Showing posts with label 2018 midterms. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2018 midterms. Show all posts

Thursday, November 8, 2018

2018 Midterms: Realignment Election

This morning World Socialist Web Site argues that the European elite, based on press reaction to Tuesday's midterms in the United States, believe Trump is here to stay and the constituents of the "indispensable nation" have fully embraced fascism.

That's way off base. Trump showed the inherent weakness of the Bannon strategy of catering to a hard-shell Dixiecrat base. Yes, Trump triumphed in the senate, but that victory only highlighted the essentially undemocratic nature of the U.S. Senate.

The piece to read this morning is Thomas Edsall's "The Polarizer-in-Chief Meets the Midterms." Edsall goes into the Trump lock on the senate. He also succinctly lays out the import of the 2018 midterms in his opening paragraphs. Basically, thanks to Trump, it was a realignment election, but not in the ways the Republican Party wants:
There is no clearer sign of the changing shape of the Democratic coalition than the fact that going into the 2018 midterm elections, six of the 20 richest congressional districts were represented by Republicans but that when the new Congress is sworn in, all 20 will be represented by Democrats.
The Democratic Party is continuing to extend its core support among minority constituencies — now 41 percent of the Democratic electorate— into upscale, often suburban, areas as college-educated white women abandon the Republican Party in droves and as education, more broadly, becomes a new partisan dividing line.
There are, to give another example, 13 well-to-do congressional districts that voted for Mitt Romney in 2012 and Hillary Clinton in 2016. All 13 have Republican congressman. On Tuesday, Democrats won 10 of those districts.
What European observers don't understand about U.S. politics is it never strays far from the Civil War. That's bedrock. Needless to say, it's not terribly wise to base a strategy for national governance on the Lost Cause.

Thursday, March 8, 2018

Texas Reveals No Wave. Democratic Crackup is Coming.

Lambert Strether's Water Cooler from yesterday examined the numbers from this week's primary election in Texas:
TX: “Here’s what happened in the 2018 Texas primaries” [Texas Monthly]. Some snippets: 1. “More than 1.5 million people voted in the Republican primary, with close to 100 percent reporting, compared to about 1 million Democrats, also with a near 100 percent reporting.” Hard to see how that signals a wave that will “turn Texas Blue,” as the slogan has it, though of course that doesn’t preclude the pickup of individual seats. 2. “Laura Moser secured a slot in the party’s primary runoff Tuesday, despite rare attempts [Rare? Really?] by national Democrats to end her bid over concerns she is too liberal for the district. Moser, (24%) a journalist and activist, will face attorney Lizzie Pannill Fletcher (30%) in the May 22 runoff — which will likely be a brutal intra-party fight and could divide west Houston and the national Democratic Party.” I’d be happier if there were 10 such races.
But according to Musa al-Gharbi in "About That Blue Wave …" the Texas results don't point to Dems picking up Lone Star congressional districts:
As for the specific seats Democrats hope to capture in November, it appears that Republicans would retain control if the races were decided on the basis of Tuesday’s primary vote. Democrats have a lot of work to do to catch up.
But just as important, if not more so, there were marked differences between the parties in terms of the tone of their primaries.
On the Democratic side, there was bitter internal strife, dating back to the previous election cycle, between the “establishment” Democrats and the populist “Berniecrats.” Many of the latter are not committed partisans: While they are highly motivated to support populists, many refuse to lend their support to more conventional Democratic candidates. As we saw in 2016, many former Sanders supporters sat out the general election, voted for a third-party candidate or voted for Donald Trump.
Democrats should be concerned about their ability to mobilize populists in the races “establishment” figures won. So the party could find itself facing another enthusiasm deficit for many key races, even with Mr. Trump in the White House.
On the Republican side, there was clear unity behind the president and his party. The races were mostly about which candidate was most supportive of President Trump. As a result, it seems likely that Republican voters will support whoever is on their ticket in the general election.
We can count on Republican primary voters to turn out in November as well. Republicans reliably vote in midterms, and again it is important to note that primary patterns suggest that enthusiasm is particularly high in the Republican base this year, too.
The base GOP voter likes his guy, Trump, while the base Democratic voter is split. One part of the base feeds at the MSNBC trough and is praying for a Joe Biden run; the other is sharpening its pitchforks as Bernie readies for another presidential campaign.

