Monday, March 5, 2018

Democratic Wave Unlikely This Year. Then the Party Splits in 2020.

Last week there were a number of stories on the upcoming wave election for the Democrats in November, the most emphatic of which might have been Sean McElwee's "The Midterms and the Turn Leftward": "Democrats will take the House, probably winning around forty seats."

Dems need to pick up 24 seats. I'm not saying that it can't happen, but I'm just skeptical that it will. A lot of the "Democratic wave" prognostications appear to be based on the generic ballot, a wholly unreliable lens to look at the myriad individual congressional races. Lambert Strether's Water Cooler from last Wednesday had these two items:
  • “Dems surge in generic ballot as economy fades from spotlight” [The Hill]. “[P]ollsters warn that the generic ballot is better as a gauge of the entire electorate’s mood than as a predictor of outcomes in individual races. In the Senate, Democrats are defending 25 seats, while Republicans are only tasked with defending eight seats. Many of the GOP incumbents are running in states that Trump won handily in 2016, while several Democrats are running in states Trump won by double-digit margins. Pollsters say not to read too deeply into generic ballot polling at this early stage, pointing to the extreme volatility in the polls in recent weeks. Over the past month, polls have put the Democratic advantage everywhere from 2 points to 16 points.”
  • “Democratic National Committee war plan: Target 50 million voters” [NBC News]. “The DNC, which has struggled financially and faced doubts about its relevance, will focus its 2018 organizing plans for the midterms around partnerships with a wide range of groups aimed at boosting turnout among Democratic-leaning voters, who have been less likely to get to the polls in recent nonpresidential elections.” Wake me when the Democrat party makes voter registration and expanding the base a core party function, 24/7/365, instead of a random, election by election effort. (Oh, and a political version of Conway’s Law seems to be at work: Liberals think of themselves as an aggregation of silos (mostly identity-based silos), hence the “partnerships with a wide range of groups,” i.e. not a core party function.
Last week Trump announced his tariffs on aluminum and steel. If this is sincere, and not some hocus pocus to screen his failure to overhaul NAFTA, then Trump has secured the continued allegiance of his base MAGA voter.

A president's first midterm is supposed to be a plebiscite on his performance. If true, and assuming the U.S. is not drawn deeper into Syria and/or attacks North Korea and/or falls into recession, then I think the GOP will perform better than expected.

Granted, Trump's tariffs cut against the grain, creating a situation where Paul Ryan is criticizing Trump while Sherrod Brown is praising him. But I doubt there will be many blue-collar districts where the Republican on the ballot distances himself from Trump.

The biggest wake-up for Democrats has to be the ongoing collapse of the center-left in Europe. Yes, the SPD membership in Germany strongly backed GroKo. But it will be the last GroKo. What has to give U.S. Democrats pause is the failure of Italy's Democratic Party (PD). Today Matteo Renzi announced his resignation. PD managed 23% less than 20% of the vote.

The Democratic Party in the U.S. is splitting. Machine pols are battling the new liberal power, the #MeToos. And this is just a tune-up for the main event come 2020 --  Bernie redux.

Bernie redux will be Armageddon for the Democratic Party. The Democratic Party will block Bernie again. And once again it will lose a close general election to Trump.

But let's imagine a successful wave, a children's crusade that topples the DNC leadership and nominates Bernie. What happens then? Mike Bloomberg or some other billionaire bankrolls a centrist third party a la En Marche!, dooming the party of Jackson and Van Buren.

We can only hope.

Sunday, March 4, 2018

Exit Polls Looking Good for Five Star Movement

UPDATE IV: A tweet from Antonello Guerrera is being hailed as the best summation so far of the Italian general election of 2018:
- M5S 1st party 
- Centre-right 1st coalition 
- Italy split in 3 
- Populist & anti-eurosceptic front close to 50% of votes 
- Renzi's PD collapsing
- Perfect hung parliament looming
Guerrero says that Renzi is likely to resign if the PD polls under 20%. We can only hope!

