Friday, May 8, 2015

British Election Results Spell Doom for Democrats in the U.S.

I'm surprised it wasn't on the front page of the print edition of The New York Times this morning. But I suppose there was some concern that the exit polling predicting a big win for the Tories wasn't to be trusted entirely. Well, that is all changed now, as Steven Erlanger and Stephen Castle trumpet in "David Cameron and Conservatives Get Majority in British Election" from the top spot on the Gray Lady's homepage:
LONDON — Prime Minister David Cameron and his Conservatives won a resounding victory in the British general election, with nearly complete results on Friday showing that the party had secured an overall majority in Parliament. 
The vote was a stunning disappointment for the opposition Labour Party and its leader, Ed Miliband, who had shifted the party away from the more centrist strategy it pursued in the late 1990s and early 2000s under Tony Blair. Mr. Miliband stepped down on Friday, opening up a new debate over the party’s direction. 
The result defied pre-election opinion polls that suggested a tight race between the Conservatives and Labour. It returns Mr. Cameron to 10 Downing Street for a second term, with enough seats in the House of Commons to act on his agenda without having to rely on support from smaller parties. 
He went to Buckingham Palace on Friday to be invited by the queen to form a new government.
Labour was nearly wiped out in Scotland by the surging Scottish National Party and did more poorly than pre-election opinion polls had suggested it would in the rest of Britain. Several of Mr. Miliband’s top lieutenants lost their seats.
The predicted final tally is 331 seats for the Tories out of 650, a stunning gain of 24 seats from the last election in 2010; stunning because the Conservatives have governed so diffidently, implementing unpopular neoliberal austerity that is au courant on the German-dominated Continent.

The "dead-on-arrival" Liberal Democrats were replaced as Britain's third party by the surging Scottish National Party (SNP). SNP ended up with 56 out of 59 seats in Scotland.

But nothing is more noteworthy than the complete collapse of Labour under Ed Miliband. Labour is predicted to end up with 232 seats, a loss of 26 seats from 2010. What makes this collapse so noteworthy is that it clearly augurs ill for the Democrats going into the 2016 presidential elections.

Labour and the Democrats are largely the same, led to the weakened, listing place they are today by the corporate-friendly leadership of Bill Clinton and Tony Blair.

Miliband made all the right noises during the campaign. He attacked austerity, promised to raise wages and restore funding to National Health, much the same way that Hillary is mouthing the appropriate progressive words on income inequality and racial justice. But here is the thing: No one, only the most deeply-committed partisan, believes anything that Labour/Democrats say anymore. Everyone knows that once Labour/Dems take office and begin to govern the "people" they answer to are the corporations.

Is there any other way to interpret the election results in Britain?

Democrat bosses in New York City and Washington D.C. should take note and quickly implement a Plan B. SNP kicked ass because the party has no baggage and it stands for something that people want: independence from empire, broad equality and social spending.

Democrats should take a page from the GOP playbook post-2008 and do a "Tea Party makeover," except in this case the Dems need to swing sharply to the left. It is the only way to avoid disaster. Instead the Democrats are doubling down on the New Democrat corporate-friendly leadership of Hillary Clinton, a strategy that has placed the party at the edge of doom.

I bang my little toy drum on this page. The Democrats should beat a retreat from Clinton right now to avoid disaster -- unified government under a radically conservative Republican Party. That no change will be made, no Plan B implemented to avoid this onrushing calamity is amazing to me. Yet it is a sign of the times.

****

Look for Hippies vs. Punks tomorrow morning -- Black Flag's My War.

Thursday, May 7, 2015

"Need That Poison Gas" Redux

For the states -- Turkey, Saudi Arabia, as well as other members of the Gulf Cooperation Council -- that came tantalizingly close to pulling off the Ghouta sarin gas scam in August 2013 the temptation to pluck the note again and again until the desired result is finally achieved -- the exit of the Baathists from power in Syria -- never ends.

Not long after Syria started dismantling its arsenal of chemical weapons in a deal brokered by Russia, reports started to emerge of chlorine bombs being dropped from helicopters. These reports usually originated with "activists" aligned with the "opposition" to the Syrian state, and they were summarily dismissed as crude propaganda by representatives of the Assad government. But the stories have remained a regular feature as the months roll along.