Trump is going to have his base solidly beneath him. (It turns out those tariffs on aluminum and steel were part of the NAFTA negotiations.) Partisan Dems are going to have to be broken. It is existential crisis. Biden is not the answer. All he has to offer is Russophobia. And what does that get a voter at the end of the day? Nothing.

The successful teachers strike in West Virginia shows the way forward. See "What the Teachers Won":
First of all, if we can do it, anybody can do it. It’s not like we’re a special group of activist teachers who have been studying for twenty years about how to mobilize the working class. We’re not. 
Another one of the big lessons I’ve learned is that you need to organize people around a specific issue. For us, it was the insurance. That’s a big-tent issue that affected one in seven West Virginians. It meant that we had a large base of support.
Bernie has it -- Medicare for All, and he's campaigning on it. The partisan Dems only have Russiaphobia. It's not going to work. The Dems might keep Bernie from the nomination again, but it's not going to beat Trump. If Bernie does manage a miracle and capture the party's nomination, expect a well-funded third-party challenge. And Trump wins again.

Monday, March 5, 2018

Democratic Wave Unlikely This Year. Then the Party Splits in 2020.

Last week there were a number of stories on the upcoming wave election for the Democrats in November, the most emphatic of which might have been Sean McElwee's "The Midterms and the Turn Leftward": "Democrats will take the House, probably winning around forty seats."

Dems need to pick up 24 seats. I'm not saying that it can't happen, but I'm just skeptical that it will. A lot of the "Democratic wave" prognostications appear to be based on the generic ballot, a wholly unreliable lens to look at the myriad individual congressional races. Lambert Strether's Water Cooler from last Wednesday had these two items:
  • “Dems surge in generic ballot as economy fades from spotlight” [The Hill]. “[P]ollsters warn that the generic ballot is better as a gauge of the entire electorate’s mood than as a predictor of outcomes in individual races. In the Senate, Democrats are defending 25 seats, while Republicans are only tasked with defending eight seats. Many of the GOP incumbents are running in states that Trump won handily in 2016, while several Democrats are running in states Trump won by double-digit margins. Pollsters say not to read too deeply into generic ballot polling at this early stage, pointing to the extreme volatility in the polls in recent weeks. Over the past month, polls have put the Democratic advantage everywhere from 2 points to 16 points.”
  • “Democratic National Committee war plan: Target 50 million voters” [NBC News]. “The DNC, which has struggled financially and faced doubts about its relevance, will focus its 2018 organizing plans for the midterms around partnerships with a wide range of groups aimed at boosting turnout among Democratic-leaning voters, who have been less likely to get to the polls in recent nonpresidential elections.” Wake me when the Democrat party makes voter registration and expanding the base a core party function, 24/7/365, instead of a random, election by election effort. (Oh, and a political version of Conway’s Law seems to be at work: Liberals think of themselves as an aggregation of silos (mostly identity-based silos), hence the “partnerships with a wide range of groups,” i.e. not a core party function.
Last week Trump announced his tariffs on aluminum and steel. If this is sincere, and not some hocus pocus to screen his failure to overhaul NAFTA, then Trump has secured the continued allegiance of his base MAGA voter.

A president's first midterm is supposed to be a plebiscite on his performance. If true, and assuming the U.S. is not drawn deeper into Syria and/or attacks North Korea and/or falls into recession, then I think the GOP will perform better than expected.

Granted, Trump's tariffs cut against the grain, creating a situation where Paul Ryan is criticizing Trump while Sherrod Brown is praising him. But I doubt there will be many blue-collar districts where the Republican on the ballot distances himself from Trump.

The biggest wake-up for Democrats has to be the ongoing collapse of the center-left in Europe. Yes, the SPD membership in Germany strongly backed GroKo. But it will be the last GroKo. What has to give U.S. Democrats pause is the failure of Italy's Democratic Party (PD). Today Matteo Renzi announced his resignation. PD managed 23% less than 20% of the vote.

The Democratic Party in the U.S. is splitting. Machine pols are battling the new liberal power, the #MeToos. And this is just a tune-up for the main event come 2020 --  Bernie redux.

