Showing posts with label 2018 Italian General Elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2018 Italian General Elections. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 5, 2018

M5S-League Policy Priorities + California Primary Today

UPDATE: There is a good rundown on the California primary by FiveThirtyEight's Nathaniel Rakich, "California’s Jungle Primary Might Screw Over Both Parties." It goes into some depth about the congressional districts in play. In several of the races the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee has actually made things worse by backing the moneybags candidate over the favorite or the choice of the state party.

One vital point made is that if the GOP is locked out in the big races -- governor, U.S. senate -- at the top of the ticket, it is going to depress conservative turnout come November:
Both California’s senatorial and gubernatorial races were always going to be safely Democratic in this D+26 state, so it may seem like no big deal if Republicans fail to advance in them. It’s even happened before: Democrats Kamala Harris and Loretta Sanchez were the top two vote-getters in the 2016 Senate primary before facing off in the general election. But this year, without a presidential race on the ballot, the races for Senate and governor matter more than just for their own sake. As the two races headlining California’s 2018 ballot, they have the power to drive turnout across this state of 40 million — and all 53 of its congressional races.
A Republican shutout at the top of the ticket could depress conservative turnout statewide, perhaps nudging districts where the Republican is currently favored, like the 4th and 21st, more toward the toss-up column. That could damage the party’s chances in a dozen swing districts, not just in one, like a shutout in an individual House race would. In 2014, poor turnout in “orphan states” — those without competitive races for governor or Senate — cost Democrats House seats that they didn’t even know were in danger. The biggest consequence of the jungle primary could be that California becomes 2018’s version of an orphan state — for Republicans.
**** 

Today and tomorrow the Five Star Movement (M5S)-League government is seeking approval from parliament. Every indication is that the Italian senate will provide its backing today with the lower house following along tomorrow.

Now is a good time to list some of the main policy objectives of the anti-establishment government because the only one you are going to be reminded of is the League's hostility to immigrants. The list is provided by AFP's The Local, "Here are the key proposals from the M5S-League government programme":
On Italy's debt
Italy is battling a public debt of €2.3 trillion, 132 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) – the second highest ratio in the EU behind Greece. The M5S-League coalition promises to stimulate the economy through more spending.
"The government's actions will target a programme of public debt reduction not through revenue based on taxes and austerity, policies that have not achieved their goal, but rather through increased GDP by the revival of internal demand," the document says.
Just four sentences of the document dealt with the public debt and deficit.
On the EU
The eurosceptic coalition promises a series of measures to reign in the EU including renegotiation of EU treaties and a review of the bloc's economic governance on issues such as the single currency.
On tax and 'basic income'
The League has inserted its flat tax policy into the programme, adding a 20 percent rate to the 15 percent proposed before the election. Also included is Five Star's flagship basic income plan, which sees €780 a month paid to those with no revenue, while those earning less than the basic will see their income topped up. It will be revoked from anyone who refuses three job offers within two years.
On immigration
The parties pledge to stop "the business" of migration, cracking down on smuggling networks and cooperatives that manage asylum centres. They also want to speed up expulsions of illegal immigrants.
They demand Italy have "a decisive role" in European negotiations on migration and want to accelerate the examination of asylum applications and systematic repatriation of rejected applicants, who can be held up to 18 months in detention centres.
On Islam
Also mooted are a registry of imams, immediate closure of unauthorized mosques and the inclusion of "community involvement" into a new law on the building of mosques.
On southern Italy
The parties decided not to outline specific measures targeting the south of the country, which has historically had a higher level of unemployment and poverty and a lower level of public services. This decision was taken "in the knowledge that all the political choices in this contract... are oriented towards a homogeneous economic development for the country".
On pensions
A gradual roll back of a retirement that is due to reach 67 in 2019, instead enabling retirement when the sum of a person's age and years of social security contributions reach 100.
On security
In the name of self-defence individuals would be allowed to shoot anyone who enters their home, even in the absence of a clear physical threat. This is something Salvini's League has campaigned for after several high-profile cases in which people have faced charges for shooting burglars.
New prisons would be constructed, "as many foreign prisoners as possible" sent to serve sentences in their home country and large numbers of police officers -- all equipped with a video camera -- and carabinieri military police recruited. The parties also want tougher sentences for sexual crimes and under-age offenders.
On Russia
The "contract" underlines Italy's place in the Atlantic alliance "with the United States as a privileged partner", but asks for the immediate removal of sanctions against Russia "which should not be perceived as a threat but as an economic and commercial partner". Both parties have courted Russia in recent years.
On institutional reforms
Among the more drastic proposals is slashing the number of parliamentarians to 400 MPs (from 630) and 200 senators (from 318). All would be banned from changing political parties during the legislature. They also want to beef up the use of popular referenda in law-making and grant more power to the regions.
On corruption
A "severe and incisive anti-corruption law" is planned to recover resources and boost competitiveness. The parties propose increased penalties, life-time banishment from public office and the introduction of "agents provocateurs" to test the honesty of officials.
On the economy
Setting up an unspecified legal minimum wage, blocking the sale of the Alitalia airline and completely re-negotiating the controversial Turin-Lyon high-speed railway are all in the plan, which also sets out measures to increase savings protection and the accountability of both the management and supervisory authorities of banks.
 
