Showing posts with label GroKo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GroKo. Show all posts

Monday, December 2, 2019

Germany's GroKo in Trouble. How Long Before a Red-Red-Green Government?

Hopeful news was to be found over the weekend in Germany. Saskia Esken and Norbert Walter-Borjans won the Social Democratic Party dual leadership contest, beating business-as-usual pro-centrists Olaf Scholz, Germany's finance minister, and Klara Geywitz. As Jeremy Cliffe reports for the New Statesman,
All agree that the result will destabilise the “grand coalition” of Angela Merkel’s centre-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU), its conservative (CSU) sister party and the SPD. Esken, in particular, has questioned its future and suggested that the CDU and CSU will have to make hefty leftwards concessions to keep the SPD on-board. At a conference in Berlin next weekend the SPD will vote on whether to stay or to walk.
The pessimism is understandable. Since Gerhard Schröder lost the chancellery to Merkel in 2005, the SPD has governed as the junior partner in grand coalitions with her for 10 of the 14 succeeding years and along the way has has lurched from crisis to crisis. It has gone through 11 leaders, five of them provisional, and seen its vote share fall from its election-losing 34 per cent in 2005 to a record-low 20.5 per cent in 2017, which according to current polls would fall again by at least a third were elections held today.
The CDU's mini-Merkel, Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer, was dismissive of renegotiating the terms of the GroKo, saying that, according to Reuters, “We are concentrating on dedicating ourselves to work of substance — we are not a therapy facility for the coalition parties.”

We'll have a better idea what's in store for Germany's governing coalition after the SPD party congress begins on Friday. Reuters notes that
If the Social Democrats did decide to walk out, it’s unclear what would happen. Merkel’s bloc could seek to carry on in a minority government or, theoretically at least, negotiate an alternative coalition; or the result could eventually be an early election.
Merkel has said that this is her last term and she won’t run in the next election, currently due in the fall of 2021.
If elections to the Bundestag were to be held today, the CDU would nose out the Greens. The problem for the Christian Democrats is that parties aren't willing to govern with the far right Alternative for Germany (AfD).

The only other natural partners for the CDU are the Free Democrats, but they're too small to create a majority. So this leaves the SPD as the key party.

Right now the SPD and AfD are essentially tied in polling as the number three party behind the Christian Democrats and Greens.

A red-red-green coalition appears to be the only path forward. The problem is that we might have to wait another two years before that path is chosen.

Friday, August 16, 2019

Political Shakeup in Germany

While not as dire as a Brexit crash-out, politics in Germany is set to scramble the status quo before the end of the year. Reuters reports that German finance minister Olaf Scholz will run for the leadership of the Social Democrats. The Social Democratic Party (SPD) has been led by three interim chiefs since Andrea Nahles' resigned following the party's disastrous performance in European Parliament elections in May. Scholz is a pro-GroKo, which means he supports the maintenance of the Grand Coalition government of the SPD and Angela Merkel's Christian Democrats (CDU). The GroKo has been extremely damaging to the popularity of the SPD.

There are six main parties in Germany divided into three tiers in the polls. The top tier is occupied by the Greens and CDU, running currently in the mid-20s; then comes the far right Alternative for Germany (AfD) and SPD in the low teens. The bottom tier is occupied by The Left Party and the Free Democrats, both in single digits.

If Scholz is defeated by an anti-GroKo candidate in December there will either be a new red-red-green government (SPD-Left Party-Greens) or general elections that will likely see a red-red-green government as the result.

In July Adam Tooze sussed it all out in a lengthy article, "Which is worse?," published in The London Review of Books. I recommend it. Change is coming.

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Italian General Election + Results of SPD Groko Vote This Sunday

Italians hold their general election on Sunday. The Five Star Movement (M5S) has been leading in the polls all year. The problem is this lead likely won't translate into a parliamentary majority. Conventional wisdom is that the Berulsconi-led right-wing coalition, which includes the Northern League, will form a government. But it is unclear to me that they will have the votes.

One thing seems certain. Matteo Renzi and the establishment Democratic Party will do poorly. This continues the trend across Europe where the mainstream political left is collapsing. U.S. Democrats should take note.

Also on Sunday results of a membership vote will be announced in Germany as to whether the Social Democratic Party (SPD) should renew its grand coalition (Groko) with the Christian Democrats.

Given the stakes of both the Italian election and SPD Groko referendum the lack of coverage in "the newspaper of record" has been noteworthy. Peter Goodman wrote a good story for the business page the other day, "Italy Is Having an Election. Most Italians Are Too Depressed to Care." The elements of malaise he describes -- youth unemployment; long-term joblessness; lean, capital-intensive production; political apathy -- could be applied to any Western nation.

One thing can be gleaned from NYT's sparse Italian reporting, even from the sneering Jason Horowitz -- M5S is on the rise.

