Thursday, March 8, 2018

Texas Reveals No Wave. Democratic Crackup is Coming.

Lambert Strether's Water Cooler from yesterday examined the numbers from this week's primary election in Texas:
TX: “Here’s what happened in the 2018 Texas primaries” [Texas Monthly]. Some snippets: 1. “More than 1.5 million people voted in the Republican primary, with close to 100 percent reporting, compared to about 1 million Democrats, also with a near 100 percent reporting.” Hard to see how that signals a wave that will “turn Texas Blue,” as the slogan has it, though of course that doesn’t preclude the pickup of individual seats. 2. “Laura Moser secured a slot in the party’s primary runoff Tuesday, despite rare attempts [Rare? Really?] by national Democrats to end her bid over concerns she is too liberal for the district. Moser, (24%) a journalist and activist, will face attorney Lizzie Pannill Fletcher (30%) in the May 22 runoff — which will likely be a brutal intra-party fight and could divide west Houston and the national Democratic Party.” I’d be happier if there were 10 such races.
But according to Musa al-Gharbi in "About That Blue Wave …" the Texas results don't point to Dems picking up Lone Star congressional districts:
As for the specific seats Democrats hope to capture in November, it appears that Republicans would retain control if the races were decided on the basis of Tuesday’s primary vote. Democrats have a lot of work to do to catch up.
But just as important, if not more so, there were marked differences between the parties in terms of the tone of their primaries.
On the Democratic side, there was bitter internal strife, dating back to the previous election cycle, between the “establishment” Democrats and the populist “Berniecrats.” Many of the latter are not committed partisans: While they are highly motivated to support populists, many refuse to lend their support to more conventional Democratic candidates. As we saw in 2016, many former Sanders supporters sat out the general election, voted for a third-party candidate or voted for Donald Trump.
Democrats should be concerned about their ability to mobilize populists in the races “establishment” figures won. So the party could find itself facing another enthusiasm deficit for many key races, even with Mr. Trump in the White House.
On the Republican side, there was clear unity behind the president and his party. The races were mostly about which candidate was most supportive of President Trump. As a result, it seems likely that Republican voters will support whoever is on their ticket in the general election.
We can count on Republican primary voters to turn out in November as well. Republicans reliably vote in midterms, and again it is important to note that primary patterns suggest that enthusiasm is particularly high in the Republican base this year, too.
The base GOP voter likes his guy, Trump, while the base Democratic voter is split. One part of the base feeds at the MSNBC trough and is praying for a Joe Biden run; the other is sharpening its pitchforks as Bernie readies for another presidential campaign.

Trump is going to have his base solidly beneath him. (It turns out those tariffs on aluminum and steel were part of the NAFTA negotiations.) Partisan Dems are going to have to be broken. It is existential crisis. Biden is not the answer. All he has to offer is Russophobia. And what does that get a voter at the end of the day? Nothing.

The successful teachers strike in West Virginia shows the way forward. See "What the Teachers Won":
First of all, if we can do it, anybody can do it. It’s not like we’re a special group of activist teachers who have been studying for twenty years about how to mobilize the working class. We’re not. 
Another one of the big lessons I’ve learned is that you need to organize people around a specific issue. For us, it was the insurance. That’s a big-tent issue that affected one in seven West Virginians. It meant that we had a large base of support.
Bernie has it -- Medicare for All, and he's campaigning on it. The partisan Dems only have Russiaphobia. It's not going to work. The Dems might keep Bernie from the nomination again, but it's not going to beat Trump. If Bernie does manage a miracle and capture the party's nomination, expect a well-funded third-party challenge. And Trump wins again.

Wednesday, March 7, 2018

The YPG/YPJ Have to Hold Afrin City

Rudaw reported yesterday, "Turkish forces advance, closing in on Afrin city," that the battle for Afrin has reached the point of a siege of the city. The Kurdish-led SDF responded by announcing a move of 1,700 fighters from the eastern Syrian province of Deir al-Zour. The SDF in Deir al-Zour are there primarily to guard the oil fields war booty coveted by the U.S.

