Showing posts with label Sergio Mattarella. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sergio Mattarella. Show all posts

Thursday, May 31, 2018

It's Luigi Di Maio of the Five Star Movement, Not the League's Matteo Salvini, Who is the Real Power

Well, the technocratic government of Carlo Cottarelli, the one president Sergio Mattarella blessed after tomahawking the M5S-League combine, is being hastily and quietly dismissed. The negative reaction of the divine market quickly made it apparent to Mattarella that he had blundered enormously. Cottarelli would not survive a confidence vote, and it would be back to the campaign hustings as early as July. Matteo Salvini of the League and Luigi Di Maio of the Five Star Movement (M5S) would pad their parliamentary majority.

So Salvini and Di Maio are back to negotiating with Mattarella. The deal, depending on where you read about it, involves getting rid of Paolo Savona as minister of the economy. The Guardian reports that
The leader of the Italian far-right party the League, Matteo Salvini, has cancelled political rallies to return to Rome, in what was seen as a sign that a political impasse that has left the country without a fully functioning government for months may soon be coming to an end.
Salvini was heading back to the capital to meet his coalition partner, Luigi Di Maio, the head of the anti-establishment Five Star Movement, after the Italian president, Sergio Mattarella, gave the pair more time to form a government.
Italian press reports indicated that any agreement to form a new populist government involving the League, formerly known as the Northern League, and M5S would include the nomination – again – of Giuseppe Conte, a formerly obscure law professor, to serve as prime minister.
But Di Maio and Salvini are expected to back down on their earlier insistence that Paolo Savona, a Eurosceptic who has called Italy’s adoption of the euro a “historic mistake”, should serve as finance minister.
The odious Jason Horowitz, writing for The New York Times, sees another element to the bargain. Not only is Savona out, but so too is Conte:
But simultaneous negotiations with the Five Star Movement seemed to center on a top official in his party, Giancarlo Giorgetti, taking the position of prime minister. Some analysts speculated that Mr. Salvini coveted the position himself, and that he had the leverage of Mr. Savona, and his own popularity, to force the Five Star leadership to accept.
The Five Star Movement, reluctant to give up its primacy in the alliance, after winning nearly a third of the Italian vote, is resisting, according to reports in the Italian press. And Mr. Mattarella, who is very much an audience of one for all of the political performances, would also have to sign off.
It appears that Di Maio has the upper hand here. While Salvini has been strutting and preening, Di Maio has been trying to salvage the nascent M5S-League government. His reasonableness is conveyed by the Guardian quote,
Di Maio said that if a deal could not be reached, he favoured snap elections. “There are two paths ahead. Either we launch the Conte government with a reasonable solution or we vote right away,” he said.
For all the talk that Salvini is surging, I would not rule out M5S as the party on the rise. Di Maio has displayed his prowess.

Wednesday, May 30, 2018

Why Italy is Important: The Neoliberal Center No Longer Believes Its Own Prescriptions

Isn't the irony rich that markets are responding so negatively to the diktats of their champions? The M5S-League government was aborted in deference to the wisdom of the markets, and the markets have deemed this an unwise decision. As Yves Smith says this morning in "NIRP’s Revenge: Italian Bonds Plunge, Worst Day in Decades":
Yves here. While Mr. Market got in quite a tizzy today over 5 Star and Lega’s abandonment of their effort to form a coalition government after the President Sergio Mattarella nixed their choice of economy minister, Paolo Savona. This has produced a first-class political crisis. The technocrats, in trying to appease Mr. Market, has done the reverse.
The Times editorial board spins this obvious blunder -- this is the preferred argument du jour for neoliberals -- as a necessary move to allow Italian voters to come to their senses:
However spooked the markets were, they had been equally wary of the coalition and its grandiose spending plans, and given the mutual hostility of the coalition partners, their government might not have survived for long. Mr. Mattarella’s stand, at least, gives Italian voters a second chance to weigh their options after glimpsing what their earlier choices might mean. That’s something some Brexit voters in Britain, or Trump voters in the United States, might have welcomed.
Such an argument doesn't appeal to Italians though, as Steven Erlanger notes in his lengthy write-up, "Italy Pushes Euro to Fore, the Last Place Europe Wants It":
On Tuesday, the European Commissioner for the budget, Günther H. Oettinger, a German, told the broadcaster Deutsche Welle that the markets and a “darkened outlook” would teach the Italians to vote for the right thing. 
They may yet do so, but it’s impolitic to say so, especially for a Brussels-based German.
One of the first to point out the offense was Mr. Di Maio himself, who in his own message on Twitter called the remark “absurd.”
“These people treat Italy like a summer colony where they come to vacation,” Mr. Di Maio wrote. “But in a few months a government of change will be born and Europe will finally respect us.”
Di Maio is right; hence, the market reaction.

This marks an important turning. The neoliberal center no longer believes in its own prescriptions.

Monday, May 28, 2018

"Italian Voters! Achtung! We're Doing You a Favor by Not Honoring the Results of This Election."

