speeches, the role of a single large donor, Mr. Steyer, in apparently influencing the details of her proposal was suggested by her press secretary, Brian Fallon. On Twitter he said, “Counting nuclear, as Steyer does, she exceeds his 50 percent goal” for 2030.
But Mrs. Clinton showed some limits to how far she would go to address climate change by refusing to say, once again, if she opposed the Keystone XL pipeline — a litmus test for grass-roots environmentalists. The pipeline would deliver oil from the oil sands of northern Alberta in Canada to Texas. 
Recusing herself because she had played a role as secretary of state in evaluating the pipeline, Mrs. Clinton said the decision was in the hands of the Obama administration. Mr. Sanders and Mr. O’Malley oppose the pipeline. 
Just as liberal Democrats have tried to pull Mrs. Clinton to the left on economic issues, environmental groups have sought stronger statements from her opposing hydraulic fracturing, oil trains and drilling in the Arctic.
Anti-Keystone protesters have greeted Mrs. Clinton on the campaign trail in New Hampshire and even outside a May fund-raiser for her at Mr. Steyer’s home in San Francisco overlooking the Golden Gate Bridge.
“Hillary Clinton is just half the way there,” said Bill McKibben, head of the group 350.org, which has led the grass-roots movement calling for Mr. Obama to reject the Keystone pipeline. “This is a credible commitment to renewable energy, and a recognition that the economics of electricity are changing fast. Now, we need Clinton to show she understands the other half of the climate change equation — and prove she has the courage to stand up against fossil fuel projects like offshore and Arctic drilling, coal leasing in the Powder River basin, and the Keystone XL pipeline.”
What is interesting is that Hillary has a winner here. We're back to where we were when An Inconvenient Truth (2006) gained attention. The polling has shifted on green energy and climate change to the point now where it is a huge advantage for Democrats against Republicans.
While running for re-election in the 2012 campaign, Mr. Obama almost never mentioned climate change. But Democratic strategists say they now see it as a resonant campaign issue. 
A January poll conducted by The New York Times, Stanford University and Resources for the Future found that two-thirds of Americans said they were more likely to vote for political candidates who campaign on fighting climate change.
“This issue now polls better than any other issue for Democrats,” said Paul Bledsoe, a former top climate change official in the Clinton administration. “It’s in Clinton’s interest to talk about the issue, both for primary voters and to highlight Republican vulnerabilities in the general election.”
The problem for the Clinton campaign is that people don't believe that Hillary is anything but what she actually is -- a member of the ruling elite, a figurehead of the Deep State, the 1% of the 1% -- and that she will bring no change but only more of the same. The continuing investigation of Clinton's use of a personal email account for classified data (which she denied) will continue to bleed Hillary. I still don't see how she can win a general election.

Sunday, April 12, 2015

New Avengers #30


Last Sunday I hit a stride and read somewhere around ten issues of Jonathan Hickman's New Avengers. For almost two years now Hickman has been plotting the story of the extinction of all life, not just in our universe but in universes throughout all dimensions, the multiverse. This multidimensional pan-universal extinction is triggered when one Earth from one dimension collides with another Earth from another dimension at an incursion point.

Most of the action in the title to date has been superheroes, the Illuminati,  rushing around weighted down with the moral quandary of having to commit genocide by destroying the intruding, non-Earth-616 planet before it collapses both.

On this day, the day that Hillary Clinton announces her candidacy for President of the United States, collapse is an appropriate topic. The Democrats are in a state of denial so extreme it approaches brain death. Most deep-blue Democrats when pushed will acknowledge that Hillary is not the best candidate -- Elizabeth Warren is most often sited as a preference -- but they don't see a way around Hillary's name recognition and deep pockets. So Democrats plan to sit tight and hope for the best. In the meantime, the tune that is being whistled as the Democratic Party drives past the graveyard is that Hillary will be able to mobilize and deliver to the polls the "Obama coalition" -- blacks, youth, Latinos.

That's not going to happen. The only thing that might save Hillary's bacon, assuming a dark horse like Jim Webb doesn't get traction and trounce her in the primaries, as Barack Hussein did in 2008, is if the Republican primary is so chaotic and vicious with billionaire funders engaged in mutually assured destruction that it deliveries up a terminally wounded standard bearer, a la Mitt Romney in 2012.

Right now let's assume that both the Ted Cruz clown car and the Marco Rubio daydream don't survive long after Iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina -- granted, this is a large assumption -- and the race for the GOP nomination boils down to Scott Walker vs. Jeb Bush. I think either one beats Hillary.