Today's offering is a fine example. In "Syria Is Using Chemical Weapons Again, Rescue Workers Say" Anne Barnard and Somini Sengupta earn their pay as propagandists for the USG by filing another fallacious story about Syria's use of chemical weapons; fallacious because it is sourced to a "civilian defense" NGO called White Helmets. An inspection of the group's web site -- Barrel Bombs! -- linked to in the Barnard-Sengupta article, leaves one with the distinct impression that it is a CIA front. The allegations of White Helmets are then amplified by USG officials. This is the old familiar propaganda pattern. You have an "Astro-Turf" organization, an ersatz citizen group of some sort that has been mocked up by a foreign intelligence agency, make a specious charge, and then that charge is taken up by the United States in the United Nations Security Council:
Two years after President Bashar al-Assad agreed to dismantle Syria’s chemical weapons stockpile, there is mounting evidence that his government is flouting international law to drop jerry-built chlorine bombs on insurgent-held areas. Lately, the pace of the bombardments in contested areas like Idlib Province has picked up, rescue workers say, as government forces have faced new threats from insurgents. The Assad government has so far evaded more formal scrutiny because of political, legal and technical obstacles to assigning blame for the attacks — a situation that feels surreal to many Syrians under the bombs, who say it is patently clear the government drops them.
“People are so used to it, they know from the sound,” said Hatem Abu Marwan, 29, a rescue worker with the White Helmets civil defense organization, a note of exasperation creeping into his voice when asked to explain. “We know the sound of a helicopter that goes to a low height and drops a barrel. Nobody has aircraft except the regime.”
Prodded by the United States, the United Nations Security Council is discussing a draft resolution that would create a panel, reporting to the secretary general, to determine which of the warring parties is responsible for using chlorine as a weapon, according to Council diplomats.
“The Security Council must address the need to determine who is responsible for using chlorine as weapons in Syria,” said an American official, who declined to offer specifics and requested anonymity to discuss continuing negotiations. “Doing so is critical to getting justice for the Syrian people and accountability for those who have repeatedly used chemical weapons in Syria.”
Advertisement
Syrian state media dismiss the allegations as propaganda, and the Council remains divided and hamstrung. That leaves people like Mr. Abu Marwan, who has responded to nine suspected chlorine attacks, feeling abandoned. “There is no law to defend us as human beings, this is what we understand from the Security Council,” said Mr. Abu Marwan, a law school graduate, weeping as he recalled holding a dying child in Sarmeen. “I didn’t see in humanitarian law anything that says ‘except for Syrians.’ ”
You have the propaganda all there in a nutshell: the nefarious Assad; the hamstrung UNSC; the devoted, virtuous law-school graduate weeping with a dead gassed baby cradled in his arms. It is crass, and, at this point, tapped so often as it has been, it is ineffective. But the propaganda machine must extrude its product regardless of quality.

The "smoking gun" in the Barnard-Sengupta story is the helicopter. The chlorine gas is dropped in barrels by low-flying helicopters. We are supposed to baldly accept that only the Syrian government possesses helicopters. What the propagandists are attempting to capitalize on is the "barrel bombs" meme that the Western mainstream media has invested so robustly in. The reader has been conditioned to accept that the Syrian government and only the Syrian government bombs its people from the air by rolling barrels packed with explosives out of helicopters.

Hence, the conclusion to the Barnard-Sengupta piece:
A video taken Sunday in the town of Khansafra shows a barrel dropping from a helicopter and rescue workers holding up a portion of a canister labeled in English. The camera shakes, blurring all but a few words: “hazard,” “may cause irritation,” “caution,” “breathing.”
The obvious question is, Whose helicopter is it? Are there any markings? If it is a black helicopter, is there evidence that the Syrian government uses such helicopters?

An obvious question is, Why couldn't one of the Islamist jihadi groups, which have captured much Iraqi and Syrian military equipment, have piloted the helicopter?

The fact that Barnard and Sengupta give hardly a hint of the Iraqi Kurd reports from March that Islamic State used chlorine gas in attacks against its peshmerga is a strong tell that the two Gray Lady reporters are singing for their supper. Any open-minded reporter would explore the possibility that Nusra or ISIS could stage chlorine attacks. There is only this pro forma mention:
Frustrated with the Security Council’s impasse over the issue, rescue workers and doctors are now working to bring evidence of chlorine gas attacks directly to the French, British and American governments for testing. The aim is to give states a solid basis for action against the attacks, in the Security Council or through quieter diplomatic pressure, said James Le Mesurier, the British director of a nonprofit group, Mayday Rescue, that trains and equips the White Helmets, Syrian volunteers supported by the British, Danish and Dutch governments. 
Going directly to governments that have pushed for Mr. Assad’s ouster creates its own challenges. His allies may dismiss their evidence as politically tainted and can point to recent chlorine attacks in Iraq for which the government there blamed insurgents, not to mention the discredited American claims of an Iraqi chemical weapons program that were used to justify invading Iraq.
All we need to know about the recent spate of chlorine bomb attacks is that the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW), which set up a special mission last spring to look into the use of chlorine gas in Syria, won't endorse the claims that the Syrian government is to blame:
But investigators face difficulties. Chlorine dissipates quickly in the atmosphere and does not last in blood or urine, and residue stays in soil for just 48 hours, leaving little time to transport samples across borders. Also, Mr. Le Mesurier said, the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons differentiates evidence it collects itself from evidence collected by rescue workers, categorizing the latter as circumstantial.
Emergency workers said they met recently with investigators from the organization, but Dr. Tennari called the body’s response “poor and slow.” Mr. Le Mesurier remarked, “No one showed up on a white steed.”
Three other Syrian doctors said the organization’s rules resulted in valuable evidence they collected going unexamined. 
One, who protects his identity with the nickname “Chemical Hazem” for his safety, said he reached one of the April 2014 attack sites, Tal Minnes, within hours, smelling bleach in the air. He smuggled samples from two victims to Turkey without waiting for border clearances. But he said the O.P.C.W. refused to accept an unexploded canister, which remains in Syria. 
“The ultimate evidence of the regime’s use of chemical weapons is gone,” he said, adding that no one seemed interested in getting samples out of Syria. “We can’t blame anyone who wants to follow the legal channels — but do any exist?”

Wednesday, May 6, 2015

Two Good Signs: The Rise of the Scottish National Party and the Diminution of Police Exceptionalism in the U.S.