UPDATE: Succinct statement on Italy's political crisis lifted from the comments section of this morning's post, "Italy’s Political Crisis….How Ugly Might It Get?," by Yves Smith:
Please take the time, if you will, to ponder on article 1 of the Italian Constitution, and tell me how 25% unemployment, a majority without government, a government without majority, the fifth unelected prime minister in 5 years and street protests against the Head of State square with this:
Italy is a democratic Republic founded on labour. Sovereignty belongs to the people and is exercised by the people in the forms and within the limits of the Constitution.
****

I read the headline in the airport "Populist Parties in Italy Fail to Form Government," and I was confused. I had been away from newspapers and television news over the weekend. Last I heard the M5S-League government was on its way to a successful launch. Maybe there had been a last second dust-up between Salvini and Di Maio over the choice of Paolo Savona, an academic who has questioned the wisdom of the euro, as minister of the economy.

But that was not the case. Reading the story by the odious Jason Horowitz, it was apparent that the headline was one of the more misleading in a seemingly daily grab bag of misleading headlines. The populist parties did not fail to form a government. President Sergio Mattarella tomahawked the infant government as it was exiting the birth canal.

In this he did the bidding of the banks, the member states of the European Union, as well as the mainstream press. All had been calling for Mattarella to crush the M5S-League upstarts. They got their wish. Even better for the neoliberal center, Mattarella asked a former International Monetary Fund bureaucrat to form a new government.

As Jason Horowitz reports today in story with a much more accurate headline, "Italian President’s Loyalty to the Euro Creates Chaos":
On Monday morning, as markets rose and fell with the whiplashing events in Italy, Mr. Mattarella gave a new mandate to form a government to Carlo Cottarelli, a respected economist, former International Monetary Fund official and Italian government appointee, who told reporters that he would form a caretaker government only with the goal of passing a budget and guiding Italy to new elections.
If Parliament votes in support of his caretaker government, elections would take place in early 2019. If it does not, which seems much more likely, he would quit “immediately” and elections would take place sometime after August.
RT reports that there is zero chance that Cottarelli's technocratic government will be supported in parliament:
Italian journalist Marcello Foa told RT that Cottarelli’s chances of forming a new government are “non-existent,”noting that the anti-establishment Five Star Movement (M5S) and its rightist coalition ally Lega Nord are unlikely to support Cottarelli’s efforts because they would then “lose all credibility with the voters.” The two parties were the top performers in March’s parliamentary elections and have spent the last two months negotiating the formation of a coalition government.
Yanis Varoufakis appears on the mark with his dissection: "President Mattarella of Italy: From moral drift to tactical blunder":
Beyond his moral drift (as he condones Mr Salvini’s industrial-scale misanthropy while vetoing a legitimate concern about the eurozone’s capacity to let Italy breathe in its midst), President Mattarella has made a major tactical blunder.
In short, he fell right into Mr Salvini’s trap. The formation of another ‘technical’ government, under a former IMF apparatchik, is a fantastic gift to Mr Salvini.
Mr Salvini is secretly salivating at the thought of another election – one that he will fight not as the misanthropic, divisive populist that he is but as the defender of democracy against the Deep Establishment. Already last night he scaled the high moral with the stirring words: “Italy is not a colony, we are not slaves of the Germans, the French, the spread or finance.”
If Mr Mattarella takes solace from the fact that previous Italian Presidents managed to put in place technical governments that did the establishment’s job (so ‘successfully’ that the country’s political centre was destroyed), he is very badly mistaken. This time around he, unlike his predecessors, has no parliamentary majority to pass a budget or indeed to give his government a vote of confidence. Thus, he is forced to go into elections that, courtesy of his moral drift and tactical incompetence, will return an even stronger majority for 5S-Lega, possibly in alliance with the enfeebled Forza Italia of Silvio Berlusconi.
And then what Mr Mattarella? 
For a sample of how the mainstream is spinning Mattarella's radical move, take a look at "What Comes Next for Italy?" by Beppe Severgnini, editor in chief of Corriere della Sera’s magazine 7:
Right or wrong, the financial markets and the rest of Europe were convinced that the proposed government was a fundamental threat; now that it has been sidetracked, they will do what they can to prevent its return.
[snip]
It sounds naïve to say it, but the real winners here are Italy’s voters. Thanks to their coolheaded president, they have a chance to rethink their answers to a very important question. By voting for the League and Five Star, they set Italy on a collision course with the European Union. British voters made a similarly emotional decision to leave the union, and they don’t get a second chance. Italy should consider itself lucky: A solid Constitution is better than a rushed referendum.
This is how the radical neoliberal center paves the way for fascism -- "Voters! Achtung! We're doing you a favor by not honoring the results of this election."