**** 

UPDATE III: Plenty of "fear and loathing" ahead from the prestige press over the badly hung parliament. But there is this helpful Guardian thumbnail sketch of the Five Star Movement. M5S is deemed a false-consciousness party by socialists and communists, a stalking horse for fascists. I have never seen M5S that way. I have seen the party as purely an "anti" construct -- anti-neoliberalism, anti-neoconservatism, anti-"staus quo of the last 40 years." It refuses to hemmed in and defined. As I said the other day, the best hope for rejuvenating moribund democracy in the West is M5S and Labour's Momentum:

"So, what exactly is the Five Star Movement?
"The anti-establisment party, started by comedian Beppe Grillo, burst onto the political scene in 2012 and has gone from strength to strength. The 69-year-old remains a figurehead, though he has handed over leadership to sharp-suited disciple Luigi Di Maio.
"Since its beginnings, the party has experienced a meteoric rise to prominence amid an outpouring of frustration and anger towards mainstream political parties.
"The movement calls itself “the first and only political party based on online participation and direct democracy.” Using an internet portal called Rousseau, M5S uses online votes of members to decide its policies, draft legislation and candidates.
M5S is proposing a universal basic income of €780 ($963) a month for those living in poverty.
"M5S supports a hotchpotch of policies from across the political spectrum and has gained a reputation for political flip-flopping, leading their critics to brand them as immature and incompetent. The party had promised its supporters a referendum on leaving the eurozone, but has had a change of heart in recent months.
"M5S is currently projected to be the single party with the largest share of votes in the election. You can read more about its moment of truth here.
****

UPDATE II: The state broadcaster Rai's first seat projection:
Centre-right 225-265
M5S 195-235
Centre-left 115-155
LEU 12-20
The chatter about possible coalitions has already begun. One being discussed is between M5S and Renzi's establishment Democratic Party (PD). Absurd! For sure, one conclusion that won't be lost in the chatter is the continuing failure of the mainstream center. Italians have "gone native," with M5S and Lega (what used to be the Northern League) the parties on the rise. Matteo Salvini is definitely photogenic:


****

UPDATE: From Guardian Rome bureau chief Stephanie Kirchgaessner:
"The Five Star Movement, an anti-establishment party that was founded by former comedian Beppe Grillo and has voiced deep scepticism about the euro and Italy’s role in NATO, appeared to have won between 29-31% of the votes, according to the early exit polls."
****

Five Star Movement is topping the exit polls. From The Guardian:
Italy’s national public broadcaster, Rai, has roughly comparable numbers in its first exit poll: 
M5S 29%-32%
Forza Italia 13-16% 
Lega 13-16% 
PD 20.5-23.5%
In its live election coverage The Guardian has this helpful breakdown of the policy positions of the various parties in today's election -- far more illuminating (by leaps and bounds) than any reporting provided by "the newspaper of record." For instance, in none of its reporting -- and I'm going by memory here; I might have missed one Berlusconi story --did it mention that Forza Italia favors a universal basic income (and more generous than that proposed by M5S!). Really and truly, The New York Times has become inseparable from the USG.

Centre-right: Forza Italia, led by four-time prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, aims to introduce a “parallel currency” for domestic use, keeping the euro for international trade; have a single, flat rate income tax for companies and individuals; abolish housing, inheritance and road tax; double the minimum pension; introduce a minimum income of €1,000 a month for all and block new immigrant arrivals.
Radical right: The League (formerly the Northern League), led by Matteo Salvini, would also introduce a parallel currency; abolish the EU’s fiscal compact; bring in a flat tax for all at 15%; allow earlier retirement; repatriate 100,000 illegal immigrants a year; and reopen Italy’s brothels. Brothers of Italy, led by Giorgia Meloni, is a southern equivalent of the League with neofascist roots and similar policies.
Anti-establishment: The Five Star Movement, led by 31-year-old Luigi Di Maio, proposes a minimum monthly income of €780; raising the budget deficit; repealing 400 “useless” laws including labour and pension reforms to allow earlier retirement and make firing harder; raising taxes on energy companies and improving relations with Russia.
Centre-left: The Democratic party, led by former prime minister Matteo Renzi, proposes an increase in the minimum wage; negotiating to abolish the fiscal compact and raising the budget deficit to 3% of GDP so as to cut taxes and increase investment.
Left: Free and Equal is led by Pietro Grasso, and is a new party uniting smaller groups that left Renzi’s Democratic party. It proposes repealing labour and pension reforms and boosting public spending. 

Friday, March 2, 2018

What Comes Next is Fascism

With the Italian general election a few days away The New York Times is definitely gunning for the Five Star Movement (M5S). Yesterday it was "The Mystery Man Who Runs Italy’s ‘Five Star’ From the Shadows." Today it is "Will Russia Meddle in Italy’s Election? It May Not Have To." Both are written by Jason Horowitz, the Rome bureau chief, who is a journalistic hit man specializing in tabloid  smears. He held the "Get Bernie" portfolio in 2016. After Sunday, The Times will probably send Horowitz to the next election hot spot so he can peddle his fictions and innuendo.