Bernie redux will be Armageddon for the Democratic Party. The Democratic Party will block Bernie again. And once again it will lose a close general election to Trump.

But let's imagine a successful wave, a children's crusade that topples the DNC leadership and nominates Bernie. What happens then? Mike Bloomberg or some other billionaire bankrolls a centrist third party a la En Marche!, dooming the party of Jackson and Van Buren.

We can only hope.

Thursday, February 8, 2018

The Wave Won't Come

The GOP-controlled congress appears keen to turn the page on the shutdown politics that have dominated the nation for the last seven years. Democrats are willing to go along -- January's mini-shutdown proved to be a debacle for the party -- and they're hoping that Pelosi's eight-hour Dreamers speech yesterday on the House floor will somehow mollify and inspire #Resistance and make groups like Indivisible forget promises made that there would be no budget deal, no lifting of the debt limit, until the Dreamers were taken care of. Well, that's obviously not going to happen.

Thomas Kaplan provides the basics of the McConnell-Schumer budget deal in "Senate Leaders Reach Budget Deal to Raise Spending Over Two Years":
WASHINGTON — Senate leaders struck a far-reaching bipartisan agreement on Wednesday that would add hundreds of billions of dollars to military and domestic programs over the next two years while raising the federal debt limit, moving to end the cycle of fiscal showdowns that have roiled the Capitol.
The accord between Senators Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the majority leader, and Chuck Schumer of New York, his Democratic counterpart, would raise strict caps on military and domestic spending that were imposed in 2011 as part of a deal with President Barack Obama that was once seen as a key triumph for Republicans in Congress.
The deal would raise the spending caps by about $300 billion over two years. The limit on military spending would be increased by $80 billion in the current fiscal year and $85 billion in the next year, which begins Oct. 1. The limit on nondefense spending would increase by $63 billion this year and $68 billion next year.
[snip]
From the increase in domestic spending, Mr. Schumer said the deal includes $20 billion for infrastructure, $6 billion for the opioid crisis and mental health, $5.8 billion for child care and $4 billion for veterans hospitals and clinics. In addition, the deal includes almost $90 billion in disaster relief in response to last year’s hurricanes and wildfires.
The agreement includes an additional four-year extension of funding for the Children’s Health Insurance Program, on top of the six-year extension that Congress approved last month.
The deal also lifts the debt limit until March 2019, pushing any future confrontation over that issue until after the midterm elections. The Congressional Budget Office recently projected that the Treasury would probably run out of cash in the first half of March if the limit were not raised.
[snip]
The Senate was expected to vote on the deal on Thursday, with the House to follow afterward. It was not clear if enough Democrats would oppose the deal to imperil its passage in the House, given the likely opposition from at least some fiscal conservatives. If lawmakers cannot pass a temporary funding measure by the end of Thursday — either tied to the budget pact or by itself — the government would shut down for the second time this year.
Pelosi promises a "No" vote on the budget. But will she be able to bring enough rank'n'file Democrats with her -- after adding many likely Republican "No" votes from the Freedom Caucus -- to block the budget deal?

Highly unlikely. Pelosi's opposition is purely ceremonial. Democrats won't trigger another shutdown because they know that Trump will eat them alive.

So the Democrats are back to where they were before the rise of #Resistance. The Resistance has been foiled by Democratic leadership. Will this spur a break with the Democratic Party? That's the only move to make. A no-brainer, right?  But it's not going to happen.

What will happen is Democratic turnout will likely fall short in November. You need proof of live to go to the polls. And there's nothing alive about the Dems. The wave election will not appear.