The development of the "green-economy" and use of electric cars is also a priority.
On politics and society
The document proposes that no-one convicted of corruption, being investigated for serious crimes or Freemasons can become ministers, while conflict of interest criteria for parliamentarians will be beefed up. 
Italy's commitments to international military missions would be reassessed. 
To shore up Italy's collapsing birthrate, the state would offer free nursery schooling for children of "Italian families" (whether this would in fact include all families resident in Italy is unclear) and not apply VAT on early childhood products. All illegal Roma camps to be closed and Roma children who don't attend school removed from their families. 
More stringent regulations on the gambling industry are mooted, including a complete ban on advertising and sponsorship.
If the new government can deliver on pension reform, a basic income,thereby stimulating growth, it can expect to be in power for a long time. That's why the stakes are high. The neoliberals will do everything they can to hamper the implementation of these proposals.

****

Today is the primary election in California. There are a number of congressional districts (seven or eight) in the southern part of the state that have been deemed to be in play because Hillary out-preformed Trump there in 2016. (See Adam Nagourney's "California Midterm Elections: What to Expect From the June 5 Primaries.")

If the Democrats have any chance of reclaiming the House of Representatives this fall it is going to be based on their performance in California. After today's primary we should have a better idea of the size of the often discussed "Blue Wave."

My sense -- after several months of skepticism -- is that there will be a Blue Wave. Democrats are more motivated than Republicans by a sizable margin. Motivation is what matters in elections. 

Friday, June 1, 2018

The Takeaway from Italy: A Big Loss for the Neoliberal Consensus

The cabinet of the new M5S-League government was accepted by president Mattarella. Paolo Savona, the economist whose rejection as finance minister set off the political crisis, was merely shuffled to the minister for EU affairs. As Yves Smith notes,
It is far from clear how much the coalition retreated. Savona, the proposed firebrand economy minister, is the Minister for EU affairs, and chose another Eurozone doubter, Giiovanni Tria, as finance minister. Given that it is the Finance minister that is a member of the Eurogroup, and members of the European Parliament that have some sway with the European Commission, this posting in and of itself looks like a way for Savona to poke a stick in the eye of European officials. His bully pulpit may be more important than his formal influence. But he could also influence other Cabinet members.
Jason Horowitz is up to his usual tricks. Rather than acknowledge the obvious -- that it's a big win for M5S and the League; that the neoliberals seriously erred in their attempt to block the new government; that and Mattarella's appointment of an IMF bureaucrat as prime minister was such an obvious farce it had to be immediately excused -- Horowitz disingenuously summarizes,
An inconclusive election led to months of stalemate. Mr. Mattarella threatened to form a caretaker government, which triggered the formation of an alliance between the Five Star and League parties. After weeks of intense negotiations, they presented a prime minister and a cabinet that Mr. Mattarella rejected.
The president was about to exercise his authority to create a caretaker government but held off, as the populist parties struggled to give it another shot.
Mr. Di Maio, 31, triumphant after his party claimed a third of the March vote, was this week reduced to imploring Mr. Salvini to abandon his calls for another election. With grumbling growing inside his own party, Mr. Di Maio needed help forming a government.
This is not what happened at all. What happened is that the neoliberal center collapsed literally overnight when its god the market rejected Mattarella's move. There was zero chance of the Cottarelli technocratic government surviving a confidence vote. It's a huge loss for the neoliberal governing consensus. That's the takeaway.