Anne Barnard reports today from her office in Beirut that Turkey has requested that the U.S. block this troop transfer ("Turkey Asks U.S. to Stop Kurds From Shifting Fighters to Western Syria"). I would say that the chances of this happening are close to zero.

The Kurds of the YPG/YPJ have to hold Afrin because if they don't then they will have proven to be incapable of acting independently of the protection provided by U.S. air power and logistics. If Turkey and the CIA-trained Free Syrian Army triumph, then the Kurds will be seen as merely another mercenary proxy force that the U.S. exploits willy-nilly to achieve its objectives.

At this point the Turks appear to have all the advantage. They can lay siege to Afrin city indefinitely. Don't expect the same outrage over Afrin in the Western media as there is for East Ghouta.

Tuesday, March 6, 2018

NYT's Roger Cohen Calls for Central Banker Draghi to Run Italy

UPDATE: The animal wails emanating from The New York Times opinion page are hard to ignore. The cries and woe-is-me moans are all about Italy's general election results. David Brooks' "The Chaos After Trump" is a good example. His column concludes: "Vladimir Putin’s admirers are surging. The center is still hollowing out. Nothing is inevitable in life, but liberal democracy clearly ain’t going to automatically fix itself."

In all of this, as in The Times' unsigned editorial "Demagogues Win as Europe’s Populist Tide Sweeps Italy," there is this tone of exasperated victimization. The poor, poor elite who have been guzzling at the trough for decades are finally being abandoned by the voters. And make no mistake, the elitism is oozing out. Note the editorial's reference to M5S leader Di Maio's lack of a college degree:
The big winner, with about 32 percent of the vote, was the Five Star Movement, a grass-roots mélange of libertarians, progressives, Euroskeptics and other disenchanted voters formed less than a decade ago by a comedian, and now led by a 31-year-old college dropout, Luigi Di Maio. [Oh, my goodness!]
Or the very similar complaint by Brooks that Di Maio's never worked full-time
The big winner is the populist Five Star Movement, which was started by a comedian and is now led by a 31-year-old who had never held a full-time job. [Di Maio has been a member of the Italian Chamber of Deputies since 2013.]
It's all unhinged, panicked. Brooks at least calls out that the center is imploding. David Broder writing for Jacobin, "Notes on Italy’s Election," doesn't see M5S as a precursor to fascism, nor does he see it as in the same league as the UK's Momentum. Broder labels M5S as basically an uninspired technocratic, reformist movement. To which I would say,You could dismiss the entire progressive era of American political history on the same terms.
M5S parliamentarians have long abstained on controversial issues, from migration to gay rights, in order to maintain the movement’s “catch-all,” oppositional image. Entering government demands greater political definition. M5S promises to speak to “all political forces” — probably including the Lega — about the way ahead, but clearly risks being unbalanced should it ally with some more cohesive force. Yet while the party system is fluid, even a pact with the Lega will not automatically see voters turn back to the Left. If M5S could represent the forces of discontent, it could do this because what is still called the “center-left” has been hollowed out over decades.
The M5S is not an Italian Front National. It is not even a strongly Eurosceptic force, having abandoned this cause in the name of presenting a more “professional” and less “extreme” face. Nor does it offer some new democratic vision. Far from empowering citizens to mobilize for social change, its guru proposed a well-worn set of ideas based on removing “ideology” from the realm of state administration, in this drawing on the technocratic ideals of typewriter kingpin Adriano Olivetti. It repeats a hackneyed cry of making Italy a “normal country,” free of corruption and inefficiency, even though it has already abandoned its own anti-corruption charter.
Be that as it may, the M5S captured a wider discontent, and looks best placed to try and form a government. Its prime ministerial candidate Luigi Di Maio’s range of choices, plus the evident difficulties forming an opposite, grand coalition, mean that this could go on for several weeks. This will invariably feed a narrative of mounting “EU chaos” or “destabilization” coming from Rome. But least of all should we rely on the baleful tweets of Le Pen or Farage to tell us what is happening. Even if it does reach office, M5S is not about to bring down the EU (it already abandoned calls for a euro referendum) and nor is Fascism Returning in Its Historic Heartlands.
The rise of Lega and the M5S is grim news for anyone who believes in progressive politics, or who retains some memory of the Italian left’s past glories. In France, when Macron and Le Pen reached the second round, we could at least see that France Insoumise had laid down a marker. In the UK Labour has advanced, and even in the US the Sanders campaign provided a platform for left renewal. March 4 offered no such room for hope. But nor is panic about some alleged “rising fascism” going to offer it. As one old Marxist once put it: the old is dying, and something superficially different but not all that new has been born. May other things be born, and soon.
****