Horowitz is tarring M5S as corrupt, opaque and a Russian cutout; the young people who are the base of the party's support, shameful dupes, much like the kids who swelled Bernie's ranks.

It is fascinating to bear witness to the propaganda organs of the Democratic center as it implodes. The only argument on offer is an omniscient Russian meddling. There is never any substantive discussion of why the Socialists in France, why the SPD in Germany, why Matteo Renzi's Democratic Party in Italy are performing worse than ever before. The only reason given is the evil Putin somehow pulling strings from the Kremlin. Call it the present-day version of the stab-in-the-back myth.

It is the same in the United States. When you talk to a stalwart Democratic she will talk first of Russian meddling. There is no positive vision of the future. Even "Medicare For All" is dismissed with the exasperated question, "Well, who is going to pay for it?"

The Democratic center, mainstream neoliberalism, is at its end. What comes next -- unless new parties like M5S or a Momentum-captured Labour catch on -- is fascism.

Thursday, March 1, 2018

Liberals Beginning to Question Cold War 2.0?

A good article this morning picked up from Niqnaq is BuzzFeed's "Stop Blaming Russian Bots For Everything," by Miriam Elder and Charlie Wartzel. Elder and Wartzel are Russophobic. For instance, they believe the DNC hack was perpetrated by Russia. Nonetheless they can't abide recent excesses in the prestige press that link every bit of dissent within the U.S. to a Kremlin-engineered bot. In other words, there is an element within the shrinking liberal consensus that sees that the New Cold War as a pit trap:
By now you know the drill: massive news event happens, journalists scramble to figure out what’s going on, and within a couple hours the culprit is found — Russian bots.
Russian bots were blamed for driving attention to the Nunes memo, a Republican-authored document on the Trump-Russia probe. They were blamed for pushing for Roy Moore to win in Alabama’s special election. And here they are wading into the gun debate following the Parkland shooting. “[T]he messages from these automated accounts, or bots, were designed to widen the divide and make compromise even more difficult,” wrote the New York Times in a story following the shooting, citing little more than “Twitter accounts suspected of having links to Russia.”
This is, not to mince words, total bullshit.
The thing is, nearly every time you see a story blaming Russian bots for something, you can be pretty sure that the story can be traced back to a single source: the Hamilton 68 dashboard, founded by a group of respected researchers, including Clint Watts and JM Berger, and currently run under the auspices of the German Marshall Fund.
But even some of the people who popularized that metric now acknowledge it’s become totally overblown.
“I’m not convinced on this bot thing,” said Watts, the cofounder of a project that is widely cited as the main, if not only, source of information on Russian bots. He also called the narrative “overdone.”
The dashboard monitors 600 Twitter accounts “linked to Russian influence efforts online,” according to its own description, which means the accounts are not all directly traced back to Kremlin efforts, or even necessarily to Russia. “They are not all in Russia,” Watts said during a phone interview last week. “We don’t even think they’re all commanded in Russia — at all. We think some of them are legitimately passionate people that are just really into promoting Russia.” So, not bots.
We’ll likely never know the contents of the list for sure — because the researchers decline to divulge the identity of who they are monitoring. (The reasons they give for secrecy include worries that the accounts would then change their behavior and concerns over identifying accounts that are not, in fact, linked to Russian influence efforts, aka making a mistake.)

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Italian General Election + Results of SPD Groko Vote This Sunday

Italians hold their general election on Sunday. The Five Star Movement (M5S) has been leading in the polls all year. The problem is this lead likely won't translate into a parliamentary majority. Conventional wisdom is that the Berulsconi-led right-wing coalition, which includes the Northern League, will form a government. But it is unclear to me that they will have the votes.

One thing seems certain. Matteo Renzi and the establishment Democratic Party will do poorly. This continues the trend across Europe where the mainstream political left is collapsing. U.S. Democrats should take note.

Also on Sunday results of a membership vote will be announced in Germany as to whether the Social Democratic Party (SPD) should renew its grand coalition (Groko) with the Christian Democrats.

Given the stakes of both the Italian election and SPD Groko referendum the lack of coverage in "the newspaper of record" has been noteworthy. Peter Goodman wrote a good story for the business page the other day, "Italy Is Having an Election. Most Italians Are Too Depressed to Care." The elements of malaise he describes -- youth unemployment; long-term joblessness; lean, capital-intensive production; political apathy -- could be applied to any Western nation.

One thing can be gleaned from NYT's sparse Italian reporting, even from the sneering Jason Horowitz -- M5S is on the rise.