Thursday, May 31, 2018

It's Luigi Di Maio of the Five Star Movement, Not the League's Matteo Salvini, Who is the Real Power

Well, the technocratic government of Carlo Cottarelli, the one president Sergio Mattarella blessed after tomahawking the M5S-League combine, is being hastily and quietly dismissed. The negative reaction of the divine market quickly made it apparent to Mattarella that he had blundered enormously. Cottarelli would not survive a confidence vote, and it would be back to the campaign hustings as early as July. Matteo Salvini of the League and Luigi Di Maio of the Five Star Movement (M5S) would pad their parliamentary majority.

So Salvini and Di Maio are back to negotiating with Mattarella. The deal, depending on where you read about it, involves getting rid of Paolo Savona as minister of the economy. The Guardian reports that
The leader of the Italian far-right party the League, Matteo Salvini, has cancelled political rallies to return to Rome, in what was seen as a sign that a political impasse that has left the country without a fully functioning government for months may soon be coming to an end.
Salvini was heading back to the capital to meet his coalition partner, Luigi Di Maio, the head of the anti-establishment Five Star Movement, after the Italian president, Sergio Mattarella, gave the pair more time to form a government.
Italian press reports indicated that any agreement to form a new populist government involving the League, formerly known as the Northern League, and M5S would include the nomination – again – of Giuseppe Conte, a formerly obscure law professor, to serve as prime minister.
But Di Maio and Salvini are expected to back down on their earlier insistence that Paolo Savona, a Eurosceptic who has called Italy’s adoption of the euro a “historic mistake”, should serve as finance minister.
The odious Jason Horowitz, writing for The New York Times, sees another element to the bargain. Not only is Savona out, but so too is Conte:
But simultaneous negotiations with the Five Star Movement seemed to center on a top official in his party, Giancarlo Giorgetti, taking the position of prime minister. Some analysts speculated that Mr. Salvini coveted the position himself, and that he had the leverage of Mr. Savona, and his own popularity, to force the Five Star leadership to accept.
The Five Star Movement, reluctant to give up its primacy in the alliance, after winning nearly a third of the Italian vote, is resisting, according to reports in the Italian press. And Mr. Mattarella, who is very much an audience of one for all of the political performances, would also have to sign off.
It appears that Di Maio has the upper hand here. While Salvini has been strutting and preening, Di Maio has been trying to salvage the nascent M5S-League government. His reasonableness is conveyed by the Guardian quote,
Di Maio said that if a deal could not be reached, he favoured snap elections. “There are two paths ahead. Either we launch the Conte government with a reasonable solution or we vote right away,” he said.
For all the talk that Salvini is surging, I would not rule out M5S as the party on the rise. Di Maio has displayed his prowess.