Two rays of sunshine greet today's reader of the Gray Lady: Noam Scheiber's frontpage "Police Struggle With Loss of Privileged Position" and Katrin Bennhold must-read "Nicola Sturgeon, Not Running in British Election, May Yet Prevail."

Scheiber's story is a useful recap of police missteps over the last year. No longer can police automatically rely on "thin blue line" fear-mongering and racial hatred to guarantee a privileged status. Scheiber anchors his piece with a description of St. Louis's decade-plus effort to finally pass civilian review legislation:
Early this year, Megan E. Green, a St. Louis alderwoman, met with officials of a local police union to discuss a proposal for a civilian oversight board that would look into accusations of police misconduct. After Ms. Green refused to soften her support for the proposal, the union backed an aggressive mailing campaign against her. 
But Ms. Green won her primary with over 70 percent of the vote, and the Board of Aldermen approved the oversight board by a large margin. “All that stuff backfired,” Ms. Green said. “The more they attacked me for it, the more people seemed to rally around me.” 
During the urban crime epidemic of the 1970s and ’80s and the sharp decline in crime that began in the 1990s, the unions representing police officers in many cities enjoyed a nearly unassailable political position. Their opposition could cripple political candidates and kill police-reform proposals in gestation.

But amid a rash of high-profile encounters involving allegations of police overreach in New York, Baltimore, Cleveland, Ferguson, Mo., and North Charleston, S.C., the political context in which the police unions have enjoyed a privileged position is rapidly changing. And the unions are struggling to adapt. 
“There was a time in this country when elected officials — legislators, chief executives — were willing to contextualize what police do,” said Eugene O’Donnell, a former New York City police officer and prosecutor who now teaches at John Jay College of Criminal Justice. “And that time is mostly gone.”
***
St. Louis offers a particularly vivid example of the inability of police unions to update their tactics amid widespread frustration with policing. The St. Louis Board of Aldermen first passed a measure creating a civilian oversight board back in 2006. Mayor Francis G. Slay, a Democrat, vetoed the bill at the time, citing its “inflammatory antipolice” language and questioning whether it would survive a legal challenge given that the State of Missouri still formally controlled the local Police Department. 
But, in December, after months of outrage following the shooting death of Michael Brown by a police officer in nearby Ferguson, Mr. Slay agreed to support a bill similar to the one he vetoed a decade ago. A spokeswoman for the mayor said that local control of the Police Department now made the bill legally defensible. 
The St. Louis Fraternal Order of Police, one of two prominent local unions, was not persuaded. Although the alderman involved in drafting the legislation met with union officials around the same time and asked them for input, the union offered suggestions in writing only on April 13, two days before the board was set to vote on the bill, and far too late to incorporate any of its changes.
“When we met with them in December, I was honestly interested in their thoughts,” said Alderman Terry Kennedy, who sponsored the legislation. “I would have tried to incorporate as much as I could have.” But, Mr. Kennedy said, the union’s objections proved to be a “constantly moving target.” 
Jeff Roorda, a spokesman for the union, said that once it became clear that the Board of Aldermen was determined to give the oversight board investigative authority, rather than simply review powers, the union felt it was better to save its reservations for a future legal challenge.
Civilian police review boards, even those with subpoena powers, are no panacea. Members are usually appointed by politicians, and politicians are loath to mess with the police. Once misconduct or lawbreaking is exposed, the civilian review board must then rely on police department officials and/or prosecutors to enforce penalties. Civilian review boards in one form or another exist in cities throughout the country, in New York City, for instance, and they have not proven able to check the fundamental excesses -- the racism, lethal force, and gangster-like impunity -- of the police status quo. They are better than nothing. That's about it.

Nonetheless, the fact that city legislatures are beginning to get some traction on long-stalled civilian review laws is a positive sign.

But a truly positive sign is the rise of the Scottish National Party (SNP) out of the ashes of last September's independence referendum defeat. The SNP is positioned to win 45 seats in British parliamentary elections tomorrow, basically scouring Labour leadership out of Scotland, and giving party leader Nicola Sturgeon a great deal of say in any coalition government Ed Miliband expects to form.

