Showing posts with label Matteo Salvini. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matteo Salvini. Show all posts

Thursday, August 22, 2019

M5S-PD Coalition Set to Govern Italy

It took about 14 months for the Five Star Movement-League coalition government to burst apart, but explode it has. Italian prime minister Giuseppe Conte resigned Tuesday ahead of a no confidence vote. The no confidence vote was brought about League firebrand and government interior minister Matteo Salvini withdrawing his support from the coalition.

The widely accepted view is that Salvini sees the late summer as his best opportunity to hold new elections, the result of which would be to make him prime minister. Over the last year the anti-immigrant League has replaced the Five Star Movement (M5S) as the most popular party in Italy. In May's European Parliament elections the League won 34% of the vote, whereas the M5S, with close to 33% in the national parliamentary elections last year, fell to 17%.

Today Italian president Sergio Mattarella will meet with party leaders to see if a new coalition can form a government. The main contender is M5S-Democratic Party (PD) combine; strange bedfellows given that M5S came to power relentlessly skewering the neoliberal austerity and Brussels group-think of the PD. But the bigger threat for both parties now is the dramatic rise of the Italian Trump, Salvini.

If Mattarella fails to find a successor coalition, something explained by Marianne Arens, he can always name a technocratic government:
The next step is at the discretion of the 78-year-old President Mattarella, who himself comes from the PD. If no new coalition is formed, he could also appoint a government of experts, which would then also require a parliamentary majority. If Mattarella opts for new elections, which is considered unlikely, they must take place within 60 days. One last possibility would be for the Lega and the Five Star Movement to resume their coalition.
The politics of the collapse of the M5S-League government has to do with writing a budget due in October. Arens explains,
The most immediate task of the next government is to present a budget that complies with European Union deficit guidelines by October 15, which will require massive cuts at the expense of the working class. If the PD and the Five Stars take on this task, Salvini and Lega, which would then nominally be in opposition, could be further strengthened.
The acidic Jason Horowitz  writing in the neoliberal NYT notes that "Some analysts speculated that Mr. Salvini actually wanted out in order to avoid the difficult budget cutting required in the coming months to avoid an automatic tax hike."

My guess is that the Democratic Party will aggressively pursue the coalition with M5S, confident that it can zombify the party in the next three years. M5S will likely go along because its fate at the polls looks particularly bleak now. The question is whether the online membership of the M5S will ratify a coalition with the PD.

Sunday, February 10, 2019

Italy Beats France

The British press has been much more thorough in its coverage of the flourishing conflict between the governments of Italy and France. Last week, in what is being called an "unprecedented" move, France recalled its ambassador to Italy. Why? Because Italian deputy prime minister Luigi Di Maio traveled to France to meet with leaders of the Yellow Vest (gilets jaunes) insurgency (a suitable analogy would be if the Canadian prime minister had traveled to Zuccotti Park to meet with the Occupy Wall Street protesters). Reuters explains that
Di Maio's decision . . . to visit France and meet several representatives of the "yellow vest" movement, which for months has waged a sometimes violent campaign against Macron and his policies, was deemed a bridge too far.
"The idea that a (deputy) prime minister of an EU country would come to France without letting France know in advance ... It's not some harmless thing," said a French diplomatic source. "It's just not acceptable behavior within the EU ...
"One hopes (withdrawing the ambassador) will force some reflection among the political parties and Italian institutions. It cannot help but underline how serious the situation is."
Officials say the ambassador will probably be sent back soon, but tensions are likely to persist.
For the most part, the mainstream media rushed to defend French president Emmanuel Macron. Di Maio and his fellow deputy prime minister Matteo Salvini are routinely dismissed as anti-immigrant populists working to undermine European unity. Italy's torpedoing an EU statement endorsing the U.S.-led coup underway in Venezuela is more grist for the mainstream mill.

The principal bulwark erected around the enfeebled Macron is a demonization of the Yellow Vests as a violent mob. The Reuters headline for yesterday's protest has been the standard messaging for the last month-plus: "More violence in Paris as 'yellow vests' keep marching."