Wednesday, May 30, 2018

Why Italy is Important: The Neoliberal Center No Longer Believes Its Own Prescriptions

Isn't the irony rich that markets are responding so negatively to the diktats of their champions? The M5S-League government was aborted in deference to the wisdom of the markets, and the markets have deemed this an unwise decision. As Yves Smith says this morning in "NIRP’s Revenge: Italian Bonds Plunge, Worst Day in Decades":
Yves here. While Mr. Market got in quite a tizzy today over 5 Star and Lega’s abandonment of their effort to form a coalition government after the President Sergio Mattarella nixed their choice of economy minister, Paolo Savona. This has produced a first-class political crisis. The technocrats, in trying to appease Mr. Market, has done the reverse.
The Times editorial board spins this obvious blunder -- this is the preferred argument du jour for neoliberals -- as a necessary move to allow Italian voters to come to their senses:
However spooked the markets were, they had been equally wary of the coalition and its grandiose spending plans, and given the mutual hostility of the coalition partners, their government might not have survived for long. Mr. Mattarella’s stand, at least, gives Italian voters a second chance to weigh their options after glimpsing what their earlier choices might mean. That’s something some Brexit voters in Britain, or Trump voters in the United States, might have welcomed.
Such an argument doesn't appeal to Italians though, as Steven Erlanger notes in his lengthy write-up, "Italy Pushes Euro to Fore, the Last Place Europe Wants It":
On Tuesday, the European Commissioner for the budget, Günther H. Oettinger, a German, told the broadcaster Deutsche Welle that the markets and a “darkened outlook” would teach the Italians to vote for the right thing. 
They may yet do so, but it’s impolitic to say so, especially for a Brussels-based German.
One of the first to point out the offense was Mr. Di Maio himself, who in his own message on Twitter called the remark “absurd.”
“These people treat Italy like a summer colony where they come to vacation,” Mr. Di Maio wrote. “But in a few months a government of change will be born and Europe will finally respect us.”
Di Maio is right; hence, the market reaction.

This marks an important turning. The neoliberal center no longer believes in its own prescriptions.

Friday, May 18, 2018

Another Brexit-Size Shock to the EU?

It finally happened. A government is on the verge of being formed in Italy.

Italian parliamentary elections took place on March 4, followed by round after round of inconclusive negotiations. The main sticking point for the top vote-getting party, the Five Star Movement (M5S), was the center-right's insistence that Silvio Berlusconi be prime minister.

Once the League's Matteo Salvini agreed to sideline the octogenarian -- the League is the real power of the center-right coalition, not Berlusconi's Forza Italia -- things got cooking; that, and president Sergio Mattarella threatened to name a technocratic caretaker government.

The League-M5S plan has been published, and it has two components that are sure to stir things up: an end to the EU sanctions on Russia and an increase in debt spending. RT crows, "Italy’s anti-establishment Five Star Movement and Lega Nord parties have called for an immediate lifting of sanctions imposed on Russia." Reuters outlines other features of the plan:
The document, published after 11 weeks of political stalemate in the euro zone’s third-largest economy, calls for billions of euros in tax cuts, additional spending on welfare for the poor, and a roll-back of pension reforms.
The euro sank on the latest developments on Friday and was headed for its fifth straight weekly fall against the dollar, in what would be a first for the currency since 2015.
The possibility of a eurosceptic government in Rome is shaking investor confidence ... at this point, a larger fiscal deficit and greater bond issuance (in Italy) does seem likely,” said David Madden, a strategist at CMC Markets.
The euro gave up gains and fell 0.2 percent to $1.1778 after the Italian parties outlined their economic plans. It settled near a five-month low reached on Wednesday of $1.1763.
The final accord dropped a previous draft proposal, seen by Reuters, to create fiscal headroom by adjusting the formula used to calculate debt burdens in the EU, and contained nothing questioning Italy’s membership of the euro.
But it still called for a review of EU governance and fiscal rules — setting the stage for the bloc’s biggest political challenge since Britain voted to leave two years ago.
So we're right back to back to Syriza 2015 and the question of whether a nation-state can change course through democratic elections or is the status quo so cemented in place that nothing short of armed rebellion can alter the neoliberal Washington Consensus.

The neoliberals are pining for Mattarella to take control, which Politico encapsulates here:
What role does the president play?
If the deal passes muster with members, the parties will present it to President Mattarella. As guarantor of Italy’s constitution and international treaties, he has the power to approve or reject ministers and even specific bills in the government’s program if he deems them to be unaffordable. He can even reject the coalition government altogether and appoint his own — a power that has been used once before, in 1953.
M5S's Luigi di Maio and Salvini are going to meet with Mattarella Monday. M5S members are currently voting online whether to support the new government. The candidate for prime minister has yet to be named.