Then what are we looking at? I think if it is Walker we'll see the repeal of Davis-Bacon. And with the loss of federal prevailing wage, there will be an even more pronounced spike in income inequality. Labor unions will become an almost non-factor in national politics. Union density is already so low, around 11%, one has to go all the way back to before the U.S. entered World War One to find a similar level.

Historians will tell you: When inequality spikes, societies fracture and collapse. That is what Hillary's candidacy augurs.

And we haven't even discussed the rapid disappearance of the Earth's ice. The April Harper's had a terrific and terrifying story by Gretel Ehrlich, "Rotten Ice: Traveling by dogsled in the melting Arctic." The Greenland Inuit are finding it increasingly difficult to hunt because so much of the ice is weak and in retreat. Many subsistence hunters are committing suicide.

So Hickman's New Avengers tale of collapse, genocide and extinction is timely and should find a receptive audience. What I particularly like about issue #30 is the art of Dalibor Talajic. (You will find eight scans below. Alan Davis is the cover artist, found in the scan at the top of the post.)

Talajic's work reminds me of the great Wally Wood and the work he did on the early Daredevil, with its heavy inks of the horror comics of the 1950s but in a superhero setting -- very appropriate for Hickman's epic of the death of the multiverse.







Sunday, November 16, 2014

The Unassailable Math of Climate Change: Gaius Publius Interviews Michael Mann

Naked Capitalism posted yesterday an interview by politics blogger Gaius Publius with climate scientist Michael Mann. The interview is a good primer on the carbon math of global warming. The standard marker established by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is +2°C warming. As Gaius Publius says,
Most still think that 350 ppm (parts per million) CO2 is what’s needed to keep us at the upper end of Holocene (era of civilized human culture) temperatures. [Like Bill McKibben's 350.org.] For contrast, the ice ages averaged about 180 ppm CO2 at the bottom, and pre-industrial (pre-1750) concentrations were about 280 ppm CO2. Pre-industrial temperatures were at the bottom of the Holocene (post–ice age) temperature range, so there’s some headroom above that 280 ppm number. How much exactly? No one knows. 
It looks like we’re headed for a IPCC-”safe” 450 ppm CO2 unless we stop. Not safe, in my opinion, nor in Dr. Mann’s. For starters, this “450 ppm” measures CO2 only, not other GHGs like methane and nitrous oxide. The effective ppm in “CO2 equivalent” with those other added GHGs is higher if only CO2 is at 450. 
It’s thought that the original ice sheet formations of 35 million years ago, which gave us modern Antarctic, Greenland and Arctic ice, occurred in a cooling environment that crossed roughly below CO2 concentrations in the range of 550-400 ppm or so. 
First, that’s a wide range. Second, that’s no indication of what will happen going the other direction, where the warming tipping points are. Hansen writes, correctly IMO, that real climate sensitivity depends on (a) the starting point (i.e., how near we are to tipping points), and (b) the direction (effect of warming of X amount is not necessarily correlated to the effect of cooling of that same amount). 
Nevertheless, the massive uncertainty, plus the world-historical consequences, gives most of us pause. I personally worry that 450 ppm CO2 is ultimately a death sentence for civilized humans. Back to life as hunter-gatherers for our third- or fourth-generation descendants. And if worldwide social chaos takes over before we stop, the process could run to conclusion, which, the old IPCC A1FI scenario says, tops out at +7°C warming.
Science is a story based on measurement. For climate-science deniers, where's the math? What about the massive ice-sheet melt? To deny or ignore the science is to repeal the Enlightenment, pitching us backwards to the days when the churchmen ruled a flat Earth. That's what the ISIS response to the Arab Spring is all about, and what is planned for us all if certain reactionary political formations (like those backed by the Kochs) have their way.

Check out the Gaius Publius-Michael Mann interview.

Thursday, November 13, 2014

The U.S.-China Carbon Accord: a Nod to the Competitiveness of the Green Economy, but Primarily Poltical

As we enter a second day where the U.S.-China climate accord fills the newspaper gobbling up precious column inches you have to hand it to Obama: he has flipped the conversation off the abominable performance of his party in last week's midterms and reestablished his relevance. And that is the way to look at the carbon-reduction agreement with China: foremost it is a strategic move on the political battlefield of the homeland; it elicits hostile reactions from the Republican leadership in Congress that paints them as knuckle-draggers sucking on billionaire Koch brothers tits at the same time it galvanizes important segments of the Obama-Coalition voters Democrats will need in 2016.

A set narrative regarding the Obama-Xi Jinping climate deal is already taking shape. First, the numbers. The United States has already pledged to reduce carbon emissions 17% below 2005 levels by 2020. Obama plans to achieve this through limits on tailpipe and power-plant smokestack emissions implemented by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The deal announced the other day in Beijing commits the U.S. to reduce carbon emissions further to between 26-28% below 2005 levels by 2025.

