Showing posts with label Janus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Janus. Show all posts

Friday, June 29, 2018

The End of Schengen + Hodeidah & Janus Updates

The new Italian government, by promising to block all regular business at the EU summit, managed to achieve a new resolution on migration. Sputnik summarizes the agreement as follows:
According to a final statement made after 9 hours of talks, the leaders agreed to enhance screening migrants for asylum eligibility and set up "disembarkation platforms” in North Africa to discourage those fleeing to Europe from boarding smuggling boats.
The plan also stipulates the establishment of joint processing camps within the bloc and to restrict their movement across member-states.
The second part of the last sentence should placate Merkel's coalition partner, the Bavarian CSU.

It brings an end to the Schengen Area of free travel because some form of border will have to be erected to keep registered migrants from moving between countries.

In the latest issue of New Left Review Stathis Kouvelakis argues in "Borderland" that it is the de facto system already in place. There are already detention centers in Africa and refugees are already barred from free travel within Europe. The new Brussel's deal is merely an official acknowledgement.

And it's not going to placate the ascendant ethno-nationalist parties, as Steven Erlanger and Katrin Bennhold report in "E.U. Reaches Deal on Migration at Summit, but Details Sketchy":
Ms. Merkel’s pro-European stance and her decision to open Germany’s borders to more than 1.4 million migrants since 2015 have earned her a reputation as a defender of liberal values, while also making her the main target of far-right and populist forces across the Continent.
Her address in Parliament on Thursday was unusually combative, and it was frequently interrupted by heckling from representatives of Alternative for Germany. The noise level was so high at one point that Ms. Merkel stopped and said: “My God. Really?” 
In Brussels, the Hungarian prime minister, Victor Orban, was characteristically harsh.
“I think the people really request two things: First is, no more migrants in,” he said. The second, he said, would be the deportation of those who are already in Europe but do not qualify as refugees.
“So that’s what the people want,” Mr. Orban said. “So I think in order to restore the European democracy, we have to move to that direction.”
**** 

Hodeidah Update: There is no deal for the UN to take over control of the seaport because the Saudi-puppet president of Yemen Abdrabbuh Mansur Hadi won't allow any Houthi militia to remain in the city.

****

Janus Update: Calls are starting to come in from our public sector employers asking if any of our members are fee payers. These are people known as Beck Objectors, individuals who have resigned their union membership but continue to pay fees that amount to the cost of representing them. Now post-Janus, they won't have to pay anything.

There is a complex accounting that goes into determining what a union local can charge for representation. At our local because we only have one staff organizer and the political action committee is completely fire-walled from all other aspects of the union the chargeable rate is high, usually around 95%

Fortunately we have very few fee payers. I had the satisfaction of telling the county and the ferry system that we had no fee payers there. I asked the person from the ferries if she was experiencing any blow back from Janus. She said so far, no. But she still had to call the inlandboat union and the sheet metal workers.

My assessment is that there is no strong anti-union current of the Zeitgeist. If one surfaces then it will have to have been generated externally.

Wednesday, June 27, 2018

Waiting for Janus

UPDATE: First day after the Janus ruling wasn't too bad at the local. I'm anticipating it will be different in the coming weeks as right-wing groups roll out whatever mobilization plan they have.

Here's a good bit of analysis pulled from the comments section of the main NYT story by Adam Liptak devoted to the ruling:
Sean
New Haven, Connecticut June 27
This decision is outrageous, and Justices Kagan and Sotomayor rightly call it out for the naked partisan ruling it is.
Justice Kagan especially cites the cynical way in which the Republican justices cite themselves from over the past few years in order to overturn a law for no other reason than because they just don't like it.
Even more sinister, she and Justice Sotomayor note, is how they have clearly weaponized the First Amendment to prevent democratic governance in this country. They are paving the way for a libertarian dystopia in which any attempt by citizens in a system of self-governance to install necessary and logical regulations is crushed by a reflexive and meaningless complaint of infringement upon an individual's free speech.