To get a whiff of dirty diapers read Roger Cohen's infantile "Italy’s Five-Star Electoral Performance." At the end he wails for ECB's Mario Draghi to save the day. It is unbelievable --
Other possibilities, none of which look stable, include a center-right coalition that would need outside support to have enough seats to govern and would presumably see the odious Salvini as prime minister; a far-fetched coalition of the Five Star Movement and the Left; or a German-style grand coalition that, as in Germany, would see the defeated mainstream parties trying to govern and would thereby fuel rage against democracies that refuse to heed what voters say.
Putin is certainly happy. Trump is likely happy. The giants of European unity and freedom — Alcide De Gasperi of Italy, Konrad Adenauer of Germany, Robert Schuman of France — are turning in their graves. The almost three decades since the fall of the Berlin Wall have been a long strange trip to the politics of the mob.
The wise Mario Draghi completes his term as governor of the European Central Bank in October. He’s the best answer to Italy’s problems I can see. Rome has seen empires come and go; it can see out the seven months until then.
What so strange about the reporting in the organs of the corporate press is that there is hardly ever an explanation of why, as Jason Horowitz put it in "Italy’s Surging Populists Run Into a Political Muddle. But for How Long?," "[A]nti-Democratic forces [are] sweeping up furious voters across Europe." It is as if arbitrarily a xenophobic steroidal rage has descended upon the continent. At least that's the sense one gets from reading The New York Times.

The answers are obvious: 1) a plutocratic economic order where the benefits of increased productivity have been vacuumed up by the rich, leaving the working class with longer hours of work and higher housing costs, and 2) perpetual warfare abroad, which is a principal cause of Europe's immigration crisis, and terrorist attacks at home. Who in her right mind would endorse such political outcomes year in and year out for decades? You would have to be insane (like Roger Cohen).

The encouraging news found in Horowitz's article is the Five Star Movement wants to govern and wants to govern based on issues-based ad hoc coalitions. Let's hope Europe's Russophobia is blown down and that a large national economy enacts a guaranteed basic income:
It now falls to Italy’s president, Sergio Mattarella, the keeper of its institutions and now the nation’s most powerful person, to find someone who can put together a stable government that can survive a confidence vote in the new parliament, which meets on March 23.
It doesn’t look easy. Any solution that does not include the Five Star Movement or the League, the hard-right, formerly northern-based secessionist party, will raise questions of democratic legitimacy.
“Mattarella can’t keep the populists out,” Massimo Franco, a political columnist with il Corriere della Sera, said in an interview.
“If he keeps the Five Star out, they’ll say that they have twice the votes of the League,” he continued. “If he keeps the League out, they will say that their coalition has more than the Five Star. We have two relative winners, that’s one of the problems.”
Luigi Di Maio, the Five Star Movement’s candidate for prime minister, made it clear on Monday that his party wanted to run things.

Monday, March 5, 2018

Democratic Wave Unlikely This Year. Then the Party Splits in 2020.

Last week there were a number of stories on the upcoming wave election for the Democrats in November, the most emphatic of which might have been Sean McElwee's "The Midterms and the Turn Leftward": "Democrats will take the House, probably winning around forty seats."