The Saturday gilets jaunes protests, ongoing since November, have maintained their robust size. But the mainstream media, originally balanced in its reporting, has pivoted to emphasizing the violent, destructive nature of the protests. Macron has been lauded, albeit backhandedly, for making concessions to the working class, as well as for launching his "Great National Debate" public relations campaign.

Now the spin, on display in The Guardian, is that Macron has turned things around. The frame here is EU parliamentary elections in May:
Opinion polls in France have suggested that the main impact of one or more gilets jaunes parties running in the European elections would be to reduce support for the far-right party of Marine Le Pen and the far left, led by Jean-Luc Mélenchon.
A survey last month by Elabé showed 13% of voters could vote for a gilets jaunes party, knocking three points off the score of Le Pen’s National Rally and 1.5 off that of Mélenchon’s France Unbowed, and extending the lead of Macron’s La République En Marche (LREM).
“A gilets jaunes party would likely mobilise people who do not usually vote, but also take votes from the National Rally and France Unbowed,” Emmanuel Rivière of he pollsters Kantar Public France told Le Monde. “Paradoxically, the principal beneficiary would be the party of the president.”
An Ifop opinion poll published on Wednesday showed Macron’s approval rating surging from 23% in December to 34% in February.
Macron is important to the neoliberal consensus because his victory in 2017 is the last great electoral achievement for the market orthodoxy camp. It took the Jiffy Popping of a brand new political party and a massive"Russian bogeyman" psyop, but a win is a win.

The crisis for the neoliberal elites who govern the globe is that TINA ("There Is No Alternative") no longer holds sway among voters. The Russia bogeyman only works on people already committed to TINA.

There is a very good think piece in The Independent by Kim Sengupta that looks at the diplomatic row between Italy and France through the lens of Libya:
There is a feeling in Italy, not just among the supporters of the current government, and not unjustified, that the country has borne a disproportionate number of refugees while other northern European states are not taking their fair share.
France is a particular target on this count, not just because it has sent refugees back to Italy but also because of its part in getting Nato to carry out the bombing campaign which led to the overthrow of Muammar Gaddafi, and the state of semi-anarchy in the country which made it a haven for people-smugglers. It is worth recalling that the European Union used to pay Col Gaddafi to ensure that his country was not a major conduit for the trade, and he had broadly kept his side of the bargain.
This is a rare mention of the role of perpetual war in creating the immigration crisis that has led to the growth of populism in Europe.

Salvini, painted as a anti-African racist in the prestige press, a Mussolini wannabe, has scored major points in the dust-up with Macron. Never before, at least to my recollection, has such a balanced synopsis of Italy's position on immigration vis-a-vis France appeared in The New York Times:
On Thursday, Mr. Salvini responded to the French ambassador’s recall with a series of complaints, including France’s closing of its border to stop illegal migrants passing through Italy.
‘‘Stop with pushbacks at the borders,’’ said Mr. Salvini, who leads the anti-immigrant League party, the Italian government’s coalition partner. ‘‘There have been about 60,000 since 2017, and those include children and women abandoned in the forest.’’
[snip] 
The dispute came to a boil last summer over the migrant issue. The Italians, having borne the brunt of the migrant wave since 2015, were outraged last year when Mr. Macron denounced the new Italian government for failing to take in hundreds of migrants aboard the Aquarius humanitarian rescue boat.
The Italian prime minister’s office reacted with fury, saying it could not “accept hypocritical lessons from a country that, on migration, has always preferred to turn its back on its partners.” And it was true that France has made a regular practice of blocking migrants crossing the Italian border.
“The Italians have been justified — a lot of Italians feel that France’s behavior, with its grand speeches but refusal to welcome migrants, is unacceptable,” Mr. Lazar said.
For this reason alone -- clarifying the dispute on immigration between Italy and France -- Salvini and Di Maio have come out ahead of Macron in this kerfuffle.