Take note of the adulatory opening to Katrin Bennhold's story:
ST. ANDREWS, Scotland — Nicola Sturgeon was late getting to her burgundy helicopter. It had taken her 45 minutes to traverse the 50 yards between the medieval church and the high street — and not just because of her perilous-looking designer heels.
Ms. Sturgeon, the leader of Scotland’s semiautonomous government, was campaigning for her Scottish National Party before the general election on Thursday, and the reception, by the standards of British politics, was rapturous. 
Teenagers screamed. Supporters wearing “I’m with Nicola” badges shouted her name. A half-dozen schoolgirls who skipped class for the occasion lined up to take selfies. A grandfather wanted her autograph on his new party membership card. (“My whole family has joined, three generations,” he said proudly.) 
Then, a man with a distinctly English accent approached. “I’m a fan from London,” he told her. “I wish I could vote for you.”
The affluent university town of St. Andrews, where Prince William and Kate Middleton studied, has never elected a parliamentary candidate from the left-leaning, separatist Scottish National Party in a general election. But it appears likely to do so this week, along with most of Scotland.
Ms. Sturgeon, a 44-year-old feminist from Ayrshire, a working-class county in southwest Scotland, wants to lock the Conservatives out of power, rid Britain of its nuclear weapons and end austerity measures. She has attracted the spotlight in the election campaign — and she is not even running for Parliament herself. 
Judging by opinion polls, she is all but certain to emerge as a national political force, commanding the third-largest bloc of seats in Parliament and ending the Labour Party’s long dominance in Scotland. 
Barely known in England before she took over her party last year, she has gained prominence in a series of televised debates in recent weeks. In one exchange, she challenged the head of the populist U.K. Independence Party, Nigel Farage, after he blamed immigrants for a housing crisis. 
Immigrants “make a net contribution to our country,” she told Mr. Farage. “So if we can maybe just put the boogeyman to one side, we can actually debate these issues for real and in substance,” she continued, to thunderous applause.
“It’s astonishing — —” a shocked Mr. Farage began. 
“You are, yes,” Ms. Sturgeon retorted, to more cheers. 
After she explained to a national audience why she wanted a higher minimum wage, more spending on health and child care and an end to steep budget cuts, people outside Scotland suddenly wanted to know if they could vote for her party. 
They cannot. Her party is fielding candidates only in Scotland. But with neither the Conservatives nor Labour expected to win a majority, Ms. Sturgeon could well determine the shape of the next British government — or whether one can be formed at all.

What is remarkable in Bennhold's story is the rocket-like rise of the SNP following its defeat at the polls for Scottish independence, after which Sturgeon took over party leadership from Alex Salmond:
So far, Ed Miliband, the Labour leader, has ruled out setting up a formal coalition, suggesting that he expects the Scottish Nationalists to support his agenda in any case. The two parties have similar economic platforms, though they differ sharply on some other issues, like nuclear disarmament and Scottish independence. 
But Ms. Sturgeon says that Labour cannot be trusted to make Britain a fairer country on its own. “We can bring an influence to bear on Ed Miliband and a Labour government to make them more progressive,” she said in an interview.
“There is as much of an appetite for political change in England as there is in Scotland,” she continued. “The fact that neither Labour nor the Tories are ahead in the polls reflects the fact that people think they haven’t got much of a choice.”
The right-leaning tabloid The Daily Mail has called her “the most dangerous woman in British politics.” Prime Minister David Cameron has described a possible coalition with her as “a match made in hell.” The Conservative mayor of London, Boris Johnson, likened her to a scorpion and said that allowing her party into a coalition government would be like putting King Herod in charge of a baby farm.
One Conservative campaign poster shows Mr. Miliband peeking out of Ms. Sturgeon’s pocket. Another has her as his puppet master.
Ms. Sturgeon shrugs off the vitriol. “People only try and shoot at you if you’re worth shooting at,” she said. Noting that her party has been in government in Scotland since 2007 and won a majority there in 2011, she said, “If the S.N.P. wasn’t doing well, nobody would be bothering about us.”
In the meantime, each English insult seems to strengthen her in Scotland. 
“Every time David Cameron or Ed Miliband says something stupid, there is a surge in party membership,” said Heather McLean, 59, a former Labour voter from Dundee who joined the Scottish Nationalists during the independence referendum campaign last year. “And they do that quite a lot, you know, say something stupid.” 
The referendum galvanized voters on both sides of the independence debate, drawing nearly 85 percent of Scottish voters to the polls, the highest turnout in any British election in a century. Membership in the Scottish National Party has quadrupled. [!]
Even The Sun, Rupert Murdoch’s tabloid, which is backing the Conservatives elsewhere, has jumped on the nationalist bandwagon in Scotland. Its Scottish edition depicted Ms. Sturgeon as a light-saber-wielding Princess Leia from “Star Wars” and told readers it was “time to vote S.N.P.” 
Ms. Sturgeon was delighted. “If I cast my mind back a decade, the idea of any tabloid newspaper endorsing the S.N.P. would have seemed a bit fanciful,” she said. 
When she joined the party as a teenager, it was a fringe group with three seats in the national Parliament (Scotland would not have its own legislature for another decade). It took two decades and numerous defeats before she finally won election to the Scottish Parliament. When she took her seat, she refused to take an oath of allegiance to the queen, instead swearing loyalty “to the sovereignty of the people of Scotland.”
Oh, what a beautiful thing it is. I know adoration of politicians leads nowhere but to heartbreak, but maybe there is enough intelligence and courage left in the electorate that some sort of counter-hegemonic democratic shift can come about. One thing is for sure. The United States needs the equivalent of the Scottish National Party.

Tuesday, May 5, 2015

Taliban-Afghan Pugwash Conference a Success

Call me naive, but I think the Pugwash Conference held at a beach resort in Doha, Qatar the last couple of days featuring informal talks between representatives of the Afghan Taliban and the government of Ashraf Ghani was a big success. Tentative, non-binding "common points" were reached on several topics that have proved to be stumbling blocks in the past. Both sides agreed that 1) the current Afghan constitution is not sacrosanct; 2) the Taliban can open and operate a political office in Qatar, something which sent Hamid Karzai through the roof in 2013; and 3) interference by neighboring foreign states and Daesh (ISIS) is not welcome.