Dems need to pick up 24 seats. I'm not saying that it can't happen, but I'm just skeptical that it will. A lot of the "Democratic wave" prognostications appear to be based on the generic ballot, a wholly unreliable lens to look at the myriad individual congressional races. Lambert Strether's Water Cooler from last Wednesday had these two items:
  • “Dems surge in generic ballot as economy fades from spotlight” [The Hill]. “[P]ollsters warn that the generic ballot is better as a gauge of the entire electorate’s mood than as a predictor of outcomes in individual races. In the Senate, Democrats are defending 25 seats, while Republicans are only tasked with defending eight seats. Many of the GOP incumbents are running in states that Trump won handily in 2016, while several Democrats are running in states Trump won by double-digit margins. Pollsters say not to read too deeply into generic ballot polling at this early stage, pointing to the extreme volatility in the polls in recent weeks. Over the past month, polls have put the Democratic advantage everywhere from 2 points to 16 points.”
  • “Democratic National Committee war plan: Target 50 million voters” [NBC News]. “The DNC, which has struggled financially and faced doubts about its relevance, will focus its 2018 organizing plans for the midterms around partnerships with a wide range of groups aimed at boosting turnout among Democratic-leaning voters, who have been less likely to get to the polls in recent nonpresidential elections.” Wake me when the Democrat party makes voter registration and expanding the base a core party function, 24/7/365, instead of a random, election by election effort. (Oh, and a political version of Conway’s Law seems to be at work: Liberals think of themselves as an aggregation of silos (mostly identity-based silos), hence the “partnerships with a wide range of groups,” i.e. not a core party function.
Last week Trump announced his tariffs on aluminum and steel. If this is sincere, and not some hocus pocus to screen his failure to overhaul NAFTA, then Trump has secured the continued allegiance of his base MAGA voter.

A president's first midterm is supposed to be a plebiscite on his performance. If true, and assuming the U.S. is not drawn deeper into Syria and/or attacks North Korea and/or falls into recession, then I think the GOP will perform better than expected.

Granted, Trump's tariffs cut against the grain, creating a situation where Paul Ryan is criticizing Trump while Sherrod Brown is praising him. But I doubt there will be many blue-collar districts where the Republican on the ballot distances himself from Trump.

The biggest wake-up for Democrats has to be the ongoing collapse of the center-left in Europe. Yes, the SPD membership in Germany strongly backed GroKo. But it will be the last GroKo. What has to give U.S. Democrats pause is the failure of Italy's Democratic Party (PD). Today Matteo Renzi announced his resignation. PD managed 23% less than 20% of the vote.

The Democratic Party in the U.S. is splitting. Machine pols are battling the new liberal power, the #MeToos. And this is just a tune-up for the main event come 2020 --  Bernie redux.

Bernie redux will be Armageddon for the Democratic Party. The Democratic Party will block Bernie again. And once again it will lose a close general election to Trump.

But let's imagine a successful wave, a children's crusade that topples the DNC leadership and nominates Bernie. What happens then? Mike Bloomberg or some other billionaire bankrolls a centrist third party a la En Marche!, dooming the party of Jackson and Van Buren.

We can only hope.

Sunday, March 4, 2018

Exit Polls Looking Good for Five Star Movement

UPDATE IV: A tweet from Antonello Guerrera is being hailed as the best summation so far of the Italian general election of 2018:
- M5S 1st party 
- Centre-right 1st coalition 
- Italy split in 3 
- Populist & anti-eurosceptic front close to 50% of votes 
- Renzi's PD collapsing
- Perfect hung parliament looming
Guerrero says that Renzi is likely to resign if the PD polls under 20%. We can only hope!