China has agreed to reach peak carbon emissions by 2030 as well as shift 20% of its energy supply to clean, renewable sources.

The positive of the bilateral accord is presented in unsigned Gray Lady editorial, "A Major Breakthrough on Climate Change":
The climate accord represents a startling turnaround after years of futile efforts to cooperate in a meaningful way on global warming. It sends two critically important messages, one to the world and the other to the United States Congress. China and the United States together account for about 45 percent of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions. Their new commitments are thus almost certain to energize other countries to set more ambitious targets of their own before negotiators meet to frame a new global agreement at the climate summit meeting in Paris in December 2015. 
In the United States, the agreement cuts the ground from under people like Mitch McConnell, the next Senate majority leader, and others who have long argued that there is no point in taking aggressive steps against greenhouse gases as long as major developing countries refused to do likewise. This argument effectively undermined Senate support for ratification of the 1997 Kyoto Protocol. The climate deniers in Congress will find other reasons to oppose a strong climate strategy, and are doing so even now. But the “China” argument has effectively disappeared.
Throughout the stories written about the climate deal with China these two points are consistently made: 1) it provides a strong impetus for something of substance coming out of the global negotiations in Paris next December, and 2) it rights a wrong, salves a wound that goes back to the Kyoto Protocol which the U.S. Senate failed to ratify because of any limits placed on China.

But I think the real positive of the agreement is one that Bill McKibben mentions in his assessment of the deal, "The Big Climate Deal: What It Is, and What It Isn’t," which appeared yesterday, namely, the Green Economy is already here:
These numbers are easy — if you were really being cynical, you could say they’re trying to put a floor under the retreat from carbon, to manage a retreat from fossil fuels instead of really putting carbon on the run. The Germans, for instance, will be moving in on 60 percent of their energy from clean sources by the mid-2020s, when we’ll still be cutting carbon emissions by small increments.
Germany, one of the planet's key industrial economies, and one of its most competitive, proves that the cutting edge is green energy. This is all about economic advantage among the big players. Germany has shot far out ahead, and what China and the U.S. are doing with the bilateral agreement is, as McKibben says, putting "a floor under the retreat from carbon."

The big negative is that the deal isn't big enough. As Henry Fountain and Jonathan Schwartz point out in  "Climate Accord Relies on Environmental Policies Now in Place":
Experts said that the emissions reductions in the agreement would not be enough to enable the world to keep global warming below the target of a 2-degree Celsius, or 3.6-degree Fahrenheit, rise in global temperatures that was adopted at a climate meeting in Copenhagen in 2009.
Two-degree temperature rise is an important marker because once you hit it there's no going back; we're cooked, so to speak.

Fountain and Scwartz also point out a lack of commitment of other big players internationally:
Beyond the reductions, they said the deal was important for what it showed the rest of the world, particularly other large carbon emitters like India and Russia, in advance of a meeting in Paris next year to negotiate a new climate treaty. 
“It shows that the two big dogs in the room are taking the issue seriously,” said Kevin Kennedy of the World Resources Institute, a think tank. “It provides a real opportunity for the start of what could become a race to the top.” 
But it remains unclear whether that will happen. In India, the world’s third-largest carbon polluter, the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi has signaled that it will not announce a reduction target for emissions cuts. India has long maintained that it should not be required to commit to such goals.
The must-read story is Coral Davenport's "In Climate Deal With China, Obama May Set 2016 Theme"; she offers a compelling account that the Obama administration is guided primarily by politics here. First off, Obama's climate-plan architect is none other than John Podesta, Clinton eminence grise who soon plans to leave his White House post to manage Hillary's presidential campaign:
The architect of Mr. Obama’s climate change plan is none other than his senior counselor, John D. Podesta, who is likely to leave the White House next year to work as the chairman of Mrs. Clinton’s campaign. 
The climate plan that Mr. Podesta has drafted for Mr. Obama is expected to serve as a blueprint for Mrs. Clinton’s climate change policy, should she run.
Climate change is a wedge issue for suburban swing voters, as potent as welfare queens were for Reagan Democrats. As Davenport says,
President Obama’s landmark agreement with China to cut greenhouse gas pollution is a bet by the president and Democrats that on the issue of climate change, American voters are far ahead of Washington’s warring factions and that the environment will be a winning cause in the 2016 presidential campaign. 
A variety of polls show that a majority of American voters now believe that climate change is occurring, are worried about it, and support candidates who back policies to stop it. In particular, polls show that majorities of Hispanics, young people and unmarried women — the voters who were central to Mr. Obama’s victories in 2008 and 2012 — support candidates who back climate change policy. 
But Republicans are betting that despite the polls, they can make the case that regulations to cut greenhouse pollution will result in the loss of jobs and hurt the economy.
***
As evidence, Republican strategists point to their recent wave of victories in this year’s midterm elections, when they campaigned aggressively against Mr. Obama’s E.P.A. regulations. 
But Democrats are increasingly emboldened by polls showing that in national elections, candidates who push climate change policies will win support from voters. 
According to a 2013 poll by Stanford University, 73 percent of Americans believe that the earth has been warming over the past 100 years, while 81 percent of Americans think global warming poses a serious problem in the United States. In addition, 81 percent think the federal government should limit the amount of greenhouse gases that American businesses can emit.
Twenty-one percent of Americans think producing electricity from coal is a good idea, while 91 percent of Americans think making electricity from sunlight is a good idea.