Here is the complete list of "common points" as published by the Pugwash Conference:
1. There was a general appreciation of the positive value of the meeting, and a widely shared sense of gratitude towards the State of Qatar for the hospitality and the assistance given to the participants in the meeting. 
2. The idea of bringing about peace in Afghanistan and ending the conflict was wholeheartedly supported by all the participants. 
3. The civilian casualties of the Afghan conflict have been lamented by everybody, even though differences may exist on who bears the main responsibility of these casualties. Protection of civilians is, as it should be, a priority for everybody. 
4. The role of foreign forces that are or have been present in Afghanistan were evaluated in different ways (also in relation to the civilian casualties mentioned above). Everybody agreed that foreign forces have to leave Afghanistan soon. Some expressed concern that there should be an agreement among Afghan political forces before the departure of the foreign forces. 
5. Any political discrimination against any Afghan political party or group would be an obstacle to the peace process. In particular, the delisting of black-listed Taliban would facilitate the peace process. Political prisoners should be released. 
6. Corruption and the production/selling of drugs are among the most serious problems of Afghanistan. 
7. The value of education for both men and women was underlined by everybody. Economic development in Afghanistan will heavily depend on peace. 
8. The structure of the political system (and the constitution of Afghanistan) should be discussed in detail, and, while different opinions may arise in this respect, there is a general agreement that no party should have a monopoly on power. 
9.  In any case, the government of Afghanistan will be an Islamic one. This does not mean that minorities of any sort should be discriminated against. [Pamela Geller will love this one.]
10. The model of the so-called Islamic State (Daesh) is alien to the tradition and the desires of the Afghan people. This point was agreed upon by everybody. 
11.The relation with neighboring countries should be kept amicable, and cooperation with such countries should be strengthened. This does not mean that neighboring countries are welcome to interfere with Afghan internal affairs. 
12. The meeting of 2-3 May 2015 should be followed up by other meetings in order that the peace process be sustained. It is vital that communication among different Afghan parties and groups be kept alive, even at an unofficial level. In general, the peace process should be speeded up! Some would welcome the possibility of talks between the Taliban and the Government. 
13. The Taliban in Doha played an important role in the organization of this meeting. The Taliban’s office should be opened to facilitate meetings and talks. 
14. Qatar, UN and non-governmental international organizations such as Pugwash should hopefully continue to support the Afghan peace process. 
15. The public interest and the well-being of the Afghan people will be at the center of the attention of the participants in this meeting and in the forthcoming ones.
Interestingly, Rod Nordland, back in Kabul after assignment in Iraq, chooses to accentuate point #4 in "Some Progress Is Reported in Informal Afghan-Taliban Talks" as a tentative retraction of the Taliban demand that formal peace negotiations cannot begin until all occupying military forces withdraw from Afghanistan: "The Taliban signaled that they might be willing to drop their demand that all foreign troops, such as the residual American and NATO force of 13,000 trainers and counterterrorism troops, would have to be withdrawn before peace talks could take place."

Nordland cited the Taliban's post-conference statement as proof for his interpretation of point #4: "In a separate statement, the Taliban denounced the American role in the country and demanded a withdrawal, but did not appear to make that a precondition for peace talks, as they often have in the past."

But point #4, as is, says nothing about the Taliban dropping their demand on the removal of all foreign troops as a condition for the start of a formal peace process.

What Nordland's story makes clear, and one that he wrote which appeared in yesterday's paper ("Afghan and Taliban Representatives Meet in Qatar"), is that the Pugwash Conference in Doha was successful to the extent that it cut out Pakistan. This from today's story:
“Peace cannot be achieved just in talks and slogans,” the Taliban statement, posted on the group’s website, read. “There is a need for determination and good intentions.” They also appeared to dismiss a role for Pakistan in future talks, criticizing “peace talk offers that are usually made to neighboring countries.” 
Pakistan has long allowed the Taliban’s senior leadership to take refuge on its side of the border and has been wary of peace overtures that its government does not control.
And from the story yesterday:
Pakistan has long been seen as an important potential broker of any peace process between the Afghan government and the Taliban, given that many insurgent leaders have found continued shelter there. But the Qatari conference represented an effort by the Taliban to strike out independently of the Pakistanis, Mr. Mutmaeen ["an Afghan writer and journalist who previously served as an official in the Taliban government"] said. “The important point is that there are no Chinese, no Saudis or no one from Pakistan, only from Europe and the United Nations” other than the Afghans, he said. “This is a good development.” 
“This is an opportunity,” Mr. Qasimyar ["foreign policy committee chief at the Afghan government’s High Peace Council"] said. “They get together, they may have a chance to have tea or dinner or lunch at the same table, and that’s all right.”
Much has been made recently about China's sizable investment in Pakistan and its plans to build a land bridge to the Arabian Sea, as well as its own efforts to host peace talks. The Pugwash Conference highlights the obvious (something that easily gets lost): the Taliban is not a monolith. There are many different factions and players; some are agents of Pakistan, and some opposed to Pakistan. How this all plays out as the spring offensive in Afghanistan continues to get underway is hard to say. But the results of the Pugwash Conference are better news than we have had for some time.

Monday, May 4, 2015

Signs of Collapse: Non-Enforcement of Federal Election Law, Repeal of Prevailing Wage and the Return of Radical Chic

Something is happening here. When I got off the train after work on Friday the telltale massing of security officers was located at the mouth of the transit station. The underground bus/light-rail train tunnel must be a vulnerable and vital node in the city. Once up on street level I noticed helicopters hovering to the east above Capitol Hill, my neighborhood. The helicopters looked to be stationed over Seattle Central Community College. It was May Day. So I assumed some sort of protest had morphed into a street occupation and/or confrontation with the police.