Signs are good that an M5S-League government will be the real deal. Reuters says that, "Salvini’s pre-election ally, former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, accused him of betraying their centre-right electoral alliance and urged him to back out of the deal with Di Maio and 'come back home'."

The U.S. is already making threats about upending Russian sanctions. From Politico:
In June, the European Council will have to roll over the Russian sanctions that the two parties strongly oppose. Last month Kurt Volker, U.S. President Donald Trump’s special envoy for Ukraine, warned Rome that “Italy cannot lift the measures without serious consequences.”
An outbreak of European democracy comes just at the right time. The U.S. is trying to maintain the Continent's vassalage as Trump lurches from brinkmanship in East Asia to the Middle East.

The Washington Consensus is now clearly held together by nothing other than war -- economic warfare, armed conflict, genocide and information war. May the consensus collapse as soon as possible.

Tuesday, March 6, 2018

NYT's Roger Cohen Calls for Central Banker Draghi to Run Italy

UPDATE: The animal wails emanating from The New York Times opinion page are hard to ignore. The cries and woe-is-me moans are all about Italy's general election results. David Brooks' "The Chaos After Trump" is a good example. His column concludes: "Vladimir Putin’s admirers are surging. The center is still hollowing out. Nothing is inevitable in life, but liberal democracy clearly ain’t going to automatically fix itself."

In all of this, as in The Times' unsigned editorial "Demagogues Win as Europe’s Populist Tide Sweeps Italy," there is this tone of exasperated victimization. The poor, poor elite who have been guzzling at the trough for decades are finally being abandoned by the voters. And make no mistake, the elitism is oozing out. Note the editorial's reference to M5S leader Di Maio's lack of a college degree:
The big winner, with about 32 percent of the vote, was the Five Star Movement, a grass-roots mélange of libertarians, progressives, Euroskeptics and other disenchanted voters formed less than a decade ago by a comedian, and now led by a 31-year-old college dropout, Luigi Di Maio. [Oh, my goodness!]
Or the very similar complaint by Brooks that Di Maio's never worked full-time
The big winner is the populist Five Star Movement, which was started by a comedian and is now led by a 31-year-old who had never held a full-time job. [Di Maio has been a member of the Italian Chamber of Deputies since 2013.]
It's all unhinged, panicked. Brooks at least calls out that the center is imploding. David Broder writing for Jacobin, "Notes on Italy’s Election," doesn't see M5S as a precursor to fascism, nor does he see it as in the same league as the UK's Momentum. Broder labels M5S as basically an uninspired technocratic, reformist movement. To which I would say,You could dismiss the entire progressive era of American political history on the same terms.
M5S parliamentarians have long abstained on controversial issues, from migration to gay rights, in order to maintain the movement’s “catch-all,” oppositional image. Entering government demands greater political definition. M5S promises to speak to “all political forces” — probably including the Lega — about the way ahead, but clearly risks being unbalanced should it ally with some more cohesive force. Yet while the party system is fluid, even a pact with the Lega will not automatically see voters turn back to the Left. If M5S could represent the forces of discontent, it could do this because what is still called the “center-left” has been hollowed out over decades.
The M5S is not an Italian Front National. It is not even a strongly Eurosceptic force, having abandoned this cause in the name of presenting a more “professional” and less “extreme” face. Nor does it offer some new democratic vision. Far from empowering citizens to mobilize for social change, its guru proposed a well-worn set of ideas based on removing “ideology” from the realm of state administration, in this drawing on the technocratic ideals of typewriter kingpin Adriano Olivetti. It repeats a hackneyed cry of making Italy a “normal country,” free of corruption and inefficiency, even though it has already abandoned its own anti-corruption charter.
Be that as it may, the M5S captured a wider discontent, and looks best placed to try and form a government. Its prime ministerial candidate Luigi Di Maio’s range of choices, plus the evident difficulties forming an opposite, grand coalition, mean that this could go on for several weeks. This will invariably feed a narrative of mounting “EU chaos” or “destabilization” coming from Rome. But least of all should we rely on the baleful tweets of Le Pen or Farage to tell us what is happening. Even if it does reach office, M5S is not about to bring down the EU (it already abandoned calls for a euro referendum) and nor is Fascism Returning in Its Historic Heartlands.
The rise of Lega and the M5S is grim news for anyone who believes in progressive politics, or who retains some memory of the Italian left’s past glories. In France, when Macron and Le Pen reached the second round, we could at least see that France Insoumise had laid down a marker. In the UK Labour has advanced, and even in the US the Sanders campaign provided a platform for left renewal. March 4 offered no such room for hope. But nor is panic about some alleged “rising fascism” going to offer it. As one old Marxist once put it: the old is dying, and something superficially different but not all that new has been born. May other things be born, and soon.
****