A 2014 poll by the Yale Project on Climate Change Communication, meanwhile, found that majorities of women, minorities and young people support candidates who strongly endorse climate action. That poll found that 65 percent of Hispanics, 53 percent of blacks and 53 percent of unmarried women support candidates who back climate change action.
Thomas Edsall in his midterm postmortem, "The Demise of the White Democratic Voter," argued convincingly that GOP success was due to the national party's ability to muzzle the Tea Party knuckle-draggers, the troubadours of "legitimate rape" and the global-warming deniers who provide the incendiary soundbites that not only drive Democrats to the polls but also prompt fickle suburbanites to let their inner liberal run free. As Edsall frames it:
Republicans are not satisfied with winning 62 percent of the white vote. To counter the demographic growth of Democratic constituencies whose votes threaten Republican success in high-turnout presidential elections, Republicans have begun a concerted effort to rupture the partisan loyalty of the remaining white Democratic voters. Their main target is socially liberal, fiscally conservative suburbanites, the weakest reeds in the Democratic coalition. These middle-income white voters do not share the acute economic needs of so-called downscale Democratic voters and they are less reliant on government services.
The Republican strategy to win over these more culturally tolerant, but still financially pressed, white voters is to continue to focus on material concerns – on anxiety about rising tax burdens, for example — while downplaying the preoccupation of many of the most visible Republicans with social, moral and cultural repression.
These are the very voters who believe in climate science and can see that converting to a Green Economy is a job creator that makes the U.S. more economically competitive. The Koch brothers who didn't appear to be such an enormous albatross in the midterms -- because Democrats often ran away from criticism of the oil and gas industry -- will not fair so well in 2016.

The next card for a suddenly more potent POTUS to play will be on immigration. Once that is done, the GOP will be effectively boxed for the next two years. The electoral science is largely settled: a presidential candidate can't win with Latino support in the high-twenty-percent range (Romney) or low-thirties (McCain).

If Obama plays his cards right, as he did in Beijing, the old warhorse Hillary might be bound for the White House after all.

Wednesday, November 12, 2014

Clues Why Not to Expect Much from Big Green Groups

What is troubling about the announcement this morning of a carbon-reduction agreement reached between the United States and China (Mark Landler, "U.S. and China Reach Climate Accord After Months of Talks") is the lack of reaction to be found on any of the web sites of the main environmental organizations.

The deal as summarized in an opinion piece by Secretary of State John Kerry that appears this morning in the Gray Lady, "China, America and Our Warming Planet: Our Historic Agreement With China on Climate Change," is as follows:
The targets themselves are also important. Ambitious action by our countries together is the foundation to build the low-carbon global economy needed to combat climate change. The United States intends to reduce net greenhouse gas emissions by 26 to 28 percent below 2005 levels by 2025 – a target that is both ambitious and feasible. It roughly doubles the pace of carbon reductions in the period from 2020 to 2025 as compared to the period from 2005 to 2020. It puts us on a path to transform our economy, with emissions reductions on the order of 80 percent by 2050. It is grounded in an extensive analysis of the potential to reduce emissions in all sectors of our economy, with significant added benefits for health, clean air, and energy security. 
Our target builds on the ambitious goal President Obama set in 2009 to cut emissions in the range of 17 percent below 2005 levels by 2020. We are on track to meet that goal, while creating jobs and growing the economy, with the help of a burgeoning clean energy sector. Since the president took office, wind energy production has tripled and solar energy has increased by a factor of ten. This summer, the Environmental Protection Agency proposed the first carbon pollution standards for existing power plants, which account for a third of United States carbon pollution.
The Chinese targets also represent a major advance. For the first time China is announcing a peak year for its carbon emissions – around 2030 – along with a commitment to try to reach the peak earlier. That matters because over the past 15 years, China has accounted for roughly 60 percent of the growth in carbon dioxide emissions world-wide. We are confident that China can and will reach peak emissions before 2030, in light of President Xi’s commitments to restructure the economy, dramatically reduce air pollution and stimulate an energy revolution. 
China is also announcing today that it would expand the share of total energy consumption coming from zero-emission sources (renewable and nuclear energy) to around 20 percent by 2030, sending a powerful signal to investors and energy markets around the world and helping accelerate the global transition to clean-energy economies. To meet its goal, China will need to deploy an additional 800 to 1,000 gigawatts of nuclear, wind, solar and other renewable generation capacity by 2030 – an enormous amount, about the same as all the coal-fired power plants in China today, and nearly as much as the total electricity generation capacity of the United States.
This agreement was fully expected. Prior to Obama's appearance at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, Landler clued in his readers that a climate deal between the two largest economies was rumored to be forthcoming, a way to sculpt next year's global negotiations in Paris.