Thursday, May 31, 2018

It's Luigi Di Maio of the Five Star Movement, Not the League's Matteo Salvini, Who is the Real Power

Well, the technocratic government of Carlo Cottarelli, the one president Sergio Mattarella blessed after tomahawking the M5S-League combine, is being hastily and quietly dismissed. The negative reaction of the divine market quickly made it apparent to Mattarella that he had blundered enormously. Cottarelli would not survive a confidence vote, and it would be back to the campaign hustings as early as July. Matteo Salvini of the League and Luigi Di Maio of the Five Star Movement (M5S) would pad their parliamentary majority.

So Salvini and Di Maio are back to negotiating with Mattarella. The deal, depending on where you read about it, involves getting rid of Paolo Savona as minister of the economy. The Guardian reports that
The leader of the Italian far-right party the League, Matteo Salvini, has cancelled political rallies to return to Rome, in what was seen as a sign that a political impasse that has left the country without a fully functioning government for months may soon be coming to an end.
Salvini was heading back to the capital to meet his coalition partner, Luigi Di Maio, the head of the anti-establishment Five Star Movement, after the Italian president, Sergio Mattarella, gave the pair more time to form a government.
Italian press reports indicated that any agreement to form a new populist government involving the League, formerly known as the Northern League, and M5S would include the nomination – again – of Giuseppe Conte, a formerly obscure law professor, to serve as prime minister.
But Di Maio and Salvini are expected to back down on their earlier insistence that Paolo Savona, a Eurosceptic who has called Italy’s adoption of the euro a “historic mistake”, should serve as finance minister.
The odious Jason Horowitz, writing for The New York Times, sees another element to the bargain. Not only is Savona out, but so too is Conte:
But simultaneous negotiations with the Five Star Movement seemed to center on a top official in his party, Giancarlo Giorgetti, taking the position of prime minister. Some analysts speculated that Mr. Salvini coveted the position himself, and that he had the leverage of Mr. Savona, and his own popularity, to force the Five Star leadership to accept.
The Five Star Movement, reluctant to give up its primacy in the alliance, after winning nearly a third of the Italian vote, is resisting, according to reports in the Italian press. And Mr. Mattarella, who is very much an audience of one for all of the political performances, would also have to sign off.
It appears that Di Maio has the upper hand here. While Salvini has been strutting and preening, Di Maio has been trying to salvage the nascent M5S-League government. His reasonableness is conveyed by the Guardian quote,
Di Maio said that if a deal could not be reached, he favoured snap elections. “There are two paths ahead. Either we launch the Conte government with a reasonable solution or we vote right away,” he said.
For all the talk that Salvini is surging, I would not rule out M5S as the party on the rise. Di Maio has displayed his prowess.

Monday, May 28, 2018

"Italian Voters! Achtung! We're Doing You a Favor by Not Honoring the Results of This Election."

UPDATE: Succinct statement on Italy's political crisis lifted from the comments section of this morning's post, "Italy’s Political Crisis….How Ugly Might It Get?," by Yves Smith:
Please take the time, if you will, to ponder on article 1 of the Italian Constitution, and tell me how 25% unemployment, a majority without government, a government without majority, the fifth unelected prime minister in 5 years and street protests against the Head of State square with this:
Italy is a democratic Republic founded on labour. Sovereignty belongs to the people and is exercised by the people in the forms and within the limits of the Constitution.
****

I read the headline in the airport "Populist Parties in Italy Fail to Form Government," and I was confused. I had been away from newspapers and television news over the weekend. Last I heard the M5S-League government was on its way to a successful launch. Maybe there had been a last second dust-up between Salvini and Di Maio over the choice of Paolo Savona, an academic who has questioned the wisdom of the euro, as minister of the economy.

But that was not the case. Reading the story by the odious Jason Horowitz, it was apparent that the headline was one of the more misleading in a seemingly daily grab bag of misleading headlines. The populist parties did not fail to form a government. President Sergio Mattarella tomahawked the infant government as it was exiting the birth canal.