Tuesday, January 16, 2018

It's "Shithole" vs. "Shithouse": Don't Bet on a Government Shutdown this Week

The basis for Trump's claims that Senator Dick Durbin lied about the profanity the president used in a White House meeting last week on DACA apparently -- and unbelievably -- boils down to "shithole" versus "shithouse." According to a fine story, "As Shutdown Talk Rises, Trump’s Immigration Words Pose Risks for Both Parties," by Jonathan Martin, Michael Shear and Sheryl Gay Stolberg:
. . . Mr. Durbin, who told local reporters in Illinois on Monday that he stood by his account of Thursday’s meeting with the president.
“I know what happened. I stand behind every word I said,” he said, adding that he is focused on the immigration legislation “full time.”
A White House official who spoke on condition of anonymity suggested on Monday that Mr. Trump had said “shithouse countries,” not “shithole countries.” Mr. Durbin expressed disbelief that anyone would see a substantive difference between the terms.
“I stick with my original interpretation. I am stunned that this is their defense,” he said.
Two Republican officials independently said on Monday that Mr. Trump had said the original phrase.
 A government shutdown looms by the end of the week if a deal can't be reached on the Dreamers:
Mr. Short [Marc Short, White House legislative director] said the current proposal devised by Mr. Graham and Mr. Durbin did not do enough to satisfy the president’s demands for enhanced border security. And, he said, it failed to broadly end what Republicans call “chain migration,” a process by which American citizens can eventually bring their extended families into the United States over a period of many years.
Mr. Short argued that the current proposal would actually increase the ability of DACA recipients to bring some family members into the country since, under their current legal status, they are barred from sponsoring entry for anyone else.
“Their proposal only expands chain migration for that group,” he said.
Under pressure from immigrant rights activists, Democrats are likely to resist broader efforts to limit immigrants from sponsoring their family members, an idea that Democrats view favorably as “family reunification” — a part of American immigration law for decades.
Mr. Short also urged Democrats to put off efforts to address immigrants from Haiti, Honduras, El Salvador and other countries who have been in the United States under a program called Temporary Protected Status. The Graham-Durbin plan called for issuing new visas for those immigrants after the Trump administration said they would end T.P.S. status for people from those countries.
“I don’t think we envision it as part of this deal,” Mr. Short said of the T.P.S. program. “That expands it into comprehensive immigration reform.”
And then there is the wall. Trump wants any deal on DACA to include funds for his beautiful wall along the southern border.

DACA negotiations are splitting both parties, but the Democrats more so. It's 2016 all over again, the social democrats versus the neoliberals:
For Democratic lawmakers, the pressure from their left flank to demand relief for the Dreamers is only rising.
“We are going to be telling Democrats the following: If you vote for a spending bill that does not include relief for Dreamers, you are voting for funds that will be used to deport Dreamers,” said Frank Sharry, executive director of America’s Voice, an immigrants rights group.
But the wisdom of eventually forcing a shutdown to shield the migrants is dividing the party.
Some Democratic strategists, such as former Representative Steve Israel of New York, said Democrats should seize their leverage now that Republicans already have enough political headaches, namely the president’s historic unpopularity.
“They absolutely have the upper hand as a matter of policy and as also as a matter of politics,” said Mr. Israel. “Republicans cannot afford to shut down the government in one of the roughest midterm environments they’ve ever had. Democrats have the upper hand and they should play the upper hand.”
Yet to other Democrats, forcing a government shutdown in the same fashion that congressional Republicans did in President Barack Obama’s second term would be to take a considerable political risk, the legislative equivalent of the nuclear option.
“It looks like a big Washington mess to people,” said David Axelrod, Mr. Obama’s former top strategist. “Dealing with Trump is obviously a very, very difficult issue not just for Democrats but for Republicans because he is so mercurial and unreliable. The question is: Have you reached that point now where you want to employ what is the most explosive tool in your toolbox?”
Or as Ms. McCaskill put it: “I am not interested in drawing a line in sand as negotiations continue because I think that’s how negotiations get blown up.”
The Axelrod quote makes it clear that a government shutdown is unlikely. As Martin et al. write earlier in the story:
Ten Democratic senators are on the ballot this November in states that are heavily white, have little sympathy for undocumented immigrants and that Mr. Trump won. Many of these lawmakers have no desire to force a government shutdown over an immigration issue. Some of the party’s most at-risk seats are in Missouri, Indiana, West Virginia and North Dakota.
If they side with Senate Republicans, Congress could pass yet another short-term spending bill by Friday that would end the shutdown threat for now as negotiations continue.
 At this point it is all about those midterms. Democrats, with the exception of potential presidential candidates angling for 2020, are hugging the center line in the belief that 2018 is going to be a wave election when the mythical white suburban moderate -- the one who didn't vote for Hillary -- will come to the polls to cast a ballot for the Democrat. So don't expect a government shutdown this week.