To get a whiff of dirty diapers read Roger Cohen's infantile "Italy’s Five-Star Electoral Performance." At the end he wails for ECB's Mario Draghi to save the day. It is unbelievable --
Other possibilities, none of which look stable, include a center-right coalition that would need outside support to have enough seats to govern and would presumably see the odious Salvini as prime minister; a far-fetched coalition of the Five Star Movement and the Left; or a German-style grand coalition that, as in Germany, would see the defeated mainstream parties trying to govern and would thereby fuel rage against democracies that refuse to heed what voters say.
Putin is certainly happy. Trump is likely happy. The giants of European unity and freedom — Alcide De Gasperi of Italy, Konrad Adenauer of Germany, Robert Schuman of France — are turning in their graves. The almost three decades since the fall of the Berlin Wall have been a long strange trip to the politics of the mob.
The wise Mario Draghi completes his term as governor of the European Central Bank in October. He’s the best answer to Italy’s problems I can see. Rome has seen empires come and go; it can see out the seven months until then.
What so strange about the reporting in the organs of the corporate press is that there is hardly ever an explanation of why, as Jason Horowitz put it in "Italy’s Surging Populists Run Into a Political Muddle. But for How Long?," "[A]nti-Democratic forces [are] sweeping up furious voters across Europe." It is as if arbitrarily a xenophobic steroidal rage has descended upon the continent. At least that's the sense one gets from reading The New York Times.

The answers are obvious: 1) a plutocratic economic order where the benefits of increased productivity have been vacuumed up by the rich, leaving the working class with longer hours of work and higher housing costs, and 2) perpetual warfare abroad, which is a principal cause of Europe's immigration crisis, and terrorist attacks at home. Who in her right mind would endorse such political outcomes year in and year out for decades? You would have to be insane (like Roger Cohen).

The encouraging news found in Horowitz's article is the Five Star Movement wants to govern and wants to govern based on issues-based ad hoc coalitions. Let's hope Europe's Russophobia is blown down and that a large national economy enacts a guaranteed basic income:
It now falls to Italy’s president, Sergio Mattarella, the keeper of its institutions and now the nation’s most powerful person, to find someone who can put together a stable government that can survive a confidence vote in the new parliament, which meets on March 23.
It doesn’t look easy. Any solution that does not include the Five Star Movement or the League, the hard-right, formerly northern-based secessionist party, will raise questions of democratic legitimacy.
“Mattarella can’t keep the populists out,” Massimo Franco, a political columnist with il Corriere della Sera, said in an interview.
“If he keeps the Five Star out, they’ll say that they have twice the votes of the League,” he continued. “If he keeps the League out, they will say that their coalition has more than the Five Star. We have two relative winners, that’s one of the problems.”
Luigi Di Maio, the Five Star Movement’s candidate for prime minister, made it clear on Monday that his party wanted to run things.