In this he did the bidding of the banks, the member states of the European Union, as well as the mainstream press. All had been calling for Mattarella to crush the M5S-League upstarts. They got their wish. Even better for the neoliberal center, Mattarella asked a former International Monetary Fund bureaucrat to form a new government.

As Jason Horowitz reports today in story with a much more accurate headline, "Italian President’s Loyalty to the Euro Creates Chaos":
On Monday morning, as markets rose and fell with the whiplashing events in Italy, Mr. Mattarella gave a new mandate to form a government to Carlo Cottarelli, a respected economist, former International Monetary Fund official and Italian government appointee, who told reporters that he would form a caretaker government only with the goal of passing a budget and guiding Italy to new elections.
If Parliament votes in support of his caretaker government, elections would take place in early 2019. If it does not, which seems much more likely, he would quit “immediately” and elections would take place sometime after August.
RT reports that there is zero chance that Cottarelli's technocratic government will be supported in parliament:
Italian journalist Marcello Foa told RT that Cottarelli’s chances of forming a new government are “non-existent,”noting that the anti-establishment Five Star Movement (M5S) and its rightist coalition ally Lega Nord are unlikely to support Cottarelli’s efforts because they would then “lose all credibility with the voters.” The two parties were the top performers in March’s parliamentary elections and have spent the last two months negotiating the formation of a coalition government.
Yanis Varoufakis appears on the mark with his dissection: "President Mattarella of Italy: From moral drift to tactical blunder":
Beyond his moral drift (as he condones Mr Salvini’s industrial-scale misanthropy while vetoing a legitimate concern about the eurozone’s capacity to let Italy breathe in its midst), President Mattarella has made a major tactical blunder.
In short, he fell right into Mr Salvini’s trap. The formation of another ‘technical’ government, under a former IMF apparatchik, is a fantastic gift to Mr Salvini.
Mr Salvini is secretly salivating at the thought of another election – one that he will fight not as the misanthropic, divisive populist that he is but as the defender of democracy against the Deep Establishment. Already last night he scaled the high moral with the stirring words: “Italy is not a colony, we are not slaves of the Germans, the French, the spread or finance.”
If Mr Mattarella takes solace from the fact that previous Italian Presidents managed to put in place technical governments that did the establishment’s job (so ‘successfully’ that the country’s political centre was destroyed), he is very badly mistaken. This time around he, unlike his predecessors, has no parliamentary majority to pass a budget or indeed to give his government a vote of confidence. Thus, he is forced to go into elections that, courtesy of his moral drift and tactical incompetence, will return an even stronger majority for 5S-Lega, possibly in alliance with the enfeebled Forza Italia of Silvio Berlusconi.
And then what Mr Mattarella? 
For a sample of how the mainstream is spinning Mattarella's radical move, take a look at "What Comes Next for Italy?" by Beppe Severgnini, editor in chief of Corriere della Sera’s magazine 7:
Right or wrong, the financial markets and the rest of Europe were convinced that the proposed government was a fundamental threat; now that it has been sidetracked, they will do what they can to prevent its return.
[snip]
It sounds naïve to say it, but the real winners here are Italy’s voters. Thanks to their coolheaded president, they have a chance to rethink their answers to a very important question. By voting for the League and Five Star, they set Italy on a collision course with the European Union. British voters made a similarly emotional decision to leave the union, and they don’t get a second chance. Italy should consider itself lucky: A solid Constitution is better than a rushed referendum.
This is how the radical neoliberal center paves the way for fascism -- "Voters! Achtung! We're doing you a favor by not honoring the results of this election."

Friday, May 25, 2018

NYT Editorializes Against New Italian Government

The editorial page of The New York Times takes aim at Italy's nascent M5S-League government in "The Populists Take Rome." Its main purposes is to repeat previous slurs: Conte inflated his resume with universities he never attended; Di Maio is a college dropout; Salvini wears a sweatshirt (oh, my). It's exhausted and foolish. One imagines that these nameless editorial writers feel suffocated having to churn out attack after attack in defense of a status quo to which no one is devoted other than the rich and powerful.