The Times doesn't have a Macron to fluff in Italy or Germany. So rather than really report on what is happening -- we live in an age when there is remarkable broad-based disdain for the governing political parties and said parties are collapsing -- the Times mostly prefers to say nothing.

Which says a lot.

Tuesday, February 27, 2018

Janus: Beginning of a Real Labor Party in the U.S.?

In "Key Voice Is Silent in Supreme Court Case on Unions" Adam Liptak provides the write-up of the Janus arguments before the Supreme Court yesterday:
WASHINGTON — A crucial voice was silent at Supreme Court arguments on Monday in a case that could deal a sharp blow to public unions. Justice Neil M. Gorsuch, who almost certainly holds the decisive vote, asked no questions, leaving some doubt, if only a glimmer, about whether he would join the court’s conservative majority to rule that forcing workers to support public unions violates the First Amendment.
Justice Gorsuch generally votes with the court’s conservatives, and he is likely to do so in this case. But his silence during the argument meant that observers knew no more about his thinking by the time it ended than when it had begun.
I took it the opposite way, proof that it is a done deal. Gorsuch kept his mouth shut because it is broadly accepted that his appointment to the court was predicated on his support for overturning Abood:
The court’s more liberal members said that states should have broad leeway in managing public workplaces. They added that a decision against the unions would require overruling a 40-year-old precedent, striking down more than 20 state laws, creating confusion about thousands of union contracts and disrupting the lives of millions of workers.
“I don’t think that we have ever overruled a case where reliance interests are remotely as strong as they are here,” Justice Elena Kagan said.
A decision overruling the precedent would conclude a decades-long political and legal campaign by conservative groups aimed at weakening public-sector unions. Those unions stand to lose fees from workers who object to the positions the unions take and from those who simply choose not to join while benefiting from the unions’ efforts on their behalf.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg reflected on the consequences of ruling against the union in the case before the court. “It drains it of resources that make it an equal partner” with the government in negotiations, she told William L. Messenger, a lawyer for Mark Janus, an Illinois child support specialist who objected to positions taken by his union in negotiations. “And then you’ll have a union with diminished resources, not able to investigate what it should demand at the bargaining table, not equal to the employer that it faces.”
Near the end of the argument, Justice Sonia Sotomayor said the case represented an existential threat to the labor movement. “You’re basically arguing, ‘Do away with unions,’ ” she told Mr. Messenger.
The case was a challenge to an Illinois law that requires government workers who choose not to join unions to “pay their proportionate share of the costs of the collective bargaining process, contract administration and pursuing matters affecting wages, hours and other conditions of employment.” More than 20 states have similar laws.
The Supreme Court ruled that such laws are constitutional in Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, a foundational 1977 decision that made a distinction between two kinds of compelled payments. Forcing nonmembers to pay for a union’s political activities violated the First Amendment, the court said. But it was constitutional, the court added, to require nonmembers to help pay for the union’s collective bargaining efforts to prevent freeloading and ensure “labor peace.”
We have very few fair-share payers in my union. Whether and how much this changes once the court rules in favor of Janus remains to be seen.

Noam Scheiber and Kenneth Vogel penned an excellent article, "Behind a Key Anti-Labor Case, a Web of Conservative Donors," about the principal conservative financial backers of the assault on unions. Not only is there the legal attack, but there is also the outreach effort to rank'n'file members prompting them to opt out:
During 2015 and 2016, the foundation also substantially increased its contributions, totaling well over $1 million, to groups like the Independence Institute of Colorado and the Freedom Foundation of Washington State. Those groups have used such tools as direct mail, phone calls and door knocking to persuade public-sector workers to give up union membership.
Richard Graber, the chief executive of the Bradley Foundation, said the foundation avoided short-term tactical considerations in its giving. But he acknowledged that the increase was driven partly by the recent Supreme Court developments, which promised to make such opt-out campaigns more compelling for union members. (Some conservative groups are currently raising money for even more ambitious opt-out campaigns to take advantage of a favorable ruling this year.)
This is the real problem. Most union members, even the virulently conservative ones, are satisfied leaving well enough alone. They might grumble about the union, but they don't want to be seen by coworkers as free riders. Suddenly if millions of dollars are being spent to organize them to leave the union, that's a different story. The Walker attack on unions in Wisconsin had a devastating impact:
In 2011, Wisconsin rolled back the right of most public unions to bargain over anything other than wages and eliminated the requirement that nonmembers pay fees. The portion of unionized public-sector workers in the state plummeted from half to just over one-quarter within five years.
There is no way to sugarcoat this. There is going to be loss and disruption. But if there is a silver lining here it is that now shop-floor organizing is going to be unavoidable for public-sector unions. Regular people are going to have claim an ownership stake in their union locals rather than being passive fee-for-service consumers. Otherwise the gravy train gets derailed.