Sunday, March 4, 2018

Exit Polls Looking Good for Five Star Movement

UPDATE IV: A tweet from Antonello Guerrera is being hailed as the best summation so far of the Italian general election of 2018:
- M5S 1st party 
- Centre-right 1st coalition 
- Italy split in 3 
- Populist & anti-eurosceptic front close to 50% of votes 
- Renzi's PD collapsing
- Perfect hung parliament looming
Guerrero says that Renzi is likely to resign if the PD polls under 20%. We can only hope!

**** 

UPDATE III: Plenty of "fear and loathing" ahead from the prestige press over the badly hung parliament. But there is this helpful Guardian thumbnail sketch of the Five Star Movement. M5S is deemed a false-consciousness party by socialists and communists, a stalking horse for fascists. I have never seen M5S that way. I have seen the party as purely an "anti" construct -- anti-neoliberalism, anti-neoconservatism, anti-"staus quo of the last 40 years." It refuses to hemmed in and defined. As I said the other day, the best hope for rejuvenating moribund democracy in the West is M5S and Labour's Momentum:

"So, what exactly is the Five Star Movement?
"The anti-establisment party, started by comedian Beppe Grillo, burst onto the political scene in 2012 and has gone from strength to strength. The 69-year-old remains a figurehead, though he has handed over leadership to sharp-suited disciple Luigi Di Maio.
"Since its beginnings, the party has experienced a meteoric rise to prominence amid an outpouring of frustration and anger towards mainstream political parties.
"The movement calls itself “the first and only political party based on online participation and direct democracy.” Using an internet portal called Rousseau, M5S uses online votes of members to decide its policies, draft legislation and candidates.
M5S is proposing a universal basic income of €780 ($963) a month for those living in poverty.
"M5S supports a hotchpotch of policies from across the political spectrum and has gained a reputation for political flip-flopping, leading their critics to brand them as immature and incompetent. The party had promised its supporters a referendum on leaving the eurozone, but has had a change of heart in recent months.
"M5S is currently projected to be the single party with the largest share of votes in the election. You can read more about its moment of truth here.
****

UPDATE II: The state broadcaster Rai's first seat projection:
Centre-right 225-265
M5S 195-235
Centre-left 115-155
LEU 12-20
The chatter about possible coalitions has already begun. One being discussed is between M5S and Renzi's establishment Democratic Party (PD). Absurd! For sure, one conclusion that won't be lost in the chatter is the continuing failure of the mainstream center. Italians have "gone native," with M5S and Lega (what used to be the Northern League) the parties on the rise. Matteo Salvini is definitely photogenic:


****

UPDATE: From Guardian Rome bureau chief Stephanie Kirchgaessner:
"The Five Star Movement, an anti-establishment party that was founded by former comedian Beppe Grillo and has voiced deep scepticism about the euro and Italy’s role in NATO, appeared to have won between 29-31% of the votes, according to the early exit polls."
****

Five Star Movement is topping the exit polls. From The Guardian:
Italy’s national public broadcaster, Rai, has roughly comparable numbers in its first exit poll: 
M5S 29%-32%
Forza Italia 13-16% 
Lega 13-16% 
PD 20.5-23.5%
In its live election coverage The Guardian has this helpful breakdown of the policy positions of the various parties in today's election -- far more illuminating (by leaps and bounds) than any reporting provided by "the newspaper of record." For instance, in none of its reporting -- and I'm going by memory here; I might have missed one Berlusconi story --did it mention that Forza Italia favors a universal basic income (and more generous than that proposed by M5S!). Really and truly, The New York Times has become inseparable from the USG.