The exhaustion is on display in the tepid concession paragraph:
Yet the new Italian government cannot be dismissed as just another in Italy’s long history of political crises. The shift of a core member of the European Union, one whose allegiance to the “European project” had not been in doubt, toward the new Central European members hostile to Brussels is a serious blow to the deeper European integration championed by President Emmanuel Macron of France and Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany.
The editorial doesn't mention that Merkel is on her way out and Macron is diminishing by the day. The political center as wishfully conceived by The New York Times does not exist.

Friday, May 18, 2018

Another Brexit-Size Shock to the EU?

It finally happened. A government is on the verge of being formed in Italy.

Italian parliamentary elections took place on March 4, followed by round after round of inconclusive negotiations. The main sticking point for the top vote-getting party, the Five Star Movement (M5S), was the center-right's insistence that Silvio Berlusconi be prime minister.

Once the League's Matteo Salvini agreed to sideline the octogenarian -- the League is the real power of the center-right coalition, not Berlusconi's Forza Italia -- things got cooking; that, and president Sergio Mattarella threatened to name a technocratic caretaker government.

The League-M5S plan has been published, and it has two components that are sure to stir things up: an end to the EU sanctions on Russia and an increase in debt spending. RT crows, "Italy’s anti-establishment Five Star Movement and Lega Nord parties have called for an immediate lifting of sanctions imposed on Russia." Reuters outlines other features of the plan:
The document, published after 11 weeks of political stalemate in the euro zone’s third-largest economy, calls for billions of euros in tax cuts, additional spending on welfare for the poor, and a roll-back of pension reforms.
The euro sank on the latest developments on Friday and was headed for its fifth straight weekly fall against the dollar, in what would be a first for the currency since 2015.
The possibility of a eurosceptic government in Rome is shaking investor confidence ... at this point, a larger fiscal deficit and greater bond issuance (in Italy) does seem likely,” said David Madden, a strategist at CMC Markets.
The euro gave up gains and fell 0.2 percent to $1.1778 after the Italian parties outlined their economic plans. It settled near a five-month low reached on Wednesday of $1.1763.
The final accord dropped a previous draft proposal, seen by Reuters, to create fiscal headroom by adjusting the formula used to calculate debt burdens in the EU, and contained nothing questioning Italy’s membership of the euro.
But it still called for a review of EU governance and fiscal rules — setting the stage for the bloc’s biggest political challenge since Britain voted to leave two years ago.
So we're right back to back to Syriza 2015 and the question of whether a nation-state can change course through democratic elections or is the status quo so cemented in place that nothing short of armed rebellion can alter the neoliberal Washington Consensus.

The neoliberals are pining for Mattarella to take control, which Politico encapsulates here:
What role does the president play?
If the deal passes muster with members, the parties will present it to President Mattarella. As guarantor of Italy’s constitution and international treaties, he has the power to approve or reject ministers and even specific bills in the government’s program if he deems them to be unaffordable. He can even reject the coalition government altogether and appoint his own — a power that has been used once before, in 1953.
M5S's Luigi di Maio and Salvini are going to meet with Mattarella Monday. M5S members are currently voting online whether to support the new government. The candidate for prime minister has yet to be named.

Signs are good that an M5S-League government will be the real deal. Reuters says that, "Salvini’s pre-election ally, former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, accused him of betraying their centre-right electoral alliance and urged him to back out of the deal with Di Maio and 'come back home'."

The U.S. is already making threats about upending Russian sanctions. From Politico:
In June, the European Council will have to roll over the Russian sanctions that the two parties strongly oppose. Last month Kurt Volker, U.S. President Donald Trump’s special envoy for Ukraine, warned Rome that “Italy cannot lift the measures without serious consequences.”
An outbreak of European democracy comes just at the right time. The U.S. is trying to maintain the Continent's vassalage as Trump lurches from brinkmanship in East Asia to the Middle East.

The Washington Consensus is now clearly held together by nothing other than war -- economic warfare, armed conflict, genocide and information war. May the consensus collapse as soon as possible.