That's why it is bizarre that there is (so far) basically nothing available about the bilateral accord on 350.org (a Tweet that linked to a story, "US and China strike deal on carbon cuts in push for global climate pact," by The Guardian); National Resources Defense Council (a pro forma press release, that is difficult to find on their home page, which was used in The Guardian story -- "Frances Beinecke, president of US-based environmental group the Natural Resources Defence Council, said: 'These landmark commitments to curtail carbon pollution are a necessary, critical step forward in the global fight against climate change. We look forward to working with both governments to strengthen their efforts because we are confident that both can achieve even greater reductions' "); Friends of the Earth (zero); Sierra Club (nothing this morning, though they do have a press release about TPP impasse at the APEC summit in Beijing); and Greenpeace (nothing).

More evidence of sclerosis in institutions (along with organized labor and the Democratic Party) purportedly popular and progressive. Not an encouraging sign going forward that any sustained effort is going to be mounted by mainstream environmental groups against the Koch brothers dominantion of national government.

Ben Adler writing for Grist, "New U.S.-China climate deal is a game changer," is supportive:
Reaching the new emission-reduction targets is certainly technologically possible, and allowable under existing law — as long as Congress doesn’t figure out a way to stop to it. Emissions have already declined, we’ve got new rules on tailpipes, and with the proposed power plant rules, we are almost there already. “I think it’s achievable,” says Tyson Slocum, director of Public Citizen’s energy program. “They might have to make some tweaks [to the power-plant targets], but I don’t see it as being a radical rewrite of the goal.”
It will be necessary to finalize power-plant rules — the centerpiece of Obama’s Climate Action Plan — that are as strong, if not stronger, than what is already proposed. Other components of the plan, like possible rules to limit methane leakage from fracking, don’t have the potential to achieve such big reductions. Still, moving forward with them will also be necessary. 
But any tightening of EPA regulations or introduction of new ones would risk inciting even stronger political backlash or being overturned in court. Even Democrats in fossil fuel–producing red states ran away from the rules in this last election. (They still got clobbered.) Republicans are already mulling ways to impede the power-plant rules by defunding the regulatory process. The stronger the rules get, the more childish they’ll act. And they will have the same reaction to anything else Obama tries to do through executive action.
Coral Davenport had a story yesterday, "Republicans Vow to Fight E.P.A. and Approve Keystone Pipeline," confirming Adler's point. The G.O.P. marinated, as Nader says (and also the focus of a good column by Gail Collins last Saturday, "Republicans ♥ Pipeline"), in oil and gas money will dig in and attempt to hollow out the EPA and flirt with another government shutdown to get Keystone XL passed, thereby pleasing their Koch paymasters. According to Davenport,
Republicans also planned to use their majority to enact legislation requiring the president to approve the Keystone pipeline. Republicans and the oil industry have issued angry calls for construction of the pipeline, which they see as a crucial conduit for oil. 
Environmentalists have campaigned against the project, which they see as a symbol of environmental degradation. Mr. Obama has delayed a decision on the project for years, as the State Department conducted numerous reviews of its impact on the nation’s environment, economy and national security. 
The State Department is now awaiting a decision by a Nebraska court on the route of the pipeline before any decision is made. 
If Republicans send a Keystone bill to Mr. Obama before the Nebraska verdict, the president is likely to veto it. But people familiar with the president’s thinking say that when it comes to climate change policy, Mr. Obama sees the E.P.A. regulations as the centerpiece of his environmental agenda and the Keystone pipeline as a sideline issue. 
Asked about the project at a news conference last week, Mr. Obama said, “I’m going to let that process play out.” Then he added, “And I’m just going to gather up the facts.” 
Republicans were likely to add a Keystone-approval provision to key spending bills, again daring Mr. Obama to veto such a measure. Mr. Obama appeared willing to veto such measures to protect the climate change rules, which could have an impact on the nation’s energy economy for the coming decades. But he may not be willing to do so for the pipeline, a single piece of infrastructure. 
“I think there is probably a deal to be had on Keystone,” said David Goldwyn, who led the State Department’s Bureau of Energy Resources in Mr. Obama’s first term. “If Republicans attach Keystone to a budget bill, I don’t think he’s so principally opposed to it that he would veto it.”
Previously I entertained the possibility of Obama's acquiescence to Keystone XL causing Bill McKibben to spearhead the creation of a new political party, or a political coalition with the Green Party and some of the existing socialist parties. Now, judging from the lack of reaction to the Obama-Xi Jinping carbon-reduction deal, I'm convinced nothing of the sort will happen.