As I walked up the hill on Pine Street, big black unmarked SUVs with police inside sped by. When I arrived in my neighborhood, the bars were full as usual on Friday evening. People seemed to be going about their business in spite of the noisy gyrations of helicopters overhead. At the grocery store, where I had stopped for weekend provisions, the young checker told me he had been on edge during the day because of rumors that anarchists armed with hammers would attack the supermarket, a local company that had been bought out some time ago by Kroger, a corporate behemoth.

I was going to deliver a mild defense of anarchism, something to the effect that when the state fails and is so completely captured by capital the people need to step in, but I stopped myself. The young checker was about to finish his shift and just wanted to get home. I understood completely because after a long week so did I. Outside the grocery store a cluster of police officials stood on Broadway next to a police van. The noise from the helicopters above blanketed everything.

The problem for the police now, for law enforcement throughout the country, is "radical chic" appears to be back several years after the last Occupy Wall Street encampment was torn down. Popular enthusiasm for protest and confrontation appears to be renewed. Case in point is during that Friday evening walk home after I left the transit center, I passed a young handsome couple very well dressed out on the town for a night out. The guy had on a tie and jacket; the woman, a dress. They both looked hip, not square, and elegant. But the problem for them is that they were out of place in an environment where helicopters were making industrial-strength noise overhead and black Chevy Suburbans packed with cops gunned up and down the street. The young handsome couple seemed indulgent and fragile, more like figurines on a wedding cake. They would have been better off in jeans and kaffiyeh.

That order is collapsing should be beyond dispute at this point. The United States is now committed to perpetual warfare. How long before a political formation arises that addresses that problem is unclear.

The problem for the U.S. homeland is that things are going to get a lot worse before they get better, Two stories in yesterday's paper illustrate this.

First, Eric Lichtblau reports in "F.E.C. Can’t Curb 2016 Election Abuse, Commission Chief Says"
of a mini-Bulworth moment for the chairwoman of the Federal Election Commission Ann Ravel when she says that the commission can no longer enforce federal election law:
WASHINGTON — The leader of the Federal Election Commission, the agency charged with regulating the way political money is raised and spent, says she has largely given up hope of reining in abuses in the 2016 presidential campaign, which could generate a record $10 billion in spending. 
“The likelihood of the laws being enforced is slim,” Ann M. Ravel, the chairwoman, said in an interview. “I never want to give up, but I’m not under any illusions. People think the F.E.C. is dysfunctional. It’s worse than dysfunctional.” 
Her unusually frank assessment reflects a worsening stalemate among the agency’s six commissioners. They are perpetually locked in 3-to-3 ties along party lines on key votes because of a fundamental disagreement over the mandate of the commission, which was created 40 years ago in response to the political corruption of Watergate. 
Some commissioners are barely on speaking terms, cross-aisle negotiations are infrequent, and with no consensus on which rules to enforce, the caseload against violators has plummeted. 
The F.E.C.’s paralysis comes at a particularly critical time because of the sea change brought about by the Supreme Court’s decision in 2010 in the Citizens United case, which freed corporations and unions to spend unlimited funds in support of political candidates. Billionaire donors and “super PACs” are already gaining an outsize role in the 2016 campaign, and the lines have become increasingly stretched and blurred over what presidential candidates and political groups are allowed to do. 
Watchdog groups have gone to the F.E.C. with complaints that probable presidential candidates like Jeb Bush and Martin O’Malley are skirting finance laws by raising millions without officially declaring that they are considering running.
A variety of functions usually handled by a campaign committee, such as expensive bulk mailings, are being offloaded to super PACs, which can raise unlimited amounts of money. The problem is that there is not supposed to be any coordination between candidates' campaign committees and Super PACs. This turns out to be a fictitious problem since there is no enforcement mechanism.

The basic point is the obvious one. You cannot have a democracy with concentrated wealth controlling the political process.

How the plutocratic control of the political process is making itself felt is the feeding frenzy on the corpse of organized labor that is currently underway. This is collapse story number two from yesterday, Monica Davey's "G.O.P. Expands Labor Battle to Laws Setting State Construction Wages." To go along with the raft of new right-to-work legislation is the effort to repeal prevailing- wage at the state level (and then when Scott Walker wins the presidency in 2016, you repeal the Big Kahuna, Davis-Bacon). Once prevailing wage, which provides a union-scale peg for government construction projects, is abolished income inequality will really take off.
Efforts to end prevailing-wage laws are emerging in statehouses around the nation. Opponents say these efforts would lower wages and see them as a new front in a battle by increasingly Republican legislatures to weaken labor unions. Advocates, like Mr. Bosma [House speaker of the Indiana state legislature], say the bills are aimed at sparing the budgets of struggling cities and states through free-market principles, and ending an inconsistent, inflated and sometimes politicized system for calculating what wage should be the standard.
Advertisement
In West Virginia, where Republicans took control of the Legislature this year for the first time since the 1930s, lawmakers ended the prevailing wage for projects worth $500,000 or less.
In Nevada, where Republicans also newly dominate, lawmakers in March exempted school construction projects from that state’s requirement.
Proposals to repeal such laws entirely have been offered in more than a dozen states, including Michigan and Missouri, as well as Wisconsin, where one conservative lawmaker has called for a vote this week but Republicans appear divided on the matter.
In Illinois, Gov. Bruce Rauner, a Republican newly at the helm of a legislature controlled by Democrats, has called for changes, arguing that from 2002 to 2011 the financially devastated state “overspent by $1.6 billion” on education projects alone because of the state’s prevailing-wage rule.