Today's decision makes it abundantly clear that compromise with the radical right-wing GOP is no longer possible. They have only one goal: the complete dismantling of a democratic government in which individuals negotiate their own self-interest with the need to create a stable and functioning society as a whole. And they continue to demonstrate that there is no new low to which they will stoop to achieve that.

It becomes harder and harder to see how we are not barreling towards another civil war, in which once again nothing less than the soul of the Union is at stake.
****

The Janus decision will be announced by the Supreme Court at some point this morning. The local where I work has been preparing for it for months. Everyone thinks it's a foregone conclusion that Abood will be overturned, the 1977 decision which upheld the legality of the union shop and fair share fees in the public sector. The court was split 4-4 on Friedrichs, a similar case having to do with union shop in the public sector, because Antonin Scalia died unexpectedly.

What does it mean? If Wisconsin is any indication, public sector unions will bleed out quickly nationwide. I'm not sure that Janus will be as draconian as Scott Walker's Act 10. It could be. Some say the court is moving in the direction to outlaw all unions.

It's not good. Once the decision is announced, right-wing groups will contact public sector union members and ask them to opt out. Disgruntled and misinformed union members will then demand to be free of their local union.

It's an attack. Unions will have to marshal resources to respond. Our local is 20% public sector. Financially we can probably weather a worst-case scenario. But there are ripple effects. So much energy is going to be required to respond to a presumably significant number of workers wanting to opt out that other things will fall through the cracks.

I have worked for various union locals, central labor councils and Taft-Hartley trusts for nearly 20 years. During that time there always been some form of crisis. It has never been easy. I figured that I worked in a dying industry. But what industry isn't dying at this point?

Thursday, June 14, 2018

Zombie Neoliberalism Racking Up Victories

With the U.S. Supreme Court set to roll back public sector unions any day now, it never ceases to amaze me how a zombie paradigm, neoliberalism, can keep on racking up victories absent any mass base of public support.

The latest example is the privatization of the French national railway, SNCF, by the government of Emmanuel Macron. The French National Assembly voted for privatization and the reduction of rail-worker benefits yesterday; the Senate will approve the legislation today.

Alissa Rubin's elegy, "Can Strikes in France Still Make a Difference?," for strike-based egalitarian French culture is worth reading. What we are losing as zombie neoliberalism plods on is hard to fathom, but it is enormous.

On most Wednesdays I treat myself to takeout from my local Thai restaurant. While I am waiting for my order I'll sample from the always numerous selection of pamphlets from the Atammayatarama Buddhist Monastery near the front counter.

Last night this paragraph from page 13 of Food for Thought caught my eye:
One day, people will not be able to muster inspiration nor recall the way to seek spiritual sustenance. In the end, the minds of human beings will be empty except for thoughts of sensuality and selfishness. This is when fire will wash the face of the earth.

Tuesday, February 27, 2018

Janus: Beginning of a Real Labor Party in the U.S.?