As for the viability of the bilateral accord, a commentator, cosmicomics, to Adler's piece says it well:
“The real proof will be in the pudding. There’s no way approving the Keystone XL pipeline and additional fossil fuel development is compatible with this pathway.”
The problem isn't just American emissions, but America's contribution to global emissions, so reducing American emissions doesn't help if U.S. policy continues to encourage the development of fossil fuels, which then can be used elsewhere. Obama appears to have a climate policy that aims to reduce emissions, while at the same time promoting an energy policy that increases them. 
“...the reality is that Obama has spent the last six years expanding coal, oil and gas production under his “all of the above” energy strategy. 
'We quadrupled the number of operating rigs to a record high. We’ve added enough new oil and gas pipeline to encircle the earth and then some,' Obama told a rally during his 2012 re-election campaign. 
Coal exports have risen on Obama’s watch, with mining companies shipping some 100m tonnes a year for each of the last three years...

Monday, September 22, 2014

New Government in Afghanistan + Climate March + Matt Bai on Gary Hart's Fall

On this last day of summer it seems as if events are finally settling down. Maybe not settling down so much as taking shape.

A third Gulf War is in the works for the United States. And while there are a lot of unknowns as to what this Gulf War III will end up looking like, for now at least the caliphate no longer appears to be inevitable. Islamic State is no longer making broad territorial gains. U.S. air power along with promises to reassert itself in Syria seems to have made an impact.

In the Donbass a nominal ceasefire is holding, giving the warring parties time to reflect. The lust for more violence has diminished greatly. The junta remains the critical player here. The fact that Poroshenko has maintained the ceasefire as long as he has tells me that Kiev is seriously in danger if the fighting continues.

Even Afghanistan, with Kabul a few weeks ago close to violence because of the contested presidential recount between Abdullah Abdullah and Ashraf Ghani, now appears temporarily stable. Ashraf Ghani and Abdullah Abdullah signed off yesterday on a new unity government. Adbullah Abdullah will be the prime minister, and he will apparently be more than a ceremonial official. Ashraf Ghani will be the president will all the powers granted to the presidency according to the Afghan Constitution. One wonders about the legitimacy of this agreement. Can the exiting president, Hamid Karzai, create by fiat these changes in the organization of government? Doesn't there have to be a constitutional or legislative process to implement the agreement? In any event, a big win for the United States. Now the Obama administration can get its bilateral security agreement signed and figure out its force structure for the next few years.

There was a big climate march publicity event yesterday. Counterpunch ran a story by Arun Gupta over the weekend that is worth reading, "Business as Usual in Manhattan: How the People’s Climate March Became a Corporate PR Campaign," the gist of which is that the large organizations behind the march, 350.org and Avaaz, billed it as an "Occupy"-type direct action while working assiduously behind the scene to make sure that it was nothing of the sort. The goal was to have a "family friendly" march that would provide pretty visuals but no real threat to business as usual.

There was an associated climate march here in the Emerald City. But, having spent all Saturday downtown among the tourists, I spent Sunday, after completing a run around Lake Union, in front of the television watching the NFL. I did manage to muddle my way through Matt Bai's lengthy feature in the New York Times Magazine, "How Gary Hart’s Downfall Forever Changed American Politics."

I was expecting more because I do think the 1988 presidential election campaign is something of a dividing line. Certainly Bush I's presidency is the last of the post-war (WWII) consensus-type administrations. But Bai spends most of his time rehashing all the ridiculous, sordid details of the stakeout of Hart's D.C. townhouse by Miami Herald reporters.

There is not a lot of big picture stuff. Bai does explore the shift in journalism following Watergate. But he doesn't explain why it took another 15 years for Fourth Estate to go after the sexual infidelities of politicians. What changed in that 15 years?

The Carter administration was treated to the first ersatz Watergate just a few years after Nixon resigned. That was the Bert Lance affair. The public has been treated to one -Gate scandal after the next ever since.