During the Great Depression, numerous states passed prevailing-wage laws in an effort to prevent companies from offering low bids to the detriment of ordinary workers. The laws, which exist in 32 states as well as on federal contracts, require private contractors to pay workers on public projects wages in line with those earned by people doing comparable work in the same region.
Efforts to repeal the laws have been around for decades, and groups like the American Legislative Exchange Council have included repeal as a model policy for years. But as Republicans have gained power in the states — they control 68 of 98 partisan state legislative chambers, the most in the party’s history — they found new traction on the prevailing wage. 
Though the issue is not explicitly about labor power, unions tend to favor the wage regulations, and opponents of the prevailing wage, which states determine differently, contend that it often amounts to higher, union scale wages. 
So some view ending wage rules as a next goal for those who once were more focused on pressing for laws barring organized labor from requiring all workers to pay union fees or dues. With a flurry of those so-called right-to-work laws enacted recently in parts of the industrial Midwest — states like Indiana, Michigan and Wisconsin — the prevailing wage has taken center stage.
Where is the AFL-CIO in all of this? Nowhere. Well, that is not true. The AFL is with the Democrats. That is the extent of the AFL's game plan -- elect Democrats. But Democrats are proving incapable of defending laws that have been around for generations.

Sunday, May 3, 2015

The Colt 45 Chronicle #93

The end is in sight. I have scanned and counted the last installments of this project, which end with #98. Below is the last letter that has a seasonal date scrawled at the top in pencil; the remainder, numbers 94 through 98, are miscellany, undated and unsent, though one, the next installment, #94, is a birthday note to my buddy Mark that I do believe was delivered.

The letter below is a another fine example of the steep price of the high life, the trapdoor of Romanticism. Young people like a good party. Much of their lives are spent in pursuit of the bacchanal. But often the bacchanal goes awry, as I describe below.

The epistle concludes with a description of spousal abuse, a verbal lashing I gave my wife for a lapse in her memory -- probably from too much alcohol, pot brownies and too many medical-school textbooks -- that led to the aborted bacchanal. No wonder the marriage would disintegrate in a little more than half a year. Also, the final paragraph provides a convenient transition to the forthcoming miscellany. I explain to my friend Mark my inability to write unless I am drunk; subsequently, as I explain, there is much that has gone unsaid and unmailed.  
Autumn 1989
Well, Mark, it's Saturday night here and around 52 degrees. This morning the temperature was in the mid-80s. Around 12 o'clock PM the thermostat started to drop. Two hours later it was 58 degrees. That's almost 30 degrees in 120 minutes. I think the television  was saying that it was record of some sort for the month of September. But anyway, 52 degrees feels pretty damn cold.
Shit, I'm sorry I missed you on Thursday. Ashley and I had gone out to grab a bite to eat, and when we got back Colin told us that you had called from JFK. I feel shitty about not getting in touch with you before you left. I think you called twice from California: once when I had puked and passed out after a couple quarts of Colt 45 and half a fifth of Jim Beam charcoal-filtered -- or some such filtered -- bourbon whiskey; and the other time I was out post-work $3-a-bottle beering with the boys.
As to the first call you made, get this -- Ashley never even told me that you had called; rather, I should say, that she did tell me, but not until I had got a bunch of people and quart bottles together for your eagerly anticipated Monday-night arrival. Gary and Eleni were over; Antony was going to make his way up on the 1 train as soon as I gave the signal; Ashley, yes, that's right, all-forgetting Ashley, was busy preparing pot chocolate chip cookies (she had chopped down one of her plants that night, one of the males that was about to go to seed); the stereo was chirping loud and happy; and we were all in that great good stride of a real goddamn shindig.
But the clock ticked right on up to 11 and you were nowhere to be seen or heard. The cookies had long ago been made. Antony had called and cancelled because of the late hour. Eleni was beginning to whine about work in the morning. Gary was looking star-dusty after gnawing through a few of the freshly-baked treats; and I was getting real sore, busting into new quarts and cursing the day that you had been born because -- goddamnitall! -- you hadn't phoned to inform us about what was what. I was totally amazed at your disregard, especially since you had made a point of having me write down your September 11 flight information.
During this whole drama you mus'n't forget little rosebud and petunia Peterson. The whole time that we're expecting you to come striding in the door, she's just as giddy and enthusiastic as the rest of us; but as soon as the festivities began to sour, she was the first to pile on and start complaining about what a inconsiderate dick-sucker you were.
By 11:45 PM the lights were out and Gary and Eleni were gone. Ashley and I were in bed. The beer massaged me and I was rapidly scooting off to dreamland when all of a sudden Ashley blurted out into the dark bedroom, "Oh Mike! I forgot to tell you! Mark called Friday. It was that night; you got really drunk. And . . . well, um . . . oh . . . I had been drinking too, and, oh . . . I'm sorry, but he called that night to tell you that he wouldn't be coming to New York, something about not being to get a flight, or something."
I couldn't believe my ears. There was no way she could be saying this; it was far too cruel to be dismissed as inconsequential, a benign loss of memory. So I let out a good roar and started tearing right in: I called her disgusting and selfish; I told her that she was dripping with the shit from her own bloated ass; I told her that she was vain and disrespectful, that she was a worthless ninny with an acute case Alzheimer's disease at the ripe old age of 24. I concluded the oration with a flourish: an elaborate, breathtaking construction of an onto-psychological schema which put forth in no uncertain terms that little petunia Peterson was deeply and mortally flawed. There was absolutely no hope for her; and that as soon as she woke up in the morning she should get right on the phone and make all the necessary arrangements to have herself institutionalized.
Ah, yes, with that said, I turned my face to the wall and nestled my head into a fluffy pillow. A smile creased my cheeks. I was soothed in the knowledge that Ashley was feeling bad, and that I, subsequently, was feeling better.
Man, you know what? I've written a lot of stuff to you that I've never sent. It's usually written when sober, tossed down on subways, on palms and napkins. But I can't double-write; I can't copy down from notes, whether crude or immaculate. I can't copy them down and put them into a letter. I am suffering from the myth of self-presence (as Derrida would say). Sure, sometimes I cheat. But when I cheat it's usually just a humble and malnourished subway idea, never whole stories, never whole lines. 
Fuck sobriety. It has to be done from the gut, or the heart, or the beer-buzzing brain, but never ever otherwise. It has to be done all at once, in a streak, like Roger Craig hurtling and cleating for pay dirt over a team full of linebackers; like Mendoza slapping high fives with Asian drunks in Irish bars after the 49ers trounced the Chicago Bears in 1987. I was there to see the majesty of Mendoza, and I'll always been there, a gape-eye appreciator. Hopefully we'll make it to heaven together.