Another potential positive -- this is more of a long shot -- is that organized labor might start asking more of the Democratic Party. If the Democrats can't prevent Doomsday from arriving, why pledge allegiance? Maybe after weathering the worst that the right can muster a shrunken but hardened union movement can launch a real Labor Party.

That's the question the McResistance needs to be asking. The Democrats have failed to deliver on DACA. They are about to fail to deliver on gun safety. (I don't think Dems in congress are even talking about an assault weapons ban.) They have been unable to protect public-sector unions from right-to-work. What is the point of the Democratic Party?

Monday, February 26, 2018

Stasis and Super Bowl LII

"The Schiff memo released Saturday is in every respect a right-wing document. It graphically illustrates the fact that the Democratic Party has shifted so far to the right that it has become the most subservient defender of the Pentagon, the CIA, the NSA, the FBI and the entire repressive apparatus of the American capitalist state." 
Barry Grey, "Democratic memo defends FBI’s illegal spying on Trump campaign"
"Lawmakers on Capitol Hill are also back, after a weeklong recess. They face intense pressure to act on gun control, but, as our reporters note, 'If the past is prologue, Congress will do nothing.' "
Chris Stanford, "Xi Jinping, Winter Olympics, Weinstein Company: Your Monday Briefing"
Stasis is stagnation. It is usually called "gridlock." One of the first great works of Western literature, Thucydides' History of the Peloponnesian War, was devoted to it. A society will collapse if stasis goes on for too long.

That's where we are now. We are in our fourth decade of neoliberalism. It is well past time for a change, but the rich don't want to change, don't even want modest reforms. So we're headed for, are actively experiencing, a crackup.

It has been three weeks since Super Bowl LII, a wonderful game that had a wonderful outcome. The match-up featured the stalwarts of the corporate ruling class, the very white New England Patriots, versus the upstart, and very black Philadelphia Eagles.


The Eagles ran on the field Super Bowl Sunday to Meek Mill's "Dreams and Nightmares." "Dreams and Nightmares" is the number one track off the album of the same name released in 2012. New England ran on the field to that hoary headbanger classic "Crazy Train." The Patriots have been making their field entrance to Ozzy Osbourne's "Crazy Train" for years. "Crazy Train" is a single off Osbourne's debut solo album, Blizzard of Ozz, recorded and released in 1980.

It would have been as if one of the teams at the first Super Bowl in 1967 ran on the field to a song by Rudy Vallee and his Connecticut Yankees, while the other entered to the sounds of "Good Day Sunshine" by the Beatles.

It said everything about the stasis gripping our society. The corporate exemplars clutching their totem from the outset of the age of neoliberalism; the upstarts, a hip hop anthem of the underclass.

What is truly noteworthy about Super Bowl LII is that the suits of the National Football League got it. They understood the dynamic at play. For all the scapegoating of Colin Kaepernick, they are aware that the ratings drop that has plagued the league the last two seasons is a problem of their own making.

So what did they do? They actively came down on the side of the Eagles. There were two booth reviews of touchdowns during the game that would have gone against the Eagles during the regular season but instead they were upheld. In other words, if Super Bowl LII would have been officiated like any regular season game, the Patriots would have won.

Prior to the game wherever I went whomever I spoke with wanted Philadelphia to win. I must have talked to 20 people. The league no doubt was receiving the same message.

Nonetheless ratings for the game were still down. But at least the league made a correction. There is no evidence that the political system is capable of such a move.

As I was telling a coworker last week, the Parkland massacre is a basic test whether we have a functioning democracy. We have a single issue that everyone understands, and a simple legislative fix that was recently on the books that everyone understands. If we cannot ban assault weapons, then we have concrete proof that we don't live in an open society.

There is an argument that congress will ban bump stocks and strengthen background checks, both of which were promised after the Las Vegas massacre, as a sop to the high school kids; that way leadership in the House and Senate can pretend to be responsive to the popular will.

On the other hand, why change anything when you control everything? That's the sentiment on high.

Under neoliberalism it appears that we have more power as consumers than citizens. Political reform appears impossible in the current dispensation. We know from Thucydides where this leads. And it is not pretty nor is it pleasant. A collapse is coming.