Tuesday, December 31, 2013

House of Saud Destabilizes Lebanon

While taking in the final Sunday of regular season NFL action I finally got around to reading Dahr Jamail's devastating summary piece on the current predictions of some climate scientists who see a massive dying coming our way in the not-to-distant future because of huge releases of trapped methane and carbon as the Arctic permafrost thaws.

The dystopia presented by Jamail is a world where the places food is now grown will no longer be able to support crops. Most people will die and those remaining will migrate north and south to the Arctic and Antarctica. It is a dire forecast but one that is grounded in science. The only way to avoid further warming is to have a reduction in growth, something antithetical to the global capitalist order. So get ready for dystopia.

What is being peddled by the capitalists is "technology will save us." A book that has been recommended to me, one which I recently checked out at the library and plan to get started on this weekend, is Abundance: The Future is Better Than You Think (2012) by Peter Diamandis and Steven Kotler. It seems manifestly like snake oil to me, this idea that we can come up with a quick and dirty tech solution to global system failure brought on by a couple of centuries of industrial capitalism; but I'll report back once I read the book.

In any event, the Jamail piece has an impact on the way one looks at the world; it makes it hard to not look at the world as a Manichean. There are forces of dark and there are forces of light. The purveyors of darkness want to maintain the current corrupt capitalist world order with its extraction of wealth and plenty for the 1%. They are arrayed against the rest of us, who while currently benighted at least have a yearning (in various stages of consciousness) for a little peace and calm.

The United States as principal architect of our current doomed paradigm is the demiurge. But the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is stepping up its devilish activities to fill the void the shrinking hyperpower leaves as it pivots to Asia to confront China.

The latest installments in bloody Saudi skullduggery are in Lebanon. Anne Barnard, the Gray Lady's Beirut bureau chief, has a useful summary today, "Lebanon, Worried About Border, Fires on Syrian Helicopters in Its Airspace," of some of the recent spillover effects from the war in Syria. The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia recently announced that it has made a $3 billion purchase of the Lebanese Army:
On Sunday, the Lebanese president, Michel Suleiman, said the government had accepted a $3 billion aid package for the army from Saudi Arabia, an amount believed to be larger than the country’s defense budget. 
The move was welcomed by some as a way to strengthen the army, which is facing a growing array of threats from militants inside Lebanon. But it was viewed as provocative by supporters of Hezbollah, the Shiite militant group, who saw it as a bid to reduce the group’s influence over the army. Hezbollah, backed by Iran, supports the Syrian government, while Saudi Arabia is one of the main financiers of the Syrian insurgency. 
Speculation arose Monday that the army’s new assertiveness against the Syrian airspace violation was at Saudi Arabia’s bidding in response to the aid package. Security officials said it was policy to respond to any violation of Lebanese territory. The army has also pursued and killed Syrian insurgents on Lebanese territory in recent weeks, according to the official National News Agency.
Couple this with a rocket fired Sunday, likely by Al Qaeda, into Israel from Lebanon (not to mention the series of terror bombings in Beirut) and the prodigious shadows of the sheikhs become visible. Isabel Kershner reporting from Jerusalem yesterday had the story, "Rocket Fire From Lebanon Prompts Shelling by Israel":
There was no immediate claim of responsibility for the attack on Sunday, though those in recent years generally appear to have been the work of small militant groups in Lebanon rather than of Hezbollah. 
In August, four rockets were fired from Lebanon into Israel for the first time in two years. A militant group called the Brigades of Abdullah Azzam, an offshoot of Al Qaeda in Iraq, claimed responsibility. Israel responded to that attack by bombing what military officials here described as a “terrorist site” between the Lebanese cities of Beirut and Sidon. 
The Israeli defense minister, Moshe Yaalon, said Sunday that Israel would not tolerate fire from Lebanese territory and would use more force if necessary. “I do not recommend that anyone test our patience and our determination to preserve the security of Israeli citizens,” he said in a statement. 
Notwithstanding the heightened tensions and harsh talk, an Israeli expert said that neither Israel nor Hezbollah, which is embroiled in the civil war in Syria, had an interest now in a full-blown confrontation on the Israeli-Lebanese front. 
Aviv Oreg, a former head of the Al Qaeda and Global Jihad desk in Israel’s military intelligence department, told reporters that some kind of radical Islamic “global jihad” organization was probably behind the rocket fire on Sunday and that the attackers might have been trying to provoke Israel into retaliating against Hezbollah, since jihadist groups and Hezbollah are fighting on opposite sides of the conflict in Syria.
Nonetheless Netanyahu, working seamlessly per usual with his Saudi allies, blamed Hezbollah of war crimes.