The Times doesn't have a Macron to fluff in Italy or Germany. So rather than really report on what is happening -- we live in an age when there is remarkable broad-based disdain for the governing political parties and said parties are collapsing -- the Times mostly prefers to say nothing.

Which says a lot.

Tuesday, February 6, 2018

Disintegration of the Social Democratic Party in Germany

Coalition talks are still underway in Germany. Judging from a story in The Guardian by Philip Oltermann, "German parties hope to reach coalition deal this week," Social Democratic Party leader Martin Schulz is pushing hard for the type of policies it is hard to imagine Merkel's CDU can accept:
The SPD leader, Martin Schulz, announced on Monday that the two sides had also reached an agreement on the European chapter of the coalition agreement that amounted to “an urgently needed signal for a fresh start for Europe”.
The agreement would commit the next German government to “more investments, an investment budget for the eurozone, and an end to the austerity mantra”, as well as “fair taxation” of internet giants such as Google, Apple, Facebook and Amazon, Schulz said via an information service for SPD party members.
Schulz has to push hard because the SPD is in real trouble. Alternative for Germany (AfD) is only a few points shy of overtaking the SPD as the second-largest party in Germany behind CDU. Katrin Bennhold explores the abandonment of the SPD for AfD by rank'n'file union members in traditional industrial strongholds.

Bennhold's story, "Workers of Germany, Unite: The New Siren Call of the Far Right," is worth reading for the insight it provides into the sway of Trump among the U.S. white working class.

Elites throughout the West are loyally wedded to neoliberalism. A particularly acute articulation of this commitment could be found over the weekend in Anna Sauerbrey's "How Millennials Are Changing German Politics":
Real politics always consists of bullet points. You want to lift up the lower middle classes? You have to pass tax relief, restructure social security contributions, bolster the education budget — which is what the next grand coalition will vow to do, if the negotiations are successful.
The challenge for German politicians, moving forward, will be to come up with a narrative big enough to create a sense of direction, of being based on values more fundamental than raising the gross domestic product a few percentage points, but avoiding the sort of utopian visions that German voters rightly distrust.
If they succeed, they could set free a new era of political energy. If they fail, we could see a dark turn toward the sort of fractured, incoherent politics haunting the rest of the world, full of holes that the far right can move through. There’s a trap, however. In raging against the slow and boring politics of compromise, the members of the new generation are joining the very populist chant they are setting out to defeat.
In other words, more compromise, cuts to social programs, no utopias -- more of the same. That's the mantra of the neoliberals. And by doing more of the same we will magically "set free a new era of political energy." This is derangement, plain and simple.

The safest bet in any book is the bet that the traditional parties of the mainstream left in the West will continue to disintegrate.

Thursday, February 1, 2018

The German GroKo

Jacobin has a good interview, "Germany’s Groundhog Day," with Die Linke lawmaker Fabio de Masi. De Masi talks about GroKo, the abbreviation for grand coalition. Negotiations between the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) and the Social Democratic Party (SPD) are presently drawing to a close. Reuters is reporting this morning that a deal will be reached by Sunday.

What makes this iteration of the grand coalition interesting is that it is clearly a death march for the SPD. Party leader Martin Schulz proclaimed after the disastrous federal elections in September that the SPD would return to its social-democratic roots and stand in opposition to any Merkel-led government. Then when Merkel's attempt at a coalition with the Greens and the business-friendly Free Democratic Party collapsed, Schulz quickly performed an about-face.

The problem for Schulz and any future GroKo is that there is fulsome rank'n'file opposition within the SPD, led principally by its youth wing, JUSOS, and any final deal that emerges has to be ratified by the party membership. As the Reuters story summarizes,
The party's roughly 440,000 members could yet sink any deal as they have the final say in a ballot.
The JUSOS youth wing of the SPD, along with other leftist members, are deeply opposed to rejoining a coalition under Merkel, fearing it will decimate their support.
But something that de Masi said really struck me as being pertinent to the entire mainstream left in the Western neoliberal world:
When Schulz was first elected leader of the SPD, he hinted at reversing some of the labor market reforms that his party introduced with the Agenda 2010. Even vaguely gesturing in this direction caused the party’s polling to go up by nearly 10 percent. However, the SPD stayed in government instead of using a potential majority with Die Linke and the Greens in the last parliament to correct some of their past mistakes, cause snap elections and set the agenda. Hence, the Schulz hype was only temporary. There is a substantial section of voters that the SPD could tap into, who are disappointed, but who also have unfortunately not become Die Linke voters.
Democrats in the U.S. could mop up at the polls if they replaced their old leaders and then pledged to reverse peak neoliberalism. That they don't is proof that centrist parties of the left will continue to disintegrate. Corbyn's Labour seems to be the only exception.