Friday, May 1, 2015

Hippies vs. Punks: The Drive-By Truckers' Southern Rock Opera


In this morning of May Day, a day devoted to the rites of spring and the rights of working people, it is time to approach Hippies vs. Punks from a different angle.

My tendency of late has been to lean heavily on the recordings of one of the most productive and creative bands of the last 15 years. I speak here of the Drive-By Truckers.

For the last month or so, on the train ride home on Friday after another debilitating work week has been crossed off the calendar, I have plugged into Decoration Day (2003).

If you want a stepping-off point for an introduction to the Drive-By Truckers, Decoration Day is a good place to start. It is the band's fourth album. From there I would move backward or hop to the first record, Ganstabilly (1998) and then move forward to Pizza Deliverance (1999):


Before arriving at the third album, the masterful Southern Rock Opera (2001).

Southern Rock Opera is a two-disk tour de force exploration of Lynyrd Skynyrd, George Wallace, classic rock, and the "Southern Thing." It is worthy of lengthy study. The first disk is the more analytic, dense one of the pair. You can kind of get it all in one gulp with the cut "The Three Great Alabama Icons":


Disk two is a straight-up display of pure power. I have probably played disk two as much as any album over the last five years. It speaks to the enduring power of classic rock. Patterson Hood sums it up perfectly in the first track, "Let There Be Rock":


And here we have arrived at a golden truth of Hippies vs. Punks. The clash between Hippies and Punks in the late 1970s is more a mirage of historical perception than an actual moment in the Zeitgeist. Though I think such a moment does exist, and, as I have argued elsewhere, it takes place during the summer of 1976 and then plays out primarily in the years 1977 and 1978, the real clash is earlier in the 1970s. It's less a clash than a retreat from the field of battle.

Southern rock rises, first with the The Allman Brothers Band, and then with Lynyrd Skynyrd and ZZ Top; as does Glitter/Glam and Disco. All enervate the Hippies, or point to an abandonment of the belief in a broad social transformation.

This coincides with the rise of classic rock. "Sex, drugs and rock 'n' roll." Hedonism absent the goal of liberation from capitalism.

Classic rock is perfectly exemplified by two massive radio hits from 1974: Skynyrd's "Sweet Home Alabama" and Eric Clapton's cover of Marley's "I Shot the Sheriff":




I remember driving along in a Chevy El Camino pickup truck with my father and sister listening to both the summer of 1974. I remember one evening pulling into the driveway of our home, and my father turning off the engine but leaving the radio on. The three of us sat in the dark and listened to "Sweet Home Alabama." It was a powerful new narcotic in 1974.

Nixon was on his way out of the White House. But his "Southern Strategy," as promulgated by a young Kevin Phillips, remains in control of the country to this day. Phillips' idea was to co-opt for the GOP George Wallace's third-party American Independent Party electoral base by tapping the rich vein of white working class resentment and paranoia over any modest material gains for the African-American underclass.

Now, nearly half a century later, the cities are still burning and Dixie has a stranglehold on Congress.

But if you listen to the Drive-By Truckers and the band's truth-telling about white Red State America -- the failed marriages, the alcoholism and drug abuse, the dead-end jobs, the girlfriends faking orgasms, Santa Claus raping his reindeer -- you realize that the white underclass is no different than any other underclass, black or brown, red or yellow.

It is the politicians and the Fourth Estate that pit us against each other so that the plutocrats can continue to call the shots. Maybe there is enough room left within the exhausted neoliberal paradigm -- maybe there is enough juice left in classic rock -- that we can undergo a shift in consciousness, and social transformation will once again become an aspiration of the masses.