**** 

UPDATE III: Plenty of "fear and loathing" ahead from the prestige press over the badly hung parliament. But there is this helpful Guardian thumbnail sketch of the Five Star Movement. M5S is deemed a false-consciousness party by socialists and communists, a stalking horse for fascists. I have never seen M5S that way. I have seen the party as purely an "anti" construct -- anti-neoliberalism, anti-neoconservatism, anti-"staus quo of the last 40 years." It refuses to hemmed in and defined. As I said the other day, the best hope for rejuvenating moribund democracy in the West is M5S and Labour's Momentum:

"So, what exactly is the Five Star Movement?
"The anti-establisment party, started by comedian Beppe Grillo, burst onto the political scene in 2012 and has gone from strength to strength. The 69-year-old remains a figurehead, though he has handed over leadership to sharp-suited disciple Luigi Di Maio.
"Since its beginnings, the party has experienced a meteoric rise to prominence amid an outpouring of frustration and anger towards mainstream political parties.
"The movement calls itself “the first and only political party based on online participation and direct democracy.” Using an internet portal called Rousseau, M5S uses online votes of members to decide its policies, draft legislation and candidates.
M5S is proposing a universal basic income of €780 ($963) a month for those living in poverty.
"M5S supports a hotchpotch of policies from across the political spectrum and has gained a reputation for political flip-flopping, leading their critics to brand them as immature and incompetent. The party had promised its supporters a referendum on leaving the eurozone, but has had a change of heart in recent months.
"M5S is currently projected to be the single party with the largest share of votes in the election. You can read more about its moment of truth here.
****

UPDATE II: The state broadcaster Rai's first seat projection:
Centre-right 225-265
M5S 195-235
Centre-left 115-155
LEU 12-20
The chatter about possible coalitions has already begun. One being discussed is between M5S and Renzi's establishment Democratic Party (PD). Absurd! For sure, one conclusion that won't be lost in the chatter is the continuing failure of the mainstream center. Italians have "gone native," with M5S and Lega (what used to be the Northern League) the parties on the rise. Matteo Salvini is definitely photogenic:


****

UPDATE: From Guardian Rome bureau chief Stephanie Kirchgaessner:
"The Five Star Movement, an anti-establishment party that was founded by former comedian Beppe Grillo and has voiced deep scepticism about the euro and Italy’s role in NATO, appeared to have won between 29-31% of the votes, according to the early exit polls."
****

Five Star Movement is topping the exit polls. From The Guardian:
Italy’s national public broadcaster, Rai, has roughly comparable numbers in its first exit poll: 
M5S 29%-32%
Forza Italia 13-16% 
Lega 13-16% 
PD 20.5-23.5%
In its live election coverage The Guardian has this helpful breakdown of the policy positions of the various parties in today's election -- far more illuminating (by leaps and bounds) than any reporting provided by "the newspaper of record." For instance, in none of its reporting -- and I'm going by memory here; I might have missed one Berlusconi story --did it mention that Forza Italia favors a universal basic income (and more generous than that proposed by M5S!). Really and truly, The New York Times has become inseparable from the USG.

Centre-right: Forza Italia, led by four-time prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, aims to introduce a “parallel currency” for domestic use, keeping the euro for international trade; have a single, flat rate income tax for companies and individuals; abolish housing, inheritance and road tax; double the minimum pension; introduce a minimum income of €1,000 a month for all and block new immigrant arrivals.
Radical right: The League (formerly the Northern League), led by Matteo Salvini, would also introduce a parallel currency; abolish the EU’s fiscal compact; bring in a flat tax for all at 15%; allow earlier retirement; repatriate 100,000 illegal immigrants a year; and reopen Italy’s brothels. Brothers of Italy, led by Giorgia Meloni, is a southern equivalent of the League with neofascist roots and similar policies.
Anti-establishment: The Five Star Movement, led by 31-year-old Luigi Di Maio, proposes a minimum monthly income of €780; raising the budget deficit; repealing 400 “useless” laws including labour and pension reforms to allow earlier retirement and make firing harder; raising taxes on energy companies and improving relations with Russia.
Centre-left: The Democratic party, led by former prime minister Matteo Renzi, proposes an increase in the minimum wage; negotiating to abolish the fiscal compact and raising the budget deficit to 3% of GDP so as to cut taxes and increase investment.
Left: Free and Equal is led by Pietro Grasso, and is a new party uniting smaller groups that left Renzi’s Democratic party. It proposes repealing labour and pension reforms and boosting public spending. 