Centre-right: Forza Italia, led by four-time prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, aims to introduce a “parallel currency” for domestic use, keeping the euro for international trade; have a single, flat rate income tax for companies and individuals; abolish housing, inheritance and road tax; double the minimum pension; introduce a minimum income of €1,000 a month for all and block new immigrant arrivals.
Radical right: The League (formerly the Northern League), led by Matteo Salvini, would also introduce a parallel currency; abolish the EU’s fiscal compact; bring in a flat tax for all at 15%; allow earlier retirement; repatriate 100,000 illegal immigrants a year; and reopen Italy’s brothels. Brothers of Italy, led by Giorgia Meloni, is a southern equivalent of the League with neofascist roots and similar policies.
Anti-establishment: The Five Star Movement, led by 31-year-old Luigi Di Maio, proposes a minimum monthly income of €780; raising the budget deficit; repealing 400 “useless” laws including labour and pension reforms to allow earlier retirement and make firing harder; raising taxes on energy companies and improving relations with Russia.
Centre-left: The Democratic party, led by former prime minister Matteo Renzi, proposes an increase in the minimum wage; negotiating to abolish the fiscal compact and raising the budget deficit to 3% of GDP so as to cut taxes and increase investment.
Left: Free and Equal is led by Pietro Grasso, and is a new party uniting smaller groups that left Renzi’s Democratic party. It proposes repealing labour and pension reforms and boosting public spending. 

Friday, March 2, 2018

What Comes Next is Fascism

With the Italian general election a few days away The New York Times is definitely gunning for the Five Star Movement (M5S). Yesterday it was "The Mystery Man Who Runs Italy’s ‘Five Star’ From the Shadows." Today it is "Will Russia Meddle in Italy’s Election? It May Not Have To." Both are written by Jason Horowitz, the Rome bureau chief, who is a journalistic hit man specializing in tabloid  smears. He held the "Get Bernie" portfolio in 2016. After Sunday, The Times will probably send Horowitz to the next election hot spot so he can peddle his fictions and innuendo.

Horowitz is tarring M5S as corrupt, opaque and a Russian cutout; the young people who are the base of the party's support, shameful dupes, much like the kids who swelled Bernie's ranks.

It is fascinating to bear witness to the propaganda organs of the Democratic center as it implodes. The only argument on offer is an omniscient Russian meddling. There is never any substantive discussion of why the Socialists in France, why the SPD in Germany, why Matteo Renzi's Democratic Party in Italy are performing worse than ever before. The only reason given is the evil Putin somehow pulling strings from the Kremlin. Call it the present-day version of the stab-in-the-back myth.

It is the same in the United States. When you talk to a stalwart Democratic she will talk first of Russian meddling. There is no positive vision of the future. Even "Medicare For All" is dismissed with the exasperated question, "Well, who is going to pay for it?"

The Democratic center, mainstream neoliberalism, is at its end. What comes next -- unless new parties like M5S or a Momentum-captured Labour catch on -- is fascism.

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Italian General Election + Results of SPD Groko Vote This Sunday

Italians hold their general election on Sunday. The Five Star Movement (M5S) has been leading in the polls all year. The problem is this lead likely won't translate into a parliamentary majority. Conventional wisdom is that the Berulsconi-led right-wing coalition, which includes the Northern League, will form a government. But it is unclear to me that they will have the votes.

One thing seems certain. Matteo Renzi and the establishment Democratic Party will do poorly. This continues the trend across Europe where the mainstream political left is collapsing. U.S. Democrats should take note.

Also on Sunday results of a membership vote will be announced in Germany as to whether the Social Democratic Party (SPD) should renew its grand coalition (Groko) with the Christian Democrats.

Given the stakes of both the Italian election and SPD Groko referendum the lack of coverage in "the newspaper of record" has been noteworthy. Peter Goodman wrote a good story for the business page the other day, "Italy Is Having an Election. Most Italians Are Too Depressed to Care." The elements of malaise he describes -- youth unemployment; long-term joblessness; lean, capital-intensive production; political apathy -- could be applied to any Western nation.

One thing can be gleaned from NYT's sparse Italian reporting, even from the sneering Jason Horowitz -- M5S is on the rise.

The Times doesn't have a Macron to fluff in Italy or Germany. So rather than really report on what is happening -- we live in an age when there is remarkable broad-based disdain for the governing political parties and said parties are collapsing -- the Times mostly prefers to say nothing.

Which says a lot.