Wednesday, May 23, 2018

Jason Horowitz Now in Rome Up to His Usual Dirty Tricks

UPDATE: An absolutely damning piece on the M5S-League government in formation (Lib-Pop Politics: Italy’s New Government Is More Neoliberal Than Populist by Mario Pianta) was posted this morning by Yves Smith. Pianta's point is that M5S is rudderless while Salvini's League is on the ascent:
Current polls reflect this trend of a growing Lega and a stable Five Stars consensus; when Five Stars support weakens – as happened in the peripheries of Rome and Turin, run by weak Five Stars mayors – Salvini is set to grab a large part of their disappointed voters. Thus, the political outlook suggests Salvini as a likely winner of a real majority for the centre-right whenever new elections take place, giving him the upper hand in talks for the new government – the alternatives being an early vote in autumn or in May 2019 when they could be held together with the European elections.
That's something to think about: If Mattarella somehow tomahawks the nascent government, which is the drumbeat in the corporate press, and another round of elections is scheduled, Pianta argues that the League would be the clear winner with the center-right coalition likely able to form a government on its own.

The reason Pianta sees this as a problem is that the League is nothing more than Italian Trumpism, espousing tax cuts and bashing immigrants. Pianata concludes with this sobering assessment of the M5S-League program:
The asymmetry between a Lega with clear priorities – in terms of class and nation – and a Five Stars with its only concern to strike a deal, has produced a government programme that includes some general concerns of the Five Stars – on legality and minimum income – and most practical measures designed by the Lega – on taxes and migrants.
Demands for renegotiating European treaties and restoring national sovereignty in some areas are enough to open up a rhetorical confrontation with Brussels – and much attention from the media. But they have little concrete content.
The most important specific policy that will be introduced by the new government is the Italian version of the ‘flat tax’; firms and individuals will pay either 15 or 20% of income taxes, as opposed to the current 43% for the top income bracket.
It is clearly stated that no wealth tax will be introduced (Italy has often been criticized by the EU for having cancelled real estate taxes on home-owners). Tax controls on Italy’s large number of small firms and self-employed will be scaled down, basically legalising tax evasion for a large number of right-wing, medium and high-income voters.
For financial firms and banks no control or limit on their activities will be introduced. This will make Italy a neoliberal business paradise, competing with Ireland in the race to the bottom of business taxes in Europe, offering some room for the survival of Italy’s small businesses dramatically hit by a decade of crisis.
In this way, the transfer of income to the richest 20% of Italians will be huge, with the very rich benefiting the most. Berlusconi would have never been able with his past majorities to introduce such a pro-rich agenda.
Such measures are the easiest to implement, as they simply scale back state redistribution, leaving unequal outcomes of market processes untouched. More difficult is the implementation of the only ‘pro-poor’ measure long championed by the Five Stars: the so-called ‘citizen income’. In the programme this is reduced to an income support of €780 a month for a maximum of two years for unemployed Italians (no residents with foreign citizenship will obtain it) ready to accept any job offer; no figure for potential recipients or funding for implementing it is mentioned.
But the darkest success of the Lega in the government programme is the chapter on migrants, envisaging a stop to the flows of refugees, changes in European rules on asylum and free movement, and proposing the repatriation of the 500,000 immigrants with irregular status now present in Italy.
Combined with harsh measures on law and order, this policy caters to the ‘fear effect’ that is behind the growth of Lega’s support. In parallel the rise of the Five Stars was based on a ‘poverty effect’ – especially in the South (see here). The tragedy is that the poorest Italians have overwhelmingly voted for two political forces that are now creating the most pro-rich, pro-business government in Italy’s history. Even worse, Lib-pop politicscould be just the starter for an outright far-right political future.
****

My suspicion when Jason Horowitz was made bureau chief of Rome by The New York Times, a reward for his work in slandering Bernie Sanders' 2016 presidential campaign, is that the flagship of neoliberal hegemony was positioning a poison pen to take out the biggest internal threat to the European Union, Italy's Five Star Movement (M5S).

Horowitz faced a tough pull during the run-up to parliamentary elections because the political center has absolutely collapsed in Italy. While he churned away with his typical attacks, it was all just so much piss in the wind because it was clear that the insurgent parties, M5S and Northern League, were going to kick ass. And kick ass they did. In France, the NYT praised a party of neophytes, Macron's En Marche! And anything tech based usually garners accolades aplenty from the Gray Lady. But M5S does not support the Washington Consensus. So it must not be allowed to govern.

Horowitz earned his supper the other day when he published an innocuous two paragraphs in "Italy’s Populists Offer Giuseppe Conte for Prime Minister; N.Y.U. Claim in Question" casting doubt on the M5S-League candidate for prime minister, Giuseppe Conte:
[Giuseppe Conte] lists research at famous universities around the world, including Yale, the Sorbonne in France and New York University, where he said he “perfected and updated his studies” while staying at the college for at least a month every summer between 2008 and 2012.
Asked about Mr. Conte’s experience at N.Y.U., Michelle Tsai, a spokeswoman, said Monday, “A person by this name does not show up in any of our records as either a student or faculty member,” adding that it was possible he attended one or two-day programs for which the school does not keep records.
Clearly Washington's plan is to strangle the M5S-League government in the cradle. Bloomberg has at least a story a day which all but beg the Italian president Sergio Mattarella to take over. It's fascism without the slightest hint of a mass base.