In "Key Voice Is Silent in Supreme Court Case on Unions" Adam Liptak provides the write-up of the Janus arguments before the Supreme Court yesterday:
WASHINGTON — A crucial voice was silent at Supreme Court arguments on Monday in a case that could deal a sharp blow to public unions. Justice Neil M. Gorsuch, who almost certainly holds the decisive vote, asked no questions, leaving some doubt, if only a glimmer, about whether he would join the court’s conservative majority to rule that forcing workers to support public unions violates the First Amendment.
Justice Gorsuch generally votes with the court’s conservatives, and he is likely to do so in this case. But his silence during the argument meant that observers knew no more about his thinking by the time it ended than when it had begun.
I took it the opposite way, proof that it is a done deal. Gorsuch kept his mouth shut because it is broadly accepted that his appointment to the court was predicated on his support for overturning Abood:
The court’s more liberal members said that states should have broad leeway in managing public workplaces. They added that a decision against the unions would require overruling a 40-year-old precedent, striking down more than 20 state laws, creating confusion about thousands of union contracts and disrupting the lives of millions of workers.
“I don’t think that we have ever overruled a case where reliance interests are remotely as strong as they are here,” Justice Elena Kagan said.
A decision overruling the precedent would conclude a decades-long political and legal campaign by conservative groups aimed at weakening public-sector unions. Those unions stand to lose fees from workers who object to the positions the unions take and from those who simply choose not to join while benefiting from the unions’ efforts on their behalf.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg reflected on the consequences of ruling against the union in the case before the court. “It drains it of resources that make it an equal partner” with the government in negotiations, she told William L. Messenger, a lawyer for Mark Janus, an Illinois child support specialist who objected to positions taken by his union in negotiations. “And then you’ll have a union with diminished resources, not able to investigate what it should demand at the bargaining table, not equal to the employer that it faces.”
Near the end of the argument, Justice Sonia Sotomayor said the case represented an existential threat to the labor movement. “You’re basically arguing, ‘Do away with unions,’ ” she told Mr. Messenger.
The case was a challenge to an Illinois law that requires government workers who choose not to join unions to “pay their proportionate share of the costs of the collective bargaining process, contract administration and pursuing matters affecting wages, hours and other conditions of employment.” More than 20 states have similar laws.
The Supreme Court ruled that such laws are constitutional in Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, a foundational 1977 decision that made a distinction between two kinds of compelled payments. Forcing nonmembers to pay for a union’s political activities violated the First Amendment, the court said. But it was constitutional, the court added, to require nonmembers to help pay for the union’s collective bargaining efforts to prevent freeloading and ensure “labor peace.”
We have very few fair-share payers in my union. Whether and how much this changes once the court rules in favor of Janus remains to be seen.

Noam Scheiber and Kenneth Vogel penned an excellent article, "Behind a Key Anti-Labor Case, a Web of Conservative Donors," about the principal conservative financial backers of the assault on unions. Not only is there the legal attack, but there is also the outreach effort to rank'n'file members prompting them to opt out:
During 2015 and 2016, the foundation also substantially increased its contributions, totaling well over $1 million, to groups like the Independence Institute of Colorado and the Freedom Foundation of Washington State. Those groups have used such tools as direct mail, phone calls and door knocking to persuade public-sector workers to give up union membership.
Richard Graber, the chief executive of the Bradley Foundation, said the foundation avoided short-term tactical considerations in its giving. But he acknowledged that the increase was driven partly by the recent Supreme Court developments, which promised to make such opt-out campaigns more compelling for union members. (Some conservative groups are currently raising money for even more ambitious opt-out campaigns to take advantage of a favorable ruling this year.)
This is the real problem. Most union members, even the virulently conservative ones, are satisfied leaving well enough alone. They might grumble about the union, but they don't want to be seen by coworkers as free riders. Suddenly if millions of dollars are being spent to organize them to leave the union, that's a different story. The Walker attack on unions in Wisconsin had a devastating impact:
In 2011, Wisconsin rolled back the right of most public unions to bargain over anything other than wages and eliminated the requirement that nonmembers pay fees. The portion of unionized public-sector workers in the state plummeted from half to just over one-quarter within five years.
There is no way to sugarcoat this. There is going to be loss and disruption. But if there is a silver lining here it is that now shop-floor organizing is going to be unavoidable for public-sector unions. Regular people are going to have claim an ownership stake in their union locals rather than being passive fee-for-service consumers. Otherwise the gravy train gets derailed.

Another potential positive -- this is more of a long shot -- is that organized labor might start asking more of the Democratic Party. If the Democrats can't prevent Doomsday from arriving, why pledge allegiance? Maybe after weathering the worst that the right can muster a shrunken but hardened union movement can launch a real Labor Party.

That's the question the McResistance needs to be asking. The Democrats have failed to deliver on DACA. They are about to fail to deliver on gun safety. (I don't think Dems in congress are even talking about an assault weapons ban.) They have been unable to protect public-sector unions from right-to-work. What is the point of the Democratic Party?