Friday, March 2, 2018

What Comes Next is Fascism

With the Italian general election a few days away The New York Times is definitely gunning for the Five Star Movement (M5S). Yesterday it was "The Mystery Man Who Runs Italy’s ‘Five Star’ From the Shadows." Today it is "Will Russia Meddle in Italy’s Election? It May Not Have To." Both are written by Jason Horowitz, the Rome bureau chief, who is a journalistic hit man specializing in tabloid  smears. He held the "Get Bernie" portfolio in 2016. After Sunday, The Times will probably send Horowitz to the next election hot spot so he can peddle his fictions and innuendo.

Horowitz is tarring M5S as corrupt, opaque and a Russian cutout; the young people who are the base of the party's support, shameful dupes, much like the kids who swelled Bernie's ranks.

It is fascinating to bear witness to the propaganda organs of the Democratic center as it implodes. The only argument on offer is an omniscient Russian meddling. There is never any substantive discussion of why the Socialists in France, why the SPD in Germany, why Matteo Renzi's Democratic Party in Italy are performing worse than ever before. The only reason given is the evil Putin somehow pulling strings from the Kremlin. Call it the present-day version of the stab-in-the-back myth.

It is the same in the United States. When you talk to a stalwart Democratic she will talk first of Russian meddling. There is no positive vision of the future. Even "Medicare For All" is dismissed with the exasperated question, "Well, who is going to pay for it?"

The Democratic center, mainstream neoliberalism, is at its end. What comes next -- unless new parties like M5S or a Momentum-captured Labour catch on -- is fascism.

Thursday, March 1, 2018

Liberals Beginning to Question Cold War 2.0?

A good article this morning picked up from Niqnaq is BuzzFeed's "Stop Blaming Russian Bots For Everything," by Miriam Elder and Charlie Wartzel. Elder and Wartzel are Russophobic. For instance, they believe the DNC hack was perpetrated by Russia. Nonetheless they can't abide recent excesses in the prestige press that link every bit of dissent within the U.S. to a Kremlin-engineered bot. In other words, there is an element within the shrinking liberal consensus that sees that the New Cold War as a pit trap:
By now you know the drill: massive news event happens, journalists scramble to figure out what’s going on, and within a couple hours the culprit is found — Russian bots.
Russian bots were blamed for driving attention to the Nunes memo, a Republican-authored document on the Trump-Russia probe. They were blamed for pushing for Roy Moore to win in Alabama’s special election. And here they are wading into the gun debate following the Parkland shooting. “[T]he messages from these automated accounts, or bots, were designed to widen the divide and make compromise even more difficult,” wrote the New York Times in a story following the shooting, citing little more than “Twitter accounts suspected of having links to Russia.”
This is, not to mince words, total bullshit.
The thing is, nearly every time you see a story blaming Russian bots for something, you can be pretty sure that the story can be traced back to a single source: the Hamilton 68 dashboard, founded by a group of respected researchers, including Clint Watts and JM Berger, and currently run under the auspices of the German Marshall Fund.
But even some of the people who popularized that metric now acknowledge it’s become totally overblown.
“I’m not convinced on this bot thing,” said Watts, the cofounder of a project that is widely cited as the main, if not only, source of information on Russian bots. He also called the narrative “overdone.”
The dashboard monitors 600 Twitter accounts “linked to Russian influence efforts online,” according to its own description, which means the accounts are not all directly traced back to Kremlin efforts, or even necessarily to Russia. “They are not all in Russia,” Watts said during a phone interview last week. “We don’t even think they’re all commanded in Russia — at all. We think some of them are legitimately passionate people that are just really into promoting Russia.” So, not bots.
We’ll likely never know the contents of the list for sure — because the researchers decline to divulge the identity of who they are monitoring. (The reasons they give for secrecy include worries that the accounts would then change their behavior and concerns over identifying accounts that are not, in fact, linked to Russian influence efforts, aka making a mistake.)