As the planet pitches toward a methane burp of "great dying," the Saudis are moving full speed ahead with a "smash and grab" of the Middle East.

Monday, December 30, 2013

Where Monsters Dwell #19: The Insect Man

"The Insect Man" originally appeared in the Tales of Suspense #24 (December 1961). It is classic Silver Age science fiction by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby. Kirby's art is beautiful, much stronger than Lee's story, which includes elements Lee uses elsewhere: a subterranean capsule and a "It must have all just been a dream" ending.

Where Monsters Dwell #19 (January 1973) is noteworthy because it features original cover art by the great Gil Kane, Marvel's go-to cover artist in the early Bronze Age.


In "The Insect Man" a U.S. Army sergeant is sent far underground in a space capsule as part of a preparedness program for a flight to the moon. The brass is worried about man's ability to survive long stretches alone. Putting a man in a capsule and dropping the capsule far below the surface of the earth is a way to gauge his suitability for space flight.

Once underground the sergeant is captured by a giant race of insects. He becomes a plaything for an adolescent giant insect. Right when the sergeant is about to be vivisected by the curious giant insects he makes his getaway. Back on the surface the military brass assure him that the giant insects must have been a hallucination brought about by his isolation.


These Lee-Kirby scifi stories from the early 1960s all seem very quaint now with their preoccupation with monsters from outer space or from deep underground. Nowadays science is far more scary than any fiction we could dream up. Take for example Dahr Jamail's "Are We Falling Off the Climate Precipice," an article that appeared on TomDispatch.com earlier this month and that generated some interest. In it Jamail assesses the current predictions of some well-established climate scientists who are a little more pessimistic than their colleagues.

Jamail mostly focuses on what happens to the planet when the methane and carbon that is trapped in the Arctic are released into the atmosphere as the permafrost thaws, as it is now. Here is a sample:
How serious is the potential global methane build-up? Not all scientists think it’s an immediate threat or even the major threat we face, but Ira Leifer, an atmospheric and marine scientist at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and one of the authors of the recent Arctic Methane study pointed out to me that “the Permian mass extinction that occurred 250 million years ago is related to methane and thought to be the key to what caused the extinction of most species on the planet.” In that extinction episode, it is estimated that 95% of all species were wiped out. 
Also known as “The Great Dying,” it was triggered by a massive lava flow in an area of Siberia that led to an increase in global temperatures of six degrees Celsius. That, in turn, caused the melting of frozen methane deposits under the seas. Released into the atmosphere, it caused temperatures to skyrocket further. All of this occurred over a period of approximately 80,000 years. 
We are currently in the midst of what scientists consider the sixth mass extinction in planetary history, with between 150 and 200 species going extinct daily, a pace 1,000 times greater than the “natural” or “background” extinction rate. This event may already be comparable to, or even exceed, both the speed and intensity of the Permian mass extinction. The difference being that ours is human caused, isn’t going to take 80,000 years, has so far lasted just a few centuries, and is now gaining speed in a non-linear fashion. 
It is possible that, on top of the vast quantities of carbon dioxide from fossil fuels that continue to enter the atmosphere in record amounts yearly, an increased release of methane could signal the beginning of the sort of process that led to the Great Dying. Some scientists fear that the situation is already so serious and so many self-reinforcing feedback loops are already in play that we are in the process of causing our own extinction. Worse yet, some are convinced that it could happen far more quickly than generally believed possible -- even in the course of just the next few decades.



Read Jamail's article. It is a clear-eyed appraisal of approaching system failure. Capitalism is of course killing us. We're not even listening to our scientists anymore. Here is how Jamail puts it:
Not surprisingly, scientists with such views are often not the most popular guys in the global room. McPherson [Guy McPherson, professor emeritus of evolutionary biology, natural resources, and ecology at the University of Arizona and a climate change expert of 25 years], for instance, has often been labeled “Guy McStinction” -- to which he responds, “I’m just reporting the results from other scientists. Nearly all of these results are published in established, esteemed literature. I don’t think anybody is taking issue with NASA, or Nature, or Science, or the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. [Those] and the others I report are reasonably well known and come from legitimate sources, like NOAA [the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration], for example. I’m not making this information up, I’m just connecting a couple of dots, and it’s something many people have difficulty with.” 
McPherson does not hold out much hope for the future, nor for a governmental willingness to make anything close to the radical changes that would be necessary to quickly ease the flow of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere; nor does he expect the mainstream media to put much effort into reporting on all of this because, as he says, “There’s not much money in the end of civilization, and even less to be made in human extinction.” The destruction of the planet, on the other hand, is a good bet, he believes, “because there is money in this, and as long as that’s the case, it is going to continue.”